Go back

Roy Cooper and Noam Scheiber: We Gotta Rein Trump In

1h 21m 44s

Roy Cooper and Noam Scheiber: We Gotta Rein Trump In

The podcast explores the rise of left-wing economic populism, particularly among college-educated workers, who feel disillusioned by the promise of their education. This disillusionment has led to increased political radicalization, unionization, and support for democratic socialist candidates. The narrative is rooted in a generational shift: despite strong promotion of college as a path to success, graduates face stagnant job markets, high debt, and unmet expectations. This economic frustration converges with a broader cultural sense of "underdogism"—a distrust in U.S. power and institutions—fueling ideological leftward shifts. While economic issues unite college-educated and traditional working-class voters, cultural and identity-based divisions fracture political coalitions. The discussion also highlights Elon Musk’s harmful role in undermining Ukraine’s defense, raising ethical and political alarms. Meanwhile, the detention of Miriam Tamasebi and her family in a Dili internment camp is presented as a symbol of authoritarianism and a failure of democratic norms. The midterms are seen as a turning point, where economic populism gains momentum, and left-leaning candidates emerge as vehicles for systemic change. The podcast concludes that while political unity on economic issues is growing, deeper cultural and class-based divisions remain, and future elections—including the 2028 presidential race—could see a surge in radical left movements, especially if traditional Democratic strategies fail to address working-class grievances.

