Go back

Sports Supplements for Active Folks

40m

Sports Supplements for Active Folks

Dietary supplements are a multi-billion-dollar industry but face significant regulatory gaps—products can be sold without proof of safety or efficacy, leading to risks like contamination, incorrect dosing, and undisclosed ingredients. This is especially concerning for athletes, who may unknowingly consume banned substances. While many supplements are overhyped, certain ones like creatine and omega-3s have strong scientific support for muscle recovery, inflammation reduction, and brain health. Third-party testing organizations (e.g., NSF, ConsumerLab) help ensure product integrity. Supplements like pre-workouts and green powders often contain stimulants or unproven ingredients, and overuse can lead to side effects. Experts stress that supplements should not replace a balanced diet, and consumers should consult dietitians to avoid nutrient overload or toxicity. Key nutrients like magnesium and beta-alanine show benefit only when used appropriately. Ultimately, the most reliable guidance comes from clinical evidence, not marketing, and a growing consensus is needed before endorsing any supplement for performance or health. Consumers are urged to verify products through trusted third-party certifications and to prioritize dietary sources over supplements whenever possible.

Transcription

7580 Words, 41551 Characters

English
You are listening to Spot On, a health and wellness podcast that breaks through the latest media headlines to provide you with accurate and usable information that is, well, spot on, spot on to meet your needs. I am your host, Dr. Joan Salju Blake, a nutrition professor at Boston University, and the author of the college textbook called Nutrition and You, which is used in colleges across the United States and abroad. I want to thank you so much for listening to Spot On, and I hope that you subscribe to it so that you don't miss any of our episodes. And again, can you kindly follow me on TikTok, Instagram, and Facebook at Joan Salju Blake. So Spot On, Listeners, and Viewers, now they're on YouTube. Today we're going to talk about nutrition sports supplements of people who are athletes or just weekend warriors are taking over $50 billion worth of supplements. Wow. And the question is, do you need these? Do they do anything or more importantly, do they do any harm? So stay tuned, and we're going to learn more. Hello, Spot On, Listeners, and Viewers. We're back. Okay. I have an expert with me to talk about the sports nutrition supplements for athletes or even very active people. And I have with me Dana Angelo White, and she is a duel. Get ready for this. She's got two titles, Credential Registered Dietitian Nutrition, and that's why I love her to pieces. And also, which is fabulous, a certified athletic trainer. So now we got two for the price of one, and she's been doing this over two decades, even though she looks like she's 10. She's authored, authored about nine textbooks. And she's an expert content expert in the media where people are asking her the same questions that I'm asking her, and get ready for this. She's the sports dietitian and clinical professor of athletic training at Quinnipi Pack University. So should I call you Professor Dana, or what should I call you? I just prefer Dana. Professor sounds weird. Dana White is always funny because there's another Dana White out there, and I'm not him. So Dana's good. I'll tell you what every time I see Dana White, I think of Vanna White. That's how old I am. You know what? I'd rather be compared to her, honestly, but it's always funny working with college students and college athletes. Like, they hear my name or it's introduced, and there's a chuckle, and I'm like, yeah, I have nothing to do with the UFC and things like that. It's interesting. That's great. That's adorable. Okay. You know, I open this talking about how lucrative this dietary supplement market is for people who are active. It's unbelievable. So let's go really to the top. Can you explain, are these supplements regulated? Is somebody overseeing this? Yeah, I wish I could just say yes, and we could move on, but it's really not that simple. So I feel like the reflex answer for a lot of clinicians is to say they're not regulated. That's not entirely true. So let's be fair, and I think the supplement companies, they don't like it when people say there's no regulation. I like to say that the industry in general is loosely regulated, poorly regulated, inefficiently regulated, one or the other. Okay. Here is this thing, there is a government act called Dishay that was passed in 1994. It passed the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act. So what that aims to do is to provide some oversight. Where I see some deficiencies in that is that it basically long story short, it doesn't call for real regulation until after the supplements go to market, right? So that's when we talk about food or prescription medications or over-the-counter medications, those products need to be evaluated by the FDA before they are sold. Before it is say, you know, those manufacturers had to prove to the FDA that those products were safe and effective when used as prescribed, right? So there's could be dangers if you misuse these things, but they had to prove those things ahead of time. Safety, efficacy, that the labels were accurate, so on and so forth, that doesn't apply to Dietary Supplements. So Dietary Supplements can be sold everywhere, right, online, at Target, everywhere, before that manufacturer has to prove that they are safe or effective. You know, that's wild DNA, that's absolutely, that's what it's called the Wild Wild West. I mean, because something could get up on the shelf anywhere and it could say all these wonderful things and, you know, not do that or more importantly, it could have things in it, right? Other things that could be part of those, they slip in other things in these supplements. You know, you say, I want supplement A for this, blah, blah, blah, but they can be adding other ingredients to this that can make it that you don't know about. Right, right. And so this is where, you know, the concerns come in. So let's just say, like even if we take, I mean, I work with athletes most of the time and things like that. Let's take athletes out of it the picture for a second. What if you have an allergy, what if, you know, a clear, so we worry about things being intentionally adulterated, unintentionally adulterated, right? So what if, you know, again, if no one's checking a lot, not all, but many supplement income companies maybe aren't doing their due diligence, right? So there could be, you know, intentional adulteration, there could be accidental contamination. And then we see issues with improper dosing or, you know, what batch to batch, the product isn't consistent. And in some cases, you know, there's evidence to support that, you know, the company says something's in the bottle. It's not even there. There's none of it, right? Then when we talk about drug tested athletes, there's an increased level, right? So