Go back

Prohibiting What? Censorship and the Catholic Church in the Scientific Revolution - Dr. Nuno Castel-Branco

from The Thomistic Institute

49m 5s

Prohibiting What? Censorship and the Catholic Church in the Scientific Revolution  - Dr. Nuno Castel-Branco

The transcript highlights the intersection of theology, science, and historical censorship in early modern Europe. It begins by promoting graduate theology programs at the Dominican House of Studies, offering students a holistic education rooted in prayer and scholarship, supported by competitive scholarships. It then shifts to a historical analysis of scientific developments, focusing on the influence of Nicolaus Steno and Charles Darwin, who were shaped by geological theories that challenged literal interpretations of Scripture. Steno’s groundbreaking work in stratigraphy—developed in 1667 despite Catholic institutional oversight—was published with Inquisition permissions, suggesting a porous censorship system. The narrative emphasizes that early modern censorship was largely theological, targeting heresy and non-traditional doctrine, not scientific inquiry. Cases like Galileo and Descartes reveal that scientific ideas persisted despite official disapproval, as books were often corrected rather than banned and remained widely circulated. Historical evidence shows that censorship was ineffective and inconsistent, with many works continuing to circulate and influence thought. The discussion concludes that the popular myth of the Church suppressing science is inaccurate and requires deeper historical scrutiny, urging historians and readers to examine primary sources critically. This reframing underscores the importance of rigorous scholarship in understanding the history of science and religion.

