Following sweeping Democratic gains in the midterms, internal party tensions have intensified over leadership, with Chuck Schumer facing a challenge from progressive Chris Van Holland and Hakeem Jeffries confronting skepticism over his alignment with voter priorities. While Schumer maintains institutional support and fundraising power, many base voters credit their success to grassroots activism rather than top-down leadership, creating a rift between establishment figures and the party’s broader base. Van Holland’s rise is rooted in his advocacy for immigration rights and constitutional principles, positioning him as a symbol of progressive change. Critics argue that figures like Schumer and Jeffries represent a stagnant, middle-of-the-road approach that failed to deliver on promises during the campaign cycle. The debate reflects deeper ideological divides over how the party should govern—whether through incremental consensus-building or bold, transformative action. Progressive voices stress that leadership must be both accountable and aggressive, capable of standing up to the Republican administration and advancing systemic change. There is growing belief that the party’s future depends not on preserving traditional power structures, but on mobilizing the base with a clear vision, fighting for what truly matters, and rejecting the idea that compromise means settling for less. This moment calls for leadership that embodies both courage and integrity, capable of transforming the Democratic Party into a force for equity and accountability.
On Monday of last week, we here at today explained from Vox, brought you a show titled Impeach Hegseth. And then on Tuesday of last week, the United States House of Representatives held a preliminary vote on doing just that, but it didn't go anywhere because 11 Democrats just didn't bother to show up. That had a lot of people scratching their heads because for months, Democrats have been arguing that Hegseth is unfit for his job and should be removed from office. So of course, people started to conspire to question the Democrats' motives and to question the party's leadership one week out of sweeping wins in the midterms. By Thursday, Chuck Schumer had a challenger. At a conference on Friday, Hakim Jeffries was getting called out by protesters. And Democrats are fighting, and as you'll soon hear argued on the show today, maybe they should be. Hi, I'm Guy Roz. On how I built this, I sit down with the people behind some of the world's most recognizable brands, like Nvidia and Starbucks and Raising Canes, to find out how they actually built them. Think of it as a free MBA, told through deeply personal stories about taking risks, making mistakes, and building something great. I'm Guy Roz, listen to and follow how I built this wherever you get your podcasts. Hey everybody, it's Sue Bird. The WNBA season may officially be over, but there's still plenty of basketball to discuss. This week on Bird's I View, we're launching a special series dedicated to 30 years of the league. Take things off, I've got WNBA OG and Hall of Famer Rebecca Lobo. She talks about what drew her to the WNBA, playing in the league's inaugural game, her dream starting five, and the rise of the W's first dynasty. Check out this week's Bird's I View on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts. Donald Trump's first 100 days can be defined by one big F word. The day explained. Instead herndon hosts America, actually at Vox, and he's here to tell us about challenges to democratic leadership ahead of their return to power in the new year. Now I would say that the challenge for Chuck Schumer's may be a little higher than Hakeem Jeffries. The speaker of the house is a famously difficult job. Republicans had a hard time finding somebody who wants it. Hakeem Jeffries has been groomed for this position by Nancy Pelosi for a long time. He obviously will be a history maker as the first black speaker of the house. So there's a lot of factors here that I think make Jeffries roared to securing that leadership spot a little easier on the Chuck Schumer front. You know, there's been vocals in the candidates, folks like Abdul al-Sahead, who make clear that they won the new direction of the party. This is a moment where we need to pivot from the past into the future. Now you've got this crop of freshman senators that hail from different parts of the country, we didn't know would elect a Democratic senator. And almost all of us came in saying that we needed to take a fresh approach and new approach to governing. You didn't even have people like Mississippi Scott Cologne who necessarily wouldn't maybe wouldn't fall in that progressive wing, but I said he worries about how much of democratic leadership comes from just New York. It is not a good thing that our national democratic party has two leaders. Now the majority leaders, they'll be so that they both live in the same borough. I know you're talking about the same city, the same borough in the same city. That's not a good sign. This was a thing that we heard across a lot of Senate candidates, letting the other challenge for a Schumer, it's just age, you know, like I think he is a physical representation of a geriatric establishment. And so it makes him, I think, an easier sort of target for folks. And so you have the challenge emerging for him in a much clearer way. This seems pretty confident that he's got this vote locked down, but now he's got a challenger in Chris Van Holland. Tell us about the challenge. Well Chris Van Holland is someone who I think has really stood out over the last couple years. Now, this