The Collar, the Chains, and the Bunker: The Girls Who Escaped Hell | The Cases of Jeannette Tamayo & Elizabeth Shoaf | UNSEEN
39m 50s
Nine-year-old Jeanette Tamayo was abducted from her home in San Jose, California, after her abductor forced her to call the family. Held in a basement, she endured violent assault but remained calm, using her instincts to gather evidence—such as a watch, toys, and underwear—and memorize details of her captor’s movements. She eventually escaped by convincing her abductor to let her go, then used a pizza box to hide clues. A neighbor’s security camera provided a timeline of the abduction, leading police to track down the suspect, David Montiel Cruz, who was arrested and charged with multiple crimes. Meanwhile, 14-year-old Elizabeth Shove was kidnapped in South Carolina and held in an underground bunker by Vincent Filia, where she was sexually assaulted. After months of isolation, she escaped by secretly texting her mother through the captor’s phone, sending a message that alerted authorities. The message triggered a search, leading to Filia’s capture. Both girls demonstrate extraordinary courage, using intelligence and resilience to survive and help bring their abusers to justice. Their stories highlight the power of personal agency, the importance of evidence, and the lasting impact of trauma and recovery in the face of violence. Today, Jeanette studies law enforcement to help others, while Elizabeth has become a voice for missing children and victims of violence, proving that even in the darkest moments, people can find strength and purpose.
On July 8, 2003, a Little Caesars cashier in San Jose, California, received the most
unusual call: a little girl with a whimpering voice, holding back her tears as she spelled
every letter of her address, one by one.
Little did they know, she had been kidnapped and her abductor was forcing her to call them.
After multiple days of captivity, this had been her only contact with the outside world.
Kidnapped, assaulted, and held in bounds, nine-year-old Jeanette Tamayo was long gone
when the police finally arrived at the scene.
"A young girl with a whimpering voice, holding back her tears as she spelled every letter
of her address, one by one.
A young girl was abducted from her home after school.
The police later got their hands on some footage from a nearby security camera,
but it was quickly deemed useless due to the low quality of the recording.
Police have no leads in the disappearance of nine-year-old Jeanette Tamayo.
After days without any development in her case, and no statewide Amber Alert issued,
Jeanette knew she had to take matters into her own hands.
My fear turned into courage, and I told myself,
My fear turned into courage, and I told myself,
"I'm a fighter. I'm gonna make it."
In the thriving city of San Jose, California, in the heart of Silicon Valley,
nine-year-old Jeanette Tamayo just got off her school bus and was heading home.
Once there, she noticed that the screen door was slightly ajar.
She thought that maybe her mother came back from work early and didn't think much of it.
Once inside, she went to her room and realized that something was wrong.
Her bedroom window had been smashed, and there was broken glass everywhere.
She immediately took a step back and ran toward the phone to call her mom.
But to her dismay, the cable had been cut off.
Before she had time to understand what was happening, she heard someone knocking at the door.
Jeanette turned around and saw a stranger behind the screen.
Scared and confused, she reluctantly opened it.
And when he was asking me questions, he was kind of peeking inside, trying to see who was in there.
And that started making me feel really uncomfortable, and I started slowly closing the sliding door.
I got scared because I felt a really bad vibe from him.
And he was like, "I don't know. I don't know. I don't know."
And he was like, "I don't know. I don't know."
And he put his hand in the way, slid it open, grabbed me, and took me to my brother's room.
He threw me on the bed and took off my pants.
Out of respect for Jeanette, we won't cover the assault, as it is extremely graphic.
After he was done, her attacker handcuffed her and tied her legs together.
He then carried her to his car parked in the garage.
There, the man tried to open the door, but couldn't lift it more than a few inches
before he saw another vehicle stopping right in front of the garage.
From the backseat, Jeanette reckoned,
and recognized her mother's car.
My brother crawled under the garage when it opened a few inches,
and the first thing I told him was to run.
But her attacker was already at it.
He got out of the car and started walking toward him.
At only 15, Paul knew he wouldn't stand a chance, but he chose to fight him anyway.
He grabbed a screwdriver from the counter and ran at him.
The man then immediately disarmed him and started punching him in the face, over and over.
Restrained by the handcuffs and the rope around her leg,
Jeanette couldn't do anything except watch in horror as the man dragged
her brother inside the house.
As soon as they entered, they came face to face with Roselia, Jeanette's mother.
She attempted to fight the man and successfully separated him from her son.
Then, Paul rushed toward the kitchen cabinet and pulled out a frying pan from it.
He tried to help his mom, but once again, the man disarmed him before he could do anything
and turned the improvised weapon against Roselia, striking her repeatedly until she fell to
the ground.
