Go back

The 6 rules you need for a long, healthy life and how to cut your risk of dementia, heart disease and cancer | Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel

61m 34s

The 6 rules you need for a long, healthy life and how to cut your risk of dementia, heart disease and cancer | Dr. Ezekiel Emanuel

In this episode, Dr. E.C.L.A., an oncologist and bioethicist, challenges the modern wellness industry, which he calls the "wellness industrial complex." He argues that its obsession with extreme optimization—whether through intense exercise regimens, unregulated supplements, or restrictive diets—is misguided and often harmful. His book was sparked by fury over Peter Attia's "Outlive," which he felt neglected the most vital health factor: social relationships. He explains that wellness trends historically resurge during turbulent times, offering people a false sense of control. He debunks claims of extended longevity, noting the maximum human lifespan remains around 120 years. He criticizes excessive exercise beyond a certain plateau, highlighting opportunity costs, and warns against risky peptides and supplements. On alcohol, he advocates moderation—3-4 drinks weekly, used socially—rather than total abstinence, acknowledging its role in social bonding. He identifies ultra-processed foods as a major driver of obesity and cognitive decline, urging reductions in sodas and packaged snacks. Ultimately, his six rules emphasize balance, social connections, and living a meaningful life, arguing wellness should be a means to an end, not the end itself. He stresses that sustainable health comes from moderation, not self-denial, and that simple, inexpensive fundamentals—like nurturing relationships—are more impactful than any complex optimization strategy.

