Go back

South Africa's Underworld is Killing Itself

53m 42s

South Africa's Underworld is Killing Itself

The podcast explores the deepening crisis in Cape Town’s organized crime, where gang wars over nightclubs, drugs, and real estate have spiraled into a violent, corrupt system. Central figures like Mark Liffman, Jerome Donkey Boyson, and Nafiz Modak are caught in a web of assassinations, failed hit attempts, and shifting alliances. A major factor is the systemic corruption within South Africa’s police force, where officers are accused of covering up crimes, selling weapons, and interfering in investigations. The criminal networks have evolved beyond street-level violence, infiltrating government contracts and construction projects—showcasing a transition from petty crime to state-level exploitation. This expansion is evident in the killing of city official Wendy Kloppers and the arrest of figures like Ralph Stanfield, who linked street gang operations to large-scale government development. Despite numerous arrests and trials, there are no convictions for key murders, and several suspects—such as Donkey and Modak—remain unprosecuted or in custody. The violence and corruption have created what the show describes as a "mafia state," where law enforcement and politicians are complicit. The narrative underscores a widespread pattern of impunity, with internal police conflicts, failed investigations, and the targeting of investigators like Charles Kinnear. As the conflict escalates, the lack of justice highlights a fundamental breakdown in South Africa’s criminal justice system, where power, money, and violence are deeply entrenched. The episode concludes with a sobering reflection on how organized crime has become a structural force in the country’s economy and society.

