Sarah Longwell and Pedro Gonzalez: Meet the Young MAGA Edgelords—and the One Who Got Away
1h 29m 15s
Sarah Longwell’s new book, *How to Eat an Elephant*, offers a sharp analysis of how Trump’s political rise has fundamentally reshaped the Republican Party, particularly among younger voters. She argues that modern conservatism is no longer rooted in traditional economic or social policy but instead in identity-based, racially charged, and gendered ideologies. These include deep anti-immigrant sentiment, hostility toward women’s political agency, and a worldview that frames politics as a racialized battle for the future of America. The book highlights that young Republicans, raised on Trump’s messaging, view politics through a lens of tribal loyalty, often embracing toxic rhetoric and conspiracy theories. This shift is evident in their preference for figures like Tucker Carlson and Candace Owens, who embody the movement’s values of hostility and emotional intensity. The analysis also extends to emerging dangers in the digital age, particularly how AI could be weaponized to spread misinformation, deepen polarization, and manipulate public discourse. The conversation with ex-Maga writer Pedro González reinforces this narrative, detailing how his personal journey from radical right-wing activism to disillusionment reflects a broader pattern of ideological entrapment. Both contributors emphasize that Trumpism is not about policy but about identity—specifically, a cultural war defined by racial purity, gender exclusion, and anti-globalism. They warn that such movements, once entrenched, resist genuine reform and instead thrive on tribal loyalty and emotional polarization. The book ultimately serves as both a critique and an optimistic call to action: that democratic renewal requires understanding these deep-rooted dynamics and engaging with voters not through hostility, but through empathy, transparency, and shared values.
(upbeat music) - Hello and welcome to the "Bullard Daily." I'm your host Tim Miller. We have a massive show for you today about redemption and rebirth, figuring out how to beat Maga. We're gonna do an install tour and have feelings. You guys don't know what you're in for today. In segment two, an ex-magas stall where two once attacked my jawline on Twitter it gives just a second interview since Flipping. So there's gonna be some interesting stuff there. But more importantly, in first, she's the publisher of the bulwark and she has a new book you may have heard of. It's called "How to Eat an Elephant." One voter at a time, nom, nom, nom. It's out right now, Sarah Longwell. I've right here. - Let's eat, let's eat, brother. - Ah, let's eat. Some announcements, you're the publishers. We gotta do business really quick. We added a show in Dayton. A Benefit Show, a fundraiser for the Haitian community there. That is in two weeks, September 25th. So get your tickets, come spend the weekend in Ohio. Everyone loves to spend, you went to college in Ohio. You can find things to do there for a weekend, right? - I'm gonna be a Kenyan next week for the book tour. And I gotta say, Dayton is lovely this time of year. There's a lot of you, if you live in Columbus, if you live in Cleveland, drive to Dayton. It's not that far. - It's not that bad. It's a nice little hotel, little boutique. The bulwark.com/events. I'm gonna go to Springfield in Saturday too. So come make a little weekend out of it. I'm also live tonight on YouTube, watching JD Vance. And this is, Sarah is paying me extra for it. It's Sass or Pay. I've gotta watch JD Vance tonight. So come hang out with us. And Subsec on YouTube and Subsec tonight, we're live. I didn't watch last night because that was at the chance of rapper concert. I was kind of getting blessed up. So Sarah, I got the jest, I guess. It seemed long and rambly and Trump is bribing people. But do you have any big takeaways from last night before we get to the book? - I mean, I'm in a bit of a book tour news vacuum. But I'll say, obviously I'm still addicted to Twitter. So I've seen the clips. My main thing, I gotta get Andrew Weisman on the phone. Is it legal, Tim? Both of us very much not lawyers. We didn't even ace the LSATs like JBL. But I can't imagine that offering $5,000 to everybody who if Republicans win, that feels illegal. And now, remember when Elon offered a million dollars, he basically did a raffle. That was for voter registration. Like, it wasn't if Republicans win. Like if my team wins, everybody gets to go to the casino. So I just would be shocked if that is not a legal violation. - Yeah, people have messed it. - That the law matters that much. - Yeah, we don't, no, we don't, we're not gonna play his voice. But $5,000, he said, if the Republicans win the House in the Senate, it's a little strange because Republicans have the House in the Senate now. But if they win it again, it's a bribe to vote for him. $5,000. Also at this morning, offering a new $500 rebate check for people, I don't have the details on this yet, but something related to Obamacare being bad and you get 500 bucks. It's the subsidy replacement, I guess. - And on top of those doge checks that are still in the mail, I think. - Yeah, Catherine pointed this out. Catherine Rampell, he had promised a 5,000 stimulus check via the doge dividend, $2,000 via a tear of dividend, $1,000 via savings from the expiring health care subsidy. So people lose their health care, but we save some money so people could go check for that. Another 5,000 dividend, if the Republicans win the midterms and a new $500 rebate check, all of those has been preven promised. None have hit any mailboxes. And I love that they call it a dividend. It's like, ooh, if we call it a dividend, it's not socialism. You know, it's not all the things we attacked Obamacare for the stimulus 10 years ago, 'cause it's a dividend now, you know? - Yeah, totally different. - So they totally different. He said, it's just like in a business, you get a great windfall in your country and you give people bonuses. Like he gave Natalie the human printer, $45,000, just as a weird bonus. Hey, you said something on TV. You and I were both on a cold the other day. You said something on TV that I actually wanted to disagree with you about a little bit. - But you weren't gonna do it on cable, you wanted to do it here among friends. - I just didn't get a chance if she'd given me another shot at it, I would have come for you. But you were talking about how, it doesn't feel like Trump wants to win the midterms, right? It feels like he's doing everything in his power to just like screw Republicans. And I disagree with that. I just think he's unwilling to do the substantive things that would put him in a better position to win. Like he's unwilling to get rid of the tariffs 'cause he wants to be in a trade war with Canada. He is unwilling to end the war in Iran 'cause he doesn't know how to get out. Now we're into deep. So the substantive things that would change the trajectory for Republicans, he's totally unwilling to do. What he is willing to do is he's willing to digerrymand or things to hell and be in a gerrymand or war 'cause that was a, you know, mid, I go redistricting, was a real move on his part. And he's willing to offer a $5,000 dividend and probably deploy ice to the streets. Like he does want to win. I do think he is afraid of the oversight that comes with a Democratic Congress and also with the idea that he's a loser. So that was the part I just kind of disagree with. - This is a classic Kenyan debate club note, which I like, which is, hey, I'm gonna take this thing that you said the other day, characterize it unfavorably. (laughing) And then, I wanna see my quote. Do you have the transcript? I wanna defend myself from what I said 'cause I don't, I think that maybe I was saying that his focus was out of what was wrong, you know? And he's focused on these other things. He doesn't really care that much about winning the midterms. And that's, I think true. I think he cares about himself more than he cares about whether or not John Hustet wins in Ohio. I think that's almost verbatim what you said actually. I think you literally said Hustet. And I guess, and this is why it is a, it's a friendly debate 'cause I, maybe you're not saying that he doesn't want to win, but I do think he's afraid of oversight, but I do agree with you also that like, it's not because he cares if the Republicans win 'cause he's like on the team, he just doesn't want Democrats to now hold the gavel on anything. - I have a little bit of a contrarian point that's related to this. And so I'll concede, it's your book lunch week. So I'll concede that you have me on that one. I may be overstated by case because he also announced last night said that he's gonna be traveling around a lot. And this I think goes against what a lot of the conventional wisdom was. And for me, for example, I thought God, 80 years old, even get tired, jet lag, I just figured he wasn't gonna do it, but he's claiming he's gonna do it. I do think like the talking point you see and kind of anti-dem circles is like, we love that, get out there. And I, my feeling that is a little bit, I don't know, isn't that the best thing you can do? I mean, he's delts these Republicans a horrible hand. You know, he's at the bush line. The focus has not been on people's pocketbooks, right? But like in a midterm, isn't like trying to nag and congeal the people that are still tribally Republicans and devoting like kind of the best thing that he can do? Yeah, I mean, it's probably different 'cause he's president this time, but he also did this in 2022, you know, for his candidates. And it didn't work. And that to me is the big indicator is that I've always felt this way that Trump has to literally be on the ballot to turn out the people who are the Trump-only voters. And I'm just gonna slip in a little book anecdote here where right in my introduction, I talk about that deal book summit when we came and did a podcast right after it. But, you know, Kevin McCarthy was in the green room that day and he was sort of preening around being like, Trump is such a turnout machine. Like, and he knew all the county level numbers for what Trump had done on turnout. And I went and looked back at like my hometown and how many voters Trump has added to the turnout. They don't turn out midterms. Like, Trump can go hold the rallies. They might even go to the rally. But like, when it comes to turning out to vote, they just like can't be bothered. And so that would be my argument, but also to your point of like, isn't that the best he could think he could do? Probably a little bit helpful to juice it. Especially just given the, you know, where the close elections are this time. I wonder if it's been this in 2022. It's like he's going out to try to help carry Lake or whatever in Arizona, which is a swing state. And it's like, that might be backfiring, you know, going to, I don't know where he'll get, Fort Worth and West Iowa and stuff to try to juice turnout. I don't think it's like really going to work, but on the margins, could it possibly help some of these shore up a couple of these red states where he won by 10 or 11 points and we got coin flip races, maybe. And so I think it will cut both ways in some way. I'll just say like he can go to Iowa. He's way underwater in Iowa. Like the farmers are getting cooked out there. And so like, I wonder what it will be like for him. I mean, I guess they're still, I'm sure there's mega faithful who will turn out, but like he's not as popular. Like as even he might have been in 2022 when he was like, yeah, the election was stolen for me. Like, what is he going to campaign on? I'm very excited for his entire campaign. Right in people. Yeah, that's right. They give people checks. I mean, like this is it. And he's going to talk to him. It's simultaneously we are really scared about the socialists, the Muslim socialists, especially scared about the socialists. And also, I'm going to put mass spend in the street, round people up and then buy companies and give you the money back in a dividend. That's a cash bribe, 'cause that's not socialism at all, 'cause we're really scared of socialism. We don't want socialism. We definitely don't. So I'm just going to give you Trump. I guess that's true. He will go on.
