Go back

Protein Powder, Part 1 - Ep. #78

from Inside Sports Nutrition

46m 31s

Protein Powder, Part 1 - Ep. #78

Protein powders are a common supplement in daily nutrition, but their use and ingredients are often misunderstood. The podcast emphasizes that protein powder is not just a processed food—it's a tool that should be used strategically, not as a replacement for whole foods. Many products contain added sugars, artificial ingredients, or hidden components like proprietary blends, making transparency and ingredient disclosure critical. The hosts stress the importance of third-party certifications (NSF, Informed Sport) to ensure purity and safety. They break down animal-based sources like whey, casein, egg, and goat protein, noting differences in lactose content, digestibility, and suitability for lactose-intolerant individuals. While some alternative proteins like cricket powder are gaining interest for sustainability, they often lack essential amino acids and are not ideal for muscle-building. The hosts caution against using collagen or bone broth powders as primary protein sources due to incomplete amino acid profiles. Ultimately, protein powders should be used based on individual needs—such as age, activity level, or dietary restrictions—and not as a default solution. The discussion sets up a two-part series: part two will cover plant-based proteins, and part three will explore essential amino acid supplements, offering a comprehensive view of protein sources in sports and daily nutrition.

Transcription

8218 Words, 44586 Characters

English
Are you using a protein powder in your daily nutrition or as part of your workout, preparation or recovery? What is in your protein powder? What is the source and what about all of those other ingredients? And is it serving you? If any of this is peaking your interest, stay tuned here for episode number 78. Welcome to the Inside Sports Nutrition Podcast, your source for all things sports nutrition related. The show is hosted by myself, Dina Griffin and my co-host Bob C.Bahar. We are both registered dietitians and board certified specialists in sports dietetics with combined professional experience exceeding 40 years. We're here to help provide translations of nutrition and sports science to real life. Give you interviews with a variety of experts and athletes where you enhance your knowledge and bring a fun nutrition convo to you each week. So in this episode, protein powder part one, we hope you will enjoy this episode, and we'd love to connect with you over on Instagram, ISN podcast, connect with us there, leave us a DM if you have a question or a topic you'd like for us to pursue in a future episode, and also it'd be fun to connect with you on our respective business accounts as well. So if you're all over on Instagram, you can connect with Bob over at Energy Performance, ENRG Performance, or myself, Dina at Nutrition Mechanic. Thank you so much listeners for being here and let's get to episode number 78. Hello Bob, it's time to talk about another product that we know a lot of our listeners are using. We could call it a food product, we could call it a supplement, we can call it a mysterious powder. It is kind of mysterious. It is. Protein powders is the topic du jour. Bob, have you had any protein powder today? Near and dear to my heart and daily nutrition. Now here's a thing. Have I had some today? Yes, I have actually. I was just thinking about what did I have for breakfast this morning. Yes, so I make a really mean bowl of oats and I've got so much stuff I add in there. But as we know, there's not a lot of protein, at least not the protein quantity I need in a bowl of oats, even though I'd dress it quite well with other things. So yes, I did hit some unflavored protein isolate powder today in my morning bowl of oat concoction. Awesome. I think the listeners need to, we all need to get on the same page here, talking about protein powders because there's a lot of confusion out there, the different types, what's best when you're shopping around. Are they a highly processed food and we shouldn't even have protein powders. So we wanted to bring some essentials here to the table in terms of, you know, here pun intended, the scoop behind protein powder. And then also break down animal versus plant. But Bob, we're probably going to have to split this and do a couple episodes because there's a lot of content here to go over and a lot of good stuff we want to share with our listeners. Yeah, so listeners, this is part one in our protein powder series. So today, we're going to be talking a little bit about the background, kind of the ins and outs. And then we're going to end by focusing on the animal based protein powders. And then part two, we're going to delve into plant based protein powders. So just kind of keep an eye for that for that split series here. Awesome, Bob. I feel like we have to start with a pretty basic thing. Like what is a protein powder? I mean, do you feel like everyone knows what a protein powder is? I don't actually, like even though it says in the name protein powder, I have to qualify it. When I work with athletes, when they say, oh, I had a protein shake or a protein smoothie or protein drink or whatever, I always have to qualify a couple of things in my mind first, Dina. The first thing I qualify is does it have carbohydrates, right? Because if you think and maybe people don't think like I do, but if I hear protein powder, I'm assuming it's protein only, right? So and that is my assumption because, you know, we can make wonderful smoothies with protein powders and add in some great periods and vegetables for the carbohydrate. But there are some quote-unquote air quotes protein powder that actually have a lot of carbohydrates too. So I do think it's quite confusing because listen, when you look on these shelves or online or wherever a protein powder is not just a protein powder, we really need to look at these things carefully. It's very similar to energy bars or snack bars for that matter. It's such a great point to start with, Bob. I have to reinforce it because I mean, all right, we need, you know, the companies out there have to do their marketing and sell their products. And that marketing can be tricky for the consumer because it'll say in big bold letters and snazzy fonts like protein powder. And then you, you know, get your detective hat on, turn around the fancy package and look and exactly what you just said. There's a whole bunch of other stuff in there besides protein. And then sadly, sometimes those protein powders don't even have that much protein. So there's a lot of learning and empowerment here that we want all our listeners to have. And it depends on how you use them, right? Of course, but we know, I mean, protein