is someone who was more vocal, even about supporting Palestinian rights, but even more so than that, he was someone who really made a name for himself when he stood up for his constituent who was wrongfully targeted for deportation. This case is about upholding constitutional rights for Obrego Garcia and for every American. And particularly at a time when the Democratic caucus was kind of a little scared about pushing back against Trump in early 2025, there was a little bit of a sense that immigration was not something that the Democrats wanted to really get in a tussle with Trump on. And Van Holland really stood against that. He met with Camara Obrego Garcia and it really stood out. There's never a wrong time to stand up for the Constitution of the United States and do process. And I think Americans of all political persuasions really don't like people who put their finger to the wind and try and decide what to do. And then doing that, I think it really shows the type of fight that some versions of Democrats really want right now. And so he's become someone who, although certainly himself, an older member of the Democratic establishment, he becomes his represent a different type of politics. And so progressives have started to lean in to his challenge as someone who can take the party in a different sort of direction. So he's secured a couple early endorsements just after recently announcing Abdul-El-Sahed has said he would endorse Van Holland, you have that also true of Peggy Flanagan, another progressive who will be coming into the Senate from the state of Minnesota. I believe Chris Van Holland is the leader and fighter we need to bring about real change, so no American is left behind. It's still unclear whether Van Holland has enough to sustain a meaningful challenge to Schumer. Schumer has a lot that institutional backing. You've heard even people like Ruben Gaigo or Tammy Baldwin. I heard you use these kind of sports analogies saying, "When the manager takes you to the world series, you give them another contract." Talking about the Democrats' big wins, but I think the real question is, are those wins Schumer's to own, you know? And I think that's really what's at the heart of this dispute. It's kind of funny that to challenge an establishment leadership figure like Chuck Schumer 75 years of age, you go with Chris Van Holland, 67 years of age like the new mud is beyond retirement age. You know, I think it is important to point out, but these were talking about establishment positions, right? These are fights that are mostly about pulling those access inside of levers in Washington, wrangling votes, securing fundraising, setting legislative priorities. Like you don't get that without knowing how the place works. And so in some ways, I think this represents a kind of pragmatic understanding from the left that you can't fully blow up the functions of DC. Like I think it represents how desperate some people are for a different type of politics, or for a different type of leadership. And so they're willing to make some concessions if they feel like that gets them closer to that. So when in the party associated with the party, you know, just voters at home watching this happen, saying, hey, maybe it's not a good look to have like an intra party fight. The second we win back a bunch of power, a lot of people are saying that. I mean, I'm currently at the what's next conference in Denver, which is a convening of a lot of what I would call maybe more center moderate Democrats. Put it on by majority Democrats, a group that is trying to take a lot of credit for some of the big wins we saw from the party. And that's mainly their point is that this isn't the time for kind of factional fighting more so than it is for looking ahead. Now I don't know if the voters are on that front too, though, because for the reason these people were successful was for the mere promise of pushing back and getting their own party. So I think that there are kind of, you know, DC camps on this front. But I don't think we should put that on to a voting base democratic base once action. And I think has called out for a type of congressional leadership that will more frontally oppose Republicans, right? Like the when we go low, they go high era is over like, you know, like they're looking to get in the mud. I assume the Schumer's big wins that he helped orchestrate in the Senate, bought him some goodwill in the Senate. But does that translate to the base is the base looking at taloriko and and everything else, Mississippi, South Carolina, whatever, Kansas and saying, Oh, yeah, Schumer. Schumer did that. Yeah, no, I think that's an important distinction like, you know, uh, did Schumer recover? I'm laughing at the question because it feels absurd. Yeah, I'm like, I don't think some of the people think, you know, I think they think they did it. They think democratic voters did it, right? Like they don't think that top down party leadership did it. I think that's fair reason for that. Certainly Schumer raised money, recruited, particularly candidates in those battleground states. But yeah, some big misfires in this last couple years too. Uh, Schumer was big on Janet Mills, the candidate in Maine, who did not take off at all, opened up space for Grand Platon and eventually Troy Jackson. Of course, Schumer was all in on Haley Stevens and Michigan, who ends up endorsing the Republican the day. Well, two days before the election, we all want Democrats to win. I'm a really proud Democrat. So I think there were high profile moments that really signal to people that this wasn't a Washington top down.