all of those risks apply for them, then we worry about band substances, right? So we have an athlete taking a product that they think is safe and is not going to put them at risk. And, and then it is because it's not listed on the label or something like that. So it really does, there's a call for concern, for sure. Right. And I know, I, Kuni Piac and I know we have Boston University, we're division one athletes and they tested all the time because, and, you know, making sure that they don't consume band substances, and you're right, they could inadvertently have taken something and then the band from, you know, the sport for X amount of time or whatever, which is very, very serious. You know, not only that from a scholastic level, but again, we don't know the harm that's going to be done here. So there could be really some really bad side effects. So you know, I, this is where, you know, there's always good, but then the bad bring down the good. So is there a way that if a supplement says it is containing blank that you as a consumer can say, okay, this is legit. I know based upon, not just, you know, it's, it's a name brand, but is there some kind of testing or certainification took that that will, you know, give the consumer a heads up that if you're going to buy this supplement, this is the one you want to buy. Yeah. Isn't it nice? That's some reassurance that what you see is what you get, right? You know, so yes, the answer is yes. So there are, and it really, it's, this whole process has been created in reaction to the way the industry sort of operates, right? So there are third, they're third party testing organizations. That's, that's how a lot of sports citations would, would refer to these, these companies. But what some supplement manufacturers can do is pay third party lab, third party companies is, you know, to independently test their products and verify them. And, and so there are a few sort of top tier that there's a few different companies that do third party testing. But there's a few, certainly in the sports world that we sort of rely more heavily on because there's some companies that will do third party testing for, you know, contaminants, right? Make sure there's no lead in there. Make sure that the dose is appropriate, right? So for many people that might be enough, then for athletes when we start tipping over into worrying about band substances and other things like that, there are, you know, other organizations that are more geared for, for sports. So there's NSF for sport is considered one of the top tiers that we use in, in collegiate and professional athletics. And then there's the informed family, so there's informed choice and informed sport. They do it, they have websites, they have apps, they have very robust. Information for consumers so that they can seek out a product that, again, that they know, now again, doesn't mean that all these products are perfect or that they're magic or you can't take them incorrectly, but at least you know that what you see is what you get, right? Which I think is, is a good place to start. You know, I'm teaching a course, a brand new course here at Boston University this semester, all about food supplements and consumer health, that's actually the name of it. And what I have introduced these students to is something called consumer labs. Can you explain what that is because this, this, I love this website. And you know, it's a modest amount of money to join it, it really isn't. But go ahead, Danny. You're the pro. Tell them about it because it's phenomenal. Right. Consumer Labs is great. And again, another platform where there's a lot of robust information and it's like, here's how you're supposed to take something. And here's, and we're naming names, right? Here's brands that you can rely on if you need a vitamin D supplement or things like that. So yeah, I would say that's a perfect example of one of those other third party outfits that is very reliable and has great information. They don't, to my knowledge, consumer labs doesn't test for banned substances. But again, that is a smaller subset of the population that needs to worry about that. So, you know, I think for the average person that's looking to get a good fish oil or multibitamin, you know, I think consumer labs can be great. USP is another one where, you know, again, those are like the, you know, the typical things you might find in the drug store. And again, those supplements can be improperly, you know, they're, they're subject to the same risk. So yeah, I like consumer lab lab as well. For drug tested athletes, I would still gravitate towards some of the other companies again, because they do that extra level of saying we're also going to verify that this product is free of banned substances, which for those competitive athletes is important. You know, but with the, with the market, this lucrative, it's just not athletes taking these supplements because there's no wicked way that this that many athletes that around that would, you know, just support this category. So, there are a lot of consumers taking this stuff. And that's one of the reasons why I wanted to, you know, have a discussion about that. They're marketed brilliantly. I think that's the thing, you know, and, and, and, and then, you know, high school athletes, right? So, I work with a lot of high school athletes as well. Many of them aspire to be collegiate athletes, but it's a much larger pool. And listen, they are in the market for these for sure, right? And in social media, make some very compelling and sexy. So, again, the marketing is brilliant. I always joke, if I can market anything as well as a dietary supplement, you know, I'd be a very wealthy dietitian. But it's just, you know, it, people want the magic pill, but, you know, you and I know that there isn't one. Right. And, you know, when you say that to teenagers and young people who are buying these, the parents have to be aware of, or whoever buys these because these are expensive. I mean, so, whoever buys these got to be aware, we're like, okay, whoa, whoa, whoa, why do you want to take this? What do we know about this? Let's get onto consumer labs or legitimate site to figure out, does this work? Is there any harm? And if I'm going to buy it, it'll actually tell you the best brand to buy and the cheapest one to buy, too. That's why I love it. I'll do that. Okay, so, my good colleague here, Dana, she wrote an article today's dietitian, all about this subject. And that's actually how I stumbled upon it. And we're going to put a copy of this article up on the spot on Facebook page, but they, you had a hit list of supplements that are overhyped and those that I could actually work because I believe that there's room for supplements of, oh, yeah, if I didn't mean minimal supplements, a lot of people are deficient in these nutrients. So, let's, for your hit list, let's go to the ones that don't work. So, right off the bat, let's get those out of the way. Then we can focus on the ones that work. So, you talked about some calming and sleeping products. So, what's the story on