Speaker 1The Telegraph Russell has asked me to read something to you today. Beloved brothers and sisters in Christ, God bless you for your support. As you know, I am not guilty for the offences I have been jailed for. So something strange is happening. The good news is that Christ is with us when we choose him, and I do. I am incarcerated in HMP Little Hay. Little, as in small, and Hay, as in hay. I'm in the biggest sex offenders prison in Europe. The good news is that I have already seen that the staff here are strong, they are kind, and they are dedicated. And I am not guilty for the offences I have been jailed for. And as for my fellow prisoners, I now know that I am in no position to judge anyone. I don't know which other men here are not guilty, and the ones that are, they are people that Christ died to save, like you and me. Let us all love, pray for, and forgive one another, as God forgave us. Please support my treasured wife and family. I feel your prayers, your brother in Christ, Russell.
Speaker 2So that, Tim, is Laura Brand, who we seem to be describing as Laura Gallagher. I'm not sure why, because she goes by Mrs. Brand. Should we start every Daily Tea with beloved brothers and sisters in Christ? No. There is something extraordinary, I think, and Suzanne Moore has written about this for us today, about Brand now trying to control, I think, both his wife and his audience, from prison. I find it extraordinary. I mean, I suppose if you were going to go with the pretense that he is innocent, that's what he's claiming, that's what she's claiming. She's standing by her man, and she reserves the right to do that as both a wife and a mother, that you would continue the podcast. But on the other hand, I find these claims as to his innocence and the idea that he is in prison with other innocent men a little bit difficult to fathom and stomach. He's been found guilty in a court of law. He's entitled to appeal against that judgment. But generally, prisons are full of people who are technically guilty, legally guilty. They've been found guilty by either judges or juries, and then they need to serve their time, Tim.
Speaker 3Well, he's in a Category C prison, HMP Little Hay. He will be surrounded by sex offenders, many of whom will have done really appalling things. So I know he's not saying they are. But almost everything Russell Brand says and has said for about the last five years feels as though it's calibrated to cast doubt upon the system and its judgments. Yes. So as a strategy, it makes some sense to go in there and ally yourself with your fellow inmates. That's clever, because word will get back to them. But also to spread the idea that maybe prisons, you know, prisons, they're sort of holding pegs. They're holding pens for society's dissidents.
Speaker 2Yes, that's right.
Speaker 3No, they're not. No, they're holding pens for society's rapists. He will be surrounded by people who have raped their own children. Yes. OK, so it's serious stuff. And it's therefore I get entirely why people are horrified that the first thing he does is put out a statement of innocence, suggesting no acceptance of his own guilt and responsibility, and that he appropriates the language of Christianity. And that he appropriates the language of Christianity to do that, for which there will be an audience who want to believe not just him, but want to believe him as a Christian. But what do you think of
Speaker 2this as a Christian? Because I am a lapsed Catholic, but I consider myself to be Christian. I consider myself to be a good person. Yes. And I would imagine that the first thing any committed Christian would do, regardless of their own protestations of innocence, would be to apologize to victims. In light of an actual conviction in an actual court of law. And then I would try and repent for my sins. I think I would. Jonathan Aitken wrote about this for us at the weekend. This is the former Tory who was convicted and then has now become a prison chaplain, saying that Brand approached him and he didn't find his breed of Christianity particularly convincing. Yes. Do you?
Speaker 3OK, so there are several things there. First of all, sometimes innocent people are saved. Yes. In Australia, there was the case of Cardinal Pell, whose conviction was subsequently overturned and he was released. That man was 100% innocent and was accused of the most vile crime of interfering with two boys.
Speaker 2OK, Birmingham 6, Guildford 4, I grant you.
Speaker 3It does happen. If I went to prison and I believed I was innocent and I was innocent, then I would insist that I was innocent as a matter of maintaining my own dignity and sanity. Yes. The last thing you want if you are innocent, is to crumble and accept a false verdict. So, this is the difficulty here. But we all think he is guilty. The evidence is overwhelming.
Speaker 2And there are currently new police investigations being carried out into new allegations against him.
Speaker 3Right. He has been moved from Wandsworth, which people think is a Category A, but is actually a Category B prison, to HMP Little, which is a Category C prison.
Speaker 2Because apparently when he arrived at Wandsworth, somebody did a dirty protest in his cell. Right. I mean, let's be honest, fellow prisoners aren't going to take kindly to Brand's unique breed of celebrity behind bars, are they?
