The Ben Affleck Hall of Fame and ‘Animals.’ Plus: ‘Other Mommy’ Is Jump-Scary and Silly
128m 47s
The episode explores two recent films—*Other Mommy* and *Animals*—through a lens of genre, narrative, and audience reaction. *Other Mommy*, based on a novel and starring Jessica Chastain, is praised for its inventive visuals, especially the balloon and ball pit sequences, but criticized for a disjointed plot, inconsistent storytelling, and shallow emotional depth. Despite its unsettling premise involving a girl haunted by a demonic "Other Mommy," it fails to deliver a coherent narrative, leaning heavily on genre tropes without grounding them in believable logic. In contrast, *Animals*, a Netflix film directed by Ben Affleck, is dismissed as a chaotic, genre-blending disaster. It attempts to merge political drama, family conflict, and social commentary into a single story, but suffers from disjointed pacing, misused actors (like Steven Yeun), and a lack of authentic emotional stakes. The film’s structure feels like a series of unrelated plotlines stitched together, undermining its narrative integrity. Both films exemplify a broader trend in modern cinema where ambitious concepts and strong marketing fail due to poor execution and lack of focus. The discussion also touches on how online fan communities and critical backlash amplify the impact of underperforming films, especially when they take bold or controversial risks. Ultimately, the show underscores the importance of genre authenticity and narrative clarity, arguing that even with high-profile casting and marketing, films must deliver genuine emotional and structural coherence to resonate with audiences. The episode ends with a nod to the growing role of fan-driven discourse in shaping cinematic success, while questioning whether filmmakers are better suited to television or more focused storytelling in film.
I'm Sean Fennessy.
I'm Amanda Dobbins.
And this is the Big Picture, a conversation show about animals, mommies, and Big Ben.
Today on the show, Amanda and I will dig into The Weeknd's Jessica Chastain-starring horror hit Other Mommy,
as well as the new film Animals, which premiered on the Netflix streaming service over the weekend.
Animals is the latest directorial effort from Amanda's spirit animal, Ben Affleck.
Nice way of putting it.
And yet we have never built a hall of fame for the actor, writer, director, former Batman, Ben Affleck.
So we will do that very thing today on the show as well.
But first, some movie news right after this.
Coca-Cola.
For the big.
For the small.
The short.
And the tall.
Peacemaker.
Risk takers.
For the optimist.
Pessimist.
For long-distance love.
For introverts and extroverts.
The thinkers and the doers.
For old friends and new.
Coca-Cola.
For everyone.
Pick up some Coca-Cola at a store near you.
Okay, Amanda.
I transport you back to 1985.
Yeah.
You are doing what?
I'm learning to walk.
Maybe if you're lucky.
Maybe?
I think at that point.
Okay.
1985, this is an important year at the cinema next year because Miami Vice 85 is officially happening.
We've seen some early images from this film.
It's going to star Michael B. Jordan as Tubbs and Austin Butler as Crockett.
How many episodes of the television show Miami Vice have you ever seen?
I was going to say, who is who?
Like, that's assuming that I know the names.
Yes.
I don't.
Really?
So you've not seen Miami Vice before?
I have seen the Michael Mann film.
Okay.
And I'm sure I've seen an episode or two, you know, in the orbit of my father.
But it's the same way I've like, quote unquote, seen episodes of Columbo, you know, which is just, it was on.
Okay.
And my dad is like, hey, what's up?
And I was not really paying attention.
Did you happen to see, thank you for bringing up Columbo.
Yeah.
Andrew Garfield on Good Hangs, Peter Falk.
Incredible.
What the fuck?
It was so, so good.
Obviously, he's the goat, but you have a Peter Falk in your bag.
That was amazing.
Anyhow, I love Columbo.
Miami Vice, not a huge show for me, but definitely something I watched growing up a little bit
as well.
This new movie is not related to the Michael Mann film, although it is clearly inspired
very much by the series that Michael Mann helmed, directed by Joseph Kaczynski, coming
off of Top Gun Maverick and F1, written by Dan Gilroy.
Yes.
Tony Gilroy's brother, the writer of a number of films.
You know, obviously, this is.
Very interesting to Chris Ryan.
I was just going to say.
For you, how do you feel about this?
We need to phone a friend segment.
It's just like phone a CR.
I'm following his lead.
There's been this wave of news connected to his soul.
Right?
So, and he hasn't been on the show in a minute.
Maybe next time he comes back, we'll get a full download from him.
We tried to recruit him, but for this.
Oh, for today's episode.
For today, yeah.
He's about to be traveling.
So, will you see it?
Will you see the movie?
Yeah, of course.
I mean, I like these guys.
Michael B. Jordan, Austin Butler.
Yes.
Joseph Kaczynski.
I've seen most of his work.
Huge fan.
So, like, Dan Gilroy can have fun and write a fun script.
And if this is a fun time at the movies with movie stars, I, you know, I accept.
Yeah, it's IP, but like soft IP.
It's just kind of an excuse to put guns in these guys' hands, I think.
And I'm down with that.
Box office.
Now, we'll get to Other Mommy momentarily.
It won the weekend with $28 million, which is not terribly surprising given how well
that movie was marketed.
The Social Reckoning earned $5.5 million.
Yeah, no bueno.
That's not, that's really bad.
That's really bad.
That's a, that is bomb status.
That's, what happened, do you think?
I don't know.
Everyone wrote it off.
I mean, I suppose a theatrical-only sequel to The Social Network that is led by Aaron Sorkin,
Mikey Madison, and Jeremy Allen White, who I wanted to call Jonathan Anderson because
the initials are the same.
You have one track mind these days.
I do.
Yeah.
Um, you know, it was marketed at a certain group of people.
It was not going to be a hundred million dollar opener.
Nor was The Social Network.
No, but the original film did well at the box office.
Yeah, but then everybody who was interested in it saw a trailer, read a review, and was
like, no, no, no, fool me twice.
That was going to be my question was, um, you know, it's related to Digger as well,
because obviously Digger pretty significantly underperformed.
And despite there being this huge kind of groundswell of emotional online support for
Digger, the Digger movement, um, it didn't.
It didn't do better in its second week either.
And so I'm kind of, I'm thinking a little bit about what is the impact of criticism
and word of mouth and for movies like this.
And your face being on phones saying, I did not think this worked.
Uh, well, I guess I wasn't thinking so specifically about myself, but I guess I am a part of the
problem in that case.
You know, the, the, the social reckoning wasn't good.
I mean, it didn't work.
And so I wonder, was it depressed, the audience depressed because it was
clear that the film wasn't working or was it just that there was no audience for a movie
like this regardless?
I think it's a smaller audience to start with.
And that's an audience that also reads reviews and thinks about the quality of things and
is not, and if a movie is bad, they're not going to check it out or they're going to
wait and watch it at home like an episode of the morning show, which it is.
I think that's right.
I mean, the social network made $225 million back in 2010 and did very, very well, obviously,
was an awards contender and helmed by a very successful commercial filmmaker and Fincher
at that time.
But, uh, $5.5 million.
I mean, I think it just kind of puts truth to what we felt like has been happening with
Sorkin too, which is his last two movies were streaming only, um, being the Ricardos being
on Amazon prime and trial of Chicago seven being on Netflix.
Molly's game was nine years ago and it only made $58 million back then.
Right.
And that was about celebrities paying, playing poker.
That's right.
There was a kind of built in, you know, promotional tool.
And so, I mean, Sorkin is just not a box office draw and he's not really much of a filmmaker.
So what do you do next?
If you're Aaron Sorkin, what do you think?
Make a TV show?
Probably the idea.
Yeah.
And this would have been an interesting miniseries, which we discussed, right?
That there at least would have been more, it would have been more coherent to try to tackle
so many different things in one movie.
And I don't, I don't want to push our filmmakers towards television, but Aaron Sorkin comes
from TV.
He does.
And he was quite good at it.
Yeah.
And we.
We still reference the TV that he made along with the scripts that he wrote in the 90s
far more than any of his directorial work.
I also feel like he was so ahead of the curve in the 30 minute dramedy zone with Sports
Night, you know, that, you know, there had obviously been, you know, some TV creators
like Norman Lear in the 70s who were making 30 minute dramedy style shows, but that's
a hard thing to do.
And they're more common now making shows like that.
I would love to see him take a crack at something like that instead of 82 minute newsroom episodes.
Why can't we just bring back Sports Night?
I would love that.
I think that'd be great.
And do it in 2026.
It'd be amazing.
Honestly, it'd be really smart because it would mirror the careers of many of the men
and women for whom that show is based on.
Yeah.
So the Keith Olbermanns, the Dan Patrick's, the Rich Eisen's, like all of those guys
are still sportscasters in our lives.
Rich Eisen is now back at ESPN after all these years.
So that would be interesting.
Sports Night reboot.
Wow.
Listen, I want, I want the best for everyone, including Josh Charles, who's now like the
good doctor.
The new doctor, the local doctor.
What's the doctor?
You guys have seen these commercials on football.
This is a television show?
Yes.
Josh Charles is leading a network television series where he's a doctor.
Best Medicine.
Best Medicine.
Okay.
What is that?
Is that an aphorism?
He is Dr. Martin Best.
Yeah.
See, this is what I'm saying.
Help the guy out.
That's because his last name is Best.
Aaron Sorkin, we need you.
And so does Josh Charles in the television format.
Okay.
That's just not very creative.
Well, listen, you don't watch these commercials during football?
That would be like if that show was about me and it was called Fantasy Medicine.
Yeah, right.
Just because your last name is Best.
All right.
Is Best Medicine the name of his practice, do we think?
No, I think like the best medicine is something is a saying.
I don't, but I don't know.
I don't know how to finish the sentence.
Listen, this is on like CBS or some shit.
Like, what do you want me to tell you?
It's a Skydance project.
David Ellison, CBS.
I don't know.
What network is it on?
I shouldn't.
Blaspheme.
I'll have to look.
Yeah.
Okay.
That's the medicine.
That made my day.
Okay.
Okay.
Sorkin back to TV.
Got it.
Yeah.
Good job by you.
Thank you.
Heart of the Beast, Resident Evil, and Primetime.
Doing pretty well.
So.
Yeah.
I think it's, I'm kind of working my way through the social reckoning thing doing so poorly
because Heart of the Beast shows that there's still like an older audience for a certain
kind of a movie.
Primetime is showing there's a younger audience for a certain kind of movie.
It was interesting to watch those movies go up against each other.
You know, Heart of the Beast cost a lot of money, but it's going to end up making like
over a hundred million dollars.
Probably worldwide.
Primetime is going to make 75 million dollars, maybe a hundred million dollars worldwide.
Those movies do really well.
Resident Evil, we know that's IP done well and horror.
All that stuff is explicable to us, right?
Yes.
But to me, the lesson is if you're not going to be like a 800 million billion dollar IP
thing, then you have to find your exact audience.
You have to know what it is and you also have to make a movie good enough that they'll go.
Yeah.
Heart of the Beast, the dog, they had the dog audience.