I remember hearing my mom screaming, and it went quiet.
I couldn't hear much after that.
I rushed back into the garage and into the car, and when I saw blood on his face, I was
like, "Did you kill them?"
And he just started laughing, and I just started to cry.
I was like, "I didn't know if he had killed them."
I didn't know if they were there anymore, if he had killed them, and I was just thinking
with the blood on his face that they were gone.
My family was gone.
Driving like a madman, Jeanette's kidnapper cut through some of her neighbor's bushes.
Fighting through her restraints, she managed to turn around and take one last look at her
house before they turned the corner.
She felt an overwhelming feeling of relief when she made eye contact with Roselia, running
amok behind the car.
Her face was heavily wounded and covered in blood, but at least she was alive.
Not far behind, her brother Paul was painfully limping towards some bystanders, waving his
arm in the air and screaming for help.
When an intruder approaches a home, they expect a camera.
What they don't expect.
Stop.
This is simply safe.
Police are on the way.
Using smart AI cameras, live US-based agents help deter intruders in under 30 seconds.
Just record a break-in.
Stop it from ever happening.
Plans starting around a dollar a day.
Right now, get 70% off your new system with professional monitoring at simplysafe.com/spotify.
Thirty seconds response time requires monitoring plan with outdoor protection starting at $49.99
a month.
Visit simplysafe.com/licenses for alarm license information.
As soon as the car passed the corner, Jeanette started to scream at the other drivers passing
by, slamming her shoulder against the window in an attempt to catch their attention, but
her undertaking didn't go unnoticed, as her attacker immediately grabbed the screwdriver
from earlier and violently attacked her.
After being hit twice, she moved out of his reach.
I just remember sliding down the lane there and looking up at the ceiling of the car and
just thinking to myself, I'm not going to make it, I'm going to die.
Back at the house, after the police arrived, Rosalia was refusing to get into the ambulance.
She was trying to explain everything that happened to the detective and the other officers,
but her condition kept getting worse by the minute.
And her panicked state didn't do much to help.
So after they secured Paul, they had to force her onto a stretcher against her will.
They were both sent to the nearest hospital.
To a mother?
I don't care what happened to you, you thinking and your kids, but I don't can do anything.
I don't can do anything.
I don't protect my kids.
With their only witnesses gone, the police had barely any information to work with.
From the get-go, they knew that Jeanette had been kidnapped.
And they knew that someone broke into the house, cut the phone cords, and attacked them
before leaving with her.
But other than that, all they had was the crime scene.
One of the first things that I did notice in the garage was a lot of blood.
I knew at that point this was a very violent crime.
You start thinking, are we going to bring her home alive?
Heather Randall, the detective assigned to the case, initially thought that maybe some
of the blood around the kitchen and the garage belonged to Jeanette.
As her forensic team were grabbing samples and examining the scene, she also found that
Jeanette had been kidnapped.
She also called in handlers and bloodhounds to get the search started as soon as possible.
But sadly, this didn't lead them very far, since neither Jeanette nor her attacker were
injured during the initial attack.
As this was happening, she also noticed a security camera in the driveway of one of
the neighbors.
By reviewing the footage it captured in the last hour, they were able to establish a rough
timeline of the events.
Thirty minutes before Jeanette arrived, her attacker smashed her bedroom window and burglarized
the house.
He then went back to his car and waited for Jeanette to arrive.
Afterward, he followed her and knocked at the door.
He then assaulted her in the bedroom for almost thirty minutes, at which point they headed
to the garage.
Meanwhile, Paul and Rosalia made it to the house.
In the last bit of the recording, we can clearly hear Rosalia and Paul screaming for help.
But Randall was mainly interested in one particular moment, here, when the attacker's car was
right in front of the camera.
In California, it is mandatory to have either a name, a license plate number, or a phone
number tied to the perpetrator to issue a statewide Amber Alert.
"It's heartbreaking, you have the evidence right there, it's so close, and yet you need
just a little bit clearer video."
So before she was able to fall back on Paul and Rosalia, she alerted the media hoping
that, even without an Amber Alert, maybe the population would mobilize themselves anyway
and spread the word about her disappearance.
Together with her department, they got service helicopters in the air with them.
"We had to make sure that we had enough loudspeakers calling out her name and gave
press conference after press conference just to make sure Jeanette's name was on everyone's
mind in San Jose."
"It puts a thousand more sets of eyes out on the street, and we knew it was extremely
important to push the information out to the public, give them a picture of Jeanette, make
sure that flyers were flooded throughout the city."
Along the way, Jeanette kept mental notes of every turn they made, hoping she would
be able to find her way home if she ever escaped.
