This episode of *Science Versus* investigates whether the full moon truly influences human behavior and biology. Host Wendy Zuckerman and producer Meryl Horne begin by collecting anecdotes from New Yorkers, who blame the moon for erratic behavior, workplace chaos, and menstrual syncing. However, scientific evidence challenges these claims. Emergency physician Wendy Coates found no increase in ER admissions or trauma severity during full moons, and reviews of crime studies show no lunar effect. Animal behaviors, such as coral spawning and coyote howling, are linked to lunar cycles, but not in the ways commonly assumed. A more compelling finding comes from sleep researcher Horacio de la Iglesia, who discovered that people, even in light-polluted cities like Seattle, sleep less and later in the days leading up to a full moon, displaying a clear sinusoidal pattern. The cause remains mysterious; the moon’s gravitational pull on humans is negligible, but it may subtly alter Earth’s magnetic field, which humans could detect via cryptochrome proteins, though this is highly speculative. Regarding menstruation, a small study suggested a weak link, but a massive analysis of millions of cycles found no syncing. Ultimately, while many full moon myths are debunked, the moon does appear to have a subtle, unexplained effect on sleep, leaving scientists humble about its potential influence on our bodies.
Hi, I'm Wendy Zuckerman, and you're listening to Science Versus.
This is the show that pits facts against the full moon.
Does it change who we are?
This episode about the full moon has been one of our most requested episodes this past
year.
You asked for it, so here it is.
And to start our journey, we sent senior producer Meryl Horne out to brave the streets of New
York City.
Picture it.
There's a chill in the air.
Out in the east, the full moon was on the rise, and she ventured into a park to hear
firsthand what people experience when there's a full moon.
Makes people wild.
It makes them carnal.
It's a carnal thing happening.
Everyone does not act right.
It's terrible.
I think people are just wilding out.
Claws out, you know.
I'm blaming the moon.
It's that damn moon.
Some people said that the full moon stirred up all this drama in their lives.
One guy said that sometimes he doesn't even go out when there's a full moon.
I'm going to stay in on that night.
I'm going to play it safe.
Just like, because I know I could feel weird or do crazy stuff.
Folks said you just knew it was going to be a full moon that night.
Because people at work would be going bonkers.
And this is in the research, too.
It shows,
that some health care workers think the full moon makes their patients behave stranger.
One survey even showed that some doctors and nurses think they should get full moon hazard pay.
Meryl heard about this as well at the park.
My mom was a nurse at the state hospital and she had a lot of like psychiatric patients.
And she was like, oh, man, the full moon is the worst.
It's the absolute worst.
Because people do act crazy.
I've worked in retail.
I worked there for like a full year.
And every single time on the full moon, we had the craziest customers.
And I would tell everyone, I'd be like, it's the full moon.
Watch out.
And they'd be like, it's not going to be that bad of a day.
It was.
It was the worst days.
Every single day.
You still work there?
No, I quit.
I quit on the full moon, actually.
Like, fully quit on the full moon.
And perhaps the creepiest thing of all, people said that the full moon could make blood come out of your vagina.
I mean, they didn't put it quite like that.
No.
It definitely affects me from like the feminine cycle, the monthly cycle.
Do you think you sync up with the full moon?
Yeah, for sure.
My period will probably be coming because it's usually cycled with the moon.
Literally, I go to beauty school.
I go to cosmetology school.
It's mostly women.
All their cycles synced up to this week, basically.
So up to the full moon.
So like they're in the middle of their periods literally today.
So could the moon be affecting our body and our behavior in these strange ways?
Well, this idea might sound like it belongs in the world of horoscopes, perhaps even fairy tales.
Some scientists have been taking it very seriously.
And in the past few years in particular, there's been a slew of peer reviewed scientific papers coming out and claiming that the moon really can affect our bodies in very surprising ways.
So in today's episode, we are going to look at this cutting edge theory.
And by the end of the ep, you might just be feeling a little carnal yourself.
For hundreds of years, we've blamed all sorts of stuff on the. That damn moon.
But then there's science.
Science versus the full moon is coming up after the break.
This episode is brought to you by Accenture.
When your advertising operations fall out of sync,
everything else follows.
