Go back

The Gen Z Movie Takeover and ‘The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping.’ Plus: ‘Paper Tiger’ With James Gray!

2h 21m 1s

The Gen Z Movie Takeover and ‘The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping.’ Plus: ‘Paper Tiger’ With James Gray!

The episode reviews two major films: *The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping*, a prequel that rehashes the original film’s plot with minimal innovation, leading to criticism for its slow pacing, poor visuals, and lack of originality despite strong Gen Z casting. While it taps into nostalgia and appeals to younger fans, it fails to deliver fresh narrative momentum or emotional depth. In contrast, *Paper Tiger*, directed by James Gray, is lauded as a mature, deeply personal crime thriller that blends real-life family dynamics with genre storytelling. Its powerful performances—especially Adam Driver and Miles Teller—elevate the narrative, with moments of raw emotional intensity and artistic cinematography. The episode highlights a shift in blockbuster filmmaking, where Gen Z actors are now central to major franchises, and where personal storytelling is increasingly valued over formulaic repetition. It also underscores how franchises like *The Hunger Games* remain commercially viable by adapting to new audiences, while films like *Paper Tiger* demonstrate that high emotional stakes and authentic character development can still drive critical success in a competitive market.

Transcription

25261 Words, 132775 Characters

English
I'm Sean Fantasy and this is the big picture a conversation show about lions and tigers and catnases oh my today on the show we're talking about the weekend's big new release the Hunger Games sunrise on the reaping it's the sixth Hunger Games film a prequel starring Jesse Plemmons refines Glenn Close Cure and Culkin L. Fanning and some other new faces we talk about what works what doesn't and what comes next in the series later in the episode I'm in and I will dive into paper tiger James Gray's new film starring Adam Driver Scarlett Johansson and Miles Teller paper tiger is a welcome return to the dread inducing New York City crime thrillers that gray made his name on decades ago and this is a movie that is more than worthy of a continuation of those stories then James one of the true OG guests of this show joins me to talk about his new film his return to this milieu the art of the thriller among many other things James is consistently one of the most eloquent entertaining and insightful guests and he did not disappoint here stick around to hear our extended conversation but first some movie news ready for this. Okay Amanda it's grand theft auto six weekend where will you be playing the game I want to follow up did you ask James Gray about meeting do a leap at the paper tiger party didn't come up I mean you got it call me you got a you got to answer text messages you got to think just what you got a sub one question in for me did you I'm actually open to that to Amanda's question corner if you want me to convey things like that in the future but I need like a formal request okay you know like an NDA style document every time as you know I love bureaucracy that's right so that'll that'll definitely happen so no GTA six for you yeah I know that this is a thing and I know that people are like well they're not releasing any really big movies on Thanksgiving because you know GTA is gonna which is a acronym that I use all the time in a very natural saying out loud it's gonna be so big that the the children and the elders won't go to the movies and number one that's not true because a lot of people are gonna see the Hunger Games and number two like I don't know grand theft auto is just not taking up my mind share it's one of those things I just I've said it's it's not in my business and I'm doing other things what if I told you I was coming over with the game and me and you and the three boys that live in your house would play for 12 consecutive hours I would not let you in my house with grand theft auto I like no because that's it's pressure me pressed against the window showing the game to your son knocks my boy come join me I think it's a little mature for him yes you don't say better content would be the big picture GTA play along oh yeah so both in terms of video games which is we're just not doing that in the home okay right now at least and for as long as possible though you know I have backbone so I believe it can be forever and back to this and for sure and then also as you guys alluded mature content it's tough though because and not to step on next week up next week's episode but we will be talking about misadventures of Cliff Booth Cliff Booth and that is that has a lot of mature content but is also the most my four year old movie I've ever seen in my entire life both like location wise and like interests cars yeah is he also into Carla Gugino bananas I'm sure you know so I it's I'm gonna focus on that if if my son gets one piece of extremely violent content it's gonna be further misadventures of Cliff Booth that's really good to know okay let's let's pivot to movies okay because we're in games that's not our that's not our bailiway I mean I know I brought up punk games sunrise on the reaping you did we'll we'll get there we have we'll have a robust conversation about that feature film Mapel and he did some reporting on the on the Bond casting and according to him Josh O'Connor was reportedly the first pick for James Bond yeah Denny Villeneuve's first pick yeah and you know you know you know we kind of like touched on though this could have been interesting I can see it it would have been very different sure but it's he's he's he is a different actor and vibe than Timothy Shalamet but it's not on Timmy like in the um the empathy and the like emotional wellspring that then Denny is putting in the center of a major franchise and presumably turning your loyalties over the time I don't think that like James Bond is gonna be straight cool hero in Denny Villeneuve's interpretation that's I don't know anything he didn't tell me anything but I so I can see the manipulation in the same way that he's approaching and moving the politreaties character I almost forgot it but then I I landed the name okay but will he be like a a dark overlord in the in the direction that Paul seems to be moving well he works for intelligence services and he's a killer you know and that's very third that is the in the interview that Denny gave to Zach Barron who happens to my husband like talked a lot about the physicality but like the the fact that this person is an assassin and that there is a darkness to what he does it's you know it's not Sean Connery just been like let me wriggle through some you know bars and pull a weapon out of my ring or whatever and I start wearing a signet ring sure is that something you're interested in I'm thinking a lot about the future okay yeah I mean listen Lacey you just opened your eyes you know and I think that's great everybody as you said to me every once in a while you just got to remember that you have it because you have a renewed sense of purpose and you do so now you're gonna dye your hair yep you're gonna signet ring uh-huh you told me you're very in a cardigan's again which I like I don't know whether that is Laya say do coded but she seems to you know have a have a taste for lots of life except for stale chocolate croissants so I do not see the purpose of this is still the best Laya say do moment of the past month but she was good with you too I tried I tried to live up to that yeah some more news mm-hmm the the wachowski's mm-hmm reportedly are attempting to reclaim their copyright on the matrix okay which I think is fascinating now obviously this film franchises now under the the tent of skydance but apparently after a 30 year period that claim of copyright can be claimed by the the creators and they're attempting to challenge that here now there is a movie the matrix five in development with Drew gotter the writer director and it it sounds like according a puck that the wachowski's have spoken to Drew and maybe are even working with Drew about the development of that project but that they are still pursuing this yeah and I guess there's this open question of do the wachowski's want to take back that property to own it and license it elsewhere or make another film in the future or is this just a leverage point to continue to get paid a large sum of money to participate in matrix filmmaking it's a bit of a wonky business story but I think it's actually quite interesting and relevant given a lot of the conversations we've been having about the ceiling the necessary ceiling of blockbuster filmmaking right which is something I've really been turning over in my head since the merger and you know since the DC firings and all that other stuff that's going on I don't know what and that two billion is the new one point five billion yeah you open my mind with that one billion yeah you know you know me just always think as big as possible when it comes to to pay tracks capitalist capitalism's greatest soldier a little bit of why can't it be both I mean I do also wonder whether it's the particular owner in question that is playing a role in wanting to have it back but yeah literally a lot of very outspoken against David Ellison in recent years yeah but um why would it you want to own it you know I like that from a business perspective you know go for it totally agree so and if you don't get it then you have the leverage yeah and that's something that you know that came up in the conversation about sinners and what Ryan Kuhner was able to negotiate for himself something that we know quite in turn Tino gets on his movies yeah um what's something really interesting about that about artists who have made something iconic and what they might do with it when it is in their primary possession right I don't know if we've totally seen that demonstrated at large beyond George Lucas that's interesting we were at the Lucas museum last week I have tickets to go to the Lucas museum again later this month that's and I was we were was in there at at Zach's event with Danny and looking around and talking to friends of ours and we were to somehow the conversation turned to merchandising and I was like this is really the house that merchandising built yeah because that was one of the smartest things George Lucas ever did was he retained the rights to sell the merchandising to the Star Wars franchise and that's you know he made he made money in many different directions but he made so much money from that and he used it to do a number of things including building like one of the architectural fascinations of the 21st century in Los Angeles it's such a crazy building that they build I thought it was so beautiful we only saw we were in the lobby and then we were in a wonderful screening room yeah it was really really very comfortable and beautiful yeah I thought it looks great and was very chic I haven't seen the collection yet yeah I look forward to returning yeah I don't you know on the flip side of that is the Hunger Games sunrise on the reaping which is the big movie the weekend as I said it is directed by Francis Lawrence this is his fifth time helming a movie Gary Ross directed the original Hunger Games film and I think Francis has been on all the film since the screenplay is by decorated screenwriter Billy Ray and Michael Leslie it is based on the 2025 novel reaping sunrise on the reaping so this movie is technically a sequel with a a large time gap to the ballad of songbirds and snakes, which was the 2023 film starring Rachel Zegler that we talked about on the show. It is also, yes, the luminaires film. It's also a prequel to 2012's The Hunger Games and the three subsequent film starring Jennifer Lawrence. The movie stars Joseph Zada, Jesse Plemons, Ray Fines, Glenn Close, Karen Culkin, Elphanning, McKenna Grace, Maya Hawk, Whitney Peek, and Kelvin Harrison. Set 24 years before the events of The Hunger Games, the story begins on the morning of the 50th Hunger Games known as the second quarter quell, because it is a quarter quell, twice as many tributes are drawn from across Pan M. 16-year-old Hamich Abernathy of District 12 is thrust into the brutal arena, forming an alliance with fellow tribute, measly donner, as he fights to survive and push back against President Snow and the Capitol. What did you think of Sunrise on the Reeping? - This girl is on fire! Do you know how many times? I couldn't even get through it. You and I saw this movie together last night at a. - Early access fans for me. - Yeah, exactly. It was not an IMAX as it was intended to be seen, I guess. - Premium large format. - And the number of times that I almost just burst out singing this girl is on fire in the screening because I was A, so bored, and B, I just thought it would be funny because I needed some way to entertain myself. It was upwards of five. This did not work for me at all. And you made a point that, in our outline and that you wanna discuss that, I think is right, is that I don't think it's supposed to work for me. This movie is gonna make a lot of money and has had a huge attendant press tour that I have been aware of because it's very mainstream but I have also felt too old for throughout the process. I felt very old because I was there connecting with the grown-up actors who are playing the bit character parts and who are there as the candy to bring the grandpa and grandma in as a new generation is launched. - Lily Taylor and Curen Colton, how exciting. A night at the cinema. - Sure, and you know, where Jesse Plemons goes, I follow. - No doubt. - So, I thought that this movie was far too long, poorly paced, visually insulting, and fairly dull as evidenced by, you know, my attempted Alicia Keys jokes. But I don't think that totally matters. What I think. - Well, yeah, I do wanna talk about that. And maybe we can table that when we get to the end of the conversation about the movie itself, the movie isn't 158 minutes. And it's the second leg of prequel in this series. And it is focused on Hamach who's played by Woody Harrelson in the original Hunger Games films. - Yes. - And so, you know. - As you, helpfully, stage whispered to me four minutes into the show. - Would you have been confused? - Woody Harrelson. - Yes, if I hadn't read some Instagram post connecting the dots for me about, you know, two days before we saw this. - And obviously any fan of the Hunger Games is gonna know that, Hamach is a very memorable name. All the names in the Susan Collins universe are very memorable. - Sure. - That's been part of the appeal. I was kind of aghast at how much of a rerun of the first film this movie was, and how unflinchingly they essentially just recreated the many steps that Katniss Everdeen went through in the original film - Yes. - In terms of explicating the selection of competitors, of showing us the sort of more destitute districts of Panem and the way that people were living at that time in history, the way that the groups were formed and how there's a sense of rivalry and there are the training sessions and the stylists and all of those steps that we saw, the characters go through in these films. And this is a weird thing because the Hunger Games movies are not even 15 years old. But that is effectively one generation that we are now removed from. And I think that's a really important note that they have managed to kind of keep this IP warm. So now we've got 15 year olds who are getting really into it. And so they're still drawing in the 30 year olds in the 45 year olds and maybe even the 60 year olds. But now 15 year olds are getting excited about it and they're gonna have their own posable action figures in this universe. For me, I was like literally the first one hour and 15 minutes of the movie is just rerunning the same playbook from the first film. And it is Deathly Boring. - Yeah. - Deathly Boring. I can't believe they devoted so much time to doing that. And I do get it for the 15 year olds, right? And if this is like, "Baby's first Hunger Games," I get it or maybe you just love being in that world and so you wanna watch it again. The same way a young Jedi needs to learn how to use a lightsaber and there's something kind of anithemic about that, right? I do understand that these are tropes that are meaningful to the world and the story being told. But man, it is a freaking dirge through the first hour and a half of the movie. I literally turned you on one point and I was like, "When will they start killing each other?" Like is that novel we are here for? Now, I will say when they started killing each other, I perked up. I got a little bit more interested in the film. Obviously we know that Heymitch is a figure who participates pretty dramatically in the rebellion in the previous four films or in the coming four films in the future. Okay. It's a little unclear. Can I just pause you there for a second with your obviously? Okay. So you do have a good memory for films and for arcane lore that doesn't matter at all. You don't remember anything I've ever said to you, but what do you think that means? You can remember that Heymitch participated in the rebellion or whatever. Yeah, sure. How much of the Hunger Games lore do you remember? I have read the first three bucks. No kidding. Yeah, I read them as they were coming out. I saw all of the movies and theaters. I, like at some point in my blogging 1.0 days, let it be like a, a jokey, but still I think fairly innovative team gale movement. Sure. Which, you know what happened then? You got to do that. Yeah, it didn't work out. Now he lives in Australia again. But so I've been there and I retained nothing, you know? And I was kind of, I found myself doing the math and being like, okay, so quarter quell, they've said it's the 50th. So that means that the original Hunger Games started with the 74th Hunger Games or something because the first year, it's just a normal Hunger Games and then they have to do the quarter quell again. The next year it's the sequel. The 74 is a really random time to start a thing. Like this is, these are the kinds of things that I was thinking to myself, both that I don't remember all the lore, but I remember enough to have like more questions about some of the lore. You actually do remember this? I don't know the granular arcana in this world, the way that I would in something like Star Wars. Not at all. I didn't read the books. I'm not a scholar of this. It was, I wouldn't say it was over my head or anything. I just, but I watched the movies. I actually have a very similar relationship to these movies that I have to Harry Potter. I didn't read the books and as I told you, I've been reading the Harry Potter books in my daughter. And so now I'm kind of like learning a lot more about that world of story. These movies were just movies to me, just like the Harry Potter movies. They were just movies to me. And I thought they were above average. I didn't think they were great. Yeah, I thought they were like pretty entertaining. You know, they're obviously hugely lifting from Battle Royale, the Fukusago movie, which is an amazing movie, where young people are kind of forced to kill each other in this dystopian world. They're not nearly as kind of brutal and violent, but they're pretty brutal and violent. And I don't know. I like watching people get killed on screen. It's something I've always enjoyed. So I don't have negative feelings about them. And I think they also very smartly, just like this movie, very smartly, had Stanley Tucci and Phil Pseymour Hoffman and Julian Moore and Elizabeth Banks. And they were really smart about surrounding these younger performers with this kind of August cast of Thespians who were cash in a check. Right. And so that makes those movies fun. Fucking Donald Sutherland is in these movies. I like the movies a lot. I had a great time. Again, Sutherland theaters usually around Thanksgiving. And took the younger generation of Thanksgiving cousins to the movies 15 years ago. Now I'm hoping to take them to Club Kid, 'cause we're all grownups. It's hysterical. But so yeah, I like them too. It's more just kind of what have you retained? Because then you're watching this movie that is just a remake of the original. And it's Hamich in place of Katniss. And in that sense is different from songbirds and snakes. Movie I didn't enjoy that did also feature a Hunger Games but had a lot of singing and a lot of more district 12 stuff. It's funny. I thought this movie was a little bit more successful than that movie, but I thought that that movie's reason for existence was more well-represented. Because that was the origin of snow and the sort of birth of this world. Okay. So I understood that as like an ancient prequel. This movie, the point I was gonna make about Hamich is we know we're going with Hamich. We know that Hamich wins. That's why he was a mentor in the original film. So there's no confusion there. We don't know the details of how he won, but we know he's gonna win the Hunger Games. And we also know that he is ultimately opposed to what the Capitol is up to. And to what President Snow is up to. So there's no been in terms of the allegiances and I thought that the the films and I'm sure in the books as well had this interesting game where you like you learned actually in the was in the second film or maybe at the end of the third film or the beginning of the fourth film that Plutarkevins be who's also in this film was actually not working for the Capitol that he was a secret spy and I thought you know the idea of casting films you were off into that role was I was really excited I really dug that stuff. But in this movie you already know where Plutarkevins be is you know who he's allied with ultimately and you know what hate mitch is going to turn into and so the movie is just narratively drained of consequence. In a way that bugged me and the other thing that it does is it kind of kind of skimps out on a lot of the battles between the kids it's not there's not nearly as much of it as at least as I remember from the original movies. And I'm not totally sure why that is