Stadium • Hur är det att jobba hos oss? #WorkatStadium
from Jobcast
17m 12s
The story of *Ben Hurr* began as a revolutionary novel by Lou Wallace in 1880, blending religious themes with adventure, political intrigue, and a famed chariot race. Its success led to a groundbreaking stage adaptation in 1899, featuring live horses and elaborate stage machinery, which toured globally and reached millions. The novel’s rights sparked early copyright precedents in film, leading to the 1907 unauthorized adaptation and a legal crackdown. The 1925 silent film version, despite massive costs and production chaos, became a box office sensation and a technical milestone, using innovative filming techniques and real stunts. The 1959 MGM version, directed by William Wyler, redefined cinematic spectacle with its massive set, real horses, and high-stakes stunts, winning 11 Academy Awards and becoming a cultural landmark. In contrast, the 2016 remake failed due to poor critical reception and reliance on CGI, underscoring the enduring power of live action in storytelling. *Ben Hurr* stands as a testament to how one narrative has been reinvented across media, adapting to each era’s technology and audience expectations—demonstrating the evolution of popular entertainment from literature to live spectacle to cinematic grandeur.
In the late 19th century, one novel became one of America's biggest literary sensations.
Its story was so ambitious that bringing it to the stage required technological innovations,
live horses, and one of the most elaborate theatrical productions ever attempted.
Decades later, filmmakers took on the same challenge, first in the silent era, and then
again in one of Hollywood's greatest epics.
Learn more about the remarkable history of Ben Hurr on this episode of Everything Everywhere
Daily.
This episode is sponsored by Quince.
Autumn is here, which means it's time to start bringing out all your cold weather gear.
And for me, it means taking out my Quince Mongolian cashmere sweaters and my Quince blankets.
I have a thick fisherman's blanket for sitting on the couch and an organic waffle bed blanket
that I use as a bed cover.
My Quince products not only keep me warm, but they look really good too, and they do so at
a fraction of the price of other retailers.
Everything at Quince is priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands.
They work directly with ethical factories and cut out the middlemen so you're paying for
high quality, not brand markup.
Find your next fall favorites at Quince.
Download the Quince app for app exclusive offers or go to quince.com.
Get free shipping on your order and 365 day returns.
Now available in Canada in the UK too.
And when Quince asks you where you heard about them, let them know it was everything everywhere
at daily.
It's the best way to support the show.
This episode is sponsored by Mint Mobile.
If you had to choose between two identical items but one was cheaper than the other, you'd
choose the cheaper one, right?
That's not a theoretical scenario.
That is the choice you can make right now with Mint Mobile.
Mint Mobile works with your current phone, your current phone number, and you can keep
all your contacts.
It uses the T-Mobile network, which is the fastest mobile network in the United States.
You just spend less money because Mint Mobile doesn't have the overhead of other mobile
companies.
That's why I recommend Mint Mobile.
To hear your new wireless plan for just 15 bucks a month, go to mintmobile.com/ED.
That's mintmobile.com/ED.
Cut your wireless bill to 15 bucks a month at mintmobile.com/ED.
That's it.
There's no catch.
Up front payment of $45 for $3, $90 for six months or $180 for 12 month plan required,
$15 per month equivalent, taxes and fees extra, initial plan term only.
Greater than 50 gigabyte may slow when network is busy, includes up to 20 gigabyte hotspot.
Capable device required, availability speed and coverage varies, see mintmobile.com.
In the past, I've dedicated episodes to great movies like Citizen Kane, The Godfather and
Star Wars.
And you might think that this is another episode like those.
And in a way, it is.
But there is a lot more to the story than a 1959 movie starring Charlton Heston.
And her is unusual in the entertainment industry, because essentially the same story became
a landmark spectacle in not one, not two, but three different forms of media.
And in one of those media forms, film, it was the biggest movie ever produced on two
different occasions.
The story of Benher begins with Lou Wallace, a former Union general in the Civil War,
editorial governor, diplomat and the author of the book.
His novel Benher, A Tale of the Christ, was published in 1880 after roughly seven years
of research and writing.
It tells the story of Judah Benher, a wealthy Jewish prince in Roman-occupied Judea, whose
friendship with the Roman masala turns into a bitter rivalry.
Judah is falsely condemned, survives slavery as a galley roar, returns to seek revenge,
and ultimately encounters Jesus and the Christian message of forgiveness.
Jesus is important in the novel, but he is not really its central character.