Spotify and Accenture are working together
to reinvent the rhythm of ad sales.
Using automation, analytics, and smarter workflows
to simplify campaign delivery
and access better data across the business.
The result?
Less time spent on operations,
more time connecting brands with the moments and fandom
that matter most.
Learn more at Accenture.com slash Spotify.
Welcome back.
Today on the show, we're looking at the full moon.
There's one coming up on Monday.
And so we're asking,
can it really influence us, change our behavior?
And fellow lunar explorer, Meryl Horne is here.
Hi, Wendy.
Okay, so first up,
can we just get a bit of a lay of the land?
Can you just explain
why do you see a full moon
or a half moon or whatever?
Why does it change?
Yes, I can explain this.
I actually brought a prop.
Ooh, great.
Okay, so I have like a model of the sun,
the earth, and the moon for you.
My God, you've really gone all out, Meryl.
Okay, so we are right now
on the surface of the earth, right?
Yeah.
That, I know.
Yes.
So imagine you're spinning around and around.
The earth is moving around and around.
And when we are on the part of the earth
that's facing away from the sun,
that's what we call nighttime, right?
Right, yes.
Well, the moon also has a side that's lit up
and a side that's dark.
And we see different amounts of that lit up side
depending on where the moon is in its orbit around the sun.
So when we see a full moon,
it's when the moon is in this really particular position
where you've got the moon on one side of the earth
and then the sun like on the other side.
So it's almost like the sun and the moon
are making an earth sandwich.
Okay, and the earth is in the middle.
It's the meat cheese of the sandwich.
Yeah, and so the new moon, when the moon looks dark,
is when it's in a different position.
So in that case, the moon is like,
the meat of the sandwich
and the earth and the sun are the bread.
Okay, so could it,
could just that fact
that the billiard balls up in space
are in this arrangement affect our behavior?
I mean, it feels like maybe far-fetched at first,
but if you think about it,
we know that the moon affects other animals.
That's right.
And you know, it's funny,
the one thing that everybody,
everybody associates with the full moon,
wolves howling,
I actually couldn't find any evidence
backing that up at all.
Oh, okay.
But what I do have for you is that
coyotes will howl more together on a new moon night.
That's what they sound like?
Yeah, kind of even creepier, right?
Like there are these coyotes that will like
yip together in groups at the darkest time of the month.
Some owls will call,
call out more when the moon is darker
and badgers will pee more on stuff during a new moon.
But what about, wait,
who's affected by the full moon?
I'm getting there.
Meryl, the episode is called Full Moon, not New Moon.
All right, and then on full moon,
some birds will hatch more around a full moon.
There's a, there's a little worm that does a mating dance
that happens just after a full moon.
Corals release their spawns a few nights after a full moon
or just after a full moon.
Which is an incredible event that you can see from space.
And some primates, like nocturnal ones,
will eat more during full moons.
And I even found this one reference from the 1800s
where a scientist said that rhesus monkeys
were at their most fertile during full moons.
So there are like all these ways that the moon is affecting animals.
Now we're cooking with the rhesus monkeys.
We're in primate land.
I feel a kinship.
All right, but what about human animals?
Meryl, are we affected by the moon?
And why don't we start with the idea that on a full moon,
hospitals get packed, patients are going wild.
Yeah, yeah.
So researchers have actually looked into this.
So there is, you know, the thinking is that
if the full moon really is making people act more recklessly,
then maybe we'll like see evidence for that
in how busy ERs are.
And I mean, there is just a lot of evidence
and a long history of people thinking
that this kind of thing is true.
You can see it in our language,
like the word lunatic that comes from the moon.
Right.
And so to find out if this is real,
I talked to another Wendy, Wendy Coates.
Is that going to be confusing for you?
No, it'll make me feel right at home.
So what does expert Wendy say?
Well, she's been an emergency medicine physician
for over three decades.
And she published one of the first studies on this question of whether ERs
are more busy on full moons.
Okay.
It came out a few decades ago.
Great.
So I got in touch.
You reached out right around the time of the blood moon
that was receiving so much popular press attention here.
And every time there's something about the full moon, I kind of remember sort of nostalgically back to this study.
