This episode of Smosh Reads explores real Reddit stories centered around exes, divorce, and relationship breakdowns, revealing how seemingly small incidents can spiral into major emotional crises. One story details a couple's rupture after a man’s excessive turkey-eating at Thanksgiving, which escalated into a harmful abandonment and later a betrayal with a fitness influencer. Another shows how a lighthearted workplace roast of a coworker’s weight loss unintentionally triggered a divorce, highlighting how insensitive comments can deeply hurt individuals during vulnerable times. A third story features a woman joking about wanting a divorce, which led her husband to leave abruptly and file actual divorce papers, underscoring how serious intentions can be misinterpreted or exploited. The episode critiques the culture of online pranks and jokes, warning that they can backfire when real emotions are involved. It also explores broader themes of emotional boundaries, respect, and communication in relationships—particularly when children are involved. Ultimately, the stories reveal that relationships are fragile, and even well-intentioned actions can have devastating outcomes if not handled with empathy and awareness. The commentary emphasizes that trust, honesty, and emotional intelligence are essential in maintaining healthy connections, especially in high-stress or emotionally charged moments.
Hello, and welcome to Smosh Reads Reddit Stories.
I'm Shane, and today's theme is exes and divorce.
And I'm joined by two people who I would divorce in a heartbeat.
Angela Giratana and special guest, John Marco Cerezi.
Hey.
Hello, hello.
Hello, hello.
John Marco, you have joined us for Reddit Stories before, live.
Live.
Live show.
Netflix is a joke, months ago.
And then you wanted to come back, but you specifically had a category that you wanted for an episode.
Yeah.
And you were like, I want to do exes and divorce.
Oh, this is so good.
Which, to be fair, very good pitch.
Yeah, my parents have divorced.
I don't talk about it a lot.
And my mom's been divorced multiple times, dad multiple times.
And I have this fantasy of, like, when my friends finally start getting divorced,
especially if they have kids, like, I want to be a source of, like, no, do this.
Do this.
You should try that.
Your fantasy is to, like, help?
Your fantasy is for your friends to get divorced.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
And then they come to me.
You want to help the kid and be like, this is the best way to do it, because I was a kid of this.
Yeah.
Or the best way to manipulate the kid.
Like, it depends if I am both their sides or am I, like, rooting for one.
Here's how you win in the divorce.
I could teach all the ways to win.
Okay.
All the ways.
So you as a kid, child of divorce, you were, like, learning strategy.
You're like, okay, so I see my dad made a good move there.
Yeah, I was more a victim of their strategy.
Right, right.
But you were also learning, yeah.
I'm sorry about that.
Yeah, it's fine.
I wouldn't be here if it were not for that.
Okay, okay.
Like, my father, like, he picked me up from mom's house once.
He said, what do you have here you don't have at my house?
Let's go buy it.
And, like, that's the kind of stuff we're talking about.
So that's kind of a really cool, like, Santa figure that's like, let me buy whatever you want and make this house better.
Okay.
Okay.
Wow.
Yeah.
Kind of a cool thing.
Are you with divorced parents?
No.
Okay.
Which is, honestly, can I tell you?
I feel like sometimes I'm in a room and I'm the only person with parents.
Oh, it's a rare thing.
Yeah.
It's absolutely rare.
I would say, especially here in L.A., for some, I mean, for some.
Are you saying people who move here to become stars are damaged?
It actually does seem like a lot of actors are children of divorce.
And, unfortunately, I think a lot of them.
Especially because I came out here when I was young.
There's the unfortunate connotation I think a lot of people have that by moving out here, like, one parent joins them or whatever and it causes strain.
Like, there is a lot of, like, or a lot of people who are out here young to be actors, they did have one parent who came with them because their parents are divorced and stuff.
And there's a lot.
I don't know.
I noticed a trend.
But I think it's also just kind of common.
Yeah.
I have a lot of friends at this.
Now, at this age, I have a lot of friends that are divorced.
I know.
Which is good.
Send them.
Send them my way.
Yeah.
Give them my number.
I feel like most people I know nowadays are either single or divorced.
Or, I guess, a combo.
Nobody's dating.
They're either divorced.
Nobody's dating.
Somehow, you're not dating and then you're divorced.
Yeah.
Yeah.
You just jump right to there.
With kids or no kids, though?
I don't have a lot.
Most of my friends that have kids just had a kid.
No divorced yet.
Okay.
I hardly know anyone who has kids also.
Mm-hmm.
Yeah.
Amanda's like the one.
Divorce without kids is a breakup.
There you go.
Divorce with kids is. Yeah.
You're not serious about it.
Yeah.
But then, okay, let's talk exes here because have you ever. Like, I've shared a dog with an ex.
Ooh.
What was the custody arrangement?
It was that I couldn't afford dog care, child care.
Uh-huh.
And I went, I'm taking the dog.
And when I need a sitter, you're taking him.
So, I guess we didn't really share him.
He just wanted to see the dog.
And I was like, you can see him when I'm busy.
Okay.
It's kind of how it worked out.
But at least there's. It's like a mutual, like, you guys were still communicative.
Yeah, but then it would get. It doesn't sound healthy at all.
It would get a little dicey every once in a while.
Like, if one of us was dating somebody, it was like. I remember looking at the dog going, who'd you see last night?
Ah, okay.
Did you watch him fuck somebody else?
Wow.
You know dogs are looking.
Yeah.
They're. They'll come in.
They'll come in.
They'll watch.
Okay.
They'll be like, I wish that was me.
That's what they're thinking?
I think they're going, they're like, I got some. I got some notes on that doggy style.
You think they're going like, ah. Hey, that's my thing.
What the hell?
Hey.
I don't do missionary.
Looks like you're making fun of me.
Is that your impression of me?
With a pillow?
Okay.
Very funny, guys.
Anyways.
Wait, when. So, there's a guy, and they were dating someone else.
Yeah.
And you were still sharing the dog?
Yeah.
That must have been a fight on their side, 100%.
Yeah.
Which is a preview of, like, kids.
Yeah, there you go.
Yeah.
So, there's a lot.
That's what's tough, because with a lot of breakups, I've always. I am personally someone of, like, you got to clean break.
Like, you got to, like. Yeah.
You can't.
Like, that's tough.
What do you mean?
Like, like. No contact.
And it's just kind of like, yeah, like, we got to go our separate ways.
Like, you can't, like, when people are like, oh, we'll stay friends.
It's like, we could be friends maybe someday, but, like, you kind of need to. That's the thing with divorce with kids.
Oh, with kids, you can't. You've got no time.
You cannot do that.
You've got to be friends right now.
You really have to.
Well, you, even if you hate each other, you have to be so respectful and really work together
for the sake of the child, but parents don't do that.
But this is my thing.
Like, when I talk with my partner about having kids, I go, you got to be able to be friends
with your ex.
I need to know people who are friends with their ex, because if you're going to have
a kid, there's a chance of divorce, and you have to be capable of that.
If you're someone who goes, I would never speak to my ex, don't have kids with that
person.
Right.
No, it makes sense.
Right.
Also, you know, I have another friend who shares a Peloton with their ex.
What?
That's worse than a dog.
Worse than a dog?
It's an L.A. kid.
Because then you're there cycling.
It's like, I wonder if Mike was watching him fuck yesterday on the Peloton.
Did you see anything yesterday?
Mike's there like, okay, guys, let's get into gear.
I watched your ex fuck yesterday.
They're not moving the Peloton back and forth.
No, one's going in, using the Peloton when one's gone, because they split it.
Some people, look, okay, my experience is different than other people's, right?
And that's, I don't have many exes.
So, but some people are friends with their exes.
Like, I think.
I think if two people are respectful people, I think it can work.
But you just got to make sure.
Before you have kids, you got to make sure.
I have a feeling we're going to read a lot about a bunch of people who can't make it work.
Probably.
Great.
Okay.
Let's hop into these ex stories.
This first story was posted in December of 2025 from the Am I Overreacting subreddit.
And it was also posted onto Am I the Ex?
Are you familiar with that subreddit?
Am I the Ex?
No.
So, Am I the Ex?
Subreddit for when people write in not realizing they've probably already been broken up with.
I see.
They still think they're dealing with a relationship problem.
Oh.
The relationship's probably over.
That's devastating.
And their post gets moved to that?
People will repost it over to there.
Be like, sorry, bud.
What a devastating thing to see.
Yeah.
Here we go.
Am I overreacting for taking a break from my boyfriend after he ripped through a whole turkey at our family Thanksgiving?
Okay.
My boyfriend, a 28-year-old man, and I, a 27-year-old woman, have been dating for almost two years and living together for six months now.
I met him through my friend at a house party, and we immediately hit it off.
He was almost exactly like a guy I wanted.
Extremely tall and huge, witty with jokes, kind and well-dressed, and he was absolutely buffed.
I like how they said almost exactly like a guy.
I wanted.
And then listen to all the things.
We vibed throughout the party and exchanged numbers at the end.
He has met my family a couple of times after we moved in together, and they absolutely loved him.
My grandparents host Thanksgiving dinner almost every year, and we were both invited to it.
I thought it would have been lovely to make him meet with them and my other family members, too, since my uncle's family would be there, too.
He had to drop his sister off at his parents' house, two-hour drive, and picked me up from our house.
It was a 1.5-hour drive to my grandparents' house.
Everyone was there.