Primetime is a great movie and has found its young people audience, I think the A24 audience
of it all. They've marketed that very well. Robert Pattinson has been very
involved um i think resident evil you know and the zach crager identified the up-and-coming auteur so
audience and built into that social reckoning i guess knew its audience but unfortunately its
audience is just watching msnbc at home i think you're right so and and once again its audience
heard that it was quite poor so you know sometimes things are just not good and so they don't work
i want to ask you one last thing about digger yeah so not specifically about the movie digger
but since it's not doing well it obviously has a strong vocal advocacy and we've seen this i have
participated in this with other movies over the years sure that have not done as well but that
have been very audacious films babylon high forever obviously that's something that i will
always live with um but this is now an interesting trend in cinephilia where a big film that takes a
lot of chances and swings that typically has a very big budget that usually features stars
but
Hope doesn't perform well at the box office and then you get this enormous noisy blowback from a
small but in theory powerful contingent of people i didn't think of i couldn't think of a too many
other examples of it but there have been three or four over the last 10 years is this just that we
like we like to get behind something that feels like the underdog even if it's the overdog well i
think it's more evidence of that cinephilia and movies are back in a specific way and that people
got to post about something
you know that movies kind of have their own stand hive at this point specific just to movies which
is great yeah and people and the industry is finding different ways to make money off of that
unless you're aaron sorkin and the social reckoning but i think that it's just part of
online stand culture is that then you gotta you gotta find bits you gotta find ways to post you
know we have some great posters on our team the team being the the cinephile team uh we you and
i do what we can absolutely post as well i've been reducing my posting but yes well i'm not posting
i'm not part of digger hide right you know my answer to what i think of it is still i don't
know like i've been talking a lot about it and i don't really know uh i haven't still haven't seen
it a second time and i will um you know i i don't i'm not sure if i'm gonna be moved off of what my
position on the movie was but i it's actually been fun to observe this not being a part of it
with babylon it was kind of like you put your blinders on and you're just like this moved me
sometimes it's hard to put to words why it moved me and once you start pushing someone to start
explaining why something is special which is our entire jobs the themes can unravel a little bit
um but i i do appreciate that people really love the movie yeah the only other thing i would say
about digger you noted on our episode that the reviews were quite vicious and then it really
did feel like a critical generation was just coming for you to read you yes uh and had been
almost waiting for this moment and you know you and i are not historical
big and rich people but it did it does feel like when a movie is not as disastrous as the reviews
lead it to believe then people also jump in and are like wait well you know which is just the
well actually brain of the internet applied to old school too yeah that was true 60 years ago
with the bosley crowdlers of the world writing reviews of films for young people and him not
getting them and then kind of rejecting the old guard of criticism yeah so it's interesting that
something like that could happen now now it happening with
one of the most decorated filmmakers and the biggest movie star is also complicates this in
an interesting way but it just becoming this cause celeb has been fascinating to me um and i do think
that in addition to obviously the fans of the movie in the world there are a lot of filmmakers
and actors who really like the movie or who are at least publicly supporting the movie
which i think supports my like watch the boomerang award season on this movie i do i really do because
i think no one's seen it really but the people who are watching the movie are the people who are
going to bat for it the only people who are not going to bat for it are critics
other people are kind of going to bat for it yeah so of the people who have seen it right which is
this very this movie's made less than 35 million dollars it's a it's doing really poorly at the
box office i think that's the other thing which is you're right there may be more people and
especially academy voters and awards voters who see it and think oh this was better than i expected
and there may also be a lot of people who watch it at home on their screening site and turn it
off after 25 minutes definitely like that but i think it's a really good movie and i think it's
i'm quite bored definitely well or annoyed like we were discussing on the episode yeah no it's
possible i'm i'm i'm fascinated to see how it all shakes out and we shall cover it on the show
a couple of trailers for us over the weekend in front of other mommy we got the trailer for the
movie river which i mentioned earlier on the show that premiered at the toronto film festival which
adam name incited in our episode and then um was picked up it was originally going to be an ifc
movie and then blumhouse bought it from ifc they were going to put it on shutter and then i guess
paid a premium and now that movie's coming out
january 15th 2027 uh jane levy jessica roth slasher on a river i made you watch the trailer
any thoughts do we know which river is the river named no i don't know okay i'm just curious
geographically i'd like to know how much they engage with the you know local geography and
topography is it the nile can we get a fact check on that i mean i you know death on the nile one of
my favorite movies that's right yeah the
version not whatever kind of friend i did the bigger the bigger headline after river is exorcist
martyrs which is the will now be the fifth exorcist film the a quick follow-up to exorcist believer
which i don't think you ever got a chance to see no should i put that on my list i would keep things
that way okay uh that movie came out a few years ago david gordon green after rebooting halloween
for blumhouse he was attempting to reboot exorcist which i was reminded recently blumhouse paid 400
million dollars for the rights to make exorcist movies they made believer and they made exorcist
it bombed terribly and was awful so now they're back in the game very quickly mike flanagan is
hired to make exorcist martyrs which i think will effectively pretend like believer didn't happen
okay this new movie stars scarlett johansson that's also how i cope with tragedy uh by
pretend deleting things from your mind yeah i know it's amazing uh scar joe plays a homicide
detective who witnesses the execution of a famous serial killer played by john leguizamo in this
movie but the killings are not the same as the killings of john leguizamo in this movie but the
killings are not the same as the killings of john leguizamo in this movie but the killings are not
continue after he dies who do you think's doing that satan could be could be could be yeah so
i'm this is this is an observational spoiler from watching a trailer i'm just going to put
this out there people who've paid close attention already know this yeah but if you don't want to
know anything else about exorcist martyrs you could turn it off or not watch the trailer uh
this seems like it's a direct sequel to exorcist 3 exorcist 3 one of the most underrated horror
movies of all time occasionally chris ryan and i will discuss it uh that film
star george c scott as a homicide detective i think scar joe was playing his daughter
interesting what makes you say that well you can see the name kinderman on her okay uniform yeah
that was the name of george c scott's character in the movie george c scott's wig as bad as hers
is in this trailer he's not wearing a wig in that film okay that you know of that's true yeah but he
has like white hair that is thinning so i'm not sure that that would make a ton of sense for him
um i'm looking forward to this mike flanagan did this once before with doctor sleep
he made a sequel to a beloved horror classic and i liked it as i mentioned last week on the show
so will you see this sure okay yeah we um scarlett johansson was not at the can premiere of paper
tiger because she was filming this movie so i just gotta i gotta square the circle on that one
remember interesting and then they facetimed her that's right and then she didn't pick up yeah that
was tough heartbreaking i thought that was a good use of ovation time what else are you supposed to
do trying to call her yeah yeah it was a good bit next time i am
fed it at can yes i will call you okay i promise and i just try to pick up a couple more quick
things sadie sink to star in an adaptation of emma klein's the guest did you read the guest i did
i haven't read the new emma klein yet but i read and liked the guest i think this is great
casting i lorian skifaria is going to direct which is a great assignment is this her first feature
since hustlers i think it is maybe she's done a lot of tv in the intervening time um i'm very pro
seems great yeah i'm excited about that too um netflix and and
eric seen france are adapting gary paulson's book hatchet which we were reminded of in 1980s
this was very classic big in the elementary schools yeah and like and the scholastic book
fair exactly that's what i remember funny you should say that my daughter has her book fair
today today's the scholastic book fair that's really funny i got a photo already of her shopping
for a book oh my that i lived for those book fairs it's so fun shopping and books it's like wow
um so this is cool i obviously i love seeing france and i think it's a good idea to do that
probably hard for him to get theatrical movies made you know what was his last film was not
roof man roof man thank you uh which you liked i did like roof man i liked the kirsten dunst was in
it okay good enough last note of news yeah the beatles films now we said this when the news was
originally broken but then we got confused we've been doing bits about the beatles movies for what
feels like five years but it turns out that these movies which are coming out in april 2028 will
come out sequentially over
consecutive weeks in the month so there will be four movies about each movie about a different
member of the beatles so i guess it'll be like april 4th april 11th april 18th april 25th yeah
did you do you know that those are the fridays or you just i'm just i'm just guessing yeah i'm
sorry i mean we do have the technology available well i'm speaking right now so it's a little hard
to google and speak but uh i think we can find the proper dates okay and we'll correct the record
yeah you can you can use i mean just saying because then people will need to plan their
parties and then they'll be able to do it so i'm just saying because then people need to plan their
parties for like the four last big picture episodes that's right yeah well and then the
x-men extravaganza right right that would be like the like the christmas special you know the x-men
that's right
We're going to do that episode on the Queen Mary, and then we're going to take off.
We're just out to sea forever.
Four movies in four weekends.
This was my first thought about this.
Yes.
Do people have time for this?
Like, we have time, obviously.
I have time.
But, like, do even common movie fans have 14 hours in a month to devote to going to see these films in theaters?
Well, all of the loyalty programs suggest to me that people have time for a lot of tickets.
The films will also stay in theaters.
So, whatever film is number one.
And the order has not been released.
But right now, I think you've got to do Paul, George, Ringo, John.
That's just where I am.
Paul, George, Ringo, John.
I think that's great.
Thank you.
I think that's brilliant.
So, Paul will still be in theaters when Ringo hits.
And John.
John hits.
So, you could, theoretically, just wait.
Who gets pulled from theaters first?
George, sadly.
No, Ringo.
Listen.
Come on, George.
George is the best.
But George is.
Listen.
Ringo's going.
No shot.
Ringo's still alive.
He's still with us.
God bless him.
Ringo's going out first.
Okay.
The Ringo movie?
There's a whole movie about Ringo?
I love Ringo.
What are we doing?
Think about it chronologically.
Oh, there's more story to tell?
I think Ringo is when they break up.
And it's just like Ringo there being like, what's happening?
Oh, he's smart.
Yeah.
I'm so sad.
And I'm really good at drumming.
No, he was a binding force during the breakups.
Well, then he's trying to keep it together.
Because he was the link between Paul and George.
And he can't.
Yeah.
And that's the conflict of the movie.
So, then people will want to go see it.
Why aren't we producers on this?
No, you're so smart.
That's such a smart observation that you have to have the most incident in Ringo.
Like, there has to be the most dramatic moments.
And then John can be more of an existential exploration given that his life was cut so short.
Here's why we're not producers on this.
Because we've seen all the pictures.
Of the wigs.
And have said so many negative things.
That we haven't really.
I like can't.
You've been doing it privately.
I don't really do that because.
My Instagram's not private.
It's very public.
Oh, yeah.
You have been doing that publicly.
I haven't been doing that publicly.
Because behind the scenes photos are just not to be trusted.
I just don't.
That's true.
I don't judge movies based on somebody taking a photo 80 feet away of a person in makeup.
Like, we have post-production in films for a reason.
I am concerned about the wigs.
Sure.
I mean, that is a problem that can be applied to almost every film that I see.
But, yeah.
So, that makes me nervous.
Okay.
But, I'm rooting for those guys.
Just the actual structure of four films over four weekends.
I think for any hardcore movie fan or for any hardcore Beatles fan, logical.
Yeah.
For regular people?
I don't know.
Maybe it's what gets them back.
It's a gambit.
It's a real gambit.
Maybe they just pick one movie, you know?
What do you think will be the highest grossing, John?
No, Paul.
The first one.
Just from a basic number?
From a person's perspective.
This is just a delicious thing that is happening.
Yeah.
I just love something that is just completely new like this.
Like, we've just never seen.
Obviously, it's the Beatles.
We're obsessed.
For my brain, I'm like, this is so exciting.
Key check in the booth.
Do you care?
I do care.
Lucas?
Yeah, I'm very interested.
Okay.
Okay, good.
Do you care about the Beatles?
Moderately.
I do care about the Beatles.
Okay.
Well, you know, you guys are the future and we're proud of you.
Well, speaking of the future, it's time to go to Other Mommy.
All right.
All right.
This is the new film from Rob Savage.
It's based on Incidents Around the House by Josh Mallerman.
Did you read Incidents Around the House?
No.
Did you know that this was based on a novel?
I did when I opened your outline.
Okay.
So you didn't.
No.
Did you watch the credits?
No, I left.
He discussed.
This film stars Jessica Chastain, J.D. Ploss, Dyken Lachman, Arian Moyad, and Karen Allen.
The story of Other Mommy is. Bella, an eight-year-old girl living in a home with marital problems,
confronts a sinister entity that comes out of her closet.
The presence, whom she calls Other Mommy, becomes increasingly threatening to her and her family.
Now, I'm getting a vibe.
Yeah.
That maybe you were not a fan of Other Mommy.
What a fucking waste.
What a waste of a title, a premise, a marketing campaign, a cast, and my attention.
We could have done so much more.
And I would have done so much more.
I was really bored and disappointed after the first 15 minutes of this film.
I liked it.
I know.
I know.
I don't know that I loved it, but I liked it.
And I think this is somewhat similar to the Digger situation where I started seeing reviews
because the film was not screened for critics, which is usually a terrible sign.
Yeah.
And there were some early reviews on Thursday morning before I had a chance to see it that
were just like, woof, this is a real dog baby.
What happened here?
And then I actually thought it was kind of visually inventive for a horror film.
I thought narratively not coherent really at all.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
But I don't really have a huge problem with that with horror movies if I can be a little
bit swept away by it.
And I was kind of a little bit swept away by it.
Now, obviously, I love Jessica Chastain.
She gets to do a lot in this movie.
Yeah, and that's fun.
Yeah.
She seems to be having a little bit of fun.
I do think that the movie gets kind of trapped between two conceits.
One conceit is your classic, there is a demon haunting our family.
It is a kind of phantasmagoric figure.
And so we can create some kind of logic around why we're being haunted.
Is there some historical figure in the house?
Is it something related to an incident in the family?
And then there's the PTSD trauma explanation in a horror film.
And we've been going through this cycle over the last 10 years of trying to,
being more PTSD trauma and a little bit less like, you know, you move the headstones,
but you forgot to move the bodies in Poltergeist.
Right.
And when the movie was in the Poltergeist vein, and I thought of Poltergeist a lot,
while watching this movie, because it's similarly a movie about a young girl being tormented by a demon.
I was really digging it.
And then it does, I pivot into a shameful conclusion of just like emotional explanation.
Yeah.
You know, like exposition as clarification.
But also explanation that makes no sense.
And brings in complications that have nothing to do with the premise.
Like there is, there's a fairly tidy and interesting,
conclusion to this that I still would have been lukewarm to bad on the movie
because it was not visually interesting to me.
I mean, you know, I think it's sort of the reverse of when you watch a bad rom-com,
but it doesn't, and versus when I watch a bad rom-com and I see certain things that it does genre-wise
or it hits certain notes for me, then I'm like, well, this was poorly, cheaply and poorly made
and preposterous, but I enjoyed X, Y, Z.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I think you watch this and you're like, well, this is cheaply and poorly made, but, or maybe
not poorly made, but it, it hits.
To me, it's the, it's kind of the inverse where like, I felt like the story didn't really
work, but the visual components of it did work to me.
Now, I think some people would be annoyed by it, but I've been citing the movie Smile
a lot in the last few years because I think Smile is this quietly very influential movie
about the way that horror movies are cut, the way that the sound design is set up, where
they're very like abrasive and you get these kind of like portal flashing cuts where it
is opening and when it opens a new perspective, you're seeing something totally different.
This movie, the characters are almost like jumping from place to place in these really
time-cutting ways, but there are two segments in particular.
There's one during a party that Chastain and Duplass' characters are throwing where the
eight-year-old girl has a babysitter at the party.
Right.
Even though it's a party in their house.
In their house.
Which doesn't make any sense.
And then also, they're having a seventh anniversary party, which no one has a seventh
anniversary party.
Didn't understand that really.
Please continue.
In that sequence in particular.
When other mommy starts making herself known, the balloon sequence I thought was incredible
with like flipping to the ceiling.
And some of that's, I just thought that there was some visual imagination in this movie
that was really cool.
I've seen some people suggest that this stuff was done with AI, but I don't think that that's
true.
I think it was actual production design and typical VFX.
But, and then secondarily, the ball pit, which I thought worked really well.
The ball pit at the, I don't know, was it a McDonald's or wherever they were, and then
getting lost in the ball pit.
And then the ball pit becoming this place of like terror for both a parent and for a
young child.
Those two sequences, I thought were great.
And so maybe I'm, maybe I'm blind or something, but I thought they were very effective.
I guess they were fine.
I thought all the, all the CGI and the, like the demon horror gore just looked cheap and
bad.
A little fake.
Yeah.
And so that left me less willing to kind of go on the flights of fancy and also because
so much.
Of the rest of the film is kind of done on a shoestring.
Then it made me wonder what was intentional versus what are just errors.
And there's been one that's been noted in a lot of places, which is that the cake is
one flavor at the party.
And I remember that it was chocolate with white icing because I was really hungry and
I was like, I want some cake.
And then it's yellow when they get back.
Now, is that supposed to be some sort of, and then, and then people.
Well, shared some other things about where knives are placed and all sorts of issues
that just, it doesn't really seem like the shots match continuity errors.
Yes.
Yes.
So, but is that supposed to be sort of, is that an intentional of a, the camera's moving
and you don't know where you are or are they just not paying attention?
If you can't tell always, then that, that is an indication to me that for all the visual
flights of fancy, this is just kind of.
Being sewn together.
Yeah.