And then the next day, I opened my email and you're like, hi, I'm Meryl.
Whoa.
Tell us the story of Wendy's study.
So it all started when she was just an intern at a major trauma center in Pittsburgh.
And she said that pretty quickly, she started hearing about this idea that things might get busier when there's a full moon.
Okay, so you have to picture a bunch of emergency physicians and emergency nurses sitting around.
Well, we don't really sit around, but, you know, like in passing or, you know, you're sitting down to do your charting and somebody says, get ready.
It's a full moon tonight.
What did they mean?
Oh, we're going to have all these terrible accidents or.
You know, you just can't even imagine.
Here I am like a lowly intern and like all of these super experienced emergency department nurses and physicians are like gearing up for just like this intense night shift.
And so I was like, okay, well, this must be something.
Are you the coyote?
Yeah.
Well, I was everything inside.
And we wanted to go, oh, and then I realized that's no longer factually acceptable.
But those are during a new moon.
So we have to rebrand the coyote.
Oh, that's right.
Corals don't make any noise.
Okay, so Wendy, all her superiors believe this to be true.
What happens next?
Well, so then she decides to do like a proper study on this.
So here's what they did.
She worked with her advisor and they got the records from her trauma.
Center for a year, over 1400 people all together.
And she looked to see like how many people were admitted, how bad are people's injuries, whether or not they died.
And then they took the day of the full moon and also the day before that and the day after it to kind of look at all those nights around the full moon.
And then compare those nights to every other night of the month to see like, okay, is there any difference here?
Was this night different to all other nights?
Yeah.
Yeah, here's what she saw.
It was pretty funny because we're like, hmm, it looks like there's no difference.
Oh, no difference.
Yeah, there was no increase in how many people were admitted, how bad their traumas were, or how many of these patients died around the full moon.
And in fact, well, maybe there are fewer traumas and less severe traumas on the actual full moon.
Less severe traumas, she said.
Yeah, a little bit, which she thought about it and was like, oh, maybe this makes sense because on those nights.
It's brighter, so maybe it's easier to drive on dark country roads where lots of motor vehicle accidents occur.
Maybe you're not quite as likely to go stab someone.
And since Wendy's study, others have come out looking at the same thing across the world.
Like a couple studies from the Netherlands did see a tiny decrease in traumas on a full moon.
Decrease again.
Decrease again.
Yeah, yeah, it was like better.
Okay.
And overall, a review of these studies said that there's no increase in how busy emergency departments are during a full moon.
And Wendy had this really lovely theory as to, like, why this idea sticks around the ER, despite the lack of evidence.
You know, like, if you have a group of people and they're united against some sort of assault, so, you know, you're going to have this night that's crazy busy, you're not going to get to eat, you're not going to get to go to the bathroom, but, yeah, we can all unite on the reason.
Yeah.
And just like, yeah, yeah.
It's like bonding.
It's bonding time.
And we can't predict who's coming.
We can't predict how busy it's going to be.
But what we can predict is that we're all there for each other and that sometimes something like talking about a full moon or the little look you give up to the sky as you're walking past one another gives you a little bit more encouragement to help you do your job well and be together with your team to take care of all the patients who come in.
Isn't that nice?
It is nice.
It is nice.
And if only we could all be united by the full moon.
Yeah.
So where do we go to here?
Okay.
Well, so, yeah, it doesn't seem like the full moon makes ER as busier.
By the way, I also looked into this idea that there's more crime on a full moon.
Oh, yeah.
A couple studies looked at that and did not see anything there either.
Okay.
But, Wendy, this does not put the kibosh on the whole idea that the moon can affect our behavior.
Actually?
Yeah.
Actually, after doing all of this research, I am more of a true believer.
Meryl Hawn never thought I'd see the day.
Meryl Hawn, Ph.D.
I know.
What did you find?
Okay.
So there's this one super interesting study that I want to tell you about.
Okay.
All right.
So it was done by Professor Horacio de la Iglesia at the University of Washington in Seattle.
Have you ever howled at the moon?
Not really.
Not yet.
But maybe, you know, if I keep doing research.
If I keep doing research on it, I might end up doing that.
