Go back

REPORT CARD: Matthew Stafford = C+? Grading Sean McVay, Aaron Donald, Quentin Lake, and More Rams!

from Locked On Rams - Daily Podcast On The Los Angeles Rams

33m 16s

REPORT CARD: Matthew Stafford = C+? Grading Sean McVay, Aaron Donald, Quentin Lake, and More Rams!

This episode of Locked on Rams is a midseason report card, with hosts Travis Rogers and Gavin Carlson grading the Rams' offense, coaching staff, and defense through roughly ten games. The conversation begins with Matthew Stafford, the most polarizing player to evaluate. Both hosts settle on a B minus, noting that his yardage and touchdown totals remain strong but that turnovers, a lower depth of target, and diminished arm zip have kept him well below his MVP form. The offensive line earns high marks for protecting Stafford and powering a consistent run game despite injuries, while Sean McVay receives a B plus for steering an injury-ravaged roster to a 6-4 record, with some criticism for questionable decisions and play calls. On defense, Aaron Donald earns an A-plus for coming off the couch and performing at a top-15 level despite constant double teams, and Trent McDuffie is a no-brainer A-plus as the NFL's highest-graded cornerback. Quinn Lake and Byron Young get B plus grades, while Nate Landman and Cam Curl receive C plus marks for inconsistent play. Omar Spates and Emmanuel Forbes earn praise for quietly strong seasons. Miles Garrett is graded incomplete because he has barely played, and special teams would receive a grade below an F. The hosts close by noting the team's resilience and looking ahead to the Packers game.

