Questlove Teaches Us How to Listen to Earth, Wind & Fire
56m 2s
Earth, Wind & Fire’s cultural impact is explored through a blend of music, history, and personal narrative. The documentary reveals how the band's music—particularly songs like "September" and "Let's Groove"—was crafted with intentional design, using character voices, minimalism, and spiritual messaging to deliver positivity subtly and universally. Maurice White’s journey from a young orphan to a visionary musician shaped by jazz, blues, and African influences is central to the story, highlighting his deep commitment to creating music that uplifts and transforms lives. The band’s musical innovation, such as the use of the kalimba and sophisticated arrangements, sets them apart from contemporaries, while their ability to blend funk, jazz, and soul creates a timeless sound. Despite being dismissed at times as "boring" or "inauthentic," their music resonated deeply with audiences, fostering long-term personal growth and a sense of possibility. The film also examines how Earth, Wind & Fire’s legacy extends beyond hits, with their full discography and deep arrangements reflecting true artistic mastery. Ultimately, the documentary positions Earth, Wind & Fire not just as a musical phenomenon but as a cultural force that helped shape a generation’s mindset, proving that music can be both a form of resistance and a source of hope.
Before we start the music, can you just introduce yourself?
What's up? This is Amir Questlove Thompson.
Welcome to the Trackstar HQ, World Headquarters.
Very honored to be here. I made it. I made it.
Finally. I feel like this has been such a long time coming.
I knew it was coming eventually. I don't want to press it.
So this is the plan. You have a film coming out.
Indeed I do.
Probably by the time this comes out. It's already out. Go watch it right now.
It's a hit.
Earth, Wind & Fire.
Yes.
We're going to talk about that movie. We're going to listen to some songs.
Okay.
And then for the second half, we'll hit the streets and we'll pull you to the test and we'll play a bunch of stuff.
I'm ready. I'm ready.
I know you're ready.
You know how long people have been saying, like, you've got to have Questlove.
Like, he's not going to be stumpable.
This is the show I dreamt about coming on, so I'm glad to be here.
To kick this conversation off, I just want to start with. That's at the beginning of the film, right?
Yeah.
I used a teaser of "Badiah" because I believe it was Philip that told me that, you know, I asked him, like, the word "Badiah" and "ba-ba-bop" are in many an Earth, Wind & Fire song, and what does that mean exactly?
And he told me that, you know, them being heavily influenced by Brazilian music, especially the work of Sergio Mendes, and them typically using "ba-ba-da-ba-ba-ba-ba-da-ba-da-ba," you know, and if you listen to any Brazil '66 music, it's kind of like that.
Yeah.
And I think that's the reason why I'm so excited to be here.
Yeah, and you see the influence there.
When the song got a second lease on life, at least for Gen Z,
which I believe kind of started when Taylor Swift did her cover of it
and kind of set the internet on fire.
This is where I struck up my friendship with the songwriter, Allie Willis.
Allie Willis, of course, famous for writing other songs like, well,
she wrote the theme, The Friends, I'll Be There For You.
If you're a fan of Beverly Hills Cop, she wrote Stir It Up for-
Patti LaBelle.
Patti LaBelle, and I think she wrote New Charm Dance for
the Pointer Sisters as well.
And if you're a fan or worshiper of the work of Jay Dilla,
kind of some key samples of his from Herbie Hancock.
Just Come Running to Me, which, of course, Lum Village used in Get This Money.
She wrote that as well.
I think she told me that she was so shy in meeting Maurice White
that she hid in the uh the ladies room of the studio yeah inside of a stall but you know like
in the movies where like people put their feet up so when you look under the stall you can't see
their feet she just sat there in a position and eventually like maurice walked in and looked under
and he's like well i know you're in there so you might as well put your feet down and she like
reluctantly came out the bathroom and then in about i think she said they wrote it in about
20 minutes and just use some place of words like body like i'll fill it in later and then uh you
know maurice had told her that we're kind of accustomed to the body so we'll just keep it
there like it doesn't mean anything but yeah september the the the most unlikely legacy song
ever it's easy to sing along to the body house too because you need to memorize the lyrics well
that's the thing it it it's it and it's kind of weird that just coming off the heels of the slide
in the family stone doc i just did i learned something about harmony and singing in unison
um you know oftentimes like you'll have acts that want to show off their chops like hey we're better
than you know and they'll do these intricate harmonies but when you all sing in unison
that's more comforting to your listener because then they feel like oh i can sing with you because
we're all singing the same note and so you know september is probably the most fun sing-along song
but it's also for a group like earth, wood, and fire the most unlikely kind of signature song
because there's so many songs in their arsenal that are that are significant for other reasons
and like even bigger hits yeah but when the smoke clears it's like the people have spoken like the
Same can be said for Run-D.M.C.
They've done historical, important songs like Walk This Way and all that stuff.
But when the smoke clears, It's Tricky is going to be the signature Run-D.M.C. song.
It's tricky to rock around, to rock around.
That's right, on time, it's tricky.
It's tricky, tricky.
Even though that's the song that, you know, like, September and It's Tricky sort of have the same meaning.
Like, they didn't know back then, September was just a throwaway song on a Grey's Hits record, you know.
And it did nice numbers, but it wasn't going to be like,
this is the song that's going to define us for--
this is our Billie Jean.
You just don't know.
This song is going to be played at every wedding
from here on out.
