Go back

Stop Believing Everything You Think

45m 54s

Stop Believing Everything You Think

In a conversation with organizational psychologist Adam Grant, Gwyneth Paltrow explores the dangers of clinging to certainty and the importance of rethinking beliefs. Grant argues that people resist change because their identity is tied to their convictions, leading to echo chambers and defensive reactions. He highlights how intelligence often correlates with rigidity, as individuals use logic to protect their views rather than open themselves to new ideas. The concept of the "logic bully"—someone who bombards others with facts to prove correctness—undermines dialogue and learning. Instead, Grant promotes humility, vulnerability, and curiosity, such as by asking "how" rather than "why," to uncover complexity. He emphasizes that admitting ignorance or being wrong is not a failure but a sign of growth. Leaders and parents can model this by openly acknowledging their mistakes and fostering a culture where questioning is encouraged. The book *Think Again* advocates for a mindset of continuous reevaluation, where confidence coexists with humility, allowing both personal and collective evolution in relationships, workplaces, and society. This approach not only strengthens dialogue on sensitive issues but also cultivates self-awareness, resilience, and genuine connection.

Transcription

8245 Words, 44243 Characters

English
[MUSIC] When you are pioneering anything or introducing new ideas to the culture, you get criticized. You do? Yeah, did you hear about that? I didn't find the one. I found someone I respected and we made it the one. In the sort of longing kind of view of love, people understand each other as if by magic. Nothing in itself is addictive, one on one hand. And in the end, everything could be addictive. If there's an emptiness in that person that needs to be filled. I now know that nobody changes until they change their energy. And when you change your energy, you change your life. I'm Gwyneth Paltrow. This is the GOOP podcast, bringing together thought leaders, culture changers, creatives, founders and CEOs, scientists, doctors, healers and seekers, here to start conversations. Because simply asking questions and listening has the power to change the way we see the world. Here we go. This week, we're sharing a gem from the GOOP podcast archives. [MUSIC] My guest today is the brilliant Adam Grant. Adam is an organizational psychologist and a beloved professor at Wharton. He is also a number one New York Times bestselling author. And his latest book is called Think Again, the Power of Knowing What You Don't Know. Adam and I talked about why people generally fear being wrong. He says that we live in a world that celebrates certainty and often mistakes confidence for competence. We also talked about why intelligent thinkers fail to rethink a concept and how this limits their potential. Adam explains the trap of letting our ideas become our identities. And how we can find common ground with one another while navigating a charged topic. You'll also find out why Adam is a recovering logic bully. Last, if you can hear it, I'm sorry about the background noise in the very beginning of the conversation. That's just some work from home life for you. So let's get to my chat with Adam Grant. [MUSIC] How is everything? It's kind of fun to launch a book and go on book to your sitting in one place. So that's been the highlight, I guess. How about you? It's kind of amazing, especially when you have kids at home, right? And you're not going from one plane to another. Love that I can be in nine countries in one day. [LAUGHTER] Oh my god. Did you start writing this book pre-quarantine? Yeah, it was an accident. So tell me about the inception of it. I've had a hard time admitting that I'm wrong for most of my life. As a kid, my friends called me Mr. Facts. My best friend in middle school one day hung up the phone on me and said he refused to ever speak to me again until I admitted that I was wrong. And then, you know, passed forward a few years. And I'm seeing the same thing in all the people that I work with. Three years ago, I tried to get a bunch of CEOs to run a little remote Friday experiment. And they all said no thanks. And of course, if they had been willing to try that experiment, they would have had all of 2018 and 2019 to figure out how to make remote work work when we weren't-- working while we're taking three kids through online school and trying to avoid COVID. And I think seeing that resistance to rethinking in myself and also running into brick walls over and over again made me think, all right, somebody needs to tackle this. How would you describe the thesis of the book? I guess the thesis of the book is that people generally assume that if they're good at thinking, they're going to be good at rethinking. And that's not true. In fact, the smarter you are, often the worse you are at rethinking because you can use your intelligence to contort the truth into what you want to hear and what you want to believe. And I think this is important because we live in a rapidly changing world where it's possible to become an expert for a world that doesn't exist anymore. And the slower we are to think again, the more likely it is that we're going to be wrong a lot. And is it because you mentioned to think about intelligence and I think you mentioned in the book this great thing about being a logic bully, which I thought was so funny. Guilty as charged. I might even become a logic bully at some point in this conversation. And if I am, please call me out. No, I'll be so honored to be bullied by your brilliant logic. It'll go on my resume. But I'm just wondering a little bit about how this happens because I was thinking about this because of you the other night at the dinner table. And my teenagers, they are rethinkers. They're learning and they're open. They've not gotten to that place where they're calcified and they're thinking or they're right. It's extremely kind of agile. And so what is the kind of data that we gather throughout our lives to convince us that we're right? And what happens to us do we conflate opinion with self? Yeah, I think so many of us let our ideas become our identities. And it sort of makes sense. It's a way of maintaining a healthy level of self-esteem to feel validated. It's a way of making the world around you more predictable. If you were rethinking every single opinion that you had, you would feel like you're just living in chaos. And it's also a way to fit into your social circle. If you let go of your beliefs or admit that you're wrong, then you risk exclusion