Speaker 1Hello I'm Joanne Wood and I'm Mark Cowan.
Speaker 2Welcome to Journeys of Accountancy. Today we speak
Speaker 1with Nick Gaddioso, a CPA, a graduate of Boise State, and a senior manager at Big Four Deloitte. Nick, thank you for joining us today.
Speaker 2Thanks for having me. So let's start by having you tell us your background and what led you to major in accounting at Boise State.
Speaker 3Yeah so my background is I got an undergrad in accounting and finance at Boise State University, did my master's in accounting here, then ended up going into the transfer pricing group at Deloitte, which I've been there for
Speaker 2about 10 years now. So what made you decide, when did you decide to major in accounting and finance?
Speaker 3Yeah so I think it was when I was around a freshman I was debating between doing engineering and accounting and I ended up taking a couple, you know, introduction to accounting courses, financial and managerial, and I just really kind of fell in love with how accounting can help you make business decisions and just overall just getting more involved in kind of understanding a business through accounting and so I think that's what's really triggered me to go more into accounting is just I was interested in overall learning about business and accounting for me to try to learn more about that as a business major opposed to like marketing or another discipline. I just really thought it was a good way. And overall I had kind of an analytical interest so I paired it with finance and also some economics and they all really seemed to join together well as I moved through my academic and now professional career.
Speaker 2So a very quantitative numbers-based approach to your education. Yeah. Understandably from someone who was thinking about being an engineer. So now let's talk about your accounting career and most students think of working in public accounting as oh I'm doing a tax return or I'm auditing the financial statements. You actually work in a specialized area, transfer pricing, and many students may not be aware of what transfer pricing entails. Very important area however in business and a lot of money, a lot of money. So could you give us maybe a brief transfer pricing 101 course and tell us why it matters?
Speaker 3Yeah I'll try my best. So overall transfer pricing deals with when you have a control transaction. So that could be you know within a multinational corporation, within a partnership, within a tax exempt, and potentially the issue is that you're you know having a provision of goods or services or maybe a use of intangible property between two related parties. And the issue comes up is that you have control of how you set that price. And so the the issue with transfer pricing comes up a lot is is that price right or not or is it a market price. And so what transfer pricing consultants or transfer pricing you know professionals do is help companies figure out what's the right price to set between those two related parties. And where it comes up a lot is in a multinational corporation. So a simple example would be say you're a global manufacturer of of a widget or a project product and you have something in Europe right. Your raw materials are in Europe but you need to sell those to the U.S. to do a final you know processing of the goods and then selling it into the market. The question comes up how are you going to price that good so that overall right one from a business perspective your prices are right and in market prices but more importantly from a tax perspective that you've recognized profit correctly. Because a lot of tax authorities will come in and try to challenge that whichever entity didn't earn the right profit they should have earned more. And so that's where transfer pricing comes in and there's a lot of methods to try to price different transfer pricing methods. There's a lot of ways to do this and there's a lot of ways that you can do this and there's a lot of different ways to do this and there's a lot of ways that you can do this. One of the ways that you can do this is by looking at a lot of the transactions but overall what you're doing is trying to find first is there some type of comparable price in the market like with crude oil where I can just look to the market and observe that price and price the related party transaction the same way. Now a lot of transactions out there don't have you know market data where you can price something like that. So then it becomes a more detailed analysis looking at you know what's actually going on in the business. The other way is to benchmark the profit and then finally with intangibles that are very you know kind of a hot button issue you can look at you know comparable agreements out in the market. But finally a lot of times stuff comes down to valuation but overall what you're trying to do at a high level is trying to make sure that the value created is commensurate with the functions assets and risks of those companies. So that when a tax authority comes in or an independent party you can justify why that profit is sitting there and defend that from a business perspective overall.
Speaker 2Yeah so just to back up a little bit. Normally you think of the tax authority. So the tax authority would be like in the United States the IRS or in the United Kingdom or HMRC yeah his majesty's you know whatever Canada Revenue Agency all over. Normally a tax authority will respect market transactions. If I sell you something we're not related parties we're not relatives so we're not related parties we're not relatives so we're not related parties. So we're going to negotiate hard. I'm going to try to charge as much as I can. You're going to try to pay as little as you can. Whatever price we set up will be at arm's length and the IRS will respect it on both ends. But you're talking about one company that's selling from one subsidiary completely controlled by the same people to the other subsidiary and crossing national borders. The tax authority is going to be very critical that you are not thinking you're not negotiating very hard within essentially negotiating with yourself right. So that that's why you have to use all this data from the outside world to try and figure out to justify it right.