powders are, I mean, as we're talking about from animal sources, I mean, it's made from milk, right? I mean, we're looking at it's predominantly way right now in casing protein, but, you know, our protein powders are processed food. I would probably have to go out and say, well, yeah, there is processing because they have to take it from a milk, you know, constituent into a powder form. And through that process, at least with weight protein, through that process, you can actually reduce the lactose content. And that's one thing I did want to bring up D for our lactose intolerant or allergen athletes out there that I do want to just hit on that not right now, but somewhere through this conversation, the type, if you're going to choose a way, because here's the thing, if you're lactose intolerant, it is still possible to have weight protein, depending on your degree of intolerance or degree of allergy, if it's an allergy, I wouldn't have it, but if you're just intolerant, you can still have weight protein, but has to be a certain one. Yeah, we're going to talk about that. But I love what you just brought up the question, like, well, geez, protein powders are processed. I don't do processed foods. I think being clear, I mean, technically, yes, I agree. It is a processed food, but it's quite different than the soy cheese, for example, or like, yeah, the franken food type thing that's highly ultra processed. So with protein powders, the source is basically dried or evaporated, dried and to remove whatever other compounds, remove water, and some of these other things. And then in some filtering, and depending on the company, some other processing steps, but I mean, it's kind of like oats, right? It is harvested from the ground, and then quote-unquote processed into flakes or those edible pieces and bits. But it doesn't mean it's the same as something that's highly processed or ultra processed. So just some nuances there, and maybe just words being shifted around to say, don't worry too much about protein powders in terms of the processing. But of course, we'll talk about some of the other aspects we want to keep our eyes on. That you do want to worry about? That's not possible. Yeah, exactly, exactly. Yeah, yeah. All right, Bob, well, what about like, how do we know if we need them, or why would we use a protein powder? Yeah, that's a good question. You know, if we go back to just my example, my breakfast this morning. So here's what I put in there. I put oats. I put our unflavered way protein isolate powder. I put cinnamon, walnuts, banana, what else did I put in there? Three, I'm trying to add up all my ingredients, chia seeds, and then I did some unsweetened almond milk. So if you're thinking about that, taking the protein powder out of it, not a lot of protein in there, right? And aside, I don't know, maybe putting some tofu in there, or using how's milk or something, and that still wouldn't push me over what I need to provide more protein. Okay, kind of just flip me out, because I never thought of mixing tofu and oats. Tofu. What? Wait, I didn't. Oat too. Oat food. Oat food. That would work. Oh my gosh. Hey, and I just want to just for the record, I've never tried it, but it definitely is something that I would try. Okay, you think about it. Do you like, if you just like mash up some tofu and put it in there, and then you heat it up, like you could probably work. It's going to have a little bit of a weird texture, but oatmeal already has a weird texture. Okay, well, you keep as posted on your oat food. Any who own it, sounds like we're we're in a Disney movie or something. But no, here's the thing, like the reason I use it for that particular breakfast is because I know I need a certain amount or I want a certain amount of protein, and I don't, aside from eating eggs, and that's a completely different breakfast, that's why I use protein powder in that specific meal. So it complementing a meal or perhaps being part of a stack as well. And then we have our other athlete context here or active lifestyle. Maybe just around workouts, different kinds of training sessions, protein powders coming in pretty handy as a way to get the needed amino acids or just enhance our overall daily protein intake. So I think that's a good point because you and I focus so heavily on protein and balancing and optimizing control and blood sugar and everything. And I think you and I still find a lot of athletes consume under what they should be eating for protein. And I do think that's where possibly a protein powder. If we've exhausted the options of protein rich foods or those aren't available or whatever, I think, you know, literally mixing up some protein powder in your choice of fluid could be a great afternoon snack. And if you need extra carbohydrates, throw some fruit in there with it or some nuts or something, it's such an easy way to do it. I don't, but I want to say this. I want to be on record saying, I don't want you to discount the power of food because food will have so many more micronutrients and other nutrients in it to support our body and our brain. I view a protein powder as a snack as a great option, but more as a lower priority option, but also to make like, you know, if someone presents and says, Hey, I'm either going to skip my snack and destroy my blood sugar and possibly binge later or I'm going to have some fluid, milk, water, whatever with some protein powder. I'm going to choose the latter 100% of the time. Like, yeah, have your protein powder because it is for a specific reason. Agreed. Not meant to be replacing all of our other whole food sources or intact protein sources in our daily plan. Yep. Okay. Well, Bob, anything else behind reasons to use protein or use cases before we I'm kind of, I'm kind of going at like with my own, you know, uh, you know, perspective and how I use it. Like, and even not only with myself, but with other athletes. And I know we'll talk about this later when we talk about animal protein powders, but there are certain ones you can use before bed also. And that might also be very advantageous for preserving lean muscle mass and for some of our athletes who kind of that's one of their goals within the scope of health and/or performance. So I know we'll talk about those differences, but I do want to make sure that that conversation and you can do this through food also. There are foods with this specific protein, but I do find that protein powder sometimes comes in really handy. Now, I would be, it would be wrong for me not to say this, the cost of protein powders has risen significantly in the past few years, just like creatin. I think the pandemic did something crazy to our supply chain. And I'm going to say this because you can look at, like, because I've done this pricing