there a couple of brutal moments once we actually get down to the to the fight yeah but. You know and you know you mentioned the look of it and there's a lot of CGI some of which is real dodgy I was hoping this movie was going to be beautiful because the trailer showed a lot of the most beautiful images. And I didn't see the CGI butterflies in the CGI creature and the CGI flowers which reminded me a lot of seeing the Wizard of Oz at the sphere and you know and what kind of what is landed into to fill out the frame or in this case suggest I don't know what. But you know color that will kill you I guess yeah so yeah I agree with you I think one of the the issues the way that this movie is trying to innovate is instead of kind of the brute force battle scenes that you're talking about they're trying to bring in the Plutarch heavens be character more in this idea of designing the games. That gives Jesse plemons more scenes is trying really hard to carry this movie yeah and he's really good you know Jesse plemons innocent always happy to see him me too. But it does mean that a lot more on is on the focus of the arena and the games as like a machine that's a thing that they keep saying and so then you just have a lot of scenes where people are talking about hacking or you know like. People are just talking about design in a way that is as I said to you halfway through the movie this is great cinema you know it's not so. There's just kind of like you have to go down through the well and you have to do X right there's a conversation Joseph Zada and Kelman Harrison Jr's character is just like a 98 second. Exosition moment that is just like awful and you know movies like that need this stuff but you want them to be a little bit more cinematically appealing and. Right sometimes the movie is that mostly it's not and then also what that sets up is that all of the moments of like excitement and achievement and the hamach character defeating the game are they're not about kids. You know hitting each other or worse they're about him like slipping through some other place or I guess there are a couple of explosions but that's as much like visual excitement as you get. Have you ever seen Logan's run you know movie 70 science fiction film starring Michael York that is like very kitschy but very colorful and similarly kind of dystopian futuristic tail and this plot is very similar to that. And you know you can say the hungry and story in general similar Logan's run but this one in particular because it's a blonde male lead who's on the run from the powers that be once was a part of the civilized society and then it's trying to break that society. And so it feels a little iterative of something that we've seen before in a way that the hunger games with catness seemed kind of fresh. I don't know that there had really been a heroin like that in move a young woman who was you know the strongest person on screen you know that she's I guess you can make the case a couple of Sigourney weaver parts but that's a pretty I don't know revolutionaries not the right word but you know that was a cool way for Jennifer Lawrence to kind of elevate her stature. Well that's the other half of it is that it was actually Jennifer Lawrence now you've really evolved on this matter over time but Jennifer Lawrence is a generational talent and you don't and has gone on to do many other really interesting things and continues to and it's just amazing. And it's just amazing to watch on screen and it's kind of you know it's the 10 years later version of the child actor just like you don't know when you're casting these very young actors in in these big franchise roles and these YA adaptations you don't always know that they're going to grow up to really have the juice but here's the thing at this age you can tell a little bit. And so when I'm watching everybody else in this movie I'm like well you're not Jennifer Lawrence now almost no one is and that's sort of that's something that's working against every subsequent Hunger Games movie is they got so lucky with what Jennifer Lawrence is doing in Hunger Games it's top line YA action franchise stuff yeah. You can't really recreate it and you don't need you can't even really match it in and those movies with all respect to Josh Hutchinson and Liam Hemsworth yeah. That's the thing is that one for three yeah yeah but they got they got the number one really what right so. Unless you have Jennifer Lawrence you just you're not you're not going to get there you're not going to get there yeah in the same way. I generally agree with you I always thought that this was this was at that time when I was less into Jennifer Lawrence that this was the good version of her because it was channeling what made her so good in winter's bone I thought the direction that she pivoted to in her career where she was like a zini. You know high dramatic high comic actor she had not really like honed her skills candidly as an actor and I feel like she was being praised for just being like really hot and fun and not necessarily for her I feel like as a performer she's gotten really good in the last 10 years. But back then. These movies channel that kind of steely power that she demonstrated in which is bone which is why I was more or less on board with these movies I didn't love them but I like them enough. Yeah I agree with you though that she's obviously a find and it's very rare that you come across an actor who can become such a star like she has. Joseph Zada has to do that job in this movie yeah. Now he's kind of he's kind of doubly fucked in this movie because he's not Jennifer Lawrence and he's also got to try to be Woody Harrelson and Woody Harrelson. I don't know no matter what you think of him there's only one guy like Woody Harrelson and he's having a very singular career in Hollywood history and people. I don't know if there's a single person on earth who when he shows up and something it's like I hate this guy he's a very persistent force in Hollywood for 40 years. But he's also playing he's Woody Harrelson before things have turned you know and the Hamid character that you meet in the original Hunger Games. Yes who's like a drunk and is you know kind of kind of a care nothing about the world kind of. Right um you you get his origin story and drips and drives but this is just like a very basic trauma story that someone who. It like you know a charming confident guy who loses the the luck of the draw on the big day has some really messed up stuff happen to him and then he's mad it's but it's not that interesting yeah. Of a development and also it means that he has to play like the not that fun part of the he's he's he's not Woody he has to play the you know the nice guy before you get to be like weird unexpected Woody. I want to talk about him and the whole young cast before I do like you mentioned plemons mm-hmm we've got L fanning as F.E. Trinket that's the character is Elizabeth Banks played pretty small part she's only in three scenes yeah bringing a lot of energy I'm not sure if she's quite matching Elizabeth Banks is performance. Oh I like it I like what she's doing. Um Cure and Colton he's playing the character who's Stanley Tucci played the season flickerman the host of the TV show but he's also playing uh Cure and Colton very much um refines. It's really a snow he's the Sutherland part um who's also played by Tom Blythe in the ballot of songbirds and stinks. Oh I'd forgotten about that yes and Glenn close plays. You're still a capitalist court for district 12 um this movie feels significant to me because this is the first movie that we've covered on this show I think. That is a blockbuster that every major role is portrayed by a Gen Z actor. Every major role in this movie is someone born in 1997 or later. Now there have been a lot of movies starring actors that yeah but what franchise tent pole movie. As had you've got Joseph Zada of course as a image you've got McKenna Grace as Maisley who is essentially his compatriot from district 12 playing in the games. You've got Maya Hawk who is the most recent winner of the games and is a mentor. You've got Whitney Peak who's Lenore Dove who is the love interest and a significant character and Ben Wong who's why at another district 12 participant. Now of course Ray Fines and Jesse plemons and. Right right right right and they're important to the movie. But the movie is being sold on these characters. Okay and what was your cut off 1997 90 and I think is roughly Gen Z. Okay so I just google the cast of Thunderbolts asterisk new Avengers dead Avengers dark revenge stand. I know I'm looking I'm sure someone come up with something is 93 so I'm you know I'm just I'm trying to engage my question. I appreciate it. It is kind of my it's kind of my point that is like we're in a transitional moment. Yeah. And we're all the kind of carping and celebrating I've been doing about how millennials have some control here. - Yeah, how it's our time and everything is being catered to us except the things that are actually supposed to make a two billion dollars. And now they're the Gen Z kids. - That's where I'm going. - Yeah. - And I get it and it is right. It is right and it is correct. And it's interesting 'cause I didn't, I wouldn't say I really clicked with any of these actors aside from McKenna Grace who I think has some juice. I think she might be a little miscast in this movie, but I like watching her in movies. And I feel like if she were utilized properly, she could be quite good. I feel like she has a nervy energy that is more comic than it is dramatic and she keeps getting cast into these dramatic movies. And weirdly the only movie that has kind of gotten her thing is the Ghostbusters movies which I don't think work very well, but she's pretty funny trying to do paralleled ramies in those movies. But you know, and Maya Hawk is well known, right? And you've got, but we do have this generation of actors that are coming up. Some of whom are like Maya that came out of stranger things for example, which is a, that's a significant Gen Z collection of performers. And this is what it's gonna be now. And there's a part of me that wants to be like, think deeply about how you criticize these people because these may be the people in your life as a professional person for the next 25 years. I don't know if Joseph Zada is gonna make it or not. - He was also on East of Eden. - He was on East of Eden. - I follow his stylist Jason Bolden on Instagram. So I've been getting a lot of Joseph Zada like content that, but I have not actually seen him act in anything until this I thought he was not bad. - He's not bad. - And he has a lot to do much of it on fun and grim. And he's got a couple emotional scenes with Jesse Plimmons at the end where I was like, oh, okay. - He's good in that stuff. - Yeah, that's the stuff where you shine. - Yeah, you can do this. And you know, I wish we had a little bit more of that fire in the first half of the movie. - I know that there's dramatic reason for that and because of the consequences of the story, but there's a moment in the final third where he is in his home. - Yeah. - That where you're like, oh, he woke up. And but I thought of you and your Gen Z stuff a little bit where I was like, this is a little sleepy. Like all these people talking to each other is a little like dead on the energy is down. Yeah, we're not speaking at the animated volumes that you, I mean, you know, and that's maybe a matter of perspective and you and I may be way too extra for the people. - Of course we are. - Yeah. - I agree with you that I think my Ken and Grace is miscast. - Yeah. - That she is more fun either in something edgier and or in the greatest of the Colleen Hoover adaptations in my opinion, regretting you as the as the teen. - Yeah. - But even there, it starts to be about our age and how we're receiving them because it is true. I watched this movie as the grown up paying attention to the grown ups and this movie is a movie about the teen characters. It is a YA adaptation, you know? So like everyone's doing the right thing but these people all seemed a little young and like undercooked to me. And that is possibly a little bit about the script. That's possibly a little bit about the casting. That's possibly a little bit about, you know, time marching inexorably on. And that's how it goes. - Yeah, I wrote, we'll talk a lot about Pattinson and Bond and how this was like we're not leaving anything to chance moment. We're gonna get a huge star in a part that is usually not reserved for a huge star. - Right. - And how there had been this run Star Wars from Mark Hamill to Daisy Ridley. You got, think about the way that Robert Downey Jr. was utilized in Iron Man where it was like he was low in his career and he gave them some gravitas but he needed them and they needed him or the Chris's in the MCU or Chris Pratt in Jurassic Park or, you know, that period of time where you used relative unknowns to launch franchises. This is actually using that old strategy. It's not using the new strategy of, we need Jack Black from Minecraft. We need Robert Pattinson for Batman. We need every significant young movie star for Dune. We're gonna overwhelm you with the number of exciting cool people in this movie. - Or that is another great example of the like, we're just blowing it out of the water. And it's happening at the same time that, the Pattinson news to me fully clicked in the place that like the movie star debate is dead, like the do movie stars matter. We did that on the show for years and we kind of held steadfast where we were like, this does still matter. - Right. - It is the same butts in seats thing that it was for 75 years of the movies, but it is still something. It does don't matter to some extent. - Well, I do also think that some of it was about like the type of movies that were reigning supreme and that this coincides with like a retrenchment in the superhero. It doesn't mean that they're going away, you know, Dune's Day, December 18th, like, woo, but I'm so excited. But that that was a particular era. When the superheroes were truly, when we had like three, four or five a year, and that was the center of movie culture, like it was the character and not the person. And I think we felt the downward stream of, we weren't creating movie stars or in the same way, or they just weren't getting the same opportunities because the characters were taking up all the space at the box office. Now that's less, that's, you know, Superman and Supergirl do not have the same stranglehold that they did even 10 years ago. - It's true, but something cool happened. And this is why I'm thinking about this connectivity generationally. - Yeah. - Some of the smartest ones or luckiest ones or skilled ones or however you want to define it, they use the IP to set their own path. - Yeah. - And that's hard to do, and you mentioned how Jennifer Lawrence was able to do it out of the Hunger Games. Michael B. Jordan was able to do it out of the Creed Films. Timothy Shalmy was able to do it out of a number of different things specifically Dune and Wonka. Zendai was able to do it out of Spider-Man. Tom Holland was able to do it out of Spider-Man. Sydney Sweeney is going to be able to do it. - Tom Holland, the Odyssey is the only one he has outside of Spider-Man. - Mine is going to work. - I think I'm very excited for the Fred Astaire movie, but that is-- - I think he's having a reset. - Yes, but you know, we had Cherry. We had what, was he and he wasn't in Spider-Head, was he? - Uncharted, he was in-- - Uncharted, thank you. - Uncharted, thank you. - I'm who was a hit. It's not good, but he was a hit. - Okay, I agree with you that Tom Holland would be in like eighth place on that list, but that there is a class of superstar actor now. - Right, and maybe was not, they were not superstars eight years ago. - Right, and he's doing, he wanted to do the Odyssey, which is kind of like the bridge. And now he's doing the Fred Astaire. He's like taking it out first, but I totally agree. - And so that generation now, they're winning Academy Awards. You know, like Marco Robbie is in this conversation. There's a bunch of people now who are 41 to 33 to 41, who are kind of seizing their moment patents in the biggest example of this. So now behind them, of course, now that we have established the new class, Joseph Zada and McKenna Grace and Millie Bobby Brown and this whole other collection, we thought it was gonna be Jenna Ortega, we thought it was gonna be a handful of other people, some of whom have panned out, some of whom are kind of stuck in neutral. But it's interesting to me that this could, it's kind of like the system is leveling out. In a way that in 2021, I was like, oh no. Like it's over forever, you know? And now it's just kind of gone back to the mean where characters matter and they've mattered pretty consistently for 35 years. I mean, I think George Lucas and Steven Spielberg, perhaps accidentally brought on this huge dramatic shift in terms of what we think the ceiling of cinematic commercial storytelling can be. But we were raised in an era in which Tom Hanks and Julia Roberts and Tom Cruise and Denzel Washington and Meg Ryan, they were the reason to go. - Yeah. - And there is a little bit of a reason to go. And this young group of people, I don't wanna make this, this movie shouldn't have to bear the brunt of my dramatic generational dissection, but it means something to the wider atmosphere of movies. - Yeah, they are the next class. And they are somewhat graduating from Stranger Things, like half of them, literally from Stranger Things and or another Netflix show, even a press to just want an East of Eden was on Netflix. - Jacob Allordy from the kissing movie. - Yeah, to the YA breakout area. And maybe some of them will be Jennifer Lawrence and maybe some of them will be Josh Hutcherson, both of whom show up at the end of this film. - Spoiler. - Well, it's not a spoiler because they've been very, very public about the fact that they show up in the movie and they also do, they were on the red carpet. - Why did they do that? 'Cause they don't care, they're like screwed. It's not that big of a deal that we appear in the epilogue. - There was a moment about two hours through where I was like, oh no, did I miss Jennifer Lawrence? Was I like too busy planning my bits? And I didn't see her. - How have they all gone over? - I think they're really, really good. - Okay, good. - You know. And so I think I hoped they would actually like be worked in the film some way. So I think you have, the appeal is to get people like us to stay through and be like, okay, well, I really would actually like to see Katniss and Peter and then it turns out it's just at the end. They didn't really think about it at all. - The other reason I thought about this is because Frances Lawrence's previous film was the long walk. I don't know if you ever got a chance to see them. - No, but yeah. - I think maybe Chris and I may have talked about it on the show. And that movie, which is a But I had mixed feelings on an adaptation of Stephen King's story. Start Cooper Hoffman and David Johnson. And I was like, no matter what happens here, these two guys are great. These two guys, I hope these guys are in movies for 50 years. They're awesome. They were awesome together. And then David Johnson was announced as Black Panther in the Marvel films. And now Cooper Hoffman, it was in five movies this year and is in the upcoming artificial. And so, you know, Francis Lawrence, who has a huge history of music video direction. And when we're working with very young people for a very long time, like he has an eye for these kinds of people. And if Joseph Zada turns out to be like his massive discovery, that will be a feather in his cap for this franchise. There is something really interesting to me about the way that this movie is at least tracking box office-wise relative to the ballad of songbirds and snakes, which was a Hunger Games prequel directed by Francis Lawrence, featured a young up-and-coming star on Rachel Zegler, you know, Tom Blithe, also somebody who was highly touted. And then that, I mean, it didn't bomb, but it really didn't make any noise. I think it made about $167 million worldwide, which is way below the previous four Hunger Games movies. And now this movie is tracking for like $150 million in its opening weekend worldwide. That was 2023. And this is 2026 and the movies are back and the kids are going to the theaters. And also, I think crucially, like the theaters and the marketers have figured that out. And I do think that that's three years of learned experience of finding the young audience and knowing that if you can eventize it, they will, you know, come and go nuts. So I think that's part of it. I think that also the similarity to the original Hunger Games is very helpful. Like it is, for us, it didn't yield like an interesting rivalry movie experience, but it is also what everybody knows and they're like, oh, cool, a new Hunger Games. It's kind of the forced awakens of other games in that way. So and that might be more than enough to be successful. I'll be curious to see like when, when the world at large goes to see the movie. If there's any disappointment or not, because I think there was a great, a pretty significant amount of anticipation, especially among young fans, and whether or not. Like could this also be baby's first cynical movie experience where you're like, oh, I've already seen this movie before, you know, like that there's not, or it's just, I loved it, you know, we never know what the feedback is going to be on this kind of thing. I know that for me, it was just a little bit too similar to the previous films to really get invested in, but it's not bad. It's just a pretty dull, I think. Yeah, it's not great. I wish it, I wish that it looked better. I was really, it looked very, very, very artificial and screen savoury and then in a way. And I do feel like we're getting more blockbusters that actually look good. Maybe that's just because I saw the June 3 trailer that I've been trying to avoid before this screening. And I was like, oh, right. You can use effects and make them look, you know, real and, or at least photo real. So I, I don't know, but this felt like a step backwards to me. Yes, I disagree with you. Let's go back to the past. Okay. Let's talk about paper tiger written and directed by James Gray, star, Adam Driver, Scarlett Johansson, Miles Teller, set in New York City in 1986, two brothers, Gary and Irwin launching new business venture that pulls them into conflict with the Russian mafia. He saw this film at the Gallup premiere at the Cannes Film Festival. We did. We both liked it quite a bit. I watched it a second time this week and I liked it even more. Yeah. Unsurprising on a James Gray film, something that happens with almost every James Gray movie. I think the first time that I watched it, I may have shared these thoughts on the Cannes episode. I was like, this is a James Gray movie. It's a very similar dynamics, very familiar framework. Three of his first four films, Little Odessa, We Own the Night in the Yards, feature this brother, brother is getting ensnared in the world of crime, framework. This movie, I thought, um, was a lot more expressionistic and philosophically deep than even those early films, which those early films, which I really love and admire, feel very much like him working hard to emulate his heroes. And this is a movie and maybe it's because it's so personal, but also genre that I was like, oh, this is kind of like, it's not his best movie, but it's something that you've been working towards for a very long time. So I responded to it even more the second time. What did you think about it? I felt the same way and not to compare to Hunger Games sunrise on the reaping in any way, shape or form, but it was an example of to your point, it is a familiar formula that like it is very much a James Gray movie. And so I think you and I both saw it and we were like, okay, yes. This is a very good version of a thing we really love and admire. And on the second viewing, I was like, wait, this is a great version of a thing that I really love and admire and it is doing some new things. There are a couple set pieces in this film that I were bracing the first time and equally upsetting. The second time and also, I was looking forward to them. I from one, from one viewing and it's like, okay, this is about to get really, really upsetting and a better lock in. And that's pretty, that's pretty remarkable that it lodges in your brain and even watching those sequences the second time and being like, okay, I'm gonna try to see what he did here. The choices are really effective. I still, even though I was trying to be analytical, get slurped into the emotional play of both of them. So, it's, you know, it's a wonderful and really excellent advancement of the James Gray project. And which is a project I'm a huge fan of. Great performances. Really good. All three of them. Yeah. We talked about them a bit in May. I think this might be my favorite driver performance. I am, I am, I find this to be a very complicated movie for me and I talked to James about it just because of the, there are many echoes of my own personal family experience in this movie. Yeah. It's not the same exactly, but, you know, in, you know, in, can you turn to me as the, you know, the first scene open and you were like, this is exactly where my family lives. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. The accents, what people's jobs are, how they think about the world. I think I probably underrated how much of my lived experience is it was in watching the Miles Teller character and like hit that character's interpretation of masculinity and duty and inability to express oneself. And you know, the movie, it started out as a direct sequel to Armageddon time and then it was meant to be, you know, a lot of the details in the story are true to James's life. But because some actors changed and Ann Hathaway couldn't do it and, and they decided, he decided to rewrite it and make it more of this kind of thriller, but he has retained a lot of specific things. His mom got sick. That's also represented in Little Odessa. His father got into some legal trouble. That's clearly represented here. He had a complicated relationship with his own brother, like that's represented here. So I love the way that it is like the highest level of personal filmmaking inside the genre container, where there are some moments in this movie as you pointed out, some set pieces that are legitimately scary. Yeah. And they're not horror films, but they're maybe as close as he's going to get to making a horror film. It's the same in their home is scarier to me than any of the horror movies that I have watched on assignment this year. And the movie is shot on film and lit so brilliantly. And the way that he shoots stuff like that, the way that he shoots darkness, however, how movies that are supposed to be light look dark all the time, but his darkness and the way that he leans on shadow and what sources of light he leans on, which is like maybe a single light bulb hanging in a room or just a shaft of light coming through an open door. Such artistic, thoughtful construction of sequences that, you know, there's some people who don't really get the James Gray thing. They're like, I watch this movie. It seemed fine. You know, like I got the plot. I understand the beats. It's a very, he's such an intentional filmmaker. And I think it's this movie, it's going to be more evident to people because you've got that home invasion sequence that you're talking about. You've got this incredibly dramatic closing sequence that I don't want to spoil for people that they should absolutely check out. And then there's just a conversation scene where the two brothers go to visit the head of the Russian mafia and they just talk. Yeah. And I'm on the edge of my seat and I've already seen the movie before. Yeah. And so, you know, I think because driver who has always had this really interesting blend of dashing in handsome but also kind of nervy and looks like he's going to snap at any moment. And Miles Teller who for years has tried to beat dashing in handsome but I think is always at his best when he's in the spectacular now or whiplash where he's like a little bit more unsure of himself and his he has kind of like a fragility to his masculinity. I think he's wonderful in this movie and then Scarjo, this is going to be a device of performance. Yeah. I'll just say this is how my mom sounded. So if you watch this movie and you're like, this is too much, it's too big. James and I talked about this but I'm like, this is, that's regional bias, you know. This performance worked better on me the second time that I saw at the first time. It is very big. I do also, I kind of resent what I've started calling mom drag, you know, which is when the very, very beautiful actresses put on the unflattering glasses and it's kind of like you've had a reverse movie at like makeover. Yes. She's not all that. And I'm like, oh, I'm like, okay, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. It's hard to believe on behalf of the actress 'cause she's still scarred now. And then I'm also just like, this is a non-fair representation of moms. But anyway. And Hathaway just did this. Yeah, totally. Listen, it comes up a lot and you can't fool me. But I do, I think that she's really, she has a couple of solo scenes 'cause her character does like start her own, you know, quiet solo journey. And she's very, very good in the quieter moments of those. And the, and the bigness at some point fits the scene. Like when the male solo character takes his sons to go on us in the middle of the night, like I would be pissed too, you know? Well, yeah, there's a really, I think a really thoughtful, emotional, dynamic running through the movie that makes the story coherent to me because it's a movie that's mostly about these guys. And mom has to be big and loud to show that she really does have a voice in this family, you know, and not only has she raised these boys probably mostly by herself, given how men and women worked in the 1980s. But that she deserves her seat at the table. And the movie is basically like these men didn't really respect her place in the world. And she was overlooked. And you can tell because she goes through this enormous crisis in the movie and no one is there for her. And she doesn't want to bother them, which is another classic Queen's mom thing. Like I can handle it, it's fine, don't worry about it. But they don't realize that she's in crisis 'cause they're dealing with their stuff and they're too locked in on their lives. And you could, the first time I watched the movie, I was like, oh, this kind of seems like it's operating on two tracks, but those two tracks really intersect. And I think a very sad way that is very representative of how a lot of these families worked. That thought was very insightful. And I like what she's doing. I think that you could see a world where she has maybe a couple more scenes in the movie that gives some of that storyline a little bit more weight instead of her having to compete in a noisy restaurant or in a noisy dinner table with the rest of the guys. But you're right that there's one scene in particular in a doctor's office. It is very powerful. What else? - You said that you think it's the driver best performance and then driver's best performance and then you kind of be entered away from that. So, he's really, really, he's great. - So he plays a police officer, a retired police officer who has gone off into the private sector. He sold a company that he started and made some money. You can see he's divorced and he's kind of, maybe in his early 40s, mid 40s. And this is true of many police officers because usually you give 20 years service time and then you retire and then you can go on to a second career. I know many, many of my dad's friends have been through this. My dad did have a second career as well. And a lot of these guys who make it in this way are these kind of swaggering, entrepreneurial, good in any room types. And he just, he just fucking nails this guy. And maybe it's easier for me to say 'cause I'm like, I know this guy, but he nails this guy and he does two things with it. One is he gets to play proud and then he has to play scared. And in between, he've lashed us out literally. There's a moment where he wanders into a Chinese restaurant and handles some business that is like, Kylo Ren is back for a second. - Yeah. - But in the back half of the movie, when he feels it's slipping through his fingers, I just think he's doing amazing work. Like I'm not, not a lot of dialogue doesn't really talk through his feelings. I think some of the dramaturgy, like when he goes to visit his former colleague, I think some of that stuff's a little creaky. - Yeah. - But his performance in the last 10 minutes of the movie. - Is unreal. - Amazing. - Yeah. - Amazing. When he goes to see Teller and they have that conversation is that's big, that was big time stuff. And maybe if this movie had a little bit more stature in the Oscar races or whatever, he would be in the mix. But I'm like, how is this not a, this is like the best supporting actor Oscar win to me let alone nomination. - Yeah, he's wonderful. Though I keep, he is the, he's the flip side of the Scarsio and Mom drag, which is like, he is still Adam Driver wearing the Patrick Bateman suits running around and like, and that makes the movie feel like a movie and it's an incredible performance. And he is just the most watchable of any actor that we have going. - I love him. I think he's so great. - Like I, he's wonderful. But so he's, he's also like a, you know, a movie star doing his stuff. And the amazing thing about the Miles Teller performance to me is how much, he's, it's just, he's really dad. He's not pulling in any of the, there is, you know, there's kind of a, you know, a dad like Charm to it. And when he's fixing the windows, the, you know, the opening scenes are very loving. And I find the last scene very, very moving. But he's really just, he's playing middle age. He's not playing, you know, Eagles fan Miles Teller, plays a dad and the transformation and that he just, he hits the, the energy right where the movie is in a way that I think is pretty amazing. - I totally agree with you. And I think it's interesting to think about if this was Jeremy Strong. Because Jeremy Strong played this part and on again time, and this was the intention originally. And Jeremy Strong is a wonderful actor, but he's so maddered. - Yeah. - And the Miles Teller performance is like turning it all off. He's doing, he's doing an accent, right? And he is trying to represent this part of the world after. And he's kind of, he's basically from this part of the world. I think he's from Jersey, right, Miles Teller? So he's getting, he gets it. But I was really impressed and it kind of made me sad about what he's been doing the last 10 years. 'Cause when he was very young, I thought he was such a special actor and like rabbit hole and spectacular now in whiplash. I was like, whoa, man, he's really gonna be, he has a chance to be one of the greats. - Yeah. - And I think he's tried some interesting parts over time, but he's just, he's really fit in this movie like a glove and he's not getting the same accolades, the driver is getting and not even the scar, scar, scar joy is getting. - Well, it's not this flashy part, you know. It's not shiny and it's not like, hey, look at me. I'm doing really big in crisis mom over here. - Yeah. I really dug this movie and I look forward to seeing it again. There's been an ongoing James Gray, when will he get over the line thing? Well, he went a prize at can, he didn't want a prize at can. You know, he, this movie may not be nominated for any Oscars. I don't really know. I'm curious to know because I've, people that I've talked to have seen it have really liked it. And there's this sense that, and we're even framing the movie in this way. It's like, oh, well, it's like a James Gray movie, but he hasn't made a movie like this in a very long time. His last few movies, Armageddon Time, and @astra and a lot of easy, which is my favorite. - And immigrant and two lovers. Like, those movies are all different from this movie. - I love two lovers. - I know, that's still my favorite. - Yeah, no, it's the best one. But this, I mean, here, we on the night, which I visited recently to prep for this, still bangs, it's really, really good. But it's been almost 20 years since he made a movie like this. And I don't know, I hope it'll remind people of ways to people up. - I hope so too. I still remember in France the day after the awards were announced. And this movie got nothing. I think it was the figureo, but one of the newspapers was outraged. - And it was like our-- - Juckoos. - Yeah, Juckoos, like our pom-dor, of course, goes to paper tiger. - Yeah. I mean, he's obviously been beloved in France for many years. - So, I mean, which is really, you know, my only goal in life to be beloved in France. - That's true. You guys share similar aspirations. - Congratulations. - Have you met James? - Yes. - You have? - Yeah, yeah, yeah. And he and Zach also interviewed him. So, you know, and James has that quality of befriending everyone that he meets and speaking, drawing them all into a conversation, so. - Couldn't have said it better myself. Now, let's take a quick break before going to my conversation with James Gray. This episode is brought to you by Amazon Prime. We all know the holidays never quite go to plan. There's always a last minute white elephant, friends popping over a family dinner that somehow turns into a neighborhood potluck. And suddenly you need more decorations, one more gift, and something everyone can agree to watch. But hear me out. Those unexpected moments are often the ones we cherish most. And Prime helps make them happen with fast, reliable delivery and plenty of movies, shows, and live sports to stream together. Go to Amazon.com/Prime to learn more. Delivering joy. It's on Prime. - James Gray, back on the show. This is the ninth or 12th time I've interviewed you in a formal setting. - That is anytime, it's really? - I think so. - Does that include you including like Criterion? - Criterion, FIC stuff, you know. - Put it on a long list. And I'm so happy. - The hint, Sean, I guess I like doing it. I like doing it, that's the other thing. So let's talk about the new film, which I love. And it started as a direct sequel to Armageddon Time, did it not? - Well, not for very long, but yes. I mean, initially what happened was in the formulation of the idea, I was sort of coming up and said, "Okay, well I'll look at my life in the late 80s "because in some ways it was as dramatic if not more so." And then I had one conversation with Anne Hathaway and they put the Kai Bosh on it really. Because Anne he said, "Well, I'll do the movie, "I'm interested in all that." And I loved working with them all. She was very nice. And then she said, "Well, I'm doing, "one thing you should know is I'm doing Chris Nolan's movie, "The Odyssey." And knowing Chris and the size of his productions, I sort of thought to myself, "Well, that means you're unavailable until the year 2091." So I said, "Well, how long has that?" She said seven months with a head, and I was-- like, yeah, it's okay. So she's not going to do it. And then Jeremy was going to do it for a while. But then, you know, he, he's still shooting, I think, this TV show that he got hooked into is an adaptation. I think it boys, boys from Brazil. And so I realized, okay, I can't get the actors back. Would you have done it with Jeremy, but not with Anne? I guess so. Yeah. Brilliant actor. But I, but I, I think that would have now that I think about it. I think it was right that I didn't because I think that that would have led to a cognitive dissonance and the thing. And also, I think, and this is not to insult Jeremy's persona at all. It's actually not him as a person. I was a persona, but he has a kind of wily, dust and Hoffman thing. Whereas I think in the way that the part was written, it demanded a more alpha male concept, which you could then deconstruct, if that makes sense, which we can get into in bigger detail. But I think because the story demands a kind of idea of like a certain idea of a working class person, who has worked his way up to the position of engineer, who considers himself very much a man and how to dismantle that. If it's, if it's Jeremy, it's a different thing. Was it a thriller when it was more related to the previous film? No, it wasn't. I took on more of a, to, to use a, a kind of a cliched or a more fancy word, "horry" term. It became a Hitchcockian thing in my head to try and do two to three to four Hitchcockian sequences built entirely on a kind of quiet, prolonged suspense. Because I just felt that that was an under served part of the cinema landscape today. We do certain things very well. We do great action sequences, elaborate actions were very well. A lot of loud stuff very well, a lot of great explosion stuff. I was thinking what if you could not raise the decibel level at all? And also again, philosophically, there was a difference, which was that so much of what would be scary would be offscreen out of the frame. So these two considerations began to drive the film creatively. And so I became a very different kind of movie than my last one. Had you written anything in the previous situation? Not really. I had started to outline. It was more of a kind of, for lack of a better term, again, near realistic idea. But I, I think, and maybe even more palatable for certain Derra used this dirty word art film circles. It took on a more pulpy for like, again, for like better word. Because it's not quite pulpy. That's not right word. But it took on a more, like I said, a kind of more thriller also, but not right. Boy, I'm having trouble suspense. Suspense. The idea built around suspense. It's a little bit more pulpy than the original concept, which was a little bit more slice of life. Because part of it also shown is that the whole picture, I'd made up very little. But it took place over about a 13 or 14-month period. And there are kind of stretches of languishness with that long. So to get it to where it has a compact impact, the time frame of the film now is about a month. So you're taking all those events and basically crushing them into a small zone. I found it quite rewarding. I love doing the film that way. And, you know, Hitchcock is, I mean, if not number one for me, he's certainly up there. Did you look at any specific movies? I did. I looked at a bunch. I mean, the one that I found particularly interesting, which I hadn't seen. I want to say in 25 years, but a long time was his remake of the man who knew too much. Because what you have in that is you have, for laughs, you have a kind of jolly feeling in some sections of the film, particularly the very end. But other than some of the Hitchcockian humor touches, it's a shockingly dark movie. And it's a family that is, quote unquote, "normal" actor from the Midwest, his housewife, very 1950s concept, and they're one young son and he's kidnapped. And Hitchcock gets away with something. You know, he has this title card at the beginning after the opening credits, which you see the orchestra at the Royal Albert Hall, which of course sets up the climax of the picture. And it's something like, it doesn't say this exactly, but this is like, this is about the catastrophe that befalls an American family. So I thought to myself, OK, well, that's interesting. What you would think of as a normal family, no, no family is normal. But we use that term essentially to describe a kind of nuclear unit that the system seems to digest. So how do you impart catastrophic circumstances onto that? We're very good at catastrophic circumstances for kings and queens and super heroes, or mythic figures, mythic characters, because that's an outsized reality. Yeah. It's harder to convince people that catastrophe can befall, quote unquote, "normal" people. Yeah. You use that construct, though, in a lot of your films that you, the word Shakespearean is often thrown around when describing your movies, right? You know, people say that, but I, I