Steamy Texts, A Shotgun, & 2 Mistrials: Who Killed Lisa Techel?

[MUSIC] Hello, everyone, and welcome back to another episode of True Crime with Kendall Ray. Thank you so much, as always, for joining me today. I'm so happy to have you here, and I hope you are having a great day. If you are new to my show, make sure that you click subscribe or follow or whatever it is on the podcast apps so that you never miss an episode of mine. Also, I just wanted to say thank you so much for the great feedback on my new set. I absolutely love it. I am going to be making a couple little changes, just a couple little things, first of all. So many of you commented with a fantastic idea to put a framed picture of Lily on one of the shelves so that she's kind of always with me. I love that. I love that. Thank you to all of you who came up with that idea, and I'm going to be getting on that as soon as possible, so that will be here soon. But yes, thank you. I really appreciate the positive feedback, and I'm so excited about this set. You guys have no idea. I have so much more space in this room. I have a place to record without distractions of my nine pets. Obviously, I did like having my cat and my dog with me in the room, and oftentimes, my dog, Bernie, is in here. I have a bed for him off to the side that you can't see, but I do have two massive dogs at home that are very loud and my daughter, for a little four-year-old. She can create quite a lot of noise. I can hear her what I call heffalumping upstairs, just running back and forth. If you know that's a poo bear reference, I'm pretty sure they were called heffalums. But yeah, that's what I always refer to it as, and it gets loud, it gets distracting. So I'm just in this nice, quiet, professional space. I feel so much more locked in. So thank you guys for all of your support, and I, you know, it is not lost on me. I wouldn't be able to have the equipment I have in the studio I have, and the studios we have built for all of our mile hire media shows, which if you haven't checked them out, I'll put some overlay of our other studios here. If you want to check out any of our other new sets or shows, if you've never checked them out as well. But yeah, we know that we would not be able to do any of this without the amazing audience we have, and the support that you've all given us over the years. So big thank you. Now the case that I am going to be telling you about today made me especially angry because today we're going to be talking about the murder of a pregnant woman who not only was pregnant, but just seemed like a fantastic person with a wonderful family. And it has just broken my heart researching for this case. Now this is one that I had first discovered, first heard about when I was pregnant. And I just knew I couldn't mentally handle talking about it at that time. You know, there's only so much I can mentally take on right now. For instance, I know there are some very, very highly requested cases right now, specifically the Lindsay Clancy case that I know you guys want me to cover, but I am five months postpartum. In that case from the day I heard about it years ago, just absolutely wrecked me following it to some degree because I can only mentally handle so much has been extremely upsetting. It is such, such a difficult case. And so I just can't mentally take it on, but I feel like I'm in a good place now where I can at least talk about Lisa Teckles case because her case absolutely needs more awareness. Her story needs more awareness. And I just really want to highlight how amazing I think her family is now Lisa Teckles was about halfway through her pregnancy very far along when her life was taken from her. And I assure you when you learn the reason why her killer took her life, you will be just as pissed off as I am. And don't even get me started on how many attempts it took to bring her killer to justice. Before getting into this episode, I just wanted to thank you all for listening to and supporting my show and also any of the mile hire media shows. Your support makes it possible for us to continue funding grants through my foundation higher hope, which supports victims of violent crimes, their families and like-minded nonprofits. Let's go ahead and get into this episode and I want to start out by, of course, talking about Lisa and telling you how awesome she was. So Lisa Marie Caldwell was born on May 7, 1989 in Ottawa, Iowa as the oldest daughter to her parents Todd and Tracy who despite not staying together were equally committed to loving her and her family says that she was just an absolute joy to be around from the time that she was little and she was always really the life of the party. And for any Elvis fans out there, she was named Lisa Marie after Elvis's daughter of course Lisa Marie and that was a name that her dad says she really lived up to and it's been said that once she started talking, she didn't stop, which I can relate to that. I'm a big yapper myself. But yeah, she always wanted to do everything to the best of her ability, according to her loved ones. And one area that Lisa truly put her entire heart into was her family. I mean, you can just tell from interviews what a strong bond this family had and still has of course, but you know what I mean. From a very early age, for example, even after her parents blew it up when she was a teen, her dad got remarried to a woman named Amy and ended up having twins with her. And even though of course there was quite a big age difference there that did not stop Lisa from getting close to them. In fact, Todd and Amy said that she was almost like a second mom to the twins with how much she helped take care of them. And in addition to her sibling, she also spent a lot of time getting close to Amy. And I loved this, but she said that one of their favorite things to do together was watch old episodes of Golden Girls, which is something that I used to do with my grandma. And that show just holds a very special place in my heart. And I know like anyone who's a Golden Girls fan understands how special the show it was and just like what a, you know, iconic era of television. And I guess Lisa would always joke with Amy that she was like Dorothy because she was super grumpy. But from what I can tell, it sounds like Amy was both like a mom and a friend to Lisa. And one thing that I loved hearing about is how she would always pry into Lisa's personal life. Like she wanted to be in the know fully involved when it came to everything, like for example, who she was dating. And actually everyone was quite thrilled when Lisa told them that she was dating a local boy named Seth Teckle. Now some background here. Okay, so growing up Lisa got really into bullying and like everything that she set her mind to from what I understand, she was really good at it. And I'm not just saying she got a couple strikes here and there. No, she was like state champion level good. And during this time she decided to get a job at the bowling alley, of course. And Seth happened to work there as well. And his dad was actually Lisa's bowling coach and owned this bowling alley. So the Teckle family was no stranger to the called wells. And both families really had a good reputation. Seth's grandfather was actually the mayor and his mom was a social worker. And then as for Lisa's dad, he was a sheriff's deputy. And something that was really interesting to learn was how close Lisa and Seth got with the other person's family and friends. They really became intermingled and all of Seth's friends really, really liked Lisa because she was into things like hunting and fishing and shooting guns. And when it