Go back

The Flowerpot Killer Tapes | The Case of Kristin Smart | UNSEEN

26m 17s

The Flowerpot Killer Tapes | The Case of Kristin Smart | UNSEEN

Kristen Smart disappeared during a 1996 college party in San Luis Obispo, California, and was last seen with 19-year-old Paul Flores. Despite initial skepticism and lack of physical evidence, her parents, Stan and Denise, remained convinced of Paul’s involvement. Over the years, inconsistencies in Paul’s statements, including fabricated explanations for injuries and refusal to cooperate with investigators, fueled suspicion. A neighbor’s account of a nightly beeping sound and a piece of jewelry matching Kristen’s photo added disturbing clues. Survivors revealed Paul’s history of assault and predatory behavior, which became key evidence. In 2021, investigators discovered disturbing evidence at Paul’s and his father’s homes, including human blood in soil under a deck and sexually explicit videos. Though Kristen’s body was never found and no DNA matched, the circumstantial evidence and patterns of abuse led to Paul’s arrest and conviction for first-degree murder in 2022. His father was acquitted of aiding in concealment. The case prompted the creation of the Kristen Smart Campus Safety Act, improving campus safety protocols. The conviction marked a long-overdue reckoning, affirming that relentless pursuit of truth—driven by love and determination—can ultimately bring justice, even decades after a crime.

