Go back

Terms Of Attachment: How We Learn about Connection and Disconnection

from Complex Trauma Recovery

30m 22s

Terms Of Attachment: How We Learn about Connection and Disconnection

Kina Wolfenstein introduces the concept of "terms of attachment" as a foundational framework in understanding complex trauma. These are unconscious, early-life learnings about what behaviors, emotions, or thoughts are required or forbidden in relationships with caregivers to gain love or avoid rejection. Rooted in developmental experiences, such rules become generalized beliefs about how relationships work globally, shaping present-day emotional patterns, self-worth, and relational behaviors. These implicit learnings generate significant distress—causing anxiety, dissociation, and emotional suppression—because individuals live in fear of re-experiencing past trauma like abandonment or abuse. The core healing process involves de-generalizing these rules, helping individuals recognize that childhood attachment patterns do not apply to all relationships. This shift allows for reintegration of suppressed aspects of the self, leading to greater emotional safety, authenticity, and secure attachment. Wolfenstein emphasizes that traditional cognitive approaches are insufficient; instead, experiential, bottom-up trauma therapies are vital for retrieving and transforming these deep emotional learnings. She highlights her new workbook, *The Felt Sense Attachment Workbook*, which includes exercises and prompts to help individuals uncover and heal their terms of attachment, offering both personal and therapeutic tools. The episode concludes with a strong call for trauma-informed, attachment-specialized therapy to support real, lasting recovery.