and I don't know about you, but like I've got so many my college athletes asking me about protein powder that I've, I've had to research the different costs like per ounce, per gram of protein for all these different like NSF certified for sport brands. And some of them out there are really, really expensive. I'm not going to like, I would, I would go to the point saying, I don't think I would spend my money on that. If, if I'm using protein powder daily, now if it's once every few days, totally fine, like spend a little bit more money on the high quality. And I'm not saying go low quality, but I'm just saying based on how often you use protein powder, you might want to shop around a little bit to find the best and most economical. Yes, cost per serving. Yes. But then that tricky line between like you get what you're paying for sometimes but yeah, yeah, frequency of use, what your goals are. Can we use whole food instead that might be more affordable? Well, and even looking at bulk, like, you know, I had this conversation again back to my college athletes and, you know, a lot of these protein powders are sold in one or two pound canisters or bags, which is totally fine. But remember, sometimes, sometimes not all the time, if you buy in bulk, like a five or 10 pound bag, and that might seem so intimidating. And like, there's no way I'm going through this. But remember, if you're going to say, like, sometimes you could pay half the price, yeah, if you get a little bit more and trust me, you will use that. Eventually, right, the date of expiration is very, very neat on most protein powders. So just keep that in mind and looking for bulk. I mean, it was a reason I could get a little extra shelf space installed in my kitchen area because I needed for the 10 pound container. Exactly. So some house improvements just because I needed room for the tub of protein. But I love that anyways, but now I'm thinking a little bit more here on quality of protein powder, because even if we're going to narrow this down to talking more about animal protein, there's some rules that apply to all the protein powders out there that being like, what the heck is in it besides the protein source? Yeah, you want to start with this thought to your Bob? Yeah, I mean, when it really comes down to it, I mean, let's just be as, let me just use this word as naked as we can, right? As transparent as we can, you just need protein powder. That's it. Like sometimes there's some less than like some sunflower less than to kind of, you know, prevent it from sticking together, totally get that. But you don't need, unless you're going to do a flavor protein powder, right? And we'll talk about that in a second, but that's probably the basic. Like I tried to, actually, I have usually one or two different protein powders floating around on our house. And one is always an unflavered because I want that option of just having literally protein powder. So I think that's number one. Number two is the proprietary blends. If you ever see proprietary blend, I mean, honestly, I would just stay away from it because you don't know how much of what is actually in there. And that's kind of scary, right? I mean, I wouldn't, I wouldn't want to eat something or consume something that I don't know what it actually is, right? Or how much of something is going in my body. That's right. You don't know how much of each, like if there's more than one protein source, you don't know how much of each source is in there. And then, yeah, that their secret formula, I mean, it's just a little suspect. I shouldn't say suspect. It's just, but like, why can't you just share the breakdown? Well, you know, I think, I think I'm going to, I'm going to correct you, Dina. It is suspect. It really is. Like, if I'm making a protein, if it's Bob and Dina's protein powder, why would we do anything proprietary, like wouldn't we want consumers to know exactly what's in it? I mean, I want to know exactly what I put in my body. So I don't know. I would go out there on the limb and say, it's true. We should demand that. Yeah. I mean, I'm, I'm thinking the word proprietary, then confers this notion, like it's exclusive. It is made in the special secret lab. Yeah. Therefore, we also can charge you zillions more person. So anyway, is that something to keep an eye on when we're looking at those formulations? Absolutely. What do you think about artificial ingredients? Because once you start reading the ingredients, and now I'm getting away from just the not the unflavored protein powders. But so now we're into the flavored, and there's so many flavors out there. I mean, it's crazy. You know, you've got like, you know, fruity pebbles protein powder right now. But what do you think about all these ingredients and artificial ingredients? And but I mean, what do you, what do you teach? I'd like to, you know, I, okay, here's where I start is like, what are your flavor preferences? If we're going to use a protein powder, we've gotten to that point. What are your flavor needs for your palate? And can we do that with some other addition? Like is it cocoa powder or, you know, some vanilla extract or something like that for doing some basics? But in the end, if we're looking at a product to be everything with some flavor added, Bob, I, I do get a little more careful when we see things like artificial sweeteners or things that just say on the label, like artificial flavors added and they're not really delineating for us what those are. I mean, I know the research is a little bit mixed on impact of artificial sweeteners and things like sugar, alcohols on gut health and, and maybe even some effects on brain and so forth. But I think in general, I hate to use this word cleaner, but let's say the more pure the better in my, in my sequence of decision making. Yeah, I agree. You know, it's a tough line. I know for manufacturers because they're, you know, they're trying to get really product placement. And to really, I mean, it's such a competitive market as everything is, right? But that's why I get what they're trying to do, but I don't get why they're doing some of the things they do. Right. So, you know, some of them add stevia or monk fruit, and I get that. I totally get that. And some of them are putting some sugar alcohols and there are some worse sugar alcohols for your gut and GI system than others. The one thing that I really don't understand is like, like you were saying, like the artificial stuff, like the artificial colorings, the preservatives, whatever it is, I'm not, I'm just going to go out and out and say this to, I'm not a big fantasy or curiosity. I just, I don't like it. I don't like the taste number one. But I've read some research on it promoting very big issues in the microbiome. So gut health. And