Claire shares her story of a toxic relationship with James, whom she initially saw as emotionally open and romantic. After meeting at a Halloween party, they bonded over shared experiences and began a relationship that quickly escalated with love bombing, constant texting, and shared planning for marriage. James portrayed himself as vulnerable, citing trauma from his father’s suicide due to infidelity and obsessive loyalty to his exes, Olivia and Brooke. Claire noticed red flags early—his secretive behavior, political activity on social media, and sudden emotional shifts—especially when he claimed to be in love while avoiding intimacy. He used deception tactics, such as hiding his political Facebook profile and avoiding phone access, to maintain control. His behavior became increasingly manipulative: he used Claire’s credit card to buy a ring without proposing, pressured her into a public engagement, and avoided discussing the relationship. As the relationship progressed, Claire’s anxiety grew, fueled by social comments, his evasiveness, and his sudden disappearances during events. A pivotal moment came when she saw him interact with a friend, Sophie, in a mocking way about their engagement, confirming his deception. He later deleted his messages and social content, showing a pattern of secrecy and control. Claire realized the relationship was built on manipulation and trauma, not genuine love. By March, she decided to end it, moving back to her mother’s house and seeking emotional recovery, emphasizing that her mental health and trust were severely compromised. The episode challenges the "crazy ex girlfriend" trope, showing how such narratives can mask deeper patterns of manipulation and emotional abuse.
The following program contains names, places and events that have been anonymized or fictionalized for the purposes of protection and safety. The following program is provided for entertainment purposes only, and any commentary from the hosts are strictly conjectured and should not be held as making any definitive statements about the truth or identity of any particular individuals or circumstances. If you or a loved one are involved in an abusive relationship, please call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233-4-Support. Happy Dating Detective's Monday! Hi everybody! How are you doing? I was just saying that it feels so good to go to LA because we got to record this episode together in LA and I was saying like when I get to go there and squeeze it squeeze hand on Molly's neck, it's almost like it's like oh finally home like it just feels so good. Thank you guys. That makes my heart so happy. I love we posted a picture and somebody deandas like but the real question is when are you going on tour again? Cool. So I think I think it's something we should discuss. I'm just saying. That was so fun and this episode was recorded when you were here. I miss you already but Claire is our guest this week and as you have seen we've called this episode "Crazy X Girlfriend" and that is a trope of swords. We have talked about it many times where somebody says like oh my god my ex is crazy. My girlfriend was crazy and usually it's like you know sometimes yeah sure but sometimes there's something going on there but it's definitely a title that has come with lots of baggage and we just kind of want to point out that title beforehand. We'll talk about it at the end but like keep an eye out for the tropes of the crazy ex girlfriend because we're challenging that a bit. I think that our audience is going to relate to her and Claire's a good storyteller. She has an interesting story to tell and I just know it's going to be relatable to so many people and that that relatability is what helps people. There's definitely some talk of like thoughts suicide and some talk of that and mental health but otherwise you know we just got a good old dogfish story coming up and man I mean dogfish have been in the news a lot lately. This halos of it home dog has really brought us talking about liars and manipulators and it's it's in the zeitgeist not that it ever is in. I mean unfortunately we have a podcast because this is a common a common personality. It's just more and more common than we think and you just before you know you could be a victim of a dogfish and you don't even realize and so it's that's why I really appreciate our guests who come and share their stories. And if you're on our patreon amazing amazing amazing we love having you it's five dollars a month and you get bonus episodes and you just get more access to a sleuthy community which includes us and if you want you can do the nine dollar tier which is all of that plus no ads ad free listening experience on all episodes and shout out to Claire's sister also speaking of people sharing the podcast. We got how Claire came to find us. She was like girl you've been you've been telling me about your story for a long time. We got to get you on the show so we're ready for her. Should we give it to Claire? We love her. Yeah let's meet Claire. Thank you Claire for being here. Thank you for having me. Oh of course we're happy to talk to you and not happy that you have a story but we could get into it if you're ready. Yeah well first of all sorry for my accent. I'm from sorry. So I'll pick that back. We love your accent. Okay thank you but I may have some trouble with some words but I'll try my best. That's understandable. We got you. Perfect so my name is Claire I'm from Quebec. I have a story about my ex-relationship ship so right now I'm married but before I was with with James for two years and then I have something like that so I was 23 years old. I just broke up with my high school boyfriend. We were together for seven years. Wow but it was a classic in a toxic relationship. So that's why it lasted so long. So when I was with him he was very controlling jealous but really like the more like high school classic in a controlling boyfriend. So when I ended the relationship I felt like I was out of prison. So I felt like a first time single lady at 23 like you know seven years is a long time to be at the relationship when you're 23 so I was like let's go I'm gonna go day I'm gonna go to parties I'm gonna meet new people because my ex was so controlling that he didn't like if a guy was talking to me with jealous so now you're like so yeah yeah exactly so I was going out I met some new people I went out on parties and stuff like that and that's how I met James so I was invited to a Halloween party and Halloween is my favorite holiday so I was very excited and it was my first Halloween party ever and then I meet James and my first impression that he was very charismatic he was intense very intense very confident but like over the top and I don't want to fat shame or anything but he was overweight but it's like he was like very confident in his his height and his weight and stuff like that like he wouldn't let people walk on him for that so that's what's my attraction of it yeah exactly but at the same time he was really like okay we're gonna sit down we're gonna talk that I was talking to some under in the party he would just like sit next to me and tell the guy go away I'm gonna talk to her or something like that so he was over the top confidence sometimes yeah okay wow can I remember that what was his costume um so he was doing some um I don't know the name in English but it's like medieval you know when you dress in medieval like costume oh medieval yeah yeah yeah yeah and then you react that why can't I remember the name of when you reenact I feel it's play larping oh larping okay live action role play larping so he was doing larping which I didn't know about and I just remember that when I met him he didn't tell me his name was James he told me his larp name because larping when you're very intense into it you you become like a new person almost like you have a new name and everything so he was called something else so that's how I met him first and we spent a whole night talking as friend we just when they weren't flirting I was flirting with another guy so and we had a lot of fun and then during the night is the first time he talked to me about his ex Olivia he said that he just broke up and he was very sad about it like sitting down and talking about it and having tears on his face wow so that he still loves her that uh she doesn't accept that the relationship is over which was weird wait he doesn't or she doesn't she doesn't like he said he loves her but they cannot be together and she has trouble accepting that it's over that it doesn't work out and that she's very intense that she's not getting over him and she's the intense one in the breakout so he cries when he speaks to me about it and for me at that time I saw it as a guy that's vulnerable and emotionally open which usually you know where I'm from or maybe because I'm a millennial we told guys don't cry because it's feminine you know so for me I was like he's trying he's you know he's vulnerable comfortable confident yeah so you saw that as like emotionally intelligent yeah and he was confiding me very fast I was like okay we have a friendship connection something like that because I really didn't see him as a love interest because he wasn't my type physically so I wasn't interested him yeah does he's like crying to you about loving his ex that's not usually flirting conversation yeah exactly exactly yeah so we do the party it's fun I go home and then we keep talking home I guess it was messenger back in the day and then we start talking about our relationship because both of us you know he just broke up with his girlfriend I just broke up with my high school boyfriend so it was maybe five months after my break up and we were talking about what we were looking for in a relationship and I tell him that what I'm looking for in the partner that want to get married and in Quebec I don't know if you know but we don't really get married like it's not we're not a big wedding social group like okay for partners and Quebec which is weird for us I know but here a lot of people are together but they're not married but they don't officially do it so I'm telling him about this and then he starts sending me some wedding inspiration like you know a surprise how he was into Pinterest for a guy so he was pinning about like suits and stuff like that okay yeah yeah so that's so weird yes I know but we're sending each other like a wedding photos and what we're looking for and stuff like that and our ideas for future and stuff like that and we were just French you know friends so it was weird but at that time it was like wow he really listened to me that feels good when you're like someone finally listened to me exactly and some somebody's funny like knows me like wants know me you know and then he continued to talk about Olivia and once he was
