Go back

Pastors REACT to Sophie Cunningham’s MASTERCLASS on Evangelism with Theo Von | Live Free with Josh Howerton

1h 24m 55s

Pastors REACT to Sophie Cunningham’s MASTERCLASS on Evangelism with Theo Von | Live Free with Josh Howerton

The podcast explores the theological debate over Matthew 16:18, where Jesus declares, “On this rock, I will build my church,” and examines how this verse divides Catholic and Protestant understandings of church authority. Catholics interpret this as establishing Peter as the foundational rock, with exclusive, unbroken authority passed to the papacy through apostolic succession. However, the Protestant view rejects this, arguing instead that the "rock" refers to Peter’s confession of Jesus as the Christ—rooted in shared faith—and that the church is a movement of believers, not a hierarchical institution. The discussion highlights how the translation of "ecclesia" into "church" has shaped theology, with William Tyndall’s courageous translation advocating for biblical accessibility, even at great personal risk. Key scriptural and historical evidence—such as the plural use of “you” in Matthew 18 about church discipline, and the absence of any mention of Peter’s supremacy in Paul’s letters—undermines Catholic claims. Early church history and councils, like Acts 15, show that leadership was shared, not centralized. The episode concludes by affirming that the unifying truth across all denominations is the confession that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of the Living God—this shared belief forms the true foundation of the Christian church. The message emphasizes biblical authority over tradition, and the importance of accessible, personal faith in a global, living church.