Transcription

15618 Words, 83380 Characters

English
Hey everybody, we've got a doubleheader for you today. We're in North Carolina on Sunday, but wasn't able to get Roy Cooper out there. So wanted to have a chance to chat with him. Like crazy what's happening in his race. North Carolina, Democrat hasn't won in 20 years. And nobody even talks about this Senate race because he is so far ahead in the polls. So we talked a little bit about why he's doing that and some little modest concerns they have about the polling. So we'll get to that with Roy Cooper. We also have Noam Scheiber, who wrote a book earlier this year. I've been wanting to get him on, talk about what I think is pretty much the most important trend that explains the rise of DSA, left economic populism, and simultaneously kind of MAGA's hold on the right. And so we get a little wonky and talk about that. I think you should enjoy that as well. For, you know, light or fair, if you missed the next level, go check out the next level podcast. And I go deep on J.D. Vance protecting himself. His gay feelings onto James Tallarico. So we talked about that on TNL and also the first press conference from Katie Zachariah as press secretary for Trump. And I mean, it was so bad that we had a commenter from France who offered a comment on our analysis on this press conference and was like, I know that English is not my first language. But is it possible that English is not her first language? Because I don't. I don't recognize this American accent. It's just like, you just haven't watched enough pageants like she does. This is a traditional American blonde accent. Sorry, blondes. We love you. I love blondes. Husbands are blonde. But it's traditional American blonde accent just turned up to 11. And it was a disastrous performance for her yesterday. So we'll have that on the next level. And tomorrow's show will give you a lot of candy with some highlights from it as well. I have one news item and then another serious thing I want to talk about before we get to the interviews. I asked Roy, we pre-taped Roy on Tuesday afternoon and we do a lot of foreign policy talks about the Russia-Ukraine situation. Since that interview, we have additional news about the total rat fuckery that Elon Musk is engaged in right now, helping Putin and hurting Ukraine as it tries to defend itself from this war. horrific invasion as its biggest city descends into darkness as we see images of mother and child buried beneath the rubble. What is Elon Musk doing? He is creating Starlink restrictions to hamper Ukraine while Russia is doing this escalation. So troops are being blindsided. Drone missions have been disrupted. And the Polish leader is attacking Musk over this. You know, we discussed with Roy, like, it seems like there's some threats being made also by Trump to Ukraine about not, you know, not sharing Intel, etc. You know, sorry, this is Russia, Russia, Russia. It was real from the start. A Russian oligarch was paying for Don Jr.'s wedding. And now you have Elon spending 300 plus million on the midterms trying to help Trump. And they're simultaneously helping Russia in their war effort. And they see that as being politically beneficial. Because they've somehow convinced themselves that, like, you know, the diesel price is the fault of Ukraine and Ukraine's effort to defend themselves. And, you know, we discussed this with Susan Rice yesterday, the degree to which that is, you know, stupidity or sinister kind of doesn't matter. It's probably both. You know, there's probably some element of them liking being able to help Putin and being on Putin's side. And there's also, I think, a stupid general belief that this is what is causing high diesel prices. Rather than the stupid war of choice in Iran. It is just completely unconscionable what Elon's up to. And I'm going to have much more on this on tomorrow's show. But just wanted to mention it since that was a development since the interview with Roy Cooper. I also want to talk about Miriam Tamasebi, her husband Issa, and their son who have been in Dili internment camp now for 187 days. Because of something that one of their ancestors did. Nothing, they've done nothing. They're here legally. They have no even alleged immigration issues. And we're holding them in a camp like it's Japanese internment again. I don't know. I've been pretty frustrated by the lack of focus on this, even from our friends in the Democratic Party. And the lack of outrage about their family. But they're just representative of a lot of people who are wrongly being interned right now. And the various camps we have all over the country. So some friends of theirs started a website. It's called Free Profs Family. Free Profs Family dot com. If you could do me a solid and send that website to your representatives, your senators, particularly if they're Democrats, really. And ask them to engage on this and speak out on it. That would be appreciated. So we'll put the link to that in the show notes. It is fucking horrific. And it's. It's fundamentally un-American. And if we believe in anything, and if we're going to do anything here when it comes to the fight for liberal democracy, it has to start with fighting for people who are being wrongly imprisoned for no reason, for political purposes, by an authoritarian state. And by Marco Rubio in particular. So there we are. Stick around for Roy Cooper at the end. I did my Roy Cooper impression. But up first, it's Noam Scheiber. Thanks for having me. Thank you for doing it. The book is about one of kind of two countervailing. political trends that you have been covering. And you've been covering, I think, from an interesting angle, looking at this from labor and workplace issues. Because I think the political trends are downstream of that. And that is these college-educated workers who feel like the promise of their education has not been fulfilled economically. And they're getting upset about it. And they're getting radicalized and going more left. And then simultaneously, you have working-class white guys that feel like they have a ceiling on their aspirations. And they're. They're getting radicalized, and they're moving right. And so, I kind of want to talk about both of those trends and how they intersect at the midterms here. But before we do that, just kind of set the table for people. Just maybe explain the Reader's Digest version of Mutiny. Yeah. So, my book is about the generation of people who graduated from college, beginning right after the Great Recession, really all the way through, you know, this past June. So, kind of younger millennials and Gen Z folks. And this was a generation of folks that was. It was really given the hardest sell of any generation in history about why they need to go to college. You know, everyone from the president, you know, Obama, Clinton saying college is no longer a luxury. It's essential to compete in the global economy to, you know, their guidance counselors and principals and teachers. I loved your anecdote that you had in there that KIPP, because my daughter went to KIPP for one year for preschool. And it was like they had a slogan, college starts in kindergarten. I mean, this really became a national obsession beginning in the early 90s. Yeah. KIPP had. You know, all these KIPPs had, you know, signs all over. You couldn't miss it. You know, college begins in kindergarten. And so, naturally, these folks, you know, were completely preoccupied with going to college. They did more to prepare for college than any generation in history. The number of people taking AP courses increases like tenfold between the 80s and the 2010s. So, just a huge increase in the number of people preparing for college. And then, you know, they obviously go to college. They take on huge amounts of debt. But when they get out, the return to a college degree is. Suddenly stagnating. And then, you know, starting to go down if you factor in all the debt that they've had to take on. And so, just a huge gap opens up between these folks' expectations of what awaited them on the other side of college and the reality that they encounter. And, yeah, as you say, that's a super radicalizing development. These people get incredibly frustrated. And they start doing things that college grads don't normally do. They're picking fights with their employers. They're staging walkouts, signing petitions. Some of them start unions. They're unionizing, going on strike. And then, you know, most relevant for this conversation, they start voting for, you know, far-left candidates, for democratic socialist candidates. The number of college grads who say they support socialism basically doubles in the 2010s from like the low 20s to over 40%. So, just this huge shift that affects everything, as you say, from the workplace to the political realm. And, yeah, I think we're still sort of living in that world. Yeah, and the book follows, like, anytime you talk about these broad trends, like, you're always kind of painting with a broad brush. I don't want anybody to kind of feel offended, right? Because there are, like, specific examples of all these different things. So, the book follows, like, about a dozen employees. Some of them end up, like, having to work at Starbucks or be Apple genius people. And some of them are at universities. And this is, you know, kind of the, you know, kind of college, kind of doctorate crowd. Some of them have, you know, kind of are stuck in jobs in, like, PR Hollywood, et cetera, and not, you know, having the growth that they thought that they would. And so, I guess my question. The question is, you know, obviously in some of these cases, the economic hardship is more than others yep and they're like certain categories of the people these people get stereotyped right i mean like this is going to be offensive to some of the dsa is listening but some of these people are just kind of the updated bobos like the david brooks like bobos and paradise book you know 10 20 years earlier which was you know kind of the bobos was bohemian bourgeoisie it was like people that like were in upper middle class upper class environments but didn't have that income and like that created the status anxiety yep you know that they had and it feels like this is like a little bit of an exasperated version of this where like they're sure there's some that are like really struggling economically but then there are others that just have this kind of like deep status anxiety that's leading to kind of resentments and and that has contributed to radicalization how do you kind of parse out those you know different categories of people yeah it's a really good question i think you're absolutely right there are a few different types of folks that are that are all kind of exist in what i broadly call the college educated working class so one is this group of people who went to college they took on debt and then you know um they just couldn't get the job that they that they anticipated so i follow a worker at an apple store in towson maryland which was the first apple store to unionize in the country her name is kaya barrett she went to towson university she majored in communications she worked at the apple store while she was in college and then was applying to like a whole bunch of companies and she was like you know i'm going to do this i'm going to do this i'm going to sort of communications um kind of instructional design training jobs you know to help train their employees so she applied to like facebook and you know industrial companies like stanley black and decker sends out hundreds of applications doesn't get any bites so it just ends up taking her college job as a full-time job you know after she graduates so i think in her case you know what we saw is just the real bite of kind of some long-term economic forces you know i cite research and in the book uh about how the labor market for college guys really starts to kind of slow down even before the great recession sort of 2003 four or five and then nosedives after the great recession and then we just never see it fully recover at least for young grads even 10 years after the great recession so she graduates in 2018 job market is still not great so there's a large cohort of people who are kind of caught up in these kind of shifting tectonic forces that are really lowering the return on a college degree lowering employment prospects but then as you say there's another group of folks who i think graduate and do okay by any conventional measure but they're not doing as well as they thought they would so this is kind of like less than a sort of objective economic reality than a kind of real gap between expectations you know they wanted to you know to be um an architect and you know they took on a lot of debt and worked really hard and you know maybe they work in an architecture firm but they're in like pr communicate you know so it's it's a it's a frustration that you're naming two of my friends right now i'm not gonna right exactly so i think i think that is a piece of this too and i think you know the third part of it is that i think it's a it's a it's a big part of it is that you know the third piece is um a group of professional workers white collar workers who i think did well both economically are making a decent amount of money and you know kind of realize the ambition so far as it goes but are just frustrated by the way those jobs have changed so i put doctors in this category you know doctors we haven't really seen wages for doctors take a big hit you know doctors still earn a pretty good living economically but what we've seen is just a huge chain in changing the working conditions you know 30 years ago doctors were you know they owned their own business they were these professionals whose opinion was deferred to no one questioned their judgment they treated patients how they saw fit if you flash forward to the present the medical profession has undergone this huge consolidation most doctors are now employees they work for these huge health care systems that are run by like mbas that give them all kinds of like marching orders about how long you can spend with your patients how long you can keep the patient in the hospital the questions you have to ask them when you see them and so doctors now feel like like you know one of the things that i've seen is that doctors are not the only ones that are trying to make sure that their patients are safe and that they're not the only ones that are trying to make sure that their patients are safe and that they're not the only employees just yank us around so i think that's this third group you know a group who um kind of achieve what they set out to achieve they still make a decent amount of money but the way that their workplace and the economy has changed has completely alienated them and so they now feel like workers whereas a generation ago they used to feel like you know owners or professionals they did not feel like labor they felt you know like capital basically to put it in the marxist terms yeah so it's interesting so we'll get to the other like the more traditional kind of union worker types and the way that they've changed but like that i think is is like the conceit of the book right which is right that these big professional class type people with varying degrees of success are you know now motivated the way that like factory workers were in a different era and and you know i do think that there's like some eye rolling at this at times in the culture right i mean what drew me to the to the book i admitted it this in the green room was jay caspian kang's article about the book you know which is which is the point of doing pr right yeah yeah exactly but his article which i read this and i was like oh man this is so right and um was titled subaru socialists and the great disappointed and he kind of pegs it around you know kind of zoron and and he writes this like after every big election night for the leftist comes some eye rolling complaint from centrists and the right oh great some gentrifiers who went to sarah lawrence are coast playing socialism and pretending they're working class and to me i kind of see both sides of that right like i see the side of why i don't know why i don't know why i don't know why i don't understand the frustration of why this is happening i also understand the eye rolling like this like this is not you know we're not in the gilded age you know like you're not in a factory like your fingers don't really hurt at the end of the day right and