Everyone was happy to meet him, and it seemed like they really liked him, until we sat down for dinner.
We said our grace, and Grandpa carved the turkey and started to pass it around the table.
It was a regular-sized turkey like we have for every Thanksgiving, enough to feed 12 and still have leftovers.
We were 10.
Both of us were sitting at the end of the table next to Grandpa, so my boyfriend was the last one to get it.
There was still a lot of it left because everyone took only a little and would pass around again for more after some time.
He placed it on the table and said,
He placed it right next to him and started digging through the entirety of it.
He was so profuse, as my nephew said later, gobbling it up.
I told him quietly to go easy, but he did not listen.
He started saying how good it was, and my grandma had a huge smile on her face.
He was eating just the turkey, and my grandpa said,
Boy, someone really likes turkey.
I like how boy is spelled B-O-I.
Everyone laughed, but it got to a point where everyone was talking about it.
They're all sitting there just like, wow, he's really fucking going in.
He did not take any hint and shrugged it off like a teenager.
My face turned red from embarrassment, and I could see everyone judging us so hard.
I could hear my uncle and his wife make unfunny jokes about it.
It was finished without getting to anyone again with no leftovers.
My boyfriend is a gym freak.
He spends a regular day at the gym.
He spends a ridiculous amount of time and money on working out, eating protein-rich meals, online courses, etc.
He has a set protein limit that he hits every day.
day, sometimes over it, but never under. He also gets his protein from just the meals,
no supplements, so he is used to having large meals. It has never been a problem with me,
and I respect his way of living, if not love it. We cook together all the time, and if I'm not in
the mood, he happily makes me a meal for me. He won't even let me contribute to grocery expenses.
Because of him, I started eating healthy and felt a lot better about my lifestyle.
After dinner, we got into a fight while driving home. He said he had been driving all day and
didn't eat anything after breakfast, so he had to hit his protein and that he wasn't enjoying it
after some time and had to just shove it down the throat. I said if he was that hungry, I would
have happily made him a meal after we had gotten home, but now everyone in my family is going to
talk about how you finished something made for the whole family. He had thought everyone took
their share. What? He got really mad and said I'm blowing this out of proportion and overreacting
over a simple meal. I snapped saying, how am I overreacting if I'm just trying to
communicate about what he did? It was an hour-long drive, so things got heated up.
He kept saying I was calling him a pig for eating like that and that I should probably get out of
his life if it's such a problem because he believes he did nothing wrong and isn't going to change
himself. He persisted on it even though that wasn't my point. It got so bad that he dropped
me at a gas station in the middle of the night and said, think about what I just did. I was
terrified. I collected myself to call an Uber to my sister's house and sobbed the entire night.
I told myself after a week things would get clear. He hasn't texted me, nor did I. I can see how I
could have reacted differently, but I can't get over the fact that he just left me stranded in
the middle of the night. Am I overreacting or should I make a move on making things straight?
Okay. You wanted a buff guy. This is what it comes with. I said the exact same thing. I went,
you can't have your fucking cake and eat it too. I want big, buff. I want really tall. I want it
massive. Oh, you know what? I'm going to eat it. I'm going to eat it. I'm going to eat it. I'm going
to eat it. I want to date the Hulk, but I don't like that he smashed. Yeah. I want him to be the
Hulk, but I want him to drink tea and eat crumpets. Like what? This is so funny. It's also,
it reads just like an SNL sketch. It is. Oh boy. That's a lot of turkey. Hey guys, this is Gregor.
Yes. I like how it started that they were all impressed. Yeah. The guy was smiling. Wow. He
really likes it. Because a part of me was like, okay, I'm going to brag. I just came home from
But in like, I feel like in some cultures, they're like, please eat as much as like, they want you to
eat as much of the food as possible. Like that's like a sign of a compliment. He made it sound like
they like, and he smacked their hand away. Like no. But also you are an asshole if you eat all of
the turkey when it hasn't been passed fully around. I want to know like how vocal were they? Like,
cause it started funny. Whoa. He likes the turkey. But maybe they're scared. Hey, hey,
knock it off. He said no, no. But he's a giant. He's a giant buff man. They were scared.
They were scared. He's only an asshole if he actively saw that they wanted some and he kept
eating it. Besides that, I think the guy was just really hungry. We've read a lot of stories about
like at a party where people like eat all of a thing, right? It's kind of like an unspoken rule
of like, yeah, you take as much, like you hope you try to leave some for other people. But then
at the end of the night when it like there's leftovers, it's like, oh, well, nobody ate that.
Damn. I wish I'd, uh, yeah, it's tough, but you're taking, I mean, clearly it,
if it's that bad, he's, he's a neurotic. He's, people get in their own food things and he's like,
I gotta hit this. Gotta hit my protein limit. And it sounds like he was driving for a long time.
Oh yeah. It's justified that he needs to eat a lot of food. Um, look, I, I'm not nearly probably
as big as this guy, but like, I, I care about hitting protein limits too, but it's like,
you got to also still be considerate of like, what's your protein? What do you need to hit?
What's your thing? You typically try to hit your body weight, your body weight, like 50 grams.
That's so far under that is disturbingly under 50 grams. There's a lot of debate, but people
like, uh, like it's probably not this amount, but it's like, if you're hitting your body weight in,
uh, in grams of protein, that's a lot of Turkey. It's a lot. How much Turkey? I have no idea how
much Turkey it is. Uh, I'm thinking about probably has a turkey breast is pretty, it has a lot of
protein, but like if this guy's, if he's not hit his protein goals for the day, he's not eating
probably trying to hit over 200 grams of protein. Like knowing what this guy sounds like, how many
grams of protein is a full Turkey? Probably a lot, but like it's already been eaten by some people.
He's got to get it. I'm like, go home and, and, and grab, grab some ribs on the way home, buddy.
I'm like, this is why when I take that first helping, I'm taking a lot. Oh yeah. What's
happening at the end of this thing? I don't necessarily assume there's going to be a second
round Thanksgiving. I've never been at a Thanksgiving where we ran out of food. I've
of food right I feel like you you always it's always hopefully supplied by quite a bit yeah but
you're right about being the guest you're like I don't know if this is a seconds type of thing so
I'm just gonna go big first and maybe he went really big first I just can't relate next to him
he brought the turkey that's the centerpiece I I do think he was very inconsiderate in that way
because like but I'm also biased because I am such a neurotic person with this stuff sure I do not
want to like be that guy but in the beginning he might have thought it was like everyone's like
hey you really like that turkey he's like yeah I do oh yeah maybe he was like and grandma's
turkey man yeah watch this a whole like yeah yeah because like I said maybe the grandma like some
people like really it's a huge compliment for them if someone if a guest comes in and wants
to eat all the food oh my god my family was like that you don't want to eat all the food
you want everyone to have some you're so right what is it about my family was this way where
they were like look at you love the lamb chops don't you like well you're an Italian I feel like
an Italian family is one where they like but if you're a guest in an Italian house like they're
like take as much food as possible but you're but yeah I just didn't really realize that it was
either always my grandma or always my aunt or somebody that would be like so thrilled yeah
that the man was eating all of the meat maybe he's Italian maybe he's Italian okay but let's
talk about get stranding her okay yeah
to be clear the the meal doesn't really matter him stranding her at the gas station
that trumps everything like you don't fucking do that yeah that was it was it open was it
I know what kind of gas station was it a pump and go was it yeah was it one of those where you can
only really stand in there for a second if somebody else comes in it's too much also like
he must have really been hangry to leave your girlfriend at a gas station still hangry after
the whole I would be falling
asleep that much turkey I think you staying awake I think if you didn't want him to leave you should
bought some beef jerky and then like more more yeah drive me home a little bit further I think
that's also where going back one last time with him I'm just like I need to hit my protein goals
like go go get a pro like get a protein shakers yeah exactly I've been in that situation but uh
no you don't leave someone like you don't leave someone at a great yeah yeah it's crazy that's
crazy leaving someone at a gas station at friggin after 10 p.m that's that's pretty much the worst
yeah and also mind you like stranded like fully stranded not like stranded like oh
my sister and not even waiting for the uber I can understand being like hey we need this we need some
time I'm gonna wait for the uber yeah wait here maybe that's maybe we need to go home separately
it's just crazy to leave her yeah yeah like to yeah but also it's like drive away the protein
surge hit hit our pantries big recently right like like we have protein water in this fridge and that
one freaks me out it freaks me out too I don't like that can I say one thing just in in his
defense maybe he's driving home turkey has that thing in it that makes you sleepy and he said oh
no I'm worried and he goes get out of the car better drop her off at the gas tryptophan I mean
he's got a whole trip to trip to farm inside him and he goes he goes hey but maybe her being
annoying is gonna keep him awake there you go he's driving home and he's like oh my god I'm
dropping her off when women are annoying I go to sleep because I don't want to hear that um okay
but sounds I just I just imagine like food neuroses can be very powerful no if he's a lifter
whatever I mean it's bad we don't know we also don't know if steroids are in the mix here
that's true very possible yeah but I we don't know I'm assuming I can't throw that in there
you gotta ask yourself do you want a guy who's gonna be better at Thanksgiving but scrawny as
hell do you want a guy who's gonna be better at Thanksgiving but scrawny as hell do you want a
guy who's gonna be better at Thanksgiving but scrawny as hell do you want a guy who's gonna be
he needs help carving the turkey because he's so weak this one's really cooked
that's my impression of a guy who can't cut a turkey okay so what happened okay okay um so
the verdict is not overreacting and I think this ended up on am I the ex because even though she's
not necessarily in the wrong here or like you know I think people he it sounds like he broke
up with her like if someone drops you off at a gas station that's that's a you're breaking yeah
you don't really come back from that yeah that's it's kind of over at that point
um at least it should be for her to end with being like should I try to make a move to make
things straight it's like I don't think you need to like I think it's over um some comments on this
someone said the bar is in hell and satan tripped over it someone said bro what lmao everything else
aside the fact he left you at a gas station should be an immediate deal breaker onto the turkey yeah
he was acting a fool and quite disrespectfully common courtesy dictates that you take a single
serving for your own dish and leave more for people to get seconds unless explicitly you
instructed to finish it off let alone this isn't even his family it's a very entitled thing to do
add to that everyone including yourself was making comments shows a lack of awareness or a willful
defiance
I've been a gym rat. I've been in that mode where you eat clean, whole foods only, and need a ton to at least maintain, if not bulk.
