Go back

Playoff Rankings Reaction: Alabama Logic Loop, SEC Losses Don’t Count & Who’s Still Alive For CFP?

27m 34s

Playoff Rankings Reaction: Alabama Logic Loop, SEC Losses Don’t Count & Who’s Still Alive For CFP?

The host of the Joel Klatt Show critiques the college football rankings committee for making illogical, inconsistent decisions that appear to prioritize the SEC's dominance over actual team merit. He highlights how Alabama’s top ranking is undermined by Texas’s superior resume, including wins over top-12 teams and a stronger strength of schedule. The analysis reveals a self-perpetuating feedback loop where rankings shift arbitrarily—such as dropping Indiana after a loss despite a strong record—creating an Orwellian logic that dismisses real performance. The host identifies several playoff locks, including Georgia, Notre Dame, Miami, and Utah, due to their manageable schedules and win potential. Other teams like Indiana, Boise State, and Oregon are considered in the playoff bubble, where success depends on one or two key wins. The critique extends to the committee’s apparent refusal to accept objective evidence, instead relying on arbitrary rules and subjective biases. Ultimately, the host calls for transparency and accountability, asserting that the rankings system fails to reflect reality and undermines the integrity of college football evaluation. He concludes with a call for fans to question the process and remain vigilant in assessing team performance beyond rankings.