Transcription

4173 Words, 24540 Characters

English
"Hey, Paul, do you have any information on that missing girl? What'd you do with her?" This is 19-year-old Paul Flores, the last person who was seen at a frat party with college students Kristen Smart, and she has now been missing for weeks. When investigators sit down with him, one thing immediately catches their attention. "Take your hair up, per se. What happened to your eye? I got help with my math blood." Paul tells them that he got a black guy from playing basketball, however, when investigators questioned him a few weeks later, he tells them a different story. "The last time we talked to you, you have a black guy, yeah, yeah, because I was uninstalling my radio, because I'm selling my truck and how do you get to black guy? I hit this terrible." Since Paul is not telling the truth, detectives turn to his parents for answers. "As your son ever told you that he did not kill Kristen Smart." "We never asked that question." "And do you have any information as to where Kristen Smart's body is located?" "Of course not." With no body and not enough evidence to charge him, Paul Flores walks free, but Kristen's parents are certain Paul and his family did something to their daughter. "Neublee Paul Flores knows what happened to your daughter and perhaps killed her, and I think she died at the hands of Paul Flores." For years, the case remains unsolved, but her family refuses to give up on the truth. "Justice for Kristen Smart, everyone! Paul Flores is my murderer." "Paul, can you tell us what happened that night between you and Kristen?" "Go. Be careful." Yet one disturbing detail has never stopped haunting Kristen's parents, according to neighbors, every morning at exactly 4.20 a.m., a strange beeping sound can be heard in the backyard of the Flores property. "It's the same sound every night, like a peep, peep, peep, peep, peep." May 24, 1996 19-year-old Kristen Smart is spending Memorial Day weekend at Cal Poly University in San Luis Obispo, California. That night, she decides to go to an off-campus college party just a few blocks away. For the first part of the night, everything seems normal, but as the night goes on, something changes. Around 2 a.m., Kristen is found lying on the lawn outside and is having trouble standing on her own. Two fellow party-goers go to help her. They're confused because everyone agrees she only had one drink earlier that night. They decide they can't leave her there and begin helping Kristen get back toward her dorm. She can barely stand on her own, but as they walk away, another student suddenly joins them. 19-year-old Paul Flores, Paul, offers to help, and the four of them begin making their way toward the dorms. Paul promises them that he will get Kristen safely back to her dorm, and so the other two students head off toward their own rooms. This will be the last time Kristen is ever seen alive. It's now Sunday. Two days have passed since anybody has seen Kristen. Kristen normally calls home every Sunday, and her mother, Denise, is expecting to hear from her. But the phone call never comes. Four days later, the Smart Family finally receives a call, but it's not Kristen. As Cal Poly campus police, a missing person report has been filed, and the officer on the line asks if Kristen is home with them. This is the first time Stan and Denise realize something is wrong. They soon learn Kristen hasn't returned to her dorm since Friday night. Her wallet, money, and ID are still inside her room, exactly where she left them. For Kristen's mother, Denise, none of this makes sense. Every single day I spoke with campus police station. Every single day they said, "Denise, I'm telling you that I don't like it. See this happens all the time. You cannot believe how many times kids just leave." She knows her daughter wouldn't disappear for days without telling anyone, and she immediately fears something is wrong. But when the smarts try to get outside law enforcement involved, they are told the case belongs to Cal Poly campus safety officers. And campus officials aren't treating Kristen's disappearance with the same urgency as her parents. "Rustration turns to criticism as Cal Poly police investigate what could have happened to missing student Kristen Smart." "They're not a lot of wet behind the ear rookies. These are experienced officers here." At first, they believe she may have simply left town for Memorial Day weekend. While Denise stays close to the phone in case Kristen calls, Kristen's father Stan makes the four-hour drive to San Luis Obispo and begins searching trails, bridges, and remote areas around the campus himself. "The entire campus is on edge over her disappearance. Everywhere students turn there are reminders from the college newspaper to flyers that are being posted throughout Cal Poly." "It's like everyone knows what's happening, so you kind of get a little nervous and stuff." But the only real clue he gets is from other students who tell him that Paul Flores might be able to tell him where Kristen is. Around campus, other students already know Paul was one of the last people seen with Kristen, and some are beginning to confront him themselves. "Hey, Paul, do you have any information on that missing girl, what you do with her?" And's attention immediately turns to Paul Flores. Campus safety officers soon bring Paul in for an informal interview. "This is not a criminal matter of it, it's not what we're doing, it's what we're dealing with still the missing person, because you're the last person, we appreciate you coming here." "When you were leaving the party, you know, I was kind of leaving. How did you end up getting together with Kristen?" "I don't even know. She walked that way, I walked that way, the last time I saw her, then the other girl left at the corner over there, and then had a couple times like on the way, maybe probably twice, you know, I wanted that, just gave her kind of a hug because she was preset." He insists Kristen was able to walk relatively well on her own, and that he wasn't holding her up. According to Paul, he only had his arm around her because she was cold, and then he'd gone home alone. "What did you say, do you remember any conversations you had walking up the hill?" "No, she just said she was, the only thing I remember, she was saying she was preset." "So, it's very important that you realize how important the investigation is, and you're grasping