Go back

Talking Dateline: Hunted

25m 40s

Talking Dateline: Hunted

The episode "Hunted" details the shocking murder of Laura McNaughton, a young mother and waitress, in Clovis, New Mexico, whose body was found naked and cleaned on a roadside. The investigation revealed she was killed by James Smith, a dentist with a disturbing obsession for dead bodies, who had access to her personal information through dental records. Despite being a respected community figure, Smith’s actions—such as placing the body in a public location and using a deceptive DVD box labeled “Give to my wife”—highlighted his psychological disturbance and intent to manipulate. Investigators found no signs of premeditated concealment, suggesting a deeply disturbed mindset. Smith admitted guilt through a plea deal that allowed him to avoid direct confession, and his defense in a prison deposition emphasized victimhood and a crafted false persona. The story also examines the emotional toll on Laura’s family, who endured trauma during a long drive and struggled with the loss of a close-knit sibling bond. The episode underscores how personal data can be weaponized, and how even familiar, everyday professions like dentistry can harbor dangerous obsessions. It concludes with a reflection on the randomness of violence and the resilience required by families facing such tragedies.

Transcription

4734 Words, 25122 Characters

English
[MUSIC] Hi everyone, I'm Andrea Canning and this is Talking Date Line. Today, I'm joined by Blaine Alexander to discuss her episode "Hunted" about the murder of a young mother and waitress that shook her new Mexico town and her killers disturbing past. But before we get into all of that, if you haven't listened to the episode yet, you can find it right below this one or stream it now on Peacock. We have a podcast exclusive clip from a deposition the killer gave and he talks about the case and later we'll answer your questions from social media. Blaine, are you ready to talk date line? I am ready, let's do it. Okay, so first, why don't you just give us a really quick recap of this episode? This story is about Laura McNaughton. She was a young woman who was killed and was found dead on the side of a road by a pair of peasant hunters and almost from the very beginning, investigators knew that this was going to be a very different and a very disturbing case because she was completely naked. She had piercings, the jewelry was removed. But not only that, it looked like her body had kind of been cleaned up or washed before she was placed out there. So that added this very disturbing element to all of it. Investigators come to find out that she was a mother of two daughters. She was divorced from her husband who was a radio DJ in town. And, you know, Clovis was a relatively small community. So they said there can't be too terribly many people that don't have some sort of a connection as they started hunting for this killer. So they looked at her ex-husband, he was cleared. They looked at a man that she had been dating, he was also cleared. And ultimately their investigation took them to James Smith, who was a dentist in the area. And he, as they came to find out through their investigation, had some sort of very disturbing sexual attraction to dead bodies. And that is basically what investigators found, kind of led him to commit this crime that he killed her and then put her body out for display. And he took an Alfred plea and is in prison still today. - Okay. Right out of the gate with this episode, the Fezend Hunters. I loved how you went out with them, to the location. You know, it's that boots on the ground, right? When you can actually sort of be as close as you can in the moment, right? Of what they went through. And you don't think all the time about the poor people who stumble upon the victims, right? That have nothing to do with the crime. They don't know these people, yet they're walking their dog. Or they pull over onto the side of the road to change a tire. Or in this case, Fezend Hunting, that they come across a murder victim. And think about how awful that is for someone. - Incredibly traumatic. I mean, I have to say, I have so much to say about the cook to cousins. They were fantastic. They were just so gracious with their time. And I mean, these are Clovis, New Mexico boys. I mean, through and through, if they're kind of those guys, they grew up Fezend Hunting. I mean, they had their trucks, they had their guns. This is the way that they do it all the time. Fezend Hunting isn't as big and Clovis now as it was back then when this happened. But they really took me through what all of that looked like and felt like. So it was very cool, like, to your point to be able to be in that moment and kind of help understand, you know, this was a day that they look forward to. Fezend Hunting season is four days long. They look forward to it, they go out with their friends. And so when you're kind of in this place where you're with your buddies, it's a good day. And then to see what you think is a mannequin, get closer, and then find that it's a dead body, it's something that you can't even brace for because it's so completely unexpected. And one of the guys told me that it ruined Fezend Hunting for them for quite some time. They weren't able to go back to this thing that they loved because of just all of the stuff that comes up when they think about it. We had in Canada, we had the sort of fishing season in our little little neck of the woods in Ontario. And I remember in West Palm Beach when I was a reporter going out for our first night