Transcription

10503 Words, 57628 Characters

English
Welcome to Zoe, Science and Nutrition, where world-leading scientists explain how their research can improve your health. In the modern world, staying healthy can feel less like living the good life and more like a full-time job. Go to the gym, take the right supplements, get to bed at the exact same time every day. Wear sunscreen. Definitely don't drink alcohol. All of this fueled by a constant stream of people selling the seductive idea, if we buy the right products and follow the perfect routine, we can live healthily to 135. But what if none of this works? Or even worse, what if our obsession with optimising our lives is making us feel more anxious, more isolated and more confused about health than ever? Our guest today believes we got it all wrong. But much of this is toxic. Instead, he's come up with six rules for good health. And today, we're going to discuss them all. Doctor is E.C.L.A. is one of the world's leading oncologists and bioethicists, a professor at the University of Pennsylvania and the author of more than 300 scientific papers. His latest book is an attack on what he calls the "wellness industrial complex". He argues that the science shows our long healthy life is not built by its stream optimisation. But by following key fundamentals that are grounded in what it is to be a human being. By the end of this fascinating and entertaining episode, you'll have learnt his six rules for good health and discovered that not one of them is complicated or expensive. Zeke, thank you so much for joining me today. My great pleasure and honor. So we have a tradition here at Zary where we always start with a quick fire round of questions. Great. And we have some very strict rules. You can give us a yes or a no or if you have to, a one sentence answer. Okay. Is loneliness worse for your health than smoking tobacco? Yes. Is being president of the United States more dangerous than climbing Everest? It's definitely a more smucky move. To books written by wellness influencers usually give good advice. It's mixed. Is the wellness industry overall doing more harm than good? Hard to know. Do you have six rules to help us live longer healthier lives? Absolutely. And finally, what's the biggest thing that the wellness industry gets wrong? Social relations. They're the most important thing you can do for your wellness, longevity and happiness. Most of the people listening to this podcast, myself included, are overwhelmed by a tidal wave of wellness information that we get on podcasts and social media from our friends, you know, from the traditional media. And we're bombarded with ads therefore for supplements and red light therapy and coffee enomas and superfoods. And now the list goes on and on and I feel like every week somebody tells me about this brand new thing that you can do. So I think it's no surprise that we all feel very confused about what we should actually do. So I'm delighted to have you with us today to hopefully help make sense of it all. And your new book outlines six simple rules for a long healthy life. And so I was curious what inspired you to write this book, anger, anger. So in December 2023, I had finished teaching in the United States, but finals in grades had weren't do in and Peter Ritea's outlive arrived at my house. Now I certainly didn't order it because I didn't even know it existed. I thought my brother sent it to me, but he denies that he said he's never even seen the book. So I just sat down and read it. It's 415 or so pages and it just made me more and more furious as I got to the end. I literally finished the book in a short flash and sat down in the next three weeks and wrote 35,000 words. And that was the first draft of this book. And what really made me mad is his obsession about exercise, a little bit about food, a little bit about sleep, but he left out the most important thing about wellness, which we just talked about, which is social relationships. He has a two page afterward. And in the afterward he says, well, you can be in great shape. You can be able to bench press 250 pounds, but if your relationship with your wife is terrible, if you don't have good friends, what's it for? And yet the book doesn't deal with that fact that social relations are so important to you, not just psychologically, physically, to your body. And so that was the genesis. And I had previously worked out in my head that they are these six rules are pretty simple, but that was the catalytic moment, if you will, that drove me. And so you regularly like driven to such levels of fury by a book that arrives in front of you that you write your own book as a post. This is the first time that's ever happened. And the first, I won't say the first time things flowed out magically and you like look back and you say, well, how did I do that? How did I put it all together? Because it seems, I mean, some writers report, you know, I was just the conduit for some higher force. It does, it has that kind of feel to me once I wrote an article which I'm sort of infamous for what I want to die at 75. And that also in three days I just finished the article and with minor touch ups, that's what got published. So there are sometimes when it does work, it just flows out. But this was quite, I mean, 35,000 words, it was quite unusual. So you were really upset by this, but you felt that this book was, it was a total disservice to humanity and it was getting a lot of attention. And I was like, this is diverting people from the way they need to really think about wellness. I mean, I'd say the other thing that the wellness industrial complex gets wrong is this sort of, I mean, it gets lots of things wrong. One is to be obsessed about wellness. You should not be obsessed about wellness. You should be obsessed about living a meaningful life. That's really what's important and wellness is only a means to an end. The second thing is a lot of it's about self denial. Things you should go on and you should work out until it really hurt. Wrong. If you're going to do wellness, you're going to do it for decades and you can't, you will not sustain self denial for decades. And that's why people give up on their new years or solutions, give up on their diets because it's mostly built around self denial. So this book is much more serious about, first of all, biology for humans is about homeostasis. The balance between one extreme and another. And this is something Aristotle understood. The happy medium, the golden middle, and it really is true in the body. If your immune system is very, very active, you have autoimmunity and you attack yourself. If it's too late and you will get infections and so you have to get a middle and the body is exquisitely tuned to some moderation and not to go to extremes. And yet the wellness industrial complex, if something is good, eating something is good, you should go and max it. That's the phrase, max it out. And no, that it, maxing is not biological. I love it. I also love this phrase, the wellness industrial complex, which is a new one on me. Why has that complex, as you put it, exploded recently? Because this is definitely different from what I grew up with. This isn't the first time wellness has sort of explode and become an obsession of the population and society. Between roughly 1870 and 1914, we had the same interest. Lots of turn to vegetarianism, exercise, worry about fresh air, worry about the food you eat. It's actually an anti-vax movement, then the vaccine was smallpox. And if you look at the two periods of time, they have a lot of similarities. Industrial revolution in the 18th, 19th century, AI and the revolution around knowledge today. Lots of small wars then. Same thing today. You also have a lot of income inequality at that time. And then you also have lots of uncertainty for people. And I think what that shows you is that wellness is a response to a topsy-turvy world. A lot of uncertainty about what the future is bringing people feeling like they're light shot of control. And so wellness is a response. This is something I can control. What I eat, the vaccines I get, the exercise. And I think that's what we have today. This is a lot about self-control, transmuted into wellness as the outlet. So that's the big social explanation. I think the personal explanation is people want to live healthy. They don't want to have these chronic diseases. And they're trying to figure out, well, what can I do besides taking a lot of medications that will make me healthier? Here's an interesting historical fact. I'm going to look at the history of the wellness industry. I came across an article in the St. Louis Post Dispatch 1909. And the headline reads, "Researcher says science will be able to allow us to live to 150 years." Could have been written yesterday by a wellness influencer. The same motivation. You know, but you know, the data are that that's very unlikely and here's why we have more people living to 90 more people who are centenarians than ever before, but it turns out the top period how long people can live roughly 120 years is the max hasn't moved and very unlikely to move. And so I think we have to recognize that it is true. We can postpone decline, we can live healthier up until our 90s. Most people at the 90s, even if they've lived in an active life, are, you know, things are beginning to slow down substantially. I just like to circle back to this idea that there are things that the wellness industry is getting wrong. And I can see this one book which I have