Speaker 3It would have been unsafe for him to remain at Wandsworth. And they make calculations not based upon celebrity, but based upon the risk to the individual. Safety. Had he stayed in Wandsworth, it would have meant just spending all his time in isolation. And it would have been awful. I do some work. I work with prisoners. I work for something called the Prison Fellowship, where you write to prisoners. And it's eye-opening. I've learned so much through doing this. And he will be experiencing right now fear. He'll be frightened. Because when you arrive at prison, the other prisoners very often make a display of, you're not welcome, we know who you are. And if you're a celebrity, it's that times a thousand.
Speaker 2And if you're a sex offender?
Speaker 3There's a particular sense of honour among prisoners that I might be a sex offender. I might have robbed people. I might have murdered someone, but I ain't a sex offender. So he'll be right at the bottom of that grim hierarchy. The other thing he'll discover very quickly is he's gone from being someone in the public eye who's able to speak his mind and communicate to thousands, to millions, to someone who is suddenly forced to wear a horrible grey tracksuit that's itchy and doesn't fit, and to sit in his cell for most of the day with highly vulnerable people. It's a very regulated, short hours of exercise. So people have pointed out that at Little Hay, for instance, you can do yoga, you can do cricket. We're talking for a couple of hours a week. Yes. Most of time in prison is just mind-numbingly dull. That is the torture of prison.
Speaker 2Also, all dignity is gone. There's very little privacy. Yes. He apparently has complained or complained when he was at Wandsworth. I think he asked for more pillows. He looked at the toilet and the fact that he had, he used it in rather transparent conditions, probably didn't have a lid.
Speaker 3And most people have all this, plus they share the cell. Yes. Can you imagine that, going to the lavatory with someone else in the room? You know, it's just awful. So he'll be experiencing all of those things. And what he's tried to do is retain his sense of self by reaching out to the public, retain a relationship with them. And also, I agree with you, using his wife as a mouthpiece to some extent, retaining his role as the paterfamilias within the family, by communicating through her.
Speaker 2Just as he's able to use a podcast as a platform to further his own aims, financial, spiritual, professional, whatever, we can have the right, reserve the right, to discuss whether his wife has been slightly brainwashed. True, yes. His family have spoken to other, her family have spoken to other journalists to suggest that they're worried about the levels of control he has exerted over her.
Speaker 3Yes.
Speaker 2But her relationship with
Speaker 3him will almost certainly change. And this is something else that's important. The effect of prison upon the family itself. Yes. Your initial reaction is going to be, I'm standing by my man. Defensive. And by the way, Laura has to do that.
Speaker 2Of course. Because she has
Speaker 3been, she's got kids, and she is totally sold on a narrative of Brand as innocent and a really important spiritual figure. If she were to accept for one moment that any element of that story was true, false, her whole interior life just collapses. So she's going to initially cling on to that. Okay, but by the way, she did have a choice
Speaker 2because she could have looked at the seriousness of the allegations. Yes. Read the victim's statements and taken a judgment on what the women said as opposed to what Brand said. Everything I say is. And this is why our conversation is linked because he has done this, he has a messianic quality to him. Initially, the hair looks like it's a grunge move, then apparently there's something in some piece of testimony suggesting that he didn't want to his hair because he enjoyed the comparisons that were made to Jesus. This is why your take on this really interests me because we have a messiah complex. We have a man who is being described in court as highly manipulative. We have a wife who is from a respectable family. The father, Bernard, is a former professional champion golfer. The sister, Kirsty, is in the public eye. She's had a few difficult moments in her career. Okay. We have her. She's clearly an intelligent, respectable woman, as you say, standing by her man. I'm looking at it wondering whether she has bought into some kind of cult along with his six million followers. So what is it about people who cultivate a messiah complex and why is it convincing? Just to say, my
Speaker 3point about her is I think in seven years' time she may feel very differently to how she does now. Yes, sure. On the religious question, this is why I think it's quite useful to watch the Netflix documentary because it tells the story of his career. And you sense from that that really fame was the chief spur, that sex and cash came second. And you watch him very cleverly reading the culture and adjusting his persona to hit fame at exactly the right moment. So he runs through clown, drunkard, junkie, to suddenly political messiah. To religious messiah. Yeah. But one theme that runs throughout his public testimony, his performances, is guilt. And there's a really striking bit during the period in which he had gone left wing and he was meeting with Ed Miliband and he was guest editing magazines, where he's in front of an audience and he talks about how awful he is and how he knows he is a terrible, terrible person. And he said, I've always thought that at some point it's going to catch up with me. And it's very hard. It's very hard now that we know what we know about Brand, not to retrospectively read that theme of guilt and self-loathing throughout much of what he does. When it comes to the theology, the theology taps into this too. It's a mix of new age and Christianity. He seems to think the universe operates as some kind of energy, which is a touch of Taoism. He mixes the rosary and speaking in tongues. So it's a potpourri of different things. And there's a lot of different religious elements. But it makes sense in the context of the internet culture today, where you have a lot of sort of self-didact, self-taught Christian preachers turning to the online space in which to evangelize. But you can take almost any clip at random from his Sunday service, where he and his wife would sit in their pajamas and go through the Bible as if they were holding a prayer meeting in someone's front room. You can take almost any clip at random and find Russell Brand discussing the Bible. And it's a lot of interesting stuff. There is what he calls an organized evil in the world, what we might otherwise call Satan. But he suggests there's a political dimension to it by saying things like our system has been corrupted. So free will almost goes out the window.
