Go back

Reddit’s Most Unhinged Crime Stories (Thread Head Submissions!)

54m 51s

Reddit’s Most Unhinged Crime Stories (Thread Head Submissions!)

This episode of *Crimes of Reddit* features a collection of real and deeply personal true crime stories submitted by listeners, highlighting the unsettling intersection of trust, authority, and hidden danger. One central story revolves around Albert Fentress, a beloved high school history teacher who, despite being admired by students, murdered and cannibalized an 18-year-old student in 1979. The case is especially disturbing due to the contrast between Fentress’s warm, engaging persona and his horrific crimes, and the fact that his former student’s mother had sat next to him on a school trip. Fentress was declared not guilty by reason of insanity and remained in psychiatric care for decades, sparking questions about how such a dangerous individual could be trusted by students. Other stories include a teacher who was later found to have drinking issues, a roommate who experienced a terrifying, unexplained stare under the bed, and a relationship that turned toxic after the individual was revealed to be a long-term stalker and peeper. Another story involves a man caught on camera assaulting a man on a bus in Seattle, who remained free on $2 million bail, highlighting systemic failures. The episode underscores how people often idealize authority figures, making their crimes all the more jarring. It also emphasizes the importance of trusting one’s instincts, especially in relationships or environments where boundaries are crossed. The hosts stress that these stories come from real people, and the emotional weight of such experiences is profound. The episode concludes with a call for greater awareness, urging listeners to share their own stories—especially those involving trust, trauma, or betrayal—on the subreddit to build a community of shared understanding and resilience.

