The documentary-style podcast episode explores the suspicious death of David Leith, who was found dead in his bedroom in 2003 with a gunshot wound, reportedly committed by suicide. However, multiple inconsistencies challenge this conclusion. Raynella Dawson-Leith, his wife, provided an alibi and claimed he had shot himself, but evidence—including a second gunshot, mismatched bullets (Remington vs. Winchester), and David’s untouched breakfast—raises doubts. The medical examiner concluded it was likely a homicide, as the victim could not have fired a fatal shot after the second one. Raynella’s past deception, such as staging her first husband Ed Dawson’s death to claim insurance, adds credibility to suspicions of foul play. Despite no direct physical evidence linking her to the crime, behavioral and narrative inconsistencies are profound. The case remains unresolved, illustrating how personal motives, social context, and missing evidence can complicate forensic conclusions. The episode also features promotional content from brands like Fair, Shopify, Ritual, and Home Chef, linking the narrative to wellness and business support. Ultimately, it presents a compelling mystery that questions the reliability of suicide claims in isolated, rural settings where personal relationships and trust are deeply rooted.
Support for Criminal comes from Fair. Fair makes it easy for independent retailers to stock products from over 100,000 unique brands worldwide. As the holidays approach, you can fill your inventory with unique high-quality products that will make you stand out. Sign up today and get 50% off your first wholesale order up to $100 at F-A-I-R-E.com/Criminal. That's F-A-I-R-E.com/Criminal, terms may apply. Hi, it's Phoebe, coming to you from the road. I'm out on tour right now with our brand new live show called Don't Worry. It's an evening of stories about my own life and family. You'll hear from people like my sister and my father, who I interviewed for the show. Who is it that everyone's great dream to have someone sit you down and say, "Tell me about your life"? Depends on the life. We've got tour dates all over the country coming up soon. You can find them all and get your tickets at thisascriminal.com/live. This episode contains descriptions of suicide. Please use discretion. Tell me, who were Raynella Dawes at Leith and David Leith? I would describe Raynella and David Leith as somewhat of a power couple. In the sense that Raynella herself was well known. For many years she had been married to the District Attorney General for Knox County. So she was in political circles and was well known in that way. She was also a nurse and at one point had been the head nurse and one of our local hospitals. This is Jamie Satterfield. For over 30 years she worked as an investigative journalist in East Tennessee. David was a very popular barber in Knoxville. You know, David had a reputation as being a really nice fellow who was glad to help people. He was big into his appearance. He went to the gym a lot and took great care to be tan and healthy and fit. And so they were known in a lot of circles here in Knox County. You know, if you talk to people that socialized with them, went to church with them. Most people would tell you they were very close. They did a lot of things together. Family matter to them, church matter to them. You know, they seemed to most people to be a pretty happy couple. Rainella Dawson Leith and David Leith had gotten married in 1993 when they were in their mid-40s. They both had children from previous relationships. Rainella Dawson Leith had two daughters. She'd also had a son who died in a car crash when he was 11. David Leith had a daughter and two grandchildren. Rainella and David Leith lived on a farm that belonged to Rainella's first husband, Ed, who had died about 11 years earlier. They lived in a very rural area outside of Knoxville. There were a lot of cattle farmers. It was pretty hilly landscape and you could get views of the mountains from there. Author Diane Fanning. It was just very agrarian. And at the time, the town of Knoxville wasn't all that big. But it was big enough with the university that they could get anything they wanted there. On the morning of March 13, 2003, at around 11 a.m., Rainella Dawson Leith called 911. She was crying on the phone and the dispatcher told her to calm down and explain what had happened. She was absolutely hysterical and she said that her husband had shot himself. Attorney Joshua Hadrick. When she calls 911, it is almost immediately going across to the Sheriff's Department that this is Rainella and this is something going on at Rainella's house. Knoxville in 2003 was the kind of place where in certain communities everybody knew everybody. And you can tell from the radio traffic on the initial 911 call that it's going straight up the chain of command to important people including the sheriff himself. And that means that people are showing up at the house. The ambulance shows up in first stages at the bottom of the hill. They do that when they're a little unsure what they're walking into. The ambulance will wait away from the scene until the law enforcement gives the all clear for the paramedics to come in. There's the first responders. There's the law enforcement who show up to the house. And when they arrived, the door was open, the front door, and Rainella was laying face down in the yard. And one of the officials who showed up initially thought that she might have been shot. She wasn't moving, speaking, anything. And so he walked over and just kind of reached out with his toe and touched her. And she suddenly jumps up and says that her husband had shot himself. Then they walked into the bedroom. And what they saw from the doorway, it appeared that David Leith was sleeping. His head was resting on a pillow. He was on his right side. His right arm was outstretched. His left arm was sort of bent at the elbow and laying on the mattress. And he was covered with cover. But as they got closer to the bed, they could see a gunshot wound to his forehead above his left eye. The lead investigator on the scene made notes as he examined the room. There was a tray of food on a nightstand next to the bed. Oatmeal, toast, jelly, and a glass of milk. It all seemed to be untouched. David Leith was under the covers, undressed, lying with a pillow between his knees. His wife later said, "That's how he liked to sleep." The investigator asked Raynella Dawes at Leith if she had covered him up with the blankets. She said she couldn't remember and that she might have. The investigator noticed that the dryer was running. In the bathroom, a Bible had been left open near the sink. There was no disarray in the home. The door had been locked for Raynella that when she got home, she used the key to open her door. So there were no signs of forced entry into the house at all. Police asked Raynella Dawes at Leith what had been going on that morning before she found David dead. Raynella explained that her youngest daughter, who was a senior in high school, had left the house around 8.15am. Raynella said that after that, she should meet David breakfast. And that at 8.30am, she presented David who was in the bed with breakfast. She gave him breakfast in bed, she said. And so she put this on a tray on a night stand next to the bed. She said she turned on a religious show, Joyce Meyer, I believe was the show that she turned on. That they often watched in the mornings. So she said she turned that on and that when she left the home, David was in bed but watching the program and she assumed was getting ready to eat. She also said that she had put clothes in the dryer before leaving. Raynella told police that she'd then driven to the hospital to visit David's mother, who had just been diagnosed with cancer. On her way there, she said she stopped at her mother-in-law's house to pick some flowers. A little later, she got a call from her daughter's school, saying her daughter needed some medication. So she headed to the school and on the way, picked up a milkshake for her daughter to drive through. She also had called David's daughter, Cindy, and said that she thought that David wasn't feeling well that day. She then heads home, and before she reaches home, she says she runs into a sheriff's department in deputy that was patrolling the neighborhood. So she had a little chat with him and then went on in the house and discovered David's body. She called 911 at 11.23 am. The police found no suicide note in the house. But they noticed something unusual when they examined the bedroom. The gun is lying on the mattress. Next to his hand, it's actually pointed away from his hand. That was consistent with the suicide. But ask.
they got closer. They saw that there had been a bullet that was fired into the wall, slightly above David's head. They found another bullet that had gone through the mattress, and then there is a third shot, this gunshot to his forehead, and it is not unheard of for someone to fire and miss, and then take a second shot. But it is highly unusual to have what you would call a multi-shot suicide, so the suspicions were great. Besides the three rounds, the lead investigator was surprised by the way David was lying in bed, quote, "I'm not saying it stinks. I'm just saying it strange." Initially, this death was labeled undetermined, because there were signs of a suicide, but there were also signs of a homicide. They found gunpowder residue on David Lee's hands. There is no residue on Rainella or her clothes, but the lead investigator was skeptical of her story. This wasn't the first husband she'd found dead. "I'm Phoebe Judge. This is criminal." He'll be right back, to listen without ads, join Criminal Plus. Support for Criminal comes from ritual. Getting well-rounded nutrition can be a struggle. Ritual wants to make it easier. Ritual's team of scientists poured over thousands of studies to identify the common gaps between nutrient needs and what people are actually consuming across different life stages. Their essential for Women 18+ contains 9 key nutrients, in two delayed release capsules designed for optimal absorption. Ritual multivitamins are vegan and gluten and major allergen-free. They're also made traceable, so you'll know where the ingredients come from and why they're there. I've tried ritual, and I like the capsules. They have a nice scent and are easy to take, and I like knowing that I've covered my essential nutrients. Instead of striving for perfect health, support your foundational health. Get early access to Ritual's Black Friday Sale for 40% of your first order when you visit Ritual.com/Criminal. That's Ritual.com/Criminal for 40% of your first month. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Support for criminal comes from Shopify. The holiday season is an important time of year for a lot of businesses. Shopify can help your business make the most of it. Shopify has pre-built website themes and an AI site builder that makes it easy to launch a beautiful, professional-looking store without ever touching a line of code. Shopify's mobile app lets you run your store from anywhere. You can use it to track inventory, respond to customers, handle payments, and more. You also get your own AI e-commerce assistant, Sidekick. Sidekick can help you manage almost any business task with a single prompt, including holiday discounts. That's why Shopify powers so many businesses worldwide, from household names to small businesses just getting started. Launch before Black Friday, a time of year when more people are already shopping and ready to buy. If you're ready to launch your business before Black Friday, go to Shopify.com/Criminal to start your free trial. That's Shopify.com/Criminal. Go to Shopify.com/Criminal today to hear your first. Let's talk a little bit about Rainella Dawson-Leith. Who was she? Tell me about her growing up. Rainella had a very interesting childhood. Her father was one of the founders of the museum at Oak Ridge. Oak Ridge was a town in East Tennessee that had been created for the Manhattan Project. 75,000 people moved there, and many of them worked on developing the atomic bomb. But most of them didn't know what exactly they were working on, until they heard the news about the atomic bombs that were dropped on Japan in 1945. After the war, the town continued to be a site for research, and Rainella's father helped create a museum in Oak Ridge that told the town's story. When the Cold War began, residents of Oak Ridge knew their town could be a target, and twice a year they practiced a complete evacuation. Still, Diane Fanning spoke with an old friend of Rainella's, who said they'd felt safe there. And Rainella went to high school there. It was a very elitist kind of high school, not because of the people's attitudes, but because of the fact that they had so many children of so many scientists in there that there were advanced degrees at a much higher rate than you find in most places in the country. Rainella did well in school, and never got in trouble. An old friend of hers from Oak Ridge described her as a, quote, "all American girl." She was described as strong and determined, an excellent student, and you could always count on in any situation that she'd be willing to take charge and fill in any gaps. In her high school, she went to East Tennessee State University to get her degree in nursing. That's where she met her first husband at Dawson, who was preparing to go to law school. They had a lot of things in common, and both of them were pretty driven people, and they were, Ed was, in particular, pretty active in politics and Republican Party, and so Rainella kind of became part of that circle, that political, social circle, Jimmy Satterfield. Rainella and Ed got married and had a daughter, and then Ed ultimately became, he won office as district attorney general, very popular, the defense bar locked him, cops locked him, the people who worked for him locked him. The family lived in a mobile home for a while, then moved to Ed's family farm, where Ed built them a new house. As his legal career took off, Ed kept working on his cattle farm. He used to tell people, "I'm a farmer first, and a lawyer second." When Ed Dawson was in his early 40s, he had to have his appendix removed, and the doctors discovered he had cancer, and had already spread, and they couldn't remove it. When Ed was diagnosed with cancer, he kept it quiet for a little bit, but Ed was someone that was a hard worker, and he was very quickly slowing down, and there would be days where he wouldn't be in the office. Naturally, folks in his office were told that he had cancer, and his prognosis was not good. At first he tried to keep working, but he got worse and worse. Friends who visited him said he struggled to get out of bed, he used a wheelchair. One of Ed's friends said it was obvious, he was dying. And then, on July 9, 1992, Renella called for an ambulance for her husband. When they got to the hospital, Ed was declared dead on arrival. But it wasn't the cancer that had killed him. Renella said that she had taken Ed out into the barn, and that he was in his wheelchair, and that he toppled over somehow, and that the cattle surged and trampled him. And that's what killed him. It's farming, but he said that was a load of bull. Now I talked to the farmers in the area, and they told me that Ed had pulled herfards, and pulled herfards are gentle and not prone to stampede in general. Pulled herfards have red bodies and white heads and chests, and they have no horns. Herfards are among the most common beef cattle breeds in the US. But they said, Ed's cattle were the most calm and not rare.
rattle type of cows they've ever seen and they could not imagine the possibility that they would have stampeded on him and it's a small area so it'd be difficult for them to build up ahead of steam anyway the plot of land that was fed was rather small and they knew Ed. Ed's cousin told Diane a cow won't even run over a dead or injured animal they're not going to run over it unless they're forced to back up to where they can't see it and there was also there was a real question about whether he could have even gotten out there at all the thought was or the belief was that he had been largely bad ridden so why in the world would he be out and he's dying why would he be out messing with this cattle. But Renella Dawson leathed so that Ed had wanted to see his cattle and so she helped him out there. The night Ed Dawson died the assistant attorney general gave a press conference and announced his death he said he and Renella were feeding cattle when the cattle surged and Ed was knocked down and trampled. What did people think had happened? I'll tell you what most people would not do and that was they're not going to speak publicly about what they think. So there were a lot of whispers and there were there were folks who believed that Renella maybe had staged this cattle trampling that Ed actually had died from the cancer and the cattle trampling was staging so that she could get more insurance money. One of Ed's high school friends said some people quote wouldn't have been surprised if it had been Ed's idea. The medical examiner said Renella didn't want a full autopsy which wasn't necessarily unusual families often don't want full autopsy's and he would need the attorney general's approval to perform an autopsy against the family's wishes. He said the assistant attorney general told him to leave it alone. Everyone knew Ed was dying. The medical examiner said he realized that the family would need Ed's death to be labeled an accident to collect the extra insurance money which could only happen if the medical examiner signed off on it. He spoke with Renella and they decided to perform a partial autopsy. They didn't do any x-rays for example. The medical examiner said he saw what appeared to be a hoof print on Ed's overalls. He also saw broken bones. There was some evidence that he had suffered some trauma that could have been from cattle, a cow stepping on it. The results of the toxicology report hadn't come back yet but the medical examiner signed off on the autopsy stating that Ed's death had been an accident. Ed Dawson was buried at the farm. So after Ed's death what happens? You know after Ed's death not much happened at all. You know it was it was headlines for a day or two and then people just kind of moved on. You know Ed had to be replaced there in the DA's office. Renella and their children continue to live out there on the farm and within weeks of Ed's death David Leith who had been Ed's best friend was starting to come around and spend more time there at the. what at that time will be the Dawson home and within a month or so people became aware that Renella and David were now dating and that raised some eyebrows. David had been a good friend to Ed Dawson and also Renella and he had only been dead about six months when these two married. We'll be right back. Support for criminal comes from growth therapy. Have you ever noticed yourself responding to a stressful situation more calmly than you would have in the past? That's what growing feels like and growth therapy wants to make those moments of growth possible. They make it easy to find the right therapist connecting you with thousands of independent license providers across the country. You can meet virtually or in person with appointments available on nights and weekends to fit your schedule. Just search based on what matters most to you whether that's insurance specialty or availability and you could get started in as little as two days. Plus sessions cost an average of just 21 dollars with insurance and some people pays a little zero depending on their plan. There are no subscriptions or long-term commitments you simply pay for each session. See if you could pay a little zero for therapy in seconds at growtherapy.com/criminal. That's growtherapy.com/criminal. Growtherapy.com/criminal. Availability and coverage vary by state and insurance plan. Support for Criminal Comes from Home Chef. Home Chef delivers restaurant quality meals right to your door. It costs less than eating out and saves you the stress of planning all your meals. Home Chef has more than 30 meal options each week with choices for different tastes and dietary needs. I got to try Home Chef recently and the meals arrive with clear instructions for how to prepare everything making it a quick and easy option especially when life gets busy. And people really love it. Home Chef is rated number one by users of other meal kits for quality convenience value taste and recipes. For a limited time Home Chef is offering our listeners 50% off and free shipping for your first box plus free dessert for life. Go to Home Chef.com/ criminal. That's Home Chef.com/criminal for 50% off your first box and free dessert for life. Home Chef.com/criminal must be an active subscriber to receive free dessert. 11 years after Ray Nella married David Leith she called 911 to say she had found him dead in their bedroom with a gunshot wound. That morning the farm was busy with people coming in going and news started spreading about David's death. David's daughter Cindy Wilkerson was at work that morning. She'd taken over her father's barber shop when he retired. A family member came to the shop and told her something had happened to David. You know when Cindy heard this news she she did not believe it right from the get go. Number one her father was a freight of guns. He didn't have him in his home. Didn't like him. Didn't want to fool with him too. He was a very religious man and suicide would not have been something that would have set well with his soul. And thirdly she found Ray Nella's activities that morning strange. Cindy said for instance that Ray Nella never visited David's mother. She's much like David's mother. Cindy also said that she had regular contact with her father. They were very close. They worked together in the barber shop for years and she had taken over the shop for him and she said that he had never indicated any kind of suicidal thoughts, any kind of depression that he was actually very forward-thinking. He had been talking about the things that were he wanted to do in the future. So Cindy was suspicious from the get go and she was particularly suspicious of Ray Nella. But Ray Nella had an alibi for most of that morning. Just about 45 minutes after her daughter left her school. People had seen Ray Nella at the hospital where she'd visited David's mother. And then later at her daughter's school after she'd received the call that her daughter needed her to bring her some medication. It wasn't clear when exactly David Leith had died. You know we see on TV we see these TV shows and they go he died at 947. It doesn't work that way. All that can really do is give a window of time. And in this case the medical examiner had opined that this death occurred sometime between 6 a.m. and 930 a.m.
because David's toes were still warm. Raynella was alone at that home by her own word between 8.15 and 8.30 a.m. Her first stop on her alibi occurred about 8.45 to 9.00 a.m. So there certainly was time for her to have carried this out. But she did have an alibi for the bulk of the time. They also did not have any kind of forensic evidence tying Raynella or anyone, frankly, to David's death. There were no fingerprints on the gun, which is it's difficult to pull prints from a gun. But in this case, the gun had appeared to have been wiped clean. There was not even smudges on it. So they had nothing on the gun. Her hands were clean. They didn't have any blood on them. They didn't have any gunshot residue on them. There was no blood on her clothing. There was nothing to suggest that she got even close to that bed. So they really didn't have any evidence to tie Raynella to this. But they also didn't have any evidence that it was someone else, particularly because there was no forced entry into the harm, and David had no known enemies. And then the autopsy report came back. The medical examiner concluded that this must be a homicide. Doctors later said that of the three rounds fired from the gun in David Lee's bedroom, it was a second shot that hit David. The medical examiner said he would have been killed instantly and he couldn't have fired the third shot. Next week on Criminal. The bullet that was recovered from David Lee was a Remington. The bullet that was recovered from the bed was a Winchester. Raynella pulled out a gun and cussed him and fired a shot. She sort of had an unusual look on her face and I could tell that she was thinking essentially the same thing. What's happening? What's going on? They did begin to reconsider the death of Raynella's first husband, Ed Dawson. If you want to listen to part two right now, sign up for Criminal Plus at patreon.com/criminal. You'll be supporting our work and getting access to exclusive benefits like no ads, live events, chat rooms, and early listening. Part two will also be in the regular Criminal Podcast feed next Friday. Criminal is created by Lauren Spore and me. Nadia Wilson is our senior producer. Katie Bishop is our supervising producer. Our producers are Susanna Robertson, Jackie Cigico, Lily Clark, and Lena Celisin. This episode was fact checked by Katie Cedarborg. Our show is mixed and engineered by Veronica Semonetti. Lily Alexander makes original illustrations for each episode of Criminal. You can see them at ThisIsCriminal.com and you can sign up for our newsletter at ThisIsCriminal.com/newsletter. We're on Facebook at ThisIsCriminal and Instagram and TikTok at Criminal_Podcast. We're also on YouTube at YouTube.com/CriminalPodcast. Criminal is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. So for more great shows at podcast.voxmedia.com. I'm Phoebe Judge. This is Criminal. As soon as Autumn rolls around and you swap your iced lattes for pumpkin spice, that's your signal to start thinking about the holidays. The decor, the gifts, the shopping lists, but more importantly, the holiday treats. Cheesecakes, cookies, is there anything better? And when the recipe calls for cream cheese, there's only one option. Philadelphia, the original cream cheese, made with fresh milk and real cream. This holiday season, whether you're going all out or keeping it simple, make it really filly good. Find your favorite holiday recipe at creamcheese.com. Support for today's episode comes from Delta, official airline of the National Women's Soccer League. Traveling is basically magic. It creates opportunities, it fosters understanding, it expands horizons, it connects people and communities to each other and to their own potential. Those are the values that drive Delta. With up to 5,500 daily Delta and Delta connection flights to more than 300 destinations on six continents, Delta is committed to helping you explore your world. Whatever gives you the travel bug, Delta is here to help you get there. Visit Delta.com for more info. Delta, wherever the journey takes you.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Rainella Dawson-Leith called 911 on March 13, 2003, reporting her husband David Leith had shot himself, but the scene and evidence raised serious doubts about the suicide claim.
The incident revealed inconsistencies in Raynella’s alibi, including a lack of forensic evidence linking her to the scene—no fingerprints, gunshot residue, or blood on her or the gun.
The medical examiner concluded the death was more likely a homicide, noting three shots fired, with the second being fatal and the third unlikely to be fired by the victim.
A major discrepancy was found in the bullets
David Leith had no known enemies, lived a peaceful life, and was known for his strong religious beliefs, making suicide unlikely.
Raynella’s past suspicious actions, including the staged death of her first husband Ed Dawson, cast suspicion on her motives and credibility.
The case remains unresolved, with authorities initially labeling it undetermined due to conflicting signs of suicide and homicide.
The episode highlights how personal narratives, inconsistencies, and lack of physical evidence can challenge official conclusions in homicide investigations.
Summary:
The documentary-style podcast episode explores the suspicious death of David Leith, who was found dead in his bedroom in 2003 with a gunshot wound, reportedly committed by suicide. However, multiple inconsistencies challenge this conclusion. Raynella Dawson-Leith, his wife, provided an alibi and claimed he had shot himself, but evidence—including a second gunshot, mismatched bullets (Remington vs.
Winchester), and David’s untouched breakfast—raises doubts. The medical examiner concluded it was likely a homicide, as the victim could not have fired a fatal shot after the second one. Raynella’s past deception, such as staging her first husband Ed Dawson’s death to claim insurance, adds credibility to suspicions of foul play.
Despite no direct physical evidence linking her to the crime, behavioral and narrative inconsistencies are profound. The case remains unresolved, illustrating how personal motives, social context, and missing evidence can complicate forensic conclusions. The episode also features promotional content from brands like Fair, Shopify, Ritual, and Home Chef, linking the narrative to wellness and business support.
Ultimately, it presents a compelling mystery that questions the reliability of suicide claims in isolated, rural settings where personal relationships and trust are deeply rooted.
FAQs
David Leith was found dead in his bed with a gunshot wound to the forehead. Initial evidence suggested suicide, but a multi-shot pattern and the absence of gunshot residue on his hands raised suspicions. The medical examiner later concluded it was a homicide, with the second shot being fatal. No forensic evidence linked his wife, Raynella, to the crime.
The investigation found both signs of suicide—like the gun position and untouched breakfast—and signs of homicide—like multiple shots and a lack of gun residue on Raynella. This contradictory evidence led investigators to label it as undetermined.
She said she visited her mother-in-law, picked up flowers, met her daughter at school, and returned home to find David dead. She claimed she had left him watching a religious show and that he was already in bed and eating breakfast.
The medical examiner concluded it was a homicide because the second bullet hit David instantly and he could not have fired a third shot. Additionally, the gun used in the bedroom was a different model than the one found, and the wound pattern was inconsistent with a suicide.
She claimed she visited David’s mother at the hospital and his daughter at school, but there were no records or witnesses confirming these visits. Her daughter, Cindy, also noticed strange behavior and reported that Raynella had not visited David’s mother, which contradicted her story.
Criminal partners with brands like Fair, Ritual, Shopify, Growth Therapy, Home Chef, and others, offering exclusive discounts or promotions to listeners through links like 'Criminal.com/'. These partnerships help fund the show and provide value to its audience.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.