so like how do you kind of tease out you know the degree to which this is legitimate versus the degree to which there's something about our cultural milieu that's creating it so in in like not to bore readers but in the political science literature about this there is a kind of debate over whether this is economics you know this is kind of materialist forces or it's ideology you know something that is untethered to you know i mean i personally think ideology is is downstream of economics i think they're tied up but in the way i think about it is um if you look at where the big shift left comes among college educated voters so in the in the 80s 90s into the early 2000s college educated folks were generally to the right of non-college folks on economic issues you know so the size of government redistribution regulation college folks were were to the right you know they were kind of right of center on economics non-college the classic i really my people you know i'm conservative on fiscal i'm basically conservative and socially liberal exactly that's exactly right beginning in about 2004 there's a great paper by a stanford political scientist named william marble who gets at this with really granular data beginning in 2004 we start to see the college educated folks move a little bit left and you know you got to think that's like that's an ideological thing it's a reaction to george w bush and you know iraq and things like that but we see this huge lurch in 2008 right and what happens in 2008 right the bottom falls out of the global economy you know even at the at the the worst part of the global financial crisis only about 10 percent of americans were unemployed which was very high you know by historical standards but that means you know 90 of folks were not unemployed so the way i think about it is the people who were directly impacted or directly feared for their job you know so 10 unemployment you know probably another 10 to 20 percent uh folks were really worried you know maybe their companies were down a little bit but they were not unemployed and they were not unemployed and they were not unemployed and they were not unemployed but they were really worried about it i would say those folks are the folks who are materially impacted by the way you know they are worried about economic conditions and they think this system is screwed up and is going to potentially cost them their job that is economics that is me worried about where my next paycheck is going to come from but i think that the way that the financial crisis played out has kind of a little bit of an impact on how i think about how i think about how i think about how i think about how i think about how i think about how i think about how i think about how i think about how i think about my paycheck but man like this whole system of institutions you know wall street and the banks and the government like it's just looking pretty rickety to me and i'm not sure i can trust it anymore and so i think at the same time as you have the people who are sort of directly or kind of indirectly impacted by the financial crisis you have a whole nother you know massive swath of college educated folks who are just like losing faith in the system and i think that's the kind of ideological shift that's happening at that point and those two things are happening at the same time so i think that the financial crisis is kind of the impetus for both of them but for like slightly different reasons everything you just laid out from that period from the economic crisis and then up through covid like makes a lot of sense to me about how you know some of these political shifts in this kind of college educated class to the economic left like is rational and downstream of economics then like biden gets in and is like really responsive to this group's concerns in particular you know you have the student loan bailout yep you have you know lena khan and you know the ability to unionize right like the in these different types of workplaces expands and so like you would think if this was just about kind of like economics and policy you'd think that then the response would be okay like well our part of this party is being responsive to my concerns yeah yeah take the way and yeah and instead you get the opposite right like more anger at at the democratic establishment than ever right now and do you have the you know quasi not really like a little bit of a tea party left wave after biden leaves yeah how do you square that yeah it's a great question and this is where i'd kind of lean heavier on the ideological component and the way i think about sort of the ideological arc of this generation is something that i sort of broadly refer to as underdogism and so i think if you're you know a baby boomer or even a gen xer i'm 50 so i'm a kind of younger gen xer you grew up in a world where um you know, maybe the US wasn't the underdog, but we faced like real admirers adversaries and we could tell a story about like this righteous fight that we're engaged in right you know certainly world war ii fighting fascism and then you know during the cold war we're fighting communism and you could feel good that you know maybe your country was flawed obviously you know things went off the rails in vietnam but basically like we are fighting a righteous fight against these kind of existentially dangerous adversaries well what happens in the 90s right our adversaries go away um and so these these folks are born in the 90s the adversaries are gone the u.s is now the unrivaled power in the world and it looks like instead of these external threats like what is the biggest danger to the world it's us right like we have we have iraq right we invade iraq and it's a huge fiasco 9-11 does happen during this period no no right i i hear you uh i mean i'm airbrushing the the narrative but yes but clearly 9-11 is an impetus but you know if you're born in the 90s you know you're a teenager you know or late 80s early 90s you're you're you're kind of in middle school right around the time of the iraq war then you have the global financial crisis right you have huge inequality so suddenly it's like you know for the previous generations that were you know the u.s was like this kind of righteous actor we're now the unrivaled superpower and we're doing all this stuff that's like messing up the world you know we're screwing up iraq in the middle east we're screwing up the global financial system we have all this inequality in the u.s we have all these corporate fat cats who are unaccountable our police are like roughing up you know black and brown people like suddenly like u.s institutions start to look deeply suspect u.s power looks deeply suspect right and these folks who've only known like the u.s as like the top dog in the world start you know start wondering like what is the deal like maybe we're like we're the danger to the world and so i think that kind of ideology of like underdogism deep skepticism of american power of american institutions really fuels the ideological component of this and i think that's a really good point and i think that's a really good point and i think just to add one more layer because i think people often struggle to wonder like where israel fits into this right israel is the ultimate example of kind of a country that goes from underdog to overdog right you know if you're gen x or a boomer israel for you in your mind is this underdog right surrounded by hostile powers trying to expunge you know the country but if you're born in in the early 90s right and you're coming of age in the 2010s all you know is israel is like the hegemon in the 90s right and you're coming of age in the early 90s all you know is israel is like the hegemon in the early 90s and despite it being the hegemon the u.s sends it billions of dollars in aids gives us all this military weaponry so it's like this kind of overdog story um it gets repeated in a whole variety of ways that really informs this generation so you see as you say biden in in many ways is doing everything that this group of voters wants right but you know gaza just brings all these contradictions to the fore and you wonder like you know in my book i write about how you know how these starbucks workers who are unionizing and they're engaged in the kind of like trench warfare with the company they unionize hundreds and hundreds of stores but they can't reach the contract and at a certain point october 7th happens and they all rally around you know palestine and the palestinian cause and you're like what on earth does palestine have to do with a contract for baristas but it actually does fit neatly into the story were these underdogs we're taking on this like terrible you know in their minds you know hugely powerful corporate actor and look palestinians are taking on this hegemon you know we're all sort of united in our fight against these kind of overdogs these hegemons and that's kind of the sort of unified theory that starts to take shape benjamin franklin wrote the phrase time is money in 1748 in a letter of advice to a young tradesman is that do we think that's true or do we think that's apocryphal it says it right here in my script that it's true i'm gonna take our our new sponsor's word for it because it feels like something ben franklin would say and time is money it's true it's a truism you is a smart founding father and uh if you subscribe to that like you should uh you should turn to our friends at ramp with ramp expenses submit themselves just text or email your receipt and ramp categorizes codes and submits it for you when you book business travel with ramp they find the best flights and hotels you're actually allowed to book no more finding out a month later that your hotel is only partially covered whatever that means ramp is the only finance platform that employees and finance teams both rave about more than 70 000 organizations from family farms to large companies and they're all part of the same thing and they're all part of the same thing and they're all part of the same thing and they're all part of the same thing and the largest fortune 100s have saved billions with ramp love ramp you guys are gonna be really shocked to hear this expenses just are not don't happen for me i mean like the amount of money that i feel like i'm a working class professional like noam schieber talks about whenever expense time comes around because i just give money to the boss i have my whole life i don't like doing it i lose the receipts makes me annoyed to do it i don't turn in my expenses so i'm like costing myself money because out of laziness and that's bad like i shouldn't do that but some some bosses kind of count on that right like i think i think that there's i think that sometimes there's a little bit of trouble making a foot at the among the capital class when it comes to expenses no more with ramp you actually do it it's easy extremely easy i use it now do not have any complaints my expenses are being paid so it's a little kind of late because it's well anyway that's that's neither here nor there but my expenses are being paid now and that's exciting you should get on earlier in your career than i did on actually turning in your expenses and use ramp time is money save both with ramp new customers get 250 off at ramp.com slash bulwark go to ramp.com slash bulwark ramp.com slash bulwark every podcaster is a little bit of a narcissist so i have i feel like we all have a good a good ear for narcissism and i i just i do think that there's a like a little bit of that in the underdog story where there are these you know folks that are like again like pretty deeply focused on their own like concerns whether it be their own material or status concerns but also like the concerns of their cohort which some of them are well meaning like obviously gaza climate etc yeah but like dismissive of the concerns of other underdogs and like this takes us to where like these things are happening and you do hear a lot from kind of the populist left like this idea that like we want to have a kind of a unifying class battle against the establishment but like the problem is i it feels like a lot of times they're pretty dismissive of the concerns that the working class like the more old school working class which i guess we sometimes shorthand as white working class but there are a lot of i mean there are plenty of black and brown factory workers like so like the more traditional let's go industrial working class industrial working class there you go and and like they're dismissive of their cultural concerns or status concerns their views that they're being talked down to religious you know gap you know between you know religiosity and church going and i don't know i just wonder as you kind of have covered both of these trends it feels like there's more lip service being paid to the class unity than there is actual empathy towards the concerns of the the voters that have put trump in the white house yeah i guess i would say two things first of all i think it's a good question because i think it's a good thing i mean one is that i think we are seeing a real convergence on economics you know so if you just look at economic issues this this paper i cited earlier you really do see this convergence you know the college educated folks and the non-college folks by 2016 are kind of like right in the same spot and in fact that actually the college grads end up even moving further to the left of the non-college folks right but but basically you know you you had um the college folks to the you know well to the right on economics on on these you know taxes redistribution government regulation in the 80s 90s early 2000s and then they really do converge on on economics and the you know the moment that this becomes clear to me is in 2023 you had all these strikes you know you have hollywood strikes you had the uaw going on strike for um six weeks something like that and gallup did a really interesting set of polls where they asked folks you know do you side with the striking workers or do you side with the companies and if you looked at say support for uaw striking uaw workers it was about 70 percent of american supported the workers over the companies and if you just broke it out by college educated folks they were even higher you know they were like 75 support for the workers so on economics you had this real convergence on sort of um social issues on rhetoric on you know a whole variety of kind of cultural issues foreign policy i think you're absolutely right i mean you you see this real convergence on economics but um a real distance on on a whole variety of cultural issues like i often would join the um some of the workers that i write about in the book at starbucks and apple were very generous and letting me sit in on on calls you know bargaining sessions organizing meetings things like that and um on economics you know any factory worker at a ford or gm plant would have been 100 comfortable with where these people are coming from but there was definitely a language around a whole variety of identity issues that would you know that just no question would be alienating and i think they really struggled to sort of modulate that because you know i guess sometimes you get the impression that they like the idea of this coalition of the sort of college educated working class and the industrial working class they like that in theory you know but the sort of lived reality of the interactions is is a little tricky there are kind of two case studies where i write about this coalition kind of falling apart one is at amazon right where you had you know a mix of kind of college educated workers and more traditionally working class folks at amazon they came together for the sake of winning this election at a amazon warehouse on stat island was the first unionized facility in the country but then it it just descends into kind of recrimination And the non-college folks would refer to them as like Ivy Leaguers, you know, even if they'd gone to like a random state gets wrapped up into this. Exactly. Yeah. So so the Amazon thing kind of unravels along those grounds. And then at the UAW, too, you have this sort of coalition of grad students, which the UAW represents now tens of thousands of grad students and traditional factory workers. They came together to elect this reformist militant leader named Sean Fain, who then leads the strike. But then after that strike, that coalition kind of unravels, too. And you just start to get, you know, a whole