Transcription

17480 Words, 92266 Characters

English
- A lawyer's job is to make an airtight case. A witness's job is just to share their side of the story. Here's what I saw. Here's what I experienced. - The one who builds the church is the one who conquers the great. - Am I trying to win or am I trying to win them over? My aim determines my tone and my tactics. - Well, hey, a live free nation. Before we jump into the episode, this podcast is recorded right here at Lake Point Church in Dallas, Texas. But the live free nation is spread all over the country and all around the world. So if you've been watching and thinking, man, I wish I could be part of something like this. We want to invite you to take a simple next step and that is join us for church online. Every weekend we stream our services live on YouTube, Facebook and our church online platform and it's more than just watching a service. There are live hosts in the chat. Prayer teams ready to stand with you and people all around the world worshiping together in real time. And so whether you're exploring the faith, coming back to church or just looking for a place to start, church online is a great way to jump in and experience what God is doing here at Lake Point. We would love to see you in the chat this weekend and now enjoy the podcast. - Well, hey, welcome back to another episode of the live free podcast. - Hey, another one. - He just really went for the another. - Dude, you know who said another one? Another one? You know who says that? - You know who that guy, too? Are you kidding me? - Another one. - No, bro, you think about it. - I'm here to help you. DJ Khaled, he says another one. - Hey, Khaled, say something. - I don't know who that is. - Oh, right, goodness. - Bro, I don't know who that is. - How the tables turn over here. I don't know. - How the turn tables. - How the turn tables turn. - I got that one. Did you get that one? - Yeah, it's Michael Scott. - Come on, dude. - Now, Carlos, you're the cat, man. - Hey, look at me. Look at me. - We've got to build the episode in 40 seconds. - Hey, my name is Carlos Arrozzo, and today I'm here with Pastor Josh Howardton and Pastor Paul Cunningham. This is another one. - Hey, you guys learned something. You're welcome. - Yeah, thank you. - Thank you. - Well, we learned before this episode, which movie have you not seen? - Well, many, but he didn't know who built the village. - He didn't know who built the village. - And then he thought that we were old for him, not now. - I was like, he called it Vincent Bardem. Like, you know, Vincent Bardem. - I know, Vincent Bardem. - That was like, one of Superbowl when I was six years ago. - Hey, we're taking a pig right now. We have a lot to cover. We have a great episode today. - Bro, this is a lot here. - We're gonna talk about Matthew 16, specifically the part where Jesus says, "You are Peter, and on this rock, "I will build my church." That's a big statement. We're gonna talk about what that means. - That statement, we're gonna get to see something. That statement and the statement of media following because the next knee says, "And I will give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven. "And what have you bind on earth should be bound on earth, "what have you loosened on earth will be loosened in heaven." Okay, let me tease something. The interpretation of those two verses literally splits church history in half. It's pretty kind of a big deal. - That's a big deal. - We're gonna settle it once and for all today. - Yeah. We're gonna explain to us the differences between Catholic understanding of that passage and the Protestant understanding. We're gonna get a reformed vibe on right now. We're gonna be asking, does the church have the keys to the kingdom and will, is Peter the first pope? And we're gonna be wrapping the episode with a reaction of a video of Sophie Cunningham. - Listen, dude. Sophie. - Sophie, Sophie, she crushed it in this. - Professional basketball player for the Indiana fever, talking about her faith with Theo Vaughn. She's gonna bring you great episode. It's a big crush, man. We're really cool. We're talking about pigs. I-- (laughing) - I'm excited for this. - Paul was in here when I asked this earlier. Did you know, this is, I'm not joking. This is not a joke. You guys are looking at me like you're waiting for a punchline for me to say. - I don't know what this is. - We've restarted reading with our kids a Christmas book. Did you know JK Rowling wrote a Christmas book? It's called Der Pig. - Der Pig? - Der Pig. - I'm not telling you. You have to read the book. But it's like for kids. And so like we'll do dinner. And then we read one, should we make everybody a guy around and we read one chapter. It's fantastic. - Interesting. - One might even say Carlos. It's magical. - Oh boy. - It's a magical book. - It's the same way that the "Low Rooms" is a magical movie. This is a magical movie. - I'm sure it is. I believe you. - Wait, oh speaking of Christmas, let me just say it, in about a week and a half, we have Christmas sets of movies. Come on, let's go out. - That's a great segue, dude. That was great. - Oh my goodness. - Explain to us what that means. - Yeah, so it's what it is not, is preaching movies. We're gonna say that. We're doing the same thing Jesus did. He would take modern day stories, parables, and throw a spiritual truth alongside the popular story to illustrate a spiritual truth. Same thing. We take a modern day story, a movie, throw alongside of its spiritual truths. So it's using movies to illustrate biblical truths. We do it for one week to kick off the Christmas weekend. I'll shoot everybody really straight. I for so many years had church members being like, hey, the week of Thanksgiving, my whole family comes in and my moms, my one more, or my brothers, my one more, my aunts, my one more, could we do something that will like help be geared towards reaching lots of people for Jesus? So honestly, that's what we did it. And it's a really cool way to kick off the Christmas tosses. And I will not, I won't give away the movie. - Okay. - I will say. - It's not the takeer role in Christmas. - I will neither confirm nor deny. - Okay. - I will say, I am told this is the best one we've ever done by the video team. That's what I have recently been told. - Okay. - Well, to find out, come November 28th and 29th, all of our campuses in person only. - Boom. - It's gonna be great. Hey, Pastor Josh, I like your merch, and Josh, you'll see. - Oh, wait, I gotta shout this out. So shout out, live free nation. Y'all are insane. So last week, we launched the live free gear shop. We have to decide, are we calling it gear or merch? - Merch. - I like gear. I'll submit. (laughing) So the merch shop that has been officially decided, the day come things sold out like a ton of the items within about 12 hours. Like it was absolutely stupid. We did not expect that. So first of all, you can head over there. - Shout out. - Shout out. It's live free, dot shop. Hey, it's live free, dot shop. Carlos, it's live free, dot shop. - Wait, wait, what is it again? - It's live free, dot shop is what it is. And there you can find, look at this. Look at this. You can find items like this. - Hey, oh. - Oh, wow. - In Texas way, can you see it? - Yes. - Is it, can you see it? - Yup. - It takes live free. So you can come live free in our liberal state of Texas. - We're living free in a rock vacation. - It hits a little different. - It does. - But we got this guy, and then we're gonna get it, we're gonna get it restocked. - That's right. - This is for what I understand. So we'll get you to take care of. - And free shipping for orders over $100. Code free 100. - Oh. - Shout out to the definition. - The free nation represent that way. We all know nobody's walking up to us to punch us in airports. - That's right. - That'd be great. - If you are on YouTube, speaking of merch, if you are on YouTube or Spotify, jump in the comment section and drop the word hat. And we love to do a giveaway every single episode. So if that's you, and just if it wasn't clear, if Pastor Josh did not say it enough, leave free that shop and text the word hat to 20411 to get the merch. They also to download the Lake Point app and get a daily Bible reading plan plus the weekly sermon from our wonderful senior pastor, delivering the hits every single weekend, plus an early release of the live free podcast and get also a discipleship guide text the word app to 20411, or go to the Apple or Google Play Store. - Carlos. - Your reader. - Are you writing anything good lately? - I have actually, bro. So this right here, this should pull some worship out of your heart. This is pretty crazy. This is hidden detail in the story of Adam and Eve when they sit in the garden, so check this out. So we own all the story. Adam and Eve, they sit and they hide in the Bible says in Genesis chapter three or seven that at that point they realize they were naked. And because of that, they sowed fake leaves together to cover themselves. Now we've all heard this before, but the question is I wanna ask, why does the author of Genesis bother to give us this specific detail about what type of leaf they were covering themselves. - I've always wondered this. - Okay, please tell me. - So we'll try to hit that. So here's a photo right here of fake leaves. So this is basically the same leaf that they use. Not from a biological perspective, fake leaves actually contain a milky white sap. And it is this liquid that comes out and if it touches your skin, it can severely irritate your skin. And when you expose it to the sun, it can actually burn you. So if you think about what's going on here, Adam and Eve, they have all the plants in the garden and out of all the options that they have, they chose the fake leaves to try to cover themselves with that. So they chose the leaf that when it touches your skin, it actually burns you, it irritates you, it stinks you and it causes itching and blister. So again, you gotta picture Adam and Eve, they're full of shame and guilt and they're grabbing these leaves and they're breaking the stems and tearing the leaves and kind of putting it under naked skin. Now the Bible doesn't specifically spell this out, but we must assume or we can assume that in their attempt to cover their shame and guilt in their own effort, they actually ended up hurting themselves. And honestly, that's what we do every single day. I mean, today in our culture, we see this all the time. We try to cover our insecurity by chasing likes and validation in social media. We try to cover our shame with pornography and sexual immorality. We try to cover our brokenness, just pretending everything's okay with a smile when it's not. We try to numb our pain with alcohol, entertainment and more. And as we do, that ends up hurting us more than it ends up helping us. And the good news is that when you keep reading the story, what you see in the Bible is that when God sees Adam and Eve trying to cover themselves up this way, the Bible says in Genesis 3 verse 21, that God makes clothing from animal skins for Adam and his wife. In other words, bro, this is the third chapter in the Bible. Here's what you see. God sheds blood to cover their nakedness and shame of sin so this is obviously a foreshadowing of Jesus so what you see is you see Adam and Eve they took from a tree and the result was a curse but then you go to Jesus and you see Jesus he gave himself on a tree and the result was salvation. Adam and Eve they stood naked at Eden full of guilt and shame when you go to the cross you see Jesus hanging naked at the cross and there he took our guilt and shame. You see Adam and Eve and they're trying to cover their sin with fig leaves at the cross Jesus covers our sin with his blood and by the way I've never seen this one before so Adam and Eve were driven out of paradise because of their sin. Jesus looks at the thief in the cross and he says today you will be with me where in Christ here's a good news in Christ you can be made free of your curse you can be made free of your sin or you can be made free of your guilt and of your shame why because what he lost through disobedience Jesus restores through his obedience that's why. Oh man bro. Well it's been a good podcast. Oh my god dude you doing that every week is like the best three minutes a week. That's crazy. Oh man. That's good news. Okay we gotta we gotta speed run this podcast. Let's speed run it. Carlos ask me to ask me. Oh yeah yeah I have a question for you. I will allow it. What did you make it? Sorry. Alright let me do this. Let me do this. We got it. This is pretty pretty quick. So this was a massive week in life our church. We finished our into the breach series massive and let me just say we had the best most sacrificial loving generous people ever. Yes we did the best. I don't even got words. So I'll talk more about that later. I only got words. Here's what we did. This was an I will build my church sermon. Okay so this is here's where there's a Matthew 16 and we're going to do this kind of thing. This is literally why we start the podcast because like there's the there's the preaching that you can get in and then dude there's like all the theologies like like it hurt to leave some of this out like it hurt. Okay so here's what this is. Let me just set this up and we tease this last week. Let me go all all the way in and so we're okay so right before Jesus what we're getting ready to read. So go ahead and toss that first one up right before this. Jesus is at you see right there. He's at the Sea of Galilee. By the way can anyone name a pop quiz? Can anyone name another name that the Bible uses for the Sea of Galilee? Sea of Tiberius? Tiberius. That's one. Anybody know another one? I do not. Ganesorette is another one. Dude and I'm forgetting one. There's actually four names that interest people up. There's four names people used for the Sea of Galilee and you're reading it and you don't know that's all the Sea of Galilee. What I'm saying the Old Testament has dropped me nuts I can't remember. I'm in Deuteronomy. I'm in Deuteronomy. I'm personal. Yeah. Grocken. I didn't plan on doing this. I'm in the Deuteronomy in my personal Bible reading and it's like he's God's mapping out the territory and this is the little things like I read from the salt sea to the and it's something clicks. Oh he's talking about the Dead Sea. Yeah the salt sea is the Dead Sea. You got it. Yeah. There's multiple ones. So Galilee, Tiberias, Ganesha Red, Chinnas. That's it. Chinara. Chinara. Chinara. Chinara. Chinara. That's the one in Deuteronomy. Chinara. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. That's right. Numbers in Joshua. Numbers in Joshua. My bad. I'm so sorry. Carlin. I'm just reading. Oh, this is before Deuteronomy. I'm trying to cover the two books on other side of Deuteronomy. Sorry. Hey, sorry. Hey, thank you. If you hadn't done that tomorrow, we would be viral on X for, for like, uh, it's right. He got it wrong. He's preaching false teaching on around or lies to you about the name of this Lucy of Galilee. Okay. So let's bring this back in. So first of all, there's your little fun facts to know and tell for the Bible nerds. There are four names for the Sea of Galilee. So anyway, that's great. Right before this, Jesus, see a gallery. Galilee. Now this is going to matter here in a second. So Jesus walks is 25 miles as the crow flies from Sea of Galilee up to this is Incessory of Philippi. Y'all got to go to Cesory of Philippi. By the way, we were in Israel. We did not go there. You gotta go. You gotta go. It's one of my favorite spots of the whole trip. Now this is really interesting because here's the question that we teased this last week. Why? Why is Jesus walk 25 miles out into the middle of nowhere to have the moment that becomes like one of the most significant moments literally in all of church history. And then if you read the passage, he goes out there has this moment six days later with transfiguration. And then boom, he just walks right back. Yeah. Let me just tell you something man. Jesus don't do anything on accident. All right. So here's the question class. Why walk 25 miles? Probably up two to three days. Yeah. Just walk here out here. Now this that's question of wrong question number two. Let me show you what's going on. We teased this last week. Let's let here's a little recap. So here's the geographic region. So what you got, he walks out to Mount Herman. This is what one of the gospel's submissions, Mount Herman. So Mount Herman, that's what a transfiguration almost certainly takes place. Book that bookmark that in your head. That's going to be important. At the very bottom right down there, there it is. That's where you feel a pie sacred cave. That's almost certainly where Matthew 16 takes place. I do just want to say this. Dude, if you ever get a chance, it doesn't have to be with us. Don't care. You need to go and see the stuff in the holy land. It's something you need to do it. You need to actually just call it Israel. You need to do it. Your Bible goes from black and white to color and you walk away and you just like, you never the same. You know the same. So you're standing right there. And so let me just set this up. It's today. It's beautiful. So when you walk up, go to that next one. This is what you see. Now look at the little brook there. And this is going to be important when I explain this passage and what I didn't have time to get to in the sermon here in a second. So you see this little brook. That brook used to flow. It does not now used to flow right out of the mouth of that cave. You can see it the back left of the picture. Okay. Now as you walk up, you start seeing go to that next one. There's these little things that are carved into the side of the little mountain face. And this is my iPhone picture. I got on and I just found this in sermon prep. Go to that next one. So you can sit there everywhere. Okay. Now so what happened is over time, all this is going to make sense here in a second. We've mentioned this like a couple years ago, but I want to kind of a couple dots. So over time, what happens is I'll explain why this specific site becomes it is a place of Greco-Roman pagan god and goddess worship. So what they did is they carved these little, I don't know what you can call those things, alcoves. And they would put particularly at this place, it was the, the god, the Roman god, a pan, P-A-N. By the way, that is the name from which we get the English derivative for the word panic, the god of fear. That's what you got right here. Now I'll show you why. This is just a little fun fact no one tell. So this is to go to this next one. This is a picture. No, no, the picture of the statue. So yeah, right here. So can you zoom in on the face? Do you have the ability to do that training? I don't know if you can do that. I should have told you that early. Let's see if we can zoom in. So if you're on YouTube, especially I want you to see this, my brother is terrifying. So he's like, in every sculpture they've ever found, he looks like a demon or a devil. He's got these elongated faces. Scroll up where you can see the top of his head. He has horns. He's have goat. Yeah, half goat, half man. Yep. That's right. But, but terrifying. Okay, so god pan from which we get the English word panic. So go actually go backwards to that last one. So if you would, when you would have been walking up, you would have been seeing in all these little, you know, the last one where the three little alcoves were, you would have been seeing those little statues to this god, like right there in all these little alcoves. You know what's interesting too? You know what else comes from the word pan, Peter pan. Seriously, I'm not joking. What's the, it's the Greek god. It's just an illusion to the Greek god. But what's the connection? Oh, I don't know. I don't know. But like Peter pan is like, is it because he's like a boy. I have to research that one, but I know the name comes from the Greek, from the Greek god pan. So it's the same guy you just showed. Well, Peter pan's a lot less terrifying. That's true. That's true. What is his name? I don't know. All right, so let me, let me keep going. Now go to the go to the go to the next one. Okay, so when this is how it looks today. Okay, now, so just start putting all this together. Why is Jesus walk 25 miles out of the way three days? And this is where he's going to announce, uh, I will build my church in the gates of, uh, by the way, people say the gates of hell, that's not what it says. The actual Greek says the gates of a Hades. This is very important. This is a really big deal. The gates of Hades will not prevail against it. So, bro, here's what's going on. This, so when he's pointing on this rock, uh, when you read it, we're going to read it in a second. He's points to Peter and he says, you are petrace. And on this petrace, I will build with it. By the way, that's going to be important here in a second. We're talking about how Catholics and Protestants differentiate between their understanding this. Uh, he's pointing at this rock, bro. So here's what happens. Let me put all this together. So the Greek god pan was known as like this is his dwelling place. You have this rock right here. Now, 2000 years ago, that cave wall from what I, from what I was told is there was an earthquake. I don't know how long ago that closed off the back of that cave that used to be an open cave out of which the brook that you just saw used to flow. So people would walk up dark cave, dark water flowing out of the cave, fault line. This became known as the entry point to the Greek Greco. Roman underworld which is called Hades. So why does Jesus, this was the gateway to Hades. So why does Jesus walk all the way out here and stand right here, point to that rock and say, on this rock, I will build my church and the gates of Hades will not prevail against it. Bro, what he literally did is he was like, I'm going to run straight into the breach. Wow. Where's the breach? Where are the bullets flying the fastest? Where is hell the hottest? Where all the things like, I'm going to walk right up to the gates where you think all the evil things emanate from the underworld. And that right there is where I'm going to say, I'm going to build this church and the gates of Hades will never prevail against it right there, Bro. Come on. Wow. Now, let me do one other thing real quick. And then I want to get into this, to help people understand what goes on, to understand this passage. One thing that is interesting for our Bible nerds, in Matthew 16, this is the first time in the original languages. The original, so excluding the Septuagint, which is the Greek translation of the Hebrew Old Testament, it was written later. This is the first time in the entire Bible you're ever going to see the word church. So we've, you gotta remember, nobody's ever heard this word before, used in the way that Jesus uses it. This is interesting. The Greek word he uses is the word ecclesia. This is really important, ecclesia. It's a, it is a Greek compound word. Ech is a Greek prefix that means out of kaleto means to call. So when Jesus, the word that gets translated in English, it's honestly, a lot of people would say it's not a great translation. When Jesus says on this rock, I will build my church. What he's literally saying is ecclesia called out ones. Now dude, here's, here's where translation stuff starts to matter. So then you may be asking a question, bro, where, so where do we get the English word church? If the original word was ecclesia, where we get the English word church? So fast forward, a thousand years or so. In German, they eventually start using the word cierka. Paul, did I pronounce it right? I want to hear you pronounce it. Cierka. Perfect. It's great to hear that. I don't speak German, but I can go to check. Cierka. Oh, it's great. Thank you. Thank you. Appreciate it. That's your people. How are 10? Come on. I mean, we're English. Okay. We're from England. German, they're kind of a little closer to each other. Yeah. So yeah, it's one of those white people. Yeah, yeah. That's right. Up there. Yeah, yeah. Wait, wait, we all look the same to you, don't we? Yeah, that's right. It's hard to distinguish between both of you. I don't know what you're talking about here, dude. It's easy, dude. All right. We may add that out. We'll keep going. Cierka. Cierka, let me get back to you. I will say, I will say in the comment section when Paul has in a video in a real, people are like, why is Pastor Josh looking a little different? So I'm just, I'm just saying, I'm not the only one. When you're just the two of us doing a bonus episode, people will say that one person said, this is not all kind of Josh Howard, and this is obviously AI generated talking about me. Oh my gosh. Hey, bro, let me just say usually the AI generated versions are more jacked and better looking. Great. That's what they think about you. I can finally wear medium size shirt. That's great. All right, Cierka. Cierka. So in Germany, they start using the word Kierka, which is where we get the English word church. Kierka, Kirk church. That's how it goes. That honestly, dude, here's here's where translation stuff starts to matter in German. Kierka or Kirk, where we get church, it does not mean like the Ecclesia vibe was, hey, Jesus, this is a movement. Yeah. You're the called out ones. He's referring to a people that he's creating. Kierka in German, it means sacred place. So dude, here's why it matters when we start inserting Kierka or church in. It actually subtly shifts the mentality of what is Jesus talking about. He's not talking about a building, even though buildings for literally 2,000 years have been one of the greatest tools the churches use to disciple people reach people all the things. He's talking about a people. He's going, I'm going to create a movement. By the way, that's why our vision statement says a movement for all people, where does all people come from, the great commission in Greek, it says taethne. What does taethne mean? It means all people. That's what we got that. That's where church of 11, 22. Got that. I heard it first. That's where the great deal. I've heard it said. I've heard it taught life. So that's what he says to sacred place. Now what people started doing, early translators, they start going, hey man, these two words church and Ecclesia have different connotations. One's about a place, one's about a people. So here's a fun fact. No, and tell for your little church history nerds, William Tyndall is the first guy to translate the Bible in English in modern language. So William Tyndall starts translating the Bible into English for the first time. He gets to this word, how am I going to translate Ecclesia? And for people had been saying church from the German Kierke, William Tyndall looks to the original language, Greek, and he goes, hey bro, that's not the vibe of the word Ecclesia. In his original translation, he chooses to translate it congregation instead of church. William Tyndall does this. By the way, I did my little research this week. That is one of the primary things that puts him at odds with the authorities of the day. This right here, this decision is one of the decisions that leads to William Tyndall being burned at the stake alive. That one translation thing. So he gets tried as a heretic because the authorities view that is he's undermining their control. Hey, we have authority over this place. And you're saying it's not the word doesn't primarily refer to the place it refers to. So anyway, this is what it does. Now bro, this is what I love. This is a fun little thing. At William Tyndall's trial, you love stories about faithful, courageous Christians. At William Tyndall's trial where he's being tried as a heretic, I'm going to read it famous quote. One of the final things he says is he says, if God spares my life air these many years, I will cause the boy that drives the plow to know more of the scriptures than you do. It goes so hard. He goes so hard. He's like looking at the people who he knows they may burn me alive for this because they were like quit translating the Bible in languages. Everybody can understand their vibe. We're going to get to this with Roman Catholicism in a second. Their vibe was like keep the Bible in Latin primarily because normal people can't be trusted to read and serve to the Bible at William Tyndall. Bro, I'm just going to read it again because it goes so hard. Plants his feet, chest out, looks right of the people who are eventually going to kill him. If God spares my life air these many years, I will cause the boy that drives the plow to know more of the scriptures than you do. He ends up successfully translating the Bible into English so that every normal dude, like every farmer, every smith can read his own Bible in English for the first time in human history. His last words before he's burned at the stake are Lord, open the king of England's eyes. And listen, listen, listen. A few years later, the King of England commissions the King James Bible. In the language of English, the Lord answered William Tyndall's final prayer, open the king of England's eyes. And today, that is why we have something that for a thousand years, Christians didn't have where we can sit down and feast on the precious words of God in our own language in my living room this morning. Thank you, William Tyndall. Yes, I'm so crazy. It goes hard. That's amazing. It goes hard. Now, let me, let's get into this thing real quick here, okay? Because I'm not joking or exaggerating when I say how you interpret this past, it has literally split church history in, in half. So I'm just going to read it straight from the scribes right here. This is Matthew 16. Here's, here's the whole thing. Now, when Jesus came to the district of Cessaria, Philippi, he asked his disciples, who do people say the Son of Man is about what we're going to brag on. So if he cutting him, shout out, live free nation. She did this in an interview with the Elvon recently. She literally did this. And they said, well, some say John the Baptist, others say Elijah, others Jeremiah are one of the prophets. Then he, Jesus said to them, most important question any human being ever has to answer. But who do you say that I am? Simon Peter replied, you are the Christ, the Son of the living God. Now, here's where we start getting into stuff that divides church history. And Jesus answered him, blessed are you Simon, bar, Jonah. That just means son of Jonah. Yeah. For flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, but my, but my father who is in heaven, that's a gentle way for Jesus to say, you're not that smart. Hey, brother, you're not that smart. That's a gentle way. Verse 18. And here we go. And I tell you, you are Peter, Greek, Petros. And on this rock, Greek, Petra. Okay. I will build my church at Glacier. And the gates of the English Bible says, hell, you should say, hey, these shall not prevail against it. Here's another