The Humanities in Crisis: On the Value of Creative Labour and Spirituality with Marie Trotter
35m 50s
Sally Rooney’s *Beautiful World, Where Are You?* is analyzed through the lens of humanities scholarship, revealing its engagement with deep social, existential, and political themes. The novel’s complex, reflective style resists easy interpretation, mirroring the intellectual rigor and internal struggle of its characters. Central to the narrative is a critique of millennial malaise—defined as constant hyper-awareness of global crises and a paralyzing anxiety that permeates daily life. Religion and spirituality are explored not as answers but as points of contemplation, with Simon’s stable faith contrasted against Alice’s growing, hesitant curiosity. A subtle Marxist undercurrent emerges in the characters’ recognition of exploitation and consumption without meaningful action, highlighting a gap between awareness and change. Class and labor are interrogated, as characters assign value to their identities based on work type, revealing a narrow, often dehumanizing view of labor. The novel also reflects on the crisis of the humanities, where academic labor is undervalued economically despite its cultural and emotional significance. Through its email format, the narrative simulates open, accessible academic discourse, making philosophical and existential questions public and relatable. Ultimately, Rooney’s work does not provide definitive answers but instead offers a nuanced exploration of identity, meaning, and the human condition in a world marked by anxiety and uncertainty.
Welcome to Reading Rooney, an exercise in collaborative scholarship.
On this podcast, you will hear from a variety of book lovers, including English literary
scholars, graduate students, and general readers, as we openly discuss, celebrate, and critique
the work of author Sally Rooney.
I'm your host, Christina Marcucci, and wherever you are, thank you sincerely for being
here.
Today I am joined by Marie Trotter, a PhD student in the Department of English at McGill University.
She studies Renaissance drama with an emphasis on meta-theater in both contemporary and
historical performances of Shakespeare.
Marie also writes arts and theater criticism, poetry, and plays.
In this episode, we explore the emphasis on the value of creative labor in beautiful
world where are you, linking it to some of our own experiences as humanity scholars.
We also chat about the themes of religion, spirituality, and the search for meaning in
the novel.
Here's our conversation.
So, my first broad question is just when you think about the writing of Sally Rooney,
what is the first word that comes to your mind?
Oh gosh.
Well, I should preface this by saying I've only read one through books, and I've only
read beautiful world, where are you?
The first word that comes to my mind is complex, but I don't know that that's an accurate
description of how I feel about her work, but I think that there's something about it
that, for me, when reading the book, I felt sort of a complexity that was resisting
easy meaning.
For me, as the reader, that it took a while for me to get into her style and to realize
this was her narrative voice and then to settle into reading it.
Do you think that's in part because of the form?
I think so, yeah.
So I started reading this book with no prior knowledge of Rooney as an author, and then
I remember from the very beginning just realizing, oh, this is a totally different narrative
style than what I'm accustomed to, and it is kind of opaque at first.
And she, I think, resists giving you easy information that other authors would make
obvious right away.
Yeah, there's something surprisingly nondescript actually about her style of writing.
Yes.
Yeah, that's a good word for it.
You cited the themes, Catholicism, religion, and the search for meaning as being very
kind of operative in beautiful worlds.
Could you speak a little bit more to that?
Sure.
Yeah.
So I was doing kind of a quick reread for our conversation, and I think that something
I noticed this time that I didn't pick up on last time was sort of the skepticism that
is underlying in Rooney's spreading.
And I think this comes out most through Eileen and Alice.
So I'm thinking specifically of the scene where Simon goes to Mass and Alice goes with
him, or sorry, I lead goes with him.
I get the two mixed up.
I lead goes with him to Mass and is skeptical the entire time and is wondering why is this
something Simon's doing and how is he totally uneironic about religious faith?
So I think skepticism is the main thing that I noticed that Rooney is kind of considering
through the character of Simon, what religious faith looks like, but from that outsider perspective.
So it's not really what religious faith looks like for an individual, but how it is seen
by others who are at a distance from it, I think.
And maybe also how it defines their sense of identity and belonging.
I think there's a long, it's either Eileen or Alice who says that, or maybe even Felix,
that Simon is less anxious or something like that because he has a very clear worldview.
And like a set of like structuring principles.
