Dr. Ray Wengrant recounts a pivotal moment during her research in Tanzania, where she witnessed the poaching of a giraffe and the subsequent community response. Though initially shocked by the violence, she realized the deeper significance: the dead giraffe’s meat was distributed to local Maasai women, who walked miles to collect it for food, demonstrating how poaching, while tragic, can provide vital nutrition in impoverished communities. This experience shifted her perspective on conservation, revealing that animal protection must be intertwined with human well-being. She argues that conservation efforts are incomplete without addressing the socioeconomic realities of local people, who often face extreme poverty and lack access to basic resources. The incident underscores the complexity of environmental ethics—where human dignity and survival take precedence over animal preservation. Wengrant calls for the conservation community to prepare for situations where human needs must be prioritized, viewing such compromises not as failures but as necessary and ethical steps. Her story challenges the dominant narrative of poaching as purely an animal crime, instead framing it as a symptom of broader systemic inequality. Ultimately, she emphasizes that true conservation must be human-centered, recognizing that people, not just species, are central to ecological balance.
So, there's this expectation that because I spent so much time in East Africa studying lions that my most impactful stories will be about lions. And as it turns out, one of the stories that really was the most moving to me and remains at the top of my mind so, so much is about a giraffe that I never even saw alive. I'm Dr. Ray Wengrant and this is a different kind of nature show, a podcast all about the human drama of saving animals. I want to tell you my story and what it's actually like to track bears in the seeras, chase lemurs and Madagascar, live with lions in Tanzania, and do all of that as a black female scientist. This is Going Wild. I'm Nate Hegey, host of Outside In, a show where curiosity in the natural world collide. I call it helium, but that's Sir Helium to you because this is one noble gas. That's exactly what Darwin thought, that song-free dated speech and human ancestors sang some sort of wordless songs. I have to say it is just perfectly dry down here. Stay curious with Outside In from NHPR, available wherever you get your podcasts. Poaching in East Africa is a really big threat to wildlife. Poachers go after animals for their hides, their bones, their organs, all kinds of things, and I was about to experience it firsthand. It was the year 2009 and I was in the middle of my master's degree and my research was to go to Tanzania that summer to work with the African Wildlife Foundation in their Ted and Gary lion project. In Swahili, that it was translated to Utafiti, Wasimba. So I finally arrived at the camp and it was this super rugged, you know, roughen it, dirty, scrappy little camp in the middle of the bush and although that might be intimidating to some and maybe even a different version of me would have been intimidated, it was exactly what I wanted. Look at this, you know, I'm part of this team and this is an exclusive place, you know, for real science. It was a wonderful place to call home for that summer. So besides me, the team consisted of Ifura, who was our fearless leader. Steven, who was a pretty general assistant in all kinds of ways, ED, who was a fix it man. And then Peter, who was second in command to Ifura, and he was another up-and-coming scientist, super tall guy. He came from a nearby Masai village, so he also helped us relate to the community. Every day, most of us on the team would pile into our junkie clunky field vehicle and head out into the bush to look for lions. We wanted to know where lions went and where they didn't go in order to figure out what kinds of habitats they need for their conservation, but also in order to communicate with the local Masai, who are pastoralists. So they could understand where it was safe for them to herd their cattle and where it wasn't. So there was this one week where instead of the whole team coming out to do the lion surveys, it was just me and Peter. And it was pretty fun when it was just us, because we would hit it early in the morning, and then we would usually have a lot of extra time. And instead of wanting to just head back to the field station, Peter loved taking game drives. Just driving around, seeing what kind of animals were out and about, and really taking note of them. And it wasn't like this leisurely thing for Peter. He actually was studying them all the time. Peter wanted to be a park ranger for Ted and Getteray National Park. That was his big goal. And so I really loved the days that it was just us together, because I wanted to support Peter and his preparation for being a park ranger. And also I loved going on game drives too. So we were kind of the perfect team, and we were just geeking out all the time by driving around and seeing zebra gazelles and Paula. And especially the super tall majestic giraffes. They were everywhere in this part of the landscape, and they were incredible. I think I loved, I loved them for a lot of reasons. It was one of the first Swahili words I learned was the word twiga, which means giraffe. And they're really special because there's so many grazers on this savanna. There's so many animals that put their