bunch of recriminations and rivalries between the college folks and the non-college folks. So you do see how even though the you know, you see the sort of basis for the coalition, but you also see how fragile it is and how quickly it can kind of unravel. Like another example, I'm going to get to some positive parts about this coalition in the midterms in a second. But we're going to we're going to go through all of my all my concerns first. So, you know, stick around if you're starting to get depressed about the about the trajectory here. But like the projecting out like an agenda for another Democratic president. Right. Like another way you see that, like people will say, well, like there is unity on economic populism. And there is like on certain things. Right. Like, you know, income inequality, you know, the tech billionaire class still needed that. Like, you know, broader support for unionization, as you said. But then like on priorities like this is something that Biden fell into. Right. Like if you are a, you know, in the people you write about in your book, college educated working class, you're for like student loan forgiveness stuff because that addresses what you're doing. If you didn't go to college, that does nothing for you. Right. Yeah. And if you didn't go to college and you're more in the industrial working class, you know, whatever, cutting red tape to build more factories is important to you so you can have higher paying jobs. And that is going to come in conflict at some point. And I think that is going to come in conflict with some of the kind of left green concerns or maybe left ideological hostility towards the AI build out, you know, that means limiting kind of the expansion of jobs. So, like, how do you see kind of like that, even in the just pure economic side of things like that tension playing out? Yeah. I mean, I say there's probably a little more overlap than, you know, than the common narrative, you know. So the Biden education loan forgiveness, for example. Yeah. I think the administration argued with some justification that the people in the worst of all worlds were the people who'd gone to college for a year or two, didn't get that degree, but still have that debt, you know, and a lot of those people are sort of traditional working class. You know, you went to your state school or even community college, you ran up $10,000, $20,000 in debt. Now you work at an Amazon fulfillment center. You never got that degree, so you don't get the benefit of having gone to college, but you still have that $20,000 in debt, you know. So I do think there's a little more overlap. But on your broader point, it's a totally fair point. I think there are clear sort of. You know, tensions in the coalition. I think that, you know, you probably see that most in actually mentioned green energy. And I think, you know, if you kind of dug a little bit around the green energy debate in the Biden administration, you really did see this tension because the people who are most concerned about climate change are saying, like, why are we like slowing this down and putting all these union requirements on this stuff? Like, why don't we just buy a bunch of solar panels from China because they produce that stuff way more cheaply? And if we're really concerned about climate change, like that would be the fastest, cheapest, most efficient way to do that. Whereas the Biden folks were like, no, we've both got to do the green energy, but we've got to make it a source of jobs. I think to critics, that was just like incoherent, right? Like either you're you care about jobs and you want to do industrial policy or you care about climate change, but like pick what your priority is. Right. And the Biden folks, you know, I understand the political logic. We're really concerned that this not be seen as this kind of upscale, you know, kind of lefty green initiative. Right. They wanted it wanted politically for it to be seen as a jobs program, too. But that, you know, that makes it less efficient. It slows it down. So you really saw that tension between the two groups and the circle the Biden folks were trying to square in the implement, you know, in the conceit and implementation of that program. All right. Holiday travel is stressful enough without worrying about your suitcase and whether everything's going to fit and whether it's safe and whether you're going to be able to charge, whether you're going to be able to. Stay hydrated. We've got a product here that helps you solve all those problems. And it is with our friends at Noble Travel. Noble completely removes the zipper. It's slick. It's zipperless latch lock suitcase closes like a safe two halves meet with a tight seal. It's nice. You can hear and feel it. It's very satisfying sound. It's better sound than the one I just imitated, but it's good. But it's not just the safest luggage out there. They fix everything that annoys you about travel. They got a built in charging. Port to your phone's charging. I mean, I literally my life motto is ABC always be charging and still one out of three flights. I get on the plane. My phone's a 42%. The plug isn't working at the seat. They don't have a plug. No more. Not with the suitcase. Not with the Noble suitcase. They also have a laptop pocket makes going through TSA and breeze. If you don't have TSA pre and they got to flip out cup holder right into the luggage. Every time we have this ad, I have a new story. Because. I'm just such a mess on planes like I need this suitcase to to make me like basically competent like minimally competent to boarding a flight and I was late boarding on flight to Springfield for our live show you know the luggage container above my seat was full and so I'm having to like go further back and then I'm like I'm dropping something I have my hand and then I find a spot and I put it up. But then like I like I noticed about the waters about because I'm the waters in the cup holder which is nice and convenient 98% of the time except for when you forget that's there and then you pick it up and then and then I turn around and the guy there is like hey Tim big fan. I'm just like oh my gosh. So like this is how I'm working with the best suitcase on the market. All right. Imagine the disaster that I was two years ago. You don't even want to know the horror stories make holiday travel a little less stressful with Noble. Security design and convenience all in one had to Noble travel.com for up to 46% off your entire order. That's no bl travel.com for up to 46% off after you purchase. They'll ask where you heard about them. Please support our show and tell them we sent you. One of the things you wrote lately is recently was about concealing for attainment for people coming out of the traditional working class non-college folks to go to college which like maybe it wasn't true in past generations and that. Extends also to the politics debate and like there's something this is not to take away like I think that there are earnest people on both sides of this who like care deeply about working class people's concerns like you do end up kind of in this kind of weird performative political world where you have the Ivy League working class that you're talking about kind of a college educated professional working class like competing with old school capital tech guys and like the car dealer owners on the right. Yeah like for. The support of the people that are like actually the traditional kind of working class right and so they end up you know I think as we project out to the next decade like that group like the old school teamsters union types like are going to become like basically the swing voters you know like in the past people the past like the swing voters is like my people like college at suburban whatever security moms or whatever soccer moms like that's not it anymore so you have these two kind of professional classes like competing over the working class I maybe that gives them power I don't know how do you kind of see that playing out. Yeah I think that you know the class is like fascinating and fraught and all the ways that you said I mean I think you know the traditional as I thought about class and who gets to you know claim that they're working class is bubbled up obviously like in Graham Platner's campaign in Maine right now that was the sort of peg for my writing about it was you know this guy his father is a Ivy League trained lawyer his grandfather was a famous architect he went to sort of private schools but then you know ended up sort of downwardly mobile right as this Western farmer he served in the military as a Marine in Iraq and Afghanistan so yeah I mean the way I see it at a broad level is the left kind of thinks of class as what you are now right like your relationship to capital now so you may come from a really privileged background your parents may have gone to Ivy League schools you may have gone to college but if you're just like driving Uber and you know delivering for Amazon Flex or whatever you're working class and the right tends to see class as like inherited you know so it's why you can have like a car dealer you know who makes 10 or 20 million dollars a year right owning like a chain of 12 car dealerships across the Midwest but if that person grew up working class they think that they get to claim that they're working class you know so you have this sort of two clashes of vision you know the left it's like what you are now in your immediate circumstances in your relationship to to work in capital and the right it's like what did your parents do and how did you grow up and I think you know where that hits the road where that rubber hits the road politically is is very much in that like who's kind of story about class feels like realer in any in any given moment you know and there are times when the right story feels realer because right you know we get into these kind of cultural conversations the you know these conversations about you know vocabulary and you know gender and identity and everyone who sort of grew up a certain way is like wow this is like totally alien to me and then we get into other moments when like, you know, as in the last year or two, when like affordability looms incredibly large and inflation is hitting people and they feel like they can't keep up when it's like your current circumstances, like just that feels like what defines class and privilege. And so in a way, to me, it's like the kind of swing voter is defined by the narrative that one or the other side succeeds at putting at the center of the election. And obviously that's, you know, that's dictated by external circumstances and in this kind of affordability moment. Well, that takes us to the happy part of the midterms, which is that obviously the left story is winning now. And I think that, you know, if you look at kind of where the Democrats seem likely to gain this year, it is going to be clawing back some of the white working class voters in the industrial Midwest. It's going to be clawing back Hispanic. Working class voters, a lot of places and calling back some of the younger voters that I think were caught up in this economic anxiety that you're writing about. And particularly the men, you know, maybe hopefully we're just very briefly enamored with, you know, the story that Trump was offering and in part because their like experience was about the tough economy during Biden years. Like, is that too simple for you or is that kind of what you see basically happening right now? Yeah, no, I see that. I mean, again, to go back to the kind of political science analysis of this, I think, you know, you have this this thing that doesn't make sense right over the past 15 years. If college educated Democrats are moving to the left on economics and we have now this huge majority of folks, you know, from college educated to non-college folks, all of whom have more populist economic preferences. Right. How is how is the right winning? You know, I mean, you know, it's a little more complicated. I mean, Trump, to his credit, recognizes this and he breaks with Republicans. Over traditional economic issues on trade, on globalization, manufacturing, things like that. So Trump recognizes this. You know, he's he's a very savvy political actor, obviously. But I think the biggest reason, you know, you would say that Republicans succeeded in this period where the whole country was moving left on economics is by making elections about non-economic issues, about about culture, about grievance, things like that. Well, I guess I just want to pivot on that for a second. I think that Trump also we talked about this a little bit yesterday with Jackie. Right. About the Hispanic vote. It was a lie. Right. But Trump told an aspirational economic story to working people. And like, despite the fact that he was a nepo baby, rich kid, like because of his like, yeah, sort of like middle class, middle brow, you know, kind of cultural status. Right. I think he was able to kind of tell a little bit of economically aspirational story why you had a lot of the people in the Democratic leadership that like didn't have, like, that coherent of an economic narrative at all, actually, like, you know, and people might have been moving more to the left and that you see them this appeal of Bernie, et cetera. But I don't know. And Jay writes about this in the article about your book. It's like, what would I Kamala Harris's like messages about opportunity, economy, and it was a lot of all three of them really had the last three nominees had a lot of a little bit of a mushy, like economic message, maybe. Is that okay? Is that no, you think it's all culture? No, no, I think that's fair. I mean, I think there's an element of that. I mean, I'd say two other things to me that mattered. One is just a huge focus on the right, often successfully on identity, you know, and you just can't, you know, whether it's black, brown, or, you know, gay, lesbian, trans, you know, just the elevation of identity during this period, I think is hugely successful for the right. And the other thing is, yes, there is an economic message. And it's a kind of aspirational story that Trump is telling. I think that is very appealing for some, but it's, it's tied up in him as this kind of, pop cultural figure to this kind of celebrity thing, which, you know, again, has economic resonance, but also has a kind of cultural resonance to, you know, so, yeah, it's a little tricky, but I think you're right. I think there's an element of that. But, you know, suffice it to say, we're now in this moment where, you know, the price of gas and home heating oil, and, you know, your rent and interest rates, right, is, is now just focusing the mind like never before. And I you just talked about, you know, young people, non-college sort of traditional industrial working class and the college educated working class that I write about. And that's just like a very potent coalition, obviously, because if you're in a world where, you know, two thirds to three quarters of the country thinks of themselves as working class and is pretty left, you know, on economic issues. And that's what the election is about. You know, do the math, right? It's a pretty favorable environment. Yeah. And it's also related to this. I think JBL read about this in his newsletter yesterday, and I'd recommend people go read that just about people. There's a real sense of feeling stuck right now. And if you feel stuck, then, you know, like the Trump like message sounds starts to sound ridiculous to people. You know what I mean? Like people that are not like fully on board with the cultural side of Trumpism. You know, he was focusing particularly on the housing side. And I guess we haven't really talked about that. But so maybe talk about this as it relates to your book as well, which is he's like, we're in this weird moment right now. Like Trump has managed to create an economy where it's bad for buyers and sellers. Like people feel like your housing value is going down. But if you want to downsize, the cost of your new mortgage would go up because of the interest rates. Right, right, right. Exactly. So anyway, talk about the degree to which housing overlaps on all this. Yeah. No, I think housing is a huge issue. And just to go back to the kind of the big theme of my book is this sort of story that young folks were sold, right? Is like, go to college. That's your ticket to the upper middle class, right? And what is like the signature upper middle class investment? It's