Go back

Rachel Maddow in conversation with Hillary Clinton - Part 2

43m 13s

Rachel Maddow in conversation with Hillary Clinton - Part 2

The transcript draws powerful historical parallels between past and present U.S. government abuses, particularly in the treatment of immigrant communities and civil rights leaders. It highlights the moral corruption seen in the 1920s under J. Edgar Hoover and today under Trump and allies, such as JD Vance, who used dehumanizing rhetoric to target Haitians in Ohio, leading to the unjust revocation of Temporary Protected Status and widespread fear. This pattern of political manipulation is contrasted with courageous individuals like Louis Post and John Doerr, who stood up for justice despite personal risk, showing that moral integrity often emerges in response to crisis. The book underscores the deep flaws in the current structure of the Justice Department, especially the rise of the Unitary Executive theory, which grants unchecked presidential power and undermines accountability. The transcript calls for urgent reforms—such as stricter Senate vetting, judicial oversight of appointments, and institutional checks to prevent executive overreach. It also emphasizes the vital role of grassroots civic action, including protests and community solidarity, in restoring democratic values and public trust. These efforts, especially in the face of dehumanizing narratives, build resilience and demonstrate the power of real-world human connection. Ultimately, the narrative argues that while the U.S. has faced moral and institutional crises throughout history, the strength of democracy depends on vigilant, principled leadership and the courage of ordinary citizens to stand up when their country is at risk.