came to his family, they could not have liked her more. They really viewed her like a daughter. They really brought her into their family, treated her as such. And it was the same way that the called wells felt about Seth. One of Lisa's sisters, Presley, who was also obviously named after Elvis, even described him as being one of her best friends. So as you can imagine, everyone was just thrilled when the two of them announced that they were going to get married. Chad said that Seth was very traditional and he even asked permission before proposing, which Todd, of course, said yes to, I mean, he loved Seth. He thought he was a great fit for his daughter. His only request was that Seth promised to love and protect his daughter. And he said he would. So after seven years of dating, they tied the knot in October of 2011. When Lisa was 22 years old, and Seth was 21. Now, when it comes to their ages, I know there are always a lot of mixed opinions on people who get married young in my audience, and just the internet in general. And listen, there are plenty of people that get married young and go on to have very successful marriages. I was, I think, 23, maybe 24 when I got married back. My husband and I were definitely on the younger side. And we have a great marriage. I mean, our marriage is literally better than it ever has been. And I have no regrets about getting married that young, but, you know, it doesn't always go that way, of course. But in this specific case, you know, given their history, their relatively young ages didn't seem to be a concern at all to them or to their families. And honestly, I don't think I can really explain enough just how tight knit all of them were. For example, Seth and Todd were so close that Todd was even helping him get a job at the Sheriff's Department. And Seth had always been drawn to careers in service. He had been a volunteer firefighter. And then at the time, he was a security guard. So getting a job at the Sheriff's Office was sort of the next step up for him. And actually, Lisa was pursuing a career in the same field after earning her degree in criminal justice. She worked as a reserve deputy and then as a jailer at the Washington County jail. And I know her dad was really proud to see her fall. in his footsteps, but I think like any father, he had his concerns when she first expressed wanting to work in law enforcement, mainly because there, of course, are inherent dangers when it comes to that kind of job. So he wanted her to be exceptionally good at it so that he didn't have to worry about her safety. But she certainly did. I mean, I don't think she ever gave him any reason to be worried about her. She was smart. She was driven. She was incredibly hardworking, in my opinion, she was a total badass. So whatever she put her effort into was something that she was going to be great at, basically. And that was supposed to apply to motherhood as well. And if she was given a chance to be a mother, I have no doubt that she would have been a fantastic one. And that child would have been born into a wonderful family. When you run a small business, you don't just do the job. You're also the hiring manager, the payroll department, the benefits team, and usually that's all before lunch. Gusto can take a few of those things off of your plate quickly and seamlessly. Gusto is the online payroll and benefits software built for small businesses. It's all-in-one, remote-friendly, and incredibly easy to use so that you can just pay higher on board and support your team from anywhere I can speak from experience. The offer automatic payroll tax filing, simple direct deposits, health benefits, commuter benefits, workers comp, 401k, you name it. Gusto makes it simple and has options for nearly every budget. They even offer unlimited payroll runs for just one monthly price. No hidden fees, no surprises, and you can save time with built-in, augmented tools, offer letters, onboarding docs, direct deposit, and more. And it's quick and simple to switch to Gusto. Just transfer your existing data to get up and running fast. Plus, don't pay a cent until you run your first payroll. It's ranked number one on G2's highest satisfaction products list for 2026 and trusted by over 500,000 small businesses. At Mile Higher Media, we have been using Gusto for years, and it's been such a nice experience for us. We've literally never had issues, and there's been so many times where we have just looked at each other like, wow, the amount of time that we are saving by using Gusto, the headaches we have saved ourselves, is honestly crazy. So try Gusto today at Gusto.com/tckr and get three months free when you run your first payroll. That's three months free of free payroll at Gusto.com/tckr. One more time, Gusto.com/tckr. By May of 2012, Lisa was halfway through her first pregnancy, and she was having a little girl who they planned on naming Zoe Maria. But in the early morning hours of May 26th, Lisa was shot in the bedroom of her trailer that she lived in with Seth, which ended both her life and the life of her unborn baby. Now the gunshot that killed them rang out around 5.05 am. And according to Seth, he was in the shower when he first heard the commotion, and he said it took him a minute to process it understandably. But once he registered what was going on, he immediately jumped out of the shower and ran to her. And he said he could tell right away that she had been shot in her side. Now his first response was to grab one of his guns and run outside because he thought maybe the killer was out there and he wanted to try and catch them. And then he didn't end up seeing anyone, so he ran back inside and at that point, he called 911. The call came in at 5.23 am, which notably is 18 minutes after he said he heard the gunshot. And coincidentally, the responding deputy was someone he knew, which honestly doesn't surprise me because they lived in a really remote area in agency Iowa. I mean, this is the kind of place where everyone just seems to know everyone. But anyway, when the deputy and the paramedics got there, it was sadly too late. Lisa was gone and there was no way it would have been able to save her or her baby Zoe. And I should also mention that this was actually the first murder in their town in over 15 years. So it was definitely not something that anyone was particularly used to handling, right? And I say that because in hindsight, the responding deputy says he regretted his decision to call Lisa's dad soon after what happened. And Todd was one of the first people who got called to the scene. And as I'm sure you can imagine, he rushed over there as fast as he could. He and Amy were both asleep when the call came in, but they both got in their cars and just sped to Lisa's trailer. And I don't think I mentioned this earlier, but Amy is actually a nurse. So she thought if she could just get there fast enough, that maybe there was something that she could do to save her, but both she and Todd knew as soon as they got there, that that wouldn't be possible, leaving the two of them just absolutely beside themselves with grief. The scene, the two of them or sobbing, you're able to hear it in an episode, I think of 48 hours in the body cam footage. And it is absolutely heart wrenching. It is so painful to listen to and I'm definitely not going to be playing it here because it's just, it's too upsetting and there's no reason to play that in my opinion. Meanwhile, Seth is also having to explain through his sobs about the intruder that he says shot his wife and also in the dash cam footage, which my video viewers can see on screen. And it's important to see