Transcription

9979 Words, 52946 Characters

English
A year or two before all this happened, my mom went on a school trip to Washington, D.C. and sat next to him on the bus on this trip. So imagine being a teenager, going on a school trip with one of your favorite teachers where you like them a lot, you're sitting next to them, you have this completely normal experience, and then a year or two later you find out that same teacher murdered and cannibalized an 18 year old kid. Subscribe now and step inside the world of Crimes of Reddit. Hello and welcome back to Crimes of Reddit. I'm Sabrina Deanna Rugga, I'm Alexis Linkletter, and we're excited to be back. We are so back. We're so back. Look, we've got merch on. Crimes of Reddit. It's perfect. We're matching, but we're not fully matching, because people were saying we were giving cult, which I kind of like, but I, you know, yeah, I'm not mad at that, but like, I think the coordinating is like a class year way to do it. It's more approachable. Don't get used to it. I mean, we like to match, so yeah, it's only a matter of time. Okay. I have something exciting to tell you that's completely out of left field. Did you know they discovered, and everyone's Sabrina's a cat person? I am. Very much a cat person, so this is why I'm bringing this up. For the first time in over a hundred years, they've discovered a new cat species. Did you know this? No, I did not. It's called the Tilkayo. What does it look like? Google it. T-I-L-C-A-Y-O. Lepardus, Tilkayo. It is so cute. Not only is it cute, it's like a fraction of the size of a house cat. It's like two pounds, they found them in Bolivia. If you want to Google this cat, it's going to blow your mind. It's like two to three pounds. Oh my goodness. Are you blown away with how cute it is? It's so cute. I know. I really want to get another cat, but I travel so much that I feel like it's been really hard to. Well, if you venture to Bolivia, you might be able to get one of these. I think it's so cute. What? The heck? Little nose. Look at it. Big eyes. I know. Three pounds. Yep. Wow. Thank you for sharing that. Welcome. I love cat news. Yeah. We also love true crime stories that you all submit to us. And that's like the coolest thing about starting this show, seeing how many of you, which we're calling you Threadheads, if that's like okay with you, if you consent to it, most of you voted for it. I wanted to scroll patrol, but it didn't win. We can interchange them. You can be both. Whatever you feel fits you. That's right. But it's been so cool to see how many people are submitting their own stories on our subreddit, which if you didn't know, we have a subreddit. It's called, it's our slash crimes of pod where you can submit your own stories or you can submit stories that you've read on Reddit that you want us to cover on the show, but it's so cool to see. It's also sad because a lot of people have experienced some really rough stuff. Yeah. The stories are wild and actually just like shows how resilient everybody is. Yes. It's incredible. Everyone's so willing to share, which is even more incredible. Everyone's been so supportive and nice. So because of that, we wanted to do an entire episode dedicated to stories that you, Threadheads, scroll patrolers, listeners have put on our subreddit, and that's what today is. That's what this episode is. We each have stories. I don't know what stories you have. You don't know what stories I have. We're going to react in real time. Yeah. Yeah. It's going to be a good. That's a good episode. They're just getting better. Yeah. But I think this one, especially because now we know it's a different connection to the story knowing that the relationship submitted it is listening and wanted to share it with us. Yeah. So it means a lot. It does mean a lot. Also exciting news, we recently launched an Instagram for crimes of Reddit. It is at crimes of Reddit pod. So be sure to follow us over there. We're going to keep posting updates and cute little friendship videos and other things that follow us. Yeah. Go over there. Right away. If you need more of us, we're there. Yep. Yeah. We'll inundate your feed with silly videos. Precisely. Okay. So we'll get into the episode and some of our stories. But before we do, we want to give a content morning because in this episode, there are mentions of murder, sexual assault, rape, child abuse, mutilation, cannibalism, gun violence, suicidal ideation. Oh my gosh. Sorry. Wow. That's so big harassment. So please listen with care. This one does have a lot in it. That is the longest trigger warning we've ever had yet or maybe that I've ever heard on any show. Yeah. Just covering all our bases. I do think a lot of them come from this first story. Okay. Yeah. I mean, I was just looking at how long it is. There's a lot. So this was posted on our feed on our subreddit crimes of pod. And it is called my mom's favorite teacher was a murderer. Hello, ladies. I hope you're doing well. As you can see by the title, this story is kind of extreme. I don't know how much of the detail I should go into because it's kind of crazy, but here we go. My family is from New York. Go Yankees. Also, as a Yankees fan living in Boston, it's been like one of the hardest things that I've experienced. Do you tell people or do you just keep it yourself? I tell my friends. Okay. And they harass me, but I love when the Yankees play the red socks because then I can wear my Yankees stuff and not hide. Okay. I love that. Yeah. Anyway, go Yankees. And this happened in 1979 when my mom was in high school. And honestly, this is why this story hits a little differently for me because this teacher was my mom's teacher. His name was Albert Ventress. Now this was not a random teacher. I've all had teachers who just kind of just show up because they're required to be, but no. I asked my mom recently and she remembers how good of a teacher Albert was. He was the type of teacher who made history interesting and somebody who made an impression on his students. A year or two before all this happened, my mom went on a school trip to Washington, DC and sat next to him on the bus on this trip. So imagine being a teenager, going on a school trip with one of your favorite teachers where you like them a lot, you're sitting next to them, you have this completely normal experience. And then a year or two later, you find out that same teacher murdered and cannibalized an 18 year old kid. Yeah. Any thoughts? I wish there was something stronger in here. I am a guest and I, yeah, I'm eager to hear more because like incredible setup, but horrible, horrible. Okay. The murder took place. Albert Fentress from the accounts I found was actually a pretty memorable teacher. This is not just my mom's account. It's also in the court record too. Former students like my mom talked about him dressing up as historical figures and really getting into what he was teaching. So this was not somebody that everyone looked at and thought, wow, there's something wrong with that guy. No. He was a teacher who seemed to genuinely love his kids to love teaching, which makes his crime all the more crazy. More later, accounts about students actually harassing him and vandalizing his home, including a really disturbing incident involving a homophobic slur being burned into his lawn. I do say that part carefully because some of those details come from later reporting and retellings rather than the original court record. So it's hard to know if it's real. Regardless, according to those accounts, it is said that Fentress had become increasingly paranoid and afraid that someone was going to break into his house because of the increase in vandalism, he bought a handgun and kept it in his home. So then we get to August of 1979. There had been a fight involving high school students one night. And I've seen the story told us there was a planned rumble, West Side Story rumble. Yeah, type of thing between rival schools. Police found out about it and there's nothing official to say what actually happened. It's more some eyewitnesses who were there that night, but it's reported that 18-year-old Paul Masters ended up in Fentress's yard after running from the police following a fight involving other high school students, so like this rumble. And this, when Paul Masters ends up in Albert Fentress's yard, is where everything changes. I've heard the story. You have. Yeah. It's like a big, it's a big real case that like we have news articles. That's insane. Yeah. And this was our listener's mom's teacher. Okay. Wow. Paul in his yard and who knows what was going through his mind at that point, but something terrible happened. So content warning here for readers and listeners, I guess, because we're reading a lot. According to later reporting and statements from Fentress himself, he asked Paul to help bring some wood down to his basement because it was too heavy for him. Once he got Paul into his basement, he restrained him, tying him to a pole on the support beam on the floor. He sexually