Benjamin Elliott, a 17-year-old twin, was arrested after calling 911 to report he had stabbed his sister Megan to death in her sleep. He claimed the incident was a vivid nightmare and that he was sleepwalking, a defense supported by witnesses of past sleepwalking incidents and a sleep expert. However, multiple inconsistencies undermine this narrative: phone records show he was awake and active hours before the stabbing, his emotional detachment and lack of concern for his sister’s condition during the 911 call raise red flags, and forensic evidence indicates two deep stab wounds with no visible blood at the scene—contradicting his story of using a pillow to stop bleeding. The prosecution countered that violent sleepwalking is rare and impossible to perform complex actions like unsheathing a knife, and that dreaming during sleepwalking is scientifically invalid. Despite a lack of motive and a clean criminal record, Benjamin was convicted of first-degree murder. The jury reached a verdict quickly and later requested leniency, leading to a 15-year sentence—an unusually light punishment for a murder conviction. His case remains controversial due to the absence of clear signs of premeditation, the strength of the sleepwalking defense, and the emotional disconnect in his behavior. Benjamin continues to maintain he did not intend to kill his sister, and the case highlights the tension between medical explanations, behavioral anomalies, and the difficulty of determining intent in emotionally complex family tragedies.
Everyone saw them as the perfect family. That was until their 17-year-old son called 911 in the middle of the night because he had just stabbed his twin sister to death in her sleep. This is one of those cases where we might never know what actually happened that night. The defense would claim that Benjamin Elliott was sleepwalking the night that he killed his sister. But the state was adamant that this innocent-looking teenage boy was a cruel, calculated, and cold-blooded killer. My name is Buriana, and I'm hot on the case. Twins, Benjamin, and Megan Elliott were born to the parents Michael and Kathy on November 14th 2003, and were raised in Katie, Texas with their older sister Elizabeth. They lived in a nice, safe area. It was the suburbs. And the Elliott's seemed like your average nice, normal family. No one ever had anything bad to say about any of them. The daughter's Elizabeth and Megan used to share a room, but Megan now had her own room. Because by 2021, it was just Michael, Kathy, and the two twins at home because the eldest child Elizabeth was already off at college in Georgia. The entire family was extremely close, but it really did seem like it was Ben and Megan that were the closest. But obviously, that's probably not surprising to you or anyone else considering that they were twins. Twins are known to have this super special bond that other people can't understand. Ben and Megan both did fine in school, and neither of them were the type of kid that would get in trouble at school. In comparison to a majority of their peers, Ben and Megan were definitely more shy and quiet, but out of the two of them, it was definitely Ben that was the more outgoing one. As a teenager, Megan was diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder. She really preferred to stick to herself. She wasn't very confident. And sadly, she was unfairly the target for bullies at school. Megan would often seek out her brother, Ben, at school, whenever she was feeling uncomfortable, and Ben definitely stepped into a protector role for his sister, Megan, and it seemed like he was very proud to be that person for his sister. Megan Elliott was a very sensitive and creative person. She loved writing poetry and she loved drawing. She even had her own YouTube channel where she did art. Megan felt that she could be a lot more herself online. She was a lot more confident online, especially making friends, so a majority of her friends were people that she meant on the internet. And her mother had actually said recently it seemed like Megan was a lot more confident and sure of herself in the person that she was. Not really worrying about what everyone else wanted her to be. Whereas Megan was more creative, her twin brother Benjamin was more analytical. He planned to study mechanical engineering and actually had plans to take his SATs that very weekend. Ben and Megan were both 17 years old in 2021, meaning college was right around the corner. And the twins had actually toured separate universities, meaning they did not plan to go to the same college together. To be honest, I don't think that this is very weird or a red flag. I feel like with twins, it's pretty 50/50. Some twins really want to go to the same college together. They want to spend a majority of their time together. That's where they feel more comfortable, where a lot of other twins obviously love their twin, but they also want to feel like they're their own person and are paving their own path. It doesn't mean that either set of twins are more close or bonded than the other. But yeah, it really did seem like the Elliott's had a normal, dare I say, perfect family. That was until September 29, 2021, at 441 AM, when 17-year-old Benjamin Elliott called 911 to report that he had just stabbed and killed his twin sister Megan. There is County number one with the location of your emergency. I just killed my sister. Tell me what your name is. Benjamin Elliott's. Okay, tell me exactly what happened. I thought it was a dream. I took my wife and I stabbed her. I don't know where to live. How old is she? 17 or twins. Is she awake? Yes. She's like barely alive. Is there anyone else there in the house at you? There is just my parents, but they're asleep. Okay, I need you to wake them up. Wow, we're going to have to start CPR right now. One, two, three, four, one, two. You're acting her chest. Just like that, okay? Ben is whispering on the 911 call. He's telling the operator that he thought it was just a dream, a really realistic nightmare that he was stabbing his sister to