Go back

13: Tech Is Breaking. Is Anyone In Charge?

1h 17m 52s

13: Tech Is Breaking. Is Anyone In Charge?

The episode explores the intersection of political dynamics and technological upheaval, focusing on the internal struggles within the Democratic Party over leadership succession and the widening national debate on AI and national security. Hakeem Jeffries is emerging as a strong alternative to Chuck Schumer, supported by better public approval and a more activist approach, while Schumer faces backlash over his handling of the government shutdown and perceived lack of modern relevance. The core tension centers on allegations that NVIDIA, under Jensen Huang, facilitated AI chip exports to China through intermediary data centers, raising serious questions about corporate compliance with U.S. export controls. This is compounded by the broader political context: Donald Trump’s recent embrace of China, including a symbolic hug with President Xi Jinping, appears to betray his long-standing skepticism of China—a key pillar of his political platform. This creates a narrative of political betrayal and cronyism, fueling public distrust in both corporate leaders and political figures. The episode also highlights the tech industry’s lack of political maturity, with leaders like Huang and Elon Musk failing to demonstrate strategic or ethical leadership. Despite the urgency, public concern over AI remains fragmented, driven more by media cycles than deep policy anxiety. The writers suggest that significant legislative action on AI regulation—like a national "hard stop" or data center moratorium—is unlikely without a genuine crisis, such as widespread system failures or public panic. While AI is advancing rapidly, with tools like Flipper improving modeling efficiency, the political and institutional mechanisms to regulate it remain slow and fragmented. The episode ends with a cautionary note: the U.S. may be in a period of political and technological instability, where short-term media shocks—like aviation or banking outages—could spark broader public concern, but sustained policy change is still distant.

