The ‘Chernobyl’ Pod. Plus, ‘Succession’ Season 4 Trailer and Oscar Nom Reactions!
from The Watch
1h 34m 27s
This podcast episode features hosts Chris Ryan and Andy Greenwald as they finally discuss the 2019 HBO miniseries "Chernobyl." They begin with a brief news segment covering the trailer for "Succession" season four, the upcoming international all-star season of "Top Chef," and the new Peacock series "Poker Face." The conversation then shifts to a lengthy analysis of the 2023 Oscar nominations. The hosts debate the purpose of the Oscars, discussing whether they should celebrate artistic achievement or popular films. They express their thoughts on several Best Picture nominees, including "Top Gun: Maverick," "The Fabelmans," and "Tár," and discuss the implications of the nominations for the film industry. The main segment of the episode is dedicated to "Chernobyl." The hosts acknowledge they missed the show upon its initial release and explore why. They praise the series for its masterful execution, its ability to create a deeply realized and terrifying reality, and its focus on human behavior during a catastrophe. They also discuss the show's blend of historical fact and artistic license, noting that its power lies in its storytelling rather than its literal accuracy.
Yo, this is Rob Harvilla from 60 Solls that explain the 90s, the world's greatest loopy and perverse and inaccurately named Music Nostalgia Podcast.
We're doing 90 Solls now because there's too many songs, Pearl Jam, Jay Z, Jewel, U2, Cher, Hoodie.
These are just some of the names people yell at me on the internet because we're back.
More great songs, more rad special guests, more loopy perversity.
Join us once more on 60 Solls that explain the 90s every Wednesday on Spotify.
I'm Pro Football Hall of Famer Brian Dawkins and I live for a long time with something I did not know the name of.
Major Depressive Disorder.
I carried sadness and anger because I thought I could handle it alone, but I couldn't.
Now I want to make sure others know that that support is out there.
If you're experiencing similar symptoms, talk to a healthcare professional, visit mddallies.com to watch my story.
Paid partnership with Johnson & Johnson, Brian Dawkins is not prescribed caplite a luma teperon.
I needed more from my antidepressant, so my doctor added caplite a luma teperon, proven to provide greater relief from depression symptoms than an antidepressant alone.
Building on my progress without starting over.
Caplite is for adults with major depressive disorder when used with an antidepressant and is available by prescription only.
Individual results may vary.
In clinical trials, late game was not common.
Elderly dementia patients have increased risk of death or stroke.
Caplite is not approved for dementia-related psychosis.
Call your doctor about newer sudden mood changes, behaviors, or suicidal thoughts right away.
Antidepressants may increase these risks.
Report fever, confusion, stiff muscles, which may be life-threatening, or uncontrolled muscle movements, which may be permanent.
High cholesterol and weight gain may occur, as can high blood sugar, which may be fatal.
Monitoring is recommended.
Common side effects are sleepiness, dizziness, nausea, dry mouth, feeling tired, and diarrhea.
These aren't all the side effects.
Ask your doctor about caplite.
Learn more at caplite.com or call 888-2524824.
Observe the North American dad.
50s. Great polo collection.
He enters his vehicle information on Carvana and offers appears in minutes.
Remarkable.
He squints, reads it again, smiles and says, "Dang, that's a good offer."
The highest form of approval.
No haggling.
No hassle.
No one called him boss.
He's still on the couch, astonishing.
Sell your car today on Carvana.com. Pick up these may apply.
I need support staff to clear the room.
Stand up and walk. Now!
Hello and welcome to the watch.
My name is Chris Ryan. I am an editor at TheRinger.com.
And joining me in the studio, touching a button that says, "AZ5?"
It's a degree world!
Comrades.
Foot on the Eiger counter!
Wait, Eiger got the Chernobyl music?
Yeah.
Oh, that was the same thing?
Yeah.
So the, wait, so the chairman of Disney.
Yeah. So the joke is it's supposed to be the Geiger counter.
Yes.
But I call it the Eiger counter.
But Geiger counters are for earthquakes.
You know what I mean.
They're not just decimators.
Well, now I know. I've watched Chernobyl.
I did.
Like, obviously, I had no idea.
Andy, it's great to see you.
We're in the studio again.
Kaya is recording us from parts unknown in California today.
Well, the thing is we're recording from reactor four.
Yeah.
And she's safely in Moscow.
So as you may have guessed, as we've teased,
Andy and I are going to be talking extensively
about a three and a half year old piece of television today.
The Chernobyl mini-series from the Homebox Office network
that we both, we missed out on the first time around
and then we turned into a bit of having not watched it.
Then we turned into a bit of all the broadcasting
we had done about it that nobody had ever heard.
Now we actually watched it.
Now we're actually going to talk about it since Craig Mason
who did Chernobyl is also doing the last of us.
People love this.
People love this bit.
I just feel like this is a really good way
to celebrate our 11th year of broadcasting.
I think so.
I think just digging in the crates.
But I think it's a really. I've learned a lot from doing this.
And I can't wait to talk about this show with you.
You've learned a lot by watching the show?
Yeah.
I've learned a lot from like going back
and like interrogating both my prejudices
and also like thinking about like my failures.
Yeah.
So it's going to be. I think failure is a key theme of Chernobyl.
I think that what we're doing is the figurative equivalent
of 400 nude miners descending beneath radioactive soil
to dig in a necessary hole.
That's right.
Bill's going to give us 400 rubles when we're done.
Really?
And take care of our families.
But first we wanted to talk about a couple of news and notes
things.
So succession season four trailer dropped today.
It was also announced that succession is returning
on March 26th with Mage Makes.
And amazingly packed March.
I don't know if you're ready for this.
I'm not.
But tell me why.
The last of us will be coming to a conclusion.
Top Chef.
Oh.
We'll be coming back.
I have some thoughts about that.
Top Chef, which is London, Paris?
Entirely or all of Europe?
I guess it's a little unclear.
It's called Top Chef International.
Okay.
They based in London.
They based the season.
They based themselves in London.
I swear to God if this the finale is in a Mexican resort,
I'm going to lose my fucking mind.
I assume it'll be elsewhere in Europe.
And what they announced, we knew this.
When Gail came on the podcast, she told us this.
And then maybe we had to cut that part out
because she broke the embargo.
I don't remember.
But the international part had been announced.
Well, and then everybody had been Instagramming from London.
Yeah.
But what I hadn't understood, although we could have predicted it,
predicted it.
And I'm thrilled about it.
That it is essentially an all-star season
where they have cold contestants
from all of the international versions of Top Chef.
Oh, I didn't know that.
Yes.
So like wonderful Top Chef US contestants and winners,
like Buddha went straight from winning Top Chef
to being back on Top Chef.
He is on the season competing again.
No shit.
Yes.
Dawn is competing this season, right?
Yeah.
Sarah from Kentucky competing this season.
But then the winners are runners-ups or finalists
from Top Chef North Africa,
from Top Chef Spain, Canada, France,
like all the different iterations.
They're all competing.
You are so high.
I am completely derailed from talking about success.
High success.
Do you think that they are going to accurately reflect
British food culture?
I'll tell you what I think they're going to accurately reflect.
And you could see this in these,
even in the promotional stills and the eyes of the hosts.
That member, like they went to Texas,
where no one in Texas was doing COVID anymore.
Yeah.
And they were all wearing mass and whole foods.
Their eyes are like wearing England.
And if there's one thing you and I learned in the last year,
is that England makes--
Against the mother issues.
Yeah.
England makes Texas look like Berkeley.
Yeah.
In terms of like their adherence to COVID mandate.
So they are psyched.
Yeah.
So Top Chef's coming back.
I think March 9th.
Amanda Lurian comes back in March.
Yellow Jackets comes back in March.
And now succession.
At the end of March, March 26th.
A two-minute trailer.
I would say about as illuminating as a next week on Mad Men.
Add back in the day when Mad Men used to be like,
next to them on Mad Men.
Well, wait.
That's my hat.
Next time on Mad Men.
Wait.
I'm going to push back on that.
I don't agree.
I don't agree.
Do you mean in terms of like what it told you about the plot?
Yeah.
I'm just saying like at this point, succession prints its own money.
Yeah.
So I need a little bit.
I just need it as Pete Posselway said in the town.
The lead train.
I gave her a little taste.
You know.
And that's all I need.
Bill's giving you 450 rubles now.
That's incredible.
I just need a little taste.
And I got it.
There's an Israel Palestine joke.
Just right on the edge.
Right on the edge.
And the end of this trailer.
There's a couple of good Kendall moments.
But I don't need to know who's merging with who.
Yeah.
I mean, let's remember the genius of succession.
And this trailer is genius.
And this trailer is like it just we're back.
Just full, full flavor.
Full fat yogurt, let's say.
The brilliance of succession is that I don't really care who's merging with who.
Or even ultimately who's succeeding who.
It's just let's get back and let's get lost in the sauce.
Let's get this gang back together and have all sorts of non-sense shenanigans on boats and boardrooms.
And now the deck shuffled.
So I feel like it did tell us that, right?
Sure.
Yeah.
It's exceptional.
It's back on March 26th.
But that the Roy kids are going to try to do their own thing.
But they still can't do it without dad.
But succession has become a little bit famous for like the faint.
Like you get to the end of certain episodes.
And you're like, oh my god.
Like Shiv and Kendall.
Like had this like incredible moment of like like interpersonal understanding with one another.
It's going to change their relationship.
And like two episodes later they're like, fuck you, no fuck you.
I think what's weird, not weird.
But I think what's going to be surprising about the season, if I can make a prediction,
is that Kendall survives the season.
But Reed Richards is introduced in episode three.
And it's John Fresinski.
So I know you've been, I know your deep dives have been coming up a little empty recently.
Unlike Conrad Gluckhoff in episode three of Chernobyl.
There's somebody who has been touted as the next Reed Richards.
And I can't remember who it is.
Driver, we talked about this.
Yeah, that's right.
Yeah.
I don't agree.
I think it should be, I think I go Krasinski over driver.
A million percent.
You think if I get fired up white noise, it's just like, that's my guy.
I mean, he is a scientist and we're not a scientist.
He's a Hitler scientist.
So it's clearly a one to one, I don't know.
It's just, we don't have a lot of shows
that just they don't, it's not like,
it's not like, oh, it's back firing on all cylinders.
It's just one cylinder and it's the best cylinder.
- I think it's, what was the man who tries
to zag on succession?
- Yes.
- You know, I've tried it.
Did you, I think I tried to be like,
they should, I think with all due respect to our listeners,
who I think at this point, succession is part of like,
the cost of entry to the spot casso.
I'm assuming you guys all know that in the last season,
it seemed like for about 10 minutes,
Kendall Roy might be dead.