chafe it because then people will think I say it, which means they think I think I'm Shakespeare, which, OK, you can, it's very uncomfortable for me to hear that, but you're quite right that Shakespeare never dealt with this sort of thing, right? It's actually in many ways, if we're talking the longer run of culture, I think we owe a lot to a French novelist named Emile Zola, who wrote, among other great books, a book that everybody should read called Jean-Mineau, which is about coal miners. And he brought to the idea, what we call "verismo," which is the idea that elevated narratives, not just in novels, but at the time, but also in opera and Puccini certainly took on this mantle, that elevated narratives, high drama can apply to working-class people, poor people, doesn't have to be kings and queens. If you think about all of Western culture before that, it was entirely focused on royalty, right? I mean, even Mozart's operas, certainly Marge Figaro is very revolutionary because it shows you both the servant and the count, but you still need the count. And that's Aristotle. Every story needs to be about a king in some way. So that was trying to break the mold, this idea in the mid-19th century, really, was to break the mold that every story has to be about a king. So I tried to put a king in every story. Yeah, this is literally a question that I wrote down that this is, I revisited some of the films this week, especially we on the night. And this movie, it has a father in it, but it does not have a king in it. Yeah, it does. Sure does. Who was it? Who was the king? Samian. Right. He's an evil king. Right, but he's the king. I guess that's true. And I guess he's the horrible, horrible king. Yeah, he feels like a more insurgent character, I guess, because of the way that he's introduced than someone who kind of presides over the landscape. Maybe that's your perspective, too, on having grown up in that milieu, then maybe it felt like he'd loomed larger than he does to us in the story. Oh, that's interesting. I hadn't thought about that. You don't dare say his name. That was the attitude. He's still alive, by the way. There's a real guy named Samian Makilovitch, who I think he, I know, is in Russia. He's still on the top 10 most wanted FBI list. I mean, it's not him, obviously, in the movie, but there is a guy that that's like that who's still around. You mentioned Criterion, we talked about your first film, Little Odessa a few months back. And a lot about that as a framework for some of the stories that interested you over time, and I think it was maybe a week or two before I saw a paper tiger when we had that conversation. And it was before canned, for sure. Oh, yeah, it was. And so, and then I saw a paper tiger, and I was like, oh, my, like, this is really, it's kind of a return. It's like a recurrence in a way of some ideas and themes and structures that you like. It's not the same thing, but variation. Yeah, you're right about that. If I, so this is obviously you get it out of me, the honest form, right? I couldn't articulate this to you then, even. And I think I was finishing the film at the time. But I can, I look back on it now, I think it's trying to make the original concept better. In some ways, it is a remake. It's not, but in some ways, it's a remake. It's a Hitchcock thing we're talking about. Made in too much was a remake him trying to try to, to get it better, to get it right. It doesn't mean that I made a ton of mistakes in the first one that I'm conscious of. I'm not always make mistakes. What it does mean, though, is you're a different person now in your 50s and you were when you were in your early 20s. And so you review, for example, my mother's illness, I have a different take on it now than I did when I was 23. So I was just trying to bring something else to it to a variation, so to speak. But this is not uncommon in cinema, when you're if you're lucky, and I have been very lucky. But also in painting, music, you know, how many times do you have the good fortune to see Van Gogh's portrait, self-portraits? How many did he do? How many times did Hokusai do a wave? It's the artist, if I use that dirty word, trying to get it right, and over and over. How do I get it more pure? How do I get it more honest? How do I not screw it up as much? And in that sense, you have to come to it with a fair degree of humility, which is a totally outmoded idea. The culture really celebrates ego and celebrates self-possessed qualities. It's self-possessed is also it celebrates a kind of there I use the word viciousness. And it does not celebrate also nuance from the other side, you know? So this humility thing, very important for a creative person, because you have to have all the narcissism in the world to get the film made, but once the film starts, you have to forget at all. And humility has to really take over. It's interesting though that you would you would use Hitchcock as a lighthouse for the story, but that it's so undeniably a very personal piece of writing and Hitchcock, while there's a lot of personal predilection in his movies very rarely autobiographical if ever. And your story is like, so how do you essentially how do you be true and have humility, but also be entertaining, you know, that's like you because he entertained. But first of all, he made movies in the 1940s and 50s in his heyday into the early 60s, and when the cinema changed to a more directly autobiographical and times and often more what we might call overtly personal, he started to slip up a little bit, he lost his footing. So I think part of it is he just was working in a very different cultural environment. The studio system obviously had tremendous weaknesses, but it also had tremendous strengths. One of which is that they had an idea of narrative. I mean, this is a much longer conversation, which I'm happy to have, but they had an idea of narrative, which is not American at all. We love to talk about the American studio system. It's almost no Americans in it. Howard Hawks, in fact, distinguishes himself probably as the one American director of prominence. John Ford was born in the United States, but very much a kind of product of the Irish immigrant experience. You had Billy Wilder, obviously, from Central Europe, Austria and Germany. You had William Weiler from Switzerland, Germany, Ernst Lubitsch, obviously not an American Fritz Lang, obviously German. So Frank Capra, Italy, so you had all of these people who had a different concept of narrative, George Stevens. Well, George Stevens, the very later George Stevens is a fascinating figure, right? Because he is very American, very white guy American. And in fact, swing time is great as it is as a terribly racist dance sequence, which is sort of horrifying. And he was very much part of a patrician white guy culture. And he made superficially entertaining movies in the 30s, some of which like I say, I love swing time with the exception of that sequence has remarkable stuff in it, obviously. But what happened to him? He became a great director. Why? Because he went to the war. He got a cultured it to something in Europe, which was absolutely catastrophic. His movies get so tough and they change completely. Yeah, you see a place in the sun that is not a movie he would have made before his trip to Europe. I'm sorry, but even Hitchcock, who was of course English. Look at the movies before the war, 39 steps, for example, which is a remarkable movie. But what's the movie he makes after he comes back? And by the way, he shot a lot of concentration camp footage, which he was so traumatized by, he told the BFI said, don't show this. And they only discovered it in '86, six years after he died. The movie he makes after the war is notorious, which is a deeply brooding, upsetting, confrontational movie and it really respects her humanity. But it is, it is a dark, dark movie. And you look at vertigo when you see Jimmy Stewart, catatonic, essentially replaying his own nervous breakdown after being in a bombardier and what was the highest mortality rate of the war. In other words, the European experience on narratives was that effect on narratives in the United States cinema was vast and the whole studio process where you were to only to entertain. They kind of it became a weird combination of both of those things conflicting with each other and it produced some incredible works of art. But they are of a certain type of thing. What happened really was in the late 1960s. Europe's influence on American cinema starts to fade in the late 1950s. And what is an American movie? An American movie really is "pature wagon." That's an American movie. Very little influence from Europe. It's the studio system lost, but it's the studio system giving you an entertainment around the world in 80 days. That's another one. That's a very American movie. What happens? Benton and Newman, right, Bonnie and Clyde, who are the directors they want to go to first? Francois Truffaut and Jean-Luc Godard. They don't get either of them. They get Arthur Penn, who was a New Yorker, had an artfulness about him. It's still very influenced by Europe, very influenced by the French new wave, the graduate same year directed by a man named Mike Nichols as we as we know, not an American again, very much part of the European system. So they bring Europe back, the Godfather, Francis Coppola brings Italy into the mafia, where it had been made as famously as Evans talks about in his book by American Jews, before that. Marty Scroessess, he brings mean streets, the feel of the immigrant experience. So Hitchcock was, Hitchcock did not have that at his disposal. So he's using World War II in certain cases and his experience in Europe in different ways. It comes out in his wonderful observations about class, for example. But it doesn't, he's not allowed to be as directly autobiographical as we became starting in the late 60s with what we call those New Hollywood movies and the thread continues with the independent cinema in the 90s, which is what I'm a product of. I've not answered your question. No, you have a follow-up that is related to it, but this is a very important part of history for the cinema because people don't fully understand, I don't think, how important the depth of the humanities experience from Europe is for the American movies and how important it is both in good and bad ways. They had an amazing sense of class, but they had terrible ideas about race, for example, I mean, they're shameful. But they also had weirdly advanced views of women's roles sometimes. So you see Catherine Hepburn or Barbara Stanwick having amazing roles. I didn't mean to interrupt you. What are we going to ask? No, no, no. Well, it's all interesting because some many of those filmmakers who use sighted and making films in the 30s, 40s and 50s, fled fascist regimes to come to America. And then you put that into their stories as well. And so that's kind of there's some fructive tension between that idea and making entertaining Hollywood movies that is so useful. But you know, you're a product of the 90s independent wave, but you know, the bulk of your films are made in the 2000s in the 21st century. And I've been sorting in my head like, what is the character of this century of movies? You know, it's not hard for you as somebody who knows so much about its cinema history to say, well, this is what how the Europeans informed the 40s. This is how the American studio system changed in the 60s and 70s. What is this here time? It's totally American. Now, there are some people who work in this language, who do it brilliantly. I regard Quentin Tarantino as a totally American director and he's spectacular. I cannot do what he does. I can't try to do what he does because if I did, it would be not good. It's him. Yeah. But he's a very, he's like, you know, Howard Hawks or something. So he, in fact, he loves Rio Bravo, for example, idolizes it. And so it makes sense. He's a very American director and there are others who are just great. What happened was in my read for this century that we're, if you're asking about it, is that the American cinema, took on such a major hegemonic role right around the period we're talking about the late 90s that it started to overwhelm all of the other nations that had very proud cinematic traditions. Berlusconi when he got rid of the R.A.I. funding eviscerated the Italian film industry, the French film industry started to knuckle under because the American global effort started. it to overwhelm. So now the American language took over completely and we don't get the same feedback from it from Europe because the Europeans are kind of doing American movies. What is Luke Besson? Luke Besson was a French director essentially making the American style of cinema. So when we look at this century, what we see is the hegemonic control of the United States for mainstream cinema, then what's the effect in a place like Venice or Cannes or Berlin? It's to go so far in the opposite direction that we abjure ideas of emotional involvement or a controlled narrative that's two hours, like all those things that we thought we learned. So you see three and a half hour long films, you see things that are really taking huge risks, that's an act against the American hegemony. So we have essentially colonized the world's unconscious cinematically. And now there are other countries that sometimes do films in our style better than we do. Certainly some of these Asian directors who are an astonishing force. So they have been influenced by American cinema, first and foremost, if you ask Bong who what movie he loves, 85% of them are going to be American. So I just think people underrate the power of the American when American movies became truly global, which which happened around that time. The big blockbuster idea, which took over and really colonized the mainstream even in Europe. Okay. You've affirmed what my feelings are about that. Let's go back to your movie. I totally agree. I think I'm still trying to figure out maybe what the emotional identity is of those movies. If one exists. Yeah. I know. I don't want to just be just reduce it all the way down to that. But it's not this is a big long conversation, obviously. It is. I mean, I don't know. We'll probably boring your listeners. No. It has to do with, I mean, there is such a push because there is no more competition for our hearts and minds. It's now all about how can you make money? And if there's no more competition for your soul, it becomes everything. It's not. And by the way, even when the films, when I love the films, as I often do, when I serve on juries, which I like to do, I see out of the 20 I see often, I find a 12 or 13 that are at least very interesting and five or six that I think are flat out excellent. They are acting in opposition to this capitalist to Germanic thing. So that's the dialogue. No, that's really that's that's me. I mean, that's kind of in the text of the film too. You know, that this is very much this desire to get more and to get legitimate and to get elevated and, you know, the way that that drives us. So I'll just give you like a little bit of personal reflection on the movie as it means to ask you about it because, you know, my father was a police officer in Nassau County, and he was very similar to driver's character, a very kind of debonair detective who retired after 20 years and then took another job and always kind of entrepreneurial and well spoken. And he's not exactly like that character, but there's a lot of him in it. The way that Scarlett Johansson portrays the mother looks, talks, and sounds like my mom, my family's from Astoria. And also, there's a part of Miles' character who is also my dad, a very blue collar kind of person who built things and made things with his hands and, you know, was a Met's fan and looked after two boys. So it's this is a very hard movie for me to like watch with any distance. And, you know, your movie is kind of always draw something out of me, but this one I find to be so fascinating. So revisiting me on the night and thinking about the psychology of cops. And that movie is very much about the psychology of cops. And this is a movie that sort of feels like an extension of that. And like the mentality of I was kind of fascinated to know why driver's character is a police officer, why that's useful, why that sprung to mind in the construction of the movie. Because it's very different from say Little Odessa, which is a world of crime. Why I had someone in my family was a police officer and there's a, you know, the law is an object in some ways of fetish. If you, you know, I have three children, right? So if I said to them when they were young and they still act this way, you can swim up until that rope. They always swam just past it. Now, if the rope had been five feet closer, they would have swam just past the rope. Then you're speaking of my parental experience. This is what it is. The idea is that as soon as you lay down a law, so to speak, it becomes the object of your fetish. How can I step right past it? And so when you are looking at the extremes of human behavior, it's almost always about what is lawful and what is not. A police officer serves a tremendously good dramatic objective correlative to this idea. What is the law? What is the ethical line? And what does it mean to cross it? What does it mean not to cross it? That is dramatically very useful to us. So I found in this story, I mean, it's also obviously part of the experience of my own as well. But this idea of a person who's been out of the game for a bit, who still thinks he understands the lay of the land and turns out he didn't understand it at all. Is that an act of naive tear or stupidity? No. The world changes. And also your assessment of threat in front of you is totally warped. You think you have more power as a police officer than you do. You think the system is more malleable than it is. You retired. I don't know about your dad's situation, but New York police officers retire very young. They have a very very healthy pension system. And it was just based on a person that I knew that it retired early and made a ton of money in the security, the world of private security. And I don't actually, it's funny, the landscape itself too. The Italian mafia was really they had huge damage done to them by the employment of RICO laws. And their power really did wane. And what filled the vacuum? Well, I think it is in part a kind of classist and racist idea that people did not really contemplate that the engineers and scientists out of Russia who emigrated in the late 1970s as part of a sort of mini-day taunt action by the Soviet Union, that some of them would go into criminal enterprise and located in Brighton Beach really first and foremost. Whereas the Mario boat lift from Cuba with Latino people was considered an absolutely abominable thing where you're letting in all these terrible people. And I think that, you know, when I look at my own situation, for example, what my father winds up doing the choice he makes in the film. I don't blame him for it because the idea that there would be some tremendous Russian criminal enterprise known as the organizatia to us now was totally unheard of and unknown in 1986. The cops did not have a division for it. The FBI didn't think until '87 or '88. It really caught them quite by surprise. So this idea of the police officer who thinks he's got it all in control actually has nothing in control. And it's really about how the times can change and move past you in a major way. There's also just an amazing document of local geographical history with Goanis and the way that that is portrayed. Like, can you just like maybe talk a bit about that because I think it's a little lost on some people. What it means if you live there or interacted with it, there's no question you're right about that. Well, the Goanis Canal, which I think is still certainly in the United States. I don't know about the world anymore. But for a long time, it was known as the most polluted waterway in the world. It started out in the 1840s. There were tanneries up and down that started the pollution process. The army had munitions up and down. There was all kinds of dumping into about a mile and a half to two miles of stretch of water in Brooklyn. And now the situation is it's 30 feet deep, the Goanis Canal. And 10 feet thick at the bottom of petrochemicals and other harmful PCBs, things like that. And to dig it up, it's almost impossible to clean it. The EPA declared it a super fun site. I want to say about 25 years ago, but they still are not. They to dig it all up and to find a place to put. It's like it's a mammoth task. Now the funny thing is both Adam Driver and Miles tells his characters turned turned out to be totally right. All that real estate became incredibly valuable. And when you go to the Goanis Canal in Brooklyn now, it looks like the Rapongi district in Tokyo or something. It's incredible. The skyscrapers. When I left New York, the whole foods It just opened down at the edge of parts of the roof and I was like oh my god But this is actually finally changing, this neighborhood, which for 75 years was considered a waste site. That's right. Well, now they have all those major chains that moved in, they have luxury apartments. But the movie, it's like a nice snapshot of a piece of lost history, you know? It is lost because when I went there, I said, oh, I said to the crew, I said, we have to go to the Gwanis. We have to shoot there. Okay. So we go scout the Gwanis, I said, well, what the hell is this? When does this end? I know the old buildings built up. Where do we go for the Gwanis that I remember? And it's gone. It's totally gone. The water is still disgusting. Nothing can swim in it. In fact, when the pandemic hit and there were lockdowns, the East River and the Hudson River are remarkable success stories. They are totally cleaned up. You can fish in the Hudson. The oysters have returned to Ellis Island. I mean, like a crazy success story. This, the dolphin would swim into the Gwanis and die instantly. And they saw it during the pandemic, they would make essentially make a left turn coming down the East