assaulted Paul and mutilated him. Fentress then shot Paul twice in the head with a very gun he had bought for protection. But that is not all. Afterward, Fentress cooked an eight parts of Paul's body. After it happened, Albert Fentress called someone at 212 in the morning. He called a friend named Wallace Schwartz, who was a friend of his and a former student. have become a lawyer and Fentress trusted him very much. On the phone call, he went on to tell Wallace that he was about to kill himself and take his own life. And at first, Wallace thought maybe something had happened accidentally. The court record says that Fentress was speaking in a low monotone voice that he was very obviously distraught, but was still coherent. Wallace tried to talk him out of it. He offered to come over. He offered to have Fentress come to his house, but Fentress refused all offers. He hung up with Wallace and Wallace concerned then called his mother and they called the police. They were concerned about Fentress's mental health of someone that they considered a friend. And they had no idea what was going on with him. When the police arrived, Fentress did not try to run. He was near an open window and actually beckoned officers inside. He said, Officer, please come in and take the gun. Police searched the house. They found the body part in a pot on the stove and found Paul Masters' mutilated corpse on the basement floor restrained. During the trial, the judge went through all of those phone calls and conversations in details. And it's truly one of the strangest parts of reading the actual court record because you can follow the night almost minute by minute, hour by hour, and you can see where everything just goes completely wrong. So during the trial, the question of insanity came in. Fentress was found not guilty by reason of insanity in 1980 and was committed to psychiatric care instead of being sent to prison. He remained there. Despite the fact that he killed someone over the years, Fentress repeatedly came before the courts over whether he should be released from psychiatric care. In 1999, a jury actually determined that he was mentally ill, but voted that he did not require inpatient care because of a substantial risk of physical harm. The judge ultimately set that decision aside and Fentress remained in psychiatric care. Then in 2002, he was moved to a locked forensic psychiatric facility after testimony involving allegations that he had actually sexually abused two young boys before the murder. By 2006, psychiatrists were still arguing that he needed to remain in a secure psychiatric setting. They testified that Fentress couldn't properly grasp or explain what he had done to Paul. And now this is where I keep coming back to my mom. Because when I hear this story, I don't just picture some random teacher from the '70s. I picture the fact that this was my mom's favorite teacher. That she sat next to him on a school trip to Washington, DC and had no reason to look at him or think that he was capable of murdering anyone. I think we want the person who does something horrible to look like somebody who would do something horrible. We want there to be a warning sign. But sometimes there isn't one. Sometimes the person is the teacher everybody likes. Someone who makes history interesting. And honestly, that's what makes this case so disturbing to me. Not just what he did to Paul, but also very much what he did to Paul. Yes. But also the fact that before any of it happened, he was somebody's favorite teacher. They did share their name, so I'll read it. It's from Katie. Shout out Katie. Thank you for sharing the story. Yeah, but you can look up news articles about this. It's a very real case. It's so interesting because I didn't read all the court records. But it seems to be painted as if he snapped. And he doesn't even understand why he did the things that he did, but it's so extreme. Yeah. And I think that based on my recollection, the vandalism of the house, at least in the retelling that I received, like that apparently was pretty relentless. So he might not have ever done something like this, had Paul not wandered into his yard. And it might have started as you're one of them who's been doing this. And then once this kid is in his house, he saw an opportunity, and then maybe the rage that he had, simmering about what he was doing, mixed with his true impulses that he may have been trying to suppress. I mean, if he was sexually abusing two students prior to this, he didn't fully suppress them. But it was probably a mixture of opportunity and resentment. And this once a student's in his house, this strange fantasy thing took over for him. Like he gives into this darkest. You're not operating the way that a normal human does. Like you're making decisions that you know are wrong. Yeah. Did you ever have a teacher, not who murdered and cannibalized, but did you ever have a teacher? Because I think naturally we, or else we for myself, like idolize people in positions of power, like parents, teachers. And you just think that they're these like perfect humans, especially while you're growing up and you don't really have a full understanding of the world and reality. Have you ever experienced someone having a secret dark side in that role? Kind of. It's funny and I just found out about this. I'm friends with this teacher on Facebook, by the way. He was like my favorite teacher. He was my fifth grade teacher. I'm not going to say his name. But my best friend Rita, who listens to crimes of Reddit. Hey, Rita. I was just home in Long Island visiting her on Long Island. And I talked about our teacher. We had in fifth grade. And she had tea from somebody who he's still a teacher. And apparently he was like put on leave or something because he was drinking, he brought a coffee cup with him. And apparently it was like he was drinking straight liquor every day. And they found out. And like, I don't know if he's tenured or what, but they moved him to like an administrative role where he's not with kids right now. And I was like, he was the best, he was the best teacher. Right now it's like, I mean, my problem is it's like once you're willing to cross one boundary around kids, then you've already-- it's already too dangerous. Because if you've been able to excuse that, especially this day and age when schools are not as safe as they used to be, you need to be on your shit. And if you're able to excuse-- if you're able to break one rule around children, it's a slippery slope. Because your boundaries need to be rock solid when you're around kids. I did, recently, have-- I just learned someone who was a teacher at my college was under review for like inappropriate behavior. You did that, so what is inappropriate behavior? I've just-- my Italian's coming out as I speak with my hands-- inappropriate behavior with students. He was under review. And then I just saw on Facebook. He was like, it's sad to say goodbye. He's painting it as if he's leaving on his own will. But I'm like, this is suspicious. I think they probably made some deal. Yeah. I don't like that. That I don't like. No, but I've also had some teachers with incredible boundaries. That does remind me there are good ones, which is great. What a story. Let me see if there's any comments or anything on this one. There's no updates or comments. But yeah, that's really-- Is this orienting to have someone who is in such a crucial role become a monster? Yeah, I mean, I think it's traumatizing, especially at that age, that impacts your worldview. Like you trusted that authority figure. You liked them. It wasn't just respect because of fear. And to find out someone you liked is capable of that is really disturbing. I'm really curious for all of you out there who are listening or watching. If you have experiences similar to this, or if any type of authority role or figure that you had in your life turned out to be a terrible person. School of Reddit stories would be great. That's a good one. When you're doing an episode on that. Because there's like school pranks gone wrong. There's like strange teacher stories. That would be a great-- Like senior pranks. Did you have a senior prank? I'm sure we did. Oh, yeah, it's the same thing every year, though. What is it? So I went to a school called Smithtown High School. And the whole mascot for the whole town is this ball. Because the legend is, this guy rode this ball for as long as he could ride it. And that's how big of the town is. That's like the Native American said, you can have that land for Smithtown. So the ball is like the this giant ball statue in the middle of the town. And every year somebody paints its penis red. For the prank, it happens every year. One person doesn't. We don't know who does it. Someone does it every year. Interesting. So that's what happened that year. Well, I know I want to know who passes the baton. I don't know, I think. How do you get chosen? You think you just take the initiative? One person just doesn't. You know, you have an inner calling. That's