on sort of the anti-socialism tour. Hey, one thing I wanted to ask you about, 'cause I did see this, I saw the 12-cut testimonial from John Fetterman, and I just wanted to bat this around with you a little bit, because I look, I'm sort of been generally enraged by Fetterman, but I'm also like, I don't know. I said, Fetterman was a bad move, guys. This is like this kind of like dirt baggy, whatever, just 'cause he fakes looking like a working class, like the Downwardly Mobile Guy, you know, I was a big Conor Lamperson. So I've always just been like, yeah, Fetterman sucks, but him going and doing this glaze of McCormick at Trump's Trumpopalooza for the midterms is a level of party betrayal. And like, I know he's got it in his head that this is like, well, this is country over party stuff that I'm doing, and he thinks he's a hero on it. That is the one good headline that Trump really got out of this Trumpopalooza, like the whole rest of it, but being able to get a Democrat to show up and say, we've all got to come together, I know that people listening to this podcast will be like, who cares about Fetterman? No one will take him seriously. It's a real signal to people that like, no, no, no, what Trump's doing is fine. - Yeah, the Democrat that had a stroke and can barely talk is the one that really connects with Trump. - He sounds terrible in that video. - Terrible, and he does sound terrible. I mean, he really, he should be getting himself help seriously. I think that Fetterman, I have two thoughts. It enrages me even more of that Tom Tillis and John Cornin and Bill Cassidy. It's like, well, John Fetterman is just like having a tantrum with the Democrats. There's really nothing that substantive that he disagrees with the one besides Israel, which I'm about to get to, but like, it's like the whole Trump era for 10 years. There's not been one Republican house or Senate person that does an act of flip. I mean, some of them haven't been retired, you know, but like, it's crazy that it's going the other way amidst all of these horrors. And the thing about Fetterman, I like a little moment of clarity last night, this is kind of an obvious point, but I think that framed up like this, like explains just how petty it is. If you asked him, what are his substantive complaints to the Democratic Party, he said this in the video. It's like, he does not believe in socialism, an anti-Americanism, and he wants to support Israel. But like, his home state governor is the most emblematic Democrat in the country on those issues. Like Josh Shapiro is not a fan of socialism. Josh Shapiro is pro-Israel. He is about to win in a landslide as a Democrat from his home state. And instead of like, siding up to Josh Shapiro and saying, hey, we've got this tag team of pro-Israel, capitalist Democrats in Pennsylvania. Like, he's decided to tag up with Trump and McCormack because it's fucking petty and childish. He doesn't like Josh Shapiro personally. - He doesn't like Josh Shapiro. That's right. - The people have been mean to him. That's what it's all about. - That's right. I mean, this is, look, I've said this before and Federman is clearly in a very narcissistic phase of his life. I very much doubt he runs again. He might flip just for like, shits and giggles because it's about who's nice to him. Like, he is like so susceptible. And I don't know about people with strokes or anything like that. But when I watched that video, the 12 cuts and he still sounds that bad, like-- - For people who don't know what that means. So if you have a short video, you put up a politician or you'll notice this, I'll give you a little hint behind the curtain here. You'll notice this sometimes when I do a monologue at the beginning of this episode or being of a podcast and like, I'll stop for a second and zoom in on me or zoom out. It's because I fucked up and said something wrong. - Yeah. - And so over the course, like yesterday, I had an eight or nine minute monologue. Maybe two or three of those. Federer had talked for one minute and there were 12. - Yeah, they're called jump cuts and they're used to cover mistakes and there were 12 of them. And then what they got out of him was still stilted and clearly like something is on well. And so you just think these Republicans like sidle up to him and love on him and man, hey man, I love your sweatshirt and shorts. And now suddenly, like, they've got him in the palm of his hands. I was skeptical for a little bit of the flipping. I'm not anymore. - It's interesting. So we'll get to see because I'm going a little bit the other way. He put out a statement about how he ran as a Democrat and he'll continue to be the 51st vote as a Democrat this morning. And I think that I think that John Federer may like desperately wants to be the 51st vote as a Democrat. Like I think the thing that would make him give him the most joy. - He wants the Joe mention, yeah. - As to annoy the Democrats. But I think if it's not that, if it ends up being 50, 50 or so, I do think a switch is very possible. But I think you'd love to be the deciding vote on stuff. And boy, will people not like John Federer and after that? All right, let's do some book stuff. How's it going? How's the book tour going? You're an author now. It's been two days. How are your vibes? - Actually, the vibes are incredible. - Are you reading all the reviews insanely? - I read some. - Before you go to bed. - I read some. I think JVL put it in the triad to drop a review because suddenly there's a lot of them and they're from our people and they're lovely. So they do make me happy. So yes, I've given them a look, see. Look, I want feedback on the book. I'm excited about the book. I work hard on the book and I feel like it's a good book. Like I think it's a fun read and that there's a bunch of interesting stuff and I think it was a good chance for me to expand as opposed to talking for one hour. Like we do all the time on News the Day, like my theory of the case. 90 Second Streetwide with JVL was awesome, packed house. So we had to tell their security that they couldn't stop people from yelling like their security is really tight there. There's a lot of them and they're like, if somebody shouts out, we remove them immediately and we're like, ooh, it's not gonna work with our crowd. They're kind of, they're into it. - They're shouting. - They're shouting. And we love that. We love that. - There was more a bulwark Sarah Origin lore in the book than I expected, which I liked. - Yeah. - I particularly liked the Sarah Origin lore because I knew most of it. But it's nice to be refreshed. And there were some little monkeys I didn't know about high school Sarah. And then you did include how I was depressed when the bulwark got started, which I, which is nice. That's a nice thing to have me mention. - That's true. - That's a nice thing to have me mention. You love it when your one mention is in the book is about your depression. But you know, that's all fun. - Do you feel sad about that? 'Cause I remember I asked you before I said it. I was like, was it fair to characterize? 'Cause this was, you guys got to remember. Like, I do wanna tell you about Tim at this phase, right? Like, Trump had won, you, it was really hard for you. And it was like hard to get you back in the game. Like you didn't really wanna get back in the game for a bit. Mel and I came and saw you a couple of times. (laughs) - Yeah. - It was like my buddy had moved to Oakland. You got long hair. I came to see you and I was like, oh no. Come on, man, you're in a dark place. (laughs) But you bounced back. Look at you now. - Look at you now. - Look at me now. I wanna talk about two things that are relevant to the next guest on the show. And we'll put links on that. Obviously you just buy the book and read the whole thing, but you've discussed a lot of the kind of main, I think that listeners of this podcast know the gist of Sarah's theory of the case for the Democratic Party. So I think we can table that. I wanna talk about the Trump's children's chapter and kind of how you see the future going. You know, 'cause I think that there is a lot of us out there right now, people are already, people like to get ahead of themselves already. Talking about the post-Trump future. And the book does have a section that kind of looks into where things are going and the young magas. And you even mention kind of the Bernie Broda Maga pipeline and the next guest kind of fits that mold. So anyway, what did you come away with on that? - Yeah, I mean, a lot of the book is rooted in the focus groups. And so we do focus groups with young voters all the time. And young Republican voters. And I think one of the things when I said with the chapter, Trump's children is not about Don Jr. and Ivanka and Eric. It's about all of the young Republicans who don't remember politics before Trump. Like Trump showed up in their formative years and they think that that's what Republicans are about. And he's taught them all kinds of horrible lessons. Some of it is just like the vice signaling as a way to show you're on the team. The things that come out from the young Republicans of so and so, and it's all this Nazi talk and putting people in ovens and this edged lord, anti-Semitic, anti-black racist garbage, is like the way that you show you're on the team now. And the people who are rising to prominence, like when you talk to these young voters and you say, okay, well, who do you listen to? Snick Fuentes, it's Tucker, it's Candace Owens, all day long. >> They like gates when he was around. Gates was not very much popular. >> Mac gates, that's right. And so there's a, when I say we're not going back to the Old Republican Party, I see this to some of the, to some of the olds, the people who, their Democrats, but the party of Mitt Romney was a fair party. And they were, okay, and they're like, well, maybe we'll get back to that. There are still a lot of people who labor under the illusion that we might go back to something like the Mitt Romney, John. >> No, absolutely not. And part of it is that this new generation is coming up. And they have been taught by Trump how to behave. And they're quite toxic. >> They're also not that, I mean, they're ideological along the vectors of like immigration, race, gender, right? More than any of the kind of three-legged stool conservatism stuff that you write about the book for when you were coming up in ISI. You know, it's not. I mean, for better or worse, in some places, like they don't.