- That's what I was referring to, yeah.
- And I was like, that's the bravest,
most beautiful thing a show's ever known.
- You wept.
- I didn't, but I was like, I think I wept intellectually,
like where I was just like, these takes are crying.
- CR, intellectual weeper.
- And they didn't, they brought 'em back.
And that's fine.
And I love Jeremy Strong,
so I'm excited to see more Kendall Roy.
Brian Cox keeps doing interviews where he's like,
I think we're gonna end the show soon.
And if that is the case, I do wonder,
death is not the only outcome for us it is,
but for these characters, it's not.
I would love to see like, some kind of like,
you can't come back from this moment.
- Right.
- Some real like, this was the stakes
and these are the consequences kind of thing,
but honestly, I'm not really bothered with it.
- Well, 'cause there's no, I mean, at least, you know,
because they haven't done it yet means that when they do it,
it's gonna feel even more significant and surprising,
but I certainly went into this trailer thinking this
and came out of the trailer thinking it.
I would imagine the Roy kids get back together
with their dad this season.
I don't feel like the Civil War is from here
to the end of series.
I don't know what that looks like.
I don't know what that means.
I don't know how many of them end up on which side.
- Right.
But to your other point, you know,
I don't know if this is ready to be a meme yet,
but to like tell me you're running five seasons
without telling me you're only gonna run five seasons,
like that has been the consistent communication,
which would mean that this season is the dare I say.
- Penultimate.
- Say it again.
- Pen, ultimate.
- Yes.
- Which is exciting.
But like, my only other takeaway is Matthew McFadian
and Brian Cox just on an island.
That's a good one.
- And they may actually be on an island.
- Right.
- Because it's succession.
- An island owned by Adrian Brody.
Not the character he plays.
- You didn't get a chance to see Pokerface, did you?
- I haven't watched it yet.
- Okay, so I just wanted to mention first of all,
like embargoes or whatever, I think it's great.
I think it gets better and better through the season.
I've seen a few episodes and the first four went up.
- Yeah.
- And I was just gonna ask,
peacock losing a billion dollars a size.
- Hey, hey, under a billion dollars.
- Yeah.
- Well, you gotta have room to grow.
Is that smart for a mystery of the week
to put up four episodes?
- Yes.
- Yes.
- I mean, there's, first of all, peacock, yes.
(laughing)
- Yes.
- Like there's no--
- Is it smart to show Pokerface
during the Women's World Figure Skating Championships?
- Like there's nothing that peacock can,
if we're talking about it, then yes, it was worth doing.
- Okay.
- That is good for them.
I mean, this show is not in any way analogous to the boys,
but we have constantly praised the fact that Amazon
has figured out what feels like the right system
for that show, which is we'll give you three
and then you gotta wait.
- You know what, that's called?
- What's that?
- They gave us a little taste.
- It's called the Full Postal Weight.
- Do you know the scene I'm talking about?
- Yeah, vaguely.
- Have you seen the town?
- Yes.
- Okay, so in the town.
- For me, it is just a watchable though.
It was not a re-watch.
- That athlete goes into the,
he posses way as a florist slash gangster.
- Oh yeah, yeah.
- And he goes into the flower shop.
And he posses way is there.
And he's got a cool glove on that you need to use
to like, when you're skin and roses,
I don't know what he, what do you do?
- You need a gardening glove?
- Yeah.
- You're making it sound like he's fucking boring.
- Well, but it's like almost closer to like an archery glove.
- Oh.
- Or like like falconry?
- Yeah.
And he's doing this rose up and Ben Affleck's like,
here's your money, I'm not gonna work for you.
And he's like, oh, you're gonna work for me, Laddie.
And then they have this whole conversation
that it turns out that Pee Possilate,
to keep his dad at, keep Ben Affleck's dad in line,
made his mom addicted to drugs.
- Wow.
- And he's like, I gave her a little taste.
And it's just been banging around my head.
- So we're talking about Peecock.
- This is incredible.
I do think that this is now, that's what it's called.
When a streaming service gives you more than one episode,
but then restricts access.
- Yes, it's the Possilate.
- It's called the full Possilate.
That's just canon now.
- It's not the same as the boys for many reasons.
But the primary one for the point of my statement
is that it is not serialized in that way intentionally.
But I think that Peecock needs to explain what this is.
They need to make as many of them as available as possible,
because there's a world where you watch the first episode
of poker face. - Yeah.
- And you could imagine with a modern TV brain
that the show is serialized in a different way,
that she is on the run specifically from these people,
that this was just the premise pilot
and the rest of it is them chasing her.
And that's not what the show is.
- Right.
- So I think it's great.
I think we at this podcast, we are supported by
and we support Kaya and Peecock is her favorite streaming service.
- That's true.
- And we want it to succeed.
- I can't get the image out of my head of you
at the Griffith Park Zoo going up to a Peecock
and being like, you need to tell your story.
You need to get it out there.
- Let me.
By the way, it's not just the zoo.
Have you spent much time in the Pasadena alternative area?
- Yeah, right.
There's Peecock's are just on the streets now.
- You could leave like Disconso Gardens.
- You see like three Peecox and there's like one on your car.
And they're like, then you find out that Jeff Shell
from NBCU lives there.
And that's why I thought this was a good idea.
Everybody knows what's a commonplace site
on your television screen and in your life, Peecock.
- Do you think you will voraciously take down four episodes?
Or do you think you'll be like,
I'm going to parcel this out?
- I think that--
- I ask both on a practical level,
but also out of curiosity with your as an audience member.
- I can probably think of the last thing I wanted
to watch four consecutive episodes of in quick succession.
- Sure.
- Is it like Chernobyl, Chris?
- Yeah, it's exactly like sure.
- But we're going to talk about, on Monday,
we're going to talk about last of us three
and poke our face at least the first two.
- Let's talk about the Oscar nominations,
'cause that's why people listen to this podcast.
- Yeah.
- We're here in studio seven.
It's Spotify and Los Angeles.
And starting in just a few minutes
is going to be an episode of a podcast called The Big Picture.
- Oh, is that new?
- And they did a great podcast
very early in the morning on Tuesday
about the Oscar nominations.
And I thought,
so I give you everything you need to know.
And then on top of that,
on Tuesday night, Bill had Wesley on,
Buzz and Morris, our buddy, on his podcast,
and they talked about the Oscar nominations.
And Wesley said something that really what,
I thought was kind of like really,
I thought was very thought provoking,
which was just casually saying,
I think that the Oscars are important.
I'm paraphrasing Leslie,
but he was like, the Oscars are important
because it tells the story of the year in movies
by the people who make movies.
I hadn't really thought about it that way necessarily.
I think that there's a lot of disagreement
about why the Oscars are significant
or why they may be continuing to matter
or don't matter or what have you.
Why do you think the Oscars are important?
- It's a heavy question.
- Yeah.
- Because I immediately my brain bifurcates
into the two tracks of how or why are they important
artistically and how and why are they important
commercially and what they represent
or the business that they could provide.
I think that Wesley is right in the sense
that it is like an annual shareholders meeting
of the movie industry, of like here's what we're making,
here's who we are and here's how we see ourselves
and what we value.
And that in and of itself is a constant negotiation
with the larger marketplace.
But the ways that that develops are fascinating,
especially with this year's nominees.
- I was trying to like, I think for myself,
I think I have a little bit of an issue
where I can't decide whether or not the Oscars
should be about the best movie or about popularizing
the movies, you know, that are.
- Yes.
- I'm having a little bit of like an issue,
I think because of the Top Gun Maverick thing.
And how if you had asked me six months ago,
obviously before all the Oscar contending movies
came out, what Top Gun Maverick not only represented,
but it's achievement in and of itself
and like the feelings that it gave the audience,
I think that went beyond just like,
it was a good popcorn movie,
but we're like, that's actually like why I go,
in a perfect world, this is why I go to the movies
is to feel this, to you know,
have a relationship with movie stars,
to go through like this gamut of emotions,
to be thrilled, to see something
and to experience something I've never seen before.
And I guess you could make the same argument
for the way of water, I haven't had that pleasure yet.
But as the months went on,
I feel like the idea of what Top Gun's achievement
has been sort of minimized to some extent in the Oscar race
by the artistic brilliance of tar or banshees
or what have you.
And now it seems like it's basically a two horse race.
It seems like it best picture is essentially down
to banshees of Inner Sharon
and everything everywhere all at once.
So I guess I'd ask you,
does Top Gun and Avatar's presence lift all boats
and kind of make the show a little bit more popular this year?
There's a few things that are nominated
that have been seen by quite a few people.
And that will then maybe throw more of a spotlight on tar
or more of a spotlight on banshees or whatever.
Or are they making like the same mistake
Is this 10 movie best picture?
or approval, now kind of like, well, people are gonna think
that they're coming to see Top Gun or Avatar celebrated
and they're gonna wind up like seeing tar jokes being made.
- I think that that's a really important distinction
to make because there is the risk
that doesn't really get talked about
of the feeling of ropeado, right?
Like, does anyone actually, I know we all want,
like I want movies, contrary to my popular,
contrary to my public position,
I want movies to be successful.
- Yeah.
- But does anyone think that Top Gun Maverick
being nominated for best picture is going to significantly
or meaningful increase the ratings,
especially when people will tune in to watch it lose.
Like, it's not going to win, right?
And it's not really touching the party
that's gonna be happening.
I would imagine when lesser seen movies dominate
across the board.
So I'm not sure if that argument really holds water
or the way of water, not to be confused
with Oscar winner, the shape of water.
But I think, I'm thrilled that it was nominated
not because I want more people to watch the Oscars
or movies to be more successful generally,
but because I think circling back to Wesley's point,
it is interesting to see the narrative
of what movies are each year.
And it's not always visible in the moment
when you look back on past years.
You're like, oh, I can kind of get a sense
of what people, not only what they were watching,
but what the industry thought it was doing
and where it was as an industry.
And Top Gun Maverick is brilliant filmmaking.
I mean, it's just absolutely successful
in what it set out to do and what it set out to be.
And in our conversation about it,
it wasn't just that like, oh,
this is the greatest popcorn movie of the year.
It was like the way that this movie has surgically zeroed in
on what was good about action movies from the '80s,
but made it in a 2020s box and used certain technologies
and also chose not to use other technologies.
Like that is a very, very contemporary thing.
And one of the reasons I'm thinking about this
is because, you know, Chris, I'm Mr. Saturday night
on Wednesdays.
And I had a free night.
This is relevant to this conversation.
I know.
I took myself, you know, treat yourself, right?
So I took myself out on a little solo,
solo mandate to the Lemling Glendale,
but just one, please, ticket to the Oscar nominated film
and living, starring Bill Nye in my love.