Transcription

5129 Words, 28955 Characters

English
Hi everyone, this is Kina Wolfenstein and you're listening to the Complex Trauma Recovery podcast, which I am revitalizing, bringing back to life after a very long hiatus. It does not been active for a few years now. I'm choosing to keep this podcast ad free to make the listening experience more enjoyable, but if you'd like to support my work here are some ways that you can do that. You can always subscribe to my podcast or leave a good review. You can find and follow me on Instagram at CPTSD Therapist, and if you're a therapist and you're looking for training and educational resources for working with Complex Trauma, check out my training website, KinaWolfensteinTraining.com, where I offer live trainings, consultation, mentorship, and pre-recorded courses for trauma therapists. You can also join my Patreon community at patreon.com/complextraumarecovery, where I've created a vast library of videos sharing my knowledge about working with CPTSD and using bottom-up therapy approaches. I also have a very exciting announcement to share. I just published a workbook. It's called The Felt Sense Attachment Workbook, exercises and prompts for exploring your inner world of attachment. So it's written to be a resource for people with attachment trauma who are on their own healing journeys. It can be used independently, like you can just use it to do your own personal work, or you can also use it as a support for work that you're already doing with a therapist. It can also be helpful for therapists who are doing attachment work with their clients and are looking for more guidance and education and ideas for how to really get to the roots of attachment trauma. I'm very proud of it. Very excited to get it out into the world. It includes a bunch of different exercises and prompts that are intended to be really deep and facilitate exploration of attachment patterns. And it also includes lists of suggested, reparative exercises that I found can be deeply cathartic and transformative for people with complex trauma. The links for the workbook and for all the other resources mentioned will be below. And with that announcement, let me launch into today's podcast. So today I'm going to be talking about a concept that I first heard when I was reading unlocking the emotional brain, which is the main book for coherence therapy. For those of you who are familiar with my work, you probably know coherence therapy is my favorite therapeutic approach, really the cornerstone of my practice. I am a certified trainer for the coherence ecology institute, which I wasn't last time I made a podcast that's actually exciting news to share also really, really honored to get to be a trainer and help other therapists learn about coherence therapy. So I was reading unlocking the emotional brain and I was introduced to this concept called the terms of attachment. And this is just a way of thinking about and understanding people's attachment patterns that immediately made so much sense to me, just intuitively aligned so well with what I have observed firsthand in my work as a trauma therapist and also just as a human being. And ever since I have really come to understand terms of attachment, I have just seen how central it is in so many of the things that people struggle with who have experienced particularly attachment trauma. So I'm going to start by reading you a quote from unlocking the emotional brain where they define it and then I'll talk a little bit more about what I have observed. Okay, so terms of attachment is a phrase used in the emotional coherence framework to refer to a person's learnings of how a primary bond relationship works. That is the forms of connection and interaction that are available with significant others. And importantly, the specific behaviors, thoughts and feelings required and forbidden in order to participate in such connection. I'm actually going to read that out as part again. The specific behaviors, thoughts and feelings that are required and forbidden in order to participate in such connection. Terms of attachment are the individuals detailed and living knowledge of the conditionality of love, the rules for being acceptable and admitted into full connection, whatever full connection consists of with the individual's caregivers. So those two words are really key, required and forbidden. So what is required of me? How do I need to behave? How do I need to show up? What are the important qualities that I need to have in order to get the most possible connection with caregivers? Like what parts of me are the most acceptable? What parts of me get the most, you know, positive response? Or what is forbidden? So what are the emotions, behaviors, thoughts, qualities, you know, personality traits that are the most off limits and not okay within my family system, where I will receive the most punishment, disconnection, cruelty, where I'll be most alone, rejected, abandoned, right, where I will be the most cut off from the available connection. So required and forbidden are kind of the two main categories of terms of attachment learnings. And these learnings, because they happen often in a very early attachment context, like often very early developmental experiences, they may not be conscious. So they may not be things that have ever been actually thought or put into words. So you're about to hear some examples of what some terms of attachment might be, some examples of terms of attachment. But this is after they have been brought into conscious awareness and verbalized, which is part of the process of coherence therapy and it happens a lot in different more experiential forms of trauma therapy, because we're working with implicit learnings. We're not just working with the conscious cognitive mind. And so a lot of these learnings exist on an unconscious embodied level. They are felt sense level knowings often referred to as emotional knowings or emotional learnings. And so they haven't been put into words, but they exist as this just deep sense of what is real and how relationships work and how the world works. And because they are unconscious, often they guide so many of our different behaviors, both in relationships and outside of relationships, like our just general patterns in life, which I'm going to get more into later in this episode. But let me start by by listing some of the examples of terms of attachment that have been listed in this introduction in the unlocking the emotional brain chapter. And then I'll talk more about what I've found in my work with how these different things develop and how they show up in present day life. So here are some examples of terms of attachment that have been verbalized after retrieval into awareness. So usually someone doesn't come into therapy already saying here's what my learnings are about attachment. It takes time to uncover these emotional learnings. I must never like something that mom or dad doesn't like or I'll be humiliated for it. I must never think I matter or try to tell mom what I feel or need because then I'm a toxic thing that ruins her day and she'll ignore me for hours. They'll pay attention to me and include me only if I say something clever and funny. Don't cry no matter what happens or I'll be slapped. Don't have energy or strong feelings negative or positive or I'll be screamed at. Dad pays attention to me only if I talk about what he likes. I'm acceptable if I do things exactly how mom wants and if I do one thing wrong I'm totally unworthy. Oh, all