I don't like that. Right. And this doesn't even come down to protein powder is actually evaluating a sports drink for a college athlete the other day. [BLANK_AUDIO] She's like, hey, what do you think of this? And I'm not going to say the brand. I'm just not going to say it. But I was reading the ingredients. I'm like, oh, okay, check, check, sucralose. Why in my only thought was, why are you putting sucralose in a sport drink? Just, it already has cane sugar or whatever. You know, glucose free, just like, why are you adding sucralose? What is the purpose, right? I get it with a protein powder, because if you're going to do like a chocolate or vanilla, it does, it should have a little sweetness, right? Or I guess you're going to argue that. But again, why not just use stevia or monk fruit? I mean, it's, it's a little better, right? So I'm with you there. I mean, the less artificial stuff, the better. And, you know, I've even seen some companies going off and in their marketing, they specifically highlight no artificial ingredients, right? Which is great. It's a first step, for sure. Well, what, speaking of sweeteners and like that, that taste combination, what is your take then on the companies that put in the added sugar, whether that's cane sugar or some other whole sugar source? My take on this is, this is protein powder. You don't need too many added sugars, right? So usually they put them in for flavor, right? And I totally get that. They're going to do like cane sugar. But my rule of thumb is if you can stay under about three grams of carbohydrate or added sugars per serving and, you know, 20 to 30 grams of protein, that's usually what I try to use because I get what they're trying to do in terms of the flavor, but I just don't see the purpose of adding more. Because now in my mind, it's not really functioning as a protein powder, it's kind of functioning as that post workout gets your carbs and protein powder. And that's a whole different product. Yeah, that's right. Of the recovery shakes or powders, right? That ratio and formulations different to serve a different purpose. And that almost could be episode number three or four. Yeah, listen, if you're using protein powder as a post workout supplement, okay, if you're trying to get protein in, but if you're really trying to get carbohydrates too, I mean, just use a solid protein powder and eat a banana or something. I mean, come on. Do you really need to pay that much money for these really, you know, very expensive powders that have carbs and protein when you can just literally get a banana for 25 cents at the store, whatever, right? Good point. Yeah, speaking of the nutrient content of the whole food source, we're gonna get a lot more from the banana than just a teaspoon of table sugar or a tablespoon of table sugar that's added. Yes, yes. So what about the protein per serving? 'Cause that is kind of all over the place, isn't it? Depending on the product and the company. That's true, Bob. And so, whoever we're working with and, you know, whoever you are out there listening, that is not standardized. Essentially, I mean, if you're looking at the same kind of powder, let's say, a way isolate. Yeah, pretty much the companies will fall in the same range, like, you know, 18 to 25 grams of protein per serving, which could be, you know, whatever their scoop size is, but. Right. Whether or not that's sufficient amount for you will, again, depend on that use case. Are we using this as part of a meal or part of a post-training protein hit? So that's something else to take note of. And remember that the protein content isn't all the same, even if it is the same source. There might be a little bit of difference there. Oh my gosh, can I just go off on a quick tangent? Because you mentioned the scoop. And I have so many athletes who say, 'cause when I ask 'em, you know, I do use protein parity, how much do you put? Oh, I put a scoop. I'm like, but what does that mean? Well, you don't know. Because just like you said, it can range 18, 25, if I've seen 15 to 30. I mean, it's all over the place. So if you talk to a sport dietician listeners, make sure you tell us the grams of protein because that's what matters. 'Cause most of the time we're looking, I mean, for a snack, I don't know what, 15 to 25 grams of protein somewhere around there, right? For a meal, although I don't know why you would be using this for a meal, but it's higher for a meal or even certain populations, right? Yes. Exactly. So when do we need maybe more protein D, or who do we need more protein? I mean, we could think about our master's age athletes. So all of us, you know, over 35, 40 male female, but also for our perian postmenopause athletes. Yes. Yes. So those couple cases definitely maybe even in the situation of injury or other situations where intake is lower through food, trying to meet those needs through a protein powder could come in handy. Absolutely. Yeah. And that's where I think, yeah. Oh, I'm sorry. I was just gonna say real quick. I think those populations myself included. I think that's one reason I do utilize protein powders 'cause sometimes I know as an aging athlete, I just, I'm not willing to eat that much meat or cheese or deer or whatever it is 'cause I'm like, oh, it's just so much. And maybe I don't want all the extra whatever that comes with them. Maybe I just need to top off my protein a little bit. What, you know what I mean? And so I think we do need to consider our age, our gender and where we are if we are female on that menstrual journey. Yes, I was just thinking of something you said earlier. A protein powder should be just protein basically, but Bob, have you noticed some of the products out there that do have like vitamin, it's like a greens powder and a probiotic and then they throw in extra fiber sources and end up being like a meal replacement powder. But have you seen some of those trends too? Oh, it's so popular. Yeah. These days and you know why? You know what it stems from it? It stems from us being lazy. It really does. And I get it. Like, I'm not saying I'm not. But it's a pain in the butt sometimes to cook meals or to prepare these things. Like I get it and I think that's why a lot of companies are like, you know what? We're gonna go after these consumers who don't have a lot of time to prep or cook. They're eating out a lot and we're just gonna dump everything in here. So now not only from a marketing standpoint, we can maybe sell our product, but maybe we can actually give them more nutrients that they need. But here's the thing you just hit at D. It's not a protein powder anymore. It's a meal replacement powder. And if that's why you're using it, fantastic. But remember, it serves a different purpose. Yes. Okay. I think we're getting our