doing is sending me screenshots of their conversation, but never the whole conversation. And he said, I want to respect her. Some that's in the new, the whole thing. So I'm just in parts of it. And he was only shown me parts of the message I looked like she was obsessed with it. Of course. And he was showing me her Facebook post and a lot of them were hospital foes. So she got hospitalized after the breakup. And it may look like she was like almost psychotic because of the breakup. Okay. Oh. And it was always cryptid message that she was writing, but we could figure out it was about him because she was doing like drawing that reference him. Like for during the relationship, he was like the bear for her because he's so like huge and big. She was drawing bears pictures and so like that. So we knew it. She was talking about him. So I was like, Jesus, she's really something, you know, like the way she was president, her to me, I was like, I didn't have a lot of empathy because I was like, she must be that. And that's what he was telling me. And it was matching what he was saying. So I was like, why would I believe him, you know? And I didn't know her. And in the some of the texting between them, she was talking about me. Like, is she just a friend blah, blah, blah. So I was like, oh my god, she's obsessed like she thinks we're dating. We're not blah, blah, blah. Why is he still talking to her? Yeah. That's my question. You'll figure it out. Oh boy. Do you guys know those pieces in your closet that you find yourself reaching for over and over again, the sweater that goes with everything or the jeans that you know will always fit just right or the bag you carry everywhere. Those are pieces that are in a permanent place in your wardrobe. And that's exactly what Quince does so well. Quince is an amazing brand. I literally love everything they have. So it's hard for me to pick out just a couple of things, but they make elevated everyday essentials using premium materials like Mongolian cashmere, organic cotton, premium stretch, denim, and their designs are timeless. They're thoughtfully crafted, but they're made to be worn again and again. And they have amazing basics, which is what I love because every gal needs a basic piece. And they also have a bunch of home stuff. So if you're looking for rugs or bedding, anything like that, they have jewelry. They have responsibly sourced down jackets, cozy cashmere scarves and gloves and 14 carat gold jewelry. And everything at Quince is price 50 to 80 percent less than similar brands because they work directly with ethical factories and cut out the middleman. So you're paying for the quality, not the brand markup. Find the fall pieces you'll reach for most at Quince. Download the Quince app for app exclusive offers or go to quince.com, get free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. And they are now available in Canada and the UK too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know it was the dating detectives podcast. And it's the best way to support the show. So we still talk from time to time. We see each other in the other events. And then one time, I do a little party in my apartment, I invite friends over. And during that night, that's where we really click. We started listening to some music and then our music tastes were aligned. We talked about TV shows and it just clicked really a lot that time. And then in November, my best friend does another party and we decided to attend together. So he was going to meet me at my place. And he arrived with roses. Because earlier in all over the conversation, I told him that my ex never bought me flowers. And he's like, you know, as a friend, I want to give you flowers because your ex never give it to you. He says I deserve to be treated better. So he's giving me flowers. That would work on me. And I remember during the day when I was getting really and I was looking at myself on the mirror, I was like, do I have feeding for him? Like, look, you know, you're doing your hair and you're like, oh my god, I think I have feeding. But I'm like, no, I cannot have feeding for James. Like, no. Oh my gosh, you're sorry? Like, he shows up with the flowers. Yeah. And then we go to the party. And that party was weird because guys, I think two, three guys, I dated in my six months single life, all came to the party. So it was really weird. Overwhelming. So me and James and two other friends that were dating, we decided to go to James because he was living closer. And then we just chill on the sofa and stuff like that. And then I think it was maybe two, three o'clock in the morning. I'm like, okay, let's go home and a couple were living close to my place. I was going to lift them home. And it's like, can I come? I'm like, well, to go where I could come to your place. And my room mates weren't home that night. So he's like, oh, I can sleep on the couch. I'm like, okay, come. You can come, whatever. So I told you, he's very confident. Like, he's like looking through what he wants. And I remember, I'm in my doorway of my room. He's on the sofa. And he's like, you're not going to leave me here, right? I'm like, yeah, we said on the sofa inside, but I'm going to be cold. And then I look at him and I'm like, okay, you can sleep in my bed. Oh, did you have suspicions that was going to happen? Did you want that to happen? Or did he really kind of push you in? I'm very naive. So you didn't think about it. Well, you only had the one relationship to really go off of. Yeah, really had no experience. 16. Yeah, 16 in my head. Like, I never dated an adult life, you know. But nothing happens on my. We just sleep. We call. And then the day after then we kiss. And this was maybe end of November. And we start off the official beginning of December. And then the love bombing starts. So we start daily. He buys me flowers all the time. He plans dates, which my ex wasn't doing. And when December, he pays for a spa day for both of us. And he doesn't have a lot of money. He's not having a high paying jobs, but he pays me the whole thing like, you know, whole day at the spa with a massage and everything. So he buys me this. He sends me a long, romantic message. He was talking about her future together. How much he loved me. He couldn't believe that, you know, he met me and stuff like that. Oh, wow. So when he's talking about the future, what's going through your head? I'm all like, I'm over the top in love with him. Yeah, like finally someone that is romantic. He's the business. He plans dates. He wants to be with me. When I was with my ex, I told you, I felt like I was in prison. We weren't going out. I was going to parties. Right. Suddenly we're going everywhere. And at that point, when I left my ex, I had a lot of anxiety and my anxiety dropped a lot when I was single. So going out and everything, my mental health was really, really high. I was very well. So going out and stuff like that. I was like, oh, I'm finally living my youth, you know, doing stuff. We're planning vacation stuff like that. But at one point, I don't remember when exactly. He tells me in a romantic way that when we started talking, he went on my Facebook. And I don't know, if you remember Facebook, we used to like everything. Yes. Our TV shows are interesting. It was all our Facebook page. Yes. He went there to see what I was liking. Oh, we saw the pages I was following, the music, the shows, he did a whole Facebook swap. But at that time, when he told me if I was a bit weird, but romantic, you know, like he took interest in me. But now I know it was a way to make sure that we have the same interests. So I get attached to him. What is that called when they're mirroring? Mirroring. Yeah. So when that's our daily hand, the spa and everything, I really thought I found my prints charming. I was like, this is the man of my dream. And I was over the head, and with him like the pink glasses, you know, I didn't see any red ones. The rose colored glasses. Yeah, exactly. A little bit about him. He was working nights. When he was working, he was working for a company that was supervising stuff during the night. Nothing very important. He was very smart. Not by his true. And I don't want to say exactly what it is, but nothing important. Yeah, he was very smart. He has a memory incredible, but like he can learn language easily, like everything, but he's lazy. Oh yeah, okay. He's very lazy. So he didn't go to university. He just had an entry paying job during the nights. So he was working nights. So sometimes we just saw each other for an hour between both shifts. And I met his family very fast. So his mom, he has a mom and a sister. His mom, the first thing told me about his mom is she's a doctor. She's a psychiatrist. And that was one of the first life. She wasn't. What is she's not just, but she's a mental health worker. Okay, she's not a doctor. But that's close to the truth. His sister was young, so she was, we have Cijep here, which is like a college. So she's
She was in college, and then he tells me, and that's very important, sorry, he tells me that his father died by suicide when he was very young. So he doesn't have the same father as his sister. And that his mother in fidelity calls his father's death. Oh my gosh. Yeah. Well, that is quite a sob story. Yeah, so he tells me that he's crying. Remember, he's a good cryer, he's crying telling me that when he was young, his mother was cheating on his dad, and he killed himself because she cheated on him. He's laying the groundwork for don't cheat on me because it'll affect me too badly. Uh, not the other way. I could never cheat on you because of what my mom did to my dad. Oh, okay. I hear them. Okay. Yeah, I could never do it because I know how much pain it caused. So every time we were watching TV show or movie that was a suicide, it was triggering for him. He had to stop watching it or he was crying and stuff like that. So I was very careful to pause the movie or skip ahead. And I understand that because I have a vomit phobia. So what phobia? Vomiting. Oh, okay. Yeah. You were sensitive. Yeah. Yeah. So I know what, you know, if I see puking in the movie, I react the same way. So I understand that. I was very like, I'm going to take care of you, you know? But every time we ask questions about it, it's like, oh, no, we'll put it in the box. Mama and I, we never talk about it. It's in the box. We don't talk about it. But that's the main reason I trusted him during the whole relationship because I was like, he can cheat on me, you know? And even during my relationship, my cousin, one of my close cousin, her husband of ten years cheated on her. And I remember we were in the kitchen, I told him, oh, my God, she just got cheating on her from her husband. I was crying. And he was like, I could never do that to you. You know, I could never do that to you. My mom did that to my dad, it's terrible. So I thought really that I could trust him. But at the same time, very early on in our relationship, he had one rule, never check his phone or his computer. And it's all idea behind it is my ex. So yeah, two ex before me. They were always checking my Facebook or my email with it. And it triggers me exactly. He destroyed his trust. So in a way, he won't prove that I'm different from them, you know? Yep. So I never did. Never did. So remember when I told you about his larping? Yes. He was larping also in his life, meaning he has two Facebook profile. So yeah. So he had one that was his personal profile. And at that time, he was his larp name. And then he had a professional Facebook because he wasn't politics. As a, I don't know how to explain it, but like, probably you have that in the state. So you have politics, you have like the Democrats and Republicans, you can, you can act as a youth like a young guy, like a young, you're not like a politician, but you help like an intern. Like a member. Yeah, something like that. But it's all volunteer. Okay. Yeah. Gotcha. You're an activist kind of. Yes. Okay. Yeah, that's a good word. Activist. So on his personal page, he was very good at posting romantic photos. Every time we were going on the date, he was posting. And I thought it was so romantic, you know? Writing messages about our relationship to the public, you know, showing our friends how much we're in love or the perfect couple. But on his political page, he told me, don't comment. He was never a knowledge that was existing. And he says that opponents were going to use it against him. Oh. And remember, he's, he's just an activist. He's not going to say, is he that important where they could be like, no, no, no, girl, friend. But when you get it, that is a good excuse to, when you get into politics, of course, it's like, I gotta be careful what I say because someone, yeah, so he was using that as like a reason. Okay. So now he has a reason that he'll never cheat on you. He has a reason that you that you never go through his phone. And now he has a reason you should not be on his Facebook. Okay. Yes. Exactly. And like you said, I thought it was, make it sense. Yeah. And I remember when I started dating him, I didn't want to be with a guy from politics because they're all liars and genius and blah blah. They have a bad, a bad rep. Reputation. But he made me believe that he was different, you know, but he was also very careful about his image, either on his professional Facebook or in real life. And one thing that was weird is he's always wearing suits. Even like going out with friends, he's in full suit. And what? Like in T-shirts and like, yeah, pants. Why? So he was always in suits. He was always for the job he wanted, I guess. Yes. No, yeah. He was paying a long time, you know, doing his beard, his hair. When he was taking pictures of me or himself or the, or us as a couple, it was like a photograph, you know, like taking time to make sure that everything was well fitting and everything was perfect. Everything had perfect all the time. But in real life, he wasn't like that. So he's always showing like, I'm clean, I'm you know, groomed, I'm just nice. But in everyday life, he could spend days without a shower. One thing was, yeah, one thing was doing was taking a shower without soak, like just rinsing off, which I thought it was weird. Right. So he wanted to appear like he has money. He has influence, he has power, but he has a low paying job. I was making more than him. And he had no credit. So he was 22, I think it was one year younger than me, he already had no credit. So he had a credit