Go back

Post Mortem | Murder at Mount Hood

25m 1s

Post Mortem | Murder at Mount Hood

The disappearance of 61-year-old Susan Lane, known as Phoenix, in November 2024 near Mount Hood, Oregon, sparked both an official search and a powerful community response. Phoenix had lived in the remote, close-knit mountain community, known for its "mountain justice" culture, where locals look out for one another. Her friends and family raised red flags over her strained relationship with husband Michael Fornier, who had shown controlling behavior and denied being at home when she went missing. Surveillance footage revealed Phoenix’s truck with her dogs near an auto part store, contradicting Fornier’s story of hitchhiking. Investigators found her body in the woods, killed with three gunshot wounds, and later discovered her dogs with zip ties, indicating a premeditated and cruel attack. Fornier, who initially claimed he was poisoned by Phoenix, was found guilty of second-degree murder after the prosecution presented blood evidence, a shell casing, and ammunition matching the murder weapon. His defense focused on challenging the investigation process, but failed to overturn the evidence. He was also charged with aggravated animal abuse for the dogs’ deaths. The case highlighted the strength of community vigilance and support, with Phoenix’s legacy preserved through a dedicated room at the Hoodland Bizarre that promotes women’s empowerment and anti-domestic violence. The story underscores how close-knit communities can respond to tragedy with compassion, while also exposing the dangers of domestic abuse and the consequences of deception.

