Go back

That Feeling of "Always-Behind and Never-Enough"—Here's the Antidote | Ellen Hendriksen

1h 5m 39s

That Feeling of "Always-Behind and Never-Enough"—Here's the Antidote | Ellen Hendriksen

Perfectionism is not about achieving flawlessness, but rather a deep-seated fear of inadequacy that drives people to equate their self-worth with performance. According to clinical psychologist Ellen Hendrickson, this mindset is a misnomer—what people truly struggle with is never feeling "enough." Rooted in both genetics and environment, perfectionism thrives in competitive, performance-oriented cultures and often manifests physically through chronic stress or pain. It is strongly linked to anxiety disorders such as OCD and eating disorders, where self-evaluation is tied to performance. Perfectionism stems from a flawed belief that one must perform flawlessly to be accepted or loved, leading to emotional isolation and self-criticism. However, healthy perfectionism—driven by conscientiousness and high standards—differs from maladaptive forms that equate self-worth with outcomes. The solution lies in shifting from rigid rules to flexible, value-based living, embracing mistakes, and cultivating self-compassion through kindness and actions. Key strategies include replacing self-criticism with self-compassion, moving from performance to authenticity, and rejecting social comparison in favor of contentment. Most importantly, true connection comes not from impressing others but from showing up as one’s authentic self, prioritizing warmth and emotional presence over performance. This shift allows individuals to live more freely, feel more connected, and finally experience a sense of sufficiency without constant striving.