schooling here. I think so. We've talked a lot about things we don't want in our protein powders. Are there some things we wanna just mention here in brief before we talk about some animal sources, things we do want to look for? Well, you've heard me say this over and over again. It doesn't matter who you are. If you're a competitive athlete, college pro leads, it doesn't matter. If you're just a recreational UNI, Dina, right? Please look for one that has a third-party testing organization stamp of approval certification. So the two I really like are NSF certified for sports or informed sport certified. It doesn't matter, 'cause I get a lot of people are like, like my recreation athletes, like, no, you know, I don't get drug tests. It doesn't matter. Well, yes, it matters 'cause these organizations are actually testing what is in it. Not only if it's legal or not for our competitive athletes, but looking at the quantities of the ingredients, making sure there are no arsenic or anything else in there. Like, it's really important. So that's first and foremost for me in looking at any protein powder. Like I will not use one that does not have one of those certifications. Agreed, Bob. And then there are a couple other websites, too, where you can cross check the quality of the product. So I mean, just if you were looking at a couple that appeared to be meeting those criteria, some independent parties or independent groups are evaluating. In addition, just with the quality and purity is, like consumer lab or lab door, those are some other reference sites that can be used. Just check in the boxes to make sure we're getting what we're paying for. Exactly. We should include those in the show notes, for sure. Sounds good. Yeah. And then I think another thing is looking, and it doesn't apply too much for the animal proteins, but definitely for the plant, which we'll talk about in episode two here or part two, is looking at the amino acid breakdown, right? It's very important to know in most animal proteins, especially when we talk about way has a very good combination and a subset of amino acids, right? 'Cause it's from an animal product, but amino acid breakdown is very, very important. And I think we unpackaged that a little bit more when we talk about plant blends. Sounds good, Bob. Wow, okay, you mentioned milk earlier. So when we're talking about sources of protein powder and here towards the end of this episode, wanting to focus on animal derived sources. Mm-hmm. Milk protein is a primary source. Do you wanna break it down a little bit for us, Bob? Yeah, it's definitely probably, when you think protein powder, I think almost everybody, unless you're a vegan and you have been for quite a while, almost everybody is automatically thinking way protein, right? Because it's the most popular. Like it is literally, I don't know what kind of market share it has, but it has probably the highest market share, right? 'Cause it's familiar, it's been a very long time. around for a while comes from cows, right? So way protein is one of the constituents of milk as is casing, which we'll talk about here in a second. But when it comes to milk protein, and there's like milk protein isolates, but when we look at that, we kind of need to define which animal is it coming from because I have seen a rise in popularity in goat protein powder. Have you seen this? - I have too, yes. - Okay, and I haven't tried it to be honest with you, I do not know what it tastes like. So I cannot speak to that, but all I can say is a lot of individuals, I believe are navigating a little bit more towards the goat protein. And here's the thing that, 'cause I actually had to look this up, 'cause I don't know too much about it, but goat protein powder has less lactose. So for our lactose intolerant or allergic athletes, it also has some prebiotics, 'cause it has oligosaccharides in it. So those prebiotics help feed those wonderful probiotics in our tum-tum. And I think it's what people are saying is it's better for our lactose intolerant athletes although I'm gonna disagree with that in one second, but that's probably the extent of what I know about goat protein powder. - I was just gonna add, I think I've seen some sheep protein powder as well. And yeah, I think ultimately digestibility for the milk proteins and yeah, the lactose content it would be the reason to consider one of the non-cow dairies as far as a protein powder. - Well, and I think, so let's talk, let's unpackage that really quick, right? If we look at that way protein powder, like way protein powder isn't just way protein powder, there's actually three different more popular classifications of it. So there is what is called way protein concentrate. And that actually has more lactose in it. There's way protein isolates, which is probably the most popular one. That has less lactose. And this is just due to the processing and how they do this. And then there's a way hydrodrocelate, which has, I mean, even less lactose than an isolate, right? Because of the ultra-processing. So I often find that lactose intolerant athletes can still tolerate a little bit of the isolate. They can definitely tolerate a lot more of the hydrodrocelate, but the concentrate, here's the thing, you're gonna pay less for the concentrate, 'cause usually it's a little bit less way protein also, but it's a little bit tougher when you have lactose intolerance. So what did I say is you also, I have athletes doing this all the time, they'll go on Amazon or whatever, and they're like, oh, this one's cheap. I'm like, look at the type of way protein first, 'cause it's probably a concentrate, 'cause it is a lot cheaper, 'cause there are less steps than making it. - Good points, Bob. - Yeah, so our lactose intolerant don't discount your way powder yet, but we definitely have to get to that isolate form. And like you're saying, Bob, depending on severity of allergy or that level of intolerance, these way isolates can potentially work just fine. - Absolutely, and I think we also need to mention that way is very what we call fast acting or fast absorbing, right, because a lot of athletes will use way after a workout or before a workout, because it assimilates and metabolizes very quickly as opposed to if it's cousin casing, right? And casing is still part of that milk product, so it kind of comes from the dairy, but or from the cow or the goat for that sense. Although, D, is there goat casing powder? - I have not searched for that or had a need for that. - So listeners, if you take goat casing powder, can you just email us? Hello at InsideSports Nutrition.com. We just love to just learn about that, right? 