of these are like so emotionally powerful because I think we can all relate to this idea of terms of attachment and this just goes back to us being social creatures that are you know evolutionarily wired to seek connection and belonging especially when we're children especially with our families but even you know as adults among peers and communities it's a it's a you know central survival need to figure out how can I get belonging how can I get connection. So everyone is going to have some terms of attachment learnings but for folks with complex attachment trauma these learnings are going to be very painful and often pretty numerous because we're going to have different terms of attachment learnings for different attachment figures. So you might have one set of terms of attachment learnings for your dad and another for your mom and maybe another for a sibling or for another caregiver who was important in your life or maybe then another set of terms of attachment learnings for your peers in a social setting as you get older. So as these learnings are being constructed on an unconscious level the child is basically figuring out how to maneuver themselves how to alter the way that they show up and navigate the world in order to avoid these really painful experiences of disconnection and in order to gain more positive experiences of connection and the really tragic thing with attachment trauma is that these terms of attachment learnings are basically teaching the child that who they are authentically is not eligible for belonging. So it's like I can't just show up and be myself and have my full range of emotions, my full range of humanity be a full human being and have belonging and connection and be treated with dignity and respect. So instead people learn that there are often really significant parts of their humanness there's just like personhood that need to be cut off or suppressed or managed or altered in order to get connection in order to be safe. So when we have a really painful experience like the first exam. I must never like something that mom and dad doesn't like or I'll be humiliated for it. This is more about what's forbidden, right? I must never It is forbidden for me to do X, Y or Z or I'll be met with humiliation or abuse ostracization, the silent treatment. I'll be screamed at. I'll be cut off from connection and love like all of these very painful painful experiences that we can have and then what is required that is learned more through positive reinforcement, right? That's more like, oh, any time I get good grades at school mom and dad actually look at me and pay attention to me or any time I Take care of my siblings and I take on this kind of parentified role in the household. I get affirmation. I get validation Um, I have to kind of jump through these certain hoops or or perform these certain these certain attitudes that I know get a a positive response from my caregivers. So I found some people are gonna lean more towards terms of attachment learnings that are about avoiding painful experiences especially for people that had caregivers that really were like volatile or abusive or unpredictable and then other people their terms of attachment learnings are gonna be more oriented to What's required to try to earn the love to earn the approval to be good enough, right? to be accepted So how does this show up in the present? I'm sure you can imagine, you know, one of the main ways that this shows up in the present is of course how we perform roles in our current relationships So one of the most important things to understand about emotional learning or implicit learning is That it happens in well actually two there's two things that I want you to understand about it So first of all it happens in a very specific developmental context and Based on the developmental context in which it occurs. It takes on certain qualities So what I mean by that is Let's say you are five years old and you're having this attachment experience where anytime you cry You get rejected and chained and told you know suck it up or Tough up or boys don't cry or whatever like you're getting these negative negative messages about your emotions The way you learn from that experience is going to be Highly oriented to your current developmental stage So you are going to make sense of that experience through the mind of a five-year-old You're not going to make sense of it through your adult mind and think oh wow my parents really have a lot of negative Beliefs about emotions and they never learned how to feel comfortable with their own emotions And that's why they can't hold space for my emotions and what a shame that mom and dad you know aren't emotionally mature enough to Love and support me when I'm sad right like of course not know if no five-year-old is going to think that what is a five-year-old going to think through their developmental Capacity in their context at the time. They're going to think oh my god. There's something wrong with me It's bad to cry. It's bad to have feelings mom and dad don't like me. I've made them mad. They don't love me. I need to I need to you know Stop crying in front of them. It's all going to be through the filter through the lens of a five-year-old attachment system of five-year-old's brain development and That emotional learning when it forms. This is getting more into kind of the neuroscience of it It stays consolidated in the brain in that original Context of how it was learned so it doesn't change with time It's not like oh now now I'm 15 and I have this like new mature perspective on it We might have a new mature mature perspective on it at 15 or 25 or 35 or 45 But the the original learning that happened at five years old is still in there is still stored in the brain in like a particular neural network And so how might that show up? You know, it's this person might experience that anytime they feel the urge to cry They suddenly feel really embarrassed and they feel like they should apologize and they don't know why because logically They're like I know it's okay to cry, but I just feel so embarrassed when the tears start coming or maybe they When they feel sad and they feel emotional and vulnerable They just start to dissociate and they kind of their body freezes and shuts down. It's like something just cuts off the emotion You know, that can be something that is experienced in therapy a lot of times people can be frustrated Why is it so hard for me to get in touch with my feelings? You know, why is it that any time I start to process something intense my body shuts down and I can't feel it anymore Well, that might be a terms of attachment learning right because the this person has learned implicitly that It's not okay, and it's not safe within relationships to express emotion Um, and that it won't lead to positive connection or safe attachment with others So so yes, the the learnings happen and are stored in a specific developmental context And then the other thing that's important to understand is that they don't stay specific to just the original attachment figures Most of the time there's always caveats with these things But the majority of the time The attachment learnings become a globalized and generalized truths They become over arching kind of broad knowings about the very nature of reality So the the child experiences their family system as basically a sample of how the the whole world works right like kids Obviously this kind of goes back to the developmental capacity thing kids don't know That this might just