- Do you think you would have seen that
if it hadn't been nominated for an Oscar?
- Well, yes, 'cause I love Bill Nye.
And I was interested that it was like a,
Kazoo Ishiguro, the great novelist wrote the screenplay
and it's like a remake of a Kurosawa film.
It's like, oh, this just seems, come on.
- Yeah.
- I gotta be me.
What was curious was I had a lot of confidence
that I could just waltz into the theater
and buy it ticket, like as it was starting.
- And movies are back.
- And I think it was because of the Oscar nominations,
it was pretty well attended, which was nice.
But his performance is amazing,
thrilled that he got nominated.
There are a lot of things to recommend this movie.
But it is also deeply strange
because it's not just that the movie is set in 1955.
It is as if the filmmakers set out to make a movie
from 1955, including the way the credits play
in the way it says, the end at the end.
And you're like, is this a bit or is this an homage?
Like, what is this?
And I think of this to say, not only did I think,
I don't think that choice worked,
even though the movie is worthwhile,
that the movies nominated this year are 2022 movies.
- Oh yeah.
- Through and through.
And that in and of itself is worthy of celebration
and interrogation and examination.
Because this is what we're working with.
That it's not living, which is like,
it's a cover.
Literally, it's a cover of another movie,
but also it's a cover of another movie making style
that felt so inert and detached.
And whatever argument you could make about these 10 nominees,
and I haven't seen all of them yet,
but I would like to see more of them.
My guess is that these do speak to something
relevant or cultural now.
- So you have best picture,
you start to knock out the whale, right?
- You get nominated.
- Oh, didn't.
- This is a win for me.
- So wait, what was the best picture is?
- Top Gun Maverick.
- Side.
- It's antithesis, women talking.
- Yeah.
- Like literally, those two movies,
and then there's everything,
all at once, in between them.
- Exactly.
- Everything everywhere, all at once,
the banshees of Ineshear and Triangle of Sadness,
surprise not to Amanda Dobbins.
- Yeah.
- Surprise nominee.
- I love that movie.
Amanda called that.
- She did?
- Yeah.
- She called it a shot.
- Yeah.
- Kind of like Brock Purdy looking down the barrel
of a--
- Of a sci-blitz.
- Of a sci-blitz.
- Is Amanda in that?
- Yeah.
- The Fabelman's all quiet on the western front,
Avatar of the Way of Water, Elvis and Tara.
- I've seen all of them.
- Most of these.
I haven't seen a women talking.
- I just want to commend the Netflix corporation
for making a best picture nominated film
that I'd never heard about.
- Until last week.
- Oh, I'll quiet.
- Directed by Edward Berger.
- Yeah.
- Is a brilliant director.
- I can tell you a movie that you will not want to watch.
- Yeah.
- That one.
- But I love that dude.
He worked on Deutschland 83.
He did Patrick Mellrose in that movie.
- We're about to do a Chernobyl pod.
- I know, I'm just telling you.
Just as it heads up.
- I bet it's better than the Fabelman's.
- That is a really loaded statement.
- It's interesting.
Oh wow, yeah, I didn't realize that.
I'm allowed to say that.
- Yeah, you are.
- Cool.
- Half of me is allowed to say that.
- You fucking hated the Fabelman's.
- Yeah.
- Yeah.
- To make the content, dude, come on.
The TikTok camera's not on, tell me about it.
- Well, I mean, I loved the last five minutes.
- Okay.
- I thought the last five minutes were absolutely incredible.
And representative of what I think the movie,
maybe the movie that they wanted to make.
- Okay.
- Otherwise--
- You think Steve just let this one get away from him?
- I mean, it is, look, who in America--
- Did he didn't have a personal relationship
to the story?
- Brother.
Who in America can't get behind the pull yourself up
from your bootstrap story of a young man
who dreams of becoming a filmmaker
and then becomes one with no obstacles whatsoever?
(laughing)
It was insane to me, this movie.
Pretty just like, I'm interested in doing something.
I guess there's some sad things.
I'm doing the thing.
It's just, it's like when,
it's when famous people write their autobiographies
and can't see the parts of themselves
that are more interesting than others
and think that because it resulted in a win,
then this was all moving content.
And the tonal shifts in the midst of it,
the jud her scene is awful.
Like, he's great, but that is an,
I just thought that was awful.
And broadly, I thought Michelle Williams was like,
one of those classic, like,
"Puccino or De Niro" in a movie where no one's telling him
to just scratch it down a little bit.
- This is my favorite kind of--
- I know.
- Yeah. - Then it becomes,
I'm going to, I'm going to go before the last one.
- Then it becomes, oh, so I just spoiled it for you.
- It's more like-- - He becomes a filmmaker, Chris.
- Yeah, no, I think that-- - Stability Fableman
makes it.
It becomes a high school romp midway through.
- Okay.
- I just thought it was really bizarre
where it seemed like Steve was making an art house movie
and Tony Kushner was writing a play
and then they made this movie.
I just thought it was a misfire.
- I would like to hear what you thought of Banshee,
of not Banshee.
I would definitely love to hear you talk about Banshee's.
I really want to know what you think
of Triangle, sadness.
- I don't love on-screen barfing.
- There's a lot of that.
- I know. - It's part spoiler alert.
- Like that's less appealing to me
than watching dudes get ground TF up in trench warfare, I think.
- Yeah. - I think.
- Well, all quiet on the Western Front,
very available on Netflix for you.
- But broadly, I thought what was interesting about this,
these nominees is, I also listened to the big picture podcast.
I just searched for it 'cause I'd never heard of it before.
- Well, you don't subscribe to it.
You only subscribe to Fresh Air WTF and Bill.
- And Philly Special. - I've listened to so many hours of that show this week.
They put up a new podcast every day.
- It's in the fucking NFC championship.
- I know.
This Sean was like, Sean was very pleased
with the nominating class.
And I think that he, I thought that was a really interesting point
that this does kind of get its arms around
what the movie business is in a way
that recent nominee groups haven't.
- That was really interesting.
It was like a very equitable distribution
of different kinds of movies, including like the,
I thought it did a really good job
of validating why you have a 10 film best pictures.
Now, I don't pretend to understand exactly
how the voting works.
I know that there's preferential balloting.
Amanda, who was right about triangle of sadness,
has been very strong on,
Tara will be everyone's second favorite.
And that that could make it a dark horse
to get in everything everywhere.
All at once, Banshee sweepstakes.
I think Banshee's is gonna win, but I could be wrong.
You know, I'm in no way an Oscar expert.
But that was, Tara was my second favorite.
I mean, to Top Gun, Tara, Banshee's.
- Right.
- And then some deplorable horror movies
were my favorite films the last year.
- I was excited to see that 20% of the actors nominated
for Best Actor have been on this podcast.
- Is that true?
- I mean, that's two, but who are they?
- Our good friend Colin Farrell has been on three times, I think.
- On the watch?
- Well, he's been on the, well, that's true.
He was on my show, the Andy Greenwald podcast.
I'm so sorry.
- Where's Colin Farrell on the watch?
- Oh, he was on, you were on with him with Bill.
- Yeah.
- Okay.
- Yeah.
- So he's been on--
- He's been on the whole time.
- That's cool.
He's been on with me, I guess.
That's different times.
- What was that for?
- That was for, woof.
I don't even remember.
I mean, does he need a reason to come on the podcast?
- I was curious about the Hollywood perspective archives.
- Yeah.
- 'Cause they are somewhat lost at time
'cause they were an ASPN project
and we didn't take them with us.
But I mentioned to you the other day, I was like,
oh, it looks like somebody found like three or four episodes
and you were like, I wonder if they've found
the Andy Greenwald show.
- First of all, it was the podcast.
- No, I didn't, first of all, I didn't.
what I was asking for.
or was the Tony Bourdainer, which was on Hollywood perspective,
perspectives, which I wish I had.
- Yeah.
- That's all.
- I think it's out there in the ether, you know?
- I'm sure someone has heard it.
- N-E-R-D, like they gotta have it out there somewhere.
- That one, the first Lindsey Buckingham,
like the one that you get to talk to your favorite people,
Colin Farrell.
Although I think that was for this website,
so I bet it still exists.
- Okay.
- I'm pretty sure it does.
- What have you been in?
- I was in a Yorgos thing.
I remember watching something very rainy.
I don't remember.
- And how was it like you're doing Colin Farrell and I'm not?
- He was in New York.
- Oh.
- And it was early days.
- Back in the day when you used to just--
- He used to go into ear wolf, mid-tempe briefly,
like at the start of the ringer, before it was the ringer.
But Paul Mesco, big fan.
He's nominated.
That was nice.
- Yeah, I think the only other point that I want,
I mean, everyone's been talking about this,
but I think it's interesting to say,
like there's always debate, and this is obviously
Sean and Amanda are always all over this
in terms of like, what are the Oscars actually saying
to America is this real life for these things people want to see?
Do they care about these things?
What is the obligation of something like the Oscars
in terms of the mass audience?
And then it nominates Andrea Reisboro,
whom I think is amazing.
She was in zero, zero, zero.
She's still to the musical.
She's always good.
And I remember reading when this sort of groundswell
of support started like 10 days ago for her role in Too Leslie,
that one of the things that may be hurting her
is that she's a chameleon.
She's always different can do just about anything.
- So like, for instance, she can sit between two dead guys
and give a cartel leader some crypto.
- Yes.
- And she doesn't zero, zero, zero.
- I mean, who among us?
- Yeah.
- But then this, so broadly like,
Andrea Reisboro getting nominated is great
'cause I think she's a great actor.
I think that's awesome.
I'm also happy for my favorite podcaster, Mark Marion.
- You know, who was the co-star of that film?
- What if Bill was the co-star of Too Leslie?
Do you think it would have been as good a movie?
- I haven't seen it, but I'm interested.
You had my interest, now you have my attention.
But my point is that like, it just seemed like
there was five days of tweets
and she got an Oscar nomination.
And I think about how we correctly, I believe say,
Twitter is not real life,
but Twitter is the film academy.
- Uh-huh.
- I don't know if there's a good or bad thing,
but that was really fascinating.
- I can't begin to explain it.
I do think Amanda made the point on big pick
that this will probably be the first and last time
this happens.
- Do you know what I mean, 'cause like the next time
somebody's trying to do an organic viral,
like I had to break protocol
and just talk about my great friend, this person,
I don't think that it's gonna have the same resonance
as it did this time.
- I also think that this isn't exactly
the dawn of the Justice League.
Oh, like the flash breaks the time barrier
as the most memorable moment.
- No, I mean, like this wasn't,
this wasn't just like a bot invasion.
- Yeah.
- A really good actor and apparently gives
an incredible performance.