Transcription

6874 Words, 35752 Characters

English
Speaker 1It's time for bi-week grades here on Locked on Rams. We're going to ask, is Matthew Stafford still elite? Are there two backups who deserve an A-plus? And does Miles Garrett even get a grade? That's all up on today's Locked on Rams. Let's get it going. You are Locked on Rams, your daily Los Angeles Rams podcast. Part of the Locked on Podcast Network, your team every day. Who's house? Rams house. What is going on, Ramley? And welcome back to Locked on Rams. It's free and available both on YouTube and wherever you get the Locked on Rams audio podcast feed. He's the people's tramp, Travis Rogers. I am Gavin Carlson. And on today's show, we're going to wrap things up, giving you a little 20 pony personnel breakdown. Explain why Sean McVay used. It on Sunday against the Cardinals and why, in my opinion, at least, he has to keep using it, given some of the injuries for the Rams. But today is all about grades, Travis. We're going to, of course, grade some of the defenders for our Rams and start today's show, grading some of the players on this Rams offense.
Speaker 2I always wanted to be a teacher. Now I get to hand out some grades. It's very excited on today's episode brought to you by FanDuel. Get in on the NFL action all season long with FanDuel. You can get started at FanDuel.com.
Speaker 1I love it. I love it, Travis. Travis, the teacher today. I can't wait to see what we've got. And it's fun because we can disagree on grades, give students different grades and, you know, figure out what happens there. But there's nowhere else you should start than on offense and with Matthew Stafford because it's the most important position in sports. And arguably, when I was kind of planning who we would talk about, probably the most polarizing player in terms of what grade he should get because based on some numbers, he's been no good. Based on other numbers, he's been Matthew Stafford. And, you know, he's like, like you typically say, probably somewhere in between the two extremes. I want to hear your grade first before I give mine and then go through some of the stats. Then maybe we change our mind because I think that's part of the thing here that's interesting about this is a lot of the times your perception and what the stats tell you are different. And then it's like, how much do I believe what my eyes are telling me? So if you had to go somewhere for Matthew Stafford through these first nine or ten games, where are you going to go?
Speaker 2I'd give him a B minus. Yeah. I don't think he's been bad, but I'm also grading him against his typical performance. And he's an A student. He might be a valedictorian. So when he shows up and gives you something that doesn't look like a perfect report, then it's going to kind of jump out at you. And he has not been perfect. He has been far from perfect. Now, he's been better of late. He's been dealing with a lot of, you know, a lot of expectations. A lot of frustrations, namely not having his weapons for the most part, other than Pukunukuwa. But look, we've seen him miss some throws. We've seen him, you know, he does not look the way he looked a year ago. Now, that may have been the very high watermark of his career. He may never look like that again. I think it's probably likely he will never look like that again. But the reason it's not worse than a B minus is that when he's got to have it, he's pretty much has it. And in those two games, he's got to have it. In those two-minute situations, in the second half in particular, I think he looks a lot like the best version of himself. But overall, when you watch him play, there have not been a lot of, holy smoke, did you see that? And last year, it was a lot of that. In his entire Rams career, there's been a lot of, can you believe what it is you're looking at? He hasn't been dreadful where he's throwing a bunch of interceptions every week. He was not very good early in the season. Of late, he's been much better. Again, the competition matters. So I'll give, you know, the more I think about it too, I might even elevate it to just a regular B and take the minus off it. I think it's been good, but it's been far from great.
Speaker 1That's hilarious, Travis. I literally have on my notes, B minus or B kind of, and I'm always going to depend on what Travis said and kind of play off it. So the exact same thing for me. It's funny because he's played two kind of different seasons in a way. Like people forget there was that stretch at Denver, at Philly, and then Monday night football against, the bills where he goes 55 pass attempts, 51 pass attempts, 54 pass attempts in three straight games. And statistically has three pretty darn good games, or at least from a yardage perspective, 390 yards, 317 yards, 383 yards. And even the game before against the giants, only 31 pass attempts, still 327 yards. The problem is he has turnovers or interceptions in three of those four games, including two interceptions. In both the Denver game and the Philly game, even this Arizona game on Sunday was kind of a perfect example of a Matthew Stafford game that so far this season, like you always say, Travis, he starts off a little bit slow. Again, like you said, maybe he's more of a reliever this year, dang near a closer sometimes and not a starter, right? He has a interception on a no look throw where it's like Matthew Stafford, what are you doing? No look throwing in this game and this stage. And then a few throws later, he throws a beautiful, no, look throw to complete a pass. He has multiple and plus impressive throws in that game. And you're like, wait, this is why this guy won an MVP at his age. He still has arm talent out there, you know, top five in the league when he's feeling it. So that's why he's so polarizing. I think I'm going to go B minus as well, just because the stats are great. The performance really isn't. And then for me, the tiebreaker and why it's B minus not B is just too many turnovers, too many turnovers to justify. Giving a super friendly grade too.