Transcription

10886 Words, 60616 Characters

English
Hey, hey, welcome to the 10% happier podcast on your host, Dan Harris. Perfectionism really can be the ultimate head fuck. You know what's driving you crazy, that feeling of always behind and never enough, but you tell yourself you need this relentless self-criticism in order to succeed. That anything less would be an unacceptable, even dangerous lowering of your standards. All lies, according to my guests today. Ellen Hendrickson is a clinical psychologist at Boston University's Center for Anxiety and Related Disorders. Her latest book is called How to Be Enough Self-Exceptance for Self-Critics. She first appeared on this podcast to discuss said book back in 2025, but we're bringing in the episode back because it was a staff favorite. I should also add that this was her second appearance on the podcast she had come on several years earlier to discuss her first book about social anxiety called How to Be Yourself. You can find more from Ellen on substack. Her newsletter is called How to Be Good to Yourself When You're Hard On Yourself. In this conversation, we talk about the relationship between perfectionism and anxiety. The definition of perfectionism and why the word itself is actually a misnomer. Dr. Hendrickson's own struggles with perfectionism and how they manifested physically, quite significantly, the difference between adaptive or healthy perfectionism and maladaptive perfectionism, how to change your relationship, your inner critic, how to shift from rigid rules to flexibility, how to keep high standards while making room for mistakes, how to overcome procrastination, navigating social comparison, and much more. It's a rich conversation. A few things before we hear from our sponsors, I highly recommend that you head on over to Dan Harris.com to check out my new ish meditation app 10% with Dan Harris. Right now we're in the middle of this really cool series where every Sunday, the legendary Dharma teacher Sharon Salzberg is leading a live session where she does some teachings on the Buddha's eightfold path. You can think of the eightfold path as the Buddha's foundational list. It's his cookbook for leading a happy life. Sharon does some teaching on one aspect of the path. She guides a meditation and then she takes your questions or in the middle of it right now, but it's not too late to join you can sign up at Dan Harris.com and you can watch the first few sessions on video replay and then join the rest of them live. It's really cool. One of the keys, I believe, and this is an evidence-based assertion, one of the keys to starting a habit or maintaining a habit like meditation is doing it with other people. And that's what we're doing over on 10% with Dan Harris. If it's better in the carpool lane, join the party, we'll get started with Ellen Hendrickson right after this. Dr. Ellen Hendrickson, welcome back to the show. Thank you so much. I'm excited to be back. Excited to have you back. All right. So tell me how this latest book came about because the last time you're on the show we're talking about social anxiety, this book is related but quite distinct related in some ways to anxiety, but quite distinct from social anxiety. I suspect this, and I'd love to hear this story if you're comfortable telling it, I suspect this book has its roots in your own struggles with perfectionism. How did you guess? Yes. I write about my own problems. Oh, yeah. Well, and there are enough people out there I've realized with the exact same problem so that it forms an audience in there for a community. So yeah, for sure. You're absolutely right. Yeah, social anxiety and perfectionism are at the very least siblings or to change the metaphor. If we drill down on social anxiety, we find a foundation of perfectionism because they're both based on the same flawed perception of self, the felt sense of inadequacy that keeps us separated from others. And in both, we have to work or rethink. We have to work hard to avoid fighting ourselves in a situation that would reveal that inadequacy to others. So we need to either hide or avoid or over compensate. But regardless of whether it's social anxiety, perfectionism that hiding and concealing and overcompensating backfires because that steals the credit for keeping us safe. And in both, we think we have to perform as superbly as possible for people to like us. Right. So that's the connection. And then you asked personally about perfectionism. And yeah, for sure. So let me back up and give a definition of perfectionism. I find it highly ironic that perfectionism researchers can't agree on a perfect definition of perfectionism. And so the one that I like is that it's demanding of ourselves a level of performance higher than is required for the situation. And I like that because you can look at it two ways, you can look at it as like that's quite healthy. Please keep doing that. You know, shoot for the stars. Do more than the bare minimum, you know, research shows that setting goals and striving to achieve them confers all sorts of cool things like mastery and purpose. So like, yeah, please demand of yourself a level of performance higher than what is required for the situation. However, where it tips over into less healthy mindsets and behaviors is when we start to equate our performance with our character, we look to answer that universal, very human question of like, am I okay, am I good enough by looking at how well we do things, like looking at our performance? For me, for too much of my life, I held that classic mindset of making my self-evaluation, my self-worth overly dependent on meeting my personally demanding standards that I set for myself. So high school and college probably put too much stock in grades. When I was a young adult and social life is very important, I probably put too much stock in social behavior when I was launching my career and like a young mom, the measure was productivity. And so not only was I conflating what I did with who I was, but I also did three things that made my life harder. The specifics gets into the universal because this is what we all do when we start to conflate who we are with our performance. One is that I would focus on flaws and details. For example, in my social behavior era, if there was an awkward silence on a date or like I told a joke, no one seemed to get even if everything else went well, that details what I would think about afterwards. I would do the equivalent of focusing on the one frowning face in the crowd of smiles. Two, I would give myself only two options, all or nothing for evaluating outcomes. Let's look at grades. I was aiming for straight A's and I got that except for 189, that disqualified all the other A's and shunted me from all to nothing. So I gave myself this very narrow criteria for success and a very wide gulf for if we're defining failure as not meeting expectations for failure. When I was looking at productivity too closely, if there were a couple of things on the to-do list that went undone, like that wasn't good enough. And then the third thing I did is that I was hurt on myself. And so when we fall short of our personal and demanding standards, we will often self-criticize. But this is, I find ironic, if we somehow pull out all the stops and meet our personal and demanding standards, we decide those standards were insufficiently demanding in the first place and move the gulf host. So that's me. So again, I wrote this book for myself, but I also wrote it for everyone else. I think there's a silent epidemic of perfectionism happening and as a clinical psychologist at an anxiety specialty center, the vast majority of my clients have perfectionism at the center of their challenges. But no one has ever come in and said, "Oh, and I'm a perfectionist. I need help with perfectionism." No one ever says that. What they say is things like, I feel like I'm failing or I feel like I'm falling behind. I'm not reaching my potential. I have so many things in my plate and I'm not doing any of them well. We all say things like that. That's because perfectionism is a little bit of a misnomer. It's really not about striving to be perfect. It's about never feeling good enough. And that's something that a lot of us can relate to, especially in 2025. Well, let's just pause on that for a second. I hate when people do this to me, but I'm going to ask you to say that again because I think it's worth dwelling on. Miningism as a word is a bit of a misnomer when applied to the actual condition. Yes. Because the mindset through my own experience and observing that of clients and the research shows that it is less about striving to be perfect and more about never feeling good enough. We think we have to perform as superbly as possible to be sufficient as a person. So it's not actually about nailing it. It may manifest as a desire for the perfect outcome of whatever you're doing. But the underlying issue is not enoughness. Correct. Yes. And we often think about perfectionism as like a personality profile. Like sort of type a picky detail oriented and it can be that. But again, that heart of it is conflating our self-evaluation with our performance. And it can be about anything, like I talked about grades and social behavior and productivity, but it could be our work evaluation, our weight, our bank account, our last musical or athletic performance or even more subtle things like, "Did I stick to healthy eating today? Was I a good parent today? Did I meditate? Did I do it well enough? Did I get distracted?" You know, it's anything where we think we have to perform as separately as possible to be sufficient, to be enough. Sixteen years of meditation and you're describing my inner dialogue to this day, although I will say that I catch myself much more rapidly and much more kind to myself in a million different ways, but the conditioning remains because it is so, so deeply ingrained, culturally and historically. The question that comes screaming out of this conversation is, well, how do we address that insufficiency? And we will get to that. But I do want to stay on perfectionism for a second. And specifically on your perfectionism, because if memory serves, it manifested physically for you? Yeah. So when I was