from whatever tribe you happen to belong to. And I think over time, a lot of us, we prefer the comfort of conviction over the discomfort of doubt. And it's easy to say, all right, I'm just going to listen to the ideas that make me feel good. Not the ones that make me think hard. To surround myself with people who agree with my thought-- or excuse me, to surround myself with people who agree with my conclusions. Not the ones who challenge my thought process. And I think that's such a travesty because over time, we get trapped in a filter bubble or an echo chamber. And then we're just affirming our beliefs, which is not learning. We're not evolving. And it's incremental, right? I mean, people get convinced slowly as they go along that they're more and more right. Yeah, I think we're great revisionist historians. The term for it in psychology is the totalitarian ego, where there's this mini dictator living in your brain, trying to control the flow of negative information and shield you from it the same way that Kim Jong-un would keep out bad press in North Korea. And that means that all the times we're wrong, we can explain away, we forget, we make excuses for. But the times we're right, we take pride in those. And that's who I am. What is underneath it, though? What hurts us so much about being wrong? Well, I might be wrong about this. So this is just a hypothesis in the spirit of practicing what I teach. But I think one of the reasons it's so painful to be wrong is we live in a world that celebrates and rewards certainty and that mistakes, confidence for competence. So there's this fear, right? I walk around thinking, oh no, if I find out that I was incorrect, then everybody's gonna think I'm an idiot. And that means I can't succeed, I can't make friends, and I'm in big trouble in life. What do you make of that? I think that makes a lot of sense to me. Well, there's certainly it seems like there's a survival piece to it, right? I have to, I equate my competence with survival. I also just wonder how it's linked to self-esteem and how much of our lives we spend fighting the idea of who we're afraid we are and how much being wrong sort of punctuate that. Yeah, it's, my favorite definition of hostility is the one the psychologist George Kelly used where he said that hostility is that sense of aggression or anger that you have toward someone who's convinced you against your will, that something that you already know deep down isn't true, is in fact not true. And then you just, you just want to lash out at them. You're like, no, no, no, I've been working really hard to persuade myself that that thing I was wrong about, I was not wrong about, and I hate you for making me see the light. So how would you apply that to, for example, what's going on right now in our country and this way this book is so incredibly timely? I think it's hard. I don't have any silver bullets, but I think there are steps we could take that on the margin might help. So which version of our country's problems do you want to talk about, Gweta? Well, let's start from the point of what you were just saying, which is somebody basically shines a light on some aspect of a person that they don't like or they've convinced themselves isn't real and then it's resonant and brought back up. So if you take this binary thinking, you know, take any issue that binary, right, take abortion. So there is a charge to talking about that topic, no matter which way you think and what you believe and what God you believe in and what freedom you believe in, whatever. There is such a charge to that issue and it becomes so incredibly emotional for people so quickly. And certainly for cohorts, for whom it will have never impact like men or grandmothers or whatever the case may be, but it's so deeply personal. So I'm wondering if it's true that people get super triggered by some unresolved aspect of them, how does that apply to one of these super hot button binary issues in the way people think about them? And why are they so reluctant to rethink them? Okay, so I think if I were talking to somebody who has a passionate view about abortion, that's different from mine. I would probably start by just acknowledging that I might be wrong or my understanding might be incomplete, right? I want to show humility. I think the mistake that people make when they go into these kinds of charge conversations is they go into preacher and prosecutor mode. I'm right, you're wrong. And then the other person either attacks or shuts down. What I want to do then is I want to signpost the conversation and say, you know, look, I've spent too much of my life as a logic bully. I just bombard people with, you know, data and with reasons. And I realize when I do that, I don't learn anything. And I also come across as really stubborn. And that's not the kind of person I want to be. And so I would love to hear some of your perspective and try to understand it better and learn from you. And very often with the other person will do that and say, oh, well, you know what? Actually, I'm interested in learning too. And then we've set the stage for a little bit of openness. Then I think the second thing I would do is I would try to establish that this opinion does not have to be your identity. So on abortion, it turns out that if you go back to the late 1960s, views on abortion were not divided on party lines. This is this is a relatively new ideological position. And I just ask a bunch of questions. Why is that? How did that happen? How is it that conservatives were not strongly opposed to abortion back in the 60s, but they are today? And the hope is that as we explore that, you recognize, all right, these beliefs are not said in stone. And once you recognize that, right, you're a little bit more flexible than you were before. And then from there, what I want to do, you talked about binary bias earlier. We're so good at taking these complex issues and oversimplifying them into two categories. I want to see the shades of gray. I want to say, okay, look, you know what? Let's find the areas that we agree on. We agree that 40 weeks, no abortions. We probably agree also that condoms are okay, preconception. Maybe. Let's find out. And let's now figure out where we draw the line in between and we can try to be a little bit more nuanced that way. But something happens to human beings in this process, and that's from sort of trying to understand is something happens along the way where even in a conversation that starts from a relatively open place, although nobody's going to approach it as you are unless we take your class and read the book, which I hope everybody will try