Speaker 3Exactly yeah. Overall that's the whole the whole thing is that you're trying to prove that that internal price is the same as what would be between what you're saying unrelated or uncontrolled parties is how a lot of the. regs or OECD guidelines define transfer pricing is trying to make you kind of indifferent between those two right. If I sell the related party or if I sold to an uncontrolled party I'm paying the same price so then the tax authority should be indifferent right. I'm doing the right thing it's justified it's at arm's length but where problems come up is you know there's a lot of subjectivity around what price you charge right. You never can get an exact point so it's always dealt with in ranges and so where you sit in that range sometimes can be challenged by a tax authority. What comparables you're using can be challenged by a tax authority and so overall transfer pricing is neither good nor bad. I think maybe sometimes you hear in the news like transfer pricing and then oh this big tax adjustment but transfer pricing is kind of the cornerstone of trying to support those cross-border transactions so that you are acting as you would a third party because if you're not then the tax authority can come in give their view of the story and change and then you know there's a tax adjustment potentially double taxation and other stuff can happen in an unseen cost to a business.
Speaker 1Just to go back a little bit as he's talked about regulations and you know the understanding of taxing price I like to point out to our younger accounting students that are listening to this that he's talking about after you've had the direct materials the direct labor and the overhead taken care of in the foreign entity then it might come into the United States or it could go the other way so they have to make sure they cover the cost but the same time they need to be fair to what's coming into the business.
Speaker 3That's a good point and one interesting thing that gets challenged a lot globally is when you talk about overhead is that one kind of issue is providing global services and so a lot of times if you think of a U.S. multinational a lot of executives or you know global managers sit there right and to your point overhead they want to charge their cost to a foreign affiliate because they say hey I spent time on this I was you know useful the U.S. isn't going to allow that cost in the tax return so they want to charge it to say somewhere in UK to be part of the product cost overall the issue could be is you need to prove that that's actually beneficial which comes back to transfer pricing and it actually was used in that part of the business so even some of those overhead costs that are built in right might be considered if they're cross-border or you have a ton of centralization in the U.S. or a foreign jurisdiction a question for a tax authority like hey you're you know you built this product here right we see all the direct costs here why do we have this overhead charge coming from a outside country we don't think it's relevant but if through transfer pricing you can defend that that's what a third party would pay and need to incur those overhead costs and it's you know deductible in the local jurisdiction
Speaker 2and this is so important because and the tax authorities are so on it and you're so concerned about documenting everything and coming up with a transfer price that can withstand scrutiny because there's so much money involved so much so much at stake it means a lot of of taxes whether the way you priced a where you priced an intercompany transaction whether those profits end up in say Brazil where they're taxed one way or they end up in the United States where they're taxed a different
Speaker 3way yeah I have a good example like to your point about a lot of dollars at stake I work a lot advanced pricing agreements or APA's and so this is when you have a contentious issue and and you're really worried about the scrutiny to your point so you go to a tax authority and this was bilateral so you go to two tax authorities and you say hey I want to negotiate the price up front and I want to tell you what I'm doing because I don't want to have you know a big audit on the back end and something change. And so, and these take, you know, multiple years, like, you know, two to three years between friendly treaty partners. That exact issue happened is that it was, you know, kind of a sale of a commodity and how we were pricing that between two related parties. But depending on if it was taxed in the U.S. or taxed in the foreign jurisdiction, there was, you know, hundreds of millions of dollars at stake. And so the issue is to get the tax authorities there to agree up front, to your point, that they accept that, and then they get into an agreement with each other called an APA. But there is a lot of tax on the line, even if it's not between how you typically hear in the news, like a tax haven in the U.S. It could just be between two very typical tax authorities, like a Europe versus U.S., where you have a tax rate of, let's say, 35 somewhere, or a tax rate of 21. And that split of where you hit the profit could trigger a very different tax outcome. So a lot of times there you would see APAs and negotiations to make sure the tax authority up front agrees with what you're doing, and then there's no adverse consequences. When they do make a final decision, there might be some more taxes owed, but not penalties or anything like that, or interest owed on those adjustments.
