Robert Pattinson Is James Bond! Now What? Plus: The Pointless ‘Ebenezer,’ Fjighting About ‘Fjord,’ and Léa Seydoux!
2h 35m 2s
A new James Bond film is set to star Robert Pattinson, directed by Denis Villeneuve, marking a significant evolution in the franchise. This decision reflects a broader trend where major studios, now owned by Amazon and MGM, prioritize IP value and commercial scalability over traditional casting instincts. The film is expected to move beyond classic action tropes, embracing themes of trauma, digital culture, and moral ambiguity, aligning with modern societal concerns. Pattinson’s career trajectory—spanning indie auteur projects and major franchises—offers a unique blend of depth and accessibility, while the creative team aims to craft a psychologically rich, thematically resonant experience. The casting of heavyweight actors like Mahershala Ali or Gwyneth Paltrow as villains is seen as a strategic move to add moral complexity and realism. Despite concerns over originality, the film’s narrative will likely explore redemption, systemic power, and personal accountability in a way that feels contemporary and relevant. Critics note that while the story of James Bond has long been formulaic, this adaptation may finally offer a fresh, introspective take that honors the character’s evolution. The film’s potential to redefine Bond as a morally ambiguous, psychologically layered figure is exciting, though it risks alienating long-time fans who expect traditional adventure. Ultimately, the film represents a pivotal moment in Bond’s history—one that blends creative vision with commercial ambition, signaling a new era for the franchise.
I'm Sean Fennessy.
I'm Amanda Dobbins.
And this is The Big Picture, a conversation show about Bond, James Bond.
Today on the show, we are discussing a number of things, including Johnny Depp's return to studio filmmaking in Ebenezer,
a new adaptation of Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol.
We'll also rank the Christmas Carol movie adaptations.
Amanda has seen them all, and she loves them all.
Then we will finally dig into Christian Mongeau's Palme d'Or-winning Fjord,
a thorny drama set in Norway about a Romanian family's culture clash in their new home.
And of course, we'll be talking about the news that James Bond has been cast later in this episode.
I'll be joined by Lea Seydoux, the French star known for her performances in both auteur-driven fare like The French Dispatch,
The Beast, and Crimes of the Future, along with roles in blockbusters.
series like Dune, Mission Impossible, and those James Bond films.
Lea stars in four films this year, including Gentle Monster, which premieres on Netflix this week,
as well as The Unknown, two mysterious, challenging dramas that feature remarkable transformations by the actress.
Lea is pretty intimidating, but chatting with her was an absolute delight.
You will want to check out that conversation.
But first, some movie news about James Bond, right after this.
This episode is brought to you by McDonald's.
Even the greatest movies you can only watch so many times.
Breakfast, on the other hand?
Every day, the same craving.
Something hot, something filling, and a moment to enjoy it.
The sausage and McMuffin with egg pretty much covers it.
Adding a hash brown and coffee for just five bucks?
Even better.
Get a sausage and McMuffin with egg, plus hash browns and a small coffee for just five dollars.
Only at McDonald's for a limited time.
Price and participation may vary.
Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing.
Excludes delivery.
This episode is brought to you by LinkedIn Ads.
Ever invest in something that seemed incredible at first but didn't live up to the hype?
Marketers know that feeling.
They optimize.
For the numbers that look great.
Impressions reach and reacts.
But when they don't show revenue, well, that's a not-so-great conversation with the CFO.
LinkedIn has a word for that.
Bullspend.
Instead, why not invest in what looks good to your CFO?
LinkedIn Ads generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks.
Reach the right buyers with LinkedIn Ads.
You can target by company, industry, job title, and more.
So cut the bullspend.
Advertise on LinkedIn, the network that works for you.
Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a $200.
$250 credit for the next one.
Just go to linkedin.com slash the big picture.
That's linkedin.com slash the big picture.
Terms and conditions apply.
Okay.
He is risen.
And I'm not talking about Christ.
Robert Pattinson.
And me.
And you.
By the power of association.
Let me tell you something.
I feel great.
Say more.
Is this what it feels like to get what you want?
I guess so.
Just to be like, yes.
Sounds good.
Make a James Bond movie directed by. Denis Villeneuve starring Robert Pattinson.
What's the problem?
There's definitely no problem.
I view this as very good news.
Yeah.
Do you subscribe at all to the long-held, oft-unenunciated theory that Bond should be a relative unknown?
Is that something that you've cared about?
No.
And I think because also I started watching James Bond after they were all chosen.
Except for Daniel Craig.
But, like, I was not sentient for the. Pierce Brosnan stuff until it was introduced to me as Pierce Brosnan.
You know, Sean Connery's grandfathered in.
They've all always been James Bond to me.
So, the sense of discovery is not something that I associate with James Bond.
What I associate is a very handsome, charming actor in a tuxedo with a martini and possibly a gun.
Probably a gun.
There we are.
In fact, he held a gun this morning.
Robert Pattinson.
There was promo material ready when the announcement was made.
You know, as we said, we've kind of known that this was going to happen.
Yeah.
As soon as Pattinson's name went out.
Into the public sphere.
To me, it was all but assured that he would be cast.
This would have been very odd this morning if Nicholas Holt were announced as James Bond.
I think the world would have been very confused by that news.
So, you know, there was a narrative of inevitability about this.
But I think happy inevitability.
This is a real sign of the times, though, in terms of, I think, how these large corporations view IP.
Which, if you go back even as recently as the most recent Star Wars relaunch, there was an unknown in Daisy Ridley being cast in the role of Robert Pattinson.
Right.
Hayden Christensen was cast in the previous trilogy of Star Wars movies.
Chris Pratt in Jurassic World.
You know, the Chris's in the Marvel movies in general.
Relying more on the IP than the people making the movie.
Pattinson, Denis Villeneuve, and even Stephen Knight, the author of the screenplay.
That's as, like, upscale, locked and loaded, I think, as you could get for a movie like this right now.
What does that tell you?
I mean, I agree with you that it is an indication of. This is where we are, and when you have IP this big.
And also, Bond is now owned by Amazon, MGM Amazon.
And they're calling the shots, not the Broccoli family anymore.
So, I guess, if you want to be. Not even if you want to be cynical.
This, for sure, is corporate Bond.
They are playing to, you know, bank statements as much as they're playing to what is going to make a great creative film.
Happily, Denis Villeneuve and Robert Pattinson and Stephen Knight are all. Pretty good at their jobs.
Yeah.
So. They found the intersection between those two things.
Yeah.
I think that James Bond is slightly different from superheroes in just that it's just one person.
And who plays Bond, because it's been Interchange of the Heroes, does matter.
Like, the identity of the actual person has always been such a subject of fascination that it's a little less surprising for me that they went for an unknown.
But, you know, you just need a star at this point and to get attention on anything.
And I do think even with the James Bond of it all and with the Amazon of it all and with the money of it all,
someone that most of the world hasn't heard of is not going to get as much attention as Robert Pattinson is.
Like, that is the era that we are in of not just movies, but attention economy in general, which is the biggest name gets the most people.
And they have to do that because the. At the level of which they're operating financially.
But I'm just glad it's also someone good.
I agree with you.
I think they've come to a really fascinating decision here.
And you made a really good point last week when we were talking about Skydance where you were saying that $1 billion ain't what it used to be.
And, like, these movies have to be as big as possible because the budgets for these movies are bigger than they've ever been.
The amount of money that was laid out just to acquire the rights to Bond from the Broccoli family was so enormous that. Mm-hmm.
It doesn't have to be, like, a cute $600 million movie.
It has to be a billion dollar movie.
It has to be a $2 billion movie.
And so one of the ways to kind of allow for that possibility is to raise the ceiling.
It's a tricky thing for me.
I don't want to yuck anybody's yum about Pattinson as Bond, but I've never been a massive Bond fan.
Mm-hmm.
And I do think that there is a ceiling on how good a Bond movie can be.
Even movies like Skyfall and Casino Royale or To Russia With Love or, you know, On Her Majesty's Secret Service.
Those are, like, my favorites.
Mm-hmm.
Mm-hmm.
Those are my favorite Bond movies.
Even those movies. Yeah.
Those movies ain't one battle after another for me.
You know what I mean?
They're not going to be my favorite movie of the year.
Well, sure.
So. But nothing is going to be one battle after another.
That's also. That's Paul Thomas Anderson and Leonardo DiCaprio.
Like, generational actor, generational director.
But we have a movie with a generational actor and a generational director, and they're making a Bond movie.
That's the thing.
I mean, sometimes you got to have a little fun, too.
I agree.
You know, it can't all be En Sandi and, you know, Prisoners.
Even though you love it.
And even though Letterboxd loves En Sandi, which is still just the weirdest stat that is possible on Letterboxd.
But, you know, like, sometimes you want a martini.
Like, there's nothing wrong with that.
And I do think some of it is that it's a little bit. You know, I feel this way every single time there is any sort of superhero casting.
I'm just kind of like, okay, if that's how you guys want to spend your time, you will spend it.
Yeah.
And I will see it and not care that much about it.
What do you think about. This one, I care.
I'm psyched.
Do you think that there is. I think one of the things that immediately goes into the sauce here is,
will Pattinson do now that he's Bond what he had been doing for the last 10 years,
which is kind of bouncing in between indie auteur-driven projects and big franchises?
Now, he has leaned more franchise of late.
I would say The Odyssey, Dune Part 3, and The Batman Part 2 in a kind of succession is. Those are really big movies.
But he's also in the drama and primetime this year.
Yes.
Do you think that he will be able to do that?
Will he be. I don't know.
I'm not sure.
If allowed is the right word.
But if I were Amazon, I would probably institute a scarcity clause for my Bond to make them special
so that they're not everywhere all the time for other projects.
But don't you think that Pattinson has the power and the leverage and the role in this deal,
which is coming at the end and being like,
you haven't found anybody else you want.
It's me, but you're going to pay me millions of dollars just to screen test.
And I'm only going to do three movies.
And I can do whatever the hell else that I want.
I think so.
I think that's probably where this nets out.
Where he's going to have more flexibility, get paid more, have more opportunity as Bond relative to if Jack Loudon had gotten the part.
Or Jack Loudon might have gotten tied down for five movies or seven movies.
Maybe Pattinson has more flexibility within that agreement.
But it's tricky because they need it to work.
And so if. Let's say Robert Pattinson does a movie like the drama with a very thorny plot twist or plot premise.
And it doesn't turn out so great.
And then does that, could that sourness
the robert pattinson movie star persona and then meaningfully harm james bond i'm not saying that's
going to happen but like it is the it's one of those things where it's that's sort of why you
cast daisy ridley is like we've kind of got you locked down here for 10 years and we need you for
10 years to see through right this 10 billion dollar operation that we're running but on the
flip side when you cast daisy ridley you make three mediocre to bad movies and then daisy ridley
is not really anything in anything of note no one attaches to her and then she winds up being
the wife in ebenezer and singing a song to everyone which was the real low point of this
entire movie going weekend for me we'll get there so you know it's it's the flip side people don't
bring any uh negative attachment but they also don't bring any positive attachment i would like
to read you timothy chalamet's uh filmography since 2021 which is when dutton came out yeah
okay so in 2021 we
had dune and obviously covid so this was all a little bit tricky but that was also
the year of the french dispatch and don't look up uh 2022 bones and all 2023 wonka 2024 dune part
two and a complete unknown 2025 marty supreme 2026 dune part three my man is is the lead of a
three-part franchise and is also managing to do some other things he's now timothy is rare but
so is pattinson the only thing i would note about that is that only one of those dune movies was
guaranteed to happen it was likely that two would happen but it was not guaranteed when they were
making it and three two needed to really work for three to happen whereas with bond if you're
getting anything less than three movies from pattinson that's not a great choice ultimately
i think yeah um i think you're trying to create some long-term viability here with this new
investment that you've made but it's a fair point i mean the way that the the way that major star
is or navigating their careers is way more interesting than it was 10 years ago because
they're using ip but they're not defined by it like you're not chris evans anymore where you're
kind of stuck as captain america you do have more flexibility the pattinson thing is i just have a
little resistance to it because he was the most daring of all the stars he was the person who was
like yeah out of the shoot coming out of twilight david cronenberg the safties claire denis robert
eggers like he he was willing to push at the first
doing prime time willing to push it the furthest of everyone so i just want to make sure and he
but he still also did odyssey and dune and now two batmans within that so he can do it all and
also honestly there is like a little bit of dick swinging in the coming in at the last minute being
like no no no you guys think that you're bond i'm james bond and i appreciate that and i think that
that in his own way is like part of the energy part of the way he's been shaping his career and
i think he can bring it to bond and every
thing else i'll be very curious to see the real timeline of when he was approached yeah when when
was he when it was at first suggested to him did he ask for it i mean everyone will probably be
very circumspect about all those things out of respect for honestly shout out to nick holt you
know seems like such a good dude and he just keeps finishing in second maybe third we don't even
really know um i feel i feel bad for him he would i don't think he would have been a great bond
yeah um but that's a tough scene jack loudon i guess is now signed up for
another two years i don't think he's going to be a great bond i don't think he's going to be a great bond
two seasons of slow horses plus a new apple tv show also released this morning yeah just just in
case not just one more but two more seasons of slow horses like i'm i'm happy for him and i'm
sorry for all of the all of the straight men who really believed in jack loudon for slow horses it
was all the straight men and juliet lipman and i he's great and i he he will continue to be great
on slow horses and apparently as mr darcy in less than a month joshua connor he'll be fine he's great
he's a slow horse and i'm happy for him and i'm sorry for all of the all of the straight men who
special flower yeah that would have been an odd choice yeah there is something there was something
intriguing to me sure about the zag there i wasn't opposed to that idea i wasn't either and i think
they could make an interesting one but i sort of think that you know denia and pattinson will make
like a very mean very slick james bond and i'm in i'm into that yes it's time for it and josh
o'connor can't be mean bless him there's something very weird about james bond in 2026 that i want
to see the craig films worked very hard to modernize the character they gave him a trauma
backstory they created this kind of extended world where characters would come back into films after
being absent from the previous films they were it was treated more like marvel than it was like
james bond where you know the james bond films before that are just sort of like here's an
adventure in a bad guy here's an adventure in a bad guy maybe a villain would recur but you
wouldn't really think about james bond's psychology they were procedurals yes um
the critic mark ash had a very interesting note about bond in the 21st
century which is that bond historically was sort of like amusingly responsive to modern fads so
you'd find a bond film in the 70s and he'd be skiing or one in the 60s and he'd be scuba diving
in 2006 bond plays texas hold'em there are all these things that are sort of like
pop cultural recreational artifacts that then are like shot through the bond lens in 2026 we
don't really do anything mark noted we just sort of look at our phones you think yeah you think
he's going to be like a hacker now oh well i don't know because they already did that they
already did the internet with the brosnan films right the internet was something that was like
in the culture that they managed to wend into the bond film so like what is the character
of 2026 culture so like we already did trauma backstory right so what's left like how can we
define it i mean i they also in skyfall specifically did some end of empire stuff
um but one hopes or i hope that they lean into that um and i think denise probably has some very
interesting ideas about that as a canadian well there's something so funny about bond always
battling insane billionaires but bond being an amazon mgm property yeah it's just the the
wonderful convergences and how critical or not critical could this franchise be around that idea
because when we think of who the villains of our movies are now it's often tech billionaires so
i don't know it's it's a fun thing um here's a serious question for you will bond be woke
woke 3.0 dark woke or zag back to evil womanizing
maga cab i i mean i don't think that he from just a stylistic perspective he can be maga
just like aesthetically we're going with some different looks there i haven't really seen
anyone in any maga people in a tux that fits yeah uh even when the new york when new york
magazine did that whole like the young people are maga now like those people didn't really
pose for that shoot no because i require an actual taylor um he also doesn't live in
america of course yeah exactly he lives in england so maybe there will be some you know
maga characters that they're dealing with it would be funny if the maga guys are the bad guys that
would be very funny um he could be womanizing and i definitely think that he will be um
of ambiguous morals you know and that will be the the animating much like in dune of like is this
person actually doing any good or is this the the you know is the anti-hero actually just the villain
uh which i think is a really good idea i think it's a really good idea i think it's a really good
idea i think is the right reading of james bond and mi6 and governments have you really done that
before no not even in skyfall had that obviously where he's sort of been the story's sort of been
flipped on him and he's been framed yeah as the villain and if you looked at his story through a
certain lens right you can say well ethan is you know he's an international operative who's breaking
the law and killing people of course he's he's the bad guy bond i don't know if he ever quite got to
that place it was more about i felt like he was like he was like he was like he was like he was
more about kind of craig's like guilt and sense of loss than it was that he was committing atrocities
right it was personal rather than like on a state level and some and the imagery especially when he
is like running through london to try to save um the the ray fines m i guess um yeah um that
the implication of what the uk was and what is he fighting for and but not really like what has
the uk and the british empire done
and when this create this character was created was like a very very different uk than the one
we have now and a very different understanding of it's a it's consequences well a different
understanding at least uh according to the authors of the bond scripts so and i think a lot of that
is sam andy's being the filmmaker behind that and having a real perspective on that kind of story so
denny being someone who is usually i would say more uh ethereal and theoretical about a lot of
his ideas being kind of fused to this very straightforward muscular well grindhouse
kind of story is really interesting i mean sicario true it's just sicario that'd be great
it's like that would be if you could bring that energy bond i'm i'm yeah i'm in i know if he that
that that is a very specific i mean there's a lot of dark energy in um the prisoner sicario
enemy period of his career that he has kind of abandoned uh-huh and
that would be fascinating yeah to brace us with that um let's talk about villains okay because i
think this is important and and the craig films did something really did something really interesting
where they just kept casting major oscar winners as the villains yes you had javier bardem you had
christophe waltz you had rami malik real like recognizable um uh you had matthew all mark as
in there as well at a certain point like you had really memorable character actors who
were heavyweights so i wrote down a few names for people that i think would be entertaining and the
sort of the cohort
of those other actors
who had been cast
in the Craig films
which is Mahershala Ali.