Well, I think if he keeps doing research on it, he'll know that that's a myth, Meryl.
That's true.
So he's done fieldwork in Argentina, where he's from, with a group of indigenous people,
the Toba Combe, who are living in a really remote area with no electricity.
And he was curious whether living in these conditions, the moon might be affecting their sleep.
Their sleep.
Yeah.
Essentially, they live very much in tune with the natural daylight and the natural light-dark cycle.
So there is no streetlights, no. No, no streetlights, no lights in the houses.
So he asks people to wear a device on their wrist, sort of like a Fitbit, but fancier,
that tracks their sleep.
25 people agreed to do this.
And then he, like, plotted out all of this sleep data next to the, like, lunar cycle,
to see if there were any patterns.
So, if on a full moon, people slept more or less.
Yeah.
And he did see that on the days leading up to a full moon, people were sleeping less.
People were going to bed much later, up to an hour later, and sleeping by about an hour less.
Huh.
That's a pretty big effect.
Yeah, that's a huge effect in sleep terms, right?
On average, it was about a 45-minute difference.
Huh.
And Orazio thought that it was probably the brightness of the moon that was doing this.
Yeah, right.
Pretty clearly for this community.
We don't realize how bright the moon is, particularly when you are under totally natural light conditions, right?
Because suddenly, the sunset, it gets very dark, and if the moon happens to come up just before, you know,
you're about to go to bed, it's nearly impossible to go to bed, right?
You see the moon there.
It's that bright out there.
Exactly.
You know, you could even read under full moonlight.
Oh, wow.
So, then Orazio decides to look at places that weren't rural, like cities.
He starts with a group of Topocone people who are living in a more urban area.
Okay.
And weirdly, he found that their sleep was still affected by the moon.
Huh.
So, now Orazio is like, okay, let's run the experiment again where he lives in the U.S.
in Seattle, in Washington State.
Mm-hmm.
He gets sleep data from about 120 people there, mostly young adults, and he still sees the same pattern.
So, these people living in Seattle were also sleeping less on the nights leading up to a full moon, by like 20 to 40 minutes.
And so, now he's sure it's not the brightness of the moon anymore?
Well, yeah, because this is Seattle.
Like, it's cloudy most of the time in the winter there.
And Orazio is still seeing this pattern, even in the winter.
And then the moonlight is also competing with other forms of light in a city.
Like, apparently, the moon, even when it's full. is still something like 50 times less bright
than a single streetlight.
The fact is that we see very clear lunar rhythms
in people living in a place where light pollution
is way above the intensity of full moon nights.
And we cannot explain that by moonlight.
So what's going on?
Was it just that they were partying more on a full moon?
Yeah, you mean like going to like full moon parties?
I guess so.
Well, you know, sitting out in the park,
watching the full moon.
I don't think so.
Because when you look at the data,
it's not like people were like suddenly sleeping less
just on the night where there is a full moon.
What you actually see is this pattern
where you kind of like sleep less and less gradually
in the days leading up to the full moon.
And then it kind of peaks.
And then you start sleeping more and more and more.
And then the full moon happens
and you keep sleeping more.
And it kind of goes like up and down, up and down
in this like wave pattern.
And Horacio saw this across all his data.
By now, I have no doubt
that there's a lunar month modulation of sleep,
particularly when you see single people
doing this beautiful sinusoidal oscillation in their sleep.
Would you want to see the wave pattern?
Yeah.
Oh, yeah.
Yeah, there's a very nice wave pattern there.
Very nice.
Very intriguing.
It's a beautiful sinusoidal pattern.
It is a beautiful sinusoidal pattern.
So, yeah, it really doesn't feel like you could like
create that pattern of sleep even if you tried, right?
It's not like people party a little bit more.
Yeah.
And if the moon affects our sleep,
then that kind of opens the door to it
maybe affecting us in other ways too
because we know that sleep can affect our mood
and our mental health.
And in fact, like there are actually studies
on bipolar disorder,
specifically this thing called rapid cycling bipolar disorder.
And what the researchers are seeing there
is that these patients seem to like be switching
between mania and depression
in a timing that kind of lines up
with the cycles of the moon.
