Go back

Sean Duffy Goes on FIVE Sunday Shows and Blames Everyone but Himself

23m 36s

Sean Duffy Goes on FIVE Sunday Shows and Blames Everyone but Himself

The air traffic shutdown prompted widespread scrutiny of Sean Duffy’s response as Transportation Secretary, which was characterized by a series of televised interviews where he consistently deflected blame. Rather than acknowledging responsibility, Duffy blamed outdated systems inherited from past administrations and insufficient funding from Congress, citing the General Accounting Office’s warnings about rushed upgrades. He portrayed the shutdown as an unavoidable consequence of decades of underinvestment, while downplaying the severity of a single router or cable failure that disrupted the entire national air network during peak travel. Critics argue his explanations lack technical coherence and fail to address why such a failure occurred during high-demand hours. Duffy repeatedly used the “shaggy defense,” shifting responsibility onto predecessors and Congress, while claiming he is simply trying to modernize a failing system. His responses were widely seen as performative, emphasizing optics over accountability, with a style reminiscent of reality TV. The incident underscores a broader pattern of crisis management through deflection, where leadership is preserved by blaming external forces. Ultimately, Duffy’s performance—coined as the “full Duffy”—demonstrates a strategic effort to protect his position and align with Donald Trump’s narrative, rather than confront the systemic flaws that led to the disruption. The event highlights a gap between public-facing messaging and actual infrastructure management, raising concerns about transparency and accountability in federal operations.