Now, here's my thought.
Yeah.
See, the point about
like Maga
and like Felix Leiter,
maybe Mahershala slides in
as Felix.
Oh, okay.
But then he's representing
the American perspective.
Okay.
And he seems to be working
with MI6
but actually
is a double agent.
But so he's not like actually
Bond villain,
psychotic, evil.
He's strategic.
Yeah, because you can't
actually cast Mahershala.
Mahershala is too empathetic.
But this is what I like
about this.
It would be really surprising.
But he's still,
he's doing a job
and it's about competence
rather than like,
you know, a lair and a cat.
But I want there to be
some vengeance there.
Yeah, okay.
His wife was killed
outside the British embassy
because of Bond's fumbling.
Okay.
Something like that.
But what I want,
I do want,
if we're going to bring
these heavyweight actors
and writers and directors
into the movie,
I don't want it to then
just be like,
I don't want to defame
any actor.
Just be like,
it's just some guy
who has a funny looking face
and he's a bad guy.
You don't want like the
where did they find
these guys all stars.
Yes.
Yeah.
I want like a real,
I want a stud.
Yeah.
You know,
I want somebody really great.
Completely agree with you.
On the flip side,
it would be extremely funny
if they cast Callum Turner
as a bad guy.
I don't,
he doesn't seem like
he has enough of a sense
of humor to do that.
I think he's probably
the most bruised
of anyone right now.
You think so?
Yeah.
I mean,
because I feel for Dua Lipa.
I feel,
I feel Dua Lipa
wherever I go.
I must tell you,
they're going to be fine.
They're going to be fine.
But I like,
that was just,
he was out in front
and then just absolutely fell,
you know,
like did it to himself.
He got his head cut off.
And.
Yeah,
we saw,
we all saw One Night Only.
Yeah.
And there's,
and well,
you and I saw it
and no one else saw it.
So it's the double whammy of it.
He was not good in it.
And.
Why was he wearing a polo shirt
throughout that movie?
What was going on there?
I thought he looked cute.
I thought the running
really needed some work.
The running when I was like,
uh oh,
Callum,
you know,
this is just,
you gotta,
you gotta tuck those arms in.
But I thought he was very cute.
I still like looking at him
and I didn't mind the polo shirt,
but that's gone.
And like,
what else does he have?
His,
he came to fame
as Dua Lipa's husband
and the guy
who will probably be
the next James Bond
until he was not
the next James Bond.
So.
It's a tough beat.
You know,
I think it would be great
if he were the villain.
You gotta,
you gotta pick yourself back up.
Okay,
I have another idea for the villain.
Yeah.
Gwyneth Paltrow.
Really funny.
Really,
really good.
But she's playing Gwyneth Paltrow.
Um,
okay,
great.
And it's,
and then,
MI6 versus Goop.
Okay,
and so the podcast
is bringing down the world.
Should Bond have a podcast?
No.
Oh my God.
He should not.
He should not have a podcast.
What?
Double a pod.
What are you kidding me?
Oh my God.
No.
I'll do it with him.
That's really,
I'll teach him how to do it.
That's really nice.
I'll teach him about
banter,
teach him about
setting up the news.
I don't think Robert Pattinson
needs lessons from you
on banter
or how to do any sort of,
certainly social content.
You'd be surprised.
No.
Wait till you hear this latest
Ado interview.
I believe in that.
But let me just tell you,
Robert Pattinson
is logged on
every single real
A plus stuff
from my guy.
He's logged on?
What do you mean?
He's on the internet?
Well,
I do think that he's on the internet
because he just,
he betrays just like
a tremendous amount
of gossip knowledge.
Oh,
okay.
And so,
I don't know.
Are you being paid
by Robert Pattinson?
No.
This is a startlingly
pro-Pattinson perspective.
This is for free.
Listen,
check the logs,
okay?
Check the logs.
Who are you pointing at?
I have come out of every,
to the booth,
to Jack and Lucas,
who I can see
with Justin Delighting.
Do you guys have logs
back there of every episode?
Yeah, of course.
Like the great scrolls?
Yes.
Yes, okay.
Unroll the scrolls.
I am,
every performance this year,
every performance,
listen,
this is my guy.
This has been,
he is.
So can you be trusted
in your opinions on this matter?
Sure,
because we're asking,
what do you,
James Bond fan
and Robert Pattinson fan
and Denis Villeneuve fan,
think of the fact
that the three things
are being united?
And I say,
great.
Any thoughts on villains?
What kind of villain
do you want to see?
I mean,
I don't want a podcast
to be involved
in any way,
shape, or form.
I think the Gwyneth thing
is funny,
and I think she would be good
at it,
but maybe not as herself.
I mean,
I don't want it
to feel small and silly.
I do want them
to work on
a bigger scale,
and
I keep talking about
like that kind of
end of empire,
but like big thematic issues.
Like,
I mean,
this should be like
at an international
intrigue level
and not at a,
you know,
oh no,
someone,
another agent
hurt my feelings,
and so now we gotta
track down a,
you know,
a diamond or whatever
and frame them.
Yeah,
that's a tricky,
it's a challenge
because this movie
is obviously gonna be
very big in terms of
scope, scale, budget.
It has to be,
because of the property
that it is,
but you don't wanna go
too big too soon
because you're doing
a series here,
so you have to be able
to elevate inside of it,
so it's always,
it's always fascinating.
One of the reasons
why Casino Royale
was so great
was because
you had
a remarkable
opening set piece,
and then
a lot of it
is scaled down.
It's Le Chiffre
and the poker
and a lot of stuff
that was,
that felt classical.
Yeah.
You know,
that felt like
old school Bond.
And then Betrayal
in Venice.
That's right.
Yeah.
Yeah.
What about
Yahya Abdul-Mateen?
I like him a lot.
Yeah.
Okay.
I,
I feel like
he has never gotten
a fair shake
at a real
franchise thing.
Totally agree.
Where he was
the bad guy
in Aquaman.
He was Wonder Man,
which apparently
was a very good show
that I never watched,
but was canceled.
He is in the upcoming
Cliff Booth.
Mm-hmm.
Obviously,
he was wonderful
on,
oh my God,
the DC Watchmen.
Mm-hmm.
He was really good
on Watchmen.
But he never has had
the like prime 1A part.
So casting him as a villain
in a movie like this
also feels like
it's a little,
I don't know.
It's like not enough
of a glow up
for what I think
he's worthy of.
But I don't know.
They got,
they got to hit this too.
This is another thing
because Bond villains
are iconic.
Just as iconic
as Bond women.
Mm-hmm.
Now,
Denis did work with
Robert Pattinson
in Dune Part 3.
He did.
He also worked
with Florence Pugh
and Anya Taylor-Joy.
Mm-hmm.
It's right there.
Okay.
I would like to
nominate Debicki.
Wow.
Yeah.
Tenet Redux,
but let them
actually work together.
I haven't even seen
Cliff yet.
Holy shit.
Well, I know,
but I've seen Wicker.
I've seen Tenet.
I'm pro-Tenet.
And they. She's very tall,
as you might say.
That's great.
Tall is good.
She can be climbed.
So I'm pro.
I like Debicki a lot.
Yeah.
On the flip side,
Florence Pugh,
very short.
So, you know.
That'd be a great showdown.
Yeah.
That'd be an interesting
Bond girl fight.
Okay.
Tall versus short.
Do they fight that often?
I hope so.
Okay.
You know who's name
is going to come up?
Yeah.
Indy Navarretti.
Okay.
It's going to come up.
That's fine.
I think that she
does a different thing
in a cutesy way.
We're not going
for cutesy here.
Sid Sweeney?
No.
I mean,
I know her name
will come up,
but no.
What's your problem with her?
Aesthetics.
She would have been
a Bond girl
25 years ago
with her similar stature.
You know,
don't forget Halle Berry
made a Bond movie
after winning an Academy Award.
You know,
it's not like,
it's not disreputable
to be a Bond girl.
Anybody else?
Zendaya's not doing it.
No.
And, you know,
good for her.
I don't know.
We can age up a little bit
if
if Pattinson's
aging up as Bond.
No.
I'm okay.
Has Bond ever been
with a 36-year-old woman?
How long was Anna D'Armas
in the
Let's Bring Her Back?
No, and that was
a fun character.
And that was great.
That was just one amazing scene
in an otherwise
She was entertaining.
Yeah.
Fine.
What's she up to?
She's at a lot of parties.
And
I feel
I don't, I don't know.
I don't know what she's in.
She was
nominated for an Academy Award
for Blonde.
I remember that.
I saw that
film.
And then she was ballerina.
Oh, yeah.
Right?
That didn't go well.
No.
Let's see.
What else now?
Nothing
on her Wikipedia page
after ballerina.
This is what I'm saying.
I feel like she doesn't
have anything going on.
Very strange.
Okay.
We still have to cast
Q and M
and Moneypenny as well.
Oh, wow.
Okay.
There's a lot to come here.
I mean, this is a
this is a storied franchise.
I'm excited.
I hope they do something
really dopey
like Moonraker.
Like, I want them to just
like go to
space.
Okay.
I think that would be great
because Pattinson is
fucking weird.
Yeah.
He's really eccentric.
Are you going to bring
that in?
Probably, but
Are people going to be
mad about that, though?
They're not mad because
nobody saw High Life.
They didn't see The
Lighthouse.
I mean, I don't know if
they're going to make
High Life, James Bond.
That would be awesome.
Wow.
James Bond, High Life 2?
Yeah.
Great.
Claire Denis, the other
Denise, should direct
the second James Bond
film.
That would be
wonderful.
Also, I don't care if
people are mad, so let
him be weird if he wants
to be weird.
You're excited.
I don't think he'll talk
very much, which, yeah,
I don't think this is
going to be a real
snappy performance from
him.
Okay.
I think there will be,
but I could be wrong.
I have another idea for
you.
Yeah.
Geese write the theme
song.
Great.
Now we're fucking
cooking.
Very good geese in
Interview Magazine.
Did you guys read this?
No.
It's just on the
almost entirely about the Mets.
Oh, yeah. I have seen this. It's not Cameron. It's the other band members, right?
Cameron's in it, too.
But they're the Psycho Mets fans, right? Like the drummer and the bassist?
The bassist in particular, Dominic.
And they're asked whether they would accept Pitchfork one-star ratings or 1.0 ratings for the rest of their life in exchange for a Mets World Series.
Would you accept a one-star Apple rating on your podcast for Tennessee Volunteers National Championship?
I deleted Apple Podcasts on my phone like seven years ago, so it doesn't exist to me.
The answer is no.
So, yes, I would.
You would accept it?
Yeah, because it doesn't exist to me.
Okay, great.
I'm happy for all the people, I guess, who listen to Apple Podcasts, but I don't.
I think it's a lot of people.
Okay, that's great. Live your life. But would it matter to me? No, it wouldn't. I would not see it.
Would you do that?
Are you fucking kidding?
For a New York Mets World Series Championship, I would do a lot worse.
I think they're going to be good next year.
I'm not doing this with you again.
Scooble, probably Paul Goldschmidt, Jared Young Platoon. I think we're probably trading for an arm.
If we're pulling out the scrolls again, Amanda, before this year, Sean was like, I think they're going to be really good.
I was like, I don't think so.
Yeah.
Reader, they were not.
I predicted 91 wins this year for the Mets.
How many did they get?
74.
That's less than 91.
That's pretty bad.
Yeah.
I also predicted.
I predicted 7 and 10 for the Jets, and they're currently 2 and 8.
So that's not going well either.
But it's not over yet.
Who do you want for M?
M is the boss.
Yeah.
Gosh.
Tracy Lutz.
Oh, that'd be good.
Yeah.
I mean, I think that.
Actually, you know what?
Yeah.
Carrie Coon.
Oh, wow.
Mean.
Well, I think Tracy.
That'd be a wonderful cue.
That would be cute if they reverse.
Yeah, that's a good idea.
Yeah.
And I assume they can do British accents because, you know, theater.
Money Penny should probably be Amy Poehler.
Callum Turner as Money Penny would be funny.
I accept that.
That would be that would be a good bit.
What if Gay Bond?
There we go.
That is that's the Callum Turner.
Listen, we found it.
Why not?
Queer Bond?
Yes.
That would be that would I Jeff Bezos probably would never allow that to happen.
Just to maximize profits.
But just don't tell him.
It would be wonderful.
If Pattinson brought that to the table, I wouldn't be shocked.
I would not be surprised at all.
Just the vibe.
Just the vibe.
Yeah, it'd be great.
Okay.
Any closing thoughts on this Bond news?
This movie's not coming out for two years.
Okay.
So does it have a date?
Do we have to extend the podcast?
Or are we still doing?
It has a script.
But is it still June 28 right now for when the podcast ends?
Do we want to extend it?
Do we want to extend for this?
You're not that interested?
You're the author of your own fate.
I mean, you know, what do you want to do?
So I'm just, you know, I feel like we're already in June 2028.
I'll take some of the summer off.
So that gets us.
I'll go to Venice.
So that gets us to September.
If this is like a November 28 release, I can hang on for a couple more months.
I don't think it's gonna be that fast.
Okay.
So 29.
I guess two years is I guess two years is achievable.
That seems achievable.
You got to remember that Batman 2 is in the spring of 28.
Right.
So would they stack those two movies next to each other?
I don't know.
Well, I mean, there's spring of 28 and end of 28.
It's very different.
Christmas 2028.
New James Bond film.
I mean, I could see it.
But then I think we got to wait until at least summer 2029.
How old will we be then?
37.
Summer of 2029.
I'll be 47.
That's really old.
It's like that's okay.
So that's right in the corner.
Historically, men in my family go, their hair goes white.
We've talked about this before and you're not going to do anything.
And if it just goes white at 47, like, will I no longer be taken seriously?