success. At the same time, you know, there was a lot of money raised. There was a lot of way that I think you can say someone like a King Jeffries led Democrats in a shutdown that elevated the issue of health care. Like that was important for the party. So I think that, you know, you can certainly point to things that have bought them some goodwill, particularly in DC. But I don't think that's how folks are think though, like, you know, like who is to get the credit for democratic successes? I think if you ask your kind of base, Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries would not be in the top five. And this tension between, you know, where the people want the party to go and where people like Schumer establishment figures are, I feel like it manifests itself in no better case than his lack of an endorsement for Zora on Mamdani, which people still seem to hold against him. And as Mamdani seems to become even more of a kingmaker and even more of a, you know, prominent figure in the Democratic Party, like it suggests that even if Schumer wins this leadership fight, that this tension isn't going away for him. Oh, absolutely. I was there, you know, I was on the trail with Mamdani last summer. And I think both Schumer and Jeffries may very clear that they stood in opposition to a democratic nominee that had widespread base support. And I think as even Mamdani's governance has justified some of that. I mean, I should say Jeffries got there in the end or things like that. But I'm like, but as Mamdani has followed through on some of that in office, I think it's only become more clear where the red lines for some of these members of the party are. Now, you know, I mean, I think this kind of can be a little delicate, but a lot of that role for congressional leadership is about fundraising. It's about donors is about making sure the party has relationship with the type of people who write them big checks. And the priorities of those people are different than the priorities among the base. So their priorities on AI, on crypto, on Israel are different than where the base is. And so I think that lives in some of the tension between these figures. And I think it played out in Mamdani because his politics were so transparent. And I think openly progressive. I think a lot of people have a lot of ego in their face from the Zoran race, particularly an establishment that tried to sell him as a scary figure. Those type of choices do linger in folks imagination. And I think particularly when they stood in opposition to a mayor that has now nationally recognized his transformative. That was a stead who reports on the Democrats, but when today explained is back, we're going to hear the perspective of a big deal Democratic operative. Support for today's point comes from built. Here's a question. Are you getting rewarded for paying your rent or mortgage if the answer is no, you might want to check out built becoming a built member means earning points on your housing payments no matter where you live. Built points can be redeemed for flights hotels. Liftridesamazon.com purchases future housing payments so much more. An unexpected benefit built gives every member is access to its agentic neighborhood concierge in the built app. It doesn't just give you information about your home and neighborhood it executes. You can ask it to pay your rent, make it dinner reservation, book a fitness class, schedule a lift, so much more. Just download the built app, link any credit or debit card to that app so purchases at your local spots become even more rewarding and ask the neighborhood concierge in the app pretty much anything. For the homeowners out there, built works for mortgages too. Download the built app and join the membership for where you live at joinbuilt.com/explain. That's j-o-i-n-b-i-l-t.com/explain. Use our link so they know we sent you. Support for today comes from Shopify. If you've been waiting for a sign or maybe a sound to start your business, consider the odds that you turn on a podcast and hear me talking about you starting your business. Wow, depending on how many podcasts you listen to, of course, maybe the odds are actually pretty high. However, I digress. In any case, Shopify can help you make it happen. Shopify's pre-built website themes and AI site builder make it easy to launch a beautiful, professional looking store without ever touching a line of code. Shopify's mobile app lets you run your store from anywhere, from tracking inventory to customer support to handling payments and more. Launch before Black Friday at the time of year when more people are already shopping and ready to buy. If you're ready to launch your business before Black Friday, go to Shopify.com/explain to start your free trial at Shopify.com/explain. Go to Shopify.com/explain. Today, to hear your first tier, it comes. Support for the show comes from hymns. Let's get into it. Intimacy is best when you can be present. hymns makes it simple to access personalized treatment plans. So in intimate moments, you can actually be in the moment. hymns combines personalized treatment plans and a hundred percent online, like your boyfriend, process. There are no office visits. You don't have to wait in a pharmacy line and you don't have to worry about any awkward conversations. Hate those. You just connect with a licensed provider who can determine if treatment is right for you. Not everyone needs the same thing, which is why hymns works with you to find the best option for you. Ready to build a better sex life? Visit hymns.com/explain for a personalized plan for sex, hair, weight loss and more. That's h-i-m-s.com/explain. Prescription products