I think that all long-time listeners of this podcast
and even occasional visitors to "Dadding to an Island"
will know where the real, real juice is
in this year's Oscar nominees.
And that's where my pick for actually best movie of the year,
Marcel the Shell with shoes on,
is up against Puss and Boots the last wish,
which was a very contentious.
- What category are they up against?
- Cinematography.
- No, they're not.
(laughing)
Come on, costume design.
The Shell's shoes are very, very intricate.
- I, you had more Oscar takes.
So I thought you were going to--
- That's a battle for the Soul of America
right there is one thing.
- What's in Boots versus Marcel the Shell?
- Yes.
- I did see Marcel the Shell.
- He was quite moving, yeah.
- Did we talk about that?
- No, I don't think so.
- So you saw my favorite movie and--
- I didn't actually, honestly, you throw praise around.
Like you'll be like--
- That is not something that people say about me.
- So you'll be like, if you see a movie and you like it,
you're like, that's the greatest movie I've ever seen.
- Accurate.
- Yeah.
- I've seen nine movies.
- You said that about Tar.
You said that about Top Gun.
- I didn't say that.
- That was the greatest movie I've ever seen.
- Marcel the Shell was your favorite film of the year.
- It wasn't.
- Yeah.
- Tar was.
Okay, Tar was.
But Marcel was really good.
And I was really happy he was nominated.
Do you want me to do my top three movies
if the three movies I saw this year?
- You did, Ari.
- I know.
- The new series 12, 12, 12 is now streaming on Apple TV.
This is the biggest banking heist in the history of Europe.
- That's beautiful.
- As soon as they realize it's something's missing,
we'll be seven times on its way.
- Storm Emmy nominee Anthony Mackey.
He stole it for me.
And Golden Globe nominee Jimmy Dornam.
- This is all for our family.
The heist is just the beginning.
12 hours starts now, 12, 12, 12.
We're now streaming on Apple TV.
- Life is all about making decisions.
Sometimes you make questionable ones.
Like buying a new TV that's too big for the wall
because the electronic store employee was a little,
it's all too good at their job.
Then sometimes you make great ones,
like protecting your home and auto with progressive.
You get customized coverage options,
so you can be sure you have the right coverage.
Get your quote today at progressive.com.
Progressive casualty insurance company affiliates
and other insurers, not available in all states.
Sometimes remembering where you started
makes you think where you're going.
What if there's another way, another way to breathe,
another way to connect, another way to create?
What if there's another way to grow?
Another way to fly.
There's always another way.
Paradigm, Odipa Farm, and the new puffer by Prada.
- Credit Karma connects your finances in one place.
So you can spend smarter,
reach your savings goals faster,
and set yourself up for your next money move.
It really makes you feel like you're ahead of the game.
Like waking up early on a Sunday morning to wash the car,
meal prep for the week.
Repot the monster and get all your steps in
before enjoying those mimosas at brunch.
Credit Karma, on top of your money, on top of the world.
Download the app today.
Should we just get into talking about Chernobyl?
I don't think we can put it off any longer.
You can try.
I mean, it's been four years.
- Just as like a, I don't want to belabor the fact
that we didn't talk about this.
So we're going to be talking about Chernobyl now.
Spoilers for Chernobyl.
We, in 2019, I believe is when this show came on,
it was in May of 2019.
And I was trying to think back like,
what were we doing?
Do you know what I mean?
And so I went back to the archives.
- I was in Albuquerque.
- You were in Albuquerque,
but even through all that,
I just thought I would mention
that these were the podcasts that we did in May.
- Oh, Jesus.
- Breaking down Avengers 10 game.
- Oh.
- Breaking down Game of Thrones,
season eight, episode four,
a very deep and David Cross episode.
- David Cross.
- I think I must have talked to David Cross.
The penultimate episode of Game of Thrones.
- Well, that seemed important.
- A larger conversation about the end of Game of Thrones,
and I guess I podcasted about the finale of Survivor that year.
The finale of Game of Thrones,
Barry and Fleabag,
Dead with the movie and Black Mirror season five.
Now, I don't know how many of those you were on
'cause you were also making her and show it that time.
- I think we all know that I was not there
for the survivor and Dead with conversations.
- Did you ever see the Dead with the movie?
- No. - Okay.
So we were busy.
And then what happened was,
I think to Craig Mason,
the creator of Chernobyl and the writer of Chernobyl,
now the co-creator and writer of Last of Us,
and the writer of Hangover Part Two and Three.
Let's be real.
- And some scary movie sequels.
I think that he was one of the first people
to do a podcast project he did with Peter Siegel
from NPR, where he was like,
I'm gonna kind of document this show in real time
on this podcast.
And honestly, kind of took all my bits.
I was just kind of like, I don't really,
I don't really know what we would do.
He's doing such a good job.
Mal and Sean did a part about Chernobyl a little bit,
I think into its run.
That was great.
But I just never, I know that I started
the first episode a few times.
And then it just kind of got lost to time
and then obviously came a bit.
So anyway, we can just kind of draw a line
under I don't want to apologize
for like 40 minutes about the show,
but that was, I did want to say,
I think that's why it kind of slipped
through the cracks a little bit.
- Yeah, I think, and as I said at the time,
like I was busy, I was in production
and it was too heavy.
I just didn't want to make the investment
or the journey.
And I have some words for that version of myself
because this isn't that.
I mean, it is horrific and it is haunting
and it is deeply disturbing.
But it is, it executes at such a high level
that my takeaway from an episode was never,
I can't believe what's been done to me.
My takeaway was, oh my God,
I mean, it is a full sensory experience
at a very high artistic level and is worth,
it's worth it.
- Yeah.
- It's simply worth it.
And I do wish, I think we're going to get into this.
I do wish, I didn't have foam at the time.
It became a bit for us.
But I do think seeing it in 2019
would have positively informed some of our conversations
of things subsequent.
- That's what I was going to say
because that Chernobyl, I don't think Chernobyl was flawless,
but had I seen Chernobyl,
I think it would have impacted the way
I watched specifically Andor,
not in any way a dang of Andor or any way,
like Andor's not as good as I thought it was.
Andor's still my favorite show of last year.
And in a lot of ways,
it's certainly easier to watch Andor
because it's taking place in a fictional galaxy
than it is to just be like, this was, you know,
this is Russia just a few decades.
to go. And obviously, Tony Gilroy has the freedom for the most part to explore a lot of
different ideas and also have characters do things and have it be like, well, I've just
decided that this is what this character does here. Whereas in Chernobyl, I think Craig
Mason was at once restrained by history and real events, but also if he chose to deviate
from that was lately dinged for that. And I was actually pretty surprised. Chernobyl has
such a great reputation since it's airing that I went back and I was like, oh, Mike Hale
at The New York Times had a pretty critical review of it. Masha Guesson at The New Yorker
obviously took issue with a couple of elements of it. So it wasn't a uniformly praised show,
I don't think.
I do think like Masha Guesson's piece and she's not a TV critic per se. And she's just a
brilliant thinker and essayist and cultural thinker. She wishes political thinker. That's
right. If only her piece was written, I think, at the conclusion of the series in response
to the critical hazans in a way to throw some I know throwing some water on it is a fraught
phrase when you're talking about Chernobyl and nuclear reactors in general. Just sticking
a rod in there.
It's fine. It's fine. Yes, I think to your Andorra point, it's funny. It's like when you
see something in a vacuum and you, I think, correctly praise it, it's always interesting
to then see what unquestionably is an influence. Now to your point, Tony can do anything. He's
one of our heroes and it's an imagined universe set within an already imagined universe. But
it's not just the borrowing or the hiring of Luke Hall who is a God, God tier production
designer who broke through with Chernobyl onto Andorr. It's also the deep, deep, the usage
of the deepest bench imaginable of brilliant actors from the UK. And just on another note,
the idea that you can take a snapshot of a large structural systemic governmental organization
or power in decline and make that compelling television through details, through brilliantly
chosen, surgically investigated details. So there is a one to one in that. But I would
even take it further and say like we've spent a lot of time either unpacking or avoiding
the glut of what we termed Wikipedia shows, ripped from the headlines. A lot of them true
crimes. A lot of them true crime are based on podcasts. No one is going to say, I don't
think it's very fruitful to say like we crashed and Chernobyl are the same and one is better
than the other. That is not a useful critical designation. But it would be sick if we waited
this long and then we're just like, that was the summation because we didn't talk about
that one either really. It's really more that the power of the medium to enlighten and
entertain using historical precedent. Chernobyl is a masterclass in that and showed me things,
not just factual things that I didn't know, but showed me things about TV as a storytelling
medium that I had not previously known or expected. And I'm not expecting the producers
of whatever tech genius was actually a fraudster or scammer to have that kind of rigor or be
given the amount of time or frankly to be as passionate or as a research laden as Craig
Mason was. I mean, that is an Apple store and just thing. But it did that leave me feeling
like, oh, look what TV can do. Oh yeah. So that actually segues to I think what I think
is its primary achievement, which is it crystallized or clarified for me this thing that I think
I've been trying to articulate to myself in no way is this an original thought, but that
the goal of a film story should not be like this replication of reality, but the manufacturing
of a reality, right? So even if it's a reality, even if the show is based on real events,
the show is only responsible to the story itself. Viewers can take or leave the literal truthfulness
of a show or a story, but they can only deal with the reality that the show presents. And
in that sense, like Chernobyl might be unrivaled when it comes to creating the quote Chernobyl
quote reality, not the literal Chernobyl reality, but the reality of the show is so deeply
realized. I don't know if it has that many rivals. So that that was the thing that it really
kind of crystallized for me that the best television, whether it's and or mayor of East
town or whatever shows I've been responding to recently, is that they create a tonal
consistency that makes sense for the show itself or the story it's telling.
Absolutely. I mean, I think that you could make it even a broader point. I think that the
best art isn't a window. It's a mirror. And if you are looking towards filmed entertainment
to teach you the facts, respectfully, you might be doing it wrong. I think that there's
a commonality between successful adaptations, whether they're adapting books or something
from another medium or historical events, where the best of them, you feel the personal
aesthetic, intellectual, creative, emotional touch of the adapter who brought something
of themselves or what interested them to it. I mean, that's what elevates it. That's
what transforms it. So that's why I deeply respected Masha Gesson's now four-year-old
piece in the New Yorker who knows how Masha Gesson would feel about that now. But at the
same time, some of the points made, like, yes, the Chernobyl series got the details right
to a staggering degree for a Western show, almost to the point where the sunlight looked
as if it was taken from sunlight in the Middle East, but then but the creation of Emily
Watson's character as a composite and the slow turn towards the series as a little guy
and Gell stand up to the regime is a Hollywoodization, is a Westernization, is a fiction, is a
fantasy, and thus it did, it disrespected the truth. And I don't know if I agree with
that because I think that this was both historically devastating and bracing and illuminating and
causing me to want to read more and learn more. But also, this was a television show made
by an American in 2019 at a time when truth and lies and systems of government and their
role in people's lives was changing in a different way for this country and the way
people, the conversations we were having about that. And I think that there, I mean, Gesson
calls out this point of like certain characters speaking back to Apparachics or speaking
back, speaking truth to the power in a way that no one ever would. And it's like, I respect
that and I appreciate that. But the large majority of Western audiences won't know that distinction
and might need some reminding of who ran the Soviet Union and what those people valued
and why they were promoted. So I think that it's doing a lot of things at once. But I think
what's remarkable, and I'm sure, Craig Mason has spoken about this at length in various
podcasts and things from Dateline four years ago, was the decision making of this is where
my field to the truth ends and this is where the art begins. And you can feel that pendulum
move at times during the series. And it's, to my mind, it's almost entirely successful.