card when he was young and then they closed it because he was not good with money. So now I know I'm pretty sure that's what he did. I call it the first breakup test. So that was in January, if I'm not mistaken. We go out with him and my best friend Megan and we decide to maybe go out dancing. So we did other stuff before and then we are all, let's go dancing. But my anxiety was through the roof and I was like, I'm not sure I want to go dancing. And then we go home, we bring my best friend to her place and then we go home. And then he starts accusing me of being ashamed of him or you don't want to go dancing because you don't want people to see you dancing with a fat man. And he threatens to end the relationship, like we're going to break up. And I'm crying and saying, well, my first ex broke once choke about the size of my penis in front of our friends. And since then, I swear to never let anyone last at my weight or my anything. You know, he's telling me that I'm terrible that he's going to break up with me and I'm begging him, begging him, I'm apologised, please don't break up with me. I swear I didn't mean to, I'm not ashamed of you. And then it's like nothing happened. And then a month later it's Valentine's Day and we go to a hotel and the whole romantic things happen again. So well, he got you feeling like being in a relationship with him was this privilege that he was still willing to give you, like you now should be grateful that he didn't break up with you for this thing that told you you did wrong. Or one way I saw it is he was like checking, like the how much he could pull on me. And I was still staying with him. He's testing. He's pushing the buttons. And then he meets my parents, he meets my sister. And everyone's saying, he's a good guy for you. You should trust him. Like nobody was saying he had any red flags. And then I was losing my apartment because my roommates were leaving and I had to find a new place. Same thing with him. He was losing his roommate and he was like, let's move in together after six months, which is one of the biggest red flags. Then second test, two weeks after we move in together, two weeks. And we're trying to buy a bed, like just a bed frame, mattress. Thank you. The bed frame. Yeah. Bed frame. All marketplace. So you have marketplace. And we're fighting for something minor over the bed frame or something like that. And then out of freaking nowhere, he tells me he's on Tinder. What? Yeah. What? He's like, if I have to tell you I'm on Tinder in 10 years, I call it Tinder was still huge, like relationship. It wasn't just like right now, I think now people are more on the hinge for a relationship and Tinder is more for having sex. Yeah. So he was on Tinder. He tells me I'm on Tinder. I'm sorry. I had to tell you. And I'm just like, what the fuck? He's like, I'm not playing on cheating. I just fell in secure and I want to know if women were still matching with me. Oh, so he's the victim again. Yeah. And I'm like, what? You're in Tinder. He's like, I'm sorry, he's crying. He's like, I already deleted it. Why do you say anything? Like, what was the point? Like, did he want to inst, like in that moment, make you jealous or something? He wants to see how much he can push my buttons. How much can she believe my bullshit and stuff like that? We'll talk about the process of accepting his apology when you look back what was going through your head. Well, what do you want me to do? We've been two weeks. We've been moving together. Yeah. Like, what am I supposed to do? I'm going to be stuck. [BLANK_AUDIO]
to move back to my parents' house and had cats and my parents were allergic, so I was like, I'm not going to get rid of my cat, that's for sure. So I was stuck. So I was like, okay, I'm going to, you know, go forgive you and go, you know, we're going to go past this. One thing that was weird is like, he's begging me to not tell my best friend. So I-- - About what? - About the Tinder. - About just that, nothing-- - He's never asked you. - He's never asked you not to tell your best friend about anything else. - No, just that. - Okay. - So I'm like, okay, I still love him. I'm like, everyone makes mistakes. His dad died by suicide because of cheating. He won't cheat on me. That's-- - You're just needed validation. We can work on that. - Exactly. And I'm going to-- yeah, we can work on that. And I'm 23. I never live with someone. - Right. - I was stuck. You're never stuck, but you feel stuck. - Yeah. - Put that on the phone. And then I started to see more and more about his personality. So one example that really stuck with me is they were a tennis court next to our house. And we went to play badminton. And he told me that it was good at badminton. And I did badminton in college. So I was like, okay, let's play. - Yeah. And he was able to hit it, you know? I was like, okay. And there were two guys that were like, shot, you know, muscle. And it just was playing. And they start laughing. He started taking his racket and slamming down on the floor. And just leaves. We came by a bike. So he goes on his bike and just leave me there alone. - Oh. - Yeah. And I'm like, what the fuck? And then I go home. I call my best friend. I'm like, he just left. I don't know where he is. And then he arrived an hour later. And he's like, I'm sorry. I got mad. I thought they were laughing at me. It's my insecurities. And then it's like, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. So that's one of the things that happened in the beginning. And then one other thing that happened in the first year is our sex life. So in the beginning, the sex life was incredible. Like I was so in love. So for me being in love makes the sex even better. - Yeah, totally. And then suddenly like slowly started showing less and less interest in sex with me. But I could see that he was really compulsive with masturbation. I was always catching him masturbating in his office. But he was always rejected me when I was initiating sex. I couldn't understand it because my ex from high school, it was the opposite. So he was very like always pushing for a second one saying though. And in my mind of 24 was I men are always horny. He should be saying yes, no, which is false. But one thing he was doing is when I was sleeping and he was sleeping, he was touching me. So I would wake up with him like trying to penetrate me or putting his fingers or stuff like that. - I don't. - The middle of the night. - The sleeping I can't do. I'm sorry. Was he claiming to also be a sleep? - He was sleeping. It's a sleep disorder. Like you have sex with him. But for him, I'm not sure 100% if it is. But it was like okay, you don't want sex but your body during the night have like you have sex with him. - Yeah, yeah, yeah. I have to google that. - And then at one point I was like why don't you want to have sex? I was crying. I was like I want affection, you know, I feel like my self it seems going down. And then he tells me well what turns me on the most is the chase in the beginning. - Oh boy. - So I was like okay, but why do you want to be in the long term relationship? You know, there's no more chase, you know. Well, they're flirting everything, but so we were working through that. And I remember in December, the first year anniversary we go to this expensive restaurant, which is like one of the best where I'm from. It gives me romantic letters. It gives me like I think it gives me a niche at that time. It's very, very like fancy and everything. And he didn't have a lot of money. And then it's like perfect night. And then we get home. And I'm just very sexy like over the top sexy. And then I try to have sex and he's like no, I'm not into it. And that's when he told me about the chase. I was like okay, but it's her anniversary. He still don't want to have sex. And he tells me about the chase. So first anniversary, I was crying at the end of the now. So another thing he was doing is he was always texting. And you know how we're addicted to her phone now? 10 years ago was less than that. Yeah. And have like TikTok and stuff like that. But you noticed that he was texting more more like always constantly texting. And I was like, I remember doing a small medical procedure that you're fully awake. And I was having anxiety. And he was on his phone. Oh, we went to Hawaii together. And he was always on his phone in Hawaii. And he said, Oh, it's politics. So I'm doing, I'm texting for politics blah, blah, blah. Very important work. And it usually he gave me his password and fingerprint access. And then out of nowhere, he changed his passport. He changed his access. And he gave me weird explanation. But I promise him to not read his messages. So I'm like, okay, fine. And one thing he was doing, I think he was for to build trust. It's out of nowhere who was sending his location on messenger. Like, this is my location or send me a picture. So he makes it seem like he has nothing to hide because why would I hide some things and you everything. So if we go back to the crazy or girlfriend pattern. So he had two ex girlfriend. And he told me both of them are crazy. That was the word he was using. So Olivia, she cannot move on. She was hospitalized. She was really intense. Like for at least a year in our relationship. She was like intense. And then there's Brooke. And that was the whole story. Supposedly she attacked him with knives. Oh god. Like wait, attacked him with knives like more than one. Yeah. Yeah. So he was always saying it was a running joke with his friend with me. He was always saying at least your ex didn't attack you with knives. Oh. Yeah. So I was like, yeah, his ex are crazy. He was clearly clearly a victim. So it gives me context for his behavior. You know why he's so controlling with his text scene, everything. Like his work triggered. Yeah. Exactly. He her ex laughed at him for his penis, you know, stuff like that. Right. So we can't handle it if somebody's laughing on that. Yeah. He told me about bullying when he was young too and stuff like that. So there was always a story. So if we go back to politics, he was always bringing me to politic events. So, you know, like in a bar, like a whole weekend and stuff like that. Okay. So we know that was for real. He was really like that's something he for real. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I did like stuff with him. But in the beginning, he was bringing me everywhere. Tell me to dress nice. We're gonna go out showing me to everyone. Like this is my girlfriend, blah, blah, blah. And then we events in time and then suddenly, he doesn't want to bring me anywhere. So I'm like, okay. And this is all you've been together a year now. Yeah. The first year was bringing me everywhere the second year suddenly doesn't bring me anymore to the events. And it's like, are they going to be boring? Are they going to cost too much? Always far or you know, I'm just going to go there to meet some colleagues. But the switch was so sudden because he was taking me picture with members of the political party and stuff like that. And then suddenly, yeah, I don't exist. It's like he doesn't want people to know I exist because remember he has two Facebook. Did you ever have any inkling of this in the moment? Like I know everything's always hindsight, but in the moment, did you ever get suspicious of that? No. So the first hour of suspicious was in April. December was a first year anniversary. So five months later, it's April. I start having anxiety, a lot of anxiety and not related to my puking phobia because my anxiety is related to that. Right. So out of nowhere, I started being anxious and I'm like, hmm, this is where why am I so anxious? And I remember he had a whole weekend event and it was a Saturday and then the Saturday evening, he tells me we're going to go up to a bar afterwards. And like, well, I want to come. No, you won't find it fun, blah, blah. And I'm like, no, I'm going to come and then I was getting mad and was like, this time I'm coming. And he said, okay, fine, come. So I get to the bar. And then I open the door and I see him walking towards the bathroom. And I'm like, hey, James, I'm here. He's like, okay, go see my friend here that you've met before. She's going to tell you where we're sitting. So I go see this girl. And she's with another guy. And she's like, oh, this is James girlfriend. And the guy is like, James has a girlfriend. Oh, that is not what you want to hear. But he says it's like 10 times. He's like, James has a girlfriend. He has a girlfriend. And I'm like, yeah. And the face he made, I was like, yeah, I'm his girlfriend. And he was so shocked. But like I just told him like he was a murderer or something.