Transcription

13900 Words, 77199 Characters

English
And Andrew Ross Sorkin was like, uh, well, we just got word that J.D. Vance will not be coming. He says that he's held up in, like, meetings about, like, all the outages. I mean, I canceled all my meetings because of the outages t-shirt, but there's nothing wrong. T-shirt, like, doesn't exactly reassure anybody. I canceled all my meetings because of the outages t-shirt, but there's nothing wrong. Print it. We need merch. Welcome to Still Counting. I'm Galen Druk. I'm Claire Malone. I'm Nate Silver. I don't know how to say it. How come I always have to go third? How come I never get to go first or second? Don't ask a question. Declare it. Just say. I'm, who are you? Nate Silver. I'm Nate Silver. Have you seen the Norm MacDonald skit of, like, Charles Kuralt? But look that one up. It's hard. The clip's hard to find. It's like, anyway. This is literally just an instruction. And to go Google something. Okay, got it. On today's show, to invoke the words of my favorite painter, George W. Bush, speaking about Donald Trump's first inauguration, that was some weird shit. And I'm talking here about the eerie spate of tech outages this week across banking, national security, and aviation. We will talk about all of that later in the show. In the meantime, please use your last remaining internet and leave a comment on our RSS or YouTube feeds. But before we get into that, we're going to take stock of congressional Democrats' efforts to pick their leaders. Boring. Maybe Nate will opt out of that. Let's talk about NVIDIA. Let's talk about the internet breaking. We can keep it to five minutes, Nate. We can keep it to five minutes. Yes. And yes, we are all very eager to talk about NVIDIA and Jensen Huang, or as my favorite Tina Brown said, Jensen's Johnson. But there are also, obviously, a lot of other angles to that. Okay, the questions that everyone sent in ahead of the midterms were fantastic, and we had a very fun time answering them. But they obviously had an expiration date. We are past the midterms. So, please send all of your post-midterms questions to us. We may or may not be doing some mailbag answering questions in next week's pre-Thanksgiving episode. Email those questions to stillcountingatcrooked.com. Okay. You're going to need things. You're going to need things to listen to when there's another FAA outage, and you're stuck at Allentown Regional Airport for the next 27 hours. I'll say, I flew. I took two flights yesterday. I'm taking two more flights today. For the haters who told me the last time that I record this podcast from a hotel room and told me that my wall hangings were ugly, I was in a hotel room, and I'm in a hotel room again today. And I'll just say, you know, I'm not afraid of flying. You shouldn't be either. Things seem to be just fine. But we'll get to that later in the show. We'll get to that. And if you cannot, if you are listening to this and cannot see Galen's corporate housing in, like, Hong Kong or Divorce Dad in Peoria housing, please go to our YouTube and check it out. There are a series of muted. There's a Keurig machine. Yeah, Keurig machine. Get those microplastics directly into your coffee. It looks like one of those, like, Danish prisons. And I am not going to say, which hotel it is because I don't want us to get sued. Okay, let's start with Democrats. Capitol Hill Compulsos will know that Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen is currently challenging Chuck Schumer for Senate Majority Leader. And on the House side, Hakeem Jeffries, who would be the first Black Speaker of the House, appears to have locked down the Speaker's gavel as of this morning, despite a lot of grumbling from the activist base. As I said, this morning, the House Democrats held an internal vote. The caucus. Held a vote to decide who to put forward as Speaker when the new Congress is sworn in in January. And a lot of times this is done by voice vote. But Jeffries asked that a recorded tally could be made so that he could gauge the number of defectors that he's dealing with. So it's an interesting, you know, abandonment of the Seeger ballot. But he won with 251 votes, 11 no's, and two Democrats not voting. He will need 218 votes in. January. For frame of reference, Nancy Pelosi got 203 votes in the internal tally in 2018. Okay. Nate, what is the pushback on Schumer? And we're mostly talking about Schumer here. And to some extent, Jeffries, say about what's happening right now in this post-midterms period for Democrats. Yeah, I mean, a couple of observations. One is just like kind of fish and visitors stink after three days. After three weeks after an election is kind of when the honeymoon. When the honeymoon is over a little bit, right? The degree of like online infighting among Democrats has increased a lot. And appropriately, in a way, because it is kind of a leaderless party. The party has a lot more power now, and they have to choose a presidential nominee for 2028. You know, I think Schumer, if you had asked me before the midterm, I would have said, well, I think Schumer is probably on his way out, right? He was quite unpopular, even among Democrats. I personally thought that the shutdown was handled poorly last year. He's old. He may well be challenged by AOC or some other young Democrat in New York. However, a lot of his recruits did do pretty well this time. If you look at the prediction markets, I don't want to turn into one of those like billboards for Polymarket Kalshi, but like they seem to think he's probably going to hold on to that gavel. But yeah, you know, I don't know. I mean, if it were me, I'd want some younger person to represent the Democratic caucus. But. But. Party leaders are not designed to be popular. They're designed to instill. They have a thankless job in some ways, and the betting money is that he'll hold on. But do you have different views? I tend to align with your view. And I also think that Nancy Pelosi in 2018 is. I know we were talking about the House there, but is maybe instructive for how Schumer is going to approach this. He knows that patience is wearing thin on his time in leadership. And what Nancy. Pelosi did when she took back the gavel in the beginning of 2019 was say, I'm only going to be here for two more sessions. And then I'm going to leave leadership. And also in the process, I'm going to elevate new people and create a line of succession. I kind of imagine that Chuck Schumer could do something like that, talking about the next two years as potentially his last, you know, given both frustration with leadership and also the fact of his re-election campaign being potentially in jeopardy. If he were to try in New York in 2028. And I think, like, it's no surprise here that Jeffries is less embattled than Schumer. I mean, if you just look at the raw favorability ratings for the two of them, Jeffries is 10 points above water with Democrats, and Schumer is 10 points below water with Democrats. You know, just to add a little more data. With Democrats. Just to add a little more data to that, Jeffries is 56, Schumer is 75. And like, now that we're increasingly talking about candidates' appearances, looks frail. And so I think that the same generational change argument can't be made about Jeffries that can be made about Schumer. And to your point, Nate, about the shutdown last year, I mean, Schumer was one of, what was it, nine Democrats in the Senate who voted with Republicans to keep the government funded. And that was at the same time that Hakeem Jeffries had whipped all of the Democrats in the House to vote against that funding bill. And so Jeffries has been on the side of the sort of fight more activist-based at times when Schumer has not been. I would also say, I think what is sort of being missed in some of the coverage of this, obviously there's a lot of ideological stuff going on within the parties. I do think this is a negotiating position, right? Like, progressives on both sides know that they have some leverage here. And like, that's what smart negotiators do. Like, you might not, you know, Van Hollen might not think that he's actually going to, in the end, become speaker, but he wants to extract something. And that's like, kind of what you should do. Like, that is what smart business people do. That's what smart negotiators do. And I think that's probably what is happening here. And I'm not sure I have a clear sense of what exactly they're trying to get, but I'm sure that that is a huge part of what is going on with all of this. Although they have less leverage because the caucus is so large, right? It's not a Republican chaos situation where any small faction defects. Yeah, I haven't done the math yet to see kind of what the blocks are within Democrat. But you need, like, a larger block now, right? It can't just be, like, the four squad members or the four blue dogs and, yeah. Oh, yeah. We talked about this on Chidi Politics on Monday with Gabe Fleischer. And it's, you know, Democrats can lose, like, Hakeem Jeffries can lose, you know, 40 members in the House and still get legislation passed. The squad has grown from four to now they're calling it the block, which is like seven to 10. You know, if you look at the progressive caucus in the House, yeah, it's like over 100. But a lot of it is, like, a lot of those people are just mainstream Democrats. And if you look at new Democrats, which is maybe the more sort of moderate-ish, I mean, truly the moderates in the House are the blue dog Democrats who have grown in ranks are larger, certainly than the block or the squad or whatever, you know, in the 20s or 30s at this point. But the new Dems are something like 140 members. So, you know, to get to a 45-plus person block that can hold up anything against the leaders will is going to be quite tricky. And again, in the Senate, Schumer or whoever it is will be able to lose five. Mary Peltola, that race was projected Tuesday night. The majority leader in the Senate will be able to lose five senators. And that's a place where, yes, Peggy Flanagan, Troy Jackson, Abdul El-Sayed are more progressive and are going to try to, and Chris Van Hollen are going to try to hold Schumer or whoever's feet to the fire a bit, but that's not going to be a large enough block there either to hold things up in favor of saying, you know, oh, I don't want to, like what the arguments are going to be is, okay, do we want to restore cuts to Medicaid or do we want to pass a Medicare for all bill? You're going to have like maybe four or five people who are going to say, no, like I want to do Medicare for all or nothing, and otherwise it's not going through. And that's just, it's not going to hold things up. And the other little bonus for Democrats is that a Peltola or a Hamilton or, or, Scott Cologne can depart from the party and use that to show their bipartisan stripes and not jeopardize passage of a bill. Yeah. Little bonus. This episode is brought to you by the International Rescue Committee. You've seen the headlines, wars, floods, and crises are forcing millions of families to flee their homes with nothing but what they can carry on their backs. Tonight, many of them are living in makeshift shelters, in the cold, without enough food, without clean water, without the medicine their children need to survive. You can help. The International Rescue Committee is on the ground in more than 40 countries, providing families with what they need to survive, food, clean water, medicine, safety. And right now, for a limited time, every gift you make will be matched. So your donation makes an even bigger impact for the people who need it most, families who've lost everything. This is a moment to act. Please give now at rescue.org. That's rescue.org. Still Counting is brought to you by Made In. I do a lot of cooking, and there is nothing that makes the experience more pleasurable or easier than having a wonderful pan, and the Made In pan that I have is a stunner. Claire, I can do you one better. Please. Literally ate fried eggs off of a Made In pan this morning before recording the podcast. Did you do a little trick where you sprinkle water and make sure the pan? No, no, I just sprayed a little oil on there. It was like fried eggs, toast, and avocado. That's like a power breakfast to get you through a podcast recording. That's so good. Oh, I'm just dreaming about sticking some toast in a runny egg right now. If you're considering the pros and cons of different cookware brands, you should know that Made In has more of the pros like Tom Colicchio and Brooke Williamson and many other professional chefs who all trust their cooking to Made In cookware. The fact is, Made In has a long-standing, relationship with professional chefs. The company evolves from a hundred-year-old kitchen supply business and works with multi-generational craftsmen to make each piece. They make exactly what demanding chefs are looking for, including a wide selection of curated products from carbon steel to stainless clad, plus plateware, glassware, and