Go back

Part One: Pastor Paul Mackenzie: Kenya's Doomsday Starvation Cult Leader

1h 18m 23s

Part One: Pastor Paul Mackenzie: Kenya's Doomsday Starvation Cult Leader

Paul McKinsey, a Kenyan religious leader, founded a radical cult in Melindi that promoted extreme anti-education and anti-Western ideologies, claiming schools and modern society were evil and corrupt. Starting in 2003, he attracted followers by promising spiritual salvation and rejecting conventional life, including formal education and family life. His teachings, which included conspiracy theories about global institutions and the devil in education, gained traction among vulnerable individuals, especially children. In 2017, authorities raided his compound and rescued 93 children who had been kept out of school. Despite facing multiple criminal charges—such as operating an unlicensed school and unregistered TV station—McKinsey consistently avoided prosecution by pleading not guilty and securing bail. He claimed his ministry ended due to divine instruction, not legal action, and publicly shifted to farming as a "normal" lifestyle. The case highlights systemic failures in Kenya’s response to religious extremism, where powerful Christian right movements and weak enforcement allow dangerous cults to flourish. Experts note that McKinsey’s actions are part of a wider trend in Kenya, where leaders exploit vulnerability, promise miracles, and use fear and isolation to maintain control. Though details remain limited, the case underscores how cults often begin with normal or even healthy beliefs before spiraling into manipulation, violence, and social harm. The lack of accountability and media focus on isolated incidents reflects deeper societal and institutional issues in Kenya’s religious and legal systems.

Transcription

14574 Words, 79045 Characters

English
Welcome back to Behind the Bastards, a podcast about the very worst people in all of history. And folks, we got a doozy this week, you know, every now and then a cult leader comes along that is fairly new, newer than I tend to cover. I like to wait until like we've got some more inside narratives about what's happening. This is still fairly fresh, cult stuff, but it's so extreme that we just had to cover it. And there's no guest I would rather have on for this episode than a behind the bastard's classic guest host. If you want to know how's it going, look, I'm a classic man. Yeah, you're my first year. Yeah. Yeah. What's up, AC? Hey, what's up? Are you doing, buddy? Yeah, you remember we were all of that one building together from time to time. I sure remember. You don't know. I sure remember. Yeah. Yeah. What else do you do when a company that you work for is providing snacks, but still as many as possible for your home kitchen? Exactly. Exactly. It's one of the most important things, exactly. Yeah. Yeah. That's how we all fight back against wage theft is by stealing stacks from the break room. Exactly. You know, it's all in there. It's all in there. If he, you got some plug-ables to plug before we announced who the actual cult leader bastard is for the week. Oh, yes. I know. It's plug before we know how bad it is. Yes. 19th Thursday, November 19th, funny bone Columbus on the 21st. I'm in Tacoma, Washington on 22nd. I'm in Spokane, Washington. Oh, yeah. My back yard. Yeah. And we'll see. You should come through. Come, come on to Spokane and see what we can do. Okay. Well, you got a big backyard. It's party in Spokane. Yeah. Uh, but then, uh, in the second of, uh, December, I'm at in Philly and then on the third, I'm in Hoboken, New Jersey, New Jersey, New Jersey, New Jersey, New Jersey. I got you tattooer in everywhere. Well, right, you know, being a standup comedian is a little like being a cult leader for just one night, right? You know, or an hour. Yeah. You know, that's kind of. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But for some people, that's not enough. And they need, they need to have that, that feeling of having a bunch of people listening to whatever they say all the time. And then sometimes they get really angry about the idea of those people leaving and decide to kill them all, right? And when most naturally, naturally, right, it's the natural, um, I mean, what, what, what great comedian doesn't occasionally want to murder the audience, right? Um, but, but you, but you hold yourself back because that's really bad for continuing to get booked. Um, it's not bad for cult leaders, well, I mean, I guess that depends on how you look at it. And when we're talking about like an American, in, in the American context, a cult leader who killed a bunch of their followers, Jones town is what everybody thinks of, right? A hundred percent. Yes. It's not, they didn't Guyana, but like it's an American cult that started in the United States, right? Um, and that tends to be like, it, it's become such a, like most people don't even know any real details about Jones town. They just know a bunch of people drank Kool-Aid and, and died, right? Like drinking the Kool-Aid is a phrase people know, you know, it's just kind of, Jones turns our watch word for his charismatic cult leader killing all of these people. Well, this week we're going to talk about a very different cult, but one that shares some important things with Jones town, number one, the creation of an autonomous rural community governed by bizarre religious laws and the massacre of a huge number of people living in that rural community, right? So it, it's got, it's got all of those factors. But in this case, the cult leader didn't kill them by poisoning the Kool-Aid, and in fact, he didn't kill them by feeding them anything at all. This was a starvation death for a shocking number. This is a messed up fucking cult. Yeah. I'm sorry. I'm sorry, Effie. And it's, yeah, it's, it's fucked up. And it's, we don't have as many details about this guy as I'd like. This is a Kenyan cult leader. And so all of my stories I've got, there's a lot of local Kenyan sources who have done a good job of reporting on this guy so far. But the destruction of his followers was so comprehensive. There are not as many details about what was happening inside as we like to get. But I'm going to do the best job I can to put this together for you. Yeah. Am I right that this guy was sentenced like this? Just just a couple of weeks ago. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. He got caught in 2023. So this is a few years old, but he just got like, well, he's not even sentenced. He gets sentenced like the week this comes out. Yeah. But he's been convicted. Yeah. And his name is Paul McKinsey and thing. Well, Robert, I'm seeing that he got 200 years. Like eight hours. Oh, no, that they just announced it. Yeah. They just announced it. Yeah. 200 years sounds about right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. We'll explain why shortly. Yeah. Yeah, that's that. It's what's super wild about this is I think I vaguely remember this. And this person spent all this time, you know, doing cult stuff when he could have really just built a nice family and had a daughter who has the best life because everyone would be calling her miss and thing. Yeah. He gave it all up. He threw it all away. Yeah. For a cult. For his cult. Yeah. This isn't I heart podcast. Guaranteed human. A young teacher fails to show up for her first day of school, a hike of vanishes from a mountain in Colorado. How can someone just disappear? I remember screaming one night. Where is my brother? Where is my brother? I'm Lucy Shariff and this is Gone, The Disappearances. We dive into stories of people who've gone missing and the family and loved ones they leave behind grasping for answers. Listen to Gone, The Disappearances, on the I Heart Radio app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. How do you know that cloud won't become manipulative? This is a constant worry and you can actually catch the model thinking I think X is actually true, but I'm going to tell the user why. I'm Walter Isaacson. I'm my new podcast, The Builders. I'm going inside the minds of the people shaping our future. Listen to The Builders starting October 13th on the I Heart Radio app, Apple Podcast, or wherever you get your podcasts. November is Pancreatic Cancer Awareness Month, and I want to tell you about my brother, David, a podcast that documents my brother's journey with this disease. The experience of pancreatic cancer patients goes under the radar, down to calcivive, but just because we die so fast. Let's change the pancreatic cancer narrative and turn sympathy into survival. Listen to my brother, David, on the I Heart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. It's all just a joke. What is the value of these women? I'm Bridget Armstrong, back with season 2 of the podcast, Curse of Miss America. We're talking to participants, whistleblowers, and people who say Miss America didn't live up to their promises. He looks and he goes, "You don't look like you suffered in the eating disorder." I never received scholarship, I need to pay for my student loans. Maybe this is the meta question for the podcast. What is Miss America at this point? Listen to the Curse of Miss America on the I Heart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. So Paul may have been born in the Sultan Hamud area of County County in Kenya in 1960. I've heard a couple of different things as to where exactly he was born, so it's not perfectly clear, but he was certainly born in that general area, which is a part of like, it's a part of a rural landlocked region of southern Kenya with a semi-arid climate. His family migrated when he was young, down to Machakos County, or up to Machakos County, which is a little further north, where there was more work at the time. We don't know a lot about this guy's childhood in early life. He's not in like a rich part of Kenya, but I don't think it's like the poorest either, but it is kind of like a rural community. People live in villages there. A lot of folks, their life is more like, the village he was born in, people were surprised that his family moved and left, because people don't do that very often, right? So it's kind of a community like that is where he comes from. We don't know enough about this guy's childhood in early life, one of the few, very few papers to devote any time to finding and interviewing his family and former friends is the standard, which is a Kenya new site that has a very annoying paywall. You have to have like a Kenyan cell phone to pay to access. So I had to find a fan who is in Kenya who will keep anonymous, but thank you so that I could gain access to like a lot of the reporting, because I don't have a Kenyan cell phone. I was like, it's one thing that it's behind this paywall, but now you're making it hard to pay you. I just want to give you my money. Yes. Why only? I think there's some legal stuff about how these have to be media organizations and Kenya have to be registered. I don't fully know, but like there's a specific kind of cell phone number that like is registered and that you have to have in order to do this. Anyway. So thank you to that anonymous fan. So the standards reporting claims that Paul was born in Mombasa. But again, I don't know if that's accurate. They say that his dad left his family and village behind before Paul was born, defined work in the big city, and he was born in Mombasa. I've heard both. It's not really clear to me. Paul's uncle would later claim that Paul went to school in Mombasa, and I've certainly seen reporting on that account, so that seems to be accurate. He said of his nephew, quote, that they rarely went home. I met him years later when he was a young boy, right? So he does not have his dad does not take them back. He doesn't have a lot of connection to his family. So this may be a kid