724. The Charge of the Light Brigade: Into The Valley of Death (Part 4)
1h 10m 53s
The Charge of the Light Brigade, a pivotal moment in the Crimean War, is a tragic example of military misdirection and flawed command. On October 25, 1854, British forces at Balaclava faced a massive Russian advance, with the causeway heights and Voronzov Road being critical to supply lines. Despite having strong defensive positions, Lord Raglan's vague order—directing the light brigade to "advance and prevent the enemy from carrying away guns"—was misunderstood. Lord Lucan, the cavalry commander, interpreted it as a stand-off, while Lord Cardigan, the light brigade commander, led a reckless charge into a valley where Russian artillery dominated on all sides. The order was fatally ambiguous, and the light brigade, unaware of the danger, charged into a deadly crossfire. Captain Nolan, a cavalry expert, was killed by shrapnel while trying to warn the brigade of the trap. Though the charge succeeded in scattering Russian cavalry and silencing some guns, it cost over 500 men and 500 horses, with only 195 survivors. Strategically, the British lost control of the vital Voronzov Road, disrupting supply routes. The event became a legendary paradox—celebrated as a display of courage but condemned as a devastating blunder. Lord Lucan was scapegoated and later cleared, while Cardigan retired in disgrace. The incident profoundly shaped historical memory, with Alfred Tennyson’s poem immortalizing the event as a symbol of both glory and folly. It remains a powerful lesson in the necessity of clear, decisive command in warfare.
This episode is brought to you by Revolut.
Standing still leaves no legacy.
History is written by progress, by revolution.
Fighting for independence, dismantling those broken systems, defying injustice.
Every revolution begins with the refusal to accept the norm.
A demand for more.
And Revolut is founded on the same principle.
Originally established to push back the frontiers of traditional banking,
it puts the power back into your hands.
You can manage all of your money in one app.
Plus, you can earn while you spend with the RevPoints reward system.
As a fully authorised UK bank, your money is FSCS protected.
Sign up to Revolut today at revolut.com forward slash T-R-I-H.
That's all lowercase.
And. You'll get £20 after the first time that you spend.
18+.
End date and promotion T's and C's apply.
And RevPoints T's and C's apply.
Cannon to right of them.
Cannon to left of them.
Cannon behind them volleyed and thundered.
Stormed at with shock.
Shot and shell.
While horse and hero fell.
They that had fought so well came through the jaws of death.
Back from the mouth of hell.
All that was left of them.
Left of 600.
When can their glory fade?
Oh, the wild charge they made.
All the world wandered.
Honour the charge they made.
Honour the Light Brigade.
Noble 600.
So, welcome everybody to The Rest is History.
It is dawn on the 25th of October, 1854.
And this is the day when the Light Brigade will make the most famous,
the most heroic and the most calamitous cavalry charge in British,
surely, world history.
And that reading, of course, was from the great poem by Alfred Lord Tennyson.
And Tennyson was motivated to write It Wasn't He, Tom?
by reading a report.
In The Times, Britain's newspaper of record, about the charge at Balaclava.
Only very top people write for The Times, don't they, Dominic?
Only top people either read The Times or write for The Times.
And a very top person had written this report.
Somebody we mentioned before on the show, and that was William Howard Russell.
Yes.
So, he is the first correspondent to be employed by a British newspaper to cover an entire campaign,
not just in detail, but on location.
And without Russell's report,
of The Charge of the Light Brigade,
there probably would have been no poem by Tennyson.
And I think that without Tennyson's poem,
we probably wouldn't be doing this podcast,
because The Charge of the Light Brigade wouldn't have the resonance that Tennyson's poem gave it.
You know, I was thinking about this,
and reflecting that this is what makes The Charge of the Light Brigade
a really amazing historical topic,
because it's simultaneously an event for which we have incredibly detailed sources,
kind of really looking forward to the depth,
of source material that you have for 20th century history.
But it's also a theme that's been burnished by this incredible poem into a legend.
And it's the combination of the two that makes it such a distinctive topic.
It's a great topic.
It's a great topic.
So, let's set the context.
So, we ended last time with The Great Cliffhanger.
The Battle of Balaclava is about to begin.
And you described last time the link between Balaclava,
which is this, you know, formerly kind of bucolic seaside town that's been taken over by,
you know, the dysentery-plagued British,
and Sebastopol, which is the great naval base,
the great Crimean naval base that is the headquarters for Russia's Black Sea Fleet.
Of course, the Russian Black Sea Fleet is based in Crimea to this day.
And Sebastopol is the target.
But Tombalaclava is so important because it is basically the lifeline to the sea for the British, isn't it?
Yeah.
So, it's just a very small port,
and it's,
it's on the side of a narrow inlet,
which is almost like a fjord.
And it is,
as you say,
absolutely the key to the British war effort,
because it's the only link that the British army in the Crimea,
and specifically in the siege positions outside Sebastopol,
have to the outside world.
And if they lose it,
then they will lose contact with the Royal Navy,
with their supply ships,
and with everything that they need to maintain the siege.
So, effectively,
the equation is,
lose Balaclava,
and the siege of Sebastopol will effectively be over.
And basically, the war.
Yes.
And the British, of course,
are not alone in realizing this,
because the Russians have realized it too.
And this is why,
by the 24th of October,
a huge Russian army has amassed at a village called Chorgon,
which is some five miles as the crow flies to the northeast of Balaclava.
And it's a very strong force.
So, there's some 20,000 infantry,
some 3,000 soldiers,
some 2,400 cavalry,
78 guns.
It's a very menacing force.
That said,
the challenge facing the Russians is considerable.
And this is a matter less of troop numbers,
because the British are outnumbered on the field of Balaclava,
about five to one,
than of the terrain.
Because the approach from Chorgon to Balaclava
is not at all an easy one to negotiate.
And at this point,
if you are watching on YouTube,
I am anticipating that a map will have flashed up.
Surely.
If it hasn't,
and definitely if you are listening to this on the podcast,
I am now going to attempt to paint a picture of the landscape for you with the magic of words.
This is so exciting.
Everyone's looking forward to this.
So finally,
the rest is geography has become a reality.
You are going to give us the rest is Crimean geography.
Yeah.
And massive excitement because the word escarpment is going to fail.
Feature and you always know that you're you're on the brink of a battle when the word escarpment features.
Yeah.
So imagine that you are looking at a map or sheet of a four or something Balaclava.
This little fjord like port is at the bottom and on the left hand of the mat.
So the left hand side of the paper,
imagine that there is a very high plateau and this is the plateau that stands between Balaclava and Sebastopol to the to the west.
Yeah.
So the eastern edge of the plateau.
So this is looking out over the landscape in which the battle of Balaclava is going to be fought.
This is the escarpment.
It's very,
very high 700 to 800 feet high.
And these are called the Sapunae Heights.
And this is the vantage point from which Lord Raglan when he gets the summons that the battle is starting,
he's been camped out in a farmhouse about four miles from this escarpment.
So midway between.
Balaclava and Sebastopol.
And he gets the call and he comes running to the Sapunae Heights.
And from here he will look at the day's proceedings.
He will watch the battle unfolding below him as will William Russell,
the Times correspondent.
And in his report for the battle,
he describes being on these heights as being like in the box of a theater from where the field of Balaclava was as plainly seen as the stage.
So he has this all this landscape spread out below him and he thinks that the view is stunning.
