Rewind with Karen & Georgia - 103: Live At The Balboa Theatre in San Diego
1h 38m 52s
The podcast episode explores the true crime case of Betty Broderick, who murdered her husband Dan and his legal assistant Linda Colkena in San Diego in 1989. After years of emotional and financial abuse, including neglect, isolation, and psychological manipulation, Betty’s mental health collapsed. The story details how Dan’s affair with Linda, combined with his workaholic lifestyle and emotional detachment, created a toxic environment. Betty, who had previously raised their four children alone, became increasingly unhinged, culminating in a premeditated home invasion where she shot both victims. The trial was highly publicized, with the first jury deadlocked and the second convicting her of second-degree murder, citing psychological abuse as a defense. Despite the tragic outcome, the narrative emphasizes the children’s suffering and the damaging impact of prolonged domestic abuse. The episode blends the factual account with personal humor and reflections from the hosts, such as their own experiences with mental health and podcasting. It underscores how domestic violence, especially in the context of gendered expectations and financial control, can escalate into violence. The story serves as a cautionary tale about emotional abuse and the importance of recognizing signs of psychological harm. The episode is framed within a broader discussion of true crime storytelling, mental health, and the evolving public understanding of abuse. While the case is dark and disturbing, the hosts maintain a reflective tone, highlighting the emotional toll on victims and the need for societal awareness. The narrative concludes with a note of empathy, acknowledging the complexity of human behavior under extreme duress.
this is exactly right
do you really know the person sleeping next to you tanya bales thought she did you may know john
mehan from the dirty john podcast but there's one story you haven't heard now it's being told from
the women who knew him first tanya was john's wife for 10 years in the first wife she recounts
the abuse she suffered from a man who was coercive and dangerous what do you do when the person you
trusted most was never real listen to the first wife wherever you get your podcasts audible
subscribers can binge all episodes early and ad free right now goodbye my favorite murder is
brought to you by yellow jackets on paramount plus the emmy nominated series about a 90s girls
soccer team stranded in the wilderness after a plane crash returns for its final season and this
season the yellow jackets are finally coming home but a swarm of endless questions awaits how did
they survive what really happened
out there and what did they do to finally escape featuring melanie linsky christina ricci
tawny cypress and hillary swank catch the final season of yellow jackets streaming november 20th
on paramount plus goodbye you know a favorite m word magnesium like the kind that's in dr teal's
magnesium spray made from a proprietary blend of topical minerals it's designed to relax and
prepare you for a night of rest if you need a reset after your day make dr teal's magnesium
spray part of your nighttime routine generously spritz
each foot before bed and you'll be all set i've actually started doing this and i'm obsessed with
magnesium it does everything something like this is just like it's simple it's easy and it actually
works totally for wellness you can feel find dr teal's magnesium spray online or in your local
bath aisle goodbye
hello and welcome to rewind with karen and georgia this is the show where we step into the past
through our old episodes and we emerge from the other side with brand new feelings case updates
and more today we're rewinding to episode 103 which we named live at the balboa theater in san
diego god this was a good show it was so good um this episode originally came out january 11th 2018
all right let's listen to the intro of episode 103
what's up san diego
oh good there's an exit there there's two back there and of course there's one right over there
there you go house right stage left there you go and of course we brought the the the rug that my
great-grandmother
wove on a loom yes this is uh yeah the kilgara family rug uh was handed down from uh galway
ireland all the way down to uh it's beautiful it's beautiful god bless it's just gorgeous and
it's and then i just spilled my nail polish that i just painted literally just painted my nails with
backstage george and i say a pre-show prayer this is the insider information for locals only
and this is not a joke because they're like you guys are atheists no we really say a prayer we
really say a prayer tonight we said a prayer to the oceans and the local manicurists yeah
just kind of start talking and then at some point someone goes amen yeah and so i just painted my
nails and she went to grab my hands well we i know we actually started the prayer all right
and then i went to say something you were like we were like trying to be fake spiritual it's what we
do and at one point i went to say something you're just goes watch the fingers
that's much for me because i don't give a shit no it's for this show you're right it's for the
people no i don't want it to get all over your hands oh these old things look at my hands are
covered in pen and worry it's fine sun damage some yeah some gap jeans die because i'm not
never not going like this oh no my god i'm so sorry i'm so sorry i'm so sorry i'm so sorry i'm so
sorry i'm so sorry i'm so sorry i'm so sorry i'm so sorry i'm so sorry i'm so sorry well it's great to be here in san diego
that's my segue that was my segue is this new did you just write this i just wrote this is this
gonna be your new thing this is my new thing eileen oh my god this is local georgia you're
from nearby i'm from nearby i like you guys better than my hometown don't tell them not me
norcal all the way all right oh thank you no i like norcal better than my hometown too
so we're everyone's happy let's let's rate the entire united states right now
um the last time i was in san diego actually was for comic-con
you've been and i got in a huge screaming fight with my friend in either the gas light or the
gas lamp district and i just either the gas light or the i can't hear anything
i beg you it's um it's the gas lamp district because the gas light district is where people
take you to convince you that your thoughts are wrong right which is what we got in a fight about
don't go there that's right she was doing that she was gas lamping me in the gas light
she gas lamped the shit out of you we're friends now it's fine but if anyone witnessed it
congratulations remember that private memory of georgia's that none of us were there for
well that's just a lie
last memory i have a san diego so i'm really happy that this is the last one now yes you're
making new memories all the time right oh san diego i went to bilbo with eater instead of i
got in a screaming fight you know what i mean yeah the last time i was here i just had a really
mediocre set of comedy so i also apologize for my last my last experience here in san diego i
didn't deliver any of the goods i mean they should apologize to you i feel the same because you
probably brought it am i wrong i brought it in my house
in my special way that only certain people would care about luckily i've accessed that audience now
we found them back in 20 2008 nobody was having it it was a different time it was a different time
new material that's right all this you know i don't want to look but are my spanks past my
knees right now it feet that's what it feels like let's all be friends and tell her oh no they're
right there okay
i gave up on those motherfuckers a long time ago i thought i had capri spanks on for a second
knee-high it scared me knee-high spanks knee-high spanks why isn't that a thing
some girls and guys hate their calves that's true knee-high spanks yeah you oh my god calf
only spanks might be a niche that we get rich off steven cut that out steven that's ours
send it in the mail
i don't know where are you seriously missing your cue
yes what what happened what if he were wearing the knee-high spanks
look at him he's he's panning he's panning to the audience
steven graduated from the zoo in 1916
just this old giraffe it's true i went back
to my old cage it was great
oh you're so glad you're free now no he's not
now he's in this zoo we keep him caged in the back that's why it took a minute to open the
cage so he took a minute to get out here they had to shoo him out he was way in the corner all like
now steven you're a local yes i'm from southern california and i love san diego
oh that seems sarcastic
sweater it's real yeah
we'll leave you
any last message for san diego
stay stay sexy
bye get your own fucking saying
he steals our motto right in front of us and then we and then we walk off that's it well he just
ended the show
what if we were like that i mean we're going to be very soon look at this huge shows of people
going to be very soon look at this huge shows of people going to be very soon look at this huge shows of people
come to see a podcast this is nuts it's nuts it's so fucking crazy you guys what are you doing you
guys thank you for making this our job we love it it's so stupid i used to do like work on with
food stuff and that's really cool because i love food but then you have to write like a new recipe
for fucking um super bowl every year it was like what are you supposed to do with fucking buffalo
chicken what would you do there's no way to do it you have to do it you have to do it you have to do it
other way to make it a thing. Let's hear
some options right now. What would you do?
Chicken dip, buffalo and chicken splinters, buffalo and chicken fucking. No, let's change it up a little bit.
It's impossible.
Buffalo chicken pudding.
Cake.
Karen, you should be at buffalo pudding jello.
I don't know what it. Put a wing into a jello mold and then hide it in someone's mailbox.
It's a different. My thing is a different thing.
My point was that yesterday I was like, murder.
I can't find a murder.
Where's the murder?
I'm like, oh my God, my life is so much cooler now.
I was so happy that it was like, I love food, but I love true crime.
And I didn't realize it was going to be a job.
And then I was like, oh my God.
Because then you see all the food bloggers who are like, here's a new recipe for Thanksgiving thing.
New thing to put stuffing in.
Good luck.
Stop it.
Oh, hazelnuts, you blew my mind.
That was a rant.
You really went off on it.
I really did.
I mean, here's the problem.
We drove down from L.A. today.
Normally we have all. We have all kinds of travel anecdotes and funny, hilarious things of how this city is different than our city.
And we're just like, should we go back tonight or just stay?
Like, it's not. This is a little bit hometown-y for us.
We're just. Yeah.
This is a lot like. We're staying.
It's like L.A., but here's the thing.
People here don't give a shit.
And that rules.
It rules.
If you're in the industry, it's like in the chillest way possible.
You're not. You're not, like, in the industry and, like, really care.
You make movies about pot or whatever.
Like. Yeah, yeah.
I saw a guy that I. When we were driving through, and from the head up, he looked like my friend's dad.
And I was like, whoa.
But then from the neck down, he was dressed like a 19-year-old surfer.
And I'm like, that's not Christine's dad.
It's not. It can't be him.
He wouldn't have changed that much this quickly.
Maybe he went into the, um. What's it called when they hide you when you're in the car?
Witness protection.
Witness protection program.
There you go.
Thank you.
Wouldn't you call it when they hide you?
Oh.
This is my favorite murder, by the way.
Oh, yeah.
That's Karen Kilgara.
Good one.
Thank you.
Good point.
That's a really good point.
This is my favorite murder.
Yeah.
I wanted to say so after I tripped over the words witness protection program.
So. We are highly qualified true crime podcasters.
Yeah.
That's Georgia Hartstark.
Thank you.
Thank you.
We actually now like to say that to our audiences before we start.
