Sarah Matthews and Jason Horowitz: Trump Propaganda and Italian Fascism
1h 8m 32s
Hero Bread presents a solution to the challenge of enjoying comforting, familiar foods without compromising health goals. Its soft, flavorful, low-carb, high-protein products—like bread, bagels, and noodles—allow consumers to enjoy meals like mac and cheese or grilled cheese while staying aligned with wellness objectives. A current 10% discount using code IHEART makes the product more accessible. The broader discussion in the transcript goes beyond food, focusing on the erosion of free press integrity under political leadership. Sarah Matthews, a former Deputy White House Press Secretary, explains how the White House has taken control of media access, banning outlets like CNN and Politico, and expanding influence through state-aligned media such as OANN and Newsmax. This move undermines independent journalism and amplifies propaganda, especially in the context of Trump’s media strategies, including the launch of Trump TV. The erosion of press independence is seen as a dangerous trend that threatens democratic accountability. Meanwhile, polling data reveals a shift in Republican voter identity, with a growing number of voters identifying as Republicans rather than Trump supporters, though this may not reflect a genuine shift in political loyalty. The analysis also draws parallels between Italy’s political evolution and today’s U.S. landscape, noting how far-right movements like Georgia Maloney’s have transitioned into mainstream politics, signaling a broader trend of nationalism and political manipulation. These developments suggest that both media and political systems are being reshaped in ways that prioritize control and loyalty over transparency and accountability.
Fall and comfort foods go hand-in-hand.
Grandma's mac and cheese, soup and grilled cheese.
But how do you create those cozy moments
while still maintaining your health goals?
Hero Bread can help.
Hero Bread's soft, fluffy, flavorful sliced breads,
bagels, tortillas, and hero noodles
have only zero to five grams net carbs
and up to 19 grams of protein per serving.
So go ahead, enjoy some cheesy mac and cheese.
Enjoy that stacked sandwich with Hero Bread for lunch
or start your day with a fully loaded bagel.
Because with Hero Bread,
there's none of the stiff baked goods you expect
from better for your brands.
And right now, Hero Bread is offering 10% off your order.
Go to hero.co and use code IHEART at checkout.
That's H-E-R-O.C-O, code IHEART.
All figures per serving of Hero Bread.
See nutrition facts on hero.co for sodium and sugar content.
Hello and welcome to the Bulwark Daily.
I am your host, Tim Miller.
I got a great email, an uplifting email this morning
from a listener, Nicole Bassett,
who said that in part because of some rants
that I've done on this show,
she decided to jump into an R plus 19,
state Senate district in Oregon.
And I do truly believe this.
I just think that there are not enough people running
in some of these local districts
that you think are Republican,
but where folks might be gettable this year
because they're so unhappy with Trump.
And so I'm happy Nicole jumped in.
You can go find out more about her at bassettfororegon.com.
Appreciate her.
We got a double header for you today.
In segment two, it is Jason Horowitz,
an old friend of mine.
We're going to talk about fascism in Italy,
and the Bulwark Pope.
But up first, couldn't be happier to welcome back to the show,
a contributor to the Bulwark, doing our TikToks and more.
She's also sparring with Scott Jennings on CNN a lot
and really getting some good reps in there.
She used to be Deputy White House Press Secretary
in the first Trump administration.
It's Sarah Matthews.
What's up, Sarah?
Hey, Tim.
Thanks for having me back on the pod.
Happy to do it.
I wanted to chat with you a little bit
because I feel like sometimes, you know,
I get into my insidery gossipy side about politics.
And like, there are a lot of people out there.
They're like, what the fuck are you talking about, Tim?
And I think that's particularly potent when you get into these kind of media stories
around what's happening in the White House.
And so that'd be interesting since you were there as Deputy Press Secretary,
like talk about, like, just like the basics of what's happening here with like the,
you know, with Politico and CNN and MSNOW getting kicked out.
Like, what does that mean?
Like, do these guys have an office in the White House?
Like, how do you get a seat in the pool?
Like, like, maybe you're just going to run through for people.
Like, what actually happens and then why it's significant?
Yeah.
So you can be credentialed White House media and not necessarily be part of the pool
because the purpose of the pool is that it's just a select number of reporters
who are on duty to follow the president's movements that day.
And that's because you can't have all of these hundreds of credentialed White House media
in the room at every event.
You can't squeeze them all into the Oval Office.
You can't take them all on Air Force One.
And so it becomes this group of around 15 to 20 reporters.
And it's all split up between you have print reporters who are putting out a pool report
of what the president is doing and saying throughout the course of the day.
You have a TV camera crew that is there that is recording all the video and audio.
And then they're sending that and sharing it to all the other TV networks.
A radio reporter, still photographers, the list goes on.
And so you have those reporters who are on duty.
And they're on duty to be part of the White House press pool that day
and then just share and disseminate what they are gathering from the president's actions that day.
And the reason that this is important is because the White House is sending out its own information.
They send out their own transcripts.
They publish their own photos and video and all of these things.
But the White House gets to choose and be selective about what they are sharing with the public.
And so that's why you need an independent White House.
You need an independent White House press pool that is there gathering what is actually happening.
Because they can tell you, here's what happened when the cameras were off.
Here's who walked into this meeting or left this meeting.
And give you all these details that maybe the White House wouldn't be so willing to share.
And what we've seen happen, actually, that's been interesting,
even before Trump's ban on Politico and CNN and MSNOW,
is that at the beginning of Trump's tenure in Trump 2.0,
the White House actually took control of the White House pool.
Typically, this was decided by the White House Correspondents Association.
They would set the rotation for who was a part of the pool each day.
But when Caroline Leavitt took over as press secretary,
that was probably the biggest change that she made was that she said,
no, we're taking that away from the White House Correspondents Association
and we're going to be deciding who those pool reporters are.
And that gave them substantially more power over how the
president was covered.
And that's why we're seeing these new media seats sometimes be part of,
which I would say is bullshit, fake news, my interpretation of fake news,
but these kind of fake outlets like OANN and Newsmax and where it's completely biased.
But Caroline took control of that and set what the pool, who the pool reporters were.
And now we're seeing what the consequences of that are of Walker even giving a little bit of
power to the White House, where now the White House is banning certain press from not just being part of the pool,
but not even having access to the White House in general.
I think this is why this is just important in a layman's way, right?
Because it's just like it kind of layers the propaganda upon propaganda, right?
And this has been happening slowly, right, where you're inviting in these more new media people.
So it's like now OANN's in there and now Newsmax is in there and now Lindell TV has a seat, right?
And like all this like nonsense, right?
And so they're in the rotation. And so the White House is putting out one thing.
But then the people that are there to monitor it are basically in league with the White House, right?
And so they're like still some people around, you know, but like this has been like a gradual move away from it.
And to me, like that ties into like the other thing that they just launched yesterday, which was Trump TV.
There's a great article our guy Brendan wrote in the Bulwark.
He had to suffer through six hours of Trump TV.
Luckily, they're not good at propaganda yet.
It's extremely boring.
And Brendan, I think, wanted to start doing self-harm after a few hours.
He needs a raise for everything that Sam puts him through.
Go read his article.
But to me, like everything, this is all in service of just like building to more and more of just a full propaganda effort that like looks more like how things look in authoritarian countries.
And like we're not there yet, you know, but like that is the trajectory this is going.
No, it's a slippery slope.
And I think that even if you don't watch CNN.
CNN or MSNOW or read Politico and you don't care about these journalists that are being affected by this ban, you actually should care as an American, because this is an attack on the free press.