researching this book, I came across a paper, and I'm going to mangle this title, but it was something like perfectionist at 20 work-life balance issues at 40. And I was like, "Oh, these people have been in my house. What is this?" So, yeah, for me, I think I had been grinding for so long, basically, and this is a tangent. Sorry, that you use the word culture, that our culture rewards in an ever more competitive ratings-oriented optimization focus culture. It makes sense that we respond by feeling like we're never doing enough, aren't good enough. So I've been grinding for a long time, and yeah, around 40, it really started to manifest in my body. And I went through like a number of rounds of physical therapy. I woke up one morning. I couldn't turn my head to the right, because my muscles were too tight. I had blown out my forearm from typing too much. I got a GI illness. So yeah, it absolutely manifested physically, and I had already kind of known this wasn't sustainable, but that really drove that message home. That's something needed to change. So it manifested physically for you. That makes sense for me, just to me, because I've had so many of my psychological ailments manifest physically. It's like there's a mind-body connection or something. Alan Langer would say it's mind-body unity. It's not even a connection. It's the same thing. I want to pick up on something that's related to this, and also that it's a breadcrumb you dropped several paragraphs ago, where in your work at a center that specializes in anxiety and related disorders, your sense is that perfectionism is at the root of, and I believe you write about this in your book, it's at the root of, or at least linked to obsessive-compulsive disorder and eating disorders. Can you say a little bit more about this? Yeah, absolutely. So perfectionism is not a disorder in and of itself. It's not diagnosable. It's more of a mindset or a trait, but it definitely lies at the heart of other diagnosable disorders, like social anxiety or OCD eating disorders, some kind of treatment-resistant anxiety. Sometimes we will worry ourselves into a depression because of perfectionism. Yeah, the heart is that we have to perform as superbly as we can. And so in eating disorders, it's either on body, weight, or shape, or on feeling in control when we eat. In social anxiety, it's that idea that there's kind of a fatal flaw about us, and it will be revealed unless we work really hard to conceal it. We have to perform correctly, socially, and not make mistakes. So it's at the heart of a lot of what we do. The number of clients I have who are struggling with perfectionism, if you line up 100 different people, you will see 100 different phenotypes of perfectionism. I work with a musician, a stay-at-home mom, an academic, a neuroscientist, like there's just all sorts of varieties of people who are making their performance of referendum on their character. Performance of referendum on your character. I suspect many heads are nodding asynchronously as people consume this podcast. Where does this come from? Do we evolve for perfectionism or is that a more modern development? Okay, it definitely comes from both within and from all around us, which I think is really interesting. It has been shown to be genetic. Again, even though it's not diagnosable, it definitely runs in families. Then speaking of families, it can be conferred upon us from certainly any kind of family, but there are a number of different styles of parenting that have been identified as making it more likely that will come out perfectionistic. That is, if we are from a family that's perfectionistic itself. If we're from helicopter, snow, plow, family, where caution and avoiding risk and mistakes is really important. If we're from a family that conferred a lot of contingent approval or love sort of got confused with pride, we got attention and positive regard when we accomplished things. Then fourth is if our family was chaotic or dramatic or radical abusive, when that's where kids will often find safety and control through their performance. If I can't control dad's drinking, at least I can control my grades. If I can't control mom getting angry, I can be charismatic and be the most popular kid in school. So definitely there's some that comes from within, but it also comes from all around us from the environment. I would argue from 2025 because every human reacts to the situations we're put in and so in a society that really is getting more demanding, competitive, performance oriented due to capitalism competition, advertising, social media, you name it. All these messages are coming at us saying that we have to perform and consume and achieve to ever higher levels to be sufficient as a person. The researcher Andrew Hill says that perfectionistic climates turn us all into perfectionists. I certainly agree. Just to go back to evolution, would it be safe to say, and this is kind of just a surmise on my end after having listened to you, that there may be aspects of the human mind dating back to our origins that predispose us toward this trait, but that latent potential has been put on steroids because of how culture has evolved. Yeah, I'll surmise along with you for sure. So perfectionism, we usually think of it as a personal problem, but it's really an inter-personal problem and we can talk more about that later, but my point is that perfectionism is inter-personally motivated. We do it to try to stay in others good graces, to try not to get criticized or rejected or judged, and so, again, we're doing things as well as possible to try to keep criticism and judgment at bay, and ultimately it's because we want to connect with people, and so I think evolutionarily, yeah, we learned to perform as well as possible because we thought that it kept the group together, kept it going, helped us get along harmoniously with everybody else. That is my surmising. Yeah, it makes a complete sense based on the very limited understanding I have of how we evolved. I mean, it all whittles down to love and safety. Absolutely. Yeah, but I think the thing that we get confused when we double down on performance is that admiration and being impressive is different fundamentally from being accepted or belonging. Again, pride and love are different. Yes, yes, and the persona, which is actually probably a kind of form of armor that we create in order to get what we think is love, but is actually admiration. Paradoxically and maddeningly gets us further away from what our underlying goal is. We can end right now. That is the message for sure. Because the wall that we put up to try to protect ourselves from criticism and judgment acts as a wall that separates us from others. So we end up being on this pedestal, but that means we're alone. When we're singular, we're separate. It's ironic that we are doing this to try to gain connection, love, belonging, and we end up with sort of an ersatz version of that admiration, approval, compliments, but those are fundamentally different. And I would just add to that even if you're not getting the approval and you're still a perfectionist because I think that describes many of us. I've been a failed perfectionist in many areas of my life. I'm not getting what I hope for, and I'm kicking my own ass, the compulsive, reflexive, persistent self-evaluation removes you from the world, makes you less available, less authentic, and widens the gulf between you and what you actually want, whether you are singular or not in your achievements. Yeah, for sure. I mean, we don't see the world as it is, right? We see the world as we are. And so if we're holding ourselves to personally demanding standards, we assume other people are holding us to those same standards. But that's not what relationships and connecting are about. Think about why your friends are your friends. Are you friends with your friends because they're good at things because they meet personal demanding standards and metrics. Like they're good at public speaking or they always pick a good restaurant or they're good at meditating. You know, probably not. Like I'm guessing your friends with your friends because of how you feel when you're together. You feel supported, understood. Like you can be yourself and that you don't have to perform at all. Like that's that difference. Real friends. Yes. Real friends. Right. Not connections or networks. Yeah. Right. Exactly. I can't remember who said this, but it's something like people never remember what you say. They remember how you made them feel. Yes. So the internet taught me that that's a myangelo quote, but the internet is often wrong. So I can be wrong in that. But she said so many brilliant things. The odds are pretty high. That's true. All right. There's a term you're using the book. The many salads of perfectionism. Have you heard from sweet greens, lawyers? And what do you mean by this? Sure. Okay. What I mean by a salad of perfectionism is that it's this tortured metaphor where there are a million different salads out there like things as different as tabooly and niswa salad and jello salad are all salads. So there's all these different phenotypes. Likewise, as I alluded to before, you line up 100 different people with perfectionism and you have 100 different phenotypes. There's infinite ways of being perfectionistic. So again, it could be about how much money you're bringing in. It could be about how healthy you ate today. It could be whether or not you yield your kids at so many different ways. But the definition of a salad is that it's a variety of ingredients bonded by a common dressing. So there are some commonalities in perfectionism. Most people will be sort of allergic to mistakes. I say that we have sort of a peanut allergy to mistakes. And if you make a mistake, there's a big reaction. We often procrastinate. We often compare ourselves to others. We do this thing called perfectionistic self-presentation where we show the world what's going well. And we sort of hide what's not going so well. Colloquially, this is called duck syndrome. It's where we look like we're gliding effortlessly across the surface. But really there are little duck feet are working really, really hard underneath the surface. So there are a number of things