Transcription

6290 Words, 34589 Characters

English
The chapter that really unfortunately resonated with what is going on today was about 1920 when a 24-year-old J. Edgar Hoover was running warrantless alien enemy raids, arresting a pregnant woman, a 13-year-old girl, parading people and chains for the cameras. It just is so shocking when we think back to what we saw on our streets in Minnesota and so many other places, and that's when Louis Post shows up. Now, who are the Louis Posts today? That's a great question. You know, I've been thinking about this in terms of the class of Democrats that was just elected. I was thinking about this in terms of Amy Acton. Amy Acton, you all know she is. She's just elected governor of Ohio. And one of the most disgusting things that has ever happened in public life in my lifetime, and I am old, is the way that Donald Trump and in particular, JD Vance, used the most repulsive language and the most repulsive rhetorical tactics you could invent to go after Haitians in Springfield, Ohio. And JD Vance, you know, he's just written a book on Catholicism, embracing that, and almost acknowledging that he knew it was false, but just going with it anyway in order to try to make people believe in anyway. And I'm not going to repeat it. You all know what I'm talking about. I don't need to repeat it. But that, I mean, Springfield, Ohio is in crisis right now, not only because of that incredible, like, pogrom style, dehumanizing language that they were, and what they were trying to stir up against Haitians in Springfield, but because, as a matter of policy, the administration then just yanked temporary protected status from Haitian Americans. And what that means, it's a technical term, and it sounds like we're talking Washington speak, but what it means is that people who were here legally were suddenly and instantly illegalized. They did not come here illegally. They were here legally, and essentially the invitation of the US government, and then they were made illegal. Their presence was made illegal, and they were given ankle bracelets, and they've been arrested on the streets, and people are living in terror. And the weekend before the election, there was a march, a sort of small, ecumenical faith leaders driven march of Haitians, Haitian Americans, and people of faith from Springfield supporting them, marching from Springfield to the state capital, just asking for mercy. And what same the act isn't going to do. What can the damn now-blue Ohio do to not just save those people, but to fix that harm? Well, I've had a long conversation with Amy, who I deeply admire, and she is going to do everything she can to try to, at the state level, which, as we know, doesn't control immigration and these decisions about things like TPS, to help the people who are still there. And also, remember, part of the reasons the Haitians were in Springfield, Ohio, is they were doing jobs that needed to be filled. These were tough jobs that other people, frankly, did not want to do. And the Haitians were thrilled to have these jobs and put their kids in school and join their churches and do everything that they could to be part of the community, which is why that march was, you know, kind of almost a memorial to what had been before Trump and Vance together made up those lies about the Haitians in Springfield. And the corruption comes in many forms. Corruption is financial corruption, but it's also moral corruption. And the moral corruption in what they said about the Haitians and knew they were lying and did not care. And what they said about Amy Acton in that horrific ad knew it was a lie and did not care. That moral corruption is equally corrosive to our body politic and has to be addressed. And the question arises, who stands up against it and says, no, and what effect does that have? And I think the thing that I keep learning again and again and again from our American history and from these challenges that we've had generation after generation century after century is that good people usually don't pick the fight that they end up in that proves their moral worth. Good people have a strong moral foundation and have skills and civic mindedness and then something comes across their desk or something comes to them with Lewis Post. He was working at the labor department. He wasn't even working on immigration. He wasn't the secretary of labor. He wasn't even the guy who was in charge of the labor department part that had something to do with immigration. But when he saw what was happening, he thought, you know what, I'm going to take this. This is now going to become my job. And the Department of Justice apparently doesn't believe in due process anymore. I don't work at the Department of Justice, but I can enforce due process and these proceedings, which I have no expertise in, but I'm going to do it. And he saved thousands of people from unjust deportations. And similarly, I don't know that the Minneapolis mayor, Jacob Fry, knew that he was going to be needing to stand up for his people as they stood up against a militarized assault on the people of that community. But you don't get to pick your fights. Your fights come to you and may you be worthy of them when they do. And I think that is what we're learning about these difficult times that we're in. You never know. Gabriel Sterling, you know, the assistant secretary of state or whatever he was in Georgia, Republican official there, Brad Raffensberger there, the Republican lieutenant governor of Utah right now who stood up against the Todd Blanch Justice Department and what they were trying to do with stealing Utah's voter rolls. I mean, these are not folks who woke up saying I'm going to be the marine leading us up the L at Iwo Jima. These are folks who are going to do normal Republican politics, normal civic stuff. And the fight came to them and they found that they were made of stern or stuff and the people who were bringing the attack to their door. And that is I just think what we should hope for. It's the reason you should have faith. It's the reason that you should work on your character. It's the reason you should have people in your personal life will hold you to account because you never know when your country or your people are going to need you and may you be worthy of it when it happens. Well, another time when I think the Justice Department stepped up and showed that it was worthy was during the civil rights movement. And you write about John door in particular. And I mentioned to you that I knew John door I worked for John door when I was on the Nixon impeachment investigative staff. And John door was the lead lawyer asked to serve by the Democratic chair then of the judiciary committee. He had gone into the Justice Department as an old fashioned Republican from upstate Wisconsin. But he had been on the front lines of enforcing the