read, triggered a lot of fury, but if we're going to step back more broadly across this whole industry, one of the main things for you that they're getting wrong because I think a lot of people are saying, but like they tell you to do more exercise and think more about what you're doing. Surely this is basically all great. Hi, first of all Tim Specter here. Have you heard about our documentary The Gut Health Challenge? We challenge Sarah, Rob and Lucida transform their health in just six weeks by improving their gut health. If you've ever wondered how Zoey works, this documentary reveals all. When our participants started, they struggled with everything from brain fog and sleep troubles and low energy. Can eating the Zoey way address these issues and improve their health markers in just six weeks? You'll get a behind the scenes look at Zoey and discover some great action or advice from Federica and Sarah. Follow their journey by searching Gut Health Challenge on YouTube. No, first of all, it isn't all great. Let me just give you one example, the exercise example. If you follow Peter Rittia, 10 hours a week, that's what he recommends and he's got it broken down by various things. It turns out that there's a plateau in terms of exercises to how much you will improve your longevity if you exercise more. That plateau is around 150 minutes of vigorous exercise every week and about 300 minutes, five hours of moderate exercise every week. Beyond that, there's no real bump in terms of longevity. What is there if you keep exercising? The most important thing is what the economist called opportunity cost. What could you be doing in those five hours that you're not doing because you're pumping iron in a gym or you're out running or rowing? Now, I'm not saying those aren't bad things and you can't be rejuvenated by them. But I do think that there's big opportunity cost by spending too much time obsessing about these activities that they recommend. That again goes to this issue that they make wellness the center of life as opposed to a means to the ends, which is a fulfilling life. Seven and a half hours a week while you're awake is a substantial portion of your wakefulness hour. You got to figure, what should I be doing in that time? Maybe you should be reading a book cover to cover. That's just one thing. You could spend that time with close friends. There are lots and lots of good things you can do that are good for your community and also good for you. Is that the only thing that is it just exercise duration that the wellness industry is getting wrong? No. I mean, they're selling you lots of goods. They just supplement that supplement. First of all, for many of them, it's just the waste of money. Some of them are probably dangerous for you. This whole new wave of peptides. Take these peptides and stack them. Don't take one. Why one is okay, but let's max it. Let's go five at one time. Just idiotic and probably dangerous. Not everyone will understand what peptides are. Obviously, there's been an explosion of this online, particularly in the states because the regulations are much lower. In a lot of other countries, it's hard to get them. So I just want to make sure that everyone understands. You can just explain what's going on. Then can you talk about whether they're safe? Peptides are basically short proteins. The body is full of proteins. That's how we live. The DNA codes proteins and things like insulin are proteins or these new weight loss drugs, GLP ones are proteins and peptides. And peptides is just a short protein. They have a lot of important effects in the body. We need peptides. We need peptides to signal to cells. We need peptides, obviously, like insulin, to stimulate cells to take up glucose. These peptides, mainly from produced in China, are not well studied. We don't know the effects in the body. We don't know they're positive. And like everything, peptides will also have negative effects. Too much of them will be bad. And we don't really understand some of the combinations of these peptides. That's not to say all these peptides well produced, very carefully monitored, aren't going to be good. It is to say that going to a storefront and getting an infusion of peptides for $500 or something is crazy and probably could very well be dangerous. I think a lot of people think about it a bit like, well, I'm just getting some vitamins what can go wrong. Lots of things can go wrong. You can get the toxic reaction. They might be contaminated in their production. What they say they are, they might not be at all. And if they are, what they claim to be, does that mean? No, because we haven't studied them. People who take these weight loss drugs are GLP ones, right? They have side effects. And some of those side effects can be bad. That's why we research them for safety and effectiveness and have rules on who should get them, what the trade offs are and how much you should administer. So this is like just injecting a completely unregulated drug in the same way. Certainly in the United States. That is stupid. Does sound good. Stupid. I'd love now to sort of get into the topics that are in your book. And I'd like to start first with sort of what you say we should stop doing before going on to these six simple rules. But I'm very conscious that we don't really like to say you should restrict yourself. We generally feel that this is not sustainable and not a good balance. But I know that there are some things that are in your view things we should worry about. I'd like to just talk about them for a minute. And can we start with alcohol? Do I need to give it up? So alcohol is very controversial. You know, just a few years ago was you should have red wine and red wines got this magical French element that allows you to drink wine, enjoy it and live a long time. And now you've got studies from the WHO and in Britain zero. Alcohol is the right level. So we should be very clear. We do know that there are downsides to alcohol. We've known this for a long time. It's associated with a dramatic increase of risk of at least seven cancers. Liver disease, cirrhosis and its evolution. We know that it destroys brain cells and so enhances cognitive impairment. But we also know that humans have been drinking it forever. But it's not just humans. You know, birds go to fermented fruits, chimpanzees and other primates go to fermented fruits. And you know, nature seems to like the buzz. The other thing is we have to recognize two thirds of the population in countries actually are drinkers, one third are T totalers. You're not going from two thirds to zero. So we need to be realistic about it. And there are studies about how much is the right amount and it varies. Recent report out in the United States probably one drink a day, seven drinks a week, beyond that really dramatic increase. So that by eight drinks or nine drinks a week, you get a pretty substantial increase in the risk of mortality. There's also some studies that suggest it's less. It's three or four, which is what I recommend in the book, three or four drinks a week. And I think that's the kind of right level. But the other point I would make is alcohol is a lubricant for social interaction. It allows people to talk and that's a balance. All right, it's got this increased risk of harm. And it also increases the chance that you're going to have conversations with people and you're actually going to talk. And that's the kind of balance. I happen to be a T totaler. My wife happens to enjoy alcohol, enjoy cocktails. And I think getting the right balance is very, very important. Three or four drinks, no binging. Don't drink alone. Use it in social interactions. And don't use it to drown out your sorrows to avoid dealing with them. Look, when I have a dinner party at home, do I serve alcohol? The answer is yes. I think I like to talk about next is a topic that we end up talking about on this podcast a lot, which is ultra-priced as foods. A huge problem. If you had to say, all right, let's look at the last 60, 70 years, what's been the chief problem, I would say, ultra-process foods. Because they're bad cognitively. We've got some recent very good studies from Brazil and now one from the United States that they actually accelerate cognitive decline. We also know that they are addictive in the way they're formulated and they are energy dense. So they're a major reason we have the obesity epidemic. [BLANK_AUDIO] of things from the obesity epidemic, increased diabetes, increased renal disease, increased hypertension, increased cardiac disease, that is really, that is a major force driving our healthcare expenditures in every country up. Ultra-process foods are a serious problem. Now, the United States, we are the world's leader in consumption of ultra-process foods, so adults, about 60% of calories are ultra-process foods, Britain, a good close second. Now, you're in 50% of calories, ultra-process foods. That is an area you definitely have to reduce substantially. The contrast class is, you know, Italy, Italians are about 20% of calories, ultra-process foods, and that's where we have to move to, and start with two things, in my view. First, stop with the sodas, zero nutritional value, just stop. And diet sodas, no better, they're just as bad for you. And the second thing we have to do is decrease the package snacks, package cakes, package cookies, muffins, pretzels, chips, no good, and you know, there are lots of things you can substitute if you sort of, package and want to eat something, nuts, hummus and carrots, apples