Whereas I think Alice and Eileen are both quite confused about their identity and their
place in the world in maybe an existential way that Simon is not.
I think so and I think that they seem maybe envious of that, even if they don't explicitly
say it that way.
I think Alice ends up being more open to the idea of God and the idea of religion towards
the end of the book.
But yeah, there's, you know, again, that same passage where Simon and Eileen go to Mass
and Eileen talks about envying Simon.
And it's partly because of kind of the sincerity of his belief but also because she recognizes,
"Oh, he has this principle in his life that I don't have and could it be that he values
God more than he values me?"
And there's sort of an insecurity there that comes up, which I think is really interesting.
And I think that the other characters, Elak of Faith, also feeds into maybe the fatalistic
undertone of this novel or what we'd call a lot of people have called the kind of millennial
malaise or something of the sort.
Right.
And in email to Alice, Eileen asks, "Do you think the problem of the contemporary novel
is simply the problem of contemporary life?"
I agree it seems vulgar, decadent, even epistemically violent to invest energy into the trivialities
of sex and friendship when human civilization is facing collapse.
But at the same time, this is what I do every day.
So obviously, this is a statement about the existential anxieties of working in the creative
sphere in a time of imminent global crises.
But I think the sentiment about the value of art and literature gets also to the heart
of like the crisis of the humanities that we're, you know, you and I are very much.
We talk about a lot.
Could you explain what the crisis is for a general audience that maybe doesn't know?
Sure.
Yeah.
So I think it's a crisis of anxiety over the value of work and the value of the humanities
in a world that does not really create economic space for them.
So you know, why do we invest time and money in the study of literature when literature
doesn't get you a job in the way that the study of finance or technology or science or
whatever gets you a job?
So there's this need for study and work to be materially productive and humanities studies
don't seem productive in the same sense.
I think that they're incredibly productive and valuable in another sense, but it just can't
be quantified, right?
And I think that that anxiety seems to be present in the novel, especially in the way, you
know, Alice and I lean both of you their own work, right?
Because they are both sort of working in the humanities in a sense, making totally different
sums of money and facing kind of questions about the value of their labor.
And I think there's, there's a lot of skepticism about the value of art broadly as like, well,
it's not productive in the same way that, you know, somebody in engineering would be doing
something, quote unquote, productive.
But at the same time, we're reading this book.
There are millions of people reading this material object.
So I think that does kind of speak to, well, there is value.
I don't think it's just for entertainment.
And I think that Rooney is exploring a lot of really important and often uncomfortable
questions in this novel in the same way that us as humanity scholars do often explore
in our work.
Could you talk a little bit about your personal experience with this kind of anxiety over
studying in the humanities?
So you're a PhD student, right?
You've been in this field for a while.
What has that been like?
Well, I've had to justify myself a lot to other people.
Yeah.
And I think that that's a common experience for grad students or early career scholars
in needing to explain why you're willing to invest a lot of time in doing something
again that isn't, you know, materially, financially, very sustainable, productive, whatever.
So I think I've spent a lot of time doing that justification to others and I'm less interested
in it now because it takes me away from the value I believe is in my own work, right?
And the value and the pleasure and excitement I drive from doing literary study.
So taking that posture of the defensive, it causes, I mean, it makes me self-guess myself.
I'm second guessing all the time, right?
So, you know, while that anxiety has been present, I would say it's less present for me now
than it was a couple of years ago.
I think the longer I've actually been in this field, the more I felt, first of all, the
value of the humanities and critical discussion and serious academic work.
But also, more so, my own ability to rest in that and appreciate it and enjoy it without
needing to explain it to others.
So yeah, so in a way, I'm actually kind of, not that I'm doing this all the time, but
I'm sort of rejecting the argument from the start.
And it's like, I don't want to go there with people, I don't want to feel that I have
to defend myself because, again, beginning from that posture of defense is, I think, starting
from a place of insecurity.
Yeah.
Do you think that more work needs to be done in terms of democratizing the kind of knowledge
production that we do in the humanities?
If the kind of knowledge and the kind of research that we were doing is like shared more widely
with the public in a way that's accessible, do you think it would maybe take away or
L.A. some of the justification that we have to do for why
were studying in this field, like do you think it would just maybe give a greater awareness
over what we do, what we actually do, because I think that a lot of the time for people who are
not in this field, it can seem vague, even kind of superficial, or I don't know, self-serving.