Transcription

10652 Words, 56982 Characters

English
Shaq here. What's it like to buy a car from Carvana 100% online and get it delivered to your door? Let me tell you. Your car is here, Mr. Shaq. Thank you, Mr. Carvana guy. Can't wait to take it for a spin. Only the best for you, Mr. Shaq. Hey, have you always been so big, tall, and handsome? Not always. I was 6'10 once. Seven days delivered or returned, Mr. Shaq? Not that I would. You never do. No, I never do. So buy your car today on Carvana. Delivery fees may apply. See our seven day return policy at carvana.com. FanDuel is now available everywhere in the U.S. So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are, including these places. Make this your most rewarding season ever with FanDuel. Age and location restrictions apply. Product availability varies by market. See FanDuel.com for eligibility. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Sunday, November 3rd, 2024 in George, South Africa at 1138 in the morning. George is a golf town. It's about 270 miles east of Cape Town along the coast with mountains behind it, the Indian Ocean in front of it, retirees and fairways, a nice suburban life complete with a garden route mall, a big suburban mall with a big suburban parking lot. And on a Sunday morning at the start of the summer, that lot is full of families. A man is walking across that lot towards a blue Ford pickup. He's 57. He's got a house on the golf estate outside town and a house back in Cape Town on the Atlantic seaboard where the apartments are not cheap. And he is, for the first time anybody can remember, by himself. No driver, no bodyguard, just a guy with his car keys in a suburban mall parking lot. The reason this man usually has a bodyguard is because he's among the most powerful crime lords in South Africa. To say he has a lot of enemies would be putting it lightly. At the current moment, he's due back in court the next day as part of the trial for helping orchestrate the murder of another underworld top dog, a man known as the Steroid King. A white VW Polo comes across the lot. From it, all of a sudden, gunfire. Five shots. The man goes down between the parked cars. The Polo swings out of the lot so fast it nearly hits a car coming in and it's gone. And the man is dead on the pavement in front of the parking lot. And the man is dead on the Sunday shoppers before anyone has any idea what happened or who he is. Forty minutes later, at a farm a few miles out of town, a security camera picks up two men standing beside that white Polo. They're taking the license plates off and putting different ones on. There's a bullet hole in the left passenger window shot from the inside and they tape over it. Then they drive east along the coast and then they turn inland, up into the mountains, toward a little town called Uniondale. At about four in the afternoon, on the Uniondale road, 70 miles from the mall, the police stop the Polo. Inside it, they find three wigs, two black motorcycle helmets, nine millimeter rounds, a dash cam, a roll of duct tape, and license plates registered to a homeless man and to an elderly couple in the Winelands. It's sloppy, sloppy work for a hit team that just took out a kingpin. The two men in the car, they work for a security company in Cape Town. One of them used a 10 bar at a notorious beach bar that was shot up by a member of the 27's gang back in 2017. In the middle of a war over control of Cape Town's nightclubs. That's the war that started it all. And as it unraveled, the bodies kept piling up. The dead man in the parking lot is Mark Liffman. The newspapers call him the gentleman gangster of Cape Town. He's part of a criminal syndicate the police call the Brotherhood, which dominated Cape Town's nightlife and underworld in the 2010s and fought that bloody war with another syndicate to keep that control. A war that put two literal gangster brothers on opposing sides. He, of course, won't be making it to court the next day for the murder of the so-called steroid king, seeing how he's just been gunned down in that suburban mall parking lot. He's also the fourth man accused in that case to be shot dead. And he won't be the last. This is the Underworld Podcast. Welcome back to the Underworld Podcast, an audiovisual experience program that takes the listeners on a journey through international organized crime, past, present, and future, around the globe and back, hosted by two journalists who spent their careers traveling all over reporting on stories like this and only partially regret it. I'm Danny Gold, and I'm joined as always by Sean, the steroid queen Williams in Buenos Aires, Argentina, who has been dabbling in performance-enhancing drugs so he can keep pace with the young Argentines in his Sunday football league. How's that working out for you, big guy? God, it's so demeaning as a start. I'm just trying to keep my T-levels above a 90-year-old woman, and this guy comes along. Yeah, I'm good, I guess. When this comes out, I think I'm going to finish all my drafts for the year, which means I can actually get back to enjoying life again, which is, you know, a bit inside baseball. No one cares who cares about journalists, but it's going to be good for me. And I'm going to go up on a rooftop bar after this and smoke some cigarettes, man. I'm going to really let my hair down. You know, I always tell people, I always tell people, he might come off like a soft English rose, but that's Sean Williams. He is a man, you know? He's out there doing man stuff, living a man's life. His T-levels are naturally high. Sometimes I smoke three cigarettes in a year. God, I miss cigarettes so much. What a man. As you may or may not know, we do bonus episodes, and you can get them and support us on Patreon at patreon.com slash generalpodcast. You're not going to have to listen to them. You can just throw us some cash. We have like tens of thousands of listeners, close to six figures and like 600 Patreon supporters. It doesn't make any sense. Tell us what to do. If you want us to be more left wing, we'll be more left wing. You want us to be more right wing, we'll do it. Just give us $5 a month. We'll do whatever you say. Sean will show his feet. Anyway, this is the burden we chose. You can also get those bonus episodes by signing up through Spotify or iTunes. Merch is at underworldpod.com. Email us at the underworldpodcast at gmail.com. Tips, advertising, ideas, all that. If you're watching on YouTube, comment, go on our socials, share our 70 second slot videos with your followers. Let's crack that algorithm, shall we? Yeah. How do we become one of those shows where they show like people donating like one, two dollars at a time coming through the whole time? Can we do that? You have to do it live and you have to like, I don't know. Do you have to have charisma? Because I'm out. Bad. No, you do not have to have charisma. Oh, okay. It's the opposite of charisma. All right. I'm going on too long. So we are headed back to Cape Town where the gangland is awash. Some violence and murders over what else? The drug trade and control the nightclubs and fights over real estate, the steroid market and some good old fashioned disrespect thrown in as well. I'm going to do a quick recap of last week's episode, I guess two weeks ago's episode because a lot happened. There's a lot of names and all of the gangsters in Cape Town, they all seem to know each other. It's like a high school. It's all very confusing. So I will attempt to recap this and Sean, you ask questions when needed for our listeners because I want them to get this and there is a lot on the table. So the whole thing about the Cape Town underworld is it runs through the network. It runs through the network. It runs through the nightclub doors, at least in this world. Because in Cape Town, whoever controls the bouncers on the doors of these nightclubs controls who sells drugs inside and who gets paid substantial protection money to keep the peace. So there's a karate black belt with an alleged mafia affiliation and a spy rumor named Cyril Bika. He is the OG boss and he seizes control shortly after apartheid falls and the South African economy and nightlife sector kick up quite a notch, especially as drugs flow in. He rules for like a decade plus until he shot at 17 times. I don't know how many times he's hit at a traffic light in 2011 while being chauffeured around by the guy who killed the infamous Arkon, the Balkan warlord of Arkon's Tigers fans and our first ever subject. Now, the men who've been fighting Bika merge into one company run by a bouncer named Andre Naudi, bankrolled by a gangster businessman named Mark Livman with a soldier supplied by a gang boss from the Notorious Flats neighborhood named Jerome Boyson, otherwise known as Donkey, who ran a street gang called the South African Gang. And he's a guy who's been killed by a gang boss from the South African Gang. He's a guy who's been killed by a gang boss from the South African Gang. , ,, , ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, But in 2016, there is a bar fight involving the notorious Numbers Prison Gang. I think this was the 27th. Remember there are three sects of the Numbers Gangs that interact with each other but also kill each other. And Donkey splits with his brother Colin, Donkey Jerome. He splits with his brother Colin, also a top level gangster. Colin Boyson, he teams up with a loud young gangster named Nafiz Modak. And together, they launch an attack on the brotherhood trying to take over territory in the night. ,, That's when the attacks and the shootings and everything starts. And start they do. There are six attempted hits on Donkey in about 15 months. He sits on the opposite