I mean, I think it's probably a movie that had reshoots as most movies like this.
do it also is definitely has a cheaper budget it's 18 million dollars um i just you know the
the middle segment is just boring ghostbusters and i didn't think it was funny when they go to
karen allen's house yeah and listen respect to karen allen forever but i was really bored
severance right i don't watch severance i didn't know who that lady was and i it was very much like
where'd they find this person yeah uh so yeah yeah on tv and she's been around for a while
um yeah i mean to me it was just it's just a romp like it's not it's not a deep and meaningful movie
i thought it was i didn't have fun i thought it was so boring okay um and i do also think other
mommy is such a good idea well here's one of the big challenges of this movie you know there's a
story that came out that james wan really wanted to name the movie other mother and they didn't
name the movie other mother the reason they didn't do that i presume is because the movie coralline
exists and that's the premise of coralline is that there's a movie that's called other mother
another mother on the other side of the portal that coralline has to engage with and it seems
like she's really appealing and loving and wants to bring her into our world but she's a demon
yeah and so you know this movie kind of exists already sure but this could i mean the other
problem with this movie is that if this were actually a movie about jessica chastain and her
character because the first 10 minutes i was like oh this is about a mom who's not like being a quote
traditional like good mom and so now she's being haunted by a demon right and that's interesting but
this movie isn't called mommy well but no but then there is another mommy and the idea of the
other listen i encounter other mommies all the time the other mommies that like you know know
how to sew halloween costumes and the other mommies that are home for lunch and meanwhile
the real mommy in this movie does actually drink a negroni while facing down the demon at home
so i was like oh there's something here that's useful and you should read the story i'd be
curious to know and then and then it's like well you're somebody else's or something
you're somebody else's or something you're somebody else's or something you're somebody
no well what what is this reveal uh what is this the reveal and who cares about the dad the spoiler
is that i mean that is her daughter but that she was that she was not necessarily the most willing
parent um and that the father was not in the picture but jay duplass stepped up and he wanted
to be the he wanted to be the not the other father he wanted to be the real daddy you know and that's
going to be the sequel that i'm working on okay real daddy yeah great and it's for all the real
yeah who who are home for lunch you know and who do so the halloween costumes we don't have enough
movies about those people right now yeah the number of movies about those people in proportion
to the number of real daddies well you know maybe more women should get out there and make more
horror films okay you know that's my encouragement to you uh this is real like you see five horror
movies a year and i see a hundred yes but and that's well so that's also where the the rom-com
thing and and a little bit the next movie we're going to talk about as well which is like you are
looking for a new movie and you're looking for a new movie and you're looking for a new movie
for something different from this and also when it hits certain genre conventions for you as a fan
of these things you are you respond to them right and when i see them they don't respond to the
genre conventions and the other stuff makes no sense and so i'm out but i was really really
bored like very bored okay good to know um america was not bored america was in another
although i think it did get a d plus yeah i was gonna say like my also my
theater was silent uh i guess i don't really remember what do you expect it to be
you know at least screaming at the top of your lungs no or laughing at something or just being
like whoa or being surprised by a jump scare or something you know like normally you hear something
yeah i think um this is interesting i obsession and to a lesser extent backrooms has like distorted
the market here yeah on what people think this genre is
i know but this is like also it's like very annoying i would just say to all of the people
who have been cinephilia like horror fans or like i liked it back when i was on vinyl and now you
guys saw obsession it is kind of like if you want obsession to be the story and you want all of the
attention and have it be like wow i don't care what a huge market it is then like now we go see
horror movies and yeah that's that's that's your problem not my problem because i still get to
enjoy the movie yeah you're the one who's watching the movie but i am just a little bit of like the
this is what happens when something goes mainstream which it is a little bit and like
or what great big business okay well now we're going to take it seriously and be like this is
boring now but i mean with respect you're totally wrong i mean this is the story of horror forever
is that it is completely misunderstood by people who don't follow it closely and so you get
mainstream critics shitting on it and then you cut back to 60 years later and you look at the
reviews of movies that are now considered classics because people didn't understand the genre so i
hear what you're saying i'm not saying other mommy will be a classic 60 years from now but
i'm not saying other mommy will be a classic 60 years from now but i'm not saying other mommy will be a
i don't think horror fans are like thank god obsession was a huge hit so that our genre
i mean it is funny because everyone all of the horror people were like i liked it but are we
sure it's this good you could feel it as soon as obsession right right containment yeah and people
who are not horror people are like oh wow i really liked this yeah yeah and everyone else like well
it's like pretty standard and it has like some you know ingenious scenes and yada yada but this
this sense of it breaking it going on and it's like oh my god i'm not sure what's going on with
outside of your you know your little world was already like you can feel the discomfort yeah
maybe i think so i mean because when i was like oh wow i really liked obsession
everyone you know was like all of the horror people like yeah i guess so sure yeah i don't know i liked
it i was very positive about it i think i do think that you're right that the horror crowd in general
is very territorial yeah um as our most like very genre tightly focused people who are like i only
really like these kinds of movies and i'm like yeah i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't
movies i think it's more the other mommy thing is more like this is kind of bog standard yeah
you know blumhouse original and some of them are way worse and some of them are way better
but most of them are kind of in this place yeah and so it is funny that like i think part of the
challenges is that this movie was so unmarketed and that that trailer was attached to the odyssey
right and so that everybody knew about this movie most people don't know about any movies
but when a movie makes two billion dollars everybody's
like oh yeah i saw that trailer like i am actually aware of this title it is a good title and poster
and like they they found something that again like breaks containment yeah and so when it breaks the
genre thing this is what i'm talking about of the rom-com thing of like for the most part i think the
people who read and watch all of the streaming things really liked love hypothesis and really
and like verity i think the colleen hoover fans were mad because it didn't meet their you know it
kind of betwixt in between but most people who consume all this stuff think very differently
about it than we do like kind of jumping in so i just you know that's all and i was just like well
this is kind of empirically boring i'll go with you 100 on love hypothesis verity is trash
verity is not good i would just i did remember over the weekend that they have josh hartnett
and the jesus and mary change shirt and that's really funny sure there's like lots of funny stuff
about it
yeah i don't i don't know a lot of people that are writing for verity i do understand
i do understand people writing for love but i'm just like i do think that there are people who
watch it and what it does in certain capacities in the genre like honestly and like how shiny
dakota johnson's hair is in the t-shirt selection of josh hartnett could not give a fuck well i know
but like that's why i'm like i don't give a fuck about the balloons you know like i watch it and
i was like okay cool and this doesn't make any sense so i there there is a difference
yeah
depending on how like deep you are within the genre i get what you're fighting for
i'm not fighting for anything i'm just pointing out the inconsistencies
yeah okay okay if you had maybe mounted a stronger defense of verity i might have been
able to roll with you on that i just like verity is fair and i think i actually should read the
book that other mommy is based on because one of the challenges i think with verity was
it seemed like it was extremely loyal to the material faithful to the material yeah and the
material is so good and i think it's really good and i think it's really good and i think it's really
bad i mean i've never seen four colleen hoover movies they're fucking bad like the the plotting
is terrible in those movies so and you know what maybe this is unfair or like an imbalanced way of
imagining it but horror movie plotting is kind of secondary right in a way that like in erotic
thrillers for example like the plotting does kind of matter so i guess maybe that's a complete
double standard i maybe i'm too close to it i think it might be and then when i think also that
you're not giving one of those movies that you're not giving one of those movies that you're not
giving one genre the like the credit for the filmmaking accomplishment and choices that it
does make and like because i i do think like verity looks much much better than all the
colleen hoover movies right it also costs twice as much money well sure that but like that also
like that has like real stars in it no but that also matters that is those are that's actually
part of making a movie that matters in terms of filmmaking just spending more money uh spending
money on the right things yeah i guess so i to me that this is an interesting question because
yeah dialectic because like verity looking good means nothing to me like it is like this
deeply unengaging right and the balloon sequence in this movie means literally nothing to me i was
like i do not care about this i am bored okay so i mean and that that is really just someone watching
different versions of painting a visual tableau and responding to them yeah so okay i would just
point it out because i do think that there is like starting to be a little bit of we respond
one way to one type of filmmaking and one way to another and i think that's a really good point
one way to another.
- Well.
- That's all.
- Yeah.
- And I like, frankly,
don't think both are very good yeah okay just pointing it out okay I think you sometimes
I'll let it sit I'll let it sit I won't I won't I won't push it because I think that there is
a slight difference between something that is low and low on purpose and something that is
aspiring to higher and failing I mean I think that that was aspiring to high low on purpose
sure same I mean same difference yeah and in like some ways it worked and in some ways it didn't
um did Verity work at all I didn't have a bad time okay okay I was I was like more engaged
with Verity than I was with other sure but this that that's a genre that you don't care about I
do care about the genre of Verity Verity is a Hitchcock movie I mean it's like that's what
it's trying it's working in a tradition I love sort of until it's not because it's the Colin
Hoover is not in any way Hitchcock related right but
the tone of this story is not it isn't a rom-com where it's like okay you might say well that
isn't my or a pure romance specifically that's the one genre yeah I'm not really this isn't
really my thing um but a Hitchcock movie I agree with great stars agree though I think that other
mommy is like it's J Duplass you know it's not it's it's not J Duplass was fine in this movie
I like J Duplass listen Datto Innocent oh Datto I know oh yeah that's the other thing you know
father of a daughter movie you know you gotta see that's what I'm saying
okay speaking of fathers let's talk about your father yeah well let's talk about animals yeah
should we have this same exact discussion all over again well I I do think that they're
they're like well paired in that this is like a very poorly made movie that I was entertained by
and I was way less bored in in animals than I was in other mommy and that has something to do with
it has what I'm interested in as opposed to what I'm not interested in this case Ben Affleck making
a movie about the concept of J Duplass I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't
with Ben Affleck?
Sure.
We'll get into that.
This movie is directed
by Ben Affleck.
It stars Ben Affleck.
It also stars
Kerry Washington,
Gillian Anderson,
Adriana Paz,
Steven Yeun.
The story of Animals,
which is streaming now
on Netflix,
is when the son
of Los Angeles mayoral candidate
Mark Kimball
is kidnapped.
He and his wife
have a few hours
to come up
with the ransom payment.
With most of their money
spent on his political campaign,
normal,
they have to get
their hands dirty
and expose a side
of their lives
they never intended
to see the light of day.
So,
setting the scene here,
this is in fact
more or less
the second remake
of Akira Kurosawa's
High and Low
that we have received
in the last 12 months.
Last year,
Spike Lee released one
called Highest to Lowest
starring Denzel Washington.
This film is not
a direct remake.
It's not,
doesn't say,
this isn't an adapted
screenplay.
It doesn't even say
inspired by in the credits.
I read,
I don't know if this is true,
that Ben Affleck
has not seen High and Low.
Did he say that?
That seems. I read that somewhere.
If I'm misreporting that,
I apologize.
Ben Affleck,
a real cinephile,
I would encourage him
to watch the film.
It's definitely worth
your time.
Sure.
So,
what did you think
of the movie?
It's really,
really not good.
It's a not good movie
that is fun to watch
and we're,
again,
an episode of TV show
and specifically
an episode of Scandal,
which also starred
Kerry Washington
dealing with political
scandals
and also personal scandals
while someone,
while someone dressed
primarily in white
comes around
to try to fix things.
I would have enjoyed it.
I watched almost
every episode of Scandal.
You know,
I like it.
And,
but the actual filmmaking
is really,
really quite depressing.
And I,
just a lot,
a lot of drone shots,
a lot of,
you know,
slick inserts
to cover the fact
that they don't
know how to tell
the story
and it's,
the acting besides
Ben Affleck
has its highs and lows,
forgive me.
So,
I,
I,
it's not,
it's not,
it's not good.
It's not,
it's not very good.
I didn't,
but I did,
like,
I rewatched it
this morning
and I was just,
anytime Ben's on screen,
I'm just kind of leaning in,
you know?
So I'm not going to
turn down Ben Affleck.
Okay.
And it is,
the most interesting it is,
is when it is about,
when it is very thinly veiled
text about Ben Affleck,
the public persona
and Ben Affleck
in a marriage
or Ben Affleck,
he's running for mayor
in this case.
But the commercial
that opens,
the mayoral commercial
that opens the movie
is pretty funny
and pretty knowing
about Ben
and about LA.
We are also in the middle
of a mayoral election,
so good timing wise.
It's sort of well-timed,
yeah.
Yeah.
Although he represents
not at all what's going on
in the race right now.
and they've, like,
made absolutely,
they want to stay
as far away from that
as possible.
The real world components.
Yeah, exactly.
And that's the kind of movie
it is, right?
Where it's, like,
allegedly about
our modern times
and how we, like,
engage with each other
and the world around us
and it,
it has absolutely no depth.
Yeah.
I think this movie
is extremely unsuccessful.
And I think Affleck
is a very good filmmaker.
So I think there's
a couple reasons for it.
One of them is,
the general plotting
is extremely noisy
and there's a lot going on
in this.
It's trying to be a lot
of different kinds of things.
And I felt this way a bit
about Highest to Lowest,
but one of the reasons,
I thought Highest to Lowest
was a better film than this.
I know a lot of people
watched that at home
and thought it sucked.
I thought there was a lot
to recommend about it,
although it's definitely flawed.
But both of those movies
commit a similar problem to me,
which is,
in High and Low,
the Toshiro Mifune character
is a shoe salesman.
He's kind of an anonymous,
very successful rich guy.
He's like a shoe magnate.
In Japan.
But he's not like
a public person.
And in both Highest to Lowest
and in this movie,
you've got a mayoral candidate
and you've got a very,
like a Diddy-esque
record executive.
You know,
none of Diddy's
horrible extracurriculars,
but just like his success
and notoriety.
And I think that
kind of misunderstands
High and Low a little bit,
which is that like,
this is a person
who has been like targeted
because of his wealth,
but not because of his notoriety
specifically.
And then the confusion
that happens in the film
and the story,
and this happens in all three
of these films,
where one child is kidnapped
and the kidnappers believe
they have kidnapped
the well-known person's child.
But in fact,
they've kidnapped the person
who works for that
well-known person,
someone who's of a much lower
kind of financial class in life.
It tilts the balance of power
and then it becomes about
what are you going to do publicly?