to your own risk. But something happens in the course of these conversations where that kicks in, right, the resistance kicks in and the certainty kicks in. And is it possible to parse the fear piece or the fear of the ego piece from the actual subject in hand? And how do we get back to the actual discourse? Yes. Okay, good. So I'm thinking about the psychology of self-affirmation, which is about how when if I were to question your beliefs about abortion, neuroscientists would say you might feel like you've been punched in the mind. There's a literal activation of either your fear circuitry or you know, the punishment system and your natural impulse is to try to protect and defend. And one of the ways that I can preempt that is by affirming a core value of yours. To say, hey, Gwyneth, I know that you are somebody who cares deeply about human beings and who devotes a lot of your life to letting people be authentic. And once that's affirmed, it's a little bit easier to question one of your beliefs or your principles because all of a sudden your identity is more complex than just I have a stance on abortion. I might start there. And then I guess the other thing that I would be very curious about is the psychology of this is that jumping out from me is this difference between asking why and asking how. So when you ask people why questions, they tend to double down. They find lots of reasons to stick to their guns or maybe their gun vans depending on their ideology. When you ask people how, then they start to see gaps in their knowledge. And so I might shift the conversation a little bit and say, okay, I want to talk about the substance of abortion given that there are state rights, not just federal rights in America. How in the world would you even go about formulating a policy and advancing your view? And as people start to think that through, they're like, wow, this is really complex. It's probably not realistic to have one dogmatic stance. And so now I need to be a little bit more flexible. And again, the hope is that we can have a conversation then as opposed to just putting up a wall and saying that's the end of it. So I guess I should go back to this because your phrase logic bully, which I love. I guess the reason that this whole thing makes me, it always makes me think about where how our ego plays a role above anything else about what we actually think or actually believe and we can convince ourselves because my tribe believes something, I believe in something. And in order to try to convince other people, like we try to break other people down with logic. And it's super effective. I mean, if somebody, I think if somebody's coming at something with more of an emotional, emotionally driven opinion, and they don't feel as articulate to be kind of bombarded with with data and history and facts, it really just tends to separate people more. So how do we identify if we are logic bullies? Because I don't think any of us walk around thinking that we are. But in fact, we might very well be. I mean, if you really wanted to get scientific about it, you could start to track your own conversations. So I don't know that anybody wants to do this with the level of precision that we like in social science, but we measure things like question to statement ratios. And you see that if you're only giving answers and you're not asking questions, then you're probably more in logic bully mode. Another, I think, hallmark of being a logic bully. And I know because this is what I do all the time is like, okay, I just realized that somebody seems to be wrong about something that I think I'm an expert on, and it's my now, it's my moral responsibility to correct them. And then what I'll do is I'll start giving them 14 reasons. And not only am I making it clear to them that I'm trying to influence them, which leads them to put their guard up, but I'm also diluting my own argument. If they're resistant to what I'm about to say, then they'll just pick the least compelling reason, number 12, and just throw out the whole case on that basis, right? Whereas if I gave them my two strongest reasons, I'm less of a logic bully. And I'm also not giving them an easy excuse to just say, nah, I don't buy it. Oh my gosh. But I think the real way to tell that your logic bully is you're in a conversation with a student who calls you for career advice. And she says, Adam, you're a logic bully. Thank you for telling me. I didn't know that. And then maybe a week or two later, my wife told me the same thing. And she said, not everyone wants to have a three and a half hour argument about the future of self-driving cars. That's probably true. You know, I don't even think I want to have that argument. But when I get into it, and I think somebody's wrong, I just, I love this cartoon where there's a guy who's sitting at a computer and he can't sleep. And the little thought bubble is, like, someone is wrong on the internet. That's, that's the story of my life. Oh my gosh. I think that's the story of my life, too. Is it? I mean, sort of when I was sort of doing my own inventory around my own thinking. I think what you're saying is so interesting because I do think that if you're able to cultivate a feeling of that vulnerability is okay and you're not going to be humiliated by being in a debate where somebody's going to, you know, out-logic you or be super didactic or dogmatic and there's no point to it. It's really interesting how this flow can come forward between two people. And when when you're in defensiveness, it's such a, it's such a protection, having an opinion and being right. And what you touched on earlier, it's such a safe way to not explore the harder parts of yourself. And I think you can, in the workplace, too, and obviously this is an area of expertise for you, but trying to find that balance between like leading with that kind of vulnerability or an openness while also trying to lead and inspire and create boundaries and expectations. I wanted to ask you a little bit about that because it's a difficult balance and one that I'm trying to think a lot about as a leader. So how do you advise people to cultivate that balance? Individually or in their culture? Either both. Well, let's start on the personal level. I think we model behavior every day that signals to people what's going to get rewarded and what's going to get punished. Right? So I think one of the best moves we can make is to be the person we want other people to be. Right? Like Gandhi would have said be the change. I think what I'm looking for here is to say we could all model a little bit more confident humility, which is to be secure enough in