Because we know that sometimes people bring an outsider.
We'll call them outsiders to the show.
Yeah.
Pony boys and soda pops and whatnot.
They bring them to the show.
And they sit here and they listen to us blather about fucking nothing.
And then like I'll say pockets and everyone starts screaming.
And they're like, what the fuck is going on?
And we feel bad for you and we're sorry.
And we know the majority of you are men.
And you're like, what is happening to my spouse?
Yeah.
This goes out to the Asher's too, by the way.
Dudes.
Yeah.
Dudes.
Yeah.
So yeah, we just, just so you know, like we talk about true crime, which is very dark
and horrifying, but then we're also make jokes, which is highly inappropriate.
And we know you don't need to let us know.
We know.
Yeah, we know.
If my mom's told me, then it, then I know.
It's in there.
And I'm purposely doing otherwise just to piss her off.
That's right.
So you don't get it.
Because we're always 14.
That's true.
Right?
Yeah.
Come on.
Let's do it.
Anything to wrap up?
Any other questions?
No.
No.
I guess that that's all I got.
You got those allergies going again?
Fucking, at least this time I brought a tissue and didn't have to blow my nose on my skirt
or the tablecloth, which I've done before.
I feel like you have blown your nose on every surface.
Of the, of anything in this country.
It's some of the major theaters in this country.
Just don't care anymore.
Yeah.
You know?
It's a great feeling.
Do you guys know a good allergist?
Please let me know.
Email it.
Email it.
And thank you.
In advance.
For helping me.
Do you want?
The one allergist.
Yeah, that's right.
I love reactive tissue.
That's not what allergists do.
Do you want to show everybody your shoes real quick?
Oh, sure.
These things.
You rarely wear them.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I love them.
I love it.
I love it.
I wear a high heel.
I fucking hate high heels.
And those look good.
Thank you.
They're only mildly painful.
Thank you.
They belong in the Gaslight District if anything does.
They do.
They really do.
Can I do the thing?
They're vintage.
They are.
And they're, that's why they're more comfortable is because someone wore them for years and
then I put them on my feet.
It's disgusting.
Some old Italian lady wore them for like 40 years.
They were her church shoes.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I'm letting it up in them.
Yeah.
The poor, I'm ruining the memory of, what's her name?
Oh, of, you mean Giancarla Rossetti?
Yeah.
Yes.
Whoops.
Sounds right.
So bad at improvising Italian women's names.
Yeah.
We've always said that about you.
I know.
I have to take that class at UCB.
Should we?
Sit down.
Yes.
Yeah.
Oh.
Yes.
Director's chairs.
Director's chairs in San Diego.
We're going to take a seat.
Oh.
Oh.
Here we go.
We're going to tell you guys what to do.
Man, I'm directing.
Directing.
Is that how it works?
I think so.
And then you just like, and then you just pack it up and walk the fuck away.
That's the nice part.
We get to keep these.
Did you hear?
Excuse that.
So just now.
Yeah.
Here.
Okay.
To go with the rug.
Okay.
Beverages.
Did you guys just see me trying to talk into this?
I just tried to go like this.
Beverages are opened and that's, that's how you know the show's starting, is it?
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I'm trying to talk into it.
Right now the sound guy's watching you hold a bottle of water that close to a mic.
He's like, "I'll kill her."
Fair enough.
Consummate.
Professionals.
Professionals.
Guys, someday I'm going to get some tights that are the same color as my dress.
Or maybe ones you just don't notice.
And then I won't bring all of George's hair with me on stage.
Oh, I thought you said George's hair.
I'm so sorry.
Because George's hair.
This shit.
Yeah.
I didn't know I was losing all my hair like that all over you.
Oh, yeah.
Clumps of it are coming out.
I just didn't want to talk about it.
What if I just didn't know?
Yeah.
And then you just said it and I was like, "Oh, that's so funny."
Who goes first?
It's me.
Okay.
Guys.
Are you ready?
Yeah.
I'm ready.
I'm ready.
I'm ready.
I'm ready.
Are you ready?
I'm ready.
Are you ready?
I'm ready.
I'm ready.
I'm ready.
I'm ready.
I'm ready.
Yeah.
It's time.
It's time to talk about all the things you're not supposed to talk about.
And we're back.
The gas lamp quarter.
There we go.
That's the one.
Well, we're over "Therapize," so we're in the gaslight quarter and we're aware of it.
I should have known that one.
But whatever.
What are you gonna do?
The gaslight quarter.
Oh, yeah.
It's intense, but it's really fun.
It is.
Now, if I remember this correctly, we stayed in San Diego because we were in like a high-rise
hotel.
Yeah.
By the harbor.
Yeah.
With a gorgeous view.
Yeah.
We didn't go home that night.
That would have been dangerous.
No.
In my room, it felt very like an '80s psychological thriller.
It was very blue and white with huge windows overlooking like the harbor.
Oh, like a. It was a. It was like Miami Vice episode.
Like a very special. Yeah.
Like I should have tried to ask like the bellhop to get me a kilo of cocaine.
You know what I mean?
Really get into it.
I think we've only done really rad stories in San Diego too.
Like remember the one that you did about the guy who drove a tank?
Yes.
Stole a tank?
I remember when that happened.
Yeah.
But I mean, not the way those guys. That was like, you know. Yeah.
That was a whole room full of people's hometown.
That's the luckiest story you can tell.
Totally.
Well, I think the one I do this time around, like it's one of those stories where I'm like,
okay, I decided to do it and now I have to wait for a live show, but I can't wait to
tell you.
And if you pick it before I do it, I'm going to lose my mind.
So I just really want to just do it now, but I have to save it for San Diego.
Yep.
I know.
We have to get real strategic.
We've learned a lot over the years.
At what point did podcasting start feeling like a real job instead of a lucky accident?
Say it with me.
The network.
The network.
Oh, yeah.
Right?
Absolutely.
But I was like, when touring became nonstop, we got into a touring loop and we were just
never not touring.
Right.
And that was when it was, I think we got, I was going to say strung out, but I mean
like wrung out.
Yeah.
I mean, I think it just like, you can't do that much work.
Yeah.
And traveling, especially because I had left my old life of doing food stuff.
Because I was so sick of traveling to like eat.
Oh, yeah.
You guys had to travel all over.
Yeah.
It was just part of it.
And I was like, okay, I want something else where I can be home with my cat.
And then it's suddenly like, guess what?
You're going to be away even more.
And Vince is coming with you.
So you have to leave him with Steven, which is obviously fine, but disruptive.
But at least Vince got to come.
Yeah.
It was just hard.
You know, it was just like, there was, the pile got higher and higher than the book.
We were doing a lot of stuff at one time.
I think this was like a real peak.
It peaks out here in the next couple of years.
And then look, we didn't know what the world didn't know, COVID was waiting for us to sit
and shut up that's right I couldn't have come at a better time I'm sorry to say it because I know
it's it's definitely a place of privilege but I felt yeah like it saved my brain I got to spend
Elvis's last like year and a half with him every day which was like so meaningful to me the whole
experience was just so so absolutely surreal it was like all these things were happening and then
it's like shutting down the world yeah the world was like sit down and shut up yeah take a seat
yeah and we're like okay and then we're like okay and we won't get up for about six more years right
and I'm atrophied my butt yeah all right your story is a fucking classic and it's so good
let's get into it shall we yes please okay here's Karen's story about Betty Broderick
and guess who I'm going to talk about Betty Broderick
I was so excited when uh I put together well really when Stephen sent me Stephen sends us
like lists of choices that we could have every city we go to he's very thorough um and each get
different choices so we don't overlap it's a wonderful system and when I saw Betty Broderick's
name on my list I was like oh fuck yeah I forgot she lived down there I have seen every single
fucking Forensic Files 2020 Nightline every single I've seen this woman all my life the
full the full house episode she was in she's seen them all I'm saying that because I don't know who
she is off the top of my head so when I find out I'm gonna be like oh I'm really bummed I made that
job Bob Hope Young Comedian special where she nailed that seven minute set I mean she's just
been in my life no you do know her I bet I'm sure but I don't know names um well I'll just
talk about it but I got that'd be great all of my most of my information from of course uh Wikipedia
God bless him I use them daily won't give him a dime just kidding donate
that's what my father used to say when I would walk in and he would be watching PBS at night
and I'd be like what are you watching he'd be like Nova for free that was his big brag I've never
done oh my God hilarious we are he's never listening to this episode he can't we have
to burn this the second that we're done uh-huh um but I got some really good information from
a podcast called once upon a crime that you guys probably listened to has hosted by Esther Ludlow
Elizabeth Ann Broderick grew up in the New York City suburb of Eastchester she was the third of
six children born to a devout Roman two devout Roman Catholic parents her mother was Irish American and
her was Italian American that's a bad combination by the way I don't know if are there any Irish
Italians here because they're all it's not good it's not right you're a lunatic right they're
screaming super repressed but then you also scream all the time like nothing makes sense
the vasiglias were very strict parents um uh and as Betty later recalled she was trained to act as
a housewife since the day she was born uh go to Catholic schools be careful with dating until you
are a Catholic man support him while he works be blessed in your later years with beautiful
grandchildren that was the past hard pass no what's my other option uh I guess like snort
cocaine in a small room until you die great yes yes I picked that one okay she graduates from East
Chester High School in 1965 and that same year when she was 17 she traveled to Indiana with her
friend to go watch Notre Dame
really we're in San Diego
pretend you're from San Diego
play it cool just kidding go go date Notre Dame
um she goes to see a Notre Dame football game with her friend and there she meets a man named
Dan Broderick he was born in Pittsburgh he was the eldest son of a large Irish Catholic family
oof all Irish Catholic you're done for that's what I'm from
not good okay he wasn't as tall or athletic as the boys that Betty was used to dating because she
was gorgeous you know like uh had her choice of men but he lavished her with attention from the
second that they met he doted on her um so uh she graduates from the College of Mount St Vincent in
the Bronx uh where she majored in early childhood education um and she and Dan date and then on
12, 1969, they are married. They honeymoon in the Caribbean, and very soon after they return
from the honeymoon, she finds out she's pregnant. That's right. You guys. You Italians and you
Irish. Just get started right away. Get those babies. Don't get to know each other at all.