death. But then he woke up and realized that it wasn't a dream at all and it was real. Ben said that his sister was barely alive. She was dying and he begged for someone to come and help her. The 911 operator tells Ben to wake up his parents. She also tells him to perform CPR, which is what Ben is doing when officers arrive at the home only 10 minutes later. And considering that Ben had just confessed to being the one that stabbed Meghan, he was immediately put into handcuffs and brought into police custody. And you can hear him on police body cam footage just repeating the same words that he had told the 911 operator. He thought it was all just a dream. But something that a lot of people that have seen this body cam footage have pointed out as pretty odd is that this officer is leading Ben out of his house. He has been in handcuffs and this officer is trying to be friendly with Ben, like kind of start a rapport with Ben. And the officer tells Ben, "I'm going to treat you with respect. Please do the same with me." And Ben responds, "I don't deserve respect. I just killed my sister." Ben and Meghan's parents, Michael and Kathy, are obviously very confused about what is going on. They thought they had a normal night. The family had dinner together. They started settling down to bed. They played video games together. And now police are in their home telling them that one of their children has just stopped the other one in the middle of the night. Michael is actually the first of the parents to wake up. You can actually hear him screaming on Ben's 911 call. And he continues to scream in horror and shock when police arrive at his home. Kathy wakes up later around the time that police actually arrive at her home. And she never actually even goes into her daughter's room where Meghan is because police are standing in front of it and not letting her inside. Kathy is begging to see her daughter. She has CPR or medical training. She's begging for them to let her in. She thinks that she can help her daughter. Both Michael and Kathy are begging the officers for any sort of update about their daughter. But tragically, it was already too late by the time officers arrived at the home 17 year old Meghan Elliott was already dead. Police were in a very complicated situation. You have these two parents in front of you that are desperate for answers about their daughter and their teenage daughter has been killed. But it's also those same parents whose teenage son was the one that has just confessed to being the one that killed his sister. So police actually made the decision not to say anything to anyone at this point. Back at the police station, Ben is being questioned by police. He asks multiple times for some sort of update on his sister. He wants to know if Meghan is okay if she's still alive. And police actually lie to Ben and they tell him that as far as they know, Meghan is still alive and she is doing okay. But this was just a strategy to keep Ben talking. If he thought that Meghan was alive and doing okay, he would be a lot more likely to keep talking to police than if she was dead because then he would be in a lot more trouble. Ben's story was that he fell asleep that night sometime around 2 30 30 30 in the morning. And he was having this terrible dream where he grabbed a knife, went into his sister's bedroom, and while she was sleeping, he just was stabbing her. And then he woke up and realized that it wasn't a dream at all, he was actually stabbing his sister. He truly thought that it was just his horrific realistic nightmare. But when
When he wakes up, he's standing over his sister's bed. His hand was around the handle of this knife, and the knife was plunged into his twin sister's neck. And he just kept repeating that he thought he was dreaming. He was sleepwalking during the time that he killed his sister, and the entire thing was just as terrible, tragic accident. And this is the question at the center of this case. Has Ben really sleepwalking at the time that he killed his sister? Or is this 17-year-old boy a cold, blooded, calculated killer? One of the first things that I noticed when researching for this case was how quickly Benjamin Elliott started trying to establish his sleepwalking defense. One of the first things that he says on this 9-1-1 call was, "Thought I was a dream." I thought I was a dream. He says it over and over again, I stabbed my sister, but I thought I was a dream. Some police have him in handcuffs and are walking him out of his home. He's repeating the same thing over and over again. And literally the first thing that Ben says in the interrogation room, when officers ask him, "So can you tell me what happened this morning was, 'Have you ever had a super realistic dream?' Just trying to lay the foundation for the defense that he plans to use. But I just feel like the more likely and genuine reaction that someone would have if they actually woke up and found their loved one hurt, would be to want to get them help. That would be the first priority not trying to help yourself." On the 9-1-1 call, instead of focusing on getting his sister help, he's focusing on establishing his sleepwalking defense. And then only minutes later, police are in his home. They have him in handcuffs. And even though his sister is in the other room, only feet away from him, he never once asks, "Is she okay? Is she going to be okay? Please help her. Please help her." Again, he's just repeating, "I thought it was a dream. I thought it was a dream." And it's the same thing in his interrogation. The first thing he's asked is, "Please tell me what happened this morning." And instead of trying to explain this really bizarre and traumatic thing that has just happened, then asks the detectives a question back. Have you ever had a super realistic dream before? The police aren't asking, "Why did this happen?" They're asking, "What happened?" But Benjamin's main priority is laying the bricks, the foundation of his defense that he plans to use, which personally is a huge red flag for me while I'm looking into this case. I've watched