that bind people with perfectionism even as we all look very, very different. That lands. That makes complete sense. As promised, we are soon going to get to like how does one address the root causes here? The sense of interventions. We're just staying at a higher level for a second. There's a lingering question that I suspect some listeners are gnawing at in their minds, which is isn't there a case for perfectionism and high standards sometimes. And I believe you even say in the book, there's a difference between adaptive and maladaptive perfectionism. Yeah, don't for sure. Okay. It's like again, some research would disagree with me. But others would totally agree with me that there is such a thing as healthy perfectionism. And that's when we strive for excellence. We do good work for the work sake. We set high standards. We care deeply. In fact, the healthy heart of perfectionism is a personality trait called conscientiousness, which comes from the root word conscious or conscience, our sense of right and wrong. Essentially conscientiousness is according to research, including by the psychologist Dr. Angela Duckworth, who's better known for her work on grit. Conscientiousness is the number one trait for a good life both subjectively and objectively. So if you got to choose a personality, conscientiousness is the one to choose. And sometimes that does overgrow into perfectionism. We have self-control that sometimes gets a little out of control. But yes, it can absolutely be healthy and at its heart means well and can do great things. So how do we walk the line between adaptive and maladaptive perfectionism? So we can't entirely separate out ourselves from our performance. Nor would we want to. Of course, we're going to feel proud when we do something well. Of course, we're going to be bummed or disappointed when things go wrong. But I think we can try to separate them out a little bit and be able to gain some distance and perspective. There's a difference between our self-worth and our performance. The technical name for this is over-evaluation. Our evaluation of our work gets overgrown and becomes an evaluation of ourselves. So one of the things we can do is we can try to shift from evaluation to information to make it about the work, not about you. So we could take the stance of like a sculptor eye in a block of marble or like a chef tasting a dish. We inherently know that the sculptor and the sculpture are different. The chef and the dish are different. All right, I'm going to mix my metaphors. Our attention is like a spotlight and we get to choose where to point it. If we point it at the work, whatever it is we're trying to do, we generally feel better and perform better. If we point it at ourselves, we generally feel worse and perform worse. And so I'll tell you a story from the book to illustrate this. I tell the story of Kribe Abdul-Jabbar and his time at UCLA under the legendary basketball coach, John Wooden. During his time there or around that time, the UCLA basketball team was just a powerhouse and had seven in a row national titles. It was incredible. All under coach Wooden. And so two education researchers, doctors, Roland Tharp and Roland Gallemore decided to sit in the stands for every single practice of the 74-75 season to see like, what is the secret sauce? How does coach Wooden do this? And what they discovered is that he very seldom praised or criticized his players. That instead, he would focus on the work. He would tell them what to do and how to do it. So he wouldn't say things like good job or no, like you staying, you have to practice more. He would say, pass from the chest. Take lots of shots where you might get them in games. Pass the ball to someone short. He would give you information as opposed to evaluation. And that shift from yourself to the work seems subtle but makes a big difference. So do you never want to say to yourself, good job? No, no, no. Again, there are degrees of this for sure. We can certainly be proud of what we do, but we're trying to get some perspective and get some distance that we are not our work. We are not our performance that those two things can be related, but not. If you picture a van diagram, we want it to not be completely overlapping, which is what I will often see when folks come into the clinic. So we worked to try to crank them apart just a little bit. And that, okay, here, this is another quick story. A potential client emailed me and say, hey, I'd like to work on perfectionism. I said, cool, come on in and we set up an intake. And the day before she emailed me again and she said, you know, I have given this some thought. And I want to wait until I have lots of time and can put lots of energy and effort until like fighting this problem. But I said to her and what I would say to listeners here by be, you know, nodding, is that to your question, you don't have to separate out worth and performance or never say, good job. Just like a 5% difference, a 10% difference. That's really all you need. It's not this complete cleaving of a worth and performance. Coming up, Ellen talks about the 7C shifts for addressing the underlying causes of perfectionism. Well, you've brought us to the practical, which I've been promising for a while. And the book consists of 7 different shifts we can make to help us address what you're calling, and I'm sympathetic to your argument, what you're calling the underlying root cause of perfectionism, which is a sense of not enoughness in sufficiency. So shift number one is from self-criticism to kindness. My goal for the rest of the interview is to kind of just go through as many of these shifts as we can cover. The first one is from self-criticism to kindness. Can you, I suspect we may have already covered some of this, but can you hold forth on that one? Yeah, for sure. Let me just normalize things also that everybody criticizes themselves from time to time. Self-criticism is the core of human ability to self-regulate. A healthy dose of self-judgment helps us evaluate or behavior, modify it to improve ourselves, like get along more harmoniously with our fellow humans. Evolutionarily, we critique ourselves to better ourselves. So some self-criticism is going to happen, but perfectionistic self-criticism is particularly harsh and particularly personalistic. It's about us. I have found that as an anxiety therapist, I have two levers I can pull. I can pull change or acceptance. We could change self-criticism and we can, but I've gotten a lot farther with folks by trying to change their relationship to self-criticism. What I mean by that, actually, here, this is a good story. Many years ago, I was on your show and I was there as a first-time author. author, this was the biggest show I had ever been on to date, and I was quite anxious. We recorded, and you asked such good questions, and we're so kind. And along the way, I made a totally reasonable number of mistakes. I think I lost my train of thought at one point. I think I stumbled over my words a couple of times. At one point, I actually remember thinking that I had offended you. And so, after recording, despite you and your producer and everyone just being so nice and so complimentary, like that's all I could think about. All I could think about was like the errors. And so I was just kicking myself on the way out the door, and my poor editor who had come with me steered me into the nearest bar and bought me a gin and tonic, ostensibly to celebrate. But I think he knew that my self-criticism had really started going. And so I have now fast-forward seven years done this enough, like something with a microphone or put my work out into the world enough that I know this is just kind of what happens. That I will do something with a microphone, and then my brain will just start to zero in on the mistakes or the details or the things that went wrong, and we'll focus on that. But rather than trying to not think about that, or like let me reframe this, which you absolutely can't work, I have tried to change my relationship to the self-criticism and think, you know, this is just how I'm wired. This is what happens when I do something involving a microphone. And it's just part of the script, kind of like, you know, I go to a restaurant, the hostess seats me, the waiter comes, I order, the food comes, I eat, I pay, I leave. Okay, that's just the script. When I do something, a podcast recording, part of the script is that I record, I leave, I think it stinks, I think about all the mistakes I made, and then usually it's fine. And if it's not fine, either I can learn from that, or sometimes things just don't go well. And that's okay. And I know that other people have their own version of this, like my partner, whenever he gives a PowerPoint presentation, comes home and thinks it sucks, and we'll think of all the mistakes he made. And we've learned, this is just how it goes. This is just part of the script. And so by taking the stance of kind of listening to myself criticism, like the music at a coffee shop, that is made all the difference. It's there. My brain is still making those thoughts. I can hear it, but I don't have to sing along. I don't have to take myself criticism seriously, or literally it can just happen, and I can change my relationship to it. I'm really interested in this dialectic change, I don't know if I'm using that word correctly, but change and acceptance, the argument you just made for acceptance completely lands for me. And as you were talking, I was thinking about the work of both Kristen Neff and Ethan Cross, both of whom have been on the show, I'll put some links in the show notes. They both talk a lot about rewiring your own inner chatter, so it would be less on the acceptance side, although they're both pro-acceptance, but more their emphasis is more on the change side that you can learn, anybody can, without massive meditation interventions or anything like that, learn how to just develop the habit of talking to yourself kindly, and it doesn't have to be cheesy, well, it can be cheesy, but it doesn't have to be unrealistic affirmations pretending that you're perfect or being in denial, et cetera, et cetera. It's more like the way a good coach talks to their players. And so I'm just curious, what's