your ego to say things like I might be wrong. I don't know. I, I, I had not very informed about this topic. And what that does is it sends that message, right? It says to other people, hey, you know what? Like this is, this is not a sign of ignorance when you say you don't know something. That's actually a sign that you're not insecure and that you're you're interested in improving yourself, not just proving yourself. And I think as a leader, if you can take that a step further, I did some research at the Gates Foundation where there was there was a real interest. in creating psychological safety so that people could take those kinds of risks and say, "Okay, if I ask for help or I admit that I made a mistake, I'm not going to get punished." And one of the things that I found was that when leaders criticized themselves out loud, so Melinda Gates, for example, reading negative feedback from employees out loud that people felt much more comfortable trying new things, taking risks, rethinking their own views, inviting leaders to rethink some of their assumptions. And I think what's so powerful about being able to criticize yourself out loud is you're not just showing that you're open to it, you're proving you can take it. And I think that's something we need more leaders to do. So I want to ask you this because I have teenagers, I have two of my own and two step. And as I mentioned before, they are inherently open-minded. But I'm worried that as time goes on and life goes on and they start to compound being right with being successful and they start to, as we all do, how do you, as a parent, encourage rethinking or that openness and thinking to be part of their foundation? I think one of the most effective things you can do is to talk about your own rethinking, to show your work. The modeling is a really big thing here. It is. I hadn't realized that was a pattern, but it is. And it's a pattern because if you, I mean, every parent has had the experience of, you know, of preaching at your kids and seeing them do the exact opposite. And they obviously pay more attention to what we do than what we say. And in this case, you could do both at the same time, which is I've actually, I've started talking with our kids, and my wife and I sometimes do this at dinner, we'll have a family dinner table conversation about our biggest mistakes, the, you know, the things that we were most wrong about. Sometimes it's actually really fun and light-hearted. We had a whole conversation, this is, I think last year, where they were, I think they were talking about the solar system. And it came out that we learned in school that Pluto was a planet. And they were shocked and horrified. How in the world could you think that? But they started asking us what century we were from and are we living in the dark ages? And it was a great moment for us to laugh at ourselves, right, to say, you know what? And not part of one of the conversations we ended up having was I said, look, not only did I believe for most of my life that Pluto was a planet, I also was resistant to letting go of that belief because I grew up thinking there were nine planets. If the solar system isn't what I thought it was, what else am I believing that's wrong? And that's pretty destabilizing. And so it was a chance for them to make fun of me, for me to make fun of myself. But then to really show, hey, you know what? When you screw up, when you're wrong about something, you can laugh at yourself. And yeah, maybe you're a little bit embarrassed that you were holding on to an outdated belief. But that's a sign you've learned something in showing that, right? You're teaching your kids to laugh at themselves too. Yeah. And so important to separate that feeling of, as you say, humiliation from being wrong, you know, because sometimes, I mean, actually this brings me to another question that I wanted to ask you about, which was, you talk about imposter syndrome in the book. And this is something that particularly, I'm not sure about men, but I definitely know that women and my peers, women CEOs absolutely feel it a lot. And there's a great deal of energy that goes into covering for that feeling. But you say that there are actually some advantages, right, to having imposter syndrome. So I would love to hear you explain that a little bit more. Sure. And I'm curious to hear whether this tracks with your experience at all, or the many gay women CEOs and founders that you hang out with. So this all started when we had a doctoral student at Wharton-Bassima-Tufik, who was interested in imposter syndrome. And she decided to study it and look at what impact it had on performance and different kinds of jobs. And she found, she basically just measured how often people had imposter thoughts. So how often do you doubt yourself, question your abilities, think that you're not as good as everyone else thinks you are. And she found with investment professionals and medical professionals. There were no costs of having more frequent imposter thoughts. And there were some benefits that investment professionals were more likely to second-guess their decisions instead of being overconfident, to say, hey, maybe I don't have all the answers. That physicians were more likely to listen to their patients instead of interrupting them. Yeah. Oh, maybe I should get a second opinion here. Maybe the diagnosis I was sure of in the first four seconds is not accurate. And I think what she came away realizing is if we define imposter syndrome as just your confidence being below your competence, that that creates a gap where you feel like, okay, I have something to prove. So that motivates you to work harder to close the gap. And then also you believe you don't know everything and that keeps you humble and it makes you curious and you learn more from the people around you instead of being on a pedestal of expertise. And I think where I landed on this was to say, why do we have to make this into a syndrome? Like a chronic debilitating condition? No. Yeah, okay. There are some people who walk around with this, you know, chronic sense that I'm unworthy. I'm a fraud. Everyone is going to find out that I don't deserve anything I've ever achieved in my life. My professors from 20 years ago are going to take away all of my grades because I can't possibly have known anything. That's rare, right? What's common is the everyday doubt of the, what if I've lost a step? What if I'm not prepared for this role? And having those thoughts is what keeps us motivated to succeed and motivated to learn is my thought. The data did show that women were a little bit more likely to hesitate in the