After a short ride, the car suddenly stopped.
The man drove into the garage of a large white house.
He opened the door, picked her up, and carried her inside.
There, he went up the stairs to the second floor and opened a locked door.
Behind it was a very small room with a TV, a little window, a bed, and a bathroom.
He threw her on the ground and approached her with a menacing look.
After each assault, he would clench her wrists to the showerhead using a pair of handcuffs,
run the water, and leave her there for a while.
"I didn't cry.
That was my only safe place was the shower because every time he left me in the shower,
it was when he didn't touch me, he wouldn't hurt me, or he wouldn't rape me."
The next morning, the aftermath of the kidnapping took its toll.
While the rest of the Tamayo family gathered around Rosalia in San Jose, the police asked
some of the family members to take part in the public address.
"In the morning, he was watching the news again.
My cousin was talking to me through the news.
I said, 'Jannette, if you can hear us, just know that.
Be strong, girl.
We're looking for you.'
She was like, 'Just don't give up.'
gave me hope, that gave me the strength. Either I'm going to fight to get out of here or die trying.
During her second day of captivity, Jeanette started to plan out what would be her best
course of action against her abductor. Because my life was at risk, I said to myself,
"I have to have a conversation with him so he gains my trust."
So she tried to ask him the most casual question she could think of.
I remember asking him, "Where are you from?"
Her attacker turned around with a dubious look on his face. He stood up,
looked at her straight in the eyes, and for the first time since he kidnapped her, smiled.
An intense feeling of disgust filled her chest. At that moment, she wished she could have spit
at his face, stab him in the back with his screwdriver, or any other acts of retaliation
one could think of. But instead, she listened to her instinct. She smiled back, trying to look
as innocent as possible. She then asked him if she could get a glass of water. He handcuffed her and
for the first time, left her alone in the room while he went down the stairs to go and get it.
Now by herself, she started to nervously tinker with the handcuffs since she had
noticed that the lock didn't require any key. It was mechanical.
I remember feeling with my fingers a little button and like a latch.
I realized that if I moved the latch one way and pressed that button, the handcuffs would release.
Now freed, she knew she only had a minute to think of something useful.
Something that could either save her, or maybe help the police find the culprit if she ended up
getting murdered. My brother and I would always watch CSI Law and Order, and the detectives on
the shows would always look for clues. Swiftly, she grabbed the watch the
man left on the nightstand. Then, she rushed to the other side of the room, where the man
had placed a few toys for her to play with. She grabbed a little clay turtle out of them,
and finally, she ran by the bathroom and grabbed her underwear. She remembered that the CSI cast often
used the victim's underwear in sexual assault cases, and she wanted him to be punished for what
he did to her. But soon enough, her investigation was cut short as she began to hear the heavy
footsteps of her kidnapper walking up the stairs. I jumped back on the bed, put the handcuffs on,
and once he walked through the door, he just looked at me. And in my mind, I was hoping,
"Please don't touch me," because I had things on me that I was afraid that he might find.
On the third day, Jeanette's family was devastated,
by the lack of progress the case had made. Despite the incredible amount of effort pulled by Randall,
the police still had nothing on hand that could lead to her location.
When the police tried to tell Roselia that past the 48 hours mark,
most kidnapped children are never found, she refused to listen.
And she was very, very, very sad because she was scared.
My daughter, she's a little kid. She has only 10 years. I asked the police what
happened with my daughter. When my daughter came by, she said, "Maybe never." And screaming. And
screaming a lot. My daughter, I don't see for three days. I don't feel comfortable because I
don't protect her. I don't protect her. I don't feel good.
It is at this point that Jeanette became completely numbed to her kidnapper's assault.
Her only impulse was to stay strong and stick to her strategy.
She needed to continue to manipulate him. This was her only chance at survival.
My befriending was working. He asked me, "Are you hungry?" And I looked at him and I said, "Yeah."
He gave me his cell phone. He had a cell phone with him. And he made me call for pizza. He gave
me the phone number of the cell phone that he had. And I gave it to the man. The man on the
other side of the phone said, "Can I get your address?" He told me the address.
And just like she did with the movement of the car two days ago, she memorized all of it. If she ever
got away, she wanted to be sure she would be able to take him down afterward. Eventually,
someone rang the doorbell, and her kidnapper left the room for a minute. When he came back,
he had a smile on his face. He put the pizza on the floor, and on top of the box, there was a
missing person flyer with her face on it. He then told her that he would get rid of her tonight,
before leaving the room. Once he closed the door behind him, she threw away the pizza and started
to grab all the evidence she could. She then stuffed all of it inside the pizza box and hid it
under the bed. When he came back,
he grabbed a pillow and started smothering her with it. Gasping for air, she tried to push her
face against the side, but the man was too strong. As the lack of oxygen started to take its toll,
she felt an immense rush of adrenaline running through her body, and in one final push,
successfully slid her face to the side, enough so that she was able to take one last breath.