And the purpose of a free press is so that we can have an independent media body that is holding our government to account and our government is operating in our name.
And so we should care about what they're doing.
And that is what's so scary about state run media is that we wouldn't be getting this independent account of everything that's happening.
And, you know, for now, the it seems like some of the media networks are banning together to push back on this ban.
We saw that the TV networks all said that they weren't going to carry Trump's remarks at the United Nation because of him banning CNN and CNN was supposed to be the TV pool reporter that day.
And I don't know how long that will last.
Obviously, I these networks are challenging it in court.
And I think it's going to vary.
It's going to very much be struck down.
It just depends on how soon and how quickly that can happen.
But these media networks for now are banning together, but we're not sure how long that will hold and that will last.
And I mean, it's my frustration with them with them because they they all seem to kind of bend the knee a bit when I mean, I think back to them even hosting the dinner, the White House Correspondents Dinner with him.
I mean, it's just such a slap in the face to the free press.
And then something like this happens and it's it's not a shocking thing to me at all.
It's just crazy to me.
They went to that dinner still.
I get so it's one thing and one night, but it's like in retrospect, you went to this fucking cozy, jokey dinner with the guy and then a couple of like, what do you think was going to happen?
Yeah.
A couple months later, he's going to take your credential away.
There's still some.
I mean, Caitlin, he gets to other places where they don't have as much control as they do inside the White House.
So they did have Caitlin Collins up in New York yesterday.
I got a kick out of that.
Trump was yelling at her.
I'm surprised CNN is here covering me.
You shouldn't be here.
You should not be here.
So I did like watching him fly.
All right.
I want to talk about a couple of things.
I was seeing some music last night and right before he came on, I was able to get a little jolt of energy that it wasn't from the alcohol.
It was from like just a big, hefty snort of opium.
When the Texas poll came off, it was just a big fat line of opium came right across my phone.
Marist poll in Texas, legit pollster, Tallarico 50, Paxton 44.
I think it's the first Tallarico 50 I've seen at least.
the legitimate poll i get a little bit worried when he's like up 47 43 because a lot
which just might mean that he can't get to 50.
Maris has been pretty good.
You look at the last three cycles,
they've been off by about two points on average.
So, you know, again, we could be in a seltzer situation.
She also was pretty good for a while,
but this is a huge trend of polls.
It's not one outlier.
And for like a really solid pollster there in Texas
to have Talrico up six,
are you getting high on Hopium with me?
Where are you at?
I think I'm getting high with you.
I think that this seems like the perfect storm
for Texas to finally go blue.
And it took a lot of factors to get there.
You know, you look at the state of the economy
and Trump's leadership
and how frustrated voters are with him.
But then you look at who Talrico's running against.
I mean, Ken Paxton is just a dream candidate
for Democrats to be running against.
Just so corrupt, so unlikable.
I mean, even John Cornyn and George W. Bush
are fundraising for Republican Senate candidates,
not including someone
from their own state.
They're not fundraising for Ken Paxton.
So even Republicans within the own party
are against this guy.
And so then, you know,
you put up a Boy Scout like Talrico.
I think that it really is just a perfect storm.
And I think there's a chance that Texas goes blue.
You're saying there's a chance.
I did a big rant about George W.
over on the Next Level feed.
So if people want to, you know,
feel my rage and how incensed I am about George W.
his fundraiser.
Nice that he didn't do Paxton,
but that he was doing the other people.
You can go check out the Next Level.
I don't, I'm not.
Yeah, disappointing to see him put party loyalty
over the country.
Yeah.
In the spirit of compassionate conservatism,
I'm going to fundraise for a bunch of people
that are voting for Donald Trump's gulags.
Anyway, I don't know.
Not for me.
That's people that supported the gutting of Pat Farr.
Okay, go to the Next Level.
I already did 10 minutes on this.
I just want to get your take on,
I always, whenever you're on,
I kind of like to have your temperature
because I feel like you're me
from five years ago.
Five years ago,
where I still kind of had a temperature
on what was happening
in Republican operative world
because people still talk,
people don't talk,
nobody talks to me anymore.
And so, you know,
you have a few tentacles still left
since it was a more recent departure.
Give me a vibe check on,
you know,
how people are feeling in your life
about kind of the state of,
you know, Trump.
Yeah.
People are often surprised to hear
that I still have connections
into the Republican Party and Trump world.
And I mean,
it's just a product of having worked
in Republican politics for so long.
And yes,
there are a lot of people
who don't fuck with me anymore.
And I'm happy that they don't.
And I don't fuck with them either.
But there are some people
who still talk to me
and, you know,
we'll talk shop
and they know how bad things are.
I mean,
they see the writing on the wall.
They know that November
is going to be brutal.
And they privately say things to me like,
God, all this is so batshit.
Like just the other day,
I had multiple people text me
about Trump TV
and the state run media.
I mean,
it's basically state run media.
And I had people who work
in the administration
and on Capitol Hill
who work for Republicans
who said to me,
this is insane.
And, you know,
and I've had conversations with them
about, you know,
Trump's decision to launch
the war with Iran
and all these things
where it's like,
these are unforced errors
on his part
where they're self-inflicted wounds
that he had to make.
And it really has made
this situation
so much worse for them.
And they're frustrated.
And so, yeah,
I have a lot of people
who privately say to me,
Sarah, I love your bulwark videos
and I'll watch them.
You'll never see me
liking any of them.
But just know that I support you
and that you're right.
And I'm like. Oh, thanks.
Profile and courage.
You can't even do it like. I try not to hold the staffers.
Think about our soldiers
fighting the war in Iran.
Think about the soldiers
on the USS Lincoln
and what they're doing.
And you won't even like my answer.
Instagram post.
There's this poll in Puck yesterday
that I sent you.
I want to just talk about it for a sec.
Where's this. It's been this big change.
It's kind of. It became a common poll question
over the last 10 years.
Did I get a sense
for Trump's sway within the party?
Like, are you more of a Republican
or more of a Trump fan?
Basically, it's the question.
And in January of 25,
after he wins,
it's 60 Trump, 36 Republican.
That's going to be the answer
to that question.
This week, the poll that came out
was 34% Trump.
56 Republican.
So a flip.
This is just within
Republican voters, of course.
I think that's interesting.
There's some ways to look at that
in a hopeful way.
It's like many people are like,
I've had enough of the crazy.
There's another way to look at that,
which is like of the 56,
maybe like some of those people
are like, I'm not Trump
because I'm more of a. some other, you know,
more even populist nationalist
version of the party.
I'd like to dig into that
a little more.
But I'm wondering like
what your reaction is to that.
And if you're. Are you sensing any
kind of vibe shift there?
You know, it's like
when I initially saw that,
it gave me hope
and I got excited about it.
Yeah.
And then reality starts to set in a bit
and I try not to get too excited
about things anymore.
And that's just,
I've become so cynical
about our politics
and today's Republican Party.
And so I look at that 56%
and I think
how many of those people
would still vote for Trump
if he were on the ballot today?
Probably nearly all of them.
And, but maybe I'm wrong
and I hope I'm wrong.
And I hope that, you know,
this is a sign
that the Republican Party is healing
and that they're moving away
from this cult of personality
and that they've had enough of Trump.
But like, I think about
what did it take to get here?
Higher gas prices.
That was what it took for you guys
to get here, to flip on him.
I mean, beggars can't be choosers.
I'm happy if people are identifying. But that's not encouraging really.
Yeah.
I'm happy if people are identifying more,
first and foremost,
as members of the Republican Party
than a Trump supporter.
That is a good thing.
But I'm not completely sold yet.
Maybe I need to see it to believe it.