be how my family is right or this that the whole world isn't isn't like this usually whatever's happening in the home Feels like it is a sample of how the whole world operates It is teaching them like what to expect from human beings Of course, right the family is the the first Uh sample of of relationships and what it means to have relationships with other people So whatever those terms of attachment learnings are they become broad and generalized truths They're not just true for dad now they're true for everybody and again that that can be operating on a very unconscious level so a person might not be thinking that to themselves but Let's say this this person has grown up and now they are a 30 year old man trying to build friendships trying to date And there's this immense difficulty with being emotionally vulnerable and this huge like brick wall around showing any tenderness or vulnerability Or anything that would elicit that shaming and rejecting response from caregivers And it's because that that terms of attachment learning Is not just activated when he goes home and visits mom and dad right that terms of attachment learning is now something that is carried with him all the time In most if not all relational contexts And so this goes this goes into kind of the neuroscience again Emotional learnings are essentially predictive models It is the brains really quite sophisticated and um evolutionarily advantageous System for predicting what will happen Forming these predictive models for how life works how people work and How to respond to that how to keep myself safe right How to get my needs met how to avoid pain and so the predictive model says When I cry I will be met with humiliation and rejection and shaming when I show vulnerability I will not be met with kindness or care or warmth and that predictive model is active in Most relational context now. It's carried on you know carried on Well beyond uh, you know reaching way beyond its original context with with caregivers so That is just one example of how Terms of attachment learnings can impact more than just like our our specific relational Patterns although the example that I gave I I'm realizing as I'm speaking that is a specific relational pattern to not be vulnerable in relationships But the point that I'm actually making here is that this particular example of a terms of attachment learning Has changed the way that this person relates to their emotions So even their relationship with their emotions like is it okay to cry is it okay to show vulnerability? Is it okay to to let myself feel things right um? I guess I'm thinking back to the example about Like being in therapy and not being able to feel your own emotions or get in touch with your body Even that could be something that stems from a terms of attachment learning because this person has has learned to Adaptively kind of put up this this big brick wall that stops them from from really feeling um Because feeling would subject them to this painful disconnection with caregivers And so now it shows up as intellectualizing it shows up as being kind of cut off from the body and just like living in the head and Having trouble really processing anything on an emotional level So it can show up in the roles that we play in relationships for sure like whatever role Was required of you growing up you're very likely to then Play that role in your current adult relationships like oh, you know What was required of me as a kid was to always care take for other people's emotions kind of be the family therapist the family mediator So that's the role that I automatically step into and play in my adult relationships today Or you know, what was required of me was that I um Perfect and I get good grades and I am always like performing well in making mom and dad proud in the ways that would make them proud And so now I'm really afraid of failure and I'm like a really high achiever And I beat myself up and I have all of this like harsh self criticism if I ever make a mistake So, the learnings about the terms of attachment impact self-worth, relationship with emotions, relationship with other people, all kinds of things related to like identity and self-image, like what makes me good, what makes me bad, what do I value about myself, what do I not value about myself, all of that can be highly influenced by terms of attachment, there's all kinds of things where people might come into therapy with some particular pattern that they like to work on, like I want to work on the fact that I stress out about work all the time and I can't put my phone down and I can't stop checking my work email, like something that doesn't really seem all that attachment related, and yet you start doing some exploratory work and it turns out, oh my gosh, this is terms of attachment actually, because maybe this person learned that I need to always be showing that I'm busy and I'm doing something because my dad hates it when I'm lazy, right, my dad would always get so mad if he felt like I was being lazier, unproductive, and he always would, he would only be proud of me if I was like doing my homework or cleaning the house or helping with the dogs or whatever, whatever, and now I've internalized this like restless flight energy that I can never really sit down and relax and I always need to be working and productive, but it actually goes back to terms of attachment, this is what gives me eligibility into dad's acceptance and dad's approval, so I look out for terms of attachment learnings all the time now in my work as a trauma therapist, it's been hugely helpful for me to understand and I'll speak just a little bit about, you know, what can help help people heal from terms of attachment learnings, and the main thing that I think of is the de-generalizing of the terms of attachment, so remember a few minutes ago when I was talking about how these terms of attachment learnings, they don't stay circumstantial, they don't stay specific to just the context of the caregivers, they become these big, huge, globalized truths about the very nature of relationships, so it's that process in reverse that really helps people heal, it's like even if we know logically that not everyone behaves exactly the same as mom and dad, that predictive model of implicit learning is expecting, even if it's on an unconscious level, that everybody will, that whatever the rules for attachment we're growing up are still the same rules today, the same things are forbidden, the same things are required, and so it's a really profound relief when we can help people's brains and nervous systems and bodies really take in, that actually those were the family rules for the terms of attachment, and the same things are not required in forbidden, in all relationships, like there are places in the world, there are people in the world where you can actually be a more full and well balanced and authentic version of yourself and have eligibility for belonging and connection, right, and so doing that healing work really depends on understanding very specifically what your terms of attachment learnings are, like if you learned that your anger is forbidden and you're never allowed to get angry, and now anytime you're feeling angry, you just find yourself self-isolating and kind of pulling back and you can't be honest and you don't know how to work through conflict in a healthy way because you're so afraid of sharing your anger with people, then that would be what we would be trying to update in trauma therapy, would be this deep