As soon as five seconds later after I got some air, he pulled the pillow off and he asked me,
"Do you want to take a shower?" When she came out of the shower, she quickly dressed up and made
sure the pieces of evidence she gathered earlier were still in her pockets. She then heard someone
knocking loudly at the door downstairs. She wanted to scream, but her kidnapper immediately jumped on
her and put his hands over her mouth. Afraid that he would try to kill her again, she calmed down
and waited for the person at the door to leave. He was sitting in the room for a while and
afterwards when he heard that it was all quiet, that's when he took me downstairs into the garage.
It was all dark. He then forced her into his car, put her back in handcuffs, and started driving.
The ride was long, and Jeanette couldn't stop crying and screaming. Midway through it,
she took a second to calm herself down in an attempt to make some sense of what had happened
to her so far. But even then, she hadn't fully given up yet. Along the way, she once again did
her best to remember every turn they took, but they rode for over 30 minutes, making it far more
difficult than the first time. After a while, the car approached the neon-lit parking lot of a liquor
store not far from the highway. The car had stopped, and as soon as he stopped the car,
he grabbed me by my hair. When I looked around, I was like, "Where are we?" And he was like,
"I'm letting you go." And when he grabbed me by the back of my head, by my hair,
he pulled me towards him. He was like, "If you ever tell anybody what I did, or who I am, or
anything about me, I will come back for you, and I will kill your family, and I will kill you too."
As her kid
napper left, she ran toward the liquor store. She couldn't believe she succeeded. She somehow
gained his trust. These thoughts and emotions flooded her mind, and before she knew it,
she was face-to-face with the cashier. I was just all kinds of emotions in one,
and I remember the gentleman that was behind the counter looking at me and asking me,
"Are you okay?" And then he said, "You're the little girl from TV."
The man behind the counter didn't hesitate. He handed her the phone,
and when he realized she was distraught,
picked it back up, and called 911 himself.
She said, "Let me use the phone." I said, "Okay, here's the phone."
When she started dialing the phone, she was panicking, scared. She didn't know how to dial
the number. Once the San Jose police got word that Jeanette had been located in East Palo Alto,
they immediately reached her. Detective Randall was overjoyed to finally see the little girl with
her own eyes. But in the back of her mind, she knew they needed to act quickly if they ever
wanted to get their hands on the culprit. I walked up to her, and I said, "Hello, Jeanette. My name's
Heather, and I'm here to help you." And before I really said anything else,
she let me know that she had some evidence in her pocket.
She proceeded to pull the toys, her underwear, the kidnapper's watch, and other items out of
her pockets. Shocked to see how clever the little girl was, Randall asked her if she had anything
else that could help them catch him. Jeanette asked for a sheet of paper and drew the house,
bits of the address, his exact phone number, and every other piece of information she could
remember from her time with the kidnapper. She said, "I'm here to help you, and I'm here to
help you." Noticing how knowledgeable she was, Randall asked her a decisive question.
While the police were heading back to San Jose to look for the man's house, another officer started
to call every pizza place in the area to see if they could match the phone number to a complete
address. But before they knew it, they were already closing in on the place,
as Jeanette shuddered with excitement in the back of the house.
"I felt brave. I think that's why I stood up in the back of the car and started
yelling and saying, 'That's it.'"
A few minutes later, Randall received a confirmation from the pizza place that this was,
in fact, the right address, so she ordered a tactical team and a K-9 squad to raid the home.
"Prize Pigs Packs are here. Rip digital packs and get real basketball,
football, and Pokemon cards. Sell cards instantly for cash or ship them home.
Prize Pigs Packs gives everyone the opportunity to pull the one-of-one Cooper flag rookie card."
"We have a prize-picking card worth $8 million and a Pikachu illustrator card worth $2.8 million
and packs as low as just $1. Download Prize Picks and use code 'Spotify' to get $25
instantly in bonus packs when you buy your first $5 pack. Prize Picks. Run your game."
"18+ eligible areas. Terms apply. Collect responsibly."
"Our SWAT team then put a plan in place to go and take him into custody. They had a layout of the
home from Jeanette and they went in and were able to determine that he was hiding up in the attic."
"The suspect, David Montiel Cruz, attempted to evade arrest and threatened the officers
inside the house, so they unleashed the dogs at him. He suffered multiple injuries on his arms
and was escorted outside of the house. Inside, Heather also found the evidence-filled pizza box
under the bed." "Police say they know little about the background of the suspect.