And, you know,
I think November will be really telling
of if it's a, you know,
total just wipe out blue wave
or if it's closer than we think.
You know, obviously last election,
they thought there were going to be
bigger blowouts and there weren't.
And so I don't know.
Like I'm trying to be positive,
but it's really hard
when I've become so cynical.
Over the years.
But I think it's a good thing.
Well, there's good reason for cynicism.
Good reason for cynicism.
I agree.
I don't know.
It's an interesting data point to monitor.
Like we can just leave it there
rather than getting excited about it.
A related thing kind of to me
is like tucked into a story about RFK.
There's this line that is a book coming out
and the book is called
America's Path Back to Moral Leadership.
That seems like what somebody
who's running for president
would title their book.
To me.
And again, when you look at that 56
and start to think,
where could the party go?
You know, people will talk about
Vance and Rubio and all this.
Is it crazy to think that like RFK
might try to be a vessel for Trumpism?
Is that crazy to you?
No, I don't think it's crazy at all.
I think there's going to be
a lot of people who throw their names in the hat.
And I think RFK is certainly
one of those people.
We know he obviously has presidential
aspirations and he probably
sees, you know, a lane for himself
where people are moving away from,
you know, just that poll we were just
talking about, people are moving away
from identifying first and foremost
as a Trump supporter.
And so he'd think he might be able
to capture some of those people, maybe.
I mean, there's been murmurs
of Pete Hegseth wanting to run
and like him calling around
and which is absolutely hilarious
to think about.
But I think there's a lot of people
who are going to,
you know, throw their name in the hat.
But yeah, that's a pretty interesting
title for a book.
Even if it's just that 36%,
that's like a lot of power,
whatever it is, 34%.
It's a lot of power that Trump
has a sway over all those people.
And that's why JVL is always like,
it's going to be another Trump.
And yesterday, Stuart Stevens is like,
I think JD is going to solve that problem
by making Ivanka his VP.
Anything is possible in this crazy ass world.
I think that that's interesting.
And there's something about,
I feel like it would play to Trump's ego,
though, that's like,
maybe my successor should be a Kennedy.
Actually,
apparently he's looking at
putting his name on Ford's theater.
It's just like, it's all fucking so crazy.
Anyway, that's something that I was looking at.
We're going to fucking rip his name off
of Ford's theater, though,
if he tries to put it on there.
Rip his name off of everything,
tear down the arch.
I mean, I want it all gone.
I just make it fucking stop.
I'm so freaking, I can't even,
I can't even believe that they're trying
to put his name on Ford's theater.
It's actually something you would think
is straight out of the onion,
but no, it's real.
And like, what was craziest to me
is that it was aides who created a list
of potential places that Trump
could attach his name to.
What that says to me is that
he's having tantrums in the White House
and he's lashing out at them.
And so they're trying to think,
okay, how can we make the boss feel better?
Okay, let's find different buildings
that we can put his name on.
You know, obviously he's had two judges now
strike down him,
adding his name to the Kennedy Center.
So they're trying to come up with anything.
But I mean, it's just-
It's like Jabba the Hutt Chung.
Come up with a list.
No, literally.
Go to chat GBT.
What can I put my name on?
All right, final thing.
You wrote a little while ago
about Max Miller,
your experience with this son of a bitch.
You got a tip yesterday
that the Republican House Super PAC, CLF,
is putting 5 million in to that one house race
to try to save him.
So it's not just that they're like not,
you know, stepping away like Democrats did on Platinum, like even Republicans did back
in the day on Todd Akin. It's not even like that, that they're stepping away. It's not even that
they're just saying, you know, good luck, Max. It's like they're saying we're putting in resources
that could go to any Republican in the country, and we're going to put it into this race to try
to get this guy credibly accused by multiple Republican women that you know of assault and
battery. We're going to try to make sure he can stay in Congress. And it's pretty unbelievable.
And it's, no, that's not true. It's pretty seconding. It's very believable.
It's very believable, but it doesn't make it any less sickening. And yeah, I wrote about this
recently for The Bulwark because I'm from Ohio, and where I grew up is just a town over from that
district. And so Northeast Ohio is somewhere that I love. If you know any Ohioan, you know that
they have a weird obsession with Ohio. Like we love Ohio and love being from there and are so
proud. And so it makes me sick that a man like him is represented.
My state and having known the women who have credibly accused him of domestic abuse and just
even the allegations that there are against him from his ex-wife, you know, things like he held
a gun to her head. He broke their two-year-old daughter's collarbone. And that's not enough
for someone like Speaker Johnson or CLF to say enough is enough. I mean, I'm going to get
credit where credit's due. There are some Republicans who have come out and said that
Max Miller should step aside, like obviously Senator Bernie Marino, who has a vested interest
in this because his daughter is one of the women who has accused Max Miller because she's his ex-wife.
Senator John Husted has also said the same. But it just shows you how the Republican Party
is just rotten to its core because anything has become excusable in the Republican Party
's eyes if you're helpful to the party. And so clearly they're worried about holding on
to their majority. And that matters more than if it comes down between women and power and
holding on to power, they are going to choose power every time over women. And it's just
sickening. And it's why someone like Max Miller can survive and thrive and rise in
the Republican Party. And I thought what was most telling about what Max Miller said when
he did interviews when he was facing all this pressure to step out of the race when it was
before the deadline where they could replace him on the ballot. He said on Jake Tapper show on CNN
that he felt inspired to stay in the race and fight because he watched Donald Trump do so in
2016. So that just goes to show you that he learned that lesson that the Republican Party is willing
to support people like this who are,
incredibly accused of violence, whether that be sexual assault in the case of Donald Trump or domestic violence in the case of Max Miller. And God, the guy's just such a piece of shit. And it just makes me so angry hearing that they're putting 5 million behind him. But they clearly see that there's a chance and I really hope that the people of Northeast Ohio don't vote for him because I actually think that he has a strong opponent in that race too.
Yeah, Brian Poindexter, good candidate.
Yeah, great candidate. So I
think that, you know, hopefully we'll see him prevail. But I, I don't know. Obviously, if they're putting money behind him, they think that there's a chance that he could definitely still win. But that just tells you everything about the Republican Party that a guy like that who is credibly accused of breaking his own two year old daughter's collarbone and throwing boiling water on his wife and holding a gun to her head could still get reelected in today's party. But I mean, that's what Trump has done to this party.
And it's become so warped that they, they care more about holding on to power than actually putting up people of moral good character.
We got some good daughter points tucked into your article, because I saw that you said that your mother who is living back in Ohio was looking at jobs in district offices. And I mentioned Max Morty, or you're like, don't do it, mom. Don't do it.
Yeah, my mom, my mom had worked in congressional offices and in the district, her whole career working for a number of different Republicans in different seats across.
Northeast Ohio. And she had been working for Anthony Gonzalez, actually, one of the few who voted to impeach Trump after January six, really, really good man, and such a loss for the party that, you know, he got pushed out after that. But then, yeah, she got asked to interview for a job with Max Miller. And I was like, absolutely not. But thankfully, she was in full agreement. It didn't take much convincing.
So good to always be looking out for mom. All right, you know, payback. She looked out for you a lot. Speaking of Ohio.
We're there. I'm there on Friday in Dayton. We've got two days to our fundraiser and benefit show for the Haitians in Springfield. Come hang everybody. There's still tickets if you live somewhere around there. It's a Friday night, you can come drive make a little weekend out of it. The bork.com slash events. We opened up a new section because we've got so many people wanting to come, which I really appreciate. So come on down. See us in Ohio. Sarah, thanks for coming on.