That's the gift.
That's the gift that keeps on giving, yes.
Why did you decide to take on this project?
What was interesting to you about Earth, Wind, and Fire?
And let's go way back, early in your life,
when you first became aware of them,
and then how they became interesting to you
as a documentary subject?
- I don't know if I've shared this story before.
So my father and I,
my father who was a notable local doo-wop legend
from the '50s, he was on Chess Records.
Name of his group was Lee Andrews in the Hearts.
He was Lee Andrews.
You know, 20 years after his career started,
he was the first in the first wave of nostalgia cycle
where I will say Hendrix is responsible for Nostalgia Cycle
when he told the organizers of Woodstock,
hey, there's this group that sings songs
from the '50s called Sha Na Na.
I'll do it if you bring them to you.
You know, and it was sort of like a novelty thing.
Like, hey, we're still singing songs from like 15 years ago.
But it caught on at Woodstock,
and then promoters realized like,
Oh, so people in their late 20s and early 30s still want to hear the music that they were listening to when they were 10 and 11.
So suddenly in the 70s, you had like American Graffiti and Happy Days and Grease and all those 50s things.
So my father was part of that, you know, part of that cycle.
And but he also had a nightclub show, which basically meant that, yes, he was doing his 50s hits, but he also had to do contemporary hits.
every other week my dad and i would binge shop um maybe like two to three hundred dollars worth
of records a week now in the early 70s that means that we're coming home with about 150 to like 200
records and 45s yeah and so just pretty much i'll say that my childhood home was probably this times
maybe 10 like it's like 3 000 records in the house so i just remember one day in 1975 um
my grandmother had to be rushed to the hospital but that was also on like ben's shopping day
yeah so maybe two days after us visiting her in the hospital dad and i like went to the record
store and laid eyes on the that's the way the world album cover i just remember seeing them
like jumping in mid-air and trying to figure out how the camera captured like them in action like
with their feet without their feet being on the ground i didn't know about gravity i mean i was
four years old so i just yeah that album just stood out to me because it just sounded different
than every other album in my parents collection
it's interesting that you it like you have this image of the cover in your head and there's such
of visual aspect but then the music obviously grabs you yeah i think um for a lot of us that
were around the time of the 70s when we're trying to describe the feeling that we have of the music
then there's this other encompassing uh indescribable feeling of listening to a record
and studying the album cover
and looking at it and reading the liner notes
as you hear the music.
And record releases were events back in the day.
Like, when Songs in the Key of Life came out,
that was an event.
Like, the whole family sat by the stereo
and just looked at the speakers as. It was like, you know, like when you hear,
see movies of, like, old-timey radio show
where they're just listening to War of the Worlds.
Like, it was an event.
So in my household, record releases were almost akin to movies coming out.
Okay, so that's how you became aware of them early on.
Now fast forward to how did this documentary sort of start to come together?
Coming from a band that sometimes gets misidentified.
I've read many a press release on The Roots.
I know that oftentimes when people are describing The Roots,
they're describing the idea of the roots,
which kinda makes it like their ideal version of the roots,
which is like, you know, they think that we're
these incense lighting, you know,
metaphysical, positive, tofu eating,
you know what I mean, like vegan,
whatever that group is that you think is in your head.
that was the case for Earth, Wind, and Fire
we would
just sort of say like
oh they're deep and their deep
comes in heavy air quotes meaning
that they're just on another spiritual level
that you're not too aware
of
and the more I started
studying them
I too had a burning question
which was
how did this band trick
their entire audience into eating
their vegetables
you know what parents have to go through to get you to eat
you won't get no dessert unless you eat all that
asparagus like Earth, Wind, and Fire
is the healthy cereal that
you don't choose and you'd rather
have Captain Crunch but you know
you need that to survive for nutrients
and all those things so I always
wondered how did they trick
their audience into
positivity and
what I learned about
Maurice's
songwriting structure like none of
that
was by accident and was very much
by design where
even the way that Maurice
and Philip Bailey sing with each
other they sing in like
these character voices like
if you were to imitate Maurice White
it'd sound everything
it's almost like his
version of a 70's street cat
where he just uses
yeah what's up
and he talked almost like in a male blink
like if
Bugs Bunny had some like
street to him and sometimes the words
aren't clear but what what what he's
doing is he's subconsciously put
planting these seeds of positivity in
your mind and when you sing along with
them because the music is infectious you
by default are also singing affirmations
you know they were very careful on the
usage of proper nouns and pronouns like
they didn't want to limit it so it
wasn't a thing where it's like girl I
love you so much because then it's like
okay you're only singing the half the
audience so all their music all the
lyrics had to apply to their entire
universal audience and they were about
positivity but they wanted to do it in a
way where it didn't seem boring or like
here comes the goody two-shoes so that
to me is a trick they pulled off and I
wanted to use their story so that people
have some sort of way to get through
what we're living through now like how
do you stay in a positive mind state in
the worst times ever so earth wouldn't
fire will be our our Wikipedia got I was
thinking about the voice thing on when I
was listening to this music yesterday on
the plane I was thinking about that
voice that character voice and I was
thinking about grunge music and how
these different types of music come
along where the vocal has this
signature thing to it and I was I was
like wondering like why is that and you
you have to sound like your audience
yeah and so that's the thing like there
in in the beginning they were well
meaning and and and even though they
meant well they there was still a
distance between them and their audience