and cheeses. Those are things that are healthy for you and can substitute for these package ultra-process foods. You know, one of the tests I like to say to people, go and get an old magazine with a lot of pictures in it from the early 1960s. You'll have a hard time. You know, even candid pictures out of finding obese people, or go and get what in the United States, a year books of a school, you know, all the kids lined up. You won't see an obese kid in there. You just won't. And the change has been, you know, what is the change? Is it genetic? Absolutely not. Genes don't change that fast. Ultra-processed foods is a very big component. It's not the only component, but it is the major driver of that change. And, you know, we have to get away from it. Moving on. And everyone knows smoking is a terrible idea. Even people who smoke, they all know that it's not good for them. But what about vaping? Maybe better than smoking, but that doesn't make it healthy. We've been studying smoking for decades, more than 75 years ago, I think, was the first Richard Dahl, you know, showed in his epidemiology that smoking was causing lung cancer. We don't have 75 years of vaping. That's the first thing. The second thing is there's some good data about, yes, vaping can get people to quit smoking, but it also can get people to actually smoke. And there's more chemicals than vaping that we don't actually fully understand, and we've already had a couple of new lung diseases caused by vaping. Bad idea. Is that right? We're seeing diseases. Sometimes I feel like, you know, doctors, they always want to tell you that you can't do something. So the fact everyone's taking up vaping, they have to then tell you that it's a bad idea, but there is genuinely evidence. There is. Now they've taken some of those chemicals that we have been able to identify, but there are hundreds of chemicals in these vapes, and that's not again, not a good thing to put into your body. And so let's say your kids are vaping, because you definitely see this explosion in younger people as the same person's gone, how worried should you be about that? Yeah. This is all the other things that you might be worried about. No, no, I think that's something you do want to worry about. And it does point to the fact that the vaping industry has just ripped out a page from the tobacco industry. Get them young, get them hooked, and you'll have them for life. And that's a, you know, recurrent revenue stream. And it's really, it's totally exploitative. Final ones on things you might want to reduce or stop supplements. Okay. Very complicated. And it's kind of like the alcohol story, sometimes good, sometimes bad. So I think in general, and most of the medical profession would say, should not do supplements, they're a waste of money, they're not good. And especially the idea that some vitamins and minerals are important, maxing them ought to be good. You can get toxic reactions. What I'm hesitant at and what you're hearing that has a sense of life, there are some recent studies that suggest that a multivitamin might actually slow the cognitive decline of old age. You know, you take it with multivitamin a day, no harm in that except the expense. And if it has this positive benefit on cognitive decline, probably worth it. And there are some other population groups that do need some kinds of supplements, women and folate who are thinking of getting pregnant or are pregnant. Vitamin B12 for vegans is another one. People who don't get outside either because of mobility issues or whatever and don't get enough sunlight, you definitely need things like vitamin D. So I think there are some special categories for the vast majority of your listeners besides the multivitamin for the reason I said, probably not very useful. For most of these, the biggest harm is likely to be in the checkbook or the, you know, the wallet, not in the health. This is just about spending too much money that has no benefit or is there actually risks from this sort of wellness explosion around some of the supplements where you take too much. There are risks. But, you know, let's take protein. Huge push on protein. We're in this sort of protein max moment where everyone has got to take grams and grams of protein per kilogram. You can actually get gout, for example, from protein. You can create kidney stones depending upon the protein. An idea to go way too high into protein max. That is an example of a problem that can arise from too much protein. And, you know, gout used to be a disease of old rich men, you know, Ben Franklin had gout why because he was eating very rich food, not getting a lot of exercise, hydration, not terribly good. And it can happen today too. I'd lownite to talk about your six rules and what we should be doing to support healthy age aging. And I'd like to start with the first one, which is the best rule that I have heard in anything around wellness because I'm afraid you have sort of written a wellness book, so you just say, you know, the first rule in your book is don't be a schmuck. What does that mean? Yeah, don't be stupid. And this is something my father used to say to his three sons very commonly when we were doing something dumb. He would say, hit us on the back of the head and say, don't be a schmuck. And I have a cute story in the book about when I bought my first car and definitely was a schmuck. But there are things we do, right? Life is full of risks. Let's be clear. You cannot, you don't want to live a life in bubble wrap and you are going to take risk. For most of us, the riskiest thing we do is turn the car ignition on in the morning. Riski is a risky activity, I would just say in the United States, the chance of dying over a lifetime is more than one and a hundred from a car accident. Smoking and vaping, we know are real risks. Not taking your vaccines, despite what, you know, the American Secretary of Health and Human Services said is a real risk. I mean, the risks of polio, the risks of measles, the risks of chickenpox have all dramatically declined because of vaccines and people are healthier as a result of vaccines. So get those vaccine, get the cancer screening test. But there are other things that are really dangerous for you and doing them are schmucky moves. So when I was writing the book, when I, that first 35,000 words, I was like, well, it got to be the stupidest thing you can do is base jumping, you know, getting in that Michelin Mansuit with the wings, no propulsion, jumping into the wind where the wind might smash you into the mountain, you just jumped off of. So I looked up the data and, you know, one in 2700 jumps is a mortal jump. You die. And a lot of the people doing base jumping realize they will die by base jumping. I was like, why would you do a sport where the end result is your death? That's schmucky. And then I looked up the data about climbing Mount Everest. And I'm like, holy cow, this is the stupidest thing you can possibly do because all comers, the risks of dying on the climbing Mount Everest, it's actually mainly on the descent is one in a hundred, one in a hundred, one in a hundred. And so it's like, why are you doing this for such a high risk of death? And I understand if your focus in life is being a mountaineer and climbing the peaks, but that's a risky, risky activity. And he mentioned being president of the United States. We've had 45 men as president and four have been assassinated in office. Okay, Lincoln, Garfield, McKinley and John F. Kennedy, four out of 45. That's a one in 11 chance of dying way higher than climbing Mount Everest. And it also turns out there were eight assassination attempts, which were quote unquote, I would say successful. So being president is very risky. All right. The first one on your list is social relationships. And I think a lot of people listening will be very surprised that this is basically the top of a list of rules for better health. Can you help us understand? That's what the science says. So, 2500 years ago, Aristotle wrote that man by nature is a social animal. And he knew he understood we're social beings. Our brain is constructed to interact, communicate, collaborate with people. And when I say, you know, so interacting with people, having close friends, spending time with them is the most important thing you can do for your health. They're like, okay, I understand it's psychologically important. Though it's biologically important, what goes on in the brain is actually important for your body. So when you interact with someone, it stimulates oxytocin. That's so called love peptide to go up dopamine. The reward peptide goes up the hypothalamus pituitary access down to the adrenal gland, decreases your stress hormones, some genes, if you're lonely are turned on. They're not good genes, they're for inflammation and reducing your immune response to vaccines and virus exposure. So lots of changes in your body. And there's some recent studies, very interesting studies in our brain stem, right? The lowest, the oldest part of the brain, there seems to be a very close regulation of social time and alone time. And that when you're having social time, you know, that gets stimulated, but you need to balance it with alone time. Not all of us have slightly different balances. Some of us are extroverts. We need more social time. Some of us are introverts. We need more alone time. But this balance is very, turns out to be very, very important for our bodies, happiness and health. And so our entire brain is constructed around social interactions