He describes it as a panorama.
It's a panorama of exceeding beauty.
A picture of green valley and plains framed with mountain ridges on all sides.
So the view is incredible.
If you were up on the Sapunae Heights,
you can basically see everything spread below you.
Imagine you're standing on the Sapunae Heights looking out over this battlefield.
Look to your right towards the south.
This is where the sea is.
So you've got the Crimean coastline and you've got Balaclava itself.
Then above Balaclava,
there is an expanse of level terrain,
which the British called the south.
Valley.
Okay.
Beyond that.
So this is now directly below where Raglan and Russell and everybody will be standing.
Yeah.
You have a low rounded ridge called the Causeway Heights.
And this is the ridge along which the Voronsov Road runs.
And this is the metal road.
It's the only metal road in the region.
So it's crucial for communications between Balaclava and Sebastopol and is of vital importance to the British.
Beyond that,
these Causeway Heights,
there is another valley,
the North Valley.
And beyond the North Valley,
there are more heights,
the Fedyukin Heights.
And I know that all this is quite complicated.
But again,
just to reiterate,
because it's important for understanding how the rhythms of the battle and particularly where the light brigade are going to be charging.
You're looking at the map.
You've got Balaclava at the bottom.
Then you've got a valley.
Then you've got a ridge.
And these are the South Valley,
the Causeway Heights,
the North Valley,
the Fedyukin Heights.
So just to be clear,
if you're in the battlefield at any given point,
if you're down there.
Yeah.
Your view of things is blocked by the fact that there's valleys and ridges and valleys and ridges.
So you can't see what's over the ridges.
Yes.
You can't necessarily see what is on the top of the Causeway Heights.
Right.
Exactly.
If you are on the Sapunae Heights,
800 feet above them,
you can see everything.
Yeah.
Because Lord Raglan is watching from the side,
like it says,
like he's watching action on a stage, he can see all the valleys laid out below him.
but the people down there can't see these things which is an absolutely central thing to get in
your heads to understand why the charge of the library gate happens yes right so this is the
situation and if you think the the russians are they're approaching the kind of the the opening
of of the north valley um from the northeast right and they occupy the fedyakun heights which
are the the heights that run if you imagine at the top of the map so on the northern side of the
north valley um and they occupy this with 5 000 troops and about 10 to 14 heavy guns yeah others
at the um foot of the north valley and their aim is to start capturing the redoubts that have been
built along the causeway heights and these causeway heights are kind of a natural defensive
line screening balaclava from the advancing russians and these heights are are therefore
a key strategic objective for the russians because they're blocking their advance
on the north valley and they're not going to be able to get to the north valley and they're not
on balaclava and there's no prospect that the russians can capture balaclava unless they capture
the causeway heights conversely the british their goal is to stop the russians from taking the
causeway heights and so therefore we should now come to what defenses do the british have lined up
to stop this russian advance so to repeat the british are massively outnumbered there is a
garrison stationed for the protection of balaclava but it's it's much smaller than the russian
attacking force but it's much smaller than the russian attacking force
because most of the british forces are in the siege lines facing sebastopol so as dawn breaks
on the 25th of october there are three main bodies of troops who have been stationed to
defend the approaches to balaclava and the first body is positioned on the causeway heights this
natural ridge which runs between the north and the south valleys and this is occupied by around
a thousand turkish troops who are under the command of british artillery officers and we
mentioned at the end of the previous episode there are six earthwork redoubts here yeah
escarpments redoubts we've got we've got everything and these have been dug along the length of the
ridge and four of these redoubts have been equipped with guns that have been brought from royal navy
ships and dragged up from balaclava and placed within these redoubts on the causeway heights
and the most formidable of these redoubts is the most easterly one so in other words the redoubt
that is directly in the line of the russian advance
and the site of this redoubt had been identified as the key strategic point that the british should
try to hold actually not by raglan but by the the new french commander-in-chief um general can
robert yeah he'd come and he said this is the place that you really need to fortify and so as
a result it's named by the british can robert hill can robert hill very good and so imagine
that you got through all these redoubts there's then another line of defense isn't there and this
is our old friends the highlanders so it's great to have some scottish
history on the show yes and this is just one of the three highland regiments so this is the 93rd
highlanders and the other two have been sent by raglan to um take part in the siege of sebastopol
and they are stationed just south of the causeway heights so above balaclava and they're in a
village called catechoi um and they are directly across the road that leads down from the causeway
heights to balaclava so a key line of defense and then finally there is the cavalry the light
and the heavy brigades both of them they're stationed in the south valley like the highlanders
are and they are just northwest of catechoi and they are positioned where the causeway heights
meets the foot of the sapune heights the cavalry is stationed kind of at the point where the two
heights meet so they're sort of towards the bottom left of the map if you're looking down at it right
yes and they are under the command of lord lucan who is a man desperate to prove himself
because he knows that the cavalry are chafing at the bit to have a crack at the russians
and he knows that they blame him very unfairly for keeping them on a kind of insanely tight leash
because in fact this is the doing of lord raglan the british commander and raglan's reason for not
wanting to allow the cavalry to go sweeping off and having adventures is because they're much
depleted by disease and raglan doesn't want to risk losing them but lucan gets the blame for this
and so we said in the previous episode he's been nicked
named lord look on it's unfair but yeah you know war isn't fair dominic no and lucan is conscious
of this though isn't he so he has been you know it's nagging at him the whole time and he's been
working his men especially hard in the build-up to the charge of the light brigade yes and so
on the morning of the 25th of october as he's been doing pretty much every morning since they've
arrived in the south valley he's been getting his men up at five o'clock to stand beside their horses
and be inspected so this is the light brigade
brigade the heavy brigade all the cavalry all the cavalry except for one man and that is
that is the commander of the light brigade who is lord cardigan and he is still tucked up on his
yacht you know as this parade is going on yeah i mean he's there with his french cook and his great
mate mr de burr aka the squire oh the absolute legend the ledge so the cardigan is french cook
and the squire are all asleep on the yacht right and cardigan has been nicknamed the noble yachtsman
so you've got lord look on and the noble yachtsman brilliant so meanwhile lucan is you know he's very
busy very responsible very proactive he's done this parade and then he and his staff officers
they canter along the south valley um at the foot of the causeway heights towards can robert hill
which is the most easterly and most strategically significant of these redoubts and as they're
approaching it the sun is kind of hinting at dawn and so the light is improving and they can
observe through the gloom that up on can robert heights there's not one flag flying but two
and this is a signal pre-arranged signal that the enemy have been seen approaching
and as lucan and his staff notice this there is this massive crash of artillery from can roberts
hill and it is then answered by another crash from the russian gun
beyond the causeway heights and it's a signal that the enemy is indeed approaching it is six
o'clock in the morning and it is evident that a great battle is beginning so for the next 90
minutes or so this battle rages and the focus at this point is can robert hill right they've got a
turkish garrison and british officers yeah and the turk has been much underrated he has earlier in
this series because of his abomination
but actually this turns out to be a massive misreading of the fighting pluck of the of
johnny turk yes the turk puts up a very good show and as you say for an hour and a half
giving the russians what for superb but ultimately they're too exposed and they're too far
to the east of the main body of the british forces to get substantial reinforcements
and so by 7 30 the defenses of can robert hill are starting to give way
and the russians break in and they slaughter perhaps a third of the turkish garrison the rest
managed to escape down the side of the ridge into the south valley the british commander spikes the
guns that he's being forced to leave behind in can robert hill and then he joins the retreat
and the cossacks surge down the side of the hill cutting down the retreating turks which is what
light cavalry is meant to do when you see retreating soldiers this is what the light
brigade had failed to do after the battle of alma and meanwhile
the turkish soldiers are being forced to leave behind in can robert hill and the cossacks surge
into the front of the ridge to try and capture them and seize control of the entire length of
the causeway heights so the british can see this happening and they are frantically preparing for
the onslaught that they now know is to come because there is nothing really between them
and the russians the full might of the russian army is soon to descend on these massively outnumbered
forces meanwhile up on the sapunae heights raglan and his staff are arriving they've been alerted to
what is going on and they turn up and there below them spread out you know like a 3d map is the
battlefield and shortly afterwards they are joined by can robert the french general commander-in-chief
and his deputy general bosque who is the guy who stormed the heights at the battle of alma and can
robert and raglan consult and they agree that this is looking very ominous and therefore there
is an urgent need to send reinforcements down to balaclava they agree that they can spare 10 000
infantry plus the only cavalry that the french have this just recently arrived and this is a
brigade called the chasseur d'afrique and their light cavalry they're mounted on very small hardy
horses so habituated to the landscape of algeria and they wear light blue tunics red trousers and
red kp so they're going to be able to do a lot of work and they're going to be able to do a lot of
work and they're very dashing so you know this will be very helpful for the british if these
reinforcements can get down from the heights to the low valleys below in time but there is a problem
this descent is going to take around two hours so the british forces that are down in the south
valley effectively are going to have to hold out for at least a couple of hours and this means that
effectively there are only two lines of defense between the russians and the british forces
and Balaclava
and this is the 93rd Highlander's
under the command of Sir Colin Campbell, and the cavalry under the command of Lord Lucan.