I would never crush the remainder of a family meal at my own house, let alone someone else's, without being explicitly told to multiple times.
His lack of breakfast is his own problem, or at worst, both of yours, not the entire family's.
4,000 upvotes.
Someone replied saying, yeah, how vile, OP. Tell him to shove some protein up his ass.
Let me tell you, if I was at this table, if I was part of this family, I would not have stayed silent until the whole turkey was gone.
I would have seen half, and I'd be like, hey, I get that he's big and scary, but you guys all got to unite.
If it's next to him, I would at least be like, time to pass it.
Like, move it.
That's getting crazy.
Okay, imagine the intimidation.
All right, gigantic, huge buff guy walks in.
I'm picturing the mountain from Game of Thrones.
Yeah, and he just pushes it.
And the turkey comes to him, and he just grabs the turkey, and he just pulls it to his side, and then just starts eating it.
I think I'd be like.
I think you'd be like, you would.
I'd be like, it's time for my grandmother to eat.
Yeah, I'd say time for me to eat.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
You pull the turkey to you.
Yes.
Last comment.
Someone said, when you wear rose-colored glasses, red flags are just flags.
That commenter.
Is obsessed with their day.
Obsessed with themselves.
They closed their laptop, and they Googled it.
Was I the first to say that?
Holy shit, did that just come off the dome?
Yeah, it's.
Even better.
It's a common phrase.
We have an update.
Awesome.
Okay.
I called him to talk about what had happened.
The call was answered by a woman whose voice I didn't recognize.
Let's go.
Yes, it wasn't his sister.
I know her voice very well.
When I asked if I could talk.
She replied, he is in a cardio session.
I'll tell him to call you later.
Jesus.
I was puzzled after this.
It's a woman.
It's a big turkey with a bikini on.
I was puzzled after this, so I waited for his call, imagining all the worst things,
and it turned out to be right.
He was cheating on me.
He told me he had been seeing her for a couple of months.
She works as a coach in the gym that he goes to.
I searched her up on Instagram, and she is a fitness influencer with a lot of followers.
A lot.
He said she is a better match for him and will help him grow his career on social media.
Yes, he has a fitness channel, too, but with nowhere near the amount of followers she has.
She has a much better body than me.
When asked why didn't he tell me earlier and end things right there, he said he knew I
would overreact and act emotionally immature like I am doing right now and wouldn't understand
him.
Instead, he just dropped her off at a gas station?
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
He was like, "I'm going to try to make it right."
He's just in it for that turkey.
Yeah.
That was all for the turkey.
Hey, let's talk.
Just because it's Thanksgiving tomorrow, no, baby, no.
I just want to go back to your family, and I just want to be there.
I love your family.
Oh, my God.
He's like the Tinder swindler, but just with turkeys.
Just with turkeys.
He hit up all of our turkeys at Thanksgiving dinner.
"He has packed my things in boxes and kept them in the garage and told me to collect it or not.
He doesn't care and ended the call.
I started sobbing.
I was lying uncontrollably.
My sister was beside me and comforted me.
She said his fitness influencer girlfriend might not even know that we had been dating,
and he is running after her followers, not her.
I started saying he couldn't do that, and she replied that I'm in denial, and he probably
saw the opportunity on Thanksgiving argument and got rid of me, making me think I was the
one that caused the end of our relationship.
I'm taking my sister and her boyfriend to collect my things this week and probably get closure."
I don't know.
Closure?
You're not getting closure from this guy.
Yeah.
No.
I feel bad for her.
She liked the idea of this guy, but it sounds like he was a piece of shit from the start.
Yeah, and it feels like she really wanted a big, buff guy, and she got every version
of a buff guy.
Yeah.
Like, "I want to date the girl at the gym."
It just feels. Yeah, it's unfortunate.
I mean, look, I will say, though, the stereotype, there's a lot of people that fit the stereotype
and suck.
There are also a lot of people who fit that stereotype who are honestly the coolest people
ever, but she unfortunately got one of the shittiest ones, so that's tough.
Yeah.
I could never. I love. Do you have a lot of buff friends that you're looking out for here?
It looks like you're looking out for the buff community.
I just. I think. Just so you know, they're not all like. No, they're his brothers.
They're his brothers.
A lot of buff guys, pretty cool.
No.
This guy needs car junkie.
That's true.
But here's the thing, though.
Here's the thing, because there's a lot of this, is like, people who are like, "I'm
going to be a buff guy."
I'm going to be a buff guy.
I'm going to be a buff guy.
Here's the thing, because there's a lot of this, is like, people like. Some people out there want like, "Oh, I want the fittest," whatever person.
It's like, some of those people, their entire life and religion is the gym, and you really
want that, because it's like. It's kind of the same where people are like. There's things of people being like, "I want to date someone who's super successful."
It's like, "Do you want to date someone whose entire life is their work?"
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
There's balance of like, "Hey, maybe you don't. Maybe it sounds nicer than it actually is, but I don't know."
Maybe we can understand if we replace protein with comedy.
Sure.
When I'm at Thanksgiving, I'm taking all the comedy.
I'm taking all the jokes.
I mean, think about it.
Yeah.
In the beginning, grandma's like, "Aha, that's nice."
And then I'm like, "More."
You really like that comedy.
More.
Yeah, yeah.
Yeah.
I'm going, "I didn't get enough. "
It's like, "Hey, Angela, you're not letting other people say jokes at the table."
I mean, if I had a long drive in the silence that morning, I'm walking in there, and I'm
going, "Let's hit."
Yeah.
"Let's go."
Yeah.
No, but anyways.
Okay.
Okay.
I feel bad for her.
This sucks.
Yeah.
Don't date buff guys.
Listen, I don't have any buff friends.
No buff guys.
Actually, you know what?
No buff guys.
Yeah.
It might look nice, but the meals are going to be nightmares.
Every meal's going to be a nightmare.
There's going to be no fun meals.
You can't just get an acai bowl.
You know what I mean?
You got to add bacon.
Oh, I see.
That's just candy, really.
Yeah.
Okay.
By the way, I'm talking about me now.
But it's. All right.
This episode of Reddit Stories is sponsored by Reddit.
I'm your host, Matt.
I'm your host, Matt.
I used to always dread the end of the month.
I knew I needed to sit down, get my spreadsheets out,
and look over my finances.
It took forever.
Combing through each transaction, categorizing them,
and figuring out how much money I could put into my savings,
it was a lot.
But then I started using Rocket Money.
Rocket Money has been my go-to app
for all of my finance needs.
Rocket Money offers automatic transaction categorization
across all my accounts.
And the time I'm saving is incredible.
Now I can just jump onto my dashboard and get a clear overview.
Saving has become a breeze, too.
With automated savings, I can reach my goals faster.
I just set the amount of money I want it to pull from my income,
and then I don't have to think or worry about it.
Rocket Money is a personal finance app that helps find and cancel unwanted subscriptions,
monitors your spending, and helps lower your bills so you can grow your savings.
Let Rocket Money help you reach your financial goals faster.
Join at rocketmoney.com slash pitreddit.
That's rocketmoney.com slash pitreddit.
rocketmoney.com slash pitreddit.
Back to the show.
This is Jill Schlesinger from Money Moves.
You started a business to follow your passion, not to get buried in financial details.
Xero makes managing your numbers simple by bringing accounting, payments, payroll, and analytics together in one place.
Instead of trying to sound smart, Xero is designed to make you feel smart.
with easy-to-read dashboards and smart insights that give you better control over your money.
Join 5 million customers worldwide who trust Xero to keep their business running smoothly without the hassle.
Learn more at Xero.com.
Moving on to our next story.
And this one comes from the subreddit TodayIFuckedUp.
This was posted back in December of 2019.
Today I fucked up by roasting a co-worker going through a divorce.
Okay.
How good was the roast?
It is mostly men where I work,
so naturally there is always some casual, lighthearted roasting going on.
Everybody does it, and it is all in good fun.
Builds morale, and so on and so on.
One of my coworkers, who is always an average-looking guy,
not ugly or unattractive, but until recently had a bit of a dad bod.
His wife, however, was very pretty.
I noticed this morning that he had lost some weight,
and I commented, you're losing weight, bro, looking good.
finally you're looking good enough
to deserve that pretty wife of yours.
Ha ha!
Fuck.
Whew!
Okay.