this. Seth is absolutely hysterical. He's stomping around. He is pulling on the fence. He punches a car at one point. So yeah, he has just beside himself as well. And interestingly, when he was telling his story about what happened, Todd, Lisa's father said he knew of someone who could have done this. And he told the deputies to go get him. He's in the body cam footage as well. And he's referring to his daughter's 56 year old neighbor, Brian Tate. Now when it comes to Brian, there is some things that we need to go over because context is super important here. So I need to jump back about two months because that's around the time that a feud developed between them to say the least. And like I touched on earlier, Seth and Lisa were living in a trailer in a remote area in agency Iowa. And it was a place where they had a few neighbors, but everyone was separated by a bit of land. And among these neighbors was Brian Tate, who I should also mention was a disabled veteran. And he had also been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia. And with that came troubles with Lisa and Seth. And it's a pretty weird story. I don't even fully understand it. But I guess two months before she was killed, Seth said that he found a dead deer on the side of the road, sort of near the property line. And for whatever reason, this is what I don't get. He and Brian kept throwing it back over the other person's side of the fence. And that ended up causing a feud between them. Or I'd imagine there was some type of feud or some disagreement that happened before that. That would make them want to keep putting the deer back and forth, which is so gross and so bizarre. Or maybe that was the reason that the feud started. I'm not totally sure. Very strange though. But anyway, things had escalated to a point where someone started throwing rocks and dog shit at Brian's house. And it's honestly really, really sad to think about. Brian ended up calling the police about it in April of 2012. And of all the people to respond to that call, Todd was the one who showed up. And that interaction was captured on his dash cam. And Brian explained to Todd that he believed that these were acts of terrorism, which obviously tells you that Brian was pretty scared and very upset and disturbed by this whole situation. And when hearing this, Todd started to realize that Brian is probably not in his right mind. And he didn't know the exact specifics of his diagnosis and everything, but he really started to question things and felt like maybe he was unsafe for his daughter to be living next door to. And I mean, don't get me wrong. I would be furious if someone was throwing rocks and dog shit at my house too, but terrorism is a very strong word to describe what was happening. I mean, it's really just bullying and vandalism, not okay by any means, but for him to use the word terrorism, I think was a bit shocking to Todd, but that is how Brian truly saw it. And of course, we also know that he was struggling with his mental health. I mean, he's a veteran. And so it does make sense that he perceived it that way. However, since he was telling Todd that his daughter and Seth were to blame for this terrorism going on, Todd realized that he probably shouldn't let Brian know that he was actually related to the people he was accusing of terrorism. So instead, he just told Brian that he would look into it. He also went privately to Seth to be like, listen, dude, if this is you throwing the rocks in the shit at Brian's house or any of your friends. friends or you know about this in any way you got to cut that shit out because you know you're really upsetting Brian and he struggles with mental illness and you need to be careful he's very upset but Seth denied any responsibility for this either way regardless of who was responsible Todd did not have a great feeling about Brian in general especially because he had seen that he was carrying his shotgun so he really was worried about Seth and Lisa's safety Todd even ended up writing a letter to his fellow deputies just letting them know that you know they could be dealing with a mentally ill individual here and since the vandalism did not stop after this call tensions continued to rise so much so that both of their families were on edge about the whole situation that being said Lisa and Seth assured them that they could handle it however only 11 days before she was killed Brian called the cops again complaining that the terrorism was getting worse Todd was called to the scene this time as well and he along with another deputy agreed that Brian didn't appear to be stable so fast forward to the morning of May 26th you can probably understand why Todd's brain immediately went to Brian after he found out that his daughter had been murdered so naturally he becomes number one suspect in this case and investigators ended up confronting him that morning right at his house and what's interesting about that interaction was that they were expecting him to be pretty hostile but that wasn't the case at all Ryan was very calm he even pulled up lawn chairs for everyone to sit down in so that they could just talk and what investigators couldn't quite figure out was whether or not they could fully believe his alibi according to Brian he had taken a heavy dose of his anti-psychotic meds and he did that the night before and he said that because of the medication he was asleep until 11 a.m. and he straight up told them that he was diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia and that he would walk his property line to guard his house early in the morning but not on that morning because he was asleep due to taking this heavy dose of his medication I went to bed about 830 yeah after a mom did you hear anything in the middle of the night last night I was in bed and normally I would have been up doing guard duty with all this s**t that happened but I'm schizophrenic very annoying I said earlier Brian that you you'd sit outside here at night yeah when's the last time you did that it's been a good week or so they don't want me to do guard duty anymore they want me to get sleep take more medications we were such a calm quiet guy until his vandalism started and then you're just like a different person I was mr. nice guy for a long time it done me no good people took advantage of me so I'm kind of taking a different approach to life right now and more serious and more not such a nice guy now his mom who was there when all of this was happening corroborated this and she also told investigators just how much this whole vandalism thing had really changed her son she said that he was actually doing really well emotionally before it started happening but he almost became a different person afterwards and honestly nobody was quite sure what to believe of course moms lie for their children all the time I mean we have covered plenty of cases where that happens but also they didn't have any actual evidence that he killed Lisa so at least for the time being Brian remained a suspect I come from a long line of people who love a good deal especially my mom oh man she loves a good deal we spent nearly every weekend during the summer at a garage sale and that was my favorite way to spend the day honestly we'd find so many cool treasures and that was really instilled in me at a young age that finding a deal feels great and that's why I've had so much fun with the app what not it's actually the number one live shopping app in the United States making totally see why it's an absolute blast and you can get some incredible deals and it's the app where shopping happens in real-time with real people real