Go back

Sunday Special: This Summer in Culture

48m 48s

Sunday Special: This Summer in Culture

The inaugural episode of The Sunday Special features a cultural deep dive into summer 2023, centered on the global excitement over Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce’s engagement. Their Instagram post, showing a romantic garden and a lavish engagement ring, sparked widespread celebration and discussion, with critics highlighting both the emotional resonance and the absurdity of casual engagement fashion. The episode also explores Taylor Swift’s new album reveal on her fiancé’s podcast, where her performance is praised for its emotional authenticity, even if heavily curated. Music trends are examined with skepticism toward the concept of a single “song of the summer,” instead emphasizing viral, multimedia content like “Can’t Go Broke” and the animated film *K-Pop Demon Hunter*, whose song “Golden” went viral through TikTok. Internet culture is dissected through trends like Coldplaygate, the “Judd to holiday” meme, and the viral Benson Boone x Crumble cookie, which illustrate how humor and absurdity dominate digital engagement. The discussion also touches on the film *Material*, which, despite its financial satire, is appreciated for its vivid setting and critique of transactional relationships. The episode concludes with a playful pop culture quiz, highlighting the interconnectedness of music, film, and internet trends. The Sunday Special aims to provide a fresh, accessible platform for cultural commentary through in-depth, conversational storytelling.