Transcription

9118 Words, 50861 Characters

English
grow in your knowledge of God through graduate studies in domestic theology at the pontifical faculty of the Immaculate Conception at the Dominican House of Studies. These graduate programs provide a unique opportunity to learn in a Dominican House of Formation, allowing students to integrate prayer and study. Pursue a master of arts in theology, a master of divinity, a PhD in theology, or an ecclesiastical degree through the Domestic Institutes Competitive full-ride scholarship program with an annual living stipend. To learn more and to apply for this scholarship, visit DomesticInstitute.org/scholarships. The deadline to apply is January 8, 2027. [MUSIC PLAYING] Welcome to the Domestic Institute podcast. Our mission is to promote the Catholic intellectual tradition in the university, the church, and the wider public square. The lectures on this podcast are organized by university students at Domestic Institute chapters around the world. To learn more and to attend these events, visit us at DomesticInstitute.org. So let me start by going not to the times of the scientific revolution, which is a 16th and 17th century, but to the 19th century, to 1830s. When these men-- who is he, you know? It's not Mendo. Darwin-- this is Charles Darwin. And in the 1830s, he's not that old. He's a young guy who's invited to go on board the Beagle. He's a major trip around the world where he will make very, very important discoveries and observations, especially about variation of species, that will lay the groundwork for the theory of evolution. A theory that did not emerge without controversy, right? From the very beginning of Darwin's first publications on the origin of species, scientists and Christians raised many problems with a theory of evolution, problems which still remain today in many circles. It is still controversial for many people. Now, there was another thing that was very important in that trip, that sailing trip around the world that Darwin did, which is that when he arrived on board the captain of the ship gave him a book to read that had just come out of the press. And that book was this one. Charles Lyle's Principles of Geology, which is a very, very important work in the history of geology, especially 19th century geology. And this was important for Darwin because Lyle says that the Earth, as we see it, the mountains, the valleys, the rivers, emerged due to very small changes but happening throughout millions of years, right? So this is a theory called uniformitarianism. It was known as uniformitarianism. And it challenged another view called catastrophism, which explained that everything that you see today on the Earth is the result of big catastrophes. Things like Noah's Flood. There's Noah's Flood and we have geological evidence of that. Lyle would say, look, we don't see floods like that and we haven't seen any like that in the entire world. So these things probably didn't happen. And so the world, as you see today, is a result of things that we see, but acting through millions of years. And so that was hugely influential for Darwin, but you can also see how that raises some problems with Christianity and especially with literal readings of the Bible. Now in the very first pages of this book which Darwin read, "All the Volumes on Board the Bigel," Lyle mentions the name of Nikolaus Steno, the main character, the main hero of my book, "The Traveling Anatomist," and he says that Steno's work, he's a 17th century Danish, was the most remarkable work of that period. It was published by Steno a Dane from Denmark, once Professor of Anatomy at Padua and who afterwards resided many years at the court of the Grand Duke of Tuscany in Florence. Now it happens that Steno was also became a Catholic priest and bishop and not just that, he actually became a saint. He was beatified by John Paul II in 1988. So one of the heroes of the beginning of Lyle's book is this Catholic saint in a way. And for sure that Darwin read about that because he writes more about Steno in the book, not just this. And Darwin read Lyle's book very carefully. In fact, he would say to his friends that he always felt as if my books came out of Lyle's brain. And in fact, Janet Brown, who is an emeritus professor of the history of science at Harvard and really the leading biographer of Darwin says that without Lyle, there would be no Darwin. And in a way, we could say that without Steno, there would be no Lyle. But there needs to be more work to really study the influence of Steno in Lyle's work. But we do know that Steno's work was groundbreaking in his time. And so let's go back to his period, the period of the scientific revolution, as more or less the time of Newton, in which Steno discovered that stones found on drylands were actually teeth of shark. They were fossils. And not only that, he actually explained how parts of sea animals ended up in dry mountains and tubs. And he does that by arguing that the earth has a long history and that that history can be known through a series of principles, you can see his diagrams known today and taught today as Steno's laws of stratigraphy. And the principle of superposition of the strata, the principle of original rezontality, things that we learned today in basic high school geology, these were invented by Steno. And because of that, he is known in certain circles as the founder of modern geology, the late Stephen G. Goldett Harvard, used to call him that. Now, what is remarkable, and that's why I'm bringing this story to this talk about censorship, is that Steno publishes these ideas for the first time in human history, one could say, in Florence, in 1667. And this is, you know, 30 years after Galileo was condemned by the Roman Inquisition for defending the scientific theory, namely that the sun is at the center of the universe and not the earth. It's a time and period in which the Catholic church rules the lens with the Inquisition and censorship, right? And yet this book is published, apparently with no problem at all, talking about that the earth has a history, namely that the book of Genesis shouldn't be read in a literal way. And so on, not just that, you can see in the very bottom that it comes with the permission of the superiors. And in fact, if you flip, and you go to the final page of the book, there's actually a long list of authorizations that the book had. You can see, for example, you know, this guy called Augustinos, called Elinos, who is a consultant of the sacrum of fichum, which is the Holy Office, which is the Inquisition. And he's also a liberal censor, which is the censor of books. And he says that the book is preludinium, you know, it's worthy of being printed. And then in the very bottom, it says stanta, et cetera, that is having set all these imprimators. So let it be printed. In fact, many Catholic books today, if you go to the first page, still say that. So you'll say, "Nihilovsat, nothing to object." And then it says imprimator, "Let it be printed." My book doesn't say that, so be careful. But now, how is it possible that these groundbreaking and in a way revolutionary theory about the history of the earth was published and was accepted by the Inquisition at the time? Well, historians have actually tried to explain this because it seems to them a problem. And one of the reasons I said is that, well, you have to read Steno carefully what he's saying. And Steno, in fact, caveats many things that he says in this way. He says that he doesn't want to argue that defenders of contrary views are wrong. And he's also very careful in saying that he's opinion. He's only similar to truth. And so, you know, I could be wrong and so on. And so those who have written about Steno and his work have said, look, see, he's trying to avoid the censorship of the Catholic Church. So he writes in very careful terms. He is, in a way, censoring himself. Now, did Steno really censor himself? This is a question that I had to grapple at as I was doing research for this book because that's what people were saying. And I think it could be that he was self-sensoring. But there's other things that need to be explained if he was doing that. For example, Steno's letters don't suggest that. There are many other people in the 17th century who were self-sensoring themselves. But, you know, you know, from that letters that they actually believe things that they wrote. The best example is Isaac Newton. I mean, Isaac Newton was in the eyes of the Church of England, a heretic. He was an Aryan. He didn't believe in the Holy Trinity. But no one knew that. We know these today because we have access to these manuscripts to his private letters. Because