Transcription

3818 Words, 21392 Characters

English
Hey, I'm Tony DeCouple, anchor of the CBS evening news on my new daily podcast Great Question with Tony DeCouple. We go deeper on the one big question you haven't heard answered, or maybe haven't even heard asked. Follow and listen wherever you get your podcasts. It was a gruesome discovery off a dirt road in Georgia. Hunters had found a body. Was it immediately clear to you that this woman had been murdered? Yes. But who was this mystery woman in the woods? That looks like Mindy. I'm Aaron Moriarty, and from 48 hours, this is the woman in the woods. I have never wanted to be wrong, like this in my whole entire life. Benj, the full series, the woman in the woods, wherever you get your podcasts. Welcome back to Postmortem. I'm your host, 48 hours correspondent, Anne Mori Green, and I'm joined by 48 hours correspondent Peter Van Sant. And today we are discussing the murder of 61-year-old Susan Lane, who also went by the name Phoenix. In 2024, when Phoenix disappeared near Oregon's Mount Hood, the local community rallied to find her and bring her killer to justice. Peter, such a beautiful backdrop for such a terrible heartbreaking story, but I'm really glad you're here. Hey, great to be with you, Anne Mori. I'm from the Great Pacific Northwest. No Mount Hood, pretty well. So this was a fascinating story for me. It also stands out to me because of the remarkable effort from these locals to find Phoenix. They organized searches, gave law enforcement tips and advice, and a local was the one who ultimately found Phoenix's body. Yeah, and we are going to get into that. But first, of course, my usual reminder to everyone. If you haven't watched or listened to this episode, it's called Murder at Mount Hood. Go check it out and then come on back for this conversation. All right, so let's start things off. November 22, 2024, Phoenix does not show up at her job, at a gift shop in Welch's Oregon. That's near Mount Hood. Nobody can get ahold of her. And so Phoenix is friend who owns a a Pizzeria right next door in the area, Sarah Caswell. She calls law enforcement, and she says in the hour that often it takes a long time for law enforcement to make their way up the mountain when they do call. And so the people who live in this area have their own way of taking care of business. You might say, Peter, they call it mountain justice. Absolutely. It's fascinating. Welch's is a remote mountain community, about 45 miles outside of Portland in the foothills of Mount Hood, which is a majestic mountain over 11,000 feet tall surrounded by a vast national forest. And there's only one road in and out and cell phone service up there can be spotty. That's how remote this area is. So mountain justice is basically the practice of locals looking out for each other. I like that. I like that. And Phoenix really found a home in this community later in life. She had two adult sons, Jesse and Dakota, who she raised in California and cancels with her former husband, Fred. After Fred died in a car accident in 2009, she started dating a long haul trucker by the name of Michael forney A. And on one of their trucking trips, she discovered Mount Hood and fell in love and then eventually bought a home nearby. What about this community drew her in? We get it when you're there. It's such a beautiful wild place. And it draws a unique group of people. There are artists. There's loggers. And when you're there, it draws you because there's such a welcoming group. And according to her son, Jesse, she really desired a simple life up there in those woods. And she married Michael forney A in 2012 and eventually began working at a local gift shop, the Hoodlin Bizarre, which was in a strip mall that was a real community hub. Everybody would come there to say hi, greet each other. It's owned by an Afghan immigrant. And it's very funky. They sell crystals, Turkish lamps. Afghan will rugs among other things. Phoenix also led these things, which I had never heard of before, called sound baths. And it was really fascinating. It's a beautiful sound and you go in and you meditate and relax. It's quite soothing. Oh, let me tell you something, Peter. All of that into all the woo-woo. That is right off my alley. I thought to myself, I would love this town. And it sounded like it was a perfect fit for Phoenix. She became sort of a fixture in the community. Absolutely. And Phoenix's friend Kristen Prudence said that locals had enormous respect for Phoenix, who they saw as a wise woman in their community. So then after Phoenix doesn't show up for work on Friday, November 22nd, 2024, her friend Sarah actually posts on Facebook asking people to be on the lookout for her white pickup truck. And then on Saturday, another friend, Kerry Gesh, spots Phoenix's truck while driving through Mount Hood National Forest. And the thing about it is authorities, you know, figured that's a good place to start their search. They begin searching the area. But Phoenix's friends almost immediately think this is a bad idea. They are not convinced that she would go hiking in that area. Why not? Well, Sarah told us that Phoenix was very outdoorsy and very comfortable in the wilderness. She knew this backcountry so well. She spent a lot of time walking her two dogs, El Ros and El Ronde taking them out for hikes. But she did so in places that nobody else would go because they weren't dogs. You just have around other dogs or other people. According to Phoenix, they were wolf hybrids. Sarah believed she wouldn't have walked them on the trail near where her truck was found because a lot of tourists go there. Phoenix's friends and family also shared their concerns about Phoenix's husband, Michael Fornier with authorities. Investigators tried calling Fornier, but got no answer. I'm curious about, you know, what Fornier's reputation was like in the in the community. Well, people told us that Fornier didn't seem to have any close friends in the immediate area. And Sarah said that she'd never met him, which is really strange since she was a good friend of Phoenix. And Kristen never met him either. Phoenix had told some of her friends that she and Fornier were having problems in their marriage. Kristen said that she didn't know exactly how bad things were, but it was clear that there was something going on at home. And Sarah said that Phoenix told her that Fornier put padlocks on their home pantry, if you can believe this, after Phoenix donated soup to the community food pantry. He didn't like that. And according to Sarah, a month before Phoenix's disappearance, Phoenix told her she'd grown tired of Fornier's controlling behavior and was making plans to leave him. Well, of course, when Phoenix goes missing, investigators are trying to track him down. It takes two days before he finally returns a phone call to the Sheriff's office. And he tells them that they have been living separate lives that Phoenix in fact served him with divorce papers just days earlier. Fornier says the last time he actually saw Phoenix was at their home the morning that she had gone missing. And then, you know, he had been away for the rest of the day. But then he comes up with this like really odd story. He says that he hitchhiked to an auto part store that's like 30 miles away. What did investigators think of his alibi? Detective Jim White, with the clock in Miss County Sheriff's Office told us that to him, Fornier's story was almost farcical. But even though Fornier's story may have seemed unlikely, it was a key to solving this case. In other words, he boxed himself in with this crazy story. When