Go back

‘The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore’ and the ‘Love Is Blind’ Boston Cast

1h 45m 14s

‘The Life of a Showgirl: The Encore’ and the ‘Love Is Blind’ Boston Cast

This episode of *Rear Obsessed* delves into the concept of obsession in modern pop culture, using Taylor Swift’s *Life of the Showgirl* album and its subsequent "encore" as a central lens. The hosts examine how Swift’s creative output—particularly the song "Patient Zero"—reflects both artistic ambition and emotional vulnerability, yet also reveals contradictions in tone and structure, including a problematic, AI-sounding bridge that many find jarring. The discussion extends to broader cultural phenomena, such as the romanticized, formulaic dating profiles in the Netflix series *Lovis Blind*, which mirror millennial anxieties about love, commitment, and identity. The podcast also analyzes SeaWorld’s "Hello Scream" Halloween exhibit, which features macho antiheroes and fantasy-themed cosplay, as a commercial spectacle that commodifies eroticized romance and raises concerns about the blurring of fantasy and reality. Throughout, the hosts highlight how fan reactions to Swift’s music and pop culture trends reveal a deep desire for emotional authenticity, connection, and escape from judgment. While Swift’s work often appears defiant or reactive to criticism, the episode suggests it may also reflect an internal struggle with self-perception, fame, and the pressure to maintain a curated public image. Ultimately, the conversation underscores how obsession—whether in music, love, or fantasy—serves as a coping mechanism in a world where authenticity feels increasingly rare.