Yeah. I think that the reality of the show stays consistent, even if the literal truthfulness
of the show varies, right? And that, that was one of those things that was really interesting
as I went along. So I'll just say it was funny watching the first one because it was like
the fifth time I'd seen it. The first one largely is a disaster movie. It consists of this,
the immediate impact of this meltdown and some of the mistakes that were made, but in a kind
of chopped up way that will get further illuminated at the end of the series. It basically starts
in media res, like where this amazing character played by Paul Reader, the character's empty
outlaw. And he walks into this room and like the show starts.
Well, it starts with Jared Harris starts with the end. Right. And then yes, it starts,
I mean, we can just, I mean, this is the thing about it. You're like, historically, we
might be a little older. I think some of our audience, I'm not sure. The degree to which
I didn't know anything other than the top line was humbling. And I think that's true
for a lot of people. And I think, you know, one thing that I learned from Usha Guest
and its piece is that largely the truth wasn't owned by anyone for the last 20 years.
Well, they tried to keep it a secret. Yes, according to the show, they tried to keep it
a secret for as long as they possibly could. So we knew, I mean, where you and I are nine
years old, and I guess it's on the cover of Time Magazine that there's a nuclear problem,
but we don't know what that means. We don't know what that looks like. We don't know anything
about the lived experience of it. And so then you turn on a show about it. And my mind being,
I guess, more conservative than I even imagined is like, oh, I guess we're going to do a,
you know, almost like a, like a broad church, like the murder is coming, you know,
TikTok of like this day when everything's fine and then bad things are going to happen.
It's absolutely not that. No, you are suddenly in a room you've never been in before with people
you've never seen dressed in a certain way, at least these white, almost lab coats of nuclear
technicians. And it's not just that the catastrophe has happened. It's that known in that room,
the people in the room and the large, the large majority of the audience, right? We don't know.
Right. We don't understand. And we can't understand. And we continue to not be able to understand
because it's invisible. It's, it's, it's a genius opening. Yeah. And you get to see Jared Harris
in the beginning of the series, but that the first episode is largely a disaster story or a disaster,
you can say disaster movie, that jumps around from POVs to jumps around from, okay, so am I now
with Jessie Buckley? Is she the star of the show or is she the, she's going to be the protagonist
and all this stuff? Like obviously I knew going back into it that's Dylan Scars, Garden,
Jared Harris and Emily Watson. We're going to be the three primary performers, but it's,
it's a really disorienting,
thrilling, imaginative way into the story
to have it be this true ensemble piece
that does not feature the center pieces of the ensemble.
- Yeah, because it will continue like the disaster itself,
it will continue to spread in like concentric waves
as it touches people, literally another way.
- Now that being said, I think the first episode's wonderful.
I think the second and third episodes
are among the two best episodes of television I've ever seen.
- Can I detour for one second?
I agree with you.
We could fold this into our larger conversation
on the Monday show's going forward,
but I found it really striking and jarring
to see an actual disaster into the world show about our world.
It was horrifying.
And it was horrifying and effective in a way that,
and this is a show I like that has just started,
but in a way that last of us isn't,
they're not doing the same thing.
So I'm not trying to put puff one up
at the expense of the other,
but I am saying that we have seen a lot
of dystopian shit and I know that you,
not me, have seen a lot of horror movies and things.
I can't imagine any of them are more effective than this,
both because of its historical truth,
but also just the nature of it.
And the fact that it correctly,
not just correctly represents and depicts,
but is laser focused on what humans are actually like
in catastrophe, which is human.
And devoted to their own pre-existing ideologies
and hopes and plans and really, really hard to deviate,
it's really hard to deviate them from that, right?
It both the physical horror and the mental
and emotional anguish of it really fuck me up.
It's a challenge.
- I think it's really interesting that you bring this up
because for as different as it is from the last of us,
I do see some similarities in mazans ability to create tension
and it frankly, adventure out of horror.
- And I think that's a good point.
- In the last of us, what it is is like we were talking
about on Mondays and the mechanics of video games
and whether or not this sort of side quest
and test climbing over this to get to the,
that's all very video gamey kind of problem solving.
But maybe that's just storytelling.
One of the things that really strikes me about the second
and third episodes of Chernobyl is the way it's second one
is basically a men and a mission show
where it's assembling the team that's going to figure this out
and how are we going to drop boron and sand
and then Emily Watson is like don't do that.
They have all these kind of like,
it's essentially like a towering and fernome movie there.
And then the third one is this amazing split
between an investigative show
because you've got Emily Watson visiting patients
trying to get to these people before they pass away.
And as you mentioned, the coal miners,
which turns into kind of like this,
I mean, it's practically Apollo 13, right?
But it's all of these people for the most part.
And interesting, it never really happens with the,
with the Emily Watson character
who is I guess a fictional creation.
- Is a composite, yeah.
- The thing that hangs over everything
is just the certainty of death, right?
Like the idea that they are essentially throwing away
or have had taken from them the rest of their lives.
And what they choose to do with the rest of their lives
will impact thousands of millions of more people.
- And I think what Mason has been praised for
and I feel trepidaceous even to like wait, wait into this
because I'm not an expert in other people have said,
other people with experience,
whether they are Russians themselves,
Russian Americans are experts on the field
have talked about this.
But the way that the show skillfully articulates
an element of the Russian character.
And it was interesting to consider it the pieces
that you're talking about in reflection to Americans,
which is like we, I think there's an American story
that we roll up our sleeves and do what's needed
for the common good.
But that's actually not the American story.
The American story is broadly like,
I'm here to have my own little fiefdom,
and I'm gonna patrol my own patch and whatever.
- This is the Dutton Ranch brother.
- Exactly, exactly.
And so this, when the miners are like,
we are introduced to them brilliantly
and they're telling that joke about the Russian,
how you build a Soviet machine.
And they're asked to basically just stop doing
what they've been doing their whole lives,
move somewhere else and risk their lives
and their futures for something that might not work
and that they don't understand.
And that incredible tension between understanding,
you are a, I guess, I don't want to put judgment into it,
but you are essentially an insignificant cog
in a much larger structure,
but that there is some nobility in that
or there's some duty in that.
There is something communist on a lower KC about that,
was really powerful and it was really profound
and then increasingly disturbing.
Because I'm not sure where we're gonna talk about it,
I think we just gotta say Luke Hall's name again.
Luke Hall's name because--
- I was gonna, I mean, I--
- I just said it three times like it was a Russian oil giant,
Luke Hall, the production designer.
- Yeah.
- Luke Hall.
- And I think that's what I said.
- So to say thanks to our new sponsor,
Luke Oil, you guys have been doing amazing stuff.
And you know what?
I don't, you know, you're a past to ask nicely.
- Let's, they want that gas.
- I just, I'm, you guys know I'm pro privatization,
just about anything.
Every room that these characters are in was considered,
every detail, every, and this is not cheap, you know,
and it's not cheap financially and it's not cheap like,
in terms of like intellectual and creative labor.
And whether it's absolute accuracy,
like the trash pale apparently that Jared Harris has
and is opening scene that he takes out
before he stashes his secret recordings
or the rotary phones that are in the hotels and Pripyat,
or the giant painting that Ivan the Terrible and his son
that is looming inside the Kremlin
that we see the characters sitting in front of
before they're called into the Polipero meeting
with Gorbachev.
That's not actually there,
but is, you know, it's in the National Gallery
or whatever the equivalent is in Moscow.
But it's artistic license in the best possible way
because it's a painting of a Russian leader
who is so consumed with emotion
he accidentally killed his own son.
And it's looming, you know, and it's like, yeah, this is.
- What if I was like, I can't get past that.
I can't get past the Ivan the Terrible.
- I think there are sticklers who feel that way.
- Yeah, I'm sure.
I think that the, so the second and third episodes
I just wanna talk about briefly because,
and you know, there's that moment in the second episode
where I think was the, obviously in the first episode,
it's so terrible, but like, the real the bottom
of your stomach falls out is when Harris
and Garzgarter having this sort of like,
what are we gonna do?
What are we gonna do?
And Garzgarter's still kind of like,
this is not only fixable, but like,
I'm still thinking about saving my own skin
and coming out.
- Politically and, literally.
- And like, us, it's just like, we're gonna die.
Like, probably within five years.
- Yeah.
- You know, so like, get that through your head
and that kind of, freeing Serbina up
to be a better person or to be a more thoughtful person
and how the lack of self preservation and ambition
winds up being the, like, kind of like the,
their fatal, their fatal fate
is now like the reverse of the fatal flaw.
Like, it becomes their saving grace
that they don't have to think about,
where am I gonna be in 11 years?
What is my, what is my like, bank account gonna look like?
- It's also the plot of the Oscar nominated film living,
just a few really into that.
I just thought you should know.
- So you just spoiled Philman's end living today.
- This is one of my best podcasts ever.
- So you have Batchy's ends?
- I,
just relevant to your point, but also as a side note,
one thing I forgot about myself is that I am,
have, at times in my life been obsessed
and freaked out by radiation poisoning
and this as a actual thing.
- Three mile on thing?
- No, when we were,
we've talked about this in different contexts,
but one of the hallmarks of our shared childhood,
not together, but not too far apart,
was that we both had cable
and there were just movies that played on cable.
And, you know, if you were homesick,
you'd maybe watch prices right in the morning
and then, but like around 2 p.m.
- China syndrome.
- The cable, no, but like at 2 p.m.,
the cable channels are like, yeah.
And they would just start playing whatever.
- Yeah.
- A movie that played a lot, a lot,
was a movie called Fat Man and Little Boy.
- Yeah.
- With Paul Newman and John Kisek.
Actually, an amazing cast, including
Tarte director Todd Field.
And it is a lightly fictionalized,
it's like a prequel, no, it's Oppenheimer.