who, if we're trying to like psychoanalyze with what Little Libby has. There's certainly a level of disconnection with his family background that may have some impact on him, but I don't really know. His maternal uncle also lived with the family in Mombasa for a while and went on to host Paul when he was in high school. This uncle recalled Paul as being a good and obedient young man who was in general, good-natured, which is really an interesting way to spend, generally he was good-natured. - Yeah. - Okay. Except when he would organize the community's dogs and make them worship him. But beyond that, great guy. - He'd like to make the dogs worship him, killed him sometimes, but otherwise, he's generally in a good mood. Quote, when he wasn't busy with schoolwork, he enjoyed reading Bible stories. So we do get a bit of that that like maybe this kid is very religious from a young age, but that's not even super clear to me. He does not start being a religious leader until later in life. So I don't know if this was always a thing he was interested in or if there was just a point where he was like, you know where there's money, religion, right? (laughing) Slightly unclear to me. - What's so interesting about this too, just from where my perspective on this is typically, especially in the African diaspora, there's a lot of shame when you have someone who has done something negative, right? There's almost done something negative. And so that also, I imagine also makes it hard for these family accounts. And it makes sense that a lot of them are like, well, I didn't really see him or he was older for a little bit. When, I don't know if you remember the Nigerian guy who tried to like bomb a plane, but then his underwear caught on fire and he was kind of like a laughingstock. - Oh man. - That guy at the time looked a lot like me. And so did like the Facebook like, doppelganger challenge and I put that up. And like all my cousins from Niger were like, live it with me. There was like, he's a disgrace. You shouldn't be having his picture up and all that. And to me, I'm like, what do you mean? But it really is like, I think in African culture, it's like when you do something shameful, it is not only a shame to you, your family, but also just the culture in general. So it makes sense that everyone is like, oh, I don't know what he was doing. Yeah, yeah. - Yeah, that's a really good point. And it is like, yeah, I wouldn't feel great if this was like my cousin, given what we're about to talk about him doing. I would not feel cool about having him in the family. - And that's where the comedian becomes out. I'm bringing up every situate, every weird thing. Oh, I'm doing a deep dive. - I love my criminal relatives. Yes, but none of them did this, I gotta say. So young Paul does well enough in school that one of his uncles referred to him as a young scholar. And he was ultimately sent to attend a boarding school in Lunga Lunga for an unclear period of time. I don't know how long he's at this boarding school. I've also seen claims that he was a member in choir boy for the Africa Brotherhood Church as a youth. And the ABC is a fairly mainstream and popular Christian church in Africa, the fact that he was a member. Suggest he was a pretty normal Kenyan Christian, right? This is not like a fringe hold. You know, this is not like a weird place to be. He's not like a youthful extremist that we have evidence of. And we don't really have evidence that he was like more religious than was normal. You know, obviously he comes from a part of the world where especially rural Kenya, people are very religious. It's the norm, right? So there's no suggestion that there was anything weird or that he had weird ambitions for almost the first 40 years of Paul's life. The first clear data point, post childhood that we have is 1997. When he's in his late 30s, he moves to the city of Melindi to find work as a taxi driver. And he works out of the Powell Garden Taxi stage next to the police station and lives with his sister whose husband owned a cab at the time. One of his fellow cab drivers told the standard he did not even know how to drive, but he learned the skill here, right? So his sister kind of brings him into the town and like it seems to really be pushing him to do what her husband's doing. Like cab driving is a good way to make a money. He learns how to drive there. Another of his former colleagues gives a slightly different account quote from the standard. Julius Charo, who worked with McKinsey, said that the preacher had nothing when he came to Melindi town and that it was his sister who engineered his economic life. I have known McKinsey for over 20 years. He came here after his sister had bought a car, right? So from that sort of his sister and her husband, they're doing well enough that they're able to like take him in, pretty normal thing, right? And as his former peers describe things, Paul McKinsey was a normal taxi driver for a while. He was friendly, he's a charismatic guy. People like him, he's lequacious, he talks alike. He's popular and he's like a prominent like people know him in the cabby scene. After several years in the city driving, he starts, 'cause there's a low season, right? You've got your tourist season in Melindi where there's the most work and there's a low season. And after a few years, I think 2003 is when he starts doing this. He decides that like, well, during the low season, why don't I start at working as a preacher and like try to start like a church, you know, make some, kind of maybe even make some money in the offices and as a preacher, yeah. Yeah. So I'm not sure, maybe you just want to get a customer base. I don't know where you're going to be on Sunday. Let me get you there. Yeah, let me get you there. Yeah, cab driving preacher. So in 2003, he launches his ministry and it was at first focused. He's ministering mostly to the small community of cab