Speaker 2Say you're in a situation where you can't get that advanced agreement. It's either not available or it's too costly. A lot of times it's very
Speaker 3costly and would be a big transaction.
Speaker 2How do you manage when, say, the United States says maybe your transfer price, when you bought something from a foreign sister company, is too low? And the United Kingdom says it was too high. And they both take, like, different jurisdictions take different views of what the transfer price should be.
Speaker 3Yeah, so there's kind of two outcomes there. So one, if you have a treaty partner, you would go through mutual agreement procedures, or MAP. So because you have a treaty.
Speaker 2A tax treaty.
Speaker 3A tax treaty between, like, your example, U.S. and U.K., they agree to not double tax you. So if one party says the transfer price is something else, U.K. says the transfer price is something different, then. Under the treaty, articles of the treaty, you can file through a MAP request. You have to be able to resolve that between them. Or what could happen is, okay, fine, U.S. is saying, in your example, you underpaid, right, so there should be more profit somewhere else, right, or U.K. If somebody gives a bad outcome there, let's say they decide, okay, U.K. was the right one in this example, you'll get a foreign tax credit to try to help offset some of that. But with a treaty partner, you still need to go through mutually agreed procedures and come up with the final TP. A transfer pricing answer. Sorry, TP, I say it so much. That's transfer pricing. Probably no one else knows what that means. Not toilet paper. Not toilet paper, yeah. No one else knows what that means. Trust me, with clients, that's always an issue. But yeah, so you'd go. There is remedies for that. It takes time and effort. But if you don't have a treaty partner, so let's say it's with Peru, then the issue would be that you probably most likely won't get relief on that. So either you need to figure out a way to adjust your transfer pricing to try to accommodate that incremental tax that you're going to owe. Or you need to go through both tax authorities separately and try to defend in some type audit issue or go through appeals and then eventually the courts. But when there's treaty partners, there's a little bit more optionality there and procedures to try to get a remedy to that. But with non-treaty partners, it's mostly you have to deal with each tax authority on its own through appeals. It's good to sometimes be able to put tax authorities against themselves because then, depending on where country you are, if you're a U.S. multinational versus U.K., U.S. is most likely going to defend U.S. in the end. And have a treaty partner, you're going to have to think critically about the economics underlying the analysis done. Where if you're in separate jurisdictions and you can't get them to talk, you're stuck fighting that tax authority and usually tax authorities always think they're right. So it comes down to how strong your transfer pricing documentation is and how strong you've done to support that in an audit or appeals type scenario or eventually tax court.
Speaker 1And that's good information to know for any business major. Because a lot of times you're going to be in a management position and you're going to have things transferring between different countries or you want to go set up shop in a new company and you need to make sure you understand those international laws and if there is treaty parties in protection there.
Speaker 3Yeah, and the big thing is a lot of times where transfer pricing comes up, even for smaller companies, not your billion dollar companies that you hear in the news all the time, is when they're growing internationally and trying to set up shop in a foreign jurisdiction. And a lot of times there, it's not necessarily the risk of, you know, there's potential audit risk and everything like that, but it's more just setting it up right, getting it done up front and understanding the business so that when you set up your transfer price, you don't set up something that's burdensome on the local jurisdiction and making sure that it actually fits within the business overall. And so a lot of times companies think about transfer pricing throughout their life cycle, but usually as a smaller company, as they're growing and they're growing internationally, it becomes a key issue as they enter. New markets and try to figure out how to operate in that market overall.
Speaker 2We have a lot of students that they get into college and they think, you know, I'd like to study international business. I think that's exciting, moving stuff across borders. In your job, you actually have to be really into the details of international business and not just in general, it's good to do business in X, Y, Z country, but where are the goods flowing, supply chain, those sorts of things. Can you talk about some of the practicalities?