Speaker 2Yes. Oh, well, how convenient that you can completely absolve yourself of any responsibility because you can blame it on either the devil or
Speaker 3the system or the
Speaker 2system
Speaker 3or some vague energy of evil. This is closer to Manichaeanism in theological terms than it is to Christianity. Christianity says there is a devil, but he has no power because God always wins in the end. Whereas Manichaeanism says that the world is in an evenly balanced struggle between God and Satan. And Brand seems to come down on the side of Manichaeanism. And he says that in this war, Christ is your advocate. He's the
Speaker 2only ultimate arbiter of your behavior. And then you can also absolve yourself from the judgment of the public and crucially, the judgment of the court.
Speaker 3Because he says, and he comes back to this, judgment ultimately is God's. I know I'm broken. You know you're broken. We're all as guilty as each other. We're all imprisoned in this system of evil that makes us evil. But don't judge yourself. Don't worry about yourself because God will decide in the end. And how striking the use of the word advocate to describe Jesus. The devil is your prosecutor. The devil is the person who makes you doubt yourself and what you did 20 years ago. Jesus is your advocate and is the person who says, you're good. Don't worry about it. So I just think that's, so some would look at that and say how convenient that his theology seems to set itself up as a defense of any future accusations against him. But having said all of that, and you asked as a Christian, as a Christian, I'm very reluctant to judge other people's faith. I know it sounds like I've just done exactly that.
Speaker 2You're saying it's a faith that I think I've got a word for this and it's called bollocks ism. It's complete and utter confected hat stand. Yes. In my mind, this is somebody who is grotesquely manipulative. I'm talking about L Ron Hubbard levels of cultivating of cultism. I'm talking about this is sort of Scientology esque, total and utter hat stand designed to lure in a public. And to create an opaqueness around your own deplorable behavior. This is why I am actually, and it's terrible for me to be kind of this generalize. But the way in which he has manipulated Christ and faith, it almost sums up why I'm suspicious of these sort of self-styled religious figures across the whole of the religious spectrum, because there is no more overrated virtue than virtue itself. To cloak yourself in some degree of virtue when your behavior has been this deplorable, I think is beyond the pale. I find it sick making. I find it cynical. I am so suspicious of it. I think it's so dangerous. This is so dangerous.
Speaker 3But what I find curious is that it's almost like vice signalling rather than virtue signalling. The virtue is his recognition of how fallen he is, but the emphasis is upon we're all fallen. Guilt and sin run throughout his theology so deep. And I think this is a good argument for institutional religion and established churches, because had anyone gone to an instruction class with the Catholics or the Anglicans and had said, this is what I believe, at some point, the cleric would have said, that's wrong.
Speaker 2That's bollocks. And
Speaker 3if you went around, this is the other thing, you have to be very careful. I can't talk for other denominations and I want to make it absolutely clear. This is not a sideswipe at evangelicals who I totally respect. But if, for instance, he had called his show the Catholic Sunday Service, at some point a bishop would have got in touch and said, stop using that word.
Speaker 2Please stop. Because you're not allowed to claim to be something.
Speaker 3You're not allowed to use that unless it's approved.