side again, like we said, of his brother Colin. So it's brother versus brother, like literally, which is insane. In the middle of this gang war, you get Brian Weinstein, the steroid king, who starts some trouble and gets himself killed in his bed. That's the trial mentioned in the cold open. He had teamed up with yet another gang boss, Ralph Stanfield, the alleged head of the Numbers Prison Gang. of the 28th gang outside of prison to try to make his new his own move on the doors Wayne Cena is killed in the summer of 2017 alright deep breath do we do we is it I know you guys listen to this you're not reading it so I just want to make sure it makes sense and we do a good job of that because I know it can get confusing yeah it's good Civil War yeah the cops say Mark Liffman and Jerome Donkey Boyson paid for that hit after Liffman had already paid for a hit on Ralph Stanfield that didn't work out Liffman says he doesn't Donkey says he didn't that's where we kind of left it alright so the numbers gang we mentioned the 26th the 27th the 28th they're an insanely brutal South African prison gang three gangs actually they also have a very convoluted relationship with each other inside and outside of prison we did a big episode on them early last year if you want to know more definitely go listen to that it is a crazy one most of what you're about to hear was dug up by Karen Dolly whose books To the Wolves and Man Alone are the spine of this episode by the investigative outfit at the Mail and Guardian by the court reporters at EWN News 24 and the Daily Maverick who have sat through like every one of these hearings by the indictments which in South Africa are public documents and which I've read so you do not have to okay August 2017 okay yeah that's the deep breath we're very good very good and just one mention of 26, 27, and 28 which I like yeah I mean they're just you know they're a gang sort of kind of a cult within months of the murder of the steroid king Weinstein the hawks which is South Africa's version of the FBI arrest Weinstein's own former bodyguards they soon have the hit team they're all in custody by the end of the year but it's clear they're just the hit team right they're not the ones who really are motivated for this well they're motivated by you know what I mean the brotherhood though is still free and now they're putting together a plan to wipe out their other major enemy Nafi's Modak and Donkey's brother Colin and five others in their main circle but before this can happen the police move and not on the brotherhood on the other side in December they are really arresting Nafi's Modak Colin Boyson Cyril Bika's old manager who was working with them now and a few others for extortion of one particular bar the cop who built that case is a detective named Charles Kinnear Kinnear's from the flats you know he's a local slum boy made good and he still lives there in a house on a street where everybody knows him he's a lieutenant colonel late 40s married two boys the kind of detective the papers call one of the finest in the country and the kind whose own colleagues who are hopelessly corrupt keep ending up in his cage case files because in case you haven't been paying attention the South African police are basically kind of operating like a mafia themselves or with the mafias mobsters gangsters whatever you want to call it even at the top levels he comes up under the two cops who run the biggest police investigation in the modern history of the Western Cape which is the one that answered the question of where exactly do all the guns on the street come from spoiler alert they come from corrupt South African police now South Africa has strict gun laws on paper shouldn't be that many guns out there on the streets but when you have over 25,000 murders a year clearly there's a whole lot of them in circulation so in 2013 Western Cape detectives they start noticing something in the ballistics the same weapons keep turning up in gang shootings and when they trace the serial numbers they lead back to a police storage room outside Pretoria which is the capital where confiscated and handed in firearms sit waiting to be melted down the investigation is called Project Impeach and what it found was that a police colonel a 35 year old veteran between 2007 and 2015 had with a few other associates taken more than 2,000 guns that were supposed to be destroyed and sold them down the pipeline to the Cape Flats gangs 2,000 guns detectives linked 888 of them to 1,066 murders in the Western Cape alone the cop eventually pleaded guilty to racketeering in 2016 and got 18 years Kinnear though he's the opposite of that cop right he and he is after Modak and his crew and Modak is the one who does not like it as one would assume he wouldn't at his bail hearing after the arrest from the doc he publicly accuses Kinnear and Kinnear's boss of being on the take for Liffman and Donkey then in August Donkey is once again shot up this time walking out of a steakhouse in a mall he's hit in the arm one of the attackers is actually killed but Donkey lives surviving the 6th attempt on his life in I believe 18 months wow either a great advert for belief in God or maybe a terrible one for South African marksmanship I don't know maybe both I do feel like their hitmen are just not good at the job you know yeah there's a lot of a lot of failure that's one in yeah that's what I was gonna say that's one in six yeah that's none in six yeah four days later one of Modak's co-accused in the bar extortion case a 45 year old is shot dead in his own car in his own driveway two to the head three to the chest nobody's charged then in October one of Modak's lawyers and a popular defense attorney to half the underworld pulls up outside a private school to drop off his kids a gunman walks up and fires through the window of his black Mercedes he's killed his eight year old son is hit and lives a great polo drives off three men eventually get convicted of it but nobody ever establishes who sent them that same November in front of the cameras in the flats the government launches a new police unit to deal with all of this it's called the anti-gang unit very original name its commander is a major general named Andre Lincoln Lincoln was Mandela's personal bodyguard he's the cop Mandela sent after the Sicilian mob guy in 1936 the one whose unit writes the report from episode one that said Cyril Bika and his bouncers were tied into the real Sicilian mafia and one of Lincoln's section commanders in the new unit is Charles Kinnear the cop going after Modak that December Kinnear goes even further and he writes an internal complaint and a long one at that it's 59 pages long where he outlines police malfeasance and corruption and he sends it to the National Head of Crime Intelligence to the police watchdog and to nine other generals in the police and what it says is that there's a unit inside the Western Cape's own crime intelligence division at least six cops that is working against him interfering in his cases trying to get a prisoner and make a false statement against his colleagues tapping his phone not the criminal like tapping his phone his own police service is basically listening to his calls and quote my neighbors are also becoming paranoid as they think their lives might be at risk is what he writes in it which we're going to see is not being paranoid in January the National Crime Intelligence boss forwards it up for the National Commissioner with a recommendation that the unit should be disbanded and the legality of operations should be departmentally and criminally investigated and then as far as anybody can tell nothing happens like I said it's just their police are corrupt as all hell is this getting out in the papers at the time I feel just like this is a massive scandal and you've got like the easy hero in Kinnear as well kind of thing it's like media bait it's very like Latin American you know it's very like Brazil Mexico sort of police corruption all that sort of stuff now that brings us to 2019 and three big things happened first Andre Naudi remember him the man who controlled the suburban nightclubs at the same time as Bika became a leader in the brotherhood he gets caught up for not paying his taxes so does Liffman the sheriff of the court turns up at Naudi's house with the anti-gang unit in tow and carries his furniture and his TVs out the front door Liffman gets hit with a tax bill of 388 million rand 27 million dollars which sounds insane with the numbers we've thrown around here which seem very light right he fights it he loses they both get taken for a ride losing property cars money and with that some power yeah I feel like what we're talking about them taking over the entire door franchise is for like a few hundred grand I think in the last episode this seems like 27 million crazy amount of money so I was thinking about that I think we talked about it too it was like 300 grand that was offered but I think it was an offer that was more like take a little bit of money and shut up otherwise we're coming in hard like I think it was that kind of like it was an insulting offer for a purpose you know otherwise we're gonna come and try and shoot you six times and fail right I think I think the money thing is very confusing for me like I can't tell how profitable these guys are like how many millions they're making it seems low at some points like not even worth it and then you hear a number like this so maybe the numbers are off I don't know but the money thing is very confusing if you are in South Africa and have any idea of it email us I would really like to know FanDuel is now available everywhere in the US so you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are