if people knew that, he couldn't have his professorship of Cambridge. So there's many examples of people who did self-sensorship, right? There's no evidence that Steno did that through his notebooks and through his letters. Not just that, claims about the history of the Earth that actually not raise any censorship problems in the 17th century. So historians who are saying that Steno did self-sensorship, they are assuming, oh yeah, you cannot talk about the Earth, you know, having a long history and so on, because that's a problem for the Inquisition. But there's no evidence of that, right? Now, these questions and these historical problems that I'm presenting to you are, of course, super relevant because they talk about the larger issue of censorship in early modern Europe, which relates, of course, to a very famous and simple story that maybe we grew up with, which is that of the church governing all of Europe When you're posing, it's religious. is dogma during the so-called arcages. And then there comes the scientists, the heroes with lights and experiments and mathematics, and they face these forces. And sometimes they die in the battlefield. There's marches. Galileo is our martyr in front of the Inquisition. But in the end, they succeed in science, winds, and religion dies down. Now, of course, this simple story is very neat, but it doesn't actually match the historical evidence. And there's tens of books written about these. Hopefully, mine will add to that if I know my book is about other things in the history of science as well, not just science and religion. But this is an idea that remains very popular. I don't know if you know, but in November, there will be a new musical on Broadway called Galileo. And one can imagine what will be. The New York Times had this news piece saying, what rhymes with heretic? That's what he was asking. In fact, I used to give an entire course when I was a T.A. Johns Hopkins. I had an entire course just on the Galileo affair. And it was called was Galileo a heretic? And the answer is that-- no, he was not. But anyway, these narratives still proliferate in popular culture, and one of the reasons is that while they think that the church was against science, also with censorship. So what I would like to do in this talk is to say two things. First is that, yes, there was censorship, but it was mostly about theology. It was not about science. And even when it touched science, because the case of Galileo is a case about science, even though it's much more complex. And again, I give an entire course about that. And I'll mention a little bit that in my talk. But even when censorship was applied, both to theology and to science, it was a highly porous system. It's not that it actually forbade the ideas and they could not circulate freely. So what I'll do for the rest of the talk is basically give you the basics of censorship, how it happens, how the church use that in early modern Europe. And then we'll look at two different cases. One is the Galileo case, and the other one is the Descartes case, which will be very interesting. And then we'll come back to Steno and draw some conclusions about our present times. So censorship 101-- what does it mean to censor a book and to censor information? Basically, it means to block the circulation of information so that things that we think are in error do not reach the broader public. Now, this has happened always since humans have existed. Even before writing, you can say someone to shut up. Don't say that because this is censorship. It still happens today. We don't burn books anymore, but we do block social media accounts, like people are fired for things that they say across the political spectrum. But one of the most common ways was the burning of books. The Romans did it. The Christians did it. The Nazis did it. We don't do it anymore. At least I don't know about you guys. But one of the reasons Christians did it is because it's in the acts of the apostles. There was these people who were sorcerers and involved with magic, and then they convert to Christianity. And the first thing that they do to show that conversion is to burn their writings in public. Now, in the early modern period, the burning of books happens. So the popes burned the books of Martin Luther and John Colony and so on. But Martin Luther also burned the papal bulls and other Catholic scholarship. Even scientists burned books. So the most famous one is a man called Paracelso. It was a very important scientist from the 16th century who used to do public burnings of Galen's works, because this is the old science of the Aristotle, Galen, Hypocrisy, and so on. We need to move on to the new science. So this was done everywhere by all kinds of people, not just the Catholic church, but yes, the Catholic church also did it in public. Now, the problem with burning books is that it's very inefficient. It's not going to spread. You're burning this copy of the book, but what about all the other ones around? Who knows how many books are in the fire, these kinds of things? So the burning of books was a public spectacle, but it was an efficient way of censoring books. And in fact, in this time, meaning the 16th, 17th century, the Renaissance, early modern periods, there was something that was revolutionizing Europe and did revolutionize the history of humanity, which was the invention of the printing press. So there's many books now proliferating all around Europe and around the world as the oceanic expansion takes on. And so all political forces, including the Catholic church, they have to figure out a way to control the books that are proliferating, that are so-called bad books. They're advocating bad ideas, wrong ideas. Now, most of what the Catholic church did about these questions was defined in the Council of Trends, which is the main official response that the Catholic church found to the Protestant Reformation. And one of the things that it did, perhaps, the most important thing was to create a list of books that are forbidden. And the first papal list, the first list issued by the Pope, was from 1557. It's called the Pauline Index, because it's made by Pope Paul the fourth. Now, there were already other indexes before this one, made in Venice, one in Spain, and so on. But this is the very first that the papacy produces. But yet, there's only one copy. And we know that it was not working very well. We don't know why. So a year later, December 1558, they produced another one, which is known as the Pauline Index. Now, this index, which will evolve significantly, because as the years pass by, the church will continue to produce other indexes, more updated, because there's new books being published, and so on. And one thing that you'll see is that sometimes books are removed from the index. So we thought this was a bad book, but apparently not. So let's take it out in a new edition. But the very first edition, it's very interesting, meaning the 58 edition, is very important, because it already tells us a lot about how the church is thinking about the censorship of ideas. Even the title, it says, "Index, Octorum, et Li-Brom." So it's an index of authors and books. So it's not just books. It's authors is really the main thing, right? And so what this book is forbidding is really three categories of authors, right? You have people who are official heretics. So people like Martin Luther, John Calvin, and so on. And everything that Luther wrote is there. So they don't even list Luther's books. They just say, Martin Luther, everything he wrote. You cannot read. It's forbidden. But it also includes Catholics who are writing things that are wrong in theology, right? People, for instance, like Jordan Abruno, who was Dominican friar. But you cannot read Jordan Abruno, because he's denying the Trinity and many other things. So it goes against theology, orthodox theology. And then you also have anonymous works circulating around. But you also have, by anonymous, it also includes long lists of books. Let me show you an example. So this is the 59, 58, 59, the original Pauline index. You have M, right? And it says, "Octores, Quorum, Libri, "at Scripta, Omnia, Proviabemte." So the authors whose books and all their writings are forbidden, right? And you have there, Martinez Luther, Martin Luther, right? But this is interesting because it shows us the end of letter L, right? And there you also have, underlined, "Libri, Omnis." So all books and writings of Quorum Mancy, Geomancy, down there you have Astrology Divination. So magical stuff. Things that went against things that look like demonic or go against free will, like judicial astrology, all of that is forbidden. You cannot