Speaker 2To bring it back to an arena that I'm very, very familiar with. This is fake news versus actual journalism. What we're talking about is a false prophet versus actual, legitimate religious leaders who literally practice what they preach. We can all talk in tongues. We can all come out with this nonsense as some kind of cover. Because, by the way, in the background, let's not ignore the fact here. This is why I'm as suspicious of him as I am of Scientologists or others. He is doing this to make money, Tim.
Speaker 3Yes, it's the Internet. It's a business and it's the Internet. That's what we're seeing here is we're seeing a product of Internet culture. It is the Internet that drives what you see rather than the culture using the Internet, if that makes sense. And there are so many people like this.
Speaker 2But we know this man is a charlatan, by the way, regardless of any of his religious protestations, Because this was a man who five minutes ago was talking about taxing the rich and the system and Brexit's broken and I'm on the left and Ed Miliband this and Labour that and let's not vote and then let's vote. And then when the left turned against him, he pivoted to the right and start doing talks with Turning Point USA. And then suddenly he pivots to the right and he starts doing talks for Turning Point USA and embracing the sort of right wing podcast bros. Because, again, he did that out of, you know, fiscal and other opportunity because he had nowhere else. So this guy, he has built on sand. It's just complete and utter. As I say, the only word for it is bollocks. But what I find curious is that it's almost like vice signaling rather than virtue signaling.
Speaker 3of what he says in these sermons. But he's very good at spotting what people want. So in the case of the left, he figured out that at that moment, what they wanted was someone to make a moral case against austerity. They wanted someone who could use language as efficiently as he does, effectively as he does, in order to give them a feeling that there is a spiritual dimension to their politics, because they were feeling pretty down in the dumps at that time. He brought back romanticism. What he's done with Christians, which is, if this is what he is doing, then it really is despicable, is he's preyed upon the passionate desire of Christians to see other people saved. So there is an instinct among Christians when someone comes to you and says, I have found Jesus, the instinct is to go, oh, good, that's fantastic, and to believe them. So one reason why TPUSA and all those people welcomed him wasn't just the politics. It was because they thought they were meeting a fallen person who had genuinely found Christ.
Speaker 2But there was a complete and utter contradiction at his, let's think of the little people. Let's help the poor, because this is somebody who, as talent, treated those beneath him as beyond contempt. He treated female fans utterly disgracefully and disgustingly, setting aside disabled toilets to have sex with competition winners. He urinated and behaved appallingly in front of producers and others when he was on various shows. He paraded around naked in meetings with so-called underlings. So this is the man who cares about the masses. And now we learn, by the way, that his unique interpretation of redistribution of wealth is to dump a load of millions from one company and try and rearrange his finances ahead of his prison sentence. Because, of course, you know, that's Marxism. I mean, it's groucho Marxism.
Speaker 3He's a socialist who turned a profit. He's a feminist who abused women. Yeah, he's an utter hypocrite. And by the way, there are Catholic priests who have molested children. Of course there are. Hypocrisy runs through everything. I just think, as time goes by, Russell's going to be stuck in that prison. I'm not quite sure he can communicate effectively through his wife like this. We're going to lose interest in him. And if he can sustain, as almost no prisoner has succeeded, his own self-belief over those seven years and his own sort of identity over those seven years, I just think by the end of that period, we're going to lose interest in him. We're going to be bored with him. And I fear that we're all maybe over-investing in this and worrying about it a bit too much. I was struck by Ed Miliband, because this is just a wrong one who got caught. That's all this story is. A con man got caught. So Ed Miliband has come out and said, I met him in 2015 and I now regret that. I wish I'd never done it knowing what I do now. I'm not sure Ed Miliband actually has anything to apologize for. We didn't know what Russell Brown was accused of at the time. He was a major cultural figure. He was saying to young people, don't vote. So Ed Miliband went round to his flat to try to persuade him that it was worth voting. It's embarrassing. But if you got played by a con man, well, that's happened to me many times.
Speaker 2No, but hang on a minute. He was a self-confessed misogynist in not just one, but two autobiographies, the bookie work and bookie work two, where he revealed absolutely appalling behavior towards women, people he worked with and all the things that he was doing. So Ed Miliband was a self-confessed misogynist. He was a self-confessing misogynist. And of course, there was Saxgate. So it's all very well for Ed Miliband to say that. If Ed Miliband hadn't cloaked himself in a degree of progressive virtue.
Speaker 3Yes. But Brand was presenting himself at that point as reformed. This is my point about.
Speaker 2Well, Miliband's an idiot for buying it then, isn't he?