more. But perhaps the biggest pro is that Made In is sold online and delivered to your door. If you want to take your cooking to the next level, invest in Made In cookware. Once you try it, you'll be a pro in Made In. For full details, visit MadeInCookware.com. That's M-A-D-E-I-N Cookware.com. Okay, should we move on and talk about what Nate has been wanting to talk about for a really long time? Actually, all of us. No, let's do it. Let's talk about Jensen's Johnson. NVIDIA! NVIDIA and Jensen's Johnson. Okay, last week, Guang resigned. In disgrace after revelations that he'd had an affair with a suspected Chinese spy named Alice Wong and at least two employees and potentially helped NVIDIA sidestep U.S. policy limiting powerful AI chip exports to China. We'll just pause there to let it all sink in because it is a lot, right? He also has been plotting something of a comeback, although it's really honestly been squashed at this point by recording. But there were a lot of his Silicon Valley friends. Going on the record, you know, saying Jensen should come back as CEO. And Jensen himself sort of saying like, hey, I would be totally willing to come back and step back into the role. Although NVIDIA's board came out and said sort of officially that they would not be accepting that offer. The background to all of this is obviously cinematic in and of itself. It's unfolding as Trump meets with China's President Xi Jinping. In China this week, we had some nice little B-roll of those two boys giving each other hugs on the red carpet while, you know, young women danced with flags and flowers. It was sort of a classic, like, Trump red carpet moment. Look, I'd just like to announce that I would also consider becoming the CEO of NVIDIA. Great. If I could receive Jensen's compensation package. Oh, my God. New York Post, you got your headline. Nate Silver. Offers himself as next CEO of NVIDIA. I believe Nate is like self-professed, uninterested in managing people. And Jensen Wong had, what, 60 direct reports? Yes. So NVIDIA board, do not accept Nate's offer. Guys, let's go. I want to talk about a fucking Chinese spy. Okay, let's talk about the Chinese spy. Okay, just to finish this out, China has denied the spying allegations and Trump himself told reporters that nobody. Nobody's proven that Alice Wong is a spy, despite, I should say, his secretary of state literally giving him a briefing about this on the last trip he took to China. Okay, it's so many layers here. This story is basically like the latest tabloid phenom to sweep the country in addition to being like a national security thing, a tech story. Nate, for people who do not care about AI, can you explain why this story is so huge? Distill it down past all the tabloid stuff. It's huge on almost every dimension, right? If you. So I spent time, I wrote a New York Times article this weekend, or I spent a bunch of time last week reviewing videos of like 27 Democrats, 13 rising stars, 13 2028 candidates, and Zora Mamdani. Because he's special. He deserves his own category. He does. I get cell phone reception now in the battery tunnel because of him. Okay. What are the things from the most conservative Democrats like Adam Hamilton or Rob Sand to El-Sayed that they're all talking about? They're talking about data centers, talking about corruption. They're talking about billionaires, and they're talking about AI, and this kind of dovetails into all of that. Because I think, ironically, when you hear about the three extra marital affairs, in some ways, that's a distraction from what I think is the real story here, which is that according to lots of reporting. Right. Yeah. I think that's the real story here. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. so the company that Alice Huang ran was called Megaspeed, which I believe is a Singaporean, or is it Malaysian? Southeast Asia, you have a bunch of these intermediaries that run data centers there. And so, you know, China can rent services in the cloud there. And basically, there's a lot of circumvention over American export controls. I know it kind of sounds. Well, two specific ways, which is chip smuggling, straight up ensuring that NVIDIA chips that are not meant to make it to China because of export controls actually make it to China. And there's a strong suggestion that this was happening and Megaspeed was helping make it happen. And then there's also a loophole that Howard Lutnick has helped keep open, which is that all of these data centers in Southeast Asia, Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand, etc., are allowing Chinese companies and modelers to use all of their compute using NVIDIA chips that are all set up there. And so what is really the difference? Who cares where the chips are if you're able to use their compute? and all of this in the context of many people feeling like we are in a national security competition with China over AI. Yeah, and Lutnik also used to run Cantor Fitzgerald. It's now in his family. And they also have interest in these Southeast Asian data center companies. And Commerce's behavior, I mean, basically, Scott Besson, Marco Rubio, Because Commerce was investigating Megaspeed and mysteriously that investigation got transferred to a different department. You know, NVIDIA was lobbying. I guess they have the right to lobby, right? But like, but there's a nexus here of things that don't quite smell right. And, you know, we'll see how far that reaches. But like, you know. I think what you're saying here is that no matter whether or not Jensen Huang was sleeping with the Chinese spy, the actions of NVIDIA in concert with the Commerce Department was working to ensure that China could have access Is it illegal? Is it straight up corruption? We're going to find out. But like, and we will find out more about whether or not Alice Wong was a spy. Put that to the side. I think there's a lot of sense that NVIDIA has been potentially in concert with the Department of Commerce working against America's best interests. But I will say, and I want, you know, Nate, you're a closer watcher of this. Before all of this happened, like Jensen Wong over the past few months has been on a real sort of like coming out media tour to the American public. And Silicon Valley had a bunch of internal debates about whether or not open source AI should be allowed, allowing models, you know, people in China to have access to our models, essentially. And Jensen Wong was, you know, I remember listening to him on the Ezra Klein show in a long sit down interview. He was very pro open source models, kind of had this whole structural argument for, hey, we actually want to have people share our chips. Can you break it down a little bit? Like, yes, Alice Wong is probably a Chinese spy. Potentially. Yes, there's all this assets, intelligence asset, however you want to say it. There's all of this, you know, stuff, shenanigans going on with Howard Lutnick and these companies. But like, what was, is there an implication here that this woman was influencing Jensen Wong or was he himself kind of already of this mind that like, yeah, like China should have access to this? Can you clarify that for people? No, Jensen Wong has, you know, he has long been pro open source. He wants the market to be, as big as possible, you know, pro cooperation with China. He also believes, and I think this is sincere, that AI is a quote unquote normal technology, right? That like most technologies, it will help economic growth and help development in various ways. But he's not worried about like the P-Doom takeover scenarios that other people in Silicon Valley are. And the other background too is like, NVIDIA was a company, by the way, happy GTA 6 day. NVIDIA was a company that like, I'm trying to seem contemporary and on top of the news. Nate showing up at a local high school in a baseball hat and like Cardinal shorts. Hi, fellow kids. Hey guys, happy GTA 1 day. The median video game player is like 45 or something. Did you know that now or something? But they made graphics cards for computers for mostly video gaming applications. And it happens that these are also very good for the advanced compute, that AI models need, right? So I went from this respected, but, you know. Niche. Niche player in Silicon Valley to maybe the most strategically important company in the world for a time, the highest market cap in the world, no longer, by the way, thanks to recent declines in their stock prices, which I may or may not have, you know, may or may not be avoiding opening up my banking account to see how the brokerage is doing, you know. Okay, I guess. I'm the only one who's not over-invested in NVIDIA on this call. But look. I don't even know if I am. I just don't want to check my 401k. Well, it's such a part of these indices now that whether you have it directly or not. But he was supposed to be the one who had his head screwed on straight, right? Like he knows how to like, because he's been fighting a lot of battles for a long time and everybody has an underdog story. He is not weird in the way that Sam and Dario are weird, right? His brain did not appear to be as contrived, torted as whatever has happened to Elon Musk's brain. He was like the best ambassador. Get a mean. Maybe. Speculative. According to reporting. Allegedly. Popping on a lot of allegedlys today. No, there are allegations. Read the Wall Street Journal. I know. But like he was like the best ambassador for AI development and NVIDIA had a very good story about like, well, we'll build robotics and we'll build physical chips and we'll build infrastructure and energy, right? And it's going to be a big win for America. And since we're winning, we can, we can export our stuff to China and expand our market just like Apple would or something else, right? And now that story is very much, very much undermined. Yeah, Nate, I think the question, there are two arguments here. And he was on, clearly on one side of the argument, which was it's to the United States benefit if all of China's AI infrastructure relies ultimately on American made chips, that that is an actual strategic advantage. Some people make that argument. He very clearly made that argument. Some people would say, that's like, you know, selling China nuclear bombs in a Boeing encasement and saying, well, isn't this fantastic? It was made by an American company. You know, that's the criticism of that. But he's saying, no, we, it's better for us if China relies on us for its compute. Other people would say, no, ultimately they're going to be able to advance their models much faster, compete with America much more effectively and put America in this position where like, we feel like we can't regulate AI because we're trying to, we're trying to compete with the Chinese and, you know, make, put America at a disadvantage. Like that's, that's an actual live debate, but the whole, how are export control, there are still export controls in place either way. And was NVIDIA or Jensen Wang sort of working with Megaspeed or the commerce department to get around those is the part where this all gets tricky, no matter which side of that debate you fall on. No, and I think what's important is like, even the base case here where there's nothing, more dramatic to come out, it's still a major, major story, right? I'm not going to speculate on whether NVIDIA circumvented the law, right? You know, also Trump is involved in various ways. Trump owns quite a bit of NVIDIA stock, although he owns and trades lots of stocks. You know, NVIDIA donated to the White House ballroom reconstruction as did big other, other big tech companies. I believe the United States as part of their deal with China, the US government actually gets a piece of certain types of sales that NVIDIA is making. 