There is obviously an evangelical element of it, but the center of this is not family values and tax cuts and strong military. It's like completely different. It's completely different. And I will say one of the big overlaps, right? It's interesting when you talk to young voters, young Republicans and young progressives sound pretty similar on Israel. Like there's like almost no daylight about young people. Like if you look at the polling for both parties, it might look different. But among these, this new generation, it's not different at all. They are isolationist in their foreign policy and they're anti-Israel in their foreign policy or they have sort of the, they shouldn't control us mentality. And they're also oftentimes more populist in what they want. Like they're more economically populist. And that is why there is the Bernie to Trump pipeline. Like the overlap there is real, especially among these young voters. It's the reason that Trump wildly overperformed with, and I also have to say that the gender divide here, though, is so stark. Like it's the dudes. And like when you do young women, they're all like, yeah, I don't know that I'll get married because like the men are like off the chain. Like they're watching the, their young male peers do the Trump dance and they're like, get me out of here. - You also talk about, you know, the travel of doom and the conspiracies on that these guys get drug into. And I wonder, you know, I'm about to talk to Pedro about this, but it's sort of hard to know myself. You can say why you were the one that broke away, but life is complicated and that takes deep reflection and time. And so like for you more as an analytical standpoint, like do you have any thoughts on, you know, what is a, what would be useful strategies for kind of like pulling this type of demo out? Like obviously not, you know, somebody that's in a mega hat and is an activist and, you know, like they've chosen a team, like they're playing a team sport, but kind of the broader demographic. - Look, I think that life and our times are always, there's back lashes and front lashes and you know, it's always churning. And so I don't think it stays static. And I think that you already see Trump's numbers, he overperformed with Hispanics, he overperformed with black people, he overperformed with young people. Like they're the first ones to go. Like they're the last in first out voters and I put young people as swing voters. They're one of my categories of swing voters 'cause they're just not fully formed yet. And so I do think that if the Democratic Party starts putting forward people that young people can attach to who where it's like they're not doing the woke stuff and they're funny, whatever, but they're also like, yeah, and I think we should have universal healthcare. Like honestly, I could see Joe Rogan in a post-Trump era floating back, certainly policy wise. And so I don't think that young people are lost. I do think though you have to deal with sort of the edge lordism and the racism that now is this like weird animating like in-group way of talking. - You had one section that kind of alludes to this and then you said something that alarmed me, which is this is a topic for another book. And I didn't like that you're already thinking about another book when you're writing about this topic. But I just meant I couldn't get into the whole thing. I'm not writing another book, go down. - You go in that A, I don't know, I'm just teasing you. It's about A, I certainly can't have you being on the best or less twice when I'm only on once. It's A, I of it all. And this is like the thing that I am really obsessed with right now, but also the most flimaxed by as far as like how to combat it. Like a lot of the advice you have of the book for Democrats are things in our wheelhouse, right? How to communicate better, you know, how to reach out to different demographics and engage with them. Like this is a tougher animal, which is like how to reach people who are getting information where they don't know what's true and what's false and where the other side is more willing to play dirty with it. And I was wondering if you had any expanded thoughts on that. Actually you got into it a little bit in the book. - Yeah, I mean, I think that part of it is because I listen to voters all the time and they basically don't know how to arbitrate information already. Like the line of, I don't know what to believe anymore. And like that's where the nihilism creeps in. They don't know where to get good information. They don't know what's true. And the A, I of it all is about to come along and make the whole thing a lot worse. The reason I said I don't wanna write a whole other, or I could write a whole other book about it or it's a whole other book is we don't know where it's going. Like I honestly could make that was, I did an event last night and Nick Thompson was there. And so he and I were talking about this. And the odds that AI is both like catastrophic. Like they figure out how to launch a nuclear missile and we all end up in the rubble is a non-zero chance. There's also. - About 10% including some of the people working on it. - Yeah, about 10% according to anthropics leadership. Hold on, side note. Can I just tell you how crazy it was that the end, like normally when you get somebody who comes out like that and says like we're all gonna die, whatever. The leadership thing comes out and says, ah, so junior employee, like you should can ignore them. Whatever, the leadership came out and they were like, yeah, there's a better than 10% chance and we don't know what to do about it. - And the next decade. Like you all should be an insane asylum that we should shut down your company. That is too high of a percentage. - It's too high. I don't know why anybody would be comfortable with this, but there's sort of this like in intermediary place actually where you could see some positive benefits of because it has this cumulative knowledge of everything when people are like, what is true and they're asking AI, they're actually getting much better answers than they get from their neighbor on Facebook, which is the other place that they were looking, right? So like it is this. - It is a low bar. We don't have a low baseline, we're starting from. - But I also had a ton of fears. So like I was talking about this last night, like I know listening to voters that they often say like that they're not that informed about a race and the number of people who are gonna start typing in, who should I vote for? To AI is about to be really high and people are gonna try to manipulate that, right? Like if you're Elon's-- - And our side is to try to manipulate it actually. - Totally. We're entering into an entirely new information battle that like the terrain is still pretty unclear for everybody. - I was thinking of this year. The day somebody had read it. I was talking about Corey Lewandowski in the next level and I talked about his stank breath again and then someone on Reddit started to thread this. Like is it true that he has bad breath? There's not just Tim Stick, then another Reddit or answered. Yes, Tim one time got hit checked by Corey Lewandowski and his breath was really bad. And I'm wondering if that now gets into the AI system. You know now like for future, whether now like Claude, if ever asked about Corey Lewandowski's halitosis, we'll probably start to say yes. So good. - I think that might be true, you know. - We got to put good information into the system is what I'm saying. - Well, when I was young, you know, I, when I was on the road with Rick Santorum as I talk about in the book, he would get asked it. Every single book event he did 'cause he was on his book tour about the Google bombing that got done where they defined Santorum in a very gross and graphic way. Like it became, and it was like if you Googled Santorum, it gave you a definition that was related to the sex that two men have together when they're very much in love. - It was frothy. - It was frothy. - It was the word, frothy was the word. - It was coined by our guy, listener Dan Savage, shout out Dan, you check him out of Savage Love. All right, you gotta get through the train. There's so much good stuff in there. Everybody go get the book and you got anything else? Any other, anything you wanna leave people with? - Only that, you know, in the early days, when we didn't know what was gonna happen, it was like, just think about where it all is now. - You're a famous podcaster, we got books, JBL, let's human beings be near him. I just, I think, I wanna, you're thriving, man, you're thriving. - Thank you, sir, you are too. A lot of personal growth all around. We have a lot more work to do though. There's still in charge of everything. So, you know, the work continues. - That is where, one bite at a time. - The book is meant to be an optimistic pitch for how we get out of this mess. - Let's do it together. All right, I love you. I love you. - Love you, man. - Up next, something that's had a little less nice things to say about me. Pedro González, stick around for that. (upbeat music) - Right, and we are back. He's a writer and editor. You can find his work in Commonwealth, a nation, the spectator, and his sub-stack called Contra, you might not be able to tell from that list that he's an ex-maga. Do we do that now? He's an ex-maga writer. It's Pedro González. What's up, man? - Hey, Tim, thanks for having me. - I've been wanting to do this for a minute, you know? I've been on you. I've been trying to get you to do it because you started liking my tweets and retweeting my tweets, which was a departure from how you used to react to my face second the old days. - Yes. I was like, "I want to learn about your kind of conversion." And so for people who aren't familiar with your social media antics, maybe just give us a little speed date origin story of your ideology and what you are doing in Maga World when you are involved. - Yeah. Well, I used to say horrible things to you and basically everyone who was a perceived enemy of Maga. I guess the long and short of it is. I kind of had a leopard eating face moment, but not really. - Why did I help you begin? - Okay, sure. - 'Cause a lot of times we have the people that have, like if you look at us in the never-tumper world.