Transcription

8270 Words, 43742 Characters

English
Hey, everyone, it's Rachel. I am here with my colleague Gilbert Cruz, the editor of the New York Times Booker View. Hey, Gilbert. Hey, Rachel. Gilbert, you are also, we should point out, the culture editor here for many years. That is true. And now you're here to talk about a new project that you're working on. I am and I will. So starting today and going through the end of the year, every Sunday, you're going to find me here talking with our colleagues who cover culture and lifestyle at the New York Times about the fun stuff movies and TV and books and food and art and so many other things. I love that stuff. Do you love that? I love it too. We're calling it the Sunday special. And if you're subscribed to the daily, it will just appear in your feed. You don't have to press any buttons. I love that. I love the idea of not having to press a single button. Okay, great. So you are starting this project today. Tell us what you have planned. Absolutely. So today, I had a conversation with two very fun, very knowledgeable people here at the times. One of our music critics, our internet reporter. We talked about music. We talked about a couple movies. We talked about obviously Taylor Swift. We talked about some internet memes. It's just three of us mixing up about things that we really enjoyed over the past few months. Well, that sounds fantastic. Let's hear it. Welcome everybody to the inaugural episode of the Sunday special. This week, I'm here with two wonderful guests, John Karamonica, sitting to my left music critic, host of the podcast podcast. John, thank you for being here. Enjoy. Also in the room, sitting right across from me, right over there is Madison Malone Kircher, who covers internet culture for the New York Times. This means, according to her, she spends way too much time on TikTok. Madison, thank you for being here. Sorry. Did you say something I was scrolling? Great, great start, great start. It's Labor Day weekend, and we are going to look back at this past summer in culture. And I'm going to start really a half to start with something that's both the most recent news and arguably one of the biggest things that happened this summer, which was a certain couple got engaged. So, okay, can I say before we talk about that, do you identify as an English teacher or a gym teacher, or do you reject that those are non-overlapping categories, like do you believe that is one category? I had a gym teacher that was also my English teacher. So, wow, we can contain multitudes. That's, I like to hear that. That's actually, I feel in position at the exact middle of that then diagram, a fun being wholly honest. So, a thrilling day for English teacher rising, gym teacher moons everywhere. As someone who hasn't been to the gym in two plus years, I'm just going with English teacher respectfully. I heard the news not in a way that you would expect, which is to say, like looking at the internet, I heard it because my texts started going off crazy as if something horrific had happened. But in fact, it was just everyone trying to tell me that Taylor Swift and Travis Kelsey had gotten engaged. My group chats began blowing up and I was sitting in the cafeteria here at the office, just having sat down to eat my salad. And I had this moment of being facetimed by a friend and thinking I was going to enjoy this and then going, oh no, this is my job. And just running towards the elevators. I've since heard from at least one colleague who does not work with me, being like, I heard you were running through the news, like sprinting to get to my desk. This is commitments. This is what we do here. What are you right, Madison? Why, why news? Why was this interesting and what did people find most interesting about it? I mean, I've been preparing for this no joke since January, truly. It's you have. I thought you were going to say like 2017. The year, the year was 2007. Our song has just hit the, you know, I'm like, um, look, it's, uh, it was an educated guess that these two people seem to perhaps be on the train towards marriage. They are juggernauts both in their own spaces independently and you put them together and you sort of get, well, what's bigger than a juggernaut? People, the people needed to know, the people wanted to know. And I was shocked by the reaction online both to this news piece I wrote and more broadly, the state of my inbox. Everyone, I think needed just a little bit of happy news this week and it came in the form of the Davis engagement. Wait, it's Davis. Yeah. What? What were we're doing? Yeah. That's what we're doing. Get on board. So Madison for, I don't know, the 12th people, uh, listening right now to this episode who Ron vacation and totally missed the news. How did this actually come out? Taylor and Travis posted a joint Instagram post on a Tuesday afternoon. I believe it was one PM Eastern ish. It contained a series of photos of them standing in an elaborately decorated garden just lots of flowers and arch. I believe there's a candle chandelier covered in flowers. The works. And in the first photo, Travis is on Bended Knee in front of Taylor. She's clutching his head in her hands. Uh, he's wearing shorts, which has been criticized by some, uh, not me, but some. And, uh, the caption, your English teacher and your gym teacher are getting married. It also contains a tiny emoji. It's a stick of dynamite, um, which you might call TNT. Oh, get it. And the ring and the ring. So in a subsequent photo, you get a close up, but very, uh, let's say wisely selected close up leaves a lot of details to the imagination, but a close up of a just, I believe the official gemologist term is honking diamond ring. Uh, speculation is it's a antique cut elongated cushion in some sort of gold. Uh, I definitely know what that means. Trunkey faceting. Look, I bought an engagement ring last year. I actually bought two, one for me, one for my partner. So you learned diamond, speak, and I didn't realize it would become useful. Uh, but also in that frame is a very flashy Cartier watch. Yes. That's believe she is still the jeweled. Wow. I, why am I even here? Like seriously, I like all just bars, bars. I look, I'm not here to tell anyone what to do or how to announce their love or how to announce their engagement or what to wear when they're doing. But you're mad about the shorts. I am mad, small mad about the shorts. It's like, I don't care how warm it is. These are engagement photos. They're going to go around the world. They're going to live in their, you know, in their couple them forever. They're going to be up in every house that they own. And the guy is freaking wearing shorts. I do think that that speaks to Travis emerging, not from the world of true celebrity Hollywood. It's because he's emerging from the world of athletics. And I just like, this is no commentary on Travis's legs, you know, two thumbs up. But I do think like that, this is a person who likes to bump around in casual wear. And now he likes to get engaged in casual wear as well. I'm just going to proper up a third option. Maybe he was just hot. Perhaps it is summer. Yeah, that got nothing on that. Yeah, that's not. Look, it's extremely dangerous to bring me on to a podcast under the pretense of talking about the culture of the summer. And then it veers sharply into shorts discourse. This is, this is, this is, this is violence. You guys don't want to get to. I didn't get the ID on the low. I thought the low for was fine. It's it's shorts discourse. That's really