And those researchers also think
this could be related to sleep.
Like maybe if you're losing sleep
around the full moon,
it might kind of trigger a manic state.
What?
And so now Horacio and some other scientists
believe that like, yeah,
it does seem like the moon is doing something strange here,
that it's like somehow changing our bodies and our brains
and affecting our sleep.
And it's not just about how bright it is
or partying more or whatever.
It's like there's something else.
What though?
How is it doing it?
Well,
exactly, right?
That's what we'll look at after the break.
As a result,
less time spent on operations,
more time connecting brands
with the moments and fandoms that matter most.
Welcome back.
Meryl has promised to tell us
why the lunar cycles
might be getting into our body
and somehow affecting our sleep.
I don't know.
What's going on here, Meryl?
This is strange.
Well, I mean,
this is where things get
exciting, right?
Because now we have this thing
that the moon is doing to us
and we just need to figure out how.
And, you know,
when I talk to people
on the streets about this,
about how the full moon
could be affecting us,
they had all sorts of ideas.
I definitely think
this is an energy thing.
It's because all of us
are really here
in a sea of energy.
It's that energy.
I feel like energy,
like different types of energy,
like that you,
I don't know.
I feel like it is.
We're made of like 70% water.
And like the moon
controls the tides.
So it would make sense
that it has an effect on us too.
Humans are 70% water.
So the moon is going to
automatically influence us
if we are water.
Adults are actually
only like 55% water.
But anyway,
let's look at this
because like the general idea
is that we know the moon
creates tides in the oceans
through like the pull
of its gravity on water.
So what if it's doing
something similar to us?
Right.
Okay.
And is there any,
any evidence for that?
Well,
first my question actually
was just like,
okay, sure.
It's like pulling on us
a little bit,
but like how much,
like is it realistic
that it's a big enough force
to do anything?
So I asked an astronomer
and a tidal expert
and they didn't like
laugh it off completely,
but they did the calculations
on like how big the forces were
and they were tiny,
like minuscule.
One of them found that
the force of the moon's
gravity on our bodies
is less than if you were
just like walking by
a tall building.
Like that building next to you
would have a bigger force
on our bodies than the moon
because it's like a lot closer.
Yes.
Okay.
But still,
like just because the force is small
doesn't mean that
it's not doing anything
to anybody.
Like I wondered
if we knew of any animal
that can sense this,
this pull from the moon
and thought of the animal
that like live in the tidal zone
because those animals
are really affected
by the moon's gravitational pull.
How big the tides are
has this huge impact
on their day-to-day life.
Right.
And so how are they
detecting those changes?
Is it just, you know,
through the water
or gravitational changes
directly from the moon?
Yeah.
So to find out,
I called Professor
Christian Tesmer-Reble
at the University of New York
at the University of Vienna
in Austria
since she wrote a review
about how animals
are affected by the moon
in different ways.
Right.
So I asked her,
do we know
of any organism
that can directly sense
the changes
from the moon's gravity?
Oh,
I don't know.
No.
Who uses it?
I mean, not,
I mean, you mean not
obviously tidal changes.
Not being jostled
by the tides.
Yeah, but like directly
sensing.
Sensing the moon's gravity.
Directly sensing it.
I am not aware
of something like this.
So yeah,
the case for gravity
I'd say is pretty weak.
Much like the gravitational
force of the moon on us.
Yeah, exactly.
Okay, so it's
probably not gravity.
What else is there?
Well, there's
one other thing.
Mm-hmm.
So the earth has
this super cool
magnetic field around it.
Right.
And as the moon
revolves around the earth,
it seems to like
mess with this field.
And we do know
that some animals
can sense the earth's
magnetic field.
We know organisms
like migratory birds
that use that
for their long-distance flights.
And it's not,
it's actually not only birds,
also butterflies
sense the magnetic field,
right?
And the way
we think that
they're doing this
is through this protein
called cryptochrome.
Uh-huh.
Sounds like something
I should have invested in
10 years ago.
Right.
What is it?
Um, okay.
So yeah,
cryptochrome is a protein
in our bodies
that can interact
with the magnetic fields.
And it seems to be
helping the birds
know which direction
to fly.
