Patrick Gaspard: We Have to Keep the New Electoral Map
57m 36s
The transcript explores the evolving dynamics of American politics, emphasizing grassroots mobilization, vulnerability, and moral clarity in leadership. It highlights how Elon Musk’s past alignment with MAGA ideology contrasts sharply with his current distancing, reflecting public distrust in corporate political influence. In Mississippi, Senator-elect Scott Colombe’s campaign exemplifies effective community engagement through empathy, local partnerships, and symbolic gestures like the Nike Air Force One initiative for valedictorians, uniting Black and white voters. The discussion also underscores the importance of vulnerability in political leadership, noting that personal authenticity fosters deeper public trust. Foreign policy is framed as a moral issue, with voters rejecting authoritarianism and demanding accountability. The episode critiques performative politics, advocating for substance over spectacle, and calls for reforms like town hall debates to increase real voter engagement. It also reflects on the moral responsibilities of the U.S. in global affairs, citing the plight of deported individuals in South Sudan as a reminder that foreign policy must prioritize human dignity. Ultimately, the narrative champions democratic resilience through inclusive, compassionate, and value-driven leadership—particularly in the face of political polarization and authoritarian threats.
Twas the night before Toyotathon and all through the land, not a creature was stirring, not even Jan, that's me.
Winter plans were made, skiing, skating, hiking, and more, and they came to fruition with Tundras, Camrys, BZs, and RAV4s.
In bed, dreaming of the places they'd gone, everyone knew Toyotathon is on.
Dealer inventory may vary. Current offers on these vehicles end November 30th.
Offers are subject to change throughout Toyotathon, which ends on January 4th.
See your participating Toyota dealer for details.
Toyota, let's go places.
Hello and welcome to the Bulwark Daily. I'm your host, Tim Miller.
Delighted to welcome you back to the show.
He was National Political Director for Barack Obama's 2008 campaign, served as Ambassador to South Africa in his second term.
He was an informal advisor to Zoran Mamdani's mayor race, and more recently advised the campaign of
Senator-elect Scott Colombe. It's Patrick Gaspard. How you feeling, buddy?
I feel amazing, Tim. Thanks so much for having me back on in this new America.
It is really good. It's good to see you. You were with us in Dayton for the fundraiser we did for the Haitians.
I want to talk a little bit more about that at the end, but we got to do a little news at the start, all right?
This one's delicious. Can we just continue to keep treating ourselves at the very beginning?
You won't believe how much all of these people will never have been for this when it comes to MAGA.
And you can already see it coming. You can already see it happening.
And Elon Musk yesterday was zooming in to the dealbook summit, and there's one clip from it that's so delicious.
We just got to start there. Let's listen.
I'm not MAGA. Well, at least I'm not like, I'm not sure what MAGA means, but I don't think I'm like,
if that means sort of blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican Party, then I certainly don't have that.
I think there are positive things.
I think there are positive and negatives in both parties.
Oh, really?
Oh, really?
That's a change.
That is so rich. This is a man who not that long ago described himself as dark MAGA.
He spent over a billion dollars in a handful of years to try to elect their candidates,
including the too much money in the Wisconsin Supreme Court race, $500 million on their midterms.
He worked for MAGA. He worked literally in the Trump administration, dismantling our,
and he called it an existential threat if you are not for MAGA.
Now, all of a sudden, after an ass whooping, he's not MAGA.
It's really quite extraordinary.
He had his own merch, the dark MAGA merch.
Like, once you've got the merch, you know, you're kind of associated with the brand.
Have you ever seen the movie Inglourious Bastards?
I have seen the movie.
You probably know the scene I'm about to bring up.
But look, I want to welcome, you helped with the Mississippi race.
It's important to welcome MAGA voters into the fold.
People who have come.
People who have come to their senses.
People who have changed their point of view.
That's great.
But for, you know, for some of the generals, I am tempted to not let them get away with this.
The baseball bat's coming, isn't it?
Yeah, well.
Are you the bear here?
Yeah, kind of.
There's a scene in Inglourious Bastards where they, you know, I guess the American government
cuts the deal with the Nazi general, the little fella, and Brad Pitt's the rogue American.
And he gets him in the woods, the Nazi general.
And he's like.
And he's like, you know, you cut that deal and that's fine.
I'm not going to kill you.
Well, you're going to go back to America.
But I guess when you go to America, you won't be wearing this SS uniform anymore.
And the guy kind of just stares at him.
And then Brad Pitt goes, I want to make sure people are going to remember that you were
in the SS uniform.
Then he carves the swastika into his forehead.
I kind of want to carve the dark MAGA hat into Elon's hat.
I'd be like, sorry, brother.
This isn't working for you.
This was you.
I think that with the death of the Cybertruck and when you see, you know, where things are
have been headed for Tesla, it's carved into him.
It's permanent.
People, people ain't forgetting this.
And I want to I want to remind Elon Musk that in our campaigns across the country, not only
did we run against MAGA and Donald Trump, we specifically ran against Elon Musk and
his money.
And a lot of folks, including a lot of men that Elon Musk thinks he identifies with,
recoiled from his brand and moved to something else.
So I was in Austin on Monday on Election Day, and I thought it was maybe the most powerful
part of Tallarico and Hinojosa's closing message was talking about how Texas wasn't for sale.
And this guy, he's like trying to buy their land.
He's trying to put the data centers there.
And now he's trying to buy their very own senator and people aren't going to stand for
it.
And you just could feel a real visceral reaction to that from the crowd.
Tallarico on the campaign.
We talked about this a little yesterday.
He was like, I don't have anything against Tesla or Elon's businesses.
It's just like this type of, you know, an attempt to buy our state, our country, our
government.
People don't want it.
It's like, sorry.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Tallarico and Hinojosa came off as unbought and unbossed in this cycle, which is very,
very different than not only Paxton, but a previously popular governor of Texas, one
assumed was sailing towards.
Another coronation, but everyone saw him kind of foreclosing towards Musk and company and
the data centers and all those things.
Yes.
Yeah.
A hundred percent.
Well, it's delicious.
I'm so glad that you spiked the football on Elon Musk this morning.
It's a good, it's a good thing.
I mean, he's not MAGA.
I'm sorry.