these? Right, right. And may I say that in doing this article, I did reach out to some other experts in the field because I wanted to get their opinion on this as well. So, Flores Wardenar from ASU, Christina Widen from Northwestern University and Tavis Pietoli, like one of the OG sports dietitians. He's been a supplement guru forever. And so, I leaned on some amazing colleagues to have them weigh in as well. It made me feel good because I feel like our hit in this list was very similar, but they helped me weigh in on this as well, right? And so, yeah, if you, this whole, right, who wouldn't like to sleep better and be calmer, right? Stress release. This is a big market. It's very appealing, especially to athletes that are very over-scheduled, right? And so, these athletes that have crazy training schedules, crazy class schedules, I mean, even at the high school level, I'm a mother to three competitive athletes, a high schooler. And I mean, their schedules are crazy already, right? And so, there's a really large combination of products in this space. So, everything from melatonin to alcyanine that are promising to, you know, solve all your sleep problems. So, but in general, I think they're, they can't make up for a bad diet, right? And I'd say a lot of these products, they don't have proper therapeutic doses, right? Some are too high, some are too low. I mean, there's literally a supplement called, like, calm, right? And so, again, I understand why people gravitate to it, but again, half the time people don't even know what's in them. They're like, oh, calm sounds good. I would like to be more calm. And they're not paying attention to the list of ingredients that might be in there, right? And then when it comes to things, I ask, I get asked about melatonin all the time. And listen, you know, most of the data on melatonin is for people with jet lag. It's people think it's a sleeping pill, right? And so, athletes, you know, get, oh, you're not sleeping because you're drinking 10 energy drinks a day, because you're not, you know what I mean? And then you just think you're going to take melatonin. So, usually these are a good sign as a clinician that maybe we need to work on some other type of habits time management sleep and stay away from these kind of potentially dangerous combinations of these products. Right. And, you know, the habits that you may having all day long are preventing you from folding a sleep at night, one of which is, you know, watching, you know, Netflix or screen time. So, we know that's a problem. You know, high dose vitamins and minerals. You know, this is, I mean, I, you need vitamins and minerals. And gosh knows many, people living in the United States, they're not, their diet is not adequate, so eat it. But taking high doses of it, you know, really, what is that going to do? Right. And I think, you know, good, the mentality is more is better, right? So, it's like, oh, this nutrient is good, you know, right? And a lot of these, these, the hype and the myths we see around supplements, right? They're based, this is about nutrition in general, right? It might be based on something actually factual, but then it gets blown out of proportion, right? And I think, so you get that one person that thinks, okay, well, if the recommendation is 400 milligrams, if I take eight milligrams, eight hundred milligrams, I'll get double the benefit, right? Not true. The other thing in this space too is when you see people taking multiple dietary supplements that all have the same stuff, micronutrients in it, right? So, that individual dose of this particular nutrient might be, let's say, you know, niacin or something that has a risk of toxicity. It's fine in that one product, but you're taking six different things and they all have well over the daily value recommendation. And then it equates to what could be toxic effects of a micronutrient, right? So, I really urge people to take inventory, you know, people like, oh, I take, you know, I take a B complex, they don't even know what's in there or they take a multivitamin, they don't know what's in there, and then they don't realize that they could be stacking themselves into a micronutrient toxicity. And you're right, Dan, because it's not just they're taking stacking multivitamin supplements, they can be taking like fortified drinks, fortified bars, fortified cereals, fortified, you know, everything's fortified now. So, that it's on top of that, and they don't think of that as like a supplement, because they think a supplement at a pill, but you're right, is stacking this up between what you're eating and your regular diet, and these fortified foods and the supplements, my goodness gracious word, we could do overload here. Right, it's like your diet was fine to begin with, you didn't even need any of it, and now you got, you know, 10,000 percent. And, you know, with what desirable vitamins, we know that they urinate them away. I often say that Americans have the most expensive urine in the world, you know, because it's like they just take these things and it goes right down the septic tank. What was hot, and I still think is hot, into these pre-workout supplements, what the heck are these? Yeah, right, so this, I mean, I, I, I, sports dietitians, I think we all commiserate over this. So often, and athletic trainers as well, right, I mean, this, right, so anything that promises energy, right, which is what pre-workouts aim to do, I get why it's appealing, but the best part is, I mean, these things have no calories in them, right, so they have a ton, and they have a ton of stimulants, right? And so, I think these be cut, there's no such thing as a one-size-fits-all pre-workout, right? They're all very, very different. Again, the average consumer is maybe taking them for quote-unquote energy, and maybe might be aware that there's like caffeine or a stimulant in there, but doesn't even know what else is in there, right? So, and again, typically like creatines, in example, we can talk about creatine later, because I actually do recommend creatine in, in many circumstances, but I don't want it in the pre-workout, right? And so people don't even know they're taking a pre-workout, and they're taking the creatine on top of it, right? But I think the bigger issue is the stimulants, right? So you're never, you're rarely ever going to find a pre-workout without a stimulant or multiple stimulants in it, and those can be really, really dangerous, right? So you're over-simulating the nervous system, you're going into a situation where you're anticipating an increase in heart rate anyway, because that you're exercising, and it could be very, very dangerous. And then if you have most pre-workouts, or do not have third-party verification, right? So again, you're not sure that what you see is what you get, and I see a lot of, I work with a lot of nurses that work at high schools, boarding schools, prep schools, and things like that, and they're constantly sending athletes to the hospital, because they take a pre-workout, they take two much of a pre-workout, the heart rate through the roof, and then