So the huge question which Raglan and Canrobert are nervously asking themselves,
are these lines of defense going to hold? Are they going to be enough to prevent the Russians from
sweeping them aside and seizing Balaclava and effectively thereby ending the war?
And Russell is watching Raglan and notes that he's normally a very imperturbable man.
Raglan is palpably nervous. He's very fidgety, very fretful, as well he might have been,
because shortly after nine o'clock, they can see a great mass of Russian cavalry
starting to mass on the causeway heights above the southern plain and descend along the road
towards Balaclava.
Towards Balaclava, towards Campbell's Highlanders. And this is the massive crisis point for the battle
and perhaps for the whole of the Crimean War. Because everyone on the heights can see just how
massively outnumbered the Highlanders are. And they can see exactly the scale of what is
confronting Campbell's Highlanders. Are the Highlanders going to let them down? Well, we will see.
Now, it's the norm when cavalry attack infantry for the infantry to form squares. So famously,
this is what happens at the Battle of Waterloo. But listeners who heard our previous episode may
remember that at the Battle of the Alma, Campbell and his men had discovered just how lethal this
new rifle that they've been issued with is. It's incredibly penetrative. It can cover much
further distances than the muskets that the Russians have. It's really, really good. And so
Campbell, rather than forming a square, instead orders his men to form two lines and to just fire
and fire and fire, because this is then capitalizing the amount of firepower that they have. And he
knows that his men are nervous about this because they feel very, very vulnerable facing this great
mass of cavalry. And they're only two lines thick. And so he addresses his force with great sternness.
Remember, there is no retreat from here, men. You must die where you stand.
This is a very Teodros-style inspiration, isn't it? But it works. In this case,
it works, I suppose, because in this case, they have these amazing rifles.
Yeah. And they fire volley after volley after volley into the Russian cavalry before the Russian
cavalry can reach them. And the Russian cavalry is so stunned by, you know, we described it
earlier. This is almost like kind of machine guns being fired. They're stunned by the experience of
it. And they wheel away and they retreat. And the Highlanders have done it. They've
held the road that leads down to Balaclava. And Russell, in his report for The Times, I mean,
he describes this in very memorable terms. He writes, you know, these were heroes, that thin
red streak topped with a line of steel. And in the memories of the newspaper reading Public of
Britain, this gets shortened to the thin red line. And that's a very, you know, it's an evocative
phrase that is still used to this day. So very, very memorable and all credit to the Highlanders.
They've pulled it off. But. But there are more heroics that need doing because there's still a lot of cavalry out there. And they
may have retreated from the line of the Highlanders. But there are other ways down to Balaclava. They
could outflank them. But these positions are held by the heavy brigade. And a great mass of cavalry
is approaching the heavy brigade by this point, sweeping down from the causeway heights as they
had done against the Highlanders. Again, looking to capture Balaclava. And just as the Highlanders
had done, waiting for the Highlanders to come, they're going to capture Balaclava. And just as
they had done, waiting very coolly for the enemy to arrive, so the heavy brigade do. And with immense
composure, they hold their ground. And then there's a blast on the trumpet, a second blast. And then
there's a third blast. And the heavy brigade charge up the causeway heights. I mean, an amazing thing
to do. Heavy cavalry normally don't charge up heights. And they crash into the Russian line.
And they are led by this splendid man, Sir James Scarlet. So very red face, Scarlet face, white
moustache.
Much loved by his men. And he is at the head of the brigade. So he reaches the Russians first,
then his staff, and then the rest of the front line. And Raglan and everybody else is watching
a high up on the Sapunae Heights. And it seems to them that Scarlet and the front line of the
heavy brigade have been completely swallowed up by the great grey tide of Russian horsemen.
And they worry that they've been completely wiped out. But then, I mean, a thrilling,
moment. They see tiny red dots moving among the grey. And it is Scarlet and his front line. And then
there's another line of the heavy brigade that crashes into the Russian battle line. And then
another. And this second line is the Scots Greys. The third line is the Inniskillings. These are the
same regiments that had ridden to glory at Waterloo in the Union Brigade. And they are reliving,
recapturing that moment of glory anew on the battlefield.
Of Balaclava. And there's this great, desperate, brutal melee. And then after 10 minutes,
astonishingly, the Russians break. And they withdraw. And it is maybe even more than the
thin red line. I mean, this is the most heroic and improbable triumph. And perhaps the greatest
tribute that is paid to the achievement of Scarlet and his men comes from someone who was watching it
a mere 500 yards away. And it's a great tribute. a mere 500 yards away directly on the russian's flank and this was lord cardigan the noble yachtsman
he's deigned to join he's deigned to turn up and to join the battle but has he brought the squire
with him that's the question no the squire's been left behind because he's just a civilian he's a
legend but he's a civilian but cardigan i mean he he's a very brave man i mean you know he's been
hanging out on his yacht but he's been dying to have a go at the russians yeah and there he is
astride his warhorse one old yeah at the head of the light brigade we've forgotten to punctuate
this narrative with sufficient posh laughter ho ho so he is muttering to his staff those
damned heavies will have the love of us this day ho ho ho and he's jealous he's he's saying you
know these guys have won amazing things why can't we do the same and he's devoured by impatience
he's frantic to join the action but he believes that his brother-in-law and superior officer
Lord Lucan, whom he hates, has ordered him on no account to attack the Russians. And because by
this point, Cardigan is determined not to give Lucan any opportunity to ball him out, he stands
his ground. And this is a catastrophic error. Because had he seized the initiative, had he
shown enterprise, had he led the light brigade against the retreating Russians, he might well
have succeeded in annihilating them and winning them one of the great cavalry victories of all
time. But he doesn't because he thinks he's had this order from Lucan. Lucan rides up and is
furious and claims that he'd never given this order. Cardigan stands his ground and says,
yes, you did. Lucan says, no, I didn't. Cardigan says, yes, you did. They have this massive
blazing row. And meanwhile, the Russians are moving off and the opportunity to wipe them out
is lost and the more experienced among the light brigade those who have read captain nolan's books
on cavalry oh yeah his work work horsemanship yeah but i mean captain nolan is very big on the
fact that light cavalry must pursue broken heavy cavalry and wipe them out and so they read this
and they know this those in the light brigade who know their cavalry warfare yeah are really cut up
about this you know they had this chance and it's just completely gone begging you know they've
Of course, the other person who is agonisingly aware of this is Captain Nolan himself, who is up on the Sapuna Heights with Lord Raglan. He's been looking down and he's been tearing his hair out. And remember, this is a guy who believes there is nothing that cavalry can't do if it's well led.