investigators tracked Phoenix's cell phone location on the day she disappeared, it led them from her mountain home to the Portland airport where it went dead. And remarkably, investigators eventually found her phone in the nearby Columbia River, but the phone was too damaged to provide any more information. But because Fornier had given detectives the name of this auto part store where he had allegedly hitchhiked to, they could check cameras from the store's parking lot. They do that. And what do they see? They saw Phoenix's truck driving in with her dogs in the back. Frustratingly, they couldn't clearly see who was driving the vehicle, but Fornier is seen walking into the store moments later. So you can kind of put that two and two together. He must have been behind the wheel, right? So investigators now believed Fornier had lied to them about that hitchhiking. Detectives also found security video of Phoenix's truck driving back toward the mountain about two hours later. This time, sadly, without the dogs. They believe Fornier likely disposed of the dogs somewhere along the roadway. Yeah, and we learned more about that later, but I thought this was really sort of an interesting moment in the hour. Thanksgiving day, Phoenix's son, Jesse, who lived out of town, but had come back to the mountain, said that he was driving the highway when he caught sight of Fornier's truck. Jesse, he said he followed him home and the two men had this sort of silent standoff in the driveway for several minutes until 48 broke the silence by telling Jesse I wish I had answers for you. I want to play a clip from your interview with Jesse that was not in the hour about this meeting. So we had that silent kind of standoff and then we went in and sat down on the couch in front of the fire and drank a cup of coffee and he was just very lethargic and I kept trying to get him to open up and he just wouldn't participate and I just finally left. Now people communicate without speaking a word sometimes. What did you see in his eyes, his face, his mannerisms? Was this the behavior of an innocent man or were you now starting to be suspicious? I wasn't suspicious and I felt I really had to work through that emotion in the last couple of years, like last year and a half. Why couldn't I have been able to sense his deceit and you had always hoped for the best? Exactly. So I was hoping that I was wrong. I don't want him to be dead. I don't want him to be the one to do it. I was hoping hoping hoping. This is not just heartbreaking but really disappointing when you're trying to get answers from this man that you believe knows what happened to your mother and he just won't even participate in the conversation in any way. And remember, Jesse and Dakota, the two brothers, were teens when Michael Fournier came into their lives and of the two brothers, they told us Jesse was the one who gave Fournier more of a chance in this relationship. Jesse said he was happy that someone was there to take care of his mom and he didn't want her to be alone. With a cocktail to match the mood, we call him the show straight up available wherever you get your podcast. Welcome back. So while the official search and rescue operation was being conducted near where Phoenix's truck was found in the Mount Hood National Forest and we were talking about an area of more than a million acres, members of the local mountain community suspected Michael Fournier had done something to Phoenix and they were searching for Phoenix on their own in other areas. Can you just tell me a little bit about that? How did they organize? Why did they? Remember this community, there's places at the tourist go and there's places where they go. And the official search and rescue operation in the area around where Phoenix's truck was found really frustrated them because they thought investigators gosh, they're just going down the wrong trails. And Sarah said that instead community members searched in places that were off the beaten track, places that only locals would go to. Interesting. The official search and rescue operation was eventually called off after several days of searching. But when a community member James Evans learned that no one had searched the woods adjacent to Phoenix's house, he organized a search party to search that area. He arrived before anyone else on November 29th, and this is a week after Phoenix disappeared. Just as he starts looking around, he notices a tarp and a pile of garbage and underneath that tarp was Phoenix's body. Peter, you actually went back there with him and you talked about the moment that he lifted that tarp and realized what was underneath. Here's a clip that was not in the hour. It was kind of scary for me. I even questioned myself. It was like, is this what you really wanted to find her? Now you found her. But I had this intuition that I would find Phoenix and I wasn't going to give up. He's such a wonderful man and you can tell the tone of his voice and how difficult it was for him because the imagery, he says, is just stayed with him to have discovered his good friend's body. An autopsy later revealed that Phoenix had been shot three times in the head, the neck, and the chest. And within hours of her body being discovered, investigators approached for me at home with their guns drawn and they found him outside. He agreed to go to a nearby police station. After talking for a bit about his relationship with Phoenix before she had gone missing, he brought up a really interesting story about a bottle of gatorade. Yeah, he claimed that just a few days before Phoenix went missing, he'd gotten sick at home after washing down some heart medication with an open bottle of gatorade. Fournier said he drove to the hospital because he was feeling that bad, but began to feel better in the parking lot of the hospitals so we never went inside. He told investigators that he thought he'd been poisoned with the gatorade and he suggested that Phoenix was behind it. After nearly three hours, Detective Monarch showed Fournier video footage from the autopart store's parking lot, which captures Phoenix's truck with her dogs in the back. The detectives told Fournier they knew that he had driven Phoenix's truck and they asked him where his wife was. Well, soon after Fournier stopped answering questions and was arrested, he was charged with second degree murder and pleaded not guilty. Shortly after he was taken into custody, the bodies of Phoenix's two dogs, Elros and Elron were discovered off a highway leading out of Portland with zip ties around their necks. I really was hoping throughout the hour that, you know, the dogs were maybe let go. They were at a rescue someplace. Somebody had picked them up to hear that they were killed in this way. Seems particularly brutal. These are dogs that undoubtedly trusted Fournier and just the imagery of him putting zip ties around their necks and strangling them. It's just says everything you want to know about what was inside his, his heart and mind. It suggested two detectives that also because the zip ties were used on the dogs that Fournier must have planned this attack down to that detail that I'm going to have to kill these dogs and he needs these zip ties. And so in January 2025, almost two months after his arrest, detectives got a message that Fournier was ready to speak with them again. Now Fournier admitted to killing her dogs. He tried to justify strangling the dogs by claiming, listen to this, that if he took the dogs to the pound, they would have been euthanized because they were wolf hybrids. He said, quote, "If they're going to die, I'm