Go back

Teacher Shot By Her 6 Year Old Student

47m 41s

Teacher Shot By Her 6 Year Old Student

In January 2023, a six-year-old student at Rich Neck Elementary School, James, brought a loaded gun to class and shot his teacher, Abby Zwerner, during a first-grade lesson. James had a history of violent and disruptive behavior, including physical aggression and inappropriate actions, rooted in a toxic home environment where his parents used marijuana, engaged in domestic abuse, and kept a loaded gun accessible. The school system failed multiple times: its entry system was broken for weeks, no lockdown drills were conducted, and classroom doors were missing or unlocked. Despite multiple staff members reporting the threat—first to the assistant principal, Dr. Ebony Parker, who dismissed concerns—no action was taken. A student revealed the gun in James’s jacket, prompting a chaotic but timely response. Abby, despite being shot in the chest and nearly losing her life, managed to evacuate her 16 students before seeking help. She later faced a civil lawsuit against the school administration, which resulted in a $10 million verdict, though the case is still being appealed. Dr. Parker was found grossly negligent and charged with child neglect, though the charges were ultimately dismissed. James’s mother was convicted on multiple counts and sentenced to prison. James was removed from his mother’s care and placed with a retired army drill sergeant, where he is reported to be improving. The incident exposed deep failures in school safety, reporting protocols, and child protection, especially in homes where guns are improperly stored. Despite the trauma on both victims and witnesses, systemic changes—including locked classroom doors, metal detectors, and mandatory parental supervision—were implemented. The case underscores the urgent need for better policies, early intervention, and mandatory reporting of child abuse and gun hazards in homes.