including these places make this your most rewarding season ever with FanDuel age and location restrictions apply product availability varies by market see FanDuel.com for eligibility gambling problem call 1-800-GAMBLER a KFC tale in the pursuit of flavor the colonel never wanted to be the reason customers finished a meal unsatisfied so he created the $20 build a bucket meal with your choice of eight pieces chicken or tenders four sides and four biscuits that way if you weren't happy he could say don't blame me you built it or more succinctly you played yourself the colonel lived so we could chicken the $20 build a bucket it's finger licking good prices and participation may vary taxes, tips and fees extra extra charge for breast piece substitution choice hotels get you more of what you value comfort in it's calling your name save on the stain oh and free waffles are yours to claim book direct at storesvilletales.com then in July the father of one of the cops investigating not fees Modak gets gunned down in his driveway with a grandchild in the back of the car this is a case of mistaken identity the hit was supposed to be aimed at the cop not his dad the old man was 74 a gang member from the flats gets caught for it and takes a plea deal saying he was paid $1,700 and that the order came down from Modak and that Modak when he heard about it was proud of the hit even though he got the wrong man Modak of course denies all of it and he'll eventually be on trial for it. That same month, Andre, now that he gets shot in a parking lot but survives no suspects this is they might have the worst hit men in the world i don't think we've had a show like this well it seems like they're a lot of them are getting i mean the one that killed wincy was professional but it seems like they're mostly just getting like you know street dogs from the flats dead 27s 28s to like go for it who just don't care about their own lives um you know they're not they're not sending you know like former special forces guys after it right these guys are sloppy then in november a police colonel was shot dead a few streets away from kinnear's house and the talk in the papers is that the shooters had the wrong cop and they were supposed to kill kinnear nine days later a man is caught outside kinnear's house with a hand grenade it falls out of his pocket and doesn't go off uh he says later he can promise 3 000 ran 200 and he gets five years yeah it's it's not disproving the theory no it's very it's not it's not great it's not great you the cop's version is that modak supplied the grenade a car a photograph of kinnear and his home address to a woman the cops also say that the woman had recruited a sergeant inside kinnear's only unit to leak when the police were going to raid modak's house modak appears to be on the war path right he does not give a fuck he's even going after the cop who's hunting him and his side for what it's worth says the anti-gang unit staged the whole grenade thing to frame him which doesn't sound convincing so if you're kinnear at the end of 2019 like things are not looking good bro a year ago you tell your bosses in writing that your own colleagues are corrupt as hell and they're tapping your phone a fellow detective's father is shot in his driveway in july a colonel just got shot dead up the road from your house maybe in your place and a guy just dropped a grenade outside your front door so what does the south african police service do for you in december of 2019 it withdraws his protection the armed guard outside the house is gone his wife begs them not to do it but they do it anyway and this is like real state losing control type of stuff like real narco state things happening yeah and it's worth mentioning this is happening at the same time as there's like top and bottom right there's huge state capture across south africa that's the phrase they use like state capture it's like construction and mining mafias screwing the country for billions and when i think when this is all happening it's just before maybe the government is drafting something called operation prosper which is basically a kind of martial law light with putting armed forces on the streets which was the i guess the spark for the first story we did like one of the earliest when we started this show back in like 2020 2021 or something so it's getting really bad from top to bottom all over south africa at this point yeah i think you did one on this is about the guptas right yeah the guptas yeah yeah that was really interesting stuff and it they they have like links to some of these guys as well some of these figures pop up yeah can you just give a quick people might not have heard that like a quick three second summary at three second three second summary three second let's go no it's just a i think the guptas are a brother a pair of brothers who essentially start extorting and bribing officials to to build huge projects all up and down south africa and they get so powerful working alongside corrupt officials in the nc and it it kind of just filters down onto the streets right because you you mentioned construction projects property things like this and when you go all the way up the tree you often get to these guys the guptas and who they're giving backhanders to so it's no surprise i guess that when you get cops sniffing around this stuff uh they're either i don't know they're either trying to put him off the scent or trying to snuff him out or whatever they're trying to do but it makes sense when you look at who's in control yeah yeah for sure i mean i feel like is a bridge in that because he is a property guy as well but he's also like seems like tuned in with the street guys too you know he seems like the guptas seem like very high up in that regard he sort of seems to straddle both worlds even though he comes from like a nice background you know yeah i think stanfield as well is kind of between these worlds so he gets involved i think in the property game but he comes from the flat like he's a rough guy starting out he comes from the flats but he he's like one of those gangsters who puts on a suit and and really makes it work i think now remember that there's you know this whole thing starts from the extortion case against modak the one kenya built the one that stayed started the whole war between the two of them it's been grinding along in a cape town courtroom for two years and in february 2020 it finally collapses the prosecution finishes presenting its evidence and the court just throws it out before the defense even says a word the judge just says that since modak's company took over the bar security there have been no complaints so it doesn't seem like there should really even be a trial modak and colin boysen walk out and they go celebrate by having lunch free man at the bar and a month later somebody really starts hunting kaneer it's a debt collector up in johannesburg a thousand miles away basically like a repo guy who finds cars when people stop paying for it he uses these work tools to do it which i guess can track your phone and he does that with kaneer's phone he's tracking him through a service that pings cell phone towers and hands you back a street address which is usually used like i said to locate cars that need to be repossessed kaneer's number gets pinged more than two thousand times this guy is also tracking mark liftman's lawyer a guy named william booth 658 pings on that guy and jerome boysen and the head of the anti-gang unit soon enough a hit his stage on liftman's lawyer in his garage two masked men early morning but as we come to expect from south african hitman they miss video shows them casing a house for three days by the summer of 2020 the police have been told in writing that kaneer's phone is being tracked and that his life is in danger nothing changes then in september on a friday afternoon on the street where everybody knows him a man walks up to kaneer when he's in his driveway and guns him down while he's waiting for a son to come out and move a car the son hears the shots from the front door right away the cops point their fingers almost immediately at modak the police minister goes to the house that weekend apologizes to the family and admits in public that the police had failed to protect their own detective the national commissioner calls him one of the best investigators in the service or i guess was one of the best investigators in the service yeah seems a little late yeah definitely nobody has since been convicted of pulling that trigger a prisoner told the police watchdog this year that he could identify the shooter and that the shooter was one of ralph stanfield's 28s and then in may he refused to testify because he was afraid for his family and this is kind of what karen dolly's book is actually about because the title to the wolves isn't about the gangsters it's about who threw the detective to them which it turns out is alleged to be a rogue faction of police and to greatly simplify things there's basically like an internal civil war in the police department some on the take some not meanwhile shortly before christmas 2020 the police arrest mark liftman donkey boys in uh 27's boss who was involved in that bar fight all three of them arrested for the murder of brian waynstein they get bail and five days later two days after christmas donkeys at a funeral at a cemetery standing among the mourners at the graveside when a blue maza pulls up alongside and a man in it opens fire into the crowd he lives and i think this is actually seven attempts i think the one i said before was six so yeah seven attempts on his life now and i think this is actually seven attempts on his life now