Yeah, I think, I don't know if democratization is the way I would put it, but maybe openness,
in that if we make ourselves legible and easy to understand or easy to access, then yeah,
we'd have to do less of that work of justification. So I think partly this is, I think this is really
the responsibility of academics in a way, because we can't just complain that other people don't
understand what we do if we're not willing to explain ourselves properly in a legible and accessible
way. So I noticed this in talking about my own research, because there are a lot of jargon-y terms
that are really familiar to me and would be to other academics or other students, but talking to
someone outside the field, it's not their fault that they don't know a super-specific word that
is familiar to me, right? So I have a responsibility to speak clearly and confidently to explain myself,
not to justify, but to explain myself and to engage in that kind of open conversation.
And I need to return to what you were saying about this book being kind of a consideration of
the humanities in some ways. I think that because of the email format, what we see is to writers
considering ideas and academic questions in a really serious way, but also in a really open
accessible way, right? So if we could have this kind of academic dialogue about our research or
our projects or whatever in an email format, in that kind of everyday accessible open style,
I think that would go a long way to helping people embrace the humanities as a truly human
exercise and not just something that should stay within the academy. And in a way, like those
email exchanges do feel like an open classroom concept. They're dealing with really heavy topics,
like it's not just light and fluffy, what's going on in your personal life. No, they're actually
dealing with things like the threat to human existence and climate change and the search for meaning,
and all of these different things, very similar to the kind of work and dialogue that we have
in our own classrooms. Yeah, and I think, you know, again, as you said, this book being read by
millions of people and being a work of popular fiction is a way that, as you say, the humanities
are really present in everyday public life, right? Even if this is not, and I think you've
talked about this before, Arunia is not really considered an academic writer by any means, right?
And she isn't in the canon yet at this point, but the kind of writing she's doing is engaging
a general readership, a very wide readership in these types of serious discussions in a way that
people clearly are enjoying, right? Because her books have been so popular. And I think that she's
established her fame first, like beautiful world as her third novel. I think had she written this first,
maybe it would have been a different story, but she's established a readership in normal people
in conversations, which read very differently to beautiful world. So I feel like by the time
you reach this novel, we know that she's an amazing writer, but now she is really, I think,
flexing a more intellectual side of her skills in a way that maybe in normal people in conversations,
it's much more like, it's less philosophical, I would say. Okay, yeah, and I haven't read those
two, so I actually don't know as to be able to make the comparison, but I am curious to read them now,
now that I've finished beautiful world. They're very, very different from beautiful world,
but I still think we see the same kind of like tropes coming up of like themes of search for identity
and maybe like anxiety over the state of the world and things like that. For you, what is millennial
malaise? A lot of people have talked about this in terms of, you know, Rune's work expressing
a very millennial condition of living and being in the world, of forming romantic bonds and
friendships and to her character's various forms of labor, but what does it actually mean to be
anxious as a millennial? It's an excellent question. Yeah, so I was thinking about this and
reflecting on it, and I think it connects to what both Eileen and Alice talk about in terms of
being constantly tuned in to a flow of information and being constantly aware of the state of the
world. And I think that with the rise of social media and kind of being intensely bombarded with
news and information all the time, we don't have the luxury of distancing ourselves from reality
as maybe past generations did. I'm not trying to imply the past generations were out of touch,
but I do think that millennials kind of came of age and came into maturity in this time
of constant hyper-awareness, which is not healthy for us. So, you know, when you're making decisions
about work or study or relationships or family or all these things and have constantly in your mind,
this buzz of news information about climate change and about war and devastation and everything,
right? That is continually influencing your thinking about daily life, right? So you can't really
separate out your personal daily life from all the information you're receiving about the rest
of the world, the global world order and everything that is going on, good and bad. So I'd say the
millennial malaise is this kind of hyper-awareness that is quite unhealthy, I think, frankly.