Now, it was meant to be a compliment,
but he pulled me aside
and told me that his wife was leaving him.
Oh, man.
One of her main reasons
was that he apparently let himself go
and she decided he wasn't good enough for her.
Oh, man.
So, yeah, I felt pretty awful
and I talked it over with him
and we're good now.
I apologize,
but man, do I feel like a complete asshole.
I guess we never know what people are going through.
Whoa, really tough.
Really stepped in shit and smeared it on your face.
Jesus.
But it was a compliment.
It was a compliment.
John Marco?
He said, hey, you're looking good and your wife's pretty.
That is a compliment.
He could have followed it up when he goes, well, my wife's leaving me because she said I didn't look good enough.
He's like, well, no, but you're looking good enough now.
Yeah.
You're right.
It was kind-hearted.
I think I feel. Your roast was a little late.
If you had said it sooner, you'd still be together.
Your roast should have been a note
and it should have happened six months ago.
No, it shouldn't.
That's not a brutal roast.
Just be like, hey, you're looking good.
Yeah.
You're looking good.
Yeah, that's. What's tough about this is commenting on somebody losing. Anybody's body. I don't do it.
Even if someone is gaining muscle, I don't even. I don't talk about people's bodies anymore.
I tell everyone if I think their partner is punching above their weight or below their weight.
Oh, really?
Well, they should know.
He's got family wealth?
Like, what's going on?
Is that why?
So he must have a massive dick.
Do you ever go, okay, this is. Do you ever go like, oh, your wife's beautiful?
Would you ever say something like that to someone?
Or someone's dating someone new and you go, hey, wow.
This probably comes down to me being an anxious person.
Yeah.
I don't really comment much on people's looks.
But this has happened to you, right?
Wasn't there somebody that said that you have a hot wife?
Yes.
Does that make you feel. Oh, people. Well, also, though, here's the thing.
I think. I'm a little. I don't know if desensitized is the word.
Like, on the internet, so many people are saying that about my wife.
Like, because she is objectively attractive.
Sure.
But when a guy comes up to you and says that?
Yeah, I think I. It depends on the tone.
It depends on. But I wouldn't take it as. So, okay, let's try some tones.
So. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
All right, let's try out some tones here.
Okay.
Your wife is hot.
Hey, thanks, man.
Yeah.
Yeah, for sure.
Yeah.
Okay, how about this?
Your wife is hot.
Did that feel good at all?
Is that, like, a surprise?
That stuck.
I think that confuses me.
I'm like, did you. Okay.
Wait, okay, I'm gonna. Your wife is hot?
Yeah.
As if you haven't seen her yet?
Like. Oh, ready, ready, ready?
I got one, I got one.
I don't even have questions.
I want to play.
Yeah, let's see, let's see, let's see.
Whew, wife is hot.
Why did you check him out before saying that?
No, I. Did you see?
This is what I did.
I went. Oh, you're. This guy?
Oh, okay, yeah, yeah, yeah.
I went, like. Oh.
Because that's what sucked about that, yeah.
Your wife is hot.
Look at you, bud.
Okay, bud.
I think that would. If it's two bros together, like. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
His wife's hot.
Holy moly.
You must got some family wealth.
You're a joke.
You got a lot of followers or something?
I think that I would be like, oh, damn.
No, that's really tough.
I think I feel bad because. I feel bad for this person.
Who am I feeling bad for?
The guy who got. The guy. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
It really sucks.
And for him to pull him aside and be like,
hey, bud, my wife is leaving me.
That really sucks.
That's. But then you just follow up.
Oh, that sucks.
You look so good, though.
You'll get another one.
I'd be like, you're in, like, butterfly mode.
You're about to go.
You're about to pop out.
And, like, I'm trying to make it better.
I would. Yeah, I would quickly be like,
she's leaving you because, like,
that sucks, man.
Like, I'm really sorry about that.
I would be like,
is she seeing other people?
Because she was hot.
She's done with. Because she could be with anybody she wants.
Has she locked it down outside yet?
That's tough.
I just think, like, it's awkward.
I don't think this person, like,
did anything that wrong.
That sounds like a light, light ribbing.
That was a compliment.
It's not. Yeah.
It's not in the. Like, if he wasn't going through that divorce,
and if what we're to believe,
that this is the vibe of their workplace
that they're constantly ribbing each other.
I knew a guy where his wife was so. He was so attractive that he was used to
every time people saw a picture or two,
they went, what?
And he got used to it
because everyone would go, like, what?
That's crazy.
And it was, like, it was involuntary.
Like, you said, surely this is a Photoshopped picture.
Of your wedding.
You get used to it, I guess.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
And then she left him?
No, no, I was kidding.
No, I haven't checked, but I assume.
You know, the laws of nature.
No, I'm just kidding.
Okay.
Comments.
I once got an email from a co-worker
that I didn't really know too well in retrospect
and noticed her last name had changed.
I congratulated her on getting married.
She responded that she had just gotten divorced.
Someone replied to that one saying,
I was on the other side of the road.
I was on the other side of the road.
I was on the other end of that several times
after getting divorced.
I said, no, no, congratulations is still appropriate.
Someone said, to be honest,
if she was willing to ditch her marriage
because her partner put on a few pounds,
he's better off without her.
And OP responded, that is exactly what I told him
in different words, of course.
I agree with that.
Someone said, I got some high visibility shirts
to wear at work, and when I finally decided to wear one,
someone asked if my mom dressed me that morning.
I told him, no, your mom did,
and then remembered I just signed the sympathy card
the previous day.
The previous month, because his mom passed away.
He was okay with it, since he started with the mom jokes,
but as soon as I remembered his mother passing away,
I just felt like a dick and apologized like 10 times.
Oh, that's tough.
What's a high visibility shirt?
Yeah.
Is that like, I'm jogging.
It's at night.
Like Under Armour.
Yeah.
Oh, you mean, oh, shiny.
Yeah, that's what I'm thinking.
High visibility.
I'm guessing.
Yeah, yeah, shiny.
Shiny.
Okay, yeah.
What a weird thing to wear.
Yeah, I don't know.
I wore it so your mom could see me
from heaven.
She's gone now.
I want her to see me down here.
I'm just saying, if your mom just died,
maybe chill with the your mama jokes for a bit.
Give your invulnerable territory.
Maybe he was saying, okay,
maybe he was saying it from like a really like sad,
like meaningful place, like,
wow, you look like your mom dressed you.
I don't know what that's like.
Yeah, that's like.
Like, maybe that's where he was coming from.
But you're right.
You can't really do your mama jokes just for a second.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
I also feel like those are,
they were put to rest in like 2013, so.
As was his mother.
Ladies and gentlemen,
John Marcos Arese.
John Marcos Arese.
Yeah!
All right.
Our next story comes from Relationship Advice.
This was posted in November of 2024.
I, a 28-year-old woman,
made a joke with my husband,
29-year-old man,
and it's costing me my marriage
with a man I truly love.
I need help fixing it.
A marriage is,
it's ending over a joke.
Any, any guess?
I'm so excited to hear this.
Do you have, do you have thoughts
on what this joke could be?
It's gotta be something deep about like a personal,
It's gotta be.
Like about your, your being.
Or it's the final straw to like,
like for a single joke to, to end a good marriage.
Yeah.
That's gotta be intense.
I created the account a couple of minutes ago
to get advice.
Oh.
A joke I made is spiraling out of control,
and I'm losing a man I truly love over it.
My husband and I have been married for four years now.
I truly do love him with everything I have.
I can't see a life without him.
I took some stupid advice from some of my girlfriends
regarding a joke that they have done
with their husbands or boyfriend.
Oh, okay.
Like a TikTok prank.
Probably like a TikTok prank.
Okay, okay.
The joke is basically telling your partner
you want to break up or that you want a divorce.
That's not a joke!
No, that's not a joke!
I never wanted to do it and thought it was cruel to do,
especially to someone you love,
but I was convinced after they kept pestering me about it
as I was the only one that hadn't done it yet
out of the five of us.
They further convinced me about it
when they told me the reactions their partners had afterwards.
What were the reactions?
My husband fucking cried.
Stupidly, I did it last night.
You did it last week,
and my husband's reaction wasn't what I thought it would be.
I honestly thought that he would try to talk to me
or beg or make suggestions like my friend's partners had done,
but he didn't.
Oh.
She's saying it as if those were like good.
Like I thought he would beg.
I thought it would be so funny.
He would cry and we would laugh.
We had dinner and we were watching a movie
when I told him I'm not happy anymore
and I think we should get a divorce.
This is crazy.
Have you done that one of your specials?
Yeah, yeah, yeah, that's how I close it.
You should do it, yeah. I close it.
He looked at me for a couple of seconds
and I swear it looked like something broke in his eyes.
Yeah.
He got up.
Yeah.
He got up, walked into our bedroom,
and within 10 minutes came out with a bag
and walked out of the house without saying a word to me.
Oh, he's being so weird.
What a weirdo.
What a fucking loser.
What?
I tried to stop him,
especially after seeing him with his bag packed
and told him it was just a joke and I didn't mean it,
but he basically just brushed me off and walked out.
I tried to get ahold of him,
messages, calls, emails, video chats,
but he isn't answering me at all.
I talked to his friends,
but none of them want to tell me where he is,
when and if they answer me.
I went to his work,
but they refused me entry into the building.
I have tried his parents,
but they don't want to get involved as well.