and by the time time they get to their
fifth record suddenly Maurice finds his
voice more last as as a character he's
like
street preacher part character but you
know by the time they get to open our
eyes like listen to the the if you
listen to mighty mighty
the opening song on open our eyes where
they like if you the words are you walk
around why would you wear frown just
because little people are trying to put
you down what you need is a helping hand
and understand that everything is yours
at your command which you know a person
will look at you like you're crazy if
you're saying to me like that's their
version of don't worry be happy which of
course you know as the listener you
might have an eye roll for it like here
they come again trying to preach to me
so I think it's by on purpose that they
sing in these character
these character voices and it's just two
people Maurice and Philip but it sounds
like a group of them all that's by the
design to make you the listener and not
feel intimidated that you two can join
with them because it must be 42 million
of them singing together like they sound
like a group or a choir but they sound
like that's what street cat sounded like
in the 70s you know hey let me let me
put you on something young blood Maurice
White something that stands out to me is
he's pulling these influences from all
these different places I mean he grows
up in one place moves to another place
moves to another place there's all these
different types of musical things that
are coming in there's a line about how
their combination of funk jazz classical
chords tribal African beats can you sort
of speak to who he is and where his
musical influences came from so you know
Maurice White this this particular
angle that I used in telling me Maurice
White's story you know first of all he's
using Earth Wind and Fire as his kind of
Trojan horse as his own personal army to
get to you the listener but who Maurice
White was as a human being was this is a
story of a five-year-old orphan who
somehow some way falls into metaphysics
now if you're given away by your mother
and if you're broken-hearted about it
and you don't have a father and pretty
much you could die any moment like he's
left a fin for himself in Memphis
Tennessee and a stranger next door takes
him in as one of her own and by the age
of seven he has this vision of of what
he calls metaphysics and metaphysics is
pretty much um you know you'll hear
people try to give a differentiate like
religion
versus spirituality and for him
metaphysics was instead of like praying
and begging to a God where you don't
know if God's out there listening to you
where he just if he if he sits still then
he gets the answers and he realizes that
at an early age that if I just sit still
and silent an idea or inspiration is
going to come to me and he's been doing
that since seven and somehow he just
had this vision that one day he's going
to put together a group of people and
when they perform the entire world's
going to love them and he wants
everything that they do to be
intentional and to be positive but he
also realizes that you have to you know
kind of put sugar with the medicine and
so I mean to his core Maurice White uh
was a sort of anointed with this this gift
of organizing and he started out as a
drummer and when he graduated high
school Memphis he moves to Chicago and
it's in Chicago where he really gets
enlightened he gets into jazz he meets
John Coltrane Chicago's the epicenter of
chess records so he becomes a session
musician eventually plays with Ramsey
Lewis at the time one of the most
popular instrumental Jazz musicians like
doing pop hits with Ramsey Lewis
and kind of at the height of his his
success he realizes that he has to
chase his dream like who would leave the
safety of a well-paying job like damn
near the rock star of the jazz world for
this unknown idea of putting together a
nine-man group that's going to change
the world but just through examples I
show how he goes up against the odds
like he's playing to audiences that
aren't ready for him yet that will boo
him he's playing to demographics that
aren't necessarily looking like he does
but he literally has no fear he shows
you that you must step up to your dream
and fully immerse yourself in your dream
and so that's the story I want to tell
so this is 1966 Ramsey Lewis yeah wade
in the water doesn't sound like Earthwind
fire but you know what it is um what's
kind of revolutionary about this there's
a there's a moment after 1965 in which
you know once the the younger generation
becomes of age those who are born in the
mid-50s that are now 10 years old 11 12 13.
like the youth will always determine
what the sound of music is going to be
and you know there was resistance from
the adults like well you know very
dismissive of kids and their bubble gum
music and that sort of thing like what's
revolutionary about what we just heard
was like jazz and rhythm like really was
kind of frowned upon like why would we
lure ourselves from our from our uh kind
of high horse level of intellect to just
play with the common you know mortals
down there want to listen to their dance
music and whatnot
So even like having a pop rhythm and kind of a soul or a funk
to it, was sort of seen as compromising jazz.
In the beginning, jazz was dance music, big bands and all those things.
And then one day, I guess, musicians were like, "Well, we're going to speed this up."
And speeding it up stops the dancing and it's so fast where it's like, "Okay, now we just
got to sit down and watch these guys in their self-indulgent solos."
That's what jazz became a musician sport once bop came into play.
And by 1965, '66, '67, we were literally dancing in the streets.
And so this is why the Ramsey Lewis Trio was so popular because they had jazz sensibilities,
but they were mixing it with their soul.
And in the beginning, now this just sounds like our grandparents' music and, "Oh, it
must have been. That must have been the standard back then."
No, this was like, to a jazz purist, this might have been like what EDM is to like music.
"I don't know, get that noise out of here."
So, yeah, that was revolutionary music back then.
This is Chess Records.
This is a sort of remake, re-release of the song that's leaning into psychedelic music.
This is an era of when Chess Records becomes Cadet.
Cadet was this vanity label offspring of Chess Records and which is really catered to the
love generation, to the hippies, again, the teenagers.
And it's so weird that, yes, now 60 years after the fact, we speak highly of all of
our soul music pioneers and all those things, but you got to understand, man, in real time,
this came out like this was controversial.