this, that this is very serious business with a missing woman and that sort of thing. You're aware of all the outlier of this." During the interrogation, the interviewer notes something strange, Paul has what appears to be a black eye, and also has some abrasions on his knees. His injuries seem like more than just a coincidence, but the officer still can't seem to figure out where Kristen is, or if Paul had anything to do with it. A few days pass, and Kristen's parents are out of patience. They demand that the San Luis Obispo Sheriff's Office take over the case and bring Paul back for questioning when the Sheriff's Office reviews the evidence they immediately bring Paul in for an official interrogation. Detectives start comparing Paul's answers to what other witnesses have told them. Paul originally told them he got a bruise and a black eye from playing basketball, but now he's changed his story. Paul's story isn't holding up. His changing explanation for the black eye only raises more suspicion, and investigators are also concerned about the truck he mentioned, believing it could contain evidence, but before they can get a warrant to search it, the truck is stolen. During questioning, Paul appears increasingly nervous. He gives investigators little to work with, refuses to cooperate, and even turns down a lie detector task that could help clear up the inconsistencies in his story. To make matters worse, the Sheriff's Office realizes that campus police never treated Paul Flores' dorm room as a possible crime scene. By the time investigators finally inspect it, the room has already been emptied and cleaned by the university's janitorial staff, removing whatever evidence may have been left behind. They decide to bring in cadaver dogs to inspect the room just in case, and the dogs immediately alert near the side of Paul's bed. Even more disturbingly, four different dogs alert inside Paul Flores' room, each one hitting the exact same spot. Even without physical evidence, the dog's reaction changes what investigators believe they may be looking for. They're no longer just searching for a missing student. For the first time, they begin to fear Kristen, may have been killed. seen Kristen smart alive, the sheriff's department is now looking at him as a potential suspect. People do not vanish off the face of the earth without a trace, and as we've been told 99% of the time, the person responsible was the last person seen with them. A few months later, Paul Flores is brought before a grand jury, little is known since the proceedings are kept secret, but no criminal charges are ever filed. In the weeks that follow, Stan and Denise continue doing everything they can to find their daughter, still holding on to the hope that Kristen might come home. They lead community searches, hand out flyers, put up billboards, anything that will keep Kristen's face in front of the public. Stan hikes every trail he can find along the central coast, searching tunnels, bridges, and remote areas for any sign of his daughter, but the smarts are sure of one thing. Paul is responsible for Kristen's disappearance, and if Paul won't tell them what happened, maybe his parents will. Stan drives to Paul's parents' home in a Royal Grande, a small town north of Los Angeles, California. All he wants is to talk. He introduces himself as Kristen's father, but Paul's father, Ruben, refuses to speak with him. He indicated that I should leave or someone's happy to get shot, so I got back my being while I left. Stan's threats only strengthen the smart suspicions, and they refuse to stand by while Paul simply moves on with his life, so instead of waiting for the criminal investigation to move forward, they hire Attorney James Murphy, and they take the case to civil court. They file a wrongful death lawsuit against Paul Flores. For the first time, Stan and Denise now have someone who can legally force Paul and the people around him to answer the questions that will reveal what happened the night Kristen disappeared. The new bully, Paul Flores, knows what happened to your daughter and perhaps killed her. I think she died at the hands of Paul Flores. The smart's lawyer finally sits across from Paul Flores during a sworn deposition. Paul now has to appear and face questioning under oath. I would just state your full name for the record please. Paul, Ruben Flores. But the moment Murphy asks him to recount what happened the night Kristen disappeared, Paul does something they don't expect. What is your present dress? On the advice of my attorney, I refuse to answer that question based on the Fifth Amendment of the United States Constitution. For nearly every question, Paul invokes the Fifth Amendment, 27 times total. Where did you attend, Heisk? What is the name of your father? How old are you? On the advice of my attorney, I refuse to answer that question based on the Fifth Amendment. James Murphy is stunned. After fighting for months to get Paul under oath, they are still no closer to the truth, but Murphy hopes Paul's parents will sympathize with what the smarts are going through. Do you have any information as to where Kristen's smart's body is located? Of course not. If your husband have any information as to where Kristen's smart's body is located. No. As your son ever told you that he did not kill Kristen's smart. We never asked that question, well he's just doing the same thing about it, he says no. Neither parent admits to knowing anything and there is still nothing that proves they helped Paul cover up Kristen's disappearance. But for Stan, Denise, and Murphy, the Flores family's answers only deep in their suspicion that they're hiding something disturbing. Then, the Flores family fights back, they countersue the smarts, turning the search for Kristen into an exhausting legal battle between two families, one defending their son and the other still desperately trying to find their daughter. For the smarts, it feels like every door is closing. They have no body, no physical evidence, and no new trail leading them to Kristen. Then, just when the case seems like it's hit, a complete dead end. One of the Flores' neighbors reaches out with the potential clue. She tells him she's been hearing something strange from the Flores' backyard, something she can't explain. "At night, I'm hearing this in the backyard, in the master bedroom, I'm hearing this beep beep every night at 420 in the morning. I