Transcription

16432 Words, 85774 Characters

English
[MUSIC] Hello and welcome to Rear Obsessed, a pop culture conversation pod here on the Rear Podcast Network, I'm Jody Walker and I'm Nora Prinsiatti. Nora, you're in studio. I'm not just sad. I'm just sad to be away from you. What can I say? You're coming back soon though. I know I miss you. I'm coming back soon. I've been collecting my fall and winter clothes from where they scattered when I had that car wreck, which is not to say the highway median. They were originally a little bit. A little bit the highway median. It's a short life. It's a little bit. Which is to say Atlanta, Georgia. [LAUGHTER] You had to make a proper match. As I was getting some of my tights together, frankly, I was like, this seems like not enough tights. This seems like I don't have enough tights and it's true. Calzadonia, where are you at? Well, specifically, Calzadonia exists in the subterranean shopping center underneath our office. The Oculus had the nerve to open up a Calzadonia. The moment I started working up there in our office, I knew every time I walked past it. It's such an interesting brand. I don't know the things that I have gotten there are tights and bikinis, which are like the most disparate possible items. I took an extra gander into the store one of the first times that I walked past on my way from work because you'd highlighted Calzadonia as a branch that's near and dear to your heart. And I was surprised that they had bathing suits. And I think I've owned Calzadonia tights, but in my head, they just did tights. Well, and how could you have ever guessed that the other thing they do is bathing suits? I know. I guess it sort of makes sense because it's like undergarment adjacent things. But this is going to sound weird, but also this specific, not that any of this sounded normal so far. Really specific to me. And this is even more specific to me is that there was a period of my life where I was so into those spanks like faux leather leggings. I was like, well, clothing has been solved. Spanks made faux leather leggings and I'll never need to own anything else again. And those are those from Eritcia. What's it not the same? Not the same. I bought so many pairs of those in spanks stores in the airport. It was like, I'd be on the way to somewhere and be like, you know what? I'm just going to get another pair. And there is something about that calzodonia store that is the exact shape and size of every spanks in an airport I've ever been into. Because the Oculus does and this podcast has taken on such a niche note. So sorry about the stores do have the feeling of stores in an airport. That's true. To the point where you can even, I believe that you can make an appointment with TSA in in the Oculus. Can I get like a weird 10 minute neck massage at a place with a 3.1 rating? I would, I can't, I don't know that for a fact and yet I do, spiritually I do. You definitely can. I want you to know that I got over my spanks leggings affliction several years ago. But actually the way in which I was addicted to those leggings does remind me of everything we're talking about today. You know, I don't want to sound insane, but what if I told you that this episode is about obsession? Everything we're talking about is actually about other than the spanks leggings is like an obsession that I kind of don't understand, which is. That's a foreign feeling to me. Sure. Sure. It's sort of like not understand something in pop culture and a couple of millennials. It's like particularly millennial of sessions of it is. I still don't know what the word chugie means, but I think today's episode is making me understand. It's a no when you see it, which we're going to get to Taylor Swift. But can we just take a brief to be to where I can feel comfortable? Please, please. This is, you know, this is not a Lovis Blind podcast, but Lovis Blind is safely in my realm of personal obsessions. And you and I both, I'm, I, it's so crazy to me that they're doing Boston. What the next season? I don't know. That's such a specific culture. And they took this like huge detour into the Midwest that was like so boring. And I'm just, and you know, this could be my lack of familiarity with Boston and its folk. But I'm assuming that we're getting two dozen Karen reads and two dozen boy Karen reads. And that's just my hope. Yeah. I mean, that does kind of seem accent wise. It seems likely. I think that the my assumption, which is backed up by the the boy lineup that Netflix posted. We got our eyes on a on a grid of boys. And it's sort of like the like the tether to the the cut most eligible men in New York. It's like evil tether is this grid of Brooklyn boys for Lovis Blind. Yeah, except they're not broke. They're Boston boys, not Brooklyn boys. There is a part of Boston that is not representative of all of Boston, but is representative of. I think a lot of what you experience on a Boston dating app. Though I will say that like my knowledge of that is several years out of date. But where it says, can I say what you said though about dating? Sure. As we were going over this grid via text together, you said, I dated a lot while I lived in Boston. You were I was treated on them. I had like I had the I had the confidence in the freedom of someone who knows that they're not going to live in a place forever. The best is really I like I actually wish that on everyone. I wouldn't like in the back of your mind. It's like, okay, but what if I fell in love and then and then something. I don't know. We'll see. We'll see. I was like, what if I fell in love? I'd still move. I'd still yeah. I'd take your Boston ass with me. All of these guys have the vibe of a dude who lives in the seaport and works at Deloitte, which is definitely a part of Boston. But it's like not everything. Okay, I've seen a lot of people say this like these dudes all live in seaport. Can you tell me what that means? Like the Hudson yards of Boston. Oh my god. It's like a new development area. Where it's like big high rises and. Yeah, yeah, okay. And that's coming through to you in their eyes. They just look like. They look like guys who live in the seaport. Okay. I think that this. They really look like consultants. And they are. Mostly. Yeah. Except for Blake, the yacht captain. And most notably, the thing that I think really made even people maybe who aren't normally engaged as in love and spline. Lock into this is not the 37 year old beekeeper. Yeah. A Boston beekeeper wearing a bull tie. And do you know what's on that below tie? Honestly, I'm trying to zoom in. And my. The photo is getting a little blurry, but I assume it's a bee. I'm very confident that is a bumblebee bull tie. Buzz buzz. Buzz buzz, baby. And it's a yellow shirt. Yeah, it's a butter yellow shirt with a bull tie with a bee on it. And he's 37 years old. And he says, my son is the greatest thing in my life. Interesting. Okay. And I noted to you that I'm. And I'm sure that his son is the greatest thing in his life. And that that below be tie is a close number two. But a lot of these they have these little like. Kairan's these little captions on their grid. Photos. And like a lot of them are sort of prompts in a way that you can imagine they came out of a questionnaire in the style of the cuts. Most eligible or the bachelor. And. But the things that these reveal are like impossible to figure out what the questions were on that questionnaire. Sometimes they're like the most romantic thing I've ever done. And Marx is is take someone to Paris. He really took all the romanticism out of it with that language. Yeah. Is the type of thing where you imagine someone filling out a form. And the way that you write when you're filling out a form. But they've they've taken that and tried to turn it into prose. The one that really got me was John who is 33 years old, an account executive. And what his little blurb says is one thing I wouldn't be able to sacrifice for love is my dog. Which does to me imply that what he's saying is that he wouldn't murder his dog if a woman asked to. Nora stop asking John to murder his dog. Okay. It's that that's quite it's enough out of you. I didn't I didn't and I wouldn't and I'm wondering how often this comes up. How often does this come up that was my immediate thought like John. No one is asking you to sacrifice your dog. Like that is the most like this guy being like I wouldn't sacrifice my golden noodle for a woman. And I'm asking you to know and I mean I guess maybe he's being like if you're. allergic to dogs. It's off. We can go ahead and part ways. But it did make me think about that, like, that is a difficult, if the question on the questionnaire was, what would you not sacrifice for love? Which it clearly is, because someone else said, like, my relationship with my mother, that one's actually a little more telling. Yeah. But like, to have to come up with an answer of what you wouldn't sacrifice for love, when you don't even know who the person that you love is yet is pretty emotionally difficult. Well, right, because it also, it's like the dog thing is kind of bad in both ways. I love dogs. But John, you're really telling me that if you met the love of your life, you feel that you've found partnership for forever. And that person is allergic to dogs. You're so committed to being a dog owner, that it would be a deal breaker for you. I respect the principle if that's true. I definitely think that's what John is saying. Yeah. And yet, I think if he fell in love in the pods, he might be rethinking some things. I'm just now getting pretty curious about Wilson. I would say, I would stick with the dog over anyone you meet in the pods. Right. Because you don't worry. You won't be marrying them for sure. I wouldn't worry about that. Wilson, the 35 year old senior compliance manager, his, his caption is just, I'm going to be very vulnerable. How boring was his questionnaire that that's what they got out of it? I'm going to be very vulnerable. Tucker, no, this one is worse. Tucker, who is a senior solutions consultant. I mean, these are just the most fake hashtags. I'm very committed to the people I love in my life. I think at that point, we don't need, we don't, we maybe don't need the caption. We don't need the blur. Kim says, my fear is marrying the wrong person. And my fear is that he shouldn't have come on this show. I'm just good fear to have. That would be bad if you did that. These boring little weirdos have just made me even more excited and more curious about Boston, because I'll leave you with this. Mori, a 32 year old entrepreneur, says, I was top five big spoons in the state last year. Nora, I recently made it clear. There's a lot I don't know about Massachusetts. Is there a ranking system of big and little spoons that sort of, you know, so they're like a limited that's by the state government. I should know about. I don't believe that it is for the whisper network. Yeah, I think this is more of a DIY type of situation. Also, Mori said he was top five big spoons, which means he was four or five. Otherwise, he would have said top three. Yes. Okay, thank you. I feel more comfortable now. Anything is top, like top 10, anything, or particularly when it's not a super even number, like this happens in sports all the time. If somebody says someone is a top 14 quarterback, they mean they're 14th. They mean they are 14th on the list. And why not just say that, because it's embarrassing to say top 14. Right, because it's like, well, it's obviously not one. Okay, I've invoked the word embarrassing. So we do need to at this point get into some dangerous waters. Last Friday, during our Friday episode, so we were not able to give any immediate reactions or address it. Taylor Swift released the encore of Life of the Showgirl. So that's four additional songs for an album that was sort of decently received at the time. She started rolling this out that there were going to be more songs or at least that she was releasing another single patient zero through a series of Easter eggs, including putting like zeros in her, you know, Instagram name, etc. Did you immediately know that these were going to be like additional songs to Life of the Showgirl? Well, so funny enough, I did feel at the time, once she did the countdown where it was revealed that there was a single coming out patient zero, but before it was revealed that it was all four songs and that it was an encore to showgirl, I assumed it would belong to showgirl because there was a there was actually an erroneous solving of an Easter egg that was going around, which was that the third letter because of third. Oh, boy. Oh, no, we're doing numerology. I hate it here. I hate it here. I want to get out, let me out of this box. On her website, she has this graphic of the letter she wrote when she bought back her masters and usually the graphic looks like writing on a piece of paper that's on top of another piece of paper, totalling to two pieces of paper and suddenly a third piece of letter paper appeared in the graphic underneath it. That means people go third letter and then people went to the SVU sketch from the Emmys where she said a bit of a bit of a bit of a saccharide areas from the vineyard north south. Right. And tallied up the third letters of those words and they spelled out, well, actually didn't fact check if there were any like leftover letters. And I think I saw someone saying that maybe there weren't. But it really made the rounds online that that had spelled out encore. Encore felt like a direct enough illusion to showgirl that to me, I was I was of the mindset that this was going to belong to the showgirl era. Prior to that, I would not have assumed that because I would have rather assumed that the showgirl era would be one that she was sort of ready to move past doing an encore for it. Wait, wait, no, I got it back up. So that zodiac shit was real that third paid third letter. Now we're doing the third letters of saccharide areas and it spells out. I was real. I don't really know because they also what those words also reflected were like guest star cameos in the music video video. So saccharide sugar Colin Farrell is in a show called sugar, I think. Yeah, he is. Aries is the ram and ram's quarterback Matthew Stafford made a guest appearance in the video as did Cara Delevene Delevene from the vineyard and then Dakota Johnson starring opposite Colin Farrell. Dakota North Dakota sells to go. Oh, I just thought she was there because of bangs. I