It's mostly people that were like moderate rhino squishes initially anyway. If you look at the whoever you want to say, the Joe Scarborough, the coals or us of the bulwark. You know, there's some exceptions to that, but like for the most part, it's kind of people that are in Republican politics world in the establishment. And so it's like not that surprising that they would be unhappy with this assault on the establishment. Like, your story is different. You're kind of more reflective of like the original Trump core. As I've heard you explain it, it's like you were kind of Bernie Browish. Yeah. Some people went that familiar with this charm. But kind of then more appealing to like the paleo conservative, you know, side of things just more like an isolationist conservative and you're kind of a young guy that had some anger and like the Trump thing resonated with you. And like that's kind of the core of the type of person that Trump first appealed to. And so the fact that like you've exhalered on it, I think is, is, is notable. So anyway, maybe just talk about kind of that trajectory. I think the anger part is like a big part of it. Like, you know, my entry into politics and, and political discourse was late in the sense that I was, I think I was 20, 26 when I first got into it and it was also kind of unorthodox in the sense that it was something that I did because other doors had closed and I didn't know what I was going to do with my life, basically I was at a point in my life where I was really frustrated with this one thing, this one and only thing I'd have wanted to do right. And in the background, you have this, obviously, this, this growing populist sentiment in the United States, culminates in the election of Donald Trump. And you know, for most of my life, I'm kind of just like an ambient California liberal with like somewhat end coherent views because it didn't necessarily think too deeply about it. I liked the way that people like Bernie Sanders talked about Wall Street. I liked the way that he talked about, you know, mainstreaming left behind. It made it very easy to naturally be like, disgusted by someone like Hillary Clinton. And if not support Trump initially, at least view him as kind of like, this is a symptom of something that's been sort of bubbling beneath the surface like people in this country are very angry. They, they feel like they haven't been listened to. And this insane, like, demented clown person is sort of like their Tribune. So during this, like, really tumultuous transitional period of my personal life, the country was kind of going through one too, right? And I basically looked at writing as a way to do the thing that I was not able to do that I'd always wanted to do. And like the long and short of it is like, I had spent most of my 20s trying to get into the military. The only thing I'd ever wanted to do was to get a career in like, this sounds really funny talking about it now, but like something like special operations that's all I wanted to do, right? It's a kid that was like, I knew that that was the thing I wanted to do was to serve my country at like a high level somehow. Again, you can't talk about that without sounding cringe and embarrassing. Sure. It's like the thing I wanted to do, right? But I was born with a benign medical condition that was, it's a permanent decal for like all of the armed services, which means like, you can get waivers for some things. You can't get a waiver for what I have. And it doesn't matter like if you can run fast or swim fast or do a lot of Pulitzer pushups, like Navy or, you know, Army bureaucracy, whatever. It's like on paper, they just see, this is a condition that's a hard list of permanent decals. You're not getting a waiver. I spent most of my 20s trying to get a waiver and banging on whatever doors I could, making whatever connections I could. I was involved with like a different recruiting pipelines that were designed to help people get into these programs. But then when that door was shut, there's still this sense of like, I somehow want to continue this like, moss cause thing that I always wanted to do, which is like, defend this country that I feel really attached to, you know. And writing from a conservative political perspective, naturally, it seemed like a natural thing to do. Again, this is like, I'm trying to do this and be on the nose, but you became a literal keyboard lawyer. I did. You know, that's why it's cringe and embarrassing to him. No, I, I'm very self-aware about that. Yeah. And, you know, this is like in the 2010s, so like at the peak of like the culture wars are starting to really take off and it was so easy to fall into like the angry, right-wing populous space because it's, and you can also see it in my early writing too, like it's very combative and very confrontational. It fit the thing that I wanted to do and I believed in it, obviously. This is true. I think for a lot of people on the populous right, and it's why it's so hard for people to like, you know, you can call it the sunk-cost fallacy, but I think this is why it's so hard to get out. It's because it's not just like you're, you're part of like a party or whatever, like you're part of a movement. You're part of something bigger than yourself. You're part of something that's in an existential battle with not just political opponents, but enemies who are not, you know, we're not debating of a policy. We're debating over competing ways of life. And so as you start writing your kit, I mean, you end up kind of getting deep in, I guess what you'd call kind of mega establishment world. I mean, you're a Claremont Fellow, you know, you're kind of paling around with all these guys. You like, you know, would exchange texts with JD and Tucker, it's just kind of like talk about that process getting in scourced in that world, you know, after Trump gets in. It was, it was weird because again, like a friend described me once as like kind of like a forest gump on the right and that I just kind of fell into a lot of these things without necessarily like seeking it out. And so, you know, like, how did I get on Tucker? Basically, I tweeted something in like 2019 that he or one of his producers noticed, and I got a DM from like someone who had been on the show and they asked for my number. And then like, next thing I know Tucker's calling me and asking me to come on a show to talk about immigration. And you know, very similar process with JD, like one day, like he just just reaches out of the blue. And I don't think this is unique, like this happens with a lot of people on the right. And I've heard from people who are more familiar with the left telling me that this is kind of a unique phenomenon with the pop of this right, this sort of willingness to just sort of use the internet in particular like Twitter as kind of like a networking platform and to court influencers and kind of blurring the lines between professional, you know, I don't know, consultant or whatever and friend, right, especially when you're working in media. I mean, that was how I got sucked into that world and it was starting with writing in conservative Republican magazines, then getting picked up by a publication called American Greatness from by Chris Buscar, who's also very close to JD Vades. And then like just from spamming inboxes, getting published in like the Washington Examiner, the Daily Collar, you know, doing this on my own, just trying to get published and build my profile. And then just like I said, like little by little getting noticed and picked up, maybe that's true that it's unique of the right, the new right anyways, that it's willing to kind of take people and just elevate them based on, I don't know, they're allegiance to the party line or Donald Trump, I mean, it's a different factors, right? And the left is a lot of sociology you can do on this, but like left is more hierarchical and it's kind of funny that like the right rhetoric is more about like meritocracy and all those, but kind of like the left actually works more as a meritocracy and then there's more, it's more competitive. Yeah. There's a long line of people with resumes, you know, that could be, it could singularities for these types of leaders and like there was a vacuum there on the right in 2016 to 2024, right? And so a lot of people have to be able to kind of fill that. Yeah. Back to your kind of solid domestic story at the end, but I want to just, since now that folks kind of understand your backstory, I want to do a little bit more anthropology of what's happening in the movement first, as we sense like where we are now and it seems like, you know, who the hell knows what happens with Trump in the next two years, but there's this inflection point. I do think that we're trying to tease out the like this question of like, what is like the act or the actual earnest animating parts of MAGA, like what is part of just a Trump personality cult, you know, like the example I gave on a pod recently was, I think that it might have been reasonable in 2011 or 12 to say like the animating thing about the tea party was, you know, budget restraint. And you know, if you look back at that in 2018, that looks preposterous, right? And so kind of wondering is like, we look ahead, what are the central parts of the people that are going to not do what you did that are going to stay with stay and push it forward? I can tell you what I see and what I think are some important features of the movement and I think the two most prominent ones that it's not hard for like the average person to recognize is one race and two, maybe two or less should agree, sometimes it overlaps the sex. This is what I wrote about in the nation, that a big part of the Trumpian rights self-conception, a big part of how it justifies everything from abuses of power to corruption, to total allegiance, total allegiance to Trump or is, you know, presumed success or advance. The way that people are kept in mind is this framing of politics is not just politics as, you know, we understood it in the past, which is debates of a policy that sometimes get But again, this kind of existential battle for
the future of the country, but in his very specific sense, and what I mean is, and you kind of see this also with the rise of people on the right using the term third-worldism. It's this kind of marriage between anti-communism, which weirdly enough has been revived, you know, like Trump is trying to kind of revive communism as like a threat ahead of the midterms, but it's also being racialized. What I mean by that is that the real enemy of the right is basically minorities and immigrants and their white allies. And that's kind of how the right understands itself. It's like we're at war for the future of the country, but only in this very narrow sense, which is this kind of like white, it's so funny for me to say this stuff again because of my background is like, you know, like I was part of like the radical right, and like I was basically part of the problem, like that's the truth, right? Like I was part of the problem. I made these arguments, I amplified them and, you know, fast forward now and I'm telling you, like the right understands itself as in kind of like a racial conflict with its enemies. And that also, like I said, that also includes whites. That's why it's emphasis, like its main issue is immigration, but it's much broader. The intersection with communism is like this word that is not very popular on the right of third-worldism. Right? It's like, well, the third-worldism and those type, that types of communism kind of overlaps and then they're American-enabled, right? Or whatever. But it goes beyond, but I think it's important to understand that it goes way beyond like, you know, illegal aliens, whatever. This is very much like a very specific kind of conception of the American nation as like a purified white country against those who would stand in the way of that vision. And it sounds insane. It sounds like extreme to some extent, you're like, this is like, you know, like resist lives we're saying in like 2016, turns out they were right. But then you see like the propaganda that's coming out of the White House. You see like DHS making recruitment videos using like white nationalist songs, like it's not even up for debate. Like it's using propaganda that draws explicitly from white nationalist themes and memes and things like that. So basically winking at this crowd saying, we are your allies and then obviously, you know, every week there's like a report about some group chat or some individual who has like some like, you know, like Paul and Grasya, who there's a report about him saying something like, I have a Nazi streak. Like, and that's like super common for the type of person that gets selected and promoted within the Trump administration. I'm not saying that they're literally Nazis. I don't know. I'm sure that there are people that are, but this is how they think of themselves. And that's why this, this idea of this like broad, perpetual kind of racial conflict is central to the rights understanding. I want to come back to the sex part of it, but let's just like sit on the racial and globalized conflict a little bit because you wrote this really sharp take down. We were talking about this earlier about how you're, you were harsher to Mike Pence and the bulwark was, I think when his book came out. And one of the key points you make in that review is basically that like Pence was arguing that Trump became fully uprooted in Trump 2.0 and that there was some break between the real conservatism of what he was working with Trump on and what this new populist monster is. And in term two, and you say that that's basically self soothing. You're saying it sounds kind of insane to argue that