25%. Yeah, but, you know, Communism. Would anyone be surprised? I mean, I'm trying to assess the world probabilistically, right? Would anyone be surprised if somehow the White House, what, Nick, or maybe Trump or Trump's sons or who knows what, right? If there's some degree of like self-dealing here. But when it comes to the politics of all of this, I want to come back to the sort of drum I've been beating for a while now, which is the 2026 election being a, a betrayal election. Trump pitched a bunch of arguments in 2016 and won them. Forever wars, economic populism, the border even, you know, border security. One of those things was skepticism of China, right? He came in and he criticized the political establishment for being far too close to China. He implemented tariffs in his first term, sort of gave them the cold shoulder. Those tariffs were even kept by the Biden administration, by the time that Biden is in office in the early 2020s. Like Trump's argument about skepticism of China has completely won and is one of the most bipartisan issues in America, right? Favorability of China, the net approval rating or favorability rating of China in 2022, 2023, of course, part of this has to do with COVID as well, is like underwater by 60 points or more. And maybe, maybe things have ticked back up a little bit now, but as of right now, according to Pew, China's approval rating is net negative 44. That's like almost twice the net approval rating of Donald Trump. It's really, really bad. Americans overwhelmingly agree that we should be skeptical of China. And in the middle of all of this, much like starting a war in Iran or not actually lowering prices and doing tariffs or not actually releasing the Epstein files and all of that stuff, Trump is, literally the first thing I opened when I, the news, when I see the news this morning, it's him hugging Xi on the tarmac, right? Like it is such a betrayal of the, China is an adversary. They're eating our lunch. Like that was such a big part of his argument. Like the little guy has lost in America because China is competing with us. And he has in many ways aligned himself with Xi. And if you were going to maybe talk about how Trump has maneuvered through all of this, reportedly he was told about, Shenzhen Huang's relationship with Alice Huang in 2025 and did nothing about it. And so, you know, is this the next Russiagate where there's a lot of smoke and ultimately no fire? Or is this a, this gets at a lot of the dissatisfaction in American politics right now, which is that Trump has betrayed core arguments that he actually won on. I mean, I'm not even sure if it's, I'm not even sure if it's, the China issue, which like, like a separate thing is at this point after a decade of Trump, I feel like Americans are so used to him flip-flopping that it's almost like, it's almost nonsensical, right? Just like the, what he says and then the visuals and his, he flips all the time. To me, what will likely be the more long lasting story about this is the kind of cronyism to me that sort of seems to speak a lot more to the political moment. So yes, obviously China, which I think a lot of, Americans obviously have, as you just gave us, Galen, like ambivalent to say the least feelings about. And the only people with warm feelings towards China are Democrats and young people who are not part of Trump's coalition. Yeah, interesting. Well, you could also say that like, you know, to go back to the point, like the Howard Lutnick types, right? The idea that Trump, I mean, we said it earlier that Trump owns a lot of the stock, trading stock, like we should say, flouting historical norms of US presidents benefiting, right? like from their. negotiations and trade deals and the like. But to me, it's more about, you know, covering up for your buddy. I mean, I can't remember what Trump's exact quote was when he was first sort of asked to speak about the Jensen Huang thing. And he said something like, I'm sure he has like a good excuse or something. I mean, it was sort of like really fascinating language. And obviously he and Jensen Huang sort of had made a big deal about the closeness of their relationship. To me, it's just like, you can point to all those dots, the interpersonal relationships, and just the way that it's like this company alone that the U.S. government has put so much heft behind is now currently like tanking the stock market and potentially threatening our national security. It's like, are you kidding me? It's a genuinely amazing story. I thought, this will offend some of our listeners, I thought Russiagate was fucking stupid. Okay. Hillary Clinton did not lose the election in 2016 because she was like, maybe because of Russia, maybe because of James Comey, right? Maybe because she was a bad candidate. I thought Russiagate was stupid. But it was also something where if you ignored Russiagate, however many emergency pods we had about it back in the 538 days, it didn't really affect anything else. And that's like part of why it kind of felt like a distraction. This story, A, as we've been saying, is taking place in much warmer waters. The environment it's swimming in is an environment that helped Democrats win some enormous number, win the midterm vote by 14 points three weeks ago. And on top of that, there are knockoff implications. You know, I think the markets have some anxiety about, is AI overinvested in? Is it a bubble, right? Everyone has their opinion about that, but like, but there is potential for some contagion. And also what about relations with China? People classically said, you know, well, when you have a president who's weak, that's when, when China might want to assert itself in Taiwan a little bit. I mean, it's kind of, you know, we had this whole debate, we talked about it last week, about like, are we at the end of the Trump era? And I kind of called it like the denouement, but like, it's, would you guys see like the movie, The Substance, by chance? Yeah. Boy, was that hard to watch. The last two years of Trump might be a little bit like that. There might be some gore here. What's The Substance? Ugh, it was with Demi Moore. Yeah, it was hard to watch. That's fascinating that you've seen that movie, Nate. You know, I see a weird cross-section of movies. What Nate is describing is at the very end of the, like, it's Demi Moore's character is injecting a substance in order to be a young, hot actress. And, but the reality is like, she has to go through some process to rejuvenate and spend time sleeping or whatever. And if she doesn't, if she takes too much of the substance and doesn't sort of, you know, give enough back or whatever, little pieces of her body start becoming completely deformed. Where at the end of the movie, there's this creature that's just body parts and masses and fat and blood and eyes and gore, just like standing on a stage or on a runway. And that is what Nate is saying that the Demi Moore was the Trump administration. And the reason I make that analogy is like, I thought the movie ran on too long, right? That's my Roger Ebert review. But like, you can know what's going to happen and it still was very gory and takes a long time to play out, right? But like, this is really bad for Trump who already has a 37% approval rating. I mean, this is like, and this is all happening after this 14 point win for Democrats. And like, so yeah, no wonder J.D. Vance is like, well, maybe I'll go retire to Ohio and open a cracker barrel or whatever, right? I mean, it's directionally very bad for the White House. I mean, I don't know if you feel that way, but like when I was starting off getting into journalism, I was like, I want to do something that has an impact that matters. I agree. And these folks are trying to make it more accessible to everyone. Work should have meaning. God bless. 80,000 hours is a non-profit organization. It's a non-profit that aims to help people have a positive impact with their career. It offers free research and support to help you find a career tackling one of the world's most pressing problems. If you're starting out in your career and not sure what to do, looking to make a change to your direction mid-career, or even just want to help solve pressing global problems from your current job, they can help. Join their free newsletter and they'll send you an in-depth guide that helps you learn about what makes for a high-impact career, get new ideas for impactful paths, and make a new plan based on what you've learned and put it into action. 80,000 hours. 80,000 hours hosts a job board with nearly 1,000 currently open high-impact career opportunities. Or if you've got some ideas already, they offer free one-on-one advice to help you switch paths. They also have a podcast which hosts unusually in-depth conversations with experts about how to best tackle pressing global problems. You can subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. If you join the newsletter now, you'll get a free copy of their in-depth career guide sent to your inbox. Just sign up at 80,000hours.org slash stillcounting. Just to be clear, they're a non-profit, and everything they provide is free, always. They're fully philanthropically funded, and their only goal is to help you find a fulfilling, high-impact career. To get started planning a career that works on one of the world's most pressing problems, sign up now at 80,000hours.org slash stillcounting. That's 80,000hours.org slash stillcounting. Still Counting is brought to you by GiveDirectly. GiveDirectly is a non-profit that puts money directly into the hands of the world's poorest people, no strings attached. GiveDirectly sends your donations to a family across rural Africa living in poverty to spend as they see fit. $100 means about 100 times more to them than it does to you. The price of a nice dinner out can be life-changing for someone in extreme poverty. It can buy livestock or a new roof, cover an urgent medical visit, or get a kid back in school. It can start a business or get someone their first mattress. I don't know, $100 these days in New York City, I mean, it's kind of, it's a little eye-watering. It is. It's how little it gets you. Yeah. But one reason GiveDirectly's model is so great is that it's one of the most effective means of charitable giving. With GiveDirectly, you can be confident your gift has a proven impact. There have been hundreds of independent studies showing giving cash directly improves people's lives in many ways. Researchers have studied giving people cash, no strings attached, hundreds of times across hundreds of places. Study after study finds the same thing. Families earn more, eat better, and their kids do better in school and health. And these impacts, last for years. Why does it work so well? GiveDirectly sends families about $1,000 at once. Enough for them to make a big purchase that starts something. People buy livestock, tools, or stock for a shop. They fix a leaking roof. They pay off debt. Then they work more for themselves and own more. The money keeps earning after it's spent. If you're just hearing about GiveDirectly, don't donate yet. Just go read some of the research studies at givedirectly.org slash counting. That's givedirectly.org slash counting. I mean, like, I do feel like we should note that Elon Musk, a bunch of other people in Silicon Valley, when they came out and said, like, you know, before Jensen Wong himself said he should take he should take the CEO spot back. You know, they were very vocal about the fact that he was the only one to be able to do it. I don't know if it's a lack of creativity, a sort of like, you know, I alone can fix this mentality. But we've had, you know, there's some discussion about, like, are these tech guys actually good at politics? Are they too short-term thinkers because of the nature of their industry where change comes, you know, rapid change comes about incrementally? I mean, we had a little bit of a jumping off about this the other day in our editorial meeting. And just Simone was the one, yeah, but he was the one who was supposed to be good at politics. Clearly, Elon Musk is fucking terrible at politics, right? I would not give a great score to either. Yeah, I mean, the fact that like people are calling for Jensen Mong to be brought back, it's like, no, that can't happen, right? He fucking was like sleeping with an alleged Chinese spy. Like, you can't, you can't come back from that. And we are so far from the resolution of the story. Like, there's going to be so many investigations into this. Like, you know, Democrats are weighing what they should or shouldn't investigate. I think because of the argument I laid out about this being a direct betrayal of one of Trump's winning arguments, which is skepticism of China, that Democrats will be on solid footing, both when it comes to a dissatisfaction with corruption and a dissatisfaction with the state of the economy in pursuing this kind of an investigation. But like, when it comes to are these RAI CEOs or big tech CEOs good at politics? Like, absolutely fucking literally not. Like, across the board, I don't even think Jensen Wong is particularly good at politics. Look at, look at how every other chief of a Fortune 500 company behaves. Are they standing up behind Trump during his inauguration? Are they, like, basically making it obvious that they're friends with the guy? No, because if you want your company to do well long-term, even freaking energy companies understand this, which are one of the industries that are closest to the Republican Party going back decades, that you are going to have to ultimately work with both parties and be sort of nimble. And that's why so many of the companies many of these like big corporations give money to both parties, but they have, the AI companies have established themselves so solidly as like standing behind Trump at the inauguration or whatever that like they've made their lives so much harder. notably didn't come to the inauguration. And it's like buddy-buddiness with Trump is, I mean, people forget like they were a video game card manufacturer until like four years ago, right? This all happened very fast. And like, so one question is like, when's the timeline where it became in Jensen Wang's interest if he wants to sell chips to China or NVIDIA does, you know, to get on the