River and they would die. What we had to wind up doing shown was basically, I shot it in the Paseic River off the Paseic River, New Jersey, which is still untouched by human beings in the last 40 years. That's not been gentrified. Not the same way. No. And we added, we dropped, and I had survey photos of the Gwanis Canal from 1985 and '86, which were very high resolution. And that is the backdrop. So we dropped it in digitally. It's very seamless. It looks exactly as my memory, exactly. And you kind of can't tell. They did a brilliant job. But it's all fakery in the bakery. I mean, there's nothing, there's no Gwanis like that now. The irony is, the evidence is still there in the water. It was also the number one place where the police would find body parts and suitcases filled with heads and this sort of thing. It was a vessel. Anything out of there. Yeah. Exactly. And it would, you know, it would fit went to the bottom there, you know, you never discovered it. But I don't know if you know about this. It was, you know, the lake and it was at mid lake me either forget these things. My god, it's embarrassing. But the lake in Las Vegas, which they have been going through, you know, climate change drought on the water level has been going down. They find them all these gardens. Yeah. We're dumped by the mafia in the 40s and 50s. So it's like that in the Gwanis, except that the water level has not gone down yet. It's also such a great load bearing metaphor for capitalism, just that body of water and everything that has been for over 200 years has been dumped in there and exactly how things have changed. Exactly. You know, I, I look back on it now is I didn't think of this really, but for my last movie, I hadn't been back to my old neighborhood in 30 years. And I had a shot. It was a walk and talk of two kids outside my old public school. And the assistant director, Doug Torres, great guy, done a bunch of my movies and one of the great people ever. He takes out his stopwatch and plane number one flies over. He starts timing. And the scene is two minutes and the 38 seconds later, another plane because you know, you've got LaGuardia and Kennedy and he says, oh, man, we only got 38 seconds or 36 something like that between flights and the walk and talk is two minutes. So I did, I think I did 33 or 32 takes something like that of the two boys walking. I never got one without an airplane. Wow. Never got one. Why am I telling you this? Because I grew up there, I totally tuned out the airplane sound. But not only that, when I went back, the air smelled of jet fuel. And I had blocked it out or I had become used to it so much that I never noticed it. The air smelled like jet fuel 40 years of jet fuel flying over and so you realize that this urban pollution, which has metaphoric value for our story, but also very real tangible effects on us. We don't know. I mean, as all this talk about microplastics, obviously, that's devastating. We don't really know the full effects of the last 100 years of industrialization on our cellular makeup. So it's why, of course, I also mentioned it with Scarlett Johansson's character, what happens to her in the film. Right. It's obviously deeply correlated more than likely with the, you know, massive number of cancer cases and cancer crustaceans across parts of the communities. Speaking of the filmmaking, and I don't know if we talked about the move to digital on the last film and now going back to shooting on, is it 35 on this 35? So why did you go back? Why do you hate it? Because you didn't like digital. Yeah. That digital on the last one, because I had two children as the main characters. And everyone was saying, Oh, you know, you're going to have to roll a lot and get them. And then the kids were great. I was getting great performances from them and take one. And there was no reason that I didn't shoot on film in that in retrospect. I mean, film is more expensive. It is dramatically more expensive now. It's become a kind of boutique industry in a way. And that's a tremendous frustration, very anti-democratic move. But what can you do? So few people shoot it. The digital process I found all of the efforts I was making were to get rid of the digital look. It was to add grain. It was to, you know, to break the image a little bit down. And then I thought to myself, well, why am I doing all of this? If I'm just, just shoot film. And, you know, I don't, I probably went over budget a little bit on the film side. I probably shot too much footage, but I don't do a ton of takes. I don't do, you know, 105 takes or something. And so when you're working in some sandbox of some measure, film can, you can get away with it. I had to shoot two fewer days. I gave up to, for the film, to afford the film stock. But you know, you can't, the thing is, so one of my closest friends who is a beautiful person, named Matt Reeves, who does his Batman films are in, in digital. And he, he always says, well, that's great because on the monitor, you see exactly what you're going to get. And he loves that. And I respect that completely. He, he loves knowing exactly what the image is going to be. And I don't like that. I don't like it. I like not knowing exactly what I'm going to get. Because I've never won Sean, not ever been disappointed. When you shoot on film, even the cinematographer, the photo chemical process does something different. And when you get the footage back, I've never once said, it doesn't look quite as good as it did on set. I'm always like, there's something else going on. It has an organic messiness. You know, Walter Merch, the great sound designer and editor, said once he said imperfection, allows art to breathe. And I think that that applies to the photo chemical process, which will not give you a totally precise rendering the way digital will. You look, why is it we like sports digital? I like sports digital. Mm-hmm. Clarity. Clarity. I watched that seventh game of the World Series last year, this year, not so. Last year's World Series. I was happy for them. No, I was too. I'm not talking about the teams right now. I'm talking, and they're a great team, but not as dramatic a last year's World Series, where I didn't care who won. Although my kids were going nuts for the Dodgers, which is an nauseating thing. But fine. I'm thinking about that too. No, it's horrible. That's what I know. I know. I know. That seventh game was one of the great sporting events I've ever seen. Yep. Indigital, on a big screen with great sound, it's amazing. I don't want that from cinema. Cinema is like a dream I have. The more dreamlike, the fancy word cinema fans know is oneric. But the more dreamlike, the better. How long is our REM sleep every night if we're lucky? So how in a half to two hours, the whole art form evolved so quickly because it replicates our dream. And I've said this to my children who love, they love movies. I'll show them a movie. If they don't like the movie, dad, I hated that movie so much. Dad, I love that movie so much. I've taken them to all the best art museums in New York and in Europe. They've been very lucky that way. I've never once heard any of them say, "Dad, I love that painting so much. God, I hate that painting. Why is the cinema encouraged, that reaction, why does it encourage you?" You have the totally direct intimate relationship with the screen. You end up just explained my professional life. Is that so? Is that a good thing? Or bad stuff? I think it's wonderful. I think it's an art form that drives passion. It drives passion and it also drives, and I say this about myself. It drives ignorance because there are dreams that you have, that you hate, that are very uniquely informative about your unconscious. So when I first saw the conformist, I was 19, I think. I didn't like it. I thought it was like, "What, why am I watching this?" Thank you. that's very unpleasant. And it leads me to make mistakes all the time. I'm always wrong about movies. I have to go watch them again and reassess. And sometimes I'm wrong about a filmmaker. First or second or third movie. I hate that movie. And then you see what the filmmaker is trying to express over a longer period and you go, oh, I always talk about this. It's always body of work. It has to be body of work. - It's so beautiful when you realize it that way. Now, because you then begin to understand, oh, that's what he's sheer. They is actually trying to express. - Well, that's why this is such an interesting film for your filmography because it is, it's returning to some ideas and then maybe pushing some of those ideas forward. I like, there are, you mentioned that you wanted to draw some Hitchcocky and set pieces, right? So we've got the sequence in the car with the boys. We've got the, we've got the meeting. - It was almost like a horror movie sequence, but completely. We've got the conclusion, which is again, a kind of recurrence of another sequence from a film. Though not a replication. And how do you design those things? I mean, we talked about this a little bit with Little Odessa. Like, is it storyboarded? Is it, do you know, are you figuring things out on the day? - Well, you always have to figure something out on the day. I don't care how well you storyboard. But I do, I did storyboard those sequences in this. I did storyboard where the kids get assaulted. - Mm-hmm. - But I had a governing concept to it, which, you know, maybe sounds like or some more or two of your ears now, but you almost have to think in a pretentious fashion because if you don't, you're not aiming high enough. So what I was thinking about with those sequences is that you never saw the actual threat. Why? The whole idea of the title, paper tiger, this idea that yeah, they act like they're big deal, but they're nothing. Is a mistake we make all of the time where we underestimate the ocean of malevolence that exists below our daily lives. We do an excellent job in denying it. I try to remind my children of this, they'll put on a pair of sneakers. You lift the tongue of the sneaker and it says made in the Philippines or something. The kid never thinks about the kid who was 13 or 12 or 11 who made that sneaker. But I always try to say who made that sneaker because everything in life involves an ethical compromise. We do a good job like I say of pushing it out of our minds because the rails every hat to contemplate it. You know, you have your computer here who made your computer, what does it mean? Foxconn and China probably made it. What does that mean? Very high suicide rate. But you don't think about that. You just have your computer. Thanks for bringing it out here. No, but you have to do that. It's not your fault. Of course. It's called compartmentalism. Exactly. Your brain would break. So we do know that there is an, as I say, an ocean of exploitation, malevolence, and we don't see it. It's outside the realm of our understanding so that we can survive. So my idea for the threat in these scenes was always outside the frame, either with sound or both with sound and visual. So for example, in the home invasion, you never see the invader. You only see a shadow. You hear it, there's things outside the walls of the theater. And it's the malevolence that you don't see that is much scarier. When the guys approach in the car, I frosted the windows. Well, who's there, somebody coming? And when I shot one of the guys only from the back of his head, never from the front, there's very few outside shots, except when the kids finally leave the car, that all of this is about the threat that you is there, but that you cannot process because to do so would kind of break your brain. And that is in a larger sense about the system in which we live. The system in which we live enforces a kind of cruelty. Why is that? It needs cruelty. If I negotiate with you, I'm in negotiations. Who has more leverage? The person who has more leverage with the person who does not care enough or as much. I don't care whether I win or lose it. So I have more leverage. You want it badly, you have less. The system incentivizes not caring, a viciousness, a cruelty, Jack Welch, GE, right? And incentivizes that guy. We have to be infefficient, we have to have stock clothes, fire everybody, who cares? I would argue that long term, he did huge damage. But short term, that's the idea. So what does that mean? If a system incentivizes cruelty, the system incentivizes denial about embracing the forces that actually make products for us, the exploitation of workers, this idea is connected entirely with violence and how violence is used either directly or implied to maintain an order under which we live. So all of this went into the soup of the film that in order to, hey, this is business opportunity in Brooklyn, what does it actually mean to engage with, quote, a business opportunity? Now, there are broader questions that we live under now with AI, which is a whole other conversation. But really, we don't engage with this notion enough because it's seen as the correct way to organize a society. Do I have an answer for what we can do that you can't monetize the idea of integrity? Do I have an answer for how to fix that? I do not. Certainly, social dictatorships were not the answer. I went to the Soviet Union, it was a crumbled failed state. That's not the answer, but just because I don't have the answer, it doesn't mean it's not my job to try and build a story and a narrative and a form that somehow implies what it is we live under. Have I made any sense at all? Absolutely, I would not have imagined you would have taken us there through a question about the dynamics of making a scary movie scene, but I see what you're saying. Well, you have to because all of your formal decisions, I mean, look, maybe people don't agree with me. I don't think not many filmmakers do this. All formal decisions must stem from a broader idea of narrative. Now, our idea of narrative is what? Our idea of narrative is he went into the place, he put the cup down and then he saw a guy with a gun, right? That's that kind of, that's plot. Yeah. We understand plot, that's what we see, we get it, it's immediately digestible. Story has a broader implication. When you think of story, all the formal decisions must go into your story. What is story? Story are the events, maybe the plot is part of it, but it is a broader historical, social context for the events in the film. All of your formal decisions must somehow inform that narrative idea because that lens, what? What's the word? Unity to the work. You don't have that if you're just doing random moving shots, doesn't mean anything. So much of Hitchcock's brilliance with something like vertigo. And it's interesting, you said, we were talking about personal result of biographical. I look at vertigo and I say to myself, that feels almost autobiographical to me. I don't know what's going on with his fetish. He had her made up, he had Kim Novak made up in a very specific way. He obviously had a thing about blondes, icy blondes. She's got to drive that green role. So she's got to be of a specific class. Like there's a lot going on that feels directly autobiographical. I think this is, they're all connected. Well, you're describing feels more like desire and dream-making rather than autobiography, but that doesn't mean that it's a part of autobiography. Your dreams are not part of your autobiography? Perhaps. I understand your point. I think we could, it's a little bit semantics because in some way, yes, that's what, that's why the movie is personal. You're right that it's not autobiographical in the traditional sense. Like, I went to school at this place and then I got a job doing no working on it. It's not that, but I view our dream life as part of our autobiography. It's Freud's great leap forward. It's the idea that the unconscious is part of our story. Mm-hmm. So I think he does an incredible job with that, but all of his decisions formally, he didn't just randomly do stuff. It's why, how does the style, choice that you're making, fit the idea for the story you're telling? How does it, how does it reinforce a thematic thread? I think about this constantly. So the set pieces in the film exist outside the frame and the sound exists outside the frame to imply a malevolence that you cannot ever corral. Can we unravel this a little bit? Do you think about the purpose and intent of your work on a long form way and a beyond just film to film? Do you think of what you want the movies to represent, what change they, and if not change they can make, that idea that you're describing is something that you want people to feel and understand maybe subconsciously, but by explicating it here, your intention is clear, that we are. you'd live in a system that is stacked against us, right? And then we can't see who's working against us at all times. - Well, people know it, right? Do they? - People, oh, they do. - Maybe, maybe, they do, Sean. - I watched, I was watching "Seast Man Late One Night" as one would, and there was a chairman of the company. I won't say which, but there's a chairman of the company, in his speech, he said 95% of the people don't know there's a game. So the remaining 5%, 4% know this game don't know how to play it, and then there's the top 1% knows how to play it and wins. I think his numbers are all off. I think like 0.00001, play it and win. But I think most everybody else know this game, and doesn't quite know how to get inside to play the game. I think he's way off. But let's accept even that notion. If you look at the disquiet, or across really the entire industrialized world, why are we still grappling with this idea of the recurrence of fascism? Like, how is this not dead? This fascism caused the death of what, 85 million people, maybe even 100, depending on your estimates. That should be a kind of thing we could say, oh, that fascism thing, which led to mass death and genocide, that we could say that's not good, but it's not dead. Why? Well, first of all, it must be in us in some way, that's primal attraction to the strong man. They must know it out. There must be, but it is not only the strong man idea. Yes, it is. It's a strong man in a way that it's like a strong king or something. But it's more than just the strong man. There's a weird kind of like resentment thing that fascism also adds to the mix, a bigotry that fascism adds to the mix, and, or Nazism, we should say, because fascism and Mussolini was a little bit different, but we don't want to get into that. But the point is, there's a record essence of it because we live in a system where people at least unconsciously know they are getting screwed over and they don't know what to do about it. The number one job in the United States, other than two states, Virginia and Washington, where the number one job is software designer. And the other 48 states, truck driver. That's the number one job for men. So what's going to happen when there's self-driving trucks? What are we gonna do? Maybe not consciously the truck driver thinks of this every day, but unconsciously he knows that's coming and that is his livelihood and where does that come at? That is terror. So I think people know that the system is in some way not for them. It's not going to accommodate them. Anyone who's ever got forbid out of health emergency and that makes all of us, I think, knows dealing with health insurance companies is not exactly the most fun thing you'll ever do. All of this stuff goes into the soup in this way and it lends itself to a society that right now is very close to breaking. We feel it. I don't think it's just me that's saying this, is it? No, it's interesting though, because in the drama of the film, which is very much about corruption and shortcuts, that there are people who are trying to take a shortcut. And it's not that they're taking the shortcut that the reason they're being punished, it's because they're not good at taking shortcuts. Well, they won't take the shortcut. Adam Driver won't, he won't capitulate to being a totally corrupt, he doesn't do either. He doesn't do either. It's kind of like really meddling sense of personal morality that gets in the way of being able to get what you think you really want, which I think is an amazing, dramatic framework for the story. But it kind of messes with that idea a little bit. They are described. But it is messy in life. You'll do X, but you won't do Y. How far will you go? This is the idea of narrative with character dilemmas. We're a little bit Americans, which are many Americans versus Europeans. Americans are very much into a mannequin view of the world. Good guy, bad guy. I don't, maybe it's the New Yorker in me. I don't think it's quite so clear cut. I mean, look, obviously, you know, we're talking about fascism or Nazism. You could name these horrible people. I mean, it's hard to come up with a positive view of Paul Pot, you know, obviously. Those people exist, but that's not most people. Most people are doing their best to try and function in a given situation and they're trying to act in a way that is as ethically based as it can be, but they're in trouble. That to me is the core of drama. I mean, you could make a downfall Bruno Gans' performance and downfall as Adolf Hitler is amazing. But the reason the downfall works, in my mind, the reason why Gans' performance is so great is because it's Hitler at the end to mess shaking. He can't hold it together. And you see this mythic figure rendered as almost a weakling in a way. And that provides the dramatic situation. Hitler as a strong man is probably a terrible movie character because who cares is the most boring, awful person ever. Why do I want to watch a totally awful human being? What matters is the conflict within us. Is Michael Crowley own going to shoot Solotsu on McCluskey? He doesn't do what Clemenza says. He doesn't come out blessed and says Clemenza. What does he do? Goes back to the table, sits there, and you have that close up of Al Pacino, and he sits there in his eyes, widen a little bit, and he shagwits his teeth when the broken jaw already has. And is he going to show them? I don't know, should I show them for my father? Give up my life as a war hero. Delamah. So to me, that's the