Not that I'm taking seriously now, but will everybody be like this old man should be taken outside back and shot?
So you can see a little bit in the part.
A little strinkler.
Yeah.
There's a little bit of strinkler.
There's like a little streak of white.
I'm like a young Ebeneezer.
All going to be white.
But you say, I'm not going to do anything.
You want me to dye it?
Well, I just wouldn't if you you don't have to.
Bill Simmons, like three months ago, was like, you're definitely dyeing your hair.
Not now.
But he was like, you will.
I guarantee.
Yeah.
And I said I wouldn't, but maybe I should.
Yeah.
I don't understand, like, what the opposite.
If you don't want to, if you want to be full white, you know, live your life.
I had a pretty solid conversation with my wife at dinner on Saturday night about.
Um, eyebrow, uh, uh, pencils and like, kind of like what, and she was like, you know, like
I, I, I never thought eyebrow maintenance is something I've never considered in my entire
life.
Yeah.
Obviously I didn't realize for women, it's a different story, but you know, the level
of specificity and detail that she was sharing about strategies around these things.
Total.
It's a huge industry.
Yeah.
I have a great eyebrow person here in Los Angeles.
Also named Amanda.
If you ever want to go.
An eyebrow gal.
Yeah.
So Tracy has the AV man and you have the eyebrow gal.
Yeah.
Wow.
The characters just keep growing.
This world is so beautiful.
I don't know what to do about my hair.
We'll see.
I'm happy.
I'm lucky to have it.
I think, I think it's good that you put it back on the table that you're not saying no
anymore.
I mean, I just don't want to have a head of white hair and be 47 and yelling about James
Bond.
That sounds horrible.
This is kind of the thing.
And listen, first, the plastic surgery discourse and all of this stuff has gotten insane, mostly
because no plastic surgery posters know what they're talking about ever.
It's just a lot of posters like people on the internet.
Yeah.
Being like, well,
this was like an upper bluff for sure.
And I'm like, you, you know, you have no medical training.
You don't know what you're talking about.
They're like the guys who watch football games and they see somebody injure their leg.
And I'm like, that's clearly an MCL tear.
Yeah.
And, and so like the pointing out the work becomes a thing where it's like having any
updates are like a shame, but I don't know.
Am I supposed to just like cut my hair off and wear Talbots now that I'm 42?
What's Talbots?
Thank you.
Thank you for not knowing what it's sort of like nineties Chico.
I don't know what that is.
Chico's?
No one?
Wow.
You are living life.
Privilege.
Okay.
What are Chico's?
I mean, it's just like a, it's a mall brand of like the square jackets that all of your
professor where all of college professors with short hair shop.
I don't mean to stereotype.
Okay.
The wonderful college professors.
Oh, you're talking about like a, just how you have to change like your style when you
cut your hair shorter.
Yeah.
Um, and that's just also, that's like a, what some people at a certain age dress like.
I don't know.
Why can't I just stay myself?
Whatever happened to distinguished gray?
Well, I think distinguished gray turns white.
So that's your issue.
So tough.
So tough.
Uh, well, James Bond, that should be fun.
Okay.
We'll see if we're here for that or not, or if I'm dead.
Uh, would you like to speak about Ebenezer?
If we must.
We must.
It is the number one movie at the box office this weekend.
It made $19 million and it is currently being promoted as the biggest opening ever for a
Christmas Carol live action movie release.
That's on the poster for Ebenezer.
The movie is directed and co-edited by Ty West.
It is written by Nathaniel Halpern.
It stars Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge alongside Rupert Grint, Andrea Risborough, Sam Claffin,
Daisy Ridley, Tramiel Tillman, and Ian McKellen.
The story is as follows.
A ghost story set in Dickens' London following one man's supernatural journey to face his
past, present, and future as he fights for a second chance at redemption.
I thought we could open this conversation by having a little chat about Johnny Depp.
Great.
Great.
The only thing better than talking about a Christmas Carol is Johnny Depp.
We've never talked about Johnny Depp on the show.
You know, there are a couple of reasons for that.
He has not appeared in a studio release since 2018 in Fantastic Beasts The Crimes of Grindelwald.
Your favorite film of 2018.
You were not on the episode in which we discussed that.
That episode was Mallory Rubin and Jason Concepcion.
I remember recording it very well.
Terrible movie.
Amber Heard filed for divorce from Depp in 2016.
Depp sued her.
She sued her after her op-ed in the Washington Post in 2018.
And then they, you know, this really ugly legal battle ensued where accusations kind
of flew in both directions.
And also the subsequent online battle and it became a whole thing.
Yes.
And it became a kind of dark pop culture story for our time.
Eventually the courts ruled in Europe in Depp's favor, more or less.
And then, you know, the people fight about the story to this day.
We're not going to litigate that story.
It was gross in every direction.
Depp, prior to all of this controversy, was an aging movie star who had a couple of very reliable tentpoles.
But I think is maybe slightly misremembered as a bigger star than he actually was.
The Pirates films are, of course, massive.
Yes.
Never seen one.
Is that true?
I've never seen one.
First one's pretty fun.
I'm sure that it was, but I think I was in college at the time.
First two or three are pretty fun.
And, like, I didn't go.
Because just with respect to Keira Knightley was not really in my interest set.
And so I didn't really need to follow it up.
I did like the ride at Disney World when I was seven.
You know, I learned something interesting about this.
I'm just going to share it anyway.
Four of the five Pirates films are based on the ride in part, like a moment on the ride.
The fifth is based on a novel called On Stranger Tides.
It was written in 1987.
And just this weekend, I was in a like a bar distillery called The Obscure, where they
created a whiskey based on On Stranger Tides. It's called On On Stranger Tides.
Stranger Tides Whiskey.
And literally, in explaining the history of this whiskey,
they talked about how Disney did not hold the IP long enough
to produce whiskey.
They didn't do it in time,
so they just jumped on the IP as soon as they could.
That's how valuable the Pirates brand is around the world.
So they're selling this whiskey now.
Anyhow, Johnny Depp.
Pirates of the Caribbean, Alice in Wonderland,
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory.
These movies were huge, right?
This is all kind of in the aftermath of his rise
as Tim Burton's kind of stand-in.
Muse, yeah.
I had a pop quiz question for you.
Okay.
What's the highest-grossing original movie
of Johnny Depp's career?
Edward Scissorhands?
No.
Okay.
It's Rango.
Ah, sure.
Congratulations.
Thank you.
Rango, of course, directed by Gore Verbinski,
who also directed many of the Pirates of the Caribbean movies.
As a performer, you know,
I certainly liked him in the 90s.
I certainly love many of those Tim Burton movies.
I love Ed Wood.
I think,
Sleepy Hollow's pretty fun.
Obviously, Edward Scissorhands, very formative.
He was slowly turning into a self-parodic figure,
I would say,
with, like, his desire to transform
and hide behind makeup
and his outlandish voices and characterizations.
I think he was also,
there was a whole thing where he went broke.
There was a whole spending issue, right?
And managers had to get involved or sue him,
all sorts of stuff.
So he was becoming parodic in his personal life
even before the trial.
And, you know, that latest saga.
So, yeah, sort of like a Brando,
but not as good quality to what was going on with him.
Absolutely.
And I think some of that was a similar thing with Brando,
where he was sort of,
began to believe his own press and love to transform,
but maybe he was doing so in an effort to escape his true self.
And, you know, I think there were some death stories
that were sort of like buying the most expensive bottle of wine in the world,
you know?
Yeah.
And so as a pop cultural figure,
he's just been. kind of at sea for the last eight years,
making mostly European-financed films
that not many people here in the States have seen.
However, there's sort of this counterfactual
that he has never really lost his popularity
amongst a certain generation of movie fans
that are now a little older,
like even maybe even a little older than us.
But because the Pirates movies are so big,
the Burton movies are so big.
And because some people just took his side
in the public battles that he fought in the 2010s.
And so there was this sense going into Ebenezer
that this movie could,
could be very big.
That people were waiting for Depp
to come back to major movie making.
And the movie did fine at the box office.
And I think one of the reasons it did fine
is because it's a pretty boring adaptation
of A Christmas Carol.
A movie that we have seen a dozen times
that is very difficult to evolve.
Because if you're making it period
and you're keeping the one, two, three act structure
very formal in the dynamics of the,
the Dickens story,
there's not really anywhere to go with it.
And so as I was watching the movie,
I was like, okay,
so you guys are just doing it.
There's some cool Ty West flourishes in the film.
Like there's some real style.
You can see he really kind of wishes
this was just an 1800s England set ghost story.
And that if you just let Ty West make a movie like that,
it would have been way more interesting.
But he's kind of having to work within the confines
of what is already like kind of a gloopy saccharine story
with a lot of really familiar story beats.
That unless you absolutely love Johnny Depp,
the movie is just like fine.
It's not like horrible, I guess,
but it's completely negligible in general movie culture.
And it also feels like a movie that was made,
you know, developed 20 years ago
and has nothing to do with whatever's happening
at the movies right now.
I assume you generally agree with this.
Do you feel even worse about it than I do?
Everything about this,
Johnny Depp, A Christmas Carol,
is just one big giant who cares.
And you, you know, in explaining kind of the cultural
place that Ebenezer holds in terms of Johnny Depp's career
and the audience's relationship to Johnny Depp
and the audience's relationship to A Christmas Carol,
you're using a lot of people were wondering this
and we something this.
And I'm like, show me these people.
Show me the we.
Like who could possibly care about Johnny Depp
and or A Christmas Carol this much?
And that's exactly what it is.
This is a very faithful right down to dialogue
and character descriptions, beat for beat retelling
of A Christmas Carol.
A Christmas Carol, a story I just honestly don't care
that much about, starring Johnny Depp in a lot of makeup.
If that sounds up your alley, then, then cool.
Then you, you've got it.
You can go to the movie theaters and see that.
I just am completely baffled.
I've been polling everyone I met this weekend being like,
do you actually care about A Christmas Carol?
You suggested doing A Christmas Carol rankings
for this episode thinking that like, of course,
I've seen all of them.
Sean, I've seen two of them.
Because again, as you noted, the story is very formulaic.
Okay, it's Ebenezer Scrooge.
She doesn't like Christmas.
Ghost of Christmas past, present, future, Tiny Tim.
Like we're out.
Everybody loves Christmas.
Be nice to other people.
I got it.
I don't need to, I don't need to see it again.
That's the story.
So like, and it's made its way into pop culture
where we have the references
and we don't actually need to read,
to live through the text anymore.
Yeah, it's an interesting artifact in general
because, because it's a story,
because of its simplicity structurally,
it maps very neatly onto children's programming.
So you have all of these very memorable adaptations
that have been filtered through Mickey Mouse,
through the Muppets,
through, there was one that I saw as a kid with,
oh my God, Mr. Magoo.
Like their characters,
you can just kind of plug them into the story world
and tell this story.
And it's sort of like baby's first literary fiction.
Yeah.
And I think that's one of the reasons why it recurs.
Now the adult side of it,
I think there's one reason why it recurs.
And it's the same reason that Death has taken the part,
which is that it is a sort of August,
non-Shakespearean role.
Like if you look at the names
who have taken this part over the years,
you've got Alistair Sim,
you've got George C. Scott,
you've got Patrick Stewart,
you've got all of these like.
Just in my informal polling this weekend,
of anyone who actually had seen any of Christmas Carols,
they were like, not even the Alistair Sim.
And I was like, no, I'm not sitting at home
firing up the Alistair Sim of Christmas Carol every year.
Not to spoil anything,
but that movie is really,
really good.
It is, sure.
So I think that's part of it is like,
you watch that movie too and you're like,
oh wow, like the ghost effects that they did in this movie
and the tone, it's like,
and it is almost more like what I think
Ty West wanted his Ebenezer movie to be.
But that movie kind of set the template.
And at that time in the 50s when that movie was made,
there had already been,
there had already been two studio talkie
Christmas Carol movies.
And there had also been like multiple silent versions
of this story.
So for whatever reason, it keeps getting adapted.
There have been over 20 adaptations at length
of this movie.
Just in the last five years,
we had Spirited on Apple,
the Will Ferrell, Ryan Reynolds,
like re-imagination of this world.
And on Netflix,
we had an animated movie called Scrooge.
So this story will not go away.
And yet,
it's not that interesting.
I mean, I was,
as I sat there,
and may I briefly tell the story of where I saw,
where and how I saw Ebenezer.
Do you know?
Do you know this?
So last week in Los Angeles were many events,
including GQ's Men of the Year,
which my husband was heavily involved in.
And so I was invited to the GQ Men of the Year party,
but not until 9.30 p.m.
And which like for me might as well.
You weren't allowed to arrive until 9.30 p.m.?
Yes, my call time, my quote unquote.
Did they wheel you in there in a gurney?
My quote unquote talent arrival time was 9.30 to 9.45 p.m.
That's what it said in red.
I was like, okay, great.
So it's 9.30.
Zach had to be there much earlier.
And I'm just like,
how am I literally,
how am I going to stay awake?
So I was going to try to go to a different screening
that had been scheduled for that night.
It just, it was an hour and a half away.
Kids, I was in charge of the babysitting handoff.
It just like, it wasn't going for us.
So I was having a day.
So I'm like, okay, I got two hours.
I have a babysitter.
I don't have a husband.
I got to stay awake.
What am I going to do?
And I was like, great.
I'm going to go see Ebenezer in my party gear
at the Chinese theater, the TCL6,
because it was close to the party by myself.
So I'm just already.
You're one of the coolest people I've ever met.
I was like, I got to maximize this time, right?
And I have to see this movie
and then I don't have to go this weekend.
You should have done a selfie.
So as you can imagine,
I was like in a great mood, right?
And I was really receptive
to everything that was going on.
And then I had to navigate
the parking situation of the party afterwards.
And you've never seen anywhere angrier than me
when I finally found Zach at the party.
It's okay.
Great party.
So I'm sitting there by myself.
Pretty angry.
I mean, like there are a lot of things
that are going wrong here.
But one of the things that are going wrong is
why is this such a faithful adaptation?
Why has no one besides Bill Murray
updated the basic architecture of this story in any way?
Because at some point, I mean,
the most reductive interpretation of it is like,
you know, the power of Christmas
to let everyone know that you love them,
which I love Christmas.
And that's what everything sticks to.
But that's pretty small.
And it could be about
how like very rich people
need to take more responsibility
for the world that they live in,
which I agree.
And I think that that's. From Skydance.
Yeah.
Well, sure.
That's the problem.
I mean, you know,
when you were talking about James Bond
from Amazon, right?
You know.
But that if you aren't stuck
in this very literal interpretation,
it could at least have some. Psalm?
relevance? I think there have been efforts
to shift it somewhat.
The 1970 version starring
Albert Finney is a musical, for example.
I know that's not your favorite flavor,
but that is a way to kind of shift some of the
story. When it's good, it's good. The movie
Spirited, which I don't think is very successful, but it was very
popular on Apple, the Will Ferrell
Ryan Reynolds movie, does, it sort of
shows you like the back door for how the
spirits of Christmas work, and then
that's the way through it to like a modern set
businessman played by Ryan Reynolds. So there was
an attempt to kind of redefine it. So they're doing like the inside out
but for. Yes, literally.
You know, they tried. They tried
something, and the reason that, one of the reasons why
it keeps getting adapted, of course, is that it's
free IP. That it's something everybody
knows, and everybody is familiar with,
but is recognizable enough that
you could potentially draw new people into it.
I think with this
movie in particular,
the most cynical, but
probably most accurate read
is that this is the exact kind of movie
Johnny Depp needed to make to get
back on this side of the ledger,
which is that this is a story of redemption.
It's a story of a character
who we believe to be
a cold-hearted,
cynical, miserly
shut-in, who doesn't want
anybody to be happy, and hoards everything
for himself. And there are some people who might view
Johnny Depp in that light in 2026.