Speaker 2Yeah, I think you're right. And the only thing I'll say too, to add to this is if the Rams are going to go to the playoffs, he's going to have to be a better student. He's going to have to play better. He's going to have to look bad. It's going to have to look more similar to 2025 than it has to 2026. So far, he doesn't have to be MVP level, but he needs to be better. And I don't know if he can be better throwing the ball to two, two and Daniels and, and, and Mumfield. Now, maybe if Terrence Ferguson comes back, maybe if those tight ends get a little more healthy, that it can look a little bit better. But I, you know, at his position, he is dependent at least on to some degree on who his weapons are. And right now he's dealing with some weapons that are not of the highest NFL
Speaker 1caliber. Yeah, for sure. One last thing I will give him credit for is, and we'll talk about Chalmick baking his own grade. He's had the offensive philosophy changed like three times. Three times in the first 10 games, right? You've gone from 13 personnel and having Puka and then not having Puka and having Devontae and then not having either and going 11 personnel and then going 20, you know, so he's had these different things he's had to deal with, but just from a numbers perspective, real quick through 10 games, obviously six and four, 24 out of 30, 372. So 67% of his passes, he's near the top of the league in passing yards. Um, but the problem he's got 10 interceptions compared to those 19 touchdowns. Um, but when you look at some of the ranks,
Speaker 2I think only through eight interceptions all of last season. So when you, when you compare the two and again, it's 10 interceptions through 10 games, right? It just, it's, it just, it just, if this were just a season, not butted up against an MVP season, I think maybe the grade would be a little bit better, but it is butted up against an MVP season. We saw what it looks like at its best. And this is far from it.
Speaker 1Yeah. This is like a Kirk cousins type of year, right? Like, and like Kirk cousins, I think people would, I think people would call a B quarterback it's B minus because he's Matthew Stafford. He is 23rd out of 36 quarterbacks in terms of PFF grade. So again, there are some stats that aren't friendly to him. Um, he's 12th in big time throws, but 28th in turnover worthy plays. He really should have like 13 or 14 interceptions because there have been a few drops. Obviously he threw a really costly pick six in that Denver game on a no look. And he's throwing all those interceptions, despite not even being that aggressive of a quarterback 24th in average, depth of target. Right? So it's like, you're not throwing the ball deep and yet there's still all those turnovers, but he's on pace, Travis for 4,500 yards and 32 touchdowns. So he's still not a chump in any way.
Speaker 2Yeah, no, no, it's not bad at all. And I think that's why we're both kind of like, okay, it's like, cause your first instinct is, oh, it's a C or anything, but it's like, no, no, it's better than that. It's just not what you've come to expect. And that depth of target number that you just talked about, I think that may be a function of health and age or, or both that, that, you know, for the first time ever, we've seen balls that do not have that absolute snap and zip on them. The way that we've come to expect, like Matthew Stafford, like you mentioned a minute ago, has one of the great arms in NFL history, and he could throw it through a brick wall from 40 yards away. We haven't really seen a ton of that this year. And I don't know if it's just father time undefeated. If it's, there's something going on in his arm. I mean, think about the amount of pitches he's thrown. Think about the, you know, it's just, he's, he's at that point. We saw, you know, as a Dodger fan, as the host of locked on Dodgers, I, I saw the end Clayton Kershaw and it, it did not look like the best part of Clayton Kershaw. It just, it happens to all athletes. And especially when you're throwing things like Stafford and Chris, like it's like, yeah, that doesn't look like it used to look now. It doesn't mean it can't work. It doesn't mean it can't be really, really effective, but that 99 mile an hour fastball that Stafford used to have, he's not now he's got to hit some spots. It's just not quite the same guy. -
Speaker 1Yeah, it's strictly now a timing based offense which is so hard to do with backups and everything um backups it makes it hard to grade the offense travis so i was like do i even grade a receiver i'm like i don't think so i think puka is an a plus if he's on the field davante honestly probably deserves an a given how good he was when puka was out so it's like you don't really need to waste time there you don't really need to waste time on tight ends i mean only one of them actually played most of the games this year in tyler higby i don't know if you have a rapid fire grade for tyler higby i'd give him a based on expectation a b based on actual tight end play maybe a b minus yeah he's on the team
Speaker 2i think is a surprise i'm not even being flipped like at the end of the season we're like okay that's probably the end of the tyler higby era in la and tyler higby my my co-host on the radio said this one time and i'm like and i i was about to go what are you out of you and i stopped i'm like wait tyler higby's probably the best tight end in the history of the ramps yeah like that it sounds weird to say that but it's true and and and he's still out there he's still making plays and you know is he is he the second coming of of tony gonzalez no but but but he he gets the job done more often than not yeah
Speaker 1i totally i totally agree now we come back for the break the big guy sean mcveigh will give his grade and then we'll talk about the rams defense including travis i think two guys that might deserve an a plus in my opinion and guys that you would never expect in a million years no not two two at will but i'll tell you who after our break here on locked on rings