read. Now, this is very interesting, because there's no science at all in this list, right? This is mostly theology, heresy, and things, like divination. You know, magic and crazy stuff. And in fact, there has been a lot of research on censorship and the history of censorship and the Catholic Church. And the canonical book now was produced in 2009, 2010. And it's a very long series of volumes called "Catholic Church and Modern Science," which has basically almost every single document in the Inquisition Archives that touch scientific matters, right? And the conclusion, they mentioned in the introduction of this book of the authors, Hugo Baldini and Lisprit, is that censorship regarded in the first place religious, archaeological etero-doxy. And only in an indirect way forms of dissents that developed in other disciplinary fields. And as you know, it will touch science. Galileo will come up. And I think one of the best books, monographs about this topic, is "For Be the Knowledge by Hannah Marcus," his professor of history of science at Harvard, where she says that many of the physicians prohibited on the Pauline index for bent for reasons that had little to do with the content of their work. Now, what this means is that there were physicians listed in the-- it's not just heretics like Martin Luther. You also had people like Conrad Gessner, a great physician from Germany, or Leonardo Fuchs and others. So people who are just Protestants, but doing science, but hey, reading a book about botany or about medicine, you're a Protestant. Catholics cannot read it. Now, this is awful because if this would go in place, that means that there's an immense amount of literature that people cannot read in early modern Catholic Europe. So these would go in favor-- oh, yeah, there you go. The church is interested in theology, but because of that, it is for beating science. Now, thank God the physicians and the intellectuals who need to be replied back just months after the index, the Pauline index was published. And they asked Rome to figure out the problem. Because look, we need to read these books. These books are great, mostly medical books. And in fact, Hannah Marcus says that the narratives that these physicians were using and asking Rome to help them read these books. was very important to the development of what she calls the category of useful science, which is an important topic in the scientific revolution that science became applied in very useful Francis Bacon, the New Atlantis, and so on. She says that physicians arguing with inquisitors in Rome also developed that narrative in the Catholic world in a completely independent way from Bacon because look, these books are useful for us. We need them, right? So you have to let us read. And so Rome found two main ways to solve this problem very quickly. One of them was to provide reading licenses. So, OK, if you want to read these authors, you just ask Rome or the local bishop and we'll give you the license. These license would be two year long, three year long, and could be renewed. And they were often granted. There's very few cases in which they were not granted. They were also permanent license. So I want to read this book all for the rest of my life, right? Those were given, but not as often. And then there's another thing that the inquisition develops, which is that, OK, some books are actually quite good, but have some parts that are not good. So why don't we correct these books with censors some parts and then anyone can read them, right? So what happens is that further editions, this is the second edition of the index. It's actually the one printed in Portugal, but it's from Rome. These indexes now have a list of books that you can read if they are corrected. So this means that a bookseller. You can only sell this book if your copy is corrected. Otherwise, you can sell it, but it's in the black market, not for the normal people. Now, this generated a lot of work because now we have to read all these books and you have to correct it, you know, who's going to do this, right? So the Rome creates what is called the congregation of the index to do this. So it's not just now the inquisition, but now there's this other institution that's doing that. Another thing that also happens that will be very important for the stories that I'll tell you now is that there's also, and as you saw, the Steno book was filled with the book about the history of the earth, filled with permissions, right? So another thing that Rome also did, okay, why don't we also control the books that can be printed and give permission that already helps us, you know, filter out the bad stuff, right? So that is also ruled by Rome. Now, let's see how this plays out in practice with our good friends, Galileo, right? So I don't have, as I said, I teach an entire course on Galileo, so I won't go into all the details that I would like to explain everything that happened. I'm happy to, you know, answer them in the Q and A. But basically, in 1610, Galileo makes very important observations, that completely changed his life and the history of science forever, that the moon has mountains, that Jupiter has moons, that there's way more stars in the sky, that Venus has phases, that Saturn has rings, you know, it's huge, huge contribution to the history of science. And because of that, he becomes convinced that the Copernican model is a true model. So what happens to him, actually nothing, nothing happens to him, it's published in 1610, but some of his scientific adversaries start to hate this and try to attack him under scientific terms, but unable to do that, they accuse him before the inquisition saying that this guy is a heretic, because the Bible says that the sun is moving around the earth and he says that the sun is still. And so the inquisition needs to study now, all of these things. And because Galileo is already a prominent figure, we have to, you know, we have to study it. Now the good thing is that in the congregation of the index, there was this good cardinal called Cardinal Robert Bellarmine, who Indian became a saint. And he tried to, and he was, you know, great intellectual, and he was very much aware of everything that Galileo was writing. And so he, with the Pope, Pope Paul the fifth, reached the conclusion in 1616. So we'll tell Galileo to be, you know, more calm. You know, don't go out there boasting that you have discovered the proof of the Copernican model, because you actually haven't, you didn't have a proof. Because he said we would need to reinterpret the scriptures, and until we have a proof, there's no way we're gonna do it. Just go back home, be calmer. And whenever you talk about the Copernican model, say just a hypothesis, it's not the real model. Galileo was very happy. But the congregation of the index, this is in 1616, also makes a decision, which is let's look at all the books that talk about Copernicanism. And let's censor some of them. And it's, I'll show you three books that they read. One of them is this one by Paolo Foscarini, who was a Carmelite Friar, who was a Copernican, and wrote this book, which is a completely reinterpretation of the Bible in Copernican terms. So it's really an exegetical book. It's a theological book, right? It's not really a science book. This book is forbidden by the index. You cannot read it anymore. They also decide to study Copernican's book. The original book on the revolution of the celestial orps that defends the Copernican model, that by the way was published almost a hundred years before this happens. And no one had, no one thought it was problematic, okay? But now they have to study it, let's see. And they decide, okay, people can read Copernican's when it is corrected, okay? It needs to be corrected so that you can read, we'll see what corrections. They also studied Galileo's history and demonstrations around the Macchia Salari, which is Sunspots. Galileo writes this book on Sunspots, where he's outright Copernican, says that, you know, the Sun is moving and has spots, and he uses Sunspots to prove that. I can explain why if you want. And so it's a very Copernican book. This book, which they read because it's Galileo's works, right? The Inquisition is reading. It is not forbidden at all. Whoever wants to read it can read it. And the reason is because the book has nothing about the Bible, or theology. It's just an astronomy book. And in fact, we actually know there's lots of papers about how this book was written. And we know that Galileo had some biblical insights in that book that the Inquisition asked, "Look, if you want to publish this with permission, you cannot have that." And so you actually move that. So there's no