He was arrested at this house early yesterday morning. The district attorney's office filed
nine felony charges against Alvarez, including sexual assault, burglary, forcible lewd acts,
rape, battery and a special circumstance.
After the arrest,
Rosalia was called, but emergency services needed to get Jeanette into the ER as soon as possible.
After all, she'd been stabbed, and the wounds had yet to be treated.
So Rosalia and Paul followed them, and finally got reunited with her once she was stabilized.
I remember them taking me to the hospital, running tests on me.
I remember opening the door and seeing my mom.
And her face was so bad.
Like, she didn't even look like my mom.
I think she touched my mom's face. She said, you're hurt.
You know, she was so brave. She didn't care about herself.
She was worried about us.
You're everything to me. You empower.
Yeah.
Very happy because I remember that.
For example, it's when she was born, second time for me.
The following years have not passed easily for Jeanette.
For a time, she dealt with her personal pain on her own.
She would never leave the house, stuck in the clutches of a paralyzing fear of men
and the outside world.
But when she was 15 years old, after six years of therapy, something clicked.
She finally decided to face her fear and do something about it.
Twelve years later, TV producers reunited her with Heather Randall, the detective who,
with a little help from one clever nine-year-old, put an end to the rampage of David Montiel-Cruz
and put him behind bars for life.
It's so good to see you.
I never really got the chance to come back and, like, tell you guys thank you
for everything that you did. Like, I really appreciate it.
You were strong. You're smart.
What happened was you were amazing.
You were brave.
And that's why you're here today.
Even if her trauma hindered her childhood, she didn't let it take over her life as an adult.
Today, she decided to follow in Heather's footsteps and study law enforcement.
Her goal is to one day be a detective and help her community
in the same way Heather helped.
And on top of that, she also wants to become a voice for the missing and every victim of violence.
Everybody has a story.
And no matter what life throws at us, no matter what obstacles, we're all fighters.
And we all have the ability to keep going.
I turned my fear into courage.
I got my family back.
And I was able to do what I've always wanted to do.
And that's how I got to where I am today.
And I was able to make a difference.
This man is accused of holding a 14-year-old girl captive.
And this interview filmed just hours before his trial.
You're about to see him try to convince the host that the girl is an accomplice.
I mean, it was like she was on TV every time.
It was exciting.
It was like a vacation for her.
I mean, we were having a good time.
I mean, no more school for her, you know, just hanging out.
The first question he asked her was whether or not she was a virgin.
There are certain images, Your Honor, she told me she will never forget.
She could have went home any time she wanted to.
He took this chain, put it around her neck, wrapped it around her neck.
Are you saying that she was a willing participant the whole time?
Yeah.
14-year-old Elizabeth Shove, kidnapped, assaulted, trapped for 10 days.
But she escaped, outsmarting the man who took her.
When she got out, she made sure Vincent Villiol would never terrorize anyone else ever again.
We didn't save her. She saved herself.
In the small town of Lugov, South Carolina,
14-year-old Elizabeth Schoaf lives with her family.
She's excited about starting high school, and a boy she began dating.
It's September 6, 2006, 4.30 p.m.
Madeline Schoaf is at work, worried because her daughter Elizabeth didn't call her after school.
Donnie answered the phone, and I was like, where's your sister at?
And he said, she's not home yet.
And I was like, well, she should have been home by now.
Madeline leaves work right away and rushes home.
She calls her daughter's friends to see if they know anything.
Her husband, Don, gets home, too, and they search around the house for clues as to where Elizabeth might have gone.
All her favorite clothes were there, her music, everything.
Nothing missing out of the house.
Yeah, nothing was missing.
Night is falling.
Madeline calls friends and family to come help search for Elizabeth, knocking on every door, fanning out across the neighborhood.
But still, no trace of Elizabeth is found.
I knew it's something that happened to her.
So at that point, I called 911.
It's 7.30.
The police show up at the house.
They begin their investigation.
You know, any time a young person is missing, a lot of times they just run away.
You know, they just get mad about something.
We both know that she's not going to run away.
That's uncharacteristic of her. She was not that type of child.
The police don't take any chances.
They interrogate kids who were on the bus home from school.
Everyone recalls seeing her get off, even walking with her up the road.
She was really happy because her aunt was coming down.
We walk about halfway up the road, and a friend of mine's brother comes with his car and picks us up.
She didn't want to ride.
At that point, nobody knows anything.
She's like, she just disappeared.
September 7th, a full-scale search is launched.
Tracking dogs, air support, ATVs.