What are you going to do publicly?
And then that becomes
the primary interest
of the movies
and in Highest to Lowest
and in this film,
it becomes about
this famous man
solving the problem.
And like being in the right place
at the right time
and getting physical
with the right people
and all that stuff is like,
that's movie star bullshit.
That's not like clever
or thoughtful plotting
around some of this storytelling.
And then the secondary thing
in this movie,
which really makes it suffer,
is it's really trying to be
five movies at the same time.
It's trying to be this
complicated domestic drama
about a marriage on the rocks
between Affleck
and Kerry Washington.
It's about kind of like
seemingly a failed son,
like the son of a well-known
guy in Los Angeles
who's trying to prove
to himself
and to his dead father
and everybody else
that he can win
as an independent
in Los Angeles
in the mayoral race.
I'm not,
have we ever had an independent
win the mayoral race in LA?
I tried to do some research on this.
There's not very many
independent candidates
who've won mayoral races
in America
in the last 50 years
because we don't really
support third parties
in this country very well.
Right.
And also it's expensive
as we learn
in the first 10 minutes
of this movie.
Incredibly expensive.
Through some,
some tough expositional
dialogue
that poor Steven Yeun
has to deliver.
Yeah.
Steven Yeun,
like one of our great actors,
like completely misused
and like,
I don't,
I get,
I know,
I know they're boys
and he was in The Rip,
but like,
he's way too good
for that part.
Agree.
It's also like a,
it's meant to be like
a political thriller
a little bit
about this guy
who,
he's like the white
candidate
who thinks he has
more to say
to the Latino
class,
to the white class
of citizens
here in Los Angeles
because he speaks Spanish
and the Latina candidate
doesn't.
And so like,
there's some component
of that.
And then there's also
this component about like a,
it's like a social drama
about LA families
who employ people
in their homes
to take care of their children
and some of them
are here legally
and some of them
are here illegally
and some of the contradictions
and complications of that.
Yeah.
And then there's
this hostage thriller.
Yes.
Where Gillian Anderson
Sure.
Is a fixer
who comes in
and she knows the right way
to get money fast
so you can pay
Yeah.
hostage takers,
kidnappers.
Mm-hmm.
And this is all happening
in like one hour
and 52 minutes.
It's true.
And it's too much.
It's way too much.
It's too much.
And pretty much
everyone besides Ben Affleck
and Gillian Anderson
are misguessed.
Yeah.
I would say.
Gillian Anderson is good
but she's in a different movie.
Like, I feel like
she got the assignment,
like she got it.
Yeah.
But like,
it's a way pulpier,
shittier, fun movie.
Yeah.
It's not like a serious movie
about like,
what if this man
could be the mayor?
She is playing
the movie version
of Kerry Washington's
Olivia Pope
in Scandal.
That's right.
And I think
Kerry Washington
was great on Scandal
and she would have been great
in that part also.
Yeah.
And because
Gillian Anderson
is there opposite her,
feels the need to
like do another level
and slick the hair back.
I mean,
she's fine.
She's,
I have no problem with it.
Yeah.
Everybody's in a different movie.
Yeah.
You know,
and so because of that
it just feels really incoherent and then the other thing is just like that is a really good
I mean, Gone Baby Gone and The Town, especially to me, are fucking bangers.
You don't have to tell me.
Those are great, great films.
And this feels like it's like scaled down.
It's like a little bit too much chaotic handheld.
The performances are way too shouty.
I agree with you about the drone shots.
There's this sense of like trying to create energy maybe in a streaming movie environment where there might not be some because this is a very talky drama.
You know, there's not a lot of action that actually happens.
It's a lot of like four people in a room trying to figure out how to solve a problem.
And that's not inherently cinematic.
And so he is trying to use a lot of strategies to like pump up the energy throughout the movie that that feels like very leaden and doesn't really work.
Yeah, there there is a lot going on, but you can feel it being like cover all at the same time, whether it's, you know, literal or just kind of, oh, like we filmed this dossier and are putting this.
It's pretty tough.
And, you know, he's obviously been many places talking about.
His A.I. company and the way in which he uses A.I. in his films.
And you can't tell the difference.
And I would encourage everyone to listen to him explain A.I. for 20 minutes to my husband, Zach Baron, because it's astonishing.
And like like open A.I. should put Sam Altman in the bunker for many reasons.
But like, honestly, just hire Ben and let him sell your product because he's doing an amazing job.
But he does as a spokesperson.
But because he talks.
He talks about how much A.I. has been used in the making of this movie, even if it's like, honestly, just really procedural stuff.
You just start to feel the lack of humanness in the in the film.
And I think also the pace at which it's cut, which I suspect has something to do with the number of things that's trying to do and also something to do with it being a Netflix movie.
It just feels really, really, really busy and sort of shortcutty.
Yeah, I haven't seen 14th yet, the new Amy DuVernay movie.
But that premiered over the weekend at the New York Film Festival.
And that movie also, which got some good reviews, but also came under fire for using A.I. to animate photographs, archival photographs in her film.
And so this is something we've been talking about a lot over the last couple of years.
We talked about it with The Brutalist.
And I think at that time I was like, hey, if you have a problem with A.I. in your movies, it's going to be hard to watch movies.
But it is now like really coming in.
And if you if I learn tomorrow that, in fact, other mommy did use A.I., I wouldn't be stunned.
And so but I think that point that you make is really smart, which is.
Is that there is something about the cutting style of the movies now that feels like they're creating a little bit of chaos that looks like you're kind of swiping up on your phone and you're waiting for the next kind of tick tock edit to hit.
And that that like swarming feeling that the edits give you of just like, boom, boom, boom.
Like this keeps happening.
We talked about this forgotten island.
We talked about this with Super Mario.
Like there is something happening with the pacing of movies right now.
And for it to be happening in movies like this now also feels like a little bit of a change.
Like this.
We're very comfortable sitting in their atmosphere.
That was sort of the point of the movie.
But the atmosphere of this movie is so frenetic.
Yeah.
And and I think you're right to point out that some of it is just trying to elevate or add to the fact that it's for people sitting in a room and or talking to someone on the phone.
Yeah.
But you put all of those elements together and it it feels it feels really streaming.
It just it feels like cheap in a different way, even though I don't think it was very cheap because it was filmed here in Los Angeles.
And that costs a lot of money, as we know.
And it's so fascinating because cheap can have different meanings.
Again, Highest to Lowest didn't do this as much in some sequences when the cops would come over.
But this movie, because there's so much time spent with those four folks, Kerry Washington, Affleck, Stephen Young and Gillian Anderson.
Kind of like pushing their power around the room over time.
High and low.
One of the greatest things about it is the way that those scenes were filmed.
People were Mifune and the police officers and the people who work for him are in one large room that kind of overlooks the city.
And the way that those sequences are blocked and the way that they communicate power and where Mifune is versus where everyone else who is enthralled to him is at all times.
It's like it's one of the great filmmaking achievements for a director who didn't make very many contemporary dramas like that.
And this movie is in a it's in a really nice house in L.A.
I guess there are they in Brentwood.
One assumes.
Yeah.
And so there's in theory like.
Money to work with.
But you never really get the sense of that kind of style or intentionality.
No.
From this.
And it's disappointing.
You know, it's it's it's this this kind of bum me out this movie.
To me, the only redeeming moments are.
Are Ben Affleck alone without anybody else and the moments where he is acting and he.
He clearly understands what he's trying to do or he has an idea of what he wants to do.
But.
The offhand like very natural.
The scene when the photographer is directing him in the photo shoot and he's so clearly channeling so many ideas and.
Insecurity is about being Ben Affleck and he's like, should we take the coat off?
Do I have to do this now?
I'm doing this, that and so there are like little flashes of Ben Affleck throughout it, who is one of our great subjects and certainly one of my great, you know, studies in life.
So, again, some of it is just like, what do you what do you like watching, you know, because I think it's it's not successful, but there are glimmers of Ben.
The campaign commercial is really, really funny.
Yeah, it's it is funny that he just put himself in a movie where he could speak Spanish 30 percent of the time because he did do like some sort of study abroad where he speaks Spanish.
And so, you know, normally his Spanish is just on his press tours, but now he's got all of it.
Terrible accent, but he's just hanging in.
Yeah.
And, you know, and yelling about getting a divorce and what he's going to tell his son and all this stuff.
I was like, my guy, my guy is here in a big mess of stuff.
But he's right there.
Yeah.
So the problem, the problem with all of this is that we already have Gone Girl.
That's true.
We already have the magnum opus of Ben's study.
Like we and it is it.
Mm hmm.
You know, Gillian Flynn.
David Fincher understood.
You don't have to tell me in the construction of that movie.
And his life has changed.
Affleck's and it is evolved.
And he's been doing quite a bit of press for this film.
My Instagram is just Ben Affleck.
It's really that doesn't make it any different than any other day.
Well, we just have more to work with now.
But, you know, he has talked to Zach about this.
He's talked to others about this, that, you know, the film was originally Damon and Jennifer Garner.
And I don't think Jennifer Garner ever said.
Yes, I think that was how he imagined it.
OK.
And I think that once Damon wasn't able to do it, he went to Jen and she was like, no, we're not going to work with you.
He was like she was like, we don't want to do this, which smart lady.
Shout out to Carter.
I wonder if the movie.
If it's relieved of some of its Ben Affleck awareness, if it takes on a different energy or if he takes on a different energy, if he doesn't have to direct himself in it.
I mean, I said to you.
I said to you when we saw it, like, what if Spike had directed this movie or this script or had directed.
If they traded.
Yeah.
Or if if Spike had directed Ben Affleck in one adaptation of of High and Low.
I'm not sure Ben Affleck should have directed Highest to Lowest, but maybe that would have worked.
No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, because the best part of Highest to Lowest were I thought like the the action, the set pieces, the the trade and the Puerto Rican Day Parade.
And then also Denzel and Rocky.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Which I would not I would not put Ben Affleck in that particular scene.
In charge of that sequence?
No, nor would I cast him.
Nor would I replace Denzel with him in that scene.
I want to watch Ben Affleck rap battle A$AP Rocky.
Who doesn't want to watch that?
Love for introverts and extroverts, the thinkers and the doers for old friends and new Coca-Cola for everyone.
Yeah, this is the number one movie on Netflix.
And for a minute this morning there when I opened Netflix, it did not have a top 10 signature next to it.
And I was like, oh, no, you got nervous.
My guy is down bad.
No, no.
This is yeah, but it's doing OK.
It's yeah.
People saw it, I guess.
Or did they?
We've been evolving this idea of.
What the streaming movie is, what streaming movie stardom is, you know, many of Ben's last recent films have been streaming movies.
And now he obviously is is very much in business with Netflix right now.
Yeah.
And Air was an Amazon movie.
It comes for us all.
Yeah.
You know, it comes for us all.
Myself included.
OK, let's talk about Ben.
Did 580 million come for you from your AI company?
It did not.
Nor do I have an AI company.
I'll just put that on the record.
What makes Ben Affleck special?
Not to you.
In general.
Well, I think that I mean, he is a leading man figure, you know, tall, classically handsome and has always communicated.
Not an underdog quality, but a.
Thank you.
And we don't believe in equality, like a tarnished man to to quote a clip that's been going around. And so he's you know, he's not Jimmy Stewart, but he can play the more complicated or the dirtbags that we need in films and have you still root for him, which is, I think, essential to filmmaking.
Yeah, I think he's I think he feels like growing up, he was underestimated. And that comes through in all of his work, where no matter how handsome he gets, no matter how many awards he wins, no matter how many big movies he gets to star in, there is this incredible friction between matinee idol Burt Lancaster style, good looks, six, three, you know, granite jawed, but he's way too smart for his own good sometimes.
And you can I feel I say this as a person with an active mind. I feel an active mind.
Mm hmm.
I feel a person.
I feel a person who is always thinking about what is the right thing to do, say how to be right about something, how to be entertaining, how to be and that energy, that friction between the traditional handsomeness.
Yeah.
And this like, like race against yourself, you know?
Yeah, well, and the race against yourself goes both ways, because there is also there's a real there's some sort of fatal flaw going, you know, on with Affleck.
And obviously he's talked about his addiction and his battle with sobriety.
And we know more about his personal life than, you know, anyone should people.
Yeah.
And so we've seen him get back together with Jennifer Lopez, get married, have that end again.
So there is something about for someone who is clearly as smart and has as much to prove as he clearly feels he does.
Then he just he just does something else.
He's just always a little bit on the edge.
And there is an interesting tension to that as well, where you can't.
And I kind of can't look away.
Yeah.
And that this usually works against stars when you know these things about them.
But for him, for whatever reason, and maybe it's because he has taste or he knows how to put himself in the hands of filmmakers he likes or he knows how to generate interesting stuff for himself.
But I like knowing all that stuff about him.
I think it actually works really well in his case.
And it doesn't work as well in the case of Brad Pitt.
It doesn't work well to know things about him because Brad Pitt attempts to be mysterious and he attempts to be a very kind of quiet and powerful figure on screen.
Then Affleck is like shouting throughout.
Animals, you know, he's like having a nervous breakdown in the movie and he's not afraid to give performances like that.
He's not afraid to.
And I think you can see that like the people who first found him, Richard Linklater and Kevin Smith, they those people really understood him.
They understood what was funny about him.
Sure, they understood what was charming and handsome and compelling about him.
But like he's a motor mouth, you know, he's like he's a smart guy and a smart ass.
And then he has a long stretch of his career where he's like, I'm the strong, silent type.
And everybody's like.
No, that's not what you are.
Don't do that.
No.
And we everyone we rejected it.
Yeah, we didn't want it.
I mean, that's the other interesting thing about him is how much like ups and downs he has had.
And he's still out here asking for everybody's attention and approval.
He's not giving up.
Yeah.
And and he has, you know, summited the mountain and gone back down several times at this point and is still going.
It's pretty fascinating.
It's wonderful.
Yeah.
I mean, it makes him a great subject here and in the world of movies in general.
What do you think will be his legacy as a as a person?
Because he had he was off to this kind of crazy run as a filmmaker.
Yeah.
He makes this very acclaimed indie that turns his career around.
Yeah.
Then he makes, you know, kind of like a stone cold crime classic for the 2000s.