heads down on the ground and graze grass, but giraffes are browsers. And so they browse from trees, and they have this cool tongue that I'm kind of obsessed with. It's this black tongue, and it's long, and it's strong. It's like a huge muscle, and it wraps around the branches of trees, and pulls leaves off. And even acacia trees, which are full of thorns, so a lot of animals can't eat them, drafts of no problem at all. And one day we were driving and found a paved road. And I have to tell you, finding a paved road was something that rarely happened, you know, in my experience there, because we were so far out in the bush in the pretty wild area. Hey, where are we going? And he just replied, oh, I need to drop something off to a friend. And I thought to myself, a friend who were in the middle of nowhere, but okay, you know, he was someone I trusted completely. And so we made this turn, and we drove up this hill, again, on another dirt path. And we get to the top of the hill, and there's a camp. And there were a couple guys at this camp, and they were wearing uniforms. They were these dark green uniforms, and they all smiled really big when they saw Peter. And so I realized, oh my goodness, okay, these are, I guess some of his friends he was talking about. Not only did I not know that he had friends in this area, I don't know where the heck we are, but Peter introduced me as Ray, researcher on his project, he introduced me to these guys as park rangers for Ten and Gary National Park. It all clicked for me really, really quickly, because I realized, oh, of course he would be friends with park rangers, because he aspires to be one. And Peter was just there to, I think, you know, if I were to translate it into my kind of terminology, he was networking. They had all kinds of walkie-talkies and radios going on, like a police station or a fire station. How there's, you know, this area where there's just all kinds of chatter coming over in the walkie-talkies and the radios. And no one seemed to really be listening to it. In fact, sometimes they just turned it down, you know, so they could listen to each other. And we were there for a while sipping our water and talking about Ted and Gary and, you know, business stuff. And then one of the rangers who hadn't been sitting with us walked over quickly and said something so fast, and so I healing that I wasn't able to catch it. But everyone dropped what they were doing immediately, stood up and ran to their vehicles. Peter told me in English, okay, get up right now, we have to go. We jump into the car, and I, of course, asked what's going on. And that's when Peter told me they found some poachers. There's poachers in Ted and Gary in the National Park. I got really worried that we were unsafe. That somehow, you know, we were in close proximity to poachers of people who might actually kill us. I started kind of panicking. I said, well, where are we going? You know, if those poachers like, where are we, where are we going? Can we stay here? Are we going back to camp? What are we doing? It appeared that we were following the park rangers as they were driving super fast, way faster than I thought our little truck could go down the dirt road, making tons of dust, you know, fly into our windshield so that we could barely see anything. It felt like a high-speed chase almost, you know, almost like, like cop cars or an ambulance or fire truck, you know, racing to the scene of a crime. And as we were following them, we were listening to the radio. He was listening for a while, and he was translating with me, okay, there were three poachers, they've been captured, and they had killed a giraffe.
Unfortunately, the poachers are caught too late. Science is full of surprises. From cracking your genetic code to microbes arriving in space, the breakthroughs never stop. I'm Dr. Samantha Yamine, your host of Curiosity Weekly from Discovery. In each episode, we dive deeper into the most fascinating science stories we'll explore it all. Join me as we unpack the latest ideas that are changing how we see the world. Subscribe to Curiosity Weekly, wherever you get your podcasts. I could see the giraffe in the distance, and it made me realize that I had never seen a giraffe lying down. Because of course, who has, that's one of those cool things about giraffes, is that they don't lie down. It takes them so long to get up from even a seated position, let alone a laid down position that they don't. They even do a lot of their resting standing up. So it was this weird, unnatural sight to see a giraffe completely on its side, and its belly was so big. And under normal circumstances, its belly would be inflating and deflating with deep breaths, but this time it was just very, very still. It was not bloody. In fact, if I had come across that giraffe on my own, I don't think I would have realized that it had been shot. It was beautiful, you know, and peaceful and calm and a beautiful day, and under any other circumstances, it would have been an amazing sight to be so close to an animal like that. And instead it was dead. It was kind of this double impact because, you know, as much as I cared for the animals and really, you know, hated the idea of them being shot, I also knew that any poacher in Tanzania was motivated by their own needs that were unmet, you know. I had a lot of compassion for these people who are criminalized as poachers because more than likely they came from some kind of