of alligator hunt season, you know, there's all over this country. There's the start of these types of things that people get very excited about. And that's sad that something that was really special to them, you know, now is marred by this this tragic event. It really is, it is. And one other thing too, to your point about kind of seeing where something like this happened, I think going out there and seeing just how close to the road she was, when we went out there now, it's kind of more of a deserted area, but back then, I mean, this was like a main thoroughfare. If you were a Fezend hunter, like this was the place you would go. And there was a deep ravine that you saw in our episode this time around, 20 years ago, that wasn't there. And so it really just kind of helped put into perspective how this guy made no effort to hide her, like you're, I mean, imagine driving down a road and it's not like, oh, I looked over in a ditch and she was covered up. No, she was, she was right there. And so that just adds to all of it. Yeah, I just shot a story that hasn't aired yet where the body was dumped, just feet from a cliff. And you think to yourself, and it was right off of a road, like not to sound gruesome, but why didn't you, why didn't you try to push her over, you know, to hide it? Because then she was found by a motorist who pulled over to use nature's bathroom. And, you know, so it's like, it's, it's strange when, when there's such little, you know, sort of attempt to conceal something like that, like you, you wonder what's going through the killer's mind that they are not trying to hide this. No, and you know, I had that thought at first, too, for a second. But then I thought this killer in this case was so completely disturbing and disturbed. I mean, who, who can even try and get inside of that mind? There's no rational thought there, right? But they also said that her hand was kind of up like almost like he was trying to get attention, one to her to be found, essentially. Um, you know, I was thinking about Laura about the victim in this, and you know, the four sisters, military family, you know, I'm thinking of my, you know, my own family, five girls, military dad, you know, close-knit family, protective family. You just really, your heart just went out to this, to all of them. Yeah. I have to say, I, I really loved meeting their family. I mean, interview to all three sisters, both parents, and just got a, it was cool to of course, talk with them. We spoke with them kind of in different sections, but to see all of them all together, as we were in between our interviews and before and afterwards, I mean, this is such an incredibly close family. And so it really helped underscore what it meant for Laura to move away from them to Clovis, New Mexico, because that just wasn't something that they do. You know, some families are scattered all over the country and you see each other on holidays. That's not this family. I mean, they are a pack. And so it was a beautiful thing to see. And it also really underscores just how much was taken from them when, when Laura was killed. Yeah. And they talked about that drive, you know, going to New Mexico, that long drive when you get that news. And I've interviewed a lot of, of people on date lines where, you know, they do have to, to, to drive far distances or get on a plane after getting news like this. And they say it's the weirdest feeling because the worst thing imaginable has just happened to them, but all around them, the world keeps turning and people have no idea what they're going through. And you, it's what a lonely, traumatic experience to get a call like that and then have to get into a car or get on a plane and have all that time to think while you're trying to get to your loved one. Yes. Exactly. The time to think. And it's also this kind of feeling of your hands are tied because you can't do anything. All you can do is drive. All you can do is get there, right? And I think what was so hard to hear when they talked about their drive is it's typically a peaceful drive. I mean, you're talking about driving through miles of desert. You're talking about beautiful sandagas. It was beautiful. And so this, this drive that typically had been so serene for them was now this just horrible, you know, at one point, they said that there was no music, no, anything you could just hear the sound of their parents crying in the back seat, right? It's a, it's a really, a really tough thing. That's so sad. On a, on a later note, whole time I'm watching it, I'm thinking, okay, Laura is an actress from the 90s. Like she has that look, right? You know, she's so pretty, right? Like she, yes. I'm like, why didn't she become an actress? The hair, the, I mean, yeah, the hair, the hair cut, the way that it was colored, all of it. Yes. Yes. She was, she was beautiful. And then it's, it was crazy come to find out that, that, you know, our, our dentist had a Hillary Duff poster on his wall in the dentist's office. And then I realized Hillary Duff is not 90s. She's what, like 2000 or less 1000s. But like, also Hillary Duff was a teen at the time. Like that's an important detail. This was like Lizzie McGuire era, Hillary Duff. And you know, the thing was at one point in my interview with investigator, Loera, he said, you know, we closed the door and we saw the Hillary Duff poster on the back, which by itself isn't that strange. And I was like, oh, no, no, that's actually, that's pretty strange in an episode. I think it's strange, an old male dentist has a Hillary Duff poster at one point. Yeah. No, at work. That's