require an online consultation with a licensed healthcare provider who will determine if a prescription is appropriate restrictions apply individual results may vary based on a survey of hymns customers. See hymns.com for full details. Thank you. I am once again asking for your today explained. Corbin Trent, I'm the executive director of a fight worth having, which is a super PAC that's been started this year to get involved in races, but get involved also in the way people think about solutions and co-founder of Justice Democrats, communications director for AOC and the House and on our campaign for a couple of years, two-ton Bernie staffer, general contractor, chef, you know, you take your pick. I love it. So needless to say, when people talk about like democratic party insiders, like, you qualify. Yeah, I suppose so. So let me ask you as such an insider, who do you think should be leading Democrats in the house and set it in the new year? I think this moment calls for some sort of leadership that shows that we have a plan, an agenda, and a vision that's capable of taking on and meeting this moment. And I just, it's not Hakeem Jeffries. It's not Chuck Schumer. It's just, you know, sorry, folks. I know that, you know, that's the way we do things in the house, that's the way we do things in the Senate. But look at the popularity of both of those institutions and then think to yourself, maybe we should do things a little differently. Now, I would posit that the average American people who voted in these midterms and delivered the Democrats such sweeping wins don't think very much about leadership challenges and who's going to be majority leader and all that kind of thing. Why not for those listeners, for those voters, why not Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer? Well, Hakeem Jeffries has proven either one of two things. Either he's incapable of wrangling the caucus or his priorities are very different than the Democratic party in the independent voters that voted for the Democrats in this election. And what I mean by that is we've had three shots at stripping war powers away from Donald Trump, vis-a-vis Iran. And oh, lo and behold, one, two, three Democrats defected. He is not supporting an arms embargo to Israel. You know, he's not supporting whether or not we need to understand if that was there when deed war crimes were committed and who did it? He's not a guy who is representing the will of the people writ large. He's not, you know, he is very much the establishment Democrat that I think led to Donald Trump being elected twice. So there's one reason, one series of reasons and there's many, many more. Chuck Schumer is a man with a strongly worded letter in his back pocket. He's a man that wants to pick up a couple of voters in rural Pennsylvania that are Republicans and neither of them have a vision for building a Democratic supermajority that is a kin to the one that was built around the New Deal. And I think that this moment is very similar to that moment in that it is rife with opportunity. People are hopeful. People are ready for change, but the problem with hope is that when it's dashed, it calcifies and it becomes resentment and anger. And Democrats seem to miss that every time over and over and over and over. Like I can remember how inspired I was by Barack Obama during his first presidential campaign. So inspired that I got involved in politics had never been. I started, I went to an event in Asheville to watch him speak. I started raising money for him on his portal and like, you know, I had a watch party. I mean, you know, like, that's not what I did. Let me tell you, I was not my thing. But he inspired me to do all this stuff. And then several months later, what I'm hearing is a very different thing as a president than as a candidate. So we can't keep missing these opportunities in my mind. So Democrats,
Democrats have seen this, this cycle that you're describing, play out again and again, Democrats, elected Democrats and Democratic voters, independent voters, whatever it might be. Why do Jeffries and Schumer seem so confident in this moment? I mean, Schumer has a challenger, Chris Van Hollen, Hakim kind of has one in Ayanna Presley, but they don't seem very worried that their position might be in jeopardy right now. How come? Well, because it's just not the way things are done in the house and they, I think, have faith that things will continue being done the way they are, you know, momentum, norms, all of these things point to them not having any real problem getting, getting their leadership taken away. But, you know, Joe Crowley also felt that way. And then famously, AOC spanked his little bottom in 2018 and now he's a consultant instead of a congressman. Now we'd be having a very different conversation because he was the one that was in line to be the next speaker of the house. AOC, who I think, you know, you helped get her campaign together. She's back in Jeffries. How come? What's your reaction to that? I mean, I don't, she back in Jeffries. She's doing this weird little thread in the needle. He's the only one. What can we do? You know, I think that's, but that's the exact kind of thinking that you're saying Democrats should, should rebuff. Absolutely. They should. I mean, you know, and interestingly, the most important thing to learn from Nancy Pelosi in my mind and I'm putting this in my full page ad that runs on the hill on Tuesday is that power is not given. It is taken power is not something that people give you. It is something that you take and then utilize. And the fact is that CPC's got 99 members and going to have more. The fact is is that these members