verse, blitzed church history and half. I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven. And whatever you bind on earth, shall be bound in heaven. And whatever you loose on earth, shall be loosed in heaven. Now, Paul Cunningham, let's do some theology nerd stuff. - All right. - That right there divides Catholics and Protestants for, since the Protestant Reformation, I'm always gonna give our same caveat. We love our Catholic friends. But hey, we're honest about, we say this is image different. So Paul, can you explain why, so do two things. Why do these verses divide Protestants' Catholics throughout all of church history, and then why are the Protestants right? Go for it. - Before you do, because we want to sit the tone appropriately, we have a couple of memes to introduce. Chat you people see here. So Trinity, can you pull the first one? So here's the first one. Happy Reformation Day. So it is Martin Luther, and it says Popeyes, Popeyes, and in the bottom it says Pope, no. - That's hysterical. - So I like it. So first one, then the second one, it says Pope says Catholics who can't go to a confession can ask God directly for forgiveness, and that is Jim, kind of making a face. (laughing) - 500 years later Martin Luther feels vindicated. - Because we're talking about Peter being the rock, here's the third one. It says Peter saying, seriously, you're changing my name to Peter the rock? Why? And Jesus says, when you were walking on the water, you sunk like water. (laughing) - Okay, now's your thing, bro. - Yeah, yeah, so in terms of why it divides, we did a whole episode on denominations, and we identified five or six reasons why denominations can split. And one of them is what is the ultimate source of authority? And so Catholics right here would say, that obviously Jesus is the Lord of the church, but in terms of his delegated authority on earth, they would point to this passage and say that this shows that Peter is the rock that Jesus is gonna build his church on, and he's gonna be given the keys to the kingdom, specifically and exclusively only to Peter. And the way they interpret this is to mean that Peter, in his time had the exclusive and supreme authority to lead the church in his day. And then after that, and there's another key thing they would say, is that not only was he given that to Peter in his day, he was also establishing an office which Peter oversaw. - Hey, papal success. - The papacy, the Bishop of Rome, as they would say. They would say that Peter was the first Bishop of Rome. And then after him, whoever succeeded him as a Bishop of Rome, he had that same authority all the way to this day. So again, let me restate that. And then I'm gonna show you, I'm not just saying this up. - Unbroken succession of popes. See, let me restate that. So they understand that Peter is a rock that he's gonna build the church on, but having the keys to the kingdom, he has supreme authority over what we believe and over what we do in his day. And then every successor of him after that, the Bishop of Rome also known as the Pope has that to this day. So again, don't take my word for it. Let's read what's called Vatican I. Vatican I, around 1869, 1870, they actually hammered this out of the idea of the infallibility of the Pope and his authority. So I think we actually have some quotes that I just took some screenshots from my notes that we can look up together. This is directly from Vatican I. Speaking of the papacy, a primacy of jurisdiction. So this right here is actually referring back to Matthew 16, what you just read. Over the whole church of God was immediately and directly promised to the blessed Apostle Peter. He's specifically referring to, I'm gonna give you the keys to the kingdom of Jesus. Because here the you is singular. We'll get to a wide a minute. We shouldn't necessarily take that at face value as it was only to Peter. But he says it was to Simon alone that the Lord, after his confession, spoke these words. Blessed are you, Simon Barjona for flesh and blood is not revealed to you. But my father is from heaven. And then also in Vatican when it says both clergy and faithful, in other words, those who are official clergy and those who are just members of the Catholic church of whatever right and dignity, both singly and collectively are bound to submit to this power, the power of the papacy by the duty of hierarchical subordination and obedience. Scripture's teaching about the papacy. I laugh because this is just patently not true. About the papacy has always been understood by the Catholic church. So what they're saying is, hey guys, even though we're not really officially doing this until about 1870, everyone's always known that he gave this authority exclusively to Peter and to every bishop of Rome after him. So this is straight from Vatican one. Let me actually be clear that the real issue here, 'cause people would debate, well, like what is this rock that Jesus is speaking of? Some people would say it's Peter. Some people would say it's Jesus himself. Some people would say it's Peter to confession. - Yeah, let me just highlight this for listeners. So I don't wanna gloss over what you said. There are three primary interpretations here. - Yes. - So that here's the question that divides church history. What is the rock on which Jesus is gonna build a church? And there's three options. - You got Peter himself. - Peter himself, and that's the Catholic option. - Yep, so that's, this is the first quote. - And exclusively Peter. That's what we gotta say is they would say Peter and exclusively alone. - Peter alone. - Only him. - Wait, Catholics say that? - Yes, because they, oh yeah, yeah, okay, I do get that. - 'Cause we'll come back to that in a minute of why this is the issue, right? - Option number two. - Option number two is to Jesus Christ. - Jesus Christ is the rock himself. - He is the rock. And the argument for that interpretation is when he says on this rock, he's going, "Hey, Peter just said who Jesus was." - Yes. - And that's the rock. - And I'm sorry. - And because all throughout the New Testament, Jesus is referred to as a soul. - Well, I'm gonna get that. I'm gonna get that. - Okay, you're gonna get that on my step. - I'm gonna get this on board. And then third option is Peter's confession. So let me just hang on. Let me summarize them. So those are three options. - Yes. - The rock is Peter himself. - Yep. - The rock is Peter's confession. The rock is Jesus. - Yes. - And specifically the issue is not only, and that's why I wanted to highlight it's not just if Peter is, or because some Protestants would say that they think that he was referring to Peter when he said this. But Catholics would say it's to Peter alone and to then every successor as the Bishop of Rome after that comes after Peter. There's two really big problems with the Catholic interpretation. Number one, the testimony of the New Testament and number two, the testimony of history. - That's kind of a big deal. - It's kind of a big deal. - If one of the main problems of your interpretation is the New Testament. It's kind of a big deal. - We have a problem. - We have a problem. - And when it comes to the testimony, and I'll try to do these fast, by the way, Gavin Orland does some great videos in this. He wrote a whole book of what it called, what it means to be Protestant. - Bro, I've heard it's great. - It's fantastic. - I'm right. - So just, we're gonna give some cliff notes. If you're like, well, what you didn't address this, he addresses this further in that book and videos. He does encourage you to go watch him and read him. But let me talk about absence of supporting evidence of the Catholic interpretation outside this passage and the presence of contradictory evidence. Let me ask you guys this. We kind of are joking about this. But do we think that the New Testament's kind of an important document for like how the church should run, including its leadership? - I'm a big fan of it. - We do. - Yeah, it's kind of a big deal. So then my thing is, if it's kind of a big deal, and you would think that the apostles would want people to know how it should run after they die, like why didn't they include any hint of the idea of an office of the Bishop of Rome or petrion supremacy outside of this passage? - Not a word. - In fact, like, we actually have whole chapters on other church offices like Elders and Deacons that take up multiple chapters. And the pastoral epistles in other places. - It's actually a really good point. - All these qualifications, and you never get a hint. By the way, the Apostle Paul doesn't tell Timothy or Titus, "Hey, appoint Elders and Deacons, but make sure and tell them that they ultimately have to submit to Peter and to his successors." You never get any of that. You get no qualifications for the Bishop of Rome, no hint that any of these people have to submit to him. But what does actually Paul say? He doesn't talk about a person in Rome they have to submit to. He talks about them having to submit to sound doctrine. - That's great, dude. - Which all of the apostles were the ones who were responsible for giving down. - Now, I'll just, I'm gonna cheat and say something in advance and I want you to go back. So if you're listening to your light, "Hey, man, what are the primary differences between the Catholic Church and the Protestant Church?" Now, I'm gonna show you seven. Here in a second, I'm gonna show you the, there's the seven, the seven. One of them, honestly, you can pull it all down like this. Every single, you take every single Protestant and nomination, there's no exceptions to this. And then the Catholic teaching. The one thing that is literally true about every single Protestant and nomination that differentiates from Catholicism is this one thing that the Bible has the supreme authority over the church. - Yes. - That is the one, the Catholics do not believe that historically. Catholic tradition is that the church and scripture are equal in authority because the church has the authority as some people kind of do it like this. As possessing the keys to rightly interpret the scripture and that is as authoritative in a functional way as the actual scripture. - That's right. So what we just said for a moment was, hey, we have the absence of any kind of supporting evidence, but we also have the presence of contradictory evidence. Just two chapters after this. Jesus says that responsibility of binding and losing for church discipline is given to all the apostles. Not just a Peter, it's to all of them. - Can I read it? - Yes, please do. - So a lot of people miss this. - And there's two chapters, okay, hey, so, hey, whatever you bind and lose and people like, oh, well, that's, well, we actually, yes, two chapters later, people miss Jesus says the exact same thing. What he's doing is he's applying what he said in Matthew 16, so what we should be doing is going, huh, let's watch how he applies what he said in Matthew 16. So this is the, we're two or three are gathered passage and this is about it's the confronting a brother who sins. That's this passage. Elevates all the way up to, well, 1 Corinthians 5 would refer to as like church discipline. And then Jesus says this in Matthew 18, 18, this will sound a little familiar for you, theology nerds who just read Matthew 16. Truly, I say to you, whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven and whatever you lose on earth shall be lost in heaven and he's referring to when a church reaches the point at which they are not deciding, recognizing. This is a person who's not acting like a believer and we need to treat him that way. - And the youth. there is plural. So the you and Matthew 16 was singular. That's why Catholic would say, "Hey, this was just a Peter." The you two chapters later is plural. So it's not, "Oh, just you Peter, you decide, and everybody else you just do your thing." It's plural. There's much more than just this. Ephesians 2.20 and Revelation 21 and 14 talks about how all the apostles are the foundation of the church. Not just one. Here's a huge one. Okay, so there's the bait and an issue in the early church that culminates in Acts 15 at the first church council. And I'm just thinking that if Jesus had made it really clear to everybody that Peter is the dude, he's the one supremely in charge. Then Peter just like, "All right, I'll decide and you guys go implement." Peter does speak of that council, but he doesn't have the final word and he doesn't have the biggest word. That most church historians and theologians would actually say that you know who is in charge of the first one? James. In fact, let me quote this guy. This is what this person says. James was invested with the chief rule. He got the final word and made the final decision. And he said, "It seems good to me." And then the final decision was made. This guy said, "James was invested with the chief rule." Anyone want to guess who that was from? I don't know. Oh, surely, like Martin Luther. No, John Chrysostom, one of the early Catholic church followers. Moving on, go into this. I'll have this be my last one. Then I want to talk about. Is it true? Do I have this right, my head? Was John Chrysostom discipled by either Polycarp or Ironist? There's like a discipleship line. I forget you want to look at that. The Apostle John and then Polycarp and then I think Irenaeus and it may have actually gotten to John Chrysostom. I'm curious. We'll say why you're looking this up. Chrysostom with Spurgeon. Most people consider one of the top two or three preachers of all time. Yeah, what was the nickname for Chrysostom? It caught him like the golden tongue. He was apparently he was just a freak of nature of preaching. So it'd be the Apostle John, the Cyborg Polycarp and Polycarp the Cyborg Irenaeus, but I just can't remember. I don't know. I know why you're looking at it. I tried. I tried. I tried too. But I know more. Galatians to Paul is defending his credentials and his authority. He mentions Peter among James and John as the pillars of the church, but he says they seem to me to be, but he doesn't isolate just Peter. And then two verses later, he says I contradicted Peter to his face. And the whole point of this passage is the Apostle Paul saying, I didn't have to get permission from these guys to be an Apostle. Yeah. Well, she would think that's really interesting. If Peter is the big dude, you would kind of think that Paul would have to go to him say, hey, can I be an Apostle? And he's like, dude, no, I they seem to need to be pillars, but and then I contradicted to his face when he was wrong. Anyways, for this and more, they just don't Catholics don't have a strong spiritual case because the absence of of things that support their view and the presence of things that contradict it. Now you already said this, but here's what they'll say. Well, hey, that's just because you believe in solar scriptural, which by the way, yes, we do, and we're very proud of that. They would say, but hey, we also have the tradition of the early church. Here's the problem with that is the early church history also would take our side in this. And don't take my word for it. I actually want you to take Catholic historians words for it. Oh, my. I've got some on the screen that we need. Here's what they had to say. I woke up today wanting to read a cast. Here we go. I've got three of them very clouds. Oh, yeah, of course, Claus. Is that? So he's a Jesuit church historian. So in his book in par papal primacy, he basically asked, hey, how would a Christian in 80, 