Nolan is looking down and saying, well, the noble yachtsman, Lord, look on. These guys are absolutely terrible. They're absolutely hopeless. And he's steaming. And actually, he's not the only person to feel that the cavalry could be doing more.
Because amazingly, for the first time in the entire course of the Crimean War up to this point, Lord Raglan is starting to think this as well. And I think it's the spectacle of the heavy brigade's great triumph that has slightly changed Raglan.
Because I think that from his vantage point up on the heights, he can sense something that Lucan can't or Cardigan, which is that the Russians are palpably demoralised by what's happened, that their defeat at the hands of the Thid Red Line and of the heavy brigade.
And he can sense looking down at them as they're kind of milling around that they are ripe for the plucking. And so accordingly, he sends Lucan an order by dispatch rider to advance and to recapture the redoubts.
So he sends this order. The problem is that as is ever the case with Lord Raglan, he has expressed himself ambiguously. And the dispatch rider hands over the order.
order to Lucan and Lucan misunderstands what Raglan wants. Lucan is trying to puzzle Raglan's
meaning and of course he also you know he's had all these previous orders from Raglan telling him
on no account is he to attack the enemy and so that influences his interpretation of Raglan's
order and he takes it to mean that he is to await the descent of the infantry reinforcements from
the heights the ones that are coming down to join them and on no account to attack the Russians
before these infantry reinforcements have arrived which is exactly the opposite of what Raglan has
meant so there's a kind of confusion. This is on Raglan ultimately though isn't it? I think it is.
I mean this is Raglan's ambiguity and he's you know if the commander is not clear that's that's
on him. But this of course is not how Raglan sees it because he's up on the heights he's waiting for
Lucan to lead the cavalry and sweep the Russians from their causeway heights and quarter of an
hour passes and then half an hour and then three quarters of an hour and still the cavalry are
doing nothing and so there's
general consternation and then abruptly Raglan sees something that really does make his blood
run cold and this is a fateful moment because he can tell that the Russians on the causeway
heights are getting ready to remove the captured British guns from the redoubts and this is a
disaster because to lose guns to the enemy is universally recognized as a mark of defeat
and worse it is widely believed across the British army that the Duke of Wellington who had been
Raglan's great mentor and hero had never lost a gun in combat and so Raglan thinks oh god I cannot
allow this to happen I cannot allow the Russians to take away these captured guns and so he
summons one of his generals a man called Richard Airy and orders him to write down an order and
this is the order fateful order Lord Raglan wishes the cavalry to advance rapidly to the front follow
the enemy and try to prevent the enemy carrying away the guns and Airy's aide-de-camp is none other
than Captain Nolan and Nolan realizes that with this order Lords Lucan and Cardigan are going to
have no excuse you know they are going to be committed at last to action and so he insists on
carrying it down to Lord Lucan personally himself and remember he is the best horseman in the British
army and so because of that he backs himself he's not going to take the winding road that leads down
the side of the escarpment he's going to ride right down the face of the escarpment and it
takes him 10 minutes to do this to go down the escarpment to reach the bottom to gallop across
the north valley where Lucan had stationed himself between his two brigades the light
brigade and the heavy brigade and to deliver Raglan's order directly into Lucan's hands
and Lucan takes the order and he reads it and he frowns in bewilderment and then he reads it very
slowly and methodically again and then he looks up and his expression is one of utter puzzlement
he's got no idea what
the order means well the stage is set for the greatest disaster or the most heroic disaster
in British military history and we'll find out what the order means or what Lucan thinks it might
mean after the break this episode is brought to you by Anthropic the team behind Claude has there
ever been an occasion where you've watched something an episode perhaps and you just wish
that you could know more about it Tom
the genuine he has as you know it was recently half term and nothing says a half-term holiday
than a trip to the Baltic states I went with Sandbrook jr to Vilnius and Riga and I became
completely obsessed with the Grand Duchy of Lithuania the Grand Duchy of Lithuania for people
who don't know it covered what's now Lithuania Belarus western Ukraine and I was really interested
to read more about it because I know nothing about the history of this exotic and glamorous part of
the world and so I went and I asked Claude tell me everything that I need to know about the Grand
Duchy of Lithuania and it did it was brilliant incredible so if you want to know more about
Lithuania or if you want to know about anything at all go to Claude it's a thinking partner you
know it has the cumulative wisdom of the whole of humanity like a podcast host exactly like a
podcast like like you and me Dominic and you can discover more about Claude at claude.ai slash rest
is history
we are getting a statement from number 10 on that flight with 350 passengers
the great game strategic struggle between Britain and Russia
we assess uh prime minister with high confidence it was Russian holding the Russians accountable
is world war three they took down a British passenger jet containing 350 people man in the
Kremlin
he's playing Alex you've got to ask yourself you want to play or not you're the prime minister
you've done nothing
we would need to understand the policy context all the relevant context will be structured as
a framework today and disseminated into an operation order or frago
a frago that says to kill the president of Russia yes
an audio drama journey like no other men like Duffy they are our most valuable weapons
devised as a technically rigorous geopolitical action thriller where Britain plays its
strongest hand he's the best against its strongest foe bear hunt available now wherever you get your
podcasts
you
,
you
welcome back to the rest is history Lord Waglen wishes the cavalry to advance rapidly to the front
follow the enemy and try to prevent the enemy carrying away the guns so Tom this is the order
that is handed by Captain Nolan to Lord Lucan on the 25th of October 1854 this is the order that sets
in motion the great drama of the charge of the light brigade now when Lord Lucan first read the
order he was puzzled he read it again then he looked up and he was completely confused he's
confused because as is always the way with Lord Waglen he has not expressed himself clearly and
the key question is about the guns isn't it so what are these guns yeah which guns Lord Lucan is
stationed at the end of the North Valley and he's directly at the foot of the Sapunae Heights where
he is he can't actually see any guns so the ridge of the causeway Heights where the Russians are
busy moving the captured British naval guns he can't see it it's invisible to him there's no
there's no indication that there are guns up there Lucan turns to Nolan and he says attack sir attack
what what guns sir and Nolan in replying does not bother to hide his utter contempt for Lucan and he
waves vaguely with his hand towards the east towards the distant Russian positions and he says
there my lord is your enemy there are your guns but to repeat Lucan cannot see the guns on the
causeway Heights the guns that Raglan has
you know ordered him to go and rescue the only guns that can be seen from the top of the North
Valley are those at the far end of the valley just over a mile away the Russian positions
and it's a very menacing battery the sun can be seen glinting off their massive barrels
very very intimidating it would be mad to charge them particularly because
masked behind these guns are the Russian cavalry that had been
routed earlier by the heavy brigade an hour and a half previously and adding to the emotions of
confusion alarm that Lucan is clearly feeling at this point he knows that there are also guns
to the left on the Fedya Kuhn Heights and to the right of course up on the causeway Heights
because the British guns can be turned and aimed at anyone charging down this valley
towards the Russian batteries at the far end of the North Valley
so it is patently a death trap
some people have been watching this on YouTube so they'll hopefully see the map
you know I'm looking at a map right now for people who are just listening to us the podcast effectively
they could have gone up to the causeway Heights to try to you know capture this redoubt back or
whatever or at least stop the Russians carrying off the guns to recapture the British guns yeah
to recapture the guns that the Russians have taken from this redoubt but Lucan can't even see that
and he is looking down this valley the only guns he can see are at the end of this valley
and what is worse there are guns on either side of the valley as well so if he were to just
suddenly just charge off down the valley there would be guns fired at him from three sides
his men would be completely massacred the problem is however that these are his orders