The cover says, "This is Howlin' Wolf's new album.
He doesn't like it."
Yes.
"He didn't like his electric guitar at first either."
Yes.
Read the title of the album one more time.
"This is Howlin' Wolf's new album, period.
He doesn't like it, period.
He didn't like his electric guitar at first either."
That to me is one of the most genius album titles.
That album cover is one of my favorite covers of all time, because even the way that the
fonts look.
It grabs you in its simplicity, but you have to understand that, and especially in light
of how this pertains to Maurice White, again, a person that wanted to extract spirituality
out of religion, really starting with the musical "Ray Charles," the second he started
singing secular music, but it sounded like gospel, the black church was all up in arms.
We hear. It sounded like, "I got a woman right now," and be like, "Hey, that's standard Ray Charles."
♪ She give me money when I'm in need, yeah, she's a kind doll ♪
But back then, that was almost like the equivalent of N.W.A.'s "Fuck the Police."
The black church was angry.
And so the idea of Marshall Chess convincing his artists like, "Hey, I know you're used
to the Delta blues that you've been doing since the 30s."
Yeah.
"I know you're used to the Delta blues that you've been doing since the 30s and 40s and
50s, but to reach a new audience today, you got to put a little rhythm inside of your
music."
And similar to what Dylan went through in '65, the electric guitar, again, these things
that we just now hear is like, "Oh, this is the standard of what it used to be."
No, all this was heavily controversial.
Blues purists were like, "Oh no, he's selling out, trying to make dance music for these
teeny boppers."
They were going down the funk.
The slower the music was, the more they thought like, "Oh no, you'll shake your hips and that's
of the devil, shaking your hips and dancing sexy."
All of this was frowned upon.
But from my perspective, these were a lot of the records that DJ Muggs would use for
the first two Cypress Hill records.
So to my generation, this is the foundation for something like the best hip hop that we
heard, because there's a lot of stuff that's loopable.
But yeah, man, great album title, great cover, and really, really great, some of their best
music ever.
So I think it's interesting that this record is sort of also charting the journey
that he took, the physical journey that he took, that Maurice White took around the country,
from down South, from the blues, to Chicago, to the electrification, to California, to
the psychedelic movement.
Yes.
And it's by Charles Stepney.
Yes.
Who's Charles Stepney?
Charles Stepney was a composer, arranger, songwriter, producer that will really serve not only as a mentor to Maurice White, but really, he was a father figure to him.
Maurice White, again, was an orphan without mom or dad in the household, so everything that Maurice White did, he did it for his family.
Yes.
He did it for his parents.
He did it for his family.
off the wall or eccentric for the music. Oftentimes, especially with black music, there was
He did it for his parents.
This kind of unspoken, hands-up, don't-shoot approach to how it was executed.
If you listen to the music of Motown, you know, very calculating how safe and how pleasant it sounded
because we don't want to scare the people.
We're coming into their households.
And Charles Stepney really just let his freak flag just go wild,
especially when he starts to work with the music of "Rotary Connection."
Of course, Maya Rudolph's mother,
the great Minnie Riperton, is in "Rotary Connection."
And I would say Charles Stephanie is what you,
audio-wise, would think
what a psychedelic trip would sound like to soul music. Dissonant chords, chromatic chords, and
strange arrangements, and the engineering very psychedelic.
He was of his time and he gave the playbook to Maurice White.
is there a connection um i believe that they're connected um blood sweat and tears a group on
columbia records signed by the great clive davis there is a point where i think there's commonality
with and i don't think it's a mistake that even with earth wood and fire now touring with the
group chicago there was a point where both blood sweat and tears and chicago uh were two groups
that put emphasis on their horn section um so this is an example of jazz rock yeah big band
arrangements to rock music yeah i will say that there's a connection because in that's 1968 um
in about four years clive davis will sign uh earthwood and fire who sort of discovers their
inner horn section led army turning a nine-man group into a 14-man group so that's a lot of
like they used to yeah you know no it's it's kind of weird because when the roots first started we
started out as a trio like buskers a bright bass a drummer and a rapper and i think it was maybe
two years ago i never took a head count of the roots and we were kind of like backstage ready
to go on i had my camera up and i was just going in a circle and then when i did the third rotation
i was like wait a minute one two three four five six seven eight nine two wait we're 11 when did
we become earth one fire like it hit me maybe three years ago that we have more members in the
roots than earth one and fire like when i think of earth one fire i think of an army of musicians
And somehow we just became that.
But I'm world famous for, hey, that's dope.
Want to join us?
Yeah.
So we're the Noah's Ark of music culture.
So there's a challenge to having a band that's a certain size.
Just in terms of the orchestration, in terms of using all these pieces in the right way,
how does Earth, Wind & Fire sort of figure out how to shape all these different voices
into something that works together?
OK, so by example, James Brown proved that all instruments
can be percussion.
And there's a big difference.
In Miles Davis's hands in 1968, when
he's making the Bitches Brew album,
you could have the same amount volume-wise,
the same amount of people and participants on a song.
And in Miles Davis's case, it's a very dense, packed sound.
♪ ♪
It's like a Jackson Pollock art piece where you just throw everything everywhere.
Same year, in James Brown's case, if you have that amount of people in your arsenal, the
trick is you give them very little to do, but if it's syncopated and structured as a
well-oiled machine, it sounds like an army tank.