mean, yes, but also and also and also bangs. I think that's what the easter egg was for the stuff from the Emmys thing, but whether I'm so tired. You're doing, you're doing, I'd actually say okay, I wanted to say great, but I think you're doing okay. I'm not sure that it's possible to do great at this. So I think the point is that no one's doing great. It's it's I was I would call my reaction to all of this. These songs, the way that they rolled out the fact that they were a part of life of a show girl, although I did I did see one convincing crazy person saying that like they always knew that the encore was going to come because the end of show girl is like it's Taylor Swift and Sabrina Carpenter. Sabrina Carpenter saying like that's our show. Thanks, good night. And that does kind of like sound like then you're going to come back out for an encore as often happens in short musical setting. And so it was, but I think that there are so many things that Taylor Swift sets up like that, where then they can be explained retroactively. But if she hadn't done an encore, no one would have thought anything about it. No one would have thought anything of it. Also, here are the other things that I would say. Part of the promo of life of a show girl was this idea that it had been very edited, because it was only 12 tracks and she said it's just going to be 12 tracks. That being sort of a response to the sprawl of tortured poets being difficult for a lot of people to deal with, although I would say that I think that has aged well, whereas show girl has aged poorly and didn't feel that vital in the moment either. So she's kind of contradictory to herself by doing this. Also, it's like, how do you feel about the Toy Story song? How dare you ask me that unprovoked? No, I actually need to. No, I like it. I knew it. I knew it. I knew it. I knew it. I like it. I like it for a Toy Story song. I think like it has a sort of, you know, youthful zaniness. It sounds like nostalgic, which like that is a huge part of the Toy Story. There it is. Is this nostalgia? I like that it's a little country. And like, I guess I'd been following as best I can while keeping a very safe distance, that like she's moving, I thought moving kind of back towards country or towards Reaver. according to her original album. - Everybody likes the Toy Story song. - Okay, everybody likes the Toy Story song. I mean, I'm sure they're put. But like in general, that song has been really well received. It's really pleasant, it's sweet. It, I think it has some good like lyrical couplets. It feels sort of like an old version of her that wasn't so preoccupied with like the haters and the clap backs and the meta narrative. And I think that's really refreshing to people. It works for the movie. I think she could genuinely win an Oscar for it. I think that would mean a lot to her. It does kind of feel like this, or at least it did kind of feel like this thing that was repositioning her in a direction where she could go back and make a country album. I think that's something that a lot of people are interested in. I also think that it's something that is really fitting with the cultural moment that we're in and the musical moment that we're in where country is very popular and like very palatable. It all seemed like, particularly as she's leading up to this 20 year anniversary of her debut album, which you know, the twing was very present. People love that music. It's really special to me. Like all of that seemed like it lined up so neatly. To then do this swerve back into this album that critically did pretty badly. And that was only sort of a success in these terms of really hyped up sales because she is who she is and also because of the way that she has an audience that will buy six bajillion vinyl variants is so bizarre to me. And it is the type of own goal that I feel I have never seen her make. It feels like, and this could be me projecting from like what we're, what we'll be talking about next, which is this sort of like a compulsive behavior around fan fiction and like fantasy erotic literature. But it's like she can't help herself, you know, like it's like she knows she has these additional songs or like she wants to in some way rewrite a bit of the reception of that album or just like make it this slightly different variant in the way that she saw it but we didn't receive it or something. Something just feels like she can't follow the natural, right now she can't follow the natural progression that she's created. Like she created this kind of this off ramp into something else. And then whether it was because it was already the planner, she wanna do it, she did the meme. She did the meme of the car that's not that suddenly taking me exit. And the exit says Dakota fanning is your, I can't Dakota fan, I can't say shit. It's a different movie. It's interesting to think how she would have played that. It is. Oh my gosh, if she could get both fanning sisters in a video, that would, that would mean that's how to write this. That would mean that. I will say, I say this 100% sincerely about the patient zero music video. Perfect to Dakota Johnson vehicle. - In that. - It's sort of bad. Okay, let's talk about maybe the video. - Sure. - Before we talk a little bit about the music. - Can I ask you a question that I've been polling a lot of people about? - Yeah, pull me live. - Did you understand that the drinks were poisoned and that's why she was knocking them over? - No. - Me neither. - I barely know what you're talking about. One of the smartest women I know and no one got it. What? - No. - I think it was because then he died, but she died. - She died. - She's a ghost. - She's a ghost. - But she's patient zero and she's taken calls. - Yeah. Yeah, but then it's like the implication of it being poison is strange because you would assume it was like the sickness that killed her. - The narrative through line is shaky. It's definitely shaky. I like this. So like she has said, Taylor Swift has said that she came up with the concept for this song when one of her friends received like a phone caller a message from the current girlfriend of that friend's ex and was like basically like, have you dealt with any of this before? - Any of this unfamiliar to you. - I do think girls, if you're having to make the call, you all probably already feel like you're not in a great place. - Yeah. - And, but I guess I kind of like that concept, especially for what is like a pretty modern situation in dating, you know, like has become this sort of stereotype of a thing, I mean, I think the stereotype of more being like the hey girl text. But this is now maybe we call this patient zeroing and like, yeah, Taylor's, you know, this concept, but then the execution of everything I did not follow. - You know what's funny is actually the first two minutes or so if that's all right, I enjoy quite a bit. Actually, I really like that. I like that she used a violin. You don't get that in pop music that much. I like that sort of Celtic melancholy fiddle thing. I like combining that with this very beatboxy drum line. I think that's a good moment of production. I'm really with it until, and this is unusual. This is a sign to me that we have lost our way until the bridge and she starts toxining and she says, so let's get into it. I need, I need to take the exit. I need to swerve dramatically to the right. That was reckless behavior. - It was really reckless behavior. - Someone in her life needed to tell her that that bridge completely ruins the song. I mean, it makes it like un-listenable as a whole song. The bridge is, and I'm no music critic. I'm just as a listener and an enjoyer of Taylor Swift music, the bridge is horrifying. - It's really horrifying. - There is an epidemic of toxining bridges on this four song on Quarer. - The toxining is just ill-advised. I don't understand why she's doing it. She's capable of not doing it. And the people have pointed out that the bridge in Patient Zero, it sounds so much like those AI videos that the people make about like the, you know, like, why do all the coils? Like, why do the trucks with the coils? Why do they carry the coils on their round sides instead of their flat tops? It sounds exactly like that. I can't sing them myself because of human, but it sounds like those AI humans. - Well, there's a lot of like, there's a lot of AI vibes. I mean, I'm not saying I think she actually used it, but like the whole thing sounds a little bit like chat GP Taylor. - Yeah, I mean, that's the thing is it's like, with chat GPT and AI, it's like we're, you know, calling all of the internet to kind of then create like the greatest solutions. Those, the things that are currently or have been on the internet come from human minds. Now they're coming from AI and increasingly coming from AI. If Taylor Swift is only ever iterating on herself, she is just gathering from chat GP Taylor. - And like literally the song Babylon, which I think is in a lot of ways the sort of easiest to swallow. Yeah. It is a fractal of other songs. It is a mel, it like the, first of all, she's used the idea of the gardens of Babylon several times as a metaphor already, gave Grace the Abrams a song that does it. And then the chorus, which is like relatively pleasant to listen to, but that da, da, da. Melody is you belong with me. The peak moment of that chorus is the same descending three notes. It's also in me. It is so, there are two fabulous musicologists, Nate Sloan and Charlie Harding, who have the Switched On Pop podcast and they've written a book. They have like coined that the T drop because it is so common of a mechanism for her. And I think just like 20 years in you kind of, even if it works and even if it is kind of your own thing, it doesn't make the song bad, but it makes it really instantly forgettable because even of the first time that I listened to Babylon, I was like, okay, like this one's kind of good. It just makes you want to go to the older, better, stronger stuff. - Well, and this is what I felt about Pink Clouding, which is also, you know, there are two okay songs in these four and there are two. - Okay. - Really bad songs. - This is my hottest take. Pink Clouding is my least favorite. - I would have a music Cleveland than Pink Clouding. - That's crazy, that's a crazy thing to say you should leave. - It's really, it's that. - No, you wouldn't. - Ha, ha, ha, it's like that. That is nails on a chalkboard to me. - Okay, well, that's also in Cleveland. - I also, yeah, but like Cleveland is like, Cleveland is such a fascinating swing and a miss that at least my brain is working. Like it's, it's sparking something in me, even if it's sort of praying. - All right, so I mean, I was just gonna say about Pink Clouding is that like, I like all of Taylor Swift's color songs, top to bottom, pretty much. I like all the color songs and then it was with this one it feels a little bit like she's like, yeah, I know you like that shit You want to love when I say colors you want me to be a full of colors you little idiot. Like that's it's like. Oh, no I don't know what else is enough for pink rosewood Damn it. Okay, so that's how we feel about those should should we talk about Cleveland? You I can't believe I'm here. Where where would you say you are Cleveland? No, I'm not sure first of all he didn't take you to Cleveland I guess I think that I guess I I've been to Cleveland. I covered to A two NBA final series between the Celtics and the Caves that had me in Cleveland a lot in like 2019. Is that when that was I spent a fair bit of time in Cleveland I spent enough time in Cleveland to render Cleveland in much more vivid detail that it is rendered in the song Which mentions two things that there is a neighborhood called the Heights and that Travis Kelsey is from there That's it It's yeah, no, it's not so much about Cleveland and you know what song I love Florida. Yeah Florida has three exclamation points You you simply cannot trust a Taylor Swift song that has a single exclamation point. That's true. The history is incredibly troubled I wasn't thinking about that Florida has three and that that does like market safe from you know people saying One hell of a drug. I love Florida nor I have a question Is she with Cleveland is she trolling us? So I this is this is something that I have been thinking about A fair bit and I'm not spoiler alert. I'm not going to arrive at a definitive answer. My main take on basically all of this is I have no idea what's going on Rage bait more and more is like all that there is And I suppose that if you wanted to make something simply for the purpose of generating attention You could end up with a song like this I think the thing that is so like this is a song that kind of at least postures itself as though it's About her relationship and and the satisfaction of it But then it mostly concerns itself with kind of a list of grievances of things that people allegedly Say about her although one of them is that she's bad at dancing, which like no one no one is really bothered with that one in like a day Years in years except for my friend Becky who says she's all elbows But that's just Becky Becky doesn't even have a platform You know well, but it's like it did make me it did make me wonder is it possible that she is actually and though she you know She likes to say that she's like pretty logged off But is it possible that she's not and she is in fact so online that she is is locating These really random and uncommon Like niche criticisms which would be concerning for a whole set of reasons. I think More likely Would be that maybe she does know like it not present here say the most common criticism Issued towards her relationship like as I perceive it is the idea that she has settled and That It's like to say like she could do better. I don't know that but it is just that like there is this sort of Is that all there is to this relationship that idea is not something she Either is aware of or is willing to contend with Because she has settled. Yes What do you think she is contending with about her relationship with this song because it within this song because it is defensive It is defensive of something also she presents it as though what people say about them is that he settled Like one of the things is is she is like He could you know he should have gone for someone younger I don't like that's not a thing that I feel is in the the ether about them Yeah, I feel like really I mean I also don't think that what's in the