dangerous. You know, you're right. Let's move away from shorts discourse. I would encourage us to step aside. This is coming, of course, 13 days after, and 13 is a very auspicious number for for Taylor Swift, 13 days after another massive bit of news in her world, in their world, Taylor Swift. Not intro Jason. Oh my God. I've seen this before. Look, he's left his body. She went on her now fiance's podcast, new heights. So I wanted to show you something. Okay. What do we got? This is my brand new album. To announce her upcoming album, The Life of the Showgirl, which is coming out this fall. I can't believe this is the moment I finally had to watch a boy podcast. Yeah. Okay. I'm, well, I make a boy podcast. So you've never, you just called yourself. Yeah. Absolutely. I admittedly do not watch podcast period. I listened to them. But this one, I watched sat at my dining room table wrapped. Yeah. You made, you made an event out of it. I did. I did indeed. But did you, was that a sort of professional rapture or was that a professional rapture? Yeah. I was. I mean, we all were John. How many times did you watch it? And tell us what you thought. I watched it in full. Not twice. One full time and let's say 60% of a second time. Here are some takeaways from Taylor and Travis. One, they were having two incredibly parallel, but not not same experiences side by side. Taylor was there for war. Taylor was their eyes on the camera, eyes on the prizes, communicating with the fans. I do think at one point she looked straight into the screen and spoke my name. Is that, yes, by name. Totally. Anyone who's ever watched it. I think it was anyone who's ever bought a Taylor album. You were named just like donors on the wall at the moon or something. Yeah. Exactly. Like me, the cyclers. Yeah. Yeah. Um, Travis and Jason on the other hand, like what are they're like, they're rough housing. They're like two slanted hair. Yeah. They're like, hey, buddy, they're not in the same room. And they're still two-cylinder each other's hair. It's absolute madness. I think that they realized obviously the power of having Taylor on the show, what it would draw to them in terms of audience. But I don't think that they understood that Taylor is not there to pod, as podcasters say. She was there to settle. - Yeah, and she did. - I bought it. I bought an advanced purchase CD. - Which one did you buy? - A CD, I don't need it. - No, no, no, no, no. But of the 19 million versions of these albums, you can tell us if it makes a million. - Okay. - Original issue. I don't need purple, glitter, vinyl. I have enough of that. - Is the briefcase on sale? 'Cause I was interested in the briefcase. - I'll bet that she owe it to-- - The deal and deal with it. - I'll have the vinyl. I'll have one sent into Jersey. Thank you. - You're welcome. How do you know where I live? What, Madison? (laughing) - I was watching the show through the lens of a very active group chat of the Swift sisters. My Swift sisters, it's not a great portmanteau. And I was struck by, I can't remember who said it, perhaps my literal sister saying, "I've never heard her say this many words in a row before." And it was this illusion that we were getting for maybe the first time since Miss Americana, her documentary, a full picture, a portrait of what Taylor Swift has been up to and what her behind-the-scenes real life is like. Of course, this is highly manipulated. All of this was to use your verb, the cell. - Yes, highly choreographed. Except, you know, I as someone who listens to Taylor Swift doesn't necessarily, I don't know that I've seen Miss Americana. I'm not decoding numerology. I'm not doing any of the sort of Easter-day stuff. I knew that she had perfect lighting. I knew that she had perfect hair. I knew that this was all choreographed to the end degree. And she gave me the illusion of realness as well as I've seen in a very long time. I felt like I was there in the room with her. Even though at the same time, I knew this was highly edited completely in illusion. It was amazing. - Five a couple questions. One, how were you in the room with her, but Jason Kelsey was trapped in a basement because the lighting on his half of the podcast, like we're in here, I've got four different light sources. - Yeah. - So much light. Jason Kelsey, like borrowed under a table, like potting from underneath. - Do you think they told him, you're fine. You know, when it was like mic checking all that stuff, they were just like, now you look great. I think that boy casts don't have lighting budgets. - I see. - That's my, that's my sentence. - Surely they get afforded. No comment. - I just, he was not seated in front of a stack of art books, you know. - Whose books are those? - Ruth Asawa and, you know, all of these - No, it's literally- - No, it's literally- - It's just the Barnes and Noble, like art book table. It's just like one of the, there's probably like a cause book in there. - It's like a version of the power broker. - Exactly. Meanwhile, the Swifties are like, Ruth Asawa died at the age of 87. - I was Kelsey. It's never really seven of them. - It's song about Ruth Asawa from the new album. - Like my sincerest apologies to the Asawa family and the estate. - Are you kidding her price is about to go through the roof? It's unbelievable. Look, there's no real intimacy happening here. I appreciate that you allowed yourself to be swept away. What is that like? What must that be like? I have no idea. - I know it's been a very long time since you were able to, you know, sort of buy into the illusion. Raw cynicism, I wake up every day, dripping cynicism. - Let the world. - But how? - That is the world. I regret to inform you. That's literally the world. - So fine, I am, I am, you know, the sucker here who took it for what I wanted it to be. - You are the man who sees through the illusions who took it from what it was. - Okay, but only one of you gave her your money. And it's John. - I'm a collector. I have an archive to maintain. - Also, he's expensive, so it's fine. Also that. - Okay, so let's pivot to music more broadly. Song of the summer. John, I know that there's some contention over the entire concept of a song of the summer. Talk to me. - Okay. It is the position of me and a podcast for that matter that the song of the summer is a farce. It's not real. It's a fallacy. It does not actually exist. - Okay. - You have declining monoculture, deeply fragmented everybody's in their individual silos. They're like, I like K-pop and reality television. I like hip hop and ESPN. They're like, I'm picking and choosing from the full plate that's in front of me. And it's very, very hard for one song to really appeal broadly across people who have the option of listening to any song at any time. There has been a song that's been the number one song as you say for 10 weeks. It's called "Ordinary" by Alex Warren. ♪ When we found something so well ♪ ♪ We'll be ordinary ♪ ♪ You're gonna be kissing the ground ♪ ♪ When we say it's your Larry ♪ - It is, and I say this with, I say this zestily, but with no zest. It is heinous. It is unbearable. It makes me physically uncomfortable to listen to. - Okay. - 10 weeks at number one. - Yeah. - It makes me wonder who's out there tapping in, pressing play, absorbing. I don't know. Is that the song of the summer? If so, it's been a summer of misery. - Actually, you have a question for you about that. How much do you think of it as algorithmically driven? Because I was force fed that song against my will, not only on TikTok, but on