As with his siblings,
the only messages I got back was from his sister telling me,
"Joke or not, I fucked up."
I have sent too many messages about it being a joke,
and even sent screenshots of my conversations
with my girlfriends about the joke as proof
that it was a joke and that I'm not backtracking
all of a sudden, but nothing.
My friends didn't have any real advice
and told me to just give him time
and that he will get over it.
Her friends who are so smart.
Everything came down on me yesterday
when I was served with actual divorce papers.
It felt like someone slapped me in the face
and hit me and continued to hit me.
I was and still am in so much pain.
I frantically tried
to get a hold of him
but all I got back
was he had nothing to say
and I should talk
to his lawyer.
How can I get
the man I love back?
Wait.
I am so confused.
This is crazy.
So according to this story,
she, in the middle of the movie,
said,
I'm not happy.
I want a divorce.
And he went. Gets up.
Gets a bag.
And then meets. Ready?
Meets the fastest lawyer
you've ever met, right?
And then calls all the bosses.
They don't let her
in the building.
Yeah, and then the lawyer goes,
hey, divorce paper's easy.
Print.
There you go.
Signed.
Fast.
Fast.
Done.
He wanted the divorce.
Good point.
That's where I'm at.
It's this. Do you think he's cheating on her?
Do you think he's just. He's not happy?
This is. Look, I hate this prank, right?
Let's start off with that.
This reaction is blowing me away.
It is absolutely blowing me away.
She must be an incredible actor.
I mean, truly.
Or he's about to. It's about to all culminate.
They're gonna get to the courtroom
and he's gonna go,
and I fucking got you.
I'm gonna get you.
That. Now, that would be amazing.
He would be a king.
But, like, it's still pretty intense.
That's a lot to tell.
But look, we're in Bizarro World now.
To go to your boss and be like,
hey, my wife's gonna come.
She's gonna be crying.
Say you can't come in.
Yeah.
It's a funny thing.
We're gonna film the whole thing.
They get into the courtroom
and who's the judge?
Ashton Kutcher.
And she got punked.
This TikTok's gonna do numbers.
Yeah.
4,000 people will watch it.
Like, what is this?
This is crazy.
This is crazy.
Yeah.
This is. Everything about this.
Because it already started
where I was like,
she's nuts for doing this.
He's somehow responding
in a way where I'm like,
I don't know what's going on either.
Pranks can be funny,
but this is a lie.
We have a word for this.
It's called a lie.
Yeah, this isn't a prank.
It's not a joke.
It's not a prank.
It's a lie.
There's lies.
There's pranks.
There's jokes.
We're not even near a joke.
Like, I would love to see
what this woman thinks
of what a joke is.
I also don't get. I'm like, the point of a prank to me. I've said this so many times.
If the person
pranking is not laughing,
it's not a prank.
She's like, knock, knock.
Who's there?
Your mom's dead.
I'm serious.
This is not a joke.
Get up.
Get up.
Pack your bags.
Get up.
Leave.
Does the movie
that they were watching matter?
Oh.
Like, if it's definitely serious
versus like,
if it was Sophie's Choice?
Like, if they're watching Hamnet.
If they're watching Hamnet.
They're watching Kramer vs. Kramer.
Kramer vs. Kramer.
Pick up on happy marriages.
Yeah.
There you go.
And it's like, you know what?
I'll have what she's having.
Yeah.
And then, yeah.
Anyways, okay.
If you were watching Anchorman
and that's when you turned. Because then you'd be like,
okay, we're joking.
Come on.
Or if he picked Anchorman
or he's showing me. And then she goes,
I want a divorce.
What's that Tommy Wiseau movie
that two men have showed me before?
Yeah.
Oh.
And I, like, if two. If he's showing me this
and then I'm like,
I'm unhappy.
That's somehow the biggest
lore drop you've given us
on this show.
That men have. Two different. If you're a woman watching this
or listening to this
and a man has made
you watch this movie,
comment below and say,
I'm the silent majority.
Sorry.
Okay, we have a bunch of people.
Sorry.
The second guy to show you. You didn't say,
hey, someone's already
shown this to me?
I said everything I could.
He didn't listen.
He just put it off.
I think there's an army
of people out there.
Maybe it's not even
a gendered thing,
but where a person
makes you watch
that fucking movie.
You watch that
and you haven't seen it,
though, you should check it out.
No, no, no, no, don't, don't.
I knew he was doing it, too.
It's a cult classic.
Cult classic.
Final thing she says is,
how can I get
the man I love back?
I don't want to lose him.
I made a stupid joke.
I know that,
and now it's breaking
my world apart.
Change it to lie.
I made a stupid lie.
Yeah, I said I was
going to divorce him,
and then he divorced me.
Edit, already had questions
in my DMs about this.
We have had no issue
that I know of.
We were laughing
the whole time
throughout the day,
having fun and everything.
No fight or distance
recently between us.
Nothing like that at all.
Everything was basically perfect.
Dude, what the fuck, dude?
Your friends are awful.
A part of me, like,
almost wonders if the friends
were all, like, duping her.
Because, like,
they're all like,
oh, we all told our husbands.
All their husbands left them,
and they're like,
we got to get her to join.
Yeah, we got to figure
something out.
I just, she must have,
it must have been more than just,
I'm unhappy, let's leave.
Like, she must have stuck,
he must have been like, what?
I know, because
she says he said nothing.
You're so right.
Like,
like, that's crazy.
I just wanted
to feel like.
I'm like, damn, okay.
Because, like,
if my wife turned to me
in the middle of,
you know,
I don't know,
legally blonde,
and was like,
I want a divorce,
I'd be like,
I'd at least ask, like,
what?
Like, I'd at least ask
one question, you know?
Give me one question.
He isn't weird
for reacting that way.
It's a little funny
and bizarre,
but I will say, like,
maybe I just work
at a YouTube channel,
but if anything bizarre
happens to me,
I go, who's rolling?
Like, what do we do?
It is true, unfortunately.
I despise.
If someone's trying
to divorce you,
and they'll be like,
where's the cameras?
I go, what is this?
A challenge pit,
like, scenario situation?
I'm happy.
Okay.
I'm tired of watching the room.
Okay.
Where are the cameras?
Shane.
Okay.
Yeah.
I despise those TikTok,
like, relationship test things.
For one, though,
I think 99% of them
are all fake
all the way around, right?
It's like, oh,
the orange,
the peeling the orange thing.
What's that?
What's that one?
So that one was
women would film
their boyfriends unknowingly,
and you'd ask them
if they could peel an orange
for you.
And if your boyfriend's
willing to peel an orange for you,
then he's a good guy.
And if they go,
you can peel an orange
for yourself.
Like, it was just to be like,
oh, is your boyfriend,
is my boyfriend good enough?
Because you would never
peel your wife an orange.
I would do it in a heartbeat.
You'd be like,
baby, eat a turkey.
Eat a turkey.
But I'm like, hey,
if you're doing this test
and then posting it online,
like, you just need to,
like, talk to,
like, assess your relationship
and talk to, like.
Mostly fake
all the way around.
I think most are rage bait.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
This goes also into, like,
online territory
where people make
one joke a trend,
and that's, like, a joke.
And, like,
I think some people
who aren't maybe funny
do pranks instead of jokes.
Marriage crisis in America.
This TikTok prank
of divorcing your husband
has had families torn asunder.
It's so bizarre.
Wait, please tell me
there's an update.
Okay, so let's read
some comments.
What the actual fuck?
That is not a joke.
You did something
spectacularly stupid
and are facing
the consequences for it.
It honestly looks like
your female friends
know how ridiculously
gullible you are
and know exactly
how this would blow up
in your face.
2.4 thousand upvotes.
Jesus.
Someone said,
I'm sorry,
what was the funny part
of the joke?
I don't get it.
Ha ha.
Eight billion upvotes.
The whole world is reading.
Actually, everyone
fucking hates you.
Sorry.
Someone replied saying,
ha ha,
I broke my husband's heart
and made him beg
and cry for me
not to leave him
because my friends
said it's a joke.
So funny.
Someone said,
so many comments
recommend that you
make new friends
but honestly,
don't bother.
You are a perfect fit
for this group
of shitty people.
There's no update.
I'm sorry.
Are we kidding?
There's no update.
I searched.
Yeah.
I'm wondering
if he did say stuff
and like the way
she's writing it
is just like,
oh, he got up
and just immediately left
but we don't know.
Maybe, yeah.
But I also get like,
if you're going to say,
if you're going to tell someone
you're divorcing them,
you better be ready
to get divorced.
Like,
you don't.
Like crazy,
a world where people
mean what they say
and say what they mean.
I know.
Got him.
Whew.
Got him.
He loved that.
I just don't,
I don't think divorce is,
usually it's a,
it's a conversation.
It's not like,
well, you said the word,
got him.
I know.
If that's all it took,
my mom would have been
divorced from my stepdad
a lot sooner.
Ha ha ha.
It was eight years
before he got the bag,
you know,
and there was a lot of yapping.
Yeah.
But even just to look
at your partner
and be like,
I'm not happy
and you're dating
is just kind of,
I don't think anybody's
going to start giggling.
But if immediately
said I'm not happy,
nah,
you wouldn't be like,
sorry.
That's what she said.
Kiss me.
There's really not
like a good version.
Like I,
and I,
the friends didn't tee it up
like it was going to be
a good result anyways.
Yeah.
Like my husband begged.