problem. People can read this Copernican book. No problem. So let's look at Copernicus. How did they correct Copernicus? Because this is the censorship machine in action, right? So how did the Inquisition censor Copernicus in early modern Europe? This is a major topic, it's science and religion. So they asked a man called Francesco Ingoly, who was a theologian, but who had debated Galileo many times in Ingoly. This guy thought that the Earth was at the center of the universe, but he was also very smart. And in fact, he wrote a long essay that, you know, provides some of the best arguments against the Copernican model in that time, against Galileo. But in a way, he's a theologian. He's going to see, "Okay, what heresies does this book have?" Now, Galileo didn't like this guy, right? Because these arguments were really good. And he thought he shouldn't be the one correcting Copernicus. The people correcting Copernicus should be the Jesuit astronomers in Rome, who were his friends. They had invited him for a party, and so on. And, but anyway, the index asks this theologian to make the corrections. He makes the corrections. He knows a lot about this. He sends them to Rome, but Rome still decides to actually give the corrections to the Jesuit astronomers, to double check. Now, this is not because Galileo wanted. This is the normal practice. So the inquisition with all the congregation of the Ines would always ask experts in different fields to analyze what, you know, the final draft of the corrections. If he was a book of medicine, they would ask physicians at the University of Pablo. And so the Jesuit astronomers read it, you know, tweak some things, and they do approve the corrections. We'll look at the corrections in a second. But before we do that, so once the corrections are in place, whoever has the book has to correct it, booksellers have to correct it. Libraries of monasteries have to correct it, you know, private libraries, and so on. At least in Catholic Europe, right? Now, in Galileo's time, there were more or less 500 copies of Copernicus derevolutionary volumes around Europe in, you know, private libraries and religious libraries. Of these 500 copies, how many copies you think were censored? You're in the guess? A hundred? What? All of them? A hundred all of them? 15. So they were actually 40. So I think you're the closest, which is about 8%. So one in 12. Not just that, we actually know more or less where they were. And here's the map. Almost all of the corrected copies were in Italy, not in France, not in Iberia, not in Germany. And of course not in England, but England was not Catholic anyway. So this at least gives you a sense of how, you know, this censorship machinery was actually working. And, you know, it was not very successful, right? But let's go to Italy, well, they were censored in Italy. So let's see how that goes. Let's see how people censored their copies. And so that we can get the best example. Let's think of the person whom the inquisition was kind of spying on and wanting to have in Czechoslovakia Galloway himself. We actually have the copy of the Copernicus copy of Galloway, the one that he corrected himself. And here are the corrections. There you go. So basically, I mean, you can't see. But on the left, it says that it's the Magnitude, the Magnitude Horde, and Trim see their own. So on the sizes of these three stars, the sun, the moon, and the earth. Strike through. Why? Because the earth is not a star. The earth is the earth. So that's what they want to say. So second one, so the title, it says, on the triplet cheese module, so on the three motions, the demonstration of the three motions of the earth. And the correction, and it says, no, no, on the hypothesis of the three motions of the earth. So you can see, first of all, the kinds of corrections, which is, yeah, I mean, you cannot say this is the true model. There's no demonstration, just hypothesis. But above all, notice, in a way, how ineffective it was. It was not forbidden to read it. You could read anyone who reads the censored copy of Copernicus can read the censored ideas. In fact, it also shows a little bit what the index wanted to do, which is basically to signal, look, this idea that strike through is wrong, right? And you communicate that to the people. Now, this is, however, just the beginning of the gathering. because he is indeed condemned by the Roman acquisition in the year 1633. Now, the corrections on Copernicus come out in the year 1620, so four years after 1616. And then in 1621, something huge happens in Europe, which is that this cardinal, Cardinal Mafia of Barberini, the famous patronot of Bernini, and Caravaggio and many other, you know, broke paintings, is elected to the papacy. And this is huge because this man was one of Guadeloupe's greatest fans, but he had, there was a poem by Barberini praising Guadeloupe, he agreed with almost everything Guadeloupe said. So, Guadeloupe was over the moon about this, and in fact, he writes to a friend saying, "What a marvelous conjuncture. This is a astrological term, like the heavens are aligned now. My friend, the Pope, is the Pope, so now I can do whatever I want." And in fact, he goes to Rome and has long meetings with the Pope, Pope Urban the Eighth, is his name, and they talk in the Vatican gardens about Copernicanism and so on. And we know that Guadeloupe leaves that meeting very encouraged to finally write his, you know, great apology of the Copernican model. Not only that, he actually speaks with the main guy in the Vatican, who's in charge of censoring and giving permission to books, a man called Father Riccardi, and Guadeloupe says to a friend that this Father Riccardi has a strong opinion that this, that is Copernicanism, is not a matter of faith, and that it is not the appropriate place for this scripture. So, as long as you avoid theology, you'll be finialed to write that book. So, Guadeloupe goes back home and he writes the book, which is known as the dialogue on the two chief world systems, which is basically three people chatting over four days for big chapters. There's one who's really dumb, who's the Aristotelian, and the geocentric guy who says that the earth is in the center. Guadeloupe writes really well, so it's you really get enchanted by the way of writing, even as historians. There's the moderator, and then there's another guy who is, you know, Guadeloupe the Copernican, right? And they debate all of these things, and the guy, you know, the Celia, the geocentric guy's ridicule throughout the whole process. Now, Guadeloupe finishes the book, sends the manuscript to Rome to be checked by, you know, by the congregation of the index, but the Father Riccardi, he reads the manuscript, and he's not convinced. He thinks that Guadeloupe doesn't really have the proof that he said he had. Now, the main proof that Guadeloupe had was that because the earth is in motion, there's still things in the water, and that creates the tides. Now, everyone knows, and everyone, people already knew at the time, Kepler was saying that the tides are not caused by the motion of the earth, they caused by what? By the moon, right? And so Riccardi reads these men, these guys said he had the proof, but, you know, this is no proof. And not just that, you're not showing the ones at all, because, you know, you're really outrightly putting forward the Copernican model, so you have to show them one once. So basically, he gets a revised and resubmit. We can't publish this, but you go back home and, you know, put these corrections in practice. And, you know, Guadeloupe does that. So Guadeloupe changes the title of the book, because the book was originally called the Discourse on Tides, and the inquisitor says, "You cannot entitle these Discourse on Tides." So it becomes a dialogue on the two-chofe role systems, and he also adds some new ones into the book. Now, at these moments, there is a large epidemic that takes control of Europe, especially of Italy, because of the 30 years war. And this is just like COVID. So people have to stay at home, they cannot travel, they cannot even send packages. And so these affected the process of revision of the book, significantly. In fact, I wrote a piece for the Wall Street Journal about that when the pandemic happened, to show how pandemic affected Guadeloupe. So basically, Guadeloupe could not send the revised manuscript back to Rome. But because there was this momentum, and he wanted to publish the book, he decided, "Okay, let me take care of this here in the censorship office in Florence." So he went to Florence with all the paper, or we can see, "Look, this already has an early approval from Rome. I've made all the corrections