conversations and again incredible deals on what not you're connecting directly with sellers and other shoppers as well it's like hanging out in a group that gets you and it's a totally fun way to shop and you almost never pay full price you can shop name brands across makeup perfume clothes handbags jewelry and more all without that retail sticker shock this is the best place to find great deals on products that you love and I've been able to pick up some things like handbags that I never would have paid for full price and I am talking from brands like Louis Vuitton I actually got myself a Louis Vuitton wallet and a Louis Vuitton purse and not only did I get a great deal on them but shopping pre-loved is better for the planet and of course better for my wallet and you can find so many unique pieces that you wouldn't be able to find anywhere else things that aren't even sold anymore and there's amazing sellers with great taste that are going live literally 24/7 and you can comment in real time and they'll show you a close-up of the clothes so for instance maybe you want to understand the sizing a little bit more or you have a question about quality or the condition of a pre-owned item they can show it to you up close and maybe you want to be a seller and maybe you have clothes bags or accessories that are just sitting in your closet that you no longer reach for and maybe someone else would love what not makes it easy to turn them into cash and connect those shoppers who share your style and have fun going live while doing it. It's a great way to find new brands because sellers don't date keep. So download what not today and get $20 off your first purchase, search what not W-H-A-T-N-O-T in the App Store, sign up and start finding deals on the products you love with $20 off your first purchase. Terms apply. Fall means back to routines. I know so many people feel that way and hopefully you can find a few more moments for yourself in that routine. Maybe it's that first quiet cup of coffee after school drop off or maybe five uninterrupted minutes to actually get ready for your own day. While if you're busy mom like me or just a busy person in general, Merit Beauty makes those minutes count with effortless, elevated makeup that's designed to help you look polished without a complicated routine. A few simple swipes, a little blending with your fingers and you're ready to go. You've probably heard me talk about how much I love Merit Beauty. Their products are excellent. Every single thing I've ever tried from Merit Beauty is just wonderful and really routines only give you time back if they're efficient and Merit Beauty is designed to help you look put together in minutes. It's the perfect brand for those busy fall days when you want to feel like your best self without a complicated routine. First of all, I got to recommend that they're great skin serum for a visible healthy looking glow instantly. You can honestly just pop that on and be ready to go. It adds so much and then the minimal list, which is one of my favorites. Works double duty as both a foundation and a concealer, so you can get that quick buildable coverage. Now this is something I always carry with me. I have one in my work bag and one in my purse and then of course one in my makeup kit as well. But these two together are literally going to be your best skin in just two steps. And then I had a little flush bomb for a natural flush from within cheat color that last all day. And then you can swipe on their newly launched clean volume mascara for an effortless polished look in just five minutes. And the best part of it all is merits products are clean vegan cruelty free and made with nourishing skin care ingredients that leaders can looking better long after taking off your makeup. And fall is the perfect time for that fresh start. So go make it your back to me season with merit. And right now merit beauty is offering my listeners their signature makeup bag, which if you've already seen it. It's not just a makeup bag. It's really an accessory. I actually use it in my car is kind of my center console holder for a bunch of different things. It's so cute. And you get that free with your first order at merit beauty dot com. That's M E R I T beauty dot com merit beauty dot com. And the other person who became a suspect was of course Seth, which makes total sense, right? I mean he was home when it happened and statistics are statistics for a reason. He became someone they were interested in and that evening he was actually brought in for questioning. Now when it came to his questioning, an agent with the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigations, aka DCI was taking the lead in both the DCI and the local police were conducting the investigation. However, despite working for the sheriff's department, Todd was not involved and not because he wouldn't have wanted to be part of getting Lee's justice, but because this case was just too personal. He did say he was confident though that the people in charge would find her killer. And I thought this was interesting and also very professional on Todd's part, but he actually did not want to know anything about the investigation until an arrest was being made. And from what I gathered, nobody in their family really believed that Seth could have possibly been responsible. That just seemed really out of the question for them. And Seth himself was denying any involvement. He even told his parents not to get him a lawyer because he was so confident. He said he understood, of course, investigators have to rule him out because of protocol and there was nothing to worry about. So his questioning began that evening and he started explaining what he said happened. Hey, are you okay with what's going on? Okay, she started melting and saw the hole. and her sports brought on her left side in case of the ceiling. As I was in rated pressure on it, it's when I heard the noise in the living room. It's when I grabbed my jaw and it's when I took off running it. It was there, the door was open. It came back into the bed, the bed here. She had stopped reading. After that explanation, Seth was asked to, and he thought could have been responsible. And he didn't hesitate to say Brian's name. Explain the whole feud situation and how Todd had warned him to stay away from Brian because he was, quote, "off his rocker." And honestly, there were several points where he seemed to really be breaking down and crying about everything, which would make sense, right? I mean, he definitely looked like a grieving husband. That being said, the agent who was interrogating him didn't take his emotion as a sign of innocence by any means. And he continued to do his due diligence, which included getting Seth to list out how many guns that he kept in the house. And by that point, they had yet to identify the shot gun that was actually used to kill Lisa. So they wanted to know how many guns they could expect to find and see if they could all be accounted for. Now, despite his cooperation, the heat definitely turned up in this interview, specifically when it came to questions about his and Lisa's marriage. So he wanted to know if there were any affairs happening, of course, which is a very fair question, but Seth assured him very confidently that that was absolutely not the case. Here's the thing, though, that this is interesting. In the middle of that interview, the agent interviewing him found out that Seth was lying and listened to how crazy this is. Okay. So as this was all going on, as the interview is taking place, there was still a team of investigators over at the trailer, processing