a house, right? And yet that generation of folks, the people who, you know, kind of start graduating in the early 2010s, you know, and continue over the last 15 years, housing has never been more unattainable to any generation of Americans, you know, since we started doing, you know, the kind of modern mortgage market that it is today. I mean, the National Association of Realtors puts out a, you know, data every, I can't remember if it's every month or every quarter, but basically age of first home ownership. And, you know, by the early 2020s, that had hit about 40, which was just like way higher than it had been, you know, a generation earlier. So it's, it's both kind of economically substantively important in that, like, this is a huge part of most people's financial portfolio, but also symbolically, arguably even more important because there's nothing like more closely associated with the upper middle class lifestyle that your college degree was supposed to get you than a house. Okay, well, crystal ball this for us. You spent a lot of time with the radicalized professional working class. Are we headed towards France, you know, like mass protests among this class, maybe even like little spouts of violence, or is there a path towards, you know, rebalancing things? Yeah, I mean, look, I think what we saw. I see France, just to say, you know, I see France. Yeah, look, I think what we saw in the Democratic primaries, this election cycle was a warm-up for, for 2028. I mean, you have this pretty radicalized college-educated demographic, and you have a sense, I think you will have a sense, you know, unless things go very badly for Democrats in the midterms, that actually either, you know, you do better nominating these, you know, left populist candidates, or at least you don't do worse, right? So you can kind of vote your conscience and your ideology and not give up on your electoral process. So, you know, if Democrats end up taking the Senate, if they. if they win some of these seats, like Abdul Al-Sayed in Michigan, I think you're going to have like a very strong argument by folks in the DSA, in the kind of DSA-adjacent left, you know, certainly Bernie AOC, that like, look, we've been telling you this for years, this is a political winner. And you know what, substantively, way better, because we need to shake up this kind of neoliberal oligarchy that's been running the country for decades. So, yeah, I expect this year's, you know, sometimes divisive primaries. You know, particularly in Michigan, I suspect that we're going to see that play out on like a much bigger scale in the run up to 2028. Obviously, it'll depend on who exactly runs. I mean, I think AOC, as much as she's sort of caricatured as like a kind of unapologetic left figure, is actually, you know, somewhat pragmatic and kind of gets where the fault lines are and gets where the areas of overlap are. So I think she's actually reasonably pragmatic. But, you know, you could get any number of folks. I mean, you know, it wouldn't be crazy to imagine. We might end up in a 2012 situation, too, especially if AOC doesn't run. I mean, that's my last time. But you think back at that, and it was like, well, the seeds of Trumpism, you know, had already been planted in all the stuff we've been talking about in Iraq and the financial crisis. But just like there was no good vessel for it, you know, and so you end up kind of like ending, you end up with sort of Mitt Romney by default. And I do think it's hard to see another good vessel besides AOC. I guess maybe Abdul is running immediately, but there are a lot of issues with that. Yeah, you can imagine someone turning around. So, you know, it's hard to imagine that, like, you know, a lot of people are going to say, you know, I'm not going to be running, you know, I'm not going to be running for president. I'm going to be running for president. I'm not going to be running for president. I mean, I would, if I look like Mitt at his age, I mean, I'll, that would be my one wish for a genie. If a genie came to me. afternoon all right no anything else i didn't ask you about any fun any hot takes you've got even waiting to get off your chest no i think i mean look i'd say the only thing just per the last uh uh point that we were discussing is mamdani is a kind of power broker you know obviously he can't run for president um you have to be born in the u.s but you know i think he kind of flexed his muscles as a power broker within the party just you know you saw in new york he came out backed some of these dsa and dsa adjacent candidates they won you know i expect him you know to be a you know a player in this 2028 2032 conversation even you know again if he he won't be the candidate himself but i think he'll be pretty influential it's noam shiver the book is mutiny the rise and revolt of the college educated working class um there's going to be a lot more on this beat to come i suspect so we'll keep in touch all right brother yeah i look forward to it really really enjoyed it thanks all right he is the democratic nominee for senate in north carolina he was the governor there for two terms and also the state's longest serving attorney general it's roy cooper welcome to the show glad to be with you tim good to see you sir all right we got a bunch of politics to talk about but i'm going to do a little bit of news you know the thing i'm most interested in and what your views are on kind of headed to the senate um if you if you win here in a couple of weeks obviously his foreign policy stuff which he didn't deal with as much you know as attorney general and governor there in north carolina over the weekend trump announced uh that he was doing this diesel deal with russia and it's to buy russian diesel saw some reports that he's putting pressure on ukraine to stop their attacks on energy infrastructure in russia and threatening even to not share intelligence anymore with ukraine if they don't stop that what are you handling the conflict right now well it's frustrating we need to know who our allies are and who our enemies are and instead of this payout to putin what he ought to be doing is removing these chaotic tariffs that are costing people finding a way to end this war in iran that's costing american lives and at the same time driving up the cost of diesel and and gas here at home it's frustrating to me that this is the kind of response that he would have to people not having enough month at the end of their money uh and and struggling with paying bills this is his response instead of things that we know that he can do that most of the country i think would agree with that he could have a real effect and and to put ukraine in this position and to give the power to russia uh it's just the wrong way to go i think he's getting some bipartisan pushback on that which is we need a lot more pushback from our republican friends on this president clearly when it comes to decisions like this yeah to that bipartisan pushback and they just passed this um lindsey graham sanctioning russia and iran act um what like not even a month ago now and that would uh have authorized the president to levy tariffs and sanctions on buyers of russian oil and gas and now here we are just a couple weeks later and and we're buying it he wants to buy it and do the deal that which seems to be a total you know affront to that legislation that was passed by congress and signed i mean like on the one hand it seems illegal it seems bad strategy but also is pretty discouraging for somebody like you that wants to go to the senate and i guess do bipartisan stuff it doesn't seem like donald trump is going to be responsive to what the congress does it's turning the idea on its head but i'm just not sure that he's ever been all in on understanding that russia is an enemy and that we need to treat russia as such i think that's the the biggest problem as to uh the fact that we did or this legislation was passed it's clear that we need to put pressure on them and this not only relieves that pressure but gives them more money to drop more bombs on ukraine it it's just very frustrating i i do believe that one of the things that we can do if we are able to take back the senate and the house is to bring back those checks and balances that the framers of the constitution intended because there has just not been a pushback from the legislative branch of government uh the executive has run roughshod and and you take taking back the the constitutional authority on declaration of war on trade and tariffs on budgetary matters and i think that that's what these midterms gives the people an opportunity to do is to restore those checks and balances and i think that there will be a lot of be, particularly in January, if I'm fortunate enough to be elected by the people of North Carolina, and especially if we have a majority, which I think there's a chance that that can happen, that we will have some Republicans maybe who have just been reelected, recognizing that this is the last two years of this president's term. They may be with us on taking that authority back to the legislative branch of government. I've often found in North Carolina that things are more lasting when you do them of a bipartisan way. And although I'm a Washington outsider, my observance of what's happened in Washington is that things that are done in a bipartisan way last longer than those things that are done on a strictly partisan basis. So I'll get there and work as hard as I can to make sure we can find some bipartisan cooperation, particularly in pushback against this president right now. And I guess that leads us to kind of this question of how you see prioritization of what those obligations are as far as checks and balances. And I think it might be one thing in 2027 and another thing in 2029. But if you have a president that doesn't seem to give a shit about what the Congress is doing, it seems to me that there's a big first step, which is, you know, trying to, you know, kind of rein them in and hold the executive branch accountable as much as possible. And like that seems to me like that's going to be the big priority for 2027, you know, versus like trying to work with, you know, the two normal Republicans in the Senate and stuff. But tell me, what do you make of that? Well, look, I don't disagree with that other than I think the first priority of business is responding to the people and what we're hearing from them. We're hearing that their utility bill is too high. They can't grow groceries. They can't afford gas. So I think the first thing we need to do is to perform. We need to pass legislation that restores funding for health care subsidies that provides for child tax credit that tries to end this war in Iran and rolls back the tariffs and addressing the cost of housing. So I think the first thing we need to do is to try and put that kind of legislation on his desk. Who knows what he'll do? The housing bill that they passed in a bipartisan way, he just didn't even sign. But it became law. So who knows what he might do if we pass these things that we know are going to be good for the people? And yes, you know, I'm going to be first in line to try to find a way to overturn Citizens United and extreme partisan gerrymandering. And there's going to have to be some reforms, particularly anti-corruption, very prescriptive anti-corruption legislation that we need to pass and put on his desk. Should the president be able to have a crypto coin? There you go. I mean, you shouldn't be elected to office in order to make a buck. And there are too many there now who believe that that's part of the program. And we need to elect people who know right from wrong. Look, when I ran for governor, I sold all of my individual stocks. I put my money in widely held index fund mutual funds. I'm doing that now. I will do that. But I'm not going to be elected to the United States Senate, regardless of what the law says. I'm not going to be a lobbyist when I leave the U.S. Senate. What are you going to do? I don't know what I'm going to do. But what I'm going to do right now is go to the United States Senate. But I just don't think that we need people in office who are going to try to take advantage of that office for self-enrichment. And I think we need to elect people who are determined by the state laws to prevent that kind of thing, but who will do it regardless of what the law says. You've got a lot of people who are going to do it regardless of what the law says. who say, well, you know, I'll sell my stock if the law changes and I'm for a change in the law. And then they arrange it so that they can vote for it one time and then they can say they voted for it and it never happened. We got to change all of that. And it needs to apply to the executive branch as well. One thing I think will be interesting to watch as you try to navigate all of this stuff, whether that be, you know, I don't know, rolling back some of the tariffs is something, for example, you could imagine getting some Republicans on board for, you know, a lot of those guys used to be against tariffs until two minutes ago, you know, but on the other hand, it's been kind of hard to get people to step. Your current senator, outgoing Senator Tom Tillis there in North Carolina, he's got a new book out right now called How to Lose Friends and Antagonize Presidents, which I think is kind of an interesting title because I don't know, has he been antagonizing the president enough from your vantage point? Well, I think it's part of why Washington is broken is because we haven't had Republican leaders willing to stand up to the president when he's wrong. It's just like my opponent, Michael Watley, who's going to do and say whatever the president tells him to do and say, regardless of whether it's good for the people of North Carolina. And we have needed people who would be willing to step up. And that just that just hasn't happened. Yeah, I guess I just wonder, like, you know, don't you get a little bit nervous that Tillis will be gone, but there'll be other guys like him that maybe, I don't know, behind the scenes would agree with you on tariffs, but aren't going to aren't going to go along with y'all. And, you know, that's going to then create some tough questions about the filibuster and kind of about how you go about it. Right. Well, look, I was planning to run for this seat even before Senator Tillis. And I was going to run for this seat, but I was going to run for this seat. And I was going to run for this seat. And in fact, that was a shocking thing for me to find out that I wasn't going to be running against him because I just believed that Washington was broken. I was tired of seeing two or three things happening. It seemed like almost every single day that reached a new level of chaos and horror, any one of which we could talk about for hours. And that's how you're able to have a podcast, because we can talk about these issues for hours. And it was scattered. I would love to have a smaller audience and have the Harris administration. We could do a book day, you know, some days we could, we could talk about, you know, we could talk about the WNBA finals, whatever, you know, we could talk about Belichick. Well, I just think, let's don't talk about that. I just think, I just think that there are going to be after these elections, I think there are going to be some Republicans who are going to want to work with us. And I think it's going to be important. It's going to be important for us to work with them as much as we can, because we can't just kick and scream and yell about things and continue to be rebuffed by this executive branch. I think we're going to have to be, I think we have to be tough and we're going to have to hold people accountable who need to be held accountable. But, you know, we got three weeks in order to get this majority and people are going to have to step up. You know, they can, in, in North Carolina here, we, we haven't flipped this seat in almost two decades and we've only had two Democratic senators in almost 40 years. And we need to be helping all of these candidates in swing districts and in swing states across the country to make sure we do get this majority, because if we don't get the majority, it's going to be a real problem. And those, those issues you are talking about now, it's going to be very, very hard to get, to get bipartisan help. I want to talk about the campaign, but just on that kind of filibuster question, like, is that something that you've thought about at