the animating issue here is racialized conflict. Like was that not kind of clear in 20, like when he came down the escalator, was it not kind of clear from day one, like talking about the Mexican's bringing the rapists and the martyrs? I think there are elements of it there, obviously, and it sounds like in retrospect silly to even say like, you know, it's not, it's tough. I think that basically he was restrained by people around him. I think that his worst tendencies were restrained. I think that he was bad then in a sense, and he got much worse over time. But also the fact that he surrounded himself with loilists and the kind of person that those loilists tend to be, the ones who are kind of obsessed with this, like, you know, like Stephen Miller, and giving them more power in the second term. I think it's kind of like a witch's brew that amplifies all of the worst tendencies, not just in Trump, but in the movement. So in some sense, like I wrote, yes, it was always to some degree, even if it was a lesser degree present than, and it only got worse over time. But the point that I was making there is, you know, and again, this is like for, you know, rich or whatever for me to say is that for people like Pence, it's like, yeah, I mean, like, it's not a surprise that Trump was never truly a conservative. Like, all you had to do was listen to him talk. There were other things I wanted to include in that piece as well that kind of make this point, you know, there was a debate that between him and Ted Cruz, where Ted Cruz like slammed him for endorsing like European healthcare systems, a thing in particular, Germany. And Trump basically said, yeah, like I do think that we could learn from, you know, healthcare systems in countries like Germany. And Ted Cruz's response was like, see, he's not a real conservative. What people like Cruz in understand, then, is that was part of Trump's appeal, that he was willing to kind of break the mold on the GOP orthodoxy. It's economic orthodoxy, it's immigration orthodoxy. And I didn't include that point, I think, as I ran out of space. But the point that I was trying to make there is like, for Pence to say, like, well, we didn't know he was too conservative, like, it's just ridiculous. Like that was part of why he won in the first place in 2016. And I think that for Pence, it's a combination of him, like lying to himself or being misleading your dishonest or political reasons. But maybe also there's like guilt there that's like unresolved because like I noted in that piece, Pence's whole thing was kind of to be like a fig leaf to conventional conservatives. Right. Like, look, you're right. He's got weird ideas about economics. He says horrible things about immigrants, but Mike Pence is there. You know, and if Mike Pence is there, and maybe to some extent, this is true, like he'll be restrained. You know, like Mike Pence would not sign onto this if the guy was terrible. And I think maybe for Pence deep down, there's like a, there's something that he hasn't worked through there. And like, can't bring himself to confront, which I think a more contemplative person could have written a much better book for that reason. And I mean, like, I know it's hard, by the way, I'm speaking from experience. So, I mean, Pence, I think by going as far as you have gone, it's basically an admission that it was all, I was about to say that it was all for not, but actually worse than that. It's a great admission that you're an enabler of this thing that you now identify as this great threat. Yes. And it's much easier to, you know, kind of constitute a fantasy path where like it was the moment that they set up the gallows on the ball that like Trump broke from true conservatism and everything that Pence was involved with before that was, was a different thing. Not even there, by the way, I mentioned this in that piece, like I had to read the passage like twice because basically Pence not only sort of downplays January 6 as just an event, you know, there was the consequence of Trump's most passionate supporters as he calls them. But he basically frames Biden as much worse in the sense that Biden's policies, like his attempts to cancel student loan debt, were a much greater assault on the constitutional order than what happened on January 6, which is why he writes that like people that wanted a return to order with the election of Biden were basically robbed of that hope. And then Biden does like crazy socialist stuff. And then order was restored in 2024 when Trump won. So what are you saying, Pence, you know, it's like make up your mind. When it was Trump bad, was he bad on January 6? Was he bad in 2024? Was he bad on the campaign trail? Was he bad after he won? It's not coherent. And I really think that apart from the obvious answer, which is just, you know, I think he launched a think tank and there's, he's obviously trying to kind of stage like a recon keystone. Yeah. You know, it's easy. I know this crowd. I mean, there's many of these rich conservative donors that hate us at the ball works. It's like, is it because they just want to focus all of their anger on the left's excess. Yes. That's what the book does. Yeah. And you go back to your word soothing. Yeah. You're like that. It's a soothing thing to do to prevent you from having to kind of look internally. I want to go back to what we were on the, you know, kind of core elements of of Maga. And this kind of, I guess the, if you're still a man in four of them, like the more, you know, winning the poo in the Tuxedo version of this would be like this, the fight for Western civilization, which doesn't include a lot of the elements of the founding when it comes to liberal principles, but like is really more just about white, white ethnic and religious elements of Western civilization. So that's part of it. That fight. And then the other element you mentioned was the, was the sex talk about what you meant by that. Like trans or women's roles or the right has this like weird relationship with women where on the one hand, you know, for the longest time, it's been this, this movement that conceives itself as upholding the family as like the building block of, of any healthy society. But on the other hand, in the era of Trump, like, I guess you could argue that there was a kind of like chivalrous element to that position, right, that it's a kind of benevolent form of patriarchy. In other words, with reciprocal rights and duties, or excuse me, duties and obligations between men and women. And of course, if you're a feminist, you're like, well, that's already bad enough, like that's already implicitly very sexist and intolerable. Well, the right in the era of Trump, I think makes that look, looks very tame by comparison.
And because it's not just like, you know, the woman's true role as to be a mother, but there's there's a kind of like women are part of the problem when you look at like how they vote. They vote with their feelings basically betray us on issues like immigration because they have too much empathy and therefore women are To the degree that is possible. They need to be deprived of agency. They need to be kept at a politics. They need to be pushed out of a movement. They need to have his little influence over public life as possible and any woman who disagrees with that is implicitly somehow like contaminated my feminism and part of the problem and I guess you could say it's like not really a surprise that that would happen in the era of Trump right like this is not particularly a guy who's known for Yeah, women's empowerment. Right. Yes. Yes, and but it's just remarkable how ugly it's gotten in I guess a second term like how openly the right like Distains women like there was this record about the growth and like basically most of the jobs I think over the last year I've gone to women and Yeah, I saw this today. Just let me just give the back straight to those for people who have not like seen it online So a report came out basically that like an economic sport that said a lot of the job growth this year has gone to women Ken Paxton Sent this tweet. He goes thanks to President Trump's leadership American women are leading the way in our economic comeback Then there was this like huge backlash against him for that of all the things American Paxton about like a ton of right wing accounts One guy Joel Levin lost my vote and other, you know, Megan Bashman fellow talks about how he doesn't get it You know, this is all part of the feminist's plan to make women work and you know, this is a huge disaster Huge to see I just a ton of backlash against him for praising the idea that women are going back to the workplace one and if you took a closer look at the data It's like it's not really like what I saw it I was like well, yeah, I mean like they tend to gravitate toward some of the only fields that are consistently growing like health care So it's like this this makes sense But the reaction from the right I think is it that in that particular instance it gets it what I'm talking about this like psychotic Incoate anger directed at women, and I think like digging a little deeper there is Kind of a philosophical element to that which is what I alluded to that that women are kind of seen as like On the one hand the what the people that are sort of oppressing men and Subjecting them to the long house basically this this idea of like a social and cultural Panopticon in which women prevent men from really being men and you know are sort of demonizing boys from from early age and on the other hand that women are kind of seen as like the carriers of empathy Which is a weakness obviously if you're trying to cultivate like a hard right movement Well, you can't have women around who are like making us reconsider our positions based on our feelings right because then you won't be cruel to like immigrants you won't be cruel to mine orders And I think that's that's really fascinating Important and under-explore part of the right is this idea of of like we need to Reduce the influence of women as much as possible for these reasons So if you expand that out and you're projecting ahead politically and let's we're just assuming that Donald Trump has an either like decided he wants to try to stay or you know like some of the more crazy tail outcomes But like there's a normal Succession race. What you would say which I think feels right is as long as the next standard bear from the party is Billing to wage this war on foreign immigrants black and brown immigrants and their domestic white allies and as long as they You know are You know going to push for traditional gender roles and engage in the culture war on these fights where they prop out whether it be WNBA or Lindsey Clancy or whatever like as long as the right as long as they do those two things and They say Trump has been good like that's probably sufficient like that's mega, right? Like they can probably drop everything basically like tariffs and whatever whatever other like land of Trump thing You want to say as long as those three boxes or checks they're probably fine and that takes us to JD Vance And it seems like he's a good fit to me for that. I mean the the childless cat ladies, you know He is at this cutting edge of this the eating the dogs and cats He's at the cutting edge of that. He's decided that the true Catholic faith is anti-immigrant because Jesus met like love Your literal neighbor right like your next door neighbor was the only person you had to love Yeah, and you know, so he's got the family issue, I guess but besides that I don't know that makes me kind of feel like he's a better fit as As a successor than some like pundits laugh people believe what what do you make of that like Rubio? Yeah, absolutely Look back at the killings of Renee Good and Alex Prattie, you know, and especially in the case of Renee Good You saw these these two things come together race and sex like I don't know if you recall the vicious terms in which Renee Good was attacked after she was killed Like these were not fringe figures. It's like Matt Walsh basically saying that you know this this woman was like a disgusting lesbian and You know, she could deserve what she got and like and again like fairly mainstream figures all saying the same thing like if she had been like a true And proper woman she would have been home with the kids and this would have never happened But you know, she was like an uppity person. Of course, it wasn't even true right she was dropping her kid off at school Go back and revisit those tweets and you can see how psychotic it was like every aspect of her life was just like alone up and Made into a sort of like a poster child for everything the right hates and then it happened again with Alex Prattie You know not not a female, but a white guy basically and Seeing more importantly as an ally of immigrants and therefore deserved what he got because he got in the way of law enforcement None of that was true like in both cases The Renee Good and Alex Prattie stories and the right were completely wrong like detachment reality But in particular the acts Alex Prattie case Vance was one of the people who helped promote this false picture of him as an assassin Right, if you remember Steven Miller referred to him as a would be assassin I believe and and Vance boosted that and then when he was confronted about it by reporter Who asked him like would you like to like issue like an apology or like a statement to the pretty family and Vance smirked and said for what? When I saw that clip I was like this is gonna blow up on the right because it's him demonstrating that he just did he's a cold-blooded killer Right that he that he's cruel that he's willing to bear witness to violence So that the right can get what it wants and then smirk at