'Cause I just, that was just off on a tangent. I'm like, I don't think I've ever heard of that before. But anyway, so casing is a slower absorbing milk protein powder, right? A lot of athletes will use that. That's what I refer to earlier like right before bed, because there has been some studies on casing protein, how would you say, kind of slowing the muscle degradation process during sleep, so it preserves lean mass a little bit better during sleep. And I have a lot of my, a lot of my weight gainers using casing protein, but I also have some athletes using throughout the day, just because it does, it has a longer curve, if you will, right? So it's not that initial up and down. So I don't know, have you had good luck with casing protein? - Yeah, I have. I mean, it's not something that I've recommended too often, but certainly for those high performing athletes who do have higher energy needs and they struggle with getting in protein in the evening hours, like with afternoon workouts and so forth, just doing a little top off with casing in the evening, has been beneficial. I think the flavor, you know, that it's a little different texture and flavor than the ways you have to get a little creative. - And it's more expensive, most of the time also. - Yeah, for sure. - Well, what about egg protein powder? Some of our athletes are like, her listeners are like, what? - It's egg protein powder. I know, that's another one that's out there. I don't think it's used as commonly, but essentially it's the egg whites, not the whole egg, typically in a powder form. I mean, I think again, in my athletes, Bob, it's not as common, but for those who do have a milk allergy across the board, egg protein is highly bioavailable. It's a very high quality amino acid profile, so it certainly can be included if we're not getting in enough protein from whole food sources like whole eggs. - I agree. I mean, you are missing some of the great nutrients that you find in whole eggs, but I get using egg protein powder for sure. I don't know how it tastes. Have you ever tried it? - It's been a while. I honestly cannot remember if it was egg-y. - Right, 'cause some of this actually does come down to the taste unless you're gonna put it in a everything smoothie where you're trying to hide the taste, right? - Yeah, exactly. - And I think part of that discussion, also we can factor in beef protein powder, because that is a thing. And again, some of our listeners were like, "What's beef protein powder?" But again, to your point, with our listeners who do have these severe milk or dairy allergies, yeah, I mean, there are some opportunities to still use protein powders that are not dairy-based, right? So egg protein powder, beef protein powder, for sure, can fit throughout. - Yes. Bob, there's another one that's coming on to the scene, "Hot" for its sustainability purpose. - Oh, I know what you're gonna say. - You know, and are you ready? - I am ready. - Cricket, protein. - Cricket, yes. - Cricket protein powder. - Have you dabbled in it? - Well, here's a funny story. Years and years and years ago, when I had brick and mortar for energy performance and we had our strength training classes, had a group of individuals participating in those a couple of times a week. And one of the participants was a fellow dietician. And it wasn't you, right? - Yeah. - Let's just say. But one of them was a dietician. And one, we were talking about this. This was, I mean, honestly, it is probably six, seven years ago. And she's like, "Crickets, crickets, "cricket protein powder, cricket flour." I'm like, "What are you talking about?" She's like, "No, that's the latest thing." I'm like, and then the next class, she comes in, I'm not kidding you with a bag of crickets. And they weren't alive, they weren't alive, right? Like the whole, like the cricket, the actual cricket. They were dried or whatever you call it, right? She's like, "No, the protein is amazing." And they make protein powder. That was my introduction to cricket, right? So of course, I had to try it. And I tried a couple, I'm like, "You know what?" They're crunchy, they're not bad. And they maybe they need a little seasoning on them. But I get, and then I start researching it a little bit, not a lot. But I totally get the protein, or the sustainability aspect of that, absolutely. Now, full disclosure, I have not looked at the amino acid content comparatively to a, 'cause I don't think crickets are animals, they're insect. So, where does that fall into the hole? But have you looked at the profile before? - I haven't, Bob, so that'll be, that'll be a good assignment here. Like head to head with the same content, like by weight, you know, 100 grams or whatever, up way isolate versus your cricket, 14. And how many crickets does it take to get 100 grams or 30 grams of protein? - A lot of crickets, yeah. - Oh. - I know, I know cricket protein power has more fat, for sure, it has more fiber, right? 'Cause those are the things that are, fat is stripped from the way protein, processing. - That's a lot. - So I know off the top of my head, it is a lot of crickets, right? And they're teeny, they're not like the big old, you know, cricket grasshoppers that we think of, they're really small. So it's not, if you're gonna eat a cricket, but like it's not that intimidating. But so you should try one, that they're not bad. - I haven't had the whole crick, I have had a couple of those bars that have cricket powder in it. - Oh, yeah. - So, I just barely can't taste anything. - Baby stepping my way to get the powder. But there's a couple other powders out there, Bob, that are confusing for people. So I'm thinking of collagen and bone broth, or, you know, those broth powders that are labeled protein powder. - Well, in collagen, and I wish they wouldn't do that. I mean, I get it, it's not wrong, but I just wish they wouldn't, 'cause collagen, super, super popular these days, and we're definitely not gonna. Pupu that by any means because there are some specific purposes and instances to use collagen. But collagen powder, as I recall, is missing a certain amino acid. And I'm, please correct me if I'm wrong, I believe it's methionine. If I am correct, I'm not exactly sure. But my point is it's missing a certain amino acid. So you can't really use collagen as a true protein powder because it is missing one of the amino acids. So that's my beef with that. Like use collagen for what you're trying to use it for skin, tendons, you know, not joints. Yeah, ligaments, right, if you're trying to do that. But don't use collagen for your protein powder because it's missing an amino acid. Yes, the quality of that for muscle building or maintenance, the collagen powder doesn't quite make the mark there. So we want to use that for the other purposes that you mentioned. And I think similar, yeah, I think similar to the broad bone broths is, it's just, again, persevering. You're