law to go back to your point what Amos sacrament tried to do enforce the law and the law was very clear not only the constitutional amendments but you know obviously passing the Civil Rights Act passing the Voting Rights Act. And John door put himself at risk repeatedly by trying to calm down angry crowds trying to prevent you know civil rights marchers who are being beaten from being you know injured and trying to help you know create a situation in which their rights would be protected and the protesters against them their rights would be protected. But you point in particular to how the Department of Justice was at war with itself because Jay Edgar Hoover was still there he was still the head of the FBI he'd been the head of the FBI for what four decades some ridiculous long tenure. And he was smearing Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. He was smearing all of the other civil rights leaders while people like John door were putting their lives at risk trying to protect those very same civil rights leaders. And then you had the murder of viola Luzo after the clan murdered her she was a volunteer who had come down to try to help out with the civil rights marches and jager Hoover tried to smear her she'd been murdered and he was trying to smear her because in the other part of the Justice Department. John Doerr was trying. to convict her murderers. So talk a little bit about this, because it is such, it's like a split screen. You know, Jay Edgar Hoover doing his best to undermine civil rights leaders, to undermine the whole movement, to smear them, and lawyers like John Dore. He wasn't the only one, but you know, you focus on him as somebody who was trying to enforce the law. - It really made me think about what we heard from this White House and this Justice Department after the murder of Alex Prety. Remember, they talked about him as an assassin, right? Remember, after they killed Renee Good, they wanted to open up a federal investigation into Renee Good's widow, into her family, not to investigate the killing of Renee Good, but to investigate her family. That was what the Justice Department was gonna wait in and do there. It really reminded me of that, the treatment of the ololeosos, the ololeososome down, came down from the North Volunteer to help any way she can in practical terms. She and a young black civil rights worker who had been part of one of the Selma de Montgomery marches were in a car together. They had been ferrying people back home after the conclusion of the march and a bunch of Klansmen shot him, ran him off the road and shot him and killed her. And Jay Edgar Hoover knew two things about this. One, was that he knew that they had an FBI informant in the car with the Klansmen who pulled the trigger. And number two, he knew that he needed to make this go away. And so he smeared ololeososote, called her a drug addict, implied that she was a woman of low virtue, attacked the young man who was in the car with her. This was happening inside the Justice Department. This is the FBI. Meanwhile, John Doer, as you say, is making sure that there's a real prosecution that has a hope of bringing some justice to her murderers. And the lesson there for me, was one that you have to be on the, you have to be wary of people like Hoover, of people like Todd Blanch, of people who end up in the middle of even moral crucibles like this. But it also really, really matters that you have good people in good positions. And there are more villains than there are heroes in this book, as you know. But John Doer is one of those heroes, a rock-ribbed Republican again. But he knew the right thing to do. It mattered that he was there and he made it his job as an assistant attorney general to make sure that that murder was going to be prosecuted properly and that people would pay. And he made sure that when the National Guard was out to patrol the perimeter of the civil rights marches over the ones that we've all seen all that footage of, so that there wouldn't be sheriff's deputies and civilian posses with guns drawn and with dogs attacking those marchers, there would be National Guard there keeping the peace. He made sure that the National Guard there didn't have their backs to the clansman lining those marches. They have their backs to the marchers facing out to the people who do those marchers harm. And that just takes bravery. But it also takes smarts. Like it takes people on the inside who are good people doing things for the right reasons. Personnel really is policy. And for all of the different good stories and bad stories over the course of the history of the Department of Justice, where the book ends, as you know, we're talking about this earlier today, is on pretty doable reforms. Reforming and standing up a new the Justice Department is something that should be done with an eye toward how consequential it is. And it should be done with an eye toward the lessons of history, which I think, again and again, are that it matters who's there. And we should be way more careful about who's there. A guy like Todd Blanche never should have been allowed to even be stood up for a Justice Department position, let alone had one. If you've ever been a campaign manager or a personal lawyer or a political hack for a president, you should be disqualified from serving at a high level at the Justice Department under that president. You just should. And there's other reforms along those lines. I think there should be a higher threshold in the Senate for confirming important Justice Department personnel. I think that the judiciary should be involved in the selection of U.S. attorneys. I think that the U.S. marshals should be out of the executive branch so that Donald Trump doesn't technically control both the keys to the courthouses in America and the police that protect the judges. I just think, those are all changes that you don't need a constitutional amendment for. The Justice Department is a creature of Congress, and Congress can effectuate those kind of reforms. I think that the people who he's put up to doing illegal things and corrupt things and abuses of power in his name, or because he's condensed them because he has a get out of jail free card that somehow they'll have one, too. Those people need to be liberated from that notion. I know we're going to get to audience questions soon, but I wanted to make a point that is evident in your book. And it goes back, again, to John Doerr. So when I served under him on the impeachment inquiry staff, he was so meticulous and rigorous. We could only look at facts. You could not express a political position. You had to be totally following the evidence. And the result, which is pretty remarkable, when you think back to it, is that when Richard Nixon was impeached by the House Judiciary Committee, it was a bipartisan vote. Four Republican members of the House voted