Transcription

4698 Words, 24796 Characters

English
Hey, everybody. It's Will Salatan from The Bulwark. I'm here with my buddy, Sonny Bunch. You know, the big story of the weekend, obviously, was the air traffic shutdown. We're still trying to figure out exactly what happened and who's at fault. And yesterday, I did sort of a takedown of Sean Duffy, the transportation secretary, doing his dog and pony show at the White House, trying to explain his position on it. Today, Sunday, he went on all five Sunday shows. And this is what we used to call the full Ginsburg, except now we can call it the full Duffy. The full Duffy. And Sonny, as some of you should know, is our expert in all things cinematic and performative. And this is one of the most impressive performances I've seen. I guess, Sonny, I would call it a cabinet member trying to save his job is sort of the concept. So he did all five shows and was asked. Various questions about how this went down, whether it was his fault, whether it was the president's fault, whether it was the Republican Party's fault. And amazingly, it turns out that Sean Duffy is a hero and has absolutely no responsibility for this at all. Yes, that tracks. That's my understanding of the last 48 hours. Yeah. So so let's go through some of what he did in these interviews. There were some substantive problems with this. He was asked to explain this to the entire traffic control network and he was asked to explain it. I'm going to start with the interview that he did on Face the Nation with Margaret Brennan, because she asked him some fairly difficult questions about things he should have known or the FAA should have known or things that should have been fixed. The first thing is she brought up a report that the general accounting office did last fall, in which they warned that the FAA was moving too fast in upgrading the FAA. The second thing is she brought up a report that the general accounting office did last fall, in which they warned that the FAA was moving too fast in upgrading the FAA. The third thing is she brought up a report that the general accounting office did last fall, in which they warned that the FAA was moving too fast in upgrading the FAA. The fourth thing is she brought up a report that the general accounting office did last fall, in which they warned that the FAA was moving too fast in upgrading the FAA. The fifth thing is she brought up a report that the general accounting office did last fall, in which they warned that the FAA was moving too fast in upgrading the FAA. And that that might cause some disruptions, for example, what just happened to us. So here's what she said. My number one priority is safety, which is why we shut down the airspace on Friday. Right. We did the closure because we know I'm going to get to that. But I want to make sure that that Americans get from point A to point B safely. They get back to their loved ones. I want them to be on time, but I want them to be safe, which is why we issued the ground stop. OK, Sonny. So clearly safety is the priority. Is that right? Look, here's the thing. He's right. Safety is the priority. But the only reason. That safety is being called into question is because they're trying to do it too fast. Right. Is that is that the basic sense here? I like I agree that airplanes crashing into each other in the air would be very bad. That would look bad. Sean Duffy would not be able to talk his way out of that one. I don't think so. Instead, he shuts it down for almost five hours. I couldn't I couldn't believe it when I when I got the news alert on my phone that the that there had been a ground stop and that it did not get fixed for. It was basically the entire travel day on a Friday. I get what a nightmare, apparently. So from the reporting we have so far, there was one router in Arkansas and another another one in Texas. But that's it. That's it. And from between those two, they decided to shut down the whole system. Well, it was. Yeah. So there's there's the router in Arkansas and then there was some fiber optic cable. I think it was in San Antonio. I do love that this is a router issue. We're similar ages. I think he's a little older than me, but, you know, I'm I'm old. Old enough to remember when you when you had a router problem, you just unplugged it and plugged it back in the who's in charge of the plugging and unplugging at the FAA. That's the scapegoat he's got to find. He's got to find the guy who didn't go in the closet and unplug the router quick enough to to save this whole mess from happening. Right. Well, I hope it comforts you to know that he said that they've investigated and they found that the guy who turned on this router in some way that apparently caused this whole thing was a veteran and a patriot. So not the Iranians. So we should all be we should all be grateful that it was incompetence and not and not malice. I personally love that the excuse here is, hey, the priority is safety. So, you know, hey, it could have been worse. A plane planes could have crashed, which is something you can always say when planes didn't crash. Right. We didn't we didn't we didn't lose any planes. All right. Congratulations. I guess that's like, you know, you're getting the bare minimum award there. That's that's job number one. But like you got there's more things to do. You got you got to got to keep them in the air. Yeah, I got a feeling the answer is we're going to end up finding out that they didn't need to shut down the whole system for this, but that they you know, they're going to claim that we save people from dying. OK, well, that's a standard excuse. So then Margaret Brennan points out that Congress gave the FAA lots of money over the years to fix the this air traffic control communication system, but that apparently they still haven't upgraded the network. Here's the question. Respectfully, the American people have put a lot of money into this. They've put a lot of money into infrastructure upgrades in twenty twenty one. It was twenty five billion dollars for upgrades under Biden under your administration. The Trump administration, as you just said, twelve and a half billion for upgrades. Democrats say the lion's share of the money that was provided to you, you just have not obligated or spent. Why? And if the White House has allowed for reprogramming of funds, why do you keep saying Congress is stopping you from spending the money they're giving you? So first off. There was a lot of money that was given to the FAA in the past, and I can't answer for other secretaries or other FAA administrators. A