and you can't disobey a direct order from you know the the commander of of the army in which
you're fighting no and so lucan it comes as such a surprise to him because raglan has spent the
entire war not allowing them to go anywhere near yeah you know a russian and now suddenly he's
saying go into this death trap and be blown to pieces by guns ahead of you on your left and on
your right but he's you know orders are orders and so he draws up his plans and he decides that
the first wave of the attack will be led by the light brigade and he will then follow at the head
of the heavy brigade and so he crosses over to lord cardigan and gives cardigan his orders and
cardigan salutes and then an amazing moment because cardan is a massive stickler for etiquette it kind
of absolutely dominates all his waking moments but he at this point he does something remarkable
he objects to the orders that he has been given and he says to lucan allow me to point out to
you that the russians have a battle in the valley on our front and batteries and riflemen on both
sides to which lucan replies i know it but lord raglan will have it we have no choice but to obey
and at this cardigan salutes with his sword and he says nothing more to lucan and i think this is a
two men had got on better yeah if they didn't loathe and detest each other if they had a
sympathetic understanding they might at this point look here johnny do you not think this is a
palpably foolish command maybe there are other guns could we not consult with nolan but they
don't do this no consult with the mere captain never i don't know i think that the the mutual
hostility between card and lucan at this point is not helping them a fatal hostility a fatal
hostility yeah and as a result of that the the light brigade prepares to ride to its doom and
cardigan draws it up um in two lines and as he does so he mutters well here goes the last of the
bruden elves so the bruden elves are cardigan's family name but aside from that he displays the
utmost song for oh he's actually redeeming himself now this is his moment he's brave as a lion his
men call him
and also it's a task that requires absolutely no tactical acumen whatsoever
yeah it just requires him to do something completely insane and if you want someone to do
something completely insane lord cardigan is your man and this is his hour of glory and so he places
himself in advance of his front line and he draws his sword and he raises it and a single trumpet
and in a calm voice lord cardigan gives the light brigade their orders the brigade will advance
walk march twat so not gallop twat his men admire him hugely you know they are ready to do as he
says there's no question of any of them mutinying or complaining you know they will do what their
commander wants and even their staff officers who are much more lord cardigan skeptical they're
important to them and they're going to do what their commander wants and even their staff officers
are going to do what their commander wants and even their staff officers are impressed by him and one of
them later said that he seemed the very incarnation of bravery and he's sitting there upright in his
saddle never once looking back and his uniform is an absolutely brilliant blaze of blue and gold and
of course cherry pink and his men too i mean they don't cut quite as brave a dash as cardigan because
of course they've been camped out in mud and the effects of dysentery for the past few weeks unlike
cardigan and his men who are not as brave as cardigan and his men who are not as brave as cardigan
who's been getting laundry service on his yacht but they make a splendid show as well and they are
the best trained the best drilled the best equipped light horsemen in the world and now is their moment
and as they start advancing everyone says later this strange hush seemed to fall on the valley
so that everyone could hear the the jingle of bits and the uh the kind of the rhythmic pounding
of the horse's hooves and the
they advance at a stately pace not galloping as though they're on a kind of parade ground at hide
park or something and then suddenly as they advance there is a great crash from the guns
ahead of them more than a mile away at the head of the valley and simultaneously there is a really
extraordinary incident captain nolan who has received permission to ride with the light brigade
in its front line so this is you know he doesn't want to miss out on the action as he sees where the
brigade is moving towards towards the guns at the end of the north valley he suddenly gallops
forwards out of position and he rides diagonally and he crosses in front of lord cardigan and he
turns in his saddle and he waves his sword and he starts to yell something but the problem is there
is now suddenly crashing of the guns not just from ahead of them but to their left and to their right
and nobody can hear what he is saying and so the assumption must be that he has
realized the full horror of the mistake of the confusion of the misunderstanding that has taken
place and he is trying to rectify the disaster as he is yelling as he is not being heard a russian
shell explodes directly to the right of lord cardigan who is you know at the head of the troop
and a fragment of shrapnel rips off and it hits nolan directly in the chest and it exposes his
chest and his beating heart and the sword falls and nolan is shot dead and he is shot dead and
falls from his hand but very eerily his arm stays aloft and his body upright and rigid in his saddle
and the horse wheels and gallops backwards through the lines of the advancing light cavalry
and as it does so this terrible unearthly shriek is coming out from nolan's open mouth i mean an
incredibly chilling sound and then the horse gallops out at the back of the cavalry
and nolan falls from his saddle and he's quite dead and what does cardigan make of this does
cardigan ponder oh perhaps he's trying to alert me to a possible error here or does cardigan
assume that nolan had been trying to seize the command from him and that this is the most
outrageous affront and the most monstrous display of insubordination and does he spend the whole
charge down to one and that is the most outrageous affront and the most monstrous display of
insubordination and that is the most outrageous affront and the most outrageous affront and the
most outrageous affront and the most outrageous affront and the most outrageous affront and the
russian guns chuntering about it said to quote cecil woodham smith asked later what he thought
about as he advanced towards the guns he replied that his mind was entirely occupied with anger
against nolan that's absolutely insane from lord cardigan that as cardigan is leading the charge
of the light brigade is what he is thinking about what was nolan doing coming and yelling at me
this ghastly jumped up captain yes he's kind of muttering about it under his breath he's absolutely
furious about it's the only thing you can think about anyway he continues at this parade ground
kind of pace this this this rhythmic trot i mean that's the extraordinary thing they're not galloping
right they're proceeding you know with in a very measured way at this stage understandably as the
cannon fire is whistling all around and people are dropping from their horses the horses are
being blown up whatever there are some in the front line who do start to gallop and cardigan
isn't having this and he puts his sword out and says steady steady because they have to
maintain perfect discipline you know form requires that you advance a twat and you don't gallop until
the very last moment and so they trot as you say the shells are raining down at them at this point
and they are starting to be mown down what meanwhile is going up on the heights where lord
wagland is watching this i mean there is stunned horror raglan is appalled he can't believe what
he's seeing but there is also a kind of
stupefied sense of admiration so russell who's up there and will write about this and this is the
report that will influence tennyson we could hardly believe the evidence of our senses
surely that handful of men were not going to charge an army in position
alas it was but too true their desperate valor knew no bounds and the most famous
comment on it is made by general bosque who's with the french command say magnifique
mais c'est pas la guerre it is magnificent but it's not war and this i think down in what is
fast becoming the valley of death is something that lucan has realized as well so he's at the
head of the of the heavy brigade um the heavy brigade are much slower horses than the light
brigade have and of course they're exhausted by their previous charge they've had this kind of
battle and so they start lagging far behind the light brigade and this means that lucan can see
the full scale of the
disaster that is starting to manifest itself and he like cardigan is an absolute model of courage
he's completely indifferent to the fire that is starting to rain down on him and his brigade by
now and even one of his haters later acknowledges damn him he's brave um he gets wounded in the leg
but he displays no pain whatsoever and instead he turns to his aid and he says they have sacrificed
the light brigade they shall not the heavy if i can help it
And so he halts their charge, the heavy brigade come to a stop,
And they sit there helplessly as they watch the light brigade ride on alone into the valley
and then vanish into the smoke of the Russian battery that lies at the far end of the valley.