Transcription

7301 Words, 40333 Characters

English
No one ever wants to think that when you send your child off to school that they could be in any danger. That someone might show up to your child's school with a weapon and intent to harm. But what if it was your child on the opposite end of that gun? What if your child brought a gun to their school and shot their teacher? And what if that child was only six years old? Where is the weapon? It's on the floor. It's over there. Stop. That's not how we speak to each other. What's your name? If you want a piece of me, come get it. I don't care if you call back up, I don't care if I go to jail. This is a truly unbelievable case and one that, in my opinion, was 100% preventable. I am so interested to hear all of your thoughts on the 23rd. This is the 2023 Rich Neck Elementary School shooting of Abby Zwerner. My name is Brianna and I'm hot on the case. Make this your most rewarding season ever with FanDuel. Age and location restrictions apply. Product availability varies by market. See FanDuel.com for eligibility. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Hi, I'm Karen Slaughter. If you love untangling mysteries and uncovering the truth behind what really happened, I think you'll love The Good Daughter. Now my best-selling novel is finally coming to life and I got to write every episode. You should have died in them woods. Your father should have been a better shot. Starring Rose Byrne, Megan Fahey, and Brendan Gleeson. From page to screen, don't miss The Good Daughter, now streaming only on Peacock. I'm here, Charlie, and I'm not going away. 25-year-old Abby Zwerner always knew that she wanted to be a teacher. Abby grew up in a family of teachers. Her mother was a teacher, so that love and passion for teaching was instilled in Abby early on. In 2020, Abby graduated from James Madison University with a bachelor's and a master's degree in education. She started her career teaching fourth grade online due to the pandemic before transitioning to teaching first grade at Rich Neck Elementary School in Newport News, Virginia. Abby was extremely passionate and enthusiastic about her class and her students. She just put in a lot of effort and spent a lot of really late nights grading, lesson planning, and trying to find new and exciting things to do with her students. She was a teacher, and she was a teacher, and she was a teacher, and she was a teacher, and she was a teacher, and she was a teacher. You could really tell that Abby was the kind of teacher that truly loved her job. In my opinion, teaching is one of those careers where it's really easy to tell who has genuine love and passion for the work that they are doing. I'm sure each of us that went to public and private school can remember growing up and having teachers where you could just tell that they really, really cared about what they were doing. Unfortunately, it has been alleged that possibly the school district and Rich Neck Elementary School administration did not share the same love and care for the students. Going into the incident in this case, the buzzer for the elementary school that let people inside the building had been broken for several weeks with no plan to have it repaired. Additionally, in the last two years, the school officials failed, allegedly, to perform mandatory lockdown drills. Drills that were put in place to practice what the school, the staff, and the students would all do. In the fall of 2022, Abby Zwerner was 25 years old and also entering her third year teaching first grade at Rich Neck Elementary School. And this year, amongst the students in her first grade class was one extremely challenging and disruptive six-year-old boy. This boy's identity has not been released to the public, so for the sake of this episode, we are going to refer to him as James. James not only really struggled academically, but he also showed a lot of very serious and concerning behaviors. James very quickly developed a reputation throughout school, despite only being in the first grade, for swearing at school staff and other students. James also displayed a lot of violence at school. He would get very frustrated and angry anytime that he didn't get a lesson or anytime he was being disciplined. And he would express his frustration and anger with violence by kicking, punching, pushing, spitting on his teachers. There was one extremely concerning incident, I believe it happened the year prior while James was in kindergarten, when he came up behind his teacher and started to strangle them with his hands. There were also plenty of reports of James being physical with some of the other students. There was one extremely concerning report where a girl fell down at recess and James came up and started to touch her inappropriately. There were also multiple incidents where at recess, James would take his belt off and then start chasing the other students, trying to whip them with his belt. You have to remember that in 2022, 2023, he's only six years old, okay? Six. And a lot of these incidents started even when he was in kindergarten and pre-K. Documented disciplinary incidents, some involving violence, actually kept James out of school for much of kindergarten and pre-K. So, James was a very, very, very, very, very, very, kindergarten, and pre-K. And of course, you have to wonder when you have a child that is using this kind of language and displaying these kinds of behaviors, what exactly is going on at home? I mean, children just don't do this. I actually have a nephew the exact same age as this child. He doesn't do this. Children aren't even aware of these behaviors unless they see it. Children often mimic what they see and what they hear. So exactly what was going on at home? Why is this child violent? Why is this child cursing? And why is this child trying to grope other students? Just for the record, I'm not trying to actually accuse anyone of doing anything, but these are just the questions that come to my mind while I'm researching this case. The fact that a six-year-old, or potentially even a four or five-year-old, depending on how old he was when this was actually happening, is taking off his belt and trying to whip other children with it is a huge red flag to me. Because that act, taking off your belt and whipping someone with it, is a very well-known quote-unquote old-school form of disciplining a child. So this is very clearly behavior that he saw somewhere. And I would be very interested to know if the school even tried to get help for this child outside of what the school itself was actually capable of. The school and its staff are all mandatory reporters, meaning legally. If there is reasonable cause to suspect a child is experiencing abuse, neglect, or immediate danger, they are legally required to report this. And I'm not just saying report this to the principal or the superintendent. You are meant to report this much higher. I'm talking like CPS. But as far as I can tell from the limited information that is out there, it does not seem that they at least thought that there was. So I don't know. I seriously doubt if these behaviors were addressed any higher than the school itself. But I know that the school was at least trying to get James's parents involved. Very early on into the 2022-2023 school year, it was required by the school that James was accompanied to school every single day with one of his parents. And this was usually the mother, Deja Taylor. And this was done to try and ensure that he wouldn't act out. So let's quickly discuss a little bit that we do know of what James's home life was like. James's parents were 26-year-old Malik Ellison and 25-year-old Deja Taylor. They had James when they were pretty young. Malik would have been 20 years old and Deja would have been only 19. And although they were never married, the two were still very much in a romantic relationship when James ended up getting married to Malik. So they were still in a romantic relationship. Abbey's first grade class. Very little