Maybe a little pasta. It's Jason Horowitz. Stick around.
We'll be out in a couple of weeks. Go preorder it now. He's now the bureau chief in Madrid for the time. Some good jobs, some good posts. It's my old friend Jason Horowitz. What's up, man?
I'm great, man. Great to be here. Great to see you.
I bet you're good. You know, you've got to spend the last decade that I've been slogging through the Trump era in Rome, Madrid, you know, prancing about Europe, covering Steve Bannon, flying to Prague. It's not a bad life.
You know, they're not exactly hard luck assignments, but they're interesting.
More interesting than your friend.
When you first reached out about the fact that you have an upcoming book, you're checking in. And I was like, God, I don't know, man. And a month from the election, I'm not sure we can do Italian coverage. But in the intervening time, I become more and more fascinated with Maloney. And, and I just think that she's such an interesting character. And I want to do a deep dive on her. So we're going to do that. But first, you came to the blog podcast, we're gonna do a little TDS that's like vaguely related to the book, because you do mention that.
And I'm back in America, where when we met when you're covering American politics, and you interviewed Trump a couple of times. And there's one thing I like, I feel like I have a stored encyclopedia of all the Trump things in my head. But I'd forgotten this when I was paging through the book that you once asked Trump what his dad would think about him running for president. What did he say to that?
And it was about his dad, ostensibly, because I before taking the Rome job, I really covered Trump and his family life and sort of what made him him. Anyway, his answer to that was, he totally would have allowed me to do it. And the word that struck me was allowed. And you know, Trump was already in his 70s. And it was just it was just an odd way to frame, I was expecting would have been proud of me, or he would have had some thoughts on it, but allowed me. And it just was a tiny window into this very complex world.
complicated relationship that Trump had with his father, trying to please him often, often not pleasing him. And something that continued after his father's death, and maybe still now.
Yeah, I kind of wonder, I feel like the two things that could have taken the world on a different trajectory was Fred loving him a little more, or Donald going into the theater business. Like if he had just owned a couple theaters on Broadway, I feel like he would have been much more fulfilled.
I don't know. What do you think?
He would have had a better time. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, his brother, I did a lot of work on his brother, too. That was a sad story. And yeah, it's just, it's a complicated family.
One that died from alcoholism.
Yeah, yeah, essentially. And which is which Trump says is one of the reasons he doesn't drink. But you know, in reporting that story, they weren't very nice to him. This brother who really just wanted to fly airplanes and didn't want to be in the family business and things like that.
Yeah.
At Lehigh, if I remember correctly. It was a bizarre world. Yeah, so that was that was my Trump ancient history. But it was it's sort of important because it's good to have that sort of base and no, no ham. And just sort of it applies to other things you see.
Go to Hitler. A lot of people immediately go to Hitler, even his current vice president. And to don't know that's like the most apt. And of the kind of modern day politicians, I feel like Berlusconi is the one that had the most parallels. But you covered them closely. Why don't you talk a little bit about the similarities, differences, what could be learned from the Berlusconi experience?
Yeah, so I mean, on the surface, there's so many similarities, right? Even the complexion, right?
We both went for this sort of tangerine look.
You know, and hair obviously is an obsession for both of them.
Berlusconi lost his hair and then one year had much more hair than he ever had.
Right.
It looked like a sort of tar had been dumped on his head.
Trump clearly has hair issues.
I don't know what to call it.
I remember once actually in Mar-a-Lago, I was in Mar-a-Lago and the butler snuck me into Mar-a-Lago when he was running for president.
And he took me everywhere, showed me everything.
The one place that was off limits was where Trump went and did his hair.
It's like that was like the inner centum, the holiest of holies where no one could go.
And I was like, all right, I know my bounce.
But the similarities between Trump and Berlusconi are, I mean, they're not just physical, even though ones are tall, ones are short.
They're biography, right?
Their BMI is pretty similar, though.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly.
And though I think that Berlusconi didn't like a well-done cheeseburger as his go-to meal.
I think if you look at their biography, they both come out of real estate world, right?
They were both builders first.
And then they both had incredible sense of media, right?
Trump sort of as manipulating the media from the outside and Berlusconi as someone who became a true mogul, bought up tons of television channels and magazines sort of from nothing, right?
He created a broadcast network by essentially having people run around the country with videotapes.
And play like American soap operas at the same time to get around the rules.
And very innovative.
But media was, he realized that that was, the television was the way to go.
So there's all these sorts of similarities.
It's kind of like a Murdoch-Trump mashup, you know, a little bit.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
And Berlusconi and Murdoch also have like a long storied relationship and ended up hating each other.
But with Trump, I felt a certain point of the. The comparisons became a little too easy, right?
Just because they had these enormous appetites, just because they, you know, were sort of fast and loose with the law, right?
And there was plenty to criticize on both.
There was a difference.
And I think that the difference, what we're seeing now, especially in the second term, is that Berlusconi, for all of his enormous faults, right?
And he came into power essentially to protect his business empire.
But he didn't seem. To have limits.
And as someone, you know, a great historian once told me, don't mistake Berlusconi as a defender of democracy, right?
He's not like your go-to guy.
But at the same time, he sort of believed in the European Union project.
He believed in democracy big time.
There's a difference between believing in like democracy as in like we should have fair elections and believing in the project of liberal democracy, rule of law, you know, all that kind of stuff that Berlusconi was hostile to.
Yeah.
Exactly.
His heroes were Reagan.
Thatcher, right?
Berlusconi's heroes, right?
And he was a child of, you know, World War II.
Bombs were dropping near his house.
He did not want to go back to that.
He viewed nationalism as something sort of scary.
Now, we can talk about and we should talk about how he dealt with that nationalism in his own country.
He brought them in and that's essentially we'll get to Maloney.
But his goal was to sort of neuter them, right?
Because he feared them.
Yeah.
Berlusconi in the end.
He didn't want to go back to Mussolini.
And I think that when you listen to Trump now, and I'm not saying Trump wants to go back to Mussolini, but clearly they have very different, very different views of the borders of democracy.
And I think we're always seeing new ones with Trump, obviously.
I mean, Trump's not at all scared of fascism, I mean, or nationalism.
And he doesn't see any, have any obligation to neuter the kind of more nationalist wing, kind of the opposite.
I mean, he has various areas where they disagree and he thinks that they're weird.
But I don't.
I don't.
I don't think he thinks that neutering the project in any way is of service to him.
I'll get back to that relationship with the fascists.
But just I want to touch one more thing on the similarities.
That was more political.
That struck me reading it.
You wrote this.
Both enjoyed an opposition that played into the savior complex trap.
Berlusconi critics didn't know how to respond to his bonhomie and humor.
They often appeared mealy-mouthed killjoys in comparison.
That felt kind of like an attack on the bulwark.
But I was looking at it.
Or at least an attack on the Democratic party, you know, that is if you could get back into a time machine to 10 years ago, you know, would be the section that I would pull out and, you know, go to the Clinton campaign headquarters or whoever and say, guys, like, this is a lesson you need to learn from this guy.
Because because we did walk straight into that trap that the Berlusconi opposition fell into.
Yeah, it was something with Berlusconi.
So over and over and over again, the more they talked about him, the bigger he got.
Right.
And he did it.
He did not mind it at all.
And he also his skin was less than than Trump's.
Right.
He could take a joke a little bit.
He can play the game.
But he knew that the more everyone was talking about him, the more they were hitting him, the more Berlusconi was the central character on the Italian stage, the less room there was for everybody else.