You're still testifying.
You might not be MAGA anymore, but you're still testifying and I look forward to it.
Lawyer Rob.
Yeah.
JBL said pack a lunch.
We got a lot of questions.
It's going to be a long, long few days on Capitol Hill for you.
All right.
The other news.
And we're going to go deep on this tomorrow with one of our favorite, most optimistic,
always positive foreign policy correspondence.
But I, it would be remiss to just at least mention it this morning.
So Trump had the trilateral meeting with Putin and she last night, as Bill Kristol called
it this morning in the newsletter, the world's worst throuple.
And there's this video of Trump going and like meeting Putin and he comes in and you
just see like beaming on his face and he's like,
who is he teasing with him?
That's my friend.
Nice to see you.
You know, just kind of like seeing your college roommates that you haven't had this got to
see in a decade.
I, he just was so excited and it's just, it's pretty, I mean, it's sad and it's all, it's
embarrassing.
It's sad.
It brings up a lot of emotions, but, but what are your kind of reactions to what we're saying
in Shenzhen?
Nothing turns on Donald Trump more than an autocrat or a redecoration project.
Like these are, these, these are the things that, that, uh,
that, that, that sails his boat and, uh, it's, it's still astonishing to see all these years
later, right?
When he came on the scene a decade ago and he was sending bouquets to the North Korean
leader, the Russian leader, the Chinese, Turkish leader, et cetera.
Uh, it seemed like a weird aberration that we just really couldn't make sense of.
We understood that, um, Americans, Democrats, Republicans, independents were concerned about
the amount of money we were spending overseas, the partnerships we had, the endless wars,
et cetera.
But it seemed like such a,
bizarre anti-democratic stretch to say, Hey, we're actually making common cause with these
people.
Uh, and 10 years later, it's, it's no less shocking now than it was, uh, then, uh, and
it's clear that, um, there is no, no Trump 2.0.
He can't like, he can't reset even after, uh, the butt kicking that he got, uh, in the
midterm elections.
And even though it's clear, abundantly clear that everybody's rejecting this, uh, this
attraction that he has to, to these characters.
That's another kind of piqued my interest as I want to do a little more 2028 stuff later,
but just, just narrowly on foreign policy, you have these, some of these democratic guys
are calling you and asking you for thoughts on this.
And at some level, I do feel like the Harris got caught in a little bit of a trap on this,
you know, where she's just, I think rightly like trying to demonstrate that she wants
America to be strong and that, you know, the, the caricature of a California progressive
isn't true.
And then like simultaneously also kind of trying to talk.
We're talking about how Trump is reckless and you don't know it's got right.
And it's, it's a little challenging, right?
It's challenging for a Democrat to both say, Hey, okay, when we take over, we are, we are
going to be strong and resolute.
And also we're not going to talk about the dictators.
We're not going to get into these stupid wars like Iran, you know, and you've, it's tough.
Like, you know, you, if you have the event with the generals, all of a sudden people
are like, well, wait a minute.
You know, I think that it turned off some, some voters who were attracted to like the
08 Obama message, which was more conciliatory.
And so I, you know, but there are going to be big challenges like receding from the world
is one thing that's like easy to say, but like, it's going to be really hard to do that
in the 2029.
It's going to be so many problems in the world.
So I don't know what, what's your advice to Democrats?
I kind of navigate all that.
Look, there, there will always be many, many, many problems in the world.
And when you're running to be the head of the armed forces of the most powerful military
that's ever existed on this planet, you have to have a theory of the case for the use of
power.
You just have to, but we have to also, you know, we have to have a theory of the case
of the use of power.
We have to have a theory of the case for the use of power.
We have to recognize that the economy is the prison through which Americans are judging
literally everything that we do now.
And foreign policy is subject to that more than it's ever been, particularly after endless
wars and tariffs and all the recklessness that we've seen and how we've entered into
spaces and pulled out of spaces, right?
So foreign policy is now part of domestic politics.
And the economy is how folks are going to judge the success or failure of your
your forum.
policy. And there continues to be something compelling. I hate to say it. There's still
something compelling about Trump's America first message. But America first is really just about
outcomes that folks are feeling at the pocketbook, at the kitchen table, and in this economy that
has veered for them from an industrial economy to a service economy to now an information economy
in a dizzying way that they can't understand. And they need somebody to help them to figure
it out. And they appreciate that the partnerships that we have around trade should accrue to their
benefit, but haven't been. And they're profoundly concerned about how we have spiraling costs on
gasoline and foodstuffs as a consequence of the decisions that we're making about conflicts that
are 10,000 miles away. So all of that to say, you have to have a theory of the case in power,
but it's got to be grounded in basic economic
outcomes for Americans. And they have to feel as if you are somehow making their children safer
and that you're not just engaged in one reckless intervention after another.
But there's another element here, Tim. Trump's foreign policy has clearly been driven by self-dealing.
So for a lot of folks, when they think about foreign policy, they see corruption in it.
They see a kind of cabal of elites who are getting something out of all these deals that's not working out for
them. So there's a way that the economy and corruption and the use of force all come together
in the story that we have to tell going forward. And I think that we kind of scotched all of that
in 2024. There's an Atlantic story out today. We're trying to get into more tomorrow, too,
about Jared Kushner's corruption and involvement in these deals and where he's making money from.
So I agree with that from a messaging standpoint. I do wonder, just like kind of looking just really
quick on that 2024 side of it, you know, with the with the benefit of hindsight, was there a
tangible way you think that the vice president could have handled, could have navigated that
balance better? She had a very short on-ramp. With every question from from that campaign,
you have to deal with the reality that Joe Biden shouldn't have been running. He should have bowed
out after the successful 2022 midterms and said, I'm not going to run again. And we should have
had a robust primary, which Kamala Harris might have emerged from, but she would have been a
force stronger candidate with a clear identity distinguished from Joe Biden.