face of those doubts and that men were a little bit more likely to be motivated by them. And I, you know, I'll say as a white man, I generally have had the privilege of walking around in a world where people assume that I'm competent and that I know what I'm talking about. And I can imagine if I had been a woman or a person of color, and I feel these doubts, I'm more likely to internalize them, right? Because I live in a culture where I have to prove my competence over and over again. So that's where I landed. What do you make of all this? Well, I think it's interesting because I obviously started in one career and then I went to another where the learning curve was so steep and I'm learning on the job, which I think underscores any imposter syndrome that would be kind of just baseline imposter syndrome that we all have going through the world. And for me, for example, I've been CEO for four or five years now and I've been growing the company and there are so many days I feel like an imposter because I remember when I started and I didn't know what certain acronyms were. And it was kind of googling under the table to not embarrass myself. And I was like, I don't know what the fuck anyone is talking about and trying to learn accounting and Excel and banking rules and just things that are we're completely out of my wheelhouse that I never went to school for, I don't have an MBA. So I feel like, yeah, I have a really good reason to feel like an imposter. But I think at the same time, what hurts is that it's mirrored by people who think an actress, a blonde actress, woman who started a company, she can't possibly know what she's talking about and she can't be close to her business. And I get comments all the time in meetings like, wow, you really, you're really close to your business. Like you understand your business. And so I think, wow, so the pervasive pre-judgment is that I am an imposter. So I think for me, it's a little bit heightened and I am or I used to be in a cycle of feeling like, I have to prove myself and I have to set the table by letting this person know that I actually am competent and that I do know what the acronym stands for and that I understand performance marketing and I understand inventory management or all this. But then at a certain point, I was like, you know what? This is not productive and it's not a good use of my time or energy. And I'm actually reinforcing the imposter syndrome by giving it this much contemplation time. And I also do feel that in certain aspects, it does keep me in the space of intense curiosity, intense learning and therefore intense inspiration. Yeah. Oh, that's great. So yeah. So you're trying to keep it from becoming a syndrome and just say, okay, if I feel, if I feel these doubts, then I'm going to take that as a clue that I need to work harder and learn more. Right. But I've always wondered about the confidence spill over a piece of this because you've been what Wendy Darling, Margot Tenenbaum, Pepper Potts for a lot of years, right? Obviously to master all those different roles, you had to build up a certain level of self-confidence. Is the issue that it didn't spill over into business and all of a sudden you're in, you're in a foreign culture or do you still get some of the, hey, you know what? I learned to excel at one thing, I can probably apply that same grit, that same curiosity, that same eagerness to learn to anything I try. I think the halo from the first thing is limited. It's a small halo. I think that, yeah. to truly be a founder or to start something to be an entrepreneur and to have to learn. It's like I was it was so out of my wheelhouse and I think there are certain things that I could were applicable. Like I do actually think that artists who want to succeed are by nature entrepreneurial. Like nobody believes in you but you. Nobody thinks you're going to be able to pull this off. You know you have to have more self belief than anyone else. So it's really aligned with what it means and what it to be an entrepreneur. There are some applicable things about culture. Like when you're a woman on a movie set, you learn a lot about managing dynamics and sort of keeping a peace and being a cheerleader and but other than that to go from my first career and to this one, I mean it was I was totally ill prepared completely. Got it. That's very interesting. Yeah. I think in some ways I'd rather see that in the opposite though, which is you know I worry so much about it's Tony Stark syndrome. I ace one thing and all of a sudden I over generalize that and think I must be a genius at everything. Right. Which I see with founders all the time. Yeah. I had a startup idea. Everybody told me I was crazy. It became a unicorn and changed the world. And now I believe that whenever somebody says I'm crazy, that means that means I must be right and they're all wrong. I've foreign witness to that. That's a very male founder trait I think. It might be. Yeah. I mean I think there's there's such a beauty in the world dismantling those ideas for you, even though it's so painful at the time. And look, you might be right once and you might have incredible success and you might generalize it, but pretty quickly the world will make you recalibrate. And those are, I mean for me anyway, those have been the most important lessons in rethinking the way that I think about myself and the way that I'm walking through the world is when there's a level set that happens. Because you know it's also a beautiful thing to believe so wholeheartedly and something. And the balance is where it gets so tricky. That's what's so fascinating to me is like balancing self-belief and humility. I think it's for so many people, it feels like a tight rope walk. And they're worried that I don't want to be overconfident. I don't want to be underconfident. This is what I love so much about the idea of confident humility to say, all right, you know what? I believe in myself, but I'm going to doubt my knowledge, my skills, my strategies. And that way, I'm not confident that I've figured everything out today. I'm just confident that I can learn tomorrow. Yeah, for sure. I love that phrase so much. It sets the, it's like sets the tone perfectly. You know, if you think about if you're nervous to go into a meeting or to do an interview or whatever, it's like if you can just embody that phrase and make it sort of make your molecules buzz, like you're set up for success, right? Bring it on. So this is an interesting one. So you talk up in the book as well about people pretending to know things that they don't know and that it's a pet peeve. It is, it's tough. This is a tough