ether is precisely that she settled As much as this is a very it's an unexpected and sort of strange coupling and that his You know, maybe like Dense-ness Says something about her that we don't Know I guess like that's what I would maybe pick up as a very online person But there is uh This song did invite me to think like okay is she fucking with me like Who in their 30s as a long-time musician who recently started treating herself to saying a few f words Is like hush bleeping the word whore. You know like what are what that's like right at the jump And then these these sort of very silly versus my baby likes what he likes. Oh, whoa. Oh He already took me to Cleveland. He showed me the heights like this very elementary lyricism but then the bridge Well, that's something horribly sad Well, so this is why I this is just that she settled. This is why I'm this is why this is sort of why your question about if she's rage-baiting brought me here is because I do I perceive some of the surprise at their particular coupling especially vis-a-vis his More simplistic relationship with the English language than hers Which someone is allowed to have. I think the worst thing she could do in the world is Mary a writer. Totally um But I like if that if we can at least for for the purposes of this conversation Some that up as an idea that like she has sort of she has she has settled a little bit Or that people say that Then if you were trying to Get a rise out of those people or at least provoke them in some way because in some ways It just seems like well, aren't you just proving them right? But then something that it would make sense to say in a song Would be you only need to find one person in the world who doesn't find you completely insufferable Say it right use the sort of transatlantic accent she's using I don't know if I can You need to find one person in the entire world who doesn't find you completely insufferable That would I see so I mean I guess like it's not rage. It's like It's proving people's prior like I this is where it loses me. I don't really know I also honestly think that rage beating Though it is really a part of our world right now It's really not it's not her style It's not like this is a person who wants to be liked who wants who seeks approval Who is actively trying to win an Oscar and more Grammys and like that? It feels wrong to me is not found Completely insufferable by everyone but one person like very and people love them Taylor Swift and just her like she's saying you only need to find one person who doesn't find you completely insufferable And she found him in Cleveland and he's He's huge and she found him like no you have this huge fan base who's Obsessed with you and there are certainly For Taylor Swift more than most people in the world a larger group of people who find her completely insufferable Than who just find any lay person completely insufferable. Oh absolutely give her that but to like just randomly discount It's not the norm goodgillians of people Love her are obsessed with her find any like we'll make any excuse in the world for her both musically and personally is Strange it's also terrible advice You you don't only need to find one person in the world who finds you completely insufferable In fact, I bet that most people in relationships were only their partner is their only avenue for socialization Would not recommend it you also need friends of which she has many yeah It's by all accounts like a a close and supportive and loving family I bet those people are like what the hell like what the fuck Taylor? Yeah, I think it's so it's so strange because I do feel that For the last few years although I think there have been some like ways in which you could feel this bubbling She's she's been on such a high and part of that has been that she has become pretty difficult to criticize because there has been A real apparatus built to dismiss any criticism of the work as Oh, you just hate seeing her happy and You're just sort of jealous of You know, whatever's going on. I think that that for like that really felt for a while like it was a force-field. And what's interesting to me is that this song, which does not seem aware of that at all, may represent something that's actually becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy because like I don't love what's in the what's in the air right now. Like tides feel as though they are a turn in. Well, someone in this outline, I don't know if it was you or Sasha, said, "Jody, what do you think about the musists?" It was me. It was me. And that means the various sort of people, mostly men, I guess, who have inspired her various albums and I think sort of like the idea of the idea of how much how much the guys belong in the conversation about the quality of her artistic and professional output because of course like they are. They have inspired a lot of songs, not all of them and probably less of them than she sort of gets credit for in general, but it also is a conversation that I think can deny a certain amount of agency and/or fault to the person who's actually writing the stuff. I'll I'll tell you two things. A two-part answer. One is very funny when people say that Travis Kelsey is Yoko Ono of this situation. That's funny. I like it. It might be true. Time will tell. Also, that's complicated, but number two. I think that tailors in my observation of the last several years and these iterations of her musical development or last several albums are that her single worst muse is us. Like her worst muse is the audience. Yes. And it seems at least in this time in her life, almost inextractable to take us away from Travis Kelsey and from that love story. And I guess the very public nature of it. And so many of the songs that seem to address him or talk about their love story also talk a lot about the haters and how they are perceived. And I think like perception is Taylor Swift's and I totally relate to this. Like is Taylor Swift's greatest motivation and creates some of her most impressive and ambitious projects. And it is also her greatest weakness when she lets it fool her into thinking that she's not the master of her own craft. And I think that like that's how these songs sound to me is trying to like get something across to me when when she's not receiving when there's something about whatever set whatever bubble she's sort of constructed, you know, probably at least to a certain extent for her own protection, but also because of her fame and her wealth and the ability for her to put out literally anything and have it be received. As a success at least of scale that feels like it has gotten in the way of of that ability to perceive that she's seeing everything and perceiving through a filter that's not allowing her to access a type of truth that I think everybody looks for in in art. And she she wants us to like her music and to proceed like you said earlier, I mean she she is someone who wants to be like she is not a subversive artist and to occasionally take these dips into subversiveness to kind of get back at this public narrative as she perceives it. I guess it could work sometimes, but I don't think that it is and it's like it's not a rage. No, not a successful. She's just not she might be someone who would like to be able to say that to kind of say when something doesn't go well that it was a little rage made it but she's not like at her core that is not that I do not think that that is an impulse that she falls. I'm not a rage baiter either. I can't take it you are a little bit. Hey, hey, hey, when you think about the muses, it is not unusual to be less like artistically interesting when you're in love. That is like that's so standard. You know, like it's so and like heartbreak songs are so much better and so much more relatable than love songs. That is across the board because like, you know, heartbreak has this universal understanding to it and love as I think we will get into also in our next topics is very subjective and like it is so specific to your own relationship and it's hard to invite people into that and like have them see it. Like the day to day of it can be a little boring. It's not like that happens when you have a healthy stable relationship. Yeah, there's like so much. There's so little poison in the day to day of love. I think people would be shocked. There's so little poisoning of drinks and knocking them over. It's sort of like you're making a metaphor. I mean, sort of am. I guess I'm sort of trying to use her metaphor, which actually, okay, so back to this music video, I have two questions. Why, why was she borrowing from the 50 shades of gray thing, both by casting Dakota Johnson and making it look like 50 shades of gray, like, and then to what was going on at the VMAs. This is a crazy VMAs, but not in a good way and not in the normal VMAs. Okay, it was crazy and one good way, which was that Rachel Dratch was there looking incredible. Did you see her? It was, yes, Rachel Dratch with Emma Bunton. Who knew? I really did feel like I was having no stroke when they were like, this is what I want. Rachel Dratch and Spice Girl Emma Bunton take the stage, coming up next. What the fuck? This is on CBS. You loved it. I did love it. No, I did love it. I did love it. I was confused by their little bit. I also think Emma Bunton looks fabulous. Of course. Bit of it. What were we talking about? Why is it 50 shades of gray? I think that could be rhetorical and I wonder if that's just like, I wonder if Dakota Johnson is kind of frozen in her memory there because I don't know if they met because she and Zane did the soundtrack for, I believe it was the third one. It was for 50 shades darker. I wrote a blurb about that recently. That's not information that I normally have on recall. I want that to be clear for the record. But maybe she just really associates her friend Dakota Johnson with that. Well, and the other thing that made me not know that these songs were going or at least patient zero was going to be an addendum to showgirl is that she released a lot of still images from the video in advance and within them she looks like she's doing 50 shades of gray cosplay and that did not feel of a piece with showgirl to me at all. So I was very confused and a lot of people nor can you close the loop for this on me like it was assumed when she put out the name of the song and the stills that this song was based on this piece in the Los Angeles Times that said Taylor Swift is patient zero for emotional contagion. Do you think that it's still real? Do you think it's related to that? I mean, that was just like wrong. Okay. I mean, or like you could have been in the sense that she, you know, she often talks about how she just keeps this sort of running notes app doc of relatable phrases and ideas and combinations of words and concepts and blah, blah, blah, blah. I don't really think like she's been really into as we all have been since COVID I think in a way, but she's been really into kind of like playing epidemiologist since tortured poets, I would say. It's like, I don't really think she needs to see patient zero applied to her in a Los Angeles Times article to get to get there, but like maybe that was the thing that made her go, oh, that could be an interesting thing. But I don't, I mean, what that article was about was her relationship with Travis. This obviously is not about that. I don't think there is. I will tell you that there is one theory that is almost certainly wrong, but that I would absolutely love, which is that it's actually about Ellen DeGeneres. Yeah, I see it because I can see it because both Taylor and Dakota Johnson are people have had experiences on that couch for sure. And in on the tombstone. I believe it says 1986 to 2022. When did the Ellen show start? Something I'm going to get it wrong. I'm like a little, I'm surprisingly detached from these drags. I'm more detached from them than I'd ever been. But there's something about that date range that that applies to Ellen and I think a certain Janice Ellen to it. It has a certain Janice Ellen to it. The show I believe ended in 2022 and it caught people's eye in part because as we know she was born in 1989. So to see an 80s date that is not 1989 is always like there has to be something going on here. I assumed that they were the birth that they were the years of whichever one of her friends it was who originally got the call that she sort of base this song or maybe it's maybe it's the boyfriend, you know, maybe it's the boyfriend. I mean, I think one way to solve this is that she gets those little girls who used to wrap Nicki Minaj on the Ellen show into one of these videos and then I'll tell you what then I'll be tuned in. I will be tuned into that as well. I do I'm going to choose to believe that that's true for me because I do like that idea. Final question. Did she give herself an award at the VMA? Oh, the artist director on her. The way that they keep saying that she is the making history as the first I always find that like an interesting turn of phrase to say that someone has made history for being the first winner of an award. It's like we got to choose which thing is most important that they're the first winner or they're they're not it's the award is making history I guess and she is the first recipient of it. Right. And the award is it's not an award. It's an honor. It's an honor. It's the artist director honor. If I keep saying that will it make more sense? No. The so is an artist director. So it is for accomplishments in directing one's own music videos. So it's like for directing music videos, but it can't be someone who does that for a living. It has to be like the artist themselves directing said music videos. Like if they ever let us for whatever reason, personally produce this podcast. We would be like we do the audio visuals host producer honor. Potentially we could be eligible to receive the artist director honor. That's my nightmare, by the way, for whatever slush we put out. I sound like I was speaking through a glass of water. I never want to do that. Yeah, she did I think she did you'll never make history. I make history every day babe. She did get she made up this award for herself. The producer of the VMAs sort of let it slip that the idea for this new honor came from external came from an external idea, an external idea which I think people were sort of able to connect the dots about what happened. And I will say that like she put a video on Instagram a few days ago