The real problem was that in the meantime, the left did not come up with, you know, solutions and policies and messaging that actually reached the people that they were trying to convince.
Yeah, I mean, in the end, Berlusconi had a message that was very different from Trump's.
He was much more optimistic.
You know, one could argue it was, you know, he was full of it.
Sure.
But it was an optimistic message about prosperity and, you know, a greater Italy, whereas Trump's, I think, we've seen is not is not exactly that optimism.
On the kind of the relationship with the fascists as Berlusconi is in, you've kind of this rise and I don't know, I guess maybe there's some parallels here and you can always overextend.
But like, we're kind of seeing this right now.
In the Trump movement, where there's a rise of like, an even fascist-ier wing, you know, you talk about Beppe Grillo as an example of that.
And it's kind of this sort of comedian clownish right wing nationalist type.
And I don't know if that's Tucker for like straining these metaphors.
But, you know, I'm just curious, like how that like developed.
And, you know, in these sorts of relationships, there's always a question of like, who's using who, you know, and was Berlusconi using the nationalists to, you know,
kind of maintain a more stable power or kind of the other way around, and then kind of take us from there to Maloney.
Yeah, so this sort of populist surge that starts around 2010 is in a way in response to Berlusconi, right?
Because there's a zillion trials, the corruption is, you know, pretty apparent.
And this is the time also of Bunga Bunga, I don't know if you remember, which was this wild sex scandal, where Berlusconi has having what he called elegant dinners.
And his palace, which the accusations were full of women.
Wasn't there some shirt? I'm going deep into my memory bank.
Weren't there some shirtless pictures? There were some shirtless pictures or very open shirted pictures.
Well, there was one picture. Oh, my God, I'm remembering this now.
There was a picture from his vacation resort in Sardinia with all these different leaders.
I think it was the Czech leader. Sorry if it wasn't the Czech leader.
But and no one was wearing clothes. Right.
It wasn't shirts. It was just no clothes. Right.
Yeah.
Women there who I'm assuming were not their wives.
Yeah.
Right. And or daughters.
So that was sort of the Berlusconi vibe.
But in Italy, it was like, that's the Berlusconi vibe.
It wasn't surprising anybody. Right.
That part wasn't driving everybody crazy.
The part that was driving everybody crazy was that there was like a financial crisis.
And instead of, you know, having a steady hand on the wheel, the guy has one hand texting like a girl in Naples.
Right. And so that was really the problem that.
The country had with Berlusconi at that time.
And so out of that rises this enormous upswell of populism.
And that's this guy, Beppe Grillo, who was this blogger, essentially a comedian.
He harnessed all the anger in the country.
And it was this real old school sort of populist uprising.
You know, his big calling card was like Vafanculo Day, which means go fuck yourself day, essentially.
And they would read off all the names of the people.
And Berlusconi was still on trial in Berlusconi's government and the whole, you know, hundreds of thousands of people screaming Vafanculo.
Right. And so it was like a real populist movement.
And that has not gone away.
Or right or left horseshoe.
So I think horseshoe.
Yeah.
Right. And actually, according to them, nothing, because they were never even a party.
And they also didn't believe in representative democracy.
They believed in the Internet.
So it was this weird sort of futurist things that we see now.
I sort of.
So in Italy, years in advance.
And one thing that I constantly kept thinking is like the more I reported on this place, the more the sort of land of the past started feeling like this land of the future.
Because everything I started seeing sort of came back around.
Beppe Grillo was this basically was with the futurist and there was populist futurism and this whole thing.
And they actually ended up getting into government.
And it wasn't a very successful government because they weren't very competent.
But.
It revealed this hard right populism in the country, even if they were maybe left, maybe right.
Who knows?
But it revealed that it was really there.
And so then Italian politics essentially became a competition for who could get that vote, who could get those people who were like, come out of the.
Who could get the Joe Rogan voter.
I mean, we're doing this right now.
Yeah.
Basically.
It's it's exactly what we're seeing now.
Right.
And and so there was this competition for that.
And so the Italian politicians became very good.
at appealing to those people.
- Okay, so is Maloney then, I'm trying to remember,
Like, is there, you know, another figure before her on the populist right that emerges?
Yeah.
So there's one more step before you get to Maloney.
At first, there's this guy named Matteo Salvini.
Oh, right.
And he is this, you know, also very brash populist, comes from a northern separatist party, actually started as a technically a communist in the Italian north.
But his original sort of ideology was just northern Italy should secede from southern Italy because southern times like stink, literally smell like dogs, you know, just terrible things he was saying.
But then he realizes that nationalism is the way to go after Pepe Grillo.
And so he needs a new enemy and looks further south.
And so you have Africa and you have the migrant crisis and that's what fuels everything.
Yeah.
So he has this a really strong few years and is actually in government.
With Five Star, it's this very odd government where you have the futurist populist with the nationalist northern separatist.
But that's Italy.
Like, you just get these experiments.
Right.
But he flames out in a sort of hysterical way because he's so into his power that he sort of moves the seat of government from Rome to a beach up north where he's hanging out with his like bros and drinking caipirinhas.
And there are, you know, like women on, they call them cubisti, like basically go-go dancers dancing to the national anthem.
And that was just like, OK, this is over.
I mean, if we're going to descend to Italian idiocracy and copy everything, having the next, you know, leadership try to move the capital to Miami and hang out, I don't know.
That's fine.
It's better weather.
You know, at least we'd have Caprini.
Eventually, this guy in Salvini flames out.
The government breaks.
You have this.
Small period where you have extremely competent technocratic government with this guy, Vario Draghi, who is still to this day in Europe, sort of seen as the savior of Europe.
Save the euro competence, competence, competence.
It's another time experiment.
But that falls for two.
And then we get to Maloney and Maloney is there not because she's more right wing than anybody or better at something.
But Maloney was the only one who hadn't been given a chance yet.
And Italians love to give.
People a shot.
And so they look to the place that had been off limits for a very long time since World War Two, which is the true Italian far right.
She comes out of neo-fascism.
She is.
She's the real deal.
I mean, she went to like this strange.
I was reading the book.
I was like, well, I knew nothing about this.
As a teenager, she was in kind of like a Mussolini youth group that was themed like the Lord of the Rings.
So, yes, essentially.
Yes.
So.
So it's kind of like Jewish summer camp, but for Nazis.
And they do some cosplay.
They do some Hobbit cosplay.
Instead of Ben and Jerry's, they eat.
So I've talked to Georgia Maloney about this at length.
And it seems to me there is nothing she enjoys more on Earth than talking about the Hobbit.
Right.
Like and I'll tell you why.
And it's actually sort of fascinating.
So the Georgia Maloney story is this.
She's 15 years old.
She's in a working class neighborhood of Rome.
She has a complicated family history.
Her father left.
She's raised by a single mom who, to earn extra money, starts writing romance novels under a pen name, Josie Bell.
And writes like a hundred of these books.
Maloney told me they were all.
They actually didn't make much money, but they're hysterical.
I actually know one woman who collects them now.
Her goal in life is to get all a hundred whatever Josie Bell books.
Anyway.
So Maloney is 15.
Fifteen years old in this working class neighborhood.
Something is going on in her life.
She's unhappy.
She wrote at the time that she was overweight.
She was quiet.
She knocks on the door of the neo-fascist party in Italy.
And that's a very odd thing for a girl in this neighborhood to do.
Right.
So that to me is still one of the big questions.
The why question.
She's never really explained it.
You know, she talks about because of the corruption in the country and they had just killed a, you know, a crusading prosecutor the mafia had.
And she felt that they're really the only people standing up for it with a neo-fascist.
Maybe.