your take on the, we've talked about acceptance, but what about on the change side here as it becomes to the inner critic? Man, you teed me up, just right. That was great. Okay. So, yeah, absolutely. No, I love Kristen Neff. Her work actually helped me understand perfectionism because she says that self-compassion consists of three things, of self-kindness, of non-judgmental mindfulness, and connection to the larger human experience. But the perfectionistic brain is reverse-threaded for all three of those things. So instead of self-kindness, we're wired to be self-critical, instead of non-judgmental mindfulness, we can be judgmental, you know, we zero in on flaws. And instead of connecting to the larger human experience, we see our struggles or mistakes or shortcomings as things that set us apart rather than as common experiences that connect us to others. That is not carved into a stone tablet, like we can absolutely change all of those things, but just our starting point is kind of becoming an inside a hole, basically. And so, I was taught the Kristen Neff method that self-compassion was talking to yourself like a good friend, or yet talking to yourself like a coach. But my perfectionist brain thought that that meant that I had to generate a steady stream of articulate and effective self-compassionate hype. And that was too high a bar. So, in pulling the change lever, I learned, oh my gosh, Ellen, you don't have to make it that complicated, that it can be one word. It can be easy or two words, you're okay, or something way less self-compassion presidential speech writing, ask. But in addition to words, again, pulling that change lever, I learned that self-compassion can also be actions. And for me, at least that was a lot easier, because I feel like it is hard to control our thoughts, like don't think about a cheeseburger floating above my head. It is hard to control our feelings, you know, if you've ever been told calm down or just relax or cheer up, you know, you probably wanted to punch the person to the face that you can't just change your emotion. But you can, and when I say you, I mean everybody, we can control our actions. So self-compassion can be turning towards our pain and suffering and asking what do I need? And so it could be something as simple as taking a few more minutes under the warm shower on a cold morning. It could be, I did this yesterday, I made myself go to the gym even though I didn't want to, because I knew, I just know from experience that it'll make me feel better, but it can also be giving our self permission not to do everything we expect of ourselves. It could be deciding to skip the gym, because what we really need is an extra hour of sleep. All in all, self-compassion can be words and can be actions, which was really helpful for me. And it's turning towards our pain and suffering and asking, what do I need with Karen understanding? Chris Gurmer, Kristen Neff's longtime research partner and pal said here on the show that the preeminent question of self-compassion is, what do I need right now? And so we meant everything you just said, shift number two. So just to reset, we're talking about perfectionism, Ellen's thesis is that what lies beneath perfectionism is a sense of insufficiency. And so, like, how do you start to feel like enough while there are these seven shifts that she's going to propose in the course of her book, which you should read? We talked about the first one, which is from self-criticism to kindness. Number two is coming home to your life, what do you mean by that? So with the coming home to your life, essentially, what I mean is that perfectionism drives us to focus on performance, to focus on being good at things. And I posed the question of essentially, let's change the yardstick rather than measuring ourselves by, did I do the thing? Let's switch over and ask a completely different question, which is, am I living the life I want to live? Am I being the person I want to be? And so, that implies that that takes us from a lower power position where we have to do the thing and are, you know, every performance is a referendum on our character. So our worth is never a settled question. To being able to choose and we'll get into this later, but based on our freely chosen values, what do I want to do? What is meaningful, important, purposeful fun for me? And if I could choose how to live my life and what to do next, what would I do? And surprise, we can, you know, within our context, we can do that. That's essentially, in a nutshell, what I mean by coming home to your life. Just trying to think this through as it would apply to me. So I could be obsessed with being a successful, and that's a goalpost that always moves, writer and podcaster, and that would be a label. Or I could be more focused on healing closely to my underlying values, which would be cultivating positive relationships in every aspect of my life. And the latter is much, confers much more agency. Amazing. Yes. That's under being, quote unquote, like successful podcaster and writer is that you're helping people is that building a community is that serving others like those sound like values. And as long as those feel freely chosen and not like a new rule, then, yeah, absolutely. You're running in the direction of values as opposed to trying to stick to some rule or some label. Right. It freely chosen seems important also because depending on what your chromosomal structure or pigmentation is society can impose upon you values that may not be your own. Yeah. For sure. In the book, yeah, I tried to make a distinction that folks from sexual or racial gender minorities, there's another layer because again, yeah, all humans react to the situation we're put in. So in a society or an institution or a workplace that overtly or covertly tells us you don't belong. here you don't deserve to be here, then that resulting urge to prove ourselves, you know, to earn our way into the group is no longer a personality trait, but like an understandable reaction. An example I give, so Dr. Gary Mitchell from Duke Research's College Prep Programs designed to launch, you know, high achieving black and brown kids into impressive career trajectories. And he finds that at some of these schools, the kids in the college prep programs may be subject to higher standards of behavior of, you know, academics, then kids from say like legacy or like donor families, perfectionism can be institutionalized even, and there can be higher expectations for certain folks. And so one solution there is representation, you know, when everybody belongs, it lessens that external pull to prove that you belong. And so you can spend less of your bandwidth proving you belong by doing excellent work. And instead, you can just simply do your excellent work. And then you know, another solution is community. And so Dr. Mitchell calls this a thick sense of cohort. And that assures us that we're not alone. So there can be a very real pull to prove ourselves. And then yeah, that is conferred by the environment, for sure. Shift number three, you nodded to this a little bit earlier, is from rules to flexibility, say more. Yeah. Okay. So we alluded to rules a little bit like, okay, I got to be a successful podcaster and writer. We all have rules. And especially like those of us with perfectionism, we want to know the rules so we can follow them. And like ironically, if there are no rules, we set up personally demanding rules and then we follow those. So you know, think about making up rules for healthy eating or making up rules for like, I don't know, training for a 5k or something, studying for your not a chemistry exam. Like it's not that rules are bad. It's when three different things happen that they start to get in our way. So one is when our rules become rigid, we apply them no matter the situation. So like we try to follow the diet, even on Thanksgiving, then we're getting ourselves into some questionable territory. Two, the rules are all or nothing. If we follow the rules acceptably, we're acceptable. If we mess up, then it renders us unacceptable. I ate a cookie, so like that ruins my entire healthy eating for the day and I'm bad. And then three is when we start to impose our rules on other people. It can get in the way of our relationship. For example, I'm sure I have the right way to load the dishwasher, but if I try to impose that on my other family members, then you know, it's going to cause some commotion. The dishwasher just always comes up. That's the classic example. So the shift is trying to shift from following the rules. Did I do the thing to values, which we alluded to before? And I want to take just a minute to define values because it's a word that gets thrown around a lot. So I'm going to give you the definition that some Mike Tuhig and Clarissa Ong who wrote an excellent book called The Anxious Perfectionist defined values as having four qualities and I think the fourth one is the most important. So one is values continuous. So you're never done done, you know, living a value. So a value is different than a goal. It's like making a million dollars is not a value that's a goal, but like financial security or a wealth or whatever that could be considered a value you're never done. Values are intrinsically meaningful, meaning you'd care about it even if no one else knew. So like getting famous isn't a value, but like putting in the work and putting good work out into the world is values are under your control, meaning they're not contingent upon anyone else. So like being loved isn't a value, but being loving is. And the fourth one, again, this is the one I think is most important and we've already used these words, but it's they're freely chosen. Values are never coercive or obligatory. So you freely choose to follow them and you're probably even likely to be willing to tolerate some discomfort or inconvenience to do so. So it's like the value of sustainability or like giving back might be why you're willing to give up your Saturday morning to go volunteer to pick up trash on the beach rather than spending that same morning like relaxing at the beach. And in perfectionism, the thing that I feel like we need to watch out for is that oftentimes rules were sort of