It's like,
oh, okay,
that,
maybe I,
that sounds fun.
It sounds like it was
like much more
of like a power trip.
Yeah.
It does sound like
her friends are all demons.
And incredible actors.
Like I don't think
I could sustain it.
Like all of a sudden
it's a marriage story
and they're like ground,
you know.
Sometimes I think
as performers
we judge people.
They never get a chance
to perform
and so one day
someone says,
hey,
you can be a lead
in a Eugene O'Neill play.
Tell your husband
you want a divorce.
And we,
from here,
we get,
we get to do this
every night.
We get to,
we go on stage.
I want a divorce
and it's a scene.
And we get that out.
You don't get to get that out.
God forbid,
God forbid a regular person
want to perform.
Oh, yeah,
they get to do the thing.
Let them have a chance.
That's really funny.
It sounds like she gave
a great performance.
Yeah.
Yeah.
She crushed it
because he believed it.
In the middle
of Finding Nemo.
That'd be tough.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Anyways,
got to move on
because that's it
for that one.
So,
this comes from
the subreddit
Girl Dinner Diaries
where. I'm familiar.
You're familiar?
No.
Okay.
Women write in
venting about something
going on in their life
and then they post a photo
of what their girl dinner
that they're eating
right then and that moment is.
Okay.
So,
someone writes in. Girl dinner just to,
because my girlfriend
subscribed,
it's like a smattering
of like. Traditionally,
yeah,
that's what it is.
But a lot of these
girl dinners that they post
are just a full actual dinner.
They just kind of post
what they're eating
in the moment.
Okay, okay.
They're just kind of like,
oh my God,
I'm dipping cranberries
He's in Haagen-Dazs, and my boyfriend's fucking somebody else.
Yes.
It's kind of just that.
There you go.
They write, my brother's daughter is also his niece.
My brother's daughter.
Is also his niece.
And your niece is when.
Is this an incest story?
I don't.
Oh, no.
Is this like Anne Boleyn?
Wait, my boyfriend's daughter is also his niece.
So what's a niece?
A niece is.
A niece is a brother's girl, daughter.
A sibling's child.
A sibling's son.
So this could be incest.
Or it could be like, couldn't have a baby.
And a frozen, or yeah.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
We have confirmation it's not incest.
Okay.
Oh, by the way, they're eating a brownie, or chocolate cake with vanilla ice cream.
Actually looks amazing.
Goes great with incest.
Fuck.
Okay.
This episode of Reddit Stories is sponsored by ZocDoc.
Can you believe that Thanksgiving is just around the corner?
I can't.
But that's why I cherish.
I cherish the opportunity to spend extra time with my friends and family during the holidays.
Travel, big dinners, making memories, the works.
But before I travel home, I've got so much to do, such as making a plan for all those
doctor's appointments I've been putting off.
A flu shot, routine blood work, a checkup.
Oof, the list is longer than I remember.
It would be such a bummer to make all these holiday plans only to miss out sick in bed
because I didn't plan ahead.
But luckily, ZocDoc is free to use and always there for all my appointment needs.
ZocDoc.
ZocDoc.
lets you compare local in-network doctors
and see actual appointment openings
where you can click to instantly book a visit.
You can knock out all of the appointments
you've been meaning to book fast,
usually within 24 to 72 hours,
and you can even score same-day appointments
if you're like me
and have really been putting off that to-do list.
I love ZocDoc.
It has been a huge help for me.
I was pushing off doctor's appointments for so long
until I downloaded it,
and then I had all my appointments set up within a week.
Your health matters,
and taking care of yourself shouldn't be complicated.
Ready to be seen?
Head to ZocDoc.com slash PitReddit to get started
and check that appointment off your to-do list.
That's Z-O-C-D-O-C dot com slash PitReddit.
Now back to the show.
This year, set up your holiday gifting
with a little extra magic.
The perfect shoes from Designer Shoe Warehouse.
DSW's got holiday gifts and stocking stuffers
for everyone on your list.
And tis the season for a little self-gifting, too.
Whether you bake all day, dance all night,
carol all over town,
or tiptoe under the mistletoe,
DSW is your designer shoe wonderland
for comfy slippers, joyful party shoes,
statement boots, and more.
Shop in-store or visit DSW.com.
DSW, let us surprise you.
Here's the story.
When I was in college,
my twin brother started dating my housemate.
I set them up.
After a few years, they had a kid
and then eventually got married.
On the day of their wedding,
my half-brother, who nobody had seen for about five years,
showed up out of the blue.
The three of them quickly became besties,
and when we all moved to a new city,
those three got a place together.
Fast forward a couple of years,
and it turns out that my sister-in-law
still wanted to be my sister-in-law,
but she just wanted to trade up
which brother she was married to.
So my twin brother got divorced,
my half-brother got married,
and family gatherings got complicated.
Skip ahead another couple of years,
and my half-brother and his new wife,
my twin brother's ex-wife,
had a couple of kids.
So now I have three nieces
who are simultaneously sisters and cousins
and who have dads who are both uncles and fathers.
Vanilla ice cream with a slice of chocolate cake.
Okay, so I have half-siblings,
and so I'm like, I'm starting,
I think I see the math here.
Yeah, so basically-
Because there's halves.
I mean, like, some of this is like it's a-
It's half-siblings.
I mean, even regardless,
it's just that a brother,
two brothers were,
and a wife were living in a house together,
and then the wife goes,
I'm going to stop being married to you,
and I'm going to get married to you.
Can we do it with-
Okay, so-
Let's do it with this stuff.
Okay, so twins.
This is the writer.
Those are the brothers.
These are the brothers.
So that's the wife.
She's married to that pillow.
To that pillow.
Which is, can I say, marrying up.
And then this half-brother shows up,
and they all realize like,
oh, we all have a good time hanging out.
Let's all live together.
Live together.
Big mistake on this brother's part.
Yeah, and then the wife,
just after a couple years-
Falls in love with him.
And then divorces him,
gets married to him.
We need kids.
Yeah.
But then there's kids.
So one kid is his kid.
Get some of that shit.
Yeah.
Okay, so-
Okay, so-
So, oh, that's glued.
I think everything is glued down.
There we go, there we go.
We have a kid, we have a kid.
We have a kid,
and that's the kid of-
So this kid is of these two.
Those two.
And now these guys raise them?
Well, they're still probably raising them.
But now this is his nephew
Oh, I see.
But now they've had kids.
So these kids are both cousins and siblings.
Cousins and half-siblings.
Half-siblings and half-cousins.
Or cousins and half-siblings, yeah.
Are cousins cousins?
Is there such a thing as a half-cousin?
I guess not.
Cousins?
No, you have second cousins.
But I don't think that's the case here.
I think they're half-siblings,
but they are siblings.
Like, you know what I mean?
Yeah.
You genuinely going,
are cousins cousins?
So, okay.
That one looks a lot like this one.
This will stay.
So this, okay,
so this is from the first marriage.
So this-
Is this.
That's their uncle.
That's their uncle.
Yeah.
And stepdad.
Yeah.
So uncle, stepdad.
This is these two have a kid.
Is their kid.
So now let's talk about these two.
So they're half-siblings and half-siblings.
Because they have the same mom.
Yes.
But they're half-siblings as well.
And they're cousins.
And they're also cousins.
And they're cousins.
Yeah.
And if they make a baby,
and then things get weird.
And what are they eating?
That's when it gets weird.
This is somehow becoming
the fully most insane thing
that we've read today.
This is a lot to comprehend.
Well, to me, actually,
it's not because
they're just cousins.
But they're also siblings.
But they're also half-siblings.
What are their relationships?
But they have the same mom.
They have the same mom.
All of them have the same mom.
And they're dads.
They have different dads,
but their dads are related.
That is weird.
I think the more complicated aspect
is their mom's
fucking their uncle.
Like, that's the part where. That's the weird part.
Like, how. Dude.
Like, these brothers
can't be talking to each other now, right?
Like, that's. Well, they gotta.
They share three
half-sibling uncle kids.
Sounds like hell.
This is tough.
It sounds like a Vince Vaughn movie.
Well, it was crazy to. It was crazy to move in
the three of them together.
That's. Brother you haven't seen
for five years
who just showed up
to the wedding.
Yeah.
Yeah.
He said,
you got a hot wife.
You got a. Yeah, there he goes.
Hey, your wife's really hot.
How did you. Really hot.
You should be with him.
Can I move in?
I go, hey, your wife's hot.
Can I move in?
Yeah.
That's a red flag.
Can we start a slow arc
that'll end one way or another?
Yeah.
Oh, my God.
Okay, now these
canonically live on the set
and now they are always
gonna be those people.
This sounds like
an ancient story.
This feels like
the stuff you read about
in medieval times.
Yeah.
Comments,
a bit odd for them
to start off their lives
as newlyweds
by living with
a formerly estranged sibling.
Someone said,
I was about to be like,
what in the Targaryen?
Someone said,
I have a friend
who has this situation.
She calls them
her sissons and brosons.
That's weirder.
That's weird.
That'll make them feel. Makes you look weirder.
That's weird.
You're weird.
Someone said,
I know a woman,
daughter of my
grandmother's boyfriend.
Oh, just hold on.
Whom. Daughter of my
grandmother's boyfriend.
Yeah.
Who married a twin
then fell in love
with his twin,
left him,
and had children
with the second twin.