across the board uh on issues i do think that they misread the room on foreign policy entire
entirely and because she's a woman they were trying to like put on the martial guard on her
yeah they're way overcompensated and it's just not where the country was at
and i don't think it's where the country is going to be at two years from now
all right y'all here's the thing if you have life insurance you're probably overpaying
if you don't have life insurance you should yeah there are only a few certainties in life
after all so one way to resolve this is to check out our friends at select quote they fix all your
problems they fix it if you're overpaying they fix it if you've been letting this one slide by
as life insurance brokers select quotes license agents compare over 100 life insurance products
from a bunch of trusted carriers and find you a better rate for free select quote giving life
insurance is fast free and easy the whole process takes about 15 minutes
answer a few questions their agents shop the carriers for you and you get your quote tailored
to your specific situation even if you've got something like high blood pressure or diabetes
you'll save an average of 30 so that's a good deal like i tell you on a lot of these products
i'm only interested in it if it's quick if it's easy life's too short for paperwork uh select quote
they make it nice and easy for you it's not really you know you're not always like boy how
excited am i to think about death
and so you want to make get it over with you want to be responsible you want to save yourself some
cash and have a reliable carrier to help you out get your free quote at select quote.com slash
bulwark that's select quote.com slash bulwark they shop you save all right let's talk about
mississippi mississippi let's talk about mississippi let's just go back to the beginning
like how did you get involved with scott where'd you know him from like what made you have belief
in this
so so i first met scott when i was uh senator-elect cologne uh when i was in philanthropy and he had
just become a uh prosecutor in this new uh era of prosecutors who are trying to find figure out how
to have a equitable application of the law to keep all communities safe met very briefly during some
policy discussion then always had an eye on him because his talent was abundantly apparent uh from
in the first instance uh and i have been personally obsessed with mississippi like my whole life and
i've been obsessed with mississippi since 2008 when i started working on the obama campaign and i saw
that despite the fact that we didn't put a dime in mississippi uh and never went to mississippi
didn't talk about mississippi barack obama got close to 44 percent of the vote in that election
which kind of astonished me uh and i started paying a lot more attention to local and state
elections in mississippi and saw people like mike sb and brandon presley closing the gap slowly but
surely uh and i remembered how people like me were ridiculed the very first time we started putting
money in states like georgia and north carolina because we could see what the trend lines were
and i felt as if there were the right trend lines in mississippi to kind of bend uh the arc of
history ahead of its uh ahead of its time uh and i knew scott to be a really talented uh candidate
with inexhaustible energies uh and i've paid attention to cindy hyde smith who didn't have a
in the last six years that she was a senator is gaff prone uh and is seen in the state to be part
of the double dealing uh regime that exists so i just thought it was like the right candidate the
right moment uh and the the right uh environment that we had uh with the mistakes that donald trump
uh was making with the tariffs with the war uh etc uh and i started just you know popping on
down there to try to be as helpful uh as possible uh and uh no good deed goes on
punish so every time i volunteered scott would ask me to do more that's what happened i love that
i had right thompson on on friday and you know i mean he's just written so deeply and richly about
the history of mississippi and talked about it from his perspective and you know that was that
was one that was one of the most moving interviews that you've conducted tim and the segment of that
interview where he talks about what megger evers means uh in mississippi but throughout the whole
i just i still keep telling like strangers on the street i was like you have to listen to this
interview do you realize that his dad had a cross burned on his lawn in 1982 i was like 1982 it's
like what so anyway it's just i just create it just creates a stark perception of like what
you're trying to overcome like 82 just i don't know maybe this means i'm getting old but like
doesn't feel long ago there's something about 1968 feels long ago 1982 feels like yesterday kind of
tim this is a state that still had the confederate
symbol in its state flag six years ago so this is this is not this is not ancient history i know
there's a reason you know there's a reason why donald trump won that state by 23 points
in the election so yeah but i'm just kind of curious your perspective um on the symbolic
meaning of it you know for black folks in particular i don't know i just i wasn't
expecting mississippi to happen um as listeners now uh just unbelievably pleasantly surprised
i felt like texas was going to be this big symbolic victory for democrats because they'd been
so demoralized
we'd all been demoralized let's just be honest by trump winning again and it's like the idea that
have a good midterm but to have such a good winter that you could win texas this place that feels so
republican it was a big symbolic win the mississippi thing though because of the racial
component just carries i think so much more weight tim tim texas was important but texas
was about our politics mississippi is about our soul uh during the campaign scott would constantly
say there isn't anything wrong with mississippi that can't be fixed
but everything that's right in mississippi and i would extend that further to say that
uh when mississippi gets fixed america gets fixed we know the history uh we know how
deeply um painful uh it's been and we know what the struggles continue to be not just for
african americans in mississippi but for poor white folk as well mississippi will always rank
49th out of 49th or 50th uh in metrics across the board and economic outcomes health care
outcomes all the social uh indexes uh it is a state of struggle but it's also a state uh of like real
beauty and power uh and uh a narrative that that courses from the founding of this nation uh right
to uh this new moment of self-correction uh that we're going through uh and i think that scott
embodies that but more than scott the work of black and white volunteers together that said
this is a moment where we're going to send a message about who we are
uh today uh going forward that's really powerful and uh that that makes us all like pause uh and
reflect what were the volunteers whispering to you did people sometimes you're on a campaign
where the volunteers are whispering we believe we have this and other times it's like i feel like
this is the right thing to do you know we're showing up like what was the vibes so i i would
i would look at two points uh during the course of that campaign these are the two moments that
for me uh told told me that it was possible to win and it speaks to where mississippi's
themselves were the first moment is um immediately after the calais ruling i was down in jackson
mississippi the day after uh the supreme court ruling when thousands of african-americans
poured out into a civic center in Jackson to say, not on our watch. We're not going backwards.
We're putting the flag in the ground right now. I know that national Democrats and national donors
were not paying attention to that. But in that moment, I thought, hmm, I think there's going to
be a rights and justice surge that we're going to see from African-Americans across the board here.
And Scott's campaign saw an uptick in local contributions and local volunteers immediately,
immediately after the Supreme Court ruling, and they were able to sustain that through the fall.
The second moment for me was the Corinth moment, when Donald Trump comes down to Mississippi,
and he's campaigning for Cindy Hyde-Smith in a corner of the state that borders Tennessee.
And Scott Colombe did the thing that Democrats don't do. He ran towards the fire, and he went,
and he spent some real time talking to voters who were waiting for hours online to go see Donald
Trump. And he thought, you know what?