masquerade as values or values will function as rules. That sense of it being freely chosen is what differentiates them. So the example I always like to use is I had a client who said through a combination of God and my mother, I was taught to be generous. But she said that that meant if somebody on the street asked her for a dollar or a neighbor asked her to babysit, she had to do it. It was the very opposite of the spirit of generosity because it was obligatory and coercive, the sense of I have to. That's what I have clients and folks watch out for is does this feel obligatory or does this feel freely chosen if it's freely chosen as functioning as a value? This is a very long answer, but when we stop living by only rules and shift over to values, we might not even do anything particularly differently. So for instance, I had a client who was very concerned about being a good friend amongst other things, there are things she had to do. If she was going to be a good friend, she has to remember her friend's birthday, she has to ask them detailed questions about their life. Like if they go for a walk together, she's going to surprise them with their favorite coffee order. None of these things are bad. They're lovely. Please keep doing them. But it's that sense of have to, it's that sense of coercion, like the duty, the obligation behind it that can make that friendship feel like a people pleasing grind. So she, this client, she tried to shift to a value of being supportive, being attentive. And then she was freely choosing to remember their birthday, ask them detailed questions about their life, maybe surprise them with their favorite coffee order, but the quality of the experience changed. It felt like a want rather than a should and that made all the difference. Let's just go back to the cookie for a second, because I think that's probably deeply resonant for a lot of people and it describes me and thankfully not anymore, although occasionally. But you were using the example of I have these food rules, I slipped up and ate a cookie and the whole day is out the window and I'm a bad boy, smack me on the snout. If I'm understanding this heuristic of, you know, moving from rules to flexibility, it's like, yeah, I can have cookies once in a while. My value is to take care of my body, to be as healthy as I can, but not miserable. Sometimes some cookies, that's what's called for. By stating the spirit of this correctly. 100%. Yeah. For sure. So are we getting into mistakes now? Oh, sure. Let's do that. So that is shift number four, which is mistakes, mistakes, colon from holding on to letting go. Sure. When we're over identified with our performance, whether that's, yeah, healthy eating or productivity, social behavior, et cetera, et cetera, good parenting, whatever it is, there's no room for mistakes because then it reflects on us personally. I have a shout from the rooftops, rant, where, okay, so I think the conventional advice about perfectionism is you have to lower your standards or you have to stop when things are good enough. And that doesn't go over well with people with perfectionism. If we're still working on separating out our worth from our performance, settling for subpar or mediocre performance means we're subpar or mediocre and we're not going to do that. So I think semantics are important. Keep your high standards. The high standards are not the problem. What I try to focus on is to make some room for mistakes. That's different than lowering our standards. And so I've told the story before but I think it bears repeating. I was working with a pediatrician and she had been a pediatrician for 25 years, you know, long story career. She came in one week and was just beside herself because she had misdiagnosed a little girl who came in with what she thought was constipation and it turned out to be appendicitis. Kind of a big mistake. The little girl ended up later having to go to the emergency room, have emergency surgery. She was fine, but my client was just kicking herself, saying things like I should retire early. Maybe I should get my head examined like I'm a terrible doctor. For her, I would argue that we actually don't want to lower her standards or like stop when things are good enough. She should keep the high standards of correctly diagnosing every kid who comes to the door. But there are going to be inevitable mistakes over a 25 year career. Not because she's incapable, not because she's incompetent, but because she is human. It's just going to happen, mistakes as part of the package deal of being human. And so I like to try to ask people appropriate to their situation like, all right, over a 25 year career, like what percentage of misdiagnoses do you think is reasonable or, you know, how many cookies do you think you're going to eat in a day? What is a reasonable amount of mistakes or screw ups or escape hatches or whatnot? It doesn't even matter what the answer is, as long as that answer is non-zero. Because that little bit of wiggle room is all we need to allow ourselves some of the inevitable screw ups that are part of the package deal of life. Yeah, I often tell my staff I expect excellence and I expect mistakes. Amazing. Coming up, Ellen talks about the negative impacts of social comparison why warmth and connection can be more impactful than high performance and how to channel who you are at your core. Shift number five from procrastination to productivity. Yes. Okay. So procrastination. So people are often surprised that this is part of perfectionism, but I think it makes sense. Procrastination is not a time management problem. I think the research is starting to show us and it's starting to show up in popular writing as well. Procrastination is an emotion regulation problem. And then perfectionism puts everything on steroids because aversive tasks require quite a bit of self-regulation. You have to focus and get your act together, regulate enough so you can do this thing you don't want to do. And self-regulation deteriorates under emotional distress. So if we're feeling distressed and overwhelmed because our standards are unrealistic, we feel like we have to do the whole thing in one go or we are not allowed to make mistakes or we have to do this easily the first time that sort of overwhelms our self-regulation and procrastination steps in as a coping mechanism. And it's a double whammy because it allows us to both avoid the task that's making us feel bad and immediately replace it with something that makes us feel better whether that's pandemic era, procrastabaking or like going into a tick-tock rabbit hole, not that I've ever done either of those things. What we can do is the classic of break tasks down into steps so small you feel no resistance. In perfectionism, we can make them ridiculously small. No one has to know how small our steps are. I worked with a gentleman who was trying to motivate himself to go to the gym and his first step was peel a banana. Then he would eat the banana that would feel his workout and then his next step was find car keys, which I found highly relatable. Anyway, the point is that the steps can be really really small and that's okay. No one has to know how small they are and if you feel resistance, break it down even more. So that's one. And the less classic newer technique that I found was quite helpful is to connect with your future self. It's found that folks who procrastinate and folks with perfectionism relate to their future self in a brain scanner almost as if they're relating to a stranger. We think that our future self will feel like washing the dishes or writing our literature paper or working on that slide deck when we know from experience. That's not the case, but it doesn't even matter if we picture our future self doing the task or nothing. If we can just kind of create a more realistic relationship with our future self and not kick the can down the road to it, assuming it'll be motivated and happy to do all these tasks, then it's easier to get started now. I love that we've done episodes. I'll drop a link in the show now. We did a whole episode about relating to your future self. In the interest of time, I'm going to move us along to the final two shifts. Shift number six of seven is from comparison to contentment. My wife the other day pointed out in a great moment of using my own teaching against me that I was falling into comparing mind because I joined a new workout group and I'm definitely the least fit person in this group. So anyway, from comparison to contentment, say more about this if you would. We must be in the same workout or in the similar workout groups because I feel the same way every time I go to the gym. Anyway, okay. So I want to start out by saying that comparing ourselves is inevitable. You're not doing anything wrong there. So Dr. Leon Fessner who originated the theory of social comparison essentially found that it's hardwired. I mean, we can't even tell if we're tall or short without comparing ourselves to others. So to try to stop comparing ourselves entirely is essentially fighting biology. But what perfectionism is doing is we're comparing ourselves to others to answer the question like am I doing okay? Am I enough? But then we're outsourcing our worth to the people we're comparing ourselves to and our self-esteem will rise and follow with each comparison. So what to do is so social comparison is at its heart a lack of information that we tend to compare on one metric. So to your point like fitness or something that's happening with a lot of young people like number of social media followers or likes. I had a client who was comparing herself to her boss based on age and title. So like why am I not farther along by this point in my life? We compare apples to apple pie basically and we always come out behind. And so what we can do is to try to broaden the comparison points until we're what I call comparing apples to tennis balls. With my client she was comparing on age and job title. If she's trying to answer the question am I good enough? We tried to flood the zone with tons of different variables. So we like we included things she knew like education time at the company and a million things that she didn't have any access to like work hours or partner