a lot of interrogations, and I've listened to a lot of 9-1-1 calls doing what I do. And honestly, more times than not, I find when someone is immediately and unprompted trying to establish a defense or a possible alternate theory, that person is usually guilty. Not always, but it's where a lot of the time. I can think of multiple examples just at the top of my head, and I bet a lot of you that listen to a lot of true crime also can. What explains to investigators that he got the knife that he used to kill his sister from his father, just earlier that same night? That night, the father and son were playing video games together, and there was a knife in this video game that was super similar to one that Ben's father, Michael owned. Michael was super into hunting and camping, so this was a survival-style knife. Michael went and brought out the knife, so him and his son could compare how similar it was to the one in the video game that they were playing, and both Michael and Ben would admit that this particular knife was one that Ben seemed extremely interested in. Not just on this night, but even before. They even used the words "fixated" and "anamard" to describe Ben's interest in this knife. So Michael already has this knife out, and his son has always had a lot of interest in this knife, so he decides to give this knife to his son Ben, and Ben immediately brings it into his room and puts it on his nightstand right next to his bed. And only hours later, Ben would use that exact same knife to kill his twin sister, Megan. What are the odds at the same night that his father gives him this knife that he's always been obsessed with? That's the exact same night that Ben would have a sleepwalking episode, one that would turn extremely violent. Ben claims that in this nightmare he was having, where he was stabbing his sister, he only remembers stabbing his sister one time. He said he could even physically feel the knife enter his sister's neck. That it was just super realistic. And when Ben wakes up, the knife is still plunged into Megan's neck, so he makes the choice to remove the knife from his sister's neck because he thought that it would be helpful. But just a PSA in case you were anyone you know was ever in a situation like this where you'd have like a knife, a large shard of glass or metal stuck inside of your body, keep it in there because it actually kind of works as a barrier to keep you from bleeding out. And Ben says that is exactly what started happening. He took the knife out of his sister's neck thinking it would help his sister, but then she just started bleeding, bleeding a lot and very fast. So Ben says that he grabbed a nearby pillow that was on his sister's bed and he put it over his sister's face and her neck to try and stop the bleeding. But unfortunately, the story that Ben tells doesn't actually line up with the evidence as at the scene. Megan was stabbed twice in the neck, not once, like Ben remembers. And these were stab wounds that were meant to kill. They were both extremely deep. And the second stab wound actually severed Megan's carotid artery and her jugular vein meaning because Ben removed the knife from his sister's neck, we would expect to see a lot of blood at the scene. I'm talking on the ceiling, I'm talking covering the walls, but you don't see that actually at all. Most of the blood at the scene was actually soaked up by that pillow that Ben said he used to stop his sister's bleeding, which okay makes sense. But the prosecution argued that for this to make sense, the pillow would have actually had to have already been over Megan's neck and her face when Ben removed the knife from her neck. But that does not line up with Ben's story at all. So the prosecution's theory is that Ben did not put that pillow over Megan to stop the bleeding. He actually put that pillow over Megan's face to muffle her screams before he started to kill her. Also something I think important to note, a lot of people agree that on the 911 call on the police body cam footage and during his interrogation, Ben seems oddly calm and composed. Almost emotionless. And during his interrogation, Ben keeps changing the subject from his sister's death to talking about different things. He talks about school. He talks about the plan to take the SAT that Saturday. He talks about college, how he's excited to go and what he plans to study. Something else a lot of people pointed out as pretty strange during Ben's interrogation, when police ask him where his cell phone is, Ben responds that it's at the crime scene. Those were his exact words, which police thought was a pretty odd thing for a 17 year old boy to say. Like he's not wrong, his house is a crime scene now, but why would he say it like that? It's just kind of weird, especially if he's trying to claim that this was a tragic accident and not actually a crime. And it also really seems very like disconnected. His sister is at least he knows at this point injured and he caused it. It's just a weird thing to say that my phone is at the crime scene. I don't know. Maybe that's just me. I agree with a lot of people in the police that that is kind of a weird thing to say. And then two hours into Ben's interrogation, investigators finally reveal that his sister was tragically dead, and Ben responded with just hum. Like I just said, a lot of things that Ben says and does just seems like someone that is completely disconnected from the situation. Could he be in shock? 100%, but I at least thought that all of this was worth mentioning, especially because a lot of people see this as a young man without remorse. Even today, I'm getting ahead of myself, but even in interviews he has now done five plus years later, he just seems cold and emotionless when discussing his sister and what happened. I will at least say that Ben was extremely cooperative with police. He never tried to lie or hide the fact that he was the one that killed his sister Megan. He agreed to speak with police without a lawyer and even willingly gave police permission and to go through his phone without a second.