before the ceremony. Basically confirming it herself. And being like when I saw this music video, I really wanted a platform for it. And so I was standing there saying to the team like, can you Google when the VMAs are? So she's owning it. But yeah, no, she yeah, they made up a nowhere to give her. And to me, this seems like another pivot that I guess I would have more expected is that like she wants to get more into her director artist director era direct things maybe that have artistically less to do with her that star people that are not her and that don't have the same bangs as her. And I think that would be and I think. So I think she should try it for a while. This is this is another interesting question because for years at this point, like years, there's been since since roughly when cats came out, I remember this being a thing. What a what a way to calculate one self in time. Yes, absolutely. Circle when cats came out. Maybe that's that when when did cats the musical stop running? Maybe that's 86 to two that anyway, we can go down the path. For a long time, there's been this question of like just been there have been all of these little data points of she's interested in getting into filmmaking. She's interested in being a director. She's going to do a movie at some point. The studios are really interested in her doing a movie. She's having Steven Spielberg introduce her for awards and talking about the craft. She is premiering the all too well short film at New York Film Festival, like she's done all of these movie adjacent things and done them in a way that feels as though it is gearing up to involvement in a feature film. But it has been literally years at this point, like many years and it hasn't happened. And so I don't understand what's going on. I also will say and like I am obviously this is the artist of my lifetime. I think that she like and none of this by the way to me. You cannot touch that catalog. And try as she might, as Shad D'Souza said in the end of his review for Bitch Fork, like not even Taylor Swift can get in the way of her own of the greatness of her own catalog. All of this is to say I love music videos that she directs for herself aren't that good. And they like she did all of the great Taylor Swift music videos that at least I consider to be the great ones. They are before the era of when she started doing it herself. I also don't think that the all too well-ten is that good. Well, it's, I mean, I like Sadie Singh. I guess my take would be, my take as someone you know, absolutely like projecting onto a person that I don't know who I can only observe in public settings would be that she's not doing it yet because she's like scared and not good at it. Yeah, yeah, it doesn't know how. I mean, I think it's hard to like reach the pinnacle of something. You know, like she is at the pinnacle of being a musical artist or has been and then to like start over and do something you don't know how to do. It's like yeah, I'd like to write fiction. I don't fucking know how and like to and to have to learn something and do it in a public a somewhat public manner because what are the other options like privately directing secret feature films until you're good at it. Like she's probably going to do some failing, you know. And sort of has been I guess in these little music video formats. Yeah. Did she take out the bridge in the music video? Did she take out the bridge and put in the scene in the car? Yeah, yeah. That's so interesting. I don't like listening to that bridge, but I also didn't like that scene. Oh, no, I didn't either. It's a it's a whole different low point. Um, so that section of the song is just troubled really haunted. It's really it's like we're going at least for me personally, like we're in a pretty good space for the first two minutes or so and then things just they just go off the rails. It's a shame. Yeah, here's my deal. I like liking Taylor Swift songs. There's nothing better. And so these were same. These were this was a confusing, this was a confusing weekend for me to be receiving these one upside of it quickly is that all over my timeline were these girls, these nor these gals. I I don't know anything of I haven't dug any deeper. I haven't done my general spiral. I don't know who these women are, but they are frequently wearing they sort of dress for the the album that they're listening to and live reacting to and they do these big over the top live reactions to listening to the songs. And one of them looks almost exactly like Carly Claus. And I think it's funny. I think it's funny. I don't know them. I don't know them to be like their new to you. Yeah, no, they're new to me. Uh, they were new to me and it did it did have a sort of state media. I think internet of kind of escaping just Taylor Swift this time because there's one moment when they're listening to oh, it's when it's when patient zero gets the bridge and one of them looks like she breaks. Yeah, like it looks like it broke her when she starts to sort of laugh in a different way. Um, but only time will tell. Yeah, I support them in their work. Talk about trying really hard to support women, even when you're not sure if you should be. We got to get into a couple of a couple of we're obsessed book club articles that that we've read over the last little bit. One was something that I'd been interested in. Like I kept seeing photos and videos of it and was like what it's going on. And finally, everybody say thank you wired, who does a lot of important work out there. And did a little investigative journalism that came along with the headline. SeaWorld wants to make you horny. And I had been getting that impression. I was pretty confused about it. You had to bring me in on this one. You hadn't seen this before the videos even. Okay. So earlier this month on September 11th, uh, SeaWorld or Lando opened what is apparently an annual exhibit six years running, the Hello Scream event, which is an after hours Halloween themed immersive experience at SeaWorld, which features various scare zones. So there's like, um, uh, one based on, uh, I know what you did last summer, like various sort of traditional horror films. This is not an unusual thing to happen around Halloween. The art director at SeaWorld had the novel idea. Oh, damn it. I did a pun. I hate that. You have to make it with it now to make a romanticy themed zone, uh, that includes hunky tortured romanticy antiheroes, uh, that people are either familiar with from actually reading the books or from the concept of book talk smut. One very funny thing about this exhibit is that like they don't have the rights to any specific antiheroes. Like from the, the thorns books or the crap, all of those, um, so it's just guys in, uh, masks, with painted on abs. Yeah, like they didn't, they didn't even get the sort of the old school outside of Abercrombie guys to do those. No, no, they're, they're dealing with Orlando's finest, which is to say not Abercrombie's finest. No offense. These men are working hard and I'm scared for them. Um, I just like, so this went kind of, it went viral when people started like book talkers and content creators of Orlando started visiting this, um, this exhibit, this zone. The visuals are not to be missed. Sasha, please show some of these men. Sasha, you have to show the one where he slides on his knee pads. This man will not stop sliding. There is one man. Also, by the way, I cannot imagine anything less erotic to me than a man approaching me by like sliding into the room, like he's in the pirates of Penn's hands. And like, this is where it becomes pretty evident that I understand the ways in which women especially become drawn into these, these antiheroes of romanticy and sort of, you know, get a little more comfortable with some gray areas in fantasy that they would not be comfortable with in real life. But then when you bring that then into real life in the form of actors and cosplay, it's so hard. Also, this is a sea world. What is it? Sea world. Like, this is what's happening at sea world. After hours, we already know the bad stuff that's happening at sea world. Yeah, during hours. Now there's worse stuff. Although, that is my judge. I'm trying to try really hard to stay non-judgmental as we talk about these things because I know that there are people who genuinely enjoy it and aren't going to this. That's not a promise made on behalf of the entire book. It's not for you. I only speak for myself. And I, it's a, it's not a promise. It's a try. I have a cup of water and because condensation, it's on a coaster. And every time I pick it up, the coaster comes up with it for a second. Let the coaster go babe. That's not real wood. So it's like maybe, well, Remi gave it to me and I want to be respectful of the furniture, even though you hate this table. No, I hate that table. You want me to ruin it? Remi was like real rings on it. Yeah, yeah, forget the coaster. Who cares? It's just like every time I'm about to see something incredibly rude and me inspired it, I pick up this gift and just falls to the floor. I like that you need a, you need a dramatic prop also when you're about to say yo shit. They at Nora. Well, I mean, look, like things that I have a spectrum of, I'm just not interested to, I'm actively antagonistic towards, include being scared, romanticy, Halloween, sea worlds, and theme parks. This is really a perfect storm for you. Yeah. Things that I have a really hard time with are men who look like machine gun Kelly. And that is what this place is, they got all the machine gun Kelly's in Orlando. And like to be honest, they also have a few Phoebe Bridges. They got every Draco mouthway look alike and put them in a little masquerade mask and airbrush abs on and gave them knee pads. And so like it's, so I got a hand it to Jesse Kinsey, the art director of SeaWorld Orlando. She, I believe I'm reading between the lines, being a bit of a romanticy reader and writer herself had the idea that this would be like a spectacle, a big hit if they did this. And she was right. Ultimately it has had the largest opening night of any one of these sea world Halloween events in the last six years that they've been doing it. Like sea world like into Halloween. I think it's like, well, you know, I always really worry about businesses that are like, we're coffee shop in the day and we're a bar at night. It's an all day space. They never last. Yeah, we never last. And I think that SeaWorld much like universal studios is like, okay, how do we make some money at night? We've got this, we have this big space. We got to get some Draco mouthways in here. And Nora, they're right. It's a seasonal opportunity, I guess. But like, this is not traditionally scary. You know, this is not like someone coming at you at a chain saw, like at a Halloween event you'd like to go to if you like to be scared. Well, also, and maybe this is just the stuff that's ending up on the internet. But like, I don't know what the hours are every video that I stay like, it's daylight. It's always light outside. I think it's like six feet. It's dusk. But they actually did create a space that is my worst nightmare by making it so that like, I would have to, I guess be expected to like find this horny and like be in a sort of flirtatious situation with these machine gun kelly's slipping and sliding around and going, like, it's a lot of going like, it is impossible for me. I'm really trying to have an open mind. It is impossible for me to put myself in the mindset of someone who thinks, I want to go to SeaWorld and be horny. Because I could read you this single funniest line in this wire piece, which is one of the content creators who goes and she says, this is as it was written. I wouldn't say it was scary set a creator who declined to provide their name because they did not want to jeopardize their relationship with SeaWorld. Your last mission is to jeopardize your relationship with SeaWorld. Then they continued, but it did leave me with a good feeling. I guess you could say a sexy feeling in a way. No, this is like a book top creator who this situation is tailor-made for who's still having to be like, I guess you could call it a sexy feeling. Okay, I'm sort of speechless. I mean, that's it. It's like, there's nothing complex to this except that I can't believe that it's that it's happening. Also, I just can't visually sing it and be like, what the hell is going on because the SeaWorld zone is marked by this really big book that's sort of like the visual, is this really big book, the text of which was written by the creator of SeaWorld. And it has the budget. We'll say that. It has been in very large letters. Good girls go for the bad boy. And I just kept seeing on TikTok this book that said good, this giant book that said good girls go for the bad boy. And then Machine Gungelly coming in and out on his knee pads. And I was like, what is this event? And this is what it was at SeaWorld. see world is just the one. It is an only specific phenomenon at this point. I think there used to be a couple because I'm pretty sure there was one like in Texas when I was growing up. See worlds are there. Four active sea world theme parks operating worldwide. San Diego, California, Orlando, Florida, San Antonio, Texas and Abu Dhabi. A former park in Ohio operated from 1970 to 2000 before closing and transitioning into different use. And there's an unrelated park named SeaWorld in Australia. No relation. They only do Hornie event. I'm stuck on Abu Dhabi SeaWorld. Don't go there. That's really cursed. No, that makes a lot of sense. I can see their bad situation. Okay. This is sort of where my mind was. I want to paint a picture for you as I was like they're doing romance to see exhibits at SeaWorld. They're really popular. People are loving and hating it. And then I also knew that right now, although the more I see the more I think I really shan't watch it. That there is a movie on that came out this weekend, I think, on prime called the love hypothesis. It stars Lily Reinhart. And she and I've known about this movie because she has been doing this thing where she's dressing in like very famous romcom looks at a lot of different events for a movie that is coming out on prime. Why was like what's going on here? Why does why does this direct to prime movie have so many premieres so many premieres. And okay, so this movie has actually come out. And I have found out that the love hypothesis is originally based on a star wars fan fiction. And what