it becomes a real medical concern. that you get energy, you need energy from food. You need carbohydrates, that feels you up with your body. Hallery, right, right, right. So years ago, before these pre-workouts, we would say like, before I work, I have a banana. You know what I mean, so that, yeah, right. So that was got the carbohydrates and your body, you could feed it and you could fuel, quote, unquote, air, quote, air, and queer, your workout. So what you're saying here, these are just stimulants. This is not giving the fuel that your body needs or really pushed to a workout. This is just a stimulant that's doing it. So you're really not feeding or fueling your body for that workout, unbelievable. The last one, these green powered powders, and what is this? - So, I mean, I can't really give you an answer, John. I don't, so they're, you know, they're all, they're all very different and this has become a very popular space in this supplement industry. These green powders, these, you know, that create these like concoctions that are in these crazy, like greenish brown colors. The, my favorite part is when someone asks me about them, they'll say, well, you know, I'll be like, and that, my first question is like, do you like the way it tastes? And they're like, no, it tastes disgusting. It tastes like dirt. And I'm like, what are you doing? You're paying for that? Like, what, so I, I think a rich, I mean, they're marketed, I think I, I see a lot of, this is something I see a lot of parents buy for their kids, right? My, my son or daughter, they do not, they not eat enough fruits and vegetables. Let's give them a greens powder assuming that it's an even swap, right? We know that, that's absolutely not. But I, I would say that the fruit and vegetable powders in these, in these greens powders are probably the least of my worries. You know, as opposed to the other things that come in. So now they're adding, you know, probiotics and adaptogens and corniceps and, and herbal things. And again, like, once we start to increase that list, like, what about interactions with medications? What about side effects? You know, like, you're not just getting, you know, dried kale, you know, that you're gonna mix with water, right? Which again, I'd rather just see, I'd rather just see kale. But, you know, and so they do can potentially become these really dangerous concoctions. They don't taste good. They're super, some of them are wildly expensive. So again, I mean, not worth the hype. I'm sure, I mean, even some of the experts I, I interviewed said, like, yeah, you know, there's a couple that, you know, the ingredient lists are not incredibly offensive. You know, I say that's the, the, the, the minority of them, the majority of them, they, there's something that might be concerning. They're like, but like, what do we, why? You know, like, you're not necessarily getting the benefit that you think that you're getting out of them. - Yeah, and you know, just take a moment, for everybody that's listening or watching. Go back to the days when you were little and you played soccer. So either you were little or you were apparent to play soccer. And what, what happened? What did you get for a snack? You got orange slices. Remember this? Orange slices. So you took an orange and you sliced it. And that's what you got. And everybody was happy. And you got fiber and vitamin C and orange. So really, if you go up with orange slices, what makes you think it's an adult? You're not gonna eat orange. Now, yeah, so it's just, it's my, it's absolutely my butt. And how much is an orange be inside compared to these green powder? - I mean, some of these things are literally more than $100 a month for a supply. - Yeah, I mean, it's crazy. Yeah, how many bananas and oranges and apples I can get for that for goodness? I can feed a village. All right, let's get to the good stuff. That potentially could work because I know that's what everybody's excited about. You said something about creatine. Let's talk about this. Why is this potentially good? How does it help? (upbeat music) - Alison, you know, so creatine monohydrate specifically really has, you know, it's the problem with the loose regulations about supplements that some, we're not even bothering to do enough research on them, right? I mean, the tide is turning. But I would say that one of the, the supplement would probably the longest history of good scientific evidence to support its safety and efficacy is for creatine monohydrate, right? We're finally, oh my God, it's so exciting. And I do mention this in the article. Now, we're having data on women, on females, you know, which we don't have a lot, a lot of. So, there's data, Abby Smith Ryan is really sort of leading the charge on this. She's published some amazing papers and has some more that are coming out, talking about the benefits to females and female athletes, post-menopausal women. I mean, it really, really fascinating, right? So, but really, you know, creatine is very safe. I saw something on social media I was scrolling earlier today with an expert kind of saying, yeah, it's not a steroid, right? I think it still has that sort of old school misconception that, you know, high school parents, I don't want my child taking creatine. It's a substrate. It's something your body's making already, right? And we have determined that when taken appropriately, right? Dosed appropriately, it can help with muscle building, it can help with muscle recovery. There's even some good data on its impact on brain health. I mean, there's a lot going on for creatine. So, lot to love. Here's the other thing too. It's like, I also think a lot of people think, oh, I'm just gonna take creatine and I'm gonna get all the size, right? I'm gonna get jacks, right? That's not how it works, right? If you're not eating enough, if you're not, strength training appropriately, it's not gonna work. But at least we don't have to worry about it being dangerous or harmful when taking up the proper dose. So, creatine can be very beneficial in helping to enhance performance. Both strength training and aerobic training when taken the right way. - You know, that's interesting. So, what about you would talk about older adults, the succopenia where they're losing muscle mass. Is there a place for creatine in older adults? - Not my patient population and area of expertise, but there's some data, yes, to support that again, especially so the data I looked at specifically was on post-menopausal women and their lean body mass decline, which we know is definitely a factor, right? So, again, it's more than just taking the creatine, right? It's taking the creatine and then using those muscles appropriately. So, yeah, if we can get that combination in other populations, I joke, you know, as collegiate athletes, we've, I mean, Quinnipiac, we have great strength and conditioning professionals. So, like, I know my athletes are training effectively and so we don't have to worry about that piece, but that, you know, for the average person, you know, if they're not doing any strength training, right? Again, if we use