Should Everyone Get a Prenup?

Hey everyone, it's Jess. Before we start, I wanted you all to know this is going to be my last week on the show for a while. I'm going on maternity leave. I'll be back early next year, but in the meantime, you'll be in good hands with my colleague Imani Moise, who'll be co-hosting the show with Ryan while I'm gone. Now, here's today's episode. So, I am a millennial, and a woman, which means that one important reference for me when it comes to all things love and marriage is sex in the city. What? Okay, this is a little unusual. He has you on a vesting schedule. And that includes prenuptial agreements, or prenups. There's one episode in which Charlotte is about to marry Trey, who's very wealthy. When he hands her a prenup before the wedding, she gets her lawyer friend Miranda to look over the contract, which lays out what would happen if Charlotte and Trey got divorced. For every five years that you're married, you get a percentage of $500,000. I'm only worth $500,000? Over 30 years. Well, maybe that's your wholesale price. And then, this year, there was the hit divorce memoir, Strangers, by Belle Burden. Burden stopped working to raise the kids. I really handed over my financial life to my husband because it felt. That's Burden on the Drew Barrymore Show, advising more women to have that conversation. Because when her husband abruptly left after 20 years of marriage, she was surprised at how little money she was entitled to in her prenup. To have that conversation with your partner, like, if this ended, what would happen to me? I really kind of got very comfortable in not knowing and put you in a terrible position. It did. I was really at risk of losing my financial security. These scenes, reinforce something a lot of us may think about prenups. That they're mostly for the ultra-wealthy, very rich people who want to protect their assets. But these days, prenups are changing. They're getting more popular, and they aren't just for the super-rich anymore. A 2023 survey showed that one in five adults who were either married or engaged had a prenup. And Gen Z and millennials are more likely to have one. They're more likely to have a prenup. Culturally, prenups are becoming something that's seen more of an empowerment tool rather than a stigmatized contract that kind of jinxes your marriage. Our colleague Erin Mulvaney has been reporting on prenups. It's definitely changed to be more of a financial planning tool for the middle class. And that's definitely a change that's been happening in the last few years. Welcome to The Journal. We're a show about money, business, and power. I'm Jessica Mendoza. It's Friday, September 18th. Coming up on the show, the prenup gets a modern makeover. This episode is presented by Intuit Credit Karma. Relaxation doesn't always look like spa day. It's when those pesky tasks you don't have time for, like hunting down your credit card perks, are handled for you. Like how Card Optimizer from Intuit Credit Karma brings your card details together in one simple place. So tracking rewards and redeeming benefits is actually easy. You deserve less, ugh, and more, ah, Intuit Credit Karma. Download the app to get started. This episode is brought to you by Indeed. The right hire can make or break your company, especially if you're a salesperson. And relying on luck to find that person isn't really the best strategy. But you know what it is? Using Indeed's sponsored jobs. You can use it to boost your job post to make sure it reaches more people with the right talents, certification, location, and more. Sponsored jobs posted directly on Indeed are 95% more likely to report a hire than non-sponsored jobs. Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Less stress, less time, more results. When you need the right person to cut through the chaos, this is a job for Indeed's sponsored jobs. And listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit to help get your job the premium status it deserves at Indeed.com slash podcast. Just go to Indeed.com slash podcast right now and support the show by saying you heard about Indeed here. Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed's sponsored jobs. It isn't romance. But marriage is a contract. So even if you don't get an official prenup, there are still laws that would apply if you get a divorce. In a way, whichever state you're in kind of is your prenup if you don't have one. In that case, the state decides how your assets get split up. So it kind of depends. Roughly, a judge or the couple themselves will do an equitable distribution of assets. Some states are more purely 50-50. And the court will basically kind of decide what's fair. Fair at the end of a marriage, given whatever the circumstances are. And that's largely will be kind of out of the couple's hands. Now, more and more couples are looking to change that and considering getting prenups. There's just a growing awareness about prenups just because there's TikToks, Instagram. Are prenups really that offensive or do we just not know what they are? Let me tell you a reason. Why you should get a prenup, even when you have nothing. No assets, no money. One of my non-negotiables before getting married is getting a prenup. Erin came across influencers giving advice under hashtags like prenup talk and quippy taglines like protect your peace, protect your bag, or romanticizing financial transparency. I think that that has definitely helped the messaging of what a prenup is. What has led? To the recent popularity of prenups, do you think? Yeah, a few things. One, it's the people who are younger and getting these are kind of millennial, Gen Z, who a lot of them had gone through situations where their parents got divorced and saw the other end of it. They saw what happened and they didn't want that to happen to them. In another way, people are getting married a little bit later in life and they might come into. They're married with either already having established careers or businesses or even student loans. So maybe the other spouse wouldn't necessarily have to be responsible for that. It's also easier than ever to get a prenup, with many templates online that help you start the process without