buddy-buddy side of Trump, right? And so the timelines there may be relatively recent because he notably avoided the inauguration. He had to go to like Lunar New Year, he said, or something. Right. I mean, it speaks to, again, the fact that these, like Exxon has 50-year plans, right? They're like, you know, they know when the oil is running out in, you know, Java or, you know, the LNG fields under Iran, right? They know when they're going to have to like search for new sources. They make long-term plans. They've been projecting about like renewable energy sources for years. AI and the tech industry literally are, have to be in this period, you know, short twitch muscle thinkers. And I do, in some ways, you kind of, I guess if you're inhabiting their reasoning, you can't fault them for that, right? You can't fault them for saying like, okay, we have goals for the next two to three years because of the acceleration of AI. We live in the kind of, you know, it's a democracy, obviously, but you know, a certain kind of democracy now, right? Where the president has a lot of financial interests, is capricious. We have to cozy up to him. I think what we, like what the, what the huge structural problems sort of get into is that like the U.S. economy is so reliant on these companies. And these companies are all prisoners of shareholder value. Which means that the only, they always default in all of these statements is, I have a fiduciary duty to my shareholders. There is very little, I mean, let's bring up this topic of patriotism. I really mean it. Like, I think it's an important question to sort of bring forth because like we're obviously now operating in the realm of like, are national security interests threatened? Like there's a lot more tolerance for trade protectionism. And I do wonder about the long-term viability for corporate America to sort of always default to, I have fiduciary duty to my shareholders. Therefore, I had to make the decision that is ultimately kind of damaging to the broader U.S. economy. I mean, you know, it's a bit of a, I'm sure there's a lot of, you know, if I were saying this on, you know, at the deal book summit this morning, I'd get some pushback here. But like, I do think it should be a real conversation that we're having. Yeah, I think being good at politics is in the long-term fiduciary interest of your shareholders. And even if you make the argument that AI is moving so fast, so quickly, that you only have these two years, you have to get, like, Trump on board with everything you want in terms of data center build-out or chip exports to China or whatever, we all know that that's not true. The world's not going to end after the two- to three-year data center build-out, right? The world is going to continue on and politics are going to swing. Well, it depends on who you talk to. I mean, sure. But even the P. Doom people are talking about 10 years. Oh, no, some of them have much faster timelines. I mean, it's. Still, to cast your lot so aggressively with one kind of, as you said, Claire, capricious person who changes their mind all the time and is ultimately quite unpopular is not smart politics, I don't think. And yes, like, this isn't just big tech, like, operating in a vacuum here. Like, Democrats hugged big tech very close during the Obama years, right? And Obama sort of was supportive of the idea that the social media companies would advance democracy and be this force. This force for good and all of that. And the left turned pretty aggressively on big tech. Also, there was a lot of criticism of big tech from conservatives that they were, you know, squashing conservative voices and censorship and privacy concerns and all of that stuff. And so they said, you know, the Dems don't want us anymore. We can maybe do some lobbying, some persuasion on the Republican side. Let's do that. But they went, I think, in terms of their own interests, way farther than made sense for the long term. And there's also this argument that, like, so one of the arguments against AI regulation is, ironically, that people say, oh, well, AI is inevitable. And so the only way to prevent China from winning and or the only way to prevent AIs from being misaligned is to do more AI and then give more power to AI because only AI is smart enough to check bad AI. And we can debate how sound that argument is intellectually. It's a really hard argument to land politically. Like, oops, we made this really dangerous thing and, unfortunately, the only way to fix it is to make even more of it until it's no longer dangerous. I mean, it's fucking, it's kind of fucking insane. And, like, I don't, I don't know where it goes. And even if somehow it gets resolved, does it get resolved in a way where you develop, where it doesn't crash the stock market and you develop this robust consumer market for AI? I mean, nothing is off, nothing is off the table here, right? I want to, I want to, we talked about this, I want to say, a month to six weeks ago about the idea of, and this is moving a little bit away from NVIDIA, but the idea of, like, an AI hard stop, right? And, Galen, I think you called it an extreme position and I pushed back and said, like, well, why? You know, like, why, there's a lot of, we haven't quite sort of mapped how people feel about AI onto the, you know, polarized, you know, ladder of American politics, I think Bernie Sanders, correct me if I'm wrong, came out for sort of, like, maybe it wouldn't be a bad idea to have a hard stop. There's lots of sort of how would you actually do a hard stop things to talk about it. But, like, we're looking at a new Congress coming in in January. You've got people like Alex Boras who are coming in who are saying, like, well, actually, I have an intimate knowledge of how AI works. We need more legislators who understand this. What do we think the politics around AI will actually be in the new Democratic Congress? Like, is a hard stop going to be a viable thing? No. I mean, to clarify what I said. Oh, I don't think so. I think if you had a, I think if you had a Democratic president right now, there might be aggressive efforts, executive action to, like, stop AI. I really think that, right? I mean, it doesn't help anyone, by the way, that our fucking, like, last two presidents barely know how to use a computer without exaggeration. Like, great job, voters, right? Great job, parties, and nominating these fucking 80-year-olds. To be fair, many 80-year-olds know how to use computers. Okay. But, yes. I mean, the politics, the politics of AI, I think, are interesting. I mean, I don't know exactly what I said, but the extreme, maybe I described it as the extremes. The extremes are Trump on one hand and Sanders' plan on the other, at least in terms of what's getting offered in terms of policy, which is Trump is basically fully accelerationist. And Sanders has said that he wants, you know, a ban on superintelligence, I don't know that that's necessarily, like, unpopular. A pause is on the table. Yeah. But to cap, like, to cap the production of any models beyond a certain level of compute, I think is part of the plan and also halt data center production, period, which obviously we're using data centers right now to record this podcast and this call. Like, there's a lot of things that data centers get used for that people approve of. Hopefully, recording podcasts is one of them. But I think the politics of AI are tricky because I think we first, first have to figure out how to read the 2026 midterms and whether or not, I think some folks will say, and rightly so, that voters rejected, for example, data centers in every single instance they could, which was like 40-some instances except for one, when they could vote directly on it. And so, you know, there is a skepticism. Is that skepticism more about affordability, energy, water resources, things like that? Is it actually about fear? Or is it more of AI? Like, I know people are very negative about AI, but I don't know that this is sort of one of the main priorities for Americans. But I want you, I want you to build out on that idea a little bit more. Like, let's theorize, A, that we have a Democratic president who conforms to the norms of, like, where the sort of center of the road Democratic Party is right now. And let's assume that we have, like, you know, Mitt Romney's president or Mike Pence's president. Like, someone who is a normal, rational actor who acts within the bounds of, like, normal U.S. politics, presidential ethical norms. Where are we? Like, what does the conversation look like? Because obviously we are shifted to a pretty extreme. I think we'd say any fucking circumvention of these export controls, we're going to, the government's going to sue the fuck out of you, right? And we don't care if you're shut down, right? I would be, if I were president, man, I'd be like, I'd be executive order. You guys say you can't control your fucking models, you can't control national security implications of the models, then stop production of those models or the government's going to take over your company. I'm not fucking kidding, right? Like, that's what, like, I think a certain number of presidents would be doing. And, yeah, no, you're right, Galen, that, like, it's not clear to what extent when people have concern about data centers, is that yimby or nimbyism or is that this and that, right? But the point of the story is only growing more important, arguably at an exponential rate, right? And, like, people should be concerned about AI. But have we, I mean, are we kind of, has AI been planted in this sort of soil and any of the Trump administration which has these sort of like no-holds-bars, do whatever you want. Like, is there any way to sort of reverse and normalize the conversation around AI or to extend the metaphor, is any AI fruit that grows out of the soil inevitably going to grow like a weed, going to go beyond the bounds of what we're able to do? Like, what can two houses of Congress and a Republican president do if there's a will to sort of say like, wow, this has really gone beyond the pale and we need to do something? Or is it basically just like- I mean, the American system doesn't have that many veto points and tends to move like very slowly. Like, obviously the executive branch has began to assert more authority and the Supreme Court has permitted that authority. But this might be moving too fast for the speed of congressional legislation and might require executive action. And like, and I'm not sure if Trump is capable of making those actions, right? Like, I would feel safer if J.D. Vance were president about AI who's at least someone who understands the basic issues and seems to care about things other than greasing his palm. I think an important question here is, do we reach a point at which AI is perceived publicly to be a crisis situation? And I don't mean that it necessarily, like people have to die or the banking system has to become inoperable, period. Like, you know, the whole Jacob Coxon, thing made people feel a sense of crisis. There could be other media cycles that make people feel a sense of crisis. And historically, when there's divided government, a crisis is what makes people work together and work together quickly. I'm talking about the CARES Act. I'm talking about the Troubled Asset Relief Program. I'm not necessarily popular legislation in retrospect, but Congress and the president, even from different parties, come together and pass legislation. Obviously, Trump is a wild card here. But although I'm not a big fan of Trump, I'm not a big fan of Trump. I'm not a big fan of Trump. I wouldn't make the argument that 2026 was not about AI. I think AI is extremely important and will become increasingly important as we head into 2028. And as either truthfully or not, people get the perception that AI is taking out important systems, like aviation systems, financial systems, tech systems. Then maybe we hit a point of crisis, at which point something gets done. And I think that like what Nate suggested there in terms of, I mean, export controls, to me, that's obvious. Like skepticism of China, one of the biggest winning issues in American politics today. National security, people love, you know, one of the most popular institutions. Everyone stopped trusting pretty much every institution, including aviation, but they still love the military. And so like, I think that, yeah, some of this is obvious from a political standpoint. I mean, and Galen, you're sort of transitioning us out a little bit into like what we want to talk about with everything that happened this week with travel and banking systems. But I do, you know, I, when we're talking about whether or not 2028 will be an AI election and how AI is going to play out over the next two years, one thing that I have found genuinely sort of difficult as an American and a consumer of news over the past two or three months are just like the crazy whipsaw cycles of, yeah, the Jacob Coxon news cycle of like, we're all going to die, take up smoking