going to see them die." As if that's compassionate. Notably, his explanation seemed to suggest he knew Phoenix wasn't coming back. Remember, his words keep coming back to haunt him. In that same jail interview, his story about Phoenix poisoning him with Gatorade had evolved. Fournier claimed that she had handed him the open bottle. He told detectives where they could find that bottle. It was recovered, tested, but a state forensic slab didn't find any poisons or heavy metals in that liquid. And then he wants to talk to detectives again. It's like four months after his wife's murder and he asked to speak to detectives. And he has an interesting request. He asked detectives white and monarch to let him out of jail temporarily so he can get his affairs in order. And in return, he suggested that he might provide Phoenix's sons with more answers. I mean, I've never heard of anything like this happening. I don't know if he understood the level of trouble he was in. Yeah. And the seriousness of the charge against him, detectives were straight up with 48. They told him they'd never heard of a request like the one he was making being granted. They did tell him that they would pass on his request to the district attorney's office. And the prosecutors told me it wasn't considered at all. And was quote, absolutely absurd. You're being charged with your wife's murder, sir. This isn't Jay walking like you're not getting out to do anything until this trial. So then in February of 2026, Michael Fournier went on trial for Phoenix's murder. The prosecution argued that Fournier had a motive to kill Phoenix because she had requested the property that they were living on in her divorce filing. And the prosecutor, John Miller found Fournier was served with divorce papers. And then about 41 hours later, that's when Phoenix was shot and killed. They also presented forensic evidence, including Phoenix's blood in the back of Fournier's Volkswagen truck, a shell casing found in the driveway and a 22 caliber ammunition found in the house. The ammunition was consistent with forensic reports, which confirmed she had been shot three times with a 22 caliber weapon. So this sounds like a very strong case. How did the defense counter? I mean, what you could call a tsunami of evidence. Yeah, this was another jaw dropping moment in this sad story. The defense's opening statement was one of the shortest opening statements from a defense counsel I've ever seen or heard in my long career. The attorney simply reminded jurors that the state had the burden of proof and to make sure they had enough evidence to convict. And while Michael Fornier never took the stand, his voice was heard throughout the trial as prosecutors played about eight hours of his voluntary interviews with investigators. Fornier and his defense team declined our request for interviews. But prosecutors told me that they felt the defense did the best that they could do to poke holes or overcome the evidence that had been gathered against Fornier. If you don't have a good case, you attack the process. It's the old rush to judgment. You attack how evidence was gathered. And that's what they did. Fornier was found guilty of second-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 25 years, but you know, he's an elderly man, so it's life probably. We also learned at the end of the episode in May of 2026 that Michael Fornier was also charged in connection with the killing of Phoenix's dogs and he has pleaded not guilty. I thought that was interesting. Well, Fornier was charged with two counts of aggravated animal abuse in the first degree in Multnomah County, where the dogs were found and where Fornier's interviews indicated he killed them. A different county than Clackamas, obviously. We didn't include this detail in the hour, but Phoenix's son Jesse gave several of Phoenix's friends necklaces that contained the ashes of Phoenix as well as the two dogs that she loved, Elros and Elrond. Phoenix's friend Kristen told me it's an honor to have them with her. She wears that necklace because it keeps all of them close. And then at the end of the episode, we see how the community really sort of got together at the Hoodland Bizarre where she worked to rename the room where Phoenix did her soundbaths and they renamed the room the Phoenix room. I want to play an unared clip of Carrie speaking at that dedication. I truly believe that he thought that she would go missing and no one would care and they would just assume she got lost in the woods and that was incorrect. We made sure she was not forgotten then and she won't be forgotten now. She's a reminder of strength of spirit and you know that if you are in a situation like that like many of us in this room have been that people do care and you won't be forgotten and there will be someone there to help you if you need it. So everyone please give yourself a big round of applause. It's just so great. It gives you that flavor. How much they care for each other. Look out for each other. Some of them, you know, are very individualistic in their personal lives. But when somebody within that community is in trouble they rally and it's it's fantastic. And the Phoenix room host women's groups and advocates against domestic violence. It's a part of her legacy and trust me when they say they won't forget her they they will not. They will look up and see that name and know her story. Peter, thanks for joining me today. Hey thank you and Marie. And if you like this episode please rate and review on Apple podcasts or Spotify. Now streaming on Paramount Plus. I'm Dexter Morvin. I've been killing killers for half my life. It gets to you. You're having a midlife crisis. I'm not ready for that. He's back. I'm older. I'm wiser. And sharper than ever. Things are gonna get messy. But if I can't believe in my soul I can't believe in anything. Dexter Resurrection, new season now streaming on the Paramount Plus premium plan. You have no idea what we went through out there. Catch every killer twist now streaming on Paramount Plus.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Susan Lane, known as Phoenix, disappeared in November 2024 near Mount Hood, Oregon, prompting a community-led search amid concerns about her husband Michael Fornier’s controlling behavior.
  2. Phoenix’s friends and family suspected foul play, noting her history of marital conflict with Fornier, including his reaction to her donating soup to a community pantry and her plans to file for divorce.
  3. Surveillance footage from an auto part store revealed Phoenix’s truck with her dogs, contradicting Fornier’s claim of hitchhiking, suggesting he drove the vehicle and likely killed her.
  4. The discovery of Phoenix’s body by a local search party, along with her dogs found with zip ties, indicated a premeditated and brutal murder, with evidence of planned violence.
  5. Fornier admitted to killing the dogs, claiming he wanted to see them die to spare them from euthanasia, but his story was undermined by the lack of poison in the alleged Gatorade and his inconsistent alibi.
  6. Prosecutors presented strong evidence, including Phoenix’s blood on Fornier’s truck, a shell casing, and ammunition matching the weapon used to kill her.
  7. Fornier was convicted of second-degree murder and charged separately with aggravated animal abuse, with no evidence of innocence despite legal challenges to the investigation process.
  8. The community honored Phoenix’s legacy by renaming a room at the Hoodland Bizarre the “Phoenix Room” and establishing it as a space for women’s support and anti-domestic violence advocacy.