Spotify. Like I would finish listening to seemingly disparate albums or tracks covered in a direction. - And how am I here listening to this TikTok guy? High-poused dude. - Yes. Fake British. Fake British. - Fake British? - Is that British? - C, not British. - He looks extremely British. - And also sounds extremely British. - Okay. - Yes, I do think part of his algorithmic. I do think part of it is a collective dearth of taste amongst people. So good luck with that. - Grand plan. - Yeah. - Not really. - Yeah. - To a pretty straight horse. - I know, it's also like, sorry, ordinary. It's called ordinary. - The amount of like a wedding and engagement TikToks that I watched with ordinary. Look, I'm pro love. I'm pro romance. I'm pro betrothal. - Say it loud. - I'm on that. - Yeah. - The amount of, if I come to your wedding. - October 11th, Brooklyn. - If I come to your wedding and ordinary is even playing out of an Amazon delivery van that's driving by outside, I'm going home. I cannot be in physical proximity to it. It won't, no. That's a workplace related injury. - Yeah, what was your song in the summer? - It's called Can't Go Broke. The remix of Can't Go Broke. It's by Zetti Will, who is a internet comedian, meme artist, and also emerging rapper. - Should I guess with that many jobs? - I can't go broke. - Look, I don't think it's possible. I don't think it's possible. I like to stay up by the mix all once. I can't go broke. I like to stay up by the mix. - It's almost like a great Nickelodeon skit of a rap song. Okay, top and it makes a tremendous difference. It's, it's, it's performed. It's comic. It's lighthearted. It's youthful. - I'm allowed to switch. - Really time to be in the studio bro, I'm about to quit. - Somebody call my anon now. Tell them get me out of here 'cause I'm about to fall. - I'm jumping in the pool. We're gonna get the pool. - I'm gonna get ready. - It's not really in discourse with like, what's happening on rap radio. You know, it's not there. It's very viral on TikTok. When I think of my summer and how I encountered music, I encountered so much music through the phone. I encountered a lot of music in the context of, does it make sense on a video? How does it interplay with all the other media that I'm consuming? And so for me, the song of the summer is a song of multimedia consumption. Yeah, and it's that. Madison, what is your song in the summer? - My song of the summer is a live performance of Addison Rae's Diet Pepsi by Ben Platt at a fake award show. I have worn it out. ♪ My boy's a winner ♪ ♪ He loves the gay ♪ - Madison, this is something that's sort of like, bubbled up over the last few weeks of August. - Sure, so Los Cultures, this is a podcast hosted by Matt Rodgers, Bo and Yang, and for several years now, they've run this very funny wonky fake award show. - This evening's ceremony will be just to use some technical terms, random sauce. Kukululu, shigad, here we award the film The Substance, but also The Spirit Tunnel from the Jennifer Hudson show. - Matt, I'm realizing we have a lot of fun. - And this year it kind of went more mainstream. It's on Bravo, if we just assume that to be mainstream media. - Absolutely, absolutely. - One of the acts was Ben Platt of Dear Evan Hansen fame, singing with all the earnestness and seriousness that won him the Tony Award for Dear Evan Hansen, Addison Rae's Diet Pepsi. ♪ Untouched X, O, Young, Lust, Lets ♪ ♪ When we drive in your car ♪ - It is incredibly catchy. It contains a little ad lib in which that man sings, "I like it from the fountain." - "I like it from the fountain." - Scratches the inside of my brain in a nice way. ♪ I like it from the fountain, yeah ♪ - Y'all love a meme, unbelievable. - Y'all are the problem. Speaking of dying Pepsi, speaking of sodas. because not the, the die doctor paper that you're drinking right now. - God, doc. - It's full test. - It's full test, yeah. - You talked to Addison right earlier this. - Sure did. - Yeah. - Yeah. You know what, as an Array said? - Taste is a privilege. - I saw that. - And what did you think of her saying then? - I thought that it was one of the most elegant self-aware things that a pop star has ever said to me in an interview. She was locating herself as a person who, when she was 16, 17, 18, did not have access to a lot of cultural product outside the very obvious mainstream, didn't know how or where to dig, and had this kind of life force urge to get out of the circumstance that she was in. And in moments like that, you can't necessarily be like, I wanna be artful, I wanna be weird. I have unusual perspective. You're just like, how do I get out of here as fast as possible? The, the speediest route. And for her becoming a TikTok star and kind of being very relentless about like, I'm on every trending audio, anything that's viral, I'm participating in. That was her speed run through the internet. And now, she's like, now I can have taste. It can happen for all of you. - I'm just saying, the high-poused birthdust both at a smile and Alex Warren's extraordinary taste is a privilege. - Taste is a choice and a privilege. - Can I talk about my favorite song in the summer? - My song in the summer. - It's rude we didn't ask, actually. - It is rude you didn't ask, which is why I'm budding in. - You're right, you're right. - Your song of the summer was? - Thank you for asking, Madison. My song in the summer, John's second favorite is all the summer, is Golden. - Yeah. - The song Golden from the movie K-Pop Demon Hunter. ♪ I was a ghost, I was alone ♪ (upbeat music) - Have either of you watched this movie? - No, because as John said, we all experience culture in our own fun little loud. - We're loud. - Just silos. - All right, well, let me tell you about the movie. - Please do. - Before you talk about your love, your shared love for the song Golden. This is a movie that came out earlier this year. Netflix, it's an animated film. It is, it's sort of imagines a world in which there are demons, much like the real world. - Yeah, I was gonna say it. - Demons have always haunted our world. Stealing our souls and channeling strength back to their king, Tima. - Until heroes arose to defend us. - There's always a group of three women that are responsible for keeping evil at faith. - And also in modern times, those women take the form of pop groups. (crowd cheering) - We love Hunter. - And in the movie, we're catching up with the, sort of the present day pop group, a K-pop group. They are called Huntrix. And they are out there singing songs. (upbeat music) And then the demons, they say, "Well, what if we come up with a band?" It's time for a new strategy. We fight the hunters where they're at least. Expect it. Go after the very thing that powers the Hunman, the fans, a demon boy band. - And it's Alex Warren. - And we can steal group of souls. - So it's as a river, the power of our music. - And they do. So there's Huntrix, the ladies, and then there's Saja boys. - They guys. - Just for clarity, I'm supposed to be rooting for the girl. - The woman always. - You're always, 'cause the, - Thank you, man. - Because the other group sounds pretty lit to me. - Yeah, the demon pop group, I bet the music's better. - Yeah, probably. Okay, so this movie came out in late June on Netflix and it has risen over a month and a half to be the number one most viewed movie on Netflix of all time. And in mid August, early to mid August, three or four of the songs from K-Pop demon hunters hit the Billboard charts. And that might be because there was a lot of other good