again. Like, I mean, I genuinely mean it. Like I am, I remember Y2K and my mom, like, hi mom, stockpiling like water and snacks for Y2K, which we all made fun of her for. And we did eat all the snack wells in the basement. But like, I do kind of now get that mentality. And like, I'll be honest, I bought some bottled water at Costco because I was like, I don't know, couldn't hurt. And there's like a weird feeling I have where, and I think it's partially, this is like, it's the American psychology to go from, we live very coddled, comfortable lives. You know, we, we have watched our sort of system of government informally change quite a bit over the last 10 years. And yet, you know, we still go out to dinner and we still kind of like, you know, you watch our programs and things like that. And so I do think we have in a lot of ways, a very coddled society. And then we have these things that are like, sort of sharp pins bursting our bubbles. And then people be like, but it's okay. And like, things kind of go back to normal. And in order to have like sustained change of public opinion about, you know, a technology that I think a lot of people think is going to be, you know, thinking deeply about it are terrified of, like you really have to kind of have a sustained drumbeat in the news. And I think politicians don't necessarily want to do that because like, you don't want to bum people out because you just ran a whole election about how you're going to make their lives better and like reduce gas prices, which is hard in and of itself. And so it becomes a sort of like, I don't know, like how do you get people to have the will to care about a complicated issue that, you know, might've already broken containment? Like, I mean that both as a metaphor, but literally. I think the difference between like, AI and most other issues is like, most things there is mean reversion, right? There is a spike in terrorist activity and then there's some natural force or enforcement actions that like curb that. These AI models are getting better at an exponential rate. I use them for advanced programming. And so this week we were doing little tweaks to our college basketball model. The first model work I've done since August with Flipper, basically. In, what is it, four months? This has gotten a lot faster. Fucking better, right? Like I am on this list of things that I thought would take five days. I got like most of those things done in one day. Like it's really, they're getting much smarter and faster and more persistent very quickly. And like, I don't know if you hit some plateau at some point or what, right? But like, you can't have like another magnitude of order increasing capabilities without the world profoundly changing. Yeah, I mentioned that if we're going to expect legislation to happen or movement in Washington or some sort of regulatory changes to happen, that it's going to be due to crisis. And you were like, how do we get Americans to focus their attention on this issue in a sustained way that might create that kind of environment? I did leave out that there's one other way for legislation to easily make it through, more easily make it through Washington, which is on issues that nobody's paying attention to or are not paying attention to. Or are too technical to capture the partisan imagination of talk show hosts and cable news hosts and all of that jazz, which is something more akin to the Chips and Science Act, which is it's technical, it's boring. Everyone kind of agrees that it needs to get done anyway. And even if it's a really big piece of legislation that does have major implications for industrial policy or national security or whatever, everyone just agrees and gets it through. Maybe it happens during a lame duck session even. I mean, the Chips and Science Act didn't, it did happen in a bipartisan way. And so if there is some sort, and I, you know, Trump is still at the top of all of this, but there is such a, you know, in order to override a veto, you need two thirds of the House and Senate. Who knows? Again, I don't want to turn this into West Wing fanfic, but I'm saying one way is crisis. The other way is keep it technical and boring and keep everyone in agreement. And there is overwhelming agreement in the negativity of the American public about AI. Yeah, truth, I mean, Democrats have, there's such large majorities to begin with, right? Like, I think two thirds majorities are extremely achievable with this Congress. And if I were Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer and or Chris Van Hollen, like the first thing I'd be doing is not, how am I going to investigate Trump? But like, what is not a showpiece legislation? What is actual legislation that we would like to pass about AI? Because it might actually get passed and it might survive a presidential veto. Still Counting is brought to you by Ethos. Galen. Claire. I am pushing up against 4D. I am. I just had a birthday. I mean, don't talk to me about getting older. Listen, we are, I would say, knocking on middle age's door if we are not already in the foyer. I think we might have a foot inside. I think we're inside. Anyway, middle age makes you think about a lot of serious stuff. You know, estate planning, home ownership, and life insurance. Sure thing. You got to start thinking about, you know. What's possible. What's possible. Exactly. Well put. And Ethos makes getting life insurance fast and easy. It's 100% online. You can get a quote in seconds, apply in minutes, and get same day coverage. There's no medical exam. You just answer a few simple health questions. You can get up to $3 million in coverage. Some policies are as low as $30 a month. Take 10 minutes to get covered today with life insurance through Ethos. Get your free quote at ethos.com/count. That's E-T-H-O-S dot com slash count. Application times may vary. Rates may vary. Crown Coins Casino. Winning never sounded so good. What would you do if you won big? At Crown Coins Casino, real people win real prizes every single day. Hi, this is Michael from Georgia. I won 40K and finally renovated my home. Visit crowncoins.com. Sign up in seconds, enter code CROWN, and get a free Lucky Wheel bonus. You may win up to 10,000 Sweeps coins. crowncoins.com. That's C-R-O-W-N coins.com. No purchase needed. Code valid for new users only. Void when prohibited by law. 18 plus terms and conditions apply. Crown Coins Casino. Okay, well, I think we should move on to, I think, a related topic. If we're being honest about the conversation that the American public is having, we had a, really weird past week of. modern life. The weirdness started with a global Microsoft outage last Thursday, and then the FAA obviously issued a nationwide ground stop on Friday, which lasted nearly five hours and resulted in the cancellation of over 12,000 flights. They initially blamed a router in Arkansas for the disruption, although investigations continue. On Monday, there were technical problems at the country's largest bank, JPMorgan Chase, which the bank said was related to a software bug. Then, CNN reported Tuesday that the National Security Agency's highly classified internal communications network, NASANet, NSANet, was down. CNN sources said that there's no evidence at this point of a cyber attack. There's no confirmed evidence that any of these incidents are related, but it is definitely unsettling. I have to be perfectly honest, my own, I don't think of myself as a tinfoil hat, but I was kind of like, I don't know, what's going on here? And I think that's true for a lot of us. We should also add that Apple Systems had issues on Tuesday. What's going on? Nate, you did watch the whole FAA press conference with Mark Wayne Mullen. No, look, at times of profound anxiety for the nation, to have capable, highly capable public servants like Sean Duffy and Mark Wayne Mullen, incredibly trustworthy answers they gave in that press conference on Friday night. No, they couldn't even get their story straight, right? Because Mark Wayne Mullen, Secretary Mullen, was at one point upon probing, like at first, Sean Duffy was just saying, well, there was too much pressure on the system. And sometimes, you know, we need more money. And give us $50 billion. And Trump is so great. We've been in touch with the President Trump. Give us $50 billion. And then Mark Wayne said, well, actually, Sean was installing some, new system. And well, sometimes you install a new system, and things don't go so well. And like, Sean Duffy, like, had the fucking stare from hell toward, I mean, it's a very funny moment. Some people say he physically bumped Secretary Mullen to try to take back the podium. But they have these contradictory stories. And an appearance later on, Sean Hannity, Secretary Mullen, then later speculated that, oh, well, maybe my friends in Silicon Valley, my friend in Silicon Valley, his name's not Elon Musk. Tells me that they are concerned about the capabilities of, of course, he's calling it fucking superintelligence. Like, talk about woke 2.0. It's called a fucking I. You sound like fucking Latinx if you're calling it superintelligence, right? Yeah, we should say that the Trump, they made this point to say, like, within the administration, we don't call it artificial intelligence. We call it SI, superintelligence. Obviously, going along with the acceleration, sort of like, raw rawness of the administration. When you're trying to communicate, here's the point. In a crisis, when you are trying to communicate clearly, you want to use simple, like, monosyllabic words that people, that people understand. And the basic first rule of crisis communication is explain what the fuck is going on, right? And somewhere, explain what the fuck's going on and tell people they're safe. And they did not explain what's going on. I mean, I watched, there had been a ground stop in 2023, I believe, when Transportation Secretary Mayor Pete Buttigieg was running the Transportation Department. And, you can watch his presser, and it's, like, simple and competent. And he seems like somebody who had command and control of the situation. Of course, there's spin, and he kind of low-key is lobbying for more funding, too. But, like, I mean, that press conference was extraordinary in some ways. That it just, and they're acting like, and the fact that they're, like, fucking praising Trump, like, like, Muammar Gaddafi's fucking press secretary or something, like, they just fucking lost a midterm by 14 points. Like, what the fuck are they, what the fuck are they doing? Get rid of all these fucking people, man. I'm serious. Well, I guess that comes right after Trump was like, don't start the investigations or impeachment past a hard-nosed, serious AI bill. So, which one is it, Nate? No, I think in the spirit of explaining to people what is going on, what Mark Wayne Mullen was suggesting is that with these newer systems going into place, whatever they are doing, the compute, sort of the way that they as a piecemeal new system goes into place, it fucks up the old system. And the other piece of this in terms of outages elsewhere, I think what Mark Wayne Mullen might have been saying is that someone in Silicon Valley told him is that as these different companies are using AI to probe their vulnerabilities, and then also, like, patch their vulnerabilities, they're seeing some outages go down. And so, part of this whole process, it might not be a full-on cyber attack. It may be actually updating systems, but in a way where, like, AI is playing a significant role in the role, is ideally finding vulnerabilities, patching them, but in a way that, like, marrying a new system with an old system creates problems. Did I do an okay job of explaining that, Nate? No, yeah, Galen, there is a coherent story here, right? When we apply a patch to Flipper, sometimes it fucks something up elsewhere in Flipper, or you encounter new conditions, right? You know, Friday afternoons are among the busier time for travel, by the way. It's cyclical by week, and so that is a relatively high-stress time, kind of more like rush hour. There is a relatively coherent story here. I just think it was kind of offensive that, like, Sean Duffy, Mullen was better than Duffy, but, like, Duffy didn't feel like he owed the people a clear explanation, right? That he wanted to make a political speech and lobby for fundraising. No, you get more money when you do your fucking job, right? When you're able to explain what the fuck is going on. And by the way, the other kind of pregnant question is, like, okay, if you don't know what the fuck is going on, then how can you assure Americans that it's safe to fly right now, right? That's another challenge. We say about an hour before I head to the airport. Well, Duffy has gotten that, I mean, he's gotten that question a lot this week from reporters in different forums, right? Where they're saying, like, you've told us that the system is rickety, but you're also telling us it's safe to fly. How do those two things, you know, how do we hold those at the same time? To