watch, like, beep, beep, beep, since the day I moved in." According to the neighbors, the beeping comes from a planter in the backyard that's been filled with concrete. The neighbor's account becomes even more troubling when they tell the smarts another concerning detail. They had seen the Flores family filling the very same planter with concrete. Shortly after Kristen disappeared, for Denise, the beeping immediately means something. Kristen had worked morning shifts as a lifeguard and wore a digital watch with an alarm set early enough to get her to the pool by 5am. But the neighbor has something else. She said she once found a piece of jewelry in the Flores' driveway that she believes looks like something Kristen was wearing in her missing person photo. She turned it over to a nearby police station, but when the smarts follow up with police, they receive devastating news. It's gone. The piece of jewelry was never marked as evidence and was misplaced before anyone could determine whether or not it belonged to Kristen. The smarts are stunned and furious, a mysterious alarm beneath fresh concrete. Kristen's jewelry found on the property, and now a crucial piece of potential evidence missing. For Stan and Denise, all of this together is more than enough to warrant further action and they push investigators to search the Flores' home. Investigators agree with the smarts and Colin and FBI response team. "We were very hopeful that it was going to be moving forward and that we would have answers." But multiple searches of the property still turn up no evidence of Kristen or her belongings anywhere. The news is devastating. They've been waiting for months for this moment, convinced that a search of the Flores' property could finally give them answers. The clues from the Flores' neighbors that had once seemed so promising have turned out to be yet another dead end. Years go by and in 2002, Kristen is declared "legally dead" and the case goes cold. But for Stan and Denise, her case is anything but closed. Stan continues returning to the area surrounding Cal Poly, searching places police have already looked and following leads that often go nowhere. Denise keeps calling investigators, pushing anyone willing to listen. And outside James Murphy's law office, he keeps Kristen's face on a billboard, the constant reminder to the Flores that the smart family isn't going anywhere. Stan and Denise keep closed tabs on Paul, hiring a private investigator to follow him. They know that, one day, you will make a mistake that will lead them to Kristen. And if he's the one who hurt Kristen, there's still nothing stopping him from harming other women in the community. "I'm hoping he'll see that, you know, we're still on him. We're not going away." For Stan and Denise, if police aren't going to keep the pressure on Paul, they will. "How's it going? Need some ribbons? Yeah." "Once they have learned that he's employed by someone, then people have called and complained to the management that, you know, they don't feel it's safe or appropriate." It's now 2019, the smart's determination to keep Kristen's story alive inspires someone new to ask the same questions. A local podcaster named Chris Lambert begins looking into Kristen's disappearance. The podcaster soon reaches millions of people who are hearing about Kristen's story for the first time, triggering a renewed public interest in the case. "It's been 23 years now. Kristen has been a missing person for longer than she was alive." As Lambert reveals more details about the Flores family's involvement and Kristen's parents' relentless pursuit of justice, it creates a community of people outraged by what Kristen and her parents have endured for more than two decades. "Justice for Kristen's fire, everyone! Paul Thorens, this guy murdered her. He knows he did." "Paul, can you tell us what happened that night between you and Kristen? Go, yourself." "I'm not just telling the story anymore at this point. I'm actively part of trying to push this forward." Chris starts tracking down witnesses and people who knew Paul, trying to understand who he really is. And the deeper he digs, the more disturbing the picture becomes. Women who have never gone to the police before begin coming forward about their experiences with Paul. "So I walk him up to Mr. Department and all of a sudden he just like picked me up, carried me inside, turned around and shoved the apartment door." "When he had like a butter knife and he like held it to my neck and I was screaming and my room may actually kick down the door to make him stop." "He drank pretty heavily for a freshman. Girls would tell their friends to stay away from him." "The women had a nickname for him, Chester, the molester." Under pressure from the public, the sheriff's office begins putting more resources into the case. By now, Paul is living in a home of his own, but without him knowing, investigators launch a secret operation to monitor phone conversations between the floor's family. Now police can listen to what they say when they think no one else is listening. On one of the recorded calls, Paul's mother Susan tells her son that he needs to start listening closely to the podcast, and she says something that immediately catches investigators' attention. "The only thing I need to do is to start listening to the podcast. I need you to listen to everything to say so we could punch holes in it. Wherever we can punch holes, maybe we can't. You're the one that can tell me." Between Susan's suspicious phone call and the new witnesses coming out against Paul, cops are able to get another warrant for the first time in decades to search multiple properties connected to the floor's family. "A possible break in a 23-year-old cold case, the disappearance of Kristen Smart." "Ethorities executing several search wars." Today, investigators went into this house and searched it. This time, the search is even more extensive. They search their homes, vehicles, and see several electronic devices. Cadaver dogs are brought onto the property. Newer technology with ground penetrating radar is used in the backyard, and investigators begin focusing their attention on the area beneath Ruben's deck. People from all over the central coast gathered near Ruben-Floris home Tuesday, watching as detectives investigated the area. Whatever police are finding, they aren't revealing much to the public, behind the scenes. The case against Paul Flores is