Transcription

5041 Words, 26416 Characters

English
Jagermeister knows that there's people who watch the game, and people who know the game. Knowers know rivalries aren't heated, they're ice cold. They know rankings change, traditions don't. And they know that when you drink Jagermeister on game day, you drink it ice cold. Otherwise you just don't know the game. So drink it ice cold, or don't drink it at all. Jagermeister. Damn that's cold. Drink responsibly. Jagermeister liqueur, 35% alcohol by volume. Imported by Mass Jagermeister US, White Plains, New York. Take the crayons away from the committee. I feel like we're in an Orwell novel right now. The committee is basically insisting that we reject the evidence right before our eyes. Right in front of our faces. Play hard against Chattanooga. Chattanooga. No, that's not a joke. Hey, welcome into the program. It's the Joel Klatt Show. I'm Joel Klatt. This show is. Brought to you by Hilton. Hilton for the stay. And we thank them for their support, as always. I have. I have rankings here. And we're going to react. We're going to react to them. All right. You ever. Are you ever in the car with your spouse, significant other. And you know you took a wrong turn. And. You know, your spouse might be like, why did you turn here? And you're like, no, it's, you know. Because it's the fastest way. And everyone in the car knows that you took a wrong turn. And you just won't admit it. That's kind of how I feel like. I feel like I'm in the backseat of a car right now. And the driver is just like, yes, this is the fastest way. And we're all like, no. No, it's not. Let's jump into. Let's see what we've got here. Here's what they gave us. Okay. Ole Miss down six spots after getting beat. They stay in the top 25. Avi. Florida jumps in there. They're 24. Louisville, 23. Oklahoma, big Sunday win. Big Sunday team. They were super thrilled about it, too. They were, like, super cordial about it. South Carolina obviously stays in there at 21. Listen, you don't just play Arkansas, a six-loss team. Okay. Like, that's just a great loss, obviously. Houston's 20. Arizona jumps up, by the way. And I'm here for it. Up four. Biggest jump after a loss in history, I believe. And I was there for the game. And that was an awesome game. Awesome environment. I believe that to be true. I do think. And plus, Arizona, their three losses now are to three teams in the top 12. Tech, BYU, and Utah. And they had the lead late in the game in every single one of those instances. I think that's what's going to happen. So then we've got Arizona. We've got SC in there at 18 after the loss. Boise, they're a prime position for the group of six. They're sitting there at 17. Kentucky loses, drops down to 16. Then you get this trio of Big Ten teams. I thought it was interesting because Oregon and Ohio State both kind of jumping Iowa. So not a tough one. Yeah. I think it's going to happen. Yeah. So not a ton of great wins for Iowa, even though they just continue to do Iowa things. And they're sitting there with a great chance to go 10-2, Iowa at 15. By the way, folks, they lost a game that they should never have lost at Minnesota, and that's got to be just killing them right now because they're that loss away from being right in the mix. Ohio State, they jumped way up there. Apparently now we're in. We're in on Luke Fahey. Yeah, we're in. We're back in on the Buckeyes. They jump up huge. up six to 14, and then Oregon. And Oregon's interesting, man. Like, they're up three spots. They're playing really well. More on that in a little bit. Then you get into the top 12. Tech is sitting there, first team out, clear path to the Big 12 championship game, so control their own destiny. Wake, clear path to the ACC championship game. They control their own destiny, and right now they would be the first team in. BYU needs some help to get to the Big 12 championship game, but with the win over Notre Dame, they're sitting there with two losses at 10. then Tennessee at 9, Indiana and Tennessee actually flip-flop, so Indiana is at 8, Miami 7, Notre Dame 6, Texas at 5, UCLA at 4, whatever it is we have at 3, I don't even know, Utah at 2, and Georgia at 1. Let's get started. All right. Why is Alabama at 3? Oh, because the SEC is really tough in their strength of schedule. Got it. Okay. Why is the SEC so tough, and why is their strength of schedule so tough? Well, you know, because they're number three. Right, right, right. Okay, so why is Alabama number three? Well, obviously the SEC is so tough. Got it. Why is the SEC so tough? Well, because Alabama's number three. Do you see the feedback loop? Do you see the echo chamber that we're building? Well, there's nine teams ranked. Got it. Why are nine teams ranked? Well, because the SEC is so tough. So we're perpetually in this. We've got the driver that took the wrong turn, doesn't want to admit that they went the wrong direction, so they're just driving aimlessly right now through the woods, and we're all wondering if we're just on a back road, dirt road, and we're ever going to get to our destination. I think we will. We've got South Carolina losing by 28 to 3-6 Arkansas. And they're 21st in the country? Why? To prop up Alabama. Obviously. Obviously. It's just right before our eyes. I don't understand that at all. At all. And then you get to kind of more of the specifics on the Alabama ranking. And again, this is the driver that took the wrong turn and just will not admit. Just stubborn, stubborn, stubborn. Hey, are we going to be on time? Oh, yeah, we're going to be on time. Is this a shorter way? Oh, yeah, it's definitely a shorter way. This is a shortcut, actually. I didn't take a wrong turn. This is a shortcut because you're all stupid and I'm smart. I mean, that's where we're at right now because here we are. Two spots behind Alabama is Texas, and Texas's resume is so, so much better than Alabama's. It's not even, candidly, I mean, it's not even directly comparable. They have better wins they have a better strength of schedule they have a better record over teams that are 500 or above all of those things all of those things they're both eight and two their best wins Bama is now Kentucky and South Carolina who just got the hinges blown off of their front door by Arkansas I mean wins versus teams above 500 Alabama's four and two not shabby like I'm not saying that they shouldn't be in the top 10 I have them at eight eight is the right spot seven would be like a little high eight's perfect nine would be a little bit low um and then the best wins obviously Kentucky South Carolina for Bama Texas beat Tennessee and Ohio State a Tennessee team that beat Alabama. There's no comparing those two resumes. You took a wrong turn. You're telling us it's a shortcut and now you're just stubborn. I get it. Prideful, competitive. I get it. A lot of strong personalities. You're wrong. You're wrong. Everybody