have the capacity to generate more media than most. And they can either take this moment to build power for the American people that ends up building a supermajoritarian democratic party, one that can make the Republican party small enough to drown in bathtub or they can try to do business as usual. Work with our came work with Schumer, try to extract some concessions of which they will not give because like you say, they have no fear. They do not fear these people. They respond to threats and fear, fear of losing their job. Let me be clear what that is. Help us understand why someone like AOC doesn't want this job. I mean, she's one of the most visible Democrats in the country and surely she'd be a popular candidate, right? I can't explain why people do what they do. Even I can't explain why I do what I do, let alone other people. It's not, I mean, it doesn't sound like a fun job. I'm not running for it. You know, I can understand not wanting it. There is a lot of downside, potential downside. You know, you're going to get higher because you've got to either deliver, which is going to be very difficult with Donald Trump still in the White House or you've got to be really good at working to show that you're attempting to deliver something big and you're being blocked and by whom. And the problem is a lot of people that are going to be standing in your way are going to be Democratic representatives and Democratic senators because the thing that I have come to understand is that there is a team of people that want to make this country fundamentally different, fundamentally more fair. Look at the healthcare system that we have and fundamentally rethink it. Look at the economy we have with AI and robotics, burgeoning and changing of that and fundamentally rethink it. But that team right now isn't very big and it's not like, oh, all Democrats are on board with this vision. It's a, they're not. I mean, you pointed something that I think is relevant here, which is that this job of, you know, Speaker of the House, Senate Majority Leader, it isn't a walk in the park. It takes a certain type, perhaps. Maybe it takes a consensus builder. We had Rahman Manual on the show after the midterms and he said that Hakim Jeffries was that. Do you think it takes someone in the middle of all of this to suss out where the caucuses and that's why maybe we're not getting the most exciting people, but we're getting people who've been around for a while. Well, according to Don Leonard, there's a different tack that this particular group of leadership uses to bring consensus, and it's not the hand holding middle of the road consensus building. It's threats, threats of making your life a living hell for two years, threats of not getting any committee assignments, threats of not getting gavils. I actually think that you talk softly and carry a big stick works too. But the problem is, is these people are carrying a big stick, talking goofy, and then the big stick is to get people to basically, I mean, like ultimately this gave us Romneycare, this kind of middle of the road nonsense gave us something to got rebranded as Obamacare and it has not slowed down the increase of our costs. It has not, you know, it saved lives. And here's the problem with that. I was actually thinking about this yesterday. You had a, you had a Democratic caucus with 59 or 60 votes in the Senate and a majority in the House, and you had Barack Obama in there on a wave election of change. People like me got in there. And what the reasonable people were able to tell you as a new member or as a member that wanted to say a public option or something else is that this 50, 60,000 people of your die from lack of health care, this can save four to 5,000 of those lives. Are you willing to let four or 5,000 people of your die just to stand and fight for this other thing that will save the whole 50? I mean, because that's ultimately when you're put in these positions, you're given these choices. And the choice is fight for the thing that can actually do the most good, right? Build power towards that thing and then at least make your compromise better, like the compromise should have been the public option. But that means you got to fight for something bigger. You don't have names per se and maybe the party. I don't. I think I don't have press Lee and Van Holland. That's where I'll go right now. Van Holland not exactly a bastion of progressivism, but you think you could do the job. I think he could do the job and I think part of the thing here that's just as important as getting a speaker that's better or a leader that's better is beating those people, flexing the power of the people, right? I don't, you know, I'm not going to let the perfect be the enemy of the good here. I'm going to let good be the enemy of bad, you know, and I think that's where we're at right here. I mean, Van Holland, you know, like my politics are definitely to the left of Van Holland or whatever you, whatever spectrum you want to look at that on there. But I think the fight in of itself is worth it. And then certainly winning is worth it. Horbin Trent is a co-founder of Justice Democrats. He was a communications director for AOC and a two-time Bernie Stafford. You know, you take your pick. Daniel Hewitt produced Joey Mayer's edit in Gabriel Donatov, fact check, Bridger Dunnigan and David Tatashore mixed. I'm Sean Ramos-Verm, and this is today explained. [MUSIC]
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Democrats faced internal division over leadership after sweeping midterm wins, with Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries both confronting challenges from within their ranks.