a very specific prank. Yeah, yeah. Are we ready for the next story? I am. [MUSIC PLAYING] roommate story. OK, ooh. O.P. says, I just listened to the roommate's episode. I have a short but very creepy story about a roommate I had. I am a woman. I was 20 years old when this happened. The roommate was a 21-year-old woman. We were doing a summer job at a university. And we're staying in dormitories. So we shared a bedroom. We were randomly paired. I didn't pick her. She came off a little strange, OK? We weren't really friends because we just didn't vibe that way. Therefore, we never talked much. We kept different hours. And she was always going to bed much later than me. One night, I woke up. And it was around 1 or 2 am. I had no idea what woke me up. Then I heard a weird rustling noise. That's never good. My roommate's bed was elevated on bed risers. Do you remember those? Yeah, mine was-- I had the highest possible. And then my desk was underneath. So her bed was elevated on bed risers. I rolled over. And she was crouched in a full squat looking at me. When I read this on our subreddit, it's crazy. Our beds were only about six feet apart. It was fairly dark, so I thought my eyes just weren't adjusted and we're playing tricks on me. I tried to go back to sleep. Oh, did you? Because I would be awake for the rest of my life. I really, you have to. It's like when you're like paralyzed with fear, it's just like, you know what? I'm gonna, I'm gonna pretend this doesn't exist. I guess, so I tried to go back to sleep, but I could feel eyes watching me. Oh my God. So I looked back over and yes, she was crouched under her bed looking at me. We made eye contact. I could see what little moonlight was coming through the windows reflecting off her eyes. I love that visual. Thank you for painting the picture. I feel like a predator in the wild is trying to hunt you. Yeah. So I could see the moonlight bouncing off her eyes, right? I wish I could see peering through her long dark hair that was hanging down in a Samara light. I was just like, okay, Samara. Like the ring. Like I would do this to a friend as a joke. That doesn't surprise me. That doesn't, I would do this to my dog. Your dog probably doesn't do you know I wouldn't. Oh, he continues. I said, what the fuck are you doing? And she said nothing like she was silent. And then she said nothing and backwards walked deeper under the bed in the crouched position further into the dark. That's a horror movie. Yeah. Especially when the person doesn't like break the character. Like it's one thing to do like something spooky for a second or like maybe she woke up accidentally when she was like trying to get something and it felt weird like, yeah, you're in a shared room. Maybe she was doing something weird and like you caught her and she's freaked out. But what could what could she have been doing? I don't know. People with weird stuff. People need their own space. Shared rooms are always a risk. It's so unsettling. Yeah. So the OP says something. She says, you are scaring me, please stop. She said nothing again but continued staring as she crawled backwards further under the bed. How much room is under this bed? Too much. I had nowhere else to go and didn't know what to do. So I rolled over and just tried to close my eyes. She never came out from under the bed. Eventually, I must have fallen asleep because the next thing I knew it was morning. I asked her about it the next day and she said she didn't know what I was talking about. Still creeps me out to this day. It's actually giving Alexis as a little girl screaming under your parents bed, screaming under my parents bed and having no recollection of it. So, well, maybe it was a sleepwalking incident. Maybe it was, maybe, okay, you're going to give benefit of the though. No. I mean, maybe she was on a sleep medication like Ambien or something that kind of messes with your memory, messes with your behavior. Have you heard stories about people taking drugs like that and like making, like making the equivalency of like drunk, dialing people and not remembering or doing really strange stuff like ordering things online and not remembering, right? Like certain medications can prompt really odd sleep behavior. Yeah, but I feel like a grant that we don't have any like follow up or anything. We don't get like a ton of information from OP, but the way OP paints it is like this roommate was already weird. Exhibiting odd behavior. And also, if you were, if you did have odd sleep behavior like sleepwalking, that would have been the time to mention it when the roommate confronted you about what you were doing last night on your bed. Like, oh, that happened sometimes. I sleepwalk. I'm really sorry. One of my biggest fears, and I don't sleepwalk, so it's kind of an irrational fear maybe, but is pet cemetery, where like my fear is waking up in the morning and there's like dirt in between my toes and indication that I was outside in the wilderness, but I have no recollection of it. Yeah. I don't think that will ever happen to me. I hope, but it's one of my biggest fears would be an adventure. You don't even get to know what happened. Yeah, you'd have to wear like metaglasses to sleep or something and see where you end up going. Metaglasses are kind of scary. You know, they are, but I've been seeing some incredible tiktok sawgas that like, you only have justice because you recorded everything. Yeah. Yeah. There's good to it. It does feel like a black mirror episode though. Yeah. I mean, I know the world feels like a black mirror episode really does. Yeah. I'm trying to think like, if I've had any experience similar to that, I haven't because you had bad roommate situations, yes. But never with like them staring at me in a dark room and not like mine were much more over. Yeah. Those are like, what's so the subtle creepiness is like, it's not subtle actually. Like at that point, which is like, stop straight up creepy, stop you're scaring me. I mean, and that person not remembering or claiming not to. Yeah. The worst thing I had was I, a roommate said that my cat was misaligning her chakras and her crystal heal healer said that the cat needed to go and I managed to go for me needs to go. Yeah. Yeah. Actually, no. My cat did live with my mom for four months because of that. Because of that? Yeah. Because I'm a pushover. I've gotten a lot better. I'm glad. That was 10, 15 years ago. Okay. Are you ready for the next story? I can't wait. This one, I do have a lot of personal experiences that I can relate to on it. And it is really quite horrifying because it has like elements of Golden State Killer peeping toms, like the potential of how bad it could have gotten is really, really scary. Okay. This is called our house caught the bogeyman, but first we were stalked. Hello, Sabrina and Alexis. I was listening to the episode on stalkers and the one on toxic romantic relationships. And I realized I have a story that has both. It started with stalking and climaxed with the long-weighted conclusion to a manhunt thanks to our house. This was just the beginning of a turbulent and dangerous toxic relationship that I eventually did flee. In 2018, I, 21 female, moved back to Colorado from Flagstaff, Arizona, where I had been going for school. See, my best friend and I had moved to Flagstaff, but after a really chaotic year, we both decided we had to move back home to our home state. Despite the disappointment, I took it as a sign to chase my dreams of pursuing dancing professionally. So me and the girl, my best friend from Flagstaff, moved into this darling old Victorian house in Fort Collins, Colorado. We felt far enough away from our hometown of Colorado Springs, while still being familiar in the state we grew up in. The home we rented was split into two units. The front of the house had three bedrooms, a living room, a kitchen, bathroom, and washer and dryer closet. Then, the back of the house had two bedrooms, a living room, bathroom, basement, and a kitchen, which was all much smaller than the front. But we didn't have access to that back area. When we first moved in, it was the end of spring. Summer was on the horizon. We would go out dancing every weekend, laughing, eating the best lamb gyros, gyros, gyros, gyros. Gyros? Really? I think so. Gyro? It's Greek. I'm a vegetarian. What do I know? They were having fun. Point being. Okay. We all went to festivals and concerts together. It was great. Everything was heavenly until it wasn't. So there were three of us roommates, myself, who were going to call S for the sake of the story. My best friend, who we were called G, and my best friend G's friend, who we were called D. At first, we were all going out having the best time. That is until I met this guy, J. The night I met him, we were all out dancing, and D decided to go home early because she had work in the morning. G was heartbroken over a guy and not feeling it. So the whole night, I was chasing her around, trying to cheer her up and comfort her. At a bar, while I was chasing