100, 200, 300 answer the question of whether the Bishop of Rome had the last word on all matters? His answer is that he or she would certainly have said no. Fascinating. Okay. John O'Malley also a Jesuit church historian in the first millennium. Popes did not run the church or did they claim to? By the way, Jesuits, that's like a Catholic, like, maybe you see almost like they're big time. There's the kind of Johann Donger of a little background info. So we read or quote earlier from Vatican one, where basically he says, hey, the Pope is infallible and he's supreme. And everyone is always viewed it this way. The issue with that is you had a lot of church historians that were Catholic said, guys, this is silly. This is just not true historically. The church is not always viewed it this way. In the first four centuries, not everyone bowed down to the church. And again, go read some of that. He gives a lot of examples of how this is the case. I might mention one for just speed. But Johann refused to give in. And they excommunicated him. And just we don't believe it. We're about to say, but in Catholic world, like if you don't repent, if you die excommunicated, you go to hell. Yeah, you go to hell. And he refused to. And this was why he said, he said, when asked, here's what he said, if I, why he didn't recant, if I did so in a question, which is for the historical eye perfectly clear and unambiguous, there would then be no longer for me any such thing as historical truth and certainty. I should then have to suppose that my whole life long I had been in a world of dizzy illusion and that historic and historical matters, I am altogether incapable of distinguishing truth from fable and falsehood. This is a Catholic historian who said, guys, this is ridiculous. This is not the way the church is always viewed it. So the point is in terms of the Catholic interpretation, man, their biblical case is weak and their historical case is weak. Now over the first few centuries, did the bishop and Rome accrue power that in general they gave deferrence to yes, but it wasn't absolute deferrence. Let me give one piece of evidence we could give many, but for time's sake, I'll give one. In Vatican II, and I believe also in Vatican I, it talks about how the pope alone has the power to convene church councils, ecumenical church councils, and then to decide them. Guess how many popes convened or decided the first seven ecumenical councils over the first 800 years of church history, a whopping zero zero. And in fact, at one of the councils, they excommunicated a former pope because he had been in heresy. So apparently that pope had supreme power that they he was excommunicated after he died, which would have been awkward. Does that mean like according to the belief he was in heaven and all of a sudden he just poofed like ends up in hell all of a sudden? Anyway, all right. Is that anything you want to double click on? So here's all so do this. Yeah, so first of all, let me just say, here's my belief. So Protestants reject the first of the three options. Let me just do this real quick. Protestants reject the first three options. Well, in general, Protestants reject the concept that the church is built on the papal office, and that's what Jesus is referring to, obviously. Now, the two options that Protestants typically do, then I did this in the sermon. Yeah, people didn't realize it, but that's what I was doing. I was preaching one of these two interpretations. What Protestants do is they go, hey, what the rock refers to is either Jesus himself or the confession. Now, can I just point something out? Number one, this is very interesting. So who Catholics say is the rock is Peter? Peter's the rock. Well, let's ask who does Peter himself refer to as the rock when Peter gets into the New Testament and writes first Peter. By the way, when they titled things back then, they went for clear over cute. It's just called first Peter. So this is what first Peter says. He calls Jesus a, this is so interesting to me. And I think when I read one about the read, I think what Peter's doing is Peter is interpreting what Jesus said in Matthew 16. He calls Jesus, quote, the living stone rock disavowed by men, but chosen of God and precious. You, you, there's, honestly, there's tons. Uh, uh, Ephesians 2 20 Jesus himself being the chief corner stone. First Corinthians 10, 4 and did all drink from the same spiritual drink for the drink of that spiritual rock that followed them and that rock was Christ. So I mean, like, dude, you could, so one, you see that too. I'll just point this out. It's very interesting to me. So I personally, I tend to kind of go that the primary thing Jesus is referring to there is Peter's confession. You're the Christ Son of the living God. I think that's generally the rock. He's gone and built my church on that. Here's honestly, what are the reasons I do that? If you were to take all literally every denomination, even, even Catholics, every denomination that ever exists. And I remember before I say this, what does Peter say? What's the confession? If you were to take every denomination that's ever existed, the Charismatics, the non-charismatics and the reformed and the informed and the deformed and the literally everything. Everybody that's every frozen chosen everybody, okay? He even take the Protestants and the Catholics, everybody. Listen, bro, there is one thing and one thing only every single person in the room will agree on. Jesus was the Christ, the Son of the living God. Yes. I honestly think just the witness of church history leads you to like, oh, bro, that's it. That's the thing. And I'm glad you did this, Pastor Dosh, because I spent a few minutes trying to shred a little bit of the Catholic position, but just straight it clearly. Go back to the keys of the kingdom. Protestants would say it is the faithful teaching and proclamation of the gospel that Jesus is Messiah. And then all the beliefs that correspond to that. So I actually want to connect one that I love that you put in Peter here. He says on this rock, and if we take that to be the confession of Jesus is the Messiah, they said, I will build my church future. When was the church we would believe actually created an institute at the day of pinnacles. Yeah, pinnacles. Yeah, acts to which interesting is acts to Peter is preaching a sermon. So it's like on this rock. So even if we take it to mean Peter, maybe it still fits here is like Peter preaches this initial message. And at the very end, he says this, no for certain that God has made him talk about Jesus, both Lord and Christ Messiah. I have never noticed that in the same confession thing. So in Matthew, Peter makes the confession. And then in Acts, he makes the proclamation that they then have to confess to be forgiven and then be baptized. And that's what I would say is he's pointing to this moment. So I'm right there with that. I just want to connect those dots between the confession and then the proclamation which we believe built the church. Here in just a second, we're going to talk about Sophie Cunningham, but before you're good, if I do a little theological thing as well. So are you on the Catholic prayer cabinet? - Yeah, because I got one more thing too. - Oh, you want to do yours first? - No, no, you do the rock thing, and then finish. - Yeah, so some theologians have also pointed out that there seems to be a connection between what you just read in Matthew chapter 16 and Psalm 89. So Psalm 89 is a lament, basically the psalmist is writing, talking about the kingdom that God promises is gonna be an everlasting kingdom from the line of David. And the psalmist is lamenting, "Hey, the David's kingdom actually fell into humiliation." So what happened? So there's like, "God, where are you?" And where's your faithfulness? And what about this kingdom that you promised? So that's Psalm 89. Let me just read you some verses from Psalm 89, and you tell me if it sounds familiar. Psalm 89 verse 20 says, "I have found David my servant with my holy oil. I have anointed him, that word anointed is a verb, and the root of that word is the word Christos in Greek. Again, now fast forward to Matthew 16, 16, Peter tells Jesus, "You are the Christos, "you are the Christ, you are the anointing "what the Son of the living God." Let me keep going, that's one. Number two, Psalm 89, 26, "He shall cry to me, "You are my father, my God, and the rock of my salvation." Fast forward to Jesus, Matthew 16, 18, Jesus tells Peter, "You are Peter, and on this rock, "I will build my church, same imagery." Number three, Psalm 89, four, I will establish your offspring forever, and build your throne for all generations. Build this, the word in Greek is "Oicodomio." Now look at what Jesus says in Matthew 16, 18. On this rock, I will build "Oicodomio," my church, same word, by the way, same word in the Greek, OT version, the Greek translation. Let me keep going, Psalm 89, five, "Let the heavens praise your wonders, O Lord, "your faithfulness in the assembly of the holy ones." Assembly is the word, "Ecclesia." - Bro, I have never heard this before in my life. - Fast forward to Jesus, Matthew 16, 18. On this rock, I will build my assembly, my ecclesia, my church, same word, same word. Keep going, Psalm 89, 48, "What man can live and never see death, "who can deliver his soul from the power of Chael "in the Greek translation of the Old Testament?" That word, "Chael" is translated as. - Hades. - Now look at what Jesus says, Matthew 16, 18, "And the gates of Hades shall not prevail against my church." So just in Psalm 89, you got the rock, the building, the anointed one, the assembly, and the rum of death, Hades. And so the psalmist is asking, "God, "what happened to this everlasting kingdom from David? "Where is it? Why is it not here?" And by the way, who can defeat death? And then here comes Matthew with the same words, and says the rock, the building, the anointed one, the assembly, the rum of death, and three verses later. Jesus tells his disciples that he will face death, and he will rise again on the third day, and so here's the point. The one who builds the church is the one who conquers the grave. So Jesus is the answer to the question the psalmist is asking, he is the fulfillment of the promise for that eternal kingdom. (laughing) - Welcome to Liverpool with Arles de Razo. - Psalm 89, man. - That was fire. - I'm not so good. - Bro, I've never heard of it before in my life. - I just read it this week, this is crazy. - That's insane. - So let me give, let me finish with encouragement, and then let's go Sophie. - Yeah. - Let's, we're gonna see you're on the Sophie Crushed. - Yes. - This was like a disciple being a disciple. (laughing) - Well, hey guys, one of the reasons we are intentional in creating this kind of podcast episode is because we believe that discipleship happens in relationships. Having said that, what we wanna do through the live free podcast is we wanna model what it looks like to be in a discipleship group, where we come together and open up the word of God and grow together as followers of Jesus' delivery in Christ. And so for this reason, we love that you're tuning in. And honestly, we don't just want you to be a passive listener, we want you to be an active participant. And so if you have not gotten connected to a local church, I wanna challenge you to find one near you. One starting point that might be helpful is the text map to 20411 to find where some of our partner churches are located. And because here's why, you're not one podcast away, one habit away, one decision away, one book away, or one sermon away, you are one relationship away to experience freedom in Christ in community. Let's go ahead and do that. And now, let's get back to the podcast. - Yeah, it was awesome. So here's essentially what this does. Let's bring it down to the discipleship level. This is live free not learn free, it's good. - What Jesus, what this means is that every spirit-filled believer has the keys. You got the keys. Jesus is looking at you, spirit-filled believer. And he's gone, I'm giving you the keys to the kingdom of heaven because you have the ability to faithfully share the gospel throughout the ages. And he's looking at him, he's going, "Hey, whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, whatever you loose on earth will be loose in heaven." And if you go back, this is awesome, dude. So all that goes back, a little deep cut. It all goes back by Isaiah 22. When Jesus does the key thing and bind and loose, he's referring back to another census plan, your prophecy, your fulfillment, full fulfillment. Isaiah 22, check this out, bro. It says, "I will place on his shoulder the key "of the house of David, what he opens, no man can shut, "and what he shuts, no man can open." - Wow, man. - Listen, bro. I get do anything he gives me about it. So what Jesus is saying, he's looking at every spirit-filled believer with a gospel in their mouth and the spirit in their heart and fire in their eyes and love in their soul. And he's going, "I am giving you the spirit-filled authority "to go take all the nations." And right now, there's doors that the enemy has kept locked for millennia, you go open a spirit-filled believer and when you go faithfully share the gospel in word and deed and you share this message with people. Listen, bro, it doesn't matter if the gates of hell and all the authorities on the earth are trying to keep that door shut, you're gonna open that door. So let me just do this real quick. And then, let's go talk Sophie. So last week, I alluded to this. One of my favorite quotes I've ever read, G.K. Chesterton, by the way, Catholic. (laughing) But just, hey, this is an example of how we love some of our teachers, okay? - Oh, it's awesome. - Dude, it's actually in the everlasting man. That's the book. - Oh, good book. - Okay, so a great book. Two books, if you're a super nerd and you wanna read two books, then he laughed it. - He laughed it off. - Wait, no, I'm tape. Why not? - I don't know what you said. - Two great books. - Two great books that if you're a nerd and you're like, dude, I just want to. - Wait a little book started. I missed it. - Oh, okay, go ahead. - His orthodoxy book, start there. - Okay. - Start it orthodoxy and then go everlasting man. - Okay. - So it's from everlasting man. So he's just finished, I don't have a quote up there. He's just finished going through all history about all these different like movements and moments and ideologies where everybody thought, Christianity's done. It's gonna be gone. And then Chesterton drops this bomb, at least five times, therefore, with the Aryan and the Albejinsian, I'm not getting into that right now, with the human skeptic after Voltaire and after Darwin, the faith to all appearances had gone to the dogs. And in each of these five cases, it was the dog that died. Now, bro, let me just do this real quick. If you're a Christian and you're like, looking at election results or ideologies or cultural trends and you're going, oh man, I'm scared, I'm the church is failing. What are we gonna do? Here's what we're gonna do. We're gonna have some daggum confidence. You know why? 