with all of the Democrats, including the extraordinary Barbara Jordan, who was on that committee, who had made one of the great speeches as they were considering the impeachment vote. A bipartisan vote to impeach Richard Nixon. And then what happened? Republican senators went to the White House and told President Nixon that he would be convicted in the Senate, and he should resign. And he did. Fast forward to the 1980s. And there is a movement in part in reaction to what happened to Richard Nixon, to create a theory called the Unitary Executive. And the Unitary Executive is the idea that the president personally controls the whole executive branch, prosecutors included, which started as an idea in a loan dissent by Scalia, which the Supreme Court has now made the law of the land with their immunity decision, basically telling Donald Trump, don't worry. If you can figure out how to call it part of your official duty, we're not going to let anybody go after you. And one of the great advocates for the Unitary Executive Theory was Bill Barr. And so when I think about the position we find ourselves in today, where we have a non-functioning Justice Department headed by the president's personal lawyer, and where we have a president who says things like, I'm only bound by what I want to do and what I believe, this idea that was germinating of giving the president this huge, unaccountable power has been played out now by Trump. So talk a little bit about how that developed and where we are today, because a lot of what we're going to have to do is rein in that idea that I think has no basis in the Constitution, but is a results-oriented movement conservative position that the Supreme Court, which has a majority of movement conservatives, has now embraced. One of the things I think is underappreciated about the Unitary Executive Theory is that it's horse hockey. It doesn't come from anything in American jurisprudence at all, other than that loan descent from Scalia. But the reason that it got sort of mainstream-- the reason it got sort of stov-piped to the top of Republican politics-- was because Ronald Reagan really, really, screwed up in Iran-Contra, like really broke tons of laws. And Ed Mice, who was his attorney general at the time, was rummaging around for some theory he could use to try to get Ronald Reagan out of the jam that he was in for Iran-Contra. And he glombed on to this Unitary Executive idea, essentially, as a lifeline. Just because, well, if we say we believe that, then I guess that means that Ronald Reagan can do anything that he wants to do simply because he has the title of president at one point in trying to rescue Reagan from Iran-Contra. And this is in the book. Look, Mice concludes that Ronald Reagan could have overridden effectively a law, a congressional past statute, if he had a presidential finding in contravention of the law. And it was okay if the presidential finding was never spoken or written down if it was just in his mind. So it tells you the kind of, like, the kind of reach that's what Trump claimed about how he had declassified all the material found in, you know, the bathroom at Mar-a-Lago. Yes. How did that happen? Where's the paper? I just thought it. Yes. I spoke it. It was a mental finding. That comes from Ronald Reagan and at least. And so I think that it's worth doing a little history to understand the ridiculousness of where those things come from. But I also think that we're in an interesting position right now. They just had the, first, what, first of what I imagine will be many impeachment votes on Pete Hegg's death tonight in the House of Representatives. It did not pass because at this point, the Democrats are still in the minority in the House, but they won't become January 3rd and Mr. Pete Hegg's death will be hearing from them again because the Supreme Court decision, the Roberts Court endorsing this weird monarchical presidential immunity idea, I think that we are in a really interesting position right now. Cabinet officials don't generally get impeached. It's only happened twice before in American history. Impeachment proceedings are used very, very, very rarely, but the president has been declared immune. And the president, this is a president who's been impeached twice before and it didn't do much to cow him or change his behavior. But I do think that the immunity imagined by this, even this Supreme Court, doesn't extend to anybody beyond the person of the president himself. And I think that the people who he's put up to doing illegal things and corrupt things and abuses of power in his name, or because he's convinced them because he has a get out of jail free card that somehow they'll have one too, those people need to be liberated from that notion. And a pardon is no good against an impeachment, and a pardon is no good against a state prosecution or a congressional investigation. Can I ask a follow-up question? Of course. Do you think that there is a leader of the free world right now? We have some great questions. Here's a question from Steve Bornstein. How much of the success of the midterm elections can be attributed to the no-kings demonstrations? And do you know whether more are planned? I do not know whether more are planned. I would be very interested to hear what you think about this. I mean, I've spent a lot of time on MSNOW covering various protests that started before day one of this administration. I really think that the people led the Democrats on this. The Democrats are only just now catching up, and the people showed their antibodies against this type of virus. The people showed their reflexes against this form of an authoritarian movement and the cruelty in particular toward their neighbors. And I think that the demonstrations have given us our moral standing back. I think they've shown us where our spine goes. And I think it led politics by months and months and months, but how do you feel about that? I agree. I think, look, I am a very big believer in peaceful protests. And the fact that the protests literally started as soon as he was elected, but certainly once he'd been inaugurated, and never stopped. And it wasn't just the big no-kings demonstrations that were huge and stretched from sea to shining sea. And also, people standing on overpasses, people going to their farmers markets, people outside their library, people holding their signs, even if they were like a lone, you know, signholder. And I would, I saw a lot of these pictures and, you know, I would get pictures from, you know, friends of mine around the country saying, I joined the group that, you know, gets together. Every Saturday morning at 10, and we hold our signs. Well, I think all of that gave heart to, you know, those who might not themselves have protested, but felt that, you know, there's, there needed to be something more done. So, I think, I don't know if any more