stuff out there. I put this one song, "Golden" in addition to songs like "Soda Pop" and "Your Idol" have gone up there. And I'm gonna tell you straight up, I was introduced to this movie by my child. He heard "Golden" while he was on the school bus to a camp field trip. He brought it back. We played it for days. We watched the movie. We've seen it six, seven, eight times. It's been on loop and I can't get out of my head. And I love it. I love the way it goes up, up, up in the middle. I think it's very catchy. ♪ We're going up, up, up, it's our moment ♪ ♪ You're not together, we're going ♪ ♪ Gonna be, gonna be golden ♪ All right, John. It's fine. Okay, it's fine, it's fine. Here's a thing. As, no. I love John Carrabon. I'm gonna say that's fine. It's fine. I've been writing about K-Pop's entree into the American marketplace for a decade or more. I'm aware, I've read every article. There are so many gestures of sort of what I think of as big tent K-Pop in these songs, where they are all tempered with the kind of impulses of children's music. And that'd be a casual listener would say, oh, pop and children, there's not that much gap between children's songs and pop songs. Then in many cases, there aren't. But when I hear the singing here, what I hear is a denuded, desiccated version of the vocals that I think mark the best K-Pop. I also think the production is so optimistic. K-Pop is about, or at least the generation of K-Pop that this feels like it's referencing. It's maybe like a little bit prior to what's happening now. It's broad and chaotic and kind of like nuclear powered. And this feels like, what if we just made it smile? - And you're just like, no. - No, let's hear the other guys. - You want to hear Sasha Boyz? So do pop. (upbeat music) - Can two things be true at the same time? I also like this song. - It's wonderful. - This to me is a better song. It's a better approximate, I think of K-Pop. - Yeah, I'm more pro-this. On that positive note, let's take a quick break. (upbeat music) - Madison, something that I feel like broke through all algorithms because it was everywhere in sort of gross. Was Coldplaygate? Is that what we're calling it? What are we calling it? - We're calling it Coldplaygate. - Yeah. - Coldplaygate was a Coldplay concert, at which a man and a woman who should not probably, one of the Coldplay concerts together, were spotted on the jumbo tron, look in mighty comfy. - Oh, look at these two. All right, come on, you're okay. - Tried to jump out of frame, didn't really work. - Either they're having an affair or it's very shun. - And we all knew who they were by the following morning, thanks to the magic. That is the surveillance date we currently live in. - And these were two people who were, in fact, not married to each other. And I think at least one of them was married to someone else. How did that make you feel? - Terrified. And I look frustrated because this is a story with so many deliciously easy villains, right? You've got like cheaters, Coldplay fans, Quenna Calitros ex-husband. - You didn't identify Coldplay itself as a villain. - Oh, yeah, sure, Coldplay, Chris Martin, absolutely any other easy marks in this that I'm missing. - All the people, maybe that's turned this into various memes. - Right, and so it's super fun online, right? To have somebody who's clearly quote unquote in the wrong that people like to punch ad and mock and a tech CEO makes for a real good fit for that role these days. But honestly, it's just, it's a warning shot. Like to all of us, you should be scared. Okay, a couple of things. One, are we entirely sure this isn't a sign up by Coldplay's marketing team to draw attention to how many people are Coldplay concerts? Are we entirely sure? That's number one. No, no, no, don't answer that. Don't answer that. Okay, that's the first thing. Number two, look, we should be scared. I totally agree, we should be scared. But also, you shouldn't be cheating on your wife. You shouldn't be doing it in the public place. You shouldn't be doing it where there's cameras and phones. I think we've, we've normalized this way too much, right? I've written many, many stories about scenarios like these. You know, I can think about a woman in a restaurant being like, girl, your bridesmaids actually hate you. Oh, yeah. Like, you know, your roommates secretly hate you. Don't you want to know though? No, they do hate me. That's why I don't have any bridesmaids. Oh, okay. But we've, we've normalized a culture where this is not just happening in a place where you're correct. You're at a concert. There are jumbo trons, there are cameras. Everyone is literally holding a camera, turned on the entire time. But you can try to direct a line between that and you on the New Jersey Transit being over her. So unfortunately, as we have just laid out, that was one of the bigger things on the internet the summer, arguably not great. Bad for everyone involved. Were there any less depressing internet trends of summer medicine? All I have to say is nothing. And I do mean nothing. Beats a jet to holidays. Nothing beats a jet. to you holiday. So this is an advertisement for a British touring company. The ad goes nothing but it's a Judd to holiday. Starting right now, you can save 200 pounds of a family for pretend I'm British. I'm not doing that to our listeners, but pretend. We have an AI filter for that. That's kind of you. Fantastic. Yes. And all the while Jess Glens hold my hand plays in the background. And this, it underscored just an incredibly comedic trend on TikTok, right? You would use the video to be like, I think it's a Judd to holiday and it's a picture of you just experiencing something deeply awful. It also came with a song people already like in a summer where we've described this absolute hunger for decent tunes. And this tiny little TikTok audio, which I believe originated at the beginning of the year, like January of maybe even last year, just took off like wildfire. I just one thing about the Judd to holiday mean, which is, I feel like there's always conversation of like, how do we make something go? Let's like, you know, there's people in offices higher up than our floor on the 28th floor right now. There's people on the 30th floor, the 40th floor. I don't know. There are buildings 50th 60th floor. And there's people in rooms being like, how do we make something go? And we've got like, we just stole 20 kids from a college and we put them in a room and we forced them to tell us what was viral. It's like, it's not that hard. You have a lightly funny thing that anybody can participate in. Everybody has been humiliated. Everybody has at least one video on their phone of an absolutely either traumatic or sad thing. You could be like, trauma with funny audio, viral champion. Easy. What are you doing is a music critic. It's a great job. 50th floor is all over the country. Can I say now that if anybody has an office for me on the 50th floor of any building, I'm accepting DMs? We should talk about the Benson Boon Crumb will cookie that because that actually sits kind of at the intersection of what you're talking about, which is like a highly, highly curated internet moment. Okay. I'm going to try my own crumble cookie today. Maybe my screen crumble cookie. Benson Boon. He did a crumble cookie. And in case you're not familiar with crumble, it's a. Alex Warren of cookies. It's a wild. That collab is in the works already. It's a wildly popular. It's a wildly popular bakery chain that sells cookies that contain. And this is not to shame anyone