this point, about whether you have a view on whether it's going to be important to maintain that? I've thought about it. I do know right now the filibuster has, has helped save us from the SAVE Act. And that's something that we have to think about that had that been in place, I'm not sure where our elections would be, because that would give the federal government, a lot of control over voter lists. So I think we have to look at the issues as they come. And, but that, that's, that's an important thing to think about right now is what the filibuster is doing is helping to protect voting in states across the country. It's a good point. It's a tough one. I don't think it's open shut at all. Like on the other hand, it's kind of hard to imagine the Democrats having the 59 seat majority they had during, in 2009, again, anytime soon, because of the nature of our poll order. It's, it's a polarized democracy. And so there's a lot of priorities that are going to be hard to get done without at least maybe some reforms to it or changes to kind of the way that it's, they go about it. The first two years, the real issue is going to be the veto. Right. That's something we have to do the first deal with the first two years. So there's a big agenda. There's a lot we need to do to respond to the people. And in these elections across the country, they are telling us that stuff costs too much. And we have to respond to that because that is the overwhelming issue. And I talk to person after person who are having to make decisions about couples, one of them quitting work because the childcare just costs too much. People having to change jobs because they simply can't afford to get back and forth to work with gas. It's turning lives upside down. And we have a Washington that is continuing to make it worse. And we've got to fix it. We've got to fix it. I guess that's my point. Like, if you end up in a place where it's so gridlocked still in 2029 or whatever, where like the system is not working as it's currently set up because everything is getting blocked, like does that lead you over to reforms on the way the system's working, whether it be the filibuster or otherwise? I think our democracy certainly is being threatened right now. And I think that we're going to have to look at reforms across the board and keep an open mind about all of them for sure. Right. Let's talk about the campaign. I got an unusual memo from your team. Usually people are sent to me memos about how great their candidate is doing, you know, because they want to demonstrate momentum. Your staff sent a memo talking about how we got to be a little worried about North Carolina. Got to be a lot worried about North Carolina. Yeah. Okay. Got to be a lot worried. There you go. Tom Tillis was always behind the polls, but he won anyway. The last time you were on the ballot, I think it said that the polls had you up by 5%. You ended up winning by 10,000 votes or so. What's that all about? Is that real? Are you concerned that there's some kind of shy or MAGA vote in North Carolina that's not being reflected in the polls? Because right now you've got a pretty good lead. It has been real. We've seen it in the past too many times where you can pretty much add five or six percentage points to whatever Republicans are doing in the polls in North Carolina. We had David Plouffe come and talk with us the other day and said he went through it with Obama in '08. And that's the last time North Carolina voted for a Democratic presidential candidate. It's also the last time that North Carolina voted for a Democrat to the United States Senate. And although we've been successful in electing Democrats to state offices, it's been really hard to elect Democrats to federal office. So we're pushing through the tape. We need people to help us. People can go to RoyCooper.com, to help us. I'm glad that we're helping people in these states that we didn't think we had a chance because I want to serve in the majority. And so Democratic outside money that's moved out of North Carolina that is going to these other states, I'm all for that. I think it's important because we've got to get a majority. But we have to carry this campaign across the finish line. And I'm telling people, number one, we've got to reform campaign finance. It's unconscionable, the amount of money that's being raised. But we also cannot unilaterally disarm right now. So I'm telling people they need to help everybody across the board. A lot of the questions at the beginning of this campaign were, hey, shouldn't we just concentrate on the House? This is really not a chance for us to take the U.S. Senate. We're just going to put money in the House. And my argument was, we're at a critical point in the history of our country. So we need to invest across the board in both the House and the Senate. And that has proven right. And we've got to take it all the way to the end in these last three weeks if we are going to get a majority in the Senate. These states that we're trying to win, North Carolina being one of them, Trump won them all three times. And now we're trying to flip that on his head. So that's a tough thing to do. But I believe we can, but we need people's help to get it done. All right. So I used to do PR for campaigns. I always told my candidate not to be a pundit. So I'm asking you right now to just, just for one question, just pundit with me for one question, and then we'll let you off the hook. And because there's this, a lot of dem discourse out there about what the party needs to be doing to win better, and these different models about whether it be economic populism or what El Saad is doing in Michigan, or, you know, I don't know, I don't or what Telerico is doing in Texas. And when they have those conversations, I notice nobody brings up Roy Cooper as a model really for for 2028 in the future but as you mentioned the Democrats haven't won a senate seat there in 20 years as of now you're winning the polls by a lot you're running a pretty simple campaign that looks like to me where you are talking about how you want to make sure criminals be put in jail but you know we want to treat our neighbors like we should be treated and care about everybody's pocketbooks and that seems to be working and so what do you think is that is that like a model you think that should be tried other places or is there something special about you I don't I don't know that it's a model I I know that sticking to the basics is important because most people want to live in a safe community they want their kid to get a good education they want to be able to afford a doctor when when they get sick they expect clean air and water these these are issues that bring us together 400 electoral votes that's it don't talk about anything else the Democrats that's a Ronald Reagan majority for the Democrats why don't we just do that well I'm I'm for that I mean that that's what I have done over the years when I have run for office is concentrate on the issues that affect everyday people and that they care about and that's what I it's what I care about I mean I I'm I had a I wanted a state where people were better educated where they were healthier where they had more money in their pocket and they had the opportunity to live lives of abundance that that was my uh CEO mission statement back when I became governor in 2017 and we got a Republican legislature to expand Medicaid we helped create 640,000 new better paying jobs third fastest growing state in the country yeah I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I don't know I hold the record for a number of vetoes as a governor I had a Republican legislature for all eight years and we disagreed on a lot but I think the key is to try to find where you do agree because most people are not into this hyper-partisan disputes they want government to work and that's what I tried to do as attorney general and as governor and I realize this is going to be challenging going to Washington I I just feel like I'm going to have to do a lot of work and I'm going to figure that Washington needs a little North Carolina common sense and I'm ready to come with knowing what I know I was also in the private practice of law for 18 years and had to meet a payroll so I know about the private sector as well represented everyday people and small businesses so I'm going to try to bring that experience to Washington and and try to make things better for for the people there for sure when you look at the National Democrats I I'm not going to stress any of those kind of issues or just generally like do you feel like there's something in particular that where the party's gotten out of step with everyday people or where the emphasis has been wrong well look the the number one I've I have been been encouraging people at this point in time and just during the past year to not worry about fixing the the Democratic Party what I have encouraged people to do was to support these candidates in these swing races in order to work to take back the majority because it's very hard when you just don't have any power at all at the federal level to fix anything because you can't do very much so my my argument has been let's let's support these candidates let's don't worry about the party structure or the party messaging uh that's we've got a long way to go to fix all of that let's concentrate on these candidates and we have some amazing candidates who are in tough battles right now across the country and I think if we can get a majority you know one of the things about Democrats we disagree on how to get some of these places uh how to get to getting more people health care but I think trying to focus on those issues uh leading into 2028 we've got to we've got to find common issues and try to stick to those issues because we have to win we have to win and now in these mid-derms we have to win in 2028. Press Secretary Tim is happy I tried to sneak in another pundit question on you and you didn't you didn't take the bait you're not going to pundit on me that's good I have one more policy issue of immigration here's one of my frustrations some sometimes with the Democrats on both sides of this which is I think basically everybody agrees at this point that the border got out of control under Biden and it needs to be more secure and the next Democratic Senate and hopefully president needs to do differently on that but simultaneously to that like what we're seeing with the deportations right now and with these camps that we have around the country is utterly un-American and inhumane and I do feel like some Democrats have been a little shy um because of political considerations about engaging on that question so I'm just wondering kind of how you're thinking about those issues oversight of ice reform of ice defunding maybe uh um some of the programs that they have like what what's your positions on the kind of the internal immigration enforcement that we've seen well first I agree that we need a strong secure border and that in the last administration not not a good job was done secondly we need to deport violent criminals and make sure we have people who are working on doing that but what is happening with ice right now um going around detaining people simply because of what they look like oftentimes they are American citizens shooting people in the street that's wrong you know at the very least ice officers should have to obey by the same rules and have the same training that local and state law enforcement have and it definitely needs to be reformed because what is happening is wrong and and we have to fix it and look I'm ready to roll up my sleeves and get involved in trying to to enact comprehensive immigration reform we have to have a better system in place uh than we have right now and it's it's being run over rough shot anyway and that's another thing that the legislative branch of government needs to do is to push back on the executive branch and to make sure that laws that are already on the books are being followed and that's not happening now in that area and in many other areas and just as far as like the individual like the way that people are being treated and held in the camps and the funding for all of that we've got to be humane in in the way we're dealing with people but we also need to have a system where they can have a fair hearing yeah about their legal status uh in in the United States or Nicole's doing a little you said you don't want to talk about Belichick but I don't know what's happening over there at North Carolina well you know one job the one job of a Carolina football coach what's that is to delay the question oh the question what about the basketball team I don't know you've got my old Nuggets head coach Michael Malone who I do like I just took a peek here you're 37th in the Ken Palm coming in that's what is what's happening with the program down there so that the the Carolatic football coach the only job was to delay the question and the question is when does basketball season start if you get into mid to late October and people aren't asking the question when does basketball season start then you are a successful football coach at Carolina okay look Malone uh yeah but let's start by saying that the NCAA in college sports are just the Wild West right now it's just so different there are two players on Carolina's roster who played last year and on one of them played a lot but the other one didn't on the basketball and everybody else is brand new to the system many of them coming in through the transfer portal I think Malone is is is going to be a good coach the college sports are moving toward the professional level I think players are getting their due finally I think players should have been paid yeah but we now we now have to find a way to clamp down on the transfer portal and at least bring a little sanity to to the system but you know I'm gonna bet that the Tar Heels might have a pretty good year okay it's uh well I don't know here in Louisiana Jeff Landry is the governor and the LSU athletic director so I think it'd be possible for you and especially given the Senate calendar lately you know they're barely working up there you could probably do both jobs I think if they need you down there well that's another reason I need to run for the Senate because they don't work hard enough and I'm ready to to get up there and to to do that I would hope that the majority is it going to be Schumer do you think as the majority leader don't know don't know I don't know well I'll wait till I get there to make my decision all right well whoever it is hopefully they work a few more days next year they had a pretty leisurely schedule up there I mean Donald was in the hospital for months and people barely even noticed because they weren't doing anything well you know when things got hot they just went home yeah that's what they did that's that's no way to do I mean you got to step up to your job all right we appreciate you we're gonna be in uh North Carolina I'm gonna miss you that's why we wanted to have you on the podcast um but we have a live event there on sunday p bootage is going to be in town so that'll be great if you give me charlotte tips for us a little restaurant to go to or something yeah just go to pick pick up a hornets game go to a hornets game it'll be fun are you feeling good with with lamello gone um it's kind of a new refresh they had to readjust but i i think they've got the core of of a good team you got to get out of this uh play-in game level where they are they they've got to get back to where they they need to be all right i'm googling now to see if i can get to a hornets game while i'm there we'll see yeah i don't know what the schedule is like i might be able to probably be a pre-season if it's next week it'll be pre-season if it's anything all right so that's even that's even more fun we appreciate you for all the time good luck up there the campaign trail run through the tape and uh hopefully we'll be checking in next year when you're up in washington which is kind of a downer but uh it's good for us maybe not as much for you thanks a lot tim thanks so much to gnome and uh governor cooper uh we'll see everybody in north carolina on sunday and we'll be back tomorrow with a fun psycho edition of the podcast see you all then peace the bulwark daily is brought to you thanks to the work of lead producer katie cooper associate producer ansley skipper and with video editing by dante de chico and audio engineering and editing by jason brown