have been planned, but, you know, I think we need to keep it up because we need to keep that energy going. It also connects people to each other in real life, not online, not through your phones in a way that is really valuable when you're, when part of what they're doing is trying to make us see each other as enemies, and see each other as subhuman, and all of the, you know, talking about trans people the way they do, talking about immigrants the way they do, talking about women the way they do, when they're trying to make us see each other as not human beings and as a threat to one another. Being in the real world with real other people and making common cause and looking people in the eye, even being in an event like this tonight, it matters. I think it boosts your own immune system against that dehumanizing stuff, so I have a question for you. This is from Celeste from New Jersey, Madam Secretary, how much damage has the Trump administration done to our standing in the world? What will it take for us to write the ship and how long do you think it will take? A measurable damage, but the midterms gave people hope that America can try to repair the damage and rejoin with our allies on behalf of, you know, a world that we are hoping to make better going into the future. I would say three things. First, Trump's foreign policy is incoherent, dangerous and incoherent. And we are unfortunately seeing someone who admires strongmen leaders, thinks he is one, and believes in the old fashioned concept of spheres of power. And honestly, I don't think it's exaggerating to say that he's perfectly fine with Putin doing whatever he wants with Ukraine and the rest of Europe. He's perfectly fine with Xi doing whatever he wants with Asia as long as he can dominate the Western Hemisphere and that all of them are some kind of triumvirate that is going to decide what the rest of us are capable of doing and what kind of societies we will live under. So I do think that his view of America's role in the world is a very diminished view and very transactional and transactional, not just what America can get but more importantly what he and his family and his friends and his associates can get. So will we be able to repair that? Well, that will be up, I hope, to the next Democratic president in two years or so. I don't underestimate how hard it will be because you have to rebuild a lot of relationships. You have to try to assume a stance of predictability so people know what to expect from our country. You have to be very humble about how long it will take to rebuild trust and you also have to have to have a theory of the case. What are we going to be the leader for? What do we stand for? Who are we going to bring along with us? What are our goals and how do we best organize ourselves and our friends and allies and like minded people to try to achieve those goals? So it will be a very significant undertaking and it will take several years, even if we have a not just well-meaning but disciplined smart president with a good team around the Oval Office and in the departments and agencies, it's going to be a slog to send the message out to the rest of the world that we want to get back to the order of us being part of and the leader of a coalition of nations that are going to be doing things to protect freedom and democracy and liberty and human rights and all the things we use to stand for and try at least to do. Maybe Mark Carney? That's what I was going to ask. He's certainly articulating a vision of the free countries of the world and of the liberty loving nations of the world that is about being stronger together. And there are some good individual European leaders but Europe has got to get itself organized so that the sum of the parts adds up to some kind of a whole and be able to do a better job at making some tough decisions, particularly with respect to Ukraine. They need to release the $250 million of Russian assets that are frozen in those Belgian banks and use it to defend Ukraine just for starters. So if they can begin to make some collective decisions, then I think you'll see other leaders emerge. But there's going to be, as you know, Rachel, some very consequential elections in Europe this year, like the presidency of France. And if a populist pro-Putin party emerges with a leader who is very close to Putin and very beholden to Putin, Marine Le Pen becomes the president of France and we have new problems that we're going to have to deal with. Do you think that there's anything that the Congress can do to try to rein in Hague-Seth if the impeachment fails? Oh, yes. I have another question for you. Or do you have one for me? I have one for you. You mentioned the Hague-Seth impeachment, and I don't know how many Republican votes Massey can get if they keep having a vote. But do you think that there's anything that the Congress can do to try to rein in Hague-Seth if the impeachment fails? Oh, yes. I mean, let's just talk about the very start of the Iran War. The Iran War was started by the United States of America. On the United States of America's own timeline, we decided to start the war. Therefore, we knew when the war was going to start. We can all follow along with this chain of logic thus far. Heed Hague-Seth as the Defense Secretary in the United States government was responsible for force protection measures, for American troops, and their families in bases throughout the Middle East that they knew that the U.S. knew were within reach of the inevitable retaliatory strikes that Iran would launch against us after we started that war. He did not implement force protection measures for American bases. He did not evacuate American military families from the U.S. Navy base in Bahrain. It's not like it's an unheard of thing. When they're going to be in harm's way, they get the families out of the base. He didn't bother. I mean, this is what led to more than dozen Americans being killed at that Kuwait base alone. And dozens more injured, many of them very seriously. The destruction of so many U.S. facilities throughout the Middle East, whether or not you mourn those facilities, that was Pete Hague-Seth's responsibility, and he just oops forgot. That alone, like just let's start there. I mean, we don't even need to get into, maybe we should, get into him, you know, texting sensitive, forthcoming war plans to not just the editor of the Atlantic, but also his wife and his brother were on that signal turn. I mean, those sorts of things should be investigated. Well, should be held to account. I think that they will, I think that the, what will now be the ongoing impeachment proceedings against Hague-Seth will have an investigatory element to them, and that stuff should all be exposed. And as the actions of Pete Hague-Seth, you know, illegally dipping into the promotion lists to make sure that women and non-white officers are