the scene. Meanwhile, one of Seth's friends just so happened to show up at the trailer while that was going on. And I guess Lisa and Seth had been watching his dog. So he went there to go get his dog and long story short, someone asked this guy. His name is Colton. If you questions about Lisa and Seth, which is when he spilled the beans that Seth had a second phone, he told investigators that Seth had a track phone, which he used to communicate with a woman named Rachel that he worked with. So then one of the investigators that is at the house, processing the scene, talking to this friend, texted the agent who was actively talking to Seth right at that moment to let him know what he had just found out. But interestingly, instead of telling him what information he knew, he decided to wait to reveal that information. Very smart move. But basically, he wanted to see if Seth would continue to lie. But at some point, Seth must have known what was up because he decided to randomly voluntarily bring up the fact that he had been talking to another woman. He explained that he had been texting a girl named Rachel McFarland. However, he completely downplayed everything. He not only said that Lisa knew about her, but he also reassured the agent that they were only friends. And at first, he swore that nothing sexual ever happened between them. But then he was like, alright, well, we did kiss, but I promise, that's it. And that's not even the craziest part about this interview. This is one of the wildest things I've ever seen in interrogation footage. But while all of this is all unfolding, Seth's dad started physically banging on the door of the interrogation room to try and get him to come out and stop talking. Even though Seth said he was so confident he didn't need a lawyer, he didn't want a lawyer. His dad got him one anyway and was banging on the door, trying to get Seth to leave. But I kid you not, he literally sat through it, ignored his dad and just kept talking. Mind you, he is well aware that he was free to leave at any point. And since he chose to stay, the questioning continued. And that's when it became clearer and clearer as the minutes ticked on that Seth was lying. By that point, investigators discovered that he was using his second phone to sext Rachel. And with that information, they decided to share with him what they knew. And since he physically couldn't deny it any longer, he finally admitted to more of the truth. He admitted that there was more to the Rachel situation than he originally led on, including the fact that Rachel was under the impression that he was going to be divorcing Lisa. And he apparently told her as recently as the night before that he was going to leave his wife. But Seth, he said that he never actually did plan to leave Lisa. He just liked the attention that he was getting from Rachel. And he didn't want to actually be with her, but he wanted her to think that that was a possibility. So as you have probably pieced together by this point, they are now pretty damn convinced that Seth had something to do with Lisa's murder. And naturally that made things even more intense than they already were in the interrogation room. Now the agent was straight up telling him he doesn't believe his story, and that he thinks he's responsible for her death. But Seth stuck to his story, that he didn't do this and that an intruder broke into his home. I'm telling you what happened. I can't control what other people says to you or think they see. I'm telling you that right now, I have to bury my wife and kid. I have a born kid. Whoever gets this is going to pay. That's right. The truth. They show us the universe is responsible for killing your life. Now, Seth eventually gets so upset that he ends up walking out of the room, and that was the end of that. But the unfortunate thing was that none of that brought them any closer to an arrest. What they needed was actual proof. Thankfully though, that didn't end up being that hard to find. So just a few minutes ago or so, I mentioned that Seth was asked to make a list of all of the guns that he had inside of his home to figure out if there were any that were missing. And well, what do you know? There was a missing shotgun, and it's a shotgun that Seth just so happened to forget to put on that list. Now, this gun actually belonged to his friend Lucas, who had previously been living with them, and according to what Lucas told investigators, he had left that shotgun on a gun rack in Seth's trailer. And big shock here guys, but it was no longer there when investigators went to go look for it, which doesn't feel like a coincidence does it. Although the good news is, it ended up being found pretty fast. The shotgun had been dumped in a tall, grassy area, about 20 yards away from the back door of the trailer, and to nobody's surprise, it was later confirmed to be the murder weapon. Well, I guess I shouldn't say that nobody was surprised because Lisa's family actually was. They were shocked. For the first several days, following her murder, they really struggled to believe Seth could have possibly been responsible for her murder. In fact, they met up with him and his family at a park just a few days after all of this, and they were in disbelief when they found out he was being investigated. Her father Todd was actually the only family member who didn't go to the park, but he expressed the same feelings about just being shocked and not wanting to believe that his son-in-law could have possibly done this. I mean, as I explained, they were all very, very, very close, even the girl that he had been sexting with, Rachel, who was interviewed just a few days later, said she didn't think it was him. Of course, she did admit that they had been in a sexual relationship and that he had promised he would leave his wife for her, but she said she never asked him to do that. And physically, she said it never went past making out. The rest of it was just explicit texts and photos, you know, just typical sexting kind of stuff. And I do get why at first people in their lives just could not possibly wrap their heads around this being Seth, even Rachel, because really all they were doing was sexting, and he had casually mentioned that he would leave his wife for her. He just decided to say that on his own, she never asked him to, and I see why their family and friends and everyone really just thought Brian was probably the one who did this, but he ended up getting cleared. It just seemed so shocking and confusing to everyone, and I just have to keep drilling home how close they all were. I mean, his family with Lisa and Lisa's family with Seth, I mean, they were all so intertwined and thought everyone was happy. You know, those pieces in your closet that you just find yourself reaching for over and over again, you know, that sweater that somehow just works with everything. The jeans you know are always gonna fit just right and feel comfortable or that bag you carry everywhere. Those are the pieces that earn a permanent place in your wardrobe. And that's exactly what Quince does so well and why it is one of my favorite brands. I have so many Quince pieces at this point. It's pretty wild how much it is taken over my wardrobe and not only my wardrobe, but also my kids. I have so many items from their home collection, their kitchen stuff, nothing that I have ever gotten from Quince has ever let me down. There are 100% Mongolian cashmere sweaters started just $50 giving you that softness and quality that you would expect from a luxury brand but without a luxury price. Quince also has premium stretched denim and leather bags, also footwear, and a beautiful 14 karat gold jewelry that can be the finishing touch that pulls an entire look together. I wear a small quince hoop every single day in my third lobe here, and it goes with me in the shower. During my workouts, I sleep with it every single night. I literally never take it out other than to clean it every once in a while, and it has held up so well. It's so beautiful. I've gotten so many compliments on it, and everything at quince is priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands. And that's because they work directly with ethical factories, they cut out the middle man so you're paying for quality, not brand markup. And like I said, it's not just a peril. Quince brings that same approach to everything they make from hotel quality bedding and bath, to kitchen essentials, and thoughtfully designed furniture. They make a well designed piece for everyday living. So find the fall pieces that you'll reach for the most at Quince. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to quince.com/tcr, get free shipping on your order in 365 day returns. Now available in Canada and the UK too, that's q-u-i-n-c-e-dot-com/tcr. Now investigators spoke with Brian once again, just to be sure, but they ultimately trusted his alibi, and it made sense. And that, of course, left one person with the means, the motive, and the opportunity to do it. And that was Seth Teckle. And when it came to his arrest, the timing of it was absolutely wild. It literally happened on the evening of Lisa's funeral visitation. Tons of their family, friends, and law enforcement officers had gathered to show their support, and among those people were the Teckles. And so it was over, it was just the two families in the room, and this gave me goosebumps. But I guess Seth went up to Lisa's sister, Presley, and he gave her a big hug, and said, "You'll always be my little sister, I love you." And then, shortly after that, agents came up to him and put him in the back of their squad car, after formally arresting him. And they actually used Lisa's handcuffs, which I absolutely loved. Teckle has been charged with murdering the first degree in non-consensual termination of a human pregnancy, which is a class B felony, and carries a penalty of 25 years. Of course, murdering the first degree of class A felony with a maximum penalty of life in prison. So now with Seth behind bars, the hope was that Lisa would be getting just as soon enough. However, that ended up taking a lot longer than I think anyone expected. Now let's get into the saga of the trials. It took, I kid you not, a total of three trials for this case to actually come to a close. And it was, as you can imagine, just emotional whiplash for everyone involved. His first trial began in February of 2013, and before it even started, the prosecution took a big hit because they were actually planning on having Brian Tate testify the neighbor. And they wanted to do that because they thought it would be harder for the defense to pain him out as a monster if he could speak for himself. But tragically, he actually passed away this September before, and this is just horrible. But his sister said that she thinks he died of a broken heart, and their family can't help but think that it was related to everything that happened and how much stress he was under. And I just honestly feel so bad for him. I mean, it's horrible that the end of his life was filled with all of this. But even without testimony though, the prosecution did believe they had enough to get a conviction. And their biggest piece of evidence was that shotgun. Ballistics testing proved that the weapon located outside of Sess House, that same one that belonged to his friend, was in fact the one that killed Lisa. And let's be so fucking real, I know it has happened, but it is so rare. What intruder comes into someone's home with the intention to kill and doesn't bring their own weapon, okay, just it doesn't even seem plausible even in the slightest. Then to help the jury see how capable Seth was of lying, they had his friend testify. And this may not come as a shock to you, but those acts of vandalism on Brian's property were 100% orchestrated by Seth. His friend testified that he was the one who did it, but Seth was the one who told him to do it. And I'm sure some of you are having the same thoughts as me here and I can't prove this. This is just my opinion, my speculation, but I do wonder if it was always part of Seth's sick plan to get Brian all riled up so that he could pin the murder on him. I mean, I think it would make a lot of sense. I mean, we know he was trying to pin it on him from day one. So I guess I'm just curious if the plotting went that far back and I certainly would not be surprised if that is the case. Now as for other important testimony, we got to talk about Rachel, okay? So she took the stand as the prosecution star witness and as you'd expect, she spoke about the progression of her relationship with Seth. Take a listen. >> He added me on Facebook and asked for my telephone number and just text messages from there started becoming more than just coworkers. It went from just normal conversations to flirtatious text messages. It became more sexual asking me to send pictures or just showing off my body, I guess. He started asking if, when he got a divorce from his wife, I'd move in with him. And I said no. >> The most important thing that she shared though, at least in my opinion, was a story about what happened on May 20th of 2012. This was six days before Lisa's murder and Rachel said that she and Seth met up at this nature preserve and basically they were kissing and whatnot and Seth kept telling her that he was going to get a divorce. He told Rachel that he loved her, I dropped the L word with her and that it just wasn't working out with his wife. Meanwhile, I guess Rachel tells him that she actually has another coworker that she was interested in romantically of course, and apparently that guy called her while they were together and she testified that Seth got really upset, really jealous and he told her to give him two more weeks. So it's almost like that jealousy, the idea that she may get together with this coworker over him lit a fire under him because it was only six days later that he murdered Lisa. So the prosecution's whole theory was that Seth killed Lisa in order to be with Rachel. A horrific tale as old as time that we have seen over and over again, I mean it's getting exhausting. I don't know how many times I have to say this but just get a fucking divorce. People are so stupid, so cruel and I will just truly never understand. It takes literally all of one brain cell, one tiny brain cell to understand that divorce is better than murder. But I guess Seth over here doesn't even have that one brain cell clearly. But anyway, the defense argued that the prosecution's theory was wrong because their affair wasn't even really an affair. They essentially said that nobody would kill their wife over a few make-out sessions and sexting and that's all that it ever was, which yeah, who would do that, right? I mean, what the fuck? Seth is just, I've got no words for this idiot. And of course, the defense was still pointing the finger at poor Brian, who wasn't even there to defend himself at this point, had already died. And his family thinks it's due to all the stress and being brokenhearted over what he had gone through. But anyway, but they argued that Brian had the motive means an opportunity as well. And then guys, this is so weird, but another piece of evidence that the defense presented, which genuinely just makes no sense to me, had