'Cause 2000 years ago, Jesus Christ made a promise, and His promise was I will build my church. And for 2000, let me just, let me riff on this. For 2000 years, Jesus Christ had been keeping His promise. Let me do this real quick. In 303 AD, the Roman Emperor Diacletian went on a rampage, tried to stamp out the entire church. He ordered every Bible burned and fed Christian families to lions. Just 10 years later, the Roman Emperor Constantine became a Christian and eventually ends up establishing Christianity as an acceptable religion in the Roman Empire and just a few years later it becomes the official religion of the Roman Empire. A few years later, the French atheist Voltaire in the 18th century, this dude literally said, I had to read him in high school. Dude, literally said, within 100 years of his death, no one would even remember the Bible today. In his house, I kid you not, sits a Bible printing press. I am on my grandmother's side. Personally, I'm a descendant of this. There's a little small group of Christians. Most people who never heard of, they were called the Huguenots on grandma's side, the little French Christians, Huguenots. They were a very hated gospel-loving group of Christians in France that the government tried to stamp out. And at one point, the French government thought they had completely eradicated them all. But they survived. And they grew. Today, when you travel over there to France, there is a monument commemorating the gospel-preaching Huguenots that says this, bro, this goes so hard. The monument says, pound away, you evil hands. The hammer breaks, the animal stands. (laughing) In the mid 20th century, Mao Zedong and the Chinese Communist Revolution, they tried to stamp out Christianity in the 20th century. They expelled every Western Christian missionary in 1949. Everybody in China thought, oh no, the missionary's gone. The church is gonna fall apart. Everything's gonna go away, okay? Today, Mao Zedong is very, very dead. But the church in China is growing there faster than it has ever grown anywhere in human history by the year 2050. There is projected to be more Christians in China than there are the United States. In 1979, bro, the Iranian Revolution established a hard-line Islamic regime, 1979. Over the next two decades, they kicked out every missionary. Evangelism was literally outlawed. Bibles were banned in Persia. They became scarce. Several pastors publicly tortured and killed. Many feared in that time. They were like, oh no, what's gonna happen? Church is gonna fall apart. Everything's gonna go away, gospel going away. At that time, it's estimated there were less than, bro, listen, 500, less than 500 Christians and the church would just wither and die. The exact opposite happened. Wind of the spirit began to blow on the embers who would look like this dying coal. The ember became a flame. The flame became a bonfire today. There are more Iranians that have become Christians in the last 20 years than in, listen, the previous 13 centuries combined more than a million Iranians following Jesus to the underground church. Listen to me, Jesus Christ will build his church at the gates of hell. We'll never be able to stop it. You can bank on that promise. - Amen. - Amen. - Wow. - Praise God. - Come on. - Speaking of-- - Great news. - Speaking of every spiritual Christian having a keys for a faithful gospel proclamation. We gotta do this quick. Y'all want to talk Sophie. - Let's do it. - So you may wanna set this up. What do you know about this? - Yeah, so for people that don't know, Sophie Cunningham is a professional basketball player for the Indiana Feevers. And she is, we're about to watch a clip where she's basically-- - Well, Indiana Feever. - Oh, that's right. Indiana Feever, that's right. Thank you, thank you. That's a respect. - Thank you, thank you. Don't want to internet it. Let me start over. (laughing) So Sophie Cunningham, for people that don't know, is a professional basketball player for the Indiana Feever. And well, we're about to watch as a video of her with Phil Vaughn in his podcast, and they're having a conversation, real conversation about faith in life, and how her faith plays a major role in who she is. - By the way, just based on, like some things we've seen online, Sophie Cunningham, I think, live free nation, remember here. - Shout out to you. - So I'm just gonna count it. We're not true about counting it. - We gotta get her some merch. So if you're watching this, we'd love to get you some merch. - Let us know. - Okay. Now dude, here's honestly, this is one, this is a plus, like center of Bullseye example, a brother, listen, a normal Christian, full of the spirit with a gospel in their mouth, just sitting down and sharing Christ with somebody. - Yeah. - Okay, now I don't know, like it's a little unclear, like, you know, we've even talked on the pod before. Where's Theo at? What I love is, he's moving to the right direction. So you can just see it, and I think I love the guy. I love it, okay. Now this is just, if you're a Christian and you're just like, hey man, okay, Jesus gonna build his church. He can be through me, sharing the gospel with people. I don't know how to do it. Okay, here's how you do it. So like, let me just wanna point a few things out, this legit, let's say here we go. So if we're counting hand Theo Vaughn. - Let's talk about your faith. You got baptized as an adult, right? - I'm gonna bring you to church with me. - To what church you go, what church you go to? - Because of my lifestyle. I don't have-- - It's hard to go sometimes. - Well, I just don't have like a home home church. But like, I'm just like, I was raised Catholic, but now I'm just like more Christian. So I can never say this word non-denominational. Just set it. And so like, yeah, I just, I love Jesus. And I've actually listened to you a little bit that you're starting to maybe get into it or intrigued by it a little bit. - Pause, okay. So dude, first of all, here's what I love. It's just like, hey man, here, like, that's the type of person. Here's all you need to do. Here's 95% of being I was sure Christ was somebody. You just wanna be like a normal you? - Yeah. - That loves Jesus. Like, they need to be able to look at you and go like, people honestly, brother, they wanna look at people like me and Chad G. Paul C, Bob will nerd over here and Carlos a little more normal than us, but you know, honestly, they'll look at guys like us and a lot of people will be like, I could never be a Christian like that. They'll look at Sophie Cunningham, do stuff like this and go, why could be a Christian like that? That's like half the game, okay? That dude, here's what I love is did you, so here's step one, did you notice this? So he asked her about her face, so first of all, she just out, I'm on team Jesus. He knows it. That's half the game. The people around you know that guy, that girl, team Jesus, that's it. But then here's what's awesome as she did. She said, I've heard you're starting to get intrigued about it a little bit. Now she's turning it to him. Listen Matthew 16, who do you say that he is? - Ah, bro. - So she just, hey, let me just flip it real quick. Let me just real gently and it wasn't weird, but here's like 95% of Sharon Christ. It just don't be weird. (laughing) Like just, hey man, I've heard you're starting to get intrigued about it a little bit, okay? Who do you say that he is? Now watch what she does, this is master class right here. - Oh yeah. - Or maybe that was just you, not actually? I don't know, but it's okay. But all I'm saying is I rely a lot on my face because of what I do for a living. - It's so natural. - You get a lot of praise and I think that just like morally and my head, everything, like it just keeps me stable and it keeps me to be who I am. Like I don't care what people's opinions are about me because I'm not living for their praise. - Okay, stop, stop. Okay, so here, dude, this is just like, this is master class. I'm honestly, dude, I'm so proud to be on like team Jesus with somebody who's doing that like that, okay? So here's all she does. It's like she's doing Bible verses and you don't know she's doing Bible verses. So what did Jesus say in Acts 1? He's like, you will be my, he says, but you receive power when the Holy Spirit comes on you. Help me finish the verse and you will be my witnesses. Okay, so here's all she does. She's not going in to like, okay, let me go through the scientific evidence for young earth creationism and here's the reason that theism is true and then I'm going to pivot to why Christianity has to be, it's like, no, no, so here's all she does. In a normal way, she just goes, you know what has really changed my life? Is man, I'm in a public eye a lot and people really like you get hate and you get praise. And dude, Jesus just did something in me. And man, I like, I'm good, I'm good. Dude, so like, here's all she did. She's doing a Bible verse, you don't realize it. What Christians get messed up on in evangelism, sharing Christ, is that they get the spot in the courtroom they're supposed to sit in wrong. Okay, there's a difference, but you're called to be a witness, not a lawyer. And what Christians do is they start thinking, okay, I've got to be a lawyer, when that's not what I said, you got to be a witness. Here's the difference. A lawyer, a lawyer's job is to make an airtight case. Here's what I saw. That's what she's doing when she's like, man, here's what happened to me. Couple chapters after Acts 1, the apostles are saying, we can't help but speak of what we've seen in her career. Well, they had personal experience of Jesus. And that's all she's doing right now. She's talking about what she has seen Jesus do in her life. That's what you got to do. It's masterclass, okay, I'm so proud. So now watch, I'm gonna set this up. This is the perfect case study because what comes next in this conversation, when you're trying to get somebody to Jesus all the way, the gospel, what happens next to this conversation is what you got to help people with. And you usually don't know that's what you got to help people with. So just watch what Theo says right here. Check this out. - Yeah, the part that I like the most or sometimes right now in my life is just like prayer, connection with God. But then sometimes it's like, I'll get too busy and it gets like disconnected. And then I feel scared, almost get a little bit like, oh, don't be scared, why would you? - I'm not scared. I don't know why I said scared, but I get like, I wish I had, I wish my connection was stronger right now. That's what I get like. Like, you know, it's like, it's like if you charge your phone, but then you see you get low, but you feel like dang. - Dude, I feel like you need something to feel, but there's nothing. - Possibly, okay, you know, before we go here. So here's way to, do you notice what he's wrestling with? And this is everybody. So like, I'm proud of Theo too. It's like both of them are moving, this is awesome. This is what you're seeing right here. So what he's going is, hey, man, here's what I'm wrestling with. I'm trying to do the Jesus thing. And this is some, every Christian feels. Sometimes I feel like I'm doing real good. And then sometimes I feel like I'm doing real bad. And when I'm doing real bad, I kind of get scared just kind of what he started to say, feel like the connections week. So bro, here's what's going on. When you're doing evangelism, you're sure in Christ, 99% of the time, what you're really wrestling with is you're trying to get somebody out of the mentality they have to earn the favor of God and get him to the gospel says, Jesus already earned that for you. It's about trusting, not trying. So this is what she's doing here. By the way, this will help you. What you just saw will help you understand Bible verses you haven't understood before. If you got a first John 2, there's a passage. Most people are like, why the heck did he say that? This is why. So in first John 2, he like rifts off all these verses. He's like, I'm writing to you dear children. I'm writing to you fathers. Now I'm going to say this to you young men. Now I'm going to say this to you old men. I don't have time to do it. We're trying to speed around this episode. What John's doing in first John 2 is he saying, hey, at every stage of your Christian development, there's this thing you're probably going to struggle with. What he says, he says, dear children. What he's saying to people who are either brand new baby Christians or they're dipping their toe on, team Jesus for the first time, listen to what he says. I am writing to you dear children because your sins have been forgiven on account of his name. What he's saying is when you're a brand new Christian, the greatest struggle you have is internalizing the reality. My sins really have been forgiven. Like me and God, we actually are good. And his love for me is not dependent upon my obedience to him. So when my connections weak, I don't got to be scared. Yeah. That's what first John is doing. And usually when you're doing evangelism or like very early discipleship, that's what you're trying to get into somebody's heart. Now you're going to, but she crushes this. Like this is, I'm like literally cheering. Watch what she does. I'm just going to say this and this for other people listening too. But there's nothing that you can or can't do. That's going to separate you from God's love and grace and forgiveness. Like that's what just came and died across because you already knew everything you were going to do. So like, I mean, that's up to you now to like kind of educate yourself and read the Bible of like, good, bad. How are you going to represent? but like you're already forgiven. Stop. So I just want to just point this out. So first of all, she is and she knows Theo. I've never met Theo Vaughn, but she's relating to him as a brand new Christian. So I do just want to differentiate. Yes. You don't say that to somebody that's not a Christian, because honestly, it's not true that you're already forgiven. The New Testament language is you are still in your sense. You stand condemned. A lost person actually needs to be afraid. A saved person needs to have perfect love cast out fear. So I think she and she knows more about where he's at. So I think that's that's fine. But what she's doing is she's applying the gospel to this dude that at the very least is moving towards Jesus. So I'll just say this like man, for if you're a brand new Christian that you feel you feel Theo when he's like, dude, sometimes I'm doing good and I feel good. Sometimes I'm doing bad. I get a little scared that God's angry with me, mad at me, disappointed with me. I just want to remind you something. This is what Sophie is saying right here. Romans 8, there is therefore now no condemnation for who? For those who are in Christ Jesus. In Christ Jesus. Now here's what I always do. And this is really important. Okay. What I like to do is ask people like in a sermon, hey, on a scale of one to 10 right now, get a number in your head. How does God feel about you? Most people go seven or like if they had a bad night last night, they go three or something like that. You know, if you're a Christian, the answer is it's always a 10. Yes. Because there is therefore now no condemnation. Watch for who? In Christ Jesus. God does not love you to the degree that you are like Christ Jesus. He loves you to the degree that you are in Christ Jesus. And that's always a 10. Sophie right here, what you're seeing, you have the keys to the kingdom of heaven. He is given that spirit filled Christian, spirit filled proclamation of the true gospel. That's what she did right there. Good job. That's amazing job. Good job. Now wait, he keeps going. Okay. Watch what you keep going. So like, no, I think I understand that I'm saying. Yes. You probably feel better when you are right. If you just