me, they're two different sort of government politics stories going on. On the one hand, it's like Americans have, you know, we talk about this a ton. Like, we're always citing these Gallup figures of, like, nose-diving institutional trust across the board, like in all areas of government. And this sort of feels like, you know, the incompetence of figures sort of only increases that distrust. And then if we believe the story, the official story, right, which is like software patches, yada, yada, yada, and we see, like, this system-wide, nationwide thing across banking systems, across government, you know, it speaks to and I think people sort of are saying, listen, because AI, as Nate was just saying, is growing exponentially, it also means that we are seeing, you know, when people probe systems for vulnerabilities, we're getting better at finding vulnerabilities. Maybe there are other things going on. Like, maybe there are, like, I'm just raising this, right? Like, maybe there are, you know, actors who are trying to penetrate certain systems and whatever. But it kind of speaks to, are we as a country, a government prepared for, infrastructure-wise, is our technological infrastructure prepared for this sort of accelerated moment? Like, I think that that's, aside from the institutional trust side, to me, that's the question that's on my mind as I'm watching the past week of news. No, I mean, these models are very fast and very persistent, and they don't need breaks like human coders do. And they kind of, to some degree, have minds of their own. I don't mean that in any existential sense, right? But, like, they're kind of trained to be creative about solving problems, and they get rewarded for that. And, you know, and that is what powers model capabilities. And, like, yeah, no, like, legacy systems were not built with systems like these in mind. I mean, there are also whole problems with, like, cryptography, and I don't, you know, I don't, that's not my beat, exactly. I don't understand that stuff as well. But we haven't, like, there's not a good precedent for a technology that's been for this fast and this broadly. It's not easy to put it in a self-contained box. Yeah, when I think about the politics of this, the charts that you mentioned come to mind, where it's, like, trust in every single institution, whether it's the judiciary, legislative branch, executive branch, you know, all different kinds of institutions in American life, you just see nosedive. And I would say that Republicans have been, I mean, especially starting the party era and the Trump era, more receptive to these ideas that, like, everything is broken, it can't be trusted. I mean, let's be clear, like, yes, we can talk about liberal bias in the media that is real and not imagined and whatever in the 20-teens and when Trump came on the scene and whatnot. But, like, there is more of a sort of distrust in institutions on the right than on the left. We're now in a moment where some of the people who are more, and part of this plays into the more populist your coalition is. The more distrusting or conspiratorially minded it might be, because if you look at the sort of social science research of conspiracy theories, people who have very little social power, cultural power, and sort of don't have touch points to the institutions that exist, want to explain sort of why the way that the world is working, but can't rely on these sort of institutions to do it. And so come up with different explanations. And also, believing in a is your own form of power. I know the answer to that. to this, right? They're not telling me the answer. I know it. I know the truth. I've done my research. The earth is flat or whatever. We are also, I mean, Democrats are making inroads in a populist way. So they're probably winning back over some of the more conspiratorially minded people with the Epstein-Files arguments and all of that type stuff. And I'm not saying every conspiracy theory is wrong. I'm saying it's a theory until it's actually proven to be a conspiracy. But you're also seeing now, especially because Trump is the one heading up and Republicans, Mark Wayne Mullen, Sean Duffy, all of these people are heading up government in a moment like this. You're seeing also trust amongst people who have been more inclined to trust institutions. You're seeing that fall off a cliff too. And you see in like, you know, left-wing corners of Twitter and the internet and whatever, in addition to right-wing corners of the internet, you know, Carolyn Leavitt on Fox News was like, what the fuck is going on here? You know, Trump's got to come back, from China and explain this all to us. You see people like stock up on everything. The world is ending. There's going to be some kind of emergency declaration. Like I hear this from my friends, you know, like, I don't want to be like profile people, but like college educated people who work in law and finance or whatever, you know, I have, I have working class friends as well. I'm not, you know, I don't have all fancy friends, but like people who you'd think of being like the more trust the institution types. Sure. Being like you said, like I went out to Costco and got water. Like people are really sort of, they feel like the world is out of control. They don't have the power to sort of make sense of it. And it, there is a sort of a closing inwards and a building of conspiracy theories. And what's interesting about that is obviously we talk a lot on this podcast about like, it's a little bit of a populist moment. I feel like I am often the person when we're talking about like, who's going to win the nomination? We'll say like, you know, you have to be able to break through a media environment. Like it's very, like the image is very important, but you also can't help but think how you could make the entirely opposite argument that like, maybe now this time of like fundamental breakage in law and sort of, you know, informal institutions, like you kind of need a technocrat, right. Which could be an argument for like a governor, right. Or, or someone completely different. But there does seem to be, you know, you see Mark Carney in Canada, who's kind of like an unlikely sort of like, you know, what did he call it? The sort of middle, middle countries, the rebellion of the middle countries against the superpowers. Like he's a kind of technocratic, boring banker type that has, I think, cut through a lot of noise and part on the strength of being a technocratic kind of boring, we got to change stuff person. You know, it's like a weird combination, but I do find myself making the counter argument to like, okay, in a populist moment, in a massive media environment, you need someone who will break through. On the other hand, it does also seem to be a moment for people who actually know how to do things and like solve complicated problems, which as Americans, we seem to place less and less emphasis on as our problems get more and more complicated. Claire, I think you made a such, such an important point. And from 10 years of working more than 10 years of working with Nate, one lesson I have learned repeatedly is sometimes when you think a trend is about to reach its ultimate conclusion, the apex exaggerated moment of its trend, things zig when you expect them to zag. And so I do wonder after a decade of pop you slop, like populism slop, whatever, we're like, people can just say anything. They can spend any amount of money. Nobody believes the data, the economic, the laws of the, of economics have been suspended. The laws of politics have been suspended. At a certain point, you spend so much money, you sort of make the, the populace unhappy in so many different ways. You're so corrupt, whatever, like, and the pop you slop has reached, you know, both parties. Like I think, the Biden era was not like a technocratic era of governance, um, that maybe someone zigs where everyone is zagging and you do get a technocrat. Like, I don't say that because like, that's what I want or that's what I think successful politics would look like in 2026 necessarily. But I'm just saying like, in a moment like this, maybe like you don't always get the logical conclusion of the trend. Sometimes you get a reversion to the mean. I think that is what's actually just a quick point on this is like, when I talk to people in the past couple of weeks of like the post midterm, you hear lots of different ideas about who should be the nominee, what's going to happen. And it is, I genuinely have no idea which direction the country is going to go as far as like who they're going to nominate in the next couple of years. JD Vance obviously seems to be like, maybe I think he'll probably ultimately run, but maybe he's reconsidering his run. Um, there is this real feel it of like feeling of, Oh, things are actually fluid in a way that I think it is often not fluid in the end. I mean, I don't know if it's, I don't know if it's in the United States political system. Yeah. Look, if people don't know what the fuck is going on, right, they're going to want people who can provide answers to that question. And there are maybe good ways to provide those answers and demagogic ways to provide those answers to, um, you know, maybe the right quote unquote kind of populism is some of both that, yeah, obviously we need to more, much more greatly by orders of magnitude, regulate AI and some other industries in Silicon Valley. Right. Um, but you know, I don't know that America can wait two years for AI regulation. Maybe there's a natural pause because, um, of the backlash to data centers and chips and, and maybe, you know, I mean, it's weird, you know, I mean, an AI, the AI bubble for various reasons, I think bubble is not quite the right term, but for shorthand, we're an hour plus into the episode, right? You know, I'm like, well, that'd be fucking bad for my stock portfolio if the AI bubble burst, but I'm almost like rooting for it because that might force some degree of a pause. Um, and that seems kind of, kind of fucked up. I don't know. I mean, you talked about zigging and zagging. I mean, it probably is true that like right now there are probably a fair number of false positives about, there are lots of things that don't quite work every day, outages and things are out for 20 minutes and they come back online. Right. Like right now, um, there's probably a cluster of people, you know, kind of seeing shapes in the clouds a little bit, but at the same time, they're trying to make it super intelligent, right? They are trying to make this all powerful technology and nobody's interested in stopping it. It's fucking insane. You know, we're trying to get on the show, Pope Leo. So, uh, hopefully, hopefully, hopefully, those bookers will get back in touch with us and we'll have Leo baby on the podcast soon to talk about all of this. Okay. Uh, that is it for today's episode of still counting. Listen, wherever you get your podcasts and subscribe on youtube.com slash at still counting podcast. We'll be back next Wednesday evening with another episode. I never sounded so good. What would you do if you want big at crown coins casino? Real people win real prices every single day. Hi, this is Michael from Dallas and I won 40 K and finally renovated my home. Visit crown coins.com. Sign up in seconds, enter code crown and get a free lucky wheel bonus. You may win up to 10,000 sweeps coins crown coins.com. That's C R O W N coins.com. No purchase needed. Void were prohibited by law. 18 plus terms and conditions apply.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Democratic leaders are facing internal division, with Hakeem Jeffries gaining support over Chuck Schumer due to better favorability ratings and a more activist stance.
  2. Schumer’s leadership is under pressure, with younger Democrats and progressive factions pushing for generational change, though betting markets suggest he may retain his position.
  3. The Democratic party’s internal dynamics reflect a strategic negotiation where members seek leverage, not just ideological alignment, especially on issues like AI and data centers.
  4. NVIDIA’s ties to China, including alleged chip smuggling and data center loopholes, raise serious national security concerns and suggest possible collusion with U.S. policy bypasses.
  5. The story of Jensen Huang and Alice Wong is intertwined with broader political betrayals, particularly Trump’s alignment with China, undermining his core anti-China messaging.
  6. The tech industry’s lack of political sophistication—especially in loyalty to leaders—raises concerns about long-term national security and corporate accountability.
  7. Public skepticism about AI and data centers may be driven more by fear and media cycles than by deep-rooted policy concerns, making sustained legislative action difficult.
  8. A potential AI crisis in the near future—triggered by system outages or public fear—could force bipartisan action, but current political dynamics and media patterns make sustained public awareness unlikely.