that they asked. Can you approve it?" And the Florentine inquisitor says, "Yep, I mean, yeah. In fact, he does the corrections and all that, so let's approve it. The book is approved and goes on sale." This takes a while, right? So the epidemic goes off, and the things can be sent to Rome, and the books arrive at the Pope's desk, and the Pope becomes very disappointed. And he feels betrayed by Guadeloupe. Because then once that Guadeloupe presented was that he put into the mouth of the silly guy, in the very end, after the guy's ridicule throughout the whole book, he adds this idea that, "You know what? God could have done however he wanted. Could be the geocentric model, could be the Copernican model. Who knows? I mean, it's not up to us to know. Now, this is something that the Pope had told Guadeloupe, and in fact, Guadeloupe writes in the book as if some prominent person had told him. So the Pope reads this, and he knows, "Wow, these guys really laughing at mine. You know, the things that I told him." And so he becomes furious. He's a very emotional man. People say that. And he was under a lot of pressure, but people say that he was so bothered by the sounds of birds in the Vatican gardens at sunrise that he asked him all to be killed. The Pope, this Pope barbarian. You can see the kind of man that he was. And so now, and again, there was major wars going on. Lots of freshers on him. And then you have these scientists, you know, laughing at me with his major publication. We need to do something. So he asks the inquisition to bring Guadeloupe back. You're teaching Copernicus. You cannot teach Copernicus. You were taught. You were asked in 1616 not to do it, and you're doing, you will have to be condemned. And his inquisition is the condemnation is that he stays under house arrest, cannot leave his home in Florence, and the dialogue on the two chiefal systems is forbidden. Not until corrected. It's not to be corrected. People cannot read this book. It's not burned. They don't burn the book, but they cannot buy it. Guadeloupe goes back home, keeps on working on his physics, and wants to publish his discourse on the Tunisized in Italy. But by now, no editor wants to publish Guadeloupe. It's not that it is forbidden. It's not forbidden. But who knows, these guys are a bit crazy. So we're not going to publish Guadeloupe. So he actually has to smuggle the book out to Leiden, and the book is published by El Svier in Leiden. Now, what does this mean? Does Copernicus not become a forbidden idea from now onwards? Well, more or less. Let's look at some examples. Just a few years after this, these two men who are Catholic priests Maham et Sen, Aminim Friar and Piaf Gassendi, who's a diocesan priest, write about astronomy in very openly Copernican ways. I don't say I'm Copernicus. Copernicus is true. But I mean, anyone who knows astronomy can read that and understand that's Copernicus and without a problem at all. In 1641, so less than 10 years after Guadeloupe's condemnation, a book is published in Lyon in France with Guadeloupe's dialogue and other of Guadeloupe's writings. And it has approval of the Lyon censors. And nothing happens. Is this crazy? I mean, there's a prohibition on his book and yet people are publishing it. Possibly Rome never heard of it. But this happens. I mean, this book is in libraries. And not just that. Even within the people who are more want to be obedient to the church and let's just not advocate for Copernicanism, even those taught their Copernican model in their astronomy classes. It's just another model. And here you have, for example, an Italian Jesuit teaching Copernicus in Lisbon, Portugal, just a few years, or even less than a year after the condemnation of Guadeloupe. And we know that he's aware of that because he mentions it in his textbook manuscript that's now in Portugal. So people kept on talking about Copernicus even though there was this condemnation on Guadeloupe's work because of Copernicanism. Now, this need have an effect, right? And the most important and famous one. And whenever I tell this story, people, oh, but people come to me and say, oh, what about the cards? Because the cards heard about what happens with Guadeloupe. And in fact, he writes a letter to Maramexin, this meaning prior to that I just mentioned, that was a Copernican too. And he describes his reaction to this. And here it is. Can one of you read? Go ahead. I have meant to send you my world. So my world is, let me just say, is the moon. So he's theory of the world, a book that he's about to publish, right? Sorry, go ahead. My world as a New Year's gift. But I should tell you that having inquired recently in Latin, in Amsterdam, where the Galea system of the world was available. Since I thought I had heard it was published in Italy last year. I told, I was told it had been published for all that all the time. I was told it had been published, but that all the copies were immediately burned in Rome, and that he had been fine. By the way, this is not true, right? Guadeloupe's dialogue was not burned in Rome, and he was not fine. But this is the card writing a few months after that. You know, this is his perception of what happened. This surprised me so much that I more or less decided to burn all my papers, or at least not to allow them to be seen by anyone. For I could not imagine that as an Italian, and even as, and even I have heard someone who is in good grace to the Pope, he could have been convicted for nothing more than a tempting as he surely did to establish the Earth's movement. That's okay. So after this, the card was about to publish his Le Monde, his Copernican theory of the universe, and he stops sure of it. He doesn't do it because he thinks that, you know, it's going to be censored. Now, it is published only after the card dies. Now, some things to be said about this. Now, the card was a Catholic, and so he paid attention to these things, but he was not living in Catholic lands. He was living in Leiden, the same place that published in the end, Guadeloupe's other book on physics, right? And after that, he kept on actually writing more things, the principles of philosophy, the discourse on the method. Very important the Cartesian works where he talks about about Copernicanism. So this was just like a moment that he had. Now, Descartes was trained in France by the Jesuits. And it is common to hear, in fact, I have heard colleagues replied to some of my articles and things say, well, but you say these things, but then it is true that Descartes left Catholic France and went to the Netherlands because the Netherlands was more tolerance. But actually, there's no evidence that the reason why Descartes went to the Netherlands was because it was more tolerance. In fact, the reason he says is because no one knew him there, so he could study more, you know, in a more leisurely way. And in fact, some things happened to him there. Despite the fact that he was Catholic and the main religion in the Netherlands was Calvinism. In fact, Descartes was censored. As soon as his books start to come out and some of his ideas start to come out, the University of Uttarash's Condemns, Cartesianism in 1642, they're Calvinists. Universities are not Catholic. And 1647, lie then university, too, Condemns, Cartesianism. No one can even mention the name of Descartes in the classroom. And Descartes, of course, is very disappointed by this, but it just shows how these things were going on in Protestant Europe as well. Now, the Inquisition also condemned Descartes, but 20 years later, 1663. And so it was put on the index, some of his works. But again, until they are corrected, right? And you know more or less what that means because you've seen the Copernican model. So the Descartes is a very interesting case because here you have someone who's hearing about, you know, the contamination of Galileo and decides not to publish his stuff at least in the beginning. So it means that it does have an impact on people's writings and ideas, right? But at the distance, the cart was not in Italy. He thought the books had been burned. They were not burned, so it's like the myth already starting, in a way. But what about someone who was also trained in the Netherlands and then goes to Italy, you know, is not a Catholic, goes to Italy and sees what going on? What about someone like Steno, the hero of my book, right? Steno was a Danish Lutheran. He was trained in the University of Leiden. He read all of Descartes' works and engaged significantly with it. And, but then he actually goes to Italy and he gets a job as a Protestant in the Medici court. Now, while he's there, he undergoes a major conversion to Catholicism, which is the final chapter of my book. And then, years later, he would write about his experience in Italy. He would say, well, who wants to read? Now, great. You wanna read it too? - I live in places where the English position exists, and I saw everywhere that the non-Pap likes and what the greatest free will was, that they did not do any research at all. Yet, yes, even the people court. I heard people screaming to see it, with screaming to get some faith, the ecclesiastical hierarchy, or the non-operable regime. - So you can see, I mean, Steno is writing this already, kind of, as an apologetic, right? 