That's exactly it. She's like, what's your favorite movie? It's amazing.
So he was finishing up his medical degree at Cornell, and they're so poor that they have to
move into the dorms together. There's a reenactment that I watched recently, and it's
two actors playing the two of them. I'm sure it's great. It's amazing. It's such good acting,
and some really great backding also, because they walk into this dorm room.
Backding? Is that a thing? It's my thing. I love it.
You can really get. You can do a lot with your back, if you're a good backder.
I'm going to go to backing class.
You should. You should. Because that's how you become a great extra.
Yeah, I've done that.
Right? You really let people know something's going on that way.
There's definitely me walking away in the background in a camera in TV shows and shit.
For real?
Just walking away. Walking past and walking away.
What do you mean?
I was an extra.
Oh, oh.
Oh.
I thought something happened.
When? When did you get this part?
Well, it was on Full House.
Sorry. Go on. That was irrelevant.
Wait, was that a 90s thing that you did when you moved to LA? Like, moved into the city?
Clueless, the TV show.
Yes. Dharma and Greg.
Dharma and Greg?
Yeah.
Did you. Were you one of the people in their living room?
Yeah, just in the corner. You know how they have someone in the corner hiding every episode?
You guys didn't know that? It's like a secret.
I'm just a girl hider in the living room.
Yeah.
And then some stupid shit. Other stupid shit.
Well, congratulations.
Thank you. It was really a highlight of my life.
I bet.
Did you get to wait for like 18 hours?
18 hours.
Yeah.
Eat hard-boiled eggs and. Backed it up.
Right.
Okay.
Excuse me.
Goodbye.
Oh, and Joan of Arcadia.
Whoa. Deep cut.
Yeah.
Who was Joan of Arcadia?
It was. Oh. You mean the actress?
No, the storyline.
Like, just tell me the whole series arc.
Really quick.
I was on it. I didn't watch it.
You didn't write it?
I didn't write it.
I don't understand how any of it works.
Okay.
In this reenactment. Okay.
Betty and Dan walk in and they have to move into a legit dorm room with a married couple and she's pregnant.
It's the saddest thing I've ever seen.
Like, one of those dorm rooms with the cement blocks as walls where you can't, like, put up your poster unless you get that special gum adhesive.
Like, dark. Dark times for Dan.
Dan and Betty.
Mm-hmm.
So, um, their daughter Kim is born in 1970 and a second daughter, Lee, is born the next year.
Guys.
Irish twins.
Um. Dan finishes medical school and then tells Betty he's decided that he's. No. What?
Now. Sorry.
I didn't mean stop. Go.
You meant, like, you don't like where this is headed?
No. Yeah.
Dan's now going to get his law degree.
Oh, okay.
Because he's decided that he's going to be a medical malpractice lawyer.
That that's where the money's at.
Um, which he was all about.
And so, uh, he had to get a student loan.
He goes to Harvard Law.
Um, and Betty starts working.
She's two kids and working so that he can go through law school.
Honey.
Um, after four years, uh, he graduates and he's hired by a very high-status law firm here in San Diego.
So the whole, he moves the whole family to Coral Reef.
Nobody?
No. Nothing.
Did I cut and paste that wrong?
Or did he literally move them onto a coral reef?
And that's nothing that. I feel like a lot of these, the places where bad things happen, they change the name of the place immediately.
To just to be like, you can't find it, you weirdo tourist.
Oh, that used to be called Knife Town.
But we had to change the name.
Bad things happen.
All right.
But now he's got this high-status job.
So she, she doesn't have to work anymore.
Right.
So she gets to be the housewife that she's always been told that she has to be.
Um, so Dan, um, the more successful he becomes at this law firm and he's very successful, the longer and longer his hours become.
And, uh, because he's, you know, he tells Betty he's out whining and dining clients and working really hard.
Well, she of course is getting pissed and, um, you know, she makes dinners.
And he, he misses them and she kind of starts ranting to the kids talking about their father and he's not here.
And, you know, like really she's, she always had this habit of kind of.
when she got mad she didn't care what she said in front of the kids that is a ticket to therapy
for those kids romance town 100 um but she's feeling intensely unappreciated she's caring for
two small children she's in this house by herself you know there's no adults around she doesn't like
the family dynamic essentially so at one point she convinces or they go to i shouldn't say she
convinced him they went to marriage encounter which was this catholic marriage retreat in the
70s or early 80s marriage encounter my parents not only did my parents go no my parents went
and they had a sticker on the back of my dad's volkswagen marriage encounter as if like we're
good we're doing it with the lord's help oh my god yeah big time it just sounds like a swingers
retreat
for people who believe in ufos how dare you
doesn't it marriage encounter like whenever i'm like you want to have an encounter with
your fucking partner you don't want to have like a just be something like for people who believe in
ufos marriage encounter yeah swinging with aliens that's right it's marriage encounter
yeah an encounter is just like
the least romantic marriage word yeah i don't get it it's um i'm gonna change that name marriage
passing experience what they did at marriage encounter was you'd have to write your uh spouse
a long letter talking about how you felt about the marriage and when i was like
barb when i was like eight i found my parents letters no karen i love little karen she's such
a bad girl little karen little karen didn't wasn't good with boundaries but little karen didn't raise
herself someone no i actually didn't read i started to read them and it started with my moms and it
was like dear jim you're this and you're that and then i was like ew this is none of my business
good for you you are good with boundaries though you were like here it is i'm creeped out by love
um
i mean they were they were married for like 45 years so marriage encounter works sign up today
yeah my parents didn't go divorced quickly one of them fast divorces yeah okay in dan zander he
talks about how he knows he's a workaholic and he knows he's not being a good husband or a good
father but he has these financial goals that he really wants to reach and betty's letter is all
about being alone in the marriage um it must have been
um it must have been um it must have been um it must have been um
an okay experience for them because after soon after they had their third uh third child a boy
named dan um so at this point betty has two preschoolers and an infant at home um and she
started to feel like she's losing her identity um meanwhile dan is so successful and doing so well
um he actually became slightly locally famous because he represented one of the families of
the victims of uh brent spencer the i don't like monday school shooter
so he was yeah he became well kind of well known wow um uh so by the fall of 1991 he's doing so well
he leaves his original law firm and opens his own and he gets this big fan these big fancy offices
in a high rise and he asked betty to redecorate the offices and she comes in and she kills it
it's gorgeous everyone is like amazed and it's all very high status and like
70s i bet it's so 70s oh my god the brass and the chrome
the smoked glass can you see it ferns everywhere ferns she's like we'll have a fern garden over
here macrame everywhere and armpit hair over here uh oh no sorry this is 81 rainbows neon rainbows
and a nagel in the entryway um okay so dan buys a two-seater jaguar and betty loses her fucking
shit hell yeah right it's his dream car
but she's like you clearly have no interest in being part of this family
although to be fair back in the 80s they were like throw them in the trunk or like
put them on the front seat together that's true don't worry about seatbelts grab that roof yeah
meanwhile betty drove a suburban and her personalized license plate read load them up
so she was like yeah she was doing that mother thing my god sexism exists i mean in the 80s i
don't know
doesn't anymore but she was like she was playing the part and they were super rich like she bought
they bought stuff she had a spending problem they said and she bought shit all the time
the kids had everything they could possibly want she bought designer clothes she was like super
into the way she looked but she was getting really neurotic because she was starting to
gain weight and she was getting older and she was starting to gain weight and she felt like
she was losing her looks and so she was starting to get like um compulsive kind of reaction i'm not
analyzing her i don't i don't know her but um but but she does sound a lot like when i read through
the story i was like did she take diet pills because she acts a lot like me when i was on
diet pills it's like when you start yelling at somebody and then you just kind of can't stop
yelling or you're in your mind you're like i don't feel this way anymore and yet my mouth
is still angry i don't know what to do um it's a theory it's not a fact so okay
so the fights are beginning to escalate so when dan would come home late from work she'd lock him
out of the house he'd have to throw rocks at the kids windows so they could let him in and then if
they did that betty would yell at the kids that was the worst part these kids were right in the
middle of this awful marriage and they were they got screamed at constantly by betty by betty being
angry at dan she would scream at them because they were the only ones there she would scream
about how awful he was and she started cursing and like getting really foul mouthed which i don't have
but it's not cool around five-year-olds um it works for me did janet have a mouth on her oh
fuck yeah and then she'd be like do as i say not as i do don't curse do as i say not as i do as we're
fucking jam for everything saying as she took a big drag of a joy um so uh here's this fucked up
thing she would when dan wouldn't come home from work she would sit the kids down and tell them they were
getting divorced and then all the kids would get super upset and then she'd go now since we're
getting divorced which parent do you want to live with and they it would be super upsetting and then
they it wasn't until dan would come home from work that he would be like no we're not getting
divorced it's everyone everything's fine so it was that um in in this story i always had that
thing of like you know this story has been in in kind of like in society in our minds i guess first
since it happened because at first it was like the fucking crazy wife you know it was crazy and
then there was the second wave of or was she driven crazy yeah and there's lots of ways to
take it but when i hear stories like that it's just like whatever's happening that is not fair
and that control yourself figure out a way to control yourself because you are that's abuse
you're abusing four children repeatedly um so uh and the and the other problem was that when
they would fight he would just ignore her which as i was typing it i was getting furious because it
was like it like her she already had an anger problem and he would just pretend like nothing
was happening and like sit down and eat dinner dan but he's irish catholic and that's how we do it
shut it down inside um so then it in the fall of 1983 he hires a woman named linda uh colkena
to be his legal assistant linda before
that had been a delta airlines flight attendant had no legal training bet she's hot she was she
was a very homely girl with large glasses right and large spanks no that's not true at all in fact
betty overheard dan describing her uh linda as being beautiful at a christmas party and lost