lot of money was given. Not a lot of work was done. So, Sonny, what I'm hearing is he's not taking any responsibility for his department or for the FAA. He's saying, well, that was people in the past and I don't bear any responsibility for I disassociate myself from that. Is that right now? Well, what you got to understand, look, we've all been in a situation where we have royally. Messed up where we've royally screwed. I almost went with a different word there because this is about as effed up as it gets. But the but the but what you do when you are confronted with such a situation is you figure out how to say it wasn't me. It's the shaggy defense. It wasn't me. It was I other Congress didn't do it right. They didn't appropriate the funds. The previous administration was, you know, he's caught red handed. He's caught red handed with the. The five hour delay wasn't me, wasn't me shaggy defense. Sean Duffy doing the shaggy defense on the full Duffy today was an absolute masterpiece of deflection. I have to you have to give it to him for thinking so quickly on his feet to figure out how to say in many different ways it wasn't me. Right. And personally, I'm very surprised that a cabinet member in the Trump administration would have gotten the idea that this is how one responds to questions by blaming one's predecessors. You know, I think it just seems very un-Trump like, you know, let me go on to another interview he did because another really good question. He was on ABC with Martha Raddatz and she asked him a very logical question since Duffy's been going around saying, well, the system was messed up and flimsy all along. And I've been telling people, as she says, so then why didn't you anticipate that the network might go down like it did this weekend? And here's here's how the exchange went. You know, you had an old system. You've said that again. And again, yet you said you didn't anticipate an incident of this nature could happen at this scale. Are you concerned that you and your department do not fully understand what the vulnerabilities are in this system? Well, we understand the age of the network and the work that was done on Friday that's been done thousands of times by L3 Harris in our network, it's been done thousands of times by other companies. And these issues haven't haven't haven't arisen. And so that's why we have to figure out what what went wrong here. So it doesn't sound like he has an answer to this question. Like, this is his number one excuse. They my predecessors left me with this lousy network. Congress didn't pay to upgrade it. And I'm really surprised that we had a problem that forced us to shut it down. I guess my question is, why is this being done at 1:00 p.m. or whatever, whatever time it was? I don't I don't know what I don't know what I live in. I live in Dallas, so I'm on Central Time. And I want to say it was like four or five or so that I got this this alert. Maybe it was earlier. But the why are they doing this on a Friday in the middle of the peak travel time for for folks who are trying to get out of town for a weekend? They've got business plans. You know, they're trying to, you know, I don't know, take a vacation or something. And this is not when these things happen. I mean, this is not when these things happen, you know, I mean, it's not like we're going to be able to get out of town on a Friday, but we're going to be able to get out of town in the middle of the peak travel time. I mean, it's not like we're going to be able to get out of town in the middle of the peak travel time. I mean, I guess somebody is, but the but, you know, that that's the time to do it instead of in the most busy time possible. I that is that's my question. And this comes back to what he was talking about or what he was deflecting from before, which is that, you know, they're trying to do this fast, but they're not doing it well. you know, you, you, you can have one or the other, I guess. Uh, what is it? You can have fast and cheap and well, you can't, you gotta pick two. You can't, you can't, you can't have all three and they're, they're, they're, they're trying for the full, the full trifecta. It's not working. For those of you who don't know, this is the motto of all writers. We say, look, Mr. Editor, you can have it now, or you can have it good. Right. So, but I have to say, once again, this is where I totally understand where Sean Duffy is coming from. You know, Sam Stein comes to us. He says, where's your story, Mr. Writer, man. And we say, look, I, the previous writer did not leave me the materials I needed for the research. I, my computer is in the shop, uh, because it's getting work done. I don't, I can't possibly have finished this in time. Get off my case, man. Right. So for, for those of you who actually want to know the answer to this question, Duffy's answer to why they were doing it. And on a Friday afternoon was, oh, well, if it had been really important, if it had been, in Chicago or some hub that we really knew about, then we would, we certainly would have done that in the wee hours. But, but when we do these rural unimportant, uh, routers, uh, we'd like, you know, Arkansas, who cares about Arkansas? We do it. And, you know, rush hour for that's, that's his explanation. This raises the question. If this problem can take down the whole system, why are they doing any of them at any time during the day? Right. Like I, this is, this is the question that I have. This is a question, hopefully maybe somebody in Congress will ask is like, all right, how is our system this interconnected that one bad router or maybe one downed cable in San Antonio, uh, can disrupt the whole thing? Like I, I, again, setting aside the plugging and unplugging responsibilities of the router, I would like to know what happened. So it doesn't happen again. If I'm in charge of the FAA, that being said, if I'm in charge of the FAA right now, I just lean on the, it wasn't me defense. It's like, that's not me. I didn't have anything to do with this. You'll be happy to know that that's, he's taking your cue. Uh, so after they get, he gets these tough questions and he has no answers to them. He gets asked, well, this happened under your watch. Um, are you going to apologize? And this is it. So let's see what happens. This, this is the question from Kristen Welker on meet the press. The FAA administrator apologized to the American people during the news conference that you all held yesterday. You are, of course, the transportation secretary. Do you feel you also owe an apology to the American