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The rise of left-wing economic populism among college-educated workers stems from unmet expectations after years of debt and a declining return on college degrees.
  2. A growing segment of the working class, particularly in professional fields like medicine and tech, feels alienated by changing workplace structures and loss of autonomy.
  3. A cultural shift, known as "underdogism," has fueled distrust in U.S. institutions, leading college-educated voters to embrace left-leaning ideologies despite economic convergence with non-college voters.
  4. Despite shared economic concerns, deep divides exist between college-educated and traditional industrial working-class voters, leading to internal tensions in left-wing coalitions.
  5. Housing unaffordability and the collapse of the "college degree as a path to homeownership" story have intensified economic anxiety and fueled political radicalization.
  6. Elon Musk’s actions undermining Ukraine’s defense efforts and his support for Russia are seen as politically and ethically indefensible, especially given his role in tech and political influence.
  7. The detention of Miriam Tamasebi and her family in Dili, despite no immigration violations, represents a broader pattern of political persecution and a failure of democratic accountability.
  8. The 2024 midterms signal a potential shift toward a more radicalized, economically driven left, with Democratic candidates like Abdul Al-Sayed and Michelle AOC poised to energize the movement toward deeper political realignment in 2028.

Summary:

The podcast explores the rise of left-wing economic populism, particularly among college-educated workers, who feel disillusioned by the promise of their education. This disillusionment has led to increased political radicalization, unionization, and support for democratic socialist candidates. The narrative is rooted in a generational shift: despite strong promotion of college as a path to success, graduates face stagnant job markets, high debt, and unmet expectations.