warrant. When trying to prove or disprove that Benjamin Elliott was sleepwalking at the time that he killed his sister, Megan Elliott, police decided to go through his medical records. And what they found was a diagnosis of sleep apnea. As far as I know, this is a condition where people have trouble breathing while they're sleeping. They often have to wear this very uncomfortable looking breathing machine while they are sleeping. So this is a sleeping disorder found in Benjamin Elliott's medical records. But what they don't find is any history of sleepwalking. Ben and his family felt that this was easily explainable. The reason there was no medical history of Ben's sleepwalking was because they never went to a doctor about this. They didn't think it was something that was necessary for them to discuss with Benjamin's doctor. But multiple witnesses were able to testify to the fact that Ben had a long history with sleepwalking. His older sister, Elizabeth, would testify that around seven years earlier, when Ben and Megan were around 10 years old while her and Megan were sharing a room. In the middle of the night, Megan woke her up looking equal parts scared and confused because their brother Ben was standing in their bedroom. It was like he was a zombie. It's the middle of the night and Ben is just standing there with a blank stare. He wasn't looking at either of them and he wasn't responding when they tried to ask him what he was doing and if anything was wrong. Eventually Elizabeth realized that her brother was probably sleeping and brought Ben back to his bedroom in the next morning. Ben had no memory of this ever occurring. It was something that the family just laughed about. So this is a confirmed, I would say confirmed unless Elizabeth is making this up, a confirmed incident where Ben was sleepwalking and entered his sister Megan's bedroom. Of course, this is an incident where Ben does not harm Megan when he enters her bedroom in the middle of the night sleepwalking but it at least shows a pattern that this is something that he has done in the past. And in another incident, one that I believe is even more significant to this case. In April of 2016, when Ben and Megan were both around 12 years old, they were having a sleepover with one of Ben's school friends named Anand and Anand's younger sister who was really close with Megan. All of them are having a sleepover in the living room at the Elliott's house and Anand was the first one to wake up. When he wakes up, he sees that his friend Ben who is laying on the couch, he appears to be awake. His eyes are open but again, Ben has this blank stare. Ben is just lying on the couch, eyes open, blank stare. He is a donut in his hand and he's eating the donut. Anand is talking to Ben. He's like, "Hey, man, are you good? Good morning?" Like, "What's up?" And that's when Anand says that his friend Ben woke up. Ben seems really confused. He's looking around. He doesn't know what's going on and then he sees this half-e in donut in his hand and he says to Anand, "Oh my god, this was so weird. I was just having a dream where I was eating a donut and I wake up and I'm eating a donut." And I find this extremely significant because five years later, Benjamin Elliott would stab his sister and claim that he was dreaming about stabbing a sister and woke up and he actually was. So obviously, stabbing your sister and eating a donut is not the same thing, but in both of these incidents, Benjamin Elliott was claiming that he was dreaming about the thing that he was actually doing while sleepwalking. Regardless, Benjamin Elliott was arrested for the first degree murder of his sister Megan. And after a few days being held because they were worried that Ben might harm himself, Ben was released on bail. Maybe this is surprising to you or maybe it's not. But Ben's family believes his story and supports him wholeheartedly. When Ben first killed Megan, his mother Kathy was actually scared that her son Benjamin might have been suffering with undiagnosed schizophrenia. This was because her own father was a schizophrenic, so she thought that maybe this was something that her son also developed. Boys usually develop schizophrenia around 17 years old, early 20s, so she thought that this was the only explanation why her sweet and loving son would murder his twin sister. But after he was released on bail, Ben had a psychiatric evaluation where they found absolutely nothing. So after that, his parents believed that the only other option was that Ben was really telling the truth and he was sleepwalking when he took his twin's life. After their daughter was killed in their home, Michael and Kathy knew that they could never sleep in that house again, so they actually temporarily moved into Kathy's mother's home. When Ben was really some bail and brought to his grandmother's home, Ben claimed that he was really, really scared to fall asleep because of what he did. His parents actually installed an alarm on his bedroom door that would alert him and them if he were to sleepwalk again. There's actually a bit of controversy surrounding Ben and Megan Elliott's parents. Only after their daughter was killed and their son was taken into police custody, Michael and Kathy started speaking with a lawyer. Something that the public and the prosecution would claim was very odd behavior. It was also alleged that that Michael and Kathy refused to let police search their home without a warrant. But Michael and Kathy would claim that they were really confused by this because this was just a blatant lie. Not only did they willingly let police search their home they even handed over their keys when they weren't even home. Letting the place have full access to their home where they didn't feel the need to monitor what they were doing. And they said that the only reason they spoke with the lawyer was because the police weren't telling them anything and they didn't know what they were supposed to be doing. And also this wasn't just any lawyer. Michael and Kathy reached out and started speaking and asking for advice from one of their really really close friends who yeah also just so happened to be a lawyer. In preparation for trial the defense hired a sleep expert