Uh-huh.
And do humans
have cryptochrome?
We do.
We do have a version
of cryptochrome.
It's not the exact
same protein
that the birds have,
but we actually
do have a version
where we do have
a little evidence
that our cryptochrome
can sense
the magnetic fields, too.
Uh-huh.
And so maybe
that's how the moon's
affecting us.
Because, like, okay,
what we would be looking for
if, you know,
the Earth's magnetic field
is the missing link.
Right.
It, maybe it should have
a similar kind of wave pattern
like that sinusoidal curve
that we saw
in Horacio's sleep data.
And then I stumbled
on this graph
where I was like,
whoa.
All right.
Let me, let me show this to you.
So, show me the way
the whoa graph
is it the sinusoidal again?
Because I don't know
if I can handle that, Meryl.
I don't know
if I can handle it.
So, scroll down
in the search.
Whoa!
It's the sinusoidal again.
It's the sinusoidal.
Yeah.
If you didn't think
you were listening
to a nerdy podcast,
you do now.
That is, okay,
so what is,
what is the,
is this magnetic field?
Yeah, this is the change
in magnetic fields
over a lunar cycle.
So, the line in the middle
is the full moon.
The magnetic field
is apparently lower
in the days leading up
to a full moon
just like Horacio saw.
And then it gets like
higher after the full moon.
But I don't know
if I've gone off the deep end.
Like this paper is all,
you know,
it's from like the 1960s.
Like, yeah,
it's hand drawn.
It's hand drawn.
That's for sure.
It's a, yeah,
it's like a whole.
I love these.
Like someone used a ruler.
to make those lines okay so what this shows us is that the moon affects the magnetic field
in this sinusoidal pattern that is similar to the way that the moon seems to affect our sleep
step one but then step two has anyone figured out if the cryptochrome in us
is actually detecting those changes to the magnetic field and that that is then affecting
our sleep no like nobody's actually like connected all the dots here to find out okay can we really
sense the magnetic fields at all and can that mess with their sleep when kristen was explaining
this to me there was lots of like hand waving going on and like emphasis that it's like all
kind of like magnetic field and magnetic field and magnetic field and magnetic field and magnetic
just theoretical so it's really unclear still but this is a lot of wild speculation
yeah she said that this question of whether the moon is having like a subconscious effect on us
is at the frontiers of our knowledge it's like a black hole but that doesn't mean that it's
impossible or like a silly idea just because it is a subconscious phenomenon it doesn't mean that
it doesn't exist right i think people tend to say oh i cannot feel it and therefore it doesn't exist
but we usually don't feel our liver um at least hopefully not but it's very existing right so yeah
so it's doing all sorts of stuff to us exactly exactly so i mean the fact that we are not
consciously aware of something is is true for a lot of our physiology do you think
that the moon for sure is influencing people i think yeah
the reason why i think yes is that i'm a biologist for me as a biologist
humans are just another type of animal we're made of the same stuff as the worms
exactly at the end exactly like this with some few specifications that are a bit different
from the larger perspective it's martial so
okay so here is where we are at the cycles of the
moon do seem to affect our sleep somehow we're not sure how last question can it affect
blood coming out of our vaginas you mean our menstrual cycles yes yeah let's look at that
it comes up all the time i've heard from a lot of people who think there's something there
so yeah i called up a scientist who did a pretty wild study on this
do you know describing describing a period-based study as a wild study is immediately making me
think of just a scientist throwing around dirty tampons for some reason
i don't know why i mean it's not that doesn't go that carnal but it's you know
all right let me tell you about it okay okay so the
idea first came to her when she had this commute where she was walking a lot at night i was walking
from the train station to my home family home and what did it look like on a night when there
was a moon oh fantastic because you could see everything you don't need lights in the street
so i always loved the moon to be out this is charlotta hellfreak forster senior professor
at the university of wurzburg in germany and she noticed something about her period around this time
my first day of menses was always around the full moon and when i was really astonished oh that's
interesting do you know meryl i'm i'm the exact opposite that my i will ovulate around a full moon