Speaker 3Well, maybe he is. Maybe he was being generous. Maybe he was ill-advised. I just think with Brand, we now need to let it go because he's in prison and he really can't do any more harm there. And we just need to accept that a bad man was caught out. We put him behind bars and he'll be there for a very long time.
Speaker 2He may well appeal the sentence and we'll have to cover more and more of this. By the way, number 10 isn't letting it go. Brand's message from prison is appalling and needs to be urgently investigated, says Downing Street. Oh, come. Oh, my God. So this is. Are we going to have a bill?
Speaker 3Are we going to have another law? So the other thing is they're discussing a staggered age of consent.
Speaker 2I know. Hang on. We'll get onto that in a minute. Let me just give you the spokesman for the prime minister said, this is being urgently investigated. We expect action to be taken if he's found to have broken the rules. Prisoners are strictly banned from making statements that cause distress to victims and speaking to the media is only permitted in exceptional circumstances. Prisoners cannot get around these rules by having someone else publish their comments. Prisoners can be found to have broken the rules if they give a statement to someone that they believe will be published. The Ministry of Justice is investigating, the spokesperson confirmed. Much rather the Ministry of Justice investigated historically low rape conviction rates, people being murdered in the streets, so on and so forth. Probably, Tim, I've got to be honest.
Speaker 3Well, their attempt to reduce trial by jury was partly in order to get through the enormous rape backlog. And now there is talk about changing the law so you have a staggered age of consent, which means that if you're sort of 16, you can sleep with a 17 or 18 year old, but not a 30 year
Speaker 2old. Well, to be fair, first of all, this has come about because one of Brand's alleged victims, a woman called Mia Latta, she wasn't actually anybody involved in the actual court case, but she has lifted her own anonymity to talk about how she claims she was raped by the comedian when she was 16. She's now campaigning to have the law changed, show that relations which are kind of generationally extremely opposed should be subject to some new legislation. I'm just not sure whether a law is needed, Tim. Times have changed enormously. I've had this conversation with my eldest, who's now 18, on several occasions compared to my day. And I mean, I'm married to somebody that's four years older than me. We didn't actually enter into a relationship until we were in our 20s. But I knew him from when I was a child because he was very close friend with one of my older brothers. No matter. Nothing happened then. Back in my day, if you were 16 and you're going out with a 20 year old, I mean, nobody really batted an eyelid, did they? Nowadays, however, the Gen Zs really frown on generationally different relationships. And even if somebody's 17 going out with a 19 year old, it seemed to be a bit off. So society is actually, I think it's just deemed to be, I mean, you know, it's deemed to be an imbalance. And that it shouldn't really happen. There's a
Speaker 3degree to which older
Speaker 2men and younger women, the older men are sort of depicted as nonces or something.
Speaker 3As Gore Vidal once said, everything in life is about sex, except sex, which is about power.
Speaker 2Is there something weird about a 30 year old man going out with a 16 year old, even though she's above the age of consent? There probably is, isn't there?
Speaker 3Well, maybe it's weird, but is weird a criminal matter? No. There's so much in life, which is uncomfortable or strange to us, that it doesn't mean it necessarily should end up in the courts.
Speaker 2But Bill Wyman and Mandy Smith, who he
Speaker 3met when she was 13, wouldn't
Speaker 2happen now, would it?
Speaker 3No, one hopes not.
Speaker 2No. So times have changed.
Speaker 3Times do change and the law changes to reflect that. One thing I've tried to argue in my column is, first of all, there is a risk that in rewriting laws in the wake of Russell Brand, we're responding. to a cultural problem that has already passed. Russell Brand never was a lad. He was actually a fomo-sexual. But let's call him a lad for the sake of argument. Lad culture is dead. And the studies show that younger people are actually having far less sex and have fewer partners in their life. And they tend to prefer things like platonic relationships. And as you have said, suggested, they're already self-regulating by saying it creeps them out, creeps them out or gives them the ick if someone older dates someone younger. So that's the first thing. The culture kind of self-corrects and self-regulates. So in that case, do you need the law except to protect the vulnerable who are being exploited? That's when you need the law. And that's why we have an age of consent, a Victorian inheritance introduced because there was a scare at the time about child prostitution. That's the reason why we have it and it ought to be properly enforced. One reason why I'm also skeptical of some of the people trying to inform this debate. I'm not saying this in the case of Mia Latt. I know nothing about her, but there is a view among the left that all of life is framed by power dynamics, that everything is the strong versus the weak. And they've extended the language of class conflict to that of gender conflict, which means that men and women are always at each other's throats. One's always trying to oppress the other. And you get a hierarchy in this power situation where the wealthier, the older, possibly the whiter a man is, the greater a threat he poses to women. I do think that is informing this debate.