G around, I was suddenly stopped by someone who grabbed my arm and then my hand. I stopped and looked, expecting to see someone who I knew because that's how it felt. But instead, I saw a guy who was about medium height and build brown hair, olive tone skin, and warm brown eyes. I didn't recognize him, but he was looking at me as though I should. He told me he loved my third eye pine cone and I told him thanks while still trying to place who he was. Suddenly, G came up behind me, wondering where I had gone, and then pulled me away before I could really talk to this guy. So we were at this other club, but her ex ghosted her and she was too distraught to stay. So she turned quickly and tried to leave. I tried to chase her, hoping to convince her to stay. And suddenly, I was face to face with that guy again. He was standing there patiently waiting, like he was waiting for me or had followed me. I'm just going to say that because that's what he did. Smiling confidently, I met his eyes and the next words out of his mouth were, "You would look good on my boat." In Colorado, doesn't that sound like you would look good in a grave? That's what it's giving. Maybe I know the whole story, so I don't like him. Oh, he says, "I scoffed and laughed loudly because that has to be the most ridiculous and corny line I'd ever heard. It's so snobby yet hilarious coming out of this guy who looked more like his vibe was red rocks, shoes, and deep nature camping." I thought the fact that we ran into each other twice was some kind of sign, and I liked how confident he was and how he looked at me like a miracle or a masterpiece full of meaning. So I gave him my number. We started talking. He introduced himself. I learned about him. For the sake of the story, we're calling him Jay. And then Jay and I started sleeping together super casually. But very quickly after a week or so, he asked to date exclusively. He told me he'd been single for four years and was so happy to finally have found someone he wanted to date seriously. I was touched as I had come from a very chaotic and sexually/emotionally abusive home. I had never had someone pursue me like he had. Doesn't it feel very predator? It's a love bombing. It is love bombing. Yeah. He took me on a shopping spree, fancy dinners, nice vacations. He paid for my hair, my nails, my waxing. He would write me poetry. No. Is poetry an "ick" for you? Yeah. I'm going to start writing you poems. That's different. Okay. We can write each other poems. It's one of those things where it's like cool. If you become a famous poet, maybe I'm not as "icked," but like climbing that hill to get there. No. Have you ever had a man play music for you? Yes. It back gives me an "ick." Like so much. And I'm not icking everyone else's "That's Your Thing," but he was not good. And it was also the first time we met. I was hungover in the morning and he pulls out his guitar and so seriously was play. Oh, no. And I was like, I need to get out of here. This was in college and then I ran back to my dorm and I threw up in the shower. I was so hungover. It was miserable. You weren't ready to accept the music. No. He wasn't reading the room. He was bad. Yeah. Yeah. Poetry and music, not for us. Okay. So around the same time that Jay and I became exclusive, things in our house started getting really tense between myself and my roommates because things started going missing and no one would fess up to taking things. Clothing would go missing, like socks, bras, panties, bathing suits, perfume and pictures started going missing. And we all kept thinking like one of us was doing it, but it started causing a lot of tension between us. Now, at the time I was working at a Cosmos pizza, some nights I worked as a slicer in the building and other nights I was delivering pizza and it was always till 3 a.m. One evening I came home and I went to my bedroom, which is in the back of the house. And there was a window right behind my bed next to my head and next to the nightstand. And I noticed a strange smudge on the window, but it was dark and I was tired, so I shrugged, I rolled over and went to sleep. The next morning I saw more smudges on my window. I sat up at my forearms, I turned my head to see the light catch the surface and that is when I noticed. These smudges were handprints all over my window. I put my hand up to them and I saw that they were far too large to be mine, so it wasn't OP's hand. But they were covering the window. I'm a paranormal girly, so immediately I thought, ooh, there's a spooky ghost haunting this old Victorian home, which I think will all agree we wish that was what was happening in this story. But upon closer look, I realized those handprints were not on the inside of the window. As I was trying to wipe them off, I realized they were all on the outside of the window. I put pants and shoes on and I ran outside to the side of my house to see the window and I get there and I'm sick to my stomach as I see what I didn't notice before. That old-fashioned metal screen to my window had been cut open from the top side and peeled back. Someone had been outside of my bedroom peering in. Uneasy and confused, I called Jay, the guy that OP is dating, and told him to come over and told him what I found. I was hoping for some concern and comfort, but instead Jay yelled at me and was suddenly suspicious of me saying and accusing of men climbing into my bedroom while he's not there. There were frat boys who lived next door and as context, I have trauma from sexual assault from when I was a teenager. So accusations of men sneaking into my window triggered me deeply and also like you're calling your boyfriend for support and how to fear. And then now he's like blaming you. I was furious that he blamed me so I broke up with him. I left my house to get some space and grab a coffee, but Jay wouldn't take no for an answer. So instead, he hopped into his car and raced around town chasing me trying to convince me to take him back. Due to my trauma, I thought this was really romantic and thrilling and so I did take him back. After this though, Jay was all of a sudden way more worried for me and decided that I should just stay at his house for my own safety. Again, I was wrapped up in the newness and excitement of such a passionate affair that I happily agreed. At this time, G started having occurrences, so G's the best friend who's also living there, where she would go take a shower and go to her bedroom to find the curtains that she had closed prior to going to take a shower were opened in her bedroom. Clothing continued to go missing. I eventually, along with my cat, moved into Jay's house pretty much full time because the house we were living in with my roommates felt so tense. We were all fighting a lot. One night, I'm at Jay's and G calls me in tears, panicking. She said she closed her curtains and went to go take a shower. When she came back to her bedroom, she has one window that does not have curtains. She sees a man standing there watching her touching himself. I was with Jay and we rushed over there with weapons. His new house was only a couple minutes from ours, but when we got there, no one was there and there was no evidence that was left behind to indicate who this man was or what he was doing. We discussed calling the police but decided against it because we didn't have a good history asking law enforcement for help, which is a whole different story. But because of this, we just decided not to call the police. Each time I was staying at Jay's house, this kept happening. G kept calling. Every time I was at Jay's house saying the man was basically standing there again. I begged her to call the police and tell them everything. And so finally, she did. The police asked if they could hang some cameras on the exterior of our house and we were happy that they were going to help. We were actually surprised that they wanted to do something. So we let them. Jay went on a work trip and while he was gone, I decided to go back to my house with my cat because I didn't want to be alone. And I genuinely loved my house and really wanted to get on better terms with my roommates. I came home after driving delivery all night. It was almost 3.30 a.m. I started to unlock my door when I felt a deep sense of dread. The second I stepped inside, every hair stood on end. And suddenly, I felt someone wrapping an arm around my waist, putting a hand over my mouth, holding me back to the back of the house from the front door. My body went cold. I sunk into fight mode, trying to make myself heavy, a dead weight. I sunk down. I fell to the ground. I started crawling away, but I was pulled back. It was at this moment I heard a familiar laugh. It was Jay. He pulled me onto his lap, laughing deep belly laughs in my ears, praying, "Oh, baby, did I scare you?" Ew. Yeah. Confused. I took a moment to catch my breath and calm my body. I was trembling. I asked him what he was doing back and he said he decided to come home a few days early to surprise me. What a fucked up. Ew. Stand