and it does way more for us. We know that if you're lonely, socially isolated, you dramatically increase your risks of mortality. So I think a lot of people listening will say, well, I'm not surprised to hear that social relationships have a lot of impact on feeling happy, right? That seems pretty obvious, I think, to almost anybody. But the fact that it's having these physical effects seems like much harder to believe in your saying at the end, like literally, you will die sooner if you're not having these social relationships. You're not having social relationships. Absolutely. Some of the things of studies that actually look at this, more than 3 million people worldwide have been enrolled in studies about social interaction and longevity. And the socially isolated people who have zero or one friends, don't see friends a lot, those people are much more likely to die in the next few years. So let me give you a study in the United States. We have something called the Health and Retirement Study where we look at people close to retirement, tell them every few years, examine them, talk about their interactions, etc. And in that group, 50 people age 50 and older, the people who are socially isolated or reporting lonely, they have a 25% increase risk of dying over the next eight years. They have a 25% greater risk of dying in the next eight years. This is why I say it's the most important positive rule. So the oldest running study in the world, as far as I can tell, is the Harvard Adult Development Study started in the late 30s, then merged with another study in Boston of less privileged kids. And they follow people over time for 85 years, they've been following people and then the next generation of people. And it turns out the people who lived the longest are people with social interactions who are married and remain married, very, very important. And China has emulated this study with 100,000 people and they check in with them every few years. It turns out people who, as they get old, do margong, have other social interactions, exercise with people, have their family, their kids, their grandchildren come and visit them daily. They live much longer and have fewer health impairments as they live longer lives. So that we know being socially isolated or lonely is the equivalent of smoking 15 cigarettes a day. 15 cigarettes a day. Half a pack. And so do we understand at all what that link is between the social interaction and what's actually physically happening in our body? We don't understand at all. We're beginning to unravel it. In fact, the UK BioBank is one of the big sources, actually, of some of the state of that. If you look at socially isolated people versus people who have a lot of social interaction, like a lot of friends and they see them a lot, that difference. There are about 50 genes that are activated in the socially isolated and are negative. They increase inflammation. They actually suppress your immune response to viruses and vaccines. Increase your risk of cardiovascular disease. The exact pathways have involved and worked out. But again, social interaction is going to stimulate your brain, seeing people, listening to people, talking to people, revealing yourself. I don't know what people think the mind is, but it's between your ears and it's encoded in the interactions between your neurons and those affect the body. We're learning so much more about how that happens. Do we know it perfectly? Absolutely not. But we do know that being socially isolated, being a hermit in Alaska is not good for your health. What does it mean to have this social relationship? Does that mean I need to have a few really, really deep relationships to have any value? What does this really mean? You need a healthy lifestyle. Many of these studies look at close friends. People you talk to every other week, at least every other week. People who have known you a long time so that you can have close interactions. These casual interactions are also important for people. We've got a lot of studies. There's a professor at the University of Chicago, Nick Epley, who's done a lot of these studies of asking people to, you know, on a commute, talk to the person sitting next to you on the train or on the bus. People are, "Tedent to be resistant." It's going to be a waste of time. They're not going to want to talk to me. I'm not going to learn anything. You know, it's just like going to be totally boring. I won't be able to get out of it. All of those are wrong. Just wrong. Turns out, you actually think the time goes faster. You learn something. You are happier at the end of it. All of these things turn out to be interacting with other people is biologically what we're driven for. When you do it, even if you're an introvert, when you act extroverted, you enjoy it more and you feel better. It's things like endorphin release and other positive signs. Don't mean it's a reward. So I think you need both close relationships. People you can talk to intimately. Rob and Dunbar at Oxford has the Dunbar number. Close personal relationships, five to ten, no more. You just don't have enough time and front the low experience. Then you have acquaintances. People you have over for dinner, but you might not reveal intimate mistakes you made or other issues. Then there are people acquaintances you know. You recognize you see them after a number of years, up to 150. And most of us can't have more than that. You just don't have time and be don't have the cognitive capacity to keep track of these people. I love all of that. I think anyone who knows me knows that I'm quite extrovert. So I'm basically miserable if I'm sucking the house on my own little day. I can manage about an hour and a half on this disease cost, which I'm like, you know, I need to get up and like, you know, I'd say, well, we have a recent study and I'll brag because it's my daughter who looked at remote work and people who work at home. She just published it in science. Work at home alone and they can go for several days of not seeing anyone, not going outside, not interacting with people. It turns out that working at home is actually more mental health problems, higher rates of diagnoses, higher use of drugs for mental health problems. So you can be alone, but it ain't good for your mental health and behavioral health. And again, I think people think mental health, well, that's psychological. It's somehow out there in the ether. No, it's in the brain and it affects your body and we know that people who have serious mental health problems and even mild mental health problems anxiety depression don't live as long. Do you know someone who's drive to be healthier has become very focused on supplements and intensive exercise? If so, why not send them this episode? It might reframe their quest for a long healthy life into a much broader perspective. You could add years to their life and a lot more social connection too. I'm sure they'll thank you for it. What would you say to someone who's listening to this who is isolated and you just sort of said, actually, this is really bad for your health. So there's quite a hard message to land. What advice would you give to them? Think about ways you can begin to interact with people. If you can join a book club. If you can join some other, maybe you like singing. Join a choral group. Start taking up a musical instrument or an art class and go to a class where there are other people. Go to a college and take a course or two. Volunteer where you're working with other people. You're interacting with people and you'll regain the social skills. I love that. Let's move on to the third rule which is staying mentally active. What does that mean? We all are cognitively sharp and our cognitive function, our brain power, as it goes down over time. It begins to go down late 30s or early 40s. It's kind of inevitable. What are the things that we can do to postpone the time when? You know, we will have lost so much brain power. We will become cognitively impaired, uh, God forbid, demented. The first thing you can do get more education. If you're listening and you're in your 20s, go back to school. It's really good for your brain. The second thing is there are four vaccines you can get. And I think this is very underappreciated. Four vaccines you can get that are actually good at postponing cognitive decline and dementia. One is the shingles vaccine, amazing vaccine. Uh, you get two shots at 50 and you're really covered for life. It prevents a very painful illness, but it also decreases your chance of cognitive decline by about 20%. The pneumococcal vaccine prevents a pneumonia. Get that Dpt, diphtheria pertussus tetanus vaccine. Get that. And the last one is your annual flu shot. Also, the more you get of them, the less a cognitive or the postponement of cognitive decline. I think people were really surprised to hear you jump from Stain Mentally active and they aren't expecting you to say like do the Sudoku or something. No. And you go on straight to take four vaccines. Could you just help us to understand that for a minute? Yeah. It probably suggests that viruses and the reaction to viruses have a role in cognitive decline and that if you want to prevent cognitive decline. Taking a vaccine that decreases the chance that the viruses in the case of shingles will reactivate or in the case of flu. You'll be infected by a flu is probably a good thing to protect you. We're increasingly learning that vaccines are related to serious illness. We cancer. I'm an oncologist, right. HPV and cervical