not, that's not normal. I'm sorry. And it's funny too. I mean, thinking of Hillary Duff. So this is 2005. I was, that was around that age, right? And I was a big Hillary Duff fan. Watch Lizzie McGuire, loved the Lizzie McGuire movie, right? So all of these things. I remember when our first album came out and I, and I bought it and loved Hillary Duff. So it was just, it was just a creepy reference there. I think it's a very, yeah, very creepy reference. When we come back, we've got an extra clip from a deposition that Laura's killer gave in connection to the case. [MUSIC] Let's talk about the potential suspects in this case. You never know what police called them suspects. Just someone they need to talk to, there's all different ways that they characterize people in our investigations that we cover. But the husband seemed really like a viable, possible suspect. >> Well, I'm blabbing on the radio. >> On the radio, the fact that their divorce had become so contentious. And again, I think investigators had that clue from the very beginning. This was somebody that she was familiar with in some regard. And they made the point that she's not from Clovis. She didn't make too many friends while she was there. So there were a limited number of people that she would have had familiarity with. That she would have felt comfortable opening the door for or something like that. And so they were working from that very limited number of people. And of course, Jeff McNaughton would have been at the top of that list. It was interesting going through the investigation with them. Because remember, all of this happened over a relatively short amount of time, right? We're talking about a couple of weeks. And so they were able to clear him as a suspect pretty quickly. And I remember when I spoke with the polygrapher, the DA and the investigator. All of them were very clear with the fact that when he came in and the way that he broke down, when he identified her butterfly tattoo and realized who that was, they said, you can't fake that. That was sincere. And so, of course, they went through the questioning, they did the polygrap, all of those types of things. But especially Matt Chandler, the DA who knows Jeff, considers him a friend, look, that's not something you can fake. That was real. We have really good instincts for a reason. They deal with people all the time that they have to read, get a read on, and I really trust a detective's opinion for the most part. If they think something seems a mess or something seems accurate. I correct. Because we hear people say this all the time, oh, there's no playbook for how you react if someone dies or murdered. But I feel like there is a baseline. There is sort of kind of a human nature, like how most people respond, even if they're not like bawling their eyes out, even a grown man, you know, his eyes will water and you'll see that maybe his face will turn red, like he'll, there's something there. There's something. There's nothing there. I'm sorry. That concerns me. And you can tell me all day long, oh, I, you know, I was in law enforcement, I was military. We don't show our emotions. I mean, maybe once in a while that might be true, but like, I think you've grown men get upset too. I, I, one, you could be an investigator yourself, Andrea, because you have those same instincts, right? I mean, that's what they're looking for. I mean, I think it makes a lot of sense. There's something there that gives some sort of window into your humanity, whatever it looks like. I will say that when I spoke with the team on all of this, they were a good kind of, they did some good checks and balances on each other. It seemed because, you know, Matt Chandler was there. He saw the kind of breakdown and everything. And then you had investigator Loira who said, okay, but I still have a job to do. I still need to press him, right? So all of them really kind of did what they need to do to check the box, but they all came away with that, that exact same instinct. Yeah. You held back Jeff's polygraph result. And I thought, oh, maybe they're not, they're not telling us if he passed a result. I was like, is there something coming down the plate here? Right. But then, of course, he said that he passed. He passed. All right. James is the dentist. Every time a new detail was revealed, my jaw dropped a little more and a little more and a little more. This whole being able to order videos and you can write the script yourself and actors will perform and then send it back to you. I have written here custom order five exclamation marks WTF scripts, five exclamation marks. I'm like, what, what, I think that's a very fair reaction. This is a thing. You can really, I know that I want to direct people to do this, but like, what? Apparently, it's enough of a thing that, you know, there's a business around it. I mean, it was, it was so disturbing and again, we don't know what all the other subject matter of all the other videos were that this company produces, but it was so disturbing. And the words, I think that was what got me. And I kept asking the investigator, okay, so what was being said, what were these things? And the fact that these, I mean, things were scripted that granularly with such detail. I think that there were so many things about James Smith that just made him so disturbing when you think about the fact that this man is a dentist in a position of respect, a position of power, right? At one point, I said, how did he seem to know where she worked? And her mom said, I mean, probably from the dental paperwork that you fill