Speaker 2nfl sundays are packed with action and fandle gives fans more ways to get involved in games that you're already watching so whether you're following your favorite team locked into a matchup or watching the action unfold across the league fandle lets you engage with the game before kickoff throughout the final whistle before the game here's what you do you build the same game parlay along how you think the matchup is going to play out pick the winner add a touchdown score maybe include a player prop and then you're ready to go and you're ready to go and you're ready to pick up and build your picks around your own read on the game and then once the action gets underway fandle gives you even more ways to follow along with live betting as the game develops right so you come into the game expecting the run game and then all of a sudden they're throwing it all over the yard and the matchup is totally different from what you thought it was going to be how often does that happen well almost every time right so this is why you can do both same game parlays before kickoff and live betting during the game get in on the nfl action all season long with fandle download the app or head to fandle.com to get started and make this your most rewarding season ever with fandle and today's
Speaker 1show also brought to you by game day men's health because a quiz on your phone in a box at your door isn't a clinic when it comes to men's health things like energy sleep drive and how you feel day to day deserve more than a questionnaire game day men's health is a real in-person men's health clinic with more than 430 locations across the u.s and canada men can meet face to face with a licensed clinician get labs drawn in the office and receive initial results in as little as 15 minutes game day looks at the full picture your symptoms and your lab results before developing a treatment plan and because they continue testing and evaluating care can be adjusted over time based on your data so book your complimentary test and consult at gamedaymenshealth.com again your complimentary test and consult at gamedaymenshealth.com we keep it rolling here on locked on rams it's locked on what teaching today locked on report card rams podcast we appreciate you for making locked on rams your first listen each and every day real quick travis i guess we could grade the whole offensive line right i know there's some moving parts and certainly now really some moving parts we'll talk about in segment three but in my opinion i'll just come out the gate and say like it's got to be at least an a minus i mean matthew stafford one of the least pressured and sacked quarterbacks in the league most of the season um again they have been asked to do different things whether it's 13 personnel and getting help from some tight ends or you know splitting out and doing 11 and 20 and the run game is consistently one of the best in the nfl every single week especially despite defenses knowing that the rams are going to rely on that and they've kept matthew stafford clean they survived an hour jackson suspension they've so far survived steve avila being out for a game now they're gonna have to survive a lot of games without their centers so i give it an a minus maybe even an a considering that injury context
Speaker 2i'll go yeah i i want to know where you're marking them down on anything i mean because think about what they've done like you said they run the ball really effectively with two running backs the offensive line has to get some credit for that but more importantly most importantly coming into this season what were we all terrified of what was the number one thing we're like look if this happens it's a wrap that was a lot of fun but i think it's a lot of fun because it's a lot of fun but i think it's a lot of fun because it's a lot of fun because it's a lot of fun because it's a lot if matthew stafford took hits he hasn't matthew stafford is in one place every defender knows where he's going to be he is not going to make you miss with his legs he's not now you may give you a little shoulder duck and one of these sorts of things to kind of get out of it but he is there and everybody knows that he's there and he doesn't take hits and and the amount of pressure knowing that if this guy takes you know one bad one or a series of not so bad ones that add up the series of not so bad ones that add up the series of not so bad ones that add up the series goes up in flames and they've done a really good job of not letting that happen so obviously the task is getting much more difficult as we get deeper into the season it's just the life in the nfl where the attrition of of injuries start to add up and they're they're certainly had their fair share of it um but i i i have no what have we talked about warren mcclendon once all year no and that's that's exactly what you want to talk about with your offensive line if we mentioned notson's name once all year no not really you know avala got hurt shelton we're talking about him being out that how big of a deal that is the only time we mentioned a lark jackson's name is because he does dumb you know what but but it's not because he's a bad football player right so that offensive line collectively has been absolutely fantastic i totally
Speaker 1agree i totally agree and it's a combination of them themselves individually are i think better players than casuals around the league would give them credit for they're not the big highest paid this highest paid that biggest name lineman but they get the job done the rams get credit for finding some of these diamonds in the rough they're gonna have to look at one of those and bill limmer for a while at center here and i think transitioning the last offensive guy and sean mcveigh sean mcveigh deserves credit for the offense and how they play obviously he's not out there blocking pass rushers on the edge um but he knows when a lineman might need some help from a tight end on a chip or leaving kyron into block knows when you need to go 13 personnel and use that to your advantage to generate a run game and let's see it travis no one more polarizing than sean mcveigh you know i said matthew stafford but sean mcveigh is great i want to hear from you first because i have genuinely no idea where you're going to go with this one with sean