for eating more calories than a human being needs in a week in a single cookie. I believe they actually sell like a little pizza cutter to cook to cook. Cookies until like relatively reasonable by the FDA or for really FDA portions. And they're gross. No, I don't tell RFK Junior about these cookies. I think this is like he and I like hand shake meme aligned. I most cookies are my nemesis. I wandered around New York City trying to try the Benson Boon Crumble collab cookie, which was a moonbeam ice cream cookie. And there were lines at the door at all of the crumbles I went to both for the cookies in general, but because people around the country had turned going to get this cookie into a trend. I'm here for the moonbeam ice cream cookie. You walk into a crumble and you backslip. Is there space in a crumble to backflip? It's a great one. In Jersey, the crumble you go to, is there a lot of square footages? Yeah, they're pretty big. I mean, that's what the suburbs allow. There you go. Backfliping. So look, a cookie connoisseur myself. Crumble comes along. I see all the tiktoks, people in like Irving, Texas with like a six pack, six different flavors. Again, as Madison said, all flavors that should not be in Congress with each other. And I'm like, I'm hitting crumble. Next time I see crumble, wherever it is, I'm hitting it. There are more than a thousand locations across the United States Puerto Rico and Canada. This thing is taking over. It's a blight. Well, I found one. And I said, I'm going to get just the rawest combos that you could possibly add. Just give me this string just cookies that are available here. Each one tasted like a pack of Post-it notes. It was unbelievable how for something with seven flavors in it, somehow still tasted like hard, like spiced cardboard. How can I? I'm running out of negative things. You're listening to this podcast and not watching it. So what you can't see is I'm scraping my teeth against the top of my tongue as though to remove some film that is still there. From this cookie that I ate six months ago, it was appropriate. Then that Benson Boone and Crumble came together. Absolutely. Yeah, he was the right person. And it was wildly effective. So how do we get talking about this? We got talking about it because Jettu Holiday was not meant to be this hyper viral moment. I'm just talking to blew up. Anyway, this they were hoping was going to hit. They wanted like a grimace shake. Do a window hour. They wanted a moment. Where were you in 2023? Where were you? Because I was at the McDonald's on 42nd Street drinking purple shakes for journalists. That's right. And we did it on pop cast. I went to the one on 7th Avenue. Got it live, live. We used it right out of grimace in the field. Yeah. Record it. We used it right out of grimace. Can we talk about another movie? Yes. Okay. I'd love to. Madison, you and I both saw a movie that's at least I loved even though it got a lot of crap on the internet the summer, which is a movie called material. I saw this too. Okay. Oh my god. I'm going to be a conversation. She's unbelievable. This was Celine Song, who was her first picture of past lives was nominated for best picture. This is her follow up. It stars Dakota Johnson, Chris Evans, Pedro Pascal. It was sold sort of as a rom-com definitely not a rom-com or a rom-drom. I have a thought on that. You think it's funny. And I went in. I was late to the movie. I had heard a lot of negativity about it. And I actually had a great time despite the performance. Great Twitter about this movie. Yeah. How much of the film did you miss? You weren't literally late to the movie. You were culturally late to the movie. You saw it. I did see it. And I thought it was quite beautiful. It was one of those warm, lush, New York city films that makes you go, man, I wish I could live in that city where I ostensibly live. I was infuriated by this movie, but perhaps not for the reasons that the discourse was, where you lose me is Dakota Johnson's character Lucy. Lucy. Yeah. Lucy takes great pains at one point to disclose her salary. I make 80 grand a year before taxes. Do you make more or less than that? More. I know. Finance, right? She's a matchmaker. She's a matchmaker and she makes 80,000 dollars a year is what she tells Pedro Pascal's character who does not disclose what he makes, but we are led to believe it is. $81,000 a year. It's 81. Pedro Pascal plays a very rich man. He plays someone in finance. I think I've got a former like 82. And the movie is about Dakota Johnson, who's a matchmaker, ostensibly having to choose between Pedro Pascal's very rich guy. And Chris Evans is broke actor, Bushwick residing guy. He lives with three. No, he lives in Brooklyn, somewhere. Look there. I'm not going to pay $25 to park this piece of shit for an hour. That's the cheapest we'll ever get. We'll find street parking on the next block. John, it's been 20 minutes. I'll just pay for you. Not paying. Dakota Johnson makes 80,000 dollars a year. She has a wonderful apartment. Everything's great. Everything's great. She's out here wearing Kate and Peranza and Botega. And that drove me just clearly of the real real shopper. I know the less. I think there was a lot of press sticking points. There's a lot of stress about the 80,000 dollars. I mean, I think we wrote in our debris. Do you write that? I didn't write that article. So you can just merge it if you'd like. And there are a lot of articles about like, Oh, no, 80,000. Not like it's a movie. It's like it's going to get a couple things. It's literally fiction. I agree. I agree. Here's the thing. You, when you introduced this movie, you said a rom-com, but not a rom-dram. And a lot of the 1.0 discourse on Twitter about this movie was like no human beings actually talk like this to each other. But you must know a lot about love. I know about dating. What's the difference? Dating takes a lot of effort, a lot of trial and error, a ton of risk and pain. Love is easy. Is it? I find it to be the most difficult thing in the world. That's because we can't help it. I just walk into our lives sometimes. Are you kidding on me? Definitely not. But I do think this is not how people who are falling in love or trying to feel each other out. It's a business deal. It's a transaction. So here's a question. Are these terrible lines? Are they terrible actors delivering good lines? Are they terrible actors delivering terrible lines? Are they good actors delivering? Here's my thing. Yes. It's It's actually on paper, everything's fine, but if the whole thing was delivered as like a slapstick romantic comedy from the early 2000s, kind of like, what is it like, 10 things I hate about you or whatever, if it was delivered in that manner, almost identical script, a film. But because everybody was so busy, just like having a serious, like, you're saying it's too stately. For no reason. It's not the physical comedy baked into it every romantic interaction, Lucy. That's her name. And has a handshake. It's like, we're just banging you over the head with the fact that this is a business deal. We are shaking hands. Me and Pedro Pascal in the kitchen as we break up, shake hands. I'm going to marry Chris Evans, spoiler, shake hands. Yeah. That would be very funny. I think genuinely, like, I was excited. I have very rarely been so excited by a negative discourse about a film. So much so that it made me want to see it. The Twitter conversation was so angry about this movie. And at the end, I'm like, it's almost there. But no one involved in making the movie had a