cancer HPV and oral cancer also, right. That is so we see these vaccines causing serious illness. We now know that Epstein biovibrous causes some cancers and there may be related to other kinds of cancer. So it's not surprising that they're related to, you know, decline or inflammation in the brain that probably leads to cognitive decline in dementia. Then I would say keeping yourself mentally challenged is super important. And especially as you get old and as you retire. So taking up new activities, musical instruments, learning languages and things like that. Really important. I personally about it a little more than a decade ago began a commitment to myself of every year. I'm going to do something new and out of my wheelhouse that's not related to my career or something I've done before. So I began making chocolate about 15 years ago. I collaborate with the chocolate maker learn, you know, I've gone to harvest a cow fermented dry it roasted and do all that stuff. I've now made four bars. Last year I began keeping bees and harvesting honey. So there's a lot of things you can take up. Keep your mind challenged. You know Winston Churchill painting and doing art is a very good one volunteering in school. So you teach kids. One of the most challenging issues is retirement and it's not uncontroversial. But in general, retirement is probably not good for your brain. Going to work has very, very important things you keep a schedule you get up other people are depending upon you. You have challenges at work that you have to navigate and solve. You have a friendship group at work and social interactions that you have. And when you retire, you've got all this free time 40, 50 hours a week. And what are you going to fill it with turns out unfortunately, at least in America. A lot of that times filled with one of the worst passive activities you can do. Watching TV and that actually is not stimulating your brain, not challenging your brain. So you have to consciously plan retirement very, very well to keep the social interactions to keep being challenged to keep the schedule. And I think that's something we don't actually, you know, we worry about should I retire? Will I have enough money? We should worry should I retire? How's it going to affect my cognitive function moving on to number four. And four is all about what you eat. Yeah, we've just talked a lot about that on this podcast. If you're going to say a very simple way sort of your principles for eating well. So the first two we've already stopped with the sodas and stop with the package sweets. The positives go to something that I know this podcast is really focused on, which is gut health. Over the last 10, 15 years, we've become much more appreciative of the microbiome in the body and just for your listeners, there are a hundred trillion bacteria in your gut. That's more cells in your body. By a factor of about three. They're there for a reason. So eating to make sure the microbiome is actually healthy is super important and healthy usually means a good diversity of bacteria there. And so I'm a big proponent. If you do do only two things related to food. One is fermented foods yogurt, cottage cheese, a good alpine cheese is kimchi, sour, crout. Those are really, really important for your gut and eating them is, I think, really important. The second part is those bacteria need fiber to grow. And so you've got to eat more fiber. That fiber is very important for the microbiome and to have more diverse microbiome grow. I don't know the data in Britain, but in the United States, the vast, vast vast majority of people, 93% of people don't get enough fiber. They don't eat enough fruits and vegetables. This is very important for people to add to their. So if you do only four things, those are the four things to do. And then there's many other things we probably all need to reduce the amount of meat protein. We get increase or plan protein is a good idea. Eating organic is good, not because it's got better nutrients, but because the pesticides as I like to say, you know, one of the pesticides, therefore, they're to kill bacteria and other pests, right, when they go into your mouth, they don't stop being pesticides. We don't know what they're doing in the gut. And it's probably not a good idea. Now it costs more. We recognize that. And you might not be able to afford it. But if you can afford it, it's a good thing to do. And I think we should really be pushing our food system in that direction. The fifth one is exercise. So although you were quite tough on exercise, the beginning, it's really made it into the list. And so what do you mean by exercise? Exercise is good. Just being obsessed by it is not good. There are three kinds of exercise. We really all need one is aerobic, getting your heart rate up, getting your breathing rate up. Very, very important for decreasing your risk of cardiovascular disease also happens to make you happy through endorphins. So that's very, very important. And again, we talked about about two and a half hours of vigorous exercise each week. My preferred I used to be a runner, but now I'm a big bicyclist. There are lots of things you can do to fill that you can row, you can swim. You can mountain climb or hike vigorously. The second one is strength training. And this is especially true for your listeners who are over 55 or so, where muscle mass begins to seriously decrease. So we lose about 10% of our muscle mass every decade. That's a challenge. We don't want to do that. We want to keep vigorous. We don't want to bend over. We don't want to not be able to get out of a chair. And there you have the strength training is important. Now if you swim, you know, you get strength training on the upper body. If you ride your bike or run, you get strength training in your lower body, but you need to balance the whole body. And the last one is flexibility and balance every morning. I do 20 minutes of yoga. Really important to keep that flexibility and balance going. And I think the balance and flexibility is interesting because often when I have scientists on the show, they talk a lot about the mix between this sort of strength and aerobic, but they don't necessarily talk about sort of balance. Why did that make it into this list for you? Well, one of the dangers of growing older is fractures and hip fractures and being more balanced and being more flexible is really good at decreasing that risk. It also loosens up the muscles so that you don't get contractures and things like that. And like many things, you can be social about it and you can actually have fun. Wonderful. And finally we come to the sixth and final one, which is sleep. So how much should we be aiming for? So I used to have friends and you probably did to who thought sleep was a waste of time. You know, it's like, what am I doing? I'm just sleeping. The fact that we sleep is the best response to that idea. Again, evolution has this way of getting rid of things which are waste and aren't good and sleep is a really dangerous moment. You're unconscious. All of the predators out there are willing to jump on you. So that we preserve sleep means it's biologically necessary. It's important to clean out your brain. It's important to solidify your memories and move them from the hippocampus to the frontal cortex. It's important for proteins to be rejuvenated. So you need sleep. Now there are some people who are genetically short sleepers. Right. They're 1% of the population. They need four hours. or something. You know, not many people. Yeah, you're right. That's an outlier. You're not an outlier, just the sum your average. Average is somewhere around six and a half to eight hours of sleep a night or nine hours. And that's what's important. Now you also need the right mix of sleep, rapid eye movement, sleep, deep sleep. The problem with sleep is, first of all, we've changed our environment. So it's no longer dark at night. So you got to make your room dark to make it conducive. We have a lot of stimulants, whether it's caffeine or alcohol, you got to stop drinking those, at least eight hours before sleep. There are various other things you can do. You can cool the room, down. Don't look at your screen. Get into a routine of going to bed every night. And that's not possible for all of us. I've just flown to London, right? It's like, well, there's a big time difference between the East Coast and London and you're out of whack. That's right. And you know, it'll take a problem. If you have to stay up late at night, it's important to sleep the next day and get those extra hours. Actually, the body responds to that rebound, sleep positively. It's a good thing. And see, like, how important is sleep really? Because, you know, I feel I hear these two completely conflicting messages, which is one, you know, if you don't get eight hours sleep every night, then, you know, you're going to die decades earlier. It's a worse thing that can possibly happen to you. It's like more important than anything else. And then the other hand, you know, I can think about, probably a bit the way I, you know, when I grew up, my dad's like, well, you know, you should, you could just power through it. Powering through is, that's not right. You become the equivalent of drunk if you lose sleep. And the risks are begin to be high. Your judgment is bad. You take more risks. You're terrible behind a car. So that is wrong. Powering through, yes, maybe if you'll have to power through for one night, all of us have done it, but don't make it a habit and don't create a job that requires it. You do need sleep. Is it the most important thing? No, I've already said social relations are more important than sleep. The challenge with sleep is, first of all, we are doing a bad job of it. Most of us don't get enough. And we can't will ourselves to do it. Well, everything else I've said, you know, social interaction, you can will yourself to talk to people. You can will yourself to take up a new project, new cognitively challenging activity. You can will yourself to get on the bicycle 20 minutes three times a week. You can't will yourself to sleep. It's counterproductive. Willing yourself to sleep will be guaranteed you'll stay awake. So that's the big challenge. And all of the medications made, whether it's ambian or halcyon or melatonin, don't work. So stop taking them, by the way, just they have side effects. And so sleep medication doesn't work. None of them. Okay, I used to take ambian because I wasn't getting enough sleep. What I would find is, you know, I got up in the morning. I was a little groggy. That's exactly what I was trying to get the sleep horse to prevent the groggyness. If I take the medication and I'm groggy, it's counterproductive. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine says the only thing proven is a cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia, figuring out why you're in, you know, you're not sleeping. I know for me, personally, what it happens to be. It happens to be if I've got a, you know, work dilemma or I'm writing something and I'm turning it over in my head, trying to figure out, you know, what do I exactly want to say? What's the right phrasing here? That's what keeps me up at night. And so you have to figure out a method to sort of put that to the side. And that's what cognitive behavioral therapy can help you with. Creating a sort of mini ritual around sleep plan to watch the TV show you like. Then, you know, do your bathroom routine and then get into bed and maybe end by looking at a actual book, a paper and pen book. And I know for myself that that's the routine I've adopted. I get into bed and, you know, sometimes I can read for 10 or 20 pages. Sometimes it's just a few pages. And I know when I'm done, because I've reread that paragraph two or three times and I'm not sure what it says. My eyes are sort of hanging down. It's like, all right, now's the time. But you should know that sleep is, you know, we get the sleep impulse when a dentists scene, a chemical in the brain goes up. And if you go to sleep and then wake up, which some of us do, that a dentist scene is going down. And it gets hard to go back to sleep, which is one reason again, napping can be good for you. Power naps actually are good. But power naps after 2 p.m. or so actually obstruct sleep because you use up that a dentist scene. And, you know, it's hard to get it back to put you to bed. If you were going to advise a listener who isn't doing any of these things and you were going to say, like, what's the one thing that you should focus on and try and do first? What would you tell them? Dinner parties. So you have a dinner party. You cook and you both have good healthy food because you've cooked it and you've challenged your mind because you're adding a new recipe and you're figuring out how to do it right. You have people over. So you've got social connections. You're challenging your mind with a good conversation. And when it's all over, you go out for a walk so you get some physical activity. This is like you've done almost everything in wellness. All of those elements are key to wellness. And it's the kind of thing you can do, you know, once a weekend or and it's you'll be happier. So you can like trying to do a little summary and we've covered a lot. The thing that really sticks in my mind is you're saying don't do 10 hours of vigorous exercise a week. What a waste of time. It's not going to improve your health because actually the data says you need to do about two and a half hours of vigorous exercise a week. And after that, it's sort of the benefit plateau. It stops and some more moderate exercise instead. So that's quite exciting. I love that. The second thing that I've taken away at the end is like have a dinner party. It's like the super activity that solves almost everything that supplements are mainly a waste of money and peptides are worse than that. They could really be dangerous. So don't be a schmuck. Don't don't do that. On alcohol, you're not telling us that we have to give up even if you know, often are, you know, the medical advice we're hearing from governments now is sort of none. But for you, it's like three to four drinks a week. So this is quite a small amount. And then we come onto your six rules. The first is don't be a schmuck. So don't climb Everest. Don't smoke. Don't be president. The second is social relationships. And for you, this is so important. I guess this is the central message that you've shared today. And you talked about in the book. And if I understood this rightly, you said that this research looking at people who are socially isolated over the age of 50 and they have a 25% greater risk of dying in the next eight years. Correct. And so that's an enormous difference from something that sort of seems crazy because it's not like something you're eating or a drug. It's literally just not being with people. And you shared a bunch of tips. But your number one that came in repeated was like join a book club because you managed to not only deal with the social relationship, but also your third rule, which is staying mentally active. And that's really important. Retirement is bad for you because of that. So actually everything that we're sort of like like retire early, I spent a lot of time working in France, you know, a decade ago. And it's like it's the home of retiring early. You're like, no, this is bad for you. But I think the most surprising thing you said is take these four vaccines to reduce the risk of dementia. So actually it's not about reading a book. And I think you said shingles, pneumonia, DPD, and your annual flu shot. And then actually there is hard data that suggests that if you do this, you actually reduce your risk of dementia. I've got that right. Yeah. Which is extraordinary. You're doing well. The fourth is about what you eat. I think anyone who listens to this show regularly won't be surprised, but I think just interesting how much like what you say is sort of in line with I guess sort of this gut health focus that was simply radical, you know, eight years ago. And if you're going to make it really simple, you're saying stop the sodas, reduce the ultra processed food, focus on your gut health. Fifth, we have exercise. So despite the whole book being triggered by like anger about this book about exercise, you are actually saying exercise is important. But it's not like the only thing and it's not it's not number one. And you want to have these balance of these three types of exercise. Aerobic, get your heart rate up. That's really important for your heart health. Strength training, particularly because as you get older, you're losing the muscle mass. And if you want to be able to get out of a chair and like have a good life, you need to have have muscles. And thirdly, really interesting that you want this flexibility and balance because I actually think that's really dangerous. You get older is that you fall and then you break something and then you lose mobility. And I'm sure we all have loved ones where this has happened and it's a really heartbreaking to see. So you're saying think about balance and flexibility early to help protect that. And finally, number six focus on sleep. That does really matter. And it's also the only one wearing a way getting too obsessed by it can make it harder to sleep. And I think lots of people listening to this will experience that. And I think the most, you know, I think this really struck me as you said, is like don't take sleep medicine. So if you're currently taking sleep medicine, stop. You know, the evidence is that it doesn't work. So stop. You can do this cognitive behavioral therapy. And and ultimately this is figuring out how to build routines. and think about this in a better way. But when you look at all of this together, my big takeaway is that for most people, the thing that should really be embracing is these social relationships, because that is probably the thing that if you're obsessing about all of these other ways in improving your health, you're losing this thing that is really good for your health, but also just great for your quality of life. Yeah, you get a start first. I'll end this episode with something I think you'll like, a free Zoe gut health guide. If you're a regular listener, you know just how important it is to take care of your gut. Your gut microbiome is gateway to better health, better sleep, energy and mood, the list just goes on. But many of us aren't sure how to best support our gut. I wasn't sure before doing Zoe, which is why we've developed an easy to follow gut health guide. It's completely free and offers five simple steps to improve your gut health. You'll get tips from Professor Tim Spector, Zoe's scientific co-founder and one of the world's most sighted scientists, plus recipes and shopping lists, straight to your inbox. We'll also send you ongoing gut health and nutrition insights, including how Zoe can help. To get your free Zoe gut health guide, head on over to Zoe.com/GutGuide. Thanks for tuning in and see you next time. [Music]