It's Dwight Schultz from the 18 plays Oppenheimer.
And it's basically about the what he called the project,
the Manhattan Project, where they built the bomb.
And some of it is fictionalized and some of it is,
but essentially in the movie,
I won't spoil this one too,
but one of the main characters,
based on a real scientist,
and also the inspiration for
the Dr. Manhattan character and watchman,
in order to stop a accident from going,
or I puts his hand into essentially a nuclear bomb.
And it's fine for a couple hours.
- Yeah.
- And then the movie shows this decay.
And there was something about it
that gave me more nightmares
and more like just obsessive thoughts than anything else,
because it was invisible, right?
Like you couldn't, you don't see the wound.
- Right.
- But your body is disintegrating because of this,
and that we've somehow tapped into it.
And that movie did a great job doing it,
but this is like the masterpiece of that.
- Sure.
- The thing that even I can appreciate from horror movies
is the sense that when you sit down in the theater,
or you see the state of the run of play,
you know that death or whatever is looming.
- Yes.
- Especially if you're sexually promiscuous.
- Well, yeah.
- Or you go down, if you left something in the basement.
- Yes.
- That's the feeling, right?
That's the kind of. if you're the stakes are the highest they could be,
your jittery, your pit under stomach,
that's what this entire show is
because all of these people are dead.
They're already dead, and they don't know it yet.
And it's, I think you could point to the horrific end
of Vasily or other characters that they show
to the degree that they show.
And honestly, Chernobyl is pretty,
demure isn't the word, but it's tasteful
in terms of body melting.
- Yeah.
- But that horror feeling that's through it,
I mean, this is, yeah, this is Apex Mountain
for a certain kind of horror.
- That it exists in the world,
and that's the thing that I can't really square.
Like Michael Myers isn't really coming back,
but well, hold on, it's got on the phone
with my friends from Roughhouse Pictures.
- I was, as you were talking, I thought for a second,
you were gonna be like, I'm scared of radiation
'cause Dr. Manhattan looked so lonely sitting on the moon.
- Meaning like he's gonna come back
or because I'm scared of being alone.
- Yeah, I'm scared of being so.
- Oh, right, yeah, no, right.
Existentially, intellectually.
- Yeah, we're all Dr. Manhattan.
- No, I just feel like there was something that was,
I can say it all circles back to the scene you're talking about,
which is the truest horror that I've experienced
in like a movie or TV show is a character turning
to the other and saying, you're dead.
- Yes. - We were actually already dead.
And in the natural impulse, this is for any of us to be like,
no, we're not, I'm fine, I can do this,
I can wear this mask, I can leave now,
I can wrap this around my extremities.
- Yeah, there's some lead I can put into my pants.
- Yeah, well, no, some more lead.
I can put it into my pants.
And no, you can't.
- Where should we go next for this?
So yeah, and then I find that the fourth and fifth episodes,
this is, I didn't mean to get off on a side of them.
So I track about the Masha guest in Peace in the New Yorker
or the Michael Peace in the New York Times
or sort of some of the criticisms,
but I felt like I noticed a temperature change,
so to speak, with myself in the fifth episode specifically,
not that the fifth episode was in any way overly convenient
or anything and certainly is like,
as a piece of writing, wonderful,
and the courtroom scene with all the red and blue cards
and the idea of the balance that,
I mean, I think I came out of the end of this show
with an idea of the principles of what was it play
in a way better way than I did
when it should be to ask Lagosov
to explain a nuclear reactor to him in a helicopter.
You know, like that idea of this,
everything is basically setting itself off.
And all of these guys were responsible for conducting this dance,
this really delicate dance between these elements
and that because of cost cutting,
you know, in these Russian nuclear plants,
they essentially were like throwing poison darts at themselves
with the rods.
I thought that was just brilliant.
I did feel like there was something about
the much more process oriented second and third episodes
that felt truer than the fifth one.
- Well, so, but I also noticed you're skipping over
the dog murdering episode.
- Yeah, well, we can get that out.
- With your boy, very, very,
how do you say it, Cougan?
Keegan?
- I thought it was Keegan, yeah.
- Should we just call him Barry?
- Yep, she's a Barry has a newborn son named Brando.
- Do you know that?
- I didn't know that.
- So you know a lot about him.
- I googled him.
- Well, not Google pronunciation.
- No, that's what I googled,
but there was a lot about his son.
- The internet sucks.
- You did on there trying to find one thing.
- One thing and I'm like, well, he married a dentist.
- Yeah, that's interesting.
- He did.
- Yes, I agree with you.
I mean, again, I think that there are,
this comes up in a lot of,
in our conversations about a lot of different shows,
but like ultimately this is an entertainment.
And it has an arc.
- Yeah.
- And once you lay a narrative arc over something,
it is false.
It adds, it's no longer a true thing.
So for example, you know, in cursory research,
I learned how to pronounce the name Jared Harris.
But in addition to that, I did learn,
I mean, there are things like Legasov at a family.
- Yeah.
- He was married, he had a daughter.
That's not in the show for reasons that it would complicate
the image of him.
- He's a huge Niners fan.
- So, well,
there were more than one Legasov.
You know, there were more people brought in.
There was just more.
And that's unwieldy and that's not dramatic.
So I appreciate that.
And I appreciate also that in order to,
not tie a bow on the whole thing,
but there was needed to be a courtroom scene
and there needed to be a dramatic accusation or truth telling.
Because ultimately, this show is,
its fealty isn't to the historical record of Legasov.
Its fealty is towards what it wants to say artistically
about a corrupt insular failing state
and what the cost of truth or not truth is.
And so did Legasov really stand in front of this show trial
and say what he said?
And then fear he was about to be shot in the KGB.
I don't know.
- And was Deatlof really walking around that control room
being like, I don't care about any of the warnings
hit that button, motherfucker.
- It's fun going to like the Wikipedia page where it's just like,
yes, he wasn't a brace of asshole,
but he also loved poetry and theater.
- Well.
- But also the 49ers, so unfortunately.
No, but the goal of all of that is to get to the scene
where the KGB guy is just like you fool.
- Yeah.
- What did it get you?
What does it matter why the bullet is entering your skull,
even in that case metaphorically, right?
Like that's the larger purpose of this.
So yes, I agree with you.
I agree with, I mean, we're not arguing,
but I agree that it does become a different thing
and it does become more convenient,
but that's also the nature of film narrative entertainments.
They, there's an arc and the arc that Mason put on
an unarchable event is remarkable to remarkable.
It is.
It's remarkable.
He chose very, very well so that the artifice
is still serving the larger purpose in my view.
- Yes.
And I guess I wanted to have a little bit of a comment,
there's a bunch of things I wanted to hit,
including some non-Harris scars guard,
Watson favorite characters or performances,
things that you loved about the show,
but I did want to ask you whether or not you felt like
you were watching the show with different eyes in 2023
than you would have in 2019,
not just because of like whatever you changed,
however you changed personally,
but I think that it's been well documented
that this show came out of a Trump era
where there was like people were first becoming conversant
with the idea of misinformation,
which has now become kind of maybe overused at this point
or maybe underused at this point.
I don't even know what to say,
but now it's kind of like one of those words
that you just see and you gloss right over it, right?
And you're frequent haunting of internet news.
- Just face the worst.
- I was trying to answer this question for myself,
but I was curious whether or not you felt like 2023 Andy
watched this show differently than 2019 Andy would.
- As a big Mueller she wrote guy that you were, you know?
- I think it's a great question.
And I do wonder, I can't answer it.
I do think that it's probably telling
that we did, I mean yes, we wanted to get up
on the Masonverse, like there are reasons
what we finally listened to people
that we otherwise admired and respect.
That's why we watched it now.
But I'm not saying that like everything is super chill
in Kevin McCarthy's America,
but there was a constant feeling of panic
in my body and life at the time of this show came out,
not just 'cause it was in production
and not just because I was still on Twitter,
which retrospect also was a mistake.
I think that I think that I think it may hit different
at that time when you are looking to be freaked out
and expecting to be freaked out versus maybe it just runs
back to the thing I said at the beginning of the pod,
which was as challenging as this series is,
I did not find it hard to watch.
And I wonder if that may have been different.
I don't know, how do you feel about it?
- I don't know, I think that I rarely really watch television
with an eye towards what the ideology of the show is
or what, if Craig Mason hadn't said,
this is about lack of trust and institutions
and what happens when we blot out criticism
of those institutions, that's it.
I, the thing that leapt out at me was how
that must have changed during COVID, right?
Because during COVID, I think for the most part,
I personally was like longing for trust and institutions.
Because I wanted to know, hey, you guys just tell me
what I'm supposed to do and I'll do that.
And I think that having living in a world
where those things were so frankly easily questioned
and so publicly debated was a little unsettling.
Now, obviously a pandemic is different
than an industrial disaster.
- Yes.
- Although, at this point,
if Chernobyl happened today,
you would have people who were like,
that's not really happening,
or they want you to think it's this,
but like, what about this?
And, you know, I mean, the redidization of something
like this gives me probably the kind of willies
that you get thinking about radiation coursing
through your body, you know?
- I think that that's, I think that's probably right.