In fact, Jesus only appears briefly.
Wallace instead tells the story through Judah Benher.
This allows him to combine religious fiction with an adventure story, involving battles,
romance, political intrigue, and, most famously, a chariot race.
The combination of all these things was enormously successful.
Benher became the best-selling American novel of the entire 19th century and remained a major
cultural phenomenon well into the 20th century.
Prominent figures such as Ulysses S. Grant, James Garfield, and even Queen Victoria admired
the novel, and it helped make religious historical fiction into a genre.
After the novel's success, many theatrical producers wanted to adapt the story for the
stage.
Wallace initially doubted that the novel could possibly work on stage.
His objections were practical.
How could anyone stage the chariot race, and perhaps more importantly for Wallace, how
could an actor represent Jesus?
The solution to those problems produced one of the greatest theatrical spectacles of
its era.
The first major stage version of Benher opened at New York's Broadway theater on November
29, 1899.
The screenplay was written by William W. Young, and the show was produced by Mark Law and
Abraham Erlanger.
Edward Morgan played Judah, while an actor who would later become one of the first great
Western movie stars William S. Hart played Missala Unopening Night.
The production was enormous by 19th century theater standards.
There were elaborate representations of Jerusalem, Roman galleys, shipwrecks, palaces, and crowds.
Scene changes themselves became feats of stage engineering.
In the galleys sequence, for example, scenery and performers could be transformed into the
aftermath of the shipwreck in darkness in only a few seconds.
But everything in the show revolved around one problem, the chariot race.
The producers created a mechanical illusion that must have startled audiences in 1899.
Two teams of four live horses stood on enormous treadmills built into the stage.
Behind them, huge moving panoramas and cycloramas traveled in the opposite direction.
The horses galloped at full speed while the scenery rushed past them, making the chariots
appear to hurdle around the racetrack.
It was essentially a 19th century theatrical version of filming actors against a moving
background, except that everything was happening live.
Contemporary accounts suggest that the horses were genuinely running at tremendous speeds
only a short distance in front of the audience.
The production got around the issue of having an actor play Jesus by representing him as
a beam of white light.
The combination of religion and mechanical spectacle turned Ben Hurr into a sensation.
The original Broadway engagement ran for 194 performances, but that was just the beginning.
Touring companies carried the production throughout the United States and eventually into
Britain and Australia.
Various versions of the show continued for roughly 21 years.
Estimates suggest that there were more than 6,000 performances and that perhaps as many
as 20 million people saw the play.
With the arrival of motion pictures, the Ben Hurr story was a natural for putting on film.
In 1907, the Calum company made a roughly 15 minute adaptation of the story.
However, the company had not obtained permission from Wallace's estate or other rights holders,
who promptly sued.
The resulting litigation helped establish an important principle that filmmakers could
not simply take a copyrighted book and turn it into a movie without purchasing adaptation
rights.
The case became an important early precedent in motion picture copyright.
The next attempt at filming the story would therefore begin with something Hollywood would
increasingly come to understand very well, buying the rights to the book.
By the early 1920s, the motion picture industry had advanced enough that filmmakers could
seriously contemplate doing justice to Wallace's story.
The movie rights were eventually purchased for an extraordinary $600,000 and production
began under Goldwyn Pictures.
After Metro Goldwyn Mayor was formed in 1924, the project became one of the new studios
most important productions.
And it was also nearly a catastrophe.
Production began in Italy in 1923.
Directors, actors, and producers all changed, costspiral.a control.
Much of the footage was considered unusable.
Eventually, MGM, executive Irving Falberg brought the production back to California, replaced
much of the creative team, and essentially started from scratch.
One young assistant working on the production was William Weiler, who 34 years later would
direct another version of Ben Hurr.
The silent film eventually cost about $4 million, an almost unheard of amount of money
for the period, and many times MGM's normal production budget.
It was among the most expensive films ever made up to that point.
And once again, the sequence everyone cared about was the chariot race.
Some acres conducted a gigantic circus Maximus set in Los Angeles.
Hundreds of workers spent months building it.
MGM positioned approximately 42 cameras around the course, sometimes hiding them in statues,
behind shields, and close to the track, so the editors would have views of almost every
possible angle.
As this was way before the film was released, there was still a lot of work to do.
Before computer effects or sophisticated stunt regs, the race was astonishingly dangerous.
Chariots really raced, horses really ran, and crashes really happened.
One spectacular pile-up involving horses, chariots, and stuntmen was a real accident that
made it into the finished film.