moving faster than it has in 25 years. Forensic physical evidence was located, and yes, we believe it's linked to Kristen. And yes, we did find physical evidence. In April 2021, Kristen's family receives the news they have been waiting decades to hear. Paul Flores has been arrested and charged with Kristen's smarts murder. His father Ruben has been arrested and charged as an accessory. For the first time, Paul can no longer walk away from the accusations surrounding Kristen's disappearance. And now, everything investigators have uncovered is about to be revealed in court. July 2022, more than 26 years after Kristen disappeared, Stan and Denise Smart finally walk into a courtroom to face Paul Flores, sitting only feet away as the man they have suspected from the very beginning. Paul is charged with Kristen's murder while his father Ruben is accused of helping conceal what happened afterward. The defense immediately points to the biggest weakness in the case. Kristen's body has never been found. There is no murder weapon, and no DNA definitively proves Kristen was ever inside Paul's dorm room. But this time, prosecutors have something Paul and Ruben aren't expecting. They present the jury with sworn testimonies from multiple women, recounting Paul's predatory behavior in the years after Kristen's disappearance. The survivors describe interactions where they were unknowingly drugged and assaulted by Paul Flores. But it's not just sworn statements. During the search of Paul's home, cops found even more damning evidence on his computer and external drives. Investigators find disturbing home videos taken by Paul that corroborate the women's statements about the attacks. Some of the material is stored under a folder, labeled "practice." But the strongest physical evidence is found somewhere else. At Ruben Flores' house, investigators discovered a large section of disturbed soil under his deck, the size of a human casket that had evidence of decomposition, with samples from the area testing positive for human blood. Though there's not enough DNA to positively identify that Kristen was there, nor do they find her body. Prosecutors are convinced that Kristen was murdered, that Paul and Ruben buried her there, and then moved the body later. The defense disputes the findings, and insists that none of it proves Kristen was ever there. There is no DNA, no definitive proof. But the circumstantial evidence is overwhelming, and add in the decades of predatory behavior, and it's clear to the prosecution that Paul Flores is responsible for Kristen's disappearance. Now, it's up to the jury. After months of testimony, there is nothing left for the smarts to do, but wait for the verdict. October 18th, 2022, after months of testimony, Stan and Denise returned to court one last time. Juries for both Ruben and Paul have reached a decision. The courtroom goes silent, but verdict is read, "Ruben Flores is found not guilty of helping conceal Kristen's murder." It's an emotional blow to the smarts, and they wonder if this means Paul will walk free too. Then, the second verdict comes in. Paul Flores is found guilty of first-degree murder. After 26 years of searches, setbacks, lost evidence, and unanswered questions, they've finally done what once seemed impossible. When the news of the conviction is revealed to the public, the community that worked tirelessly to support the smarts and their quest for justice celebrates alongside them. We begin with breaking news, more than 25-year-old murder case during found 45-year-old Paul Flores guilty of her murder. Finally, they've held Kristen's killer accountable. What this sentence will provide is accountability. Mr. Flores, you have a cancer to society. You are committed to the maximum sentence that I can impose by law, an indeterminate term of 25 years to life. It is clearly too late for us, but Paul, it is not too late for you to tell the truth, to free your soul and your heart from the way it must be carrying your after all human being. But their fight would have a much bigger legacy than just Paul's conviction. Today is a day of relief, that Kristen's voice was heard. When Kristen disappeared, the people responsible for finding her made costly mistakes, her case wasn't treated with enough urgency. Evidence was lost, opportunities disappeared. Stan and Denise wanted to make sure another family wouldn't have to go through what they did. Their fight helped create the Kristen Smart Campus Safety Act, changing how colleges and local police in California respond when a student is the victim of a serious crime. Kristen never got the chance to graduate, to build the life she imagined, or to become the woman her parents were waiting to see, but her name still follows thousands of students on campuses across California. Kristen's parents refused to let time decide how their daughter's story would end, in spite of the insurmountable odds facing them, and the years it took to get answers, the smarts never wavered. Their battle is proved that sometimes the truth survives for one simple reason, because someone loves you enough to never stop fighting for it.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Paul Flores was the last person seen with Kristen Smart at a college party, and his inconsistent statements about injuries and actions raise serious suspicion.
  2. Investigators found cadaver dogs alerting to multiple spots inside and near Paul’s dorm room, indicating possible evidence of a crime scene.
  3. Paul changed his story about how he acquired a black eye and injuries, and refused cooperation during interrogations, including invoking the Fifth Amendment repeatedly.
  4. A neighbor reported a nightly beeping sound from the Flores’ backyard, and a piece of jewelry resembling Kristen’s was found on the property before being lost by authorities.
  5. Survivors came forward with accounts of Paul’s predatory behavior, including assaults and drugging, which corroborate the timeline and pattern of abuse.
  6. Forensic searches revealed disturbed soil under Ruben Flores’ deck with human blood, and disturbing videos and digital evidence linking Paul to criminal activity.
  7. After 26 years, Paul was charged with first-degree murder and found guilty, while his father was acquitted of aiding in concealment.
  8. The case led to the creation of the Kristen Smart Campus Safety Act, improving how colleges and police respond to missing student cases.

