The Birthday Party Murders | The Case of Midsi Sanchez | UNSEEN
19m 30s
Mitzi Sanchez, an 8-year-old girl from Vallejo, California, was abducted on August 10, 2000, after being approached by a man who forced her into his car. Held for two days, she endured severe physical and emotional abuse, including sexual assault, chaining, and threats of death. On August 12, she escaped by jumping in front of a truck, leading to the arrest of Curtis Anderson, who confessed to the kidnappings and abuse of multiple children, including the missing girls Zianna Fairchild and Amber Swartz-Garcia. Mitzi testified at Anderson’s trial, directly identifying him and helping secure a 251-year sentence. Though her ordeal left lasting trauma, she later found strength through motherhood after surviving a car accident in 2009. She now lives a fulfilling life, using her story to advocate for missing children through the Mitzi Sanchez Foundation, promoting safety education and offering hope to victims and their families. Her journey from victim to advocate embodies resilience, proving that trauma can be transformed into purpose and empowerment.
"Happy birthday to you!"
This footage hides the most disturbing secret. It was taken on August 12, 2000,
in Vallejo, California. The girl in the window is 8-year-old Mitzi Sanchez.
She looks happy in her father's arms, surrounded by friends and family.
But on her birthday, Mitzi's life will take a shocking turn for the worse.
Twelve years earlier, Amber Swartz-Garcia is playing jump rope in her front yard in Pinole,
California, when she's abducted in broad daylight. After years of searching with no solid leads,
the 7-year-old is presumed dead. Her body is never found.
December 9, 1999, 11 years after the disappearance of Amber, 7-year-old
Zianna Fairchild goes missing after witnesses saw her talking to a man at a Vallejo gas station.
One year passes, and still Zianna is nowhere to be found.
For over 12 years, the state of California is
terrorized by a serial killer targeting children.
Having made eight victims already, no one knows where he will strike next.
But on August 12, 2000, 8-year-old Mitzi Sanchez will become the last victim of the serial killer.
She will be forever known as the one who escaped, and brought him to justice.
It's December 9, 1999. In the quiet town of Vallejo, California, Mitzi Sanchez lives a normal
life with her parents and her three siblings. 7:30 am, less than two miles away from where Mitzi lives,
7-year-old Zianna Fairchild disappears on her way to school. Police follow every possible lead,
and find her missing. When the police arrive at the crime scene, Mitzi Sanchez appears to be
in the middle of the street, and the police take her to the police station. The police search the
house, and find her in the middle of the street. In the middle of the street, the police search the house,
and find her missing. After months of investigation with the help of the FBI,
the case grows cold. Zianna Fairchild is presumed dead.
August 10, 2000, 8 months after the disappearance of Zianna, Mitzi Sanchez leaves for school at
around 7:30 am. It's Mitzi's birthday, and her mother Susanna is preparing a party for her.
At around 4 pm, Mitzi's sister begins to worry that she hasn't come home from school yet, and calls her mother.
After reaching out to teachers and friends, Susanna understands that her daughter is missing.
The entire family starts to worry, calling everyone they can to ask for help, and searching for the
8-year-old girl. When police arrive, flyers are already being handed out in the neighborhood,
people knocking on every door, but there's no trace of her.
August 11, 2000, 24 hours have passed since Mitzi went missing. The sheriff's department receives
a phone call from a landfill worker, who claims to have seen bloody clothing in one of the truck dumps,
investigators discover the cloth belonged to a Vallejo motel. They fear the worst for Mitzi and
Zianna, but as the police scour the landfill, no further evidence is found. Time is running out.