out. I know. You put your phone, your work phone number, you put different things. If there is somebody who wants to be creepy, you've got home addresses. You've got all the information you want about somebody that you may be obsessed with. That's disturbing in and of itself. And then you talk about a doctor. I mean, this is somebody with access to control substances. I mean, there are all these things, and then in a place like Clovis, there were people who would go to this dentist, like you investigated a lawyer, I said, my sister went to this guy. I mean, there were very, very close degrees of people just going and trusting and knowing this person, not to mention the church activity, not to mention he's a dad with two kids three on the way. So you see him at schools. I mean, it really is the example of a monster hiding in hindsight. Absolutely. I mean, now it gets me thinking of just how many people have our personal information in our lives, right? Sometimes you think, oh, it's safe because of, you know, I'm just giving it to my doctor's office, right? And they have something. So they can't give it away and hip in all of that stuff. No, there are lots of wonderful dentists out there who are kind people who take care of our teeth. But I will say there have been quite a few dentists featured on Dateline for the wrong reasons. That's true. That is very true. I did the safari dentist story, the dentist from Pittsburgh. And then I did the Colorado dentist and Angela Craig was the victim in that one. Yes, unfortunately, we, there are certain occupations that that we do see repeat offenders on Dateline for some reason. But again, so many wonderful dentists out there. Thank them all for taking such good care of our teeth. We do. We're very grateful. We love our smiles. And you have a beautiful smile, Blaine. Thank you. So do you, my love. Thank you. You brought up something that I was thinking before it was even set on the show as man. If this guy has an obsession like this, has he done this before? Yes. I realized they looked into your home state. I guess he had lived in Oklahoma and there were some murders there that didn't seem to pan out. That's right. They weren't able to actually officially make those connections, but they said there were some striking similarities. I will say that Laura's parents really took matters into their own hands. They actually put an ad in the paper and said, hey, if you have, we believe that, you know, this is what happened to our daughter. If you believe that there were other victims out there, reach out to us, call us, write us. And there was a family that did ultimately reach out now. We should say that James Smith was not, has not been charged or connected with their death, but they have had dialogue between the two families saying, gosh, there are similarities. Blaine, Laura's family brought a wrongful death lawsuit against James Smith. And he answered questions from the family's lawyers during a deposition in the case in 2008. And the deposition took place at the prison where he was being held. We have some audio from that that did not make our show. So let's take a listen to the dentist in his own words. And he said he had gone on me some reason, I assume I'm not lying about him on what you're thinking about. I'm here in this facility because of the bright, bright life. Well, I haven't been able to read everything that's been said and written about me. So I can understand that there's quite a lot of people trying to, I mean, to make me into a monster. With everything that's gone on, I've been put into this and we've asked me that. And yes, people, why let me. I will say after hearing that, I do not feel bad for him. He's, he is making himself out blame to sound like the victim. Yes. Yes, that's exactly it. And I think that in talking with the investigator, I mean, Laura, he basically said that that he, in no way wanted to confront what he did, the reality of what he did and kind of wanted to live in this sham personality, those are my words. But, you know, essentially this sham personality of who he had created this successful guy, activist, church, a husband, like all of these things fly in the face of the reality of what investigators uncovered about him. And so in listening to that clip, it certainly sounded like he was trying to lean more into that created reality versus what investigators found, which also speaks to the plea deal. - All right, well, after the break, Blaine, we will be here to answer all of our viewers and listeners' questions from social media. - Sounds good. (upbeat music) - Welcome back. We have comments from social media. This first one is from Andrea Haas on Facebook. She asks, "Did they determine if Laura was sexually assaulted? If so, is there a way they can tell if it was before or after death?" - That is a great question. And according to the investigation, they believe that she was either assaulted or he attempted to sexually assault her after death. - Karen Haask on Facebook asks, "I find it hard to believe she would willingly leave her house to go with him to his." - Yeah. That's one of the theories of investigators. Is remember, she had that blunt force trauma hit to her head. And so nobody knows exactly what happened in those hours but they have their theories and they believe that at some point, it's possible that you may have incapacitated her. And hit her head on the window or some part of her car to be able to take her someplace. And remember, the notion of her leaving the house willingly, that all came from James Smith and investigators knew all along