But there is one cavalry unit, though, that helps the light brigade, isn't there?
Which is the French.
The French, yes.
These are the Chasseurs d'Afrique.
So this is the brigade of light cavalry that have been serving in Algeria
and who finally made it down from the plateau high above.
And they make for the Fedyakin Heights.
So these are the heights that are on the left-hand side of the valley as the light brigade charged down.
And they perform magnificently.
They sweep the Fedyakin Heights clean of Russian gunners and of the infantry.
And this is really significant because it means that such survivors of the light brigades charge as there are
when and if they manage to make it back up the valley,
they will only have the guns on the causeway heights to deal with.
So they will be in much less danger for that reason.
But I suppose the question is, you know, are there going to be any survivors?
Because by now, eight minutes have passed since the light brigade began their advance into the valley of death.
And at last, those who are still left in their saddles are ready to gallop.
And the charge begins.
And ahead of them through the smoke, they can now see the whites of the eyes of the Russian gunners.
And as they gaze into the eyes of the Russian gunners abruptly,
there is this most massive roar.
And there's a great vomiting of flame and the whole earth beneath them shakes.
And essentially what remains of the light brigades front line dissolves into a hideous mess of blood and bone.
And one of the few survivors of that front line would later recall it as riding into the mouth of a volcano.
Now, what of Lord Cardigan?
Ronald, his heroic charger, is blown sideways.
But Cardigan.
Cardigan is able to wrench him back round to continue his charge.
And he is the first man into the Russian battery.
I mean, fair play to Lord Cardigan.
He's in his mid fifties, isn't he?
Yeah, late fifties.
I mean, he's a couple of years younger than me and I wouldn't want to charge Russian batteries.
I've got to say, I mean, you know, you say many, many things about Cardigan, but he, I mean, he is the bravest of the brave.
He is madly brave and he's setting an example, which is what a commanding officer should do.
And he's led them into the battle.
The batteries and now they are into the battery and they can set about their business, which is silencing the guns.
And this is what they do now.
As they're doing this, Cardigan has had enough.
He feels that he's done his duty.
The duty of a commanding officer is to lead his men, but it's not his job to kind of hang around and spike guns.
That's way below his dignity.
And so rather than, uh, join in the fight alongside the common soldier, uh, he turns and starts to write back.
Um, and as he goes, he's spotted by a Russian.
Prince who had, um, met him in a ballroom in London.
And so recognizes him.
And the Russian Prince says, you know, capture him.
It's Cardigan.
It's the commander of the light brigade, but Cardigan very coolly just rides on at a stately pace.
And, uh, cannon fire is coming from the left and right flanks of the valley.
And so the Russians don't dare venture out into it.
And Cardigan just continues at the stately pace, back up the valley.
And, uh, he makes it, I mean, amazingly, I don't know how he, how he kind of manages to ride out.
The storm of fire, just incredible.
Anyway, he gets to the head of the valley.
And as we said the whole way, he's been thinking about captain Nolan and he's, he's greeted by captain Scarlet, the commander of the heavy brigade.
Is he rises up all the Carter can talk about is outrageous.
Nolan's behavior.
It's been, I mean, it doesn't say anything else.
And he says to Scarlet, imagine the fellow screaming like a woman when he was hit.
Oh my God.
Oh, that's yeah.
Woke screaming from captain Nolan when he's, when he was hit in the heart by some, by some shells, shrapnel.
Anyway, Scarlet's reply to this say no more.
My Lord, you have just ridden over captain Nolan's dead body.
I mean, that's, that's the adding insult to injury, isn't it?
Twample him down, twample him down.
There's a metaphor there for the British class system.
I think.
Yeah.
And also perhaps a metaphor for the class system is that up on the Heights, Lord Ragland, who
ultimately is responsible for this whole debacle is watching completely helpless.
You know, he can't influence what's going on at all.
And he gazes at the, you know, the, the shattered remnants of the light brigade as they slowly start to stagger
and reemerge out of the smoke of the, the distant Russian batteries.
And there are ride less horses careering around.
Um, there are survivors, um, limping and leaning on each other's shoulders and one of the survivors would later describe it as.
There's a scene of havoc.
I know this last mile, it was strewn with the dead and the dying and all of them friends.
And finally, the last survivor has made it back and it's only 20 minutes, 20 minutes since the charge had begun since the, the trumpet sounded.
And of the 700 odd men who had charged the Russian guns, only 195 have made their way back.
And 500 horses have been either killed or captured and Lord Cardigan.
He.
Rides forward to greet the survivors and he tells them men.
It is a mad brain twig, but it is no fault of mine.
And a voice answers this.
Nevermind my Lord, we are ready to go again.
And to this cardigan replies, no, you have done enough today.
My men.
Yeah.
I mean, cardigan is both absolutely loathsome and kind of amazing.
Yeah.
I'm kind of heroic and months and monstrously heroic, heroically.
Monstrous.
However you want to put it.
Yes.
I mean, they don't breed him like that anymore.
You don't get that kind of chap, but I described this as a disaster and I've described it as a disaster throughout, but actually, is it a disaster?
I mean, they lose a lot of men, but they do effectively do what they were sent to do.
Do they?
I mean, I think strategically it clearly is a disaster because if you've lost your light cavalry, you have very much diminished as an armed force, but tactically, actually it's quite effective.
So we've said that light brigade do reach the Russian guns and they put the guns out of action, and that's a key, you know, that's, that's very helpful, but also amazingly, they succeed in pushing the Russian cavalry beyond them to flight.
So now that the light brigade can say that like the heavy brigade, they have, you know, beaten off a massive, great watch of Russian cavalry and to quote Orlando fighters in his great book on the Crimean war, the objective of a cavalry charge was to scatter the enemy's lines and frighten him off the battlefield.
And in this respect.
And in this respect, as the Russians acknowledged, the light brigade had achieved its aim, but the whole point is it has come at the most terrible and fearsome cost.
Yeah.
Because as you say, Raglan has been, I mean, all this time in the campaign, he has been so cautious to keep them in a band box and to keep them from harm because he can't afford to lose his cavalry.