to do with a peanut butter and jelly sandwich and a discarded glove, which I guess the glove, you know, that makes a little more sense to bring up potentially. But the peanut butter and jelly sandwich is absurd. I guess investigators found a PB&J that was just in a little Ziploc bag on the back deck of their trailer, and their argument was that it must have been the killers. They said that if it had been left there overnight, animals would have eaten it. Therefore the killer had to have dropped it in the early morning hours after the attack. Who would fucking bring a peanut butter and jelly sandwich as a little snack when you're off to commit a murder? I mean, are they for real? This is the stupidest thing I've ever heard. And the logic doesn't make sense to me at all. I mean, you can't make sense of it because they believed that Seth killed her in the morning, not the night before. So if anyone understands their point, let me know. now 'cause I'm lost on that. Now, as for this glove, it was reportedly not tested which the defense took issue with. Either way, both sides rested their case and the jury was left to deliberate, however. Because there was no conclusion after four days, the judge declared it a mistrial, which is insanely frustrating. - Well, of course we're disappointed in what happened, but I think the whole family's confident in moving forward that justice will be served. - Today's decision to grant a mistrial left everyone involved feeling a little empty. Judge Dan Wilson did not ask the jury how their vote broke down, but after a lengthy trial and four days of deliberation, the end result is difficult to swallow. - They worked extremely hard. We thank them, I know it was difficult for them, and unfortunately they weren't able to reach unanimous decision. Sometimes that happens. We talk about stories at least and that always makes everything better, you know? But it's hard to know that it's out of your control and that you just got to kind of leave it to other people. - For us, this is horrible, but I think for us too is watching our other children go through this too, you know, and feeling that sense of, you can't fix it. It is apparent you want to fix their pain and stuff like that. So I think for our other kids, it's hard to, you know, for us to sit there and watch them. And, you know, we deal with our pain, you know, 'cause we're the parent, but, you know, we're supposed to fix the boo boo's and we, you know, so I think that's hard for us. - And through the emotions of the courtroom on Friday, it was important to the Codwell family that Lisa not be forgotten. - Oh, I just think that she's a fun, loving, happy person and, you know, it would be like Lisa to not want a little bit of attention. So, you know, the fact that it's, you know, carrying on is probably, you have something to do with her 'cause she's not ready to lose the focus, you know, but, you know, she's a great person, you know. - Wonderful. - So then we're on to trial too, right? Several months later, in October of 2013, the second trial began, and for the most part, the prosecution and the defense stuck to the same argument says before. A lot of the same testimony was heard as well, including that same testimony from Rachel. However, this time Seth's text messages became a big focus. For example, at 10.51 PM, a day before Lisa's murder, he texted Rachel saying, "Wish me luck." And even though she testified that she believed he was asking for luck related to asking for a divorce, the prosecution thought it was actually about wanting luck before he killed his wife. However, despite their best efforts, the outcome of this trial was the same. And as you can imagine, this was an even bigger blow to Lisa's family. Todd said that he was flabbergasted when they learned the news, and I'm sure it had to have knocked down a lot of their confidence that justice would ever come. So then we go to trial number three. And thankfully, the third trial did bring the justice that they were hoping for, and so desperately needed at this point, although the trial was different from the others. So funny story. I am a cat owner, love my cats very much. And I also have a baby. And just this week, he moved into his own nursery for the first time. And then when I first brought him in there, I realized that the cat had peed all over his rug. So I needed a new rug as soon as possible, and I didn't want just something boring. So I knew where to go, where I got a bunch of other pieces for his nursery, and that is way fair. Now I have a space themed nursery going on, and I was able to find so many cute options for space themed rugs. I found the perfect one, and I was able to get it in just a couple of days so that my son has a nice rug in his nursery. Wayther helps you create a home that stands up to real life with quality products, great value, and trusted reviews. And they have something for every style and budget. It's honestly wild, their selection is so vast. You can shop thousands of products across every style and every budget, whether you're simply replacing an appliance or transforming your home from top to bottom for the holiday season. You can use filters to find things, customer photos, and more than 20 million verified five star reviews to confidently find the right bits for your home. Find pieces made for real life, and get even more value with Wayther rewards. Join Wayther rewards today to get 5% back on every purchase. Head to Wayther.com to shop all things home. That's w-a-y-f-a-i-r.com. Wayther every style, every home. This time Seth had a new defense team, and they took on a whole new strategy. The trial was also moved to Scott County in Davenport, and the reason he changed attorneys was reportedly because he ran out of money, not totally sure on that, but that is what is reported, and rather than try and point the finger at Brian, his new defense attorney was pointing the finger at the investigators. They argued that they zeroed in on Seth too quickly, and didn't have the evidence to support his guilt. They argued that there was no DNA to say that he did it, that it was simply a rush to judgment and bad circumstantial evidence. There was also a pretty major bombshell dropped by the defense as well, which was that Lisa was also having an affair. She had been seeing a married man, a man named Jason, who she worked with, and their relationship ended just a few weeks before she was killed. In a search of Lisa's phone, it was discovered that she and Jason spoke about ending their relationship because it was wrong, and even discussed whether or not he could be the father of her baby, which, to be clear, they ultimately decided that the timing wouldn't have lined up for him to have been the father, but, of course, this was very shocking to hear for many reasons, especially when people learn that a deputy had questioned him just days after Lisa's death, and he denied the affair. And none of it was ever documented or disclosed. And it was also interesting to people that prosecutors didn't get in touch with him until a few days before the third trial, all of which backed the defense's theory that this was a botched investigation. And this is wild, but the defense actually suggested that Jason could have been the one behind all of this, but he did have an alibi for that day. Both he and his wife testified that they were at home together when the murder occurred, plus his DNA could not be matched to the scene. Even with this bombshell, though, the prosecution maintained that Seth was the only person who could have done this. I'm sure the majority I would hope most of you if not all of you agree