So as a result, anything that's melodic is doing very small contributions to the rhythm,
and the whole band sounds like percussion.
And Maurice White just. I mean, once that came to be, and the song's called Cold Sweat
by James Brown.
That was the moment big bands and musicians realized. Oh, we can sound like an army if it's not one lead person, and then there are 13 friends
with them.
They all, as an army, play the same thing, and very little of it, that's the more powerful
you sound.
So that's something that you have to wrap your head around, that Earth, Wind & Fire
is this 14-man group, and they have a lot of expansive ideas.
Their music goes everywhere in their arrangements, especially when you listen to. Like, their filler.
If you listen to a song called See the Light, that's on That's the Way the World, or Spasmatic
Movement, on the Open Our Eyes album, or even like Running, on the All In All album.
They go all over the place, but they go all. They go all over the place as a unit, and there's not one instrument that stands out.
They all contribute.
They're 5%, but they make it count, and they're a well-oiled machine, and when they sound
well-oiled, they feel like an army, but they're doing very little.
It's my mom's favorite song.
So this is a great example.
Of how less is more.
Yeah.
Okay, so this is a Kalimba song.
This is on their 1974 Open Our Eyes album.
In '74, many of us did not know what a kalimba was.
Kalimba's a thumb piano that Maurice White discovered in his world travels with the Ramsey
Lewis Trio.
So first of all, if an Earth, Wind & Fire song is in the key of A, A minor, you already
know you're about to get a Kalimba solo.
Yeah.
So, you know, it's a great example of how much you can do.
their signature key stevie wonder is an e flat minor key because all the black keys are in the
know superstition you haven't done nothing i wish skeletons do yourself a favor all those cv wonder
songs are if you there's no wrong notes when you hit all the black notes at the same time so stevie
wonders keys in e flat minor james brown prefers d minor so at least 20 plus of his top 10 hits were
in the key of d earth wind fire was uh an a group weird enough their biggest song in a a which is
september does not have a kalimba solo so that's the one a song in their arsenal that has no
kalimba solo which shows you like kind of what an afterthought of this song was but what's brilliant
about kalimba kalimba song is that this shows you how less is more works and how
powerful less is more is now as a drummer you know if you think of a
drummer I think most people that grew up in the 90s if you think of drumming nine
times out of ten you're probably thinking of Dave Grohl's intro to like
teen spirit so in our mind it's like together together together together and the whole like
you know playing this full power thing if you listen to kalimba song ralph johnson's playing
a very simple it's it's almost like a charlie watts you know like relaxed charlie watts looks
when he's playing with the rolling stones like like he can't be bothered yeah that's literally
the effort that it takes to do that rhythm which if you're a drummer your
brains telling you oh you got to do more you got to do more to justify your
existence here which is why I like today a lot of drummers and you know we call
them they call gospel chops like if you look up just go to YouTube and look up
gospel drop drumming and those are drummers that are like influenced by
by like, you know, this fast like fusion jazz thing
where you gotta hit everything.
Like Frank Zappa, like music,
like fill the space.
But in this case, Ralph Johnson has to do
almost next to nothing.
Like it's very easy just to do
boom, cap, boom, boom, cap, boom, boom, cap.
But what winds up happening is
Verdeen White's bass is also doing
what the kick drum does, right?
Al McKay and Al McKay is the secret sauce inside if there is a Michael of the group as far as
musicians like a standout person or LeBron or Michael Jordan um Al McKay would be that person
Al McKay is given the freedom to flex a little bit and his rhythm guitar is really doing what
the hi-hat should be doing so your brain is thinking like oh that drum is getting down but
really know the drummer's just a traffic cop playing very simple what the hi-hat should be
doing that's what al mckay's doing with his guitars what verdine white is doing with his
bass and as far as adding accents to the kick drum it it makes them sound bigger than what they are
like in your mind your mind's processing like they were getting down but no they were doing
something very simplistic but because they're doing it together it feels like an army so it's
It's a whole psychological thing, and it gives space for Maurice White to do his magical work playing the kalimba.
Like, Larry Dunn's keyboard actually makes very low, which gives Maurice White a spotlight or a space.
So even having that knowledge so early in the game, they introduced a new kind of sonic sophistication sound
that I don't think is afforded to other groups of that era
because normally nine times out of ten, you're in a cheap studio.
This mic might work.
These compressors don't sound as good as da-da-da-da-da, you know,
or which engineer is going to draw the short straw.
And hip-hop was like this as well.
A lot of this stuff is done at cheap studios,
which is why hip-hop is so raw sounding.
But in this case, Earth, Wind & Fire was highly aware
of how sophisticated they wanted their sound to sound.
So that's by design.
I once had a life, or rather, life had me.
Hell of an opening.
It's hard to stop it.
Funkadelic.
Yeah, in any music phenomenon,
there's the good versus evil thing,
there's the old versus the New Testament,
there's Marvel versus DC,
There's Rolling Stones versus The Beatles.
And in our world, it was Earth, Wind & Fire versus P-Funk.
I think George himself would joke that Earth, Wind & Fire
was Harvard and P-Funk was Howard.
But both groups were equally metaphysical.