Speaker 3Yeah. So there's a group in Deloitte that we work transfer pricing together. It's called like supply chain analysis or value chain alignment. It's changed its name so many times, but ultimately it's what you're talking about, Mark. We spend a lot of time trying to understand actually how the supply chain is formed, right? So you can have, you know, regional supply change, centralized principle models. And the idea there to your example is where the goods actually transfer in international waters have international tax impacts, who's doing that has transfer pricing implications. So for instance, when you're thinking about, you know, maybe crude oil and trying to ship that around the world, depending on how you structure your transfer pricing, where is the value really sitting there? Is it in the logistics and trading part of the business, right? Because when you think about who's taking that risk for when that, you know, that oil is on the water, who's creating all the value about being able to read that oil in case there's a market opportunity. Versus is it just somebody doing, you know, some supporting function and they already have all these deals set up for 30 years. And so they're just shipping the oil to a location and there's not really any optimization that can happen. You have to really understand what's going on in the business, where it's happening, kind of what different jurisdictions are doing to create value. And then once based on that, trying to figure out the transfer pricing to align that. But we spend a lot of time trying to understand the business as a whole. What are people doing in each jurisdiction? How is that creating value for the business? Yeah. And then once you kind of understand that, does the transfer pricing align with that value creation? Or is there a mismatch and something needs to be changed? And when you're doing planning projects. So when, let's say you're setting up a whole new trading operation. To keep on that example, years ago I had the opportunity when I was, you know, at Deloitte to set it a super major as they reopened their trading business between UK and Singapore. And so there we had to actually understand at the forefront, what would all the global flows be? And who would be managing that? Who would be managing those flows for, you know, LNG, NGL, crude oil? And then being able to structure something globally that could meet that demand and comply with the tax laws. So we partnered with Deloitte Consulting and kind of did that work in tandem so that both the business rate and the tax were aligned. Because the worst is from my job is if you recommend something from a transfer pricing or tax perspective that doesn't align with the business overall because then it doesn't work for anybody. Our job is making sure that we understand the business, how it's running, who's creating the value, and then does that value align with the actual tax out.
Speaker 2I'm so glad you brought up the tax planning with respect to what's really happening in the company day to day. Because I know that comes up in a lot of my classes is that you could say, "Oh, look at this tax law. All you got to do is just do this one thing and you could save lots of taxes." Well, yeah, it's easy to say that. But then it would ruin your business. It would be, the marketing would get all screwed up, it would ruin your business strategy. So you really have to keep an eye on that business strategy and then try to, like you said, optimize that the tax is not necessarily saved the most.
Speaker 3If you do have that and it's optimized and it's aligned, then that's a good business case overall for why you're doing the tax the way you're doing it and it's always best in our job and every type of tax job to align tax with business because overall you need to understand the business, you need to understand what they're doing and you need to be able to partner with them so that when they want to go to market, open up a new thing, maybe issue a new product, develop a new technology, tax is there, transfer pricing, to partner with them to make it the best that it can be, not an impediment to them growing the
Speaker 1business overall. You were an accounting and finance major, but how did you learn how to understand somebody's business so you can help them grow it?
Speaker 3Yeah. So I think a lot of that was just. I think a lot of that was just from kind of on the job, I would say experience, but also reading a lot about industry. So I started in Houston is where I started. I'm back in Boise right now, but most of my stuff is large energy clients, technology, and then private equity and some healthcare I do. But a lot of it was first reading a lot about the industry. But then how our job is, is a lot of it is going and talking with business leaders or functional leads within a business to understand what they're doing. So over the years, right, I've done a lot of work with. Super majors. I have an understanding of what E and P does versus exploration and production versus maybe a trading arm versus a refining arm. arm, but that's from years of working with them, trying to understand and reading up on the industry. A lot of reading, you know, like, you know, industry reports or supply chain, like Mark mentioned, a lot of trying to do research on understanding what it is from a business perspective versus just a tax perspective. Because if you go in to talk with somebody who doesn't do tax, which is a lot of our job, because we need to understand what the business is doing and overall what they're actually trying to get done there, they don't, they don't understand tax. So you need to be able to bridge the gap. Like a good example would be, you can't ask someone, how do you create value? That question doesn't go over well because, you know, everyone in the business does create value, but that's not, we're not trying to get out of question. It's more just trying to understand their role or function in a business. So trying to ask questions that are more geared at what do you do from day to day, right? How is your management of the business, you know, different from someone else in the organization and trying to get those understandings or a lot of time, I spent a lot of time around intellectual property. So trying to understand what a developer, you know, activities do to change, you know, a software platform and asking those questions, or kind of how much does incremental coding or incremental development change the tool that a client uses for them. And so those types of questions around understanding day to day, what activities they're doing, rather than, you know, a tax question, you know, some certain regulation says this, you guys aren't doing this. That isn't really what we spend day to day doing in my group.