and i think this is actually seven attempts on his life now the 27's gang boss is not so lucky about a month later five weeks after his arrest for the waynstein killing out on bail a week before he's due back in court he shot dead in front of his house then in march another of the waynstein accused i believe there's 15 or 17 accused in all in the trial out on bail for three weeks he shot dead outside his house so what these guys i don't know like five for 50 at this point so yeah they must just be just hoods from the block i mean the clue i guess is that they're driving a mazda yeah in april 2021 the police finally arrest nafis modak i guess again for the murder of charles kinnear the police officer he also catches a whole slew of other charges a bunch of other murders uh like murder attempts extortion money laundering corruption on and on and on another dozen or so of his crew are arrested as well which reminds me i saw this um this like real yesterday where he was talking about like don't like don't be sad about your life like think about a guy who's arrested for attempted murder and spending 20 years in prison and he's like oh my god i'm gonna die i'm gonna die i'm gonna die i'm gonna die like he didn't even succeed he just completely failed and he's still spending 20 years in prison he did it the delivery was better but i thought it was kind of funny uh then in may the wayne city indictment finally lands 15 i guess the indictment hadn't landed the full indictment hadn't landed yet now it lands 15 accused including liftman donkey andre noddy and others do you know i was looking up there i was like i remember a very very very weird story that went around my school when i was a kid was that mazda i was like oh my god i'm gonna die i'm gonna die it was a swear word in japanese and i was looking at whether it was a swear word and it's not who would put why would you say that what a loser put that around the school we were kids there were rumors like that there were rumors about celebrities and all that there were rumors like that that just went around schools you know it wasn't like the internet where you just start a rumor easily but these things some of them just got picked up you know we don't have to go into details hey remember rumors what was that all about yeah that's a good bit just just too old people used to start rumor anyway uh remember conversations yeah throughout the next few years you have soldiers on both sides of the war taking plea deals getting double digit time the courts are active in october of 2022 another guy is charged in the winston murder conspiracy uh another guy charged in the winston murder conspiracy is killed so three now before this thing even goes to trial have been killed and remember the door racket the whole thing this was about in the first place here's what happens while everyone is shooting each other over it it grows and expands the global initiative against transnational organized crime a big organized crime think tank that mark shaw runs Does a study of Cape Town's extortion networks and finds that they are now everywhere, not just nightclubs, taxi stands, small corner shops, restaurants, like real mafia stuff, old school, you know, like produce stands back in the day. But more advanced too, because the Cape Town crime boss has realized something many, many organized crime groups around the world have realized in the past. The biggest company, the biggest business to extort and the easiest, the one with the most opportunity for bloated funds is the one with government money behind it. Public money, grant money, usually in construction projects, a housing project starts with government money, a contract and our men are going to show up and demand a percentage or a subcontract for their own companies. And if they don't get it, then the site gets shot up. It's a tried and true method for all organized crime when they realize things going like, you know, think about the Sopranos and construction sites. It's just what it is. In February of 2023, a 49-year-old woman, a city official is killed at a housing project in the flats because the city had refused to give the extortionist the work contract. The city cancels two contracts, the houses that were being built for poor people, they stop being built. Yeah, this is huge corruption and organized crime now. And that is Wendy Kloppers. She's a mother of two. And her death, I think, is the cold open for a piece that I did, a piece. And her death is the cold open for the episode that I did back in 2024. Yeah, really rough now. I mean, it's like, you can see what this show is doing a really good job of is showing how this world is just expanding and swelling, right? And just bringing so much of the economy in with it. By this point, everyone's in. Well, you know, it's been a good year, my man. Later that year, Ralph Stanfield, like we talked about, the head of the 28th and the firm, I think was the name of his gang on the outside, is arrested with his wife. A slew of charges, one involving a $55 million government contract. And like I said, that is way more than nightclub money or door money. The investigative outfit at the Mail and Guardian finds that the couple was working inside $160 million industrial development out near the airport through a company run by Stanfield's sister. And then this March finds them inside the rebuild of the central line, the train line across the flats with help from inside the passenger rail agency and reports that Stanfield's former right hand man who'd fallen out with him had been murdered. So this is. That's exactly what we talked about. Stanfield going from the streets and the street gangs into like the government, which is very impressive, to be honest with you, like a, you know, like a tattooed hooligan. Yeah, it's like from these like successful string of bell. Yeah, yeah, it really is. So that is the firm in 2023. It's not a Mandrax operation anymore. It's a construction company, specifically one that handles a whole lot of government projects from the head of a face tattooed prison gang to that. Like I said, solid jump. I feel like we used to talk about this a lot more, though, too, right? When gangsters. When gangsters graduate from the street, they just go into real estate or construction or government contracts. Kind of says a whole lot about where the real money is. In April of 2024, it's actually in AI. So I don't know if they've made those those jumps yet. Showing up at the door of Anthropics office being like, this is what your chat. This is what your chat is going to show now. Also, if you work at one of those companies, hire us like, well, we'll go. We'll work for you right now. Just give us equity. FanDuel is now available everywhere. In the U.S. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. A KFC tale in the pursuit of flavor. The colonel never wanted to be the reason customers finished a meal unsatisfied. So he created the $20 build a bucket meal with your choice of eight piece chicken or tenders, four sides and four biscuits. That way, if you weren't happy, he could say, don't blame me. You built it. Or more succinctly, you played yourself. The colonel lived so we could chicken. The $20 build a bucket. It's finger licking good. Prices and participation may vary. Taxes, tips and fees extra. Extra charge for breast piece substitution. I wrote a little song to remind you. Choice Hotels. Gets you more of the experiences you value. The Cambria Hotel's got it all. A rooftop bar, have a ball. Bring a date, your squad, or even your mom. Book direct at choicehotels.com. In April of 2024, the Weinstein trial opens in one courtroom. Modak's trial is running in the same building, and one paper describes the two camps exchanging death stares in the corridors. Liffin pleads not guilty to like nine counts. Donkey pleads not guilty to 11. And then in July, the police come for Donkey's brother, Colin. Colin, remember, is Modak's partner, and the brother of Jerome Boyson, Liffman's partner. So by the summer of 2024, the brothers who split because of a bar fight and essentially caused this gang war are both in the dock in different courtrooms for different murders from the same war. And then, that November 2024, Mark Liffman drives up to that golf town four hours east of Cape Town and finds himself in the Suburban Mall parking lot from the Cove Open, and he's shot five times and killed. The cops have on that. The two men from the polo, the 53-year-old and the former barman, both did work for the same Cape Town security company. A few days before the killing, one drew firearm permits through that company, valid right up to the day Liffman died. The two of them checked into a guest house outside George, that golf town, three days early. When the polo got stopped, the older man was driving, and one guy's fingerprint was on the freshly changed license plate. The police raid the security company's offices. They take all the guns away for testing. The company says the older man was just a contractor. He was a contractor who'd done some training work with them. Nobody has been charged with ordering it, and nobody has ever said in public why Mark Liffman died. But everybody says the same thing about how. Liffman's business took him to Johannesburg a lot, and in Johannesburg, he played paddle, padel. I always can't figure out how you say it, which, if you don't know, it's the sport rich people invented, so they wouldn't have to say pickleball or play pickleball. At a club in Santon, which is nearby, and he lunched at the fashionable spots, and he did all of it, always, always. With a bodyguard standing next to him. William Booth, his old lawyer, the one who this, you know, was also, I