learning that the only way for me to have access to connection is if I'm never upset and I'm never mad, right, and then maybe we're seeing fawning, we're seeing people pleasing, we're seeing avoidance, like all these different relational behaviors that are so difficult for people, so that's generally what I find to be the most kind of pivotal thing is to really start to take in that and take in beyond just a cognitive level, but emotionally absorb that the terms of attachment growing up are not universal and are not broadly true in all relational contexts, and when that happens it can be a really deeply liberating effect where oh I actually have options to kind of reclaim the parts of myself, my humanness that I had to suppress and I had to cut off, and that reminds me of actually another piece that I want to mention, terms of attachment leads to a lot of dissociation, because when you cannot actually be your full human self, right, when there are entire parts of your personality, emotions, authentic pieces of who you are that have to be cut off and suppressed, it's a very dissociative experience. It's like an experience of only being able to be kind of half-presenter or half a person, like parts of you just have to really fade out or disappear or be locked up and that feeling of having to like lock up or fade out different parts of yourself makes it pretty impossible to experience real connection. It really impacts the quality of relationships, because then even when you're in relationship, deep down it feels like I'm still not secure, because in order to have secure attachment we have to actually feel that we can be our true selves and be loved and accepted and have belonging as like our full real human selves. If you still are feeling that you have to perform the certain role or that there are entire parts of yourself that you have to suppress in order to gain access to connection, there's going to be a deep sense of lack of security, you know, a deep sense of lack of stability. So working with terms of attachment in trauma therapy and trauma work positively impacts so many areas of life when we can start to shift in and update it. It's identity, self-worth, relationships, you know, secure attachment with other people and can also, as a byproduct of that, just really decrease things like anxiety and depression, because terms of attachment learnings also generate a lot of anxiety and depression. Because while it's anxiety provoking, if you really feel that you must always be so careful about following these rules, these terms and not doing what's forbidden and doing what's required and not messing up and like that's a very anxiety-producing state to be in. And it's also depressing, it's sad and it's depressing and it feels lonely, it's one of the things that can make us feel really alone and lonely even when we are in connection with other people is to feel that there's kind of this delicate balance beam that I'm having to walk on. I've heard people describe it that way before, like I'm on this balance beam and if I take one step off in the wrong direction, everything can just fall apart, I can just be alone. Our predictive models, our emotional learnings include different elements of them and they include both how life works, like what to expect from relationships and also what to do about it. So this is where the adaptiveness of our behaviors becomes really clear. It's like, okay, here's what I've learned to expect from life and here's this really painful experience I've had, like some sort of real suffering and then, okay, here's my solution, here's the best thing I can do to adapt to that and avoid that suffering. And so people are expecting that if they don't follow the terms of attachment correctly, right, that they will re-experience like the same type of pain and suffering that they experienced in childhood, that's how our predictive models work. So it's like, I have to be perfect, I have to do all the right things, I have to perform these roles or I can't ever show my anger or I have to always agree with the people around me or I can't ever have conflict or disappoint people or whatever the thing is. And then the second part of the learning is, because if I do, if I do something wrong or if I don't follow the terms of attachment properly, I will then re-experience whatever though kind of most painful part of the childhood attachment trauma was. So like our attachment systems are expecting abandonment or neglect or to be hated or to be screamed at or to be hit or to be given the silent treatment or to be treated with contempt and disdain or like whatever that suffering was in that original attachment trauma, our systems are like bracing for that. And that is also just a terribly anxiety-producing and difficult state to live in. So for anyone listening who relates to this, especially if you're new to my podcast, my recommendation, if you would like to work on this type of thing, is to find a therapist who specializes in attachment trauma, who specializes in attachment work, because it is a really unique type of work. And I always recommend using more experiential and kind of bottom-up modalities because what we're working with here are unconscious emotional learnings, so they don't just get shifted with kind of cognitive approaches. You have to be able to really kind of retrieve and discover and then shift these deep implicit truths, which is the focus of my work. But anyways, I think I'll wrap this podcast episode up. I really hope that this was helpful. If you're interested in learning more about the terms of attachment, I do recommend unlocking the emotional brain. They have a lot of stuff about it in that book. And I would love if you would check out my attachment workbook that I mentioned at the beginning, the felt sense attachment workbook, I actually have an entire chapter dedicated to terms of attachment with a bunch of exercises and prompts. for discovering some of your own terms of attachment and some suggested reparative experiences that might be helpful. So you can check that out all the links are in the show notes. Thank you so much for listening and supporting my podcast. Okay, bye everybody.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Terms of attachment refer to unconscious, learned rules about what is required or forbidden in relationships with caregivers, shaping how individuals seek connection and avoid pain.
  2. These learnings originate in early childhood and are stored in the brain as implicit, embodied emotional knowledge, often remaining unconscious and non-verbal.
  3. Terms of attachment evolve from specific family experiences into generalized beliefs about how people and relationships function in the world, influencing behavior across all contexts.
  4. They create predictive models that trigger anxiety, self-suppression, dissociation, and emotional avoidance, especially when a person feels they must perform to gain approval.
  5. People with complex trauma often have multiple sets of attachment rules from different caregivers, leading to fragmented self-image and difficulty being authentic.
  6. Healing involves de-generalizing these rules—recognizing that childhood attachment patterns do not apply universally to all relationships.
  7. This shift allows individuals to reclaim suppressed parts of themselves, improve self-worth, and build more secure, authentic relationships.
  8. Bottom-up, experiential therapies are essential for accessing and transforming these deep, unconscious attachment learnings.