This is a great opportunity to listen and to demonstrate that I can extend
some grace and some humanity there. And he discovered that the folks on that line cared
about the same darn things that the folks in Jackson cared about, whether it was the data
centers, the flood cameras, the corruption that came up constantly from folks who were waiting
online to see Donald Trump. And again, it was a day where we saw an uptick in participation and
volunteers and contributions to that campaign.
Some unlikely sources. So you had two Americas, two American stories that we would think would be
in contestation with one another, but that actually were in communion with one another
on those two kind of temple moments in that campaign. And between then, the volunteers,
the activists in Mississippi were saying to me, folks like me, we're going to show the world
that Mississippi matters. We believe that we can see this thing through. We're not just doing this
as a symbolic exercise, but we're actually going to win this. And so I think that's a really good
thing. And I think that's a really good thing. And I think it's a really good thing.
that was a consistent thing. It was infectious.
We tweet to the vice president's campaign a little bit. So I do just in fairness should also say I
talked to her was maybe a couple days after that, and the clay ruling, and she'd been hearing from
people. And she was telling me she was like, Look, people are pissed, like there is going to be
major backlash and turnout. And I it wasn't that I disbelieved that it was kind of like, I want to
see it, you know what I mean? Because sometimes it's hard to separate like the
is this the activists that are already out there that are just matter? Or is this new people that
are mad, right? And that's like a meaningful different and it was the latter. It was
Tim, I'm glad you raised Vice President Harris in this context. I'll note that when others were
looking away from Mississippi, she came down to Mississippi and did what she could to turn out a
vote for for Scott Cologne. But I had a similar conversation with her after the Cali ruling,
and I'll make a confession here. She was asking me,
for some for some counsel, how she should talk about this. And I said to her, you know, I'm not
entirely sure. Madam Vice President, I think that folks are more focused on gas prices than they are
on this ruling. She disagreed with me, she was right. And she and she kind of got me to be much
more aware of what was happening. And I decided I need to spend more time on the ground because
she's seeing something here that the rest of us are missing. So, you know, tip of the cap to Vice
President Harris on that. No doubt.
You mentioned that him going to the MAGA rally, talking to people on the street. To me, that was
by far the best and most meaningful ad. Had a little bit of a hint of Zoran, too, was who was
doing that. We'll get to that in a second. But the ad that everybody, all the politicos like to talk
about, because it's so funny, was the pick another senator ad. And Scott was tweeting about how like
you guys were talking and that was the OG of the origination of that ad. So anyway, I just figured
maybe you'd give us a little bit of time to talk about that.
I'm happy to take the blame. That was a lot of fun. I knew that it could get attention. I did not
know that it would go supernova. And I'll tell you, I mean, the guy, the guy that drops the first
sheet, I mean, you couldn't, you couldn't make that happen, Patrick. But I will tell you, Tim,
that in the first draft of that script, I wrote about six eyes and shit. So, you know,
that was a directional thing that was happening there. But so here's the full
question on the ad. I saw I saw polling that showed Cindy Hyde-Smith was underwater in a state
where even, you know, Donald Trump's approval was collapsing, even in Mississippi. Cindy Hyde-Smith
was below his number in the state. And yet at the same time, about 55 percent of Mississippians
did not know that she had an opponent. And I said to Scott at the time, we've got to figure
out some ways to shake this up. Attention is the only currency that matters.
And our politics, but I've got to do something that's going to be galvanizing. I had seen a video
from Ohio for Sherrod Brown, where the F word was dropped. I thought it's a great effect. And I
thought, let's figure out some way that we use some colorful language by Mississippi metrics.
And and let's use Cindy Hyde-Smith's own words against her, where she had this kind of
let them eat cake attitude when she said that Mississippians could just, you know,
pick other proteins that they couldn't afford.
So I said, let's clip that ad, that video for saying that. And let's do something colorful.
And then he has this great young videographer, Ryan Sales, who directed the ad, found the most
authentic volunteers that he could. And we and the campaign probably spent a thousand dollars
on that ad. And it was worth ten million dollars for the effort.
Shout out. Shout out to Ryan. The behind the scenes video of the direction is hilarious.
We'll put up your post because he posted it.
And it was like and it's like the guy the first time just doesn't have enough eyes and shit.
And Ryan's just like, he's dragging out a little bit. You see the guy like I gather himself like
he's, you know, he's a theater going out onto stage on Broadway. And he's like gathering
himself. He's locking in. And that just it's really good. It's really good.
So he's Russ has become a local celebrity now in Mississippi. But the but the example of that ad,
you know, we have to.
All appreciate that we live in a moment where politics is downstream of culture and attention
and bending the algorithms is what really matters, not the old metrics of positive and negative
on how we advertise. And so it was it was good fun.
His other viral moment now that he's senator elect was recently about a suggestion he made
on social media about Nike. And I like this for a lot of reasons. But just if anybody's missed this,
Scott tweeted Nike.
at this moment in Mississippi history, how about some custom-made Air Force Ones, my favorite shoe
for every valedictorian of Mississippi high schools this year, would encourage Mississippi
students to hit the books the rest of the year. Nike replied and said that they would provide it
for valedictorians of every valedictorian around the country this year. And then Scott was talking
about that a little bit. Now that he's up in DC, the TMZ guys grabbed him. Let's just play a clip
from that. Quickly, man, you got valedictorians, Nikes. You're rocking the J's right now. So how's
that feel? You haven't even started in office yet. Well, you know, here's the thing is what's
great about that is students all across the country get to compete to get some custom-made
Air Force Ones. Every student out there that's watching this, a lot of young people watch TMZ,
hit the books. Hit the books. I like this for a lot of reasons, but why don't you go first?
Well, I'll tell you.
On a personal level, Scott's campaign team was always trying to get him out of his Air Force
Ones when he went to church and chambers of commerce, but he stuck to them. But I love,
like, you know, here we're coming out of the dark MAGA period, and Scott is reaching out to
corporate partners and saying, you know what? Let's reward hard work. Let's make people feel
good about their efforts, and let's spread a little bit of goodwill here in this moment. So
it's a good little story in that respect.
Here's what I like about it. It ties to exactly what you just said. We spent the last two years
with Donald Trump bullying big business and cajoling them and pressuring them to do what?