you know, this has been happening. All movies now are based on a Harry Styles fan. Yes. But that this one was a star wars fan fiction about Ray and Kylo Ren. And which is especially funny for this movie because the lead actor in it. Tom Bateman is married to Daisy Ridley who plays Ray in the star wars films. Anyways, I was just really interested to find this out. See what's going out there on the romcom streets. And then quite literally I was like. People still reading fan fiction like what's going on with fan fiction. And then wouldn't you know it the cut has an article for me. Yes. And they this week are also doing this kind of like spicy week where they're doing a lot of essays and pieces about. I guess smut. Yeah. More or less. Yeah. But Jen Ortiz who is the cuts deputy editor wrote an essay called titled Why are you so into this life before and after heated rivalry fan fiction. Where she very vulnerably documents her sort of obsessive spiral into heated rivalry fan fiction. And I learned that this is like this is really taking over a lot of people's lives. Yeah. I mean, she begins this essay in a way that I think is really funny by saying that give her take she has read 14 million words of heated rivalry fan fiction over the past year. And relates it to it being like getting through Robert cars. I really I got to tell you I mean, I know that show came out in December, but it's so far this year. So actually in nine months she's read. Sure. Yes. And in this calendar year as opposed to the last 12 months. The entire Lyndon B Johnson series. A dozen ish times. Which really put it in perspective for me. Yeah. And then goes on to say that however the difference between those books is there is not a version of Lyndon B Johnson who has the ability to turn himself into a dog. So he can cuddle his downtrodden neighbor as the two of them fall in love. And that's true. And that's true. That's a good point. And Nora is there a version where there's a veteran porn star who instead of getting all about eaved by a young cocky cowboy lives happily and hornally hornally ever after with them. Which is to say that that is what at least I guess two of the heated rivalry fan fictions that she has read in this past year have been about. And I appreciated how many setups for the fan fix. Yeah, she listed over the course of this as they because that was illuminating for me. Love Island contestants, a bachelor producer and the bachelor himself if you are completely unfamiliar with fan fiction, this would be setting up that the two main characters from heated rivalry are in these. There are musicians in these narrative positions in various fan fictions. A guy working the late shift at a seven 11 and a rich Russian mob boss a bounty hunter and a guy with a price on his head a yoga teacher in his student best selling authors a restaurant said chef and a pastry chef I mean it goes on and on and on. She says I haven't yet read the one where Shane is a kitten and Ilya adopts him but it's on my list. That's always where they lose me. It's just how do you is when they make them a kid? Yeah, how do you write? How do you write from that POV? How do you write from the POV of the kid? And I read I can't remember if it. Thank you. Don't turn me on, Nora. I can't remember if it was in this piece or the. It must have been but we're also going to talk about this this piece in L about a sort of. Movement of mostly in women that since they watched heated rivalry in December. Have been leaving their husbands as a direct result of having watched heated rivalry and and then read it and experienced it. And it's said that like sense heated rival or like in the weeks following heated rivalry like 265 fan fictions. New fan fictions were posted to archive of our own aka A03 every day. That's so many. It's a lot. It is a lot. It's. It is interesting because and Jen's reading them all Jen is reading them all. Yeah, and I and I appreciated that in her piece. I mean. She was pretty. She was very vulnerable and sort of exploring the line of. This reasonable behavior. And is this healthy. And she actually kind of comes down on the side of I guess if we assume that there is something inherently unhealthy about an addiction which she says that it literally is. That it's not one that's like particularly harmful so it's okay but she does call it an addiction and she does describe herself as. You know, I guess you would extrapolate from that having a certain sickness. And it comes across as an addiction that's it's a it's a as you might expect from the deputy editor of the cut. It's a very well written and well drawn essay. So like especially if you're wanting to read something that kind of makes you feel insane but also is good. I would recommend it. But she yeah, I mean it she. She says it feels like an addiction. She paints it like an addiction. She talks about that she is reading. He did rivalry and it doesn't seem like she's gotten into any other. Any other fandoms like it is he don't he did rivalry specific. She is reading fanfiction as she falls asleep. She is reading it when she wakes up. She is reading it as she walks to just salad for lunch. She says she has a three minute walking commute from her office to the just salad. And she feels the compulsion to devote those three minutes to reading heated rivalry fanfiction. That one stood out to me just because it's like the image of someone in a crosswalk like maybe getting hit by a bus because they're reading. Read it or fanfic and God, you hope your phone has a self-destruct button on it at that point. It is not the way I want to go. Someone to be talking about. Pro States and Fairamones or whatever when your phone is found open and it's the reason you went down and we don't hope that for her. But I also thought it's it stood out to me the times when she talks about that she's trying not to read it like she does have some boundaries including when she wakes up in the middle of the night. She tries not to then open fanfiction and read it then even though she's reading it until she falls asleep and the moment that she wakes up. And she's falling asleep later than she like she's she's losing sleep to devote more hours than the day to this one more chapter. She also talks to several other people experiencing a similar addiction who talk about reading it at work having like a second screen open for their remote work to be able to read it in between emails. And that it is it is a very interesting very niche phenomenon the way in which this six episode television. about two young men falling in love has like, and this is for these women's words and these pieces, sort of like reorganize their brain chemistry. - Yeah. - And made them think that the fanfiction piece is a little different than the piece in L. And for me, just someone like observing these videos happening is that there's one really popular user who comes across my Instagram feed. I think her name is like, Ren reads something. And she talks very openly about how she left her husband and asked for a divorce after watching heated rivalry. L talked to many different women of many different ages who have also done this exact same thing. Like as a direct result of experiencing the love story and heated rivalry have left their heterosexual marriages. And it's nothing new for like straight women to be have different access to a way of like experiencing sexuality or love or romantic story through a story about two gay men. And I encourage any person, but especially a heterosexual woman to evaluate their relationship and should they find it lacking? Know that they can leave it and they will be oftentimes if it's bad enough, better off. But I find it such an interesting reaction to heated rivalry, which is about two young men finding love. It's not about them being in a long-term partnership and like something that the LP said is that a lot of these women, it made them think about like the division of labor in their relationship, the equality, the lack of intimacy, these things that almost like they were settling on before and this story. And I mean, I guess it's just a shake up. They found a love story that they really liked and it made them think about what they didn't have. But it is also a fictional and fantasy love story. Well, I think yeah, so you do kind of, you don't even really have to do all that much reading between the lines. To clock that these are not necessarily all relationships that were on steady ground before this. There's one of these women who uses as an example of the problems in her marriage that she gets panic attacks and her husband didn't believe in them and would tell her to get over them. So that's troubling, right? But I wonder if maybe you're leaving your husband more because of that than because of heated rivalry. But I do think that there, like you made the joke that basically everything is a Harry Styles fanfiction. Like the one direction is the universe that has spawned the most fanfiction that I am the most aware of. That is in part because there's a really excellent book about that fandom by Caitlin Tiffany, who's a great writer, called everything I need to get from you. And when you sent these articles, I picked up my copy of that book and was just sort of like thumbing through it being like, what does this sort of say about? Phenomenons that have something in common with this. And she has a chapter on kind of the idea of like the, the screaming fan girl and someone who has taken a certain type of fandom to extremes that people look at and go, is this socially appropriate? Is this evidence of a certain type of like psychosis? And part of what she does in that chapter is draw some connections between like the one direction fandom and Beetlemania and various examples of this throughout history and culture. And one thing that she sort of identifies it is that often these groups of mostly young people and often young women who exhibit these behaviors, it's like there's a sentence that she has where it's like, they're rioting against something without having something to riot towards, to riot for. It's like when people experience, and this is often something that happens to young women on the verge of adolescence, the feeling of kind of a certain type of wall, the walls of conformity and like society's expectations of women, they close in that creates this very fertile ground for developing a fan affinity that kind of makes you crazy or like act a little crazy because you need an outlet for that. Yeah, and you need some, you need a place where you can go and sort of scream and behave in these ways that are a little bit anti-social because you feel it, but you also don't have, you don't have the cause that's not like sort of a random thing that exists in culture. And all of that felt very relative to a relevant to these stories. The difference, of course, is that in those examples, we are mostly talking about teenagers. And there's something about the heated rivalry thing where it is fascinating because I think we're largely talking about women who are later into adulthood or at least are adults. Yeah, I mean, it's really interesting to like see it a very similar thing of like needing to rail against a system that oppresses you and at this point in your life, at point for some of the people in this L piece, 25 years into a marriage to feel the ways in which you felt maybe like pressured into settling is something that these various women talk about a lot and that like, and you don't have to take it anymore. Now, for that feeling to have come around from a similar way for like a teenager experiencing fandom for like a 50 year old woman experiencing fandom is interesting, a unique story I haven't heard a lot before. But it creates this similar dynamic that you're talking about of having like something to rally against failing heterosexual relationship and not necessarily something to rally toward. I think like that's where I can remove myself from judgment of something that is like very difficult to understand is something easier to understand which is like at the end of the piece. The author said many women I spoke with said it would be better to be lonely as a single person than to feel lonely in a relationship. And I, so I think it's easy to like hear that these women are leaving their marriages because they watched a six episode series on HBO and be like, okay, but you're not, that's fiction. You're not gonna find that. And you hope that it's not like that that's than what they're looking for. But if it's just the thing that made them realize that like they weren't satisfied, right? Then that seems okay. If not a little strange, like I think it can be okay and also strange at the same time. And also even in the, even in the cut piece, I mean, and it sounds as though she has a healthy marriage but she does describe how she and her husband, his work has taken him to a different place so they're in a state of temporary long distance, which I think is she describes as being challenging and sounds as though she has more child care burdens because of that temporary situation and is like going through a hard time when this is also happening. And I don't know, like I don't know if it is actually me being judgmental that's making me go, I think I maybe see some connection between the fact that you're going through a challenging time in your life and you're exhibiting these behaviors for it. - No, that's not, she's saying that, yeah. Like I think it's fair. - And many people do. But what's interesting is that she ends the piece at the time at which we find her right now in a better place. Like her partner is back, her life feels more manageable and she's like, and I still don't want to stop reading this. - She does want to cut back a little. - But she doesn't want to stop. - She has read like, 'cause there are some examples where people are talking about how they are like dropping out of their book clubs because they don't want to read anything else. And like that's not, I don't do that. - No, don't do it. But like it's, you know, and if somebody is closing themselves off to their avenues for social connection and also the expanding of their lived experience with the world through other types of literature, like I don't think that's healthy. - It is so interesting to like view and to have the way that these people describe it. fantasy as this addiction. It really has all of the markers of addiction, but that the results of that addiction is so much less obviously harmful than