with that. And finally, the jury agreed. So in the end, Seth was found guilty on both charges after only four hours of deliberation. And as you can imagine, this was an incredibly emotional moment for both families who, despite, technically being on opposite sides, had total compassion for one another. It was really beautiful to see. I mean, before this trial, both of the dads hugged one another and they did it again after it was over. And we don't see that happen often. So I thought that was really special. And Seth's parents do believe that he is innocent, but the fact that they're still able to embrace and support Lisa's family. And the fact that her family is receptive to that, I think is really cool. Now someone else who was very relieved by this outcome was Brian's sister Sherry. And that's because she knew that this conviction meant that people would no longer suspect her brother. And that was a really big deal to her understandably. Now when it came to Seth's sentencing, he received the mandatory sentence of life in prison without parole plus a consecutive 25 years for the death of baby Zoe and boy, do I love to hear that. I hope he spends the rest of his miserable life just being in mental, anguish and torture, thinking about what he did, thinking about the fact that he not only killed his wife, but he killed his own daughter. And for what? For what? Before the sentence was handed down, now Lisa's family did have a chance to speak with him. And it was very powerful, you guys. Both Todd and Presley spoke and man was that emotional. Presley started by saying that Seth was once her best friend and her brother who she loved. And at the end, she told him that she was no longer his sister and no longer loved him. And I don't know if Seth is even capable of feeling emotion, but God damn, I hope that hurt. (upbeat music) - Turning to the crime beat, the sentence, life in prison without the possibility of parole for Seth Teckle. In July, a jury found Teckle guilty of the 2012 shooting death of his pregnant wife, Lisa. But Teckle's sentence came only after Lisa's family had their say today. KCCI's Mark Towshek is live at the Monroe County Courthouse in Albion with that testimony. - An absolutely heart wrenching afternoon here at the Courthouse, a lot of tears, a lot of anguish. If Seth Teckle was feeling any emotion, however, he kept it hidden very well. - Seth is a cold-hearted killer. I would call him an animal, but if an animal only kills out a necessity, Seth kills out a convenience. - Before Seth Teckle was sent to prison for likely the rest of his life, the family of Lisa Caldwell Teckle had a chance to let loose. - No mother should have to see her child, or a picture. make sure of her child or granddaughter on a not-topsie slab and not get answers. We have deserved the truth from day one Seth, not all of the games that have been played. Lisa was close to both her parents, especially her father Todd, a deputy in Wappelow County who Lisa worked alongside as a reserve deputy. Lisa has four siblings and two step sisters. Her sister Presley was especially close to Seth and considered him a brother. I'm going to leave you with one final thought, but I'm no longer your sister and I no longer love you. Seth Teckle sat still, barely moving and stared directly at each of Lisa's family members as they spoke. He was asked by the judge if he had anything to say. Lisa's mother shared a heart-wrenching memory for the morning she showed up to her daughter's home and saw the police stay. And all I wanted to do was sit with her and hold her hand and stroke her hair and let her know that I was there. I was with her when she took her first breath and I only wanted to know that I was there moments after she took her last. Her three trials in two years, Lisa Teckle's family heard the news. They've waited to hear. Actually this was the last time we have to see Seth Teckle and that's fine by me. Again, taking Lisa and their daughter from her family, from his family as well, from this world, for what, dude, for nothing, that's what. Men like Seth hiss me off so deeply and I'll never, I'll never, no matter how many cases like this I cover, I will never understand someone's brain and how they can justify doing something like this, how it makes sense to them in any way, shape or form, how they can even bring themselves to pull that trigger. He had it so good with Lisa. She was such an awesome person and he was loved by so many members of her family. They treated him like their own and to just throw that all away by doing the worst thing a human can do, especially over a relationship where the other person doesn't even seem that interested in you and you've only made out and do a few, you know, sexting or whatever the fuck, you know, it's just like, obviously no matter how in-depth a relationship is, there's never a good reason to do it, but it's just like shocking that you gave up all of this. You killed your wife and your daughter for that, I mean, I don't know. It's just horrible to think that their family not only has to live the rest of their lives without Lisa, but also their future granddaughter, they never got to meet her and my heart truly goes out to them. I mean, they just seem like such wonderful people watching their interviews just really, really tugged at my heartstrings. You can just feel the love that they all had, that they still have, you know, and the pain that they have all experienced and it's just, it's, there are no words, truly, it's horrible. I will say, I thought this was really beautiful, Todd actually designed himself, a beautiful headstone for them, made it himself, not just got it commissioned or something like that. It was in the shape of a heart and it depicts a mother and a baby and it's just so beautifully done. There's also two bird wings on it and I'm getting so emotional. This is just one of the saddest cases I swear, but he did that because it was always a thing for the two of them to watch the notebook together or something that they loved and they would always use that famous, very famous quote from the notebook. If you're a bird, I'm a bird and he explained that to him, that that means whatever you are, I am too. And it's like, you know, we'll always be connected no matter what, which I thought was really beautiful. But my heart truly goes out to them, what a massive, massive unnecessary loss. Anyway, guys, that is going to be it for me today. I know that was a very difficult one to get through, but a very important case to highlight, I think. And I will be back next week to discuss another case. Oh, before I go, I do just want to remind you guys that our new Halloween and fall collection of merch is now available at milehermerch.com and 100% of the proceeds support our foundation. So not only are you, you know, treating yourself to a nice piece of merch, a sweatshirt, a t-shirt, whatever it is, you are also helping victims of violent crime and their families as well as like-minded nonprofits and every single bit of the proceeds does go directly to that. There is no profit being made for mile hire media at all. I just want to be clear about that because I know people get confused, but we have some wonderful pieces. We're really proud of this collection, so make sure to go grab something for yourself before they sell out. But yeah, that's it for me today, y'all, y'all, wow, I never say that, but anyway, I will be back next week and until then, keep taking your mind a mile higher. Wait, that's the wrong one. That is literally the outro to my other podcast, wow, I'm a little fried after this case. Let's try this again. Stay safe out there.