knows it. Everybody. If you look at the logic that they used last week, Remember, you know, Indiana got dropped, what was it, five spots last week. And we were like, wow, that was an off week. So from Kurt Cignetti's recliner, he got dropped five spots. And maybe they're just unhappy with the way Kurt Cignetti has talked about them. I know that they listen, by the way. I know that for a fact. Last week, all five of 8-1 Indiana's best wins lost. and that was the rationale that was given to us all by the party, by the committee, sorry, not the party, the committee. And the Hoosiers had a bye week. They dropped five spots from four to nine. So at one point, this committee thought Indiana was the fourth best team. Then all of a sudden, that's right, never going to stop. I took the wrong turn, never coming back. And they went to nine. And now they move up one spot after getting a fairly good win by the committee's rankings, 18 USC, which is, by the way, right next to the best win for Alabama, which is 16 Kentucky. Maybe not right next to, you get it one spot apart. This week, all five of eight and two, Alabama's best wins, lost. While the tide looked very average, very average. Offense was not great. Was Keelan Russell going to play? Was he not? Yeah, but hey, it was in the SEC. Well, why is that good? well because nine teams are ranked yeah but why were nine teams ranked well because the sec is really good i okay i understand that but why is the sec well because nine teams are ranked oh oh see i didn't get it the first time thank you for clarifying same exact logic not applied this week was applied last week so they're not consistent they're stubborn we're on the dirt roads. Everyone knows it's not a shortcut except for them. And here we are very stubborn. It's basically like this. The committee, I feel like we're in an Orwell novel right now. The committee is basically, basically insisting that we reject the evidence right before our eyes, right in front of our faces. It is like their most essential command folks. It's like that. We, we can't what's right in front of us i see the resume between alabama and texas so like i said i'm this is not even an anti-sec argument because the team that's getting screwed in the alabama deal is texas their resume is better they both have two losses tennessee getting screwed by the alabama ranking they beat alabama and then obviously you've got indiana sitting there they're eighth in the country and they're 25 and one in their last 26 games and by the way i think is getting credit because they barely lost to georgia well with a fully healthy ohio state team which was a top two team in the country indiana lost by four inches so none of it makes sense they're they're asking us to suspend our ability to think and to see and to rationally look at this they're asking us to suspend all of our faculties and just believe what they give us and i refuse to do that um let's move on to the big 12 because now you've got utah at two after that huge win over arizona that was a great game by the way i'm still kind of on cloud nine after calling that game that was as fun a game as i've called in a long time so utah gets the win on the road byu is 10 and tech is sitting there at 12 um i i think there is a legitimate chance obviously for two because if if things hold where they're at you're going to get two teams in with byu and then they're going to win the champ in this case it would be utah but by the way you know there's still hope for a third because tech could actually win the conference championship they've got a clean path towards the conference championship and if they were to win like let's say over a utah utah would stay in and then tech would be in there and then maybe byu is still in there so this is what the bracket would look like boise would visit texas winner would play ucla wake would visit notre dame i wouldn't want that if i was notre dame by the way wake is an absolute wagon winner would play alabama because obviously alabama deserves a bye obviously guys we're on the dirt road it's a shortcut tennessee would now have to go on the road this week after flipping the eight nine spot with indiana they would go to bloomington and the winner would face georgia and then byu would travel to miami and the winner would go and face utah in a bowl game so that's how it kind of pans out and then then you've got that trio of big 10 teams and that's the last thing that i would i would say on this is like oregon is sitting there just kind of lurking at 13 and and we kind of talked about this on on monday's program if you haven't listened to monday's program go back and listen to monday's program right here on youtube you can go you can subscribe to the channel that would be awesome we would really appreciate it you can leave a comment down below um do you believe we're in or in an orwellian novel it kind of feels like we are to me um but you know that's just me i think that there is a lot of people that are going to be interested in there is one team that has a real chance as a nine and three pending what happens with tennessee pending what happens obviously with wake in their last few ball games byu with their last few ball games um you know texas tech in there as well oregon does not need a ton of chaos they basically need like a standard amount of college football chaos and they could be right in this thing as an at-large ohio state doesn't really have that avenue at least in my estimation why because they lost then lost to ohio state so they went with you know who won those head-to-heads right there in order but i guess that doesn't apply in the top 10 by the way i'll get to this in the tears but like what would get them to move alabama off of that spot because i guess it's gonna have to be a loss so play hard against chattanooga and that chattanooga no that's real that's who they're playing this week no that's not a joke you might have been wondering that here's what i want to do now i want to look at i want to because there's only so much of my ranting and raving that you guys probably want to hear you're like yeah joel like we get it you know we get it um i want to play a little game and it's called a who's still alive for a playoff spot and i'm going to do this in tears i think that there are a few teams right now that are just locks based on the schedule they have in front of them the quality of their team i just don't see them falling out of a playoff spot so we're going to have a category of locks and i'm going to do this in tears i think that there are a few teams we're going to have a category for teams that i think are comfortably right now kind of in the playoff now you know could that get a little dicey possibly but right now they're comfortably in the playoff then we'll get to kind of the bubble teams where you know probably have to win every one of their games and then