Summary:

The episode explores the intersection of political dynamics and technological upheaval, focusing on the internal struggles within the Democratic Party over leadership succession and the widening national debate on AI and national security. Hakeem Jeffries is emerging as a strong alternative to Chuck Schumer, supported by better public approval and a more activist approach, while Schumer faces backlash over his handling of the government shutdown and perceived lack of modern relevance. S.

export controls. This is compounded by the broader political context: Donald Trump’s recent embrace of China, including a symbolic hug with President Xi Jinping, appears to betray his long-standing skepticism of China—a key pillar of his political platform. This creates a narrative of political betrayal and cronyism, fueling public distrust in both corporate leaders and political figures.

The episode also highlights the tech industry’s lack of political maturity, with leaders like Huang and Elon Musk failing to demonstrate strategic or ethical leadership. Despite the urgency, public concern over AI remains fragmented, driven more by media cycles than deep policy anxiety. The writers suggest that significant legislative action on AI regulation—like a national "hard stop" or data center moratorium—is unlikely without a genuine crisis, such as widespread system failures or public panic.

While AI is advancing rapidly, with tools like Flipper improving modeling efficiency, the political and institutional mechanisms to regulate it remain slow and fragmented. S. may be in a period of political and technological instability, where short-term media shocks—like aviation or banking outages—could spark broader public concern, but sustained policy change is still distant.

FAQs

Democrats are experiencing heightened internal conflict after the midterms, with growing pressure on current leaders like Chuck Schumer. Younger, more progressive members like Hakeem Jeffries are gaining traction, and there's a push for generational change and leadership reform.

Schumer faces significant opposition due to his low favorability ratings among Democrats and his role in the 2022 government shutdown. Critics argue he is out of touch, while others believe he may benefit from a strategic exit plan to elevate new leaders and create succession pathways.

Hakeem Jeffries has significantly higher favorability ratings among Democrats—56%—compared to Schumer's 75%, and his more activist stance on issues like AI and data centers has strengthened his appeal with progressive voters.

The progressive bloc, now numbering over 100 members, represents a growing influence within the party. However, it's still too small to effectively block legislation, and the party's larger moderate base, like the blue dog Democrats, remains a key stabilizing force.

Allegations suggest Jensen Huang had an affair with Alice Wong, a suspected Chinese spy, and that NVIDIA may have helped circumvent U.S. export controls by enabling data centers in Southeast Asia to serve Chinese AI models, raising national security concerns.

There are concerns that the Department of Commerce’s investigation into Megaspeed was quietly transferred, and that NVIDIA lobbying and business relationships may have created a conflict of interest, potentially undermining U.S. export controls on AI chips.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.