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The guest, Dr. E.C.L.A., critiques the "wellness industrial complex" for promoting extreme optimization over fundamental health practices.
  2. He was inspired to write his book after being angered by Peter Attia's "Outlive," which he felt ignored the critical role of social relationships in health.
  3. Wellness trends historically resurge during times of societal uncertainty, offering a sense of control.
  4. Maximum longevity is around 120 years, and excessive exercise beyond a plateau (150 minutes vigorous, 300 minutes moderate weekly) yields no longevity benefits and has opportunity costs.
  5. Supplements and peptides are largely unregulated, potentially dangerous, and often waste money.
  6. Alcohol should be limited to 3-4 drinks weekly, used socially, not for coping.
  7. Ultra-processed foods are a major health crisis, driving obesity and cognitive decline; reducing sodas and packaged snacks is key.
  8. The six rules focus on moderation, social connections, and living a meaningful life, not self-denial.

Summary:

In this episode, Dr. " He argues that its obsession with extreme optimization—whether through intense exercise regimens, unregulated supplements, or restrictive diets—is misguided and often harmful. His book was sparked by fury over Peter Attia's "Outlive," which he felt neglected the most vital health factor: social relationships.

He explains that wellness trends historically resurge during turbulent times, offering people a false sense of control. He debunks claims of extended longevity, noting the maximum human lifespan remains around 120 years. He criticizes excessive exercise beyond a certain plateau, highlighting opportunity costs, and warns against risky peptides and supplements.

On alcohol, he advocates moderation—3-4 drinks weekly, used socially—rather than total abstinence, acknowledging its role in social bonding. He identifies ultra-processed foods as a major driver of obesity and cognitive decline, urging reductions in sodas and packaged snacks. Ultimately, his six rules emphasize balance, social connections, and living a meaningful life, arguing wellness should be a means to an end, not the end itself.

He stresses that sustainable health comes from moderation, not self-denial, and that simple, inexpensive fundamentals—like nurturing relationships—are more impactful than any complex optimization strategy.

FAQs

The podcast discusses six rules for good health, but the specific rules are not listed in the transcription. The focus is on fundamentals like social relationships, moderation, and avoiding extremes.

He wrote it out of anger after reading Peter Attia's 'Outlive,' which he felt ignored the importance of social relationships for wellness, focusing instead on exercise, food, and sleep.

Yes, the guest states that loneliness is worse for your health than smoking tobacco.

It's a term used to describe the industry that sells wellness products and routines, which the guest argues often promotes obsession, self-denial, and extreme practices that aren't biologically sustainable.

He recommends about 150 minutes of vigorous exercise or 300 minutes of moderate exercise per week, noting that beyond this, there's no additional longevity benefit.

Peptides can be dangerous because they are often unstudied, potentially contaminated, and may have unknown side effects, especially when taken in combinations from unregulated sources.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.