we're going to get the to the uh so you're telling me there's a chance um so lloyd christmas will join the show and he'll be in there i'd say more like one in a million okay how do you guarantee your jaeger meister is always ice cold well you could move to antarctica sure frostbite is a thing your dating apps won't let you set your radius to 3 000 miles and your neighbor is an emperor penguin who honks outside your ablue or you could just keep your jaeger meister in the freezer drink it cold or don't drink it at all jaeger meister damn that's cold drink responsibly jaeger meister liquor 35 alcohol by volume imported by mass jaeger meister u.s white plains new york playoff spots let's start with locks first here's basically what i went with on this i was trying to define it and define it cleanly but here are my locks georgia notre dame miami and utah and the reason being is because i i believe that all of them just need to win another football game just one more football game and based on the schedules in front of them i absolutely believe them capable to do that and will do that so i do not see a world in which these four teams are not in this year's football playoff these are my locks let's start with georgia they're the best team in the country i i think georgia is fantastic i think their defense is excellent they've got an ridiculously experienced and quality quarterback gunner stockton plays well in the fourth quarter when he needs to um and they're they're a lock you know they've got one more league game if they can beat who do they play i think it's south carolina this week i think it's south carolina which you never know that's a ranked south carolina team so you never know because you know arkansas is so good notre dame has the win over miami so i think 10 and 2 gets them in and with the teams that they have coming up i don't see them they have a buffer 10 and 2 gets them in they're gonna win another football game they're a lock they're in notre dame is in miami i can't see it happening where they all of a sudden slide totally out because we've seen them without tony they went on the road against notre dame and played pretty well had a chance late in that game they're going to win again they're likely going to play for the acc championship miami's going to the playoff i think they're going to win again they're likely going to play for the acc championship i know that they're seven right now the committee doesn't respect them as much as alabama obviously alabama beat kentucky and south carolina but you get where i'm going with that in miami they've got virginia tech they're 20 point favorites boston college they'll be more than 20 point favorites i don't see them falling out of this thing and then utah is the same same thing now on paper you can say like oh their games might be a little bit dicier they've got a 500 tcu team and a 500 west virginia team west virginia can play great offense with michael hawkins tcu can play great defense in the big 12 so like is there a scenario where utah doesn't win out maybe i just don't see it why because last week i saw a team that was coming off of their most emotional win maybe ever in the only top 10 holy war in history and they went on the road to face a ranked arizona team had to travel the day of they did all the things stayed focused and won so i don't see them all of a sudden taking some sort of slide i believe morgan scali is is too good of a coach so i think utah is a lock those are my locks now we get to kind of the comfortably in uh section i really should have put bama in there because why because they're bama and this committee loves them and then they took the dirt road and like they're you know they're just not gonna say that they're wrong this committee is such an outlier and i'm sorry guys i i think that you're i really like you all as people you're not doing a very good job someone take the crayons away from the committee like this is incredible i feel like i'm playing cards with my brother's kids that's another movie bam i love it all right comfortable tier sorry i'll get to it we want content here we go ucla i believe is comfortable right now um i think bama is comfortably and i think indiana even though the committee hates them maybe they just hate kurt signetti i think boise state is kind of comfortable and texas is comfortable basically the way i would define comfortable is i think it's comfortable and i think it's comfortable and i think it's comfortable i think you just need to win one more maybe you need to do a little bit more than that but that's kind of where i'm at ucla the problem with that is you could say well they've just got michigan and then they've got usc yeah well michigan still plays as good a defense as any now they didn't last week against oregon but ucla is going to have to go on the road they need to go out there and get that win one win ucla is in they'll be in indianapolis to play for the big 10 championship and if you do that if you do that yeah you'll be in uh bama would be in there because the committee loves them i they probably could lose a couple more and they might go up to two so maybe they're just a lock at this point i do think that they're in good shape my only this is actually like more realistic not based on what the committee is saying i know that they ranked them number three they're overrated and here's the here's the thing they play auburn and that's one of those games as you know i've been watching the saban doc man it's so good it's so good um that's a game that you just throw everything out and we know that. I cover Michigan, Ohio State. That's the case. Red River, that's the case. A lot of those rivalry games. And certainly the Iron Bowl is that. It's one of the great rivalries in all of college football. There's no doubt. And so you still have to win a great rivalry game. Because if you don't, now granted, will the committee still love you? Probably. And they'll probably just throw Mississippi State in there at 25 just because. Because with Camario, they were good. But the problem with that is that then you would be directly compared with Tennessee because you would fall out of that pod that the committee uses. And then you would start getting compared with teams. And it's like, I don't know. So that's why I put them in comfortable and not a lock. But we'll see where that goes. Indiana, I believe, is comfortable because they're in a position to get themselves to the Big Ten championship game. One more win, maybe two more wins. You look at their schedule. They got Washington and Purdue. They only have the one loss. It was against a full-strength Ohio State team by four inches. At some point, the committee is going to have to. Like the coaches on the committee. Guys, I know you. I covered you. You know who you are. You know. He's 25-1 in his last 26 games. Somebody, like, somebody raised your hand. Somebody