support or mental health challenge as possible nepotism. The point is if we're asking am I good enough the goal is to include so many comparison points both in quantity and variety that the answer becomes well I can't determine that by comparing myself to this person. And so the whole thing breaks down. The point is that we compare on very few things and we stake our whole self worth on it. And so what we try to do is to make it a little bit ridiculous and leave us with the conclusion of well only I can determine if I'm sufficient. I can't outsource it to my view of this person. I love it because it's like the antidote to comparison is more comparison right right exactly all right shift number seven okay from control to authenticity there's a lot in these chapters under this shift so this is dealing with emotional perfectionism which can be internal or external and essentially it boils down to needing to be appropriate however we define that in one's felt or demonstrated emotion oftentimes people with perfectionism have learned that emotion is a response to the outside situation as opposed to how we actually feel inside that we present as sad because the situation is sad or we present as amused because the situation is supposed to be lighthearted so I'll tell you a story about a client named Gus who we'll call him Gus so he came in because he wanted to optimize his performance at work and specifically wanted to work on public speaking and so that that already raised this flag for me for perfectionism anytime somebody says optimize that tells me perfectionism he wanted to be really really good at public speaking and to come off as you know not making any mistakes be impressive leave everyone with their jaw hanging open but what happened is that his perfectionistic self-presentation manifested as over preparing and over practicing to the point that it came off as wooden before meetings where he would present he would like stand at the podium like silently rehearsing his slides and he would ignore the people who came in and then when he gave the presentation he would perform his slides like it didn't really matter who was in the room and so what he was doing is to back up to some theory Susan Fisk at Princeton says there are essentially two dimensions on which human devaluate each other there's competence and warmth and competence is like how skilled talented capable is this person warmth is like how kind caring good-hearted is this person and in perfectionism we double down on competence we want to give a good performance but it turns out that warmth comes first and carries more weight in making a good impression on other people that we need to determine if people are friendly or on our side or or our our foe and working against us before we evaluate their competence and whether or not they're capable of carrying out those intentions that was nerdy and heady so what Gus was doing is he was doubling down on competence but at the expense of warmth so we tried to double down on warmth keep competence we all want to be competence we're not doing a 180 and flipping from competence to incompetence but we're just going to add on some warmth and so instead of over preparing and over practicing tried to roll him back to preparing and practicing but you know not to the point where he came off as wouldn't when instead of silently rehearsing his slides people came in he greeted them by name said hello you know how is your weekend and then this was the most important when he presented he focused on sharing his knowledge and the story he was trying to tell with the energy of look at this cool rock I found rather than trying to perform as like Gus the impressive expert to boil it all down when Gus was was using perfectionistic self-presentation, yeah, sure, he avoided mistakes, but he also missed out on connection with his colleagues and showing his colleagues that like he cared about them and trusted them, that when we show people a little bit of what's under the rug or allow them to see us before everything is perfectly polished and we have the correct highlighted answer at the end when we say like, oh, here's a little bit of my mess, we're sending two messages. We're saying, I trust you, because I'm showing this to you before it's like perfectly polished, so I trust you not to judge me or criticize me. And two, we are the same. We are equals. And this is not some kind of like mentor, mentee relationship or teacher student relationship, like we're both human, we're both equal. And implicitly sending the message, if I trust you and we are the same, is really going to draw people closer to us and get us that to come back to the beginning, that connection and belonging that we're ultimately looking for. There was a lot in what you said, but the one thing that really stood out to me was the rock. I'm going to present as if I'm showing you a cool rock and I'm guessing that Gus likes rocks and that you as a wise therapist honed in on who he really is at his core, which is a dude who likes rocks. And if you can channel who you are at your core and bring that energy into whatever room you're occupying, people are going to like you because we all like realness. Absolutely. Yeah. Like it's the energy of like, wait, look at this cool thing. You know, as opposed to like, I must present this perfectly to you, to your point about authenticity. And actually here are overall like trying to increase our feeling of enoughness. I feel like so many of us will try to like hype ourselves up or psych ourselves up with, I got this or before our client Gus could go onto his public speaking. Maybe he would try to reassure himself. But what we can do instead is to affirm what we know to be true about ourselves. And if it has nothing to do with the situation at hand, you can do this before or after. So let's pretend Gus's presentation goes poorly. He might be tempted to reassure himself. He's actually smarter. He's actually talented or to like think about presentations where it did go well. And that can try to make it self feel better at that way. But that doesn't often work. And what we can do instead is try to focus on the things we know to be unquestionably true about ourselves. I think rocks are the coolest thing ever or like reading books and making art make my world go round or I was put on earth to help the last fortunate or like I have wicked awesome style or like in whatever, whatever we genuinely hold dear. I'm a great dad. It can shore up the story of ourself and thicken our skin, which can buffer against self esteem threats. So I didn't make this up. This is the work of doctors Jeffrey Cohen and David Sherman. And they find that the goal is not to flatter ourselves or to like again, reassure ourselves that we're actually smart and like most things go well. But to really maintain sort of an overarching narrative of the self's adequacy, which again, create that buffer against the inevitable mistakes and struggles and setbacks of life. This has been enormously helpful. Before I let you go, can you just remind everybody of the name of your new book, the name of the book that you wrote before it and also anything else that we should know that you're like doing in the world that people can go consume. Yeah, sure. So this book is how to be enough self-acceptance for self-critics and perfectionists. The prettiest book, which is about social anxiety, is how to be yourself, quiet your inner critic and rise above social anxiety. And the place I am most active on the internet is sub-stack. I have a sub-stack called how to be good to yourself when you're hard on yourself, which encompasses both those topics and other related maladies of being human. Anybody who's talking about the maladies of being human is an ally of mine. So we will put links to all of those in the show notes. Dr. Alan Hendrixen, always a pleasure. Thank you. Great to talk to you again. Thank you so much for having me. Thank you so much to everybody who works so hard to make this show. 10% happier is produced by Tara Anderson and Eleanor Vasilie. Our recording and engineering is handled by the great folks over at Pod People. Lauren Smith is our managing producer. Marissa Schneiderman is our senior producer. DJ Kashmir is our executive producer and Nick Thorburn of the great Indy Rock Band Islands wrote our theme. Also one last thing before you go, remember to sign up for my new app, which is called 10% with Dan Harris. You can sign up over at DanHarris.com. On the app, you'll find a growing library of meditations from world-class teachers, ad-free access to the full expertise of our podcast guests, meaning you'll get this podcast from no ads, exclusive live stream events, which we do weekly sometimes twice a week, robust discussion threads to connect you with our team, with our teachers, and with one another. There's a free 14-day trial if you want to try before you buy, paste.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Perfectionism is not about striving for perfection but about a deep sense of never being good enough, often rooted in self-worth being tied to performance.
  2. Perfectionism manifests physically and emotionally, with extreme cases linked to chronic stress, anxiety, and health issues due to prolonged self-criticism.
  3. It is closely tied to anxiety disorders, including OCD and eating disorders, as a core mindset that equates self-worth with performance.
  4. Perfectionism arises from both genetic and environmental factors, including parenting styles, societal pressures, and a culture that rewards performance and optimization.
  5. Adaptive perfectionism—driven by conscientiousness and high standards—differs from maladaptive perfectionism, which conflates performance with self-worth and leads to self-criticism and isolation.
  6. Key shifts to overcome perfectionism include moving from self-criticism to kindness, from rigid rules to flexible values, and from comparison to contentment.
  7. True connection comes from authenticity and warmth, not performance, as social bonds are built on feeling seen, not on demonstrating competence.
  8. The root issue is not failure but a misplaced sense of insufficiency; healing begins by redefining self-worth as independent of outcomes and achievements.