August 12, 2000, 2 days since Mitzi was taken. At around 11 am, the sheriff's office receives
a call from a man named Carl Tafua, who says an 8-year-old girl jumped in front of his truck,
and says to have been kidnapped. He also has the license plate number of the car
from which the girl has escaped. When police ask for the name of the
girl, she says her name is Mitzi Sanchez. With the license plate number given to police
by the truck driver, the search focuses on one man, Curtis Anderson. Apparently,
police know Anderson very well. The location where Mitzi was rescued is close
to Anderson's former place of employment. According to a colleague, he came in to ask
for a heavy-duty garbage bag. August 12, several hours after Mitzi's escape,
Curtis Anderson is arrested. As Mitzi is brought home in the arms of her father,
she's welcomed by a crowd of cheering friends and family. Although they mean to celebrate
her return, Mitzi is visibly too upset. It was a birthday party the Sanchez family and
their Vallejo neighbors feared would never happen. No one understands the nightmare she
just went through. Her story begins on August 10. It was the day of my birthday party. I wanted to
help my mom get all this stuff together, go get the cakes, set up balloons. And so I didn't want to
go to school. I asked my mom if I could just, you know, stay home. But she said no. She didn't want
me to miss school. She wanted to surprise me, you know, and do her own thing. So I went to school
that day. Mitzi spends her day in class waiting anxiously for the bell to ring. Normally,
our routine was I would meet up with my brother right after school and some friends,
and we would walk, walk home together. They couldn't wait. The bell rang, and I, I, I, I, I,
I took off. Her house is only six blocks away. As her route is on one of the busiest streets in
Vallejo, she doesn't think twice about leaving without her siblings, convinced that nothing will
happen. When she's only one block away from her house, she notices a car parked down the road,
with a man sitting inside, looking in her direction. At first, she doesn't make much of it.
I started to approach the car. I just had this weird gut-wrenching feeling that something wasn't
right. She tries to ignore her feeling and walks straight forward, looking ahead. I remember making
eye contact with him through the rearview mirror. As she gets closer, the man gets out of the driver's
seat and approaches Mitzi. He stopped me and said, "Hey, I need your help." I was in a,
in a bike accident, and I broke my hip. He asked me to, um, reach over for some duct tape that was on
the floorboard of his car, because he said he couldn't bend over, and, and so I did.
At that moment, she feels the full-grown man press his entire weight against her, trapping her.
Though she tries to fight him off and scream, the man is too strong, and Mitzi is shoved inside the
car. He covered my mouth with his hand, and he shut the door behind me. I just tried grabbing
the door handle and opening, and it just wouldn't open. The man quickly drives off with Mitzi,
swerving through traffic. No one can see what's going on inside the car. Mitzi stops screaming
as it becomes clear no one can hear her. As we were making that left towards the highway,
I could see my home. I was that close to home. I remember just looking
at my home, wanting to be there so bad. I felt so helpless.
After driving around for a few minutes, the man turns into a hardware store parking lot.
There, he hands her a bundle of clothes and forces her to change.
My thought was, whose clothes are these? It was just so awkward to me.
I did, you know, everything he said. I didn't want to make him mad, or I didn't want,
you know, I didn't want him to hurt me, so I just, I just went along.
The man warns her, "I have a gun in the trunk. No one has ever gotten away from me, so
don't even try." Then, he drives off again. When night comes, he parks the car in a rest
area and carefully covers the windows with blankets and towels. Mitzi keeps thinking
of a way she could escape, worried of what he might do to her, waiting for the right moment.
I noticed that there were restrooms nearby, so I asked him if I could
get out and use the bathroom, and he said no.
As the man walks back into the car, he puts a chain around Mitzi's ankle and padlocks it to the
gear shift. Then, he takes out a bottle of alcohol and forces her to take a shot.
I remember he started to pull out Polaroids of naked women. I remember just
closing my eyes and not wanting to, not wanting to open them. He pulled out his Polaroid and started
snapping photos. I felt so violated and helpless. Later that night, Mitzi is awake while the man sleeps beside her.
She's exhausted, but she doesn't want to close her eyes, afraid of what might happen,
of what the man might do to her. Limited to the interior of the man's junky car,
the little girl wonders if her family is looking for her, or if they even know she's gone.
Through a small interstice, Mitzi sees a cop car patrolling the area, his lights
illuminating the parking lot. She wishes she could scream out or jump out of the vehicle,
but she remembers the man's words. If she tries anything, he'll kill her.
A few seconds later, the cop drives off. And I thought, this is it. I'm not going to
see my family again. August 11th, it's day number two. That morning, the man starts to drive off
around town. Mitzi is forced to sit on the floorboard, covered by a blanket. After a few
minutes, the car stops, and the man starts to drive off again. After a few minutes,
the car stops at a house, and the man gets out. While he's gone, Mitzi tries to pick the lock of
her chain, but soon realizes that it would be impossible for her to open it or wiggle it off.