Give him shit, right? Give him his new ballroom. Give me money to my ballroom. Give money to my
library. You know, we're going to go redesign the golf course in DC. And this shows that you can use
that there's just a flip side to that.
You can use your influence to cajole rich people, corporate America to do good for the community.
And that's the fucking job of public service.
It's just sneakers today, but it's going to ladder up into partnerships on infrastructure and
education and healthcare and all the things that is literally the job. It's not about self-dealing.
It's about community dealing. And it's like, what Scott did is brilliant. And you can tell
that Scott did that. Senator McClellan did that without turning.
He didn't turn to any of his advisors or seeking advice from a consultant. He just has like this
instinct towards good deeds. And that's what that was.
You're still a consultant. I'm a podcaster. I call them all by their first names.
No, no, no. I'm not. I'm not. I'm not. I'm not. I'm not a consultant.
I call them all by their first name still. It's fine. It is what it is. It's America.
But I want to give him a little bit more credit, right? I talked about the environment. I talked
about some of the clever work that some folks did in the campaign. But that guy worked his butt off.
A single voter in that state that if you came within his radius at all, he didn't make a beeline
for you. And it was kind of
inexhaustible. I've spent time with many, many, many politicians and the energy that Senator-elect
Cologne had on that race is the kind of energy that I saw when I got to travel with Bill Clinton
in his first campaign and travel around Bill Clinton in his first campaign. Just inexhaustible,
wanting to connect with people, wanting to listen for people and making it clear that he had a kind
of empathy that would move towards solidarity of action. It's great.
Let's keep glazing, guys, that you've been working with. We're going to get to hard
questions after that. Let's talk about Zoran for a second. I think it's interesting in the context
of when we were in Dayton together, one thing that we talked about, just kind of really backing up
the lens here for a second, is there was this dumb article that was written a couple months ago,
somebody going after me for befriending you because in the past we had political disagreements
and whatever. It's not even worth getting into. When I asked you about that in Dayton,
one thing that you were talking about,
it's just how important it is that we kind of model and cultivate across areas of agreement
when we're fighting the authoritarians and protecting the rights of people.
And we were talking about it then in the context of Haitians, but obviously you can expand it out
to a bunch of stuff. I just think that Cologne and Mamdani is such an interesting example of that
at a politician level. They're going to have some disagreements, I think, when it gets down to
a bunch of different types of issues. And yet, the themes that unite them are so kind of obvious to
me, but I want you to talk about a little bit. Yeah, that's a great observation, Tim, and I am
proud of our friendship. Me too, man, me too. Me more, more me, but go ahead.
You couldn't have two different politicians than Mayor Mamdani and Senator-elect Cologne,
but both of them have the engagement gene. They're going to lean in. They're not going to follow the
paint-by-the-numbers polling.
They're going to assume that every person out there in their city, in their state, in the nation,
you can make an appeal to them, that all of us are open to persuasion, that none of us are
represented by the worst things that we post on social media, and that the only way we're going
to get out of the spiral that we're in is if we kind of break the circuit by having just regular
conversation with folks. Both of them have that. They inhabit that. And even though they both have
very, very strong points of view on policy areas, there's a kind of capaciousness that they have in
their spirit and their soul for being able to listen and to being able to say, you know what,
maybe I don't have that entirely right, and let's keep asking some harder questions of ourselves.
And that's an extraordinary thing to see in politicians. I want to back up even a little
bit more, Tim.
Okay.
Mayor Mamdani, Senator Colon, are great examples of that. Here's the example of not getting that
right. When we won in 2020 and kind of stumbled our way back into the White House, we missed the
assignment. We thought that the job was to build back better. The job was actually to make sure
that we held on to as big a tent as possible so that the would-be autocrat could not come back
into power. Now that Americans have granted us a new map of the world,
the job still right now is to make sure that that MAGA thing is done and dusted and that figures
like Donald Trump can't come back and manipulate the most vulnerable populations that we have.
Keep the map. Hold the territory.
Hold the territory and think about what we are now obligated to do and what we have to lean into
in order to be able to hold the territory in order to accomplish job one, which is to protect
ourselves from the existential threat.
We have to be able to get to democracy, to decency, to humanity that's represented by that
movement. So I think the Zoran instinct, the Scott instinct is one that we have to carry into the
2028 debates that we're going to have.
Zoran's pragmatism has been pretty interesting. Obviously, he keeps tish.
When we had breakfast, I don't know, six months ago, I think you were either coming from or going
to a meeting with between the then mayor, mayor-elect, maybe it was, and some business
leaders, you know, who are worried about this. So I think that's a good thing. I think it's a good
thing.
I think he's worried about him in the city. And it does feel like he has navigated that in a way
that has been more practical than people expected. And anyway, I just am curious on your view of it
now, what, we're coming up on a year.
It's been really interesting for me from my approach. The mayor asked me to serve as the
chairman of his commission on government efficiency, which I've been doing for many
months now.
Code, code, intentionally rhyming with Doge.
I'm sorry, I want to go back to the question. But since you said that I should have, I should have
planned this because Josh on yesterday's show, kind of thought it was a little strange, given
how much Doge failed, the Democrats are still like using the brand for their own things. And it made
sense to me, actually. But I would be curious to you answering that question. Like, why use the
brand, given how bad it failed? Well, first, let's, let's all appreciate just how much Zoran Mamdani
understands how the, the attention to do is important. And I think that's, I think, that's
marketplace work. So, you know, wanting to rhyme with Doge and to invite questions like this
about what it is that he was doing was definitely intentional. I also think it's important to be
able to say that even progressives believe that there's a need for efficiency to be suffused
through our government. If we believe in governance, if we really want to be able to
deliver effectively on housing and healthcare and all the big things, we have to be able to show
that we do all the little things right. And so, leaning into efficiency and using the new tools
that we have to innovate around it means that we can do a whole heck of a lot more with the
resources, the shrinking resources that we have in our big cities. And we have to hold that up as a
value that actually matters to us because it actually matters for average folks who are on
the receiving end of these services. So, yeah, that's all.