and still confused. I nodded, I kissed him, I let him into the house, we went to bed. And I can't remember if it was this night or another one, but one evening, while Jay was sleeping over, I barely fell asleep. When I heard a strange creaking in my house, and again, I thought it was paranormal. So I didn't really want to open my eyes. But then I felt hot breath on my face. Ew. I opened my eyes and I saw a man in my bedroom, bent over, leaning over me to look at me. When I opened my eyes, he jumped back and ran out of my bedroom. I screamed. I cried. Jay woke up next to me, shook his head, ran out of the bedroom, chasing after this man, but he couldn't find him. After this, I was like, I'm done. So it's not Jay, which already is like, I didn't see. I mean, he seems really weird and creepy. Yeah, this is why it's an interesting story because I can't wait. Like Jay is clearly not a good guy. No, but there's like, it was not that bad. Two crimes happening. Yeah. After this, I decided I am done sleeping at my house. I did not feel safe there. My relationship with my roommates has slowly deteriorated. And a month or so later, we were notified by the police that an arrest was made and that they had caught him because he had showed up at our house. Like this was a stalker and peeping Tom that had been known to the police for the better part of a decade. All over Fort Collins for several years, young women attending CSU and living in the houses surrounding the university were being stalked. And in most cases, this is content warning. Most cases after being stalked for a really long time, they had all been molested or raped. They said that they had been trying to catch him for years and years. And when we called, they realized that this was the guy they had been looking for and that we were likely next. So they used us essentially to catch this guy. They told us his MO was stalking girls who lived close to downtown. He would follow them home, peep on them through the windows, slice open screens. He would take personal items and panties. He He would eventually break in and rape the girls in the middle of the night, sometimes drugging them. They said they were able to find out that he lived in the neighborhood for decades, and victims usually never saw him, and that's why he got away for so many years. But G was able to get a good look at him because she had seen him a couple of times in her window. Because of that, she was able to pick him out of a lineup. So yeah, that was the end of our Fort Collins stalker, but just the tip of the iceberg with my toxic relationship with Jay, which I'll add an update to finish that story, which we don't unfortunately have yet. But I have to go to work now is what our OP says, Tata for now. Well, the suspense about Jay is killing me, I got to know. But also how fucked up of Jay to know that they're dealing with essentially a stalker/peeping Tom, and copy that, yeah, it's really a bizarre, insidious joke, yes, I'm not into it. Yeah, it's messed up. And I did try to look up the story about the peeping Tom and stalker to see if they got, if there was any tip of trial, if they were convicted of their crimes, if they're behind bars or anything. Unfortunately, there are a lot of peeping Tom stories in the news in this area, really. Which is the truth. The truth, yeah. And this is what I was going to say is in college, I went to Loyola Marymount, and in the neighborhood where we all lived in the neighborhood, there were so many peeping Tom cases. And we all believe it was the same guy. He knew that these houses were college girls. He would do the same thing. He would break into people's houses. He started memorizing the girls' schedules who lived in the houses, and cops never could do anything. Like even, they would always say, put up cameras, and then we'll catch him and then be able to arrest him. This guy was so brazen, he would see the cameras recently installed. He would go up, move them, so they couldn't see what he was doing, and then still continue. So terrifying. Yeah. It's so scary. Yeah. Thank God they caught the guy in this case before it escalated. I know. It doesn't make it any more comforting though, because it's like you know that what his plans were. And I think God, I mean for how shitty Jay seems that he was there that night next to her in bed, because that could be why he didn't attack her. Right. So fucked up. Mm-hmm. Have you dealt with peeping Tom? I don't think so. That's good. It's not that I know of. Maybe a good one. It's so violating. Yeah. Especially the like stealing your underwear. I don't think I've ever had a bedroom on the first floor of any building. I don't know that I have either. I think that's probably why I haven't dealt with one. Yeah. But I don't think that like my college house, it was two stories and he would break into the house like which is crazy. Yeah. Like we had to stop leaving windows open, which is also like you're changing your entire way of living. Mm-hmm. That which is so unfair. Yeah. Yeah. So scary. We're both. Well, I'm glad you're okay. And I'm looking forward to the Jay update. I know we'll have to do like a follow up to this episode with updates. Yeah. Are we ready for our final story? Yeah. What do you have? My ex was a secret murderer. I, 26 female, was dating a guy, 30 male, for about eight months. He had met my family and things were going great. Then one day he seemed to ghost me. I couldn't get a hold of him and so I thought it was just time to move on after a few weeks of not being able to get in contact a few weeks is nuts. I'm curious how long they have been dating. Eight months. Eight months? Yeah. Being ghosted after eight months is kind of crazy. Yeah. One day our friend reached out to me and asked if they could call me. During the call they told me that Kyle had been arrested for murder. Kyle is the guy that she was dating for eight months. It turns out that he had murdered a man in the middle of his dating and acted no differently and told nobody until he was caught months later. Presumably when they were dating, when he ghosted her, is probably when he got caught. Damn. I did some digging and figured out that he had come over to my house directly after murdering the man. Mind you, he had never shown any of this type of behavior and we had bonded over being deadheads and hippies that thrive on peace and love. Well, now you can be a threadhead and bond with us over that. Much safer. Yeah. As far as I know, he's still not in prison even though him murdering that man is all on camera. I'll put the link below. Now in this news article, it basically gives this TLDR in June, 53 year old William Tapay was getting off a Metro bus in West Seattle when he brushed against a bike belonging to 30 year old Kyle Castillo Castillo jumped off the bus beat him and kicked him in the head before getting back on and bragging about it to another passenger. I know random violence. So Tapay made it a few blocks before a bystander called 9-1-1 and he died in the hospital days later. Castillo is charged with second-degree murder and is out on $2 million bail. How? Well, bail's so stupid, it's like you only have to post a percentage of that. But I'm sorry. If it's on camera of you murdering someone, that feels to get a good defense attorney to argue, whatever. Yeah, no, it feels insane and unsafe for the community at large, but this shit happens all the time where people who are clearly dangerous are let out on bail. So OP has a follow-up slash edit. She says this, he also had a bunch of past charges that none of us me and friends knew about. He kept on making excuses about why we couldn't go over to his house and spent time at mine instead. It was more central to our friends, locations, et cetera. Turns out he didn't have a house. He was living with his parents. So the times I dropped him off were just at a random area, not his actual home. Geez. So we've got some comments. Should we go through them? Yeah. And we're lucky you didn't get dragged into interrogations or court proceedings. Think goodness for that at least. Now, those are your lucky that he didn't just like randomly get angry with you and like be violent. Yeah. You said when he came over to your house after committing the act, did he not give you any type of vibes that something was off or acted in a way that gave you a sense that he was hiding something? And OP's response was that he just said he was tired and it was super late. I told him I worked the next day and couldn't really hang out. So it was quick and also like, I'm sorry, but if like you're seeing someone for a couple of months and like one night, they are kind of in a bad mood, I don't think I had to jump to, oh, they just murdered someone. No, people are in a bad mood for reasons all the time that for no reason at all. For no reason at all. Yeah. People are just tired. Can't agree. Moody. Yeah. Brooding. But anyways, like, you know what, there's synonyms coming out. You wouldn't think this isn't where anyone's mind would jump, right? No. So