The A.I. Fight Dividing the Trump Administration, and the Next James Bond
9m 38s
A growing tension exists within the Trump administration over how to restrict China’s access to U.S. AI technology, with Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnik favoring a lenient approach versus increasing pressure from top officials, including Treasury and State Department leaders, for stricter export controls. This conflict culminated in new actions targeting China’s access to offshore data centers and a criminal investigation into a chip-smuggling company. Meanwhile, a series of major technical outages—impacting United Airlines and Chase Bank—underscores the fragility of modern digital systems. A new Harvard study finds that strict school phone bans are significantly linked to improved student test scores, especially in schools with full-day restrictions. In parallel, companies are repurposing old jet engines to power data centers, raising environmental concerns due to inefficiency and pollution. A landmark study in Nature Sustainability reveals that large U.S. data centers now emit carbon levels comparable to entire countries, indicating a serious environmental toll. The casting of Robert Pattinson as the next James Bond has sparked debate, with some praising his unique character depth and others fearing it may limit his career scope. The franchise is expected to return only in 2028, marking a significant gap in the long-running series.
From the New York Times, it's the headlines. I'm Tracy Mumford. Today's Tuesday, November 17th, here's what we're covering. A divide within the Trump administration over technology and China has broken into the open, right as President Trump is headed to meet Wushijim Ping. On one side is Howard Lutnik, the Commerce Secretary, whose department writes and enforces the rules around exporting AI chips. Lutnik has taken a soft touch on that. You want to sell the Chinese enough that their developers get addicted to the American technology stack. On the other side is a group of top administration officials who've been pressing for months for stricter limits on what chips China can access. Any leakage is very frustrating because it hurts our great companies and the AI race gives the Chinese an advantage. That group includes Treasury Secretary Scott Besant, Secretary of State Marco Rubio, who is also Trump's national security adviser, and much of the National Security Council staff. And now that tough on China side seems to be gaining traction. Yesterday, the administration moved to crack down on a loophole that has allowed China to access offshore data centers, basically renting the kind of advanced chips it's not allowed to buy directly. And, late last night, the Justice and Commerce Department announced they're pursuing a criminal investigation of Megaspeed, a company suspected of chip smuggling, whose former executive had an affair with Jensen Huang of NVIDIA. For its part, Megaspeed says it's complied with all laws. The investigation announcement appeared to be a response to criticism that the case under Lutnik's leadership had moved too slowly. Yesterday, on the heels of the FAA's ground stop and the Microsoft outage, two other institutions hit technical issues, United Airlines and Chase Bank. United said it had a widespread system outage that lasted for about an hour in the afternoon, leading to delays. The airline hasn't provided additional details about the cause of the outage, which comes just as millions of Americans are preparing to fly for the week of Thanksgiving. And for JP Morgan Chase, the nation's largest bank, some customers reported on social media yesterday that they couldn't use their ATM cards or complete transactions at branches. Chase says it's now resumed normal operations after experiencing, quote, "a temporary issue related to a software bug." It said there was no evidence that the problem was cyberrelated. With the back-to-back-to-back incidents, one professor of information technology at Notre Dame said each example has an explanation that makes sense on its own, but that they all underscore, quote, "the complexity and fragility of the systems that we depend on every day." Across the country, over the past few years, Indiana State law now requires schools to make their students leave their phones at home, dozens of states have banned or restricted cell phone use in schools. Now, a large new study has found that those policies are starting to gradually improve test scores. The analysis, published by Harvard Center for Education Policy Research, looked at test scores from more than 3 million elementary through high school students over five years, and it compared kids scores in schools that put in place strict phone bans to those at schools without them. The biggest improvements were in schools with the strictest bans, like ones that require students to lock their phones and pouches the whole day. There, scores improved as much as if students had an extra week or two of school a year. There have been studies on this topic before, with mixed results, but this new study is the first to track individual students' performance before and after bans were put in place. One, education researcher who was not involved in the study cautioned against being too optimistic about modest achievement gains, but said that if they continue to add up over time, year after year, it could be, quote, "really important and really meaningful." Teachers and researchers also say that improving test scores is just one potential benefit of phone bans, which can also cut back on cyberbullying, get kids more engaged in the classroom, and boost social skills. Earlier this fall, my colleague Heroko Tabuchi went on a reporting trip to Arizona to check out what's known as an aircraft boniard. It's in the middle of the Sonoran Desert, and there are hundreds of airplanes that are parked, basically, nose to tail. The airplanes were in various states of disrepair. You could even peek in to see seats, even tray tables, and remnants of meals and things like that. They're all waiting there to be stripped for parts. And one of the parts that's gained a lot of attention recently are their powerful jet engines. These jet engines from these old aircraft are now being used for something kind of surprising. They're being used to generate power for data centers. Heroko says what's happening is that in the rush to power the data center boom across the US, companies are getting creative about how to generate as much electricity as quickly as possible. And old jet engines are a plentiful and untapped source that doesn't rely on the grid. The engines can be pulled off the wings of planes and converted into generators. But it's raising alarms with environmentalists. They say that repurposed aircraft turbines tend to be less efficient and more polluting than the kinds of engines that are