She's still with twin two
and the twins
still don't talk
to this day.
Mm-hmm.
Lastly, someone said,
oh, wow,
that is complicated.
Cake looks good.
Chocolate cake
with vanilla ice cream.
Good combo.
Give it to these kids.
They're the ones
that need some treats.
Yeah, they need some treats.
They need some treats.
Because figuring that out
is crazy.
Well, we've done
a lot of math here
and now it's time
to move on.
Our final story
comes from
Am I the Asshole?
It was posted
in August of this year.
Am I the asshole
for taking my son
to Disney World
without his mother?
Mm.
Okay.
Okay.
My ex-wife,
who's 41,
and I,
42-year-old man,
got divorced
two years ago
after eight years
of marriage.
We have a six-year-old
son together
and split custody
of him.
About a year ago,
my ex-wife
met someone new
and started dating.
After about six months
of dating,
she introduced him
to my son.
I've met this new guy
a couple of times
and don't have anything
against him.
I do, however,
have an issue
with something my ex did
shortly after introducing
our son to this new guy.
I'm a big Star Wars fan.
My wife is too
and have been looking forward
to watching the movies
with my son
for his first time.
At the time,
my ex and I
were still together.
We made a decision together
to wait until he was
a little older
so that he could understand
it more.
Well, turns out
my ex's new boyfriend
is also a Star Wars fan
and the three of them
watched a bunch
of the movies together
shortly after
the introduction.
Oh.
I found out
when I had my son
shortly after
because he was so excited
to tell me about it.
I talked to my ex about it
and she said
she didn't think
it was a big deal
and she wanted
her new boyfriend
and our son
to be able to bond
over a shared interest.
I told her
how disappointed I was
and she basically
told me to get over it
and that I was overreacting.
I know this seems petty.
and it probably is,
but I decided that I would start saving up
for a Disney trip for my son and I.
My wife is a huge Disney fan
and has never been to any of the Disney parks.
Wait, is big Disney fan never been?
Never been to any of the parks.
Almost like she hasn't seen Star Wars.
Here we go.
Here we go.
It was something we talked about a lot
before we got divorced.
According to our custody agreement,
I have our son for Thanksgiving this year.
So instead of seeing family,
I booked us a long weekend at Disney World.
I wanted it to be a surprise for my son,
but due to us having to travel out of state,
I told my ex about it
so that she knew we would be traveling.
That conversation did not go well.
We're going to Orlando, Florida.
We're going to Orlando just to see the city.
Just the beaches.
There's a Rainforest Cafe there.
Yeah.
She flipped.
She started accusing me of hiding assets
in order to afford it,
called me a bunch of names and cursed a lot.
In my head, I wanted to tell her she was overreacting,
but I knew that wouldn't help anything,
so I just let her get it all out.
Okay.
Once she stopped yelling at me,
I told her that I have no plans on changing the trip
and I am telling her in advance
so that there are no surprises.
A few weeks later,
I got a letter from a lawyer's office
stating that my ex filed a motion to try
and prevent me from taking our son out of state.
Her reasoning is that she has a fear of child abduction.
Basically, she told a lawyer that she thinks
I am going to take my son to Disney
and never come back.
That's how I feel at Disney World.
Now I have to get my own lawyer to defend,
but my ex and I co-parented quite reasonably
up until she got her new boyfriend,
and since then, things have been very contentious.
I know this trip probably plays into that,
but if I can't watch the movies with him for the first time,
I can at least take him to the theme parks
and have that be special for the two of us.
Oh, man.
You know, I was talking to my mom about the divorce
and whatever, and she was talking about
the times it was peaceful,
and it's before she started seeing.
I was like, "Oh, my God. I'm going to be a father.
Yes, of course.
I'm on the guy's side in that the kid's just benefiting.
Listen, if the grudge between the parents don't always result in you get to go to Disney World and do Star Wars,
it's usually like you don't get to play soccer this summer.
Yeah, or like they're upstairs fighting, but for them to both be fighting and you're just kind of getting all this good shit, it's kind of sweet.
But here's the thing, it's pretty petty to be like, I know she's dying to go to Disneyland.
It is petty.
It is petty.
Yeah, you want to know, all too petty, all too petty.
You say to the kid, hey, I want to take you to Disneyland.
Mommy said you can't.
Yeah, yeah, for sure.
Dropping you off, have a good time.
For sure, for sure.
That's so true.
I think what I, but, like, the reality, like, yes, the kid, if the parents are being civil and not, like, talking shit about each other and are being cool for the kid, but also, the guy knows he's not doing this for his child.
Like, he's doing this to get back at her.
But do the ends justify the means?
That's fair.
Hey, look, if you're going to Disney World, does it matter how you got there?
This Star Wars thing is a betrayal.
That's a betrayal.
That really hurts.
That would be a fucking betrayal.
She did start this battle.
He's seeing red.
He's not.
And for her to be like, oh, well, this is for the boyfriend.
It's like, the boyfriend's not, like, his relationship, like, that's.
What's really fucked up about it is that the new partner's watching Star Wars with the kid.
Yeah.
Like, that's, you know what I mean?
This would be like.
He is justified.
And for her to be like, you're overreacting, I don't give a shit.
It's like, he said that they had a conversation about this before.
Yeah, this would be like.
It's a super betrayal.
If he brought the kid to Disneyland with his new girlfriend.
Yeah.
And it's like, it's fucked up to have something that you vocalize that you're looking forward to doing with your kid and have your new partner do it.
It's also for her to be like, it's not a big deal.
I'm like, clearly it is.
You only date guys who are into Star Wars.
This is like the main thing, it would seem.
You have a type.
It's a massive milestone.
Like, that is a huge thing you're ripping from him.
And her reaction is of the same caliber.
It's like, yeah, this means a lot to me.
This was something I was hoping to experience with my son.
But first of all, but she didn't say that.
She's just always wanted to go.
Yeah, this is for her.
She never said, I want to do this with my son.
You said, I would like to watch Star Wars all together.
You made that clear.
Yeah, okay.
She just wants to go.
Yeah, the kid might not even.
Oh, you can't take your kid to Disney World because mommy's never been.
If your vindictiveness results in your kid being happy, then it's fine.
And that's a child of divorce.
Okay.
It wasn't always great, but I got, my dad, we got to do some, I got a samurai sword out of it.
Okay, that's pretty cool.
That's pretty awesome.
His mom said I couldn't have it.
That's awesome.
So.
Holy shit.
God.
Well, the verdict on Reddit is everyone sucks here.
Which I think, like, to some.
I don't, I don't think.
Listen, if he, if he was, like, bringing the kid to, like, something very specific that kids don't love to do.
He's bringing his kid to Disney World.
That's a nice thing for the kid.
It's like, sorry your mom picked the biggest IP in the entire world.
Like, oh, because mommy likes Disney, we can only go to Discovery Zone?
Is that still a thing?
Brass Pro Shop?
Yeah.
Once my family said we were going to Disneyland, they brought us to Brass Pro Shop instead.
It was awful.
Brass Pro Shop?
Isn't that crazy?
Brass Pro Shop.
Oh, whoops.
You were talking about an instrument store.
And even that would have been fun.
That's my point.
That was the other option.
The idea of like, I like Disney so the kid can't experience Disney, that's like, well, I like ice cream, so don't ever bring the kid to ice cream.
Sorry, you got divorced.
It's now a war.
And it's who's going to be the cooler parent.
You gave away Star Wars is huge.
It's clearly huge.
It's a big deal for him.
And he's watching it with a new guy you're fucking.
And by the way, you're going to Disney, so now, and I understand we're hearing one side of the story, of course.
but now you're kidnapping him now you're kidnapping i want to go to disney so much
you're gonna go to disney and never come back um she thinks disney world is like a legitimate world
that you can live at um i guess also the question for her is like what is her expectation like he's
not allowed to go to disney disney world with him is that she's the only one who's allowed to go or
that they would all go together.
But those rules, by
her letting him watch Star Wars
with her new partner, those
rules are now, they don't matter. She broke the rules.
There's no rules now. It's like when you're
with your son, you get to do whatever you want.
Your Honor, she broke the Star Wars
rules.
So I kidnapped him. The Jedi Council deems her
guilty.
The comments here, someone said,
nothing wrong with going to a theme park, but if you
let revenge against your partner dictate
your parenting choices, you're going to hurt
your kid long-term.
Do what's in their
best interest,
not what gets back
at your ex
or what causes
the most conflict.
I feel bad for your kid.
I think that's where I'm at.
Yeah, I feel bad for the kid.
He got to watch Star Wars
and go to Disney World.
This is the most
unfortunate kid in the world.
Right now, it's good,
but I do think,
would you not agree
that it's a bit
of a slippery slope?
Yeah, maybe he'll go
to Universal Studios next.
We got to get
Child Protective Services
over to this kid.
Uh-oh, she's dating
somebody else.
He's going to show him
Marvel!
This kid's got the life.
Someone said,
you are right for being upset
about the movie situation.
Your ex-wife was wrong,
so you wanted to get back at her
by taking your son to Disney
for a weekend,
which shouldn't be a big deal,
but you knew this would really be
a way to get back at your wife.
I think that the legal situation
could be resolved easily
with a letter from your lawyer
stating that you are gainfully employed
and are not moving out of your home.
She can see a copy of the ticket
and hotel reservations
showing the time frame
you will be gone.
The behavior you are
both exhibiting
is extremely childish.