Local TV stations pick up the story, broadcasting Elizabeth's picture.
Elizabeth Shove walked off her school bus and vanished into thin air.
She went to Lugov Elgin High School Wednesday wearing the clothes you see here.
Volunteers start pouring in to help with ground search and handing out flyers.
Days pass, and no new leads have been found.
You just get that policeman's feeling, that gut feeling,
that, you know, this, gosh, this really looks like it's going to turn out bad.
September 13th, it's been seven days since Elizabeth disappeared. The search is dying
out, less and less people show up to help out, fewer helicopters in the sky. A friend
of the family is holding a vigil for Elizabeth, and Madeline is getting ready to go there.
As she checks her phone for any new messages, she sees a text message from an unknown number.
The message will change the course of the entire investigation.
Hey mom, it's Lizzy. I'm gonna hold in the ground near Charm Hill. It's near that dirt road where
those big trucks go. Get the police. They'll be careful. He has bombs hidden. This message gives
hope to the mother, but she still doesn't know what happened to Elizabeth or what she had to
go through to send that message. September 6th, the day of the abduction, Elizabeth is walking
home from the bus stop with her friends.
While she's walking down the driveway, she hears rustling leaves close by. A man walks
up to her, wearing camouflage pants, a green shirt, and a hand-drawn badge that looked
like the Herkshaw County Sheriff's. He says he's a policeman, that they found marijuana
on the property, that her little brother is already in custody, and that she needs to
come with him.
Almost immediately when he mentioned my brother, I was concerned if my brother was okay. So
I agreed to approach him. I had a gut feeling that I had made a bad decision.
He puts handcuffs on her wrists and a collar around her neck with a box hanging from it.
He says it's a bomb and that if she tries anything, it will detonate.
Then he takes her far into the woods, away from her house.
He was asking me just like the oddest questions if I had a phone and if I was a virgin.
When I would continue to ask him where the police were or where my brother was, he had
said that I was a smart girl and I probably should have already figured it out.
I'm just crying, you know, asking, you know, don't kill me, don't hurt me.
I remember being terrified.
Finally, they stop in the middle of the woods.
Elizabeth fears the worst.
I thought that was where he was going to f*** me and kill me.
The man reaches down and pulls up a hatch door from the ground, hidden among the leaves.
He had told me to go down the ladder and get into the bunker.
He had, like, a rifle and a belt that had guns and handcuffs,
and I saw a taser in it.
So I knew he wasn't well-equipped to do anything
if I acted stupid or whatever.
He pretty much just raped me.
Right away?
Pretty much.
I had looked off to the side to one of the shelves that were there.
There was like a propane tank and dishes and stuff on it.
Stared at it and cried.
Elizabeth is shattered, alone on the bed.
Her attacker binds her, making sure she can't escape.
September 7th, Elizabeth learns the man's name is Vincent Filia.
He makes her watch TV while he feeds her.
The local news channel shows Elizabeth's mother pleading for help.
I just want my baby home.
If anybody sees her, please.
This reminds her of the conversation she had
with her mother that morning.
She regrets her last words to her.
Because when I left that morning, I was mad.
I was rude with her.
And then now that you're missing me,
I wish you could say sorry.
You love her and all that, but. I couldn't.
Every day, my story was on television,
watching my mom, my sister, and my aunts beg for me.
I just knew I couldn't give up.
September 9, Elizabeth and her captor
can hear helicopters flying overhead, and soon, footsteps.
This gives her hope, but Vincent panics.
He threatens her that if she screams or tries anything,
he will shoot her.
I could actually see their shadows walking
across the door above me.
And I'm just sitting there right above me.
The footsteps disappear, and soon, it dawns on her.
The only way she'll ever get out alive is by saving herself.
He would go to sleep, and I would just sit there and ponder
as to what I could possibly do to get out of the situation.
As she's sleeping one night, she musters the courage
to use Vincent's gun.
She grabs the holster and puts it down.
As she attempts to remove it, Vincent
can't move the Velcro.
Every noise she makes threatens to wake Vincent up.
But she continues slowly until, finally, the gun is free.
This is her chance.
I placed it up to his head and pulled the trigger.
And it had gotten jammed.
She puts the gun back and lays down in bed, crying.
The next morning, Elizabeth tries something different.
She pretends that she's beginning to like him.
He would start to call me nicknames like baby.
I would call him that back.
He would tell me he loved me.
I'd tell him I loved him.
Vincent is beginning to trust her.
He even agrees to unbind her.
It's September 13th, one week since the abduction.
Vince takes Elizabeth out for a walk,
where he shows her a few booby traps he's made for intruders.