Speaker 2That's what you'd find. You read pretty much any tax case that a court has ruled against. You know, you don't have to worry about whether it's a tax court case in the United States or it's a Supreme Court case about a state tax issue. They're always going to, they're going to start with the law and say the law says this, but then they're going to do exactly what you just said. And they're going to say, okay, where was the risk? Who could have lost money here? Who was adding value? Where was the value being added? They look at the reality and then they try to align what the tax system says with that reality.
Speaker 3Yeah, and that's a big thing. So one other thing we do a lot with transfer pricing, to your point, is there's usually like three things I like to think about in transfer pricing. There's the contract, which is the legal framework between related parties. There's the actual accounting to get it done, right, and to book the entries to have the system, the ERP, everything do that. And then there's the economic analysis to support the pricing and develop the actual transfer pricing behind it. All three of those components need to align. So if you have a contract in place, right, just like you would between two unrelated parties, the terms and conditions in that need to reflect the actual reality of the parties or you could run into trouble. Same with the accounting. If how you're booking entries or how you're setting up your system doesn't really align with the reality of what you're saying your transfer pricing is, that can cause trouble as well. And then finally, how you're supporting or doing your economic analysis to support the pricing, that also needs to align. So transfer pricing gives you an opportunity from day to day to see some legal, some accounting, and then some finance or economics to kind of tie everything together within an organization. And you get to do a lot of cross-functional work. Like I get to work with an accounting department. I also get to work with operations as well as legal to be able to tie all those together where instead of just being, you know, seen as tax, right, we have to be able to connect those dots. And so we get to work cross-functional across the team, usually led by, you know, someone in tax at the organization, but also that can be spirited by finance as well as, you know, others. So it's very cross-functional discipline. You know, you're not just housed within a tax function. You need to understand what everyone's doing to be able to put it together.
Speaker 1So in that process, you just listed like half of our majors in the College of Business and Economics at Boise State. So this applies to every major.
Speaker 2And I would guess, Joanne, this kind of comes, a lot of this stuff that Nick's talking about kind of comes together in managerial accounting. Wouldn't you say that?
Speaker 1It does because we're trying, in managerial accounting, we're trying to get the students to understand. You know, what's the cost and the process and all the different things that go on inside of a business that need to be tracked by somebody for the business to be successful.
Speaker 2For decision-making, for taxes, for even employee bonuses, who gets credit for what. There's a lot riding on all of this. There is a lot riding on all of this.
Speaker 3No, and I would echo that point. Everything pretty much comes back to, from a transfer pricing perspective, you know, managerial accounting. How do you make informed decision-making? understand kind of what you're trying to do right because first of all you need to kind of set what your guys are saying, strategic decisions, and then layering it across the different, you know, outcomes that you want. Is it managerial decision-making? Is it tax decision-making? Or is it some type of employee bonus decision-making? But overall, that all starts with how are you doing your internal accounting? Can you understand the data that you have and your accounting data? And then how do you use that to make informed decisions? Because at the end of the day, no matter if you're doing, you know, tax transfer pricing, or you're doing some type of supply chain analysis or you're doing some type of you know financial statement work it all comes back to the accounting data and organization and how can you use that to make informed and strategic decisions to grow or you know understand the business overall so now
Speaker 1you've just touched all the majors right all the majors that are in there want to grow the business and make decisions so if a student is listening to this right now and they're a sophomore and they still have some opportunity to to choose majors or minors and they don't quite know what to do what would you encourage them to do?
Speaker 3I mean I would always say that you should you know include accounting overall either as major or minor in accounting or double major potentially because what accounting can help you do even at a minimum as a minor is really understand the business overall I think you guys were mentioning earlier to me the language of of business which I truly believe is when you get into a certain environment everyone is always going to use financial statements or P&L or some type of financial impact you know maybe return on investment analysis to argue why they should do something versus not and that all comes back to accounting data so it's always good to try to take accounting courses and then be able to connect the dots with how does accounting feed into you know bigger financial or economic analysis that an organization does because that's where you can really differentiate yourself is, I understand the accounting data right, I understand how to prepare it, but then if you can understand how to use that to inform leadership or management overall on why certain decisions should be, then that can differentiate you from someone who might not, you know, understand the data itself or how to use it to make better decisions overall.