And yeah, I don't know that I can say optimistically that it's going to get better,
that we're going to be able to move to a healthier consumption of media,
but I do think Eileen and Alice are both tuned into that and are reflecting on that in the book,
right? That they are experiencing their daily lives and maybe are more anxious about how one day
their daily lives are because they're aware of so many big and important and quite scary
kind of global events happening around them. Would you say that a beautiful world actually
aestheticizes this constant influx of bad news? Because for me, at least in a way, when I was reading
this, it wasn't boking a little bit of anxiety. I feel like it's grading at times, it's just
constantly kind of reminding us that like climate change is imminent, you know, like just dealing
with very big existential threat. Do you think that in a way kind of mimics or reflects or
aestheticizes the kind of news influx that we're used to experiencing? I agree with you that it's
really present. I don't know if it's aestheticized in a positive way. I think Rooney is drawing our
attention to it by making it so obvious. And you know, just the structure of the novel being these
emails back and forth where Eileen and Alice are constantly going over existential questions and
talking about news items and reflecting on their identities, their lives, everything. I think she's
making us aware of that internal condition of millennial malaise. I don't know that she is,
yeah, I think she might be critiquing it by the saturation more so than aestheticizing it.
Okay, that makes sense. But I get what you're saying about the anxiety of reading it, right? But
I think at times reading their emails, I thought you need to calm down and think about something
else, right? This kind of obsessive, ruminating quality that they both have. That is the entire novel
is them ruminating and thinking and reflecting. And there isn't actually a lot of action in the book,
right? I was realizing that too while reading it over, there isn't a lot of action because
they're really trapped in these internal conversations, you know, with themselves and with each other.
And again, I think that that hyper-reflectiveness is not healthy. And I think that they draw attention
to this lack of action or lack of movement where Alice says to Eileen, like you never come visit me
or like we never actually see each other, we just like they're their relationship. They're always
talking about, they're always talking about going to see each other, but they never do, which is so
fascinating. It's like a lack of mobilization or maybe even that, it's like this feeling of being
stuck, like all we can do is actually talk about it and ruminate about these very anxiety and
voking things. But at the end of the day, is our action actually making a difference? That sounds
so depressing, but I'm not so sure that like one person's action, action, no I am sure, that one
person's action is not making a difference in like the grand scheme of things. So maybe it's just,
there's something, there's an insular quality to their email exchanges with kind of a lack of
action. Yeah, and I think, you know, if you look at the structure of the novel, it is quite static
through those exchanges and then things start to move and kind of blow up in their relationship
when they see each other, right? When they actually make movement somewhere and that's when
everything comes to a head with the relationships. And then sort of at the end, I think if it kind of
is an epilogue section, when it sort of fast forwards a bit to where they are in their lives a little
bit later. Yeah, and then you see, whoa, these people have actually changed, right? There has been,
even if not in drastic way,
there has been some kind of transition that has been worked and I think that the movement,
you know, both the physical movement but also, you know, the emotional movement is the kind of
effecting of that. And I think there's also something to be said about the fact that when they
finally do actually see each other in person, it's very awkward. It is, yeah. And yeah, and they don't,
they don't seem to love each other personally in the way they have said they do, right? Because
they're really quite expressive in the emails. I was noticing that too on this reread,
the kind of terms of endearment they use and the really affectionate language,
so that at a distance they're able to communicate that way. And then in person,
they're like, wait, who are you? Who are we to each other? It's like,
I feel like there's something even solipsistic about those emails, where it's almost just like
they're using the other as a sounding board for their own. Oh, totally. Anxieties and their own
thoughts. But then when they actually get together, their friendship is not what we would think of
as like a traditional friendship. Yeah. Let's talk a little bit about class divisions and differences
in this novel. So Rooney is a self-proclaimed Marxist, but I don't think that beautiful world is
making any kind of overtly political Marxist claim. But do you see an undercurrent of Marxist thought
or ideology in beautiful world? And could you maybe draw us to a passage and interpret that passage?
For sure. Yeah. So I will say generally first, I think that, you know, as we've been talking
about already, this spoke is more about the contemplation of things than the doing of things.
So I think that falls in the same way for Rooney's Marxist thought as well, right? It's that
they're discussing Marxist ideas, like kind of considering values, but are not really doing anything.