raised your hand, right? And so that team is very close. They beat Washington. They likely go to Indianapolis. They've got Purdue. Like, I love their defense. I think it's one of the best things that anybody does in college football. Georgia's defense. Indiana's defense. When Tony is healthy, Miami's offense. Dampier, Smith. Like, those are the best things right now in college football. And Indiana has one of those things. So I think that they're right there. Boise. I think Boise is comfortably in. They're going to host the Pac-12 championship. All they've got to do is win that, and they're in. So they're one game away. One game away. Texas. I think that they're comfortable, maybe even more than comfortable, because they've got so many quality wins. Now, I know it hasn't mattered in the comparison against Alabama, but they really do have so many quality wins. And they did something that all of us want rewarded, which is play the tough non-conference game in the non-conference. They played Ohio State. They beat Ohio State. Somebody, for the love of God, honor that. Put them above Alabama. My goodness, they're comfortably in. I think that if they were a 9-3, it might get dicey. I don't expect them to another one of these rivalry games, obviously. So we'll see there. Hey, college football season is in full swing. And this is the time of year when you start looking ahead at the games that you really want to go see in person. Once you pick the matchup, the next step is finding the best deal on tickets. And that's where SeatGeek comes in. With over 35 million downloads, SeatGeek is the number one rated ticketing app with more than 70,000 events listed across sports, concerts, festivals, and more. I love you. SeatGeek. SeatGeek.com. I think you have to win out. I think a loss would be catastrophic to any of these teams. So these are your bubble teams. If you win out, you're likely in. Certainly for Tech and Wake, that is the case. If you win out, you're going to be in. I can't totally say that about BYU because of this wrinkle where if Tech and Wake both went out, now all of a sudden, that's right, Boise would jump in there or the group of five team, group of six team, excuse me. And if Tennessee were to win out, somebody's got to be knocked out. It's not going to be Miami. And it likely wouldn't be Indiana. Is it BYU? So BYU is in a bit of a precarious spot because they could win out and still not go, but I don't think that'll be the case. So, excuse me, these are your bubble teams right now. If they win out, they're likely in the playoff and then you get to your, so you're telling me there's a chance teams. There's a few of them. Oregon's number one on this list. And I think we know that based on the rankings. They're 13th. Any amount of chaos up there, Tech loses a game. Wake loses a game. BYU loses a game. Tennessee, maybe I would be interested in seeing the, like the resume battle of Tennessee and Oregon. Although based on the way that this committee is like deeply, deeply in love with the SEC, I doubt Oregon would win that resume battle, but I think it would be interesting. They do have the win over Ohio state on the road. Ohio state is in there because there's a path to the big 10 championship game. There's a path for Oregon to the big 10 championship game as well. And at least you're getting a team that went out and beat a Northwestern team. And so maybe they're getting a little bit of their mojo. I'll be on the call for the Nebraska game this week as Ohio state goes on the road to Lincoln. Iowa is in there. I think they're going to be a 10 and two. You never know the type of chaos. They've also got a sliver of a path to Indianapolis, USC sliver of a path to Indianapolis. And then you get some of the group of six teams. And these are the teams that all they need is a Boise loss. And then Katie bar the door. Here we go. Liberty. I think Liberty should have been ranked over some of those four loss SEC teams, but who am I? Nobody. Apparently I'm just the guy in the backseat knowing that we took the wrong turn and it's not a shortcut. That's all. That's the only, that's me. Liberty's nine. And one conference USA, Memphis and UTSA likely, and we'll probably play each other in the American championship. So if Liberty can win their conference, Boise loses, maybe Liberty gets in there, Memphis or UTSA when their conference Boise loses, then they could jump in there. So those are kind of the teams with a chance from the group of six. So that's where we stand folks. I know, listen, it's redundant. I get it. I get it. And apologies for that. We're coming back with picks and previews tomorrow. I am. Listen, all you have to do is fade me and you are on fire right now. So congratulations. If you guys picked up on that and you're doing it slow clap, pick some previews coming up tomorrow, subscribe to the show. Uh, if you would just follow us on social media, wherever you like to social media, you can rate review us wherever we're at and leave a comment, down below. Was that a fair amount of criticism? Was it too much criticism? You'd be the judge comment down below. I'll try to jump in. See you tomorrow. This episode is brought to you by state farm. Football has a play for just about everything. You can go deep, keep it on the ground or draw up something nobody sees coming. And whether you want to run a flea flicker or the tush push, you need a plan to fit your unique situation. That's why state farm takes the time to get to know you so they can for your life and budget. Now that's a solid game plan. Like a good neighbor. State farm is there.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. The speaker criticizes the college football rankings committee for inconsistent, illogical decisions that appear to ignore objective team performance and resume strength.
  2. Alabama is ranked high despite Texas having a stronger, more balanced resume with better wins against top teams and a superior strength of schedule.
  3. The rankings system is described as a self-perpetuating echo chamber, where teams like Indiana and South Carolina are demoted despite strong records and defensive quality.
  4. The rankings appear to prioritize SEC strength over actual merit, creating a feedback loop that undermines fairness and rational analysis.
  5. Teams like Utah, Boise State, and Texas are seen as having legitimate playoff chances due to strong schedules and quality wins, even if currently underappreciated.
  6. The speaker argues that the committee’s decisions lack transparency and demand accountability, comparing the process to an Orwellian regime.
  7. A "who's still alive" analysis identifies Georgia, Notre Dame, Miami, and Utah as playoff locks due to their schedules and win potential.
  8. Teams such as Indiana, Boise State, and Oregon hover in the playoff bubble, relying on a single win or favorable outcomes to secure a spot.