'Cause he starts writing to convince people to become Catholic and so on. So he is biased, right? But he's not a liar. I mean, he's talking about his own experience. I mean, maybe other people had other experiences, together, perhaps, had a different experience, right? But Steno, this Protestant intellectual, you know, witnessed all of these. And in fact, it was very important for his conversion. You know, many of his prejudices against the Catholic church kind of fell through when he was in Italy. Now, but what about the history of the year? You know, how could he publish a new interpretation of the book of Genesis, and so on? Well, for us to know what happened with Steno, I think it's a good idea to look at another book published by someone who was also influenced at almost the same time with the same press, with the same people, same patrons, and who was apparently censored by the Inquisition. And this is a man called Giovanni Borrelli, who wrote this book about the Mediciaron planetarium, so which is the Medici planet, which is really the moons of Jupiter. He writes a very sophisticated theory about the motion of the moons of Jupiter that Newton will reach and will apply to his anterior gravity. So it's a very influential book in the history of astronomy. And Borrelli is, of course, the Copernican, and you read this book, and you see that he's clearly a Copernican, even though he doesn't say it explicitly. But there's a very interesting thing about this book that historians have noticed, which is, in the very bottom on the right, I'll zoom in so that you can see a little better. The date in Roman numerals, I don't know whether, who knows how to read Roman numerals here? Gosh, guys, you need to know this is basic, okay? Some of you know, of course, but all of you should know. So this is basically 1666, okay? This is the year 1666, because it has M, which is 1,000, D, which is 500, C, which is 100, so D plus C is 600, 1,600, and then L, which is 50, and then an X, which is 10, so 50 plus 10, 60, so 1,000, 60, 60, 6, right? 5 plus 1, 5 is the V, 1, wasn't right? Now, if you look closely, it's hard to notice here, but if you look closely, you will actually see that this one is written by hand. You can see there's a period here, like there's a period here, a period here, a period here, right? Someone added something with ink, right? And in fact, all the copies that exist of this book, including the ones in England that Newton owned, have these as well. Now, historians of astronomy have read these. Oh, and in fact, if you look at the interior of the book, you see that the book was already fully ready in '65. Borelli submits it to the Inquisition review process in '65. And so, he starts and says, yeah, well, so it goes to the Inquisition for review, and then, because it's so Copernican, takes a while, and then they have to do it in '66. It kind of delays the publication of the book. Now, an article that came out 10 years ago, or maybe 20, I don't remember now, actually went into the Borelli correspondence and found out the real reason for that. And guess what? It has nothing to do with religion. We actually know that Borelli asked the book to be dated, 1665, even though the book was on the published in '66, because of a priority dispute. He wanted to show that he had figured out something about the motion of the planets before another guy in Rome. And so he asked that, but everyone who received the book knew that this was a 66 book. So that just had this, because of cataloging processes and so on. So the only book in this period about science that supposedly was censored by religion was not censored by religion, right? So how can we explain Steno's caveats about his history of the earth, right? Well, he tells us, you just keep on reading the book. He will say that, well, the knowledge of these things is not yet there for me to the point I would interpose here. My judgment, Steno was very careful. I mean, the search for certain he's a major topic in my book. He's very careful about what can be known and what cannot be known. And so I'm not yet sure about this. So that's why he's caveating all these things that he's saying is not because of censorship, right? And in fact, he writes another book where he's much more certain after that. So to conclude, I hope I have convinced you that, yes, there was censorship in the early modern period, but it was not about science. It was mostly about theology. And even when it seems that it is about science, it's often not like some of the cases that I showed you just now. And not just that when censorship was put in place like with Copernicus, it was highly porous. So you could still read Copernicus and figure out what Copernicus had said. Now, this is hugely important for the history of science because it means that some of the assumptions that we had, some of the interpretations of how these books were made, are actually wrong. And we have to redo this again. I did that with Steno, some other guy did with Borreli. We've got a little people having doing that because it's a major guy. But it invites historians to go back into the sources and to actually study things more seriously. But it also should warn you about when you read things about science and religion. Be very careful because very few people do this. Even AI, AI is amazing. AI is amazing, okay? And they know a lot. But on these cases, they're still not very little. Why? Because most of what's written out there doesn't yet incorporate this novel research, right? But just not just that. Historians, the few historians who are looking at these actually think that peer review started as a nearly modern disciplinary technique, closely related to book censorship. The slow differentiation of peer review from book censorship started in the second half of the 17th century with the development of Royal Academies. And then of course, change significantly until what we have today. But we still have revise and resubmit. Thank you so much. (audience applauding) Thanks for listening to this lecture on the Tammistic Institute podcast. The generosity of people like you makes this podcast possible. If you enjoy these talks, please consider showing your support at www.tammisticinstitute.org/donate. Your donation of even a dollar helps us reach more college students and many others with the powerful truths of the faith. And it ensures that we can keep publishing top notch lectures on this podcast. Thanks a lot.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Graduate theology programs at the Pontifical Faculty of the Immaculate Conception offer a unique blend of prayer and scholarly study through the Dominican tradition.
  2. Students can pursue master’s or doctoral degrees in theology or ecclesiastical studies with full-ride scholarships, including annual living stipends, through the Domestic Institute Competitive Scholarship Program.
  3. Charles Darwin was deeply influenced by Charles Lyell’s *Principles of Geology*, particularly its uniformitarian theory, which challenged catastrophism and raised theological questions about the age of the Earth.
  4. Nicolaus Steno, a 17th-century Danish Catholic priest and saint, pioneered geology with principles like stratigraphy, and his work predated major scientific revolutions in Europe.
  5. Despite the Inquisition’s censorship policies, foundational scientific works by Steno and others were not systematically banned, and many were widely read, indicating censorship was limited and porous.
  6. Early modern censorship primarily targeted theology and heresy, not science, and often operated through licensing, corrections, or selective publication rather than outright bans.
  7. The Galileo and Descartes cases show that scientific ideas were often suppressed only in form, not in practice, as books remained in circulation and widely studied despite official objections.
  8. Historical research reveals that the narrative of scientific suppression by the Church is oversimplified and often inaccurate; censorship was inconsistent, limited, and did not halt the spread of scientific thought.