sense of humor. And it is fundamentally a funny film. But no one there knows how to laugh. Well, let's turn to something now that I'm pretty sure the two of you are going to find hilarious. We are going to have the two of you take a summer pop culture quiz. There's a quiz. I feel like we should have been allowed to cheat a little. What's the quiz? So let's take a break. We'll do that when we come back. Welcome back. I'm Gilbert Cruz. I'm here with John Caramatica and Madison Malone Kircher. We are closing out the Sunday special this week with a pop culture quiz. I've got a bunch of trivia questions here about other pop culture happenings from the summer. I'm going to read out a question and the first person who buzzes in with the correct answer gets a point. The most points win. Okay. Okay. Jeopardy Rules. You got to get through the clue first before we're allowed to buy any point. That's a good question. It wasn't right. I think for the sake of our listeners, I should ask the full question before you determine when the question is over when the sentence ends. Okay. All right. Okay. Fingers on buzzers or space bars or mouse pads ready? Let's go. Number one, what stand up comedian and actor announced this summer that he'd be ending his long running interview podcast, Mark Marin, correct. What seminal American film set over the 4th of July weekend on Martha's Vineyard celebrated its 50th anniversary this summer. A big chill, great movie, wrong answer. The answer is jaws tick tock or a little bulls official claims to have the world's only 24-karat gold version of what viral, Madison, you ragged too early. What viral plus toy? I have the old world's only 24-karat La Boo Boo! La Boo Boo! The answer is La Boo Boo. That is correct. According to a single from singer Addison Ray's album Addison released the summer, what is fame? Madison. Fame is a gun. Fame is a gun. This is a multiple choice question. One of the top grossing films of the summer was the newest installment in the Jurassic World franchise. What is the title of that film? Was it A Jurassic World Dominion, B Jurassic World Rebirth, or C Jurassic World Fallen Kingdom? Madison. Jurassic World Dominion? Correct. Rebirth. That's a real movie, right? That is a real movie. Great. Next. Trolla Lero Trolla La, Ballerino Capuchina, and Bombadero Cruckadee. Italian Brain Rod. I did not finish the course. Next question. In what video game released the summer for Nintendo's new Switch 2 console, might you see a cow shoot a blue shell at a giant ghost? Bro, what? Neither of you play video games. Video games are one of the biggest things in the world. Alright, the answer is Mario Kart World. The pop star Justin Bieber got a lot of attention in the summer for a seventh studio album Swag, but also for a viral video clip in which he berates paparazzi for not plucking that Bieber is doing what? Standing on business. He was standing on business, as we all know. Is it not clocking to you that I'm buzzing before you finish the question? Alright, next question. This is a lightning round. The summer of 2025 was full of blockbuster movies about teams. I'm going to give you the names of the members of a team. You tell me what movie that team is from. Number one, Mr. Fantastic, fantastic for next movie, Luther, Benji, Grace and Ethan. Give me the full names. What is it? If I gave you the full names, you would not have gotten that one. This is Mission Impossible. The final record date, the eighth Mission Impossible movie, Ethan, Tom Cruise. Rumi Genu Mira, K-pop even hundreds, I just talked about this. Alright. And finally, a trivia question for two people who claim to think a lot about Taylor Swift. As we discussed, she announced her album on Travis Kelsey's podcast. She talked about baking bread. What did she identify as the best sourdough variety that she bakes? You have five seconds. She puts sprinkles in it for the Kelsey kids. That's not it. No. The answer is Cinnamon's Whirl. Yeah. Yeah. You know what? Yeah. I'm going to admit defeat. We're both defeated. No, no, no, no. I just want to say I should have known that. Fair enough. I accept that and all the Swifties out there who are listening, who are going to drag me for whatever I write about the Taylor album. Yeah. Yeah. They feel free to come for me. I am getting a note from our wonderful producer that tells me that the person who won our inaugural quiz is John. Would you like to see what your prizes? I have no choice. Okay. Alice Warren emerges from out of the table. We're going to, we're going to award this every week. Oh, I'm going to, I'm going to, here we go. It is, it is a Gilby. It is a trophy by face on it. What's your face on it? Yes. Oh, I'm keeping this. I'm sorry, Madison. I really hope you didn't actually win. I read what it says. It says the Gilbert Cruze Award also knows the Gilby. The Gilby Libri Peliculae Television Music Up, which I assume is Latin for books, movies, movies, TV shows, and songs. Yes. Um, Gilbert. John. This looks cheap. It is. I, here's, okay. So now you have to invite me back because by the end of 2025, my desk covered in these, I love it. I love it. I love it. I love it. I love it. John, thank you for appearing on today's episode, looking back at this has been a culture, this has been a blessing. Madison, thank you so much for being here. Anytime. Gilbert, it was a joy. I appreciate you. I appreciate your patience. I got thrown by your side. This episode was produced by Luke Vanderplug with help from Alex Barron, Tina Antillini, Kate LaPresti, Franny Cardtoth, and Dahlia Hadad. It was edited by Wendy Doerr and Paula Schumann and engineered by Sophia Landman. It features original music by Dan Powell, Mary Luzano, and Diane Wong. Thanks for listening. See you next week.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce announced their engagement via a joint Instagram post featuring a romantic garden photo and a detailed, flashy engagement ring, sparking global attention and social media frenzy.
  2. The engagement became a cultural phenomenon, with fans celebrating the union as a moment of joy amid a season of emotional and digital saturation, while also sparking debates over casual attire in engagement imagery.
  3. Taylor Swift’s new album, *The Life of the Showgirl*, was unveiled on her fiancé’s podcast, where her performance was described as emotionally authentic and highly choreographed, creating a deep sense of intimacy despite being heavily edited.
  4. The podcast episode explores the cultural fragmentation of music, rejecting the idea of a single “song of the summer,” and instead highlights viral, context-driven tracks like “Can’t Go Broke” and “Golden” from the animated film *K-Pop Demon Hunter*.
  5. Internet culture trends such as Coldplaygate, “Judd to holiday” memes, and the viral Benson Boone x Crumble cookie reveal how absurd, shareable content spreads rapidly through platforms like TikTok and social media.
  6. A critical discussion arises around the authenticity of modern pop culture, where performances like the fake award show featuring Ben Platt and Addison Rae’s Diet Pepsi highlight the gap between illusion and genuine emotional connection.
  7. The film *Material*, despite negative reviews, is praised for its nostalgic, New York-inspired atmosphere and its sharp satire of financial transactionalism in relationships.
  8. The Sunday Special launches as a weekly cultural conversation series featuring Times journalists, focusing on music, film, internet trends, and the evolving dynamics of modern entertainment.