her fucking shit of course right and immediately became convinced that the two of them were having
an affair and she would harangue dan about it all the time and ask him about it and he was like you're
crazy you're crazy you're crazy gaslamping her um yes right you know how it is in the gaslight
district he would take her to the gaslight district and gaslamp the fuck out of her um
that november um she threw they had their both of their birthdays were in november so she threw a
huge gourmet meal he didn't fucking show up for it what a dick and that night she
you know attempted suicide very very light cuts on her wrists that when he came home he bandaged
them and put her to bed and took care of her um but she was in clearly in a very very bad place so
she started hinting around at christmas time she starts hinting around that she wants an
this emerald ring for christmas um and on christmas day when he hands her the velvet
jewelry box and she opens it up it isn't the one she wanted it's smaller and less expensive
and she throws a fucking tantrum and like shuts
christmas down uh-huh so priorities you know what i mean like you fight for what you need
emotionally i mean maybe it was ugly we don't know i mean it's an emerald what the fuck do you want
yeah what are you a fucking wizard of oz what are you gonna what are you gonna go to the emerald
city and fucking get your hair curled like dorothy who are we down so and this whole time these
fights are escalating um uh he he actually moved out after after that he packed his bags after she
ruined christmas moved out after two weeks she was like the children can't be are inconsolable
and so he moved back well that's healthy for them yeah it's healthy for all of them yeah um
uh so let's see this is a very odd point the the the straw that broke the camel's back
for daniel
was during one of these horrible fights betty threw a bottle of gel at him like hair gel hair gel
yeah was he really into his hair gel i mean it was 1985 everybody was really into hair gel
you didn't it was actually a city mandate that you had to wear a shit ton of hair gel remember
that like what was it like malibu something and it looked like jello when you just yeah
and through your hair yeah la looks thank you thank you i mean that's one brand
it was what i was thinking of to be fair that shit smelled like um bad chemicals like paste
and chemicals like chemicals like they didn't even put anything a flowery smell in it they
were like what if we kind of sent this like gasoline and then the kids can put it in their
hair that would be fun everything was flammable back then why is my hair falling out again
okay so look listen look at my moves out
it's february 1985 he buys a house his own house betty becomes increasingly unhinged and
she one night kim the oldest daughter comes home she's in high school and they she and betty get
into a fight because she came home late she drives kim over to um dan's house and leaves her on the
front porch and drives away doesn't check if dan's home he wasn't home he was working late
and so by the time dan did get home it was like 11 o'clock at night and she's just sitting on the
porch crying
so she starts living with dan well then um a little while later uh kim and dan are out
having pizza for dinner one night and when they come home um their younger brother i think it was
eight-year-old dan was sitting on the porch crying she had left him on the porch and nobody
was home and he was eight years old um so eventually dan got the custody of all four kids
um she basically went and dropped all of them off and was like this
you deal with it for a while which listen for a woman that has raised four children
entirely herself you go okay sure custody not awful yeah sure custody or do fucking something
dan um dan drives away in his jag sorry i can't hear you um okay basically their divorce was so
acrimonious and horrible it became famous um they got divorced it was finalized in 1989 uh one of the
more famous divorce cases in the united states um and part of it was because part of uh one of the
arguments was involving the fact that women who worked and put their husband through school um how
that would affect uh the alimony and yeah and the outcome of the divorce ruling they get it all
i mean yeah you'd like to think wouldn't you um
betty starts leaving incredibly profane answering machine messages uh i didn't i don't know if starts
but i mean she she was uh she was trying to like kind of contact him and make him understand
how fucking livid she was all the time and she couldn't do it so they have hours and hours of
her answering machine messages and it's fucking nuts i want to listen it's not good um she she
there were restraining orders she would break into that house and like go through his shit and try to
find stuff finally he admitted that he in fact all along had been having an affair with linda
since 1983 no one here shocked i mean yeah not good um one time she went into the house the kids
were there so she would go to dan's house the kids i think at that point both girls lived there
and the boys would live there sometimes she walked in and said there was a pie on the counter and she
and uh she said oh what's that and one of the boys the younger boys not thinking was like oh linda
made that for dad it's his favorite boston cream pie and she picked up the pie and went upstairs
and she went into the bedroom and like just started scooping out the the middle of the pie
and throwing it on the walls smearing it on the bed smearing it on his clothes i kind of love that
though
i mean you can do it you can do it yeah but was she wrong does it ultimately yes
it's better than guns but it's not good um
okay so they get uh they on april 22nd 1989 dan and linda get married
and i think oh sorry steven shit we've got several pictures that we need to show you hold on
so can you show an early picture because that's linda and that's dan no photos oh sorry the first
one was um betty and dan at their wedding okay this is linda and dan oh she's pretty he's 42 and
she's 28 linda looked basically like uh betty looked when she was that age so her whole obsession
was she'd basically just been replaced she went in she did all the work she put him through two
schools
as kids she raised his kids and then she got replaced um all right so oh the day they got
married a family friend stayed with betty to make sure that she didn't go and wreck their wedding
that's how extreme her behavior was yay so seven months after they were married betty broderick
drove to dan's house at 1041 cypress avenue in the marston hills neighborhood of san diego
and using her daughter lee's key to enter the house while the couple was asleep she shot and
killed them execution style both of them yes oh my i think i remember this now yeah right you do
because do you have her arrest photo steven oh that is one smug motherfucker she was not bummed
there's barry again oh my god barry barry's back barry is the zealig of san diego oh my god
she is most certainly not bummed
wow that's scary that's so scary i think my mom had that shirt i swear to god i think my mom had
that haircut um oh my god that's so sad yeah she she did that and then she basically um called her
daughters and told them that she did it and then and then turned herself into the police
um that was awful yeah it's it's horrifying and she did it uh two days before her 40th
second birthday um okay so two bullets hit linda in the head and chest killing her instantly
one bullet hit dan in the chest um and it looked like he was reaching for the phone
she had taken the phone and answering machine out of the room previously when she'd broken into the
house so that that came up later because it was entirely premeditated yeah she said that she went
over there she didn't go over there to kill them she just she just went over there to talk i think
yeah instead of her mouth
gun chats yeah you know
meanwhile she was getting sixteen thousand dollars a month alimony
i know right she was living in a at the time six hundred and fifty thousand dollar la jolla
beachfront property holy she had two cars and she had a live-in like or not live in
like a full-time boyfriend a full-time boyfriend
uh-oh
care and love this is how you do it i wanna get a full-time boyfriend
thank you well she doesn't want no part-time lover that's right call megan trainer i've got a hit for
her um but this is so fucked up sorry so sorry this is the part where the stranger gets very
upset yeah just so you know yeah
he gets shot he reaches through the phone there's no phone there he doesn't die instantly
and in fact he said he looked at betty and said to her okay you shot me i'm dead
those were his last words pretty fucking dark um yeah okay uh so basically okay now i just skipped
to the page look at that insanity okay so she pleads not guilty to two counts of murder
um and you know what that means well at her first trial so the first trial starts in october
22nd of 1990 and it was all of course all over the media um it was on uh broadcast live on local
television uh which i god i would have loved to watch that now could you imagine like staying home
from school and just like nine years old and i'm like mom i'm not going to school i feel sick
hear ye hear ye oh shit so at that um she testifies she didn't intend to kill her husband
she said she went to their house planning to kill herself that's what it was she went there
saying she was going to kill herself in front of them and then when she went in she has no
memory of what happened after that um uh and she says that he harassed her during the bitter divorce
left her emotionally and financially ruined you know financially ruined with your fucking
thousands and thousands of dollars of uh alimony her first trial
and uh in a deadlock jury what yeah um 10 jurors um reached the verdict of murder to hold out for
manslaughter guys do they know what that means well i think maybe some of them were like oh i put
my husband through college as well and that motherfucker lives in yeah west covina now
with someone named daniel
um they call her danny it's not cool not cool i think she roller skates for a living anyway i'm
really angry um so when she's waiting her second trial she's involved in a jailhouse scuffle with
sheriff's deputies i don't know they started it uh they allege that she uh injured three of them
and smeared feces around her jail cell
so i mean i think she just kind of went full crazo like in jail she was just like i you know
what i gotta be me i'm just gonna do this thing later days later i don't have to carpool or do
anything what will i do with my time okay so her second trial begins october 15th 1991 the
prosecution argues for finding a first degree murder uh saying that she carried out a cold
blooded execution um and the defense again
says it should be voluntary manslaughter because she was driven to the slaying by years of
psychological abuse and intimidation but under the cross-examination she just oh so she says
that when she goes into the house on this trial that she walked in and went into an altered state
of consciousness um and doesn't remember pulling the trigger um so they play back
and those answering machine messages where she's fucking going crazy um and at one point she
actually talks about getting her son to go beat up her husband his father um in december
5th 1991 superior court judge uh thomas j wheelan instructs the jury to consider options
of involuntary manslaughter voluntary manslaughter and second and first degree murders the jurors
deliberate and they come back to find betty broderick guilty of two counts of second degree
murder plus two counts of using a firearm in the commission of a felony um she just recently
was up for a parole no way uh-huh and um it was the second it's the second time she's
been up for parole and on that podcast that i mentioned um they play a tape of the four