But I just feel like there's something else.
She gets into this party.
And in this party, there are no heroes allowed anymore.
Think about it.
Like if you're a neo-fascist in the 1990s and you're a teenager, who are your heroes?
You're not allowed to have Mussolini as a hero.
There's all these sort of creepy ideologues who wrote these very strange esoteric books.
One guy named Julius Evola.
Who's who Bannon actually knows quite a lot about.
Yeah, I was just going to say, I only know about that because I saw his fucking book in Bannon's basement when I was writing about him.
Yeah.
And I've talked about a lot with Bannon.
But Evola is like a very scary thinker.
Even the Nazis were like, I think Evola is a little far out there.
They're like, we can't really do this.
But anyway, so they're reading all this weird stuff, but they don't have like a text, a founding text that they can really get behind that isn't taboo.
And then a version of the Lord of the Ring appears in Italy in the 70s.
Right.
And they glom onto this big time.
And so by the time Maloney is there as a 15 year old, the 90s, this thing has become like biblical.
Right.
So the Lord of the Rings for the hard right in Italy is not just a story about like elves and dwarves and hobbits, which when I read it to my kid, it was when I watched the cartoon when I was a kid.
That's what I thought it was.
For them, it is basically the story about about them, about, you know, people who are alienated and who are victimized and who are really just people like good people, the hobbits who now have to defend, you know, their identities.
Right. Dwarves are dwarves and elves are elves.
And no one should you know, no power should change that.
No sort of European Union or overarching power should stop a dwarf from being a dwarf.
So it's they extrapolate from this fantasy novel, all the sort of political feelings that they have and it becomes their their most important text and hers.
And one last thing on it.
She actually when she get on the phone with her friends, like in the party, their code names were like Frodo.
And and she dressed up as a hobbit.
She'd go into schools to try and get kids to like get over to the right wing a little bit because Italian high schools.
Public high schools are extremely political.
So so to show that, like, hey, we're here to they might dress up as hobbits because they thought that that might be more sort of persuasive anyway.
So it was a weird scene.
Yeah, they don't study called, you know, the bribery listeners like hobbits and deplorables and the guys in their basement, like he kind of appropriated that is like, if you're a weirdo, you know, we're taking over, you know, these whatever, you know, more dressed the bankers and, you know, the people that look down on you, et cetera.
There's like a little bit.
Yeah, they did.
They did this weird thing also in the 70s before Maloney's time where they they actually started these hobbit camps.
If you were like a young neo-fascist, you'd go to the hobbit camps and, you know, you'd be into fantasy and stuff like that.
But you'd also be into really hard right politics.
And their anthem was this song, which was actually from the movie Cabaret from the play Cabaret.
It's the scene if I don't know if you remember where some of the Nazi youth get up and they sing.
This song about the brighter tomorrow.
I think it is.
And it's a very ironic dark scene in the movie.
They just took it and they were like, yes, this is us.
And that became their anthem.
And so Maloney still like remembers that she went to a sort of reiteration of that in the 1990s.
So that's where she's coming from.
It's kind of like the anime fascists now that you see online.
OK, well, let's fast forward to her taking over.
She takes over as prime minister.
And I think the conventional wisdom.
Was that this is like Orban, right?
That she's going to have Italian Orban.
And obviously, you know, there are always little differences, but like that, that was the direction we go.
And she like gradually goes a different route.
And, you know, again, like I said, why I want to have you on one of the thoughts I had a couple of months ago is, is like, do I like Maloney?
Kind of.
I'm just going to read you a list of the things that she's been doing recently.
She denied the aircraft for the Iran war.
She's been pro NATO.
She's been pretty good on Ukraine.
All things considered, defended Pope Leo against Trump, fought back at Trump, called him a liar.
And none of this stuff has anything to do with Italian domestic politics.
If I can average person in Irpinia, that doesn't probably do anything for you.
But like for me, I'm looking at all that going.
This is kind of like a best case scenario.
So what what am I missing?
How did that happen?
Can you just kind of talk us through that trajectory?
One thing that's important to understand before getting the specifics of it is sort of.
Italy as a whole, as a country, right?
It's actually a pretty conservative country.
It does all these experiments, right?
It'll try Berlusconi.
It'll try five stars.
It'll try the super technocrat of Draghi.
It'll even try the super far right candidate in Maloney.
The deal is, once you get in, you're normal, right?
Don't change anything.
Don't mess with our inheritance laws, right?
Don't mess with our taxes.
It's a very conservative place.
You can do whatever you want.
You could say whatever you want, but don't do it.
And in fact, I think the main criticism of Maloney is that she's not actually doing much.
So it wasn't exactly shocking to me.
me that once she got in she was immediately moderating right she moderated her language
and there are certain things on immigration and things like that she's tough right she's definitely
right wing but um i mean the right wing stuff she's still doing is you know like hijab laws
like uh you know dealing with islam immigrants lgbt stuff immigration and maybe there's other
stuff which if you're maloney in italy which is a pretty conservative country it's really easy
right like it's give a little bit of red meat every now and then to your base but broadly people
are going to agree with you you know she's not um she's not advocating anything really beyond the
pale right so she throws some red meat and everyone sort of she still has numbers you can't adopt as
you know gays can't adopt in italy but i i think that was always true i don't think that she
changed it was hard i mean she has made it a crime she has made it a crime so she's criminalized my
family
so it's not nothing i mean it's not nothing you know it's not nothing okay so i just want to
acknowledge i'm not like standing maloney here i'm just saying compared to the baseline
you want like an orban mussolini mashup that we were talking about it's better than that
okay yeah yeah yeah but i think on the on the geopolitical issues i think you're right and i
think that she has been um she's been moderate because italy wants their uh their leaders to
be pretty moderate right and um they like the idea of her being this sort of bridge
to first orban which sort of worked a little bit like she got him to do some things in the
european union that he didn't want to do and then it was georgia maloney's going to be the bridge to
trump and that worked a little bit less well because you know she tried to build a relationship
with him he said all these like effusive sort of embarrassing things about her about how fantastic
she looked and things like that she went along with it it got kind of psychosexual though for
like both both when he was praising her and then when they had a breakup it was like he was trying
to act like she was a single woman and she was like she was a single woman and she was like she
was a single white female stalking him there's a lot of weird stuff from the trump side you have
to know georgia maloney she's just not going to take it right so when he did his usual thing like
oh she's stalking me she did this very sort of funny direct-to-camera thing where she's basically
just went at him really hard and said you're we don't understand why you insult your allies and
that you cozy up to bad guys and you know really hit him i think she does this very maloney thing
at the end she goes and one thing you need to understand you know we in italy we don't
beg to anyone right and like put the eyes out and it was just like okay that's that's the real maloney
she's back and so the bridge is over right which sounds like i'm talking about the bronx but i'm
talking about like georgia maloney and um and trump and so i think that what she has done is
two things that i think are really important and i think the jury's still out on this whether this
is good or not so going back to burlesconi burlesconi's big innovation if you get rid of
all this sort of scandal and all this sort of scandal and all this sort of scandal and all this
and everything like that in order to govern the first time when he made it in 1994 he needed more
support so he brought in what he called the fascists he said we're going to legitimize them
we're going to constitutionalize them they have been not allowed to participate in real italian
mainstream politics since the second world war burlesconi brought them in betting that he would
basically moderate them so then we get to maloney and the question is is maloney
the proof of that right like has she proven burlesconi right that he took the far right and
over a long process of decades he produced a georgia maloney who is who was you know knocking
on hobbit doors when she was 15 but is now you know a very mainstream center right leader in uh
in europe you could argue the only thing i would say though is the second point which is georgia
coming into power also does another thing so italy likes its