Summary:

The host of the Joel Klatt Show critiques the college football rankings committee for making illogical, inconsistent decisions that appear to prioritize the SEC's dominance over actual team merit. He highlights how Alabama’s top ranking is undermined by Texas’s superior resume, including wins over top-12 teams and a stronger strength of schedule. The analysis reveals a self-perpetuating feedback loop where rankings shift arbitrarily—such as dropping Indiana after a loss despite a strong record—creating an Orwellian logic that dismisses real performance.

The host identifies several playoff locks, including Georgia, Notre Dame, Miami, and Utah, due to their manageable schedules and win potential. Other teams like Indiana, Boise State, and Oregon are considered in the playoff bubble, where success depends on one or two key wins. The critique extends to the committee’s apparent refusal to accept objective evidence, instead relying on arbitrary rules and subjective biases.

Ultimately, the host calls for transparency and accountability, asserting that the rankings system fails to reflect reality and undermines the integrity of college football evaluation. He concludes with a call for fans to question the process and remain vigilant in assessing team performance beyond rankings.

FAQs

Alabama is ranked third due to the strength of the SEC, which is considered tough and has a strong schedule. However, critics argue this creates a feedback loop where the rankings appear inconsistent and may not reflect actual team performance.

Texas has a stronger resume with wins over top teams and a better strength of schedule. Critics point out that Alabama's ranking overlooks these factors, suggesting the rankings may be biased or inconsistent.

The committee's rankings can appear arbitrary or illogical, especially when teams like Indiana or Texas are moved without clear justification. Critics argue this undermines rational analysis and viewer trust.

Yes, teams like Georgia, Utah, and Notre Dame are considered playoff locks because they have strong schedules and are confident in winning one more game to secure their playoff spot.

Indiana has a strong defense, a winnable path to the Big Ten championship, and a history of close wins. Critics believe they are close to the playoff, even if rankings fluctuate.

Texas has quality wins, including a strong victory over Ohio State, and a solid resume. The committee's rankings overlook these strengths, but the team's performance and schedule support playoff eligibility.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.