So the pages I wanted to look at are page 38 and 39. And this is when
Eileen is writing to Alice about the sensation of being in the convenience shop and describing kind
of she's talking about, you know, the experience in the convenience shop and then sort of the
like zoomed out experience of looking at your reality really in a shopping way and recognizing,
you know, consumption and materialism and all these things. So then are you okay if I read
a little bit of it? Okay. So I'm just going to read this on page 39. She writes, "I believe
studies show that in the last couple of years, people have been spending a lot more time reading
the news and learning about current affairs. It has become normal in my life, for example,
to send text messages like the following. Tillerson out at state, LMAO with multiple O's,
it just strikes me that it really shouldn't be normal to send texts like that. Anyway,
as a consequence, each day is now become a new and unique informational unit interrupting and
placing informational world the day before," et cetera, and then she goes on to talk about culture
and earths. So it is this awareness that they both had of existing in, you know, a kind of
like a consumption culture, right? There's this rampant materialism. They're both recognizing it
and then they both have this hyper-awareness of that and are receiving it through the news.
And then it just sort of stops there. It stops at the recognition of existing in a system that
they find unpleasant and even, you know, oppressive or problematic or whatever kind of word you want
to use. It stops at recognition and it doesn't translate into action, right? Because they don't
change anything about their lives after this recognition of, you know, the sandwiches and the
convenience shop or whatever it is after the materialism and the problems of this culture.
So for me, that is, this passage is really kind of emblematic of what Rudy's Marxist thought is
doing in this novel, which is, I think how a lot of what I have observed, you know, in millennials,
interested in Marxism is that it's thought and not action, the contemplation of the idea without
doing anything. So I don't know if I'm repeating myself here, but I think that that is how I read
sort of the Marxist work in this novel. I don't know if this is the same passage or maybe later on
or the on the next page or something, but there's this moment where I think it actually is where like
Eileen is getting a sandwich that's wrapped in like plastic and then she's thinking about how that
like material plastic was like is probably not going to be recycled and that there was a whole
chain of production that went into like making this sandwich and so that it's convenient for her to
eat now. But yeah, it's like this contemplation about how we are stuck engaging in this cycle of
exploitation. We can't get out of it, but there's also nothing that we can do about it, per se.
Yeah, and also that when she recognizes that chain of production, this is really funny to me,
but when she has that moment of looking at the sandwich and thinking about all the people who
are involved in the process, there isn't any kind of recognition of the humanity of this economic
existence, right? That there are people involved in that chain. I think she's aware of that,
but it's just sort of, oh, how depressing that I am receiving the sandwich that was the product
of all these different, you know, people's labor. And she's totally alienated from them, which I
think is a reasonable Marxist response, but there's no, you know, being able to kind of envision
other people in the world and in her kind of sphere of existence as being endowed with dignity and
purpose and meaning, right? It's almost as if the people who made the sandwich just exist for her
to have the realization about how kind of tragic this all is, right? And she isn't in that sense,
you know, she sort of closed-minded and I think it can be kind of closed-minded as a novel in that
the characters are able to contemplate these grand ideas and problems without recognizing the
humanity of everyone implicated in them. So well put, like those are actual other people with
families and friends and like intimacy and their-- And valid existence is beyond just a theory,
right, or a way of reading or a way of seeing, or even just beyond like their job. Totally,
yeah, yeah, and you know, with that, again, with that question of the class differences and
labor and these different characters and their different jobs, anxiety over the work they're doing
seems to be a big factor in determining identity, right? You know, with Felix working in a warehouse,
Simon kind of working in politics, but not really having a very important position at the moment.
I don't know, I sense both Alice and Eileen making judgments of the value of other people
and the value of themselves based on the kind of work they do, which I think is a really limited
way of looking at human value. Especially because Alice and Eileen work in this creative sphere
and maybe have a different understanding of what it means to work with your hands and maybe see
that as inherently. I don't want to say like, debased, but I think that they have this, um,
maybe there's this implicit feeling that what they're doing is more like humane than working with
your hands in the same way that Felix does. Right, right, and even, you know, Felix experiences
working with his hands in this sort of dehumanized way and talks about how strange it is to use his
body for this repetitive labor and that he also uses his hands, his body to encounter
Alice as a person, right? So he experiences that, but I don't think he at any point is, um,
I don't know, devaluing himself as an individual. I don't think so. Yeah, and I don't think
Rooney is doing that either, but as you've kind of drawn our attention to this question,
I do think Rooney is, you know, considering the different values of different types of labor and
again, with this constant self-analysis, um, yeah, I don't know. I'm kind of losing my train of
thought here, but I'm just thinking like the constant analysis of work without seeing the work
in itself as something that can be good, right? And the constant anxiety over, oh, what is this job
and what is this labor and is what I'm doing having meaning? Well, maybe just do it. Maybe just do it.