Speaker 2Actually, it's amazing there isn't a hashtag, hashtag male privilege. Right, exactly. Maybe women would just regard that as just hashtag privilege. Sorry, joke there.
Speaker 3And I reject that because I don't see human relationships in that way. I don't think there's this inevitable tension between the two of them. I think men and women are designed to be together. That's the true Christian perspective. They complement each other. Of course, difference can produce friction, but it's also the basis upon which we marry and procreate and keep the species going. So I think trying to inject this sort of wider anxiety about gender, I think is unhelpful.
Speaker 2Yes. Also, then we do go down the road of, as we discussed last week, Shirley Valentine's All Men Are Potential Rapists. And as the mother of a son, not really sure I'm comfortable with that narrative either.
Speaker 3How old was Brigitte Macron when she met Emmanuel Macron in their workplace, otherwise known as his school? How many times have I got to go online and see a picture of an older actress with a fit young man where someone is saying, look at her, good for her.
Speaker 2Yes, that's true, actually.
Speaker 3Why is that all right?
Speaker 2Well, yes, we do look at older husbands with younger women and we frown. And then we look at older women with younger men and we say, oh, good on her. She's a cougar, I think is the expression. One's a nonce, the other's a cougar. But then that reflects the different power imbalances between, I mean, we've already discussed this. There is a power imbalance between the genders isn't there? Is there a sexual power imbalance between genders?
Speaker 3Yeah, there can be. And that's partly based upon physical force and the threat of violence. But again, if you speak to young people now, if you go on the right wing internet, if you look at the manosphere, their argument is that the power imbalance is the other way around. Yes. That actually women dominate the sexual market because they have much greater choice. And many men, many men feel locked out of it.
Speaker 2Although they say that because they would say that because they're not getting any and often they're incels and things. And that's one thing. But you can speak to female friends of a certain age who say that actually when you go on some of these dating sites, it seems to be very few available and attractive unmarried men and quite a large number of women chasing them. And this is where you get a slight, you get an imbalance when it comes to how many men can have a readily available string of women for no, for all sex versus the number of women that can have the same with men.
Speaker 3I'm sure if you asked a young man, they would say it's the other way around. It's all a matter of perspective. But one thing that has changed to men's disadvantage is a consumer-based sexual culture works against men who do not have a six pack. So men are now doing to their bodies what women used to have to do. And they hate it. They're having to raise their game too. Some young men absolutely love it. They spend all their time in the gym. And by the way, they very often resort to steroids and they're often destroying their bodies and pursuing absurd diets. So both are trying to make themselves more attractive for the market.
Speaker 2And then women might react to that by saying, what about time too? Equally, you've had a backlash from women against ridiculous adverts on the tube like beach body ready. And therefore we have tried to almost desexualize ourselves in the eyes of women. In the eyes of advertisers and others.
Speaker 3But I come back to the double standard. Where is my campaign to stop beach body advertising for men? Well, come on, Tim.
Speaker 2A great many uglier men have prospered in the public eye than women. There's quite a few people on the telly that I look at and say, no woman as ugly as you would ever get this far in this industry.
Speaker 3Well, and I could ask. Or as old as you actually. You as a representative of women, why, despite their ugliness and grossness, do so many young women date them?
Speaker 2Well, that's a good question.
Speaker 3Why do? Why does the 16-year-old girl go out with a 30-year-old man?
Speaker 2Can I just qualify this by saying I've never dated anybody that is 30 years older than me or, God forbid, anyone ugly? What are you saying? Some people have.
Speaker 3And those people who have, not all of them have been subject to grooming. Some of them make a conscious choice to go with an older man because.
Speaker 2Wisdom, experience, and perhaps some cash.
Speaker 3Yeah, they're drawn either to their personality or to their bank account.
Speaker 2All right. So I think we both agree that we shouldn't be legislating against. Most generationally diametrically opposed relationships, even though we deep down think they might be a bit creepy and weird.
Speaker 3Yeah, I'm not comfortable around them myself, but I'm, I think our instincts as small C conservatives is always to turn to state intervention as a last resort.