purged from the senior ranks of the military, right? What he's done with trans-service members, where he's given these sort of rules of engagement for these kangaroo court proceedings, they've been putting trans-service members through, and even those kangaroo courts are saying, no, we're not doing it, we're not kicking these people out. I mean, any of those pieces of it, investigate it, make it a multi-day news story, make them answer for what they've done. And I do think, ultimately, you and Pete Jim, whether or not the Senate chooses to remove him from office, but Donald Trump should have to decide every day, oh my God, do I want another day of Pete News? And that's part of what matters. You can also use the power of the purse to constrain some of the worst things that he's doing. Well, before we have to end, Brianna from New Jersey asks, how concerned should we be about Stephen Miller as Chief of Staff? How concerned, Secretary Clinton, should we be about Stephen Miller as Chief of Staff? I don't know. I mean, part of me thinks, Stephen Miller wants to run the government, wants to run the country. And I'm not sure Donald Trump will enjoy that, because I think Stephen Miller, with his every breath and every action, effectively is mocking Donald Trump as not really the president, because Stephen Miller thinks he's the president. And I don't think Donald Trump's going to like that. I don't think this marriage is going to last. What do you think? I think that we've seen Trump trying to decide how he's going to respond to the midterms. So in the 60-minute interview, he says, well, maybe the deportation was too much. Maybe we were too hard. We did maybe deport some good people like waitresses and landscapers and people that maybe were doing good jobs here. Yeah. So maybe it was a little too hard. And then he appoints Stephen Miller as his Chief of Staff. So I think he is struggling right now, trying to figure out, how does he respond? Because he knows that he was dealt a big loss last Tuesday. He knows whether he'll ever admit it or not that Iran is not going well. Before he launched the attack on Iran, he thought it would be over pretty quickly, decapitate leadership, change the regime, all the things that he had convinced himself of. And now we have to worry about the Houthis, which are doing a lot of damage on behalf of Iran. This issue about our facilities across the Middle East. Most of those bases have been damaged dramatically. They're not usable in whole or in part. So to even launch what he might think of as another set of strikes, I don't know where they're going to fly out of. I don't know where they're going to refuel. I don't know who's going to be servicing the three carriers they now have in the region. So it's not going well for him, which he would never, ever, ever admit. So I kind of slightly may disagree with Rachel, I think, you know, Stephen Miller is the lowest part of his id. And he expects Miller to be constantly 24/7 saying and doing terrible things to people that he wants terrible things done to. And then he'll either go along with that or he'll try to act conciliatory from time to time, because he's really in a dilemma. He doesn't quite know how he's going to play this out going forward. When Trump gives his state of the union, this is what I'm looking forward to. And he has to walk down that aisle and all these democratic women are just staring at him. It will be a sight for sore, sore eyes. We're a little bit over, but I have one last question for you. This is from June in Collingswood, New Jersey, who says that she represents the extraordinary women's league. I don't know where you are, June, but if you're wearing a cape, please wave it. Thank you very much. June says this, "What will be the impact come January when so many extraordinary women will be seated in positions of power and influence?" And then June abends a very good second question to this, which is, how can we best support them? First of all, it is just so exciting. I think we have now what 100 women in the House, and not only more women in the Senate, but the number of women governors in places that have never had a woman governor. I think that when Trump gives his State of the Union, this is what I'm looking forward to. And he has to walk down that aisle, and all these democratic women are just… staring at him, it will be a site for sore, sore eyes, and I think in terms of supporting, you know, the good news is we have this very big majority in the house, but it's difficult to organize a big majority. It's going to take a little while, and I think one of the first ways we support them is if you have newly elected women or men, you know, to let them know that you're behind them. We've got some great people who've been elected in this region who are new to the Congress. You know, do what you can to, you know, support their teams and to let them know that you're hoping that they can feel like they're accomplishing something, what can you do to make that possible? I know that Rachel will be interviewing a lot of them every Monday night, and everybody else on MS now will be interviewing them. So, you know, call their offices, say I like seeing you. I mean, this sounds like old-fashioned, it really matters. You know, if people, it go to events where they're appearing because unlike the other side, they'll have town halls. They'll actually show up with real people, and you go and you tell them you're glad that they were elected, and what can you do to help? I think to go back and maybe, you know, for me to end on this point to reiterate something that Rachel said, we need more events and places like this where people can actually gather together in person with one another. And I think those new members of the House and the Senate, and particularly these new governors, because, you know, they're inheriting some very tough issues in their states. They just need to know that we've got their backs, and the way you do that is by communicating with their offices, volunteering in their offices. You know, not everybody will do that, but, you know, showing up when you can to, you know, let them know that you're proud they're serving, and what can you do to help? It's very simple, but it used to mean the world to me when, you know, I served for eight years as your senator here in New York, and people would be so gracious and supportive. So. Well, on that note, I want to thank everybody who's here tonight. I would ask one favor before you leave tonight, which is to look around where you're sitting and say hello and shake hands with somebody who you don't know, because you have something in common with them, which is that you are interested in here in the two of us talk tonight on this topic. Meeting people in real life, there's no substitute for it, and we're so grateful for you being here tonight. And thank you. [BLANK_AUDIO]