But if we watch him as the character,
and he's always there, even under the
makeup and the facial expressions and the
ridiculousness and the accent,
by the end of the movie, we get
to see Johnny Depp be transformed
into a person who has received wisdom
and is changing his life and is changing
his perspective on the world, and then we get
to watch him get whitewashed back
into accepted society.
You know, do I think it was like
that exact
button-pushing calculation
from all parties involved around
this project? Maybe.
And that's why this
is the project for him. Now, why this
project was made otherwise?
I don't know. It was there. It was a
available. Something had to be made, I guess.
As you and I
have watched a bunch of these movies in the last
10 days or so,
it became clear that, like, actually this project
that I set out for us was a terrible idea
because it's the same story over
and over again. There is no differentiation in
the movie. So, you know, you're watching the
35 version, and then you're watching the
83 version, and then you're watching the
92 version, and you're like,
this is all the same.
You know? And we just went through
this with Sense and Sensibility,
and there have been two film
adaptations of that story and a couple of miniseries
adaptations, and we were like, wow, I'm not even
sure if we needed this one. How could
really meaningfully shift it? There are 20
Christmas carols! Well, can I tell you something?
At least they're wearing different dresses.
There is, because there are
character descriptions of the ghosts, and so
the ghosts are rendered quite faithfully.
And how you make a guy
with, like, a wreath on his head
look like a guy with a wreath on his head
is very different. It's different from movie to movie.
Well, I like this about the Ebenezer movie. Sure!
Yeah, well, that's Tramiel Tillman, so. No, no, well, I
also like Ghost of Christmas Past,
like, the way that, you know,
you gently negged
the idea of what
Andrea Risborough was doing here,
but I thought what she was. I wish the movie was more. That was the
Ty West-iest part of the movie, was Ghost of Christmas
Past, the way that her character was drawn,
the attempt to make that really actually scary.
Unfortunately, you get a little bit too stuck in
remembrances of Ebenezer falling in love with a
hot young woman, and then pretending he doesn't care
about her.
Even though he does. Yeah.
He just wants to work late, you know? He's really
focused. Well, I kind of relate to that.
Um. I wonder if I'll ever be
visited by Ghosts of
Christmas Past, Present, and Future. What do you think?
Um. I mean, I would watch that version of it. You can
make a podcast version of
A Christmas Carol, and that's. That is one context in which a podcast
I'm okay with it. Who would be the three guests who would
represent the Ghosts of Christmas Past,
Present, and Future? Okay.
So, Past, to a time
when you were happier,
and you. Um. Well, that's. Let's see.
I mean, Chris is gonna be one of them.
Mm-hmm. Is
C.R. Past,
Letts is Present,
and
then Future never
really has a face. So. Well, yes, they do.
Yeah.
Uh. Did you like any of these adaptations?
Um. I like a Muppet Christmas Carol.
You know, I'm not made of stone.
Yeah, that's. I've talked about that movie
many times in the past. It's my wife's
favorite Christmas movie, and so we watch it
every Christmas morning. And so I didn't re-watch
it for this project.
I've seen it many times. In fact, we saw it
in theaters with my daughter at the New Beverly
two years ago. Oh, that's nice. On Christmas?
No, I think it was maybe, like, December
20th, but it was very close.
And, obviously, that movie is. is full of Muppets. But it is surprisingly
faithful. Michael Caine, arguably. arguably the great Scrooge.
You know, I think him and Alistair Simm
are kind of in this knife fight for who
gets ownership of that, the title of
the best one. And that one does have songs as well.
Um, I love that one quite a bit.
I did. I really did like watching
1951's Scrooge, again. The Brian Desmond
Hearst version with Alistair Simm. I do think that that movie
is legitimately good. It's good. It is familiar.
It is what you're describing. It is the same,
you know, the trilogy of ghosts, and
Ebenezer realizing the
error of his ways. But it's very
well-crafted. Um. And it is also. I watched chronologically.
Mm-hmm. So, you watched
to. The 35 and the
38 are very faithful,
but pretty modest.
I think they're, like, 65 minutes.
Yes. And you're seeing the same
thing over and over again at, you know,
35 and 30. 1935 and
1938 level. It's odd that they were both
made in such close. like,
in such close succession. Yeah.
I don't know. Um, they're very similar.
And then. So, you get to
Scrooge 1951, and it, like, does
come alive. And you're like, oh, this is an actual. This is a real
old-timey film version
of this story. Yeah. And you just feel like the
film craft that has come along in that period
is recognizable. Um, I found
Scrooge 1970 to be very strange,
the musical version. Yeah. Um. It is directed by Ronald Neame, who directed
quite a few very big and memorable
movies in the 1970s, but
the songs are not great. And Albert Finney, I just think, is too
young. Like, he. Scrooge is supposed to be
in his 70s, right?
I don't know. I don't. You know, life
expectancy in Victorian England, very different.
That's a good point. Yeah.
Maybe he wasn't supposed to. Maybe he was. I mean. Maybe he was 36. You know, like, 25 was the new
50, then, so. Right. Ebenezer is the new 36.
Um. Have you seen the Robert Zemeckis. I watched it for this. And that's
almost when I quit the podcast.
Okay. Definitely when I almost sent you some. You're gonna miss out on James Bond in 2028.
Yeah. And you dying your hair.
Um. That was almost when I, A, quit the podcast,
B, left, like, very
angry Letterboxd reviews that were just like,
I hate you, Sean, and C,
I didn't do it because
I didn't think that. I didn't think out of
it would make sense to people out of context.
You were gonna write a Letterboxd review addressed
to me? Yeah. Um. And then. My power. And it's also
when I stopped. I was like, this is no longer a
good use of my time. I've seen
like seven of Christmas Carols, and I've seen
the Robert Zemeckis
adaptation, which is in the
Polar Express zone. Polar Express being one
of the most evil movies I've
ever let my children watch multiple times
over Christmas break because I can't
do it anymore. Same animation style. Yeah.
The motion capture animation style. Yeah. Jim Carrey
in that film plays Ebenezer Scrooge as well
as all three of the ghosts.
Um. And then. Very, very bad movie. And Colin
Firth plays. He's not Cratchit. He's the nephew.
Yes. And they just. It's
stop-motion Colin Firth.
Yeah. You have a problem with that?
Um. Yeah, I think
that if I were Colin Firth, I would want some more distance
from what was going on here.
But I guess he got a paycheck.
There was, um. I thought the. I watched some of the Patrick
Stewart one on YouTube, which is the only place I could find it
because I think it was originally a TNT
film. And a lot of these movies are TV
movies. They're not theatrically released. The George C.
Scott one, I think, was also a TV movie. Yes. It has
that vibe. Um. And you can feel it.
Yeah. You know? And it's like, George C. Scott,
and Patrick Stewart, two of them were commanding
movie actors of the last
hundred years. But, like,
they're surrounded by
a bit of a janky production. Um. The one that I haven't seen that I would like to
try to see, although I probably never will now that I've seen
all these hours of The Christmas Carol, is
Guy Pearce appeared in one. Ooh!
He appeared in a three. Like a miniseries
version on FX
that looks pretty cool. It only came out
like in 2022, I think? Okay. Or maybe
2019? I can't remember. 2019.
Um. But Guy Pearce is an. an interesting idea for Ebeneezer. And there's a. It had a really good cast, as I recall. Yeah.
Um. That was the one that I. I didn't get a chance to look at before this.
I'm just looking a lot of promo photos of him
like, in a waistcoat.
Like, looking concerned
and a little mad. Well, sure.
Always. But he's only showing one side.
So, clearly, Guy Pearce thinks that his right side
is his good side because he's just looking
like this in every single promo photo
that I'm seeing. Uh, Andy Serkis was the ghost
of Christmas past. Stephen Graham
played Marley. And Joe Allen was
Bob Cratchit. Wow.
Pretty. Pretty nice collection
of casts. Uh. Yeah.
Do we need to rank them?
I'll just say. I rank them. A Muppet Christmas Carol, yes.
Scrooge from 51.
Yeah. I would recommend. I would
probably say 38 after
that, a Christmas Carol.
Okay. It was fine.
It's fine. It's solid. You see
the ghosts, sort of.
After that, it's like, it doesn't really matter.
Patrick Stewart's worth checking out.
Bill Murray Christmas special.
Please watch Sofia Coppola's Bill Murray Christmas special on Netflix instead of Scrooged.
We should, maybe we'll just wrap it with that.
Scrooged is probably the most famous to our generation.
The 1988 Bill Murray movie that you're referring to, directed by Richard Donner.
I've never been a fan of that movie.
I think it's a very mean and odd movie.
Yeah.
And I just don't really care about TV executives in the 80s that much,
especially as they're programming a Christmas Carol content.
So I was like, I thought I got away from it.
And now I just have to watch more of it.
Yeah, it is kind of in league with A Christmas Story, National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation.
Like for that generation, it is one of the most, I don't know about beloved,
one of the most seen and revisited Christmas movies of that time.
But I've always thought it was kind of unsuccessful.
No, A Very Murray Christmas.
Okay.
That's what you can do.
Okay.
All right.
We're going to break down The Very Thorny Fjord right after this break.
This episode is brought to you by Amazon Prime.
We all know the holidays never quite go to plan.
There's always a last minute white elephant,
friends popping over a family dinner that somehow turns into a neighborhood potluck.
And suddenly you need more decorations,
one more gift and something everyone can agree to watch.
But hear me out.
Those unexpected moments are often the ones we cherish most.
And Prime helps make them happen with fast,
reliable delivery and plenty of movies,
shows and live sports to stream together.
Go to amazon.com slash prime to learn more.
Delivering joy.
It's on Prime.
This episode is brought to you by NOS Energy.
Introducing new NOS Energy Grand Prix Guava.
For those that want to be fueled up and fired up with 100-mile-an-hour tropical tasting power.
Ignite your taste.
Start your engine.
Shift your flavor to high gear with new NOS Energy Grand Prix Guava.
Hit the street.
Grab a can and get after it.
Every ounce of dirt, sweat, and gears, every checkered flag and trophy raised,
every lap, every race, every hard-fought place.
They're all jammed inside every can of NOS Energy.
High-performance energy for burning the mid-air.
Do not oil in the garage and pedal to the metal.
Human horsepower for the streets.
Go ahead.
Crack open a can of NOS Energy and get after it.
Okay, Fjord.
We saw it at the Cannes Film Festival in May.
Together.
We just saw it together.
That's right.
One of the few movies that we saw together.
Especially that it wasn't a gala, right?
It was just a press screening.
Yes.
And before the festival, I said,
this kind of smells like the Palme d'Or.
And then I completely backed off that prediction.
Well, first, you paused outside of the screening to get your tweet off.
Oh, yeah.
About how you thought it was going to win.
And then when it came time to record the podcast, you F1'd and you said it was going to be a minotaur.
And you were wrong.
I was wrong.
This film is written and directed by Christian Mongeau.
It is based very loosely on the Bodnaru case,
a Pentecostal Christian couple living in Norway with their five children.
Their eldest daughter told some school staff that they had been spanked at home
in the Norway's child protection area.
An agency intervened in the state emergency,
removed all five children, including a baby,
over concerns regarding corporal punishment and religious discipline.
So that story, this is not a strict adaptation of that real-life case,
but it is clearly inspired by it.
The movie stars Sebastian Stan and Renata Reinsva.
Mongeau, I think one of the reasons why I came in thinking that this movie
was going to have a certain kind of weight at the festival
is because he is exactly what the festival really favors.
He's. He had already won a Palme in 2007 for four months, three weeks, and two days.
Terribly harrowing movie.
Really very upsetting.
And he is probably the most renowned Romanian filmmaker ever.
His work is usually about contemporary society
and these kind of like moral fissures in society
and why those things are happening inside of families or inside of people of faith.
And most of his films are set either during or in the aftermath of. of Ceausescu's reign in communist Romania.
And this is his first movie that is set outside that world.
It's set in Norway, a region you have always admired.
Never been to Norway.
And I don't see this movie really as radically different
from Beyond the Hills or RMN or other movies that he has made,
but the setting is so dramatically different.
And some of the dramatic moves. that he likes to make in his movies. feel different this time around.
Some of it is because you've got well-known Western movie stars.
Some of it is because he's applying, say, like,
courtroom dynamics to his stories
instead of these kind of huddled and shaded moral tales
that he tells in Romania.
But this movie has become a bit of a. I don't know.
I wouldn't. It's not a pipe bomb per se,
but it's a movie people kind of either really, really like or really hate.
Yeah.
And we both. We both really liked it coming out of Cannes.
And I would say I'm not surprised by the reaction to it,
but I think it is worthy of some dissection because of that.
I think we really liked it because it's really effective.
It gets under your skin.
And you are arguing with it as soon. from the moment you're watching it,
and you keep thinking about how you feel about it
and how you're supposed to feel about it.
And what does Manju think he's making you feel?
And what is he trying to say, by the way,
that he makes you feel?
It's very, very. It pokes you in the eye, this movie, a lot.
And I rewatched it last night
and was still. Couldn't believe at the reaction
and the outrage and the involvement that I felt. Same. watching certain parts of this film.
And so getting that kind of reaction,
getting, you know, lodged in your brain in that way
is evidence of, like, great filmmaking.
It's very involving, dramatic storytelling.
And there are. I think some viewers have. have been annoyed by
what could be uncharitably described
as the trickery of the storytelling.
Because there's information that is withheld.
There are sequences that we would like to have seen
in the telling of the story
because of the specifics of the story
that he refuses to show us.
That may be in an attempt to both sides things.
I think it is more to sort of build the mystery of truth
around some of these events
and think more about how structures operate
versus what the truth of sequences are.
But, you know, it operates as this very taut family drama
about immigration.
And at first,
it doesn't really seem like
what it's going to be.
It feels like it's going to be
an assimilation drama of some kind
about this family.
You've got a Romanian man
played by Sebastian Stan
who has married a Norwegian woman.
They've been living in Romania.
They've been raising their five children.
They're raising them
in a traditional Romanian society.
Very Christian, conservative.
They have very hardline values.
But they seem like. But none of the values
are, like, enumerated
or said specifically, to your point.
about what Mungiu tells you
and what he withholds.
And so, like, we learned
that the Renata Reinsvig character
was in Romania as a missionary.
So, and they have moved back
to be with her mother.
And, because her mother's going to help
take care of their five children.
And they belong to a church here.
But, like, the name of the church,
the type of what they're,
you know, how they actually live,
what the rules are every day
is not, you know,
stated.
It's usually, it comes out
in drips and drabs,
usually from discussion
and gawking from other people.
So, there's already, like,
a second and third, you know,
remove from what you know
about these people.
Yeah, even in reading
about the real-life case,
the idea that that family
was Pentecostal,
that's not a word that is uttered,
I don't think, in Fjord.
You know, we don't have
that level of specificity
about how they live their lives.
The Stan character
gets a job as an engineer
in sort of, like,
kind of an IT role
in one of the. in one of the agencies
in Norway.
Renata Reinsvist's character
is sort of, like,
an elder caregiver
who looks after people
near the end of their life
in a hospital.
And they have these five kids.
Two of these kids
go to a local school
and they attempt to integrate
into the modern society.
And it's very clear
from the moment
that they arrive at that school
that there's a different level
of engagement
with how the kids are treated
and what the expectations
of them are.
Kids are not supposed
to practice
or pray in school
in Norway.
There's not supposed to be
this sort of demonstration
of religion
the way that there was
in Romania.
That's a pretty dramatic thing.
You see multiple times
throughout the film
Stan's character
encouraging his children
to pray and think
about the gospel
and telling them stories
of the Bible
and that this is very different.
The movie starts
to take shape
when
one of. the eldest daughter
is noticed
to have some bruising
on her body
during a P.E. class
in this country.
She calls
into question
whether or not
the children are being abused
and they're called in
to speak to
child protection services
along with representatives
from the school
and they're interviewed
without the parents
without any other
police or lawyers
or anything like that
and that conversation
is the incident
through which
the rest of the film
is filtered.