that example, so you need all those pieces to fit, but yes, I definitely think that there's some potential there. - In the article, you mentioned omega-3s and I was really excited about this. So, tell us how omega-3s could be quite helpful. - Right, so, you know, working with college athletes, I always ask them, like, how many of you eat fatty fish twice a week, you know, do any hands go up? Do any hands go up? - Two, maybe, you know what I mean, two, usually, if that. And if I'm like, do you eat salmon or two in a twice a week every week? And they're like, oh, every week? No, no, no, no, no, right. And I get it, right? The access is limited. I mean, you know, we, I always joke like, I couldn't exactly, I should, like, really good salmon, but they don't have it all the time, right? And so, like, in our dining services and things, so, you know, I get it, right? So, we know that a lot of people don't get enough of this. We know how important it can be for things like muscle recovery. Again, fighting inflammation, right? All, I always joke, my athletes are inflamed. You're all inflamed all the time, right? And so, you know, as a function of high level training, we do see this. So, you know, having them correct that shortfall in their diet, right? This is what we want supplements to be for. There's definitely a time and a place for it, right? And so, when we can identify that a lot of people in this population, certainly my population of competitive athletes. And we know that most Americans aren't eating enough fatty fish either, right? So, safe, effective. You know, we don't have a ton of, like, dosing specific to athletes, but we know that it's safe. We know it can help fill those bones in the diet, help fighting inflammation, help with injured athletes, which is kind of a whole other dimension. I don't even go into in the article. That data is continuing to emerge about its role in brain health, right? So, we know how important. We already know that omega-3s benefit, especially those DHAs, how they can benefit neurological function. Now, when we start looking at athletes that are more prone to head injuries, or, you know, recovering from head injuries, you know, again, we still need more, but there's some good data saying there might even be a preventative effect on concussion for athletes that. Again, again, more is not better, but can make up for those voids in the diet with some fish oil supplementation. - That I find that whole concussion, and maybe in prevention is huge. I mean, that is absolutely huge. For Joe and Josephine on the streets, like how much omega-3s should they be taking or can take? - So, I mean, I would start with, are you ever eating any sources of it from your diet, right? And not, but I would say, you know, somewhere around 1,000 milligrams a day, you know, with the caveat that everyone's a little bit different, but I think that, that to me is kind of a safe recommendation that I sort of go to. I'll even sometimes, you know, tell my athletes, like, hey, say when I'll for sushi that day, you had some fatty fish. Don't take the fish oil that day, save the money, right? You know, so I think, you know, if I'm gonna get a big dose of it from the diet that day, maybe, you know, just 'cause the bottle says take three pills, doesn't mean you need to take the three pills, right? And again, it is one of the more, the good quality, which is what you want, tends to be a little bit more expensive. So there's ways to offset that a bit. You know, and another thing, two people think like, you know, fatty fish, okay, they get salmon, but it's also sardines are really good. Tuna is good too, and you don't have to have it at dinner. For some reason, they think it's gotta be at dinner. But, you know, you can, now there's these canned tuners, canned salmon, or what about the pouch? I love the salmon, so affordable too. Oh my God, so you open it up, you can eat it, Well, you can eat it as a sandwich for lunch on a salad. But you know it's a fabulous snack people are saying gee. I want a high protein stack those those fish pouches are really really great So let's get those think about that the other the other two. I want to talk about first one is mag Magnesium and this is hot now on social media. So tell us about magnesium So it's so hot right and I think this is a good example of where You know we don't want to go overboard. I mean I I see people left right and so I was oh anything's wrong with you Just take magnesium right and too much magnesium can be hurtful right and and it can be toxic It can cause some nasty GI side effects, which is not going to enhance performance But we have data to support there's a large number especially an athletic population that are just falling short of what they need right They're not getting enough from their diet for a million reasons that we can go into it So supplementing you know can be beneficial We look at it in terms of muscle recovery this sleep data I think is again, I see a lot of people leaning on it for sleep and I don't know I I'd like to see a little more data really definitively saying That you know higher dose magnesium is going to help you sleep But I it maybe it's anecdotal. I have some you know athletes that say it works As long as it's the right type I think this is the case where people can get very confused right magnesium oxide glycanic citrate right so and you got to look at the So the data you know in some studies they looked at oxide and other studies they looked at the other forms So, you know, I tend to lean more towards magnesium citrate Particularly for muscle is where we're seeing some data that that should be the form to take and magnesium glycanate right so those are gonna have They're gonna tend to have less GI side effects But most of the drugstore, you know, I'd say oxide. I'm not an expert I think it's probably the more the cheaper one is magnesium oxide and that's what a lot of people go to so what I worry about is The athlete that goes oh more is better. They take half a bottle of oxide. They're in the bathroom all night, you know, but but yes, I think We're recognizing that athletes are not getting enough And so can we make up for some of those voids in the diet with some supplementation? Hey, you want to take it at night fine. Great. Is it gonna help you sleep jury's still out? But maybe on the muscle recovery piece especially for people that train frequently high-level strength training rate And that doesn't that could be your exercise enthusiast as well You know could we could we have some data supporting that as long as you're taking the right dose the right form that it could be beneficial Right, you know dietary reference intakes that tells you how much of a nutrient, you know You should have based upon your age and your your sex But there's also a tolerable upper level for some of these nutrients and magnesium. There is one where if you chronically go above a certain amount it can start having Side effects and oftentimes the first side effects are GI discomfort in a lot of these micro nutrients So be aware of that that you know and look into that and