Summary:

The inaugural episode of The Sunday Special features a cultural deep dive into summer 2023, centered on the global excitement over Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce’s engagement. Their Instagram post, showing a romantic garden and a lavish engagement ring, sparked widespread celebration and discussion, with critics highlighting both the emotional resonance and the absurdity of casual engagement fashion. The episode also explores Taylor Swift’s new album reveal on her fiancé’s podcast, where her performance is praised for its emotional authenticity, even if heavily curated.

Music trends are examined with skepticism toward the concept of a single “song of the summer,” instead emphasizing viral, multimedia content like “Can’t Go Broke” and the animated film *K-Pop Demon Hunter*, whose song “Golden” went viral through TikTok. Internet culture is dissected through trends like Coldplaygate, the “Judd to holiday” meme, and the viral Benson Boone x Crumble cookie, which illustrate how humor and absurdity dominate digital engagement. The discussion also touches on the film *Material*, which, despite its financial satire, is appreciated for its vivid setting and critique of transactional relationships.

The episode concludes with a playful pop culture quiz, highlighting the interconnectedness of music, film, and internet trends. The Sunday Special aims to provide a fresh, accessible platform for cultural commentary through in-depth, conversational storytelling.

FAQs

It's a new weekly series starting today, where culture and lifestyle editors share conversations about movies, TV, music, food, and art. It appears automatically in the daily feed for subscribers without needing to press any buttons.

They announced their engagement on Instagram with a photo of them standing in a decorated garden, with the caption 'Your English teacher and your gym teacher are getting married,' and a tiny dynamite emoji. The post went viral, sparking widespread excitement and online discussion.

It sparked a humorous and pointed discussion about Travis Kelce's casual attire in the photos, with critics noting it as unusual for engagement photos, highlighting the contrast between his athletic background and the formality typically expected in such moments.

Taylor Swift announced her upcoming album, 'The Life of the Showgirl,' on Travis Kelce's podcast. The audience was highly engaged, with many fans watching the episode and reacting with excitement, feeling they were getting a rare, intimate look into her life and creative process.

The podcast argues that the concept of a 'song of the summer' is a fallacy due to fragmented music tastes and algorithmic influence. Critics point to songs like 'Ordinary' and 'Can't Go Broke' as examples, noting their viral spread on platforms like TikTok despite lacking broad appeal.

Madison's song of the summer is a live performance of Addison Rae's 'Diet Pepsi' by Ben Platt at a fake award show. She chose it because it is catchy, humorous, and reflects a trend of pop culture blending music, internet memes, and self-awareness in viral content.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.