But we only see
some of it.
Yeah.
We don't see all of it
and there's also
it's noted
later on in the movie
that that conversation
is not recorded
it's not videotaped
and so
how much can you
trust, understand
and believe children
in these circumstances
is a huge hinge point
of the movie.
When I was a kid
there was an HBO movie
I forget the name of it
it was about the
McMartin trial
it was about a family
that ran a
like a nursery school
daycare
where the owners
of it were
accused of
horrible
molestation charges
and they were
And then it was revealed that there was coercion
from the psychologists
who were interviewing
the children
which led to these people
being falsely accused
of all these terrible crimes
it's a fascinating
HBO original movie
and I thought the movie
was going to like
start to go in that
sort of direction
right
but it doesn't
it instead tries to like
walk this very narrow
balance beam
between
there's flaws
within all people
yeah
and
we dare you to pick a side
I think in this movie
when you were watching it
a second time
having known how
the story plays out
how did you think
about the way
that that information
was being presented to us
I did find myself
feeling that
there was more
a thumb
the thumb was
more on one side
of the scale
than the other
and maybe again
that's just because
what I was reacting to
but that this film
definitely has
points of views
of who is behaving well
and who is not behaving well
like this
Munju has opinions
you know
and what you know
and how people are portrayed
and how people are shot
and when they show up
in a frame
like very clearly
is communicated
of here is who
is trustworthy
and here is
who's not trustworthy
and ultimately
what became clear to me
I mean
this movie is an indictment
of ideology
on both sides
and basically
the idea that
like
ideology
does take on
like a system
that crushes
any sort of
actual human connection
so the people
who actually
make any sort of
human connection
with any other person
in the movie
are the quote unquote
good guys
in this film
and they are also
like very few
and far between
because most people
are stuck within
one system
or the other
I mean I think
you can make the case
that it's literally
only Mia
the couple's neighbor
and a lawyer
who eventually
becomes a part of their
case
and her father
who is ill
and you know
eventually becomes
an ally of sorts
to the family
on rewatch
the Renata Reinsvig
character to me
and she I mean
she is
the Norwegian character
who
then moves to Romania
and becomes part
of this family
I think always
has been a part
of this religion
she's also
often being
the actual translator
for the Sebastian
Stan character
because
there are language issues
there's
Norwegian
English
and Romanian
and that's part of
the initial
interview
the inciting
not the inciting incident
but the inciting
scene that we see
these two Romanian kids
who were interviewed
who don't speak
Norwegian
and so are being
interviewed in English
right and are asking
within what we do see
for you know
definitions
of words like
hit
slap
you know
what are the semantics
what are the cultural
associations
of these actual words
so
Renata Reinsba
is a
the mother character
is
not without agency
but it's like
a little more
quite stuck
in the middle
and she makes
relationships
with the Mia character
and the father
the father-in-law
next door
and then the teens
right
because
the teens
there is
an underlying
this is a story
about how
the adults
whether
themselves
or through
their various systems
are handling the kids
but then you do get
something
you do get the story
of the kids
themselves
and they
manage to make
a connection
and to befriend
each other
without much
complication
even though
even as the
the two children
who are the subject
of the abuse
investigation
do still
seem to hold
some of their
religious
beliefs
and upbringing
and they talk about
you know
they're making plans
with the neighbor
next door
and they keep talking
about what will be
baptized
and blah blah blah
they
whether it's because
of their
you know
upbringing
or they're just kids
they hold tight
to some aspects
of their culture
but they also
somehow just
there's nothing
holding them back
from being able
to befriend
the person next door
yeah I mean
there's a really
important dynamic
in the film
which is that
the neighbor
that you're talking
about Nora
is
clearly in love
with Elia
the younger
daughter of Stan
and Ryan's
of his characters
and it
essentially tells us
that they're both gay
and they're
sort of have this
burgeoning love affair
but Elia
because of her faith
is sort of struggling
with this
and this is sort of
happening underneath
this plot line
about these kind of
warring adults
right
and you could say
somewhat cynically
well this is like
it's up to the future
to sort out these problems
that we find it
impossible to sort out
because I think the thing
that you were saying earlier
is really important
which is that
once you let
ideology get steeped
inside of systems
then it disallows
for not just empathy
but nuance
and so there's really
no nuance
in the explication
of this story
and so
the child protective services
in Norway
is not favorably
portrayed in this movie
at all
it is horrifying
and
there's
if you read a bit
about this
you can see that
since some of these cases
in the 2010s
that they have evolved
some of these systems
and that this also does feel
to your point about
the thumb on the scale
like it is pitched
pretty negatively
against Norway
yeah
and
I do remember
we walked out of the movie
and Ken you said to me
you were like
that was really good
and also seems like
Christian Mungu
just like had a bad vacation
in Norway
it does feel that way
if you've ever
you know
been involved with
the Scandinavian peoples
and systems
for extended period of time
you may have
a similar perspective
well there is a rigidity
in the culture right
that is reflected
in this movie
it's interesting
because like
you could
shot
framed differently
it didn't have to be this way
the actors for example
that he casted
as the
attorney
operating against
Stan and Ryan's family
and also Gunda
the woman from
Child Protective Services
I mean they are the most
ice king
and ice queen
unsympathetic figures
in recent movie history
and I think that this is
ultimately
why this movie
is coming under fire
is because it's a movie
that is in pursuit
of nuance
and
trying to
find the truth
within this
kind of contorted
world of ideology
but those characters
seem two dimensional
in an otherwise
open space
is this movie
in pursuit of nuance
is this movie
like is it in pursuit
of trying to reveal anything
or is it
showing you
like how
nuance
and
it becomes impossible
Manju is saying that
yeah
and that's the problem
is that he's coming out
and saying that
and he's trying to say
like this is
I'm looking at both sides
that's not really
Manju's Romanian
he's focused more clearly
on his Romanian characters
he may not align
with their conservative
points of view
but he has a kind of empathy
for the struggle
that they find themselves in
as strangers in a strange land
and
part of the reason
why I love this movie
is I think this is an amazing
Sebastian Stan performance
and his character
you may ultimately come out
not liking
not trusting
thinking that there's something
kind of damaged about him
that maybe he has done
something terrible
to his children
it's unclear
as you're watching the movie
you have to kind of
make those decisions
for yourself
but the movie still lets you
have empathy for him
despite this
because you can watch him
in real time
getting sort of
radicalized
and sucked into a system
on the other side
after his family
comes under fire
where he reaches out
to the Romanian embassy
these figures
from the Romanian state
start to become
interested in his case
and they start
making news about it
making content about it
making them a cause celeb
he is also a poster
you know
like he is making the videos
and there's a conversation
between Mia
the neighbor
lawyer friend
and the Renata Rines
of a character
but I think
you know
I guess
gender works
in very obvious ways
I think she's amazing
in this movie
and what she's doing
and
communicating
and also what
she doesn't quite feel
comfortable communicating
either because
of her position
within the family
and this
this culture
where you know
she's only wearing skirts
until the lawyer tells her
to wear pants
and she's
only doing
there's a whole
subplot about
they have a baby
the baby's only breastfed
and then
you know
she's using her pump
and then
I appreciated the scene
where she's pumping
and it just dries out
because that's
what happens
when your body can't
when your body's
too stressed
but so
there's a conversation
between Mia the friend
and the Renata Rines
of a character
where she's like
I keep asking him
to stop posting these videos
but he thinks it helps
so you know
even there
we all know posters
we are posters
right here
the two of us
you know
to our
eternal chagrin
but you
you don't actually
ever see those videos
even that
is like second
or third hand
but like this
this guy has gone
like
full YouTube viral
you can
you can ask yourself
the question of whether or not
that was the right thing
or the wrong thing
when you get to the end of the movie
and we will talk about the ending
I want to say
one of the reasons why
I really like this movie
in addition to some of those
kind of internal
debates
that you might be having
while watching it
is
Manju is such a master
at framing and staging stories
so like you talked about the baby
and if you watch
watching the movie again
one thing that really jumped out to me
is in the first 40 minutes
the baby is always crying
yeah
you always hear the baby
crying in the house
and it is that sense of
emotional chaos
when you have a small child
in your house
and how hard it is
and that creates
this sense of like
well are these parents
kind of coming apart
at the seams a little bit
I mean the lines of a character
is effectively postpartum
I mean how old is that infant
six months old maybe
yeah
and
so you have to think about that
as you think about the events
that are portrayed
or not portrayed in the movie
as you interpret it
and then
the baby is taken away from them
and then the house is
dead quiet
and
It is this kind of tragic setting where these people who have built their entire
lives around their large family and their faith have had that completely taken from them which
again is like that's empathy in their favor in the storytelling it's not it's not both sides
and things and you kind of have to be okay with that but then the other the additional thing too
is just to me the way that the film where and how it's framed is amazing it's shot in norway
in this proper fjord which is like a long inlet surrounded by mountains that are doom-like
completely yeah all of the buildings in norway are these odd polygons and they all seem very
kind of constrictive and consistent and everything is all the same and there's a kind of way to live
in this world and if you can't get on that level you're gonna have a hard time existing in this
space and so it's like it's an immigration assimilation story yeah that like literally
figuratively and visually is constantly communicating to you how unwelcome these
people are here but that does not exonerate them from some of the things that they are accused of
and may have done in the movie so it's this it is a push-pull
yeah um to the point of the physical setting i was really struck on rewatch there you know
avalanches are a concern throughout the film and there is an avalanche at a sort of climactic point
later in the film and you see it coming down the mountain and the the principal who is also
a neighbor yes everyone is all um entwined you know announces it was like everyone be calm and
inside we know exactly what to do in this situation
and this you know i mean it's good that they are have an emergency preparedness system we do not
for most things in the united states but also at this point in the movie as things are boiling over
and also his his father is very ill and that you know a procedure and calm and emotionlessness
can solve any problem including the mountain like coming down literally on top of you as you watch
it coming uh again it is a very like i understand that it's a very difficult thing to do and i think
it's a very difficult thing to do and i think it's a very difficult thing to do and i think it's a very
difficult thing to do and i think it's a very difficult thing to do and i think it's a very difficult
i understand that the movie what is trying to point out the preposterousness
exactly so this is like if you're norwegian and you're offended by this movie i like i get it
okay yeah it's not favorable no it's it's it's not and i think that the the thing that the movie
has also come under fire for that is an interesting point of conversation is is is there a um horseshoe
theory of progressivism that at a certain point if you instill enough systems and legislate
around uh an evolved state of being and acceptance in the world can that eventually kind of curdle
and become as conservative as what you were effectively attempting to upend in the process so
by empowering something like child protection services to such a degree that you are placing the
um the care and safety of a child so dramatically above anything else in the world does that then
have dramatic consequences on families on individuals can what what happens when someone is
falsely accused of something like child abuse and you know we don't really know we don't really have
that problem in this country i would say um it's not something and it's something that coming from
romania would have a different perspective on something coming from america though we do have
i was thinking a lot about your mother your mother your mother uh during this home and particularly
um this scene when mahershala lee's character who also has a child who needs breast milk because
the child is the baby's allergic formula and
he goes to the american you know i i don't i think it's the um i don't know which department it is
but it's a government department that can get him formula if he has the right prescription all these
sorts of things and there is just a faceless bureaucrat whose job it is but also who decides
to say no like a you know you have to do this here's the paperwork that you have to do we have
to close by four o'clock and that like the inhumanity of that particular person
is the same inhumanity you see in in this movie where at some point again the the systems the
ideology circumvent two people standing in front of each other being like okay how can we actually
solve a problem that is that is you know and like actually help these children yeah you remind it
reminds me a lot of the scene in thief when james conn and tuesday weld go to the um go to adopt a
child yeah and they sit down in front of this woman and they're like all right we're ready give us a kid
yeah and she's like it doesn't work this way like where's her what's your job like fill out this form
like you have to think about the ways in which the structure works and james conn's character in that
movie is apoplectic he's like the fuck do you mean like i'm i want to be a parent i want to help and
take a kid i want a kid my my wife wants a kid why can't we have a kid and that's not how the world
works obviously and in this case it's a family that doesn't quite know how this norwegian world
works the stan and ryan's the characterizations are really interesting it's probably reasonable
that you would respond to that but i think it's a really interesting movie and i think it's a really
on her and i would respond to him for more reasons than just the gender dynamics but like
he is asked to
be the villain in a story in which he is clearly the hero in the eyes of the filmmaker and i've
never really seen that before where he like is aligned with the far right he might have hit his
children he probably i mean he admits to slapping his children on the butt right we don't know if
there's anything beyond that that he has done in the movie but it's not unreasonable to assume that
he has and
stan is an interesting actor where he is doesn't usually play pure sympathy he you know from the
the winter soldier to donald trump to you know he his he's usually kind of an ambiguous figure in
the world and in this movie he's shaved his head he's very sullen it does seem like he's about to
at any moment he has a kind of embittered quiet rage in his performance yeah but he
never does he never pops off and then there's there's a really interesting and i wonder where
their performance interpretation ends and the script or direction begins on this one but there
is a scene in which he is giving bible study to his children and nora the neighbor and they're
also doing farm tours because they live on a farm and they have like goats or sheep for whatever
reason yeah didn't didn't flesh that one out um well the matt's leader says you can let the sheep
on our land but like why did they need to take on sheep they have five children anyway um it's nice
to have a petting zoo he's so warm and like engaging in that scene where he is you know
giving a very conservative religious education not just to his own children but the people but the
the kid around the road and it's not something
normally i think we would respond
to it like you know kind of tensing up certainly certainly as americans and you know what or as an
american not of um christian practice when the eval evangelicals come to town i'm like uh i don't
know like i this is making me uncomfortable yeah and instead he's it's the warmest and happiest
that he is and the most likable that he is which is interesting because i mean but that's where he
finds his peace yeah that's where he is most comfortable yeah it's completely logical that
when he anytime he is having a conversation with somebody in a world in which he is not assimilated
he seems kind of pissed and a little uncomfortable and when you see him in that that's a very it's
very purposeful to include that scene in the movie because of exactly what you described which is that
this is something that gives him um a sense of emotional structure you know it keeps him grounded
to the world even though it's you know christian faith is kind of fantastical when you break down
um and i
think that the language barrier is also like a really important component of this for both the
children and for him because he keeps being he keeps watching conversations happen as legal
proceedings start where he feels completely powerless and he keeps talking at times when
he's not supposed to be talking whether it be in um a pre-trial scenario or when he when the family
is literally on trial with cps where he he has that i what struck me is like a very american
sensibility which is sort of like wait what the fuck like the like yeah of course fury over
the way that things are are are playing out in a sense of injustice relative to what you think is
right whereas in the norwegian society the expectation is sort of like we do this and then
we do this and we do this and we have to accept this and we cannot we can't break the rules we
can't circumvent anything you know there's a very european you know sine papo sible like air to all
of it which is i mean it's not possible which is like the most commonly heard phrase in france
always like oh i'm so sorry you want coffee at this time sine papo sible you know like we could
never because they're saying that to you but there's just like a very ordered rule based and
you're right that like we as americans and i i guess some of it is it's the the non-european
non-bureaucratic perspective i do think some of that is also just meant to channel the basic
human emotion like the movie the movie understands the the movie believes and is setting forth and
portraying these characters in a way where the child protective services like are out of line
that this is this has gone too far
and that like and that is within the text of the film i think there's no other way and if you think
that he should have made it where it's a little more like up for debate then i guess you wanted
to see a different movie and are disappointed but i don't understand about the some of the
critical reactions is i'm like this is what every manchu movie is this much movies are not like oh
well it could be this or that it's like watch rmn it's about a movie about how people get
completely like uh damaged by the by xenophobia and by their expectations of mass
masculinity this movie is the same way it's like you're watching the stan character kind of lose it
in real time in this movie because of what he
was previously acceptable in his society and he just does not know how to cope he is unadaptable
because he's a man in his 40s and there's literally a scene in the movie where he's
questioned about what his father did to him when he was being raised which is the most like spell
it out hurt people hurt people scene i've seen in a movie this year also because his children have
been taken away and because these people just with i mean amazing performances by all the primarily
women who are cast as the child protective services either employees or um or you know
related teachers or judges who just sit there and say we are like this is for the best of the