one. But why is that this sort of, you know, we have these, this cursory knowledge of something and then we, you know, exaggerated or why do we, what is that? Like, isn't it so easy to dispel, you know, somebody's knowledge about something or but it's so sad. Like, why do we do that? Well, I think the standard explanation in psychology is that when you're a complete novice, total beginner, you don't make that mistake because you know that you know nothing. And then as you start to get a little bit competent or a little bit knowledgeable, your confidence climbs faster than your competence. And pretty soon, you're, you're paying too much attention to the rate of your learning as opposed to how much knowledge you've actually accumulated. And you see this, like, there's a, there's a great experiment that David Dunning and I think Carmen Sanchez did when assimilated zombie apocalypse where they have, they have people, you know, they're in this simulation and there are all these people who have been bitten by zombies and they're taught, you know, how to treat them and cure them. And at the very beginning, like, I'm completely incompetent and they are actually incompetent. And then as they, they treat a patient or two, all of a sudden their competence goes up a little bit and their confidence goes up all lots. And we see this, I mean, we see this with medical residents, right? I think one of the reasons that a lot of people will, will reference the July effect with new residents taking over and, and more medical, excuse me, more medical errors being made is, is not necessarily because the residents don't know what they're doing. It's because they don't know that they don't know what they're doing. And that is, that's just a frightening place to be. Is there a correlation between that and that you're starting point? Do you know what I mean? Like, if you're, so if you're, if you're one of these people that start off from a place of not, of wanting to come off that you know more than you, you do, like, is there a correlation between that and how quickly there's that divide between your competence and confidence? Oh, I, I have, you know what, I haven't seen that study it. I think my hunch is yes. It's, it's a hypothesis waiting to be tested, but I think, yeah, if you're, if you're a narcissist and you're motivated to believe that you're really great, then it's pretty easy to confirm that and ignore any evidence to the contrary. My favorite definition of of arrogance is Tim Irvings, I'm wait, but why it's arrogance equals ignorance plus conviction. Yeah, I think if you're an arrogant person, you're, you're probably, you're going to confirm your, you know, your, your inflated view of yourself. But I also think there's, it's not just, it's not just ego and motivation, right? It's also information. One of the challenges of living in this territory where you don't know that much is you don't necessarily know what it looks like to know a lot. So there's, there's another study I like of, of people who score low and emotional intelligence. They're the most likely to overestimate their emotional intelligence. It's not just because they want to think they're good at, you know, at knowing what other people are feeling and managing their emotions. It's because if you lack emotional intelligence, you literally don't know what emotional intelligence looks like. And so you can't judge yourself accurately. Right. So say you're a professor at Wharton and you're tenured since your 28th and you, you've written all these bestselling books and how do you keep yourself in check? How do you keep yourself rethinking? Because you know a hell of a lot and your insights are really profound and you teach a lot of people, you elevate a lot of people. So how do you not let that get to you? Or do you? And then you have a way of unthinking it and rethinking it? Oh, this is not a hypothetical question, is it? I don't know if you know anyone like that, but I recognize the person you're describing. It's not that it's not the person I know, but that that portrait has been painted. I mean, I do a few things that I found helpful. The first one is I married Allison, my wife, who is the first person to point out when I'm wrong and it happens almost every hour if not every day. So that's a regularly humbling experience, which I think we should all have. Allison's my best critic. She is constantly like, I'm sure you've experienced for most of your career that people look at you and they say, okay, Gwyneth Paltrow, like, of course, I want her to like me and so I'm only going to tell her the things that she wants to hear. And Allison is the first person to say, like, you have no idea what you're talking about here. I don't know why anyone listens to you. You might want to rethink this. So that's always helpful. In that, I would say she's the founding member of my challenge network, which is a kind of network we all need. We know the value of a support network. They're the people who cheerlead for us, who encourage us, who rebuild our confidence when it's shattered. We need a challenge network, a group of thoughtful critics who believe in our potential and push us to reach it. And I have gone to a bunch of people since writing Think Again and said, hey, you may not know this, but I consider you one of the founding members of my challenge network. And I know I haven't always taken your criticism well. Sometimes I've been defensive other times. I've just been distracted or dismissive. But I really appreciate it. And if you're ever worried about hurting my feelings, you can't. The only way you can hurt my feelings is by not telling me the truth. And I've gotten much better critical feedback after having those conversations because people know, oh, well, this is not something I have to be worried is going to damage our relationship. I also am going to keep a running ignorance list, which is just a list of things that I'm clueless about. So I put on the list initially, fashion, chemistry, food, financial markets, art. And it's just a good reminder to say, you know what, there are huge parts of the world that I'm just completely uninformed on. And the hope is then that I seek out people who are more knowledgeable and I learn about those things. But also I came up with really specific things too. Like I still cannot figure out why you can't tickle yourself. I've talked to a lot of neuroscientists. They say it's the element of surprise. But then you can run the experiment. It's really easy. Go and tell one of your kids you're going to tickle them. And they'll still laugh. So it's not surprise. Like what is it? I don't know. And I