kids and two of them want her to stay in jail and two of them want her to get out man it
is it ultimately the whole thing is heartbreaking there's kind of it's bad there's nothing worse
than that but because these children whatever was going on between those adults these children had
no control and nothing to do with it and their lives got so fucked up because of it obviously
i mean they ended up doing fine but the idea of that that they're they're still in the middle of
this and they're still stuck in the middle of of that that horrible life it's so shitty to end on
a nice note um i believe it was in 1992 they made a made for tv movie that meredith baxter
bernie starred in and was nominated for an emmy so let's focus on the positive that was
brady broderick everybody wow sorry no my papers
and we're back karen any updates uh just a couple betty broderick died this year
on may 8th of natural causes at the age of 78 she was still in jail she would have been up for parole
again in 2032 and just a reminder that the second season of the tv show dirty john was about this
story and amanda pete played betty and she was so fucking incredible and it was so fucking good it
was unbelievable it was a joy to watch yeah all right well great job thank you now let's get into
yes
finding the perfect holiday gift for your loved ones is a great feeling
finding it on sale is even better this black friday give a gift they'll love with aura frames
i have given aura frames as a gift i would say at this point maybe 10 times
and people go crazy it's such a good gift because it's a living photo album that just sits and
scrolls so you're always looking at memories and times and birthdays and there's stuff to talk about
and it's just everyone loves it give it a try because you'll see it's the perfect gift
aura is the number one digital frame loved by millions of families and their black friday cyber
monday deal is the best of the year for a limited time visit oraframes.com and get up to 50 off
select frames plus an additional five dollars off your order with the promo code mfm that's
auraframes.com
promo code mfm support the show by mentioning us at checkout terms and conditions apply goodbye
black friday is here and pandora jewelry has you covered enjoy up to 40 off select styles
in store and online now through december 1st explore jewelry designed to last a lifetime
like unique engravable pieces festive charms lab-grown diamonds and more made for the people
who inspire you who've been there through it all give a piece that says exactly what words can't
pandora jewelry more than a gift shop
in store or online at pandora.net exclusions apply goodbye my favorite murder is brought to you by
yellow jackets on paramount plus the emmy nominated series about a 90s girls soccer
team stranded in the wilderness after a plane crash returns for its final season and this season
the yellow jackets are finally coming home but a swarm of endless questions awaits how did they
survive what really happened out there and what did they do to finally escape featuring melanie
christina ricci tawny cypress and hillary swank catch the final season of yellow jackets
streaming november 20th on paramount plus goodbye sometimes being a little salty is completely
justified pair your salty side with something sweet with the new salted caramel flavor from
cachava cachava is a whole body shake with plant-based protein fiber greens and other
nutrients to help fill nutritional gaps just two scoops provide complete nutrition your body
craves with protein fiber greens and so much more
their new salty caramel flavor combines sweet caramel with a little salt so you get that salty
sweet balance along with the nutrition cachava is known for when the day demands your salty side
fuel it with plant-based protein that actually tastes delicious i really do love cachava and i
really do think it does taste delicious for getting you through the morning filling in the
gap if you just need some protein and you need some vitamins it's such a nice little treat it's
such an easy way to get everything you need and it tastes good too which is just huge bonus so
embrace your salty side
go to cachava.com and use code mfm for 15 off your first order that's cachava k-a-c-h-a-v-a.com
code mfm goodbye so okay um this isn't a murder because i'm gonna do whatever the fuck i want no
uh instead i'm doing the cult i most likely would have joined heaven's gate
yes yes yes this is the exact
same story of when steven sent it to me i was like murdered girl murdered girl this girl got my
heaven's gate and i was like oh my god steven i'm so angry at you that you didn't send me
heaven's gate that we're going to have a long talk after this show
after this one and before the next one he gave he did me a solid it's so good i can't wait and
listen wait maybe i maybe i won't yell at him because it's gonna be fun to not have had to do
the work listen they had a lot of beliefs and i had like six pages of their beliefs
oh yeah i was like crossing shit out you know what i mean it was like all right any offhand
that you can remember like um besides nikes and jello shots well they did this thing where they
they you know did the gave up all the jello shots why don't i listen more that was so funny
i want to join that cult you're trying to do your thing all right i'll tell you all about it
you know what let me tell you about it okay actually all right marshall
Applewhite.
He's the son of a Presbyterian minister, so already got it together.
He begins his foray, copied and pasted that.
No, you did it.
In the early 70s into biblical prophecy.
He was fired from the University of St. Thomas in Houston, Texas,
because of an alleged homosexual relationship with one of his students.
That's wrong.
Which part?
All of it.
Oh, you guys didn't know what we're like?
Okay, so he goes, at some point he goes into a psychiatric institution.
Maybe it's after this.
And in March 1972, and he meets Bonnie Nettles.
She's a 44-year-old married nurse, music teacher from Texas.
She's super into theosophy and. Theosophy.
Theosophy.
Yeah, we know theosophy.
Did I copy and paste that wrong, too?
No, it's theology and philosophy mixed together.
We know what it is.
It's kind of like. Where did mine. Okay.
Don't laugh at me.
Okay.
Laugh at me.
It's fine.
Biblical prophecy, all that shit.
She's super into it.
And they. So they kind of become really close friends pretty immediately when he gets out of the hospital.
They go on a six-month-long road trip across the United States.
They start calling. They call themselves Bo and Peep.
Sorry.
So, like, inside this mental hospital, this nurse is going around, like, handing out little cups of pills.
But she's like, I don't know.
There's something about you.
I just want to. I think we should be really good friends.
The thing about you is that your face is always in a Bible.
And you're super into the possibility that extraterrestrials exist.
Oh, almost a marriage encounter situation.
Okay.
Yeah.
I like it.
I like it.
I like it.
It was on my mind.
Yeah.
So he said he later recalled that he felt like he had known her for a long time and that he thought they had met in a past life.
And she told him that their meeting had been foretold by extraterrestrials and persuaded him that he had a divine assignment.
She was the nurse at the mental hospital?
That's what she said.
She was behind the counter.
Maybe she was lying.
And we don't know.
Not right.
So by June. June of 1974, they study religious stuff.
They're into religion, sci-fi, theology.
And they conclude that they had been chosen to fill the biblical prophecies and they had been given higher level minds than other people.
I want a relationship like that where you're like, you meet a person, you guys are sitting in Applebee's.
I mean, we would be sitting in Applebee's and you're just like, this isn't just normal chemistry.
This is alien shit happening between us.
Well, that's every fucking couple in the beginning.
They're so annoying.
It's like, we're meant to be and we're supposed to be.
And like, this is fate.
And it's like, you just met at a party.
You like the other one's smell and pheromones and you just don't understand it.
She looks like your third grade teacher and he is taller than you.
So it's all working out.
That's love, baby.
That's love.
Or maybe you're aliens.
Or maybe you're both Bible prophecy aliens.
We don't know for sure.
We shouldn't judge.
Listen.
Look.
They wrote a pamphlet that described Jesus' reincarnation as a Texan.
Sound familiar, Texas?
That's where Marshall Applewhite was from.
Maybe it's him.
Oh.
Or it could be a quarterback of the Dallas Cowboys.
Who knows?
You got a team right.
The Cowboys.
I did.
What was the other one?
I think I called the Denver Rattlesnakes.
They didn't like it.
It's not a team.
It's not a thing.
They didn't like it when I called their team a rattlesnake.
Oh, well.
It happens.
We know.
We don't care.
Okay.
They said they were two witnesses described in the end period, I wrote, and called themselves
the UFO 2.
Oh, my God.
They have the worst fucking names for themselves.
Get out of here, Bo and Peep.
You already have a name.
Already I have a better one.
The 2FO.
Come on.
The 2FOs.
How about the. Well, that is good.
That was off the top of my head.
No, she's good.
But also, how about this lifelong rule?
Don't give yourself nicknames.
It doesn't work that way.
And if you're gonna, extra two rest reels.
Like, come on.
It's so easy.
Get creative.
Two live crew of aliens.
I just want to be a part of it.
That was good.
That was good.
I mean. So they thought they would be killed and then restored to life and transported onto a spaceship
in an event called. The demonstration.
The marriage demonstration.
Aside from giving up their earthly possessions, which is like what every cult does.
Which would be like, we know.
They had an institute of strict no sex, no human level relationship, no socializing rule
without anyone outside of the cult.
They didn't call themselves a cult, I bet.
But I'm calling them that.
Sorry, so. So there's people in their cult now.
And they also don't. They're not boyfriend and girlfriend.
No.
Because he was having. He's not her full-time boyfriend.
It's not like that with them.
Well, he. I don't. They don't really say, but he had the homosexual relationship, so I think maybe he was gay
and then they. That's not his jam.
Maybe not.
But they don't talk about that.
Okay.
These kinds of decisions. It sounds like he wasn't like a dick cult leader.
He was kind of like, you want to be here and I'm not like, can I make you. He was a chill cult leader.
He's like a cool, chill cult leader.
It's about UFOs, which sounds fucking fun.
And I can't promise I wouldn't have joined this cult.
Just to see what they were like, or maybe gone to a meeting.
I mean, sounds pretty cool.
You like to check stuff out.
Yeah, if I believe in anything in this fucking life, it's aliens, so. For real?
Yeah.
Oh, I hate aliens.
I know.
I don't think we've ever seen. You know what?
I'm not going there.
Okay.
But a couple of other things I was like, yeah, yeah, that's what I thought late at night
when I can't sleep.
No.
Definitely.
Like, where do giraffes come from?
They're aliens.
No, they're not.
It just happened a long time ago.
No, it's just evolution.
It happens.
The small berries top of tall trees, you get a long neck.
It's not aliens.
Yeah, but they were. I totally agree.
Now we're fighting about evolution.
Well, I agree.
I disagree.
Anyways.
Okay, so these decisions like this were always left up to the members, and eight of them,
including Marshall, decided to voluntarily get castrated because they were like,
no sex, seriously.
It's quite a commitment.
Tis.
It's like a tattoo.
You're going to have it forever.
I'm going to ask a question and reveal a deep ignorance of mine.
Okay.
No, it's not getting your dick cut off.