And then he wins Best Picture.
Yeah.
And we're like, whoa, he's Warren Beatty.
Yeah.
This is amazing.
And then.
Live by night.
I mean, well.
I like air.
I like air.
I like like air.
You like.
I like air.
I'm like air is another one where it's like, I don't really I don't care about Nike that much.
So I'm just like air is kind of the other mommy.
Oh, yeah.
Yeah.
I mean, but it is a little bit of I would rather watch Ben Affleck walk in a room and be like, who's Ron?
You know that.
Yeah.
That's so interesting.
Well, I mean, not that I think it's better.
And I think air is probably like a more successful and like better made movie.
But I don't think it's better.
But I the the shots of the Air Force Ones or the or the Jordans, the Jordans.
Sorry.
Obviously, the Jordans like just show just so.
And I could see all the Nike people there being like, no, no, or she will only be presented
in exactly this way.
And, you know, it takes me out of it.
Whereas thinking through like, so why would Kerry Washington's password be one one one
one and and then she would still not be hiding these text messages or not be on signal?
Like, what are we?
What are we doing there?
You know?
Well, she was on signal, wasn't she?
Although maybe they only only very special stuff goes on signal because Ray Fisher at
the beginning of Animals is like, right.
Or she says, like, why did this have to come through signal?
Yeah.
Yeah.
No, because he finds the text messages from Ron.
They're just right there.
Right.
Ron.
Geez.
Ron.
Yeah.
Anyway, you know, the director versus actor thing.
He's not an acclaimed actor.
I think he's a very good actor.
And you can make the case that he's been doing his best work as an actor.
Maybe over the last five or six years, you know, that like in stuff like The Way Back
where he's giving a real performance and is not just like doing a movie star thing where
he's got to be the hero holding the gun.
Tenderbar.
He was wonderful.
Excellent in that movie.
Yeah.
That movie.
It's another movie that's like kind of a little bit of a rickety streaming movie, but he's
really, really good at that.
I don't I actually I don't know.
I don't know how how he'll be remembered for lack of a better phrase.
Well, I do think that he will be remembered as as as Ben Affleck.
As the whole story and as much the extracurricular movie star stuff as the work itself, that
it's all part and parcel and that it's all speaking to each other.
So I don't think Warren Beatty is like the worst cop.
No, I think that's that.
Yeah.
In in that respect.
And also, you know, you liked Rules Don't Apply.
But but no one else did.
That's kind of my that's my very.
Yeah, that's what I like.
But they made them look so beautiful.
80 year old Warren Beatty was so beautiful.
So it's, you know, with Warren Beatty.
There is there is a hot streak.
I think Warren Beatty was probably in more movies that changed the course of, quote, unquote, Hollywood history.
Yeah.
Then these, which is just we all really love the town.
But, you know, he's Ben Affleck is like a party to a lot of important Hollywood trends.
I mean, he is Batman at one point.
No doubt.
No doubt.
I think you can we can argue here whether or not we feel like that is the good Ben or the bad Ben popping out, you know, because as we go through his filmography and we'll start doing that right now.
That signals a shift.
He's in the middle of a phase and he exits a phase.
He has a lot of phases.
And his decision to sort of like try to surmount whatever people think he is at any given time is fascinating to me.
OK, we'll start with the we'll start with his career as an actor.
OK, obviously, his films as a director also apply to his Hall of Fame here.
Yes.
And some of those, hopefully, he's in as well.
So most of them.
All of them.
Oh, no, he's not gone.
I've been gone.
Yeah.
And yet, well, is that his best film?
Interesting question.
I don't know.
OK, so he starts out in three very small, mostly uncredited parts.
The beginning of his career.
I noticed you don't have Voyage of the Mimi on here.
I don't know what that is.
That's his first job.
That's that's like one on one.
But more right.
Voyage of the Mimi.
Yeah, it's a PBS show.
They always talk about it.
But that was his first credit.
OK, it's fine.
That's not a film, though, right?
No, but I just.
You know, sometimes you have TV work on these.
Yeah, I didn't put any of the TV work.
He didn't do that thing where he jumped back and he was like, now I'm the star of an HBO
series for 12 episodes.
You've never seen this?
Look at him.
Look at that tiny Ben Affleck.
1984.
I haven't seen the Voyage of the Mimi.
Well, you are not.
Is the Mimi a ship?
Is it a spaceship?
Yes, it's a it's the ship Mimi exploring the ocean.
Oh, and they're taking a census of humpback whales, according to Wikipedia.
You want to you want to yellow it?
I just listen.
It's not every day that you have a subject matter expert on the pod.
But today, right.
I also I also didn't add like all of the extracurricular interviews and things we could have done like
you're welcome to venture venture Ben Affleck variety that happened during covid.
When people send me the meme of like them being the third listening to our show.
That was me with that podcast where I'm like quietly in a room like listening to them talk all
excitedly.
That was me listening to Zach and Ben Affleck.
I was honestly a real head trip.
I was like, no, no, this is too intimate.
Like, why?
Why?
Why are you guys talking?
It was really strange.
Never had that with anyone else.
I know.
Yeah, they're buds.
1981.
The Dark End of the Street.
He plays Tommy.
Haven't seen this.
I know this is a child performance.
It is not going in the Hall of Fame.
I guess it's before Voyage of the Mimi.
So I'm sorry.
Yes, he must have been very young there.
1988, he played an extra in The Good Mother.
Of course, that isn't going in.
He's also uncredited in Field of Dreams.
This is another part of Ben lore.
Yeah.
Ben and Matt together.
Yes, they both appeared in Field of Dreams, though they have no speaking lines.
Yeah.
And then we go to 1992.
Yes.
Let's keep a close eye on all of Ben Affleck's character's names.
The name of his character in School Ties from 1992 about a private school that
vilifies a Jewish student played by Brendan Fraser.
Ben plays Chesty Smith.
And he's he's one of the unkind bullies.
Yeah, they all they all are.
He and Matt Damon and who's that other really tall, handsome guy.
some guy who didn't quite take off in his career who's in that movie uh randall battencourt that's
the guy yeah but chris o'donnell's also in this and he's more kind yeah yeah yeah and then cole
hauser's also in it hauser oh we'll see him again soon uh deep bench school ties probably very
important to you sexually um i do think that it's a good movie it's a fun there was a rewatch i was
not on the rewatchables but i think mallory did stand in for our generation and say as much i
mean this is a great um scouting movie right uh-huh yeah so it's not going to go in his
particular hall of fame but if you wanted to do like a list the hall of fame of of who's who for
the 90s yeah he had a tendency to pop up in a bunch of movies like that um in 1992 he plays
an unnamed character a basketball player on buffy the vampire slayer a movie i've always really
enjoyed obviously everyone knows the television series very well um starring sarah michelle
geller but i was in on the christy swanson era okay luke perry did you see this movie yeah of
course
paul rubens yeah uh rutger hauer and ben affleck yeah basketball player number 10 yes not going in
the hall of fame are basketball player numbers like associated to what position no that you play
okay uh 1993 days that's a good question i'm teaching you about voyages of mimi you can teach
me about basketball i learned something new here every week from you uh dazed and confused from
1993 he plays fredo banyan right another bully um a subject ultimately of ridicule in this movie
hysterical performance by ben affleck really funny and also as you mentioned it's link later seeing
something in ben affleck that ben affleck maybe doesn't see in himself um or maybe i think he's
given interviews since then about this experience and and link later divining something in him that
he didn't really want to see because he's given interviews about everything at this point um
but it's sort of the who's that guy moment so we could yellow it
i think we should yellow it okay great uh one of the very few movies on this list that i have not
seen is 1995's glory days glory days is a comedy starring affleck and sam rockwell about i guess a
bunch of guys who are on the verge of college graduation we're about to go out into the world
um you know pretty interesting cast here uh i haven't seen this matthew mcconaughey meredith
salinger matt damon brendan fraser and leah remini are all in small parts in this movie
it's kind of a forgotten indie i guess french stewart is the third lead okay uh it made fifteen
thousand dollars at the box office but i see here that it debuted at the hamptons international film
festival it sure did so that must have been a nice weekend glory days is red okay do you think
it's gonna be hard to get to 10 or easy easy okay 1995 mall rats chris ryan once again is not here
we need that we need the phone of chris uh chris and i will one day do our kevin smith view a skew
it's been on the schedule like five times we will do it um mall rats never my favorite i would say
my least loved in the original trilogy of kevin smith movies the clerks mall rats chasing amy yeah
um he does something funny here where he cast affleck as shannon hamilton who's sort of the
bully he's sort of the obanian he's sort of the like insinuating gross creepy guy who's moving
in on shannon doherty and it's also pretty funny i don't know i don't know i don't know i don't know
yeah this movie is i still like it i still i still like it it's not it's not very cool to
like mall rats anymore it's important to like what you like you know yeah i don't love to know that
about yourself i don't think that it goes in even i think if we're gonna pick a kevin smith or even
two kevin smiths it's not the funny thing about this movie and this is somewhat true about chasing
amy as well and we can talk about them in tandem since they come back to back is if you had said
for ten thousand dollars who will be a bigger star ben affleck or jason lee i would have said
jason lee a hundred times out of a hundred yeah and jason lee is effectively you know he's the
second lead of mall rats he's also the second lead of chasing amy but ben affleck is the lead
of chasing amy and i would say this is the first time he really gets a chance to act um he is one
of the best deliverers of kevin smith dialogue yeah i think actually his like fast talking
pop culture brain yeah um is very well suited to dialogue that most actors struggle with and one
of the reasons why kevin smith is not at the top of the heap in filmmaking is most people can't do
his dialogue you know some i think some people think this movie is not aging that well or it's
sexual politics have gotten more complicated over time it was a this was a big movie for me
yeah this is a really big movie for me um and i think he's great in it i think joey lauren adams
is great in it and it's just kind of how we all i mean because this came out it came out before
goodwill hunting right and so you know if you're if you're in the kevin smith zone you know about
ben affleck but this year you're just kind of like wait this guy and then hollywood also seems
to think that because they put him in every single blockbuster in the world so it's important to his
career these three movies in 97 are all really important to him um i think chasing amy has to
be at minimum a yellow yeah of course it is okay we can come back it is a showcase for him in a way
that he's never had before um the i i've said this before on the show the commentary track for this
movie is kevin smith scott mosher the producer affleck maybe one other person and affleck is
so fucking funny on it so funny and it is like a real like are movie stars allowed to be this
funny like are you allowed to know this much about yeah movie history like it to me it's a real
falling in love with him moment just like getting interested in this is he the great bard of the
director's commentary
he he's the punchline machine he's like the funny guy not of this movie i mean of directors
because i was gonna say like he has a famous one coming yeah exactly and that's one of like the
extras that i could have like you could put that one in the hall let's talk about it when we get
there okay um going all the way which is a small period piece that he starred in opposite uh is it
rose mcgowan and is it joining going as well i forget who the other female lead in it is um
rachel vice is in it rachel vice okay yeah and amy locaine yes so this is uh a movie about two
guys who come home from korea and pick up a couple of girls and have like a crazy night out um
jeremy davies is the lead affleck is like jeremy davies is like the wimpy yeah sad maybe ptsd
afflicted guy and ben affleck is the super handsome no problem with girls guy uh
not going in i would say no but not i remember seeing it yeah it's fine you know this was the
time when you you know it is the season tickets thing of just like i'm just gonna see anything
this guy does sure um including 1997's goodwill hunting yeah an absolute green
truly green retainer uh co-written by ben affleck yeah um some are saying based on ben affleck
now that we know we know about his scientific exploits yeah uh he's
very very funny and affecting as chuck yes i mean he gets the the best part of my day
speech at the end he does really brings it all together said a lot about goodwill hunting over
the years it's still one of the classics 30 years next year 30 years we are old we are old
yeah uh 1998 phantoms i watched the film for the first time last night you know tell you who's in
this movie okay ben affleck mm-hmm leah schreiber mm-hmm rose mcgown yeah joanna going okay
and peter o'toole wow okay peter o'toole plays a journalist working for uh what i believe is
called the worldwide news which is a kind of weekly world news national inquire style place
and he's been writing about the ancient entity oh okay for a long time which is a some sort of
lovecraftian evil okay but it's separate from the entity in mission impossible this is not ai dead
reckoning part one this is something completely different we know that it's not ai well what if
what if ai is really the ancient entity come back to i think that would mean that phantoms from 1998
has an extraordinary uh foresight into our culture um this is just like a somewhat silly
horror movie with some cool practical effects from its time kind of the other mommy of its day okay
um probably best known for the uh j joke affleck was the bomb and phantoms yo that would come in
later yeah clerks view a skew universe film yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah
sure uh phantoms isn't good so it's not going yeah it's not bad ben plays a sheriff listen he's
a sheriff who is a former fbi agent and how old is he a great question 26 that's just rapid career
advancement you know i completely agree you understand why gen z is mad at us look at these
people it's true they've had a lot of experience and then he encountered the ancient entity yeah
so he had a life experience okay um i will just say quickly about it peter o'toole he cooked
he's pretty good he's really good it's like why are you in this how good was this check
maybe peter o'toole just wants to have fun i guess so but at one point he goes into one of those um
one of those suits yeah so that he's not infected by the entity oh okay but so peter o'toole is
like walking around like he's like a scientific figure in a suit you know what my mom often says
about retirement she's like it's great except i'm not around young people anymore oh and it's like
so i feel like i'm like i don't have young people keeping me sharp
keeping me thank god for me thank god for you guys anyway maybe peter o'toole just wanted to
be around young people that honestly makes sense yeah that would be great i wish he did more junky
movies like that candidly um 1998 1998 armageddon well this is absolutely agreed this is one of the
most important movies of my childhood
absolutely he sings leaving on a jet plane to live tyler yeah and this is also when he does
possibly the most important director's commentary in physical media history uh and you know
completely uh dissects and undermines the entire premise of the film why can't you just
uh blow up what is it well i one they go to blow up the asteroid right they have to train to be
astronauts so why can't you just train astronauts to be uh oil uh oil rig operators
drillers yeah yeah i mean it's a good it's a good question yeah armageddon is great it's very sappy
i will never forget how much i cried the first time i saw it because i was what i would have
been 14 maybe maybe i saw i saw it at home i remember the tv setup i was in my mom's room
okay
summer because i couldn't drive yet and there was no school and my mom had to work and i was like i
don't want to go to like a camp or whatever so i was just like what you know millions of americans
across the country so excited for camp to spend time with their friends to make new friends did
you were you a camp person i didn't go to sleepover camp but i went to camp yeah every
day for what are you talking about so did i when i needed a babysitter and then i wasn't like a
listen but i didn't go to sleep over camp i didn't go to sleep over camp i didn't go to sleep over camp