like the stupid reporter who asks him if he feels any sense of Contrition like when I saw that I was like one it's gonna go viral into like Vance knows exactly what he's doing He knows what crowd he's playing to and like I can see someone like him being a much better fit as a successor to Trump They're Mark Rubio like like I don't like Rubio either, but whatever you want to say about Rubio It's hard to see Rubio Stooping as low as Vance's morally and more importantly trying to wink at this particular crowd of people, you know that includes Individuals on the right who look down on his his wife and his children because his wife is Indian is in laws or immigrants And his kids are mixed like you have to think about what kind of a person like Vance is willing to try to court That part of the right that sort of looks down on your family because they're not purely white And you're thinking to yourself like I need to make sure that I'm sending the signals out that these people know I'm on their side and that they can trust me to be like the based torch bearer for Donald Trump You know, I told you I wasn't gonna make you come on here to do burn book But obviously as you're kind of coming out of this JD You know are all navigating this right and and JD was like one of me and then he becomes one of you right and then you know So he's moving different directions, you know, and then Tucker ends up having to leave Fox Like it's your communicating with them like what's your sense like the way in which they're processing all this I'm like the path that they're taking to try to appeal to the audience they need to get to Tucker is very difficult to to get a read on when you're talking to him It's never clear that you're talking to like a real person It's the best way I can put it. It's like he's always sort of wearing a mask There there are some features of Tucker that are like consistent But then there are other aspects of him that are really slippery I think it's true that he's probably like unwell Psychologically like I did this is like I hate to sound like an armchair psychologist whatever But I mean, but like do I really need to you know like you just had a guest on whether you're talking about how like Algebra is like fake and like Jewish nonsense and that it's not a real math, you know and Tucker is like giggling as his guest is saying this stuff like you okay So I guess it's not that outrageous to suggest that he's unwell. I think it's gotten certainly worse since he left Fox If he was effective rhetorically of Fox is because of his writers and the people around him that like Hamden men and controlled him and once those guardrails were moved like Trump. He just you know went insane or rather revealed that he was always kind of like out there and He's just very dishonest and very slippery Tucker. I'll get to dance like in one moment, you know He's like I love chop at the next moment. He says I hate chop and this was him before he becomes a big surrogate for for Trump in 2024 he's he's telling People in private he's saying in public that he's like well not actually much less on public but in private He's like he hates chop, you know, he's like done with you. I like for yeah, he's like he's telling you know He's like anybody who's had a private conversation with
talker myself included about Trump. During that period we'll tell you he like he hated and he got the guy was a joke. And then all of a sudden like after leaving Fox, he gets in bed with the Trump family. By Trump family, I mean like his biggest advertising deal after leaving Fox. I think his first and biggest one was with a company titled on junior. I believe it was called public square. And then he, you know, goes to the campaign trail. He tells Russell Brand like, you know, I love Donald Trump. And, you know, he's also he's the peace president. And then, you know, he gets elected. And then he's just back and forth. Right now he's off the Trump train. But importantly, he's promoting Vance now. You know, he's like, guys, shucks, I was wrong about Trump. He's a liar. I could never I never saw that coming. However, you should trust me when I say that Vance is like the real deal. And Vance is very similar to Tucker in that he's very slippery. Like I remember conversations with him about about this type of character on the right who years ago was was scrutinizing him precisely because of his family background, like, you know, your wife is not white, kids are mixed, you know, can you really be trusted to be like an ally to like the hardcore immigration restrictionists who for them, immigration is not again, merely a policy issue. It's it's an existential. It's whether or not this country will be more or less white. Can we really trust you, JD? And I remember him like just talking to him about this particular type of person, I basically just characterize them as like racist libertarians. Basically, this faction of the right things like there actually there's no real issues with like the economy. There's no real issues with anything. There's just too many brown people on America. And like if we just have fewer brown people like everything would be fine. And I remember like he was receptive to that. This is like the critique he wasn't receptive to. No, to what I was to that framing. And then yeah, I mean, that was like three years ago. And now he's he basically said, you know, like he occasionally like when he's for like absolutely forced to we'll say something like I hate Nick Fuentes, whatever. And that's it. He's he's very reluctant to criticize that part of the right, which just a few years ago was attacking him. He's very reluctant to criticize them because he understands that on the right it's called counter signaling. Like he knows that counter signaling could expose him as someone who's not really on board with the program. I want to kind of go over that because that's an interesting journey because it's like you can see great vans. And we can see this publicly and you're just like having a handful of conversations privately, but like kind of grasping at like, you know, how can I ingratiate myself into this mega edge like through influencers that are like you like just not outside the balance of acceptability, right? Like what are the ways that we can kind of, you know, how can I court them? One of the ways that I can talk about this like it's a strategic thing. It's a little sociopathic. I think it's a strategic effort, you know, and it's like he goes through that effort and then kind of comes out the other side being like, you know, the only way to do this is actually just to go ahead and fully body up to the most race as far to the right because like there's unless you abide by the no enemies to the right posture, like I'm going to end up being, you know, Mike Pence to for somebody else. Yeah, you'll you'll become suspect. You will not be viewed as like a reliable ally who's willing to do what needs to be done. And I mean, there's this slogan that briefly became popular on the right. It was hard in your heart. It's funny. Yeah, like I think a bit often. I think it was maybe right after Trump got elected. It's sort of making the rounds online. People just random influencers saying like hard in your heart, kind of like get ready for what's coming in Trump 2.0. And I think that that's one way to understand Vance is that he that's that's what he has done in a very cynical way because he knows that if I want to be like the undisputed air like if I want to cast out any doubt that I am the the true and only like air at the Trump. This is what I have to do. The one other thing in advance on to get your pick your brain on is this kind of alignment with the protect side of things, kind of AI, acceleration and Tiel. Again, like I was trying to parse out what mega is and ends up being like, you could imagine a version of mega that is like in a lot of ways Ron Paul was kind of proto mega more than some of this other stuff. And there's some differences of course, but like you could imagine a version of it that is like a little more libertarian and it's kind of hostile to the surveillance state, maybe an era Alex Jones type of more of an Alex Jones version of mega. I thought like still has the racism still has some of the other, you know, the conspiracy theorizing but like is more hostile to, you know, big tech. And that doesn't seem to be what's developing with this crew. They seem to be accommodating themselves quite well to the kind of volunteer flock AI world. Part of my like introduction to the right was unusual in that I started by reading a lot of paleoconservative thinkers. And there are a few things that I think anybody is familiar with the Paleos know off the bat. One is they're typically a lot smarter than like the contemporary right winger, whether you disagree with them or not, like a lot of these guys have PhDs, they're more cerebral. And one is also very paranoid. And so, you know, pick your paleo made a lot of influence on people who don't like know the philosophical side of this on on pat you can and on on Paul, like in different ways, but like that that's sort of the part of the part of the movement. Yeah. And paleos matter because a lot of the a lot of paleo ideas and rhetoric influence the the new right and the age of mag. I think David Brooks published an essay in the New York Times, and which he said that like Sam Francis anticipated a very controversial paleo thinker anticipated everything that Donald Trump would say and do like decades before it happened. But again, you read the Paleos and you'll find deep skepticism and and basically paranoia about everything, but more importantly, the federal government. And you can see it also in the language of the use regime, Leviathan, never government. Again, this is important because like after Trump wins and Trump 1.0, even although Trump is one, like this kind of rhetoric is still very popular on the right. Like you look at the books that were being written at the time, like Trump versus the Leviathan. Right. Because like the deep states all still in there. They're still doing all of these machinations, even though we won. Yeah. And like I remember when I was a Claremont fellow, you know, they had this table where they had like free books and shirts. And I think this is like 2021. And the books all had names like that, you know, dismantling the administrative state. But then there were these shirts in the middle of the table that said hot gulag summer. And it was like an inside joke, the idea that like overall rebels involved going to end up in the gulag, whatever. I think it's remarkable that that has all completely gone away. And Trump 2.0. There is like no sense of like maybe the thing that we're calling a regime of Leviathan is going to be turned on us at some point. It's like no, give Palantir the keys to the kingdom, give, you know, Elon Musk access to like all the federal government's data, let him run wild. Like we have nothing to worry about. Our guys are in control. If you're afraid of the government in the era of Trump 2.0, it's because you're, you know, you're your brown as the right would say, I'm not joking. Like that's actually the language they use to frame these issues. Like hating Palantir is brown coded. Like that's actually what these people say, or that you're like insufficiently hardened to what must be done. Or the third is that you're like, you know, subversive in some way or I get in the fourth to be that you're like you're leftist basically. And therefore you should be scared because we're in control now. And it's just this complete inversion of the rights moved toward the government in Trump 1.0 and Trump 2.0. And then again, like you said, like this, this also this complete reversal and how the right and how it conceives itself in terms of its relationship with the government, going back to these like influential Palios who like, like I said, like although they're obscure and forgotten, I think most of them are even dead, like we're very influential on the Maggie movement. It's interesting. It's kind of like Rand now is the person that's like speaking out against this as sort of the whatever like actual ideological successor of that kind of part of the Palios. Okay, we could do a whole hour on that and let's see. Commenters, let us know if you want to. We do have to close on Pedro. And I couldn't have you on without doing this. So get excited. I don't know. We want to talk about your, you know, you falling off the horse and all that. Here's the distance that we've gone to spend this 45 minutes together. Are you ready? Here's an exchange of tweets you and I have five years ago. You criticized a young gay youngkin staffer for having pronouns in his bio. I replied defending him saying he seems like he's doing a good job. I don't know what's wrong. Why are you making fun of a gay youngkin staffer? It escalates from there. You replied, oh no, I've upset the jawless guy from the bulwark. I replied congratulating you on your conversion therapy. You said you're actually married with kids and I'm an androgynous creep adjacent to pedophiles. I said your kids will read this someday in cringe, bro. You said I won't have to explain to my kids how I couldn't find a better job than being Bill Crystal's housecock. You went on to talk about my mutant genes and I learned a word that I've stolen actually after that. You made fun of my physiognomy, my undecernable male characteristics and then you went for the jawline again. So that's not great. I mean, there's definitely some homophobia there. And then there's the famous, or at this point, you referenced it a little bit beginning on the leprosy eating facemel with you had, or like the bright bar people turned against you because you're free to send to us and link some texts.