that every step of the way, everything that he was telling was a lie. The tale he was spinning was certainly not, what the evidence showed actually happened that night. And so I do believe that that was something that they dismissed as well. - Julie Jewels on Facebook asks, so he was obsessed with corpses, not sure why the box that contained the DVDs said, "Give to my wife." Did she know about his obsession? - That's a really good question. And so, investigators believed that he put that on there as a way to kind of almost make it seem like there was something harmless inside the box. Thinking, "Hey, if you see this note, then it says, give it to my wife. No need to look any further because you wouldn't give this to my wife, right?" So almost as kind of a decoy. We also learned from one of the investigators that she had found the DVDs in the house at some point and said, "Oh my God, you need to get rid of these. Like, take these away." And that they made their way to the office. K-star Maddox on Facebook says, "Can't believe they gave him an Alfred plea." - Yeah. You know, in talking with Lucky, Laura's mom afterwards, she said, "I wish that I had had full understanding or really grasped what that meant," right? This notion of he never actually had to admit to what he did. And that's not saying that the DA didn't explain it fully or, but, you know, she said, I just really didn't think about the fact that like, it meant that he would never have to actually, you know, fess up to what he did. And that's something that's painful for her, that's still painful for her today. Gary Lee on Facebook said, "If only she had gone back to San Diego after the divorce." - So true. So, yeah, hindsight. Oh, it's something that her family says constantly. I mean, it was one of the most painful parts because she wanted to so badly. She wanted, she desperately wanted to get back to San Diego, but remember the judge had ordered in the custody hearing, you have to, you can't leave the state with your daughters. And so she had to remain in Clovis, New Mexico for at least a year under the judge's orders as they, and they split custody before, you know, she could basically appeal that decision and see if she could move back. But the custody arrangements were such that she couldn't. - Yeah. And back to Laura's family. Yag had 22 on X said, great job by Blaine and the crew keeping Laura's family comfortable as they shared their stories, the good parts, and the bad parts. Oh, that's so kind. Thank you. To end on a later note, we asked our fans what they listened to on their morning commute and one of our day-line super fans, Peeby Winston on X said, well, my morning commute is to the kitchen and then the sofa. So I listened to my thoughts. Okay, Blaine, what do you listen to on your commute? - I love that. Listen to your thoughts. That's time to get in touch with yourself. I'm also very jealous of that short commute. So, what do I listen to? It depends. I do news. I love a podcast, NPR, a first, the daily podcast. I listen to us just to see, not often, but we have to know what we're putting out, right? So that sometimes is my time to certainly listen. And I have podcasts. And then I have my, I like smooth jazz sometimes to see. - Nice. - Zen myself. Right now I'm actually listening to Christmas music. Blaine, thank you for bringing us this episode. And as always, great sensitivity that you showed and very good storytelling. And it was an interesting, interesting day line episode. - Thank you so much. Thank you. - That's it for Talking Day Line this week. Thank you so much for listening. Remember, if you have questions about our stories, you can always DM us your audio or video on our social media channels at DatelineNBC or you can leave us a voicemail at 212-413-5252 for a chance to be featured right here. And you can always watch the video version of Talking Day Line on YouTube and on the NBC News app and on Peacock. And of course, we'll see you Fridays on Dateline on NBC.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Laura McNaughton, a young mother and waitress, was found naked and seemingly cleaned before being placed on a roadside in Clovis, New Mexico, indicating a disturbing, intentional act.
  2. Investigators narrowed the suspect pool to James Smith, a dentist with a known obsession for dead bodies, who had access to Laura’s personal information through dental records and was connected to her through prior interactions.
  3. The killer, James Smith, confessed during a 2008 prison deposition, claiming he was a victim of public perception and attempted to construct a false, respectable identity to deflect blame.
  4. The case revealed a lack of effort to conceal the body—placed directly on a main road near a cliff—suggesting the killer had no intention of hiding the crime, reflecting deep psychological disturbance.
  5. Laura’s family, especially her parents, actively sought information and issued a public appeal, which led to a potential connection with another victim, though Smith was never formally linked to that case.
  6. A key detail was a DVD box labeled “Give to my wife,” which investigators believe was a deceptive decoy to appear harmless, indicating Smith’s premeditated and obsessive nature.
  7. Smith received an Alford plea, meaning he admitted guilt to the charge but not to the act itself, allowing him to avoid a full confession while maintaining a prison sentence.
  8. The episode explores the emotional trauma of the family, the randomness of such crimes, and the disturbing ways personal data can be exploited in criminal acts.