Speaker 2mcveigh i think it's b i i think it's i think it's been good because again it's important to add context to all of these things they they really have not had their full complement of weapons all season okay i know we talked about puka getting hurt now washington keep in mind puka missed a couple of games earlier in the season as well he's juggled two running backs i think incredibly effectively this this is a situation that could get sticky and ugly and one person wants more and the other all of the things come along with that that tight end room has been banged up with injuries that davante adams has missed a ton of time you just had to integrate a whole bunch of issues and they were out there and they were okay so i think that's all the good stuff some of the the less good stuff is why does it have to get so bad before you go back to just some of the basic stuff like let's run the ball so you can pass the ball run the ball so you can burn some clocks so you can keep the other like all of these sorts of things so i think that prevents it from being the a there's been some weird play calls in some weird moments screen passes some full uh some tight end dive fullbacks like that and i think that's a good thing and i think that's a good thing and i think that's a good thing and i think that's a good thing and i think it's a good thing and i think huh like what what's going on there so it hasn't been perfect but considering what you've asked him to do with what you've asked him to do it with i don't know if you could get a whole lot more other than six and four out of what you've got to consider you know they blew a couple of games early but they've also kind of stolen a couple of games that they probably shouldn't have won either so i think that kind of is a wash right there it's not the best performance i've ever seen from sean i'm going to be real slow to say he's anything other than a really really really fantastic coach because i wouldn't trade him for anybody in the
Speaker 1league yeah i was right there i said anywhere from b to a minus the reason he'd go b is you you can almost solely put the loss in australia on sean mcveigh right you can almost solely do that in my opinion in my opinion i think he deserves at least a little bit of criticism for the miles garrett situation there's no world where a player should come out after the game and say that they were not healthy when you're coming out there the day before calling him wolverine he certainly deserves some blame in my opinion for pukin akua being out for what he is in terms of how long he is in terms of how much you overused him and then of course the silly end around play call at the end of that commander's game so for things like that that's what it knocks you down but like you just said you want a four game winning streak half of it with people at wide receiver that no one else in the league has ever heard of um and there's the super team context coming into the season but that's thrown out the window when everybody is hurt so if any coach leads a team that is average from a roster perspective to a six and four record that's a b b plus performance it goes down to b for how he handled australia and some of the injuries It goes up to B plus, A minus, based on his ability to win these four games in a row, go from 11 to 13 to 20, like you said, get both running backs involved. So I think I'm going to go B plus, but it's a B plus where, man, you are half a percentage point away from being a B just in some of those other things.
Speaker 2Yeah, you said something I think that I had forgotten. I'm glad you brought it up, that if we're grading him based on the expectations of breaking camp, it's a C minus. That's not what happened, right? What the actual team has been throughout this season has been a bad photocopy version of what we thought it was going to be. Trent McDuffie's missed a ton of time. Jalen Watson has missed a ton of time. Miles Garrett missed almost the entire season up until this point. You asked Aaron Donald to do some things that he didn't sign up to do, and I know that. Look, you come back and you play, you got to do what you got to do, but you missed Puka, you missed Devontae. Your quarterback looks like he got old quick, and yet all of a sudden, you're six and four, and you're in the mix to go win a playoff game. If you took off, if we just kind of showed up in San Francisco, in Australia, and just said, okay, here's what's going on, you'd be like, oh, boy, okay, wow, let's see what's happening next, and then fast forward 10 weeks later, and you're six and four, and, you know, it's not great, also not dead, you'd be like, okay, that's a pretty good job, and I think that's a good point by you to bring up just what it was supposed to be relative to what it's actually been.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's why it's tough being a teacher, right, because you need some context. There's a lot going on, so I think, yeah, it's tough to really know for a guy like Sean McVay, for a guy like Matthew Stafford, and it's going to be tough to know for a guy like Miles Garrett, how the heck do you grade him and Aaron Donald? We'll tell you after our last break here. Let us know in the comments section what you think. As you're watching the show, I know you have your opinion, Sean McVay, Matthew Stafford, put your grades for them in the comments. We'll talk defense when we come back here on Locked on Rams. Today's show is brought to you by Quo, spelled Q-U-O. It's the business phone system built so you never miss a call. For businesses, every call can be an opportunity, and missing one can mean missing a customer. Quo brings calls, texts, and voicemails together in one place so teams can see the full conversation, respond quickly, and stay alert. It can also be set up in minutes on any device, keep an existing number, and add teammates as the business grows. Quo helps businesses stay reachable and professional without being complex, and with an optional AI agent for after-hours calls, businesses can answer questions and book appointments even when the team is offline. That is so big, right? There's nothing worse as a customer than calling a business. It says it's open, or you thought it was open. It's not, and you feel out of luck, and there's nothing worse as a business than having that customer, walk away, so that is such a big-time feature. Money is on the line, so always say hello with Quo. Try Quo for free, plus get 20% off your first six months when you go to Quo.com slash LockedOnNFL. That's Q-U-O dot com slash LockedOnNFL.