Intentional. And, you know, when you said it as a pragmatism to Zaha Mamdani,
you know what, I'm going to respond to that from a personal perspective as a Black man in this
country who grew up in very complicated politics in the Reagan 80s, who, you know, then veered into
the Clinton 90s and then the hopefulness of this Obama moment. I know that there's something about
the American identity that is ever-changing. And I think that's something that we need to
keep evolving. It is not fixed. And power within it is unfixed as well. And I know that ultimately
we have to impose our will on the arc of the moral universe if we're going to get the kind
of outcomes that folks are deserving of for their hard work and that there is enormous power that we
all have to overcome inside of both political parties and our corporations and all of our
institutions. And we're not. I'm going to make the kinds of changes that we want overnight. But if we find ways to negotiate
and navigate and make some accommodations, even like, you know, for opinions that we disagree
with, ultimately our values are going to win. So I think that Zaha Mamdani has the patience of his
values, is how I would describe it, more than a kind of pragmatism, which sounds like an expediency.
He has the patience of his values.
Any other observations from the inside? You know, I feel sometimes like I'm commenting on
Zoran's mayorship, like based on the view of it from social media, which they are trying to
speak through social media. So it's not totally warped. But, you know, you can only see so much
through social media.
Yeah. So I think that what's most impressive about Mayor Mamdani is his mastery of the minutiae,
mastery of the details. Everyone knew that he was going to be. After watching his campaign, they knew that he'd be a kind of maestro of the narrative. But he is
digging in. If you look at the announcement that he made a few days ago about how he's
reforming the kind of SWAT unit inside of the police department, if you pay attention to
announcements that he's going to make in the next few days about reforming the prison system
of Rikers, reforms that people have been clamoring for for a long time. If you look at, you know,
solutions that he's come up with, he's going to be a kind of maestro of the narrative.
He's going to be a kind of maestro of the narrative. If you look at, you know,
around basic sanitation and infrastructure in the city, you realize that this is somebody who's
diving deep, deep, deep into the details and that he has surrounded himself with a hyper
capable team that comes from the very best of prior administrations. And he has no monopoly
on ideas. And he's not being an ideologue about this stuff, even though he clearly has a set of
values that he's tethered in. So it's like the mastery of the details.
For me, that's most impressive in this, this young mayor who I learn a thing or two from every
single time I engage with him. I love being around people who are much younger than me,
who are much smarter than me. And sorry, my money is that I like people that like to be around that
like that, right? I think that it's a mark against character for folks who are threatened by that or
feel defensive about that. So anyway, I appreciate it. I want to ask about a couple other,
New York politicians and kind of how they interplay. Yesterday, you know, the Democrats officially
voted for Hakeem Jeffries to be the incoming speaker, first black speaker, 11 votes against.
I was kind of intrigued by the 11 votes against. There are three we don't know about yet, but the
eight that have admitted it are all younger incoming members, mostly kind of the DSA type
members. Some of them from New York. Some of them from New York, yeah. Who is not on the list was
AOC, who went for Speaker Jeffries against, maybe practicality or pragmatism. I don't know. I can't
get inside her head, but I'm just kind of interested in your reaction to that vote,
Jeffries' incoming speakership, how AOC is playing it. So let me back way up and say that
soon to be Speaker Jeffries is somebody that I've had a relationship with going back to when I first
met him when he was a law school student. And I was just really impressed with his sophistication
around strategy way back then. And then when he was- Did he talk, did he do the rhyming?
Talk then? Or is that how you developed that over time?
Let's just say that the first time I met him, it was clear that he was steeped in hip hop culture.
So that's always been a vibe. But look, when I first met him and when he entered into politics
in New York and my biological brother, Michael Gaspard, was one of his first campaign directors
when he was an insurgent candidate running against the machinery in Brooklyn.
He had a different identity in politics. And there was a sense that this was a young man in a hurry to
get somewhere. But his New York identity has always been tied in economic development,
housing reform, and a set of outcomes that he wanted for struggling communities like East New
York, Brooklyn. So very different, I think, than how he can be viewed nationally. I'll also say
that his ascendance is no surprise to me because I saw him year after year, state after state,
district after district. And I think that's a very good thing. I think that's a very good thing. I will respond to this. I'm kind of. Getting people's hopes up, I guess, would be my critique.
Look, across the board, coming out of Trump, I am tired and exhausted with the politics of
performance. And I want the politics of substance to trump the politics of performance going forward
for us. So I just thought coming out of the midterm elections that I wasn't entirely sure
what some of my friends were doing around some of the head fake signals. And it's time for clarity,
substance, clarity of morality, clarity of strategy. So Hakeem Jeffries had no opponent
whatsoever. It's clear that he was going to win that vote and ultimately become a speaker. I
respect and appreciate why some members, including of the New York delegation, decided that they
still didn't want to give him that vote. But he's clearly going to be speaker. And AOC
acknowledged that. And to her credit, and to his credit, AOC and Hakeem Jeffries have found ways to
work with one another around issues that both of them care about and that their constituents care
about. Look, you know, there are clearly some divisions that exist in the party and the victory
that we have should not paper over those differences. I think that those differences are
healthy. For better or worse, we live in a two-party system. And so tensions have to be contested
inside of that two-party apparatus. And so, you know, these differences are going to continue to
happen. And I think that's going to happen. And I think
when they surface, it's all well and good for, you know, freshman members to say, you know what,
DSA or non-DSA to say, that's not the course I want to be on right now. I don't think this is
what my voters sent me to Washington to do. And they are allowed to do that. And it should not
lead to face melting on social media. There's just like too much energy around that stuff.