Speaker 2Not a first resort.
Speaker 3And one of the areas of life where the state really needs to be reluctant about getting involved in is anything related to sex, relationships, and family. It's not really. It's not really the business of the government.
Speaker 2Is it funny, by the way, that the PM's aide has been caught quaffing Prosecco on the train and using chat GPT to, and I loved the prompt for this. How do I make this PM speech more emotive? Because you'd really have to do that if you were dealing with a premier who absolutely speaks from his socialist heart. He just wants to think back to the miners' strike. He wants to be channeling his hatred of Thatcher. And do you know how best to do that? It's by using AI to get your speeches written for you.
Speaker 3It's awful, isn't it? Because political speeches are dreadful as it is, but at the very least, write them yourself. But this does prove that AI will not take over the world because AI will never sit on a train writing a speech while drinking Prosecco and asking AI to make it more emotive. Yes. And I think we're going to reach a point of superintelligence with the computers where AI responds to that with, what is wrong with you? Should you really be doing this? Can you not do this yourself?
Speaker 2Get a grip of yourself. Does your boss know you're doing this?
Speaker 3Who would AI vote for? I don't believe they would vote for Andy Burnham.
Speaker 2No, I think if you put Andy Burnham through AI, they would conclude that there isn't that much there. Sorry,
Speaker 3but Andy Burnham is clearly winging it and does not know what he's saying.
Speaker 2Andy Burnham is an over-promoter. He's an over-promoted Manchester mayor who probably doesn't have the right credentials to be prime minister on account of not really running anything beyond his own quite limited jurisdiction. And by the way. Speaking of which. Yes. Can I. Could you just allow me a little Brexiteer rant for a moment? Okay. Can I? Andy Burnham wants to have an honest conversation about Brexit. Right. Okay. So he's got his big summit on Friday. He's absolutely delighted to once again be flying off to a foreign clime because it's all too difficult to stay here and deal with domestic issues like Piddington.
Speaker 3Yes. Whatever. Although he's our most popular prime minister since 2020, I'd point out. But carry on. According to polls.
Speaker 2Okay. All right. He's more popular than the last very unpopular prime ministers we've had. He wants an honest conversation about Brexit, but he isn't being honest himself, is he? Because reset deals and rejoin attempts are. An aberration of democracy. It was the biggest turnout for the biggest vote in a lifetime. Okay. It's a conceit to suggest that all of our economic woes are down to Brexit. Well, hang on a minute. Even David Cameron, the Remainer-in-Chief, is saying, you don't seem to be taking into account the pandemic, the war in the Middle East, the war in Ukraine, and I suppose the collapse of the Conservative Party. Okay. Then there's this whole sort of lie around, well, people are having regrets and everyone wants to rejoin. Yet, if you ask them, would you like to rejoin the land of milk and honey that is the EU? People go, yes, I would, please. If you say, would you like to rejoin the EU, but it's going to cost you £6,500 over a decade, according to the Growth Commission. And by the way, you know, those opt-outs that we previously had, like we don't need to accept the euro. No, you can't have them. And you're going to have. You're going to have to accept Schengen. So all of your protestations about small boats and mass migration, just cast them aside.
Speaker 3The rebate is gone. The Thatcher rebate can't come back. Exactly. The cost of being a member of the EU has gone up.
Speaker 2Brussels will go after our farming. Brussels will go after our fishing because a leopard doesn't change its bloody spots. And then you put that question to them. Popularity of rejoin, reset, whatever you want to call it, goes down to about 35%. So Boris Johnson's written a book. He's written for us. I think he's rightly saying that if all of the conditions, if we really did have an honest conversation that wasn't a load of blather from the Prime Minister about how Brexit is the sole cause of all of our woes and not three economically illiterate Labour budgets and global headwinds and all the rest of it, if we did have an honest conversation and you were honest, Prime Minister, with the fact that none of this nonsense passes your precious make-a-field test, then we could have another referendum and we'd all vote
Speaker 3leave. Very good. I agree with every word of that. Thank you. All I would add is it seems to me Remain and Leave have switched positions. So Remain is now the one that is claiming there is a silver bullet solution to all our social, political and economic problems. But also it seems to me that Remain have become the fanatics. I was long involved in Euroscepticism and that meant you meant many people who were inordinately concerned about weights and measures. Yes, monkey carrots. And God loved them, but they were a little trying. And they were never going to give up until they got what they wanted. Then they got what they wanted. And most of them have now moved on to other things. Yes. The energy of Brexit is now focused much more on immigration via reform or restore, right? By contrast, the Remainers, who previously never really thought that much about the EU, have suddenly decided overnight it's the most important issue and they're willing to die for it. Yeah, it's extraordinary. And they have become the new fanatics. But I do. think politically this is savvier than it might seem? Because remember, Labour does not need 52%. It doesn't even need 41%. It needs 35%. And if it goes into the next election, as Boris is worried, somewhere around May, saying vote for us and we will give you a second referendum or we'll just go back into the EU. OK, it'll galvanise reform, but that just means reform and the Tories are at each other's throats even more. But it probably gets you to the 35%. Because you might just
Speaker 2have to squander the Red Wall to either of the opposition parties. It doesn't unite the right this. I get exactly why he's doing it. It's a cynical ploy to unite the left. We get that. And to drag in some naive Liberal Democrats who can't get over the referendum result either. Bless their cotton socks, which they wear with sandals.