not getting the quality or the enough of those essential amino acids for the muscle purpose, like the muscle protein synthesis purpose. Exactly. So I did, I must correct myself because I just looked it up briefly. It is not methionine, it is missing tryptophan. Tryptophan. Okay. Listeners, yeah, just, just stand, you know, for worn that use, use collagen for what it's, what it's there for, but not as a, as a protein powder specifically. Okay. And same broth. I mean, bone broth is fantastic. I mean, it really is, right? I mean, you can cook, I mean, the powder, you can make a broth, thought of you, you can do all these great things with it, but maybe not as an air cool protein powder. Right. Yeah. Not providing exactly the same, same profile. Exactly. Cool, I kind of want to hear from our listeners what they're using from, you know, if they're using protein powders, the purpose and what they're go to is, you know, so if you feel like dropping us a note over at [email protected], any of your protein powder questions and what you're using would be cool to hear. Absolutely. Especially when it comes to animal because there aren't, I feel like there aren't as many sources as there are plant sources, which we'll get into in our part two, right? Because those are all over the place. But I feel like animal, there's like a handful of them, right? So yeah, listeners, you know, let us know what you're taking. Maybe even why? I would be really, like I always wonder about the why behind things, like I shared with you why I put it in my oats, right? But some mornings, you know, I mean, some days I don't even use a protein powder diet. All depends on what I'm doing with my food. Like if I have, you know, one breakfast I rotate through our eggs, I'm like, well, I don't need any protein powder. And my, you know, maybe my snacks are okay, maybe my lunch is okay in terms of having enough protein. And I don't feel like I need protein powder. And I think, I think just as a last, you know, kind of a last push here is making sure that we're not overdependent on these powders. But we use them how we feel they should be used in our daily lives. Like how do we need them personally? Just because like your friend uses it after a workout doesn't mean you need to use it. Like you need to look at why you're using it. What purpose does it serve? Are you aging? Are you parry postmanopausal? Like all these different things, it shouldn't be used as a band aid, right? It shouldn't just be like, oh, you know what? I'm just going to miss lunch and you know, traditionally miss lunch and I'm just going to have a protein shake or whatever. I couldn't agree more, um, love it. That's it. All right. That's it. That's it. That's it. And with that listeners. Oh, wait. And one other thing that I think we might have to do in another episode is this question about amino acid supplements. So like the essential amino's, the branch chains, those come in powder forms aren't they the same thing. So we'll, we'll table that Bob for a, so what you're saying is a, that this is going to be a three part series. Yes. Okay. So that will be part three. So part two coming up will be plant based protein powder is part three will be all these other amino acid branching amino acid powder. So we can kind of really get into the thick of what is going on here. Sounds good. E hot. All right. Woo. That was a great episode. listeners. We so appreciate you sticking with us. We know is a lot of information. What some great notes and things in the show notes. Please head on over to our website inside sports nutrition.com, contact us. Let us know if you have any questions or feedback. And we just appreciate you listening every single week to, you know, our banter sometimes. Thank you listeners. All right. With that, we will leave you and we will see you or hear you on the next episode. We hope you enjoyed this episode part one of protein powders. Stay tuned for next week. We've got a part two coming up looking into plant protein powders, considerations and things to know when shopping around or using a plant-based protein powder. We would love your support in promoting this podcast. Be sure you are following or subscribing over on your pod platform of choice to get the weekly episodes. And also, if you have a minute to leave a rating or review a five star rating, would be groovy. And favorable review, it does help us grow and share the content with other listeners like you around the world. You can learn more about our services and our respective businesses, follow Bob or head over to his website, energyperformance.com, ENRG, performance.com, to learn more about coaching, testing and so on. And likewise, myself, Dina, over at nutritionmechanic.com. The views and opinions expressed on this podcast are solely those of the hosts and the guests involved and do not represent a replacement for medical consultation with your doctor. The information and opinions provided here are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease or medical condition. This podcast is for information, education and entertainment purposes only.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Protein powders are often misunderstood as simple protein sources, but many contain added sugars, carbohydrates, artificial ingredients, and other additives that blur their identity as pure protein supplements.
  2. The term "protein powder" does not necessarily mean the product is free of processing; however, processing is similar to food items like oats and does not equate to ultra-processed or unhealthy food.
  3. Key concerns include hidden ingredients such as artificial sweeteners, flavorings, and proprietary blends, with the highest priority being transparency in labeling and ingredient breakdown.
  4. Protein powders should be used strategically—not as a replacement for whole foods, but as a supplement to meet protein needs, especially in meals, post-workout recovery, or for individuals with dietary restrictions.
  5. Third-party certifications like NSF Certified for Sport or Informed Sport ensure product purity and safety, while independent labs like Consumer Lab offer verification of ingredient quality.
  6. Animal-based sources include whey, casein, egg, beef, and goat protein, each with different lactose content, digestibility, and amino acid profiles—making them suitable for specific needs like lactose intolerance or muscle preservation.
  7. Plant-based and alternative proteins like cricket powder are emerging, but often lack essential amino acids or full protein quality, and should not be used as primary protein sources.
  8. Collagen and bone broth powders are not true protein powders due to missing essential amino acids and should be used for joint or skin health, not muscle synthesis.