He also takes out his phone, which he
uses to text his girlfriend.
Elizabeth listens to his nonsense while he talks.
But all she can think about is that phone.
It's nighttime.
Vincent falls asleep, and Elizabeth quietly gets out of bed.
She opens Vincent's phone and begins writing a text to her mother.
For each letter, she has to press multiple times.
She hopes Vincent won't wake up before she can send the text.
After pressing send…
Prize Picks Packs are here.
Prize Picks Packs gives everyone the opportunity to pull the one of one Cooper flagged rookie
card worth $8 million and a Pikachu Illustrator card worth $2.8 million in packs as low as just
$1.
Download Prize Picks and use code SPOTIFY to get $25 instantly in bonus packs when you
buy your first $5 pack.
Prize Picks.
Run your game.
18+ eligible areas.
Terms apply.
Collect responsibly.
The message says it failed.
And I would go up to the door, and I would try to get a signal right at the door.
I pressed send.
I was terrified that he might wake up.
He wouldn't see me.
If he did, I knew he would have killed me.
And I would continually press send, and it just failed.
Elizabeth tries again and again, even the following night, but her messages never go
through.
It's September 15th.
For the first time in days, they can hear helicopters in the air.
Vincent panics, wondering why the search has regained momentum.
And so he turns on the news.
They finally put out that my mom had got a text message.
I felt my heart drop.
He asked me if it was me.
I began crying.
I told him I loved him.
I wouldn't do that to him.
You could tell he was trying to gather his thoughts.
Figure out what he needed to do next to save himself.
And then, Vincent actually asks her what she thinks he should do.
He was just asking me, like, if he should pack stuff up and go ahead and start leaving.
Or if he should stay and wait it off.
And I just told him, like, he's not going to do it.
And then Vincent actually asks her what she thinks he should do.
He was just asking me, like, if he should pack stuff up and go ahead and start leaving or if he should stay and wait it off.
And I just told him that he needed to pack his stuff and leave while he could because if so, the police were going to get him.
And I didn't want him in jail.
And I acted like I wanted him to be safe.
His last steps out the ladder and out the door, I remember telling him I loved him.
and shut it and tied it up right there behind him.
Elizabeth is finally alone.
She's not sure if it's really happening.
She doesn't risk leaving right away
because he might be waiting outside.
Instead, she waits until morning.
September 16, Elizabeth wakes up to find she's still alone.
She doesn't waste another second and goes up the ladder.
Once outside, the thought of stepping onto one of his bombs
stops her from running off.
- I just looked around like it was the first time
I saw the outside in daytime.
So it was just beautiful to see the trees
and feel the fresh air again.
But I couldn't hear anybody around me.
So I decided to yell.
Somebody finally yelled my name back.
I instantly just fell to the ground
and started crying.
The captain ended up giving me a hug.
I was in tears.
I didn't know what to do.
But he told me I was OK and, you know, I was safe now.
I didn't have to worry about anything.
One of our guys actually carried her up the hill
to the command post where he had the ambulance standing by.
When she got just about almost there, she's like--
she said, I'm all right.
And she gets down, and she's walking.
And she's basically saying, "I'm walking out of here."
- About 7:30, I'd seen the white truck come up the road.
I was like, "Oh my God."
Captain Tom was very excited.
He was just so ecstatic.
You could tell he was crying towards the hand builder.
And you know, I was just like, "Oh my God."
I was just so happy, you know?
Just like, I mean, I just could not quit crying.
The best feeling ever to hug my parents again, to just feel my mom holding me.
Just to know that I was with her again and she didn't have to worry about me.
In South Carolina, a 14-year-old girl was back home this evening after a horrific ordeal.
Authorities say she was kidnapped by a man who sexually assaulted her and locked her inside an underground bunker.
Elizabeth is safe, but Vincent Filia is still on the run.
A few hours later, police get a tip from a woman saying she encountered Vincent as he tried to steal her car.
He had a long knife hanging off his belt.
Pretty much all I saw was his face. I recognized him from the internet.
I was kind of cursing him out for doing this in front of my child, for putting my child through this.
He's already hurt one little girl.
He knew he wasn't getting my keys, and he said, okay, never mind, and he started running down the sidewalk.
Police act quickly and locate him a few hours later.
I think it took Vincent about a minute to deny everything, and that this was all made up, that the truth would come out in the end.
Vincent agreed to an interview with Dateline's Keith Morrison hours before his trial.