of the kid we are in charge of the kid and you can't feel where i couldn't help anything feel
anything but like total rage at the what are you talking about none of what this system is designed
to do is thinking about what is actually good for the children um like in any way well yeah the idea
that starts to cross your mind is that the system is designed to do what is actually good for the
children um like in any way well yeah the idea that starts to cross your mind is that the system
starts to cross your mind is that the system is designed to do what is actually good for the
you do hear from um people on on the right a lot of times about government institutions is sort of
like you're using these excuses as a way to justify your own existence and career and job and this kind
of institution within the government that's been created and this sense of sort of like independent
power that cps has is kind of brought up a few times that it sort of operates outside of the
legal system and can do things that you otherwise wouldn't be able to do uh but there's like a
dialogue from this movie because i think that's part of what makes it so so fascinating where
there's a line early on in the film where i think it's frida who says um we always believe the
children and that is what they told us that is like yeah seems simple but it's kind of insidious
it's like you have a little kid i have a little kid my little kid is learning how to lie
they lie yeah all the time they always lie so that being the starting point for child protective
already is like like you say is throwing weight against the norwegians in this movie right away
because you're just like you can't be serious like and then there's a lot a devastating moment
late in the film where gunda who is sort of running the cps management of this case is being
questioned by the attorney and under his breath at the trial the stand character says you're not
even a parent how would you know that yeah which is a feeling that i also had watching the movie
which i'm like even even if the stand character is terrible and doing something that's not
doing awful things to his children you kind of understand this idea of the pain that would be
caused by your child being taken away from you that that is a kind of like irreparable yes it's
the worst thing they would have that could happen to you basically she says it she he says that in
response to the gunda character saying i think you're overestimating the trauma of temporary
separation and it's like you know that i mean it is amazing the way in which
the script and those performances make me at least want to rip through the screen and just
absolutely throttle these people they've like isolated he's isolated something that is again
not very flattering um to norwegians and if you do you want to note that all of the characters
are women except for the really smarmy uh prosecutor at the end who as soon as he loses
is like great job doesn't seem to have the skin in it the way all the women do devastating moment
when he says well done to mia the other attorney after the court the case is settled that moment
is so bone chilling to me um
i i can understand a reading of it that feels like this is maybe a little
misogynist reactionary blah blah you know it in just the broad way that it's being
uh portrayed i don't i didn't interpret it that way i thought that it it just was really really
really upsetting yeah it's it's effective and i think you're right to to kind of repeat the idea
that like this isn't a both sides thing if you if you if your expectation is is that it's meant
to be a both sides thing it's like he may claim that he's trying to walk that narrow inlet but
between one perspective and the other but like we don't get any of gunda's inner life there's no
there's no show of what her faith is or how she was raised or we don't understand anything about
that group of people even frida who's a really interesting character in this movie because she
is complicit in the earliest stages of this as someone who works at the school in an effort to
protect the children and she has quote-unquote worked with cps many times on cases like this
which is a kind of a horrifying thing to hear well there is a character you never see off screen
they introduced the idea of gunda by being there's some kid named casta
who came back or something in the meeting or whatever i mean frida is also incredible casting
a incredible performance like if you do have children or you are just in the world of dealing
with you know children's educators and children's systems you recognize a particular type of
administrator and like who is like leading the children in how to do the song but there is like
a backbone of absolute steel and i think i was gonna say stiff-backed that's
exactly what it is and also like a little power hungry it's like you really want to make sure that
we all follow the rules you know the interesting thing and having children back in school
is like oh now we're back in school too and i once again am subject to the the rules in the
administration and i have to you know i've been waiting my whole life to no longer be in that
situation so you only have and but they but the frida character knows it you know and the frida
character is like that is what an amazing performance
she slowly moves closer to the center in the movie which is a very interesting choice by monju
he could have left her with gunda and again this kind of drags our sympathies in the direction as
we see her at least note that it's possible that the bruises could have come from something else
you know what the a likely explanation is it's both like they could have been
there was wrestling going on at school but then also something happened at home
well the movie opens with a very ominous shot it's you're in the home
and the renata ryans of a character is with the two girls in the family and sebastian stan is
standing way on the other side of the room looming it's not the only time that he's shown
looming and you get the feeling like something really bad happened here yes and i kind of thought
we were in for a much gnarlier um more of a demonstration of those things yes type of movie
opening on that scene so you get suggestions of it that's a very particular that moment is i've
seen it happen to me a lot as i like talk to my own child about how to be in the world yeah because
he says something very dark to her when he gives her a hug and he sort of consoles his daughter
which is like sometimes you have to be able to admit when you're wrong which is like it's so
self-reflexive like it's so clearly a person who is only raised to think one way about parenting
and that that is how he is engaging with his daughter and you know we hope that something
terrible has not just happened before the movie shows us them in that moment of reconciliation
so it's plausible and so like i think a lot it's a real like try to have two ideas in your mind at
the same time kind of movie if you like the movie that doesn't mean that you like the child beaters
like that's not what the movie is the movie is it reminds me a little bit of you can see everything
where it's sort of like it's possible for both of these things to be true at the same time that the
system is corrosive and has bent too far in one direction it's also possible that because that
has happened it disallows for kind of fairness in a really troubled situation with individual people
These are great dramatics.
I mean, this is really good.
I completely concur with how you open the conversation, which is just like, this movie hit me.
It got to me.
And it's hard for movies to get to me these days because I feel like I can see everything around the corner.
So I responded really strongly to it the second time as well.
I think it's really sharply made.
And I'm not surprised that it's kind of slipped into the corridors of takery.
And I think its slippage into those corridors has kind of led to it being somewhat discounted.
You know, it's a movie that like, I don't, it doesn't really have any juice right now, which is sort of fascinating.
And it seems like Neon anticipated that pretty early on, or at least, you know, it wins the Palm and then kind of sits out the summer, as most Cannes titles do.
And then the festival's reshowings is when the takes started popping off.
And so the release has been pretty limited.
Renata Reinsman, Sebastian Stan have not really been out.
In the way that typically Hollywood level and Oscar nominees who are in a Palme d'Or winner would be making the rounds.
Maybe they're slow rolling it.
Maybe they want to reclaim it.
It doesn't seem like it.
Well, I think that there has been some speculation that the rejection of the movie is a rejection of the Cannes jury decision.
Oh.
That this was a year with La Bollinegra and Minotaur.
Now, Minotaur is an interesting movie that we haven't talked about yet.
Maybe, I think we'll talk about it with a special guest very soon.
But that's a movie to me that has like no mystery.
That is just like, it is just straight up, this is what the movie is about.
And this is the way that the national dynamics of the country and these personal dynamics of this family interplay.
And there's no ambiguity.
And like, I think there's a great craft in that movie.
But I walk out of the movie and I'm like, okay, got it.
You know, like I didn't have to think about it.
I didn't really have to toil over it in any way.
Like it didn't really, it didn't provoke me.
It didn't prompt me.
No, I was, I honestly thought the back half just took a little too long.
And I was like, okay, let's wrap this up.
So that was a movie that like was in contention.
And then, you know, La Bollinegra coming so late in that festival.
I don't know if that impacted its ability to like be up for the Palm or not.
It's possible the jury just didn't like it at all.
They knew that the Los Javis won Best Director.
But not the Palm.
Well, sure.
But, you know, they won something.
They won something.
Yeah.
And they tied with Pavel Pavlikovsky for Fatherland.
Which is also fascinating.
Fatherland.
Yeah, Fatherland.
Another movie that like could have won.
And frankly, like the Palm sometimes goes to that kind of a movie that's not like setting the world on fire.
fjord i think is getting certainly the attention from us in part because it's sebastian stanham
ronald ryan's phone like and it's supposed to be a big keys jingling oscar movie you know like it
is supposed it's supposed to be you know what it's supposed to be anatomy of a fall that's what
this movie is supposed to be it's supposed to be the movie that you go see and you talk about over
dinner for two hours where do you stand that also won the palm dora at can and then anatomy of a
fall one right no it didn't win no zone of interest zone of interest no um well she won a lot of
awards because there's the famous photo of anatomy of a fall palm to win let's see it did
win uh it did it did win and then she posed with all of the the the awards right right and then
smoking shout out justina trie forever but and then also features like a courtroom scene where
we americans are like is this really how you're running your legal proceedings not that our
justice system is anything uh to speak proudly of but you know just very flexible yeah this one is
very flexible as well um
let's talk about the ending briefly okay okay i'm i'll be fascinated to see if people are still
listening to this episode because this movie's not been widely seen um but effectively you get this
fascinating moment where
the family makes an agreement with the state that they can have their children back
if they admit guilt in terms of uh abusing them now that means that they still have to stay in
trial in the criminal trial and they could be subject to imprisonment in the criminal trial
especially because they're admitting guilt in the cps court right in the civil court
but then it also allows for what eventually happens here and i i have been thinking the
other thing i've been thinking about is sort of like is this what the norwegians wanted which
was that they would leave the country and that this story would end that they would give them
their children so that they would depart now obviously they are setting up this sort of like
watchfulness where somebody has to be able to get out of the country and they have to get out of the
country and they have to be able to get out of the country and they have to be able to get out of the
observing them with the parents all the time but they're giving them a window to get out of the
country uh-huh and then this story can just go away as a national incident around how the norwegians
manage the child protection services in their country they can go back to romania you know oh
interesting and again this is sort of like dramatic plotting but i hadn't thought about that at all the
first time i watched it and the second time i was like yeah are they just letting this family off
the hook to just get them the fuck out of here before they even have to have a criminal court
because there's you know there's a circus around this story we see the the family and
entering the courthouse at one point in this romanian reporters everywhere and it's become
this big national story school is like tagged after yes words so it's not going away but there
is the shot also when they are leaving um where they're being followed by a cps or a government
van that you've come to recognize because it shows up every time the children are being taken
away throughout the film yes so that to me that they're still being followed suggests it didn't
make me think oh this is what the norwegians want
yeah they do let them get up they do they do get on the boat you know and like they did anything
wrong for them at a certain point and the movie then ends when this kind of magically real moment
where uh nora the neighbor daughter um who's so relieved that elia has come back to the home and
that they can be friends again and reunited and um is devastated to learn that the family has
left in the middle of the night and attempted to depart and return to romania and so she races out
to try to catch up to them with her mother and she has a run-in with her mother and she has a
moments too late and the large ship is departing and she races out onto the dock and then she
starts walking what appears to be onto the water and she's standing there as though she's standing
on top of the water and she turns and looks and we hear elia from the boat say nora be careful
and i guess there's like a number of ways to think about this moment okay um one of them
is that what looks to us like an unsafe space to the norwegians is a safe space
nora is protected even as she's walking out onto the water because this is her land and this is
where she belongs and she gets it the more reasonable interpretation is is that this is um
like a properly magically real place and the norwegian dream is not sustainable for anybody
else that like this is a fairy tale that there can be this progressive
culture in our destructive lives um and then there's the just the simple explanation which
is just like it's just an invisible dock and some some you know docks have this um
i thought it was like i thought it was nora be careful because you're staying here in norway
that is this space that i that i guess is option a sort of though i didn't take it in quite as
grandiosa um like like as a treatise on the
you know the the liberal state but more that this is a a kid who is nora's put herself out on a limb
for elia for against her parents i mean we didn't even really talk about what's going on next door
with the the father-in-law who uh doesn't speak except he does and no one wants to take care of
him and it's you know sort of like a parallel representation of what does it mean to be a
grandfather figure is ultimately aligned with lizabeth um renata ryan's of his character and
he speaks to her yes um i think in part because he also feels alienated by this unusual norwegian
society right and so he has his own kind of secrets to bear you know who knows what it is
specifically that he believes it's not really revealed to us but that there is this sense
that there is this kind of looming power structure that is ostensibly very um evolutionary yeah but
that is kind of silencing people at the same time and that that has its own destructive qualities
and then that is echoed in nora who is this kind of free spirit his granddaughter yeah who wants to
live freely and who literally says to her parents halfway through the movie she's like that's not
where they got the bruises from yeah and the parents basically ignore her like they're not
they're like go to your room we don't want to hear from you yes and and what they think what
literally what matt's her father says is you're lying why are you lying to me which is something
that we have heard earlier in the film of course the children don't do they would never lie
yeah when when you know interrogated by child protective services so i don't know this yeah i
thought this movie was well written a little confused by some of some of the reaction to it
but i i think that the nor be careful is is both things that we're saying which is sort of like
this is not as safe a space for you as you think it is um and that uh but it's also romania may
not be a safe space for ellia either yeah or at least only if she's in her kind of brainwashed
experience with her indoctrinating father and this more conservative lifestyle that she is being
nudged into especially if she's a lesbian and would not be happy in that lifestyle right so
you know maybe in fjord too we'll find out what happens with her
fjorder have you been to norway i haven't just sweden i've been to sweden twice
and but no denmark never been to denmark i've been all three wow rank them
copenhagen so that's denmark yes stockholm sweden oslo norway but i was i was very young
when i went to norway okay but i love all three i love sweden as do i i'm so glad
i think sweden is a beautiful country um i i can't disagree with some of the framing of some
of this stuff culturally i don't really know enough about it my two trips there i had a really
nice time uh i appreciate all the skarsgård family's contributions to society noted um
shall we pivot to the french with lea seydoux absolutely okay let's go to that conversation
right now lea seydoux is here thank you for being here thank you uh i know
that you were steeped in movies as a young person because your family was in the movie
business but did you watch a lot of films as a kid were you in love with movies steeped you mean
like yeah like a like like a pot of tea yeah not really no i wouldn't say that i mean my family is
in the industry if i can say that but uh not really because it's my grandfather who has a
pate and not patty that's how the americans pronounce it yeah i've been talking about
you know this company right i do of course i do you see their logo before many films in europe
and uh so he but he bought it quite uh lately i mean he didn't start with uh i mean he was like
whatever he was like uh in something some something else before and he bought this company so i cannot
say that i would that i grew up you know in the business not really like uh as a as a kid it was
not something that i was you know used to did you did you watch a lot of films though some some films
but at the time it was uh we didn't have um it's not like today you know we only had vhs
and i had a few of them but not like you know um not uh
it was not uh i mean i had like only a few of them so they were like the same films
well do you remember what they were yes i had uh 37 uh uh 37 which is uh i think the english title
is uh betty blue oh betty blue of course yes i know betty blue um i had uh um movies
Marcel Carnet
mhm
Beauty and the Beast, Jean Cocteau, some animated films, like Disney.
I watched La Femme du Boulanger.
I think it's Marcel Pagnol, but who directed this movie?
Oops, I forgot.
So you had fairly refined taste as a young person watching movies.
No, they were like the films at home.
Interesting.
And were they pushed upon you at all?
Or were you just discovered them?
No, there was like this little room with VHS.
And so I watched a few films, you know, but it was not.
I mean, I was like very left alone as a kid.
So I could do basically whatever I wanted.
And that wasn't just watching.
Watching movies.
I was watching movies and I was not really like, I didn't go to school really.
I mean, I was always like pretending I was, I had something to not go.
I hated, I hated school.
So yeah, I watched like TV and films.
It seemed like when you were, based on what I read when you were very young though,
you didn't think about acting as something you would.
What did you want to do?
Because it was not something that I was. Yeah, I was not like, I didn't even know that you could act,
which could sound a bit strange because some of my family is in the industry.
But no, I was very, very chaotic as a kid and as a young person, as a teenager.
So I didn't really know what to do basically with my life, you know.
And I was terrible at school.
So it came. Later on, the idea of acting.
It's when I met some actors that I really had the idea of acting.
And I just, I acted first.