think they tried to shoot, quote, Mark took his personal safety extremely seriously. He was always surrounded by bodyguards. So one wonders why he was alone at the time. Donkey Boyson said it to a reporter that first week after the murder. He would never go alone. I am confused about why he had no bodyguards. It is a pretty interesting mystery, and one that seems like maybe some sort of, I mean, I'm throwing it out there, like speculating wildly. Like maybe the inside setup. I have no idea. Yeah, I mean, there's plenty of inside setup, so it would make sense. But I just need to take a time to stand up for Argentina, because first you're trying to get me to talk about the Falklands, and now Paddle's catching strays. I mean, what have you got against this country, man? Is Paddle an Argentinian thing? It's massive here. There's like actual courts in complexes on the sides of main streets. You can see the people playing. It's really cool, actually. And I'm about to play on Monday. It's very popular. It's very popular in the people who are doing well in New York, like finance and tech people. And I've thought about, I know people that got involved, and they took to it. You know how people start surfing, and they're just obsessed with it? I know people that have been on that with Paddle, and they also make insane connections through it, and have a good time. Yeah, I mean, it's the new, what do you call squash? Like racquetball, right? It's the same thing. I don't know. It looks fun. I mean, is it fun? Good exercise? It's fun. Maybe we should play. Yeah, it's great. It's expensive, though. Yo, in New York, it's expensive, though, dude. Oh, no. It's like five bucks. It's like five bucks an hour. Yeah, it's fine. Sponsor us. Paddle companies in New York, sponsor us. We'll start freaking doing great. That would be great, actually. Could I do a video where I'm playing some really shit, like moves? Yeah, I don't see why not. And they could sponsor me. Yeah. Do not see why not. What were we talking about again? Oh, yeah. Okay. So, South Africa, there's murders going on. Donkey goes to every hearing in George, in that golf town. That's about the murder of Liffman. He sits in the gallery with Andre Naughty, the other partner, and with his son, Joel, a few feet from the two men accused of killing their partner. And at one point, Donkey. He tells reporters he knew who was behind it, a rival boss in the security business. The company the two guys accused worked for put out a statement calling that factually incorrect. Liffman's death is like a watershed moment. He was notorious, right? Famous, a top player in organized crime. They actually call him the gentleman's gangster. One paper does. 12 arrests since 1999, zero convictions, and he dies with a 13th case open, which is the Weinstein murder. The Weinstein trial comes back a week later, and the man the prosecution had called accused number one. Had been taken off the indictment because he is Liffman and he was just shot and killed. So you really can't try a dead guy on a murder charge. In February of 2025, Modak takes a stand in his own trial and tells his version at the property auction in March of 2017. Liffman tries to buy two of Modak's own properties out from under him for less than their worth. They get into an argument and Liffman pulls a gun in his face. He then details how he took over the doors and then says that after the takeover, the head of detectives for the whole province. Kinnear's boss called him into his office in the middle of Cape Town and tells him to split the nightclub security 50-50 with Liffman. And then when Modak refuses, he says, you're either with us or against us. Again, but this is like a wanted gangster saying this stuff. So take it with a grain of salt. In June of 2025, Modak gets convicted, but only of corruption in a different court for bribing a cop back in 2011. He gets 10 years, three suspended. Less than a week later, Andre Naughty, the one of the leaders of the brotherhood, the man who controlled the second tier doors when Cyril Biko was around. Gets gunned down in broad daylight Thursday afternoon, standing on the sidewalk on the big commercial track to the northern suburbs. Next to his pickup, bodyguards around him. Charcoal BMW pulls up and the men inside open fire. Another major player in the Weinstein murder trial done in, I believe that is four. Donkey Boyson gets there while the crime scene tape is still going up. He stands behind it, shaking his head and tells a local reporter that he's shocked. A source in the underworld told the same paper, quote, they are falling like flies. Is Donkey wearing like a hot dog costume when he says this? It's nuts. Like, what is going on? I'm actually wrong. Now he's the fifth. So five of the men charged with arranging the murder of Brian Weinstein shot dead before a judge can even rule on whether they did it. Three before the trial started, two during it. So who exactly is doing it, killing out these men on trial? If you've been following along, the obvious guess would be Modak and his people, right? Modak, though, has been sitting in jail since 2021. Nobody's charged him with any of the five. Nothing is proven as of me writing this episode. Two men are in custody for Liffman. Nobody said who sent them. For Andre Naughty and two of the others, nobody's been arrested at all. But for one of the five, the state has an answer, and it's not Modak. In July of last year, the prosecutors filed an indictment against Ralph Stanfield and his gang, The Firm, which does make sense, right? Revenge for killing Weinstein, who was Stanfield's ally. The Firm also gets charged with a whole bunch of other killings, including other gangsters, an off-duty cop, that city housing official, all that sort of stuff, and trying to kill Donkey's son. Fifteen accused, 41 counts under the Organized Crime Act. The Firm operating out of four neighborhoods. On the flats with a hierarchy modeled on the 28th, with Ralph Stanfield on top of it. He's locked up in the infamous Polesmoor prison. And as I'm writing this, the trial, I believe, is about to open, or has already, as is Modak's. So just wild stuff is happening in the South African courts. Because again, you also have Weinstein's trial, or the murder of Weinstein's trial, which is ongoing. Okay. So let me just do a catch-up of the names. Hopefully you guys have kept up. Modak is in custody. No verdict. Prosecution closed its case November 2024. After 47 witnesses, Modak testified for 10 months. And this May, after months of delays, a defense witness pulling out and Modak firing his lawyers and asking for new ones, the judge did something you almost never see in order. Modak's defense closed. The trial is still going because there are 13 other accused. Colin Boyson and Ralph Stanfield both are locked up and awaiting trial. Meanwhile, in the brotherhood from the higher-ups, Donkey Boyson is really like the only last man standing, even with seven attempts on his life. The last man Cyril Bika visited, Liffman's partner, the state's alleged sexy boy's boss, is still accused number two in the Weinstein trial with a Mandak's drug lord's charge waiting behind it as well. But he is alive. Let me zoom out though again for one minute because Mark Shaw, the researcher I've mentioned a few times, who has also written a few books on South Africa's underworld, has started calling South Africa a mafia state because the violence has become the way you enforce control over the legal economy and the illegal economy at the same time. And the people are supposed to stop it are in on it. His organization keeps account of assassinations. 141 in South Africa in 2014. 122, 131 in 2023. And a hit cost by their research, anywhere from about 5,000 Rand, 300 bucks for a nobody to more than a million Rand for somebody like Liffman. And if you want to know how far up it goes, last July, a provincial police commander stood up in Johannesburg and said that the syndicate had captured parts of the police and the politicians who oversee them. And the president appointed a commission and it's still sitting. And one of its witnesses has already been shot dead outside his house. Even back in 2022, a headline in one of the newspapers said, quote, South Africa's organized crime climbs to Italy levels, racing past Mexico, Somalia, and Libya, 19th in the world, and found in the same sphere as Guatemala, Brazil, and Russia. If you want the real details on how this whole thing happened, read all of Karen Dolly's books. There are five of them and they trace it from every single angle. There you have it, folks. A lot of names, but hopefully you were able to keep up a journey through Cape Town's underworld. Yeah, no, no good times. No good times for South Africa. Pretty bad times, in fact. I mean, Mark Shaw's organization is cool, but I just found out from reading this script for the show that he does a podcast that is basically all of our episodes with a little less effort. And he even calls it Underworld, which is not as cool as Underworld. Really? Yeah. I mean, he's legit, but it's a little bit close to home, you know? Yeah. People don't need to copy us, man. We're not that. We're not that popular. He's pretty legit, though. Yeah, he is legit. He's not like some of these other crime posters, podcasters who are just, obviously, I'm not going to get into it. You guys know who I'm talking about. Did you just coin the term crime posters? Because that's quite good. That's pretty good, dude. That's really good. Crime posters is solid. So I think if people have made it through to the end of the show, I think they can have a bit of lore from you, right? You want some more lore? Yeah, let's have it. All right. We