And there is another New York politician who may be leader who's in a contest,
as well, Chuck Schumer versus Chris Van Hollen. And I think that that contest is to the credit
of the delegation and deliberation. And the right questions have to be asked about what it means to
lead that body. No, it's not, you know, there are senators who get to cast that vote. Here's what my
preference is. We need to make sure that we are listening to what the lessons were from that
election and that we are going hard, not only at the corruption in the Republican Party, but the
in our party and big lobbyists in the Democratic Party as well. And we have to understand that the
ability to narrate is hugely important. So whether Chris Van Hollen or Chuck Schumer emerge as the
majority leader, there are other senators who have really great skill and talent. Some of them
are brand spanking new, who need to be put out in front of the American people to be the drum majors
for change. I'm into that. Going back to not wincing over differences. You are the
ED of DNC in 2012. So I guess you never had to oversee the primary stuff because Obama is then
running for reelect that year. So it's different. But on the one hand, I'm with you in spirit. I
don't think that the Democrats should be wincing over differences. On the other hand, the last time
we just can't, we just stopped there. Tim, you're with me in spirit. That works. Okay, I'm with you
in spirit. Okay, but then we get to the dirty details, right? And it's like, the last time the
Democrats had an open primary, I thought it was really self harmful. And there were two things I
think that were self harmful of it. One was there were just these brutal knife fights over kind of
minor differences and like the grand scheme of things. I just think about all the blood that was
shed over different healthcare policies. And then Biden gets in there and does none of them. And it's
like not even on the agenda. It's like, why did we do all that? Like, why were there so per, you
know, like, why did we do all that? And it's like, why were there so per, you
know, like, why were there so per, you know, like, why were there so per, you know, like, why were there so
some control over? I think led to some silliness, some performative silliness, people are raising
their hands about complicated issues. You know, and, and so I do think that the structure of the
part of this is just human choice, the candidates will have to, you know, I think everybody including
me and other people should be incentivizing people that are behaving well. But also, I think that
there's a structure of this, the DNC is in charge of if you know, if somebody called you the DNC,
if Ken called you, you're thinking about that, how would you think about how to
structure something that allows for healthy debate, but doesn't?
Sure, sure. First, first of all, mostly because of the way our new communications ecosystem works.
I hate to break it to you, Tim, there's going to be loads of silliness and petty fights over
literally nothing in this next contest. Sorry, it's gonna happen. Number one, number two,
if I were asked my advice, I would say do away with debates. And instead, completely have
completely and instead convert those into town hall formats. I would not have 12 people on stage
at once. I wouldn't have eight people on stage at once. I wouldn't have four people on stage at once,
I would take three candidates at a time, and put them in town hall settings in contested
battleground spaces for two hours at a clip, and have them have a conversation that forces them
to the substance and forces actual engagement with with some set of voters that are representative
of the kinds of folks who are going to be casting ballots to make these decisions. That's what that's
what we do with that in the debates, as they were constructed in the past, or a waste of time when
you have that many people who are on stage, and everybody gets two minutes to raise their hand
and say that they're for driver's licenses. Do you think these discussions are happening?
I would imagine. I worry about inertia. You know, I think, I think that there's a, I think that
there's a lot of momentum in the party right now to do things differently, right? You can't come
off of this election. And you can't have the dynamism that we're going to have in this field. There are capable
governors and senators and all kinds of other people who are going to be running,
who don't want to be engaged in business as usual. And I think that there's, there are creatives in
the communication space that are putting some real pressure and interrogating how we've done
this stuff in the past. So I know those conversations are taking place. I'm not worried
about inertia. But you know, we'll, we'll see where it all goes. But
but 20, the way it unfolded in 2020, clearly did not work.
Do you think AOC is going to be in the field?
So I'd say this, I think that what's wonderful about AOC is that she is powerfully vulnerable,
right? She's, she's let us all in on her journey. She's been very clear about
the tension that she feels in herself to use this next moment to start a family.
There are things that she wants to take care of for her spirit, her, her community,
all being any of us who have listened to her, who have talked with her at all during this journey
have been clear that her identity is not wrapped up in politics, and she'd be okay not to be in
this. But I do think that she's got this urge, this urge to service. She is not unaware of her
talents. And I personally am encouraging as many people as possible who are thinking about running
to get in there and test the limits of what they're doing. And I think that's going to be
orders further. I think that we are at our best
when we have deep, wide fields and our best and most talented storytellers emerge.
It happened in 1992. It happened in 2008.
I think 2020 is more of an aberration than you think, Tim, because it was a COVID election and campaign.
So that was distorting. And we had a kind of sort of like an incumbent in the vice president.
This is going to be different, wide open, dynamic.
And I think the very best talent emerges at the end of it.
And I know that AOC is giving it serious consideration. And that excites me.
Tim, vulnerability is a really good trait in a person.
Is it a good trait in a presidential candidate? It's tough. It's tough to be in the presidential campaign.
You know, I had a fight about this with my friends and, you know, friends like, well, I won't name names, but there were there were folks.
I remember watching Zohan Mamdani in the latter stage of his campaign when he was talking about the hate that was being directed at him.
And he got very emotional.
And I remember a prominent podcaster saying to me that that seems like like weak tea.
Nobody wants to see like a man come close to tears.
And I said, you're totally you don't get it.
You don't know how the new tools work.
And people need to feel a sense of intimacy with you.
That's very, very different than what we used to experience in the past.
And I think that vulnerability is a is not a kryptonite.
It is a superpower.
I'd watch figures like here's here's somebody I'd pluck out of the presidential field.
J.B. Pritzker, the governor of Illinois, who, like on paper, just seems like somebody who, you know, kind of inherited a fortune, wealthy family.
But if you pay attention to his storytelling and how he enters into problem solving, he does it through vulnerability, a personal journey that comes with a tremendous amount of pain that he does not hesitate to share.
And I think it's it's catalytic and it helps to build intimacy.
And ultimately, I think.
I think helps to build a coalition.
So I do think that in the way we communicate with one another now, the way we live, the way we care about what's happening on Love Island, that vulnerability is actually going to accrue to the benefit of care of candidates.
Boy, that sometimes those podcasts just like that.
John Lovett just isn't in touch with the human spirit like some of the rest of us are, you know, I don't know.
You are you are you you you have to be like the most the most macho, two spirited guy in the world.
You're a little bit more vulnerable, Tim.
It's OK.
Me?
I cry.
I have tears.
I have salty discharge.
So, Tim, can I just talk about your vulnerability and the vulnerability of the whole Bulwark team?
Please.
You you made a slight mention of Ohio.
I haven't been on Bulwark since I joined you and saw you and Sarah Longwell, who's getting a lot of shit from a lot of morons right now.
I saw you make landing in Ohio and you went to a community that's incredibly vulnerable.
That's been under siege and you put your name, your reputation, your brand out there to extend support to the Haitian community and to and to show the world how average folk in Ohio are not buying the stereotypes and are not being twisted into this kind of ugly house of mirrors that Maga tried to present us all as.