and get my period i guess in a new moon but i just assumed it was because i'm a pretty regular cycle
and that's just what a month is you know around 28 days or whatever sure but like if you think
about it even that's pretty weird right like that for a lot of us our periods just happen to be 29
days long which is the same length as the lunar cycle i guess so right yeah why why are our cycles
the same as the cycles of the moon okay yeah i mean yeah it could just be a coincidence
but maybe something else is going on here and so
like for charlotta she started wondering how long have i been getting my periods at the full moon
right and luckily enough she had actually been keeping track of when she was getting her period
for basically her entire life um like she started when she first started getting her period
my mother told me to make always a cross in my calendar at the first day of my menses so i did
it without thinking and kept all these little calendars at her home in a cabinet and so
now she she went back to check like is this has this always been a thing for me amazing and just
by eye she could tell that like oh yeah for like many years of my life i've either been synced with
the full moon or sometimes it was the new moon and so she starts wondering all right how how many
people is this like true for so she asks her mom and her sister if they kept their calendars and
they did and she looked at their data and saw similar stuff but of course as a scientist you
know we don't know how many people we know we don't know how many people we know we don't know
that three examples are not enough and then i started to ask colleagues friends whether they
by chance had kept any recordings of her menses and so it took her about 10 years to collect this
data from 22 women who had kept track of their cycles for an average of 15 years of their life
wow okay and so now we can find out do people on average get their periods more often around
the time of a full moon great so what did she find she said
that yeah there was something there so in this group of 22 women they were more likely to start
their periods either around the time of a full moon like especially the days leading up to a full
moon or the new moon oh how curious but like i'm one of these people who does not think this is true
for me um so i asked how strong of an effect was it since i i was curious i looked at my data for
the past few months and it definitely was not sinking yeah yeah yeah to the full moon that is
very important the effect is really very small and to be honest when you look at your entire cycle
it's only a small part during a cycle that is synchronous to the moon so yeah i mean obviously
it's not like everyone's getting their periods on the full moon yeah right it more it's more like it
upped your chances a little bit that you'd get your period on either a full moon or a new moon
okay uh-huh
but there's something else that i need to tell you about her study so after it came out in 2021
all these other women start sending charlotte other calendars they're like when they got their
period so then she got data from more than a hundred other people and she tried crunching
the numbers again and here's what happened i was absolutely disappointed when i pulled all the data
the new data that i had i didn't see any synchronized
to the moon anymore so it was very different from my first study with the 22 women
ah that classic thing where you study something in a few people get a very exciting result
and then you study it in more and more people and realize it's not generalizable we've seen this
countless times before charlotte and i are the anecdote in the room that gets the headlines
okay i mean charlotta still thinks they're
like she's been looking into whether light pollution is a factor but she also pointed
me to some other data like okay so there's an analysis that came out recently from a period
tracking app and it looked at seven and a half million cycles and they didn't see any sinking
to the moon whatsoever this has actually made me feel more like a witch you know because obviously
because it's so rare yeah we couldn't all be witches you know
well i'm glad you feel special now um that's what i'm here for but i guess we're all a bit witchy
because the moon is affecting all of our sleep in this mysterious way
don't patronize me just because i have sleep still i don't feel like a witch
it's okay
do you think that the moon is affecting you
i i really love uh i love the moon i love a big full moon i like looking at it i like
thinking how small i am in this big universe reminds me of that i love when you see it rising
and it's just huge i love it for all those reasons i don't i don't know if it's having some
deeper subconscious effect on my body.
What about you?