politics very moderate it has enormous guardrails about what you're able to do
other countries don't right other countries allow you have a much stronger president or prime
minister you can do more things right georgia maloney is a pioneer for those people so if you
look to germany and afd if you look at le pen in france they point to georgia maloney and they say
well you could do it in italy why can't we do it here and is she still playing footsie with those
leaders i know that she
plays nice with macron and at the you know eu meetings and stuff but she's doing stuff behind
the scenes to boost them like jd vance does here for example no i don't think she is i think well
i think she and she and macron legitimately hate each other but they'll play they'll play nice but
they legitimately hate each other's guts she's always been a little weirded out by the afd
and um le pen is different but she's always sort of kept some distance from them also she's very
sort of wild
she sort of sees what might be a bridge too far sometimes and keeps distance but i think the big
question with maloney is has she and i guess you could say has bro sconey earlier have they opened
the door to something else in europe and the return of nationalism and mitterand i think in
france one said if nationalism is war in europe yeah and i would say the bro sconey plan failed
and that he got used by the fascists and just because maloney ended up chilling out does does
not prove his his theory right because he's a fascist and he's a fascist and he's a fascist and
he's a fascist and he's a fascist and he's a fascist and he's a fascist and he's a fascist and he's a
fascist and he's a fascist and he's a fascist and he's a fascist and he's a fascist and he's a fascist
could have gone the other way right and i do think you're saying this now with us and in some ways
maloney in herself and her party represents like what i think are the two post-trump possibilities
for the gop which is that like the best possibility is what maloney is now which is like somebody that
does nationalist culture war issues at home because i just think that's baked in but does not do trump's
craziness abroad like cozying up to dictators and creating wars with canada right like i think that's
the best case scenario but i think that's the best case scenario because i think that's the best case scenario
but like a bad version is whatever the bet bag real or whatever right i mean maybe not him exactly
but like some more you know somebody that channels the populism and is and he's even more of a true
believer about it you know and i don't think that trump or roscone had any control over what that
monster becomes like that's you know right and i yeah i mean i think it would be um naive of us to
say like well maloney's been okay for a few years for four years so that's it's okay everybody let
him go but i think that it is a data point right it is something like it's a real example but i don't
think it's like a settled example i think that we will now see as the politics evolve here was this
maybe you know like i said before is this just opening up the door to something that we're going
backwards for you know that's maybe dangerous you also covered the vatican while you're there so i
want to close with a little talk about the bulwark pope pope leo we don't have any proof that he's a
subscriber but a lot of the demographic signs point to it i feel it
yeah and uh i know you you wrote about like being there and seeing like the american pope come out
and you know you kind of covered this and a lot of these similar ideological fissures were happening
in the church that was happening outside you know what you're covering you had the rad trads and
like cardinal burke which is more whatever conservative if you want to call it ban and
i hate to keep like invoking him but whatever like that side of the church and you know you
had pope francis obviously that came from the more liberal wing and
i don't know i mean who i don't think anybody really knew i didn't know certainly like what
would succeed him and you know certainly could have been somebody and more of a benedict moles
and it ends up being leo who's both kind of an ideological successor but also american which
carries so much with it so what was just just take us behind that transition and what you were seeing
there up close yeah sure so i mean i've been covering the vatican for 25 years and so i've
covered four popes and the one rule was that you can't have an american pope because there was too
much power in one place and so it was sort of a given there was you know there's there's a couple
of like vatican truisms one was that if um if you've been promoted you've really been fired
and i doubt it's the other one that's how they get rid of people yeah so i mean covering francis
first of all was really um you know it was sort of thrilling and fascinating because he had this
amazing project and he was really passionate about it and he was really passionate about it and he was
you know he was very political right i think everyone knows that he was political but he was
a really political guy and really did not like um also did not really like the united states i don't
think i didn't trust it you know i will say that like my one like reporting uh success ever he was
on my short list so uh leo so you know that's something uh you know it's the one time i've
ever gotten to have him in the pool no i was so you know i was there i was i i had a feeling it
was going to be that day and i called my wife who was with her kids and they were with her kids and
my kids uh our kids and and uh they were like you know two kilometers away and i was like get here
now and she's like no there's time i was like there's no time it's gonna happen right now in
fact you know so they were in the in the piazza too when he was announced and my son says that
he was standing next to an italian priest when leo came out as the american pope there was a
it astonished everybody's like what you can't have this right so it was it was shocking i think
as far as who leo is and what he's doing i think he's very much in the footsteps of francis i really
do just so that those of us that have you know sometimes it's like we have such an american view
of everything and everything's about us and all this but like there was some sense out there that
like that you know you said this rule there's this rule that wasn't going to be the american pope and
it was something like
that it was because of what was happening here
that there was a feeling that not only was it okay
OK, but that is maybe necessary. Is that too is that too much, do you think?
Or is it, you know, it's one of these things where is it about like these big meta narratives or is it more about, you know, favor trading and vote counting in the, you know, among the cardinals?
Well, he checked a zillion boxes, right? He's, you know, he's he sort of ran as a Peruvian, right?
Because, you know, he's he also has Peruvian citizenship. And so a lot of the cardinals didn't even know he was American.
They're like, wait, he's American because he presented as Peruvian. His Spanish is flawless. His Italian's great.
But why? Because he feels himself in in in a Latin American context.
I do think that the European cardinals especially didn't really understand what was happening in America with Trump.
And they I think the idea of having a native who understood America from Chicago, that didn't hurt.
Yeah. Right.
I also think.
I also think it didn't hurt to have an American who understands, you know, fundraising and money.
And and I know this sounds sort of like a put down on the Vatican, but competence and like management sometimes is a little uncharitable to Leo.
But sometimes he like struck me as like a like a Microsoft VP. Right.
He was just like extremely he's just extremely.
The successor to, you know, the successor to Steve Jobs.
Yeah. Well, not even Steve Jobs.
But just like middle management, right?
Like, but the successor, like the person you always put in after the.
Got it. Yeah, I remember when I was like talking to some cardinals about him and lots of other people excited to find out everything about him.
And it was very hard to get like a meaty anecdote.
And one guy was like, well, I have something really good on him.
And I was like, all right, finally.
And it was like he's in a meeting.
He listens really well.
And I was like, he gives good meeting.
That's that's it.
Right.
So, you know, it turns out and I think what we're seeing in real time is the guy grow into the job.
Right.
And and which is really interesting.
He's young.
So he's taking his time.
But I think Trump accelerated his timetable.
Right.
And I think by calling the pope like soft on crime was weird.
And and that sort of brought Leo out of a shell a little quicker, probably than he wanted.
But he just seems.
Like he's he's growing into the job with A.I., which is central to what he views as his mission.
He's named himself after the prior Leo was during the Industrial Revolution.
He sees that this will be just as, you know, destructive to the to the labor force.
And he wants to basically be that pope.
So, you know, he's he's an interesting guy.
All praise from from this chair, the bulwark pope.
We're we're so far no disappointment.
All right.
I need some tea.
They didn't give you any good anecdotes about Leo.
But could you give me a good anecdote about the gay lobby in the Vatican?
I just want to know something.
Just give me something.
Oh, yeah.
Sure.
All right.
Well, let me see the best ones.
So I hung out.
I hung out once with this this guy who was who's terrific.
He's a fluent Latin speaker.
Right.
And so he came up.
He was a he was a priest in southern Italy, realized he was gay and then was like, all right, I can't be a priest.
This is like, you know.