is actually known about James's parents and what his home life was like. But the little that we do know is very alarming. James's mother, Deja, was a marijuana user. And unfortunately, even at six years old, James was aware of what weed was. Reportedly at school, James would tell his fellow students, his fellow classmates, that he would smoke his mother's weed. Now, whether or not you believe this or you think that this is just a child lying to get attention, I don't know. But I do think that James was aware of what weed was. And I do think that it's extremely concerning. On two incidents that we are aware of, James went into his mother's purse, stole her car keys, and then locked himself in his mother's car. On the first incident, the police had to be called and they actually had to break one of the car windows to get the boy out. And the second time, James was only five years old when he actually started driving the car and then crashed the car into parked cars that were parked on his street. Luckily, in that incident, absolutely no one was hurt, but one, does a five-year-old even reach the gas pedals? And two, how does something like that even happen twice? After the first time that your child steals your car keys and locks himself into your car and police have to be called to bust your windows to get him out, how does something like that even happen again? How does your child have enough time to get your keys again, even have access to your keys again, and have the time to get back outside and into your car with no one seeing? There are also reports of violence coming from both of James's parents. The boy's father, Malik, had a criminal record that involved prior incidents of domestic violence, not only towards his mother, Deja, but towards another woman. And then, only two weeks before the incident of this case, James's mother, Deja, suspected that Malik was cheating on her. She found Malik in a U-Haul truck that she actually rented with another woman. So she took out her gun, her nine millimeter handgun, and opened fire on her son's father. Again, luckily, in this incident, no one was hurt. And unfortunately, the police were not called. The U-Haul was never returned, and when it was later recovered, the passenger seat back window was completely shattered from multiple bullets. This is just a small window looking into what life was like for six-year-old James at home. Like previously mentioned, because of his behavior at school, six-year-old James was required to be accompanied to school every single day by his mother. Well, right before the school let out for its winter holiday break, the school staff actually believed that James had improved enough that his mother was no longer required to attend school with him. And the next week that James was back in class, the first week that he attended school without his mother with him, is when the event of this case took place. FanDuel is now available everywhere in the U.S. So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are, including these places. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Now my best-selling novel is finally coming to life, and I got to write every episode. Students returned to school after the winter break shortly after the new year. And immediately, back at school without his mother there, James started to act out again. On January 4th, 2023, during class, James took Abby's cell phone off of her desk and smashed it onto the ground, breaking it. For this, James was sent home early, and he also had a one-day suspension on top of that. And when the six-year-old returned to school on January 6th, 2023, he returned with a gun. Seven months prior, James's mother, Deja, bought this gun. A nine-millimeter handgun that she kept loaded in her purse at all times. The same gun that only two weeks earlier, she used to try and shoot James's father and his suspected mistress. The fact that Deja kept a loaded gun in her purse was something that, unfortunately, her six-year-old child was aware of. Because on the morning of January 6th, 2023, before leaving for school, James, angry and frustrated that he kept getting in trouble at school, went into his mother's bedroom and retrieved his mother's purse that was on top of her dresser and took out his mother's gun. He then hid the pistol away in his backpack and left for school. It was like the calm before the storm. Because many believed that that morning, James was actually having a really good day. But as the day went on, his behavior just got worse and worse. It was still early in the school day, only about 11.15 in the morning, when Abby Zwirner left her class and headed down to the office to speak with the AP, the assistant principal, Dr. Ebony Parker, who all disciplinary reports had to go through. Abby told Dr. Parker about James's behavior that day and how she did not think that he was ready to be back in school without his mother. But reportedly, Dr. Parker didn't even acknowledge Abby at all. She didn't say a single word to her or even bothered to look up from her computer. Now, apparently, Dr. Parker, although responsible for all of the disciplinary reports, was known to be quite dismissive when teachers came to her with reports with their concerns. But it wasn't until Abby gave up and went back to her class that Dr. Parker told the reading and learning specialist, Mrs. Amy Kovach, that she could go walk down to Abby's classroom and tell Abby that she could call James's mother and tell his mother, Deja, to come and pick up her son early. Mrs. Kovach was already very familiar with James. James really struggled with reading, and as the reading and learning specialist, the two had many one-on-one sessions together. So as Mrs. Kovach is walking to Abby's classroom, classroom 11, to tell Abby that she can call Deja and tell Deja to come pick up James early, Mrs. Kovach is stopped in the hallway by two very young female students that looked very visibly upset. And these two young girls told Mrs. Kovach that James brought a gun to school. Mrs. Kovach was already really close to him, so she still entered classroom 11, and she went and sat down right next to James. She told James what she heard and asked if she could check his backpack. But he allegedly refused and told Mrs. Kovach that no one was going to be looking through his bag. Not to cause any panic to James or the other students in his class, Mrs. Kovach just calmly sat down next to James for the entire lesson. This was now around 1230, which was recess for Abby's classroom. And book bags were not allowed out at recess. So Mrs. Kovach took this opportunity to head back down to the office and speak to the assistant principal, Dr. Parker, about what she heard. That one of the students, James, had brought a gun to school. And somehow, the assistant principal of this elementary school allegedly did not seem concerned at all. She actually, apparently, told Mrs. Kovach to just worry about her own workload and not concern herself. She told Mrs. Kovach that somebody would go check James' bag eventually, like there was no urgency at all. And even though she was just told not to concern herself, Mrs. Kovach still went back to Abby's classroom. And with Abby's class all in recess, she filled in Abby about what she heard. Mrs. Kovach also took this opportunity to go through James' backpack. But there was no gun. Could this have possibly been a gun? Could this have been a gun? Could this have possibly been just a false alarm? Well, that's when Abby told Mrs. Kovach that before heading off to recess, James actually went into his book bag and took something out of it and put it in his jacket. The two women then rushed out to recess, but were happy to see that everything was absolutely fine outside. But they did see that James was hiding behind what has been described as a rock wall. He was with another boy from another class. And James appeared to be showing this boy something. So once again, Mrs. Kovach returned to Dr. Ebony Parker's office and she asked permission to