And both of them used different approaches
to disarm the listener from recognizing that they're being educated well the number one trick
that funkadelic used in their arsenal was humor and i believe that george clinton's pin game is
without no doubt he's one of the smartest songwriters in existence all of his all of
his lyrics are either idioms like he's used every idiom under the sun you know any any terms like
you know you better wake up and smell the coffee you better uh any of those things like you don't
let the doorknob hit you with the lord split you in the like he any idioms and much like earth
wouldn't fire now earth wouldn't fire would hide their positivity their messages in these voices
that were more like street characters you know what i mean whereas george clinton
really took advantage of of the greek course um singing in unison
uh and minor parts leading to a bigger picture so a lot of his lyrics and a lot of his courses
are interchangeable
the average songwriter will just
have one bridge
no George Clinton always makes sure
that there's like five to six parts
that will stand out.
So if you're not going to sing the lyrics,
then you're going to sing the chorus if you're not going to sing the chorus we're going to have
a sha la la part where there's no lyrics that you could do but same thing for earth wind and fire
you can use lyrics you can use the cha la la body ya ba ba ba ba part and you know both groups
developed uh early in the midwest uh detroit for funkadelic chicago for earth wind and fire
they had one show together uh in the early 70s i believe late 72 or early 73
and because of the there there's what i call what we call respectability politics
um i guess now we can say like a political correctness about earth wind and fire very proper
we're sophisticated that sort of approach whereas
funkadelic was
in a constant state of zero flux given and so as a result earth wind and fire opened up for p-funk
and got blown off the stage and you know again whenever a setback hits the band
usually uh people cave into the pressure and um panic yeah and maurice white's approach to
everything was like after every show he'd sit in his
bedroom silent for an hour and just meditate and he realized the answer was al mckay we need one
more member of the group that will help emphasize the funk in a way now you know funkadelic is a
guitar based band they're a counterpart group they're the same group funkadelic was guitars
p-funk was horns but they got blown off the stage by a guitar player eddie hazel who's who's god you
know i mean all of george clinton's guitar players were god level but in this case eddie hazel and
maurice's answer to that was al mckay and al mckay once he joins the group in 1973 they will hit
their stride in these strings of hits that um will define the group uh through the next uh seven years
you're a shining star no matter who you are shining bright to see
it's always changing yeah
you know all right so you know what just happened we we just gave an example
of why that song works because there i mean the tension in music is always music and lyrics
the most important and the most dangerous part of that song are the lyrics so in order
for the lyrical um intention to land with its listener you might have to trick your audience
and in this case the song has to be so relentlessly danceable
and funky instantly we start it with right and this is also where the band realizes the power
of the messaging and how they deliver it to it maurice white wasn't singing i mean he started
in open our eyes but he's singing in that character voice yeah dreams take you very far yeah yeah it's
it's again that's that's his gospel preacher voice and that's that's by design i mean literally
you know the first four lines are straight from walt disney when you wish upon a star
it would take you very far you know and again if it's delivered in that sort of uh well intentional
you know disney way turn the radio off like that's corny like i don't even know disney the
stuff from seven years old but literally the first lines of the song is you know
if you have a desire in life to succeed just say it out loud and it will happen to you
you're a winner and you will go far in life and again i don't know why we're i mean we're averse to
good news and positivity often because as human beings we don't want to be
heartbroken you know it's too much of a risk and what Philip is saying what's in
your life that's not so clear like basically faith is the idea of
believing in something that hasn't happened yet and again the genius of the
song is the fact that they are really I meant for the first time like music
really besides Sly and the Family Stone like Sly and the Family Stone's version of
this is like you can make it if you try
Sly and the Family Stone more or less comes off like a cheerleading squad rah rah rah
you can make it you can make it we can do this but making people feel positive
especially like in the middle of you know the after-effects of Vietnam yeah
like we're we're going through hell to release this music while we're going
through hell was such a risk for an unproven group this will be their first
number one single this will be their first top ten single this is their first
hit and to put all their faith into delivering a message of positivity
without their audience knowing it there's an interview with the Obamas in
this documentary and it's a really good documentary it's really good it's really
good it's a really good documentary and there's a part where President Obama is
and there's a part where President Obama is like reflecting on seeing these guys
like reflecting on seeing these guys saying if I saw that I saw what they
saying if I saw that I saw what they were doing yes and I thought wow if
were doing yes and I thought wow if that's possible what could I do I want
that's possible what could I do I want insane quote when I look I'm gonna tell
insane quote when I look I'm gonna tell you I had two older cousins the one
you I had two older cousins the one thing I'm like I asked my mom this when
thing I'm like I asked my mom this when I finished the film like you know for two
I finished the film like you know for two people that were like hell-bent on me
people that were like hell-bent on me having
having like this musical enlightenment in my
like this musical enlightenment in my life huh the one thing you guys never
life huh the one thing you guys never did was take me to shows now mind you
did was take me to shows now mind you our job was giving shows so I you know
our job was giving shows so I you know I remember seeing like one of Jackie
I remember seeing like one of Jackie Wilson's last performances before his
Wilson's last performances before his coma but I found out in 76 that like oh
coma but I found out in 76 that like oh this is oldies music like my teachers
this is oldies music like my teachers were like well this is this is out when
were like well this is this is out when I was a kid Amir and I realized that my