you know i didn't want to be at tennis camp anymore it was hot in atlanta going out with
your friends well they didn't have driver's licenses either okay so we couldn't get anywhere
during the day while our parents were at work there's hitchhike to your friend's house um
i didn't do that instead i stayed home and i watched armageddon and i cried for like 20 minutes
by myself just like weeping and i think the only thing that made me stop crying was the
backstreet boys i wanted that way video on the box is that is that correct time wise i wanted
that way what year was i wanted that way no it's 99 okay so but if armageddon came out in 98 and
then i saw it at home in 99 that's correct okay listen what a time to have been alive your mind
is a marvel thank you ben affleck and michael bay 1998 shakespeare in love he's quite good in this
sure and it's not going in um i mean he's playing a supporting part he's pretty funny
yeah he's very funny they had one best picture yeah you're mad that's a deeply unfortunate thing
that happened yeah should not have happened uh this is also where he meets gwyneth i believe
so they were together for some time that's right he's riding high on the miramax train here so yes
and that also gives us one of the great memes which is gwyneth patro just looking
disgusted while he tries to kiss her at some point because she's pissed at him at a party
thank you to everyone involved 1989 200 cigarettes he plays bartender no not the last time he'll play
a bartender this is not going in this is an ensemble comedy uh
set on new year's eve in new york city in 1979 that's correct um 1999 forces of nature
the harper's bazaar magazine cover yeah cover from that era sits behind us that's true co-starring
sandra bullock two leos sandra bullock has your exact birthday just so you know is that true yeah
i discovered that the last time i googled to confirm that they were both leos you know who
else has that birthday tell me stanley kubrick okay well that's you know when i when i think
of people just like you i think of stanley kubrick and sandra bullock three people who know what they
want yeah uh forces of nature haven't seen it since 1999 saw it in the movie theater of course
don't recall being a big fan no but i'm sure that i had a good time this it's probably
i'm i bet it was better than verity well sure but also well but bronwen hughes that's the
director of this film oh woman yeah wow then we're oh buddy
oh she's also the director of harriet the spy that's a classic have you guys done harriet the spy yet
no we have the book we have not read it yet yeah yeah we got a great great movie also bronwen hughes
what happened bronwen hughes was the director of 2003's stander which was a bank robber movie
starring thomas jane she was also the music supervisor on that film wow okay listen bronwen
hughes we love for you to learn and grow every single day all right forces of nature not going
in dogma
it's sean's time um kevin smith was on the show to talk about this movie when it came out in 4k
this is some of ben affleck's best acting ever yeah and the movie is like simultaneously very
deep and very silly there's parts of it that are very stupid there are parts of it that are not as
cinematically impressive as you'd like them to be but there are a couple of scenes between affleck
and damon that are as affleck and damon as stuff that is in good hunting um i don't know that this
needs to go in do you want to yellow it i will just yellow it as an acknowledgement of a movie
that i enjoy also a movie that as a you know person exiting an era of faith i thought it was
very cool that there was a mainstream comedy yes attempting to joust with some of these very ideas
this was the most important movie in 1999 for people who had seen all of ben affleck's other
movies that's absolutely correct yeah um the same could be said for boiler room absolutely which
came out in 2000 uh ben affleck has a well just i'm going to do a couple of quick character names
i've overlooked a few so i'm going to do a couple of quick character names i've overlooked a few so
we've been going through in going all the way he plays gunner castleman in uh armageddon his
character's name is aj frost yeah in dogma he is named bartleby he's an angel yeah and in boiler
room he plays jim young a boring name for an intoxicating character only appears twice in
the film delivers one of the great speeches in dumb movies in the 2000s to a room full of long
island morons who think they're going to be stock market geniuses it's kind of like the philip seymour
hoffman and charlie wilson's war type
one scene that has kind of the the movie has its own charms it does on its own of a time period but
that these are the scenes that that elevate it i don't remember if we put the charlie wilson's war
monologue in the philip seymour hoffman hall of fame we may have i i don't even think i was on
the show at that point advocating for this going in well i just think we should yellow it you know
very interesting idea and i think you're right okay thank you so much because it's such a
memorable speech it's nice when we can you know come together and agree on things we come together
every okay other day to record a podcast 2000 yeah boiler room can be yellow 2000 reindeer games i
just popped in the old 4k reindeer games this morning to check it i haven't seen in a while
forgot about the premise of this movie do you know the premise of this movie uh no i've watched
recently but i've no ben affleck's in prison he's in prison with his best friend his best friend nick
his best friend nick's been having a correspondence with a woman who's not in prison who can't wait
to get out of prison yeah she's been sending him photographs they've been telling each other
about each other's lives then there's a fight in the prison nick in an effort to save rudy's life
is killed in prison two days later rudy gets out of prison ben affleck yeah who's waiting for him
this woman who's been corresponding with his dead best friend she's played by charlie's theron this
i remember charlie why is charlie's theron corresponding with the man in prison she's never
met never seen
ben affleck yeah says i'm not rudy i'm nick now even though nick's dead and i'm gonna shack up
with charlie's theron but as soon as he takes on nick's identity he gets entrenched in some
sort of crazy crime drama that part i do remember what a weird movie this is john
frankenheimer's last movie he died after this movie was made not good it's not going in bad
film uh boiler room is is red guys or excuse me reindeer games is red joseph king of dreams this
is an animated film a very rare occurrence where ben affleck lent his voice to an animated film
he plays joseph in joseph king of dreams okay so this is like post prince of egypt correct yeah
that's red all right 2001 bounce also with gwyneth paltrow i believe yeah not going in but
obviously i was there opening day crying weeping so this is this the movie about a two a couple
whose partners die on a plane yeah right am i getting that right yeah and is it don ruse it is
don ruse uh i gotta say i remember vividly seeing this movie in movie theaters and thinking like wow
what a bracing piece of material this is a really adult it's a really adult drama we were teenagers
and they were both really really hot so and they wanted to have sex with each other so that's really
yeah i this is this is missing from the culture right now okay i'm not sure if this is a good
movie i'm not saying that it is but this kind of work yeah i'm open to it what if they just
remade it the two of them right now i'd be fine with that yeah you know who shot this movie
robert elswit wow heard of them who shot there will be blood pretty good okay love to see it
uh you know what robert elswit also shot pearl harbor no animals okay
it's a long journey bounce is red pearl harbor is red yeah really quite bad yeah i was very much
on the michael bay train at this point in time as were you coming off of armageddon he brings ben
back yeah also josh hartnett you know not ideal yeah um this is a dramatization of the events of
december 7 1941 a day that will live in infamy a movie that will live in infamy very very bad i
cried so much in the theaters did you yeah again i was what i was 17 okay listen i could drive
myself to the movie theater then so i saw it opening up in the theaters and i was like oh my god i'm
going to go to the movie theater yeah and i was like oh my god i'm going to go to the movie theater
impressive thank you uh also in 2001 he made daddy in them a movie i've never seen before this is
the third film directed by billy bob thornton stars billy bob and laura dern as uh i don't
know some kind of couple who are having some kind of trouble in the american south
crazy cast
in this movie
Brenda Blethen
Laura Dern
Andy Griffith
Diane Ladd
Kelly Preston
Jamie Lee Curtis
and Ben Affleck
as a lawyer
yeah
believable as a lawyer
sure
not going in
edited by the great
Sally Menke though
2001 Jane Silent Bob
Strike Back
this is the movie
where they do
Good Will Hunting 2
yeah
which is
one of the great bits
he also plays
Holden McNeil
his character
from Chasing Amy
in this movie
please remember
that his character
in Chasing Amy
was named
Holden McNeil
as in Holden Caulfield
yeah
Kevin Smith
you want to yellow
this one
I don't
I love it
but it's a cameo part
well
sometimes cameos
are important
we got a lot of work
to do
we gotta keep going
2002 Changing Lanes
is this a movie
about you driving as well
could be right
I'm a good driver
I'm fine
Changing Lanes
is
the showdown
we've all been waiting for
between Samuel L. Jackson
and Ben Affleck
they have
a car accident
on the way to work
I believe in New York
and
it sets off
a chain reaction
their lives are
tremendously impacted
yeah
Roger Michelle
directed this movie
do you know what else
he directed
Notting Hill
that's right
yeah come on
very
I think this is his
follow up to Notting Hill
well
he only wants to work
with the best
you know
yeah
he passed away
a few years ago
Roger Michelle
very strange
directing career
how did Ben
choose parts
you know what else
Roger Michelle
directed
what else
Morning Glory
oh yeah
I didn't know that
so that's your guy
yeah
Changing Lanes
very similar to Bouncer
I was like
we need this
we need to start a dialogue
it wasn't bad
it wasn't bad
it was fine
it was fine
and then you got to
go to the movies
and see Ben Affleck
and Samuel L. Jackson
you know
have a chain of events
that's right
this movie
was really blotted
out by like
Pearl Harbor
being a nightmare
and everybody was like
Ben Affleck
I don't know about this
and this is also
is the Jenny
from the block video
this year
could be
but this is like
peak
yeah it is
it's 2002
he's gotten so famous
yeah
and they're on the front page
of every tabloid
Jenny from the block video
could also be
on the extracurricular
sure
some tremendous work
in that film
that's important stuff
he plays Gavin Bannock
in Changing Lanes
and then
in that same year
he appears in another film
with a very memorable
titular character
The Sum of All Fears
yeah
he stars as Jack Ryan
he does
he's the third Jack Ryan
yeah
he's only Jack Ryan once
just once
yeah
he's not that good at it
Morgan Freeman is the president
one might argue
this is not
where are you at
on Shadow Recruit
which one
is that the Chris Pine one
yeah
I think
Chris Pine is a better
Jack Ryan
I agree
I don't know
that it's totally
Ben Affleck's fault
and also
spoiler alert
doesn't he become
the secretary of defense
or something
at the end of this
yes
right
there is
there's like a
designated survivor
yeah
secretary of war
thing yeah
this is Phil Alden Robinson
who directed this movie
who made
Field of Dreams
and Sneakers
yeah
but
it's not very good
no
he doesn't have a handle
on international espionage
okay
Some of All Fears is red
yeah
the third wheel
I've never seen this
this is an indie
again
one of only a handful
of movies
there's a few movies
on here
that are
kind of
fascinating
like
little what's-its
in his career
right
so this one
is going to be red
as well
I don't remember this
yeah
so it's
he's like
the third person
with Luke Wilson
and Luke Wilson
could have been
Harrison Ford
who's the female lead
of the third wheel
Denise Richards
wow
yeah
and 2002 also
so
yeah
yeah
I'd be her wheel
okay
in 2002
my word
2003 Daredevil
now you've studied
this film
what are your thoughts
so I have seen this film
okay
because this is also
this is when he
and Jennifer Garner
get together
because she's in it
right
as
she plays Electra
yeah
right
and it's
it's really not good
well
this is the beginning
of a very
tragic
stretch
yeah
a very complicated stretch
now Daredevil
a very interesting superhero
he's currently
in the MCU
played by
a different actor
this film
it's made
immediately after
Spider-Man
and they got
a little ahead
of themselves
okay
in terms of what
we think
people are able
to accomplish
Daredevil
is a lawyer
you know
who has
super sensitive
and he's blind
right
he's blind
but he has
his other senses
are very powerful
and he's also
very strong
and trained
in martial arts
much like myself
Daredevil's red
Colin Farrell
is bullseye though
come on
he's giving it his all
he is
and I love that
they put the actual
bullseye on his head
so do I
he looks awesome
he looks great
the movie is not strong
yeah
2003 Gigli
really really
really tough
I mean
you
I mean
we can't green it
it is obviously
like
historically significant
yes
a world-class bomb
yeah
starring a real-life couple
Jennifer Lopez
and Ben Affleck
directed by
the great Martin Breast
who directed
Beverly Hills Cop
and directed
what am I forgetting
Midnight Run
yeah
and Scent of a Woman
and a number of other movies
and
this movie
sucks
it's awful
I re-watched it recently
for one draft
thinking like
it would fit into a category
and it could be cute
I guess for the
the bombs draft
and then
I said no
this is
really painful
here's what's so crazy
about this is
you can almost feel him
thinking like
okay well this thing
didn't work
so I'm going to try
to do this thing
and
he starts working
with really good directors
so
Roger Michelle
coming off of
Notting Hill
Phil Alden Robinson
you've got
Martin Breast here
for Gigli
and then you've got
John Woo for Paycheck
yeah
you've got really good
filmmakers
all in a row
and Paycheck is also
a complete dud
and just not a very
cleverly named movie
because
it is in fact
a paycheck
yes
this is also
a time in Affleck's
career and life
where the outside
you know
is coming for him
and you kind of
can see it
in the performances
and
he's
he's strained
he is but like
this is one where
on paper I'm like
this makes complete sense
to me
John Woo
I think is coming off
of Mission Impossible 2
at this point
it's based on a
Philip K. Dick novel
okay
it's Affleck
and Uma Thurman
and Paul Giamatti
like
this movie should be good
but it's not
it's terrible
terrible
yeah
terrible
and it is
it's the case where
like the easiest
possible joke
everyone made it
and he's really
reeling at this point
2004 he makes
Jersey Girl
yeah
a reunion with
Kevin Smith
but a much more
saccharine
sentimental
drama
a girl dad movie
shout out to the
girl dads
that is not good
and that's Red
and then
Surviving Christmas
right
comes the next year
which is a silly comedy
with Christina Applegate
James Gandolfini
that you know
has its fans
no it's not
it's not good
it's Debra Kaplan
Harry Elfant
who did Can't Hardly Wait
but
it's no Can't Hardly Wait
no
so that's Red
he shows up
in the Elektra director's cut
which I know you have
that on 4K
yeah
do you have it on 4K
no
I don't think it's been issued
in 4K
okay
do you have it on DVD
no
I don't own Daredevil
or Elektra
that's on principle
they're not films
I need to see again
okay
under really
under any circumstance
huge for nine-year-old me
Elektra
Sexual Awakening
no kidding
yeah
probably saw it on cable
later like a couple years
after it came out
I was like
oh it's going on TV right now
it was pretty cool
um
wow
well thanks for sharing that Jack
of course
Jennifer Garner in Alias
I think did that for
yeah
many of us
um
2006 Man About Town
this movie went straight to DVD
that's true
that's tough
Mike Binder
um
who had
has made many studio comedies
over the years
he made this one
with Ben Affleck
and Rebecca Romijn
and those studios
were like we're good
yeah
didn't work out
so that's how low
he was
he was in 2006
we're not even done
with 2006 yet
because we have more
well
this is
we had a little bounce back here
in 2006
okay
so
Man About Town is red
yeah
2006 Clerks 2
he's just gawking guy
it's just a cameo part
that's red
2006 Hollywoodland
oh you're gonna
try it out
your pro Hollywoodland take
well
this was kind of
a comeback for him
because he played
a real part
yes
and he's actually
asked to act
it's not a leading man part
he's a supporting character
to Adrian Brody
in the movie
um
it's not the best movie
in the world
it's a period piece
based on a true story
um
set in Los Angeles
he plays George Reeves
who is the actor
who portrayed Superman
in the Superman
television series
he wears a prosthetic
yeah
in this
and I don't
he's pretty good
in this movie
he's not bad
but the movie itself
I mean I remember
seeing this
in theaters
in New York
I had just graduated college
because once again
I'm never giving up
the season ticket
but
not many other people did
it didn't
it didn't really
make a splash
and it was like
he was trying to do
something different
and break out of the
um
the
the negative
feedback
and it wasn't a bomb
but it's not
like everyone was like
yay Hollywoodland
well
Ben Affleck earned
the Volpe Cup
for Best Actor
at the Venice Film Festival
he was also nominated
for a gold medal
Golden Globe for his performance in this movie.