who performed a sleep study on Ben. And afterwards this expert concluded that Ben was sleepwalking at the time that he killed his sister. Ben and his family hoped that this expert's opinion would have led the state to drop the charges against Ben but they didn't. And the trial went on as usual. They did offer Ben a plea deal though. Ben would plead guilty and then would be sentenced to 30 years in prison but Ben refused to take this plea deal. It actually took a while for Ben's trial to start. It didn't begin until February of 2025. And at this point Ben was 21 years old. And Ben would plead not guilty to the first degree murder charge of his twin sister Megan. The defense was obviously going with Ben was sleepwalking at the time that he killed his sister and shouldn't be held criminally responsible because it was just this freak tragic accident that could have happened to anyone. The prosecution's theory was that Ben wanted to kill his sister Megan and did it intentionally in cold blood. The entire thing was premeditated and so was his sleepwalking defense because he knew he had this sleepwalking history and multiple people would be able to testify to it. The defense would argue that Benjamin Elliott was a nice normal 17 year old boy with no criminal history and no history of acting out or getting in trouble at school. Things that we, if you saw last week's episode, we typically see in miners that kill or attempt to. But there really wasn't any known warning signs or red flags that we should see present in Benjamin Elliott. Everyone in his family was adamant that Ben and Megan were extremely close. They were best friends. They never fought. There was zero resentment between them. There was no anger or reason for Ben to want to kill his twin sister. And I'm going to be completely honest, the prosecution could not find a single possible motive for Ben wanting to intentionally kill his sister. And when you're at a first degree murder trial and the prosecution can't even come up with one single possible motive for murder. I gotta be honest, it doesn't look very good. But the prosecution would counter that you really never know what's going on behind closed doors and maybe the Elliott family and Ben and Megan's relationship wasn't as perfect as it seemed on the outside. They theorized that maybe after losing one child, the family was terrified of losing another. So, Michael and Kathy were covering up a lot of things for Ben, hiding possible motives, warning signs and red flags. Maybe there was something going on between Ben and Megan. Maybe he didn't like that his sister was becoming more confident that she needed him less, that they were going to go to different colleges. Maybe it was a complete
completely different reason that we have no clue about, that made Ben so angry. And he had been thinking about it for a while, and then he got his dad's knife, and he's staying up late, and he's just thinking about it, and he's stewing, and he's angry, and the knife is right there, and he decides on impulse to do a terrible, terrible thing. The prosecution with theorized that that maybe Benchman Elliott was a deeply disturbed young man who just had a desire, to want to know what it was like to kill. But to that, the defense would argue that Benjamin's father Michael was an avid hunter and would even try and bring his son hunting with him, but Ben really hated hunting. He didn't like the idea of taking an animal's life, which would directly invalidate the state's theory that Ben just had this fantasy this desire to kill. The defense would call their sleep expert to testify that they hired that did those sleep studies on Ben, who also believed that Ben was in fact sleepwalking at the time that he killed his twin sister Megan. This expert testified that although Ben never slept walked during his sleep studies with Ben, he did sleep talk. Ben would have full conversations with no memory of them when he woke up. The sleep expert would testify that Ben could fall asleep very easily, and when he fell asleep, Ben quickly entered non-rem sleep, and non-rem sleep is where sleepwalking occurs. He said that Ben could even enter non-rem sleep within 11 minutes. And even though it seemed unbelievable that someone, someone completely normal, could sleepwalk and murder someone that they loved someone they were extremely close with, sleepwalking defense, for murder, has actually been used before and has been successful before. In 1987, Kenneth Park's got out of his bed and drove 14 miles to his in-laws house, where he let himself in with a key and bludgeoned his mother-in-law to death with a tire iron. In 2010, Joseph Mitchell suffocated his four-year-old son Blake, killing him, and attempted to kill his 10-year-old and his 13-year-old children while they laid in bed. Both these men claimed that they were sleepwalking at the time that they committed these murders, and both of those men were found not guilty. The state hired their own sleep expert, and although this expert never performed any sleep studies on Ben, he did not believe that Ben was sleepwalking at the time that he killed his sister, and he had many reasons why he did not believe this. Now the first reason was even if Ben did have a history of sleepwalking, which could not be proven 100% either way, Ben did not have a history of violence while sleepwalking. The expert found it extremely unlikely that Ben would go from walking around his house and eating donuts while sleepwalking to viciously and brutally stabbing his twin sister to death while sleepwalking with nothing else in between. Violence while sleepwalking is rare, but it does happen. But the prosecution's expert would claim that when violence during sleepwalking occurs, it happens when the victim interacts with the sleepwalking person, like tries to wake the sleepwalking person up. And the sleepwalking person would usually just like hit or kick the victim. You don't see someone getting out of their bed unsheathing a knife walking into their sister's room and stabbing them to death completely unprompted. And the prosecution's expert said that unsheathing this particular knife would be a task too complicated for a sleepwalking person to do. When people sleepwalk, they