core of the ramen. To me, that's what most people live with. This film's set in 1986 and Queens, and there's not more New York meds in it. Why is that? That's not true. The kid has one pen on the wall. It's not just that. He's watching the meds play the expose on television at a party that he has. Okay. I forgot that. Both kids have meds things on their walls. I think there's a meds broadcast playing on the radio in another scene, is that true? Yeah. I think there's four different citations for the meds, but you know the meds traded Tom Seever in 1977. I'm aware of that. I believe for Pat Zachary was it only Pat Zachary was also Rolly Eastwick. I believe him as well. Yeah, that's, that's shameful. By the way, I know that everything is shared with me by my father. Yeah. Well, that's why I left the meds. You will undoubtedly know this, which is divine, that the meds were mismanaged in large part by a man named M Donald Grant. Indeed. And the great thing about that is, what is the name of the villain in From Russia With Love played by Robert Shaw? Is it, is it Donald Grant? Which I love. Is that an intentional choice? No, okay. Just 1963 that movie. I know M Donald Grant was never as muscular as Robert Shaw is. From the M Donald Grant. He would never win a fight on a train either. No, he would not. Well, neither does Robert Shaw mind you. That's true. Um, let's take what's called Johansson. This is a really hard part. I think, I think it is a totally brilliant performance. I will say this. It is so accurate for a New York Queens. But that is, it's, that's a very culturally specific. I know. That's what I was going to ask you about. One is how do you sort of like direct that and then how do you kind of make it? I've been, I've been, when I saw the can, I was like, that is that what that person is. Like that is because some people love that performance. Some people didn't respond as positively too. Oh, really? Well, if you know it, if you know, if you know that woman, she is that woman in a way that is so striking, insanely accurate. Yeah. Um, I haven't spoken to people who didn't respond to the performance. I can only tell you that my own feeling, look, I have humility about a lot of things. I do think I'm a pretty good judge of acting and actors. Um, and my own view is that it is a. I looked for in it and what she does is tremendous 100% emotional commitment. And it, I mean, it's hard now, but it was really hard in 1986. Let's be honest, to be a woman, it's harder than it is to be a man. And there are all these responsibilities that women were and to a large degree still are meant to, to, to take on, to fill that family unit with love, to make sure it continues, to keep the family together, maybe even sometimes paying the bills, making sure that side of it was all settled, oftentimes by the 80s to work, usually to work. Mm-hmm. Um, two incomes rather than one, very important. And, uh, and also to, uh, to support the husband's emotional life. And all while realizing that the men probably will not take a concomitant and equivalent interest in her life, emotional life, her emotional well-being, that is a harder thing to do than to be a man. It is. And so one of the things that she does in the film, which I think is amazing, is that there is all this storage of frustration and anguish. That she almost assuredly had to undergo an endure that comes out when he reveals that he basically failed her completely with the children. That is as faithfully rendered an argument from my own childhood as I possibly could have imagined. I didn't have to give her that much direction. She's a New Yorker, frankly, she's Jewish, she understood the cultural milieu completely. If anything, it's a little bit less. My mother had, if Scarlett is doing what my mother sounded like, it would sound like guys and dolls. She would sound like, you know, Vivian Blaine from Guys and Dolls on Broadway in the 50s. And so to avoid Damon Runyon, she's doing less, but it's still for some people they go what? But if you know that world, then you get it. I can't make a film where the character is not doing something accurate for that world so that someone else can quote easily get it. I don't think that the cinema, the cinema is for me is about you looking into another consciousness, seeing another world. It's not about me trying to cater to your consciousness. That would make no sense, it wouldn't be interesting on any level. So the performance is it's actually less broad than I think one's conception would be because of one scene where she explodes at him and emasculates him, which is uncomfortable. So then the question is, is it uncomfortable or is it not good? I think it's uncomfortable. I see it and it feels authentic to me. There's subtle stuff too, there's a lot, the scene when uncle comes over and the way that she regards drivers character, which is very different than the way that the boys and her brother do. And there's a kind of gestural quality, a discomfort around him. She kind of has sussed out that this is a little bit of an untrustworthy figure that is like the small choices in what she's doing that are really good. Well, she goes and listens in on the conversation. And she also, I mean, I think it's a great performance. I mean, it's a very operatic performance, maybe that's part of the, and I don't mean operatic meaning over the top. I don't think it is, but it's operatic in that there are big emotional static figure, a tragic figure. And we're not, I don't think, I'm not sure how much audiences are attuned to that at this moment, either we find something broadly melodramatic in a context of broad melodrama. So we accept it. Or it's a kind of cinema of truth. Now I love the dar dens, I love them. But you would never see a performance like this in a dar dens movie, everything is sort of like this, everybody's quote unquote real. But I don't know about your life, my, my family was quite loud. I say, yeah, obviously my family was quite loud. But the men could be, it's not to similar to this, a little more taciturn, you know, a little bit more measured, and then could be explosive at times, but mom was loud. Same thing for my household. My mother was extremely loud. You have all this laundry, pick it up. Yeah. I vividly remember as a teenager for whatever reason, falling asleep on the couch and the living room often, probably just being out too late. And every morning at six o'clock in the morning, my mother and my sister would be awake. And speaking at this volume at six o'clock in the morning and that with no understanding of the fact that they were speaking more loudly than anyone else in the world was at that time. I mean, don't you think though part of that is just cultural, I mean, I think is a specific thing to who that person is. And if you don't know it, you either accept it or it feels like a bunch of crazy people in it or something. I don't know. Because I don't know, I try very hard to avoid reactions to things. So I don't, I can't, I'm speaking to something I don't know really fully. Are you doing another movie? What's happening next? I'm unemployed. Well, I'm not unemployed. I'm now trying to make sure people see this one, which is what my time has taken up with now. You're so good at that though. I don't think I am fully, I'm not meant to be in front of the camera, it's very obvious. And also I think my answers are too long-winded and often pretentious. I'm just telling you, I don't, I'm not wholly comfortable doing stuff like this. I like talking to you, but you're, I've seen you with many other folks over the years. You're very good. Yeah. Have you considered doing this? I'm podcast, some version of this. No, I'm, I'm extremely awkward. I'm a really awkward person. It's not, I'm being completely honest with you. I'm, I, what do you think I do, sit at home and like, hey, I'm, no, I do, I do think that. That's crazy. I think you're like driver's character. I think you're very soft. No, no, I'm, I'm, I'm a completely messed up neurotic person who has a tremendous amount of love for my wife and children. And that's about the best I can say. I am, this is a very difficult environment for me because you want, the thing is, you want the film to speak for itself and I always feel like having to explain it means that I've done a terrible disservice that, that the film is not, not, I'm not talking about this movie, but any movie that you have to talk about, that the film has not done the work. Well, I always think it's an amazing dynamic since I've gotten to know you because, you know, your films don't bend over backwards to explain themselves and their, the themes are quite clear, but you're comfortable with a little bit of shaded intent, but you're so eloquent in explaining how you have gotten to the place of how you've made them that it's, I wonder if you, it's a bit of like a, a trap or a devil's bargain or something like, if I were you, I would explain because I have such a command of understanding of my choices. Thank you. Well, I, you know, exactly, I will say this, when you have been, how do I put this? When you've been taught a certain way, not vagueness is bad. We've discussed vagueness is bad or ambiguity is great. It lends a life to the work that lasts a long time, and I have a resistance to films that think the best version of themselves is Sunday school. In other words, a moral lesson that you learn by the end, and I find that that is of limited use to us. Yeah, I, this is so interesting. I mean, obviously I pursued this for my life's work, so there's something to it, but when I was a kid, I would, I'd love to watch films, and then I'd love to watch anything I could get my hands on or read anything I get my hands on of people who made films, talking about their experience, making them and what they meant by it. And sometimes they could be literal, sometimes they could be metaphorical, sometimes they could be grand eloquent about the greater place in the universe, sometimes they could be very small and modest, but I always liked hearing about that stuff. And it never took away from my enjoyment of the movie, but so often directors say, well, I don't want to explain what I meant by the movie because the work should stand on its own, but I'm not sure if I agree with that. I'm not, I'm not really, I'm not sure if that makes sense. It's why I keep inviting filmmakers on and ask them questions, like I want to know. I think people want to know. I get what you're saying, but look, I'm, this is going to sound totally pompous, but I mean, when I die and I'm closer now to the end than to the beginning, I was on me here. Well, I'm not morose. It's a fact. It's fine. It's life. By the way, it's part of what gives us beauty. You know, there's no beauty without some kind of acknowledgement of our mortality. I want the thing to be able to live in some way after I'm gone. And if I'm not here to explain it, it will be recorded this episode. Well, I understand that, but come on. You're not going to, you don't watch the movie with a running commentary. I mean, sure you do. Well, you can't. You're a very specific thing, Sean. I mean, most people don't do that. Most people just watch the movie and you want the film. You know, when the pandemic hit and lockdown started, I mean, I lost my father to COVID. So it's not like I'm making light of it, but there were, perversely, there were aspects of lockdown that I found rewarding. I became even closer to my family. I mean, we were always pretty close, but you know, my kids and I would go out and watch, we watched about 150 movies over the lockdown. I would make a dinner after chloroxing all the groceries. And then we would go out and watch a movie to the guesthouse, watch a movie, and I was very lucky about where I was living. And we started in 1928, cinema, I think, maybe 29, first picture might have been applause by Ruben Mammullian, where I showed them everything from 29 to about 1990, 1990, because that's when they started to really on their own watch stuff. [BLANK_AUDIO] And the work that stood out, and by the way, about 90% of what I chose held up brilliantly well, 10%, and maybe I shouldn't have shown that, but about 90%, the reason that stuff held up was because there was a material, no, materials the wrong word, there was a mysterious aspect to them, that the enduring unanswerables made them true works of majesty, but they were shown and probably contextualized by the world's greatest film professor who happened to live in their home as their father. I didn't give them a huge speech beforehand. I mean, I'll give you an example. I showed all three of them. The youngest was my son, Rafi. He would have been at the beginning, I guess, a leaven, and that sounds right. 11, I said, "2011, what the hell was it?" He was at 2021, 2020. So, yeah, he would have been 11. And they all loved him. And I didn't have to give him a speech at the beginning about the Weimar Republic or something. They just were like, "Oh, we love serial killers, though." I mean, come on, it was serial killers, but it's like a procedural, and then you have to kind of feel almost bad for him. It's like an amazingly complex work of art, and they were knocked out. I didn't need to explain much at all. I did give him a little context for especially grapes of wrath, and also I'm a fugitive from Chain Guy. I remember we talked about the depression a little bit. My favorites. Yeah, amazing movies. And then for Bonnie and Clyde, I had to talk to them about the Great Depression, but I think that's a very broad idea, and what makes the film's work is not really a history lesson on the depression. This has been a history lesson. Are we done? Yeah, I mean, I feel like we just scratched the surface. We didn't get anything. What else do you want to talk about? The floor is yours. It's your turn. I don't know. Did you ask me enough about the movie itself? I feel okay. I feel like I just rambled a lot. No. What? You always do this. What do you mean? Well, because you talked about the big ideas of the film. You talked about the mechanics of the film making. You talked about star performance. Oh, good. Talk about where it fits in the lineage of your filmography. Oh, good. Really? You've done good work. Okay. Good. Well, then I'll be calm. Is there something else you really like about it or you're proud of or you're interested in? I think it's about, I think, well, I'm proud of them. But I think the one thing I got closer to, you asked me about how it rhymes with Little Odessa. I think it's more, I think it's got a warmth to it that the other one doesn't have. And I'm proud of the idea of it's love being first and foremost of importance. Maybe not as weirdly, maybe not as commercially acceptable in a weird way. Love is seen as kind of quaint in some quarters. Funny. I think this movie is pretty, forgive this phrase, but conventionally entertaining. You know, I've been told there's a proper thriller. I've been told that and I love that. Yeah. I love that. What I mean is some people, they may think they might think the warmth of it is the same thing as the sentimental, but it's not. Okay. So I think I may have sent you this note after I saw the movie, but you know, you went back into the tall grass. And I think that's the, this is the best thing that you've ever done. I think the tall grass stuff in me on the night is amazing. It's different. This is way better. This is like I had no time for that in me on the night. Is that true? Yeah. I had I think I believe I had one day and you get in that amazing shot, though, of Joaquin Emerging, which is just that's the that's the law. It is wonderful shot, but that's the luck of the weather at the time, which was about to have a horrible idea that you had in the way that it comes out of the smoke and the weeds. It's very, very thick. It's incredible. Yeah, no, that's good. I'll give you that. But in this, you know, this feels more like a curussell in me, you know, the way that it's cut the way that it's shot. I stole it from actually not curussell. I stole it from a movie called Samurai Rebellion. Yeah, curussell movie. I almost shot for shot. Actually, okay. Well, that makes sense. I felt this is very Japanese sequence. No, that was intended. I've had some people say Michael Mann to me, which I frankly, I love Michael Mann. I'm reverent, but I didn't think of Michael Mann. I guess that's because of the planes overhead. Yeah, and I think that just the tension and the handgun. I did not think of of that. I thought I did steal it from the Japanese. Well, that was, you know, I have a recurring nightmare really. My brother and I got lost in a park and Howard Beach. And those, that's called fragmide's grass. People say it was corn. It's not. It's actually weeds. Yeah. And they're very tall. They're seven feet tall. So you lose your sense of geography immediately. How old are you and you got lost? 1974. So I would have been five. Yeah, my brother was seven. So we were quite panicked. And, you know, that nightmare never goes away. So I was trying also, I was not 100% thrilled with the amount of time and effort that I was able to put into we on the night. One of the things that I couldn't have conquered was it had rained. And it was very, very swampy. And to move when we were doing that sequence was almost impossible. I remember I would give a direction. And in 20 seconds later, I would walk this way and my foot would be, my shoe would be in the mud and I would be face down. So I had a lot of physical trouble in me on the night that I didn't have on this. I planned it a little differently. We also had a piece of equipment we didn't have in 19, in 2006 or 2005 when I was shocked, which was the techno crane with a 40 foot arm. So the camera could basically be right outside the weeds and then just dropped in anywhere. And that was amazing. That was the reason I was able to do this, I think better a piece of equipment. It's amazing work. Thank you. We end every episode of this show by asking filmmakers, what's the last great thing they have seen? Well, it's very difficult for me to answer that because I have not seen a new movie sadly in months. Can I ask you about that actually? Because one of the recurrences of our conversations over the years has been this kind of industrial emotional analysis of the movie industry. You're very eloquent about this and have been for a long time. You always have a really strong perspective. However, this has been for me the most fun year I've had making this show because something has happened. There is some there is a new energy in movie going, which is my favorite thing. And I have never been more hopeful about this thing. It doesn't mean every movie is great. It doesn't mean even the movies that seem like they're great are going to last the test of time. But like, there's been a shift. And I don't know if you sense this if your kids are experiencing this. I have sensed it on the basis of the obsession and backroom's discussion. But let me try to. It's not because I don't want to go. I'm dying to go. It's because starting in April when I was mixing the film, then I went off to France to publicize the movie and since the summer, I mean, I have been traveling so much. I want to go to the movies to get the popcorn to sit down like for example, people say to me, have you seen Nathan, have you seen that you can say that's a three hour long film, which I'm thrilled to see. I don't care about running time. But I'm explaining to you an hour before and hour after whatever. It's a five hour commitment. And I will get to it. I will see it. But it's going to have to be after December. It's going to have to be after this craze ends. So this is a unique situation every three years or four years when I make a film. I have this period where I don't get to see the beautiful work of others. I mean, the last movie I saw, which is not a new movie that I thought was the greatest thing ever. Does that count? Of course, I need new world. It's old. But that even that I saw maybe six or seven months ago. Light on me. Was a Claude Lansman documentary called soby, but very musical title. Soby Borer, October 14, 1943, 4 p.m. Which I don't know if it's that easy to see. I haven't seen it. Tell me about it. It is incredible. He shot at the same time. He shot show up, but he didn't really know what to do with the footage. It's an interview with a man who was one of the people who led the rebellion at Soby Borer. And he's he was in the carpentry shop and he kills the SS soldier with an axe from the carpentry shop. And it's him telling the story of how he killed this man. And he was not a killer. How he did it. And it's just him. And it was sent to me by a friend who said, you have to see this movie on DVD. And I thought I don't have time I have to go. It was actually it would have been I know exactly was it was right before I started the mix. So it would have been April of 2026. And I got into a hotel room and I watched it. And I thought it was stunning. He tells a detail, which is totally amazing. He tells a one in the camp to cover up the screams that the Nazis had assembled an ocean of geese that would make noise to cover all the noise. The level of thought to that malevolence. The description and detail of his murdering this guy who had to be murdered for the rebellion. It's an astonishment he tells the detail of the axe coming down on the man's face and seeing a spark on the tooth from the metal of the axe. And I was just like, oh my God. I couldn't think of anything else for three days. He's in the name of the film again. - Soby Borer, October 14th, 1943, 4pm. I believe that's it, maybe I have the date wrong or something, but it's Claude Lansman is the director who made, of course, show the nine hour long documentary about the Holocaust. - James, thank you. - It's always a pleasure. - My pleasure. - Okay, thank you to James Gray. Thanks for our producer, Jack Sanders, for his work on today's episode. Thanks to Lucas Kavanaugh for production support next week. We're digging into Madden. Yes, the movie Madden with a special guest, our Palmyna Kimes. And the international feature film race with our friend Tracy Lutz. We'll see you then. (upbeat music) [BLANK_AUDIO]