search James. Like physically search James' person. Like pat him down. But allegedly, Dr. Ebony Parker said no. The student that James was seen showing something to at recess was a student in another teacher's class. Teacher Jennifer West's classroom. So Abby told Jennifer what was potentially going on as all of their students were heading back in from recess. So Jennifer took her student aside and asked him, what did James show you at recess? And this little boy just started to hysterically cry. And he told his teacher that James showed him a gun and threatened to kill him if he told anyone about it. Jennifer immediately called the office and the phone in the office was picked up by another teacher named John Simms. Jennifer filled John in about what was going on. And then John passed on the report to the assistant principal, Dr. Parker, who once again, allegedly dismissed the teacher saying that James's backpack had already been searched and nothing was found. Well, no, duh. You have a little boy in his classroom hysterically crying because he's saying that James showed him a gun. The gun is in his jacket. He showed him the gun and threatened to murder him with said gun. So why would the gun be in the kid's backpack? Now, because Jennifer has a little boy hysterically crying in her classroom, she calls the schools. guidance counselor Rolanzo Rawls to come and help console this child and while Rolanzo was there in Jennifer's classroom she also fills him in with what is going on that another student a first grader a six-year-old probably has a gun so then the guidance counselor Rolanzo heads back down to the office and now there's Rolanzo Rawls and John Sims both in Dr. Ebony Parker's office and they're asking her questions why is nothing going on why has this child not been packed down and searched why are we all just sitting here doing nothing when there is a gun in the school now mind you this is now the fifth school staff member that has heard that there's a gun in a school and has gone to the assistant principal Dr. Ebony Parker's office and has told her that there's a gun in an elementary school filled with elementary school students and allegedly Dr. Ebony Parker still doesn't do anything she doesn't seem concerned all she said was that the boy's mother was already on the way to come pick him up and when she got there they would figure out what was going on but Deja never came to pick up her son early James was actually already on a modified schedule where his mother would pick him up early from school every day at 2 30 but by the time 2 30 came along it would already be too late so while all of this is still going on Abby Zwirner still has a job to do she is only 25 years old three years into her teaching career and she has to put on a brave face and try and teach the other 16 other students in her class like nothing is wrong she obviously doesn't want to alarm James if James thinks that people know what's going on he might act and Abby also of course doesn't want to worry and panic the other students in her class so Abby is just reading to her class like normal and then around 2 p.m while Abby is reading to her class six-year-old James stands up without hesitation pulls out a gun from his jacket completely unprovoked it's not like he was being talked to in that moment or being disciplined he just takes out his gun points it at his teacher Abby and with no hesitation pulls the trigger FanDuel is now available everywhere in the U.S. so you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are including these places make this your most rewarding season ever with FanDuel age and location restrictions apply product availability varies by market see FanDuel.com for eligibility gambling problem call 1-800-GAMBLER hi I'm Karen Slaughter if you love untangling mysteries and uncovering the truth behind what really happened I think you'll love The Good Daughter now my best-selling novel is finally coming to life and I got to write every episode you should have died in them woods your father should have been a better shot starring Rose Byrne, Megan Fahey, and Brendan Gleeson from page to screen don't miss The Good Daughter now streaming only on Peacock I'm here Charlie and I'm not going away instinctly Abby who sees a gun being aimed at her puts her hands up to try and defend herself to try and shield herself the single bullet tore through Abby's left hand and shot directly into the middle of her chest missing her heart by an inch or two despite being shot in the chest a bullet nearly missing her heart and nearly missing her spine Abby still manages to get the other 16 first grade students out of her classroom into safety before she even tries to leave the classroom herself to get herself help Abby then profusely bleeding stumbles all the way to the school office before collapsing to the ground meanwhile Mrs. Kovac who has known for hours that there's a gun in the school and has been trying to get it out of the classroom has been trying to get it out of the classroom to get somebody to take that seriously here's the sound of a gunshot coming from Abby's classroom and she bravely runs to that classroom the moment on January 6 that a gunshot has happened do you recall that moment yes okay and what was your first thought and what did you do my first thought I was he had a gun he shot it and I walked in that room I could not even imagine what was going on in Mrs. Kovac head in that moment she has tried so many times to get the administration to take seriously that there's a gun in school it's probably been on her mind the entire day there's probably nothing else on her mind the entire day and then to actually hear the sound of that gun go off must have been terrifying but bravely almost unbelievably brave Mrs. Kovac runs into Abby's classroom at that point the only person in that classroom was little six-year-old James and the gun was on the floor she wrapped up the boy in her arms and then called 9-1-1 the rest of the school after hearing the sound of a gun go off had already gone into lockdown but unfortunately for some reason especially in this day and age Richneck Elementary School did not have a door on every single classroom not even a door that didn't lock or didn't close all the way some of these classrooms didn't even have a door period meaning if James or some other intruder wanted to wander the hallways and find a classroom to go in there were plenty of classrooms where the teacher and all of the students wouldn't have been able to lock themselves inside also just unbelievable as you remember from the beginning of this episode the buzzer system that let people into the school was broken and had been broken at this point for several weeks so you couldn't just easily buzz someone into the building you would have to physically go and unlock the door to let anyone inside first responders arrived like two minutes after the 9-1-1 call was made but because the buzzer system was broken the door was locked and the entire school was on lockdown it actually took several crucial minutes for a janitor to see that there was police and first responding paramedics outside and he went and let them in very recently some of the body cam footage from one of the police officers that entered Abby's classroom and spoke to James has been released now obviously James's face is blurred to protect his identity but you can very clearly see that this is a very small child Mrs. Kovac is sitting at Abby's desk and it appears that she has James wrapped up in her arms and sitting on her lap and James is just so tiny he almost looks like a doll he's so small but the words that are coming out of his mouth he's cursing at these police officers he's swearing like a sailor it's very very disturbing to see and hear I'm actually going to play the body cam footage for you now but it is just you know absolutely shocking this is a six-year-old that has just pulled out a gun and shot his teacher he just admitted that he had one all right I got a weapon he had one bullet