The filming of the race scene was an event in Hollywood, and many of the top stars of
the era were in attendance. Actors, directors, producers, and other celebrities all came to
the set simply to watch. And because MGM needed thousands of people to fill the grandstands,
many of these visitors were persuaded to put on costumes and become extras.
As a result, the crowd reportedly included an extraordinary collection of established and
future stars, including Douglas Fairbanks, Mary Pickford, Lionel Barrymore, Lilian Gish,
Gerald Lloyd, Joan Crawford, Marion Davies, and many, many, many others.
Roughly 200,000 feet of film was reportedly shot just for the race before editor Lloyd
Nossler reduced it to just a fraction of that length. Rapidly cutting between wide shots,
close views of the drivers, wheels, horses, crashes, and spectators created a pace that feels
surprisingly modern.
MGM even used selected sequences in the relatively new two-color-techno-color process, giving
audiences a burst of color within an otherwise black and white film.
Released on December 30, 1925, the movie became a sensation. More importantly, it helped
establish the newly created MGM studio. Many people consider the 1925 Ben Hurr as the
high-water mark of the silent era. It grossed over 10 million at the box office and was
one of the biggest grossing silent films ever made.
By the 1950s, Hollywood faced a threat that did not exist in 1925. Television. Millions
of Americans who previously went regularly to movie theaters now had entertainment in
their living rooms. Hollywood responded by trying to give audiences things television
couldn't provide. Enormous screens, wide-screen photography, stereoscopic sound, lavish
color, and gigantic productions.
Typical sword and sandal epics suited the strategy in particular. The robe, the Ten Commandments
and Quovatas demonstrated the enormous audience for such films. An MGM still controlled the
rights to Ben Hurr, and at the time, the studio desperately needed a hit.
The studio took a gamble, hiring William Wyler to direct, and casting Charlton Heston
as Judah Ben Hurr, and Stephen Boyd as Masala.
One took place largely at the Chinachita Studios in Rome, where MGM effectively constructed
substantial portions of the ancient world. The resulting film ran about three-and-a-half
hours complete with an intermission in its original roadshow presentation.
Wyler's real contribution was that he didn't simply try to remake the 1925 movie and
make it bigger. He tried to deepen the human story.
As with all other previous productions, the centerpiece of the movie was the chariot race.
They built what was then one of the largest movie sets ever made. The arena occupied roughly
eighteen acres with enormous grandstands and a track covered with tens of thousands of
tons of sand. The set took around a year to construct.
They trained dozens of horses for months to learn how to race chariots. Charlton Heston and
Stephen Boyd learned how to drive four horse chariots themselves, allowing Wyler and the
second unit team to photograph their faces during much of the racing rather than constantly
substituting stuntmen.
The scene lasts roughly nine minutes, and one of its most remarkable characteristics is
the relative absence of music. During most of the race, the filmmakers just let the sound
of wheels, hooves, and crashes take over. One of the most memorable moments occurs when
Judas chariot races towards the wreckage of another chariot. The horse clears it, but
the chariot itself suddenly launches into the air.
Joe Kenneth, stunt director, Yakima Kenneth's son, performed the stunt. The chariot landed
violently throwing Kenneth partly forward. Heston's close-up then completed the illusion
that Judas himself had nearly been thrown out, but Kenneth actually required four stitches
on his chin.
An urban legend says that a stuntman died during the filming of the chariot scene and that
the studio left the scene in the film. This is not true. A stuntman did die during the
filming in Rome in 1925, but the studio never used that footage.
M.J.M.'s gamble succeeded spectacularly. Ben Herb became an enormous commercial hit, grossing
more than $40 million during its initial release alone. At the 1960 Academy Awards, it won
11 Oscars including Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actor, and Best Supporting Actor. 11 wins
established a record that stood alone for nearly four decades and has only been matched
by Titanic and Lord of the Rings Return of the King.
And before I conclude, just for the sake of completion I should mention the other version
of Ben Herb. In 2016, M.J.M. went to the Ben Herb well once again and this time created
what they called a "reimagining of the story". It was, to be generous, a flop. Made for
about $100 million, it grossed only about $94 million worldwide, far below the level needed
to recoup production and marketing costs, with estimates putting its losses in the tens
of millions of dollars.
Critically, it also fared poorly earning just a 24% rotten tomato score. The CGI couldn't
compete with the actual live stunts from the 1959 version, or for that matter, the 1925
version. I'm guessing that many of you didn't even realize that they made a version of Ben
Herb in 2016.