any other addiction. They're not losing money. They're not, maybe they're losing time and maybe they're losing sleep. And then they have this like awareness of that thing. I think I need to get on top of this, but is it really that bad? It's just like the brain does love iteration. Yeah. And like culture, like content that is very familiar, but has a different little twist every time is I don't have the language and the facts and figures to describe this. I think this is like maybe there's a there's a chapter about this in one of Chuck Closterman's books, but it's like been studied that that is that is kind of the easiest way to make something popular is to have it be something that is largely familiar, but just like has a slightly different twist and take. And like that that describes fan fiction, right? Like that is a very that is that kind of and they could in the cut piece she compares that as well to like comic books and to Marvel and the iterating that happens there in various universes. Like it's taking a story that you're familiar with. So you already have that familiarity. You don't have to learn something new and then putting it in a slightly new place that makes it interesting and fresh for you to just keep living in this world that feels more manageable than yours. And yeah, and that's a very that's a very appealing foundation in a lot of ways. I don't know. I don't know that I've totally wrapped my hand around. You don't have to wrap your head around it. It's something that's happening that I was just like well, no, isn't that interesting. Yeah. I did see it. Did you see that Carly Rae Jepsen named her child Ilya, I think I did see that and that's my girl that gave me pause. I mean was it specifically for the heated rivalry here? Yeah. Also like the timeline is but like honestly at least it made her fuck, you know, like not that she wasn't before but like yeah, you have some evidence that it just kind of baby. No, I know I'm saying you have some evidence so you feel good about it. I guess I'm just like I don't I don't want I don't like the idea of people's experience of sensuality being like completely detached from sex. Like actual like the actual having of the sex. Yes. And I hope yeah, I mean one of these people is like like you know, I like reading fan fiction on my way to work, but then I'm horny on the sea train and you know, ideally you can then have something to do with that that will feel fulfilling. Not on the sea train, please. Honestly, better than it's the world. And with that Nora. We asked a question last week that I wasn't realizing would it get us would keep us so firmly in like really specific obsession territory, but I love it. I love it. And the variety of the answers we received who knew. I know. But last week we asked what's the saved search you check you check in on most often or you would be most excited to get a hit on. And we opened this up beyond, you know, just the real real saved searches are just shopping. What's your RSS feed? What are your Google terms? And damn people are keeping track is so much. I know. And one of them actually because I just brought up Carly Rae Jepsen. One of them from Emily was that she searches for a bucket hat that Carly Rae sold to accompany the track Beach House. It's a bright pink bucket hat covered in beach themed motifs. And she really regrets that she didn't buy it immediately. And now they're gone forever. And no one seems willing to part with theirs. Second hand, but she's constantly looking and hoping to someday get lucky. And hopes that putting this out into the universe will help. Emily, what do you think about the fact that Carly Rae, who I also adore, named her kid after he did rivalry. Let us know in the comments. Yeah, definitely let us know. And please specify which Emily you are because we actually got a trio of Emily responses. Sometimes we get a lot of Katie's and sometimes we get a lot of Emily's. This was an Emily week. And the range of Emily's really kind of ranged the gamut of the kinds of responses we got. There were a lot of people like looking for a very nostalgic specific piece. Kind of like the Carly Rae Jepsen bucket hat. Someone was looking for a very specific pair of red dance go clogs. And they want now. And all I'll say is watch your ankles. They are supportive. But the dance goes create a very weak ankle to be another Emily gave a perfect answer for her constant search, which is that she has been waiting for a LinkedIn post on where my terrible fired boss ends up been waiting for a year now. Smiley face emoticon. Emily, I actually did know you had it. And yeah, hell yeah. That's dirty work. Rock. I mean, I mean, a category that a category was like keeping tabs on your enemies. Nora, I'm actually going to say a dominant care. That was a yes. Yeah, a majority. And keeping tabs on your exes. Yeah. Maybe while we locate one of those, I also really enjoyed a sweet run from another Emily to close out our trios of Emily. She said, this is how I learned I might be built different because my only Google alert is my elderly former neighbor who is 96. I catch up with her every so often, but we don't talk enough that I'll know when she dies. So I need that obituary straight into my inbox. Yeah. And like, I'm just not organized like that. But it's important to her. I know. I know. I just there are things that are important to me that I'm not doing a good enough job on being organized about. And I will say I got I got a good bit of support in that way of people relating that they don't have like the executive function to appropriately do save searches, including Stella, who is the person who said that she is routinely checking Facebook marketplace for a specific pair of red dance go clogs that I had as a kid. They were the most fabulous shoe I ever owned. And as a 25 year old lady, I really want to embrace that. Patent. That's what I'm seeing. Yeah. That's a good clog. I would own it in this way. Love to create like a weird obsessed marketplace because someone's got to have. I know. I know. I want to like say all of this so that people just in case I mean, just in case anybody has the Carly Rae Jepsen Beach House bucket hat and is willing to part with it. Here's one that's about keeping track of your enemies. I'm going to anonymize this. Just just can't be too careful. Yes. I thank you. There were a few where I was like, how are you saying this with your first name? This one, this one, I think I'm probably being overly cautious because unfortunately many such cases. But it's the blog page of my former best friend turned Christian nationalist LOL. I would be keeping those tabs as well. That's what he kept. I related to this so much from Amanda about just like specific things that I've had in my life that I'm forever seeking. She said, I routinely check to see if Starbucks will bring back the cherry mocha they sold for one month in February 2018. It's my white whale. Starbucks. Come on. Don't bring something cherry and chocolate to the world that you can't keep up. So it was very clearly a Valentine's Day, a Valentine's Day special that Amanda needs back. One that I really related to was from Julia who said, for 10 years, I had an e-mail alert for Grace Wedchert from Elizabeth and James, which is pre-the-ro Marik8noshley's brand, which I actually always wonder why Elizabeth and James isn't like people should be searching for particularly given their place in the fashion world and how people feel about the route. I'm always like, why are we not searching for a vintage Elizabeth and James? Anyway, this is the part that I really relate to. She said, two years ago it came up, I got it, and you know for a fact I have never worn the sweatshirt not even one time. I also liked this one. Things from the J-Crew catalog circa 2007 that I couldn't afford back then. Yep. There is like, there is something nostalgic to these things. Oh, the one that said that they're always searching the name of my crush from when I was 14. It's just elusive and I want to know what he's doing these days. Yeah. No internet footprint, a very worthy crush. Yeah. And it's good to keep up that way. Can I give you two more that I just left? Of course. One, I'm gonna anonymize us. Did he die? You know the one. I do. That's from everyone. I do know the one. and then the other one from Maddie. Until Friday, it was the Humane Society, but I brought my pup Allie home. Yay! Congratulations, Maddie, and congratulations, Allie. You're gonna have such a good home, I bet. Oh, win. I loved that so much that made my day. I see this one as an ISO, sometimes on Poshmark. Also, I would like to shout out the person who responded to the Instagram story that was like, give us your, you know, your Poshmark and you're the real, real, like, what are you looking for on there? And someone said, what about Vinted? Nora? You know, I've been fucking up Vinted. Is what about Vinted? This is my fan fiction. Like, I gotta get off Vinted. I know it's not doing anything good for me. Or is it? Or did I find myself a few things that I want? Vain is the Vinted platform and Ilya is the user who's taking a break from Poshmark. Then who's the cat? The cat is at home with Alex. Like, you may need to say it. Yeah, Alex is the dog. Maddie is the person. Anyways, if anyone wants to confer in the DMs or the Spotify comments about Vinted, I'm so far past Vinted, curious. Because when I first, my friend who does resell on the sales side was like, have you ever looked at Vinted? Like, it's kind of, and I was like, you get on and it is the worst user experience possible. And then you like, you know, find a Tom Ford era Gucci bag for $50 and you're like, well, I guess I live here now. Yeah. Anyways, I relate to you. Also this, when we are saying like, maybe you can find red dance go clogs on the weird obsessed marketplace. It's making me think about the story from the Samaritan life. Like, it was like, they did it on their social channels about how they found out that children were communicating in their Spotify comments. Like children who aren't allowed to have phones. And I wrote glass interviews, the little kids and one of the little, he's like, how did you choose in PR to like, do this on? And he was like, well, we just tried to find a place where there weren't a lot of comments. And I would like for people to start shopping their weird obsessed wares in the this American life comment section. I love it. Or just hours. I'll end with this, which I really, really related to from Alyssa, that she is forever in search of the OG Vander pump rules surdress for a biblically accurate Halloween costume. Hell yeah. And I also say, I know this meant a lot to Sasha. I know it meant a lot to Sasha. Who's doing a Vander pump rules rewatch? And I'm going to send her a few edits to patient zero from Vander pump rules, which I also know she's really going to appreciate. They cut it out before the bridge. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah, Nora. It's just that Stasi is patient zero for Jacks and Kristen is patient zero for sandable. And that's not a community that you want to be in. It's just not, but there is a song for it now. Thank goodness. Nora, thank you for joining me here today in this sort of troubled time for you personally. Wait, Joe, what? We can't forget to say the new question. Okay, you do it. Do it. Okay, the question for next week. This is a great one. And, you know, topical. What is your most, don't judge me, obsession or passion or hobby? Is it a style of fan fiction? Is it, I tried to think about this for myself and I think it is like my extremely earnest love of shark movies. Just don't judge me. I think mine is mine is the like really boycoded YouTube series that I love shout out jet lag the game. Nora, I almost put that in the dock. I was going to be like, I think that Nora is her like knock off amazing race that she watches. You know what, Jody? You know what, Jody? They are the season finale is airing in theaters. They're getting a theatrical release. Are you going? Hell yeah. And they won't judge you. I haven't gotten it yet, but I really do want to go, I love those boys so much. They're in Japan. We promise. Of course they are. They're racing. They're racing from top to bottom of Japan. They're looking for something. And we promise a no judgment zone. As you tell us, your most don't judge me obsessions, but we don't promise not to laugh at you, which is in good natured friendship between all of us. Yes, absolutely. And with that, thank you, Nora, for your beautiful mind. Thank you to Sasha. Thank you to Rimi in the booth. And we will see you back here on Friday on We Are Obsessed. Bye.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The episode explores obsession, using Taylor Swift’s *Life of the Showgirl* album and its encore as a central example of fan-driven, emotionally charged cultural phenomena.
  2. A key theme is the paradox of Taylor Swift’s artistic direction—returning to country music and re-imagining her early work while simultaneously releasing a critically divisive, emotionally erratic track like "Patient Zero."
  3. The podcast analyzes the "Patient Zero" music video and song, noting its confusing narrative, AI-like production, and offensive bridge, which many listeners perceive as a disconnect from Swift’s usual emotional authenticity.
  4. The discussion turns to the cultural obsession with dating apps and the "Boston" cast of *Lovis Blind*, where exaggerated, formulaic bios reveal deep-seated fears and romantic ideals, highlighting how pop culture reflects millennial anxieties about love and identity.
  5. The SeaWorld "Hello Scream" exhibit is examined as a commercial spectacle that commodifies romantic fantasy, featuring macho antiheroes and cosplay, raising concerns about the eroticization of fantasy and the boundaries between fantasy and reality.
  6. The episode questions whether Taylor Swift is engaging in self-reflective or self-sabotaging creative acts, driven by a need to respond to public criticism and the pressure of maintaining a public persona.
  7. A recurring theme is the tension between artistic ambition and public perception—Swift’s music often reflects a defensive, reactive stance toward criticism, blurring the line between self-awareness and self-justification.
  8. The conversation ends on a note of cultural irony, where fan reactions to Swift’s music and pop culture trends reveal a deeper yearning for emotional connection, authenticity, and escape from judgment.