severe poverty situations and they were getting paid to do this dangerous, risky, horrible work. They were choosing to do it because it probably paid better than anything else. So I had a lot of complex emotions, you know, going through my mind about the fact that we had a dead giraffe and also, you know, a couple of men whose lives are probably ruined in that moment and might not have much of a future themselves. As I was having those emotional feelings, I remember also having a lot of logistical questions kind of pop into my mind. You know, well, what do we do now? Maybe they'll take the whole giraffe's body and bring it to a museum. Maybe it can be brought to a university and can be dissected or, you know, used for science. I had all these thoughts and I realized, well, let me just ask Peter, he's standing right next to me and he's listening to all these park rangers speak so rapidly and so healing about what to do. So I nudged him again and I asked, what happens to the giraffe? And he pulled me away from the circle and I think he was actually a little bit embarrassed because he thought it was obvious what happened next and it was silly of me to not realize. But he pulled me away from the circle and he said, well, now we're all going to take some and I didn't understand and I thought, take some of what? And he said, we're all going to take some of the giraffe. Whenever an animal gets killed by poachers and is caught in time, everyone from the community is actually able to benefit. A giraffe is about a ton of weight and that amount of meat can feed so many people for so long. But we have to act rapidly. He explained that word had already been distributed throughout all of the neighboring Mosaic communities and people were on their way with baskets, with bags, with pots and pans and everyone was going to line up, take their machete, hack off some giraffe meat and bring it back home. We're in a landscape with no electricity and that meant no refrigeration so all this had to happen while the meat was still fresh and before nightfall came when surely carnivores were going to scavenge on the carcass. It was only safe for us to be there for a really short time. I almost felt embarrassed that that kind of thing didn't dawn on me. Of course, there is this opportunity to use the whole animal. What we were just going to let it sit there and rot, absolutely not. And of course, this community already has a protocol for what happens when an animal's poached or illegally killed in some kind of way. It was such a great lesson for me and all of a sudden I got excited. I was the first person to run over to the back of our truck and grab two big machetes. But before I knew it, Peter himself had his arm raised really high, almost like he was holding an axe and bringing it down really strongly and hacking into the hip area, cutting meat from her body. And it was gross, you know, it was really like a disturbing. So again, part of my body, in mind, was divided, part of me with them thinking, yes, this is purposeful, this is good, let's get it done. Another part of me was thinking, oh my goodness, this is really gruesome and brutal. And as if this poor giraffe hasn't been through enough already, now we're hacking her body to pieces. He gave me big pieces of giraffe meat and some of it even had the skin still on it, you know, with the iconic giraffe pattern. So I threw big, big, you know, 20 pound hunks of giraffe meat into the back of our trunk over and over and over again. And as I was doing it, at one point I looked up on the horizon and that's when I saw them. I can still see it so clearly even right now. I remember seeing a line, a single file line of Mossai women in the distance. And Mossai women wore these beautiful robes, you know, so these reds and blues and whites against dark, dark brown skin in a single file line. It looked like there were maybe 50 women, you know, walking over and many of them had these big baskets on their heads that were empty, but that would be used to carry the meat back. But it was also such a powerful, very, very emotionally moving site to see women who I so strongly think of as leaders of the community. Walking for miles and miles and miles to the site of a dead giraffe that everyone was upset about, but also to know that they were going to be bringing at least a day or two or three days worth of nutrition back to their homes for their children, for their partners, for, you know, their families and community members. And all of a sudden I thought to myself, God, you know, this is what's missing from the conversations in my classroom. We talk about how bad it is, how bad it is, how illegal it is, all the tragedy that comes from poaching, but we've never talked about the opportunity that it brings, the nutrition that it can offer to communities that don't often get it. Communities that used to have full rights and stewardship over these landscapes that have now been borrowed from it. And kind of shook me back into remembering that humans are more important than animals, period. Human life, human dignity, human livelihoods are way more important than any animal anywhere. And that's a really difficult concept to always keep at the top of your mind when your whole career is oriented towards saving animals. At the same time that I was working so hard to understand lions to figure out how to best protect them, there's an entire community of people living with lions, living in these ecosystems that don't have everything they need to be healthy, successful and thriving. And no lion project or no environmental project is complete if the human communities in those places have unmet needs. And that's what I mean by humans are more important than animals. I think that, in the comments,