And a girl was trying to, like, calm down the guy who was like, "Yeah, you know he has a girlfriend." Like, "Don't be weird, you're being weird, yeah." And I'm like, "Okay." And then my anxiety was like, "Woo!" Oh, yeah. I was panicking. So we sit down and I'm just trying to not cry. I'm having zero fun. And then we decide to leave. And then we meet another guy leaving. A, he makes a joke about me. Like, "Oh, you're his secret girlfriend." Like, I don't remember exactly, but he, this guy, the, not the same guy, does also a weird comment about me. And I'm like, "Where am I? What's happening? We've been together a year and five months. Like, what? We live together. Yeah. Yeah, we live together. Yeah, that's true. We live together. And I remember sitting in the car like screaming, "What's happening? Why are people saying that? I'm your secret girlfriend, or they don't even know I exist." Yeah. Like, "Well, they're all drunk, it's missing, missing, they're staining." Of course. Their incidence is nothing. But for me, I was so anxious at that time. And I remember, I don't know if you remember at what point in Facebook, you could see people's activity. Yeah. You could see, like, I was so much asked. And I remember being at work because we had a lot of down time when I was at that job. So I remembered obsessive, checking what he was doing. And I saw him, he was adding girls, always on his political Facebook. And I was like, "Who are those girls?" And so I became so anxious, like, it was crazy. Oh, I'm so sorry. I know that feeling. It's the worst. Yeah. And you feel crazy. Yeah. You do. Yes. You feel like you're insane. Yeah. And I told my best friend about it. I think it was at that time. And then I told her about Tinder. And same thing, she was like, I think you can trust him. Like, even her, she didn't know what to tell me. Because at that point, her boyfriend and James, before it, became like a couple group, like, you were always together. So she was very close to James. So she was like, "No, I'm sure it's fine." You know, it's. Anyways, it was so weird. I am really into Jones Road Beauty. I've always loved the makeup artist Bobby Brown, because she's the clean skin, no makeup makeup look OG. And this is her newest brand. If you haven't tried Jones Road Beauty products, and you're somebody who really likes minimalism, no fuss makeup, I recommend. I've been into the miracle bomb for a while. So this bomb, it's very well-named. And it's in my routine consistently, because it's very, very easy. I like to look like I got a little bit of sun. Maybe like I went on a jog, but I'd love to not get too much sun. And also, if I can avoid running, I love it. It just gives you that warmth, that, like, that flush, that glow. And it looks like your own skin, but it has so many different colors. That's another thing about Jones Road. In general, the color range is so inclusive and so wide. And it works on most skin. Because you really just don't feel like you're wearing makeup. Like, that's kind of how their whole thing is. It's clean, it's high-performing, and they have a new product alert. They just launched the Bobby Kids 6.0, which is Bobby Brown's exclusive edit for the season. It gives you the complete, effortless look without having to figure out which products and shades work together. It's personally a selected by Bobby. And you get new silky, highlighting powder and a highlight brush. You get the new lip crown, mini miracle bomb, and the statement mascara. Also, this kit for the past five years has sold out every time. So don't wait around on this one. Grab yours before it's gone. Modern day makeup that's clean, strategic, and multifunctional for effortless routines. For a limited time, our listeners are getting a free full-size mascara on their first purchase when they use code dating detectives at checkout. Just head to Jones Road Beauty.com and use code dating detectives at checkout. After you purchase, they will ask you where you heard about them. So please support us show and tell them our show sent you. So this was in April. And I tell him I'm anxious. I don't feel secure in our relationship. I don't trust you anymore. And six weeks later, end of May is my birthday. It was my 25th birthday. So usually you do a big party, you know. And he was doing a surprise for my party. So he said, "Okay, we start your surprise. We're gonna go downtown somewhere." Okay. Romantic part of the city. And then he proposed. Oh, my gosh. Did you have any expectation of that? No, no, no. She's here in the house, supposed to be a girlfriend. Yeah, she was like, you're forgetting about me half the time. Yeah. So we're in there. Yeah, we were in a restaurant. And then we had a running gag of like, if you propose to me, you're going to propose to me with a ring pop. So I opened a bag. There's a ring pop. And then he brings the ring up. And this first thing I see is the ring. And then the first thing I say is, "Oh, it looks like a ring my ex gave me." Oh, my God. That was so small. It was so small. You're like, that's how you ring. But, you know what, it was small. It's because, you remember, I told you he doesn't have a credit? Yeah. Well, naive me was like, "I'm gonna be nice. I have two credit cards. I'm gonna let you one." Oh, no. Yeah. It didn't have a big balance since then. But now he has one of your credit cards. And that's what he bought your ring on. Yeah. So he bought the ring based on the remaining space available. My credit card. Oh, my God. Was his name added to it? No, no, no. It was like tapping or he knew my password. Okay. So I realized that he didn't say for it. He did not propose. If you use your money to get you, like, there's nothing planned. It was just there. I paid for my own engagement room. Oh, no. Yeah. So what happened is he buys a ring with my credit card. It says a picture to my friends because you remember it was a surprise birthday. Right. So send it to my friend. And they're like, "Oh, my God. Is it an engagement ring?" So he's like, "Yes." It wasn't. Oh, wait. So he just bought it not planning to propose. But because your friend said that, he was like, "That's a theory." I'm sure it's. I'm sure of it. Okay. He didn't say for it. We weren't talking about getting engaged. Right. For sure. Because it was just supposed to be a surprise party for my 25th. Not as a engagement. So what happened is the party became an engagement party. So how do you add? Instead of you say yes. Yes. Yes. And I was crying. I was panicking. But you just said that you do it for your partner. Yeah. So he did the engagement. It wasn't what I wanted. I didn't want the public engagement. We were in a restaurant. Yeah. So I was scared of people looking at me. Yeah. I want to be private. I'm a private person. I don't like too much attention on me. So I was like, he did not do what I was looking for. So what's going through your head? You said, "Yes." Of course. Because you're in this overwhelming experience. Yeah. It's a dopamine. So I'm like, "Oh, my God. I'm engaged." But I was still anxious. Yes. So we start wedding planning and he avoids it. He doesn't want to talk about it. He's like, "We have time. I start doing an invitation with my friend Sarah. I remember going to her place with him. He just sits with his computer and I'm cutting invitation with her doing the list with her when it's my wedding with him." So he's really disengaged. So my anxiety calm down for maybe a month or two, something like that. And then one time I went to another event with him and we meet a guy and the guy makes a joke. He's like, "Oh, it's your sister." It points at me. Oh, no. And they both laugh about it. And I remember when I was checking his activity on Facebook, I saw him comment, "Oh, it's my sister or something like that." Or the guy said, "Oh, it is one of your sisters." And there was a, it felt like there was an inside jokes about James saying that he's not dating one, I'm his sister. So I asked him about it. He refused to explain really. He's like, "Oh, he's just a joke. Don't worry about it." And I'm like, "Okay." Yeah. But now my anxiety is overwhelming. I don't sleep nice properly. I start losing weight. I feel like something is happening, if I cannot prove it. Yeah. Yeah, I go crazy. And then James starts selling my, or comment friends, mostly my best friend and her boyfriend that my anxiety is unmanageable. Like, she needs help. He's worried about me. You're the crazy one. Yeah. My mental health is damaging the relationship, like she needs help. Like, when you're on edge on the time, so I always always felt like something was wrong. You know when, like, I'm sure some listeners have been through that when you're young or anytime, and you know somebody's going to break up with you, and you have that edge, or you're going to lose your job, or something bad is going to happen. And the days before you know it's going to happen, it felt like that all the time. So it felt like there's something bad that's going to happen, I don't know what. And my body's trying to tell me, and I was seeing signs like when I was seeing his Facebook, or stuff like that, but I didn't have any proof. So I felt like I was going crazy. And when I was talking about about that with my best friend, who, who they knew each other well, or any of the else, everyone was like, no, he's so in love if you couldn't do anything bad to you. So it was.