specifically designed for gas burning power plants. So far, Elon Musk's AI company XAI has installed eight converted turbines in Mississippi to power one of its massive data centers, according to state permits and satellite imagery. And other state permits show that more big AI companies also have plans to use turbines from a company that repurposes jet engines. Meanwhile, a major new study has given the clearest picture yet of how the data center boom has sent carbon emissions soaring. The research published yesterday in the journal Nature Sustainability found that the largest data centers in the US are responsible for releasing almost as much carbon dioxide a year as entire countries like Bolivia or Denmark. And that's likely to be a significant undercount since the study only went through the first half of last year. And since then, according to one estimate, at least 250 more data centers have come online. And finally, Sean Connery kicked things off. Roger Moore brought the camp and Daniel Craig came in and made him a bruiser. Now, we're getting our first millennial James Bond. It's Robert Pattinson, your favorite sparkly teenage vampire. A lot of people first knew Robert Pattinson from his role in Twilight, but in the years after that, he's worked with tons of great outdoor directors and he often plays very weird, almost pathetic guys, people who are down on their luck or who are kind of getting beaten up on or maybe they're very craven and cowardly as in this summer's role in the Odyssey. So it's not the kind of character that you would necessarily expect. The new James Bond to be playing, but I think that that actually is one of the things that makes him great for the role. Alyssa Wilkinson is a film critic at the times. She says people are having a lot of feelings about the casting, which was announced yesterday. Some think Pattinson is too weird or they love that he's weird and they worry that this will cut him off from more interesting roles. It is a good time to be reminded that Daniel Craig was not everybody's favorite choice back in the day. Some people called him a potato harsh and even created a protest website. IgnatBond.com. Looking ahead, we're not likely to see Pattinson's 007 for a while, 2028 at the very earliest. The last film came out in 2021, so that would be the longest we've ever gone without a Bond movie since the franchise debuted. Those are the headlines. Today on the daily, what Democrats in Congress will and won't be able to do about the country's affordability crisis when they take power in January. You can find that in the New York Times app or wherever you get your podcasts. I'm Tracy Mumford. We'll be back tomorrow.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
A rift has emerged within the Trump administration over China tech policies, with Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnik advocating leniency in AI chip exports versus a growing push from top officials for stricter controls.
The administration recently cracked down on a loophole enabling China to access offshore data centers and launched a criminal investigation into Megaspeed, a company linked to chip smuggling, in response to criticism of slow action.
Back-to-back technical failures at United Airlines and JP Morgan Chase highlight growing concerns about the fragility and complexity of critical digital infrastructure.
A new Harvard study shows that strict school phone bans are linked to improved student test scores, with the most significant gains in schools enforcing full-day phone removal.
Old aircraft jet engines are being repurposed to power data centers, including those operated by Elon Musk’s XAI, though environmentalists warn of higher emissions and inefficiency.
A major study in Nature Sustainability reveals that U.S. data centers emit nearly as much CO₂ annually as entire countries like Bolivia or Denmark, with emissions likely undercounted due to new data centers coming online.
Robert Pattinson is set to play the first millennial James Bond, a casting choice that has sparked mixed reactions, echoing past controversies over Daniel Craig’s selection.
The next Bond film is expected no earlier than 2028, marking the longest gap since the franchise began.
Summary:
S. AI technology, with Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnik favoring a lenient approach versus increasing pressure from top officials, including Treasury and State Department leaders, for stricter export controls. This conflict culminated in new actions targeting China’s access to offshore data centers and a criminal investigation into a chip-smuggling company.
Meanwhile, a series of major technical outages—impacting United Airlines and Chase Bank—underscores the fragility of modern digital systems. A new Harvard study finds that strict school phone bans are significantly linked to improved student test scores, especially in schools with full-day restrictions. In parallel, companies are repurposing old jet engines to power data centers, raising environmental concerns due to inefficiency and pollution.
S. data centers now emit carbon levels comparable to entire countries, indicating a serious environmental toll. The casting of Robert Pattinson as the next James Bond has sparked debate, with some praising his unique character depth and others fearing it may limit his career scope.
The franchise is expected to return only in 2028, marking a significant gap in the long-running series.
FAQs
There is a split between Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnik, who supports allowing China access to American technology for development, and a group of officials including Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and National Security Council members, who advocate for stricter limits on Chinese access to advanced chips.
The administration cracked down on a loophole allowing China to rent offshore data centers and launched a criminal investigation into Megaspeed, a company suspected of smuggling chips, in response to criticism over slow enforcement.
It signals growing pressure on Commerce Secretary Lutnik to act more aggressively on chip exports to China, especially as the U.S. seeks to protect its AI advantage and prevent technological leakage.
United Airlines and JP Morgan Chase experienced major system outages, with United facing an hour-long outage and Chase reporting ATM and transaction issues due to a software bug, not cyberattack.
A large study found that strict phone bans in schools are linked to significant improvements in student test scores, with the strongest gains in schools enforcing full-day phone lock policies.
Companies are repurposing jet engines from retired aircraft to generate power for data centers, especially in areas like Mississippi, as a way to meet rising energy demands without relying on the grid.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.