again We're gonna put that article that you wrote On today up today's dietician on the fun on Facebook page suddenly could read more where to it the last one you I this is really it interesting beta Alanine so can you please explain what the heck beta Alanine is? Yes, this is probably a lesser-known Nutrient but again, this is one of those products that this is one of those substances that Is in other things and athletes not know they're taking it. It's in a protein powder It's it's almost always in pre workouts and they don't even know that you know Nobody even knows that they're taking it, right? So beta Alanine is interesting So it is again, we're sort of looking at without getting like overly sciencey It's basically supposed to help increase the amount of a particular product within muscle tissue called karnasine and The idea is it can delay the onset of fatigue, right? So the idea is you get in a little more beta Alanine It kind of creates a buffer, right? So you're not creating too much acidity sort of you know what I mean? This is sort of negative byproducts in that muscle and you can you can get away You could work at higher levels delay that onset of fatigue So whether that's in the weight room you can increase your reps, right? And again, that can lead to increased strength outcomes Or looking at maybe more of a strength focus athlete, right? Where you're gonna get you're gonna that wrestler is gonna get that extra Edge of Of strength burst before they start to sort of just like, you know hit the wall So there is data to support that beta Alanine can be effective, right? That's that's the good news the bad news is that most of the time people are not taking the proper therapeutic dose It does have some side effects that some people are more sensitive to it kind of can create this sort of tingly sensation But again, you put in a pre workout people are like oh, I'm all jazzed up. It's it's working You know like so I admittedly some athletes really kind of like that But it doesn't come without side effects, right? So, you know or that's the whole point you get a good third party tested product Doesn't mean you're not gonna maybe have some side effects that you don't like doesn't mean that it's magic Again, if you just took the pre workout and you got no fuel to our point before That's not necessarily gonna give you a better a better workout just because there's beta Alanine in there But it could definitely be a piece of piece of the puzzle when it's dozed properly, you know There's so much good that can happen to with supplements, and there's a lot of You know problems that could occur So, you know, I always recommend if you're gonna be going out and taking supplements Not even just vitamin minerals supplements, but all of these other supplements that we see on the shelves to talk to a Redis dietician that specializes in area to make sure that you're not overdoing it Or maybe you need something else that you're not thinking about to do that. You can find a dietician at eatright.wag And up in the corner you can it says find an or DN and you can fly one in a local area You know people athletes or want to be athletes at universities often have a registered dietician on staff like you do at your university Here at Boston University, we have a slew of dieticians as a sergeant choice nutrition center that not only athletes can go to But anybody anybody the public the staff that work here the faculty that work here or even outside Neoposter universe can go to make an appointment It's worth it to find out what you're consuming if you and you might find out other things Where you need to be having in your diet besides just something that's gonna help out your workout. Yeah, get get the help Right, ask the questions. It's so confusing. It's so confusing and you know something if this is a big Topic of research and scientific facts and you can't stay on top of that. I can't stay on top of that I write nutrition textbooks and I can't stay on top of this Yeah, you got to go to people who specialize in certain areas. Yeah, it's it's perfect Perfect example. There was a product. We mentioned we didn't get to we didn't talk about it today Where I we kind of put it in like the no list like the got worth the hype list and then since then a publication came out and I Assess and did a new position statement on it and again like it did it didn't it a truestly didn't change I'd still keep it where I kept it in the article But it was new data that wasn't available to me a month ago, you know And I mean I would have included that reference in there and so you know, and that's the thing. It's it's it's evolutionary Well, what was the supple? It was for HMB. Oh before you go tell us. It's beta hydroxy beta methyl butary basically it is It's used as a part of branch in amino acid. So it's it's a precursor to Lucy and Lucy and is the primary amino acid responsible for building muscle, right? So this idea is oh you take some more HMB you increase the availability of Lucy and you can you could build more muscle, right? Sounds great But there's not enough data to say that this is actually that this is actually working and then There was some new data so I based my my opinion on a review and now another review came out But again, it's still like it's some of the benefits. They don't even see it in trained athletes They only see it in untrained people, right? And I think to your point. I think It's important like just because there's a study that comes out. It doesn't mean that that applies to you, right? And if it's one study, it might not really apply to anybody, right? So you know, that's our job as clinicians is to keep on top of the scientific evidence so that we can help people make decisions I'm not I'm still not going to turn around and tell all my athletes to start taking HMB necessarily But I'm interested to see where it goes But again if I'm not I'm working with a highly trained population So it's probably still not going to be where we where we go in that direction But like it came out and I was like where was this a month ago? I could have included it We have to do a follow-up. You know that that reminds me to leave you with with one thought remember when you read about a study That says something one study is no study It's when you have multiple multiple studies that support the same thing And there's a consensus out there that this is good or maybe this is something that you might want to try to avoid So that's why we need people that are on top of this and writing about this So with that I am going to thank Dana Angelo White for coming on spot on here talking about this We're going to put a copy of our article on the spot on Facebook page so you can read it and You know we Thank goodness you're on top of this because the public needs to know more about that. So thank you Thank you again my dear for being on spot on. Thanks for having me Spot on is supported by the Boston University Sergeant College's Master of Science degree in nutrition program log on to be you dot edu to learn more about this fabulous nutrition graduate program [Music]