wasn't helping. So I really felt like I was gonna, I was going crazy. And it starts putting webs in my friendship. So mostly my best friend, she started get worried about me, and he start confides in her. Like the same thing he did with me in the beginning. He started doing it with her, but about me. Oh, no. Oh, boy. I remember one night we were all gonna hang out. And he got to her place first. He talked to her for an hour about me. And I remember her telling me the day after you need to talk to James, like you have to talk. I cannot tell you like, because she didn't want to be in between, but she knew something was happening. Right. And it was beginning to be like a whole four person couple, you know it. Yeah. He was selling her stuff. She was selling me stuff, like, and, and then the boyfriend too, like we're like something was happening. And that was the crazy one. And he was succeeding in making my closest friend question my judgment. So that was very frustrating. Like make it, that's part of isolation too, is making you at odds with the people closest to you that could protect you. Yeah. And then who's left? Yeah. And I was getting very, very anxious. In my boss, I was like, maybe you should see your doctor. Can I ask in no pressure to go into detail, but can you describe how anxiety manifests for you? Cause I think it's always realized. So he went related to my phobia. So one time was on the subway. And I felt like I was going to be sick. And then because of that, I couldn't take the subway anymore. And I had to take the subway to go to work because it was far. So it was like overwhelming, like panic attacks. This is literally impacting your daily life. Like your, your life, your quality of life. Exactly. And usually when I have like, I call it relapse with my anxiety with my phobia is because I puke. I had like stomach flu and stuff like that. And I had none of that. It was just him. It's just him. We call that ladies in gentlemen, fem tuition. Yeah. Yeah. What do you say, Hannah? It's your body, your body, knowing before your brain does. Yes. Yes. But thank you for sharing that because I do think, I mean, at least I know my grandpa's always like, you kids, everybody says they have anxiety. Like that's just part of life. And I think it's good to remember. It's like a serious, serious reaction to yeah. And with saying he's what you're, it's your phobia, you're crazy. I'm not chewing on you like anyways. So at the same time, he's depressed. He's more agitated. He's mean. So I tell him, so he goes on medical leaf first. So in September, I told him you have to go set doctor. You're, you're different. You're more anxious. You're, you're weird. And then me I go in medical, even October. Oh my God. So you're both on the medical leaf. Yeah. So in Quebec, we have insurance, private insurance for our jobs. And so we can have insurance payments when we're out of work for medical leaf. So we both were still paying. And then he decides to take a paid political work at the same time. He's supposed to be on medical leaf. And he finds a job once for municipal election. So there's a like a city election. And he finds a job. He goes see the guys. Like I want to work for you. Like you're going to fire me. He's very like, I'm coming. I'm doing it. Walks in with his suit and he comes back and I'm like, you're not supposed to work. Oh, it's fine. It's going to be under the radar. Like he's going to pay me under the table. It's fine. I'm like, you're supposed to take care of you. And so yeah, I'm going to do it. Like he's like, I'm going to do it. And then during the first campaign, because they're going to be the second one. All right. You should get worse and worse. He's never home. He doesn't do dates anymore. He's, he's only do politics. And this shows me. And then I go on medical leave. And then the election finished. I think it was in the beginning of November. And I'm like, don't ever do this again. It was too stressful. I never saw you. And then we go both on medical leave at the same time. So we're home together. And the region goes improved. So we're from November to February. We're both out of work. I go back to work slowly. And during that time, I was like, okay, relationship is better. There's change. It's going to be fixed. And then he tells me one of my political friend, he wants to do an election. There's like a midterm election. And he wants to do it. And I'm going to be his campaign manager. And you're like, oh, that's going to not again. awful. He's like, I promise, it's going to be smaller. He want to figure a relationship. I'm like, please don't do him. I promise he's going to be better. And then it does. I think I'm going to research it. I never see him. And he takes my car to do everything. Where is he on finances at this point? Is he like making any money to pay back? Well, just from insurance. So what happens is he appears on television during the campaign. Okay. And his boss sees it. Of course. So for a smart guy, he's not always smart. So he loses his job because you're supposed it's insurance fraud. I guess. So he lose his job. And then he finds another job like the campaign finishes fine. His friend give him another job. Okay. But he has a big depth for me. So because I'm not stupid. I'm naive. I'm not going to say stupid. I'm naive. I want hope to tell him. So I'm giving him money. So he's driving my car because I pay for his driving classes because he did it really late. Usually we do it when you're in high school. I pay for a Hawaii trip. I pay for purchase on a credit card. So he paid for your ring. He owes me around six K. $6,000. He's racked up. Okay. So which is a lot of money when you're, I guess it was 26 at the time. Yeah. Yeah. So that's a lot of money for anyone to be honest with. But he was always paying me back. But now he was paying less and less back. And in the beginning, I started letting him money because his ex Olivia, she paid for all their furniture when they were living together. And I saw him pay her back. So I was like, he's trustworthy. And you know, he's going to pay me back. Right. Yeah. So now that that was getting bigger and bigger and bigger. And then in February, he asked me to go with him to a suaje to a karaoke party in a bar. So we go there. And then we start, we start the party at Sophie's apartment. Sophie's are important. And I knew her. I met her a couple of times. She's just a friend of yours. Not a no of him of his. Okay. I never liked her. I met her a couple of times in the like in the other events. In the first thing that he was bringing me everywhere, he told me she's an old political friend and know her for years. And you can trust her. And then during this, the karaoke, she started asking me about the engagement. And she laughs about it. She's sarcastic. She's mean. Like towards your, towards her, like what she's saying towards me. I'm telling her about how he proposed. And she has this narkey smile. And I'm like, why are you such a bitch? I don't know if you saw the carriage TV show. But I felt like that, that night because he was like, come sing with me. I'm not a singer. I sound awful. He made me sing in front of everyone. So what did you, did you have any suspicions about why Sophie was acting that way or did she? No, she was with her boyfriend. I was like, why are you so mean? So maybe a weekend or two after he goes to another political event. But it's out of town. And it's in Sherbrook. And I tell him, you're not taking my car this time. So he takes his mom's car. And during the whole weekend, he buries and so are my calls. You remember, he's a guy that sends you pictures. Yeah. His location and now he's he's evasive and everything. So I'm like, oh, something is wrong. And then he comes back on the Sunday, but he goes to another event downtown in the feeling that there's a show or something happening. And I'm like, can I go meet you there? And it's okay. Come. So of course, I'd beg him to meet him. And then I wait outside because I don't know if it's the show start or I'm sweating. He didn't tell me anything. And then I'm outside waiting. And then I see Sophie come out. I don't talk to her. And if I just see her come out, I'm like, where, why is she here? And then raster, James come out screaming at me. You're you're late. Why are you outside? You're like your trouble for your in the way. And I'm like, why are you screaming at me? He's not a screamer, so I was like, why is she screaming at me? So we go inside and there's a concert happening. I'm just crying next to him. So I tell him, I know something happened. I don't know what, but there's something happening. No relationship. I don't know what. He's like, no, I love you. He's trying to like, he's like, Oh, pop piece on and he's like, how sweet. I'm sorry. I scream at you. Like, I love you, blah, blah, blah. And then I don't know if it's the same day or the next week. He's on his computer. He likes to like put his computer on the TV so we can see bigger. Yeah. And then I see that his entire message, his story, was so face deleted. Oh, what? That's
- And they've been friends for like 10 years. - Oh. - Deleted. - So I'm like, it's like, oh, we're doing secret, political strategies. So I had to delete everything because somebody sees it. And then he just, it goes back to my anxiety, saying it's all in your hand. And then at that point, we're like, end of March. And it's like, I have to talk to you. I think we need a break. I'm gonna stay at my mother's house. And he's still me, my anxiety is destroying a relationship. - Oh, okay. - I need to start medication, I need to work on myself. Yeah. And I even start the medication. And it tells me, okay, today I'm gonna come home. And we're gonna talk. I'm promised you, we're gonna talk. I'm gonna meet you at her apartment. And then I'm in the subway. And then he takes me, okay, I'm on my way. And then I lose contact on your internet. And then I get to my station. And he says, I'm not coming anymore. We'll talk later. I'm like, well, you promise to come. And he's like, yeah, change of plan. I'm not gonna be home tonight. So I get home. I try the medication. And then it's like 10 p.m. And I get a Facebook message, a private one. You know, like they ask you a request, I can request. Thank you. And the center just started the conversation saying, I cannot keep watching what's happening. And then just sends me screenshots. Oh, and the shops are between Sophie and her friend. And it's telling that she's sleeping with James. She's, he's staying at her place. And he's hiding the affair from me. And she says something like, I she didn't in the past. And I told the guy like right away. So seeing him doing this to her, I'm not comfortable with that. He should tell her. Wait, Sophie's saying that, her? Yeah. She's telling her friend that he should, you know, tell me. Isn't Sophie in a relationship with someone else? So I text the guy, her boyfriend. Nice. Hey, what's up? She's chilling on you and like, no, hey, what's up? She broke up with me just before the event. No out of town. He's like, yeah, I know they're sleeping together. I like great. So I send James the screenshots. And it's like, okay, I'm coming home. And then at that point, I was like, I'm going to call his mother. I call his mother. He's like, no, he hasn't been home nice all week. So she comes first. He hasn't been home. And then after three days, I'm like, fuck it. I'm going on his computer. I go in his computer on his political Facebook because it was open. We didn't have all the two factors checked. Like we have now. It was easier to go on Facebook message. And then I find a conversation with a lot of women that didn't know about. Never heard of them. And then I just realized that he was using his political Facebook to talk with women. So that's what I find out. And then I contact Sophie. I tell her like, hey, you're sleeping with my fiance. And she said, I'm so sorry. It's okay if you're angry, but it's also my right to be kept out of it. She blocked me. But just before she blocked me, I told you, I'll say it's in front of me. I said, fuck you as to bitch, which means fuck you, you or something like that. Okay. Well, we're more like Quebec was lying. So he returns home, we're in his office because I'm next to his computer and I'm like, look. And then he starts, like he's sitting on the sofa. I'm sitting on the office chair. And it's like he has different masks on. And he doesn't know which one to put on. So he cries and then gets angry and then gets serious. And then he tells me, well, Sophie, I've been in love with her for the past 10 years. But she was always in a relationship. She wasn't like showing me interest. And then he cries. He said, he loves me, but he's so acting weird. And then it's really the first time that I saw his real personality. He really mimics what she wants him to be. Now, this time, he didn't know what to do. He really didn't know which face, like which personality to give me. So yeah, with the conversation, the Facebook conversation, I saw that he was driving her with my car to multiple place. I found some stuff in my car, like an elastic stuff like that from her. Oh my gosh. And the first time they slept together was at the Sherbrook weekend. So that's what happened, like two weeks. So that's why she came out of the theater