stop all right let's leave the gun there okay I told the AP that there was a threat earlier about it last year he is six years old he has been on a modified schedule his mother is to pick him up at 2:30 this is his first week without his mother coming to school with him 13:46 myself and 23:47 and the sheriff's deputy are inside room 11 with the suspect gun is secure and I called 911 when I heard this I'm the radio specialist I came down the hall she had blood We got some small handcuffs. Where's the A-pile? It's over here on the floor. Okay. Um, you two stay here. Yeah, we got it. You can stay for now, if you feel comfortable. Is he okay? He's fine. When you shot the gun, did anything hurt you? No. Let me see your hands. Where is the weapon? - All right. - It's on the floor. - It's over there, boy. - Stop. That's not. - This is. - His, I mean, he does have the gun residue, it looks like. - Okay. Let's just not touch his hands or anything, okay? - Yeah. - All right. How old is he? My mom had that. Six years old. Yes. I stole that from my mom. Okay buddy. What's your name? If you want a piece of me, come get it on me. Your name? It's his mom's disposal. I don't care if you call backup. I don't care if I go to jail. Okay buddy. We know you know that language. And you know that's not right. and you know that's not appropriate. Mrs. Kovac's not happy with that. Now at the very end of this body cam footage that has been released, I'll play it again for you very shortly, right as the officer whose body cam we are seeing is putting up his hand, he blocks the view, but you can hear the sound of a hit sound, like a hit, and that is actually the sound of six-year-old James punching Mrs. Kovac in the face. I'll play it again for you right here. You can hear it. And then of course, after shooting a teacher and now punching a teacher in the face in front of multiple police officers, James is taken away by the police officers. The fallout after the was swift. The superintendent of the district was voted out from his position. And then the principal at Richneck Elementary School, was removed from her position at Richneck and was reassigned elsewhere in the district. And then the assistant principal, Dr. Ebony Parker, well she resigned from her position. And all of this happened in very quick succession. I'm absolutely interested to know, although I'm pretty sure we will never find out, but do you think that Dr. Ebony Parker resigned from her position and that was her own choice? Or was this one of those situations where officially she's the one that left but she really didn't have a choice. When paramedics arrived to help Abby Zwirner, she was not in a stable condition and her wounds were definitely considered life-threatening. She was rushed to the hospital. She would spend two weeks in the intensive care unit and would undergo six separate surgeries. The pain that she went through was immense. Her left hand will never be fully functioning. There's bullet fragments that were two centimeters away from her aorta. It would have killed her and because it's so close to her aorta, the decision was actually made to leave part of the bullet inside of Abby's chest and it is still there to this day. But Abby Zwirner survived. Not only will Abby Zwirner have long lasting physical trauma, but the mental and emotional trauma. Bo's wounds definitely ran extremely deep. She loved working with children and now she doesn't know if she'll ever work with children ever again. Her life and her career were forever changed. Shortly after the shooting, Abby also left her position as a teacher from Richneck Elementary School. And she doesn't think she'll ever return to teaching. Also, following the shooting, Richneck Elementary School closed for several weeks. Like I previously said, Richneck Elementary School did not have a door on every single classroom. So while the school was closed, they took that time to give classroom doors. They also fixed the buzzer system. Security was hired for the school, and now every single entrance had a metal detector. Abby's old classroom was also repainted for the reopening, thinking that that would be enough to cover up all the damage and trauma and horrors those 16 first grade students saw in that classroom that day. When the school reopened on January 30th, 2023, along with the security officers and the metal detectors, students were now also required to use see-through backpacks. And upon reopening, parents were encouraged, if they were able to, to walk their children to their classroom and also therapy dogs were brought into the school. I feel like it is so overlooked in this case. I literally didn't see anyone else talking about it, but there were 16 other students in class. Sixteen six and seven year olds that witnessed their classmate take out a gun and only a few feet away from their faces shot their teacher in the chest. They witnessed blood pouring out of their teacher's chest. That is just an image that I feel like gets ingrained into a child's mind and I truly truly hope that each of those children are getting the help that they are that they desperately need very likely and that that trauma has not been overlooked for any of them at home. Because of Virginia state law that prohibits any child under the age of seven being criminally charged with a crime of this nature, James was never criminally charged. A lot of people have different feelings about that. Please let me know all of your thoughts in the comments if you are watching on YouTube or listening on Spotify. After the shooting, James was removed from his mother's custody. He is now living with his great-grandfather, Calvin Taylor. And I actually read that Calvin is a retired army drill sergeant. So if James is going to be anywhere, I think that's a pretty good place for him. Reportedly life with his great-grandfather Calvin is a much more healthy and stable home and environment for James. His great-grandfather Calvin says that James is thriving and doing much better. He's at a new school now and from what I can tell it appears that he has not had any other problems at school. He would now be in the fifth grade and would be nine years old FanDuel is now available everywhere in the US so you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are including these places make this your most rewarding season ever with FanDuel age and location restrictions apply product availability varies by market see FanDuel.com for eligibility Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. only on Peacock. Now, although James did not receive any criminal charges, other people in this case did, including his mother, Deja. When Deja purchased the gun that her child used to shoot his teacher seven months earlier, she had to fill out multiple forms, and on one of these forms, she said that she did not use marijuana, which was a lie. When police first performed an interview with Deja and also search warned of her home, she claimed that she always kept her gun unloaded and locked away on a high shelf where james could not reach this was determined to be a lie there was no lockbox like the one that she described and also her child james confirmed that this gun was always left loaded in her purse and of course if it was always locked away in a lockbox on a high shelf how would he have even gotten it in the first place. This is obviously just a bunch of bullshit. And when they searched the home, like I said, they did not find a lockbox, but they did find over an ounce of marijuana. So James's mother, Deja Taylor, was charged with four separate charges. Unlawful use of a controlled substance in possession of a firearm, making a false statement during the purchase of a firearm, recklessly leaving a loaded firearm, endangering a child, and felony child neglect. On June 12th, 2023, Deja pled guilty to the drug and firearm charges, and in November, she was sentenced to 21 months in prison. Deja also pled guilty to the felony child neglect charge, the recklessly leaving out a loaded firearm