when you are praying and you are, oh, yeah. I mean, yeah, well, I just feel I just feel more of a like personal connection when it's like I'm prayed up. Yeah. My buddy says stay prayed up. I like that. He said it all the time. Stay prayed up. It's almost like if you talk to somebody around the end that you don't have to catch up with them. Well, that's a thousand percent what it is. That's what I'm saying. Yeah, no, 100%. So it's like, but sometimes I'll get like, yeah, I'll just, yeah, I'll just get honestly busy. Yeah. So let's acknowledge this reality and I don't just want to move on. You will feel more or less intimate with God, depending on your relationship. You are never more or less loved by God, because that's dependent on Jesus. Okay. I just want to get that. So totally affirm everything. He just said right there. Let's keep going. I mean, but that's natural. That's what it is to be human. You just got to prioritize the good. Yeah. Yeah. Do you feel like I feel like someone's the media doesn't, it feels like it's the media's unfair to Christians. Do you ever feel like that? Yeah. We are about more versus. I mean, it's all all how you perceive it and your perspective on things. But I do love that there's more more people coming out that they are Christians and that they are believers and notice the word coming out. I feel like there's a revival happening. And I love when people have the confidence to be their true selves and to represent something better than them. Sometimes it can be scary of, you know, you never know how people are going to take that because people have, you know, bad experiences with the church or really with the church or religious people. And that's not really what it is. Let me just say something. If that's you and you've been running from Jesus because you have bad experiences, church kind of just say something to you. Don't let what a church did to you, keep you from what Jesus did for you. Christians are not Christ. So I just want to pause and say that. So it's really smart for her to let me just get that out of the way. So what I'm pointing out, she just like crushes and executes this entire conversation like, let me get that out of the way. Let me do that. Like this is part, keep going. You see people coming out athletes, you know, it's kind of my realm and you see more and more people who have a huge platform, have a lot of eyes and ears looking at them. It's cool to see them be able to be bold and courageous and come out about Jesus. Okay. Pause. I just want to point out the language. Yeah. It's very interesting language over and over again. Come out, come out, come out. So first of all, we just read a Bible verse that the church is Ecclesia. They called out once. Let me just point that out. Good language. I also just want to say this like, Hey, dude, if you just want to be somebody that's like an absolute nuclear force for Jesus Christ, here's all you I do. Just be the dude that everybody knows is the team Jesus guy at work or the team Jesus girl on a team. That's all you got to do. That's what we got to hear in the merch by the way. Shout out. That's true. Team Jesus. That's right, bro. Just so that's it for. Hey, it's hey, uh, for $49.99. You can just shout out. Live free not shout. Live free. That's a joke. But that's seriously it. Like if you'll just be the person everybody knows, that's the team Jesus guy. Okay. And I'll just gently say this. She uses the word come out over and over again. We say it's all time. If the world has the courage to come out of the closet for unrighteousness, Christians should have the courage to come out of the closet for team Jesus, unequivical. Full stop. Okay. That's what she's doing. Now check, check this out. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It is. I think a lot of you know what I do. Notice that you see a lot of it amongst athletes. There's a lot of faith in the athlete. That's true. There's a reason that that's real. Or do you think that that's posturing sometimes? And I guess maybe does it even matter? But I just thought about it. It's like the more like more athletes that I've got to know probably in the past four years. I've known more than ever in my whole life. Yeah. And it does seem like there's a lot more faith-based energy in their world. Yeah. I actually just want to point this out. They're actually, he's right. And there actually is a reason for this. So I just, I don't want to do this real quick. This whole theology thing. There's an enormous number of athletic parallels and analogies in the New Testament. I'm gonna read like a ton. I'm gonna get to something most people miss. This is why, dude. A lot of athletes make the best disciples. Yes. There's a reason for that. Like, please notice that. I'm gonna run, read some Bible verses. Run in such a way as to win the prize. I beat my body to make it my slave. Fight the good fight of faith. We wrestle not against flesh and blood, forgetting what lies behind and straining toward what lies ahead. Train yourself for godliness. An athlete is not crowned unless he competes. It's according to the rules. It's everywhere. So I'll just gently just kind of point this out. He's totally right. Yeah. There are actually the spiritual reasons for this. Athletics put you in touch with more aspects of being a disciple than almost anything else you ever do. It puts you in touch with things like authority, character formation. Hey, bro, I have an actual opponent. I'm trying to defeat. I need a power greater than myself. The consequences of your actions are immediately felt. You have a natural understanding of rewards. I brought all that stuff. So let me just say he's doing Bible verses and he doesn't know he's doing Bible verses. He's 100% right. Now, watch what happens next. Let's keep going. Yeah. Do you think like coming from like, is this like a comedian like the comedian world? You don't see it as much or you're just like the, because you're kind of in a different. Yeah, comedians that you don't see it as much, but comedians are just questioning everything and they're like, you know, a lot of them probably, which I don't think that's a bad thing. Like, I don't think questioning it, asking the why is bad either. Yeah. I didn't mean to, I was just gently pointed this out. This is not Theo. This is not, I'm not talking about Theo. He's right. Yeah. There are a lot, I'll just gentle observation. I don't want to go too far on this. Why are there a lot of athletes that move toward faith and a lot of comedians that run away from it? Because the new testament uses athletic analogies for being a disciple and the book of Proverbs calls the scoffer. Yeah. It says walk not on the counts of the wicked, nor stand in the way of sinners, nor sit in the seat of scoffers. Not all of them, not Theo. A lot of comedians, honest what they are, they're professional scoffers. So I just a little gentle observation. Let's keep going. I think this is all I know. Like, I've only ever been an athlete. So like, I've, there are athletes who aren't, and that's totally okay. And, you know, it is what it is. That's, that's their walk. But I know the majority of people that I'm around in, who I know, they are faith-based. Oh, yeah. I mean, I find more and more of my friends are these days or trying to, and that's really the biggest thing, is just trying to have a relationship, trying to learn about it. We want to have some more religious figures on to talk about stuff on here. It's pretty fun. You should. And like, people who love history, love science, like, talk to these people who are like, I don't know, they're just experts when it comes to the Bible. And that's what they do for living. And so people are like, oh, well, history and science, it doesn't make so I'll actually all pretty much top scientists. They figured out that Jesus did live. And he is real. And so you should have them on because I think you have a fascinating conversation. And I think you would ask some great questions. Pause. So again, this is honestly, this is like, we're weirdly doing evangelism training with so beginning of the oven because she crushed. But what I'll point out is, this is a total evangelism hack. Here's your total evangelism hack. If somebody's even mildly interested or open, when you finish the conversation, point them toward other resources or people, it's like, going, get them deeper. That's what she does. So hey, you should do this. What read this guy? I'm going to give you three. These are the ones I use in airplanes. I have Amazon these books to books to people. I sat next to one airplanes. I have three. case for Christ by at least trouble, live shout out, live free nation, at least trouble. That's the one I give to like, that's my standard go to. Okay. If I'm talking to somebody that's a little more academic or intellectual, second book, is I go reason for God, Tim Keller. - Yep, great book, great book. - So if they're a little more academic, a little more intellectual, reason for God, Tim Keller, and then third one, another live free nation member, by the way. If somebody's, if they're, they're maybe not, if you're dealing with somebody who's a little more like, they're not just academic and philosophical, they're more like, ah, I'm an agnostic, I'm an atheist. The third one I'll do is I go, I don't have enough faith to be an atheist by the way. - That's right, I figured I'd go there. - Shout out, shout out, live free nation. So I'm just going to put the, have those bullets in your gun. Like maybe stick them in an iPhone note literally right now. Those three, Case for Christ, Lee Strobel, Reason for God, Tim Keller, I don't have enough faith to be an atheist Frank Turg. - And just to go around what you're saying, one of the things we're trying to say is you don't have to have all the answers for every question. - No, it's techno. - You just got to be able to at least point them to people who can't help those. Can I, can I point out one of the most important things for you to keep going? I want to point out one thing as a teachable moment that Sophie's doing so incredible, her tone. - Yes. - In these moments, she's not trying to own him. She's not trying to be right. She's just being very conversational, very gentle, just very casual. And we just got to remember it's, I felt this conviction a couple of years ago when I'm having a conversation with someone, after most of them, am I trying to win or am I trying to win them over? - Amen. - My aim determines my tone and my tactics. And so I just wanted to double click on that and say she is killing it, not just with her responses, she's killing it with her tone and her demeanor. - Yes, that's a huge thing too. - Yeah, so when she, this is so smart, dude. It's just so, she, it's like so fee. So like, so when she goes, you're going to ask great questions. Here's what I love that she, she didn't even know she did it probably. She just subtly helped him know, hey dude, you don't have to have all your questions answered and you don't got to have all your doubts figured out to start following Jesus. - Yeah. - In fact, I love the, it's a little old Joey Martin line. If you get a lot of doubts, you're going to make a great disciple. Because the disciples had a lot of doubts. - They did. - It's like, hey, you don't eliminate all your doubts. You just pick up your doubts and follow Jesus and you're like, well, he was raised from a dead. He's probably going to figure this out for me someday. If God's the size of the Pacific Ocean in my mind's the size of a Coke canter is going to be some things that don't fit. Okay, I can do that. But he was raised from the dead. I'm going to follow that guy even though I don't got my questions answered. Masterclass. - That's great. - And then we finished where we started the podcast. Let's finish. - Yeah. Yeah, we want to have it. Yeah, yeah, thanks. And yeah, we want to have the Pope on, but he won't. I don't even know if he has a phone. - Boss, we're done here. Papa don't poke. That's it. Ladies and gentlemen, hey, do it with me. So feet, so feet, so feet. - So feet. - Good job, man. Really proud. - Incredibly proud. - That was amazing. - Carlos, Carlos. - That's up. - We pray so. - I would love to. Heavenly Father, we thank you so much for your word. Thank you because it is good news every time we open this book. And we are reminded that we know at the end of the story and it ends up with you, Jesus being King of kings and Lord of lords, because that's who you are today. So Father, thank you because we have a hope in you. Thank you for your word. Thank you because you have called us to run into the breach. Would you fill us with your Holy Spirit every single person listening to this? May every whatever was been, has been shared, whatever it is, may you use it to light up a fire and a passion to be the disciples of Jesus that by the grace of God seek to be obedient and bold in doing what you have called us to do in this season. Thank you because even as we listen to Sophie, do share what she shared with Theo. Lord, I remind it of Matthew chapter 5 or 16, "Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works and glorify your Father in heaven." Father, may that be true of the live free nation. Thank you because you are good. Thank you because you are with us and we pray all of this in your mighty name, Jesus, amen, amen, amen. Amen. Live free, brother. Live free, brother. Well, hey, thanks so much for listening. Lake Point Church is a movement for all people's in no Christ. Live free and change a world for God's glory. If you're already a member of a local church, we want you giving there, but if you'd like to make a donation to help this message go further faster, it genuinely helps us boost getting out to more people. If you'd like to make a donation, you can text the word "give" to the number 2-0-4-1 and then just choose "Church Online" from that drop-down menu. To find out more about Lake Point, you can visit lakepoint.church.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Jesus’ statement in Matthew 16 about building His church on a rock has been a central point of theological debate between Catholics and Protestants.
  2. The Catholic interpretation identifies Peter as the rock and asserts he had exclusive, unbroken authority passed to the Pope, a view supported by Vatican I but lacking clear New Testament evidence.
  3. Protestant theology rejects papal supremacy, arguing that the "rock" refers either to Jesus Christ or Peter’s confession of faith, emphasizing the church as a movement of believers, not a hierarchical institution.
  4. The original Greek word "ekklesia" (called out ones) is translated into English as "church," but the German word "Kierka" (sacred place) influenced the modern meaning, leading to a shift in understanding from a people to a place.
  5. William Tyndall’s translation of "congregation" instead of "church" challenged Catholic authority, risking his execution, but ultimately led to accessible Bible reading for all people in English.
  6. New Testament evidence shows plural apostolic authority in church discipline and leadership, contradicting the Catholic claim of Peter’s sole, exclusive power.
  7. Historical records from early church councils and church historians show that the Bishop of Rome never had absolute authority, and the idea of papal supremacy was not universally accepted.
  8. The confession that Jesus is the Christ (Son of the Living God) unifies all Christian denominations, making it the foundational "rock" on which the church is built.