I also think that post COVID,
the intro.
thing about watching it is just again I am not an expert at this and I don't want to just like
rain takes down but like what appears to me to be a profound difference in the American character
and I don't want to say Soviet or Russian but the non-American character which is to say like
Americans broadly did kind of believe including us I'll say us that like okay there's a pandemic
coming but we'll be fine or like these things will work there's a backstop that's kind of how we
felt during the Trump years too like oh well the rule of law sort of gentleman's agreement
that we won't do this that'll be fine yeah the trust institutions you're talking about and
the to contrast that with the woman milking a cow in episode four of Chernobyl who's just like
delivers a devastating dead-eyed monologue about how everyone in her family was killed their bones
ground generation upon generation of people have come through this village and told me I needed to
get out and I'm still here and my life isn't defined by my possessions or my accomplishments or
my achievements it's merely by surviving here you know and I don't expect you to understand that
and I don't expect anything to get better I just expect a milk this cow you know and that kind of
that mixture of like we're being kept in the dark and being kept ignorant but it's not like
it's a blissful ignorance sure we don't expect things to be better than this you know and horrific
things happen you know that aspect of it again our experience over the last two years of having
to order takeout more is not comparable no I know but I did think that that was an interesting
con that contrasts only became more interesting I think in the years since the show premiered
and when we watched it yeah and I think that just living through a time where on a milder probably
obviously larger but milder level of you know don't panic and then that being like a central sort
of tenant of like we just want people about to panic you know don't worry about the grocery
stores don't worry about this like we're gonna figure this out don't panic don't panic and then like
the way in which that just doesn't work anymore you know telling people to remain calm or not
panic and either as even one of these episodes is like please remain calm is the quickest way
to get in people to freak the fuck out but also how arbitrary all of it is because you could there's
a moment in the show where they're like 30 miles outside and then everybody's fine and the gossip's
like well why not 29 or why not 300 like we've poisoned the planet irreparably here yeah but the
truth is it's always arbitrary and the desire to have someone tell us what's is this okay and then
this is the point where it becomes not okay and that's what we've been living through in terms of like
so should I stop wearing a mask should I wear them on airplanes like what what am I doing here
in the answer uncomfortably smoking again apparently they certainly I mean to be openly
to pack a day in a reactor core yeah Russians are already mostly graphite that's just
it's just well no no just the filter tips are graphite the rest is boron yes that's right you know
but they cheaped out on the tips it's it's it's wild wild wild for all of those cultural reasons
but it is also and I just keep wanting to keep putting back to this it is just such like god to your
television the cast I mean run down a little bit deeper into the well done the call sheet so
we can do the the the region of this NCA tournament that's people that were also on andor
yep or or in terms of the actor Adrian Rollins and or Chernobyl and the Oscar nominated
film living which is called a full greenwald I believe you coined that term
the greenwald triple crown yes yeah Alex Fern who plays the coal miner in the two local
coal miner in Chernobyl who's also the pockets are fermenting guy in andor it's amazing
and then I mean I want to talk a little bit about Paul Reader who plays the outlaw and you know
as you said big poetry lover uh long-term believer in Brock Pertie didn't didn't believe the
mr. relevant stuff uh um but to embody this sort of uh hostile negligence and basically the
disregard for human life contemptuous but to still be utterly watchable and also like
it's not like I you feel for him like you're like everybody's had a de outlaw day you know
because I hear management style
well C.R. is going full de outlaw over there he's on cigarette number nine
he's got somebody's got a case of the Mondays or the Wednesday night safety tests yeah um
but to still be a human being I thought and and this is the thing that maybe I'm just in the bag for
if you cast a bunch of English and Scottish and Welsh and Irish actors
I find them inherently believable in a way yeah I think I know why though because they're better
no because they look like people yeah that's part of it for sure and I think that largely
American cast television and films still put a premium on this person's hot yep um
that's why we work in an audio medium no but I'm serious I agree with you you know I think that
it's like important that like the person working at the computer in shield in a in a marvel movie
is attractive and it's not important and Chernobyl no no and I know that sounds like
faint praise be like congrats Chernobyl cast you guys are fucking ugly you got an international
compliment of us bringing America the world's worst tragedy to life I mean if they hired us to do
the marketing for the show this Sunday night well be any viral skincare coming out of this one
yeah like what are the branding opportunities here um yes but also like there's something that is
so rich about it that is universal which is that people exist as people within the um the systems
that they are placed in yeah so when you have those scenes like the absolutely breathtaking scene
like that's in the basement in the first episode when all the party yeah big wigs get together to be
like well what are we gonna do and the conversation isn't how are we going to put out the fire
literally and otherwise it's not how we're gonna save people it's how are we going to choose a
story and lock it the fuck down well don't even that it's like if these guys can't tell each other
the truth how are they gonna tell the truth to the rest exactly and they are all
agreed they're doing this and what's interesting about it is that what lagasov
breaking that it's not just a choice it's a violation because he's breaking the rules it's
like saying no in an improv game like you just right no we've all agreed on the terms here
and it's worked out fine right and we were afraid of the alternative and so here we go and so
that incredible moment when um uh who is it is it uh uh Helen well no I forget about my my guy
Charkov the KGB guy Charkov is incredible that's Alan Williams yeah not Charkov but there's
the guy who was one of the early maesters in Game of Thrones super weird for me to be like my guy
Charkov is your number one um no the guy from Game of Thrones he's a maester uh um anyway in that scene
um you know he he's they look to him and he's just like we lock this down because that's what we do
as you know as loyal Soviet citizens and he like stamps his cane and everyone's applaud yeah
everyone's looking for someone to applaud you know which is fascinating and there's actually
moments like that in white noise too which is about another event which uh a scene that doesn't age
so well in comparison to Chernobyl just because of the tone in which it is portrayed but when you're
talking about performances I mentioned Adrian Rollins whose whose foam in who's one of the chief
engineers who's dodging you know blame and and has also done the andor and living but the
my guy is Khan O'Neal is the other guy who we've seen in a hundred different things he Khan O'Neal
is uh um Buchanov he gets woken up in the beginning and he has that very unique sort of raspy voice
and there's a there's a gift that many people in our Facebook group like to use of him pounding
the table uh okay yeah you know and he's he's the third guy on trial and he's just it's just so
really oh that's the guy who's like I'm gonna get promoted so yes I got to promote somebody into
my spot yeah that guy's like I would like to be considered and he's like fucking the dance
formula here exactly yeah and that's what it is all about is just that sort of petty pet the
pettiness the hunger you know and and that's the root of it which brings us back to the thing we
said at the beginning which is the way that you tell the story matters the way you dole it out the
way you bring your brought into it and the choice to bring us in in media res is brilliant for
dramatic purposes you're completely thrown you're off you don't know where you are what's going on
but you know it's bad because you know the name of the fucking show I didn't I was so dazzled by
everything that I honestly didn't expect to run the clock back in the finale so we could we could
focus on the trial but the fact that it takes us back to that day and you see the kids in the
media uniforms much I guess and didn't like that but you see life you see the guy who brings his
baby to what is now called the bridge of death to watch the explosion right with his baby you see
Viselli you know holding a baby because he'd like to have one and all these scenes of life but what
you also see is just three craven dudes just three craven dudes that that we're just businesses
usual that's the thing and and what I think is so triumphant about the way the series ends isn't
whether it was accurate or not or not accurate I it didn't say at the end that those three guys
were guilty it didn't tow the Soviet buddy line I thought the show did a brilliant job of enditing
an entire system well also and this is what LaGassev's point was saying that 25-year-old you know
in the throw of a promotion sniffing asshole.
- Like living on the line,
being like, if I don't do my job tonight,
like I get exiled or whatever.
Like, that's pretty amazing.
- Do you ever have the thing where you're like,
I mean, this is always the case
with these international productions,
but I'm like, I recognize that guy.
That guy was playing Gorbachev.
Well, first of all, that's not his real head or birthmark.
I know that, you're trying to place him,
you've seen him and stuff.
And then you realize-- - Yeah, that's what his real head.
- Well, 'cause he's wearing like a, like a,
it's his real head.
But like, he's real scout.
But he's wearing a head piece.
Because he's the creepy guy from top of the lake.
- I think he's, isn't he also in Ticker Taylor?
The-- - Yes.
- Tom Salpherson.
- I think I said Thomas Alfredson,
like he's like from Fish Town.
- The Tommy, the Tommy Alfredson version?
(laughing)
Just, just amazing.
Just another, just great actress.
- Hey, speaking of filmmaking.
- Yeah.
- Speaking of Tommy Alfredson award
for best filmmaking in Chernobyl.
The direction, instead of a photography of this,
is astounding.
- It is.
- Yeah, like every shot,
drips with that kind of internal authenticity
that I was talking about.
- Johan Rank, and we talked about this once before.
You know, you and I remember him as Stackobo
from the early '90s, and his one-hit wonder, here we go.
- I don't remember that.
- That was a big song.
That was a big song.
Like, he was like, remember Lucas with the lid off?
- Oh yeah, he looks like--
- He wasn't that-- - He wasn't that,
but he was like-- - Five Owens.
Fucked up nephew.
- He was a Swedish pop star.
- Yeah. - And had this song.
Anyway, it doesn't matter.
It's bizarre to look at this guy's CV,
and be like, oh, he's a god-leveled genius,
because there's, it's not like he ever did anything bad,
but like he directed an episode of Paul and Catch Fire.
- This guy directed the last Panthers.
- He did Bloodlines, and then he did the last Panthers.
- Goddamn.
And he said he turned down directing
Better Call Saul and Game of Thrones in Homeland,
because he only wanted-- - So did I.
- Yeah.
- I can't prove otherwise.
But no, he's legit, incredible.
Because when the filmmaking,
it's similar praise, so I think that we gave
to Renaldo Market Screen, right?
Where it's like, it is such a unique thing in this era
to see a tour, level, direction,
in a serialized narrative story
that both advances the story.
It doesn't get in the way.
It doesn't make a show of itself,
but is just services so beautifully.
- Yeah.
- It's really a stunning achievement.
And yeah, I mean, his reward is doing the Dune show,
which honestly, following in Denis Villeneuve's footsteps
isn't so bad.
- There's two choices that the creative team here makes
that I think really speaks to the,
maybe somewhat muddled idea.
I'm trying to get across of like,
if you create the reality of your show,
it doesn't matter what the reality outside the show is.
- Yeah.
- One is this choice to have an ensemble of British actors.
- Yes.
- Which I think makes a logical sense
because you start, for me, I was watching
and the reason why you never blink,
even when Emily Watson somewhat slips into like,
minor Ukrainian, you know.
- Did you think?
- I think she has like some accent stuff going on,
but I started thinking of like,
the coal mining industry of England.
And it was very easy for me to transpose
the sort of reality of like English life
to the realities of Russian life.
So there's that.
- But yeah, but that's a great point.
It's a choice.
It's a choice to not have them do Russian accented English.
- Yes.
- And it was also, I have to be honest,
it did throw me because we are in this era
of like, versimilitude and international productions
where they're English actors speaking English,
unaccented, where when all of the typography
around them is inserted.
- Really, yeah.
- But, and all the names, they're like,
they're awesome, you know, like they're--
- Yeah, or they say comrade.
They say things that maybe sound a little better
in the original Klingon, if you know what I mean.
- Sure.
- But it's a very smart choice for the reason you exactly said,
which is that immediately that barrier of like,
we have to admit that this happens.
As soon as someone speaking in other language,
a small barrier is put between us and them.
In the same way, if someone is wearing,
I just said the word I'll say it again,
a Klingon mask or something.
Like this is a little bit of distance.
- Yeah.
- This immediately, there is no denying we understand them.
We are them.
And that was a huge choice that was a successful one.
- And then the decision that Rankin and Mason made
to take something that's set in the mid '80s,
but shoot it like it's a conspiracy thriller
from the '70s.
And so you make something that if you were gonna use
the cinematic language of the time period of when it was set,
would not look like this.
- Yeah.
- You know, it would look cleaner,
it would probably look sharper.
And certainly now with the sort of digital camera,
kind of flattening that's happened,
it wouldn't look like that.
So they make this choice.
I'm sure they shot it on digital or whatever,
but to make that feel like you were watching film stock,
and that it has that tone of all the presidents,
men and parallax view and marathon man
and these kinds of three days of the condor kind of.