Okay.
If I had been wrong, I would have sounded so disgusted.
No, I've always. Every time I hear it, I. I just think someone gets Ken dolled.
It's a little. It's just a little. That's not it.
It's a little snip.
It's just a little snip of the. That's a vasectomy.
Wait.
No.
It's the balls go, right?
I think it's like a cat, right?
When you like neuter a cat.
Sir, you there.
Do you know?
Dick.
It's balls.
It's balls.
It's balls, everybody.
Thank you.
Sorry.
You are so cool about that.
Sorry.
Cool as a fucking cucumber, this guy.
Sorry to bring cucumbers into this conversation.
He's like, I hate podcasts now.
He's like, my wife, I'm really worried about her.
Castrated.
Where did. I ended on castrated.
Yep.
Okay.
Here's where I would have quit the cult.
Oh.
They were also really into the master cleanse.
Meaning, they drink nothing.
We've all fucking done it.
I'm going to do the master cleanse with me.
Lemonade.
Cayenne pepper and maple syrup.
And we're all like, I'm drinking every night.
I did it for one day.
Yeah.
Not even.
I did it from morning until my friend was like, hey, do you want to go to happy hour?
And I was like, yes.
Literally ate cheeseburgers and beer that night.
I was like, I'll do this again.
How'd that work out the next day?
I mean, my body at that point was a mess.
So, like, thank you.
Because that thing is, I think I did it the whole thing.
Did you?
I love a good starve.
I'm a starver binger.
That's my jam.
I just want to. I just want to keep on losing and gaining the same 40 pounds for the rest of my life.
I'm good at it.
I think I have all the sizes of clothes.
I'm comfortable in every fucking pair of pants I have.
Thoughts?
Feelings?
I just. How do you do full-time master cleanse?
That's like you. So, they just always had diarrhea.
I think broth.
Oh.
I think you got. The answer is always broth, isn't it?
All right.
All right.
All right.
It doesn't matter.
It doesn't matter.
Listen.
Call them.
I don't. Look.
Look and listen and call them.
Throughout the late 70s and 80s, membership grew.
They are described. The people who joined it were, quote, long-time truth seekers or spiritual hippies who had
long since believed in attempting to, quote, find themselves through spiritual means, calming
faiths in a sort of cultural milieu.
Is that how you say that?
That's how you say it.
Well into the mid-80s.
So, essentially, they were people who should. Like, now would have just gone to burnout.
Burning Man.
But back then, they had nothing.
Do you know how many castrations Burning Man is making sure don't happen every year?
It's magical.
Yeah.
Thank God.
Okay, so then, and this is just, like, a little aside in the story, but I want more info.
Fucking Bonnie Nettles then dies, and I had, she dies in 1985, and I had to, like, find
three different articles to find out how she died.
She had cancer.
Like, they don't fucking mention it again.
It's crazy.
Or even how he felt about it.
So you're like, it was secondary death.
Like, ooh, is this suspicious?
No, it's not.
I just, like, want more information about her.
Oh.
Sure.
I just think she's a bigger part of this.
Okay.
She established this goddamn cult.
I mean, she told him he was an alien or whatever.
Beep.
Bo and beep.
Beep.
Beep.
Beep.
By the mid-90s at this point, they become super reclusive.
They start calling themselves the higher source and begin recruiting via uploaded internet
content.
So the fucking.
Internet starts.
And you know it's one of those, like, fucking GeoCities pages.
Do we have that, Steven?
Yeah!
Oh, no.
Yeah.
Who designed that?
Fucking.
They did.
Heaven's Gate did.
Someone.
That looks like a bad Super Bowl trophy, doesn't it?
Kind of.
Oh, good.
Black background with green writing.
And there's, you know, there's the space theme again.
They're carrying that over into the website.
Yeah.
So.
Okay.
I'll read that later.
So.
Uploaded internet.
Then they begin to talk about the upcoming.
So this is when the Hale-Bopp comet was going to come down, which if you guys are our age,
you'll know it was a big fucking crazy exciting deal.
Sure.
Right?
Yeah.
Some people thought the world was going to end.
Oh, for sure.
Mm-hmm.
They thought it housed the secret to the ultimate salvation and descendants into the kingdom
of hell.
Heaven, a.k.a.
The Closure of Heaven's Gate.
Ah.
Um.
Oh.
They.
Sorry.
Don't fucking leave my story.
Can we show the Closure of Heaven's Gate?
Go to the screen.
Show me Closure of Heaven's Gate.
Ding.
Okay.
So they upload videos onto the webpage, the beautiful webpage, and it gained a mass following
through the internet.
And then in 96, they move into a large home.
They called the monastery.
It was a 9,000 square foot residence in a gated community of upscale homes in Rancho Santa
Fe, San Diego.
Ooh.
I thought they changed the name because they were like, they did and they knocked the fucking
house down later.
But let me tell you why first.
That's for the best, I think.
Right.
Okay.
I like that everybody in the balcony is from Rancho Santa Fe.
I also like that the front row for the first time was super helpful and awesome.
Yeah.
No, they're good people.
Not just screaming.
Don't, don't fucking, don't.
Don't overdo it.
Yeah.
Don't, don't ruin it.
Okay.
Okay.
You're ruining it.
Okay.
Uh, at this point, Heaven's Gate, they believed earth was about to be recycled.
Their only chance to survive was to leave it immediately.
And they were against suicide, but they define suicide in their own content to mean to turn
against the next level when it's offered.
Um, and they thought human bodies were only vessels, which I mean, are they wrong?
And, uh, so in 96, they purchased alien abductors.
Abduction insurance, which is a fucking thing.
Who started that company?
I don't know, but he's a genius.
She's a genius.
That's Geico right there.
That's fucking Geico.
It's now Geico.
Yep.
They changed their name to Geico.
It would cover up to 50 members and would pay out $1 million per person.
It covered abduction, impregnation, or death by aliens.
Oh.
Prove it.
That's all I want to say.
Prove I'm not impregnated by an alien.
You don't know.
You can't tell.
You can't tell.
Okay.
So on March 19th and 20th of 97, Marshall Applewhite taped himself speaking of mass
suicide and asserted it was the only way to evacuate this earth.
Do you remember the video?
Oh, yeah.
I think we have a photo of him in the video.
The eyes, the eyes, the eyes, the eyes.
What's wrong?
What's wrong, guys?
It's chill.
It's not.
If you're ever in Starbucks and that guy's behind you, like. Or taking your order.
If anyone's eyes, if their lids go out past the iris so they're showing white on top,
get the fuck out of there.
Danger.
As someone who has worked at both a health food grocery store and Starbucks,
these dudes, A, paying dirty change.
And they also, when I worked at the health food store,
they wouldn't let you scan their groceries.
Right.
Because they thought that they were going to get poisoned by the government.
And so you had to bleep, boop, bop every fucking number.
And they'd put it in the barcode and, like, if you put it near the scanner, they'd freak the fuck out.
It's like, it was, it's real fun.
They're the only ones whose brains haven't been taken over by the government.
Yeah.
They're the only normal ones because they're not, okay.
God bless them.
Please, please keep my brussel sprouts away from that right light.
Ma'am.
And then the worst, they're not nice is the thing.
I wouldn't care.
I don't care.
Do whatever you want.
But be nice.
Like, there were dicks about it.
That's the thing about hippies.
Is there's a, there's a lot of bad press about them.
Like, oh, they're so peace and love.
Hippies are fucking rude.
Yeah.
They're rude.
They're selfish.
Yeah.
Take that to the bank.
Okay.
All right.
Okay.
Taped himself.
Um, and then he persuaded 38 of his cult followers to commit suicide so that their souls could
board the craft.
So, um, he believed that after their death.
That's an unidentified flying object, UFO, we take, thank you, would take their souls
to another quote level of existence above human, which he describes as being both physical
and spiritual, their final meal together.
Here's one thing I just couldn't cut out because it was so good.
Um, where did you go earlier in your story on your date?
Applebee's not Applebee's, but it's close.
Okay.
They, they, their final meal, like right before they did this, they were like excited about
it.
And the waitress or the waiter was like, no, they have to go.
They all seem like in really good spirits, but here's the thing.
They all ate the same thing.
They all shave the same way.
They all did these things together.
Like, like a cult.
Yeah.
Um, and so they all ordered the same thing.
They went to Marie calendars.
Nice.
Yes.
Loving it.
Salad bar, sometimes live piano, good corn.
Here we go.
I'll tell you what they ate.
Okay.
They went to Marie calendars in Carlsbad after party.
I'll see you guys there.
Yes.
That Marie, I'm sorry, but that Marie calendars in Carlsbad.
Carlsbad is fucking nuts.
It's the best one.
You go there, you drink white wine.
Like you have six white wines.
Chablis.
And then you just eat pie.
It's amazing.
Well, no, they ate iced tea.
Yawn.
Have a glass of wine.
Uh, dinner salads with tomato vinegar dressing.
That sounds kind of nice.
It is nice.
And my favorite food, turkey pot pie.
I like chicken, but I love pot pie.
So I was pretty stoked on that.
That was their, their final meal was turkey pot pie.
Yeah.
Marie calendars in Carlsbad, California.
This pot pie is crispy on the top.
And crispy everywhere.
See, that's why I got fired.
No, I didn't.
I quit.
And they also had cheesecake with blueberries on top for dessert.
Nice.
Like they had dessert.
They're like, let's go kill ourselves now.
It's so crazy.
Um, the waiter said no one seemed depressed at all or anything like that.
So.
Except for the one guy who was like, I wanted Snickers pie.
We have to all do this.
Do the same thing every time.
So the adherents between the ages of 26 and 72, they died in three.
72.
Yeah.
It might've been him.
That was 72.
They included him.
I mean, I can't tell how old he is from that picture, but.
Not young.
Yeah.
So here's what they did.
They, they had three groups.
Um, and so each group would die on a different day and the other ones would take care of
them and clean them up and stuff.
Oh.
So I know it's fucked up.
So March 21st, 24th, 38 Heaven's Gate members took phenobarbital mixed with applesauce and
washed it down with vodka.
And then they put plastic bags around their heads after ingesting the mixture to induce
asphyxiation.
Yeah.
So they were not fucking around.
Yeah.
Um, right.
As you're pulling that bag on your head, you're like, I don't know.
I know.
It bums me out so much.
It's, I remember seeing this on the news when it happened and those fucking, well, sorry,
I don't want to get to that thing, but I actually kept that part in.
It's so intense.
You cut it in.
I cut it in.
Okay.
So they were found dead in their home in March 26th, 1997, lying neatly in their, each in
their own bunk beds.
And like, imagine seeing this when you're a fucking teenager and on the news, it was
so insane.
It's just perfect.
Everyone's perfect.
They're in these perfect bunk beds.
They all have, um, their faces and torsos are covered by these perfect square purple
cloths, which the people who are still living put over them.
Um, they, and they were all dressed in identical black shirts, sweat, black sweat pants and
brand new black and white Nike decade athlete shoes.
So that was like the crate, like this fucking, we didn't have them then, but this meme of
fucking back then before memes weren't a thing.
Yes.
The original.
And Nike was like, eh.
They discontinued the shoes.
Yes, they did.
and they actually you can sell them for a lot you can buy them for a shit they sold like someone
bought them for like a million dollars on ebay fuck yeah murderina yeah um good call the i
remember the thing that upset me with that video because it's such a it's such a walk through
creepy video it's it's totally uh early blair witch but um to see adults in bunk beds is not
cool at all yeah it's not that alone something's wrong if they were just asleep and the police
were like a bunch of adults slept in bunk beds i'd be like oh god get me out of here but then
they took it a step further they did um they each had a five dollar bill and a roll of quarters in
their pockets which was actually what they when they would leave the house they wouldn't you know
they didn't have earthly possessions but just in case they needed to use a bus or make a phone call
they would always bring a five dollar bill and a roll of quarters and someone was like they did it
as kind of a joke
just to like have people find it it's almost like they had a sense of humor about it because
they didn't think they were killing themselves they thought they were you know heading off to
space go into the god that's awful spirit in the sky and all that
yeah and they also were super into star trek and um just like you are just like me
who almost said star wars just now track track i did like listen look um the next generation
was my jam when i was a kid it's good it's so good it's also very this it's all like pastels it was
very it was very aesthetically pleasing to watch and that will wheaton i sure had a crush on him
sure he was wearing a body suit how could you deny him okay and so they wore they all had patches
that said heaven's gate away team which was a star trek fictional universe god these people
were funny they were kind of clever and like cool it's so odd so they had the distinction of being
the first well-known cult and the internet era and they um actually they made money designing
websites for people and that web fucking site is still up and running today by two people who are
like cult members who didn't kill themselves like they're the remaining two yeah well there's
probably more than that wow but yes um and i just remember saying didn't they all have shaved heads
or am i combining that with some other cult
i don't know they were real low-key like everything was very yeah they all wore the
same color outfits they were all you know yeah chill yeah yeah so that's uh that's your cult
heaven's gate san diego you guys wow so good
okay we're back what are the updates for the heaven's gate cult georgia there's not many
just about some media the documentary miniseries heaven's gate the cult of cults was released on
hbo max in 2020 and then a film adaptation of this story which you're gonna love this it's called the
leader it's released on june 5th so by the time this comes out it'll be out and so vera flaminga
plays bonnie and none other than tim blake nelson is playing marshall the head of heaven's gate
apple wait yes so sweet yes as the guy from the not like one of the best actors ever of course
from a
brother where are you yes like yeah he's so perfect for that that's incredible like no one's a better
actor he's gonna just act that down he's gonna act the fuck out of that and also michael c white
yeah so that'll be incredible wow that's gonna be what must watch tv what do they call it uh when
they time must see tv yeah but what's the one where they like make it an appointment oh appointment tv
so it's not appointment it's calendar tv calendar put it in your calendar tv
everybody all right we're gonna wrap it up with a hometown story from the audience in san diego
black friday is here and pandora jewelry has you covered enjoy up to 40 off select styles
in store and online now through december 1st explore jewelry designed to last a lifetime
like unique engravable pieces festive charms lab-grown diamonds and more made for the people
who inspire you who've been there through it all
give a piece that says exactly what words can't pandora jewelry more than a gift shop in store or
online at pandora.net exclusions apply goodbye my favorite murder is brought to you by yellow
jackets on paramount plus the emmy nominated series about a 90s girls soccer team stranded
in the wilderness after a plane crash returns for its final season and this season the yellow
jackets are finally coming home but a swarm of endless questions awaits how did they survive
what really happened and how did they survive and what really happened and what really happened
out there and what did they do to finally escape featuring melanie linsky christina ricci tawny cypress
and hillary swank catch the final season of yellow jackets streaming november 20th on paramount plus
goodbye sometimes being a little salty is completely justified pair your salty side
with something sweet with the new salted caramel flavor from cachava cachava is a whole body shake
with plant-based protein fiber greens and other nutrients to help fill nutritional gaps just two
provide complete nutrition your body craves with protein fiber greens and so much more their new
salty caramel flavor combines sweet caramel with a little salt so you get that salty sweet balance
along with the nutrition cachava is known for when the day demands your salty side fuel it
with plant-based protein that actually tastes delicious i really do love cachava and i really
do think it does taste delicious for getting you through the morning filling in the gap if you just
need some protein and you need some vitamins it's such a nice little treat it's such an easy
way to get everything you need and it tastes good too which is just huge bonus so embrace your salty
side go to cachava.com and use code mfm for 15 off your first order that's cachava k-a-c-h-a-v-a.com
code mfm goodbye do we have time vince vince's vince's fan wrap it up is it a wrap-up time
no he's he's making insane hand gestures that i totally don't under i think it's a yes yes he's
going like this when i don't know what that means we are gonna have to work out hand gestures that
we memorize and learn i should know what my husband's like wild insane gestures mean but
i don't yet and i feel like you don't there's something wrong with her we need to go to marriage
encounter encounters and learn each other shit okay um you do i pick or do you pick oh i don't
know like can we get the house lights up and we're gonna get a look i think we're gonna do a
hometown murder we choose
doesn't matter what you do it's our choice you can do whatever you want ultimately we choose hold
on let's see uh hold up okay i love when a girl is pointing at her friend yeah that's always good
that girl right there blondie uh-oh she's drunk or terrified she's oh no are you mad that your
friend pointed at you okay you had your hand in the air hi hi what's your name what's your name
you come here you have to
tell us your name laurie hi laurie say hi say hi to laurie everybody
do you want to face that way okay let's we can do it this way
yeah do it this way you can't read your notes can't read it no or you're just texting
do that later do that later you first you have to earn the photo by taking by telling the story
where are you from san diego oh hell yeah local girl i just want you guys to know she has sparkles
on her cheese so many sparkles
sparkly and twinkly okay where so tell us your hometown take a deep breath yeah you're great and
then go ahead and use that mic yeah you can get shit wrong okay no i will get shit wrong okay
good um we do too my heart is beating cleophas prince jr the claremont killer oh yes yes do you
know that no tell me um you seem fine i can't tell you're good you seem totally normal pretend you
gotta pretend
well just tell us how you're how do you know this story seriously right up here with these
with these motherfuckers these motherfuckers okay so 1990 um my best friend was murdered by a serial
killer okay well that's probably why you were having a hard time talking about it a little bit
a little more so like there's so many things going through my mind oh honey um it's okay
sweet baby don't comfort her it's your story i know i know okay so oh i want to get it right
uh january 1990 tiffany schultz murdered in a claremont apartment found by her boyfriend i
believe january then february um janine weinholt is her name was murdered same apartment buildings
um she's about 20 years old we found out we hear we hear it we're like oh my god there's a fucking
serial killer in our in san diego my best friend at the time was like oh my god i'm gonna get killed
by this guy and i'm like you're not gonna get killed what are you talking about and she always
had a a thing where she was afraid that her and her um mom were gonna get killed okay so yeah it
was weird march goes by we're good yeah april a girl named holly tar who was visiting her
brother same claremont apartment complex murdered stabbed to death by so then at that point they um
figured it was somebody that
was they knew and then may east san diego a woman named elisa keller who was 38 years old so these
three girls
were like in their 20s.
Elisa Keller, 38 years old, was murdered.
They didn't figure out it was the same person
because he's San Diego, like whatever.
She was murdered.
She lived in the apartment with her daughter.
They didn't figure it out, blah, blah, blah.
Okay, fast forward.
So that's four people, right?
Fast forward to September.
So in the meantime, he was burglarizing people
and stalking people but not doing anything, whatever.
So September 13th, Thursday, I get a fucking phone call
from my other best friend's mom that says,
you need to sit down, Amber was killed.
I'm like, what?
What are you talking about?
So Amber and I had been friends for a long time
and we had this like standing date
that we would talk Mondays and Thursdays.
It was kind of stupid, whatever, we were young.
And I had been calling her all day
because I had that kind of weird feeling.
But anyway, so I was told she was killed
and they obviously knew that it was the same
because of whatever.
So is this making sense?
Yeah, yeah.
Is it?
I feel like I'm just like. I'm sorry, just to let you know,
just to let you know, as a live performer
of almost 20 years, I've never heard an audience
this quiet in my life.
Like this is, they just want you
to, they want you to share what you have to say
and they trust you and they love you.
Yeah, you're good.
Yeah.
Never in a million years.
I know.
You're doing great.
Okay, so I get the phone call
and it was actually interesting.
Sorry.
Hi.
Because at the time it was a police investigation.
They weren't releasing any names.