drivers, right? So he starts by like recruiting his co-workers, you know, to go to his church. Julius Charo, who's again, one of these cabbies, recalls that he and his fellow drivers were supportive of Paul at first. Quote, we were happy that one of us had seen the light and some of us joined his ministry until he started preaching outside the Bible. So things get weird pretty quick. And these other cabbies are like, oh, that is, you know, it was so funny because there was just so much, you know, where you were like, oh, there wasn't much info. There's not much and I was like, oh, man, this is going to feel like it comes out of nowhere. And I was like, oh, nope, here it is. Here it is, here it is. Somewhere between him, whatever happened before him getting to a sister and him getting to a sister. Something happened or is that crucial period, yeah? Yeah, there was a taxi cab confession that really set him on a path. (laughing) Yeah, the absolute wrong taxi cab confession. Yeah, I don't know specifically. I'll talk in part two about a little more of what we know about his intellectual background, but this is a bit of a black box. We don't fully know. It does, I've had like, one of my cousins is a preacher now. And like, I went to see her preach at her church in Texas. It was perfectly fine, very normal, you know, good. But I did have a little like, going in and like, okay. I guess I'll, I guess I'll learn if my cousin's gotten into some weird religious stuff. And she had, you know, definitely. Yes, you're like, all right. Okay. Bart's safe. Strap in up, buckling in. Yeah. Bart's safe. Yeah, Bart's safe. (laughing) You know, it's just one of the most dangerous things you can hear aside from like a friend who's never talked about writing saying, so I wrote a novel. And I was like, oh, congratulations. Yeah. And then you start reading it while sweating. Yeah, yeah. Look, it truly is. It's like, well, on six ups, it's gonna be a manifesto. Yeah, very good chance. It's gonna be a manifesto. But hey, any other role, it's just a, it's just a bad novel. Yeah, could just be a bad, could be a good novel. Usually isn't, basically never is with a first novel. Write your novels, folks. And it's okay if it's a manifesto, you know? Sometimes manifesto's are very well written. You know, the New York Times published the Unibomors manifesto. Don't think too much about that. Okay, because you brought up, I have to do the quick aside that like we'd never criticize on the selective manifesto printings that we want to do. Because I haven't read it, but I heard like the Unibomors manifesto is kind of good. It's not. People are pulling out some, there's a couple of paragraphs that if you isolate them from everything else, sound pretty reasonable, but you have to isolate them from like, there's a lot of stuff about like, well, yeah, industrial society is really bad in a lot of ways. I'm like, oh, women are a spot. I don't think that's the case. Yeah, yeah. I don't think gay people cause this. Yeah, how'd you get there? Yeah, but yeah, like it was, like that's why, you know, like when Christian, Christian donor, they didn't want to post it. And I was like, and we just the week ago had that one kid who shot the, I think it was the sorority girls. Yeah. And they did that. It was like, he was still on the run, and they posted the manifesto. And I was like, what are we doing? I thought we'd agreed that was bad. Then we read what what donor was saying. We're like, oh, this is why you didn't want to. Yeah, you didn't want to publish this one. Yeah. We're very, very, we only publish certain manifestos publicly. Yeah. Yeah. So, anyway, we're talking about Paul McKinsey. He started being a taxi cab preacher and some of his former colleagues are not, you know, they're initially supportive, but then they start hearing some weird stuff. One of his other former cabbies gave an example of the kind of rhetoric from Paul that turned him away from the ministry. He started attacking other faiths like Muslims and Catholics. He's preaching started becoming extreme, right? So, he's very anti-Islam. He's very anti-Catholic, too. He's one of these guys who thinks the Pope is trying to control the world, which there was certainly a time when that was true, but we're a good 600 years past that era. Like, I don't think the Chicago Pope has any nefarious schemes. Maybe to try to spread deep dish, you know, keep an eye on that one. But more tomatoes on hot dogs, you know, more tomatoes in the hot dogs. Not damn you, papis. Paul McKinsey's most controversial claim at the time was that school was bad for you. Worse for your kids, right? You shouldn't be putting your kids in school. Education is the devil, right? And one of his four, like one of these cabbys who goes there initially and he lets his wife and five kids attend Paul's church, recalled, "My children would come home and tell me they didn't want to go to school." And the pastor had said, "Education is evil." Matters got worse when he started asking followers to burn their school certificates and was against children going to school. That is when I removed my family from the church and severed relations with McKinsey. - Yeah, when he has your kids burning their diplomas, you probably don't wanna give your kids a next year. - Yeah, yeah, wow. It's stuff like this, why I just left religion in general as a whole because I don't pay close enough attention. Like I would have missed that. - I would have missed that. - Yeah, I would have, my ADHD would have kicked in, I would have disassociated and next thing you know, I'm like, "Wait, why am I throwing my diploma in the fly?" I think I would have toxically let my, 'cause I'm kind of critical about like higher education in particular the way it works in this country. And so like someone just saying like, in education, like the education system is for, "Yeah, okay, I'm sure you're like, "where kid's burning stuff, what