charge was dropped, and a month after being sentenced to 21 months for the drug and firearm charges on December 15th, 2023, Deja was also sentenced to an additional two years for the felony child neglect charge. She was released from prison this year in February of 2026 with a two-year probation period. Abby also filed a civil lawsuit against the school district, the superintendent, the principal, and the assistant principal, Dr. Ebony Parker, where she was seeking $40 million in damages. And immediately, the school district actually tried to have Abby's civil lawsuit dismissed, claiming that Abby's injuries were a workman's compensation injury, pretty much implying that as a teacher in America nowadays, being shot is something that is just possibly going to be part of the job. Now, of course, the judge dismissed the appeal to have the civil trial dropped, and the trial went on as usual in October of 2025. But by then the district, the superintendent and the principal were all dropped as defendants, defendant the assistant principal dr ebony parker and the defense was arguably insulting they tried to say that abby failed to protect herself although abby and like four other staff members all directly went to dr ebony parker with their concerns about james that day and it was dr ebony parker that allegedly refused to do anything i mean it's very clear that on that day dr ebony parker had at least five six seven different chances to prevent this shooting from happening to prevent 16 children being traumatized for potentially the rest of their lives but she chose not to and it is absolutely baffling to me i just don't understand how an assistant principal that is working in a school in america in this day and age can hear that there is someone with a gun in their school and they don't want to do anything about it during the civil trial abby bravely testified she testified that she had been experiencing ptsd anxiety depression following the shooting she talked about how this ruined her career that she loved teaching and she doesn't think she'll ever be able to return to it she talks about her physical injuries she talks about what it was like during the shooting that she actually thought she was going to die could you imagine that 25 years old and you think i'm about to die she says one of the worst parts the image that she can't get out of her head was the look on that six-year-old's face when he pointed a gun at her and pulled the trigger well the defense would respond to abby's heart-wrenching testimony saying that well they actually went on her instagram and they saw that she actually after the shooting went to a taylor swift concert so clearly she wasn't that traumatized i don't know man like i get it's your job but also like have a soul what is wrong with you on november 6th 2025 the jury came back with their verdict and they found dr ebony parker grossly negligent on the day that abby's runner was shot and they awarded abby 10 million dollars in damages but just earlier this year dr ebony parker has appealed the 10 million dollar judgment there has been no ruling on this case yet but there has been some recent movement so although there hasn't been a ruling yet it does seem like something in this appeal is going to happen soon then there was also the matter of dr ebony parker's criminal charges and her criminal trial in april of 2024 a special grand jury indicted dr ebony parker on eight counts a felony child neglect each of those eight counts represented the eight bullets that were in the gun that could have potentially been eight children killed in that classroom that day because of dr ebony parker's neglect and each of those charges held a potential five years in prison meaning that dr ebony parker was facing 40 years in prison her trial actually began very recently in may of 2026 but on the fourth day of the trial the judge shocked everyone when the judge dismissed all of ebony's charges claiming that what happened that day did not legally in the state of virginia constitute child neglect and her charges were dismissed with prejudice meaning that she will never be charged or retried for those charges ever again i knew that i wanted to talk about this case for a bunch of different reasons for one thing a new school year just started not that long ago and we have a school shooting problem in america now although school shootings with a shooter this young are extremely rare in the state of virginia there has only been 17 incidents of a school shooter being under the age of 10 years old in america but there is an absolutely ginormous difference when you look at the data of school shootings in america versus other similar countries where i believe since 2009 there has been 288 school shootings in america where other similar countries will have maybe two maybe three also i believe the statistic is that 80 percent of children that show up to their school with a gun that gun belonged to their parent or guardian and that gun was not being stored away properly it is very important that if you are going to have a gun in a home with children in it that the gun is stored away properly it is locked away somewhere that the child cannot get to with a code that the child absolutely does not know that the gun is not being stored loaded and that the ammunition is being stored away locked away somewhere separately i'm extremely interested to hear from all of you all your thoughts on this case i feel like there's going to be a very differing opinion when it comes to different aspects of this case so i'm extremely interested to hear all of your thoughts but while you're in the comments just please remember that abby zwerner is a very real victim in this case and what she went through is not fair and she did to the best of her abilities what she was meant to do she was supposed to go report what was going on she was supposed to put on a brave face for her students and even after being shot and nearly killed she still got all of the other students out of her classroom into safety before going to get herself help so just in the comments just please remember that victim blaming is not cool being disrespectful to victims is not cool so just please remember that while you're in the comments i'm also especially interested to hear from all of you what do you think could have happened in this case to prevent this from happening and how far back do you think this case could have been prevented what steps should have or could have been taken i'm also really interested to hear from all of you what you think could happen or should happen to prevent something like this from ever happening again please let me know all your thoughts and opinions in the comments on this video and i'll see you in the next video bye bye youtube and spotify please make sure to like the video on youtube make sure you're subscribed and that you are following the show wherever you get your podcasts and while you're in the comments i'm also extremely interested to hear from all of you a case that you would love to see featured on a future hot in the case episode but until then that's all i have for you this week and i will see you guys all next friday when we are hot on the case once again fan duel is now available everywhere in the u.s so you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are including these places make this your most rewarding season ever with fan duel age and location restrictions apply product availability varies by market see fanduel.com for eligibility gambling problem call 1-800-GAMBLER hi i'm karen slaughter if you love untangling mysteries and uncovering the truths behind what really happened i think you'll love the good daughter now my best-selling novel is finally coming to life and i got to write every episode you should have died in them woods your father should have been a better shot starring rose byrne megan fahey and brendan gleason from page to screen don't miss the good daughter now streaming only on peacock i'm here charlie and i'm not going away