Summary:

The transcript highlights the intersection of theology, science, and historical censorship in early modern Europe. It begins by promoting graduate theology programs at the Dominican House of Studies, offering students a holistic education rooted in prayer and scholarship, supported by competitive scholarships. It then shifts to a historical analysis of scientific developments, focusing on the influence of Nicolaus Steno and Charles Darwin, who were shaped by geological theories that challenged literal interpretations of Scripture.

Steno’s groundbreaking work in stratigraphy—developed in 1667 despite Catholic institutional oversight—was published with Inquisition permissions, suggesting a porous censorship system. The narrative emphasizes that early modern censorship was largely theological, targeting heresy and non-traditional doctrine, not scientific inquiry. Cases like Galileo and Descartes reveal that scientific ideas persisted despite official disapproval, as books were often corrected rather than banned and remained widely circulated.

Historical evidence shows that censorship was ineffective and inconsistent, with many works continuing to circulate and influence thought. The discussion concludes that the popular myth of the Church suppressing science is inaccurate and requires deeper historical scrutiny, urging historians and readers to examine primary sources critically. This reframing underscores the importance of rigorous scholarship in understanding the history of science and religion.

FAQs

Students can pursue a Master of Arts in Theology, a Master of Divinity, a PhD in Theology, or an ecclesiastical degree through the Domestic Institutes Competitive Scholarship Program.

The program integrates prayer and study in a Dominican House of Formation, offering a holistic spiritual and academic experience.

Yes, the Domestic Institutes Competitive Full-Ride Scholarship Program offers annual living stipends to qualified students.

The deadline to apply is January 8, 2027.

Visit DomesticInstitute.org/scholarships for detailed information and application instructions.

Yes, but it was primarily focused on theology and religious heresy, not science itself.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.