people? This happened on your watch. Well, listen, it happened on my watch, but we have to be clear. Um, I am moving at an incredible speed that no one has done at the FAA or the DOT in decades. And I'm proud of the work we're doing, the attention we're bringing to this issue, but I can't apologize for what was, was, what was passed off to us. And I can't blame Republicans or Democrats because it's all of them. It goes back 20, 25, 30 years of a lack of investment, a lack of, you know, waving the flag to say, Hey, this is a problem. Let's fix it. Why they didn't do that. I don't know, but they gave me a system that needs to be fixed. So Sonny, the question was about whether he was going to apologize. I think the word that I kept hearing was they, right? I look, this is another great deflection tactic. You apologize for somebody else. You say, no, was it? No, they, you know, look, sorry that I'm late. My kids weren't dressed yet. I had to get them dressed. I had to bring it took it. That's, you know, look, they're kids. What are you going to do? I can't, I can't. It's, it's really pretty genius. I have to say, this is a masterclass in, in crisis avoidance. I don't know what the, what the, what the proper crisis, whatever the opposite of crisis management is, like we don't have anything to manage because somebody else's crisis. I think this is, this is actually going to be studied in a business schools for years to come. Yeah. There's a way in which he projects this earnestness as he's deflecting. It's like, well, you know, Kristen, I can't apologize for what was left to me. Like that wouldn't be honest, right? To be honest, I need to blame other people. Look, you know, our colleague, Sarah Longwell had a great video showing where Sean Duffy came from. And of course he comes from the real world. This is the, the MTV, the classic MTV reality show, the real world. That's where he, he kind of burst onto the public scene. What that show teaches anybody who is on it is the ability to look into a camera and lie to make themselves seem great. It's the, the whole confessional thing is a real misnomer because nobody's confessing to anything. They're just talking about how terrible everybody else is. Right. You know, it is really impressive to me how Duffy, I watch him in these interviews. He doesn't even blink. He has that Elizabeth Holmes thing going on, except it's like a more convincing. He's I'm going to lock my eyes on you and, and project. Even as you know, I'm lying to you. So it wasn't just asked by Welker. He also gets asked by Dana Bash on CNN. She asks him about the GAO report, which Margaret Brennan also asked about. So he was warned. And so she says, in light of the fact that the GAO issued this warning about how fast you were moving with these upgrades and how it might cause disruptions. Do you at least, she's not even asking for an apology. She says, will you at least take responsibility? I want to get to the money in a second. And I just want to say that what the GAO said was exactly what you said, that it needs to be done. But they were concerned that the way in which the FAA is doing it could cause complications. But as the secretary, do you take responsibility for what happened? Well, I have the, I have the network, right? So when we do work and things go wrong, of course, I'm the secretary, but I also have to acknowledge what was delivered to me. It's a, it's, I mean, I have systems that are from the, the nineties. I have radar that are from the sixties and seventies. So I got to tell you what I have. I take responsibility for what was given to me by prior administrations. And now I tell you how I'm going to fix it. So Sonny, that line that he, he does there where I have to take responsibility for, for what was given to me. That sounds exactly like the technique you were just, you were just describing where I apologize on someone else's behalf. I take responsibility on someone else's behalf, but I'm really saying they did it. Yeah. Oh, it's, it's, it's genius. I like, I gotta say, um, the, the, I take responsibility for what was delivered to me is really, uh, is really pretty wonderful. And you can, again, you can apply this to your own life, right? Like you, you say, well, uh, no, I, I didn't, uh, do the reading for this assignment that I was given. Um, because Amazon did not bring me the package in time. I did not have my two day prime delivery. It took three days. And well, I know that's not enough time. I can't, I can't read the whole thing. Uh, so, you know, that's very, that's very good. That's very, that's very, uh, solid effort on, on his part. So Duffy's not just trying to cover for himself in his interviews. He's also trying to cover for the most important person in the world, which of course is Donald Trump. Um, and Trump has a little problem because, um, he's been a little bit uncharacteristically silent, shall we say on this topic, you know, given that he talks about a lot of things. And so Dana Bash and her interview on CNN sort of brings this up and she asks Duffy why Trump has been talking and posting about other things, but not on this one. No, I know, but that's what's so stunning about it because he was posting on social media about the motion, motion picture, television, entertainment, many posts about revitalizing a golf course. And that's why it's so noteworthy that we didn't hear from him for almost a day and a half. I can just tell you this. I can tell you this. I was in constant contact. He was fully engaged, um, because this is important to him and it's important to America. So Mark, Wayne and I were, uh, fully engaged with the president. We were in the oval. Uh, I talked to him before we did the press conference. I talked to him after the press conference. Um, so his engagement has been remarkable and his insight into how we have to come together as Americans, R's and D's to get this done, um, is I think a sign of, of great leadership. So, uh, no, the president is fully supportive, fully engaged and was fully tracking, uh, what's happening. Sonny, I heard a lot of fully engaged that although you people out there in the imaginary world can't actually see what's going on here, the trust me, the president, the big guy is secretly really engaged on this topic. Several different things going on here. Well, first of all, uh, as you said, he's covering for Donald Trump here because, uh, this whole thing, the full Duffy, as we have coined it, um, is an effort to save his job. And the only way to save your job in the Trump administration is to go on TV. And talk on a television