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Six-year-old James, a student at Rich Neck Elementary, brought a loaded gun to school and shot his teacher, Abby Zwerner, during a first-grade class in January 2023.
  2. James had a history of violent and disruptive behavior, including physical aggression, swearing, and inappropriate touching, linked to a harmful home environment involving parental abuse and substance use.
  3. The school failed to implement critical safety measures, including a broken entry buzzer system, no mandatory lockdown drills, and no classroom doors, leaving students vulnerable.
  4. Multiple school staff members reported the gun threat to the assistant principal, Dr. Ebony Parker, who dismissed concerns and refused to act, despite multiple warnings and a child’s hysterical report.
  5. James’s mother, Deja Taylor, had a history of marijuana use, kept a loaded gun in her purse, and lied about firearm storage; she was later convicted and sentenced to prison for unlawful possession and child neglect.
  6. The school administration faced severe accountability, with the superintendent and principal removed, and Dr. Parker found grossly negligent in a civil trial, awarded $10 million in damages.
  7. Despite no criminal charges against James due to Virginia’s age laws, the 16 students who witnessed the shooting suffered lasting trauma, and no long-term mental health support is confirmed.
  8. The case highlights systemic failures in school safety, reporting protocols, and child protection, emphasizing that guns in homes with children are often improperly stored and must be strictly managed.