And he's just thrown them away in 20 minutes.
The band box has been trampled into little pieces and the hat's been ripped up and kind of shoved down a sewer.
It's an absolute disaster.
And I think that, you know, right from the beginning, Russell is up there writing the first draft of history.
The charge of the light brigade is being celebrated both as the most spectacular display of courage that anyone had ever witnessed and the most monstrous blunder.
Because as we said, Raglan, you know, he's now lost his light cavalry.
He spent the whole campaign wrapping them up in cotton wool and now they're gone in like kind of 20 minutes, just wiped out.
But because he's lost the light cavalry, he's now definitely and definitively lost control of the Causeway Heights.
And crucially with the Causeway Heights, he has lost control of the Voronzov Road, which is this metal road that joins Balaclava to Sebastopol.
So from now on, if supplies are going to be taken from Balaclava to Sebastopol, it will be by very rough, muddy roads.
And this is going to generate enormous problems.
Now, obviously Raglan is not going to accept responsibility for this debacle, even though I think.
Ultimately, the responsibility is his.
He had expressed himself poorly and it is the duty of a commanding officer to make orders that are very clear and readily understood.
Yeah, but you know, Raglan is not going to accept the responsibility.
And so obviously he blames the inevitable fall guy who is Lord Lucan and Lord Lucan was always going to be anointed the scapegoat.
And so he is, and he ends up being recalled home and Lucan is so outraged by this, I think justifiably, I don't think it's Lucan's fault at all.
And so he demands the court martial to clear his name and this is refused, but actually in time, Lucan's reputation does recover and he ends up a general.
And then, um, in 1887, which is the year before he dies, he's appointed a field marshal.
So he kind of recovers a measure of honor and reputation.
I think now Cardigan, Cardigan retires to his yacht and, uh, his bronchitis comes back.
Um, and so he is basically invalided out after the charge.
And he heads off back home in his yacht with the squire.
And meanwhile, back in Britain, news of the charge of the light brigade, um, is, you know, thrilling the British public.
Um, and even Raglan in his dispatches home, even though, you know, he's absolutely devastated by it.
He does describe it as the finest thing ever done, ever done ever in the history of the world.
And this means that when Cardigan finally gets back to England, he is hailed.
As a conquering hero, even though he's written at the head of a brigade that has effectively been annihilated.
And when he lands at Dover, he's greeted by a massive crowd
who give him enormous huzzahs and cries of three cheers for Balaclava.
And shortly afterwards, on the 5th of February, so we're in 1855 now,
he's the guest of honour at a great banquet in the mansion house
in the heart of the city of London.
He responds to this with tremendous modesty.
He arrives on horseback on the back of Waddle.
And he's absolutely resplendent in the uniform that he'd worn at the charge.
And he gives an absolutely magnificent, vainglorious speech.
He blames Lucan.
Of course he does.
He picks up himself, talks about what a hero he is.
And for a brief while, and for the first time in his life,
he's kind of the people's hero.
Everyone thinks he's absolutely brilliant.
But I'm glad to say that he hasn't lost his talent for infuriating people.
And by the time he dies in 1868, he has a stroke and falls off his horse.
He has once again become widely reviled.
So he's returned to the mean.
And he is outlived by four years by his horse, Ronald,
who is actually led in his funeral cortege.
And it's so frisky that they have to dose him with opium.
And so Ronald actually falls asleep midway through the funeral,
which is sad.
Oh my God.
But he has a dignified retirement in his stable.
And when he dies, his head is sawn off.
And preserved in a glass jar.
And it can still be seen to this day in Dean Park,
which is the ancestral home of the Brutonells.
And what about the head of Lord Cardigan?
Not Lord Cardigan.
Fuck Lord Cardigan.
I don't care about Lord Cardigan.
I want to know about the squire.
Where's his head?
Okay.
So the squire.
Basically, all we know about the squire comes from Russell's report
about how he turns up and he's this kind of unpleasant looking man
in a brown bowler hat.
And they ho-ho together.
I want to know more about him.
I want to see our four-part series about the squire.
I haven't been able to find anything else.
I haven't been able to find anything else about him.
Very little seems to be known about him.
So I think that would be an exciting research project.
I think it'd be a brilliant research project.
And frankly, it should be like the Costa Rican Civil War.
If we can't find out anything, we should just make it up.
Well, I think we know who the squire is.
We can picture him.
He's a massive ledge.
He's a massive laugh.
He's a gilet man, isn't he?
He's absolutely a gilet man.
He's a massive gilet man.
He really is.
He bloody loves the rugger.
Yeah.
He's head to toe in Hackett branded apparel.
And he's a shit.
He's really horrible to his subordinates in his merchant bank.
In a biopic, he's undoubtedly played by Dominic West.
I mean, no question whatsoever.
Yeah.
So that's the squire.
I think we should enshrine him as a friend of the show.
Completely.
We don't know much about him,
but he's a top.
Top ledge.
So that is Lord Lucan and that is Lord Cardigan.
What about Lord Ragland?
Well, he never returns from the Crimea.
Um, and he dies in June, 1855, officially of dysentery, but perhaps as well, you know,
he didn't have better help.
No, he seems to be very depressed.
Perhaps he died of a broken heart because by the summer of 1855, it's clear that the
battle of Balaclava, even though initially it had seemed a bit of a score draw, you
know, honors were even.
Actually, it's the Russians really who've done better at the battle because, um, the
consequences of Balaclava are to prove disasters for the British forces at the siege of Sebastopol.
And it's the loss of this road, this metal road.
It just means that supplying the siege positions become really, really difficult.
And the winter, which follows the battle of Balaclava is really brutal.
And it always seems to be the case that if you invade Russia, you know, in autumn, that
winter is always ferociously hard.
And so it.
Was in the Crimea as thousands of British soldiers die of frostbite and of disease.
And all of this is being reported by Russell and the whole lions led by donkeys narrative
is being shaped by Russell in the times.
And Raglan in Crimea is really well aware of this.
And shortly before his death, um, you know, he, I'm sad.
He says I could never return to England.
Now they would stone me to death.
He knows that he is seen as an abject failure.
Hmm.
So that's Raglan, Cardigan, Lucan, and they are seen as grotesquely incompetent, not unfairly.
And the fact that they are all peers of the realm, you know, and it's set against the horrors
afflicting a British army in a war that, I mean, it's not just that it hadn't gone according to plan.
There hadn't really been a plan in the first place.
You know, they've been the victims of grotesque incompetence.
And this will stir all kinds of reforms back in Britain.
But there is an appetite, isn't there for a new, you know, these people have disgraced themselves in their different ways, but there is a massive public appetite for a star to emerge from the Crimean war for somebody to seize the attention, new kind of hero, or perhaps a heroine, a woman, a woman.
Interesting.
And so who is this woman, Tom?
This woman is someone we mentioned fleetingly before she'd written a story about the oppression of Polish nuns by.
The evil forces of the Tsar, and this is a woman called Florence Nightingale, and we will be meeting her again next year, perhaps, or maybe shortly after that, when we continue the story of the Crimean war and we meet the remarkable woman, the great heroine of Victorian Britain, Florence Nightingale.
Wonderful.
So that is something for people to look forward to.
And of course, when we do finally get around to doing the next stage of the Crimean war and the story of Florence Nightingale.