And which you said some anti-Semitic stuff use the word negris Like that's kind of a long journey from that in 2021 to this in 2026 being here and saying like the main issue With these guys is that they're like in a race war like how do you how do you explain that journey to people? How much time do I have? As much as you know, that'll just kid man I don't I don't want to make light of this stuff that I said back I think it was disgusting and and like I'm not just saying that because I feel like I need to like I don't know it it's so difficult when you're like in any capacity like a public person that says things that public You know that are public or like as you said my kids will someday read because When you decide to go a different way it's always kind of you it is like face saving or like ass saving or like insincere but for me like For me and again, this this sounds funny and retrospect supporting DeSantis was An expression of my dissatisfaction with with MAGA and not just Trump but with MAGA and in some ways I was as delusional as Mike Pence and that I thought maybe there's a different way we can take you know maybe like Whatever you might think of DeSantis. He wasn't Trump and and his movement. I don't think would be his is he wouldn't enable people The way that Trump does maybe I don't know. Maybe again. Maybe this is residual Delusion, but that was why I supported him in other words I was already very disaffected and looking around myself and just being like what you know What have I been part of for the last however many years and they became a lot realer for me when People that I knew started to amplify these attacks on DeSantis and his wife like that DeSantis was a pedophile that he like cheated on his wife when she had cancer like I remember sort of Just being again Sounds so funny, but like shocked that people that I knew is like fellow travelers like wait a whole body like okay I get it. It's a primary but like really like you're gonna call him a pedophile You're gonna say these like horrible things about his wife and again It's like yes because he said that he did that with Ted Cruz, right and it's all Trump So that's when I became like even more outspokenly not just anti Trump and anti MAGA, which is why I I I came under the crosshairs and I got obliterated I remember the day that that happened. I was giving a talk to some like I don't they were like Hill staffers like young Hill staffers about Basically how to try to do good Under evil empire and then like as I'm like giving that talk. I'm like my phone is like blowing up Evil Empire is like a dramatic, you know way of looking at like DC, right? Okay, and then my phone's like blowing up and The black bar story has dropped in in that moment like Arthur Schwartz don junior like there's a coordinated push to just get this out there I'm and you know and the Tucker calls me and like he tells me like basically why it happened and who was responsible for it and It's just like who am I to become you know like public enemy number one for MAGA, right? It was just so bizarre that they decided to just single me out and destroy me and like I That's the question that people will ask me is like why did they do this to you like not like you didn't deserve it But like no offense, but you're not a big deal like so why did they decide to crucify you in a very public way? I don't know Maybe the most obvious answer or the clearest answer would be to make an example out of somebody like this is what happens If you if you step out a line and try to leave Then we'll do this to you to like this disproportionate response like my wife who's not political at all Was at home with our son and she was pregnant at the time with her second and she like held it together when I got until I got home from that trip And then she just like broke down because she was like for someone who's not political at all like not interested in politics And and she's like, you know, what are people telling me about you like like I don't understand why is this happening and This period of like introspection that I was already going through intensifies and the attacks continue by the way They didn't just stop it by part and by the time that trump gets reliked it I'm like I'm off like I'm I mean I was already off But like I'm I'm really off to the point where I'm like starting to turn not just on like obvious bad actors But like starting to be more critical of people that were formally like fellow traveler like Claremont based like now I like I think Claremont is a terrible organization. I think they have no principles at all I'm saying this is a form of fellow like I think they've completely sold their souls to Trump and Trump is them But what got me to that point was Trump's reelection and then the way that the right try to get people to revel and cruelty Like it's not just we're doing mass deportations, but we want you to partake in it at a distance with like, you know, ASMR deportation videos And it was like very clear to me that it was always intended to dehumanize people, but like in a really Usually sick way even for Trump people, right and then the killings of Renee good and Alex pretty happened and It just sort of like hit me that if that were me like if I were driving home and some like untrained like more on who works The federal government were like pull me over because of the way I look and you know Like drag me out of my car because he doesn't like a response that I make and then just executes me right there All of those people that we're cheering for Renee good and Alex ready to be killed would do the same for me or for anybody Like this is a mindless dangerous movement That is enabled by you know the president of the United States and I mean at that at that point for me It was like I'm not just gonna limit like criticism to like people that again are like obvious bad actors But like the entire conservative movement that I've been part of and I don't think can can be saved in the foreseeable future I think people would hear that and go though. Okay, but like Would you have gotten to this point if you had not like had forced introspection via like text message doxing? I mean like you are participating in a lot of the cool stuff. I mean like I said it started already with DeSantis I was already kind of like slowly Re-evaluating everything including like the the nasty rhetoric that I've taken and What I will say is that being like thrown out of the window of a 10th story building Which is what that felt like was necessary like it was one of the worst things that happened to me It's really like hard to To I don't know if you've never been there. It's hard to explain with that what that feels like. Yeah It's a I still haven't I don't think I've gotten over it But at the same time it was good in the sense that it like it Guaranteed The funny thing is I probably still cutting on back like this is the important thing about Maga is like you can actually go like and there are examples of this But if you say guaranteed internally guaranteed within you that you couldn't do it again because like frankly It would have been excited to have you back probably the lead to text were made were based. I know right for how they understand themselves No, but for me it was like I'm done for good. There's no going back burn whatever remaining bridges they are But but also like a huge part of it That was not political was how I understood myself As a father, you know again going back to what you said I kind of just like was able to step out of myself. I thought like Would my kids be proud of their dad? Looking back on like what I had done with like Maga and if I continue doing that and the answers probably like no, I don't think so and I've only spoken about this like twice one was with the nice people from the Know Your Enemy Potter now with you Which is why it's kind of like disjointed and like it's like pulling you know out of my guts, but This will sound very sentimental which by the way I think is good and I think there's a there's a real reason why the right hates like empathy but it was focusing on Being a father like focusing a lot more on my kids on my relationship with my wife and This sounds very funny, but I read the road during this time. It's a book by Cormac McCarthy It made it tremendous like if I were to say that that book Contributed to like saving my life. I would not be exaggerating as funny as that sounds But it really made a huge impact on me and just impressed upon me that there was like there was no going back and the only thing that mattered was was what I do from this point on and And a big part of that is again doing what I think would make my kids proud. So I don't feel like that's all sentimental at all I when I wrote about the kind of the people that From the first term and and why we did it Alyssa Farah who was in there and took quite after January 6th like I I didn't know her at all and We sat together for like hours just kind of drinking wine and like talking about why you know She went in and why she flipped and like this is where like she ended in the exact same place and I was moved by that But like at least me feeling a little bit like How do I put it? I was moved enough by it to use it as an insult for other people In hopes that it would shake them as evidence by our exchange But like at least me wondering like why there isn't more of that. I don't you know I don't know. Yeah, because I think that a lot of you're listening and like a big part of what our project here is It's like how do you pull people out? And it's like I don't know, you know if some at some level you hear the advice So it was like well if you shine the mirror in their face and if you tell them, you know if you call them names Like that just makes them dig in deeper But then like what's the alternative? I don't know. Do you have any any deep thoughts on that like how to get other people together?