Meryl you've been you've been researching this for a while has it changed your view of the moon
yeah I think it I don't know I feel like now I am less skeptical like when I was in the park
and everybody was telling me about how they felt like the moon was just changing the energy and
like they could feel it and that they knew there was like something there I was just like rolling
my eyes and like sure it's like changing the energy but now I'm like oh actually maybe it is
it's the magnetic fields which is like a kind of energy it's just so mysterious there is an effect
at least on our sleep that we don't understand yet and I feel like I'm more humble now about
like what's possible with our bodies and the moon do you want to yip with me
thanks Meryl thanks Wendy
you
all right Meryl how many citations in this week's episode
this week we have 52 citations and if you go to our show notes you can find links to the transcripts
where you can see all of them and read more about the moon
excellent if you want to tell us what you thought of this episode we'd love to hear from you we are
at science underscore vs on instagram I'm at tiktok at wendy zook thanks Meryl have a happy full moon
oh yeah be careful
this episode was produced by me Meryl Horn with help from Wendy Zuckerman,
Rose Rimler, Michelle Dang, and Aketi Foster-Keys. We're edited by Blythe Sorrell. Mix and sound
design by Bumi Hidaka. Fact-checking by Marlo Starling. Music written by Bumi Hidaka, Bobby
Lord, Emma Munger, So Wiley, and Peter Leonard. Thanks to all the researchers we spoke to for
this episode including Dr. Ron Flick, Dr. Michael Smolenski, Michael Benninger, and Dr. Michael
Bevington, Dr. Laurel Sims, Professor Laura Prugge, and Dr. Martin Nysten. Special thanks to Kevin
Walsh and all the folks who chatted with me about the full moon. Science Versus is a Spotify Studios
original. Listen for free on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts and if you do listen on
Spotify follow us and tap the bell for episode notifications. We'll fact you soon!
Thank you.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The full moon is popularly believed to affect human behavior, with anecdotes from New Yorkers about craziness, workplace chaos, and menstrual cycles syncing with lunar phases.
Scientific studies show no increase in emergency room visits, trauma severity, or crime during full moons, contradicting common myths.
Animals are influenced by lunar cycles, but not wolves howling at the full moon; instead, coyotes howl more at new moons, and corals spawn after full moons.
A key finding
The mechanism is unclear; gravity from the moon is minuscule, but the moon may affect Earth's magnetic field, which humans might sense via cryptochrome proteins, though this is speculative.
Menstrual cycle syncing with the moon is not supported by large-scale data; a small study showed a weak effect, but a larger analysis of 7.5 million cycles found no correlation.
Researchers remain open to the idea that the moon has subtle, subconscious effects on sleep, but many beliefs are debunked or unproven.
Summary:
This episode of *Science Versus* investigates whether the full moon truly influences human behavior and biology. Host Wendy Zuckerman and producer Meryl Horne begin by collecting anecdotes from New Yorkers, who blame the moon for erratic behavior, workplace chaos, and menstrual syncing. However, scientific evidence challenges these claims.
Emergency physician Wendy Coates found no increase in ER admissions or trauma severity during full moons, and reviews of crime studies show no lunar effect. Animal behaviors, such as coral spawning and coyote howling, are linked to lunar cycles, but not in the ways commonly assumed. A more compelling finding comes from sleep researcher Horacio de la Iglesia, who discovered that people, even in light-polluted cities like Seattle, sleep less and later in the days leading up to a full moon, displaying a clear sinusoidal pattern.
The cause remains mysterious; the moon’s gravitational pull on humans is negligible, but it may subtly alter Earth’s magnetic field, which humans could detect via cryptochrome proteins, though this is highly speculative. Regarding menstruation, a small study suggested a weak link, but a massive analysis of millions of cycles found no syncing. Ultimately, while many full moon myths are debunked, the moon does appear to have a subtle, unexplained effect on sleep, leaving scientists humble about its potential influence on our bodies.
FAQs
No, studies show no increase in ER visits, trauma severity, or crime during a full moon. The belief likely persists due to bonding among healthcare workers, not evidence.
Yes, research suggests people sleep less and go to bed later in the days leading up to a full moon, even in cities with light pollution. This effect appears as a sinusoidal pattern across lunar cycles.
Probably not, because the effect is seen even in cloudy cities like Seattle where moonlight is much dimmer than streetlights. Scientists are exploring other mechanisms, like magnetic fields.
No, the gravitational force of the moon on our bodies is minuscule—less than that of a nearby tall building. There's no evidence that any organism directly senses the moon's gravity.
Evidence is mixed. A small study suggested a slight chance of periods starting around a full or new moon, but larger analyses of millions of cycles found no synchronization.
Some animals do show lunar patterns, like coyotes howling more on new moons, corals spawning after full moons, and nocturnal primates eating more during full moons. However, these effects don't translate to human behavior like ER visits.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.