So it--
- Okay.
This was a little bit of a comeback.
Obviously, he was not nominated for an Academy Award.
And in fact, zero acting nominations.
Am I correct about that?
In his career?
At the Oscars.
Yes.
Yeah.
I think so.
Yes, I'm fairly certain that's true.
He wasn't nominated for Argo.
Not for The Town.
Yeah, zero.
Zero.
Hollywoodland, I'm just going to yellow.
Okay.
Because I feel like it's a movie that he really needed.
He also plays, like, kind of a supporting part in Smoke and Aces, the Joe Carnahan movie.
Joe Carnahan, who directed The Rip, which came out earlier this year with Ben Affleck.
Which is a very Tarantino-ish, rip-off, funny crime movie that, like, has its fans.
It's not bad.
But 2006 is sort of, he's broken up with Jennifer Lopez.
He's married Jennifer Garner.
He's receded.
He's been through a string of just, like, absolute bombs.
And so this is him showing up.
And, like, he's not.
He's not the main character.
It's not a huge deal, but it's not bad.
But also, like, he's receded a little bit, and he's making Gone Baby gone.
So this, like, it's a transitional time.
It is a transitional time.
And he takes a few years off from movies in this time.
Is this also the time of Project Greenlight?
Great question, Ben and Matt.
I feel like it might be.
Interesting.
Project Greenlight, of course, a fascinating reality competition television series about Matt Damon.
And Ben Affleck's previous production company, which was called Pearl Street, I believe,
in their efforts to discover an independent filmmaker to write and direct an independent film
that they get produced after a series of episodes chronicling the sort of, like, audition process
of finding the right person, putting the script together.
Basically, it was a reality show about making a movie.
And was very much catnip to me as a movie-obsessed young person.
This was season three.
There was, it was 2001, 2003, 2005.
Got it.
For the three seasons.
You know, none of the movies that came out of that show were any good.
Right.
But the actual show, especially seasons one and two, I thought were really, really interesting.
So, Snoke and Aces is red, I think, just because it's not a huge part.
2009, he comes back with three films.
Yeah.
And in the interim, we should say, he's directed Gone Baby Gone.
Yes.
And I just. That's 2009, right?
Oh, 2007.
Seven, yes.
So, that's why there's that big. That's what it is.
Yes, thank you.
Like, break.
And that is rapturously received.
And that is really, like, the reinvention.
It's the reset.
Oh, you thought this guy was the, you know, the dumb movie from Paycheck and the tabloids.
And now he's made this really sensitive, wonderful movie.
Gone Baby Gone, to me, is green.
Yeah.
Yeah, a thousand percent.
So, I think that only gives us, is it three greens?
Three greens, yeah.
That's what I'm saying about getting a 10.
Now, we're getting into a hot zone again?
Yeah.
So, 2009, he's just not that into you.
I've never seen it.
It stinks.
It's part of the wave of, like, the ensemble, rom-com, Valentine's Day, New Year's.
Isn't this on a book, though?
Yes, which was, it was a non-fiction book.
It was advice, dating advice for women.
Yeah.
It's a really annoying movie.
I think probably Cooper's also. Do you think Cooper's also in this?
A dating book?
Yeah.
It's, you know what it is?
Here's my dating advice.
You need to make sure, so, your response can't be longer than the text that was sent to you.
That's it.
Now we're done.
That's it.
That's the only one.
You can just do a visual test.
Wow.
There you go.
Good luck out there, everyone.
Now, what do you think that accomplishes?
The retention of power?
Yeah.
Yes, exactly.
That's how you think about marriage and relationships.
I think that that's definitely what. I don't know what marriage is, but anyway.
Understood.
Yeah.
So, he's just not that into you.
Red?
Red.
2009 State of Play.
I wanted to revisit this before this episode, and I did not yet have a chance, because I
was too busy watching Reindeer Games.
State of Play is a film adaptation of a British television series.
This was, I believe, the very first British TV show miniseries that CR was like, I have
illegally obtained this.
Okay.
Let's watch this together.
He may have even come to my apartment and watched this with me.
Well, yeah.
And if not, he sent me a link.
I was going to ask.
In 2009, how is he. We used to watch TV together.
No, I remember that, but he illegally obtained it on his laptop.
So, then how is he. He's either going to come over with his laptop or I guess. Sent the link?
I guess.
The British TV series was brilliant.
The film is not bad.
As I recall, not great.
Yeah, the British series was 2003.
So, that was early on when Chris and I were friends in like 2004, probably, when he got
his hands on it.
That series starred David Morrissey, Kelly MacDonald, Polly Walker, Bill Nighy, early
James McAvoy performance.
This movie, which is about a journalist looking into the suspicious death of a congressman
who was played by Affleck.
Yeah.
And also has a very good cast.
Rachel McAdams, Helen Mirren, Jason Bateman, Robin Wright, and it's Kevin MacDonald who
directed The Last King of Scotland.
But it's not great.
It's not great.
It's not bad.
And I think we would be so excited were it released today.
100%.
You know?
It is, again, one of these. Full episode movies.
We just need all of these.
We need these things back at the cinema.
But this is kind of like. Yeah.
We used to have this and now we have animals.
I agree with you.
I agree with you.
State of Play is red.
I feel like a lot of Affleck in State of Play is seen in flashback as well.
That sounds right.
Because it's about his murder.
Yeah.
2009 extract, he pops up very humorously in this Mike Judge comedy where he's like the
buddy, best friend.
It's sort of like a glorified cameo.
He's really, really funny in the movie, but it's not in that comedy.
Yeah, it doesn't need to go on.
Okay.
2010, The Town.
Incredibly green.
Writes, directs, and stars.
Yeah.
Co-writes?
Chuck Hogan?
Maybe.
He plays Doug McRae, a bank robber.
He sure does.
A bank robber who has got a real deep wellspring of emotional trauma.
That's true.
He's got a wild-eyed best friend who can't be trusted.
He's got a real history with some ladies from that neighborhood that aren't to be trusted.
Yeah.
And also meets some new ladies.
Well, he kidnaps some new ladies.
Well, sure.
Yeah, but then falls in love and also is once again working through that trauma.
The Town's a banger.
I last saw it at Coolidge Corner Cinema.
That's fun.
In Boston.
Fucking ripped.
A Boston classic.
I still think it should have been eligible for the baseball draft.
One of the great final set pieces in a film.
Really any baseball being played, but sure.
Listen, when I finally went to Fenway last year, I wasn't there for the baseball.
I was there for whose car we're going to take, you know?
Like, I'm seeing it finally.
What I recognized was not, like, the green monster.
It was the insights that they're, you know, dodging police officers in.
Yeah, the bowels of Fenway.
Well, 2011's The Company Men.
Yeah.
You seen this movie?
Yeah, I saw it recently.
I think for some draft that we did.
I think it was for the Costner.
For the Costner Hall of Fame.
That's right.
Yeah.
This is about, I think, a very well-meaning but very stupid movie.
Yeah.
About executives learning to be real men by working with their hands when they can no longer trade stocks.
That's, I mean, in keeping.
In keeping with the rest of the types of movies that Costner seeks out.
Yeah, it's a post-financial collapse movie that attempts to valorize men who worked on Wall Street.
Yeah.
And lost their jobs.
And, you know, it's not great.
2012 Argo.
I think just has to go in, right?
Yes.
He won the Best Picture Oscar.
Yeah, very entertaining movie.
Never one of my movies.
Really, really watchable.
It is watchable.
And I remember.
I've seen it many times because I've watched it with every member of my family.
It kind of, it hits all quadrants.
Okay.
We went from two to five real quick.
Yeah.
Because, again, he had a real, because Gone Baby Gone resets everything.
He wins Argo.
His Best Picture acceptance speech, Marriage is Hard, is also, you know, could go in the extracurricular category.
Yes.
But this is just like a very convincing, very crowd-pleasing, memorable.
Good performances.
You know, also a hostage movie, but one that you actually feel tension over, even though.
I hadn't thought of that.
He went back to the well.
Exactly.
The hostage well.
He went, I mean, listen, animals, they're also like in masks, just like in the town.
He goes back to the well with a lot of things in this movie.
Yeah.
Some thematic recurrences.
Yes.
You're noticing the motifs in the act like filmography.
Yeah, I believe.
Very impressive.
Yeah, but he wins, he wins another Oscar.
So.
Okay.
Okay, Argo's in.
2012, To the Wonder.
Yeah, no.
I like that he tried it.
I mean, he worked with Terrence Malick.
I know, it's cool.
I think this movie's pretty good.
Okay.
I think it's among the most successful of the late period Malick.
That's fine.
I think it's better than Night of Cups.
I think it's better than Song to Song, though Song to Song we should write books about.