S. power and institutions—fueling ideological leftward shifts. While economic issues unite college-educated and traditional working-class voters, cultural and identity-based divisions fracture political coalitions.

The discussion also highlights Elon Musk’s harmful role in undermining Ukraine’s defense, raising ethical and political alarms. Meanwhile, the detention of Miriam Tamasebi and her family in a Dili internment camp is presented as a symbol of authoritarianism and a failure of democratic norms. The midterms are seen as a turning point, where economic populism gains momentum, and left-leaning candidates emerge as vehicles for systemic change.

The podcast concludes that while political unity on economic issues is growing, deeper cultural and class-based divisions remain, and future elections—including the 2028 presidential race—could see a surge in radical left movements, especially if traditional Democratic strategies fail to address working-class grievances.

FAQs

North Carolina has not seen a Democratic win in 20 years, and the incumbent Roy Cooper is far ahead in the polls. This has led to minimal discussion about the Senate race, despite concerns about the accuracy of polling methods.

Elon Musk is restricting Starlink services in Ukraine, which hampers military operations and drone missions. This is seen as harmful to Ukraine’s defense efforts and raises concerns about Musk’s political alignment with Russia and his belief that high diesel prices are due to Ukraine’s actions.

College-educated workers feel their college investment has failed economically, leading to frustration, unionization, and a shift toward democratic socialist candidates. This shift is rooted in a gap between expectations and reality, especially in the post-recession job market.

Working-class white workers feel trapped by limited economic opportunities and are drawn to the right, while college-educated professionals feel status anxiety and are radicalized by economic disillusionment, leading to support for left-wing policies.

Housing has become a symbol of the upper middle class lifestyle, yet it is increasingly unattainable. This economic strain fuels discontent among young graduates, linking housing to broader economic anxiety and political radicalization.

While both groups share economic populism and support for unionization, their cultural values and priorities often clash—such as in Amazon unionization or the UAW strike—leading to internal conflicts and a fragile coalition.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.