Summary:

The podcast explores the theological debate over Matthew 16:18, where Jesus declares, “On this rock, I will build my church,” and examines how this verse divides Catholic and Protestant understandings of church authority. Catholics interpret this as establishing Peter as the foundational rock, with exclusive, unbroken authority passed to the papacy through apostolic succession. However, the Protestant view rejects this, arguing instead that the "rock" refers to Peter’s confession of Jesus as the Christ—rooted in shared faith—and that the church is a movement of believers, not a hierarchical institution.

The discussion highlights how the translation of "ecclesia" into "church" has shaped theology, with William Tyndall’s courageous translation advocating for biblical accessibility, even at great personal risk. Key scriptural and historical evidence—such as the plural use of “you” in Matthew 18 about church discipline, and the absence of any mention of Peter’s supremacy in Paul’s letters—undermines Catholic claims. Early church history and councils, like Acts 15, show that leadership was shared, not centralized.

The episode concludes by affirming that the unifying truth across all denominations is the confession that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of the Living God—this shared belief forms the true foundation of the Christian church. The message emphasizes biblical authority over tradition, and the importance of accessible, personal faith in a global, living church.

FAQs

This refers to the foundational truth of the Christian faith—specifically, Peter's confession that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of the living God. The 'rock' is not Peter himself, but the confession of faith in Christ, which becomes the foundation of the Church.

Catholics believe the 'rock' is Peter himself, and that he was given exclusive authority by Jesus, establishing the papacy. This authority is passed down through the Bishop of Rome, known as the Pope, who has supreme leadership over the Church today.

Protestants believe the 'keys' refer to the authority to teach and teach the gospel truth, not to govern the Church. This authority is shared among all believers and apostles, not limited to one person.

It splits Catholics and Protestants over whether Peter holds supreme, unchallenged authority in the Church. This leads to different understandings of Church leadership, authority, and the role of the Pope.

The Greek word 'ecclesia' means 'called out ones' or a community of believers. The English word 'church' comes from German 'Kirche,' which means 'sacred place,' subtly shifting the focus from a building to a people or movement.

William Tyndall was the first to translate the Bible into modern English. He chose 'congregation' over 'church' to reflect the original Greek meaning of 'ecclesia,' which led to controversy and was seen as heretical by authorities at the time.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.