You know what I would do?
I would go to Disneyland
that day.
I'd go,
when are you guys going?
Like, I'd be really upset
that they're going without me.
And I would fucking go.
With the guy?
I would show up.
Not with the guy, no.
I would just show up.
Okay.
And I would join them.
Because he's going to go,
Mommy!
And I'm going to be like,
I'm there too.
I think if you're
a big Disney fan
and you've eight years
of being a Disney fan
and you've never been
to Disney World,
you probably don't have
the finances to just do this? No, I guess. Yeah. I will say it is expensive as fuck. It's so
expensive. I just think if your personality is the biggest way you could wrong me would to be
bring our son to Disney World. Maybe you need to go. That's not great. I agree with that. I agree
with that. Someone said, not the asshole. There is nothing wrong with you taking your son on a trip.
Let your lawyer sort it out. Your ex sounds exhausting. As for the Star Wars thing, yes,
It's annoying, but it's typical of the petty annoyances
that take place after a divorce.
I would let it go.
Lastly, someone said, you're the asshole.
You're the asshole.
Your feelings are hurt, so you are literally escalating
the situation in such a specific way to maximize damage
so you can get personal revenge over a movie experience.
This is embarrassing and sad for your kid.
Over a theme park experience.
Like, come on.
There's both.
No, I understand what you mean.
I think also, but at the end of the day,
it's just getting, it's going to get tit for tat.
and it's gonna get bad.
- Tell me how it gets bad.
Walk me through the bad part.
- I'm thinking.
I think they just get, they're more mad at each other.
She's gonna be furious.
He's already furious.
- As long as the tactics are always positive.
- Good things, yeah.
And I just don't think that's the best.
- And I think if I'm the mom, when the kid comes back,
"Hey, you wanna try cigarettes?"
Of course.
so not divorced and don't have a kid.
So I'm fully out of my zone to talk about this.
But I also think, like, I have a hard time believing
this isn't going to slip into ways
that aren't going to hurt the child.
No, it's already bad.
I mean, it's already bad.
It's already bad.
But, like, listen, I understand how the movie thing happens.
Like, I can see how it's like you had a conversation
and then Star Wars was on.
Was on and it just happened.
No, I get it, I get it.
But you can't say, if you go, that's not a big deal,
then you've introduced the idea that there's no big deals.
So it's no big deal, we go to Disney World.
Oof.
I think it's not good.
But you can't go kidnapping charge because of Disney World.
Right.
You know?
That is very scary.
But that's also the nightmare of, like, divorces.
So, like, divorces with a kid is, like, you've got to work together.
And, like, if your partner's a nightmare and you've got to,
I just, I'm like.
Out of all my times on this show,
I have never used stuff to show.
Show people visually.
Very interactive.
Very helpful.
To be like, because usually sometimes it's like,
then she started dating somebody else.
And then they brought in somebody.
So this is helpful.
We should have, like, a thing of figurines.
We should have a little puppet show every single.
Well, when I did therapy early on, because of all the divorce,
I didn't want to talk to therapists,
so I would take action figures.
And I'd just play with action figures all day.
And the therapist would be like,
oh, is the Green Ranger your stepdad?
And I'd be like, no, he's the bad guy.
I don't know.
He's like, no, he's the Green Ranger, fucking bitch.
Why is the Green Ranger fucking the Pink Ranger
and the Red Ranger's crying in the corner?
And the therapist's like,
well, that does happen in Power Rangers,
so that's just lore.
Why is the Green Ranger showing Star Wars to the?
Yeah.
Yeah.
Huh.
Because don't you see that that's okay
and everyone still loves each other?
This is going to be a terrible divorce.
If the kidnapping allegations.
Kidnapping allegations should,
you should at least be, you know,
11, 12 before you're doing the,
kidnapping allegations.
Because they happen.
I'm telling you, like what happens,
it gets really,
you have a custody arrangement
and then let's say you're at your dad's for the weekend.
Monday is Martin Luther King Jr. Day.
So day off school.
And then there's no,
no one thought to cover that particular holiday.
So dad says, I'm going to keep him.
Mom says, no.
And he says, yeah.
And she goes, well, you're kidnapping him.
Yeah.
And then that's where it goes.
And by the way, when that happened to me,
no one brought me to fucking Disney World.
So, sorry.
Not a lot of sympathy for the kid.
Oh my God.
I love that you're like, this kid's fine.
This is ideal divorce.
You're so jealous of this kid.
This is the best it could go for this kid.
Oh my God.
All right.
Well, John Marco, thank you for joining us today.
Thank you.
I see why you picked this subject.
Oh, it's so rich.
This just should be a series.
There's so much with custody.
The problem, you wouldn't believe the complications.
The complications.
Yeah.
And just people behaving just their worst.
Oh, really?
Because people go like, oh, I'm not going to be rude to someone else
when there's a kid involved.
They let it.
Yeah.
They open up.
I also, I like the series of people talking about their divorces
and you're just going, not as bad as mine.
Not as bad as mine.
I'll be honest when it's worse.
If you can find it.
We'll find it.
Well, thank you both so much for joining me.
And John Marco, you have a special coming out soon, right?
I have a special coming out.
It's on Netflix.
It's called God Forbid.
Nice.
Nice.
Uh, if, if you have a child of divorce, take them there.
Take the, watch them, watch the show.
Take them there to the Netflix.
Take them to Netflix and watch it.
Watch it with your new boyfriend and don't tell them.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Oh my God.
Yeah.
Don't watch John Marco's special.
Especially if your ex loves John Marco Sarese.
Yeah.
Don't show him his first John Marco special.
The hope is that then the ex watches it.
Two views.
Yeah.
Two views.
Two views.
And who benefits you?
That's what it's all about, guys.
Both households, guys.
Watch the special in both households.
Yay, John Marco.
All right.
Well, thank you both for joining.
And thank you all for watching.
This has been a very silly time.
We'll see you next Saturday.
Goodbye.
Bye.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
A man’s excessive turkey consumption at a Thanksgiving dinner led to a heated argument and a traumatic mid-night abandonment of his girlfriend, revealing deeper issues of respect and emotional boundaries.
The relationship ended when the man was revealed to be cheating on his partner with a fitness influencer, exposing a pattern of emotional manipulation and deception.
A workplace roast of a coworker losing weight, initially meant as a compliment, accidentally triggered a divorce when the coworker revealed his wife had left him due to feeling undervalued.
A woman joking about wanting a divorce during a movie night with her husband caused him to leave abruptly, leading to actual divorce papers and emotional devastation.
The story highlights how pranks and jokes can spiral into serious consequences when taken seriously, especially in relationships built on trust.
The episode critiques the normalization of toxic humor and performative pranks in online culture, showing how they can damage real relationships.
It emphasizes the importance of emotional boundaries, open communication, and respect—especially in relationships involving children or shared responsibilities.
The narratives collectively illustrate how misunderstandings, poor boundaries, and lack of empathy can turn casual moments into profound relationship crises.
Summary:
This episode of Smosh Reads explores real Reddit stories centered around exes, divorce, and relationship breakdowns, revealing how seemingly small incidents can spiral into major emotional crises. One story details a couple's rupture after a man’s excessive turkey-eating at Thanksgiving, which escalated into a harmful abandonment and later a betrayal with a fitness influencer. Another shows how a lighthearted workplace roast of a coworker’s weight loss unintentionally triggered a divorce, highlighting how insensitive comments can deeply hurt individuals during vulnerable times.
A third story features a woman joking about wanting a divorce, which led her husband to leave abruptly and file actual divorce papers, underscoring how serious intentions can be misinterpreted or exploited. The episode critiques the culture of online pranks and jokes, warning that they can backfire when real emotions are involved. It also explores broader themes of emotional boundaries, respect, and communication in relationships—particularly when children are involved.
Ultimately, the stories reveal that relationships are fragile, and even well-intentioned actions can have devastating outcomes if not handled with empathy and awareness. The commentary emphasizes that trust, honesty, and emotional intelligence are essential in maintaining healthy connections, especially in high-stress or emotionally charged moments.
FAQs
The story shows that a buff guy who eats all the turkey at a family meal may seem like a compliment, but it can be seen as inconsiderate, especially when food is shared. It highlights how such behavior can be misinterpreted and lead to conflict, especially if the person feels disrespected or ignored.
She jokingly told her husband she wanted a divorce during a movie, which triggered a severe emotional reaction. He immediately packed and left without speaking, and later filed for divorce. The incident shows how serious a breakup can be, even if initiated as a joke.
The roast was meant as a compliment but accidentally revealed the coworker was going through a divorce. The comment about him not being 'good enough' for his wife deeply hurt him, showing how comments on someone’s appearance can be harmful when they’re going through personal struggles.
Sharing items like a dog or a Peloton with an ex can lead to uncomfortable or even toxic situations, especially if one partner is dating someone new. It can blur boundaries and create emotional tension, as seen when one person felt embarrassed or betrayed by the other's actions.
Leaving someone at a gas station after a fight is a serious breach of trust and respect. The story shows that such actions, even if justified by hunger, are unacceptable and can be seen as a dealbreaker, especially in relationships where mutual care and communication are vital.
Children of divorced parents often grow up observing and learning about conflict, negotiation, and emotional strategies. The story shows how they may internalize these dynamics and, even as adults, struggle to maintain healthy relationships, especially when trust is broken.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.