typically go through the motions of their daily tasks or do things that they are familiar with. But Ben was just given this knife a few hours earlier. It was not something that he was used to doing, but maybe you could argue that because he just got this knife that he was really into a few hours earlier that maybe this knife was just on his mind. Plus, and I personally think that this is some of the most damning evidence against the fence if it is true. Then story was that he was having the super realist like Nightmare where he was stabbing his sister while he was sleepwalking. But the prosecution's expert would say that this was impossible because he claims that I even went and looked this up and confirmed this myself. It is impossible to dream while sleepwalking. This is because dreaming only happens during REM sleep and sleepwalking only happens in non REM sleep. But one thing I will say if Ben really did plan to kill his sister and make up this story that he was sleepwalking when he did it, why didn't he just claim that he didn't remember anything? Why even claim that you were having this vivid Nightmare about killing your sister if anything that makes you look kind of guilty like you're thinking about doing it, you're capable of doing it. Most killers try to distance themselves from the crime they commit, but Ben doesn't do that. Plus, I know the science says that dreaming while sleepwalking is completely impossible, but five years earlier, Ben claimed that he was dreaming about eating a donut, woke up and was really eating a donut. Are you going to tell me that Benjamin Elliott is the most genius killer of all time? And five years earlier when he was 12 years old, he thought to plant the seeds that he dreams about doing things while sleepwalking and doing them, so he could five years later kill his sister and use a sleepwalking defense. I've never personally experienced sleepwalking and the only person that I know that has, I asked them and they said they don't remember anything about it like they weren't dreaming or anything, but when I covered this case on TikTok, I asked if anyone that has had a sleepwalking experience before remembers dreaming during it and where I vast majority of people said that they didn't remember anything. I definitely had a lot of comments from people saying that they've been sleepwalking their entire life and they have definitely dreamt while doing it. So I am extremely interested to hear from all of you, especially if you or someone you know has had any experience sleepwalking and what that was like and if you have ever dreamt while doing it. Another major wrench in the defense's case actually came from Ben's own phone records. We all know that our phone records what we search, who we text and who we call, but you might not know that your phone logs every single thing. It logs when you plug or unplug your phone from its charger, when you lock or unlock your phone. It can even log when you get up and walk around your room and Ben's phone records directly go against his story that he fell asleep sometime around 2.30 in the morning. Ben's phone records place him awake much later than that, watching YouTube videos and scrolling on Reddit. And then at 4.01am, Ben deactivates an alarm that he had set to wake him up for school. Why? Maybe because he knew that he wouldn't need to use it. Five minutes later at 4.06am, Ben unplugs his phone from the charger. Two minutes later at 4.08am, Ben gets up and he walks roughly 18 feet, which just so happens to be the exact distance from Ben's bed to his sister Megan's bedroom door and then back into his room. At 4.17am, Ben locks his phone and it's not unlocked again for 24 minutes until Ben picks it up, calls 911 after stabbing his sister. Are we to believe that Ben locked his phone, fell asleep, started sleepwalking, got out of bed, unchefed his knife, went into Megan's room, stabbed her, woke up from his sleepwalking episode, tried using a pillow to stop the bleeding and then called 911 all in just 24 minutes. Through the thenses sleep expert did say that Ben fell asleep really quickly and even could quickly enter non-rem sleep, he entered it in just 11 minutes once. But does that all seem even physically possible? Or are we supposed to believe that Ben was actually sleepwalking the entire time he was up watching YouTube videos, scrolling on Reddit, deactivating alarms he set for himself, unplugging his phone, and walking around his house? Or does it seem more likely that Benjamin Elliott wanted to kill his sister? He just got this knife from his dad earlier that day and he thought tonight's the night. Ben was up late trying to psych himself up to kill his sister. He's up late making sure that the rest of his family would be fast asleep. The reason he gets out of bed and walks to his sister's room before stabbing her to death was to confirm that she was in fact sleeping. Something else the first responders noticed when they first arrived at the scene remember within just minutes. After Ben claimed he stabbed his sister, was that Megan's skin appeared grey. Almost like she had been dead for quite some time. But on the night one call, Ben said that his sister was still alive barely, but definitely still alive. Something else at the prosecution would say was very