I was a kid Amir and I realized that my parents weren't putting me on to
parents weren't putting me on to contemporary music
contemporary music so the thing is that my cousins went to
so the thing is that my cousins went to the 1977 all-in-all tour of which this
the 1977 all-in-all tour of which this is when the theatrical side of earth
is when the theatrical side of earth when a fire is becoming developed show
when a fire is becoming developed show yeah this is where Henning and
yeah this is where Henning and Copperfield are putting their shows
Copperfield are putting their shows together and they're levitating there
together and they're levitating there they're exploding there's there's you
they're exploding there's there's you know blowing up pyramids and smoke and
know blowing up pyramids and smoke and all this thing like hi theater was not
all this thing like hi theater was not a thing and so they came home that night
a thing and so they came home that night and you know I'm eight years old and my
and you know I'm eight years old and my cousin Diane is like describing like
cousin Diane is like describing like nine tubes came down and they came down
nine tubes came down and they came down in these tubes and there was smoke
in these tubes and there was smoke everywhere that I thought I and it was
everywhere that I thought I and it was almost like she saw aliens or was on an
almost like she saw aliens or was on an acid trip or whatever but she was never
acid trip or whatever but she was never the same after that concert she was
the same after that concert she was never the same after that concert
and you know she was one of the cousins that did well in life or whatever and every person that I remember describing to
every person that I remember describing to me what it was like to attend an
me what it was like to attend an Earth, Wind & Fire concert between 1975 and like
Earth, Wind & Fire concert between 1975 and like 1981 all those people went on to do like
1981 all those people went on to do like greater things in life but yeah Earth
greater things in life but yeah Earth, Wind & Fire disciples there was this
Earth, Wind & Fire disciples there was this osmosis effect that made them
osmosis effect that made them and I believe it's because of the subliminal
and I believe it's because of the subliminal subconscious positivity spread
subconscious positivity spread throughout their music and cause these
throughout their music and cause these people to want to do great things in
people to want to do great things in life so you know I too thought like okay
life so you know I too thought like okay well I won't be the same after this
well I won't be the same after this movie's done and even I'm not the same
movie's done and even I'm not the same anymore like I'm done the movie and I'm
anymore like I'm done the movie and I'm still reading all the Napoleon Hill
still reading all the Napoleon Hill books and every book that Maurice White
books and every book that Maurice White ever read like I'd read two or three
ever read like I'd read two or three times over so it's still not over for me
times over so it's still not over for me now that the movie's over last one okay
well either this or because they're both kind of interesting like I could not I
now that the movie's over last one okay well either this or because they're both kind of interesting like I could not I could not both with one stone earth wouldn't fire in my
could not both with one stone earth wouldn't fire in my opinion especially in black music the
opinion especially in black music the distinct position that earth wouldn't
distinct position that earth wouldn't fire holds is also space that Stevie
fire holds is also space that Stevie Wonder slide the family stone and Prince
Wonder slide the family stone and Prince also hold which is I personally believe
also hold which is I personally believe that their greatness isn't defined by
that their greatness isn't defined by the hit singles you know an artist like
the hit singles you know an artist like Michael Jackson will make you remember
Michael Jackson will make you remember beat it Billie Jean yeah my favorite
beat it Billie Jean yeah my favorite earth wouldn't songs are not the singles
earth wouldn't songs are not the singles my favorite Stevie Wonder songs are not
my favorite Stevie Wonder songs are not the singles my favorite Prince songs
the singles my favorite Prince songs slide the family stone songs are not
slide the family stone songs are not the hit singles those are the last things I
the hit singles those are the last things I gravitate towards the filler to me is
gravitate towards the filler to me is what really defines their genius now in
what really defines their genius now in this particular case
um and it goes to show you that music really is a polaroid snapshot of where you are in life
i'll give you an example like as as many times as people have like fond memories of hearing like uh
landis marset's ironic that will forever be the first song that i had a car accident to
so i'm forever seeing a skidding on i-95 barely missing an 18-wheeler truck in the snow
hearing it's like it's like all this panic which is why like when you're in the car like you turn
the volume down if anything if you get pulled up like you don't want to
get your ass beat to a soundtrack you know what i mean so that said philip bailey
has less than fond memories of this particular period of earth wood and fire and in my mind i'm
like dude these are like your two biggest hits ever why would you ever hate this period he is
not fond of the the of the time period because he wishes and him and the band also stated that they wish
that they were more involved um in the creative process of earth wood and fire albums the band
that bears their name you know and they really weren't given agency in terms of that type of
creativity um so for him it's it's less than rosy memories for me though uh i remember hearing
boogie wonderland uh school shopping for fourth grade i mean that that's a good problem to have
where even your second biggest single won't be in anyone's top 10 list of favorite earthwood and fire
songs yet and still you brought it but it's not your favorite song so that's a great problem to
have that means that their entire canon their entire output has resonated with their audience
not just the singles let's groove however i will forever have the greatest childhood memories to it
the first thing that comes to my mind is the day that the rays album came out or the day that that
single came out i remember it being a snow day i went to school in downtown philadelphia and i lived
in west philly so you know there's no feeling like the feeling when the principal says at 10 a.m
you know we're going to let school out early because it's snow day and it's going to be a
storm so get home safely students and i had my lunch money on me and back then records were
like six dollars 35 cents i happen to have like maybe a 10 on me uh and when school was over