Speaker 2The NBA is heating up. How about my man Griney for the Lakers last night? My goodness, there's so much to follow on prize picks. Whether you're looking at a shootout in the West last night, or a Lakers and Hornets, or a boards battle in the East, you can build your lineup around the players and projections that you're watching, and prize picks is available nationwide. It is now an official daily fantasy partner of the NBA, so there are no shortage of ways to get more locked in to the sports you love, and while the NBA is obviously getting going and heating up, Lakers are 13-2, football isn't slowing down either. You can make your NBA picks around player projections like points and boards, then add football picks around touchdowns and passing yards, to that very same lineup, and with basketball and football both in full swing, there are plenty of ways to build a lineup around the players and performances you're already following. For instance, you could do a little Matthew Stafford, you know, more than on his passing total, and then you could do a little maybe less than on Luka Doncic and some turnovers. It is that easy to do. Take your numbers, more, less, you're off, you're down the road, you're having a great time. So download the app today and use the code LOCKEDONNFL to get $50.00. Instantly in lineups when you play your first $5.00 lineup. Again, download the app today. Use the code LOCKEDONNFL to get $50.00 instantly in lineups when you play your first $5.00 lineup. Prize picks, run your game.
Speaker 1We keep it rolling here on Locked on Rams. Appreciate you rambling again. Leave those grades that you have for yourself, or not for yourself, but from yourself here in the comments. And I'm going to give myself an F real quick, Travis, because I am so bad at predicting how long we are going to talk about certain things. And so once again, 20 personnel, that's going to get pushed to tomorrow because we've got to get through defensive grades still. We've only got seven minutes, man. So F for Gavin. And trust me, there's a lot of people in the comments that would love to put F for Gavin in the comments section.
Speaker 2That's right. That means you're doing a good job. Don't sweat them.
Speaker 1There you go. I love it. I love it. Well, let's talk defense. And I want to start with Aaron Donald. And I'm just going to come out and say it because I want to say it. Aaron Donald gets an A++++. I don't care. And I know stats-wise, maybe he doesn't. I know even production-wise, maybe he doesn't. This guy got off his couch. He was asked to only rush the passer on third and 15s. And yet he's out there on first and 10s getting mauled by guards because of all the injuries. And he's done an okay job. He finally got his first sack, had a sack and a half. In terms of actual production, he's actually been a lot better than you would think. He's ranked 12th on PFF in all interior defensive linemen with a 76.9 grade. So he's a top 15 D tackle in the league coming off the couch. And that's with him being asked to do things he wasn't asked to do. So I'm giving Aaron Donald an A++++, Travis.
Speaker 2Yeah, I'm not going to argue too hard with you. I might just give it a regular A because some of the quarterback sack numbers really aren't there. But you're right. I was wrong. I thought that he would show up and be Aaron Donald like we saw two years ago. The man hadn't played football in the NFL for two years. And I get it. He looks like. He's built like the Hulk. He's strong like the Hulk. And so you just thought he'd come in here and start throwing people around. Well, he got two years older. The league didn't get two years older. He got two years older. And he's in there, like you said, dealing with double. We saw it against Arizona last weekend and still dealing with triple teams. And he's still making plays on this defense week after week after week. Maybe it's not what we saw, you know, where he's in 20 sack night like he was a million years ago. But that double. That doesn't mean he hasn't been incredibly effective. He has. And I think those sack numbers, we finally saw it against the Cardinals. He got one and a half. That Miles Garrett is back allows him to be the guy that I think we thought and hoped that he would be. But that he can do this is just stupid. That he can do it at a high level is even more stupid. And that he can do it at the highest level is almost unfathomable. And that's basically what he's done. And so, yeah, I think you're spot on.
Speaker 1Yeah. It's still hard to fathom that he's done what he's done. Like, it's truly incredible. And he's playing well enough to where it's got me thinking, hey, like, this has been a rough year for the Rams. Is there a scenario where he comes back next year, Travis? And that's the year where they, like, you know, I'm trying to justify it in my brain. But I know it's not.
Speaker 2But what's so crazy is that this isn't golf. You know what I mean? Where you just come back. You're like, you know, you kind of stretch a little bit. Like, all right. This is not only is it the NFL, he plays in, interior defensive line position in the NFL. He's not a kicker or a punter or even a quarterback. I mean, nobody gets beat up more than that guy on this field. And he's out there. It's really remarkable.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's amazing. A-plus for Aaron Donald. Another guy that's a no-brainer A-plus, Trent McDuffie. He is unbelievable. The highest graded corner in the NFL so far this season. So, I mean, what else needs to be said? He's got two interceptions, a 90.6. PFF grade. Another great game against Arizona, 85.3 grade. He's given up, like, five catches the whole dang season. The only discussion is, hey, he's missed a game or two. And that's just bad luck. When he has played, he has been arguably the best Ram. So, no-brainer A-plus.