And I want to commend your vulnerability, Sarah's vulnerability in that moment.
I found it to be incredibly.
Moving and inspiring.
Thank you.
I mean, I don't know.
We just showed up one day.
It was just unbelievable, the work that people are doing, the Haitian Support Center, and appreciate your help in helping us kind of get resources to them.
And I knew we were going to be successful in the midterms when I saw the kind of community that you were able to pull together.
Thank you.
I want one more thing to end.
And it's a little melancholy, but that's OK.
We've been we've been positive.
But like there's this Nick Christoph column today about the third country deportations have been sending people to South.
Sudan and other places.
And I'll put the link in the show notes.
People can read it.
Hopefully I can have a chance to talk to Nick about it soon.
But what you like, it's 500 people we sent to these countries there.
He found five of them there and they're held prisoner in this house, basically in South Sudan.
They're nearly starving.
They can't see their families.
One of the cases, the American kids.
And I connect this to the Haitian thing, because I think that a small role that we can play is, you know, when you go back to that original conversation about how.
People want American first foreign policy, like it is true, like people want the American people want to prioritize this.
But like it is going to be so easy for these these people that are that we've condemned to hell to be forgotten about, right?
And to be deprioritized.
And I just wonder how you think about ways that we can continue to be productive and helpful and and elevating those stories without, you know, creating negative backlash.
It's like, oh, you care more about South Sudan than you care about.
You know, I'd say a couple of things, Tim.
I think that voters are more complicated than we think.
They contain multitudes.
I think that you can lean into the moral aspects of the story while still being inherently political.
I was I was looking at a graph yesterday that demonstrated that the biggest drop in support for Donald Trump happened after Minnesota, after the ice rays.
It wasn't after Iran.
It wasn't after, you know, the gas prices spike or the terroristic effect.
It was after the ice rates.
So I think that we have to.
Remind all of our friends that the moral lane that you've been on on these issues actually is good political strategy as well in a complicated electorate.
And every society, I believe in what Thoreau said, that every society should be judged by how it treats even its prisoners.
And I think that what we're doing, not just to those prisoners, but in the imposition of of of all of this on places like Sudan is not just criminal.
But sinful.
And I think that we have to stare that down and answer big questions about our identity.
You started this conversation by mocking Elon Musk.
We have to remember that Elon Musk taking apart USAID is what's leading to horrific outcomes in other places in the world.
That's going to land on our doorstep here in the USA.
So in America, first policy does have a moral core.
That runs through it, and that Nick Kristof story, which I would encourage everybody to read, needs to be shared and amplified, but amplified in a way that leads us to a set of moral questions that can be aligned with strategic design going forward.
Patrick, I appreciate you so much.
Thank you again for coming to Ohio and and we'll be we'll keep talking.
All right.
We'll see you in Mississippi soon.
I hope so.
All right.
That's Patrick Gaspard.
We'll be back tomorrow.
It's another edition of the show.
We'll see you all then.
Peace.
Good things are going on.
They're in Mississippi.
The Bulwark Daily is brought to you thanks to the work of lead producer Katie Cooper,
associate producer Ansley Skipper, and with video editing by Dante DiCicco, and audio engineering and editing by Jason Brown.
Podcast Summary
Key Points:
Elon Musk’s shift from identifying as "dark MAGA" to claiming he is no longer MAGA is seen as contradictory and hypocritical, especially given his past political spending and influence.
The campaign against Musk and his corporate influence in politics, particularly in Texas, resonated with voters who rejected attempts to buy political power or exploit data centers and land.
Scott Colombe’s campaign in Mississippi successfully united disparate communities through empathy, grassroots mobilization, and symbolic actions like the Nike Air Force One initiative for valedictorians.
The Democratic Party’s foreign policy challenges include balancing strong national leadership with resistance to authoritarianism, especially in response to Trump’s alliances with autocrats.
Vulnerability in political communication—such as emotional honesty and personal storytelling—is increasingly seen as a superpower, not a weakness, in building trust with voters.
The success of grassroots movements in Mississippi and Ohio demonstrates that community-led efforts can shift public sentiment more effectively than traditional political performance.
Political figures like Zoran Mamdani and Patrick Gaspard emphasize the importance of listening, adaptability, and values-driven governance over ideological rigidity.
The future of democratic politics requires a focus on substance, transparency, and inclusive dialogue, with town hall formats replacing performative debates to foster real voter engagement.
Summary:
The transcript explores the evolving dynamics of American politics, emphasizing grassroots mobilization, vulnerability, and moral clarity in leadership. It highlights how Elon Musk’s past alignment with MAGA ideology contrasts sharply with his current distancing, reflecting public distrust in corporate political influence. In Mississippi, Senator-elect Scott Colombe’s campaign exemplifies effective community engagement through empathy, local partnerships, and symbolic gestures like the Nike Air Force One initiative for valedictorians, uniting Black and white voters.
The discussion also underscores the importance of vulnerability in political leadership, noting that personal authenticity fosters deeper public trust. Foreign policy is framed as a moral issue, with voters rejecting authoritarianism and demanding accountability. The episode critiques performative politics, advocating for substance over spectacle, and calls for reforms like town hall debates to increase real voter engagement.
S. in global affairs, citing the plight of deported individuals in South Sudan as a reminder that foreign policy must prioritize human dignity. Ultimately, the narrative champions democratic resilience through inclusive, compassionate, and value-driven leadership—particularly in the face of political polarization and authoritarian threats.
FAQs
Toyotathon features events like skiing, skating, and hiking, with participants using Toyota vehicles such as Tundras, Camrys, BZs, and RAV4s.
Toyotathon ends on January 4th, with current offers available until November 30th.
No, dealer inventory may vary, and offers are subject to change throughout the event.
It refers to a shift in political stance, where someone once aligned with MAGA ideology now claims to not be part of it, highlighting a notable change in political positioning.
It is a metaphorical critique suggesting Elon Musk is being mocked for his past associations with MAGA, likening his shift to the film’s portrayal of a Nazi general being outed and humiliated.
Because voters were reacting strongly to concerns about data centers and political influence, showing resistance to corporate attempts to buy state or national power.
Chat with AI
Loading...
Pro features
Go deeper with this episode
Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.