Summary:

This episode of *Rear Obsessed* delves into the concept of obsession in modern pop culture, using Taylor Swift’s *Life of the Showgirl* album and its subsequent "encore" as a central lens. The hosts examine how Swift’s creative output—particularly the song "Patient Zero"—reflects both artistic ambition and emotional vulnerability, yet also reveals contradictions in tone and structure, including a problematic, AI-sounding bridge that many find jarring. The discussion extends to broader cultural phenomena, such as the romanticized, formulaic dating profiles in the Netflix series *Lovis Blind*, which mirror millennial anxieties about love, commitment, and identity.

The podcast also analyzes SeaWorld’s "Hello Scream" Halloween exhibit, which features macho antiheroes and fantasy-themed cosplay, as a commercial spectacle that commodifies eroticized romance and raises concerns about the blurring of fantasy and reality. Throughout, the hosts highlight how fan reactions to Swift’s music and pop culture trends reveal a deep desire for emotional authenticity, connection, and escape from judgment. While Swift’s work often appears defiant or reactive to criticism, the episode suggests it may also reflect an internal struggle with self-perception, fame, and the pressure to maintain a curated public image.

Ultimately, the conversation underscores how obsession—whether in music, love, or fantasy—serves as a coping mechanism in a world where authenticity feels increasingly rare.

FAQs

Calzadonia is highlighted as a niche brand that sells both tights and bathing suits, which the podcasters find surprising and interesting due to its undergarment-focused products. The store's layout and design are noted to resemble airport stores, adding to its unique and recognizable presence.

The podcasters discuss their past obsession with spanks faux-leather leggings, describing it as a form of emotional fixation. This ties into the broader theme of obsession in pop culture, showing how specific fashion choices can become deeply personal and compulsive.

The term 'chugie' is introduced as a millennial pop culture term that the podcasters admit they don’t fully understand, but which they believe is part of a larger cultural trend or phenomenon being explored in the episode.

The podcasters express fascination with the Boston season of Lovis Blind, noting its unique dating dynamics, including a grid of profiles featuring men from the Seaport area. They speculate on the cultural and romantic significance of these characters, such as a 37-year-old beekeeper wearing a bull tie with a bee.

The captions on the dating profiles are described as emotionally revealing and oddly poetic, often stemming from questionnaire-style prompts. These include statements like 'I wouldn’t sacrifice my dog for love' or 'my fear is marrying the wrong person', offering insight into personal values and fears.

The podcast questions whether 'Patient Zero' is an encore to 'Lifeline of a Showgirl', pointing to Easter eggs like references to 50 Shades of Gray and a music video featuring Dakota Johnson. They also critique the song’s bridge as out of place and AI-sounding, and note its emotional tone as defensive rather than authentic.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.