This is I'm living a lie.
But as right as he's about to quit, he gets a call from the Vatican, like the top office in the Vatican.
And so he goes to Rome and he goes into this great office.
He's in the Latin office of the Vatican.
And he just told me.
And who knows if he's telling that, like, I believe him.
But like, you know, I I'm not, you know, it's tough to verify.
But he said, and I don't know if this is the gay lobby, but he almost was a gay lobby.
Like he said, he did so much damage in the Vatican.
He slept with so many guys with the Vatican that that he put the number like 80 percent, 80 percent of the Vatican.
I was like, that seems hard.
But gays are known to exaggerate a little bit.
You know, we're a little flared at something.
But even if it's 60 percent of the Vatican, that's a lot of sex.
It was.
But he was he was great.
And he told me all the nicknames that all the cardinals give each other.
It was it was it's like a fun sexual nicknames.
Not even like.
Um.
One was the devil.
Right.
Because one cardinal who, you know, we can't name, but we certainly who was.
And and then just sort of being catty about, you know, the hairstyles of nobles who come to meet the pope.
It's a great scene.
It's clearly not the whole Vatican.
And this guy was fantastic.
But, you know, I think he had maybe a little bit of an agenda.
OK, but when he got there, well, you didn't finish the story.
You got called in.
And then what happened?
Did he get promoted?
He got fired.
Oh, he got.
Busted looking at stuff on his computer that he shouldn't have been looking at.
And one of the cardinals who was his mentor, if I'm remembering this correctly.
So it was like, you got to know when to look at the computer and then when not to look at the computer.
It wasn't like, don't do it.
It was like, come on, man, not in the office, you know.
And but I think that he got walk it walk away money from the Vatican.
If I remember correctly, maybe even the pope.
So, you know, Francis famously, who am I to judge?
Actually, you know, give give me here some of the Italian.
What are the what was the charge?
Was that how you said it?
All right.
So for charging is OK.
So Francis, let us not forget when he was alive, was still a very old guy from Argentina.
Yeah.
Right.
And so my read on the.
OK, so for for charging is basically a made up Roman slang word for.
And I guess it's bags.
Right.
It's bad.
Right.
Death slur.
But like the cardinals were all.
Using him.
Right.
And I think what I think it was a trap.
I this is my I don't know.
I didn't report this out.
But my guess is it was a trap that the conservative cardinals were saying, like, there's just too much for charging.
There's too much for charging.
And like and he and Francis always sort of wanted to be sort of down with the Romans.
Right.
Because he only read the Roman hometown newspaper.
So I think he was just like, it's a cool Roman term.
It's like a slang term.
And he used it.
It's like when I start saying mugged or stuff, you know, I'm starting.
I'm trying to pick up words and don't know it.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And it just sounded bad.
And it was bad.
It was like it was a slur.
Right.
And so so he says it the first time.
And I actually know that, like, he got called in by people I know who were trying to smoke.
But you can't say that.
Like, it's a slur.
It's bad.
It's bad.
Right.
It's like explaining to you the grand uncle or something.
But then and he's like, yes, I got it.
I got it.
I got it.
And he like, he came back and said it again.
Right.
And that's when everyone was just like, oh, this guy's just like, I mean, this is not
ideological.
This is just an old guy.
Yeah.
But anyway, it was very fun.
I appreciate it.
Jason Horowitz, the book is The Italian Job, A Reporter's Memoir in Rome.
Is that right?
I'm going from memory.
Is that the right subtitle?
I think it's an American reporter's memoir in Rome or a memoir of an American reporter.
I don't know.
Basically, I'm an American reporter.
You don't know your own subtitle?
Subtitles.
It's The Italian Job.
The Italian Job.
Go get it.
It's out in two weeks.
That's Jason Horowitz.
I appreciate it, brother.
It's good to see you.
Good to see you, too.
All right.
Thanks so much to Sarah Matthews and Jason Horowitz.
Really appreciate it.
Thanks to my guy at BJ's Lounge.
If you're ever in New Orleans, you should go check out BJ's Lounge.
He did me a solid last night.
And everybody else, we'll see you tomorrow on another edition of the Bulwark Daily.
Peace.
I'm still fighting for you.
In my own long suffering away, you were meant to watch my private ceremonies all in the dark parts of rooms.
Tries.
The Bulwark Daily is brought to you thanks to the work of lead producer Katie Cooper,
associate producer Ansley Skipper, and with video editing by.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Hero Bread offers low-carb, high-protein alternatives to traditional comfort foods, making it easier to enjoy familiar meals while supporting health goals.
The product features zero to five grams of net carbs and up to 19 grams of protein per serving, with options like sliced bread, bagels, and tortillas.
Hero Bread eliminates stiff, unappealing baked goods by offering soft, flavorful, and convenient options that fit into daily routines.
A 10% discount is available using code IHEART at hero.co, promoting accessibility and awareness of the product.
The transcript highlights concerns about media control, free press suppression, and the rise of state-aligned media under Trump, signaling a broader threat to democratic accountability.
Polls show a shift in Republican voter identity, with a decline in Trump support and a rise in identification with the party, though skepticism remains about whether this reflects true political change.
The rise of figures like Georgia Maloney in Italy is seen as a parallel to current political trends, illustrating how far-right movements can evolve into mainstream, moderate politics over time.
The political environment is increasingly shaped by nationalism, propaganda, and media manipulation, with growing distrust in both traditional and state-controlled outlets.
Summary:
Hero Bread presents a solution to the challenge of enjoying comforting, familiar foods without compromising health goals. Its soft, flavorful, low-carb, high-protein products—like bread, bagels, and noodles—allow consumers to enjoy meals like mac and cheese or grilled cheese while staying aligned with wellness objectives. A current 10% discount using code IHEART makes the product more accessible.
The broader discussion in the transcript goes beyond food, focusing on the erosion of free press integrity under political leadership. Sarah Matthews, a former Deputy White House Press Secretary, explains how the White House has taken control of media access, banning outlets like CNN and Politico, and expanding influence through state-aligned media such as OANN and Newsmax. This move undermines independent journalism and amplifies propaganda, especially in the context of Trump’s media strategies, including the launch of Trump TV.
The erosion of press independence is seen as a dangerous trend that threatens democratic accountability. Meanwhile, polling data reveals a shift in Republican voter identity, with a growing number of voters identifying as Republicans rather than Trump supporters, though this may not reflect a genuine shift in political loyalty. S.
landscape, noting how far-right movements like Georgia Maloney’s have transitioned into mainstream politics, signaling a broader trend of nationalism and political manipulation. These developments suggest that both media and political systems are being reshaped in ways that prioritize control and loyalty over transparency and accountability.
FAQs
Hero Bread offers soft, fluffy, flavorful products like sliced bread, bagels, and tortillas with only zero to five grams of net carbs and up to 19 grams of protein per serving, making it a healthy option for people following comfort food habits without compromising health goals.
Hero Bread provides up to 19 grams of protein per serving, making it a nutritious choice for balanced meals and snacks.
You can enjoy cheesy mac and cheese, a stacked sandwich, or start your day with a fully loaded bagel—all while staying within your health goals thanks to Hero Bread’s low carb and high protein profile.
Yes, Hero Bread has only zero to five grams of net carbs per serving, making it suitable for low-carb diets and ideal for those managing blood sugar or following specific dietary plans.
Hero Bread is currently offering 10% off orders when using the code IHEART at checkout on hero.co.
Hero Bread avoids the stiff, dense texture common in traditional baked goods, offering a soft, fluffy, and flavorful alternative that feels more comfortable and satisfying.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.