did. We did the Africa bike. We did the Africa bike trip already, right? Yeah. Yeah. And like the War Reporter stuff, you guys can just Google that. That's easy. So I got into journalism school in, I want to say, 2009, and I got a fellowship to go to CUNY, which is the public school here. Public school is different in America. The private school here costs like $70,000. So I've been saving up money, and I was still going to take off loans, but I get into the public school, and they give me a fellowship based on some work I had done. And so I have, like, I'm going to take the summer off, and I have money saved up. So I decide that, like, the kind of reporter I'm going to be, like, I need to know better how to defend myself. And I had backpacked in Southeast Asia before and gone to, like, a Muay Thai match. So I was like, I'm going to go to Thailand and, like, learn how to fight Muay Thai for, like, three months. And, like, I had, you know, not really done a lot of martial arts before. And this is back before. This was, like, a real thing that, like, there were tons. Like, nothing was, there were a couple places geared towards foreigners, but it wasn't like it is now where there's, like, a whole industry. And, like, everyone's on Instagram doing this sort of stuff. So I went to do a camp in, like, rural Phuket, Tiger Muay Thai, which I think is still around and one of the biggest. It's, like, 2008, 2009. And it was just, like, a lot of the other guys there were just, like, you know, Europeans who had warrants out that were like, I'm going to go to Thailand for a bit. Like, biker gang dudes with, like, you know, covered in, like, back tattoos of, like, their gravestones for all the people they'd lost. So I don't know. It was, so I spent 10 weeks, three months learning Muay Thai in Thailand. Okay. Did you fight? No, I mean, I sparred, but I never fought in, like, the ring. I was not good. Definitely not. I mean, I was good. Like, I did it every day. I stuck it out. And in Thailand, it's, like, two, three-hour sessions a day. I mean, I would do, I would only do one after a while. But, yeah, so I spent three months doing Muay Thai at a Thai Muay Thai camp in, like, 2009. Right before I went back to school. For journalism at CUNY. And if we get enough Patreon members, Danny will go back and fight in the ring. We gotta, if we get, I mean, if we get, how much money would we need to do, would I need to do this? I'm so old, though, now. If we get, um, I don't know. We'd have to get, like, like, 5,000. We'd have to have, like, a 10x. I was gonna say 5 grand. Like, an 8x. 5 grand. Not 5 grand. We'd have to have, like, an 8x increase for me to go do it. But, dude, I started, I went back, so I boxed for a while. I was in New York, too. And, again, terrible at it. But I went back to doing it, like, two months ago after, like, a seven-year break of just, you know, I was working out, but, like, seven years of not doing something physical and then also aging seven years into, like, your 40s and then starting to pick it up again. Yeah. It's just embarrassing, dude. It's, like, one of life's great small indignities. You're just in there being, like, I mean, I just don't move the same. And I'm not in bad shape. Like, and I'm pretty healthy. But, like, you just don't, your brain and your body just don't connect the way they used to. Like, it comes back a little bit. No, man. But not a lot, man. I was, like, what was I doing? I played last night and I thought I'll stay fit. I'll have, like, a soup before I play football. And I could feel the soup, man. It made me even slower. Why would you have soup? Who has, like, you have a hot soup before you play? Like, who does that before? I had a sopa azteca before I played football. Anchorman just drinking milk at, like, a marathon? What are you doing, dude? Yeah, it wasn't a good idea. Oh, no, you're like Michael Scott eating fettuccine alfredo before he does the fun run. Yeah, it was like that. It wasn't a pretty sight. I went to Bangkok once and I saw the Mai Tai. I have never seen a more sickening knockout. Like, I was basically ringside and a guy, you could hear his jaw coming off, basically. Dude. It was absolutely brutal. The guys who teach at that camp, at least back then, they were all, like, 21 years old and, like, the end of their careers, you know? Because they had, like, five or six years of experience. They had 500 fights and by the time you're 21, you're just so TTE'd out. Like, you can't, you know, clips in, like, their jaw, stuff like that. But the kids start fighting at, like, five. They'll have, like, 100 fights under their belt by the time they're 10 years old. It's wild, man. The poor kids in, like, Isan. Like, they really, they don't mess around. But it was, yeah, it was a weird time. I bought a camera. There's definitely tapes out there. I tried to do, like, a little mini documentary while I was, I should have stalked with it. Like, a little, because no one was doing that back then. I have, like, a DVX. Like, I was shooting on, like, tape. I have those tapes somewhere. Now you know what you're going to do for the Patreon. Yeah, I mean, you could. We could just become influencers. I could go out there and be like, what do you do? A four-year-old man decided to go become, I mean, I would get. I mean, some of the fighters, they would tell, like, because you could get, like, gambling on it's huge, right? So, with smoking cigarettes while you're watching the fight, it's awesome. But you could tell they knew, like, some guys would just get tomato cans, like some of the foreigners. You know, you'd go and they'd bet. And, like, none of the Thai guys taking bets would take bets on the Thai fighter, you know? But then other times. Yeah. You'd see, like, your friends would go fight and they'd be, like, serious. Like, they would take bets on the Thai fighter for sure. Um. man yeah it's a wild world man i see i see a film coming we could do a couple good more time the one with um ryan gosling uh that's a weird it's what's his name that director who i love but also does a lot of uh nick who did a pusher trilogy nicholas winding right for nicholas winding right oh yeah yeah which is like which was could have been a great he's stylistically amazing but that movie was trash or it was mediocre pusher trilogy is all incredible and then um there's the one about the prison fights uh based on a true story yeah with charlie hunnan is it charlie hunnan no it's not charlie hunnan it's uh it's a no-name uh guy who was like a not not a no-name guy but that movie's dope um that's a dark it's more about prison yeah it's a dope movie anyway uh that's a good lore we definitely increased the time period in this episode we've really people have the people who fall asleep are are really happy another 10 minutes of sleep without the d music waking them up yeah maybe i can like sing them out with one of the old uh one of the old gaucho songs i just had to fucking learn maybe patreon could just be lore like we're doing interviews with i'm supposed to interview uh the guy who did um what's his name billy billy corbin yeah uh next week and you're doing the bad movie thing maybe we just have lore talks like that will that will get us another we should literally 10 of our listeners should be on patreon and it's not that at all it's like two percent like one percent very disappointing guys what are you guys doing disappointing swear um should we end it there yeah anyway oh yeah it's enough it's enough we're all right all right thanks guys for listening if you've listened this long uh sorry sorry sorry commiserations yeah yeah all right stop it Thank you. Thank you. Fan Duel is now available everywhere in the U.S. So you can get in on the sports action no matter where you are. Including these places. Make this your most rewarding season ever with Fan Duel. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Choice Hotels. Get you more of what you value. Comfort Inn. It's calling your name. Save on the stain. Oh, and free waffles are yours to claim. Book direct at choicehotels.com.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The Cape Town underworld is characterized by a violent gang war over nightclub control, drug trafficking, and real estate, with criminal syndicates like the Brotherhood and the Numbers Gangs engaging in brutal conflicts.
  2. Key figures such as Mark Liffman, Jerome Donkey Boyson, and Nafiz Modak are central to the conflict, with multiple assassinations and failed hit attempts highlighting the instability and chaos.
  3. A deep-rooted corruption within South Africa’s police force enables organized crime, with internal theft, wiretapping, and protection rackets allowing criminals to operate with impunity.
  4. The criminal network has expanded beyond nightclubs into government contracts and construction projects, demonstrating a shift from street-level to institutional power and financial control.
  5. High-profile killings, including Liffman’s murder in 2024 and the deaths of multiple suspects before trial, suggest a state of internal civil war within the criminal and law enforcement systems.
  6. Investigations reveal that organized crime in South Africa has grown to global proportions, with violence levels rivaling those in Italy, Mexico, and Russia, and is now termed a "mafia state."
  7. The case of Ralph Stanfield and his "Firm" illustrates a transition from street gangster to government contractor, showing how criminal elites infiltrate and control state projects.
  8. Despite years of investigations and trials, no definitive convictions have been secured for key murders, and the lack of accountability underscores systemic failure in both law enforcement and justice.