when I met him there because they just spent the whole weekend and he brought her back to our city. So that's why I saw her. And so she broke up shortly before the affair with her boyfriend. I found out from another guy that during the weekend, he took intimate photos of her when she was sleeping. Oh my God. Yeah, to show his friend, like look what they, like I slept with her. So I think he may have done this with me too. Yeah, because you know, he wants to show he's a, you know, a big guy. So yeah, so that's what happened. And then during the confrontation, I'm like, well, I thought you could never cheat because of your father. And then he tells me, well, it's not true. What the whole thing with his dad ain't true? He never knew his father, he tells his girlfriend that to make them feel secure. Did he admit that to you? Yeah. And when he's saying the truth, is he a robot? Is he sad? Like, how can you admit to someone? Yeah, I made up that my dad died by suicide. My fairy is that he never knew his father because he's not on the birth certificate. So there's some weird stuff. All we know is he was lying. So I threw my engagement into his face. And then one time during the confrontation, you know when you're mad and you're like, reacting so I push him and then he, he took my arm and he's like, don't push me again, something like that. And I just saw his father. I was like, oh my god, he can be violent, this is scary. I was scared. So he left. I left for my parents' house in the middle of the night. I think it was 2 a.m. Just came to my parents' house, woke them up. And it came, I was horrible, but ended up the relationship. I wasn't the one that stayed, for me it's like, you cheated, it's over. Yeah. That was a deal breaker for me, that's for sure. And it sounds like whether or not you were super aware of it, almost preparing for this for a while. Yeah. During the break, the break was like a week or something, I knew it was going to be ending. I knew there was not coming back from that. I knew he didn't want to be with me anymore. Oh, but it's so interesting that period of, how old God, where you're like, I know this is probably not going to be it, but I'm not quite ready to call it. Yeah. And that was so sad. I remember, I was, I went back on medical leave or something, I went, no, I think I took a break. I don't know. I don't remember. I remember nothing at work. And then my sister said, come eat lunch with me. And I was just crying. And my sister was trying to, my sister is six years older than me. She's a reason I know about you. Oh, yeah. Her podcast. Well, she ain't got the players. Me too, sir. Yeah. Anyway, so we broke up on the Thursday and then on the Saturday, all my friends, my friends were amazing. My family were amazing. They all came together. Help me move out. They did the whole moving. I haven't, like, I was dealing with him. And we were trying to manage because he owes me money. So he's like, oh, I have a lawyer friend. He can help us do, like, a contract, which was not perfect because, well, it's his friend. Yeah. Of course. Yeah, my best friend, boyfriend, very nice of him. He has a lawyer friend of his dad, a big one, like someone that costs a lot of money. He met me, like, he met me for free, he checked the contract and he was, he said, this contract like is nothing, like you cannot do anything with that. So I did a contract for nothing, but anyway, so we, I was doing the contract while my friend was moving me out. And then it was like a cathartic, like you said, like, we did a message. We said fuck you on the wall, nice on papers, because it's not our apartment with, and we were all doing, like, fuck you with our fingers and we took a pictures. And most of them were friends of his, too, you know? So the difference with his ex is we had proofs. So all his friends were like, oh, okay, James is not the guy we thought he was. Yeah. It all took my part, but in his old relationship, they all took his part because he couldn't have been somebody of anything if there's no evidence in play. Yeah, he's good at it. Yeah. Yeah. So he loses almost all his friends, his close friend, he lose them because I had evidence. Yeah. Two, three weeks after, I go to my best friend party, my best friend party, and I take a picture with his friend, which were also my friend. I put it on Facebook, he sees it. And then he sends me a house of cards gift, which house of God was big back in the day. Right. Saying game on.
-Oh, my. -What? -Yeah. So that, for anybody that doesn't know the show, that's like a political show that's all about, you know, cut through revenge and rivalry. -Yeah. -That's like a threat. -Yeah. So he sends me that. He also, he sends me legal passages who intimate me. He, I begin being afraid of him. Like, what is he going to do? -And now you're probably like, -At that weight, Olivia, that girl that kept, like, kept reaching out to him and he kept having to deal with her. Like, maybe he was reaching out to her? -Yeah. Yeah. Maybe this is all him. -Yeah. Well, I met with Olivia. -Oh, wait. How did that turn out? -Oh, boy. -I decided to reach to her because I'm like, he's full of shit. I have to know her story. -Yeah. -So I contact her and I realize she tells me that he was still involved with her when he was portering me. They were still in a relationship. -He cheated on her with you. -Yeah. How was the other woman? So he did the same thing. He asked her for space, but he continued sending romantic messages. -Yeah. -He told her that was only a friend and he kept her hopeful that the relationship was going to work. And he was waiting to see how it was going to be with you. -Yeah. -And she sent me the rest of some of the messages. She said he was sending me, she sent me the other part, so I could see the conversation. -Oh, yeah. -So he was screenshotting the ones that made her seem crazy. -He was sending her like a baby's name idea. -Oh, my God. And she's like, "I can't wait to have babies with you." And then he just said, "You know, picture of "I can't wait to have babies with you." -That's a lie. -That's disgusting. -And then same thing as me, she has mental health issues, and the relationship should destroy her mental health, and that's why she was hospitalized. So same thing as me. -Oh, my God. -Yeah. -But I didn't stop there. I met with his first ex. -Let's go, Claire. -So her name is Brooke. She was the ex that he came to attack him with a knife. Knives, whatever. And then same thing, he was having a mental health crisis, and she was trying to attack herself. -Oh. -He had to call the 911. -Oh, my God. -It was like, she was, I don't know why he's saying, I attacked him because that was the last thing I wanted to do. I would have never heard him. I loved him too much, but I was going crazy. Same thing as me. Going crazy because he wasn't giving me intention anymore. I could feel like he wasn't in the relationship anymore. So he was always using the worst woman of his girlfriends to make him as a victim. -That's such a good way to put it because I feel like if you isolate, like every one of us has one isolated incident that could make us be the crazy ex-girlfriend. -Yes. -Or a crazy ex-girlfriend. -I have multiple. -Yeah, I might have obvious. -I don't know how I feel. -But I'll own it. -It's not always about the behavior right there. It's about how you repair after the fact. And it sounds like he was really just using everything to manipulate. -And if you had a slip, a weak moment. Great. That's ammo now. He can do that. -So you can set pattern now. -I think he targets people that are insecure, are naive, believe in true love. They're easy to love bomb. So he's intense pursuit. After you, he decides you're the next one. -Yeah. And then love bombing, which I didn't know about it before, sure. And then he did the same thing with his two ex-girlfriends, so he got the personal information. So the way they describe him as a boyfriend, he was a different man. Not the same interest. Not the same. Oh, he was a different man. -Wow. -Not the same taste of music. And then when he's tired of you, he doesn't bring any positive thing for him. He grows distant, and then he finds another woman. -Yeah. -And then he tells that his ex are crazy. So I'm pretty sure he told the next woman that was crazy first. So he's been doing the circle for maybe five, six years. And he had an ex in high school. He said I was his first girlfriend. And one of my friends got in a relationship with one of his high school colleagues, and he told me, no, he never went out with this girl. It's a lie. She was like the popular girl. -Yeah, of course. -He was like, oh, his girl never. -Okay. -He's like, she was obsessed with me. I broke up with her. -Yeah, sure. -And yeah, he was like the nerd unattractive guy in high school. So the guy was like, no, he never went out with her. Are you crazy? So yeah, so he started in high school being manipulative. So, in May, I decided, so we broke up in April. And then in April, beginning of May, I decided to go to France because I had some friends over there and I want to change my mind. But with the money, it was going to send me. What's going on there? -And then did. -Yeah, and then I go on Instagram, and then I see on his Instagram that he's going to Thailand. -Why? Why? For what? -I don't know. -I'm like, what? You see, but no, he writes that he's leaving Quebec, he's getting a new life in Thailand. -Oh, he's like up and uprooting. -Yeah. -And you've got forever. -Okay. -He's a very white man from Quebec. And then, yeah, so I learned. And then our leads were ending because we were supposed to move together upstairs, my parents. So our leads were ending. So I already left the apartment and I was like, shit, how's the apartment going to be? So I get to the apartment and it's everything's there. He left everything. -What do you mean? -It's closed for nature, childhood memories. -What? -I'm the photograph. He left everything. The only thing that was not there is stuff that he could sell. So we sell like the washer dryer, stuff like that. -Oh, my God. -I found evidence of high interest online loans. So instead of paying me back, he used it to leave. -Oh, my God. -And then when he's out of the country, he's a lot harder to pursue online. -Of course, I can't do anything. -I can't do nothing. What do you do? -So, yeah. So two weeks later, his mom calls me on my birthday and tells me she's too tired. She cannot clean the apartment. I can take anything I want, but she's not going to clean up the apartment. And me, as a good girl, I didn't want to leave the apartment to the new tenants like that. I didn't want the landlord to blame me. So with friends, we went there. But it was very fun because we took his thing and we throw it on the street. So it was on the second floor. So we were literally throwing everything. -Oh, my God. -And it's therapeutic. -I kept something to sell. I would get not keeping more things. But I was with friends. And like two days later. So I didn't have time to do all that. -Yeah. -But yeah, so we made that clean everything after anyway. So I sell some stuff. I recover maybe two K from the six K. He owned me. But once again, I was stuck with his choices. So on my 20. No, 26 birthday, 27, I don't remember. We did a cleansing birthday. So we had a poop pinata that we put his face on. I burned some old photograph of him and me because I did a bomb with him. And so we did a big birthday celebration on moving forward. And then my friend gave me the money to go to friends. -Oh, that's it. -Yeah, I love yours in the end of the system. -Yeah. -So when I was in friends, so the beginning of June, I was there for maybe two weeks. It sent me a love letter from Thailand by email. Because he saw on my Facebook, even if we weren't friends anymore, I guess he saw my profile picture. He saw that was. -Oh, he went well. -Yeah, so I think that he made a mistake. He misses me like the whole election and again. He just wanted to, you know, rattle me while I was having fun. -Yes. -Yeah. So over the five years, he sent me 300 bucks. That's it. -Oh, my God. -He always had reason and he'd after he stopped responding. So I never had my money. -Oh, that's good. -And then two years ago, I found that through his sister because sometimes I ask her about her. He moved back, so he wasn't Thailand for five years. He married a poor woman there. She doesn't know anything. -He brought her here to find out. She's gonna learn today. -Yeah, but poor her. He brought her here, so she doesn't know when she's very isolated. -Wait, they moved back? -Yeah, so he moved back to his mom's house. He tried to work, but he did like online training, so he has nothing. The last thing I found out about him, because sometimes I check on his Facebook because I want to know where he is. -Yeah, yeah, yeah, freaks me out. -He was wearing a Canadian military uniform, so I think he's in the army now. -What? -Because he's wearing the. I don't know if it's the same thing in the state, but when you're in the army, you can have free education. So maybe that's what he's doing. -Yeah, yeah. -But usually, how old was he at that point? -He joined the army. -Maybe 30, 31? -Well, I guess you can. Because you're saying maybe he's turning over a new leaf. but I'm like, where is his wife? (laughs) - Yes. - Gosh.