kind of reckoned with the ugliness of it. - I don't think there's a formula that you can reliably apply to shaking someone out of it. I think everyone's different. And like I said, there are examples of people that were de-Santis partisans and were de-fenestrated. And then basically apologized to Maga and were allowed back into Trump world and got jobs in the Trump administration. It all comes down to the individual. It depends on your character. It depends on your situation in life. Are you a father? How do you understand yourself as a father? Initially for me like being a dad in a weird way, like made me more conservative, but in the wrong way, because I was caught up with culture war stuff. And it's funny, it was actually talking to somebody recently who had his first kid and he said, "Having a child radicalize me." And I said, "Stop." It's very important that you understand that you separate politics from being a father because I'll tell you right now that it can make you miss what actually matters. And what you should be focusing on is not protecting your kid from the left or whatever, or like liberals, but actually just being a father and being there for your kid. As opposed to it becoming sort of like part of your overall political aesthetic of personality. Which I think the right does. And I think this contributes to why some people when they're attacked, double down. But I don't think there is a formula. - So you have no advice for us on how to make new paydress? - No, I mean, I don't know, I mean, I think shame is a pretty powerful motivator. So like I mean, the things that you said at the time, they didn't bother me but looking back. I mean, when you're confronted with all these statements like that, it's like, yes, they were right. And so it helps, I think in that sense, but there also has to be kind of like a something that triggers it. I think there's a, there's a neo-conservative, maybe Ergen Crystal, who said that a liberal, I'm not sure if it's Ergen Crystal. - Mugged by reality? - Yes. - Yes. - Served as a liberal, it's been mugged by reality. You know, it's very similar to that. Like you have to be kind of mugged by reality as a member of MAGA in order to realize that you were wrong. And okay, this is not a complaint, 'cause like I deserved it. But I see cases where this is a type of story you see, unfortunately, pretty frequently. It's like someone who voted for Trump and then like someone they love gets deported. - You're right. - And they say like, I didn't think you would happen to me in the response. - We laughed at them. - Yeah. - It's hard for me not to do that, Pedro. - I know. - It is hard for me to do that. You could try to shame me though. Maybe I'll think about my behavior too. That's fine, I'm open to that. But like, he also ran three times on this fucking thing. I don't know, it's part of the way it was. It wasn't gonna be on my topics for you. It was gonna be part of my things. It was like, you're a spanic. It was obvious from the start that he was gonna be targeting Hispanic immigrants and who knows how that ends? And I don't know. - No, it's I hear you. - That's not good to rub it in their face. But isn't it also like, okay, hello? - Well, I can try to address that question. I don't think it's below the belt. But the thing about how to respond to these cases of people basically getting what they voted for good and hard is like, I think it's okay to not, it's a funny term to use your okay. It's understandable for people to do that, to say like, well, you got what you voted for. - Yeah. - I think as long as the possibility of them being allowed back into the other side is not closed off. Because ultimately you want to convert those people into allies and to people who will help you vote this stuff out. Otherwise, like, what's the point of all this, right? That's what I do. And conservative is privately complained to me, but I'm like, I can't, this is really the final straw for me. I can't take it anymore. I'm always like, are you gonna vote Democrat? Are you going to actually put that frustration into practice and like encourage someone else to get out, get yourself out, or like vote damn or whatever? And if the answer is no, then I'll just tell them, then like, I'm sorry, then like you, I don't think you're basically just venting to me. Like, I'm not a therapist. It's understandable to kind of like, do the, you know, vibrate your face thing. But at the same time, like, I think there should still be a path for people like that to come back in and help you somehow, to be part of like the opposition. But on the question of like identity, I don't think it's unusual that it's actually not unusual at all, but there's been a large constituency of like Hispanic man who supported Trump and in particular because of his, not just despite, but because of his immigration platform. And there's different reasons for that. Well, first is Hispanics, Latinos are not a monolith. You know, like Cubans have different concerns than like Mexicans and Venezuelans and stuff. Cubans are getting that good, though, right now. Yeah, they are, yeah. But I think for my part, it's this idea of like, I don't think of myself as Mexican American. I think of myself as American. My parents are immigrants from Mexico, but I grew up very Americanized. I've never actually thought of myself as anything other than American. And some of like my earliest experiences and people that are like leftists, like campus leftists, and becoming really angry with them was them basically telling me, like you'll never actually be fully American. And that you're kind of suffering from like a false consciousness and you've been whitewashed and like, you know, like you've been brainwashed into loving a society that hates you. And this is like, like the 2010s basically, leading up to like the election of Donald Trump. And that very much influenced like how I looked at identity, not just identity politics, but identity as a whole, and then also like immigration policy. Because you think to yourself, like there's a difference between me and this other type of person who's coming from like even the same country that my parents came from, you know, that there's some kind of a dividing line there. And I think that as when you're conservative, it's easy to believe that it is that simple, that that line is so easily drawn, but it's not. And I think the Trump era has really just kind of driven at home. Like ultimately, I mean, it is true. Like this is part of why like even on immigration, like I've my views of moderated dramatically. I think because if you believe that you can deprive, like a human of their rights, of their dignity, that doesn't stop with their immigration status, right? Like the way that Trump administration treats and views immigrants, it obviously doesn't stop with them. Like again, look at Renee Good and Alex Pretty. Look at basically anyone who they view as obstacles to their agenda. So it's complicated, but it wasn't just like, I don't know, at least for me, it was not just a sort of like, well, it's not going to affect me. You know, I'm one of the good ones, whatever. It was an actual thought process about the idea of identity and how identity is basically a series of layers, you know? And I think this is also really important because for the people on the right and the left that are just basically trying to destroy, you know, anything like a kind of civic nationalism or a common conception of what it means to be American, I think that's really dangerous because you don't get rid of identity. You just scratch off one identity and the one that's beneath it rises to the surface. And I think the most obvious one is like racial and ethnic identities, which is what the right is doing, which is what it's done more and more and what it's arrived at now is like, it's not enough to be an American. It'd be a heritage American. What does that mean? Well, it's a very specific kind of white American, you know, and basically from there there's a kind of hierarchy of, you know, who is truly American? So we'll do another hour on identity ideology and the tech right another time. If the people allow it, we'll see what they say in the comments about the Pedro Gensal's upset. I really appreciate it, though. I want to close, I just want to do like, can we just have a little jaw comparison to see? I want the, I like for the viewers on YouTube to just comment on who's jawline they think is better or worse. We have a good jawline, too. We can jawline. It's not like I haven't been thinking about that for five years or anything. I apologize. We all live cocks have feelings, too, okay? Espater Gensal has read him his, his sub-stack is called Contra and I hope we'll get to checking with you again soon, all right, brother? Yeah, thank you. I will see you. [Music] The board daily is brought to you thanks to the work of lead producer Katie Cooper, associate producer Anzaly Skipper,
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Sarah Longwell’s new book *How to Eat an Elephant* explores the rise of young, toxic Republican voters shaped by Trump’s influence, highlighting racialized, populist, and anti-feminist ideologies.
The book critiques the idea of a return to "traditional" conservatism, arguing that modern Republicanism is built on racial exclusion, anti-immigrant sentiment, and gender-based hostility.
Young Republicans are taught to prioritize identity-based politics over policy, with figures like Tucker Carlson and Candace Owens dominating their discourse.
A key theme is the deep ideological overlap between young Republicans and progressives on issues like Israel, showing that the movement is not solely driven by anti-leftism but by a shared isolationist, anti-globalist worldview.
Sarah notes that AI’s rise presents a new information battleground, where misinformation and manipulation could deepen political polarization and undermine democratic discourse.
Ex-Maga writer Pedro González shares his personal journey from radical right-wing activism to disillusionment, emphasizing how Trumpism fosters a sense of existential battle over race, gender, and cultural purity.
The movement’s animating force—especially in its second term—relies on racialized conflict, with explicit use of white nationalist themes and rhetoric, including in government propaganda.
Sarah and Pedro both argue that Trump’s core appeal lies in emotional, tribal identity politics, not policy, and that this has created a self-reinforcing, deeply entrenched political culture resistant to reform.
Summary:
Sarah Longwell’s new book, *How to Eat an Elephant*, offers a sharp analysis of how Trump’s political rise has fundamentally reshaped the Republican Party, particularly among younger voters. She argues that modern conservatism is no longer rooted in traditional economic or social policy but instead in identity-based, racially charged, and gendered ideologies. These include deep anti-immigrant sentiment, hostility toward women’s political agency, and a worldview that frames politics as a racialized battle for the future of America.
The book highlights that young Republicans, raised on Trump’s messaging, view politics through a lens of tribal loyalty, often embracing toxic rhetoric and conspiracy theories. This shift is evident in their preference for figures like Tucker Carlson and Candace Owens, who embody the movement’s values of hostility and emotional intensity. The analysis also extends to emerging dangers in the digital age, particularly how AI could be weaponized to spread misinformation, deepen polarization, and manipulate public discourse.
The conversation with ex-Maga writer Pedro González reinforces this narrative, detailing how his personal journey from radical right-wing activism to disillusionment reflects a broader pattern of ideological entrapment. Both contributors emphasize that Trumpism is not about policy but about identity—specifically, a cultural war defined by racial purity, gender exclusion, and anti-globalism. They warn that such movements, once entrenched, resist genuine reform and instead thrive on tribal loyalty and emotional polarization.
The book ultimately serves as both a critique and an optimistic call to action: that democratic renewal requires understanding these deep-rooted dynamics and engaging with voters not through hostility, but through empathy, transparency, and shared values.
FAQs
The book explores the political and cultural shifts in American politics, particularly focusing on the rise of populist movements, the future of the Republican Party, and the influence of young voters. It also includes personal reflections on her journey through political disillusionment and recovery.
She argues that the current Republican Party is not returning to its traditional roots, as young Republicans have been heavily influenced by Trump’s rhetoric and messaging. They are more ideologically driven on issues like immigration, race, and gender, often displaying toxic and racist behaviors that are distinct from older forms of conservatism.
She notes that Trump introduced a new form of political rhetoric that taught young Republicans to adopt extreme, often racist or anti-Semitic views as markers of party loyalty. This has created a generation that values polarization and hostility over policy debate.
She observes a surprising similarity in foreign policy views, particularly regarding Israel, where both young Republicans and young progressives are isolationist and anti-Israel. This reflects a shared distrust of global institutions and a populist, anti-establishment mindset.
The core elements include a racialized conflict framed as a battle between 'white civilization' and minorities and immigrants, and a deep distrust of women’s political agency, seen as a threat to traditional male dominance and political purity.
Yes, she argues that Trump’s rhetoric and actions have normalized extremist language and behavior, including anti-Black, anti-immigrant, and anti-feminist sentiments, which have been amplified within the Republican movement and particularly among young supporters.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.