Our "Rest is History" club members will have early access to that series, so they'll get it all first.
And a lot of people may be listening to this and thinking, I actually didn't know they had a club and I would love to join it.
And I would love, and I would love, I would really love it if I could give my, my brother, my uncle, my next door neighbor, the postman, and other people that I'm getting Christmas gifts for, I'd love to get them a gift membership of this club.
Well, the good news is.
Good news.
And this is a, this is a dramatic innovation.
If you can go to therestishistory.com, the website, there is a special, uh, label or page, gifts.
And if you click on gifts, then you can buy the "Rest is History" gift membership for Christmas for everybody you know.
So if you do join up, if you do choose to get yourself a gift membership immediately, then the great news for you is that on Monday, you'll get both episodes of a, a new little series we're doing.
Which continues a series that we did in 2023, it's the second half of something we began in 2023, and we thought we'd leave people waiting on the longest cliffhanger in the history of the Rest is History and, you know, wherever I go, Australians and New Zealanders come up to me and Polynesians, and they say, "I want to hear about the death of Captain Cook."
Well, that's what's coming next week.
The death of Captain Cook.
There'll be all kinds of action with, uh.
Maui, there will be sailing hither and thither, there'll be ice, and there will be Captain Cook's tragic death on the beaches of Hawaii, or indeed the beach, singular.
So that's something to look forward to, but you can only get those two episodes on Monday, if you're a member of the club.
So this is a reminder to go to therestishistory.com and sign up.
I feel like I've done my duty now in plugging in the gifts and indeed the club.
So I'm just going to stop talking and say that Tom, that was a fantastic series.
Love the Charge of the Light Brigade.
Nobles 600, absolutely everybody should honour them.
Dominic, I completely agree.
I think we should honour the Light Brigade.
And so let's end this series by doing exactly that and listening to the trumpet that was blown on the day of the charge by Martin Leonard Landfried.
And he survived.
And on August the 2nd, 1890, he was recorded blowing it.
And here he is.
Take it away.
Trumpeter Landfried.
Now, for those of you who enjoyed that series as much as we did,
we have something.
Incredibly exciting news for you, don't we, Tom?
We so do, because we are going to do an extra special bonus on the single most significant figure in the entire history of the Crimean War.
Sometimes when we're doing these series, these characters kind of seize the attention, they grab centre stage.
And this was very much the case, not with Tsar Nicholas I or Lord Cardigan or any of the other characters, Flashman from the Charge of the Light Brigade.
It was actually a man who stepped forward as a total legend.
It was Hubert de Boer, the squire, alleged.
What's happened with the squire, Tom?
Tell us about the squire.
So when we were recording it originally, we said it would be quite fun to do a bonus on him.
And that's exactly what we've done.
And actually, the kind of the more detailed research that's been done into the life and times of the squire reveal an extraordinary story.
Massive shades of melodrama.
Yeah.
All kinds of shenanigans and even features a ghost.
It's a tremendous story.
Yeah.
Is the squire possibly still with us?
I mean, that would be incredible.
Anyway, so that special squire.
Squire bonus. That came out yesterday for members of the Restless History Club,
because the Squire was quite an exclusive kind of fellow, wasn't he?
Didn't want to mix with the riffraff.
No, he hung around in the clubs of St. James's in his country tweed. He wouldn't associate with
the ordinary hoi polloi, I think. So we don't want to release that special Squire episode
for the general public. We just want to keep it for our club members. And if you'd like to know
about the Squire, if you'd like to hear what will undoubtedly go down as one of the classic episodes
of the Restless History, I'm afraid you have to sign up at therestlesshistory.com. And if you
think that's out of keeping with the Squire's general vibe, you are quite wrong, because he
came from trade ultimately, didn't he, Tom? Is that right? Something like that?
He did, but he loved a club.
Yeah.
He loved a club. And if you want to meet the Squire, you've got to join a club.
So sign up at therestlesshistory.com and you can hear that bonus straight away.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The Charge of the Light Brigade is a historic military disaster driven by miscommunication, poor command, and a failure to clarify orders.
The British forces were strategically positioned to defend Balaclava, with the Highlanders and heavy cavalry holding key defensive lines.
Lord Raglan's ambiguous order for the light cavalry to advance and prevent the Russians from seizing guns led to catastrophic confusion and misinterpretation.
Lord Lucan, despite being ordered to act, misread the command and believed he was to wait for infantry reinforcements, unaware of the danger.
Lord Cardigan led the light brigade into a deadly charge, ignoring the overwhelming firepower and tactical flaws, showing extreme bravery but at massive cost.
The charge, while tactically effective in scattering Russian cavalry, was a strategic failure that damaged British supply lines and morale.
Captain Nolan, a respected cavalry expert, was killed during the charge, highlighting the deadly consequences of the flawed order.
The event became a legendary symbol of both heroic valor and military blunder, deeply influencing historical memory and literature.
Summary:
The Charge of the Light Brigade, a pivotal moment in the Crimean War, is a tragic example of military misdirection and flawed command. On October 25, 1854, British forces at Balaclava faced a massive Russian advance, with the causeway heights and Voronzov Road being critical to supply lines. Despite having strong defensive positions, Lord Raglan's vague order—directing the light brigade to "advance and prevent the enemy from carrying away guns"—was misunderstood.
Lord Lucan, the cavalry commander, interpreted it as a stand-off, while Lord Cardigan, the light brigade commander, led a reckless charge into a valley where Russian artillery dominated on all sides. The order was fatally ambiguous, and the light brigade, unaware of the danger, charged into a deadly crossfire. Captain Nolan, a cavalry expert, was killed by shrapnel while trying to warn the brigade of the trap.
Though the charge succeeded in scattering Russian cavalry and silencing some guns, it cost over 500 men and 500 horses, with only 195 survivors. Strategically, the British lost control of the vital Voronzov Road, disrupting supply routes. The event became a legendary paradox—celebrated as a display of courage but condemned as a devastating blunder.
Lord Lucan was scapegoated and later cleared, while Cardigan retired in disgrace. The incident profoundly shaped historical memory, with Alfred Tennyson’s poem immortalizing the event as a symbol of both glory and folly. It remains a powerful lesson in the necessity of clear, decisive command in warfare.
FAQs
The Light Brigade's objective was to charge the Russian guns positioned at the far end of the North Valley, aiming to silence them and push the Russian cavalry into retreat.
The charge was based on a miscommunication and misunderstanding of orders. The brigade was ordered to advance and stop the Russians from capturing British guns, but the target was incorrectly interpreted as a single battery with no awareness of surrounding Russian artillery.
Lord Raglan, the overall commander, issued an ambiguous order to advance and prevent the enemy from carrying away guns. This order was misinterpreted by Lord Lucan, who believed the enemy was in a different position and saw no immediate danger.
The charge succeeded in silencing the Russian artillery and driving the cavalry into retreat, achieving its tactical goal. However, it resulted in heavy casualties, with only 195 of the original 700+ men surviving.
Captain Nolan, who was riding ahead to warn the Light Brigade, was struck by shrapnel in the chest while trying to alert them to the danger. He died instantly, falling from his horse with his arm outstretched and his body rigid.
The British public was deeply moved, viewing the charge as an act of extraordinary bravery. It became a celebrated symbol of courage, though later also seen as a tragic and disastrous blunder.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.