are they all lighting on fire?" He doesn't want you to learn to read, oh fuck. - Yeah. - Oh, what you for? - Uh-oh, nope. I just think it's expensive and shouldn't be. - Yeah. - Yeah, totally. - So this change, he starts his ministry in 2003, this seems to have gone down, but when he really switches and starts preaching more radically, seems to be sometime around 2006 or '7, but I'm not 100% sure, right? I don't have exactly years, but by the '20 teens, by no later, maybe like 2011, 2012, so a little before the '20 teens, Paul has given up working as a taxi cab driver and has opened a larger church and has gotten enough money from his followers to build a compound in Melendi, right? So he has a church on his own private compound in the city. He is no longer driving cabs. In 2012, he registers his own TV company called Good News Media. Good news is usually variants of the name of his church and variants of his like media organizations. And he starts broadcasting. His increasingly radical sermons on a YouTube account that amasses some 7,000 subscribers. And that's not a lot in like, you know, objective numbers. - But I will embarrass you, Lisa, still more than me, still more than me. I just noticed, 'cause I don't, you know, I'm usually on other people's YouTube channels, but now I've been posting stand-up clips. And I looked, I'm like, damn, I only got free stuff. (laughing) - We can cross some on our YouTube account. We still got that. - He's cooking me. - He's giving you his church is breaking my stuff. - He's just nailing it. Well, and also you gotta think 7,000, and like if you're thinking about in terms of online influencers is not much, but Melendi has a population of 120,000. And if you assume most of those are locals, because like it's a local Kenyan churches YouTube channel, that's not an insignificant chunk of the town, right? Like that's potentially like a meaningful percentage of the city that's listening to him, right? So Paul's social media, yeah, it's potentially pretty significant. And what kind of content did he put out in his online and television sermons? Here's an excerpt from one. The devil is here on earth, persecuting those of us who've been preaching against school education. Education is evil. It is not in the plan of God. It is a way to teach our children lesbianism and homosexuality. It is those youngsters who have not gone to school who serve God, those who proceed to obtain higher education, abandoned God. Education is anti-Christ. I oppose worldly education because it has no room for God. It's teaching them lesbianism. - Well, yeah, yeah. I just, for once, what one of these preachers to explain how. I don't wanna worry, because I just wanna see the work. Not even in a way that, 'cause yes, I know, I know Kuku for Koko Puffs. But in your brain, what is doing this? - In your brain. And also, I get people in the US saying stuff like this, because like in it's wrong, but obviously like, there is very visibly like a lot of queer people and queer media in the United States. - Yeah. - It's kidney is a bit different. Like the idea of like being panicked about like, all the children are turning gay, is seems a little out of place with the actual like, public visibility, homosexuality and Kenya. - Yeah, yeah, they're kind of behind on some of these issues. That so really is like creating your own problems. - Is that really the issue for you guys? - I think you're good. I don't think that's a problem. - Like I just need a switchup at this point with the fire and brimstone talk when we get here. Like look, there was a little company just a little bit north of you that they were in Nottingham. They're called to war hammer. They were games workshop. - Exactly. - No one, I need at least one cult leader to at least take what I just need one war hammer approach. - I'm working on it, if he. - Look, I just need one. - And I'm going to blame my Catholic church is going to be trench crusade. I'm going to really go hard on those guys. They're the devil. They've trained from the light of games workshop. - Yeah, yeah, yeah, I know. I'll be the trench crusader. And we'll just beef online. And we'll just go back and forth. - We'll go after it. - Yeah. - Yeah, yeah. - Yeah, the next, it's going to be like the church of England purging the Catholics from Ireland. - Yeah. - It's crazy. - If you really like, now we're getting super nerdy, but here it is. But if you think about, since it's 12 months who was doing, you know, more time. You're like, "Yeah, yeah, that's my Martin Luther." - That's my Luther have more gaming. - Yeah. - Oh God, yeah, we need to, so many cults could be saved. If people just got a little more into spending all of their money on plastic miniatures. Drug addiction too. Kids are not going to be able to afford hard drugs if they're playing Warhammer. That was kept me so parasitine each year. - I would be, I would risk being the guy who's crucified to the machine if all the nuns look that hot. You know what I mean? - Yeah, exactly. And they had guns? - Absolutely. - That's right. Warhammer people. (laughing) It's different from those. - It is our war, our one Warhammer chapter episode that we always fall into. - We have to do it. - We knocked it out. - We knocked it out. - Legally for, legally required. So, pause issues with education. Seem to have been rooted initially at least in his opposition to the teaching of evolution, which does make like some sense, right? But as this passage from an article in The Standard Makes Clear, it was really all about control and making sure his church was the absolute center of his followers' lives. Quote, "In 2017, he faltered a clash between syllabi and religious teaching, saying that teaching children that humans came from Zazanthropus, which is like one of the, you know, our ancestor species, was contrary to the Holy Rit. But the government will support these satanic things such as education and