Summary:

Kristen Smart disappeared during a 1996 college party in San Luis Obispo, California, and was last seen with 19-year-old Paul Flores. Despite initial skepticism and lack of physical evidence, her parents, Stan and Denise, remained convinced of Paul’s involvement. Over the years, inconsistencies in Paul’s statements, including fabricated explanations for injuries and refusal to cooperate with investigators, fueled suspicion.

A neighbor’s account of a nightly beeping sound and a piece of jewelry matching Kristen’s photo added disturbing clues. Survivors revealed Paul’s history of assault and predatory behavior, which became key evidence. In 2021, investigators discovered disturbing evidence at Paul’s and his father’s homes, including human blood in soil under a deck and sexually explicit videos.

Though Kristen’s body was never found and no DNA matched, the circumstantial evidence and patterns of abuse led to Paul’s arrest and conviction for first-degree murder in 2022. His father was acquitted of aiding in concealment. The case prompted the creation of the Kristen Smart Campus Safety Act, improving campus safety protocols.

The conviction marked a long-overdue reckoning, affirming that relentless pursuit of truth—driven by love and determination—can ultimately bring justice, even decades after a crime.

FAQs

Paul Flores was the last person seen with Kristen Smart at a fraternity party on May 24, 1996. He offered to help her walk back to her dorm after she was struggling to stand, and they walked together until she was no longer seen alive.

No, Kristen Smart's body has never been found. Despite extensive searches and investigations, no physical remains have been discovered, though circumstantial evidence suggests she may have been murdered and buried.

Paul Flores was not charged due to lack of physical evidence, a missing body, and inconsistencies in his statements. No DNA or murder weapon was found, and campus police initially treated the case as a simple disappearance.

A local podcaster named Chris Lambert investigated the case and shared it widely, prompting public outrage and new testimonies from women who said Paul Flores had a history of predatory behavior.

Investigators found disturbed soil under Ruben Flores' deck with signs of decomposition and human blood. They also discovered disturbing home videos labeled 'practice' and evidence of past assaults on women.

Yes, in July 2022, Paul Flores was found guilty of first-degree murder. His father, Ruben, was acquitted of helping conceal the crime, though Paul's conviction was based on circumstantial evidence and survivor testimonies.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.