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Dietary supplements are loosely regulated, with the 1994 Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act allowing products to be sold without prior safety or efficacy approval.
  2. Many supplements lack transparency, with risks of contamination, incorrect dosing, and undisclosed ingredients that can lead to harm—especially for athletes subject to drug testing.
  3. Third-party certifications like NSF Sport, Informed Choice, and ConsumerLab offer reliable verification of ingredient accuracy and purity, helping consumers identify trustworthy products.
  4. Popular supplements such as melatonin, pre-workouts, and green powders are often overhyped, with little evidence supporting claims, and may contain harmful stimulants or cause unintended side effects.
  5. Creatine monohydrate and omega-3 fatty acids have strong scientific backing for benefits in muscle recovery, performance, and inflammation reduction, especially in athletes and older adults.
  6. Magnesium supplementation can support muscle recovery and sleep, but high doses or wrong forms (like magnesium oxide) may cause gastrointestinal discomfort.
  7. Beta-alanine may delay fatigue during exercise but requires proper dosing and is often hidden in pre-workouts without consumer awareness.
  8. Supplements like HMB lack sufficient evidence in trained populations, emphasizing the need for clinical judgment and expert dietary advice before use.

Summary:

Dietary supplements are a multi-billion-dollar industry but face significant regulatory gaps—products can be sold without proof of safety or efficacy, leading to risks like contamination, incorrect dosing, and undisclosed ingredients. This is especially concerning for athletes, who may unknowingly consume banned substances. While many supplements are overhyped, certain ones like creatine and omega-3s have strong scientific support for muscle recovery, inflammation reduction, and brain health.