- Men with bad ties smoking in rooms.
- Yeah, exactly.
And I think that's just such a brilliant choice.
And that's ultimately what shows are evaluated on
as the choices that they make.
We have that conversation with the sandwich.
Well, you can only evaluate the choices it does make,
not the choices it didn't make,
but I think crucially like this is one of those shows
that I think almost proves Sam's point
where it's like it's the choices that they did make
so that it doesn't matter
that they didn't decide to do certain things.
- Well, let's also just stay on that point of decision making
because I think, I wanna be careful how I say this
because I generally am a fan of the opposite
of what I'm about to talk about.
- Okay.
- And I think the opposite of what I'm about to talk about,
it defines contemporary TV.
And what I mean is a certain welcoming the chaos,
seat of your pants, improvisational bucket will do it
in post attitude.
- Yes.
- That is inherent to TV for a number of reasons.
One of which is that's always been TV.
It's not movies.
It has to air at 8 p.m. on Saturdays or in the old days.
So you just do your best and you move on.
There's another one coming.
It's also the nature of expanding ambition
and not necessarily similarly expanding production schedules
or even budgets despite what we've seen and reported on.
We haven't reported, we've,
we've talked about reporting into microphone sometimes
where you just, you know, everybody's doing their best
to keep up and just hide things and keep the ball moving.
And then also the nature of writers rooms
where you could walk in with a vision
of what your show is gonna be.
And it's not just that the cast might surprise you
or that you might lose a location.
It's that you're with six to eight other people
who are interesting and have their own ideas and perspectives
and they might say something that blows up your story
in a good way.
And for me, that's like, and I'm only gonna say his name
because he's, he's, he's become our friend
and I know he's listening to this
and he wanted us to watch Chernobyl.
But like that chaos energy, I think is what makes
our friend Damon Lindelof's show Watchmen great.
That chaos energy is what makes another friend
of ours Patrick Somerville's station 11 great.
And I think they would say this.
I'm sure knowing those two, they'll hear this as slightly
as an insult and I don't mean it as one.
I mean that there are things in that series
that we sat down and did a podcast about and said,
this is magnificent, this is exhilarating.
This is transformative.
And they would be like, that was an accident.
That almost didn't happen.
Someone came in on the last day and suggested it
and oh my God, it swung everything.
I love that energy.
That's not Chernobyl.
Chernobyl, maybe there's more like Android in this regard.
Chernobyl feels absolutely meticulously considered
- fully formed. - Designed, plotted and executed.
Not just because it seems like Craig Mason
and Luke Hall had a relationship like Tony had with Luke Hall
where it feels like the production design
was in lockstep with the writing.
It's just that confidence of having the beginning be the end
and not feel corny about it.
It's really a wild feeling and a rare one
and a different one to end the first episode
of a series like this and be like,
yeah, we're in the hands of masters here.
Everything about this, they nailed it.
Now I'm sure on his podcast with Peter Segal, Craig Mason,
was like, oh my God, we're flying by the seat of our pants.
We're in fucking with the wind. - Yeah, look away.
That's always the case.
But I think, do you know what I mean by that distinction?
It's like, TV energy to me is different than this
and this was a really compelling contrast.
Never in any way saying it's fundamentally better
'cause some of my favorite things have come
from that kind of happy accident.
But like, it's pretty cool.
It was really, really, really powerful.
- We can wrap it up there.
I think it goes without saying, but I'll say it.
It's just, I think Jared Harris and Scarsgard
as the seniors of this show, but also the leads.
And two guys who I think have done a lot of character work
and rarely gotten to be almost every page of a show
are beautiful, beautiful performances.
And also the sort of arc of their relationship
while I guess traditional and the certain sort of like,
and then they learn to understand each other
was like still magical, you know,
to watch these two guys profoundly changed
by their shared death warrant, essentially,
is really remarkable to watch.
- There's two kinds of exceptional casting,
I think that deserves notice, but one gets more notice.
The one that gets more notice is that,
oh, you saw something in this actor
that we haven't been able to see before
and look what they did.
The other version is, I'm going to cast people
who are perfect for this.
Not to say that they're, you know,
phoning it in or typecast, but like,
Jared Harris has such a unique combination
of being like a classically trained English actor
as father was a big, you know, famous actor and star as well.
But he's also, his energy is so different.
He is not an alpha in the lead, you know?
- That's the whole point of this character too.
- Yes, he was not supposed to be the main character, you know?
And so you cast someone who often isn't meant
meant to be the main character
and you see the way he physically reacts to that.
glare, let alone the boron or xenon poison.
It's also like, I don't think you can do what Charkov does to Lagasov at the end of
the show, which is like the thing I'm going to do to you is worse than death.
I'm going to erase you and you're going to live to see it.
Yeah.
I don't think you can do that to like Tom Hardy, you know, you have to have a guy who looks
like he's taken blows of life.
Yeah, also Tom Hardy would have insisted that Lagasov wear a mask the whole time so he
wouldn't have died.
Like, just to be classic Tom Hardy guy, he would have had like the most elaborate anti-nuclear
mask.
I was born in Chernobyl.
Yeah.
Chris, gun to your head.
Sorry to our KGB friends.
Well, this should have been better with Bane.
He's like, I was born in these pools.
Like, you get called in to Spotify meeting by Daniel Eck and a party guy you've never seen
before, right?
And he's just like.
The screen's not, it's not a one to one, but I'm just saying that he's just like, there's
been a small podcasting accident.
And I need some brave talents to go into the affected water studio studio and fix it.
Okay.
And you know what that means.
Like, you're in that scene when they're like, who's going to go head for, who's going
to go dumpster diving in new quarter, you know?
And then like when someone volunteers, do you think everyone, like, do you think there's
someone in that room who's just like, I'm going to, I'm going to move my arm, but I'm
going to do a real slow.
So like, I'm not bad.
Yeah, I would do that.
But you think, like, that's a wild thing.
Yeah.
But I just think that once you, once you're in that zone, you're probably just like the
clock stick and man, it's time to put up some highlight tape.
I mean, the irradiated zone.
Oh, oh, you mean like, let's, let's be heroes, let's be legends.
Let's burn out.
Not fade away.
Yeah.
How would the four members of Crosby Stills, Nash and Young have fared?
Are we done podcasting now when we start throwing hypotheticals?
Like, which one is the hero?
Uh, God, Eddie, well, we could play Nash.
Oh, yeah.
Later in line.
Yeah.
Alex Burns could play Crosby.
Yeah.
That's true.
All right.
Let's ask us on a very long, uh, strange trip, three and a half years in the making.
Kyle, are you going to watch Chernobyl now?
I watched Chernobyl like three years ago.
Goddamn it.
And yet, did you think it was weird three years ago that we didn't talk about it?
No.
You guys were busy.
Yeah.
That's so nice.
That's nice of you.
I can't believe you just sat here for three and a half years with us and not watching
it.
You're very, very kind.
We will be back on Monday to talk about the last of us on another show that Craig
Mason is currently overseeing and we'll also talk about poker face.
Some exciting stuff coming up down the pike.
Obviously it's super busy March.
So get all your, your season in February, Grimald.
Remember earlier in this podcast, when you were like, go on record with your Fable Mistake
and then at the end, you're like, I haven't seen it.
That was unbelievable.
Let's just, let's just remember that.
Uh, thanks for listening to the watch.
I'm going to go intellectually weep.
The new series 12, 12, 12 is now streaming on Apple TV.
This is the biggest banking highs in the history of Europe.
That's beautiful.
As soon as they realize it's something's missing, we'll reach out on time zones away.
Starring Emmy nominee Anthony Maggie, he's all for me.
And go to Globe nominee Jimmy Dornan.
This is all for our family.
The highest is just the beginning of our starts now, 12, 12, 12, 12.
Now streaming on Apple TV.
Progressive's accident response can contact emergency services if you're in a major accident.
The only thing worse than someone you love being in an accident is not being able to
help them.
So progressive is here to help when you can't.
So get peace of mind knowing your loved ones are protected with Progressive's accident
response.
Learn more at progressive.com.
Progressive casualty insurance company and affiliates limited availability in California
driver is responsible for emergency and towing charges not covered by the policy, coverage
subject to policy terms and conditions.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Rob Harvilla promotes the return of the "60 Songs That Explain the '90s" podcast on Spotify, featuring more songs and guests.
An advertisement features Brian Dawkins discussing his experience with Major Depressive Disorder and a treatment option.
A Carvana commercial highlights the ease of selling a car with a quick online offer.
The podcast episode features hosts Chris Ryan and Andy Greenwald discussing the HBO miniseries "Chernobyl" years after its release.
The hosts also touch on other television news, including trailers for "Succession" season four and the return of "Top Chef" as an international all-star season.
The 2023 Oscar nominations are a major topic, with discussion on the importance of the awards and the nominees for Best Picture.
The hosts debate the merits of films like "Top Gun
The conversation returns to "Chernobyl," praising its high-level execution, its depiction of human behavior in a catastrophe, and its ability to create a consistent and compelling reality.
Summary:
" The conversation then shifts to a lengthy analysis of the 2023 Oscar nominations. The hosts debate the purpose of the Oscars, discussing whether they should celebrate artistic achievement or popular films. They express their thoughts on several Best Picture nominees, including "Top Gun: Maverick," "The Fabelmans," and "Tár," and discuss the implications of the nominations for the film industry.
" The hosts acknowledge they missed the show upon its initial release and explore why. They praise the series for its masterful execution, its ability to create a deeply realized and terrifying reality, and its focus on human behavior during a catastrophe. They also discuss the show's blend of historical fact and artistic license, noting that its power lies in its storytelling rather than its literal accuracy.
FAQs
The main theme is the human response to catastrophe, showing how people cling to their ideologies and plans even in the face of overwhelming danger, and how the reality of disaster is both physically and emotionally devastating.
It creates a deeply realistic 'Chernobyl reality' through meticulous attention to detail, while maintaining a strong tonal consistency that makes the viewer feel immersed in the story, even when the literal events are fictionalized.
The opening starts in media res, showing a disaster in progress with multiple perspectives, which immediately disorients the viewer and effectively introduces the scale and chaos of the nuclear meltdown without familiar tropes.
While both are dystopian and horror-based, Chernobyl is more grounded in historical truth and focuses on human behavior during crisis, whereas The Last of Us relies more on video game-style problem-solving and side quests.
Her character, a composite of real-life figures, represents a moral center who resists authoritarianism and fights for truth, illustrating how individuals can stand up to power during a crisis.
No, the podcast acknowledges some criticism, such as the Westernization of certain characters, but ultimately praises its overall accuracy, emotional depth, and storytelling excellence.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.