another commenter said, oh my god, I remember this happening. I had just been on a Metro bus in West Seattle at the same time and heard about it later on. A way too close to home. I'm so sorry you had to experience that situation. Another says you're lucky to be alive. I think it's scarier that he didn't act any different. Well, let's unpack that a little bit. He might not have known that he killed someone. Okay, but he's still like really violently like beat someone. Yes, that's still yes, but I think there is something. I don't know because I'm not violent and I've never killed anybody. But like I think maybe something like maybe you'd have a moment of like existential, existential crisis being like, oh my god, this, the magnitude of this act like or even just for the sense of self preservation, like fear that now you're going to jail, like beating someone badly and murdering someone super different about like the way police pursue the case and like how badly you've messed up your life. So it's like, yeah, I agree that the casual violence and not thinking it's a big deal and just going on with your night is a huge deal no matter how you slice it and definitely red flag. But because of the way this article described what happened that he made it a few blocks before a bystander called 911, he might, you know, the serious things that he got he ran it like he walked off kind of right thing insane though. But also this is a type of man who clearly isn't thinking about consequences and is a little bit detached from his actions and like lack of empathy. I mean, there's a lot wrong with us. It's also so scary because like, can you really ever know someone that especially that early on in dating like they've been together for at that point, I don't know, six months and then eight months by the time he like goes at her, you don't really know this person, but they're saying, your house, you're spending tons of quality time with them. And then to learn that about them, I don't, I don't think I'd have a really hard time trusting or dating people in the future. Yeah. And I would say to the bigger question, can you ever really know someone? I think no, but all you can know for sure is like, I'm in a dysfunctional situation where things are being kept for me because like we've heard several instances where serial killers keep it from their family successfully. But when you unpack the kind of relationships that we're going on, super dysfunctional. So like you can know that you're under someone's control and they're compartmentalizing their lives without knowing like why, right? But if you can recognize that. then at least you could sort of anticipate that something might be going on. But when it's this early like there still are a lot of questions. Like you know, you're not. That's a really relatively young relationship. Like I still think you're young when you're 30 which the guy, the murderer was. When you're 26 you're, you're bringing just finished developing. So like I think this is still, yeah. It's where you make mistakes, you know. Damn, I'm sorry that you experienced that. I know. I'm sorry too. It's really scary. And I'm so glad you were okay. Yeah. Wow, you guys have some wild stories. We want to keep hearing from you. So please share your experience as your stories. If you can relate to any of these. If you have stories that are similar or completely different. Please share them with us on our subreddit which is our backslash crimes of pod. It's also linked in the show notes and whatnot. So easy to find. Yeah, they just hit different when they come from you to be honest. Like there's just something deeper about it. And I don't know if it's just like me personally where I feel more angry about them. Yes, because it feels like we know you. Yeah. Yeah, it's me really mad. It does make me mad. And I also feel we're going to do more episodes like this where we read stories submitted by Threadheads, scroll patrollers. And we'll also include your stories in like other theme topic episodes. But even today I was on our subreddit and looking at stories. And there's new ones that I wanted to include in this episode too. So we'll do more of these. We'll do another one. We'll do more. Yeah. A lot of these stories actually reminded me of the book you just lent to me to read, Bright Young Women by Jessica Noll, which is like a fictionalized, but somewhat based in reality, telling of the Ted Bundy story, but more about the victim of the victims. And some of the survivors, which is even like, it was a really beautiful story. Incredible. And well done. But yeah, there's a lot of like similarities with the perpetrators in these stories to like Ted Bundy. Yeah. MBTK killer and just like, be safe. Be safe. Trust no one. Correct. I did have a conversation this morning and I was like, I think I'm too trusting. Mm-hmm. But then I also don't want to live my life. I don't think you're too trusting. I just think you are so kind that you think people can change. Well, that and I also like to operate thinking that everyone has the best intention to start with. I think people want to be good, but there's some people who are just fucked up. There's some people who are just messed up. And like, it doesn't matter how hard they try, they're always gonna be messed up. And it's scary how many of those there are. They walk among us. Let's end it with a really pessimistic attitude. Trust no one. No, it's like just, if something doesn't feel good or right, it could be bigger than it's just not feeling good. You know, it's like, yeah. I just think you know when something doesn't feel good. Trust your gut. Yeah. Thank you everyone for joining us for another episode of Crimes of Reddit. Thank you to everyone who has been vulnerable and shared their stories with us. We know that it's not easy, but this is a safe space and we really want everyone to feel that way. And I mean, even from the comments, like everyone who is responding on our sub right is like so empathetic, so caring and kind. And that is so great. So we're glad that our community is full of nice people. No, the community is incredible and we're so grateful. Yeah. So we're gonna keep doing this. That's right. You know, the force me to stop. I'll fight to the nail. I have to pry the keyboard out of the cold dead hand. Exactly. Thank you for joining us for another episode of Crimes of Reddit. As a reminder, we did just launch our Instagram. Crimes of Reddit pod. So don't forget to go follow us over there. We'll post a lot of things and updates here at Crimes House. We want to thank each and every one of you for your support. If you liked what you heard today, please follow us on social media. And don't forget to rate, review, and follow Crimes of Reddit, wherever you get your podcasts, because your feedback truly makes a difference. Right. And like we've been saying several times in this episode, if you find a Reddit story or you have a Reddit story, you want us to cover, leave a comment, and maybe we'll feature it. We probably will if it's a good one. And your own crazy stories. We love those. So more of those, please, please. At our subreddit, our slash crimes of pod. We'll see you next week, where we'll have even more Reddit stories and threads that will be digging into scroll patrol in. Thread heading. It will be scroll patrol. It sounds wrong, but it feels right. But it is. Yeah, yeah. Either way, we'll be back. Bye. Bye.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. A former teacher, Albert Fentress, was a beloved educator whose students fondly remembered him, but he later murdered and cannibalized an 18-year-old student, Paul Masters, in 1979 after a school fight.
  2. The case is disturbing because Fentress was a trusted, charismatic teacher, and the victim’s family discovered the crime years later, highlighting the danger of hidden darkness in authority figures.
  3. Fentress was found not guilty by reason of insanity and remained in psychiatric care for decades, with repeated legal battles over his safety and mental state.
  4. A listener shares a personal story of a teacher who, despite being a favorite, drank heavily and was later moved to an administrative role, illustrating how boundaries in authority roles can erode.
  5. Another story involves a roommate who, during a night of shared dorm life, was unnerved by a strange, silent stare from her roommate under the bed, raising questions about hidden behaviors and trust.
  6. A woman recounts being stalked and threatened by a man she dated, who was later identified as a known peeping tom and stalker, with police using her and her friends’ experiences to catch him.
  7. A separate story reveals a man who murdered a stranger on a bus in Seattle and remained at large on $2 million bail despite being caught on camera, exposing flaws in the justice system.
  8. The podcast emphasizes how personal experiences with authority figures or relationships can reveal deep traumas, and urges listeners to trust their instincts when something feels off.