Like, maybe we don't constantly have to think of our work as meaningful. Like, maybe it is just
work and that can also be okay. Obviously, it'd be nice if it was meaningful, but I think that,
like, that's also very privileged. For sure. Yeah. I'm thinking as well of the passage where, um,
Eileen is out with some friends and they're having a conversation in a bar restaurant about
what it is to be working class. And she, I think, kind of sees herself as working class because she
has this, you know, pretty low paid job, even though it's in the arts and it's in literature.
And then one of the other characters says to her, essentially like, you're not working class.
And there's disagreement over, you know, is, does working class be like blue collar? Is it white
collar, but low paid? All this anxiety again over identity, right? How do you classify yourself?
And then how is that classified identity give you a way of finding meaning or finding value?
Yeah. That's really, really well put. Um, those were all of my questions, but was there anything
that you wanted to bring up that I haven't covered today? Um, that I haven't, that I haven't asked
[BLANK_AUDIO]
I am really interested in Rooney's treatment of Catholicism and religion and the search
for meaning and I'm wondering what you make of that presence in the novel and if you
think you know I guess both you're the character of Simon and then through Alice's kind of
move towards religious curiosity at the end like do you think that Rooney is presenting
religion as a viable way of finding meaning?
I don't think that she's shutting out that possibility.
I don't think she's actively endorsing it either.
I think that Rooney doesn't provide us with many answers but she provides us with a lot
of points for contemplation.
So I think that it's for me the undercurrent in all of her novels is just this like simmering
anxiety and worry about like how to be a conscientious person in the world and kind of like what
is our place in the world.
And so I think that in Simon it's a really interesting kind of place to explore this person
that has like a lot of certainty over his existence but I think for me again it always comes
back to this anxiety and that for me Eileen's maybe flirtation with or was it Alice?
No it was Eileen.
It's Alice.
It is.
Yeah.
Oh.
Could you draw us to the passage?
I don't remember that.
Yeah for sure I'll just I'll search here.
I mean it's sort of alluded to throughout that she's kind of curious about Christianity
and religion but then in those last few chapters.
So this is page 329 and 330.
So Felix kind of jokes you know you should tell Eileen that your Catholic know because he
asked if that he asked Alice if she believed in God and she said she didn't know and she
writes or really writes this is again this is Alice speaking.
I only feel rightly or wrongly that there's something underneath everything.
When one person kills or harms another person then there is something isn't there?
Not simply Adam's flying around in various configurations through empty space.
I don't know how to explain myself really but I feel that it does matter not to hurt other
people even in one's own self interest.
And then kind of goes on to she's thinking about you know doesn't matter if you believe
specifically in God or just kind of in a higher order of things so I'd say she kind of comes
to a position of more curiosity and interest in the idea of God whereas at the beginning
of the novel there's this reference to her making kind of Simon for his religious beliefs.
So she has a little bit of a I'm not going to call it a conversion because it isn't but
sort of a transformation yeah a move in that direction of curiosity.
I would also say that Alice is a character that is really struggling with her own identity
as an author and as a member of this like creative class and you know she's coming out of
a breakdown that's not to say that that's why she's kind of like looking for meaning but
I do think that overall we lack a sense of spirituality in contemporary life at least
I do I don't consider myself a very spiritual person but there are moments where I wish
I was I just think it would give me a maybe a sense of security instead of you know constantly
having this bombardment of like negative information and just feeling like trapped.
So I think that the illusion to faith or exploration of faith is maybe just a commentary on how
we do lack spirituality yeah I like what you said about Rudy not presenting any clear
answers to us but kind of presenting possibilities.
I think she's opening a door in that direction and yeah for me through the you know the character
of Simon again as I said before about Rudy kind of exploring religion from this alienated
distance in him like I found whose character really compelling because he does seem the
most grounded out of anyone in the novel even as he has his own anxieties and struggles.