buying of condoms. Well, no money is set aside by the treasury to support our ministry. They're paying for condoms and evolution teaching and they're not giving me money. I have a lot of it, but I want more and I want it from the government. - Oh, wow. You always just come back to that, too. - Yeah, yeah, that's. - Why are you spending money teaching kids' things that aren't me? Yeah, I feel that way, too. You know what, folks? We've got some ads. Why don't you go email a senator or two and ask them why the federal government isn't spending money on my podcast, you know? Pretty good reasons, probably. - Yeah. - Might as well harass them. - Because we block that category on ads. - Okay, well, they could just send it to me directly through PayPal or something. (laughing) - A young teacher fails to show up for her first day of school. A hiker vanishes from a mountain in Colorado. A man leaves for a meeting with his neighbor and never returns. Where we go beyond the news headlines to tell undercover stories of people who have gone missing. - In the absence of fact, you fill in the blanks. So when she disappeared, you know, the rumor mill, it went crazy 'cause we had nothing, not a boot print, absolutely nothing. - At the heart of all these stories, the vacuum that's left, the people who are left to pick up the pieces and find a way to move forward with their new normal, which seems almost impossible while they're still grasping for answers. - Listen to Gone, the Disappearances, on the iHeart Radio app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. - If there's a million times more digital intelligence than there is biological intelligence, it's hard to imagine humans being in control in that scenario. - I'm Walter Isaacson, host of the new podcast, The Builders. Right now, we're living through an AI arms race. So I went directly to the people shaping that future. - The CEO and Musk, Derio Amade, Alex Carr, Fafé Leap, Palmer Lucky, because I wanted to understand what the most consequential builders believe, what they feel, and where they think this is all headed. - Silicon Valley is always saying the cliché thing about the way to predict the future is to create it. Well, yeah, it's up to us. - But when you say us, who's us? Is it 400 people that you know in Silicon Valley? Is it me down here in New Orleans? - They're brilliant, controversial, and they're already shaping the future. The question is, who's imagination do we want to live in? - This is going to determine the fate of nations and economies and the future of humanity. - Listen to The Builders, on the IHeart Radio app, Apple Podcast, or wherever you get your podcasts. - The first thing I hate about Ulysses is they never actually tell the Turks. - I'm Dave, and I've been an (beep) for my life. (laughs) In October 2021, my brother David was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. A year later, he convinced me to make a podcast with him, this podcast. We didn't know what we were doing, so we just started recording. We discussed cancer, and we talked openly about the fact that David was going to die. My brother David is the story of the last chapter of my brother's life. It's weird, and messy, and vulnerable, and I'm going to share all of it with you. The constant back-and-forth battle about how do I not just be alive, but actually live. Listen to my brother David on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. For more than a century, Miss America sold the country of fantasy. But over the past decade, the crown's been slipping. They said, "Goodbye to swimsuits, now, hello to lawsuits." I'm Bridget Armstrong. Last season, we took you inside the world of America's next top model. Now I'm back with season two of this podcast, Curse of Miss America, investigating the rise, fall, in uncertain future of one of America's most iconic institutions, the Miss America patent. I never received scholarship, and I need to pay for my student loans. Can you look at me and go, "You don't look like you suffered in the eating disorder." It's great, but it looks too ethnic. It's a story the Miss America organization really doesn't want us to tell. An exploitation of our Miss America is treated by the Miss America organization as an attack on Miss America itself. Listen to the Curse of Miss America on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcast. There are thousands of podcasts that can tell you how to better yourself. That worse with Kyle Proo is not one of those podcasts. So if you're interested in getting thinner, going to therapy, starting peptide, setting boundaries, taking supplements, making your better getting closer, then I would humbly recommend other podcasts. But if you're interested in blackmail, love, bombing, cloning yourself, or getting revenge, then we've got a little something, something, for a dastardly individual like you. Take a listen to some of the incredible advice we've given so far. Fake a back injury, get the spray tan, up your alcohol consumption. You women should be allowed to have guns. Kill them. Kill them. Kill the gun. Listen, it's already over. I'm all about lying if it's something that really happened. The next time a bear is running at you, you just calmly stop what you're doing. You look the bear in the eye, and you say this isn't you. Do not preserve relationships. You don't need them. You only need one thing, and that's the get worse podcast. Listen to get worse with Kyle Proo on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. And we're back. So by no later than 2016, Paul was funding the activities of his growing coal by convincing his more affluent followers to give him all their stuff, right? He starts doing a, if you really believe, you got to give me all your money. You got to sign over your house to me. You got to sign over your car to me. You got to give me all your stuff, right? One follower sold his palatial home and gave the, this