conservation community, we need to prepare ourselves for the infrequent, hopefully infrequent times that we're going to have to prioritize human well-being potentially over an environmental goal. You know, if there's any compromise that ever needs to be made in the future, it might need to be made to the benefit of human dignity and well-being and that should be seen as a win not a loss. You just listened to Going Wild with Dr. Ray Wynne Grant. If you want to support us, you can follow Going Wild on your favorite podcast listening app. While you're there, please leave us a review. It really helps. You can also get updates and bonus content by following me, Dr. Ray Wynne Grant and PBS Nature on Instagram, TikTok, Twitter, and Facebook. You can catch new episodes of Nature Wednesdays at 8/7 Central on PBS, PBS.org/nature, and the PBS Video App. This episode of Going Wild was hosted and written by me, Dr. Ray Wynne Grant. Production by Rachel Aranoff, Danielle Brosa, Nathan Toby, and Great Feeling Studios. Editing by Jacob Lewis, sound design by Rob Heath and Jacob Lewis. Danielle Brosa is the digital lead, and Fred Kaufman is the executive producer for Nature. Art for this podcast was created by Ariana Bowlers and Karen Brazel. Special thanks to Amanda Schmidt, Blanche Robertson, Jane Leacy, Chelsea Satcam, Natasha Padilla, and Karen Ho. Going Wild is a new podcast by PBS Nature. Nature is an award-winning series created by the WNET Group and made possible by all of you. Funding for this podcast was provided by grants from the Anderson Family Fund and the Corporation for Public Broadcasting.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Dr. Ray Wengrant shares a deeply personal story about a giraffe poaching incident in Tanzania that profoundly impacted her understanding of conservation.
The giraffe was found dead by poachers, and instead of letting it rot, the local community, including women from the Maasai, came to collect meat for nutrition.
The event revealed a critical but overlooked aspect of conservation
Wengrant reflects on the emotional duality of witnessing violence against animals while recognizing the immediate human need for food and dignity.
She emphasizes that conservation efforts must prioritize human well-being, especially in communities living alongside wildlife.
The episode highlights how local knowledge and traditions—like community meat-sharing—can be vital to sustainable, ethical conservation.
Wengrant challenges the narrative that poaching is solely an animal crime, arguing it is often a systemic issue rooted in economic hardship.
The story calls for a shift in conservation ethics
Summary:
Dr. Ray Wengrant recounts a pivotal moment during her research in Tanzania, where she witnessed the poaching of a giraffe and the subsequent community response. Though initially shocked by the violence, she realized the deeper significance: the dead giraffe’s meat was distributed to local Maasai women, who walked miles to collect it for food, demonstrating how poaching, while tragic, can provide vital nutrition in impoverished communities.
This experience shifted her perspective on conservation, revealing that animal protection must be intertwined with human well-being. She argues that conservation efforts are incomplete without addressing the socioeconomic realities of local people, who often face extreme poverty and lack access to basic resources. The incident underscores the complexity of environmental ethics—where human dignity and survival take precedence over animal preservation.
Wengrant calls for the conservation community to prepare for situations where human needs must be prioritized, viewing such compromises not as failures but as necessary and ethical steps. Her story challenges the dominant narrative of poaching as purely an animal crime, instead framing it as a symptom of broader systemic inequality. Ultimately, she emphasizes that true conservation must be human-centered, recognizing that people, not just species, are central to ecological balance.
FAQs
The poachers had shot a giraffe, and the team discovered it during a routine game drive. The giraffe was lying down, which is extremely rare, and the scene was both tragic and peaceful.
The community members, including Mosaic women, came to collect fresh giraffe meat to feed their families, as the animal provided vital nutrition in a region with limited access to food.
They immediately realized the danger and followed the park rangers to the scene, where they learned that three poachers had been caught and that a giraffe had been killed.
Peter, a local aspiring park ranger, helped guide the team to the scene and explained the community’s protocol for sharing meat from poached animals to support local families.
Giraffes rarely lie down due to their long necks and difficulty in getting up; seeing one lying down is a rare and unnatural occurrence that made the scene even more impactful.
They learned that human well-being—especially food security and dignity—must often take precedence over animal conservation, especially in communities facing poverty and food scarcity.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.