Summary:

Perfectionism is not about achieving flawlessness, but rather a deep-seated fear of inadequacy that drives people to equate their self-worth with performance. " Rooted in both genetics and environment, perfectionism thrives in competitive, performance-oriented cultures and often manifests physically through chronic stress or pain. It is strongly linked to anxiety disorders such as OCD and eating disorders, where self-evaluation is tied to performance.

Perfectionism stems from a flawed belief that one must perform flawlessly to be accepted or loved, leading to emotional isolation and self-criticism. However, healthy perfectionism—driven by conscientiousness and high standards—differs from maladaptive forms that equate self-worth with outcomes. The solution lies in shifting from rigid rules to flexible, value-based living, embracing mistakes, and cultivating self-compassion through kindness and actions.

Key strategies include replacing self-criticism with self-compassion, moving from performance to authenticity, and rejecting social comparison in favor of contentment. Most importantly, true connection comes not from impressing others but from showing up as one’s authentic self, prioritizing warmth and emotional presence over performance. This shift allows individuals to live more freely, feel more connected, and finally experience a sense of sufficiency without constant striving.

FAQs

Perfectionism is not about striving to be perfect, but about never feeling good enough. It stems from conflating self-worth with performance, leading to a fear of failure and a need to perform flawlessly to be seen as sufficient.

Perfectionism can manifest physically, such as muscle tension, chronic pain, or gastrointestinal issues, as seen in Ellen Hendrickson's experience where long-term stress led to physical symptoms like a stiff neck and forearm injuries.

Adaptive perfectionism involves high standards and a drive for excellence without damaging self-worth, while maladaptive perfectionism equates performance with self-value, leading to self-criticism, procrastination, and emotional distress.

Yes, perfectionism is deeply linked to anxiety disorders, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and eating disorders, as it often underlies the need to perform perfectly to avoid judgment or rejection.

The seven shifts are: from self-criticism to kindness, coming home to your life, from rules to flexibility, from holding on to letting go of mistakes, from procrastination to productivity, from comparison to contentment, and from control to authenticity.

By shifting focus from evaluating oneself to viewing performance as information, using metaphors like a sculptor and their work, and recognizing that self-worth is not tied to outcomes or standards.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.