went to sound of market street and uh purchased the rays album and you know we didn't go home
immediately we went to the arcade and all that stuff and it started snowing bad and
okay it's getting bad we better get home so i remember of us having like one of the greatest
snowball fights i was using the rays album as sort of like a shield and um got home and
you know my parents went home because again snow day i remember uh making hot cakes like making
breakfast for my friends i knew how to make a greatest breakfast chef of all time and listening
to that album so i have fond memories of the rays album um and to this day philip and i always have
this inside joke like the album he hates the most of his canon which is also one of his most
successful records is one of my favorite records
favorite albums of all time and let's groove was an inescapable earth wind and fire song
that came in the nick of time and little did i know that would be one of their last
like major hits of the era but it's timeless you can play it to this day and it still works
the movie's out now yes it's called earth wind and fire to be celestial
versus that's the way to the world yes great title with all my titles have been
these like long wordy titles and um being a fan of rocky and bullwinkle yeah all their episodes
would end on a cliffhanger you know stay tuned next week for or and you know that's the way to
the world maybe it's my nod to george clinton's uh use of puns but yeah that's the way to the world
is to me a very apropos description of
all the pain that he had inside and all the creativity that he had inside and all the dreams
that he had inside to make this band that changed all of our lives like he said i want to change
lives and he's changing my life right now and you know i've only worked with him once long ago so
yeah that's it's it's
on hbo and i want you all you creatives and fans and music lovers and people that
sort of need an answer on how to navigate through life this is the movie for you yeah it's amazing
thank you i appreciate all your movies are amazing thank you um all right that's it let's go
downstairs let's do this all right part two track star podcast is a presentation of public opinion
created by me jack coin kieran coin and henry cornaros produced by hayley sobel edited by
ryan durgan's theme and original composition by kieran coin mixing by devin klein our agent
is joanna orland at uta thanks for listening see you next wednesday
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Earth, Wind & Fire’s music, particularly the song "September," became a cultural touchstone for Gen Z, especially after Taylor Swift’s cover, and is now seen as a signature song for the group due to its universal, sing-along appeal.
Maurice White intentionally used character voices and subliminal messaging—like a "street preacher" persona—to deliver positivity without seeming preachy, making their music feel accessible and emotionally resonant.
The band’s musical structure is built on unity and minimalism
Maurice White’s journey—from a young orphan in Memphis to a visionary musician influenced by jazz, blues, and African rhythms—reflects a deep spiritual and artistic evolution shaped by mentorship and personal experience.
Earth, Wind & Fire’s success was rooted in innovation, such as the use of the kalimba and the strategic use of key signatures, which added sonic sophistication and emotional depth during a time when many records were recorded in cheap, raw studios.
The band’s music had a lasting psychological impact, with fans reporting positive life changes and a sense of empowerment, suggesting a subliminal "osmosis effect" of positivity through their music.
Unlike traditional hit-driven success, Earth, Wind & Fire’s true genius lies in their "filler" songs and deep arrangements, which reveal their artistic depth and enduring influence beyond chart-topping singles.
The documentary highlights how Earth, Wind & Fire stood in contrast to other funk groups like P-Funk through their respectability, spiritual tone, and disciplined approach to message delivery, while still embracing innovation and cultural relevance.
Summary:
Earth, Wind & Fire’s cultural impact is explored through a blend of music, history, and personal narrative. The documentary reveals how the band's music—particularly songs like "September" and "Let's Groove"—was crafted with intentional design, using character voices, minimalism, and spiritual messaging to deliver positivity subtly and universally. Maurice White’s journey from a young orphan to a visionary musician shaped by jazz, blues, and African influences is central to the story, highlighting his deep commitment to creating music that uplifts and transforms lives.
The band’s musical innovation, such as the use of the kalimba and sophisticated arrangements, sets them apart from contemporaries, while their ability to blend funk, jazz, and soul creates a timeless sound. Despite being dismissed at times as "boring" or "inauthentic," their music resonated deeply with audiences, fostering long-term personal growth and a sense of possibility. The film also examines how Earth, Wind & Fire’s legacy extends beyond hits, with their full discography and deep arrangements reflecting true artistic mastery.
Ultimately, the documentary positions Earth, Wind & Fire not just as a musical phenomenon but as a cultural force that helped shape a generation’s mindset, proving that music can be both a form of resistance and a source of hope.
FAQs
He was inspired by the band's unique ability to spread positivity subtly through music and their influence on audiences, especially during difficult times. He saw Earth, Wind & Fire as a metaphor for how positive energy can transform lives.
The song 'September' gained renewed popularity after Taylor Swift's cover, sparking a viral trend and introducing the song to a new generation. This resurgence helped reignite interest in Earth, Wind & Fire's legacy and musical philosophy.
Maurice White’s distinctive, character-driven vocal style—like a street preacher or 70s cat—creates a relatable, non-intimidating presence. This subliminal messaging helps listeners internalize positive affirmations without feeling preached to.
They used a 'less is more' approach where each member contributed minimally but in harmony, creating a unified, powerful sound. The music felt like a well-oiled machine, with instruments blending seamlessly to support the overall groove.
Charles Stepney acted as a mentor and father figure to Maurice White, introducing psychedelic arrangements and innovative sonic textures. His influence helped Earth, Wind & Fire develop a sophisticated, spiritually rich sound beyond traditional soul.
While P-Funk used humor and complex layered parts to deliver messages, Earth, Wind & Fire used subtle, positive affirmations through character voices and simple, danceable rhythms to convey hope without direct preaching.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.