Summary:

Protein powders are a common supplement in daily nutrition, but their use and ingredients are often misunderstood. The podcast emphasizes that protein powder is not just a processed food—it's a tool that should be used strategically, not as a replacement for whole foods. Many products contain added sugars, artificial ingredients, or hidden components like proprietary blends, making transparency and ingredient disclosure critical.

The hosts stress the importance of third-party certifications (NSF, Informed Sport) to ensure purity and safety. They break down animal-based sources like whey, casein, egg, and goat protein, noting differences in lactose content, digestibility, and suitability for lactose-intolerant individuals. While some alternative proteins like cricket powder are gaining interest for sustainability, they often lack essential amino acids and are not ideal for muscle-building.

The hosts caution against using collagen or bone broth powders as primary protein sources due to incomplete amino acid profiles. Ultimately, protein powders should be used based on individual needs—such as age, activity level, or dietary restrictions—and not as a default solution. The discussion sets up a two-part series: part two will cover plant-based proteins, and part three will explore essential amino acid supplements, offering a comprehensive view of protein sources in sports and daily nutrition.

FAQs

A protein powder is a supplement containing protein, but it often includes other ingredients like carbohydrates, sweeteners, or additives. Look for products with clear ingredient lists, minimal processing, and high protein content per serving.

Yes, protein powders are processed, but not ultra-processed. The processing involves drying and filtering, similar to how oats are made. This doesn't mean they're unhealthy—focus instead on ingredients and overall nutritional quality.

People use protein powder to meet daily protein needs, especially when meals lack sufficient protein, after workouts, or as a convenient snack. It’s helpful for those with dietary restrictions or aging, but shouldn’t replace whole foods.

Avoid products with artificial flavors, colors, or sweeteners like sucralose. Also steer clear of proprietary blends where ingredients aren’t disclosed, as you won’t know what’s actually in the product.

Yes, many protein powders—especially whey isolate or hydrolyzed forms—have reduced lactose. Goat or sheep protein powders may also be better options due to lower lactose content and added prebiotics.

Look for third-party certifications like NSF Certified for Sport or Informed Sport, which ensure product safety, purity, and absence of banned substances or contaminants.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.