Summary:

The disappearance of 61-year-old Susan Lane, known as Phoenix, in November 2024 near Mount Hood, Oregon, sparked both an official search and a powerful community response. Phoenix had lived in the remote, close-knit mountain community, known for its "mountain justice" culture, where locals look out for one another. Her friends and family raised red flags over her strained relationship with husband Michael Fornier, who had shown controlling behavior and denied being at home when she went missing.

Surveillance footage revealed Phoenix’s truck with her dogs near an auto part store, contradicting Fornier’s story of hitchhiking. Investigators found her body in the woods, killed with three gunshot wounds, and later discovered her dogs with zip ties, indicating a premeditated and cruel attack. Fornier, who initially claimed he was poisoned by Phoenix, was found guilty of second-degree murder after the prosecution presented blood evidence, a shell casing, and ammunition matching the murder weapon.

His defense focused on challenging the investigation process, but failed to overturn the evidence. He was also charged with aggravated animal abuse for the dogs’ deaths. The case highlighted the strength of community vigilance and support, with Phoenix’s legacy preserved through a dedicated room at the Hoodland Bizarre that promotes women’s empowerment and anti-domestic violence.

The story underscores how close-knit communities can respond to tragedy with compassion, while also exposing the dangers of domestic abuse and the consequences of deception.

FAQs

Susan Lane, known as Phoenix, was a 61-year-old woman who lived near Mount Hood in Oregon. She had moved to the area after falling in love with the wilderness and eventually bought a home nearby.

After not showing up for work at the Hoodlin Bizarre gift shop, Phoenix was reported missing. Her body was later found in the woods near her home, having been shot three times in the head, neck, and chest.

Yes, Michael Fournier was charged with second-degree murder. Investigators found evidence linking him to the crime, including Phoenix’s blood in his truck and a 22-caliber shell casing at his home.

The local community organized their own search efforts, especially in remote and off-beaten-tracks areas, believing officials were missing key trails. One resident, James Evans, found Phoenix’s body under a tarp near her house after a week of searching.

Investigators found Phoenix’s blood in Fournier’s truck, a shell casing in the driveway, and 22-caliber ammunition at his home. Additionally, security footage showed his truck driving with Phoenix’s dogs in the back before returning without them.

Fournier admitted to killing Phoenix’s dogs but denied killing her, claiming he did it because they would have been euthanized as wolf hybrids. He later changed his story about Phoenix poisoning him with Gatorade, which was found to contain no poison.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.