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. *The Hunger Games
  2. The film suffers from poor pacing, excessive CGI, and a lack of originality, with many scenes focused on dialogue about game design rather than action or emotional stakes.
  3. The casting of Gen Z actors in major roles marks a generational shift in blockbuster filmmaking, with the film being the first Hunger Games entry where all key characters were born in 1997 or later.
  4. Despite its flaws, the film succeeds in appealing to younger audiences and capitalizing on nostalgia, with strong marketing and a familiar, well-established franchise framework.
  5. *Paper Tiger*, directed by James Gray, is a powerful, emotionally resonant crime thriller that blends personal family history with genre storytelling, delivering strong performances, especially from Adam Driver and Miles Teller.
  6. Driver’s performance as a retired police officer is particularly praised for its emotional depth and transformation, while Teller’s portrayal of a conflicted father is seen as authentic and nuanced.
  7. The film effectively explores themes of family, masculinity, and silence, with moments that resonate deeply due to their realism and personal significance.
  8. The success of both films reflects broader industry shifts

Summary:

The episode reviews two major films: *The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping*, a prequel that rehashes the original film’s plot with minimal innovation, leading to criticism for its slow pacing, poor visuals, and lack of originality despite strong Gen Z casting. While it taps into nostalgia and appeals to younger fans, it fails to deliver fresh narrative momentum or emotional depth. In contrast, *Paper Tiger*, directed by James Gray, is lauded as a mature, deeply personal crime thriller that blends real-life family dynamics with genre storytelling.