I mean, I have so many questions, I wish I could know, but I know I have so many questions because he just told everybody you were his like sister or something. Yeah, I know This is so it was a serial dogfish. I just keep going in circles. I'm not done So two weeks after leaving for Thailand, his lawyer friend Contacts me. Oh, he's like panicking. It's like did you know that Jane was a government spy? That's why he left for Thailand. He know damn government spy stop it. No, and like I'm like, why are you what? He's like, yeah, that's why he left and then he just like talking about his Political thing. I'm like, I'm over it. I'm like, I don't care. And then my friend Sarah Was like I'm gonna check on because she works in in the banking for the Portman, so she was like, I'm gonna check online. She couldn't check about him. Of course, but she was checking on like how do you become a government? Spy you have to have a driver license, which he didn't have for the most of our relationship. You need to have a bachelor at least he doesn't have that So he didn't mean you need to be in physical shape, which you didn't have and but what before I contacted you One of the reason I contacted you is the same freaking guy Contact me recently like this summer To say that a journalist was gonna investigate him They're gonna do like about espionage and financial fraud a book like who is lawyer friend that he's got. I know not a good one Exactly, he beat it his way and just answers is I do want to talk to the guy He's like, I'm like, yeah, so journalists and if they want to talk contact me, they can contact me directly. They're journalists. They can't find me And then it is I always gonna be in the journal like Sunday It never got in the journal. Of course, it didn't nobody's contact me. There's nothing at all The journalist wasn't even a journalist is he's an old political member. That does fronicle on the journal He's the gardener because I know someone that works for a big journal in Quebec Yeah, I told her I bought it and she was like, yeah, no, it's bullshit He's like, no, but it's gonna contact you So do they just want to stay relevant in your life like they just want a room. I do I ferry is either it was a joke manipulation appton or just another lie Maybe he was with him and they want to you know fuck me up or something at the point like it's been eight years Like why yeah over it and then I just blocked him. I was like, I'm done with this guy. Good for you So we break up is a very hard time for me I was pretty much suicidal at that point because I yeah, I was it because was it because he pushed you to the brink of like So you feel like you're so crazy. It's just how much you feel bad about it. Yeah, I was so sad It was not a real grip up So I felt like nobody I was understanding me. I was why was it happening to me and then Six months or a little bit more than six months. I mean my husband So Olivia was friend with my husband. Oh, no way And I finally found a healthy relationship, but I think some girls will understand it when you all the known toxic relationship and the We call it roller coaster like Yes, yeah, that you hide. Yeah. Um, it's very hard to be in the Quiet relationship. So my husband always say he's a river. He's very quiet river So for me in the first year when he said it was hard. I was questioning all the time if I went to be with him because I was I was the high where's the low like yeah, why do you miss that same electricity? Yeah, why you're not like Confronted me or where's the chaos? You know aren't you supposed to bring chaos? Yeah, exactly But now, you know, it's it's a different kind of relationship, but it's like we've been together for eight years. We've been married for almost three. Wow Oh, yeah Yeah, and then you said like what's the advice or what could I like what did I learn? Yes, and you said before Really listen to your body your body families and yeah, oh my god. It's crazy how My body knew a year before yes, yes a year before so Listen to it and really learn to recognize love bombing manipulation tactics Uh, it shouldn't be you shouldn't feel like super high dopamine in the beginning should be like We want to be together all the time and being like super intense over like overly dopamine Yeah, yeah intense is not the goal actually and it's okay to enjoy and get a little getty But when you get that intensity, sometimes that can be like the red flag and it's yeah Yeah, you he's not the man of your dream or the man of your life. He's gone him for two weeks You don't know someone you know you know no two weeks get a grip He's got a heart actually, yeah, but Really for me it was important to tell my story because it's very important to not feel alone because I really felt alone Post-breakup because my friend thought it was just a regular breakup, but for months I was still talking about it because it was such a mental world coaster and when you're Like I'm pretty sure is a social psychopath you have to discontruct all your memories because then you remember oh It happened this way, but actually it happened this way so you have a flashback And then you have cognitive distortion because he manipulated you so much that's so true And you don't think about it like somebody has a regular breakup usually you don't have that so my friend didn't understand why I was not over him They were almost saying like okay, it's been months like get over him. I was like no you don't understand you don't are so and it's yeah Pull assume that if you like if you go through something like that the like you just get it doesn't The things the negative things that you go through don't negate the love that you had so like the days where it was like really really good Those are good days and so That you still have love for those days like those memories still existed. Yeah, but so It's a contradiction because you have those lovin worries, but now you see the real Yes behind the mask you're like fuck and understand what happened But you can't and you can't like unravel or you can't like who know reverse like Yeah, I shouldn't felt that way because it's like no that feeling was real for you. Yeah, right and then a hundred percent Once you come to terms with that you have the added layer of then going through the shame of Wait, how did I not see that? I built this story around what he was telling me. Yes, like there's so many layers To the healing and it's not as simple as like boo. I got rejected and I was engaged and I'm not it's like yeah You are having to learn a different reality right then the one they were exactly if I compared to a cult when you leave a cult You have to Discontract everything. Yeah, so for me was it was worse And now today I can talk about it very easily. I don't feel as much pain because I went through something more traumatic. My baby girl last year was born at 28 weeks. Oh So going through that she's fine now. She's a healthy baby She made it Yeah, going through early days of hospital. Mm-hmm. Uh, I was like yeah, you know what James thing I'm over it like it's nothing compared to thinking you're gonna lose your baby But really for me now is James was a lifeless and and I'm glad I had it because if I didn't have it I'm sure I was still being a toxic relationship Because I will still be trying to find those highs and lows. Oh my gosh Thank you so much for sharing. I feel like this guy is like okay Dogfish dogfish number one Like I can't I'll never cheat on you because my mom did that to my dad like you know and that could be true, right? Let's take that groundwork. Yeah, but then Combined with oh and all I'd never want you to go through my phone because that's something that was so traumatic for me And so this is a boundary for me because this is triggering for me. So it was like okay He's drawn his boundaries so she's gonna respect those boundaries so she goes to his phone And then all these different things like this is just like dogfish 101 like this You make sure you can never get caught just What do you call it pre gaming or pre like you're pre laying the groundwork? You're making pre excuses for shit that yeah that you know you're gonna do because you're a douchebag and hindsight's 2020 man I mean, I love that you're in sex education now and I love that you're happy now and that you were so Brave to come on and share your story because you're right Like you said a lot of people going through it a lot of people don't realize they're going through it So you'll definitely help a lot of people. Yeah. Thank you so much. We appreciate you coming and sharing your story It means a lot to us and it's been so nice to meet you. Yeah, and am I your first French Canadian? I think so This is your first French Canadian. Yeah. Yeah I want to pop all your ad then tell your sister. Thank you. Yeah, tell her give us our give her our love Uh crazy x-roll friend who I wonder how many guys have said like my x is crazy, but it's because he made them crazy Yeah Well that's so real and it's why I think We use the word crazy to describe mentally ill people which is there's a whole debate around language around that in itself It's like almost inherently this bad
bad thing to say somebody was crazy. And it's not, first of all, because being mentally ill or going through any kind of mental health issue is not a bad thing. And also, the question is, is there a why there that just because you had some mental health issue in your past relationship, or even if you did something that was a result of that, that isn't a good thing. Yes, you're responsible, but you're not inherent in that. You know, he used their mental health against them to clear to all of these X's, and then was able to say, like, well, she was in the mental hospital. So she was crazy. She was the, and I think that's my point. Yeah, you're not inherent like the problem. And as soon as you hear someone was in a mental hospital, then I feel like mentally you convict them of being crazy or psycho or whatever, whatever the terms that people use to describe their X's most commonly. And I also feel there's a little bit of, it ties into some reactive abuse, right? Like, you, you, you, you poke the bear, you're going to get the horns, right? So you keep, you keep egg in a month and egg in a month and you're gaslighting and all these things. You're making this person feel crazy. Like, there is something really wrong with them. So you can check yourself into a mental hospital thinking, well, I got to do the right thing. So who's the crazy one here? You know what I mean? And you're the one who looks crazy because you went to the mental hospital when it wasn't even your fault. This point, the word is like losing meaning to me because it's just like, yes. The, he's like, she attacked me with a knife. She was self-harming. And then he's able to just take a little piece of your own mental, your own perception of your own mental health. So like with her, with Claire, yeah, she was going through stuff and he was able to say, I'm worried about you. You are unwell. This is going on in your head. And he was able to convince her friends, her best friend, that that was also the case. So when she goes to the people in her life and they say, we're worried about you, we think there's something wrong with you, you're going to believe it. Like you're going to really start believing it. And then you're going to react accordingly. It's just like this, a little cycle of manipulation, really. And that manipulation where he's getting her friends on his side so that when she goes to the people she trusts, that she's like, she's going to believe them when they say, oh, I think there might be something wrong with you. That's just another form of isolation, which is usually a huge way that abusers get most of their controllers through isolation. And I should point that I think of isolation as someone. Yeah, I always think of it as like making your friends turn against you. Well, what if it's making your friends side with your abuser or with your hair about you and they want to help you, but they don't have all the facts. Like it just feels it's it's isolated. He's he just isolated her from the safe and comfort of the friends and family. It's just it's very sinister. It's very it's just disgusting. He kept saying it's all on your head. It's all on your head. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Sleeling this show, yeah. And I felt for her when she talks about being so obsessive with checking his activity and just being so anxious. And I'm glad she kind of elaborated on what that looks like and what that feels like. Because I said it when we were talking to her, but just how easy it is to be like, yeah, everybody's anxious. And there's a level of anxiety that is really, really debilitating. Like I can't imagine there are some people in my life who just do not have any anxiety. And I'm like, shout out to my mom and we love that about her. And we are so happy for her, but we're like, that woman has never had anxiety in her life in the in the scientific sense. And I'm like, so that doesn't, that doesn't like make you wonder or worry dope. We used left last night when you fell asleep easily. Wait, there's not a voice inside your head like saying 600 different things at one time. That's nice. Okay, wait, you don't know how to check a following on somebody's Instagram and notice when a new person has followed them or a story of the restaurant where you think they were and look at other people's story to see who was in the background. Create an entire narrative. That's just speaking of creating narratives. Can we also talk about this guy? Okay, the whole thing with, I'll never cheat on you because I know what that did to my parent. And like, so he's creating this sob story. And don't go through my phone because that's very triggering for me. And so she's honoring his request, his boundaries, and saying, okay, I can understand why you wouldn't want that. And why that would be such a big deal for you. So she made a point never to do those things. And the fact that he lied about his dad dying, like, what's going on? Oh my God. That was disgusting too. Disgusting. He's just, yeah, it's at all, anything that can serve him. I just was, I was cracking up that his two rules are, I promise I'll never cheat on you and also never go through my phone. Yeah, it's like, but he was very good at making everything make sense, I thought. And especially leading up, beginning of it, like he had a reason for all of his behavior, even for being on Tinder, like, he could really, really get her understand. And I don't blame her in the slightest. And this is where, this is where things come in like, when we, when we really start to question ourselves, this is where people say, gosh, I felt so stupid. You're not stupid. He literally took advantage of her kindness. He took advantage of her respect. He took advantage of her willingness to respect his boundaries, he took advantage of that. All the thing, I mean, he did right. He took advantage of. He started the relationship with his sob story. He would, like, it cried at her about his ex and their breakup and like, he's laid this foundation to be the victim in the sympathetic character in her relationship. So anytime, anything came up that could have been seen as a red flag, he was able to say, well, I'm just dealing with this insecurity or my past has caused me this, this and this. And he's able to turn it around so she ends up apologizing and like begging while, you know, but that's what they do. They leave you so confused. I love when she said at the very end, I was stuck with his choices. Uh-huh. That's such a good way to put the feeling of losing money, of losing a plan that you had envisioned for yourself. And then they just go to Thailand, I guess, like, I guess, I hate it, frickin hate it. But yeah, the whole mental health conversation weaponizing that, using it against people in your past and using it to frame your current story is just so twisted. I spoke to a friend like two days ago who is thankfully out of a relationship with a total, like, you know, I don't know the diagnosis, but he could be on our show. And she just got the call from his most recent ex. And the girl was like, Oh, yeah, and it's one very validating for my friend who felt like, you know, even even after the fact in hindsight, you still have that little sliver of like, am I overreacting? Well, no. And then they connect and they're like, nope, that's not what he told me. That's not what he told me at all. And it's so insane that they can just tell whatever story they need to to make you feel bad for them. It's so gross. And especially for people who know the feeling of struggling with mental health in a way that's totally not like, it's just so, I can't imagine having that used so poorly against you because you already feel that like you already feel ashamed and guilty of what you were experiencing. And then to have it either used in high, like he can move on and say like, Oh, she had my ex had borderline personality disorders. So she was crazy. And now you're dragging the entire borderline community, first of all. Yeah. And we just take those labels and assume so much from them. And it's not fair. And it doesn't help the people go through it at all. Not at all. It's so not fair. Oh, it makes me so mad. I'm sure our listeners have a lot of thoughts on this and probably thoughts that are far more eloquent than mine, like I need to hear what some of you feel about that. Or if that's happened to you, where somebody's really taken your, your mental health and weaponized it. This is a good thing. Basically to talk about this. That's why mental health is so stigmatized. Like we already, there's already such a stigma behind, you know, with mental health. Like, can we not make it worse and weaponize it? Like, don't come on. If anybody has problems, is this fella? I hope nobody ever dates him again. Disgusting. He makes me sick. But Claire's happy. We're happy for Claire. She's doing. I know. I was about to say, good on her for moving on because screw that guy. Yeah. And there is such a difference. She talked about like the difference between the love bombing, the flowers, the unmet needs focusing in on that. And then actually just getting to know somebody and being respectful, being a gentleman, being a good friend without trying to get something out of it. And what a con that that is, right? You would think it would be bare minimum, but guess not. Wow. I love her. I would love everybody to share their thoughts in any kind words they want to send to Claire. We'll make sure we pass them along. Yeah. Thank you always for you guys always have the kindest, most respectful thoughts. And wishes and we're just so grateful for you guys. So thank you. And we are going to pass on any any kind remarks to Claire. So thank you again. I also want to hear what everybody thought if they saw the Nathan Field or Elizabeth Holmes documentary because it's definitely dogfish territory and man, man, I'm not going to say anything else because.
But like I would love to discuss for sure well we love you guys Thank you so much for listening and as always trust you after your fan tuition You
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Claire dated James, a man who portrayed himself as emotionally vulnerable and romantic, but exhibited controlling and manipulative behaviors throughout their relationship.
James used multiple layers of deception, including fake Facebook profiles, avoiding phone access, and hiding his political activity, to maintain a facade of trustworthiness.
Claire noticed red flags early on—his sudden emotional shifts, excessive texting, and behavior during shared events—especially when he claimed to be in love while avoiding intimacy and transparency.
James’s history of trauma, including his father’s suicide due to infidelity and his exes’ extreme behaviors, influenced his fear of betrayal and led to obsessive control and secrecy.
The relationship escalated with love bombing, public engagement without consent, and financial exploitation, including using Claire’s credit card to buy a ring.
Claire’s anxiety worsened due to repeated exposure to signs of deception, such as social comments about her being “a secret girlfriend” and his political activities.
James became increasingly evasive, cutting off communication, disappearing during events, and making false claims about his intentions, especially during political campaigns.
Ultimately, Claire recognized the relationship as a toxic pattern of manipulation, where James exploited her trust and emotional vulnerabilities, leading her to seek a break.
Summary:
Claire shares her story of a toxic relationship with James, whom she initially saw as emotionally open and romantic. After meeting at a Halloween party, they bonded over shared experiences and began a relationship that quickly escalated with love bombing, constant texting, and shared planning for marriage. James portrayed himself as vulnerable, citing trauma from his father’s suicide due to infidelity and obsessive loyalty to his exes, Olivia and Brooke.
Claire noticed red flags early—his secretive behavior, political activity on social media, and sudden emotional shifts—especially when he claimed to be in love while avoiding intimacy. He used deception tactics, such as hiding his political Facebook profile and avoiding phone access, to maintain control. His behavior became increasingly manipulative: he used Claire’s credit card to buy a ring without proposing, pressured her into a public engagement, and avoided discussing the relationship.
As the relationship progressed, Claire’s anxiety grew, fueled by social comments, his evasiveness, and his sudden disappearances during events. A pivotal moment came when she saw him interact with a friend, Sophie, in a mocking way about their engagement, confirming his deception. He later deleted his messages and social content, showing a pattern of secrecy and control.
Claire realized the relationship was built on manipulation and trauma, not genuine love. By March, she decided to end it, moving back to her mother’s house and seeking emotional recovery, emphasizing that her mental health and trust were severely compromised. The episode challenges the "crazy ex girlfriend" trope, showing how such narratives can mask deeper patterns of manipulation and emotional abuse.
FAQs
The 'Crazy Ex Girlfriend' trope refers to the stereotype that an ex partner is emotionally unstable or mentally ill. It's important to challenge this because it can lead to mislabeling and invalidate real mental health struggles. The podcast highlights that such narratives often mask deeper issues like manipulation, control, and emotional abuse.
Claire met James at a Halloween party where he impressed her with his confidence and charisma. Early signs of concern included his obsession with sharing only parts of his ex’s messages, his refusal to show his full Facebook activity, and his sudden emotional vulnerability about his ex Olivia, who was reportedly hospitalized after their breakup.
Red flags included his secretive phone use, avoiding direct contact, showing only curated parts of his personal life, his political Facebook profile where he posted about women, and his sudden decision to move in with Claire after just six months, which is a common sign of emotional manipulation.
Claire experienced anxiety due to a growing sense of betrayal and insecurity. It manifested through panic attacks, difficulty sleeping, weight loss, and obsessive checking of James’s Facebook activity. Her anxiety was deeply tied to her own phobia of vomiting and was triggered by any sign of inconsistency in James’s behavior.
Yes, James revealed that his father died by suicide after his mother cheated on him. This trauma led to a deep fear of betrayal and a belief that he would never cheat on Claire. However, this fear was used to justify controlling behavior and avoid accountability, such as hiding his social media activity and avoiding open conversations.
James maintained two Facebook profiles—one for dating and one for political activism—where he carefully controlled his image. He posted romantic content publicly but restricted access to his political page, using this as a justification for not sharing personal details. This duality revealed his efforts to create a controlled, idealized image to avoid scrutiny.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.