lawyers. There's one big trend in recent prenups that Erin says has changed the way a lot of people talk about them. It's a clause that protects a partner who leaves the workforce to take care of the kids. Some couples are putting clauses in their prenups that are helping shift the balance of power to make it less reactive and defensive and more proactively looking at answers to questions about what will happen in the future. You'll say, okay, in the event that one of us does stay home and raise the kids, what will that look like? Imagine that a person gives up their career, say, a career as a lawyer or a teacher or anything, and to raise children. You might get half of the money, but what you've given up is a job that gives you career seniority, 401k in your name that has been building interest, annual raises. And so when you're going back and you're kind of on your own, you're really starting from square one. You know, you'll get alimony potentially, but that doesn't last forever, typically. So you're just in a situation where there's a compounding factor of giving up your career, basically. The idea is that the spouse who stopped working to care for children would eventually have to go back to the workforce once the divorce is finalized. But that doesn't seem to account for the, as you said, economic disadvantage of having missed years of work, and there isn't necessarily compensation for that loss. Right. There's a lot of sad stories about people who, you know, built up their life, you know, and then they kind of feel like they have to start from scratch. Depending on how the terms are set up, the spouse who stays at home could have a trust set aside in their name in the event of a divorce, or they could get a lump sum, or a kind of alimony that reflects their previous salary. And data shows this mostly affects women. In 2025, 68% of mothers with children under six participated in a divorce. compared with 95% of fathers, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Divorce lawyers Aaron spoke with said these trigger clauses are increasingly popular, and they're part of a shift in how prenups are viewed and used. Did it surprise you to learn about this clause? Like, does it kind of flip the idea of a prenup on its head a little bit? Yeah, because I think that when you first imagine a prenup, it's more about protecting money and thinking, like, this is mine. This is mine. I earned this, so I'm going to leave with it versus acknowledging whatever you build during a marriage really is both of yours from the outset. But taking that extra step of ensuring that that's recognized for someone who actually isn't earning money and bringing it into the marriage. After the break, I get a peek into the modern day prenup conversation by sitting down with a couple who signed one last year. This episode is brought to you by Workday. Guessing is for game shows, not your business, especially when your margin for error is zero. Workday is the enterprise AI platform for everything. HR, finance, and IT with a deep understanding of your organization's context and guardrails. So every AI action is permission aware, giving you accuracy 24-7 and the ability to not just get work done, but get it done right. It's a new Workday. In the race to reach customers. Ready, set, go. Shortcodes always win. Because customers open text messages from shortcodes 98%. 88% of the time. Go shortcodes. That's why banks, airlines, hospitals, and other major businesses trust shortcodes. And it's shortcodes by a mile. Lease a shortcode today at usshortcodes.com slash podcast. Anna Morgenstern and Zachary Spice are a New York City couple in their 40s. And they signed a prenup before they got married last June. And now tell me a little bit about how you two met. Can we hear your love story? Every time I say it, he gets mad at me, so I'll let him do this one. You guys haven't sorted out how the story is told yet? I always tell stories with a little bit more flair and drama, and he doesn't like that. So I'll let you start, and I'll fill in the gaps. Perfect. So the story is. I. Decided to sell my Coachella ticket. And Anna was the buyer. Ten years ago. Ten years ago. And met Anna at a coffee shop. But how did we connect? It's like a test. I don't remember. You don't remember the website that we used? No. He hates it that I responded to his Craigslist ad. He's like, I've purposely forgotten. I erased that memory completely. Completely. So you answered the ad? I answered his ad. He was the only one that wanted to sell the ticket to me at face value. So yeah, I picked him. And we became Facebook friends before meeting to make sure that we were normal. And I remember thinking, like, oh, he's a cute Jewish guy. And then we met in person. He had zero interest in me. Didn't even look at me. He was like, here's your bracelet. Where's the cash? Thank you very much. Have a good time. And that was, I was like, oh, okay. I guess he didn't like me. After that first meeting, Zach went back to his career in art and real estate. And Anna started a matchmaking business. Eight years later, she was scrolling through a dating app, something she often did for herself and her clients. And she came across a familiar face she couldn't quite place. She sent him a like. I was like, did I set you up before? He said no. And then he called me. And in my phone, it said Zach Ticket. And I was like, oh, my gosh, there's a Coachella guy. The Coachella guy. And, yeah, we started dating after that first date, basically. Anna and Zach were engaged just months later. But in the days leading up to the engagement, Anna went on a podcast as a dating expert. And she was asked if she would ever get a prenup. It never even crossed my mind that someone like me would need a prenup or even would consider a prenup. Because, like a lot of people, Anna thought prenups were just for the ultra-wealthy. You know, I think that stereotype is just so embedded in us. In so many different TV shows or movies or stories that we hear on the news. Zach, what went through your mind when Anna brought it up? I was just a little surprised, I guess. And brought back some dark memories. The thing is, Zach had been engaged before. And he feels that