Its powerful performances—especially Adam Driver and Miles Teller—elevate the narrative, with moments of raw emotional intensity and artistic cinematography. The episode highlights a shift in blockbuster filmmaking, where Gen Z actors are now central to major franchises, and where personal storytelling is increasingly valued over formulaic repetition. It also underscores how franchises like *The Hunger Games* remain commercially viable by adapting to new audiences, while films like *Paper Tiger* demonstrate that high emotional stakes and authentic character development can still drive critical success in a competitive market.

FAQs

The film is set 24 years before the original Hunger Games and follows 16-year-old Hamich Abernathy from District 12 as he is selected for the 50th Hunger Games, a 'quarter quell' with twice as many tributes. He forms an alliance with another tribute, Measly Donner, and fights to survive against President Snow and the Capitol.

It is a prequel focusing on Hamich Abernathy, a character similar to Katniss Everdeen, and explores the early history of the Hunger Games. It also features a new generation of actors, all born in 1997 or later, marking a shift in the franchise's target audience.

It is a prequel set 24 years before the original Hunger Games, specifically to the 50th Hunger Games known as the 'second quarter quell.' It is also a prequel to the 2012 film 'The Hunger Games' and the subsequent movies.

Critics found the film to be overly familiar and similar to the original Hunger Games, with a slow pace and dull narrative. While it has strong performances, especially from Jesse Plemons, many felt it was a repetitive retelling of existing storylines without much innovation.

Jesse Plemons and Joseph Zada deliver standout performances as Hamich and Measly Donner, respectively. Other notable roles include McKenna Grace, Maya Hawk, and Whitney Peak, who bring energy and depth to their characters.

The film features every major role played by actors born in 1997 or later, signaling a generational shift in blockbuster filmmaking. This reflects a broader trend where younger actors are becoming central to major franchises, reshaping how studios approach casting and audience engagement.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.