When the man comes back, he drives off again. But when he tells Mitzi where he went,
her heart drops. He had actually walked into our home asking for flyers so he could help pass
him out around the city. As time passes, Mitzi, who is denied food or water, is becoming weaker
and weaker. After spending most of the day driving around, making numerous stops, the man drives into
an industrial parking lot away from the city. He unchained my leg and he made me jump over into
the driver's seat and he was standing outside of the car and that was the moment that he
raped me. My entire body went into shock. I felt helpless. I didn't, I didn't, I never cried in
front of him. Although I was dying and breaking and falling apart inside, I wasn't going to give
him that satisfaction.
Night falls.
As the previous night, she forbids herself to fall asleep, too fearful of what he could do
if she closes her eyes. Instead, she finds her escape in the stars, gazing at them and wishing
to be home. I didn't know what was going on at home. I just knew that I missed them. I wanted
to be with them. I prayed for God to let my family know that I love them. The next morning,
they drive out of the parking lot to his former place of work. It's around 8 10 a.m. At this point,
he remembers his usual routine. He goes out to buy alcohol and cigarettes, leaving her
chained up in the car for around 30 minutes. And when he comes back, she knows she'll be
forced to do terrible things. This time, however, something is different. The man warns her
not to look and leaves again, but Mitzi doesn't listen. She leans over to the driver's seat and sees on the
floor a ring full of keys. Mitzi hurries out of the window of the car, but as her feet hit the
floor, her knees buckle. She's too weak to run, but she can't give up now. As she walks around the car,
the man sees her and screams for her to come back, but she doesn't stop. She staggers her way down the
street. Mitzi can see the man start to chase after her. Cars pass by, and she tries to wave them down,
begging them for help, but no one stops. Still, she continues to walk as fast as her legs can
carry her. If she hesitates for just one second, she knows the man will kill her.
As she sees a truck driving in her direction, the man is almost there.
In one last attempt to escape his grasp, she jumps out in front of the truck,
in the middle of the road. Finally, the driver stops.
As Mitzi explains that she's been kidnapped, the truck driver looks around for the man,
but he's nowhere in sight. Then, a car pulls out of the parking lot in a hurry.
That's when the driver takes down his license plate and calls the police.
Within the next 10 hours, police have Curtis Anderson in custody. As news makes its way to
the community, one thought comes up. If Mitzi escaped and the man is caught,
what happened to Zianna Fairchild?
The girl who went missing the year before, is she still alive?
As everyone breathes a sigh of relief for the safe return of Mitzi Sanchez,
there is still no happy ending.
One person who can't forget about the missing girl named Zianna is Mitzi herself. She struggles
with the idea that she made it out alive, but Zianna is still out there. Less than two weeks
after her ordeal, eight-year-old Mitzi Sanchez rallies with volunteers to search for the missing
child. She feels she can't rest until they find her. January 2001, police have found the remains
of a child up in the Santa Cruz Mountains. Soon after, detectives confirm that the identity of the
child is Zianna Fairchild. According to the investigation, Zianna was murdered the same
night she was taken. Mitzi is destroyed. It's April 2001. The trial of Curtis Anderson
begins, and Mitzi is called up to the witness stand. The courtroom was packed, and I remember
seeing him sitting over in his wheelchair, and I just had to get up on that stand and do what I
had to do to be able to put him away. In front of a judge and jury, and of Curtis himself,
Mitzi describes in detail her entire ordeal. Everyone is shocked by her story. On the first
day of testimony, the eight-year-old kidnap victim climbed onto the witness stand and
calmly pointed out the man who she said grabbed her off the street and sexually molested her for
two days before she escaped. As prosecutor Donna Stashin asked her one detailed question after
another, the little girl clutched her teddy bear and answered in a strong, clear voice.
It made me feel really proud of Mitzi, that she went up there and pointed him out and said,
he's the person that did this to me. Because of her incredible memory and courage,
Anderson is sentenced to 251 years in prison.
But his taunting is not over. He confesses to the murder of another young girl 12 years prior,
Amber Schwartz, who was taken from her front yard at 7 years old. In an attempt to negotiate with
police, Anderson also confesses to having kidnapped and killed 13 other girls, but he
refuses to give up details without accommodation. I'm not going to be inmate of the month in the
cell block. The majority of the people in there are going to try and kill me the first chance
they get. And then when that happens, nobody will ever get the answers they want.
Although her captor is behind bars, Mitzi's victory is short-lived. Life becomes harder
than it was before the kidnapping. At school, Mitzi gets bullied for being
labeled the kidnapped girl. Kids think she loves the attention she gets on TV.
Every time a child goes missing, Mitzi volunteers to show support and help in the search. But every
time they find the missing child too late, Mitzi is crushed and spirals downwards again.