Summary:

The podcast explores the deepening crisis in Cape Town’s organized crime, where gang wars over nightclubs, drugs, and real estate have spiraled into a violent, corrupt system. Central figures like Mark Liffman, Jerome Donkey Boyson, and Nafiz Modak are caught in a web of assassinations, failed hit attempts, and shifting alliances. A major factor is the systemic corruption within South Africa’s police force, where officers are accused of covering up crimes, selling weapons, and interfering in investigations.

The criminal networks have evolved beyond street-level violence, infiltrating government contracts and construction projects—showcasing a transition from petty crime to state-level exploitation. This expansion is evident in the killing of city official Wendy Kloppers and the arrest of figures like Ralph Stanfield, who linked street gang operations to large-scale government development. Despite numerous arrests and trials, there are no convictions for key murders, and several suspects—such as Donkey and Modak—remain unprosecuted or in custody.

The violence and corruption have created what the show describes as a "mafia state," where law enforcement and politicians are complicit. The narrative underscores a widespread pattern of impunity, with internal police conflicts, failed investigations, and the targeting of investigators like Charles Kinnear. As the conflict escalates, the lack of justice highlights a fundamental breakdown in South Africa’s criminal justice system, where power, money, and violence are deeply entrenched.

The episode concludes with a sobering reflection on how organized crime has become a structural force in the country’s economy and society.

FAQs

You can buy a car 100% online from Carvana and have it delivered to your door. The process is fully digital, with no need to visit a dealership.

Carvana offers a seven-day return policy, allowing customers to return the vehicle if it doesn't meet their expectations.

Yes, delivery fees may apply when purchasing a car from Carvana, depending on your location and the vehicle selected.

Mark Liffman, known as the 'gentleman gangster,' was a key figure in Cape Town's underworld. His murder sparked a wider investigation into organized crime and political corruption in South Africa.

Control of nightclubs is tied to control of the door security, which in turn determines who gets protection money and who is allowed to sell drugs, creating a network of power and violence.

The police are deeply involved, with evidence suggesting widespread corruption, internal divisions, and collusion with criminal groups, undermining their ability to enforce justice.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.