really want to know. And I think having those, what are called curiosity gaps, right? A gaping hold between what you know and what you want to know? It keeps you eager to learn. - Yeah, that's for sure. I was gonna ask you about this way of thinking in a marriage. That was gonna be my last question. So, okay, so now we know how Alice in operates, but how do you apply this to your marriage? Like how do you, if the goal is to have this kind of quality of communication with your spouse, how do you bring this wisdom in the book and to a marriage? - I've been learning the hard way that I don't do it nearly as often as I should. I mean, there are days when Alice in's like, you wrote the book about thinking again, really? Really? I think the thing that I've found, I don't know, the thing that's probably been helpful most of the time is to just go in really clear about what I'm trying to accomplish. So, the mistake I make is, I'll say, hey, can you read this or, you know, what's your thought on this idea? And I'm not clear enough that I'm collecting lots of perspectives. So, what I've learned to do is to say, and sometimes I remember to do it, sometimes I don't, is to say, okay, I value your opinion the most and that means I'm gonna ask you at the beginning and at the end. And I'm gonna collect lots of different views in between because I know some of the things that I'll hear from you are quality and others might just be taste. And you're not a perfect representation of my audience and so, they're times when you love something, actually, no, they're times when you like something and other people don't, they're times when you don't like something and other people do. And so, if you hear me pushing back, that's not me not valuing your feedback. It's me trying to sort out, okay, how much weight should I put on this particular judgment or opinion? And I think that it's so interesting to me that when I seek feedback from other people and when they tell me things about my work, I know the first thing I have to do is to make it clear that I appreciated it and that if I didn't agree with it, it didn't mean I didn't value it, but I forget to do this all the time at home because I just take for granted, right? That Allison knows that I always appreciate her feedback and that's why I keep asking for it. And so, I think that's something I need to reinforce over and over and over again is, I'm asking you to help me rethink things. That doesn't mean I'm always gonna be open to it but I want you to keep doing it. How do you apply this in a marriage? - Well, you know, it's interesting because my marriage now, it's such a critical part of it's a real building block of my marriage, like having the capacity and the malleability to rethink and show up with vulnerability and talk about being called on your shit. I mean, I happen to be married to somebody who is so observant, he's so brilliant and so observant and so energetically sensitive and he leans into intimacy. And I'm like, when I get triggered, I'm like, I shut down. And so he's the one that is able to remain calm and give me the feedback that's so hard for me to hear. And hearing that feedback at the same time, you're thinking, I don't wanna be here, I'm leaving the room. I don't wanna feel anything and I know that this person is right. So at some point, I'm gonna have to figure out a way to metabolize all of this at the same time and understand that the purpose of this marriage is to break down these pre-existing ideas about myself that I've held on to so tightly in order to protect myself. And so for me, I'm really lucky because I have an amazing partner who makes me in a very nice way rethink these things. He sort of holds me to a certain standard and I think I do the same for him. But that's what's so interesting too about reading this book as a boss, as a wife, as a mother. Like there's so much incredible wisdom in the book and obviously it's your scientist that's coming from this place of research but then there's this really, it's strong together with this really beautiful human approachable way of like, you know, you just make it so applicable. I really, I'm so happy you wrote it and I'm so happy that I got to speak to you because it forced, it was a forcing function. Like I better read this right now. Otherwise I would've said, I don't have time at all but I just feel like it's gonna really stay with me and it's really amazing. Thank you so much for writing it. - Well, thank you. I hope you don't rethink anything you just said. (laughing) - Some thought should be protected and left alone. - Thank you for listening to my conversation with Adam Grant. I hope you pick up a copy of his fascinating book, Think Again. This has been a presentation of Cadence 13 Studios. I hope you'll listen, follow, rate, and review all of our episodes which are available for free on Apple podcasts, Spotify, Odyssey, or wherever you get your podcasts. - The good holiday gift guides are our calling card. We scour the earth for the best options in every category to make it easy for you to find the right gifts for everyone on your list. Think beautiful jewelry, thoughtful wellness tools, smart kitchenware, clean beauty, and more unexpected finds. Whether you're looking for a little luxury or a big splurge, you'll find something that feels personal in our curation. Explore the gift guide at goop.com and as our gift to you, take 15% off your first purchase with code podgiftexclusionsupply.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. People often resist rethinking their beliefs because they tie their identity to certainty, leading to self-protection and echo chambers.
  2. Intelligence does not guarantee openness to rethinking; instead, smart people may become more rigid, using logic to defend fixed views.
  3. The "logic bully" mindset—presenting facts aggressively—fails to foster learning and deepens division in conversations.
  4. Vulnerability and humility, such as admitting ignorance or being wrong, create psychological safety and encourage growth in individuals and groups.
  5. Shared curiosity and structured questioning (e.g., “how” instead of “why”) help break down dogma and reveal complexity in issues like abortion or policy.
  6. Imposter syndrome, while often seen as negative, can actually promote learning and humility when viewed as a natural part of growth.
  7. Leaders can model rethinking by openly acknowledging mistakes, which fosters trust and encourages others to do the same.
  8. The balance between confidence and humility—what Adam calls "confident humility"—is essential for personal growth, leadership, and healthy relationships.