Speaker 3But I just think psychologically, because of what I've just said.
Speaker 2But Tim, you're going to lose. He cannot get that majority. Listen. Do you think he's
Speaker 3going to lose Makerfield?
Speaker 2Makerfield voted for him because what alternatives did they have? Nobody of any real standing at all. Yeah, but the reform candidate was hugely controversial. It wasn't just because he was a daft candidate. Well, he had said some irretrievably stupid things that came back to haunt him. And their campaign was terrible. We went up there. There were nowhere to be found. And we were knocking on doors and finding people who were supporting Rupert Lowe.
Speaker 3The consequence of reform having all the passion and energy and leave having moved on is that I don't think much of the Red Wall. The Red Wall would particularly care because they just want to get on with their lives now.
Speaker 2OK, but also some of some of some of the wetties, OK, some of the remainer wetties, you know, wet Tories, actual liberal Democrats. Are they really going to be invested in the rejoin the bloc project when they have to consider cozying up to Marine Le Pen potentially? Yeah. Cozying up to the AFD. The economic arguments in favor of the eurozone aren't there anymore, Tim. You know, the German and French economies are flat. Lining, if not going backwards. But they can't make that economic argument. You and I voted for Brexit on fire.
Speaker 3You and I voted for Brexit despite all the economic advice being in favor of remain.
Speaker 2Yes, that's right. And this time around, again, the
Speaker 3positions are switched.
Speaker 2Project for it's all very well. All of these remainers project fear has turned out to have been completely overblown. Yes, it's hard to quantify the Brexit fallout because of the pandemic and the wars. And all the rest of it. But we do need to analyze the conceit at the heart of the government's claim. It is on one hand, Brexit has been so economically damaging for the UK that we have to rejoin the EU. And on the other, boasting of us having the fastest growth in the eurozone. We are outgrowing France
Speaker 3and Germany who are our major European competitors despite being outside of the EU.
Speaker 2Also, by the way, the Growth Commission people who are putting that £6,500 figure on rejoin are saying that. There would actually be a positive gain of £13,000 over a decade if we deregulated, particularly going into this brave new era on AI and other matters. Now, nobody wants an AI free for all, but freedom from the EU has had a load of very substantial gains. The vaccines, trade, VAT. Also, these remainers are so dishonest. They're acting as if we don't have a free trade deal with the EU. We do. And by the way, why is America doing comparatively so? Well, notwithstanding Donald Trump's woes. Isn't that the model that one wants to aspire to? Yes. I agree with you 100%. There's no honesty. What I'm saying is this is what is dishonest. It's the idea that Burnham, of all people, is having an honest conversation. No, he isn't. He's being entirely dishonest in this endeavor.
Speaker 3But all your arguments are based upon pragmatism and detail. And my point is that in the psychology of leave and remain. It has switched. Remain is no longer about pragmatism and detail. It has become a religion. And a religion that probably does attract around 35% of the country. I think you make Lib Dem and even some wet Tory areas competitive for labor if you go down this route. Because I live somewhere where I am surrounded by people who think that Britain died the day it voted for Brexit. Don't hurt people. It's mad to me. Yes. I actually think it's a cleverer strategy than it first looks.
Speaker 2Well, we're going to be following the developments in the summit and also having a good old-fashioned Euro showdown with Remainer-in-Chief Dominic Grieve later this week. So you can look forward to that. And we're going to be back tomorrow, 5pm. See you then. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye. Bye.