odd about Benjamin Elliott's 911 call was that he was whispering during the entire 911 call. If this really was some genuine, freak accident, you wake up and you see a knife in your sister's neck wouldn't you expect that person to be freaking out? So why was Ben whispering? Is it possible that he didn't wake up his parents yet and face what he had done? Or again, could he have been in shock? At the end of the trial, the jury actually came to a decision extremely quickly, which honestly shocked me a lot, because I do not think that this is a cut and dry case at all. After only four hours of deliberation, the jury came back with their verdict, and they found that now 21-year-old Benjamin Elliott guilty of the first degree murder of his twin sister, Megan Elliott. During the sentencing hearing the following day, members of the jury did something that I've honestly never heard about, I'm pretty sure, where they asked the judge for leniency when sentencing Ben, just one day after finding him guilty of first degree murder? Ben actually believes that this means there must have been some serious doubt amongst the jurors about his guilt. He doesn't understand how if you truly believed that he was this cold-blooded and calculated killer who planned it to murder his sister in her sleep and then come up with this defense that he was sleepwalking to get away with it, that you would ask the judge for leniency. And to be honest, I get where he's coming from, that doesn't really make a lot of sense to me either. Maybe it was because of his age, maybe the jury felt bad for his family because they had just lost a daughter? I'm not sure. The range of sentencing that Ben could receive was actually very large. He could be sentenced from anywhere from five to 99 years in prison. The defense asked the judge for five years. The prosecution asked for 40, but ultimately the judge sentenced Benjamin Elliott to 15 years in prison with the possibility of early release. Looking at many factors that helped guide me, this is a wide range of punishment. Five years, 99 years of life. I look at the criminal history of the defendant, look at similar cases with five patterns and what the jury has decided and there's none. I mean, we could all agree or not. And I've looked. I look at what the jury has told me and the defense did not agree with your defense. I'm sorry, they didn't. However, unsolicited, they told me to be lenient with Mr. Elliott. I will tell you that. And I told y'all that when I spoke with them, I didn't say tell me. I look at cases I've tried as a prosecutor in the fence attorney, try to look at similarities to see what I think is just a mitigation. In this case, and there's mitigation. He hasn't, there's no criminal history. He seems to be portrayed as a nice person. I can't argue with that. I look at aggravated circumstances the complainy witness. If she was young, you deserve what happened. I look at how the defendant behaved on bond. I sit there and I've told everyone before I see what people do now what they say. And I just watch them. They just see what they're going to do and he's behaved. We can't argue with that. I think about the victim. I have. I do, I will. I have. I think about the victim's family, which is also his family. I think about the defendant's age. I think about rehabilitation punishment. And I think about what I think is just and what I can live with. Because at that bottom line is I have to be able to live with whatever sentence I give. And I take that very seriously. Stand up Mr. Elliott. I'm sure you're finding you guilty of offensive murder. You're a range of punishments from five years to 99. I've sentenced you to 15 years in prison. This time you will go with the sheriff's department where your sentence will be fulfilled in the types of permanent criminal justice. And you'll get the credit that you have received while are on bond. If you serve any jail time to receive that credit as well, is there any legal reason why this why this court should not give you that punishment at this time? Any legal reason Mr. Rupert? Yeah. With that said, please go with the sheriff's department. We fulfill their sentence with the types of permanent criminal justice. An extremely light sentence for a murder conviction, only 15 years. If Ben serves his entire sentence, he will be released at the very latest in September of 2040 at only 36 years old. And at the earliest, he could be released in August of 2032 at only 28 years old. Ben immediately attempted to appeal his conviction, but his appeal was actually rejected actually not that long ago in September of 2026. To this day, he is adamant that he is not responsible for his sister's death. I am so very interested to hear all of your thoughts theories and opinions on this case. Do you think that justice was served? Do you think that it absolutely was not? Do you believe Ben's story? Or do you think he truly intended to kill a sister? What do you think the motive was if that's the case? And if you think that Ben truly was guilty of murder, do you think that there was enough reasonable doubt that he shouldn't have been convicted? I think that the most likely answer was that Ben did intend to kill his sister, Megan. But I will say that I do think that there's enough reasonable doubt in this case that I'm not sure if I was a juror on this trial that I would have been able to find him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. I think that there is enough reasonable doubt in this case. But please let me know all of your thoughts. I always find that you guys are always coming up with things that I would never put together in my own head. I really try to sit there and try to piece together different aspects and different things I find while researching. But even though I can sit with these cases for weeks, months, or years, you guys listen to my 45-minute hour-long podcast and come up with things I would never piece together in my own head. So please let me know all of your thoughts, theories, and opinions in the comments on Spotify and on YouTube. Please make sure that you are subscribed over on YouTube. And if you're listening to the podcast version of this show on Spotify or Apple Podcast, please double check that you're actually following the show. And please rate and review the show because that is what really, really helps push these episodes out to even more people. Thank you so much for listening to Megan Elliott's case. While you are in the comments, just please always remember to be respectful. At the end of the day, there is a devastating loss in this case and a family that has suffered a lot. So please always remember to be respectful. And while you're in the comments, please let me know a case that you would like to see covered in a future hot on the case episode. But until then, that's all I have for this week's investigation. And I will see you guys all next Friday when we are hot in the case once again.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Benjamin Elliott claimed he was sleepwalking and had a realistic nightmare when he stabbed his twin sister Megan to death in their home on September 29, 2021.