Summary:

In January 2023, a six-year-old student at Rich Neck Elementary School, James, brought a loaded gun to class and shot his teacher, Abby Zwerner, during a first-grade lesson. James had a history of violent and disruptive behavior, including physical aggression and inappropriate actions, rooted in a toxic home environment where his parents used marijuana, engaged in domestic abuse, and kept a loaded gun accessible. The school system failed multiple times: its entry system was broken for weeks, no lockdown drills were conducted, and classroom doors were missing or unlocked.

Despite multiple staff members reporting the threat—first to the assistant principal, Dr. Ebony Parker, who dismissed concerns—no action was taken. A student revealed the gun in James’s jacket, prompting a chaotic but timely response.

Abby, despite being shot in the chest and nearly losing her life, managed to evacuate her 16 students before seeking help. She later faced a civil lawsuit against the school administration, which resulted in a $10 million verdict, though the case is still being appealed. Dr.

Parker was found grossly negligent and charged with child neglect, though the charges were ultimately dismissed. James’s mother was convicted on multiple counts and sentenced to prison. James was removed from his mother’s care and placed with a retired army drill sergeant, where he is reported to be improving.

The incident exposed deep failures in school safety, reporting protocols, and child protection, especially in homes where guns are improperly stored. Despite the trauma on both victims and witnesses, systemic changes—including locked classroom doors, metal detectors, and mandatory parental supervision—were implemented. The case underscores the urgent need for better policies, early intervention, and mandatory reporting of child abuse and gun hazards in homes.

FAQs

A six-year-old student, James, brought a loaded gun to school and shot his first-grade teacher, Abby Zwerner, during class on January 6, 2023. The student had previously displayed violent and disruptive behavior and had access to a gun stored in his mother's purse.

James's mother, Deja Taylor, kept a loaded nine-millimeter handgun in her purse at all times. The gun was purchased seven months prior to the incident and was easily accessible to James, who retrieved it from his mother’s purse before school on the day of the shooting.

No, James was not criminally charged due to Virginia state law, which prohibits criminally charging children under seven for such acts. However, his mother, Deja Taylor, was charged and convicted on multiple counts, including unlawful possession of a firearm and child neglect.

Multiple staff members reported concerns about James’s behavior and the potential threat, including the assistant principal, Dr. Ebony Parker. Despite these reports, she dismissed the threats and failed to take immediate action, contributing to the tragedy.

The superintendent and principal were removed from their positions, and Dr. Ebony Parker resigned. She was later accused of felony child neglect in a criminal trial, though the charges were dismissed with prejudice, meaning she can never be retried.

The school closed for several weeks, installed metal detectors, secured all entrances, provided classroom doors, and implemented see-through backpacks. Therapy dogs were also introduced to support student mental health.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.