Summary:

This episode of *Crimes of Reddit* features a collection of real and deeply personal true crime stories submitted by listeners, highlighting the unsettling intersection of trust, authority, and hidden danger. One central story revolves around Albert Fentress, a beloved high school history teacher who, despite being admired by students, murdered and cannibalized an 18-year-old student in 1979. The case is especially disturbing due to the contrast between Fentress’s warm, engaging persona and his horrific crimes, and the fact that his former student’s mother had sat next to him on a school trip.

Fentress was declared not guilty by reason of insanity and remained in psychiatric care for decades, sparking questions about how such a dangerous individual could be trusted by students. Other stories include a teacher who was later found to have drinking issues, a roommate who experienced a terrifying, unexplained stare under the bed, and a relationship that turned toxic after the individual was revealed to be a long-term stalker and peeper. Another story involves a man caught on camera assaulting a man on a bus in Seattle, who remained free on $2 million bail, highlighting systemic failures.

The episode underscores how people often idealize authority figures, making their crimes all the more jarring. It also emphasizes the importance of trusting one’s instincts, especially in relationships or environments where boundaries are crossed. The hosts stress that these stories come from real people, and the emotional weight of such experiences is profound.

The episode concludes with a call for greater awareness, urging listeners to share their own stories—especially those involving trust, trauma, or betrayal—on the subreddit to build a community of shared understanding and resilience.

FAQs

Albert Fentress, a high school history teacher, murdered and cannibalized an 18-year-old student, Paul Masters, in 1979. He was found not guilty by reason of insanity and committed to psychiatric care. Despite multiple court cases, he remained in psychiatric facilities until 2006, when he was moved to a locked facility after allegations of prior sexual abuse.

The listener, whose mother was a student of Fentress, found the story disturbing because it revealed that a trusted teacher who was beloved by students could commit extreme violence. It highlighted the lack of warning signs and the terror of trusting authority figures who appear normal on the surface.

Yes, Fentress was widely regarded as an excellent teacher who made history engaging and made a strong impression on his students. Students remembered him for dressing up as historical figures and genuinely caring about their education, which made his crimes even more shocking.

Police discovered Paul Masters' mutilated body restrained in the basement and body parts in a pot on the stove. Fentress had also called a friend to report he intended to take his own life, which was later found to be a distress signal rather than a suicide attempt.

The story sparked intense emotional reactions, with many people finding it disturbing and deeply unsettling. It raised concerns about the lack of warning signs in abusers and the dangers of trusting authority figures, especially during adolescence.

Yes, the story is based on a real case involving Albert Fentress in the 1970s. Court records confirm the details, including the teacher's prior popularity with students and the violent, disturbing nature of the crime that went against public perception.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.