Speaker 1And I've talked a lot with my accounting 206 students, which are introduction to managerial accounting students about how it's important that if you're going to graduate in business administration that you set yourself apart and whether that's accounting or something but the accounting language is the language of business and it's never going to hurt you to know that language
Speaker 3anywhere you're trying to work right overall I've worked at Deloitte but I've worked at a lot of clients you know across very different spectrums from you know small non-profits where I've done pro bono work all the way up to you know very large multinationals the same thing comes back to always trying to be able to explain to someone very simply what you're trying to do overall and a great way to be able to do that is to do use accounting data or financial data to explain that to an audience where you can all share the same language right to your point about accounting and so being able to translate what you want to do even if you're an entrepreneur into something that everyone can understand or is used to seeing is kind of the crux of what accounting helps do right because if everyone had different accounting standards which there is some of that globally and different tax standards you start to get into a mess around what you're actually trying to explain or do but accounting helps to bridge that as a common core language or process overall to explain to each other this is what i'm trying to do this is how i'm going to do and this is the benefit it's going to show accounting can really help bridge that communication with leadership or either either you know cross-managerial aspects of a business
Speaker 2i like how you keep coming back to using using the accounting data because i think that's what often distinguishes that takes a while for people to learn how to use it because you can take it in school and you can often think that oh accounting is about it's like following a recipe you know as a cookbook and just do x y and z book this to that and you get this nice report that looks great and balances but using it then to inform your decisions using it to run the business using it for all these different things that's really what the value comes
Speaker 3from yeah and i think one other piece of using it is to your point being able to understand how it's constructed because a lot of times you might see a pnl but you might not actually understand how that was built up and so maybe some of that stuff you know isn't exactly correct or maybe it's not what you want it to be so being able to understand actually too what does each line item mean right how is cogs constructed from opex for a very simple example maybe there's some items in cogs that should actually be an operating expense if we're thinking about how this business is run and so making sure you can actually highlight that difference that when you use the data to your point you actually know what you're saying and so i think a lot of that stuff is understanding the basics of what you know cost of goods sold is what operating expenses even what revenue is meant to represent can really help you as you try to use data down the road because you can think about what you're
Speaker 1trying to do their profit and loss stand well that's what pnl is and in education we always call it an income statement yeah but when you go out in industry pnl and income statement they're exactly the same thing and i don't know why we teach it different from academia to industry but we do but no they're the same
Speaker 2Well, it sounds like you've had a fulfilling life. career so far in transfer pricing normally you would expect what do you like to do outside of the office how do you keep yourself kind of grounded
Speaker 3yeah I mean I like to do a lot of you know outdoors activities now that I'm back in in Idaho so like a lot of hiking a lot of trying to get kind of outside and it's just so kind of beautiful in Idaho compared to more opportunity to do Houston was really nice as well I really liked Houston I like to do exercise kind of weightlifting I also like to cook trying to learn new things to cook and then also take trips I like to go around see new places that I've never been had the opportunity personally not with work to go to Mexico City a lot of places all over US and so just always like to travel and and find it really fun but try to do stuff outside of work as always and try to keep it fun and interesting what's
Speaker 1the most exciting thing you've made in the
Speaker 3kitchen lately I don't know um probably let me think I mean probably like a baked ziti or something I'm really trying to learn more Italian dishes given my heritage I really like to make you know from scratch tomato sauce which takes a lot of effort from scratch trying to do that and then just also just trying all different things like trying to cook you know turkeys and other stuff like that but just fun things when
Speaker 2you're when you're making the tomato sauce do you find yourself pricing the tomatoes and making sure you're charging a far a fair arm's length price for the I try to go into the sauce price out of my out of my home life but yeah
Speaker 3sometimes it does come up I do think about pricing but I try my best to to keep it out of there keep it at arm's length to use the
Speaker 1well thanks again for joining us today Nick yeah it
Speaker 3was wonderful thanks for having
Speaker 1me
Speaker 2and for Journeys of Accountancy I'm Mark
Speaker 1Cowan and I'm Joanne Wood join us for our next episode © transcript Emily Beynon