Summary:

The episode "Hunted" details the shocking murder of Laura McNaughton, a young mother and waitress, in Clovis, New Mexico, whose body was found naked and cleaned on a roadside. The investigation revealed she was killed by James Smith, a dentist with a disturbing obsession for dead bodies, who had access to her personal information through dental records. Despite being a respected community figure, Smith’s actions—such as placing the body in a public location and using a deceptive DVD box labeled “Give to my wife”—highlighted his psychological disturbance and intent to manipulate.

Investigators found no signs of premeditated concealment, suggesting a deeply disturbed mindset. Smith admitted guilt through a plea deal that allowed him to avoid direct confession, and his defense in a prison deposition emphasized victimhood and a crafted false persona. The story also examines the emotional toll on Laura’s family, who endured trauma during a long drive and struggled with the loss of a close-knit sibling bond.

The episode underscores how personal data can be weaponized, and how even familiar, everyday professions like dentistry can harbor dangerous obsessions. It concludes with a reflection on the randomness of violence and the resilience required by families facing such tragedies.

FAQs

Investigators believe she was either assaulted or had an attempted sexual assault after death. There is no definitive evidence on whether it occurred before or after her death.

The poster is considered a disturbing detail, as Hillary Duff was a teen pop star in the 2000s, not the 1990s. Investigators saw it as a sign of his obsession with young women and a possible connection to his interest in bodies and personal lives.

No, investigators believe she did not willingly go with him. James Smith’s account of the event was inconsistent with the evidence, and the presence of blunt force trauma to her head suggests she may have been incapacitated or forced.

In his deposition, he claimed he didn’t want to confront the reality of what he did and instead portrayed himself as a victim. Investigators found this narrative inconsistent with the facts and believed he was creating a false image of himself.

Investigators believe the note was a decoy meant to appear harmless, suggesting he wanted people to think the box was safe or innocuous. It may have been designed to mislead or distract from the true content of the videos.

An Alford plea allows a person to admit guilt to a crime without admitting to the specific facts, meaning he never had to admit to killing Laura. This spared him from a direct confession but still led to a conviction.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.