, NSF, ConsumerLab) help ensure product integrity. Supplements like pre-workouts and green powders often contain stimulants or unproven ingredients, and overuse can lead to side effects. Experts stress that supplements should not replace a balanced diet, and consumers should consult dietitians to avoid nutrient overload or toxicity.

Key nutrients like magnesium and beta-alanine show benefit only when used appropriately. Ultimately, the most reliable guidance comes from clinical evidence, not marketing, and a growing consensus is needed before endorsing any supplement for performance or health. Consumers are urged to verify products through trusted third-party certifications and to prioritize dietary sources over supplements whenever possible.

FAQs

No, dietary supplements are not strictly regulated before being sold. The 1994 Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act provides some oversight, but it allows products to be sold without prior proof of safety or efficacy, leading to potential issues with ingredient accuracy and contamination.

Look for third-party testing certifications like NSF for Sport, Informed Choice, or USP. These organizations verify that products are free from contaminants, accurately labeled, and free from banned substances—especially important for athletes.

Pre-workout supplements are primarily stimulants, not fuel sources. They don't provide carbohydrates or proper energy for workouts. Instead, they can overstimulate the nervous system, increasing heart rate and posing health risks, especially when taken in excess.

Green powders are often expensive, taste unpleasant, and contain questionable ingredients like probiotics and adaptogens. While they may include some nutrients, they don’t replace whole fruits and vegetables, and many offer no significant benefit over a balanced diet.

Yes, creatine monohydrate is one of the most well-researched and safe supplements. It supports muscle building, recovery, and performance in strength and endurance training, and may also benefit brain health and muscle mass in older adults and women.

Yes, omega-3s—especially EPA and DHA—help reduce inflammation and support muscle recovery. They are particularly beneficial for athletes with high training loads, and can also support brain health, potentially reducing concussion risk.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.