The history of Ben Herb is really the history of popular entertainment reinventing itself.
What began as one of the most successful novels of the 19th century became a theatrical spectacle
built around live horses and then a silent film epic that pushed film making to its limits
and then finally one of the grandest productions of Hollywood's Golden Age. Each version used
the newest tools of its era to tell the same story on a larger scale. Few works have
ever been adopted so often and achieve success in so many different entertainment mediums.
Executive producer of everything everywhere daily is Charles Daniel. The associate producers
are Austin Otkin and Cameron Kiefer. My big thanks go to everyone who supports a show
around Patreon. Your support helps make this podcast possible. And I also want to remind
everyone about the community groups on Facebook and Discord. That's where everything happens
that's outside the podcast. And links to those are available in the show notes. As always,
if you leave a review on any major podcast app or in the above community groups, you
too can have it read in the show.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The novel *Ben Hurr* by Lou Wallace became a best-selling 19th-century American literary phenomenon, blending religious fiction with adventure and political intrigue.
The story was adapted into a groundbreaking theatrical production in 1899, featuring live horses, mechanical illusions, and a chariot race that revolutionized stage design.
The stage version toured widely, running for over 20 years and reaching an estimated 20 million viewers across the U.S., Britain, and Australia.
Early film adaptations faced legal battles over copyright, establishing precedent that filmmakers must purchase adaptation rights.
The 1925 silent film version was one of the most expensive and elaborate productions of its time, featuring a massive chariot race with real horses and hundreds of extras.
The 1959 MGM film, directed by William Wyler, won 11 Academy Awards and became a landmark of Hollywood’s Golden Age, known for its realism and powerful stunt work.
The 2016 remake was a critical and commercial failure, criticized for relying on CGI instead of live action and underperforming against earlier versions.
*Ben Hurr* exemplifies how a single story has been reinvented across media—novel, stage, silent film, and sound film—reflecting evolving technological and cultural trends in entertainment.
Summary:
The story of *Ben Hurr* began as a revolutionary novel by Lou Wallace in 1880, blending religious themes with adventure, political intrigue, and a famed chariot race. Its success led to a groundbreaking stage adaptation in 1899, featuring live horses and elaborate stage machinery, which toured globally and reached millions. The novel’s rights sparked early copyright precedents in film, leading to the 1907 unauthorized adaptation and a legal crackdown.
The 1925 silent film version, despite massive costs and production chaos, became a box office sensation and a technical milestone, using innovative filming techniques and real stunts. The 1959 MGM version, directed by William Wyler, redefined cinematic spectacle with its massive set, real horses, and high-stakes stunts, winning 11 Academy Awards and becoming a cultural landmark. In contrast, the 2016 remake failed due to poor critical reception and reliance on CGI, underscoring the enduring power of live action in storytelling.
*Ben Hurr* stands as a testament to how one narrative has been reinvented across media, adapting to each era’s technology and audience expectations—demonstrating the evolution of popular entertainment from literature to live spectacle to cinematic grandeur.
FAQs
The story of Ben Hurr originated from a novel titled 'Ben Hurr, A Tale of the Christ' by Lou Wallace, published in 1880 after seven years of research and writing. It tells the story of Judah Ben Hurr, a Jewish prince in Roman-occupied Judea, who faces betrayal, slavery, and ultimately encounters Jesus and the message of forgiveness.
The stage version opened in 1899 on Broadway and featured live horses running on treadmills, with moving panoramas and cycloramas that created the illusion of a chariot race. The production included elaborate sets and complex stage engineering, with scenes like shipwrecks transforming in seconds.
To avoid religious controversy, Jesus was represented as a beam of white light instead of an actor, allowing the production to blend religious themes with a mechanical spectacle without directly depicting a religious figure.
It was one of the most expensive films of its time, costing about $4 million, and featured a groundbreaking chariot race with real horses and real crashes. The film grossed over $10 million and became a box office sensation, helping establish MGM as a major studio.
Directed by William Wyler, it featured a larger scale, a real chariot race with trained horses, and a more human-centered story. The race scene was filmed with minimal music, relying on sound effects, and included a dangerous stunt that resulted in injuries to a stuntman.
The 2016 remake, made for $100 million, grossed only $94 million and was critically panned with a 24% rotten tomato score. It failed due to poor CGI and a lack of authenticity compared to the live-action 1959 version.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.