I drank and I drank and I drank. I had no tools to deal with the pain and devastation that I was
feeling. But everything changes on May 1st, 2009. After a night of drinking with friends,
Mitzi is involved in a horrific car accident. I flew through the windshield, broke my nose,
my neck, my arm. I was in a car accident. I was
And I was in a coma for two weeks.
When Mitzi wakes up, doctors tell her the news that will shift her entire world upside down.
She is pregnant with a daughter.
That was when my life took a turn for the better.
Carl Tafu is my hero.
If it weren't for him driving down that street at that exact moment,
I don't think I would be here today.
I know you don't feel like a hero, but you're my hero.
So good to see you.
So good to see you.
You had my back and you were quick thinking and everything that you did was just on point.
And I'm so grateful for you.
You truly are my hero.
Now, Mitzi is a loving mother, raising her daughter alone.
She says she owes it to Zianna and Amber and to other victims.
To make sure she makes a difference with her life.
She doesn't define herself by her ordeal anymore.
We can use our trial for triumph and come out stronger.
It's not meant to keep us down.
I am living proof that you can be successful.
You can be happy.
You can live your best life.
She sees her story as a tool to help others, a way to give hope.
She created the Mitzi Sanchez Foundation.
To fight for the recovery of missing children.
To teach children about safety is what gives me purpose in life.
I get to use my story that was just so much trauma, but I get to use it for triumph.
I'll see you next time.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Mitzi Sanchez, an 8-year-old girl from Vallejo, California, was kidnapped on August 10, 2000, after being approached by a man in a parked car.
She was held for two days, during which she was sexually abused, chained, denied food and water, and threatened with a gun.
On August 12, 2000, Mitzi escaped by jumping in front of a truck, leading to the arrest of Curtis Anderson, who confessed to abducting and abusing multiple children.
The case linked Mitzi’s kidnapping to the earlier disappearances of Zianna Fairchild and Amber Swartz-Garcia, both of whom were later confirmed dead.
Mitzi testified at Anderson’s trial, pointing directly to him and helping secure a 251-year prison sentence.
Despite the arrest, Mitzi faced ongoing trauma, including bullying at school and emotional distress from the unresolved fate of her missing peers.
After a serious car accident in 2009, she survived and became a mother, transforming her pain into purpose.
Mitzi founded the Mitzi Sanchez Foundation to support missing children’s recovery and promote child safety education.
Summary:
Mitzi Sanchez, an 8-year-old girl from Vallejo, California, was abducted on August 10, 2000, after being approached by a man who forced her into his car. Held for two days, she endured severe physical and emotional abuse, including sexual assault, chaining, and threats of death. On August 12, she escaped by jumping in front of a truck, leading to the arrest of Curtis Anderson, who confessed to the kidnappings and abuse of multiple children, including the missing girls Zianna Fairchild and Amber Swartz-Garcia.
Mitzi testified at Anderson’s trial, directly identifying him and helping secure a 251-year sentence. Though her ordeal left lasting trauma, she later found strength through motherhood after surviving a car accident in 2009. She now lives a fulfilling life, using her story to advocate for missing children through the Mitzi Sanchez Foundation, promoting safety education and offering hope to victims and their families.
Her journey from victim to advocate embodies resilience, proving that trauma can be transformed into purpose and empowerment.
FAQs
Mitzi was kidnapped from the street by a man named Curtis Anderson, who held her for two days, sexually abused her, and chained her to the car. She escaped by jumping in front of a truck, leading to her rescue.
Curtis Anderson was the man who kidnapped Mitzi Sanchez. He confessed to the murder of Amber Swartz-Garcia and the abduction and abuse of other children, including Zianna Fairchild.
Zianna Fairchild went missing the year before Mitzi was abducted. Her body was later found in the Santa Cruz Mountains, identified as the victim of the same serial killer, confirming that Mitzi's case was part of a larger pattern of child abductions.
While chained in a car, Mitzi saw a ring of keys on the floor. She managed to escape by walking toward the street, eventually jumping in front of a truck, which stopped and led to her rescue.
Mitzi testified in court, clearly describing the abduction, abuse, and escape. She pointed directly to Anderson and provided detailed evidence, leading to his conviction on multiple counts of child abuse and murder.
Zianna Fairchild’s body was discovered in the Santa Cruz Mountains in January 2001, and investigators confirmed she was murdered the night she went missing.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.