was a house that was worth the equivalent of $150,000, right? So that's a pretty sizable like house, you know? So he gives Paul like all of the proceeds from this, which Paul uses to buy land in Melindi and Mombasa, including his main coat compound, as well as two new cars. This money also helps to fund Paul's TV station. I found an article on a different local Nigerian site, Tuco.com, that quotes Adela Awalia, summarizing Paul's teachings this way. His teachings focused on the end times, the evilness of Western ways of life, such as medical services, education, food, sports and music, and the uselessness of life. And that's a big thing for Paul. It's not just don't go to the doctor, because it's a lie. If you want to get, if Jesus wants you to be sick, you know, and you want, you'll help make you sick. If you want you to be healed, he'll heal you. But also life is pointless, because everything in life is not Jesus, right? The only thing that matters is Jesus. And so like your life, your dreams being educated, having a career, having a family, all of that is meaningless. The only thing that matters is worshiping Jesus before the end of days. So give everything up and come to me, give up all your ambitions and all your hopes and dreams, and let's just wait out the apocalypse, right? That's kind of where he's preaching, you know? Yeah. That's, that's, that's dangerously kind of kind of some bar because you, like, I remember when I was, so I, I was going, one of the things that kind of like shaped my worldview is, you know, my dad was Catholic, he's an Nigerian from Nigeria, they, they give him the thalsists, and then I was going to Baptist church with my mom. And then I was dating someone who was Mormon, so I went to their church. So I went to like many different churches and thing that caused my, like, now, now newly discovered autistic. This doesn't add up. So I'm just going to immediately buck against it. And I was like, all of you are essentially teaching the same things, but you are all pretty firm in saying everyone else is really wrong. Everyone else is really wrong. Really? How you would have got me as being like, well, they're right about like, if you were getting like very, um, actually about it, it's like, well, they're right about some things, but this, but they were all like, objectively, like, nope, this is the way I was like, then you're wrong because they're saying the same thing as you. Like, if me and you were teaching something, and I felt like, oh, you're off about this one thing. That's what I would say. I'd be like, well, you know, Robert is right about these things, but every religion is like, no, they're just wrong. And you're like, but I've went to, I've been, I know it's, it's the thing, like, I had my very angry atheist period where I was just like anti-religion as like a, as like a, and then I, I spent more time out in the world and one thing I've known, like, I, there's not a single religion service that I've ever enjoyed sitting through. There's not a holy book that I, but I've, I've participated in like religious, uh, festivals and holidays with Muslims, with Hindus, uh, with Buddhists, with Christians. And I found a lot of great people and I like the people and I like like when they're doing the thing that like is them at their best, I enjoy a lot of things about his law. I enjoy a lot of things about Christianity, about Buddhism, about Hinduism. I don't like the way people take it way too seriously and go people over it. It's truly, what's funny is though, I feel like the only time I was like, ooh, if, if, and a different time you could have got me, I feel like Judaism because I like their life. Yeah, yeah. A lot of you don't agree with it. Yeah. Look at us and put me wrong. I love that it's not even. I love that rabbi has jobs. If you want to become Jewish, there's like, you shouldn't. Right, right. You don't want this. They try to discourage you so you really know, they really know you want it. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And then we find out it's like, oh, we just like community. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. can evangelical Christians will talk more about that in part two. And he's taking these conspiracy theories that started in the US about like the U.N. and the one world order in the Catholic Church working with the U.N. to take over the United States. But instead, he's rearranged it to be focused on Kenya. And the U.S. is one of the bad guys now. As opposed to we're going to get taken over by the U.N. No, the U.S. is leading the U.N. and the Catholic Church in this crusade to destroy us, which I love. I love that little spin on it. It's beautiful stuff. Now, as far as my career is concerned, the worst sin I could commit is to tell you that this guy has a song titled the Antichrist and not play any of it for you. Now, I don't speak the language, right? So I don't, but like you'll understand it a couple of points, what he's singing about in this song and this brief clip. And, okay, yeah, okay. Okay, look, sorry. Once again, I'm tasking your listeners will one thing, who is going to go ahead and make a fan cam of the NWO from W.W.F. to the soundtrack. I think we can, I think we can make it work. It's a low-temple song. It is. But I love that he's kind of got that like almost reggae beat going and his followers are clearly dancing, but he is solo energy. He's just like shuffling. He's not. He's got no sort of like presence at all. Like come on, put some energy into it, man. You're singing about the Antichrist. Yeah. He's like, no, there's no charisma for this. No, I got, I got to sell that nihilistic thing that I'm also baking into this. It is. It's kind of a nihilistic reggae. The vibes are really bizarre in that piece of music. So according to him, and this is from the reporters it to go, offering a detailed translation of that. song." According to him, the Roman