Elizabeth has barely time to recover from the traumatic 10 days she spent in the bunker
with Vincent Filia that she already has to face him in court. But like she said,
I wanted to go. It was weird to look at Vincent because I kind of felt happy just because I knew
that he was locked up and I'm sitting there in the courtroom while he's in jail. All she asked,
your honor, is sentence him so that this can never happen to anyone else. I can think of no
crimes short of murder more repulsive than these 17 different indictments and charges that have
been brought against you all sentences to run consecutive good luck to you sir vincent filial
was sentenced to 421 years in prison without the possibility of parole i remember elizabeth saying
I beat him. I'm like yes you did. You did beat him. I think of it because I don't
want to forget it because that's something I accomplished that a lot of
people might not have. It makes me feel good to know that I got to get through
something like that. How do you go through hell like that for ten days and
just come out on the other side as strong as she did? There's no playbook to
tell her what she should have done down there. There may be one now because she
made all right moves. I don't think you could ever really move past something like that happening to
you. It's always going to be there, but as the years go on, things do get easier. Today, she's
a loving mother, grateful for a new, beautiful life. Really just trying to live life to the
fullest. Now that I have a child, I'm of course wanting to give him his best life possible as
Elizabeth understands that the healing journey will take time,
but she also sees the extent of her own strength.
Elizabeth Shoff looked terror in the face and saved herself.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Nine-year-old Jeanette Tamayo was kidnapped and held captive after being forced into a home by her abductor, who assaulted her and tied her up.
During her captivity, Jeanette strategically manipulated her abductor, gathering evidence like a watch, toys, and underwear to use against him.
She memorized every detail of the abductor’s movements and the vehicle’s route, which later helped police locate him.
A neighbor’s security camera provided crucial footage showing the abduction timeline, including the attacker’s arrival and escape.
Jeanette bravely escaped by outsmarting her captor, using a pizza box to hide evidence and eventually contacting authorities after being rescued.
The suspect, David Montiel Cruz, was arrested and charged with multiple felonies, including sexual assault and burglary.
Elizabeth Shove, a 14-year-old from South Carolina, was kidnapped, sexually assaulted, and held in an underground bunker; she escaped by using her captor’s phone to send a message to her mother.
Both girls exemplify courage and resilience, using intelligence and willpower to survive and help bring their abductors to justice.
Summary:
Nine-year-old Jeanette Tamayo was abducted from her home in San Jose, California, after her abductor forced her to call the family. Held in a basement, she endured violent assault but remained calm, using her instincts to gather evidence—such as a watch, toys, and underwear—and memorize details of her captor’s movements. She eventually escaped by convincing her abductor to let her go, then used a pizza box to hide clues.
A neighbor’s security camera provided a timeline of the abduction, leading police to track down the suspect, David Montiel Cruz, who was arrested and charged with multiple crimes. Meanwhile, 14-year-old Elizabeth Shove was kidnapped in South Carolina and held in an underground bunker by Vincent Filia, where she was sexually assaulted. After months of isolation, she escaped by secretly texting her mother through the captor’s phone, sending a message that alerted authorities.
The message triggered a search, leading to Filia’s capture. Both girls demonstrate extraordinary courage, using intelligence and resilience to survive and help bring their abusers to justice. Their stories highlight the power of personal agency, the importance of evidence, and the lasting impact of trauma and recovery in the face of violence.
Today, Jeanette studies law enforcement to help others, while Elizabeth has become a voice for missing children and victims of violence, proving that even in the darkest moments, people can find strength and purpose.
FAQs
Jeanette was kidnapped from her home, abducted by a stranger, and held in a room with broken glass and a shower. She was assaulted, handcuffed, and tied up. During her captivity, she gathered evidence and used her intelligence to survive and eventually help police locate her abductor.
Jeanette used her wit and observation to survive. She noticed the mechanical nature of her handcuffs, collected items like her underwear, a watch, and toys, and used them as evidence. She also gained her kidnapper's trust by pretending to be harmless, allowing her to escape and later give police crucial information.
Jeanette's evidence, including a pizza box with items and a detailed drawing of the house, helped police identify the suspect's location. They matched the phone number from a pizza order to an address, leading to a raid on the home where the kidnapper, David Montiel Cruz, was arrested.
Since no Amber Alert was issued due to insufficient video footage, police actively spread the word through press conferences, loudspeakers, and flyers. This helped mobilize the public and increased the chances of finding Jeanette, eventually leading to her rescue.
No, Jeanette did not escape directly. She remained in captivity for several days and used her intelligence to gather evidence and manipulate her kidnapper. She eventually escaped when he left the house to meet her, and she ran to a liquor store where she was found by a cashier.
Jeanette's abductor, David Montiel Cruz, was arrested, charged with multiple felonies including sexual assault and burglary, and sentenced to prison. Jeanette recovered and later became a law enforcement student, aiming to help victims of violence.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.