because he likes it when people look good on television. That's like the one thing he respects in this, in this whole world. Um, whether or not this will get the job done hard to say, I think he's probably, I think I I'll be honest with you. I think he's probably nailing it from Trump's perspective. He's like, well, he's blaming, he's blaming the Democrats. He looks good while he's doing it. As you say, he's got that, he's got that Elizabeth Holmes stare, man. He's got that, you know, he's, he's hypnotizing the audience as he goes. His only mistake is not spending the entirety of the time on Fox news. Cause that's, I think the only thing that Donald Trump actually watches is, is Fox news. I, I, maybe somebody will bring him the clips from CBS and everywhere else, but I, you know, I he's, he's, he's, he's spreading his attention too thin. He's really just got to focus on the important network. The only one that matters Fox news. Um, the, the other thing I think that's a very key here is that the reason Donald Trump hasn't tweeted about this or truth about it, he hasn't truth socialed about it is because he doesn't care. He doesn't, he doesn't give a crap, uh, about this. Really? He can't, the, here are the things he gives a crap about. If one of the airports needed like nicer facades, if it needed more gold, Imagine, if you will, a lack of gold trim had caused this power outage. There would be a thousand truths. There would be a thousand truths about this. He would be like, this is what I've been telling you, people. We need it to look like the Charles de Gaulle, man. We got to we got to get our airports in top shape. But that's not the problem here. The problem is a router. Donald Trump doesn't know the plug it in and unplug it trick. He doesn't he doesn't understand how routers work. He's never had to work on a router in his life. I have to unplug my router three times a week to get to get the proper high speeds. Not him. He's got somebody else to do it. But if it had been about gold trim, if it had been about a golf course, could you imagine if somebody on a golf course had caused this? If like the the construction on a golf course had severed a fiber optic cable, he would invade. He would invade with the army and take over the golf course so he could redo it. So that is that's why that's why Donald Trump. Hasn't really said very much. Now, he did finally say something today. And you'll notice what he said was it turns out it was Biden by sleepy Joe Biden. And it was the previous Congresses. They didn't do their jobs. And that's why this all happened. It was not Donald Trump's fault. It's not even the Republicans who are currently in offices fault. I do love we haven't even mentioned this. Well, what do you make of Sean Duffy going out there and being like, I know I've been asking for 30 billion dollars. But what I actually need is 50 billion dollars, because I think this is actually another brilliant avoidance technique. Right. It's he's saying he's like he's it's it's like doubling down. It's like, no, actually, we need to do even more than we've been doing. We need to do it all. We need 50 billion dollars to do it. I like I am actually kind of impressed at the chutzpah. Yeah. And I have to say, in addition to asking for this money, that from what I've read about this and from what Duffy himself has said, he he keeps trying to blame Congress for not giving him money. He says they gave us 12 billion, but it's only for other radar and radio and things. It's not for the telecom system. It's not to build a new system. But what actually caused this to go down was him was him FAA doing patches on the old system. So the money that they gave him absolutely could have been used for the thing that actually caused this. And he doesn't really have a. Good answer for that. But he's managed as part of his whole deflection routine to, like, project this off onto, you know, they didn't give us money for the new system. But I think you've nailed the key thing here, which is this is this is fundamentally a TV job. His job was to go out there today and look good, as Trump would say, central casting and, you know, project that this isn't his fault. It isn't FAA's fault. And it's not certainly not Donald Trump's fault. And just blame everybody else. He's done exactly what the boss asked. And he's pulled off the the full Duffy, I would say the full Duffy, the full Duffy. Well, we'll carry that one into the future. Sonny, thank you so much for joining me on this. I think you've explained the whole performance aspect of this better than anyone else could have. And for those of you who don't know, come to the bulwark and Sonny will explain all of the people who the actual job really is to act as opposed to the transportation secretary who was actually supposed to be doing a different job. Sonny, thank you so much. And everybody hit like. Subscribe and come read Sonny and all of his work at the Bulwark.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Sean Duffy conducted a series of five televised interviews explaining the air traffic shutdown, using performative and deflective language to shift blame away from his own department.
  2. He repeatedly claimed the system failures were due to inherited outdated infrastructure from prior administrations and Congress, avoiding personal responsibility for the disruption.
  3. Duffy’s defense centers on the "shaggy defense" strategy—blaming predecessors, Congress, and past administrations for lack of investment, while portraying himself as a proactive reformer.
  4. He failed to address how a single router or fiber cable failure in rural areas could cascade to a nationwide ground stop during peak travel hours, raising questions about system interconnectivity and risk management.
  5. Duffy’s remarks suggest he does not take responsibility for the GAO’s warning about rapid upgrades, instead framing the problem as one of legacy systems rather than poor execution.
  6. His explanations are criticized as lacking technical credibility, with references to “plugging and unplugging” routers and unexplained timing of the shutdown appearing dismissive of real-world consequences.
  7. The incident reveals a pattern of crisis management through denial and deflection, with Duffy appearing to prioritize optics over accountability, echoing the style of reality TV performers.
  8. The broader implication is that the shutdown was not a failure of leadership but a product of systemic neglect, with Duffy effectively using media appearances to shield himself and Donald Trump from criticism.