Speaker 2Think about this. When you go and you acquire a player to fix a glaring problem on your team, and then you pay him an exorbitant rate, the highest rate in the league at the time, and then the guy comes in. And you're like, yep. I mean, is there anything better than you can say about a guy than that? Because that can almost only go wrong to where, hey, we had a problem. We went and got it. And it's still a problem. Hey, we went and got it. And then you paid through the nose to do it. It's like, yeah, it's better, I guess. But is it actually great? It is exactly what the doctor ordered. He has been better than advertised. And by the way, you can throw Jalen Watson in there, too. I know that he's done. But he was terrific while he was out there as well. So the Trent McDuffie acquisition, it was 10 out of 10.
Speaker 1No notes. 10 out of 10. No notes. I'm going to go rapid fire. I'm going to give you four players, my grades. And you're going to say what stands out the most, what you might disagree with. Quinn Lake, I'm giving a B plus, too. I know he's been polarizing. There's times where he gets completely fried by a slot receiver because he's not really a corner. There's times where he struggles in the run game because he's not really a linebacker. He's a safety, right? But there's times he locks down opposing tight ends. He leads the team with three. Interceptions. So I'm going to give Quinton Lake a B plus. Real quick, Byron Young gets a B plus. The B-plus for me, another hot start, slowed down a little bit, but gets a sack in the most recent game. And then I'm giving a C-plus to both Nate Landman and Cam Curl. I didn't realize how bad, from a grading perspective, Cam Curl's been 56th out of 100 safeties in terms of his grade. I know it's a little silly to only go based on grades. And Nate Landman, he's had great games. He almost single-handedly won you the Bills game, but he also has been kind of poor in coverage, so I'm going to give him a C-plus as well.
Speaker 2Yeah, those sound about right. Lake does have the three picks. It feels like he should have five or six. It feels like he's dropped a few along the way. He's clearly the guy that opposing offenses are saying, okay, we're going at 37. That's where we're going to attack this defense. I think that matters a little bit. Landman is – Landman's boom or bust, right? When he peanut punches and the ball comes out, we love him. When that's not happening, you kind of lose track of him a little bit. Curl, I'll be honest. I haven't really spent – I haven't spent a ton of time kind of breaking down. I don't feel like he's killing them. I think much like offensive linemen, we only notice these guys when it's like, what is he doing out there?
Speaker 1And they don't give a big place. They don't give a big, long pass in place.
Speaker 2And that's why I think both him and Kitchens have done – and Lake, for that matter, have done a really good job in that role. I'm trying to think. Byron Young, I think you – it's been okay. I mean, I think it's only been okay. I expected more. And again, Garrett hasn't played. There's been some extenuating circumstances. But I thought Byron Young would be better than he's been this year. This feels like a little bit of a step in the wrong direction for him in 2026.
Speaker 1Yeah, a very up and down. Real quick, sneaky guys that deserve great grades. Omar Spates, I'm giving him an A. This guy's quietly been the fourth highest graded linebacker in the NFL, the highest graded Ram based on guys that have played the number of games he has other than – Trent McDuffie. And Emmanuel Forbes is the third highest graded corner in the NFL. I know it's kind of fluky. I know it's done a ton of snaps. But you at least got to give him his credit, considering the expectations of getting absolutely cooked coming into this year. And he has been decently good. And now we're going to need him without Jalen Watson.
Speaker 2When he stopped running out of bounds on kicks is when I started liking it. There you go. Much, much better that we stopped doing it. And by the way – and you don't even have to respond to this because I know we're kind of up against it – that you did not bring up the special teams means you're a very nice guy.
Speaker 1I mean, I don't know if there's a – what's the letter that comes after F in the alphabet? Yeah, that's what special teams would get.
Speaker 2Plus, we don't have enough time to go over all the kickers that they have. You know, there's just too many people to cover.
Speaker 1The only team that would have to grade multiple long snappers, three kickers, and a punter, yeah. Four kickers. Four kickers. Yeah, you're right. Four. Oh, my goodness. Four. Four kickers. I forgot. Oh, appreciate you, Rambly. Chris, you look at today, in my opinion, Miles Garrett gets an incomplete. He hasn't shown up to enough classes. So, that's all for today. We'll see you back here tomorrow as we start to transition to the Packers game. Like, comment, and leave those grades in the comments. We'll see you back here tomorrow. Go Rams.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The hosts assign a B minus to Matthew Stafford, acknowledging solid yardage and touchdown production but citing too many turnovers and a decline from his MVP-level form.
  2. The offensive line earns an A minus or better for keeping Stafford among the least pressured and sacked quarterbacks despite injuries and a suspension.
  3. Sean McVay receives a B plus for guiding an injury-depleted roster to a 6-4 record, though questionable decisions and play calls keep him from a higher grade.
  4. Aaron Donald is awarded an A-plus for returning from retirement and performing at a high level despite constant double and triple teams.
  5. Trent McDuffie earns a no-brainer A-plus as the NFL's highest-graded cornerback, validating the Rams' major acquisition.
  6. Quinn Lake and Byron Young receive B plus grades, while Nate Landman and Cam Curl get C plus marks for inconsistent play.
  7. Omar Spates and Emmanuel Forbes earn strong grades for quietly ranking among the league's best at their positions.
  8. Miles Garrett is given an incomplete grade because he has missed nearly the entire season, and special teams would grade below an F.