Summary:

In a conversation with organizational psychologist Adam Grant, Gwyneth Paltrow explores the dangers of clinging to certainty and the importance of rethinking beliefs. Grant argues that people resist change because their identity is tied to their convictions, leading to echo chambers and defensive reactions. He highlights how intelligence often correlates with rigidity, as individuals use logic to protect their views rather than open themselves to new ideas.

The concept of the "logic bully"—someone who bombards others with facts to prove correctness—undermines dialogue and learning. Instead, Grant promotes humility, vulnerability, and curiosity, such as by asking "how" rather than "why," to uncover complexity. He emphasizes that admitting ignorance or being wrong is not a failure but a sign of growth.

Leaders and parents can model this by openly acknowledging their mistakes and fostering a culture where questioning is encouraged. The book *Think Again* advocates for a mindset of continuous reevaluation, where confidence coexists with humility, allowing both personal and collective evolution in relationships, workplaces, and society. This approach not only strengthens dialogue on sensitive issues but also cultivates self-awareness, resilience, and genuine connection.

FAQs

People resist rethinking because their beliefs often become part of their identity. This provides a sense of stability, self-esteem, and social belonging. When they admit they're wrong, they fear exclusion, loss of control, or being seen as incompetent.

A 'logic bully' is someone who uses data and arguments to dominate a conversation, often at the expense of openness. This approach fails to foster learning and can create defensiveness, making it harder for people to reevaluate their views.

By modeling vulnerable humility, such as admitting ignorance or saying 'I might be wrong,' people create a safe environment. Leaders who openly criticize themselves or share mistakes help others feel comfortable questioning their own beliefs.

People often equate self-worth with certainty. When challenged, they feel a threat to their identity, triggering a defensive response. This makes them more likely to cling to beliefs and avoid uncomfortable doubts.

Asking 'how' invites exploration of practical details and reveals gaps in knowledge, making it harder to stick to rigid views. It shifts the focus from defending beliefs to understanding real-world applications and complexities.

No—doubt about one's abilities can be a strength. It fosters humility, curiosity, and a drive to learn. When balanced with confidence, it motivates growth and helps people stay open to feedback and change.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.