Summary:

The air traffic shutdown prompted widespread scrutiny of Sean Duffy’s response as Transportation Secretary, which was characterized by a series of televised interviews where he consistently deflected blame. Rather than acknowledging responsibility, Duffy blamed outdated systems inherited from past administrations and insufficient funding from Congress, citing the General Accounting Office’s warnings about rushed upgrades. He portrayed the shutdown as an unavoidable consequence of decades of underinvestment, while downplaying the severity of a single router or cable failure that disrupted the entire national air network during peak travel.

Critics argue his explanations lack technical coherence and fail to address why such a failure occurred during high-demand hours. Duffy repeatedly used the “shaggy defense,” shifting responsibility onto predecessors and Congress, while claiming he is simply trying to modernize a failing system. His responses were widely seen as performative, emphasizing optics over accountability, with a style reminiscent of reality TV.

The incident underscores a broader pattern of crisis management through deflection, where leadership is preserved by blaming external forces. Ultimately, Duffy’s performance—coined as the “full Duffy”—demonstrates a strategic effort to protect his position and align with Donald Trump’s narrative, rather than confront the systemic flaws that led to the disruption. The event highlights a gap between public-facing messaging and actual infrastructure management, raising concerns about transparency and accountability in federal operations.

FAQs

The shutdown was caused by a router failure in Arkansas and a fiber optic cable issue in San Antonio, which disrupted the entire air traffic control system.

The shutdown was implemented to prioritize safety, as officials claimed the system's vulnerabilities posed a risk of potential aviation accidents.

Duffy cited the GAO report but attributed the system's failures to prior administrations and Congress, not to his own department or leadership.

No, Duffy denied responsibility, instead blaming previous administrations, Congress, and the aging infrastructure left behind by past leaders.

His appearances were part of a strategy to project confidence, deflect blame, and maintain public support during the crisis, often referred to as the 'full Duffy' performance.

He claimed that rural and less critical infrastructure issues like router problems are typically handled during off-peak hours, and that this incident was not a high-priority hub issue.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.