I think it's a very heartfelt movie about
losing,
feeling in a relationship,
which feels like maybe something that Ben
Affleck understands it's it's not it's not an all-time Malick classic but I think it's a very
good movie and I respect him for for doing this journey but we can do red for to the wonder
runner runner is an utter fiasco can't win them all shockingly bad yeah that's red gone girl is
green the most green maybe of all the greens because it's a wonderful movie that is also
the perfect text about Ben Affleck and runner runner he plays a man named Ivan block okay and
gone girl he plays the immortal Nick Dunn yeah even that well so the opening shot of animals
when he's filming the the commercial but it's it starts the camcorder and he's in camcorder frame
and you just think right back to the uh the press conference and gone girl so you know he is aware
of his own myth yeah as am I back to the well one too many times for sure on this one
2016 Batman versus Superman Dawn of Justice now after gone girl which is a massive hit 400
million dollar movie adaptation of a literary classic this is also a real turning point in
movie history I feel that what happens 2015 is Jurassic World for example things shift pretty
dramatically in this period away from films like gone girl being able to be super successful
and into what I think Ben Affleck to his credit sees happening yeah which is superhero movies
he's already tried it once with Daredevil and it didn't work but he's like you know what I'm a dad
I want my kids to see me as a hero yeah I want to be Batman I'm going to take on the cape and
cowl I'm going to be Bruce Wayne and I'm going to trust Zack Snyder that his vision will work
would you be Godzilla to impress Alice of course yeah I mean it's completely relatable it's just
the most understandable decision in the world also you know he's he's won an Oscar he's riding high
in gone girl which makes a lot of money like there's there's an ego aspect to it of well of
sure I'll be Batman I can do anything yeah yeah um and I want to be at the center of movies and
this is where the center of movies is right now uh he's he's not good well this is a bad movie
he's fine he's a good Bruce Wayne he's a good Bruce Wayne and I I would have loved to have seen him
in a different strain of this these stories because
he is actually oddly the only Bruce Wayne that we've gotten that is like this
because Christian Bale is like American Psycho very slick right Michael Keaton of course is a
twitchy and odd and he kind of subverted our expectations this Bruce Wayne is classical
he feels right yeah the movies are just so I mean the plotting and story of Batman v Superman is so
bad it's red it's so red they wear a lot of
vests in this as I recall I remember seeing this at the arc light I walked
down from the offices saw it I think with Sam Donsky and it's just like vests beautiful vests
that they were that were like too tight so they could you know spring out of them I mean I mean
this in their Bruce Wayne and uh Clark Kent lives not as Batman and Superman was this a summer film
I don't really remember March yeah wow this was pre-ringer launching
yeah
March 2016 were we ever so young 2016 Suicide Squad yeah bad that's red red 2016 The Accountant
I think possibly green I agree massive hit huge hit pretty cool movie a real performance yes
different from anything he had done before I'm not against it I think it is quite possibly just
purely green okay I mean I'm like my favorite Ben Affleck action movie
but it's not bad it's definitely good and he does you know he has to do a lot of whiteboard
writing as well which we always enjoy that yes we always enjoy that okay also I'll just say green
for The Accountant live by night red tough sit really really really bad really misconceived yeah
it's a real drag and this is a pivotal movie in his career because the movie's very expensive he
makes for Warner Brothers it doesn't click yeah and then many years go by before he directs another
movie it's a real shame 2017 Justice League that's red yep 2019 Triple Frontier blue
okay it's you might not have to do that we might have to green it I mean this is also I think this
is a a tough period in Affleck's life more generally I think and you can see that in the
screen in Triple Frontier as well so that's always interesting yeah I think we liked it
when the Metallica hits you know yeah I've always liked it all right that's great I think we should
green it okay we I mean we have to honor our own principles I agree with you this is our show
it's our choices Jay and Silent Bob reboot he returns as Holden McNeil Ben Affleck has played
Holden McNeil three times in his career uh that's red the last thing he wanted this movie is it also
a fiasco this we saw this at Sundance he did this is a movie that has been memory hold yeah D. Reese
was she coming off of Pariah no she was coming off of um Mudbound Academy Award nominated Mudbound
she has not directed a movie since then this movie is a real shame Ben Affleck and Anne Hathaway and
Willem Dafoe in like an international kind of espionage drama and it's a Joan Didion adaptation
yes we thought it was just going to be absolute wheelhouse and it just doesn't make sense no it's
all about um really the CIA and Central America and a journalist and man it's
it's so interesting when a movie like this comes along and just didn't this movie cost a hundred
million dollars yeah nobody saw it I mean I think some of that was also COVID it was it was for sure
and it didn't make sense but it was February 14th 2020 is when it came out on Netflix
and it's just gone forever so the last thing he wanted is red five percent on Rotten Tomatoes five
percent well I mean we knew in the room when we saw it yeah that first screening we were just like
oh man because you know that's the kind of movie you and I would love to cheer for totally tough
one 2020 the way back he's very good in this I think
yellow for now and let's revisit because there's really strong performance you know a little bit of
a predictable movie a very sad movie this was one of the very last movies I think we talked about
in person on the pod yes and one of the last movies I remember seeing in person theaters yeah
um Zack Snyder's Justice League we recorded a four and a half hour episode about that movie
a watch along in 2021 thumbs down people can check that out it's uh red the last duel
hmm he's quite good in this yeah it's very funny it introduces
like another phase of of Ben Affleck you know going back to his Chucky roots and being the
colorful supporting actor in like a pretty good movie I'm a fan so and letting other people do
the heavy serious lifting and just being charming and Ben Affleck and he co-wrote it yeah
green I think so great green I don't know how many greens it feels really nice just to be just
you know yeah
whatever we want I agree with you okay tender bar he's really good it's a great performance
yeah this is another movie that I feel not a lot of people saw I saw this movie at a screening at
the DGA oh and it was in the latter part of 2021 post vaccine and I remember thinking like hmm
something cooking here for old Ben yeah could we get a best supporting actor nomination
could would the academy look kindly upon this film the answer is no it didn't happen and people I
thought they were going to win I thought they were going to win I thought they were going to win
I thought this movie would have gone over well now you know very Long Island coded film
um but this book is also big for a lot of people well yeah I mean it's it's written by
J.R. Moehringer who has now become the king of ghostwriting world famous ghost writer and what
was what was uh what was his last book he just did a huge book after spare the Prince Harry
after spare he has one this year what is it uh it's I mean it's I'm I it's Ari Emanuel's book
oh that's right yeah yeah yeah okay um anyway tender bar I like it I feel like it's
yellow maybe yellow with a future blue status yeah okay uh 2022 deep water unfortunately a red
that's a red Adrian line um erotic thriller didn't have a bad time no Ana de Armas Jacob
Elordi and Tracy Letts with Ben Affleck this is Amanda tick-tack-toe-toe-toe right and yet
it's not good but once again sometimes the movie is just showing you what you want to see and you
say thank you Tracy had fun listen I had fun okay uh Jennifer Lopez remember all of the Ana de Armas
Ben Affleck Instagram content from this era not really but you remember when Ben Affleck showed
up to the protests with the handwritten sign no wow you just you're not paying attention it's okay
I am 2022 Jennifer Lopez halftime he plays himself I don't remember him in this Jennifer Lopez
documentary we will continue to discuss other halftime is red yeah 2022 clerks three he plays
a man named Boston John okay good for him that's red he has appeared in almost every Kevin Smith
movie I admire that friendship is very powerful it's beautiful 2023 hypnotic this is a Robert
Rodriguez thriller that you and I saw in movie theaters we did it's not going in not going in
not very good at all um but I couldn't even tell you the premise it's quite confusing there's a
science fiction component to it it had a bracing ending as I recall
which we talked about in some depth 2023 air now he directed this movie and he plays quite
amusingly Phil Knight in the movie yellow red yellow red you've always
been a little more down on this than i have yeah again it's a little i'm not a nike person and i
do think that the speech that matt damon gives at the end is is quite good yeah uh bateman he's
doing some stuff yeah but you know affleck's just kind of walking around davis she's great
but affleck's just directing a nike commercial acting yeah some of the great viola davis phone
if you want to yellow it but okay 2023 is the flash that's green um 2024 this is me now loves
the flash is red yeah this is me now a love story okay so this is like the extended music video
yeah so that is a red that did not really work for me he plays wreckstone slash biker yeah but
he shows up at the end to to save her okay um because this is about their love story greatest
love story never told is again a fascinating text he's amazing in it
you
you can feel him both he turns on as a filmmaker and he's like okay if we're gonna do this then
i'm gonna be interviewing you as the documentarian like halfway through this i'm gonna be shaping
this film and then he's also simultaneously like why are we doing this why am i not in this
why am i in this he also has the cameras scene where he just starts explaining lenses to jennifer
lopez i mean we don't have to put it in but it's just notable it's tailor-made for a blue for you
yeah okay but then i can't give the accountant too
the the blue did you see the accountant too jack not yet okay wow i had a busy movie watching
weekend okay the account too is terrible it's really terrible but i'm so excited thank you
the account is the account too it's not going in yeah i liked that he and burnthal had some fun
together yeah they're a little chit chats that that stuff was amusing all in the dog
yeah that's all right i whatever it's fine okay count two is red yeah 2026 the rip if this were
quentin tarantino's the big picture it would be going in but it's not um i'm i'm not i i'm
mixed at best on the rip i know people like it i don't really i haven't revisited it yeah
triple frontier though yeah no that's a streaming movie if you've ever seen one 2026
animals is red all right so we have one two three four five six seven eight nine we have nine greens
so we can choose one wow why are we not doing dogma well i would do chasing amy over dogma
if you if we put dogman then i would put chasey i would i would do chasing chasing
amy and i will make dogma my blue okay i'm fine with that
is that so no dazed i know that i know that you people know about dazed and confused
you know what i'm saying we would do days over the accountant
well i know you like to honor the start of the career the last duel is not better than
confused okay
then take out last duel but is the is dazed and confused more important i guess it's the
discovery dazed and confused and chasing amy feels like gilding the lily to me not to me
okay because we wouldn't be here doing this episode if it wasn't for dazed and confused
and chasing amy okay because you might be here i said okay you might be in an alternate universe
with some other guy with dean genesee but you're here with sean fennessy and so when dazed and
confused and chasing amy came out can i give you a piece of advice for this podcast no every
you can't give me take the win i said yes conversation i don't want your advice i know
exactly what i'm doing i'm in complete command right now i've never felt stronger or more sure
of myself where did we land you'd like me to read this the hall of fame i think so okay wait let's
let's let them finish their yeah because right now there's like a chartreuse kind of an interesting
you guys are doing good work okay
all right may i now read them do we have 10 would you please sure i don't know if we have 10 okay
we're gonna find out are you gonna count i want you to count okay well i can't count and read at
the same time let me give you a piece of advice okay dazed and confused chasing amy goodwill
hunting armageddon gone baby gone the town argo gone girl the accountant and triple frontier
that's 10 two blues what's your blue uh my blue is the greatest love story never told my blue
is dogma yeah what a time i feel we've done reasonable work here he means a lot to me i
don't know if this hall of fame represents the breadth of what he's accomplished in the in the
pop cultural space but i guess it does it has gone girl and it has the greatest love story never told
the armageddon director's commentary of course people should listen to that i would encourage
people to track down the chasing amy director's commentary hunting you have 30 years of matt and
ben that's right so there's um beautiful there's and you have artist equity and everything yeah
there's the the david fincher ben affleck uh podcast interview that people should seek out
there's ben affleck sitting at business conferences explaining technology to people
i i genuinely am enraptured by all of them i would watch him do that with regularity he's
an incredible spokesperson he is he is spilling duncan donuts everywhere well sure yeah the memes
we didn't do a world
most beleaguered man yeah we didn't do you know the balancing the chick-fil-a deliveries
living out loud you know i respect it i i really really respect it um we didn't do the back tattoo
nope yeah nope okay i wouldn't do that uh but it's pop culturally important no question he's he is
singular there's never been anyone like him that's true and that's why we honor him on this day okay
how do you feel great it just it feels
good to know things you know despite appearances i go through life being like i don't know am i sure
about this what's going on not on the subject of ben affleck let me give you a piece of advice
i'm never gonna let that go also the goat for refusing to wear a yankees hat and gone girl
yeah yeah yeah it's a good bit uh well you must see everything is this friday yeah you must you
can see everything you can see everything you must see you can see everything that's the name
of our podcast that's the name of the episode um what do we do we're gonna talk about it so we just
we just we're just gonna we got it's gonna be we're just gonna talk all about it no it's gonna
be spoiler zone so people are we gonna not talk about it well i just brokered a deal with eileen
that on thursday yeah i have a screening in the afternoon and that screening is just before she's
gonna go see the movie at 3 p.m on thursday so then i'm gonna do i'm gonna pick alice up great
dad of the year i can't not see this having it all like she needs she's like doesn't want it but
i'm not i'm not valorizing myself i'm just it's the point is is that she doesn't want any news
coming in on the movie every conversation i've had as soon as i can i would say like you know
but like drop off pick up all the parent like everyone every grown-up i talk to
wants to know if i've seen it and then doesn't want to know anything about it and i'm like
i'm not saying anything but you do need to go see it as soon as possible
in my own home in the booth here we were we have gotten everybody to see it so we don't
our team is fully has seen everything so i think that we just we have to treat everybody like
adults just as the movie treats everybody like adults okay and if you listen to the podcast
without having seen the film then that's on you that's that's what we'll put the
disclaimers it'll be there waiting for you once you see it
i think that's what we got to do i agree with you that's what we're going to do okay thanks
to our producer jack sanders for his work on today's episode thanks to lucas cavanaugh for
production support we are talking about you can see everything on friday we'll see you then
coca-cola for the big for the small the short and the tall peacemakers risk takers
for the optimists pessimists for long-distance love for introverts and extroverts the thinkers
and the doers for old friends and new coca-cola for everyone pick up some
coca-cola for everyone pick up some coca-cola for everyone pick up some
Coca-Cola at a store near you.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The show discusses two films
*Other Mommy* has mixed reviews, with praise for its visual creativity and standout sequences like the balloon and ball pit scenes, but criticized for poor narrative coherence and cheap CGI.
The film’s plot blends supernatural horror with PTSD themes, drawing comparisons to *Poltergeist* and *Smile*, though it fails to deliver a compelling or emotionally satisfying story.
*Animals* is described as a poorly executed, overpacked political thriller that tries to merge multiple genres—domestic drama, political intrigue, social commentary, and hostage thriller—without cohesion.
Ben Affleck’s direction is seen as directionless, relying on excessive drone shots, exposition, and stylistic flourishes that undermine storytelling, despite his public persona and filmography.
Both films reflect a trend in modern cinema where high-concept ideas and strong marketing fail due to lack of narrative depth and audience alignment.
The conversation highlights how online fan culture and critical backlash can amplify the impact of underperforming, emotionally charged films.
The discussion ends with a focus on the importance of genre authenticity, calling out the disconnect between mainstream expectations and what horror or drama fans truly value.
Summary:
The episode explores two recent films—*Other Mommy* and *Animals*—through a lens of genre, narrative, and audience reaction. *Other Mommy*, based on a novel and starring Jessica Chastain, is praised for its inventive visuals, especially the balloon and ball pit sequences, but criticized for a disjointed plot, inconsistent storytelling, and shallow emotional depth. Despite its unsettling premise involving a girl haunted by a demonic "Other Mommy," it fails to deliver a coherent narrative, leaning heavily on genre tropes without grounding them in believable logic.
In contrast, *Animals*, a Netflix film directed by Ben Affleck, is dismissed as a chaotic, genre-blending disaster. It attempts to merge political drama, family conflict, and social commentary into a single story, but suffers from disjointed pacing, misused actors (like Steven Yeun), and a lack of authentic emotional stakes. The film’s structure feels like a series of unrelated plotlines stitched together, undermining its narrative integrity.
Both films exemplify a broader trend in modern cinema where ambitious concepts and strong marketing fail due to poor execution and lack of focus. The discussion also touches on how online fan communities and critical backlash amplify the impact of underperforming films, especially when they take bold or controversial risks. Ultimately, the show underscores the importance of genre authenticity and narrative clarity, arguing that even with high-profile casting and marketing, films must deliver genuine emotional and structural coherence to resonate with audiences.
The episode ends with a nod to the growing role of fan-driven discourse in shaping cinematic success, while questioning whether filmmakers are better suited to television or more focused storytelling in film.
FAQs
The film follows a Los Angeles mayoral candidate's family as they try to ransom their kidnapped son, forcing them to expose hidden aspects of their lives. It's loosely inspired by Akira Kurosawa's 'High and Low' but not a direct remake.
The show notes that both 'Animals' and 'Highest to Lowest' are modern reinterpretations of the classic film 'High and Low,' focusing on political power, wealthy individuals, and kidnappings, though they misrepresent the original film's focus on wealth rather than public notoriety.
The film touches on political scandals, class divides, immigration, domestic marriage conflicts, and the pressures of public life, attempting to blend multiple genres into one narrative.
The hosts describe it as 'really not good' and 'extremely unsuccessful,' citing overcrowded plotlines, poor pacing, and an incoherent mix of genres that makes the film feel disjointed and superficial.
Ben Affleck is both a lead actor and director of the film, and while the hosts acknowledge his filmmaking experience, they note his public persona and political references add to the film's thematic complexity rather than improving its quality.
While 'Other Mommy' is seen as visually inventive and emotionally resonant in certain sequences, it is criticized for narrative inconsistency and cheap effects, unlike 'Animals,' which is considered a poorly executed, genre-blending effort.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.