Summary:

This episode of Locked on Rams is a midseason report card, with hosts Travis Rogers and Gavin Carlson grading the Rams' offense, coaching staff, and defense through roughly ten games. The conversation begins with Matthew Stafford, the most polarizing player to evaluate. Both hosts settle on a B minus, noting that his yardage and touchdown totals remain strong but that turnovers, a lower depth of target, and diminished arm zip have kept him well below his MVP form. The offensive line earns high marks for protecting Stafford and powering a consistent run game despite injuries, while Sean McVay receives a B plus for steering an injury-ravaged roster to a 6-4 record, with some criticism for questionable decisions and play calls.

On defense, Aaron Donald earns an A-plus for coming off the couch and performing at a top-15 level despite constant double teams, and Trent McDuffie is a no-brainer A-plus as the NFL's highest-graded cornerback. Quinn Lake and Byron Young get B plus grades, while Nate Landman and Cam Curl receive C plus marks for inconsistent play. Omar Spates and Emmanuel Forbes earn praise for quietly strong seasons. Miles Garrett is graded incomplete because he has barely played, and special teams would receive a grade below an F. The hosts close by noting the team's resilience and looking ahead to the Packers game.

FAQs

They both gave him a B minus, citing strong yardage numbers but too many turnovers. They noted he has been better of late but is not playing at his MVP level from last season.

They gave the unit at least an A minus because Stafford has been among the least pressured and sacked quarterbacks in the league. The line has also kept the run game effective despite injuries and a suspension.

The hosts landed around a B plus. He gets credit for a six-and-four record and a four-game winning streak despite major injuries, but loses points for the Australia loss, the Miles Garrett situation, and overusing Puka Nacua.

He received an A or better because he came out of retirement and has played at a high level despite facing double and triple teams. He ranks among the top interior defensive linemen in PFF grade.

He earned a no-brainer A-plus as the highest-graded corner in the NFL. He has two interceptions and has allowed very few catches, making his acquisition a clear success.

Both received a B plus. Lake leads the team with three interceptions but is sometimes targeted in coverage, while Young started hot, slowed down, and remains up and down.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.