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The historical precedent of J. Edgar Hoover’s warrantless raids and moral corruption in the 1920s mirrors today’s attacks on immigrant communities, particularly Haitians in Ohio, where dehumanizing rhetoric and the termination of Temporary Protected Status have led to fear and illegalization of lawful residents.
  2. Figures like JD Vance and Trump used false, repulsive narratives to stoke anti-Haitian sentiment, reflecting a pattern of moral corruption that undermines democratic values and public trust.
  3. Individuals like Louis Post and John Doerr exemplify how good people, even without political ambition, rise to defend justice—showing that moral courage often emerges in response to crisis rather than being premeditated.
  4. The Department of Justice has a long history of internal conflict, with figures like Hoover undermining civil rights movements while others like Doerr enforced the law, demonstrating that leadership integrity is critical to justice.
  5. The Unitary Executive theory, rooted in flawed legal reasoning and Reagan-era legal manipulation, has been institutionalized by the Supreme Court and enables unchecked presidential power, endangering accountability.
  6. Grassroots protests and civic engagement, especially in the face of authoritarian rhetoric, strengthen democratic resilience and community solidarity by fostering real-world human connection.
  7. Reforms are needed in the Justice Department, including higher Senate thresholds for appointments, judicial involvement in U.S. attorney selection, and removing U.S. marshals from executive control to prevent political power concentration.
  8. The moral and institutional damage from Trump-era policies—such as the Iran-Contra cover-up, lax military protection, and discriminatory military policies—demands accountability, public scrutiny, and structural reforms to restore trust and justice.