And at the time, my friend stepped down,
stepped down.
And my dad said, no, you can't,
we have to tell these people, these girls,
me and some, two other people that, you know,
we can't find out from the news.
So we were told, blah, blah, blah.
My best friend, Amber, and her mom, Pamela Clark,
she was 18 and Pam was 42, killed in their home by him.
Oh my God.
Six people, San Diego.
So then fast forward, we didn't know
what the fuck was going on, who it was.
We knew that they, that he,
he stalked his victims, February, 1991.
He was arrested in San Diego, then let go.
And then he went back to where he was from.
He was originally from Alabama.
Sorry, why was he let go?
Probably bail.
I'm not really sure what happened.
I don't know.
I don't know.
But he was arrested and then let go.
And then he was able to go back to Alabama.
So they probably couldn't hold him on anything
like they didn't have evidence.
Yeah, exactly.
They didn't really know.
So he went home.
Exactly.
So then they figured out from DNA at that point
that he was like the guy.
Yeah.
And then.
Did they go and get him?
They extradited him back.
Yeah.
They had the whole trial
and then he was convicted on all six plus rape
because he raped one of the girls.
Nice.
Yeah.
And plus like a shit ton of burglaries
and all this little fucking shit that he did.
So he's gone for good.
He's in San Quentin.
San Quentin.
They always send him to San Quentin.
I know, right?
Yeah.
Yeah.
So he's there still breathing air
that belongs to all those women that he killed.
So.
Thank you for telling us that.
No, thank you.
You guys.
That was amazing.
And hard.
It's one thing to tell a hometown story
about a murder 'cause it happened in your town.
It's a totally different thing
to tell something that happened in your heart.
That's fucking very difficult.
You did a great job.
Thank you for sharing that.
And it means a lot to us to know
that somebody who is so close to the grief and pain
of a victim would listen to our podcast.
'Cause that means, we only wanna do right.
We know that comedy can be very irreverent
and inappropriate sometimes when we're talking about victims,
but we never want anyone to feel like
that's what we're laughing at.
We're just laughing about talking to each other.
So it means a lot to us that you listen to our podcast.
Thank you so much.
Thank you.
Beautiful.
She just goes, beautiful.
Beautiful.
That sounded sarcastic when you said it, but I meant it.
No, it seemed like you meant it.
Wait, were you being sarcastic?
Yes.
Okay, we're back.
Are there any updates on this hometown?
No updates.
Cle Office Prince Jr. remains on death row at San Quentin.
And how brave of Laurie to come up on stage
and tell that story.
I mean, what?
Incredible.
It's so incredible that like she trusted us
and our audience, of course, because she knew that.
She knew she could tell them.
She knew who was in the room with her.
Yeah.
Yeah.
It was pretty beautiful.
That's really, that's like the special moments of the show
where people who are like, here's my trauma, let's share it.
Yeah.
They know they can.
Yeah.
Okay, so let's do the titles.
We, of course, originally entitled this show
Live at the Balboa Theater in San Diego.
But based on the show you just heard, naming it today,
we could call it Watch the Fingers.
Georgia yelling at me about the pre-show.
Oh, dear.
Gaslamping me in the gaslight.
Oh, dear.
That's like a poem.
Buffalo chicken pudding, of course.
Delicious.
Let's see.
What about Giancarlo Rossetti?
I love her.
Yes.
Swinging with aliens.
Oh, my God.
There's so many.
So many.
Pick one more.
One of your classic board plays, the two FOs.
So many good ones.
All right.
Well, I'm going to go with the last one.
I'm going to go with the last one.
So many good ones.
All right.
Well, that's it for Rewind.
Thanks for listening, guys.
That's right.
Let us say goodbye to you now from 2018 in San Diego.
You guys, this has been a fucking incredible show.
Thank you guys so much for being here.
It's very, you're such a huge crowd and you've been so awesome and then also so incredibly
respectful.
That was really beautiful and a really cool thing to see and feel.
It's been an incredible show.
Yeah.
And you know what?
Stay sexy.
Bye, you guys.
Elvis, do you want a cookie?
GhostBed has been taking the mattress industry by storm as the coolest bed in the world,
offering a clear difference in your sleep with their cooling technology and luxury design.
And now is the time to get one.
GhostBed's Black Friday sale is here, the biggest sale of the year.
And our audience gets an extra 10% off with code IHEART.
GhostBed is different.
Their beds are serious health equipment engineered for cooling, comfort and support because your
body should be healing while you sleep, not fighting for comfort.
Plus you get 101 nights to try it at home.
If you don't feel the difference, you can send it back subject to their trial terms.
So if you're waking up stiff, tossing and turning, sleeping hot, even reaching for a
pain reliever before bed, hoping tonight will be different, you got to check out GhostBed.
And during their biggest sale of the year, you can get their Black Friday savings plus
an extra 10% off exclusively for this audience.
Go to GhostBed.com/IHEART and use promo code IHEART.
That's GhostBed.com/IHEART, promo code IHEART.
Quick break from the case.
If there's a kid on your gift list this year, here's one you can close fast.
Guardian is the number one kid's bike on the market.
With over 1 million Happy Rooms.
It's the number one kid's bike on the market.
And the easiest way to learn.
They're lightweight with a wide wheel base.
So kids ride in just one day.
No training wheels needed.
Designed and assembled in the USA.
And named Wirecutter's top pick four years in a row.
Save over 40% now.
Plus, get over $120 in free accessories with every bike.
That's GuardianBikes.com.
There are exciting things happening at your local CVS.
Shop new extra big deals with Extra Care every two weeks.
No coupon needed.
Plus, get access to exclusive sale prices, personalized deals, and more as a member.
Extra Care is the way to save at CVS.
Join for free online or in-store and start saving.
Visit your local CVS store or CVS.com slash extra big deals for this week's deals.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
The podcast features a deep dive into the true crime story of Betty Broderick, a woman who murdered her husband and legal assistant, Linda Colkena, in San Diego in 1989.
Betty endured years of psychological abuse, emotional manipulation, and financial neglect from her husband Dan, who had an affair with Linda and became increasingly absent.
The narrative reveals how Betty’s mental state deteriorated due to prolonged emotional abuse, leading to extreme behaviors such as breaking into the home, destroying food, and making threatening statements.
The trial outcomes reflect societal shifts, with the first jury deadlocked and the second convicting her of second-degree murder, citing psychological abuse as a key factor.
The case gained national attention, with media coverage highlighting the abuse and the eventual execution-style killings, which were premeditated and shocking.
The story is contrasted with a broader discussion of podcasting, mental health, and the impact of true crime storytelling on public perception.
The episode includes humorous and personal anecdotes from the hosts, blending storytelling with reflections on their own lives and experiences.
The narrative ends on a somber note, emphasizing the lasting trauma on the children and the tragic consequences of long-term domestic abuse.
Summary:
The podcast episode explores the true crime case of Betty Broderick, who murdered her husband Dan and his legal assistant Linda Colkena in San Diego in 1989. After years of emotional and financial abuse, including neglect, isolation, and psychological manipulation, Betty’s mental health collapsed. The story details how Dan’s affair with Linda, combined with his workaholic lifestyle and emotional detachment, created a toxic environment.
Betty, who had previously raised their four children alone, became increasingly unhinged, culminating in a premeditated home invasion where she shot both victims. The trial was highly publicized, with the first jury deadlocked and the second convicting her of second-degree murder, citing psychological abuse as a defense. Despite the tragic outcome, the narrative emphasizes the children’s suffering and the damaging impact of prolonged domestic abuse.
The episode blends the factual account with personal humor and reflections from the hosts, such as their own experiences with mental health and podcasting. It underscores how domestic violence, especially in the context of gendered expectations and financial control, can escalate into violence. The story serves as a cautionary tale about emotional abuse and the importance of recognizing signs of psychological harm.
The episode is framed within a broader discussion of true crime storytelling, mental health, and the evolving public understanding of abuse. While the case is dark and disturbing, the hosts maintain a reflective tone, highlighting the emotional toll on victims and the need for societal awareness. The narrative concludes with a note of empathy, acknowledging the complexity of human behavior under extreme duress.
FAQs
Betty Broderick, a former housewife and mother of four, endured years of emotional and financial abuse from her husband Dan, who had an affair with a legal assistant named Linda. After a bitter divorce, Betty became increasingly unhinged, eventually breaking into Dan and Linda’s home in San Diego and shooting both of them in 1989. She claimed she intended to take her own life and was not planning to kill them. She was found guilty of second-degree murder and served time in prison, where her behavior remained volatile.
The podcast 'My Favorite Murder' discussed the Betty Broderick case in depth, highlighting the psychological abuse, the emotional toll on the children, and the eventual murder. The story was dramatized in a season of the show 'Dirty John,' with Amanda Pete portraying Betty Broderick, and praised for its accurate and impactful portrayal.
Betty Broderick exhibited signs of emotional distress, including frequent yelling, public threats, obsessive focus on financial abuse, and compulsive behaviors such as throwing tantrums over Christmas gifts. She also engaged in extreme actions like breaking into her husband’s home and destroying personal items, showing a clear deterioration in mental well-being.
Gaslighting was used to describe how Dan Broderick emotionally manipulated Betty by downplaying or denying the reality of their fights and abuses, making her question her own perceptions. This behavior is a form of psychological abuse and was a central theme in the case, illustrating how it can escalate into violent outcomes.
The children were caught in the middle of the marital conflict, enduring constant yelling, threats, and emotional abuse from their mother. The podcast emphasized that they were victims of the abuse and later expressed mixed feelings about whether Betty should be imprisoned or released, showing the long-term trauma of the situation.
The podcast revisited the story in a live episode set in San Diego, using humor and personal anecdotes to discuss the emotional and societal impact of the case. It highlighted the personal connections and feelings of the hosts, blending true crime with reflections on family, mental health, and trauma.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.