But there is this sense of there's a meaningful undercurrent that undercurrent that Alice then
talks about and I know that that is my own experience as a person of faith so even as I was
reading this book and experiencing some of the millennial anxiety and as we've talked
about like the stressful email chains and kind of over contemplation for me I thought you
know I can put this down and move on with my life because I have that undercurrent which
is God so I'm not trying to apply that readers who don't have that don't experience the
novel in a good way or a meaningful way but I kind of found not consolation necessarily
but a recognition in Simon I thought right okay there's something that makes sense about
his person and I think Rudy has even though it's from this distance I think she has captured
a sense of the security and confidence that comes with religious belief.
I agree Simon is a very stable character I mean yes just like any human being he does
have his own worries and anxieties but I think that he's he's not as conflicted about
like the meaning of his life as we see in the other characters of this novel.
We're sure yeah thank you so much I really enjoyed our conversation me too that's great
that was my conversation with Marie Trotter in the next episode I'll be joined by Professor
Tabitha Sparks to explore Rudy's feminist narrative until then thanks for listening
and happy reading.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Sally Rooney’s writing style is complex and opaque, resisting easy interpretation and requiring readers to engage deeply with its narrative voice.
The novel explores skepticism toward religion, particularly through Simon’s grounded faith, highlighting how religious belief is viewed from an outsider’s perspective and reflecting on identity and belonging.
Millennial malaise is portrayed as a state of hyper-awareness of global crises, leading to existential anxiety and rumination, with the email structure mirroring this internal, contemplative condition.
A key Marxist undercurrent involves characters recognizing materialism and exploitation without translating awareness into action, revealing a critique of contemplation over engagement with systemic issues.
Class and labor are central themes, as characters judge value and meaning in life based on work type, reflecting a limited and often dehumanizing view of labor and human dignity.
Rooney does not offer clear answers about religion or spirituality but presents openness to questioning, with Alice’s evolving curiosity suggesting a search for meaning beyond materialism.
The novel critiques the humanities’ perceived lack of economic value, reflecting broader anxieties among scholars about the sustainability and societal relevance of academic work.
The email format mirrors academic dialogue, making serious philosophical and existential questions accessible, thereby democratizing discourse and affirming the humanities in public life.
Summary:
* is analyzed through the lens of humanities scholarship, revealing its engagement with deep social, existential, and political themes. The novel’s complex, reflective style resists easy interpretation, mirroring the intellectual rigor and internal struggle of its characters. Central to the narrative is a critique of millennial malaise—defined as constant hyper-awareness of global crises and a paralyzing anxiety that permeates daily life.
Religion and spirituality are explored not as answers but as points of contemplation, with Simon’s stable faith contrasted against Alice’s growing, hesitant curiosity. A subtle Marxist undercurrent emerges in the characters’ recognition of exploitation and consumption without meaningful action, highlighting a gap between awareness and change. Class and labor are interrogated, as characters assign value to their identities based on work type, revealing a narrow, often dehumanizing view of labor.
The novel also reflects on the crisis of the humanities, where academic labor is undervalued economically despite its cultural and emotional significance. Through its email format, the narrative simulates open, accessible academic discourse, making philosophical and existential questions public and relatable. Ultimately, Rooney’s work does not provide definitive answers but instead offers a nuanced exploration of identity, meaning, and the human condition in a world marked by anxiety and uncertainty.
FAQs
The first word that comes to mind is 'complex,' as her style resists easy interpretation and takes readers time to adjust to its narrative voice.
Rooney presents religion as a point of contemplation rather than a clear answer. Simon's skepticism and Alice's growing curiosity reflect a broader exploration of faith, identity, and meaning in a world facing existential anxieties.
The millennial malaise is central to the novel, portraying a state of constant hyper-awareness of global crises, news, and climate change, which leads to anxiety and internal ruminations rather than action.
The novel highlights the anxiety over the value of creative labor and humanities work, especially when compared to more economically productive fields, mirroring real-world debates about the worth of academic study.
The email format reflects real, ongoing conversations about identity, politics, and global crises, offering a transparent, accessible look at how people process complex emotions and ideas in daily life.
Yes, there is a subtle Marxist undercurrent, particularly in characters' awareness of consumption and materialism, but the novel stops at recognition without translating it into action or a sense of human connection.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.