Despite multiple inconsistencies in his story—such as being awake and active hours before the incident, whispering during the 911 call, and no mention of asking for help—Ben remained emotionally detached and focused on defending his sleepwalking claim.
Medical records show Benjamin had sleep apnea but no documented history of violent sleepwalking, while witnesses reported prior episodes of sleepwalking, including one where he was seen eating a donut while awake.
Phone records place Benjamin awake and active from late at night until after the stabbing, contradicting his claim of falling asleep and sleepwalking in the early morning.
Forensic evidence shows Megan was stabbed twice in the neck, with a deep second wound severing major blood vessels, yet no significant blood was found at the scene, contradicting Ben’s account of using a pillow to stop bleeding.
The prosecution argued that sleepwalking could not involve unsheathing a knife or planning a violent act, and that dreaming during sleepwalking is scientifically impossible.
The jury found Benjamin guilty of first-degree murder after only four hours of deliberation, despite the lack of motive and a strong sleepwalking defense, and jurors later requested leniency.
Benjamin was sentenced to 15 years in prison with early release possibilities, a verdict seen as unusually lenient for a murder conviction, suggesting significant reasonable doubt about his guilt.
Summary:
Benjamin Elliott, a 17-year-old twin, was arrested after calling 911 to report he had stabbed his sister Megan to death in her sleep. He claimed the incident was a vivid nightmare and that he was sleepwalking, a defense supported by witnesses of past sleepwalking incidents and a sleep expert. However, multiple inconsistencies undermine this narrative: phone records show he was awake and active hours before the stabbing, his emotional detachment and lack of concern for his sister’s condition during the 911 call raise red flags, and forensic evidence indicates two deep stab wounds with no visible blood at the scene—contradicting his story of using a pillow to stop bleeding.
The prosecution countered that violent sleepwalking is rare and impossible to perform complex actions like unsheathing a knife, and that dreaming during sleepwalking is scientifically invalid. Despite a lack of motive and a clean criminal record, Benjamin was convicted of first-degree murder. The jury reached a verdict quickly and later requested leniency, leading to a 15-year sentence—an unusually light punishment for a murder conviction.
His case remains controversial due to the absence of clear signs of premeditation, the strength of the sleepwalking defense, and the emotional disconnect in his behavior. Benjamin continues to maintain he did not intend to kill his sister, and the case highlights the tension between medical explanations, behavioral anomalies, and the difficulty of determining intent in emotionally complex family tragedies.
FAQs
There is no definitive proof that Benjamin was sleepwalking. While he has a history of sleepwalking and a sleep expert testified to that, the prosecution argues it's unlikely due to the complexity of unsheathing a knife and the lack of violent sleepwalking history. Medical records show sleep apnea, not sleepwalking, and evidence like phone records and behavior during the incident cast doubt on the sleepwalking claim.
Phone records show Benjamin was awake and active at 4:01 a.m., watching videos and walking to his sister’s room, contradicting his claim of falling asleep and sleepwalking. Additionally, he claimed to have a vivid dream of stabbing his sister, but dreaming during sleepwalking is scientifically impossible, and his behavior during the 911 call — whispering and not seeking help — seems inconsistent with a shocked, awake person.
Benjamin repeatedly stated he thought it was a dream, suggesting a sleepwalking defense. However, experts argue that such a narrative is inconsistent with known sleep science, as dreaming occurs during REM sleep and sleepwalking during non-REM sleep. Moreover, the story appears to be a deliberate attempt to distance himself from the crime, rather than a genuine reaction to an accident.
Benjamin was diagnosed with sleep apnea, but there is no history of sleepwalking in his medical records. His family claims they never discussed it with doctors, though multiple witnesses, including his older sister and a friend, reported prior incidents of him sleepwalking during childhood, showing a pattern of sleepwalking behavior.
The prosecution could not identify any motive, as the family described a close, loving bond with no resentment or conflict. Benjamin's father disliked hunting, undermining the theory that he had a desire to kill. The defense argued that no clear motive existed, making the case of intentional murder highly suspicious.
After four hours of deliberation, the jury found Benjamin guilty of first-degree murder. However, they later asked for leniency during sentencing, suggesting uncertainty about his guilt. The judge sentenced him to 15 years, a remarkably light punishment for a murder conviction, indicating potential doubt among jurors.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.