Summary:

S. government abuses, particularly in the treatment of immigrant communities and civil rights leaders. It highlights the moral corruption seen in the 1920s under J.

Edgar Hoover and today under Trump and allies, such as JD Vance, who used dehumanizing rhetoric to target Haitians in Ohio, leading to the unjust revocation of Temporary Protected Status and widespread fear. This pattern of political manipulation is contrasted with courageous individuals like Louis Post and John Doerr, who stood up for justice despite personal risk, showing that moral integrity often emerges in response to crisis. The book underscores the deep flaws in the current structure of the Justice Department, especially the rise of the Unitary Executive theory, which grants unchecked presidential power and undermines accountability.

The transcript calls for urgent reforms—such as stricter Senate vetting, judicial oversight of appointments, and institutional checks to prevent executive overreach. It also emphasizes the vital role of grassroots civic action, including protests and community solidarity, in restoring democratic values and public trust. These efforts, especially in the face of dehumanizing narratives, build resilience and demonstrate the power of real-world human connection.

S. has faced moral and institutional crises throughout history, the strength of democracy depends on vigilant, principled leadership and the courage of ordinary citizens to stand up when their country is at risk.

FAQs

Modern equivalents of Louis Post are individuals who step up to defend justice and civil rights, such as local officials or activists who confront moral or political crises, even without being directly assigned to such roles.

In Springfield, Ohio, anti-Haitian rhetoric from politicians like JD Vance led to the revocation of Temporary Protected Status, which suddenly made legally residing Haitian Americans illegal, resulting in arrests, fear, and community-led protests for justice.

John Doerr, an assistant U.S. attorney general, defended civil rights leaders by prosecuting murderers, ensuring the safety of marchers, and preventing violent attacks by placing National Guard forces to protect protesters.

J. Edgar Hoover, as head of the FBI, smeared civil rights leaders like Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and tried to discredit the movement, even after the murder of civil rights worker Viola Liuzzo, by falsely labeling her as a drug addict.

The Unitary Executive theory claims the president controls all executive branch agencies, but it has no constitutional basis and was developed to justify Reagan’s Iran-Contra actions; it now enables unchecked presidential power and undermines accountability.

People can support new female leaders by reaching out to their offices, attending town halls, volunteering, and showing public support to help them feel valued and effective in their roles.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.