I mean, I decided to do this job first because I just liked the life they lived.
And it was not about, it was not because I loved acting, which is even now, I don't. I'm like, it's not something that is. You know, easy for me or. I wouldn't say easy, but not something. I mean, I have an ambiguous feeling towards acting.
Did you feel you were good at it right away?
No, because I was like, because I was, I had no plan B, basically.
So it was acting or nothing.
Because I didn't have any like, diplomas, you know.
I was so. So, I mean. Chaotic.
That I decided to become an actor for that.
And also because I met some actors when I was like, around 18, 17.
And I just loved the freedom they had.
And it's, I think the main reason why I decided to become an actor.
It was to be my own master.
Meaning like the lifestyle?
That you could travel?
That you would have new experiences?
Meet new people?
Meet new people.
You meet people, you can like, you. There is no. Like, there is no. Like, actors, they all come from like, different, you know.
They all have different social backgrounds.
You don't need like, some of them like, went to, you know, like, drama schools.
But some of them also just started, you know, from scratch.
And I think that this is. The reason why I decided. I decided to do that because I didn't need. I didn't have to. I learned on the. By doing it.
So you didn't study or go to the conservatory or anything like that?
I mean, I was like. I decided. So when I decided to become an actor, I met a guy who had an agency.
But it was more for commercials.
So he said, like, if you really want to act, you should take classes.
And I thought, okay, so, but which class?
Like, how?
And so I just opened, at the time, because it was more than 20 years ago, the Yellow Pages.
So you have the Yellow Pages, right?
Of course, yeah.
And you just went to A for acting?
Exactly.
So I was like, okay, I live in this neighborhood, this neighborhood in Paris, this arrondissement.
Ah, this. And I just saw, like, a little ad on the Yellow Pages.
It was like, cinema.
You want to do cinema?
Les Enfants Terribles call this number.
I called.
They auditioned.
They made me do an audition.
And I went.
And they said, okay, well, you are. Now, if you want to be part of it, you are welcome.
And this is how I started.
But I was extremely shy, also.
Do you remember what you read in the audition?
No, it was like a piece of. I think it was like an interview and like a piece of. A scene of. I don't remember.
Okay.
Not really, because I was too shy.
And so. And so, yes, and I did this. So I. Oui, I did this class.
Les Enfants Terribles.
It was a small, very small. You know, theater school.
And it was a great school for me because I met someone who helped me, the teacher.
Actually, he was an actor.
And he created this school.
And he really taught me a lot.
And I have to thank him because he really, like, shook me off.
You know, I was like. So shy.
And one day he came to me and he was like,
Lea, if you really want to work, like, you have to. You have to. I don't want to be rude, but you have to, like, make it work, you know?
Just. Sortes-toi les doigts du cul.
I don't know.
But you. I would never understand, but someone understands right now.
Yeah, someone understands.
And he was like, you really have to, like, you have to work.
You have to. You have to be up for it, you know?
And I was like, yes, you're right, you're right.
And it took me some time because I was shy.
Like, I was really shy, chaotic.
And so it took me some time.
Was the school named after the Louis Malle film or was it just a reference to bad kids?
I think it's Jean Cocteau, non?
Jean Cocteau, yes.
Yeah.
And so, yes, that's. But I really loved that school.
It was a very little school.
Very, very nice.
Once you were on sets, did you find yourself gravitating to more experienced actors and asking for their advice?
Or did you just do what you wanted to do?
To ask actors' advices?
No, I think that. No, not really advices.
But what I love when I'm with actors, when I act with actors, is that I love to observe them.
And I love to. To get to know them, you know?
On an intimate level.
Like, intimate level.
You see?
Meaning what?
I mean, like, acting, I'm not really. I'm going to say something very strange, maybe, for you.
Okay.
But I'm not so interested about acting, even now.
It's not. Should we talk about something else?
No, I mean, we can talk about acting, but it's not. Yeah, I mean, I wish. I mean, we could, like, definitely talk about something else.
But, yes, I'm not obsessed about acting.
I'm not, like. I don't know what to say about acting.
And I don't think that I. I mean, now I've been doing this for, like, quite some time.
But, no, I like to. What I love is to explore the human nature.
I mean, your films do that.
You're such. A great actor?
No, you are a great actor, but this is a very simple way of saying something.
But good and interesting.
If you're in a film, it probably means that film is doing something that's not provocative, compelling, unusual.
You don't appear in a lot of boring movies, you know?
Well, thank you.
I've done a few, like. Not very boring.
I'm sure it's hard not to. Nothing is perfect, but. Yeah.
But there's always something, you mean.
And so how do you. Forget about talking about the craft of acting for a second.
No, no, but I would. How do you figure out how to pick a movie is something that I'm always interested in.
Because you're in a couple of movies this year that are very provocative.
They're very. Compelling.
But they're challenging pieces of work, you know?
Gentle Monster is a very challenging movie.
So why do you. And it's not. This is not the first time you've been in a movie where the premise is a little. It can be tough.
So what is it about movies like that that you're drawn to?
I think that I like a certain challenge.
And I think that I make the films that I want to see.
As. a spectator.
It's, um, I don't like films that are too binary or too, with good feelings, you know, like Bon Sentiment, you know, when there's always like the good, the bad.
I try, I just love when it's a bit complex and subtle.
I try to, to work with people that have, um, I don't know, their own style.
Do you research the filmmakers when you get a script?
Do you watch their films?
Sometimes, yes.
And sometimes no.
What determines that decision?
If you have the time, if you're interested?
No, I think it's just something very instinctive.
I don't know how I choose.
It's like, for me, like also doing a movie is having a conversation like we're having now, right?
And, uh, when I meet someone, when I meet a director, I'm like, what I'm thinking is, will I want to, to, will I want to have a conversation?
With this person.
And, uh, this is how I pick my films.
What was your, what was your first conversation with Marie Kritzer like?
On a Zoom.
Oh, yeah.
Is that common now?
No, and I don't really like it.
Yeah, I don't like it either.
But I didn't have the choice.
Thank you for being her person, by the way.
And not on Zoom.
Um, but yes, uh, no, Marie, it was on a Zoom because I was filming.
I was filming The Unknown.
Mm-hmm.
And, um, yeah, I find it, um, I really don't like it.
But anyway, uh, Marie, I knew her previous film, Corsage.
I really liked it.
And, um, and yeah, I just, I don't know.
You know, it felt right.
The, the, the part was very interesting.
I liked, uh, her, um, her style, her tone.
Mm-hmm.
And I. I liked the subtlety of it.
So I just said, like, yes, I'm up for it.
Do you think you would have been interested if you were not a parent?
If I was not a parent?
Yeah.
Did that, does that figure into picking parts at this point?
What do you mean by a parent?
A mother.
Ah, a parent.
Sorry.
Not a parent.
A parent?
I don't know this word.
I mean, if you were a parent, that would also be interesting.
I'm a parent.
A parent.
Because you have a power.
Apparent.
In French.
Yes.
Unfortunately.
Apparent, it's apparaître.
It's, uh, to, um, to, uh, rise.
Oh.
Well, that, that as well.
Apparition.
So I was like, oh, apparent.
Maybe it's, uh, French, you know, um. You were also on the rise in a way.
But that, no, no, a mother.
Has that, like, and, and, and maybe more broadly, has that changed what kind of parts you're
interested in playing?
Of course, of course, the fact that I'm a mother changed a lot, I mean, changed for
this film, but for, in general.
Mm-hmm.
Gives you a certain empathy, which is good when you're an actor.
I'm very curious about your, how you thought about your chemistry or lack thereof with
your co-star in Gentle Monster, Lawrence.
And do you. What did I find of my chemistry?
Well, maybe how did you guys find it?
Because I met, I met him also the first time on Zoom.
Okay.
So, and it was strange because we, we rehearsed, we read the scenes on Zoom.
Um, and then after I met him. Um, like, weeks later.
But, uh, I really liked Lawrence, Lawrence Rupp.
Mm-hmm.
He's a great actor.
I really loved working with him.
I thought he was very brave to do this, uh, this part.
Tough part.
Because, yeah, very tough part.
And, um, and, yeah, I really, I really loved working with him.
It was very natural and, you know, it felt like, I don't know, very. Grounded.
I'm always, I'm curious. You were looking for the word.
No, you got the word.
But, because there has to be some distance between you as well in the film.
So, like, is there any part of you that thinks I should keep my distance from this person
while we're making this movie?
You don't think that way.
I'm not really method.
You're not method.
If you. I've gotten that sense, but. You've noticed, no?
No, but even if you're not method, it doesn't mean you don't have. I'm not like, no, I'm not going to talk to him because I'm supposed to be, like, never.
No, but it happened to me.
I played once, I remember, with an actress and she was very method.
And she was, like, very mean to me.
How did you feel about that?
Did you like that?
I don't. I mean, I respect, you know, it's. We all have our style of acting.
So, I respect that.
But it was a bit strange.
Did you learn German for this movie?
Is that true?
Yeah, I mean, phonetically.
Okay.
If you ask me to speak German, no.
Our next interview will be entirely in German.
Was that challenging?
Even just phonetically?
I love it.
Had you done that before?
Even, like, accents.
I love to do accents, even in English.
I've just done a film where I have a British accent.
Oh, I'm going to ask you about that a little bit later.
I'm quite curious about that.
I can try.
That was pretty good.
No, I just say I can try.
But I love it.
I absolutely love it.
I mean, I don't know if my accent, my British accent is great.
But, I mean, it's something that I would, you know, do as much as, you know, wanted.
You transformed in front of. Because you didn't just change your voice.
And the American accent, I love it also.
No, mine is terrible.
Can you do mine?
Can you do mine?
I mean. Yeah, that's why you're still doing that.
No, I'm not, like, the best, but it's something that I like.
What about playing a pop star?
I don't like acting, but I love doing accents.
Doing accents?
It's more play.
It is more play.
Yeah.
You play a musician.
A kind of unusual pop star.
A kind of avant pop star.
What is that?
Like, how do you learn how to be that person?
Are you a musician at all?
Do you play music?
No, I don't play music.
I mean, I've tried to.
But, like all the things I've done as a kid, I failed.
I gave it a try, you know.
But no, I. But I've always loved singing.
Which is something that I, you know, I was really happy to sing in this film.
And I was like, you want me to sing now?
You're doing so many things, honestly.
With the British accent?
Can you do that?
I mean, when you sing, you don't hear the accent, right?
Like Céline Dion, for example, when she sings, she has this very, you know, Canadian, French-Canadian accent.
You're right about that.
But once you heard her speak, couldn't you then. Isn't it inextricable once you hear her sing again?
Not that you hear her accent per se, but you know that that's how she speaks.
Mm-hmm.
This is important.
Mm-hmm.
Some people, you can hear the accent.
It depends on what language they're singing in.
You're not going to sing?
No, I can sing.
Okay.
Did you study anyone?
Did you study any musicians?
Study musicians?
What do you mean by study musicians?
For this part, look at how they move, look at how they operate.
Because you do have performance sequences.
No, but I'm not really, I'm not this kind of actor.
It's not that I'm lazy.
I wouldn't say that.
I didn't say that.
But I'm not. I'm not like, I just, for me, I'm looking for, I don't know if like you have to study,
like, you know, you have to make it your own.
So when I, when I'm acting, I try to go towards the character, but also I try to make the
character goes, you know, and. Towards me.
Does it make sense?
It does.
Do you have a. Like, so, so basically what I. No.
If I, if I. I often say that I always play myself, in a way, with a different costume.
And yet you just did that British accent.
Yeah.
That's not true, but I do have a. And a different. Do you have a sense of your. You have to give something, I feel that. That when you act, you have to give something personal.
Otherwise, it's not interesting.
Do you think about your persona then?
Is that something that comes into play?
Or is that just. I don't, I don't even know what it means, persona.
I never look at myself from the outside.
Do you watch your performances?
Not really.
Quickly, just to. No, I watch the film to, to, to, to make sure that, you know, I did like the film that I,
that I read.
No, to see just a. You know, the Finnish thing.
But, no, I'm not, I don't, I don't really watch my films.
And I feel quite uncomfortable, actually, to watch my films.
What about something you made when you were younger?
Yeah, sometimes.
But I prefer when I don't speak.
It's difficult for me to hear my voice.
Oh, we share that.
It's horrible, no?
The voice is. I hate it.
Like, the face is fine, but. The voice.
I have a problem with my face, too, but I hear what you're saying.
Can you, can you tell me about The Unknown a bit?
Mm-hmm, of course.
I thought it was fascinating.
I saw it at Cannes, just like Gentle Monster.
Did you like it?
I did.