that engagement had ended partly because of the conversations that came up around a prenup. I had a lawyer. My ex had a lawyer. And it was just like a battle. And we ended up calling off the wedding. So when Anna came to Zach with the idea of a prenup, it took him a second to warm up to it. I guess, you know, the more I thought about it and learning more about it, it just made more sense to me. Yeah, for us, we didn't have, like, assets we wanted to protect or family business. You know, we were kind of coming into a relationship in more equal footing. You know, we agreed coming into the marriage with separate properties. You know, we keep what we had previously in terms of our businesses that will remain ours. You know, neither of us will have a claim to it. Anna and Zach used an online software for their prenup, which provided them a list of questions to discuss with each other. All without lawyers present in the room. The questionnaire brought up things like, And honestly, I'm so glad we did because there's so many things we talked about through the prenup questionnaire that never even occurred to me to talk to him about. And, you know, and some of those questions, they could cause serious arguments for couples. But for us, you know, we actually agreed, I think, on most items. There's a couple of things that we had different, you know, different opinions on. But we were able to talk it through. We were able to talk it through very calmly. There was questions about the rings. You know, who gets to, you know, do you get to keep your ring? The wedding band or the engagement ring or both? Actually, both. I think it's really more for the engagement ring, I would imagine. I told him, I was like, I'm keeping this thing. And he's like, well, what if you cheat on me? I'm like, okay, if I cheat on you, you can have the ring back. There was one prompt in particular that stood out. It discussed spousal support if one of them stopped working to take care of their kids. Zach told Anna that if her business became really successful, he'd be happy to be the one who stayed home. That's probably the thing that attracted us most to each other, is that we're both entrepreneurial and have our own businesses. And, yeah, that was really touching to me that he believed in my business so much that he was like, if, you know, yours really took off and, you know, it made more sense for him to stay home. With children for child care, when they're young versus us, you know, hiring a nanny, that he'd be happy to do that. Yeah, we discussed it. And even though we don't have kids yet, you know, God willing, in the future, it makes sense that I could step up. Or if my business is booming, you know, Anna could step up. Either of us would be able to do that. In a way, it felt more like estate planning than it did like a prenup. Yeah. Thinking of what would happen if one of us passed away. And, you know, yeah, things in the future. Even there was one section about if we froze embryos, what would happen to that? You know, it was really more about all the things we were going to do and achieve and how that would play out versus I'm protecting myself from him. I never felt like that. In fact, Zach thinks it's helpful to think about it as a business deal. If you run a business, you're going to send a contract to, to the other party, right? Your client, your vendor, right? And in that contract, there's going to be some terms. And there's also going to be like a termination clause, right? The termination clause is not necessarily your goal, right? Like your goal is to get the renewal. When that year's over, you want to renew. You want to maybe raise your price. Like obviously you're not going to be doing that with your wife, right? But like. But you want to maintain the partnership. Exactly. Right? Like you want to keep that contract renewing and grow the relationship with the client. But you're putting something in writing. Do you think that all newlyweds should have a prenup? I do. I think that it will give you so much more confidence marrying the person that you're with. People, you know, I think are taught to not talk about money. It's taboo or to not. Or to be embarrassed about your finances. If you do have some debt or some things that you're working on. But it's of the utmost importance to be upfront with your partner about those things. And yeah, the prenup just made us very raw with each other and vulnerable and put it all out in the open. There's no secrets. And yeah, I do think that made us a stronger couple. Well, thank you both for sharing your story. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. That's all for today, Friday, September 18th. The Journal is a co-production of Spotify and The Wall Street Journal. The show is made by Catherine Brewer, Evelyn Fajardo-Alvarez, Pia Gidkari, Max Green, Sophie Codner, Ryan Knudsen, Matt Kwong, Colin McNulty, Laura Morris, Enrique Perez de la Rosa, Sarah Platt, Alan Rodriguez-Espinosa, Heather Rogers, Katie Shepard, Piers Singhi, Juvica Verma, Catherine Whalen, Tatiana Zamise, and me, Jessica Mendoza. Our engineers are Griffin Tanner, Nathan Singapak, and Peter Leonard. Our theme music is by So Wiley. Additional music this week from Peter Leonard, Bobby Lord, Emma Munger, Nathan Singapak, So Wiley, Griffin Tanner, and Blue Dot Sessions. Fact-checking this week by Kate Gallagher, Jennifer Gorin, and Nicole Pasulka. Thanks for listening, and keep an eye on the feed on Sunday. For an episode from our recent live event in New York. See you then. At Kroger, we love helping you save with pickup and delivery. Right now, you can save even more on fresh favorites with exclusive online deals. Like Kroger brand 80-20 select packages of ground beef for just $3.99 a pound. And fresh strawberries for only $1.99 a pound. Plus, get $20 off your first online order of $75 or more. Restrictions apply. See site for details. Download the app or visit our website to get started. Kroger. Fresh for everyone. For a limited time, you can get a Big Mac meal for just $8. That's a burger, fries, and a drink. They don't call it an extra value meal for nothing. Get a Big Mac meal only at McDonald's. Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing.