Go back

Rachel Maddow in conversation with Hillary Clinton - Part 1

41m 40s

Rachel Maddow in conversation with Hillary Clinton - Part 1

Rachel Maddo’s book *Department of Fate* chronicles the power, corruption, and moral failures of the U.S. Department of Justice over time, from its founding in 1870 to the present. It highlights pivotal figures like Amos Akerman, who led early civil rights prosecutions against the Ku Klux Klan despite political resistance, and Louis Post, who later challenged unjust deportation campaigns in the 1920s red scare. The book reveals a long history of DOJ corruption, including under Attorney General Harry Duryea, who accepted bribes and failed to investigate political scandals. It also details the suppression of key investigations during the first Trump administration—such as the $10 million Egyptian cash probe—where the DOJ under Bill Barr actively blocked accountability. The narrative underscores how the DOJ’s erosion of independence during Trump’s terms, including illegal ballot seizures and threats to election officials, has created a dangerous gap in democratic oversight. Despite these failures, the book argues that public exposure of wrongdoing is critical, and that new Democratic leadership must act to reform and refound the DOJ. A central thesis emerges: the Department of Justice is not just a legal arm, but a moral guardian of democracy. The book calls for accountability, transparency, and the removal of politically connected figures like Todd Blanche, who has shown no intent to investigate corruption. Ultimately, it contends that while the DOJ has failed, the resilience of the public, the rise of voter turnout, and the courage of whistleblowers present a historic opportunity to restore justice and ensure the country’s democratic future.

Transcription

5947 Words, 33398 Characters

English
Hello and welcome. Thank you so much for joining us. I'm Rachel Maddo and I've got something really special. I'm excited to share with you tonight. So I just published this new book. It's called "Department of Fate," the promise, the power, and the collapse of America's most consequential institution. It's about the US Department of Justice. And I recently got the chance to sit down and talk about it with none other than former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. What was particularly fun and awesome about it is that we got together for this conversation exactly one week after the blue wave of the midterm elections. So we had a ton to talk about in addition to my book. Secretary Clinton and I sat down at the Striker Center in New York City. Here is that conversation. I really hope you enjoy. [Applause] Holy guacamole. Wow. There's so many people here. Ha! Wait till Hillary Clinton comes out. Lewis Post did not look like a man spoiling for a fight. Honestly, if you had to say he looked like anything, your go-to reference might be leprechaun. Louis, as his friends called him, measured in at five foot three inches tall. He wore the sort of rimless spectacles and rumpled out of date suits, favored by retired college deans, and happy grandpa's. Already passed into his eighth decade in 1920, his impish grin suggested a lurking sense of humor. It perched amid a graying beard that was only ever glancingly trimmed and ran a tad wild. As a rule, Louis Post looked as if he dressed and groomed in darkness. Louis Post's appearance, however, belied a towering personal dignity and a ferocious commitment to his principles. Post had applied these first principles to every job he'd ever had in his 50 year career. Printers, devil, law clerk, lawyer, assistant, US attorney, political candidate, newspaper editor, lecturer, author, and government official. Lately, in 1920, at the US Department of Labor. Louis Post's career had started 50 years earlier when he was in his early 20s, and he was hired as a stenographer, literally hired to take notes on the Justice Department's prosecutions of the Ku Klux Klan in South Carolina immediately after the founding of the Department of Justice in 1870. 50 years later, after his work on the Klan trials, Louis Post's now 70 years old remained an incisive observer. The incisive observer he had been in South Carolina as a young man, he now recognized in 1920 the red raids from the first red scare of the early 1920s. He recognized those raids for what they were. Another paranoia driven mob panic. This time, it was not the Ku Klux Klan, but the US government itself feeding the mania and perpetrating the mayhem. A lawless secret militia was one kind of threat to this country in its constitution. A lawless United States government was altogether another. Federal officials had wrecked thousands of lives without justification. Their officially sanctioned disorder and havoc had been papered over with government-produced propaganda. DOJ had no legal authority to arrest or deport alien enemies, as they were called, or anyone else, who had not committed an actual crime. The regulation and enforcement of immigration matters at the time, belonged to the Department of Labor, where Louis Post was employed. But thanks to J. Edgar Hoover and his propagandists, the Justice Department had convinced much to the public that its radical division was ridding the United States of violent enemy aliens intent on destroying the American way of life. The worst of the worst. American sentiment, Post's lamented, is usually indifferent to legal technicalities when desirable results are obtained. By the time Louis Post found a way to take charge at the Labor Department of signing off on these deportations that the Justice Department sought, only a few hundred of almost 4,000 pending cases from the red raid files had been decided. Thousands of alleged alien enemies had been unable to make the excessive bail DOJ had demanded. They had since spent months trapped in jails across the country, living in a kind of legal purgatory. The evidence in most of these cases was somewhere between thin and non-existent. Louis Post went to work. Post, his departmental assistant, his confidential clerk, and a single messenger worked seven days a week deep into the night. Despite being thrust into this position of responsibility with no warning and no preparation, Post and his team raced to meet the task. They adjudicated more than 1,600 alien enemy cases in a single month. Post made sure there was sufficient evidence legally obtained to support every single expulsion, where confessions were taken by DOJ interrogators in the absence of legal counsel. Before the right to remain silent was explained, Post cancelled the warrants. Where confessions were obtained under the threat of violence or actual violence by pistol-waving DOJ detectives, Post cancelled the warrants. Where evidence was seized without proper legal authority, Post cancelled the warrants, where orders for deportation were backed up by nothing more than DOJ investigators, information and belief, in filings not even sworn by these federal agents, Post cancelled the warrants. By April 9, 1920, 33 days into the work, Louis Post had personally cancelled three out of every four deportation cases he had adjudicated. Post determined that the deportation campaign was monstrous in his words. He said it was entirely un-American and worst of all, possibly irreversible. He lamented when the Department of Justice thrust aside all respect for lawful process, the difficulty of maintaining regularity and preventing oppression rose to the level of the impossible. This is the moment that this giant of an American, Louis Post, decided to stand up and put all five foot three inches of his ponchy ill-groomed little frame in front of a speeding bureaucratic locomotive. He decided he would go public with his findings. He issued an eight-page opinion, canceling one man's deportation warrant. He meant for his decision on this one man's deportation to serve as a bill of particulars against the Department of Justice, not only in that case, but in all of these cases. Louis Post leaked his report to major newspapers and to the wire services. And then he braced for impact. So I am so grateful to you all for being here tonight. I wrote this book to try to make guys like Louis Post famous. I wanted to make an attorney general, a really important attorney general who nobody remembers whose name was Amos Akerman. I want to make him famous. He's the guy who led those clan prosecutions in South Carolina is basically the first major thing that DOJ did after it was founded in 1870. And so tonight we're going to talk about some of those heroes and some of the many, many villains who have shown the power of this one part of our government and how consequential it is. We're going to talk about how DOJ has now effectively collapsed in Donald Trump's second term. And we're going to talk about how that might actually be an opportunity for us as a country. In the same way that if you, let's say, had a car with a mouse infestation, you might welcome the news that it also had a rusted out frame. Because now at least your insurance will consider it totaled so you can replace it instead of trying to fix that irreparable mess in your wiring harness. I believe that the current attorney general of the United States, Todd Blanch, will face an impeachment investigation for what has happened. Under his watch in Trump's second term, I believe the new Democratic controlled Congress is. is going to need to reform and refound the Department of Justice within the next couple of years, so none of this nonsense can ever happen again. But I believe those things are going to happen and I believe that brighter days are ahead. And I am honored more than I can say by all of your presence here tonight and I am honored beyond words that former Senator, former Secretary of State, former First Lady Hillary Clinton is here tonight to join us to talk about it. So please welcome Hillary Rodham Clinton. Good evening, everyone. Wow. It is so wonderful to be back here at the Stryker Center. So Rachel, this is awkward. Yes. I'm interviewing you. No, I'm going to plan to undermine that somehow. Well, I came prepared to try to prevent that. But I am so pleased to be with you and to talk about this incredible book that you have not only written, but has given us the opportunity to learn more about our own Justice Department. Things in there that I had no idea about, both as you say, the villains and the heroes. But before we launch in to the book, Department of Fate, I have to ask you, are you feeling better since last Tuesday? You're asking because I had the flu, right? And so I was watching your coverage. You didn't look too sick. You look pretty happy. At 1.19 a.m., I became a petrified rock and fell off my chair. And that was it. I, you know, this was the second largest voter turnout in a century. And the increase in voter turnout among block voters and Latino voters and young voters was like nothing we have seen cycle to cycle ever. And that is incredibly moving to me. And yes, it has consequences in terms of who they voted for. And it is a profound statement in terms of just how blue that way of was. But the participation levels were really moving to me in part because I really am one of those liberals who thinks that we are up against an existential challenge to our constitutional republic. I think there is an authoritarian movement that has the president of the United States at its head. And I think he does not want us to be protected by our constitution anymore. And I think he wants to rule as a strong man indefinitely. I just believe it and you may not, but that's where I'm coming from. And part of the message of that kind of politics, that kind of leadership is that elections are frauds and elections don't matter. And democracy is weak. And it's pointless and you're a sucker if you participate in it. And the American people just gave that a one finger salute. Yeah, that's a right. How do you feel about Tuesday? Well, I feel it's been a long time coming. But it says though the blue wave has washed away the poisonous cloud that we've been living under for 10 years. And we can finally get back to trying our best to form that more perfect union by fighting back, number one, by voting. And now the Democrats have to make good things happen, both in Washington and at the state level. And I am, you know, I've said this before, I am like my late great friend, Mattel and Albright once said, I'm an optimist who worries a lot. So I was optimistic about the outcome of the election. It exceeded even my high hopes for what would happen. And now I'm incredibly excited by this new crop of members of Congress and senators and governors and attorneys, general and state legislators. They came in with the intention of fighting back and to try to write the ship of state. And one of the main issues, as we all know, was corruption. And so corruption became the issue where nine out of 10, 90% of voters said that government corruption was a major factor in their vote. And that was right up there with the cost of living because a lot of candidates made the linkage between your cost of living in part is going up because of corrupt decisions that are being made by our leaders. And your book covers a lot of corruption, you know, the financial kind of corruption, the sort of ignoring the law kind of corruption. So I would like to start there because corruption was a big driver in what we saw happen on Tuesday. And the Democrats are going to have to figure out how to balance legislating to make a difference in people's lives and help with these cost of living concerns that are very legitimate, but also conduct the investigations and they're going to have to do it without a Department of Justice, which is a different kind of situation for the Congress to be in. But I want to ask you to maybe give the audience a few examples. Because you start when the Justice Department was actually created. There had been an Attorney General, but we didn't have a Justice Department till 1870, right? And you talk about, you know, this man I'd never heard of who will get to in a minute who is our first Attorney General with an actual Justice Department. And what he tried to do to hold a southerners ex-confederate to officers, ex-slave owners accountable, and it was really hard, then you move into the gilded age. And the, you know, if you watch the program, you know, we're talking about railroads and oil and gas and things like that. And, you know, how there was an effort by the Congress even to rain in that kind of, you know, excessive wealth and power, and the Justice Department was on the side of the excessive wealth and power. And then you go into, you know, the 1920s and T. Pot Dome, and it's just an incredible read. But let's start with your whole section on a corrupt Attorney General, Harry Dottrey, whose DOJ you describe as a 10-story bribe department store. So tell us a little bit about what was going on there, but why did corruption break through in 2026 when it didn't break through in, you know, some of the prior years of our country? So and Harry Dottrey was Attorney General. He got the Attorney General job in a way that was not auspicious. He had been the campaign manager for the President. Harding. And that's just a bad, does a bad way to start. I mean, it's, you know, Robert F. Kennedy, the first one, might have been a good Attorney General. It was still a bad idea for President to pick his brother. Can we admit? You know, Nixon picking John Mitchell. He'd been a campaign manager, that was a sign. When you imagine John Mitchell now, the picture you're imagining is his mug shot. Like, there's a string of these. So, Dordy is a campaign manager to Warren G. Harding and his very dear friend. Dordy is very well off. And as soon as he gets to Washington, he gets much, much more well off, because he really is operating DOJ like a bribery department store. And he's getting very wealthy and they're selling everything that DOJ has to offer. And I mean, there's all these lurid details about thousand dollar bills stuffed into money belts and hotel lobbies and all this great, it's lurid. But the thing that actually brings Heridority down is not his own corruption and not the corruption of the Justice Department under his watch. It's that he lets corruption in the Harding Administration run wild and does not investigate it, does not curtail it, does not prosecute it, and the American people don't stand for it. Because the Justice Department isn't the only way we find out about stuff. In the case of this huge oil and oil scandal, ripping off the taxpayers to the tune of tens of millions of dollars in 1920s dollars, it's the press that picks it up. And then it's the Senate that investigates it. And it turns into the biggest scandal you can possibly imagine. And Dordy at the Justice Department doesn't do anything. Because his whole involvement in that scandal was about trying to get kickbacks for himself, trying to get a piece of it. And so what the Senate did, once the public was suitably outraged by what had happened, is that they appointed a special counsel outside the Justice Department to investigate that. And then they themselves started investigating Harry and they investigated him in the US Senate in terms of his tenure at the Justice Department and it exposed what he had been doing and he was forced out of the job and he was later indicted and that to me is a really, it was happened a century ago. It's a nice round number for us making, for history having thrown a lightning bolt to point us to what to do because the Justice Department, as you say, we need them to protect us from corruption, from crimes committed by people who are public servants and if they don't, then the Justice Department itself is a scandal and deserves both the attention of the press and the legislative branch and I think that we are seeing the legislative, the newly constituted legislative branch take that really seriously right now which is why more people have resigned from the Justice Department in the wake of these elections than from any other agency in Trump's administration. If you think back to the 2016 presidential election, I don't know if you remember. There was a lot of talk. How much time do you have? We have a current attorney general who has absolutely no intention of investigating any of the corruption, any of the stories that have come out and in fact Todd Blanch who is serving as the president's personal lawyer as opposed to our attorney general has made it very clear that he's going to fight the Congress every step of the way. So some of what you have just pointed out about what the Senate did back then could be very useful to the Senate today. Now, you know, late in the book, you write about another recent scandal that occurred in the first Trump administration. You write about the nearly $10 million in cash that the Egyptian government withdrew days before Trump's first inauguration and investigators in the Justice Department had leads that might have ended that the money might have ended up in Trump accounts. But Trump's hand picked attorney general Bill Barr basically shut that down. So the kind of ignoring corruption is not just happening right now. We can go back into the first Trump administration and find examples as well. So that $10 million. We didn't learn about this until years later after the investigation had been kiboshed. But if you think back to the 2016 presidential election, I don't know if you remember. We have all the time. There was a lot of talk about whether or not Donald Trump was going to put in some of his own money for his race against you. And he had said, remember early on in the primary, I'm not corrupt. Everybody else is corrupt because I have so much money. I don't need to raise any money. I'm going to self fund. I'm not going to be beholden to anybody. And then he didn't put in any of his own money. And so people kept asking when it really seemed like you were beating him, were you going to put in some of your money? You're going to put in some of your money and he wouldn't do it and he wouldn't do it and he wouldn't do it. And then finally, just before the election, he agreed that he was going to put in some money and it would be a loan. And then right after the inauguration, according to reporting about this $10 million of money from Egypt, and when you say cash, she means cash, she means green folding currency, pallets of dollars. We're flown out of Egypt via China and then to we don't know where, but the Justice Department was investigating where it went. And the implication was that it was possible that this loan, Trump had paid it, but Egypt had agreed to pay it back. And so that's a foreign government funding a presidential campaign. That's not good. I'm going to ask you the obvious question, which is, did you or your team have any idea anything like this was being investigated at the time? Not a clue. And given the statute of limitations on things like that, had the investigation not been kiboshed, that is the sort of thing that would have been blatantly illegal, yes? Absolutely. Yes, moving on. It matters who's at the Justice Department. And part of what the Democrats have to figure out is how to do this balance, how to do the investigation that needs to be done when you don't have a Justice Department. Because for example, if they subpoena a witness, and that witness defies the subpoena, and then they vote to hold that witness in contempt, and the witness still fails to comply, what usually happens is that the Justice Department is asked to pursue action against the witness that happened to Steve Bannon, for example, in the first Trump administration. So knowing what you know about the Justice Department and its current unfortunate demise, how does the Congress enforce their subpoenas? How do they actually follow up on what their investigation turns up? I think it's going to be really hard. But I also think that they have power short of physically compelling the presence of people who they have subpoenaed, that is going to be important to the American people understanding what they're investigating. I mean, ultimately when we talk about the forceable power of the Justice Department and the criminal justice system broadly, you're talking about a pretty narrow sliver of what it means to hold people accountable. Ultimately, it is the people who hold public officials who are corrupt to account, and they get forced out of office, they get shamed, they get disbarred, they get occasionally indicted. Yes, but exposure is the strongest weapon that we have against the kinds of corruption that I think we're suffering from under this administration. And to the extent that the U.S. House and the United States Senate under Democratic control are getting in there not to exact revenge, but to put a stop to crimes in progress. I'm not sure that we need to go right to the end of thinking about, well, you know, who do the U.S. Marshals answer to in terms of whether or not they're going to grab people. I think that the exposure of these things will earn a response from the American people, commensurate with these crimes. You have to expose it before you know what the punishment can be. I'm worried that you might not agree with me on that. No, no, I think exposure is important, but I also think accountability is important. And so once we have the exposure about, you know, what the evidence shows, then how do we hold people accountable? Now, in some cases, there may be connected, corresponding state criminal actions. And those can be pursued then by state attorneys general and district district attorneys. That's what happened coming out of Trump's first term. It was the district attorney here and our state attorney general who actually brought the cases against the Trump business and Trump personally with the 34 felony count conviction against him. So I think that we also will pay close attention to statues of limitation because if there is a, you know, change in the Justice Department in 2029, for example, some of those cases could still be pursued. But I really believe and, you know, we can debate this, but I really believe that we have to hold people accountable. I don't think we've done enough of that in the last 20 years, you know, some of the, you know, some of the financial actions coming out of 2007, 2008, nobody was held accountable. The findings led by the Senate under Diane Feinstein, when she was chair of the Intelligence Committee, finding that CIA employees and contractors violated the law with the torture that they subjected suspects to. Nobody was held accountable. So I do think that there has to be a very carefully analyzed effort to try to figure out, okay, if we're stymied by the Justice Department to actually bring cases and hold people accountable, then do we buy our time? Do we go to the States? We've got to have a bunch of potential options. You can't just have it be reported, learn that those things have happened in the first two years of Trump's term, and then have there be no consequences for them as we steam toward the 2028 presidential election. I'm sorry if that's the stuff you've been doing, you need to know you're going to have to answer for it and you're never going to get away with it. One thing that didn't happen in this election, the dog that didn't bark, thank goodness, was our fear about massive disruption of the elections, of undermining voters' right to have their vote cast and their vote counted. And I go to the book where you write about what happened in 2020, where again Bill Barr claimed mail-in fraud with no evidence, none, and basically said, I don't need evidence, I have common sense. And then he ordered fraud investigations, which led to the head of the election crimes branch quitting. Now, for the last two years, this administration and this Justice Department have done a lot. They've seized ballots, they have threatened state election officials, so it's not for the lack of trying that they were attempting to intimidate both voters and election officials. But why didn't it work this time? We had really good lawyers who were defending elections, and we had voters turning out on mass. And do you worry that there's going to be any shenanigans between the certification of the winners and the winners being seated in the weeks ahead? Well, I think that we should unpack it a little bit too. First of all, I think that Bill Barr gets way too much credit from the first Trump term for having balked at the last second after going along with every other thing that Trump was doing to undermine incompetence in the election. Secondly, in this Trump term leading into these elections, the things that they did to try to interfere with the election, I mean, they had to, apparently, force out the special agent in charge of the Atlanta field office of the FBI in order to go seize those ballots from Fulton County, Georgia, from the 2020 election. There should be an investigation there. We need to know what happened there. What happened to those ballots? Where are they now? What did the FBI get tasked to do with those ballots, given that they've taken no actions in court since it happened? It's not normal for the FBI to go seize ballots. It's not normal for the FBI to go to Puerto Rico and seize their voting machines. It's not normal for the staff at the Homeland Security Cybersecurity Agency, CISA, which they've got it, to be told to obtain a voting machine and learn how to hack it and then say nothing about it publicly, but report what they've done and how they did it to the White House. These are things that you can't let, you can't just have it be reported. We've heard that those things have happened in the first two years of Trump's term and then have there be no consequences for them as we steam toward the 2028 presidential election. The investigations of what they've already done I think are just important so that they stop doing that kind of stuff. That's why I do think an impeachment investigation of Todd Blanche is both inevitable and wise. In terms of why it didn't work, I do think that we benefit from, I think the word is idiocy. Army Dylan, bless her heart, but going 0 for 29 in her ridiculous lawsuits against states all over the country trying to get their voting roles tells you a little something about the quality of her lawyer ring. Their idiocy helped, but also the size of the win I think made up for a lot of sins. That is something that you see when authoritarians face massive democratic blowback all over the world. Nobody thought that Victor Orban was going to seed power and disappear until the force of the democratic backlash against him made it unquestionable that he would have to leave. Same goes for Serbia and same goes for Bolsonaro. These guys think that they think they're strong men. They think they've got everybody by the neck and then the people rise up and teach them otherwise. And none of them are, I think, intrinsically brave. I think they're bullies and I think bullying is a form of cowardice and I think when confronted with a force palpably larger than themselves, all of these guys melt. And that is what we saw happen this past week. It takes the right people in the right job, in the right moment, with the right kind of moral foresight and it takes political support for them to do it because it's hard work. To go back to the point you made in your introductory reading about Louis Post, there were a lot of brave people, both Republicans and Democrats, starting in the 2020 election who stood up to this effort to intimidate and bully them into changing votes, finding votes, pretending that somebody else won as opposed to who actually had. And the same thing happened in this run-up to the midterm election. There were election offices across this country that said no to the Justice Department and the ridiculous lawsuits that they were bringing. So let's go back to the beginning, Rachel, because I love the beginning of your book because there were some stories there that really needed to be told. And you open with Robert Jackson's 1940 warning to federal prosecutors. And Robert Jackson was just an exemplary lawyer, was one of the Nuremberg lawyers, was just somebody that everybody looked up to. And he talked about what it meant to have the extraordinary power of being a prosecutor. And the DOJ, you write, has always had to choose whom to pursue and whom to protect. And most people don't even know that we didn't have a Department of Justice until 1870. And tell us about that beginning, because there are some incredible characters in that very first Department of Justice office. One of the clerks working for Amos Ackerman in the first, very first iteration of the Justice Department was named Walt Whitman. And he didn't just have the same name, it was that Walt Whitman. Which is kind of, it's, yeah, the history has weird curly cues in it. But with the enforcement acts, with the 14th Amendment, with the effort that we made to turn ourself into a different kind of country after we were almost consumed by the fire of the Civil War. The Justice Department was formed in that sort of churning wake of that national tragedy. And we had the enforcement acts and we had these new constitutional amendments, including the 14th Amendment and amendments that were designed to make sure that we would be a multiracial democracy, where your citizenship would not be precluded by your race. And in that time, that is when we created a Justice Department. And when Amos Ackerman was named Attorney General, the first Attorney General to have a Justice Department under him, to have that kind of staff, it was Ackerman's gold heart led him to the south. He was the only southerner in Grant's Cabinet. He had himself been a slave owner. But he took the lessons of the Civil War to heart. He believed in the 14th Amendment. He believed that if we had mob rule and terrorist rule by the clan and by the white supremacist militias in the Southern United States, we could never be a country. Again, we would slide back into that sort of war and we would never escape the moral stain of it. And because of his golden heart, I think because of his civic virtue and because of his stubbornness, he just decided he was going to go bust the clan. And that's what he did with the first iteration of the Justice Department. And it was unbelievably dramatic stuff, thousands of prosecutions, hundreds of federal court cases. He did bring Lewis Post down to be his stenographer to literally take notes on it, which was an incredible moral education for Lewis Post, which paid off for our country 50 years later when he stood up against the red raids in the first red scare against Jay Edgar Hoover and Attorney General Mitchell Palmer. But that effort to uproot the clan, I mean, he was not bound to respect the constitutional rights of the clansmen he was prosecuting. They had martial law. They'd suspended habeas corpus. He was there in aid of, and with the aid of a detachment of cavalrymen who were there to help him, the active due to US military there to help him. But he pursued it because of his civic far-mindedness in a way that did respect due process, that did respect the rights of the clansmen, both their chiefdans and their peons. And in so doing, he unruited the clan in County South Carolina and in other places. And it was a very, very key part of reconstruction. And it was incredible moral leadership. than faltered in Washington when the rest of Grant's cabinet didn't want to hear anymore about these clan outrages and didn't want to work anymore on this type of justice. And didn't want to expend political capital and actual capital trying to stand up for the rights of black Americans. And Akerman got fired. He got fired after special interests, declared war on him, and decided they wanted somebody more pliable. And both sides of that arc, I think are really important for us to understand about the origin story of the US Justice Department, that it takes the right people in the right job, in the right moment with the right kind of moral foresight, and it takes political support for them to do it, 'cause it's hard work. It's easier to do the lazy thing. It's easier to give up. It's easier to not have those confrontations. And there are people in Washington who always want that. But the right people at the right time can do incredible work. And that's part of the reason that the thesis of the book is how consequential the department is. It's not only consequential and negative terms. It can also do almost miraculous work to heal our souls and to make us who we're supposed to be as a country. - A guy like Todd Blanche never should have been allowed to even be stood up for a Justice Department position, let alone had one. If you've ever been a campaign manager or a personal lawyer or a political hack for a president, you should be disqualified from serving at a high level at the Justice Department under that president. You just should.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Louis Post, a former US Department of Labor official, courageously challenged the Department of Justice’s illegal deportation campaigns during the 1920 red scare, canceling thousands of warrants based on legal violations and exposing systemic abuse.
  2. The book highlights the Department of Justice’s founding in 1870 under Attorney General Amos Akerman, who led groundbreaking prosecutions against Ku Klux Klan violence, exemplifying early moral leadership in enforcing civil rights.
  3. Corruption within the DOJ, such as under Attorney General Harry Duryea, who accepted bribes and failed to investigate scandals, demonstrated how political appointments and lack of oversight can undermine justice.
  4. The DOJ under Bill Barr in the first Trump administration suppressed investigations into foreign money linked to Trump’s campaign, including the $10 million Egyptian cash, reflecting a pattern of ignoring corruption.
  5. The 2020 and 2022 elections saw attempts by the DOJ and Trump allies to intimidate voters and election officials, including ballot seizures and unauthorized hacking, which failed due to public resistance and legal defenses.
  6. The book argues that the DOJ’s collapse under current leadership—particularly under Todd Blanche—creates a dangerous power vacuum, threatening democratic accountability.
  7. The author and Hillary Clinton emphasize that exposure of corruption is a vital first step, and that accountability must follow through investigations, prosecutions, or state-level actions.
  8. A major takeaway is that the DOJ only functions effectively when led by morally committed, independent figures, and that its power is both immense and deeply consequential to democracy.

Summary:

S. Department of Justice over time, from its founding in 1870 to the present. It highlights pivotal figures like Amos Akerman, who led early civil rights prosecutions against the Ku Klux Klan despite political resistance, and Louis Post, who later challenged unjust deportation campaigns in the 1920s red scare.

The book reveals a long history of DOJ corruption, including under Attorney General Harry Duryea, who accepted bribes and failed to investigate political scandals. It also details the suppression of key investigations during the first Trump administration—such as the $10 million Egyptian cash probe—where the DOJ under Bill Barr actively blocked accountability. The narrative underscores how the DOJ’s erosion of independence during Trump’s terms, including illegal ballot seizures and threats to election officials, has created a dangerous gap in democratic oversight.

Despite these failures, the book argues that public exposure of wrongdoing is critical, and that new Democratic leadership must act to reform and refound the DOJ. A central thesis emerges: the Department of Justice is not just a legal arm, but a moral guardian of democracy. The book calls for accountability, transparency, and the removal of politically connected figures like Todd Blanche, who has shown no intent to investigate corruption.

Ultimately, it contends that while the DOJ has failed, the resilience of the public, the rise of voter turnout, and the courage of whistleblowers present a historic opportunity to restore justice and ensure the country’s democratic future.

FAQs

Louis Post was a former US Department of Labor official who served as an incisive observer in the 1920s. He famously challenged the Department of Justice's deportation campaigns during the Red Scare, canceling thousands of deportation warrants based on lack of legal evidence or due process.

Amos Akerman was the first Attorney General with a full Justice Department. A former slave owner, he used the new Department to pursue prosecutions against Ku Klux Klan members in the South, advancing Reconstruction and demonstrating early moral leadership in enforcing civil rights through federal action.

Louis Post reviewed and canceled over 1,600 deportation cases in a single month, rejecting warrants based on lack of evidence, improper interrogation, or illegal processes. His actions exposed the injustice and illegality of the DOJ's campaign, making him a symbol of principled resistance.

Corruption severely undermined the DOJ under Attorney General Harry Doolery, who was a campaign manager for Warren G. Harding. He allowed bribery and corruption to flourish, and was later investigated and removed by the Senate after public outrage over an oil scandal, showing the power of legislative oversight.

The DOJ under Bill Barr pursued baseless claims of mail-in fraud and threatened election officials. These efforts failed due to strong legal defenses, widespread public turnout, and the moral resistance of election officials, which exposed the administration's attempts to intimidate voters.

She argues that the DOJ under current Attorney General Todd Blank has systematically ignored corruption investigations and intimidated election officials, violating its constitutional mandate to protect public trust and enforce the rule of law.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.