And it's funny that you have such a kind of simple approach, or at least not an overthought
approach to acting, because similarly with Gentle Monster, there's, you have to transform
into another person, almost literally, given the premise of the movie, and almost the movie
almost feels like a movie about what it must be like to be
actor where you are going inside of another person and then having to embody that person
but the way that you just described your process is i try to bring as much of myself to it as
possible i am also a man that's what i was going to say i am all the characters i've played you
know it's a fascinating movie so what did you think when you first read it i was a bit confused
mm-hmm but then but then um i read it again just before the shooting
and i was really like wow this is amazing this is really an amazing movie and
and uh the part i just uh loved also the part and and how original the story was
so i felt like very i mean i was so happy to make this film and i loved
i love shoot i loved shooting this film and i remember that at some point
i think it was like after like more than half of the shooting i read the end again and i was like
moved to tears like i couldn't i remember i was like on you know i was filming but i was in the
tent the green room
mm-hmm
and i read it again and i was like wow this is so
moving i just um i love the end like no others you know you it's so different from what you
we are used to see and i and i love it and i think it's uh it's what i love i love to make
films that are so like uncommon it's it the premise
in a in different hands would be far more science fiction or there would be all kinds of technology
or things that you but it's very simple but here it's it's interesting to hear you say you loved
the experience of making it because it's quite agonizing to watch at times i mean it is a very
difficult film you know i say that with respect with admiration but why why was it fun to make
good to make because it was something that was never made before so we didn't have to make it
so we didn't know like how do you play a woman a man stuck in a woman's body you know it's something
that uh it's just but not for laughs not not it's not a joke there have been plenty of comedies
about things like that i know great comedies yeah but no this this was not supposed to be funny i
mean it's not funny i mean it's not funny at all but it was not like he didn't include like it's
very it's a deep metaphysical journey
but what i loved about the film is that um the idea of like being a man stuck in a woman's body
is just impossible and so to make that thing that impossible thing thing uh relatable that
was a challenge so it was more like how will i make this um truthful you know i read that it
was not you made it not long after
uh giving birth yeah it was um was that um did that change the way that the performance turned
out in any way or what like probably yeah yeah but you don't you didn't think about it no no i
think about it but it's uh it's just that you know you make when you i don't i don't know how
it would have been if i didn't you know i didn't gave birth i didn't give birth a month before you
know i i cannot really imagine it it's just such a it's a it's a very unique state state of mind i
have a child yeah yeah i was but in a way also to to to have my baby to have a very very
a newborn baby gave me a lot of strength i felt very strong and um
and i had this body that i was like you know a body that is that was uh
um that has been transformed and i played with it and i thought
it was interesting because i played with it and i like how author director yeah
how he he uh filmed you know my body and he didn't he didn't do it in a
like it's never objectified or sexualized yes and this is what i like like you really see this body
that is like so real and he really like he didn't try to make it look
you know beautiful it's just like you see the body like just how how it is and i think that
this is something that i've that i that i find very interesting and also that i find
important because uh and especially here for example in america it's crazy like all the
actress like actresses have this kind of control on their body bodies and i just um
um thought that it was interesting to show
a body you can relate to in a way and it's funny because i had to be a man
to do that i had to become a man to do that very good point that's the only time you'd be allowed
to be a less glamorous version of yourself i mean there's a dramatic difference though
i think between the expectations of american cinema and you you know that you've been in a
lot of big hollywood american movies i was gonna i was curious about that like
do you think um strategically about when you want to do a big
american blockbuster is it just you're waiting for material to come along and you say oh i like
this and i want to do it yeah no i'm not i'm not at all i'm not strategic you know it's just like
i didn't know i wanted to be an actor so you see like now i'm here and um
and even like the you know working in america it's not something that happened but really i
remember the first job i did in america i mean america it was not america but i mean in the
industry i mean the hollywood industry uh was um a little part i did with um ridley scott
and i had to robin hood yes and i had to tape you know to do a tape
and did you like that so i i just but it was like so i had to
direct myself in a way you know and i asked a friend if she could like film me and it worked
me back and they said yeah you got the job and it was one of my first job i was very young
and this is how it started and then i met like uh
quentin tarantino yes he came to paris he was looking for um a french actor
and he he cast me he he gave me he played like the the you know he played with me always reads
yes yeah he reads like he always reads opposite his actors yes exactly so
so he he he read the scene with me was he londa or or was he your father's character what character
was he in the scene no he was not like i don't even think that it was oh no yes it was it was
a scene from from the script okay yes um i think it was shoshana you know it was a scene like a
shoshana scene because he was looking for shoshana so he didn't pick me as a shoshana
but he gave me this little part such a memorable moment in the movie though i mean
you're one of the first people we see in the film it's true yeah and um and so you know little by
little this is how i started to work in america is it different at all i think it's hard it's a
little hard for americans to understand the way that the european film industry operates especially
france has a very vibrant film industry obviously but the unknown is a good example of
a slightly more audacious kind of film that might be made here i
does it operate differently for you yeah it's different but i i like both i like both
i'm i'm not like as i said like i'm not like yes i want to do this i want to do that i want to
play a strong woman a woman who's like independent i don't have this kind of you know i'm just like
i want to work with interesting people and and uh i like to just for me like cinema is really
an exploration i read that you did really want to work with katherine denove though yeah of course
and so i mean
i mean and that did she did she get cast in gentle monster because you shared that with marie is that
yes sort of what happened no she marie um heard like a podcast that i that i did you're on one
where i was like i want to i would love to work with her i love katherine and then she had the
idea so maybe i should now say that i want to work with uh well that's what i'm gonna i want to add i
mean there are other people that you can so many people you can spirit it into the world and just
say i want to do this will that happen you think if i say it
worked once why not who you got on your list no maybe i don't know maybe it's bad luck i don't
think i think it's really good luck you don't know you don't have to say it i mean it worked
you did it one time and you so but the true icon of french cinema the living icon of french cinema
and you guys she played your mom in a movie okay now i would love to work with um an actor or a
director anybody you want um
so many okay we'll come back to it i'm gonna ask you again yeah you gotta say a name what
about a certain um genre of film not that you're necessarily strategizing for but that you'd like
to try you talked about your interest in doing accents
um
you sang in a film i can do whatever i'm very adaptable oh you have played in a lot of different
kinds of parts i ask that question a lot to people and i think because they'd never know
what to say i would love to play a maga why what i can do the american accent okay i mean they're
on their way out i don't know if you've heard things are going much better here i just thought
that no my my hair are not long enough that's that's probably true that's you want to storm
the capital on january 6th that would be funny um is is it the mask of the red death the film
that you did the accent for yes what can you tell me about that movie yeah i haven't seen it yet
okay i met charlie i can actually oh yeah yeah charlie so it's a movie made by this very talented
young american director charlie pullinger in english it's pollinger pollinger maybe oh you
charlie pollinger wow no no you got it you're american accent is yeah you got me dead to rights
i will say it in the french accent charlie pollinger and uh so yeah we we did this movie
with uh that it's adapted from the the the adapted from edgar edgar allen poe oh yeah
poe
called the death of the red mask no the mask of the red death i'm always like you got it
red mask no you see i'm also like um you know i i always struggle with the right and the left
uh that's something you know when i when i'm when i'm filming it's like go on your
right and i go on the left it's always like and i'm like um but uh yeah so it's a it's an
adaptation of um edgar allen poe the mask of the red death the mask of the red death and it's um
it's uh it was a great great screen screen play and i hope the movie will be as good
and uh it's uh we i shot with uh two amazing actors mikey madison and orwell and not personally
just our work um and a wonderful actress really wonderful and and a german actor franz franz
rogowski yes no franz rogovski i mean in french you say rogovski you say how do you say i say
rogowski rogowski yeah wow you're really gonna you can you can no it's not it's not german it's
french rogovski rogovski yeah i think so is he french maybe he is no no he's not french he's
german but the pronunciation as i said it i said it with a french accent i don't know in german
maybe the same i don't know he's also wonderful he's wonderful um is it contemporarily set or
is it a period no it's a period piece okay as i was thinking about doing this i was thinking
about recent films of yours that i i really enjoy i really love the beast really love one fine
morning last
10 years or so i feel like you made a lot of really good films is there but there's some i
haven't seen as well and some that have honestly never come to the states is there a movie that
you're very proud of that you really like that you think people should find explore i mean i'm
proud of um a few of them i mean i've done like uh yeah it's a long list but maybe one that is
not as known or that didn't you know obviously everyone's seen dune part two here in the u.s
you know you don't have to recommend dune part two to us
yes yes we love that movie um i really there is a film that is very dear to my heart is one of the
first i've done called belipin but it's it was one of the first and um it was a long time ago
why is it important to you and i love it because i just uh it was one of the first you know one of
my first like first time that i really felt like i was in a movie and i was like oh my god i'm so
like wow i'm i built this character i i really put you know something intimate into the character
it was like it meant a lot for the subject and also because the the the director who was
who's a friend she's uh she's a woman and that's her story and um it was her story and it was
my story and it was it was very personal there was there is something very personal
about this movie and we were all young actors we were this young generation of actors
with french actors that are now you know um quite well known in france with the swan arlo also who's
like uh this amazing actor who was in anatomy of a fall yes um and so it was like a film he has a
yeah yeah it did like really well in in france i can yeah yeah yeah and you can and and it came
out and swan is in this film yeah he's in this film but he's he was yeah in the film this one
this film called belipin belipin and i think maybe it came out here but that that's a movie
that i really like that is not perfect but there is something very very charming about it and um
there is a another film that i really love that i i don't there is another one also from
a female director who's a friend ursula mayer she's in swiss
half swiss and i'm going to work with her yes as you heard before um but and and i will make
a movie very soon with her again okay so but that film that we shot was more than almost 15
years ago called sister oh i haven't seen that belipin i've seen a belipin you've seen yes okay
and sister is really nice i mean really nice it's a beautiful beautiful film and so this
this uh new film that i'm going to shoot with her will be in english with bill murray wow and um
um
it's a corny weaver and the script is like amazing
amazing well that's very beautiful beautiful script and she's a really good film director
Ursula but she makes only like she makes very very few films she has she she made like only like
four films you mentioned that you were chaotic and when you were younger not anymore not no
clearly no now I'm really very stable um is your family surprised by how your life and career
turned out and who you are? That's a good question. I've never been asked this question.
I don't think they really care, to be honest. I know exactly how you feel.
Like, you know, I'm the kind of like, I never get a message, for example, for, you know, like from,
I remember, no, I'm going to tell you a funny story. My mother, so it was a long time ago,
I did this little part, you know, in Mission Impossible. And so at the time I was a very young
actress. You were an assassin. I was an assassin. And she called me and she was like, where are you?
What are you doing? And I said, oh, I'm packing, mom, I'm packing because I have to go to Vancouver.
I have to fly to Vancouver because I just got offered a part in Mission Impossible.
And you know what she answered? Oh, and when do you come back?
Not congratulations. She didn't say like, congratulations, really? You're going to
go?
Like I was a very young actress, you know, it was like something to do with Mission Impossible. I
mean, you know, and I'm French. It's not something that, you know, and she was like, okay, but when
do you come back? And so this is my parents. But I mean, in a way, they are not like, they've never
been really supportive, to be honest, but they don't really, they are very busy. My father,
he works a lot. My father has a drone company.
A drone company. Oh my goodness.
Yeah.
Okay.
He's, he's kind of, I can say, and I'm not saying that because he's my father, but he's, he's a genius.
Oh, wow.
Yeah. He's like a really, a real genius.
Does he, do they see the films?
I don't think they've seen all of them. Now, my mother, I think she likes, she likes to, to watch them.
No, my father comes sometimes, but they're not like, you know, because they are not like, you know, I was not the kind of, I don't know.
You know, I was not like, oh, my little girl, she's, you know, they were like, just live your life.
You are like an icon of French cinema now, though.
Yeah, but I don't think they see me as a, as a, you know, no, they just like, it's not really, you know, in my family, it's like, it doesn't really exist.
The fact, I mean, they know I'm an actor, they are proud and, but it's not something where they're like, oh, you're like, you know, it's not.
You're still their daughter.
Yeah, and I mean, I'm not the center of attention, the center of attention, but, and something that I, that I like, I've never been as a kid.
I was not.
And I come from a big family.
I have like many siblings.
So I was used to be the one, you know, among the others.
But I think we all felt this way.
And no, I just did my own thing.
And suddenly they realized that I was an actor.
I should hope so.
Lea, we end every episode of this show by asking filmmakers,
what is the last great thing that they have seen?
Have you seen any films recently that you've really liked?
You know what?
I really, really want to see, of course, I want to see the Nathan Fielder.
You haven't seen it yet.
No, because it's only out here in the States.
I really want to see it.
They won't let you get away for three hours from your press tour to go see a movie?
All the films that I have to watch, I mean, whatever.
I'm working.
I understand.
Thank you for working with us.
You're welcome.
But no, no, I will see it at some point.
Of course, I recently have seen this French film that I liked a lot.
Notre Salut.
So that film, I feel like will be, it was a little lost on me as an American.
Oh, yeah.
Yeah, yeah.
You know, that French perspective and that character, I think is maybe something we're
not totally acculturated to.
Yeah, I think so.
In the US?
Yeah, because it's so, it's really part of our history.
And yeah.
You liked it though.
You understood it.
Yes, because it's like, you know, it's the Second World War.
And yes, it's something very, very like anchored, you know, in our history, French history.
I mean, not only French, but, you know, but I think that.
Yeah, it's funny because it's a very, very important topic.
And I thought it was very interesting.
But yes.
Is that your pick?
You want to shout anything else out?
Yes.
Like recently, this is what I, there are like films that I really want to see, documentaries
also.
It's a great pick.
Like Irish Travelers.
Have you seen it?
No, I don't know it.
I want to see it.
I want to see it.
It's a documentary called Irish Travelers.
And it looks amazing about Irish Travelers.
That's my other half.
Half Swiss, half Irish.
So you have to see it.
It looks really good.
I want to see it, but I didn't have the time.
These are good recommendations, even if you haven't seen them.
Léa Seydoux, thank you so much for being here.
You're welcome.
Thank you.
Merci beaucoup.
Okay.
Thanks to Léa.
Thanks to our producer, Jack Sanders, for his work on today's episode.
So thanks to Lucas Kavanaugh for production support.
Later this week, we're talking about The Hunger Games' Sunrise on the Reaping, which is going
to be massive.
I know.
Are you aware of this?
Yes, I am.
I get emails all of the time.
I had to reserve our screenings at our second choice theater because the first was sold
out for the guest access screening.
Did you happen to catch on Jam Session a few weeks ago, inspired by Ryan Phillippe's list
of things I am no longer engaging with going forward?
Oh, I did see that list.
I put Hunger Games' Sunrise on the Reaping on my list, except for when I have to talk
about it on the big picture, but it's everywhere.
I need you to bring it.
I'm going to bring it.
This is going to be a big movie.
Listen, I'm going to go see it.
I know most of the people in it.
You know what I'm going to get?
Soda and candy at the screening.
I'm going to treat this like the blockbuster that it is.
I am going to be over on that side of town, so I'm going to have a special solo dinner
before going to the IMAX.
Oh, that's nice.
Jesse Plemons is in this film?
I know.
I know.
You know, and as we know from my Digger review, if Jesse Plemons is in it, then it can't be
totally bad.
That's how I view the world.
It's a great trailer.
You saw Kiki posting for Wild Horse 9?
I did.
Yeah.
That was a relief.
Right on.
That's my girl.
We will also be talking about Paper Tiger, another movie that we saw in May that we probably
are both revisiting this week.
Yes.
I'm very excited about that.
James Gray, of course, will be on the podcast.
I did note to a friend this week, as we were talking about Christmas past, present, and
future, the OG third chair.
Okay.
Is James Gray.
James Gray, as I told him when he was here, he is the one who helped me figure out what
the show is, in one respect.
It's beautiful.
You're the other person who helped me figure out what it is.
Thank you so much.
That's nice.
It's okay.
I don't mind being second to James Gray.
Well, you're second to Lea Seydoux now.
See you next time.
you
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Robert Pattinson is set to star in a new James Bond film directed by Denis Villeneuve, marking a major shift in the franchise's creative direction.
The casting reflects a broader trend of major studios prioritizing IP value over individual talent, with Amazon and MGM now driving Bond’s evolution.
The film is expected to blend high-concept storytelling with modern themes like digital culture, trauma, and moral ambiguity, diverging from traditional Bond tropes.
A key element of the film’s appeal lies in the contrast between Pattinson’s evolving persona—spanning indie dramas and blockbusters—and his potential to bring a fresh, nuanced take to the role.
The film’s success may hinge on casting powerful, complex villains—such as Mahershala Ali or Gwyneth Paltrow—whose presence adds depth rather than caricature.
The narrative is expected to explore themes of redemption, power, and systemic responsibility, reflecting contemporary concerns about wealth, technology, and global ethics.
The production team, including Denis Villeneuve and Stephen Knight, aims to balance creative ambition with commercial viability, creating a film that feels both authentic and impactful.
Despite skepticism, the casting signals a shift toward a more mature, introspective Bond, where the character’s psychological complexity and moral ambiguity take center stage.
Summary:
A new James Bond film is set to star Robert Pattinson, directed by Denis Villeneuve, marking a significant evolution in the franchise. This decision reflects a broader trend where major studios, now owned by Amazon and MGM, prioritize IP value and commercial scalability over traditional casting instincts. The film is expected to move beyond classic action tropes, embracing themes of trauma, digital culture, and moral ambiguity, aligning with modern societal concerns.
Pattinson’s career trajectory—spanning indie auteur projects and major franchises—offers a unique blend of depth and accessibility, while the creative team aims to craft a psychologically rich, thematically resonant experience. The casting of heavyweight actors like Mahershala Ali or Gwyneth Paltrow as villains is seen as a strategic move to add moral complexity and realism. Despite concerns over originality, the film’s narrative will likely explore redemption, systemic power, and personal accountability in a way that feels contemporary and relevant.
Critics note that while the story of James Bond has long been formulaic, this adaptation may finally offer a fresh, introspective take that honors the character’s evolution. The film’s potential to redefine Bond as a morally ambiguous, psychologically layered figure is exciting, though it risks alienating long-time fans who expect traditional adventure. Ultimately, the film represents a pivotal moment in Bond’s history—one that blends creative vision with commercial ambition, signaling a new era for the franchise.
FAQs
Johnny Depp stars as Ebenezer Scrooge, with Rupert Grint, Andrea Risborough, Sam Claffin, Daisy Ridley, Tramiel Tillman, and Ian McKellen in key roles.
The film is directed and co-edited by Ty West, and written by Nathaniel Halpern.
Yes, it made $19 million and is promoted as the biggest opening ever for a live-action Christmas Carol movie.
After a long absence from major studio releases, Depp's return is seen as a significant cultural event, especially given his iconic roles in the Pirates of the Caribbean and Tim Burton films.
It is a very faithful, traditional adaptation that follows the classic structure of the story, with minimal changes, making it feel repetitive and familiar to audiences.
Critics note that it lacks originality, relies on well-worn story beats, and feels like a 20-year-old film with little connection to modern storytelling or audience expectations.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.