Summary:

Kina Wolfenstein introduces the concept of "terms of attachment" as a foundational framework in understanding complex trauma. These are unconscious, early-life learnings about what behaviors, emotions, or thoughts are required or forbidden in relationships with caregivers to gain love or avoid rejection. Rooted in developmental experiences, such rules become generalized beliefs about how relationships work globally, shaping present-day emotional patterns, self-worth, and relational behaviors.

These implicit learnings generate significant distress—causing anxiety, dissociation, and emotional suppression—because individuals live in fear of re-experiencing past trauma like abandonment or abuse. The core healing process involves de-generalizing these rules, helping individuals recognize that childhood attachment patterns do not apply to all relationships. This shift allows for reintegration of suppressed aspects of the self, leading to greater emotional safety, authenticity, and secure attachment.

Wolfenstein emphasizes that traditional cognitive approaches are insufficient; instead, experiential, bottom-up trauma therapies are vital for retrieving and transforming these deep emotional learnings. She highlights her new workbook, *The Felt Sense Attachment Workbook*, which includes exercises and prompts to help individuals uncover and heal their terms of attachment, offering both personal and therapeutic tools. The episode concludes with a strong call for trauma-informed, attachment-specialized therapy to support real, lasting recovery.

FAQs

Terms of attachment refer to the unconscious learnings about how to behave, think, or feel to gain connection or avoid disconnection with caregivers. These include specific behaviors, thoughts, and emotions that are required or forbidden in relationships.

They develop through early attachment experiences, where children learn implicit rules about what is safe to express or show in relationships, often based on how caregivers respond to their emotions or behaviors.

Because they are formed through early developmental experiences and stored in the body and nervous system as emotional knowings, not as conscious thoughts, making them difficult to recognize or articulate.

They often become generalized beliefs about how all relationships work, leading to behaviors like emotional suppression, over-performing, or avoiding vulnerability in adult relationships.

Yes, they deeply impact self-worth, emotional regulation, and identity, as people may feel they must suppress parts of themselves to be accepted or loved.

The process involves de-generalizing these learnings—recognizing that the rules from childhood don’t apply universally—and replacing them with new, more balanced beliefs about connection and self-acceptance.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.