Chris Van Holland has emerged as a prominent progressive challenger to Schumer, gaining early endorsements for his stand on immigration and constitutional rights.
The Democratic base increasingly views party success as grassroots-driven, not top-down, questioning whether establishment leaders like Schumer deserve credit for victories.
Critics argue that Schumer and Jeffries represent entrenched, establishment politics disconnected from voter priorities, especially on issues like war powers and healthcare.
Progressive leaders like Van Holland and Zora Mamdani signal a desire for bold, principled leadership that challenges the status quo and pushes for transformative policy.
The leadership contest reflects a broader tension between institutional power, fundraising networks, and the values of the democratic base.
Historical parallels, such as Obama’s early promise vs. later reality, warn that hope and change can be lost if Democrats fail to act decisively.
The speaker of the House position is seen not just as a title, but as a tool to build power, unify the party, and confront Republican dominance with clear, actionable agendas.
Summary:
Following sweeping Democratic gains in the midterms, internal party tensions have intensified over leadership, with Chuck Schumer facing a challenge from progressive Chris Van Holland and Hakeem Jeffries confronting skepticism over his alignment with voter priorities. While Schumer maintains institutional support and fundraising power, many base voters credit their success to grassroots activism rather than top-down leadership, creating a rift between establishment figures and the party’s broader base. Van Holland’s rise is rooted in his advocacy for immigration rights and constitutional principles, positioning him as a symbol of progressive change.
Critics argue that figures like Schumer and Jeffries represent a stagnant, middle-of-the-road approach that failed to deliver on promises during the campaign cycle. The debate reflects deeper ideological divides over how the party should govern—whether through incremental consensus-building or bold, transformative action. Progressive voices stress that leadership must be both accountable and aggressive, capable of standing up to the Republican administration and advancing systemic change.
There is growing belief that the party’s future depends not on preserving traditional power structures, but on mobilizing the base with a clear vision, fighting for what truly matters, and rejecting the idea that compromise means settling for less. This moment calls for leadership that embodies both courage and integrity, capable of transforming the Democratic Party into a force for equity and accountability.
FAQs
Democrats are facing internal divisions over leadership direction, with challengers like Chris Van Holland advocating for a more progressive, constituent-focused approach that contrasts with Schumer's establishment style and priorities.
Van Holland has gained attention for standing up for constitutional rights, especially in defending a constituent wrongly targeted for deportation, and represents a more progressive, grassroots-oriented alternative to Schumer's leadership.
The debate reflects a growing tension between establishment leadership and a desire for change, with younger, progressive members pushing for a more active, forward-facing agenda to oppose Republicans and represent the public's will.
Voters largely believe the wins were due to their own choices to support the party, not top-down leadership, suggesting that leadership figures like Schumer and Jeffries are not seen as central to the party’s success.
Jeffries, as a first Black Speaker, has strong symbolic and political significance, and his leadership is seen as more aligned with progressive values, though he still faces challenges in uniting the caucus.
Leadership positions are tied to access to power, fundraising, and institutional influence, which often favor establishment figures over those with grassroots or progressive agendas, creating friction within the party.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.