Catholic Church, the United States of America and the United Nations, exists to stop the word of God, which he stands for. McKinsey dressed in flowing white and red robes, crunes to the reggae beat while chanting against the three above, right? This is pretty much what you would have guessed. Now, well, the cops in the government are not moved to act with haste over what he's doing. Because right now, he's just like one and a million of like kind of weird religious guys, but like that's, there's nothing about that video or about what he's preaching that would necessarily get the government up in arms other than the telling kids not to go to school stuff, right? And that does piss off local activists. The police and the government don't really want to do anything in part because they don't want to like be seen as cracking down on a Christian church. But there are some activists for like children in Melindi, who are like, he's making people not go to school. And also, it seems like a lot of kids are living at the compound now and not leaving. They're going to, someone should check on that, right? The police, shouldn't you do something? The meyundo children rescue center started getting complaints and receiving abused children who had fled his growing cult in 2017. Helen Wacali, the center manager, told a journalist with citizen digital that the government was overall slack in their response, right? So they start getting kids, some of them are malnourished, who are like coming in and like saying, hey, he took us out of school and we've been living in this compound. And I didn't feel safe there. And so these, this charity is like, okay, police, hey, guys, do something. Please, help us. They don't. But thankfully, they do succeed in getting the attention of a local politician. Aisa Jumwa, who is at the time, a member of parliament for Melindi, becomes one of the first voices in like the Kenyan government to like raise her voice against McKinsey. And she accuses him of bribing the local police and security services to keep his church opened and avoid prosecution. He gets arrested three times, starting in like 2017, 2018. And he gets released each time for like keeping children out of school, for telling children to leave school, for hosting them. And so he keeps getting arrested and released and no one ever shuts down the church or the compound. And so Aisa is like, what the fuck? You know, like you should be doing something like we know this guy's breaking the law. Paul seems to have considered himself immune to consequences at first. He told a reporter after one of his early arrests, if anyone feels offended about my summons and teaching and accordance to the scripture, let them go to court and produce evidence. I'm not afraid to serve my god. Unfortunately for him, they do. Aisa and other responsible members of the government call his bluff. In the spring of 2017, Paul and two of his lieutenants see their first criminal charges. He and his wife and two other women are all charged with offering basic education in an unregistered institution or operating in a legal school, because they're taking kids out of school and keeping them in this religious thing and they're claiming it's a school, but they're not teaching them, right? This is probably the crime that most closely describes what Paul and his followers were doing in like the legal code. But again, they're not actually operating a school. They're just keeping kids out of school. And this is part of why I wish we had more of Paul's childhood background, because what little we know suggests he was a decent student whose family seems to have spent money that like they didn't have a lot of to ensure he got a decent education. Maybe he hated his boarding school. I don't know. I just don't have any of that kind of stuff. I'm wondering if his rejection of education for children is rooted in something that happened to him or has something to do with his other like religious politics, which are characterized by a violent intolerance of other faiths and ways of living, right? It may be that nothing happened at all to him in his education, but he's just a guy who because of the things he comes to believe sees everything that's not literally what he's preaching as the threat to his flock, right? Like anything they learned about the outside world will pull them away from me, you know? In September at their months of bribery and stonewall, like Melindi police finally executed a raid on Paul's cult compound. In an article for Reuters, Amu Khan Ampili describes what happened next. Police searched Mackenzie's Melindi compound in 2017 and found dozens of children living there without attending school. He was charged with offering education at an unregistered facility, but continued his teachings until 2019. And 93 children in total are rescued from his good news international church compound. They take nearly a hundred kids out of this compound. Yeah. And he gets to go back to preaching. Like what? That seems like a problem. Yeah. Shouldn't do that. So the authorities start interviewing some of these students that they pulled out of his compound pern article in nation during investigation. Some of the children interrogated claims that education is satanic and said that they had left their homes in schools to follow the pastor. So some of these are kids who leave their families against their parents wishes to like join the cult. Which you're going to hear a lot of in this. There's a lot of kids who get very convinced. Some of them might just be that like if you're telling kids that they don't need to go to school, there's always going to be some kids who find that real appealing. You're like, wait, no homework. Okay. Look, look, look, when I pray, I think about power rangers. So like, like, I'm actually watching an episode of power rangers in my head. Yeah. Yeah. You're telling me God doesn't want me to go to school either? Hmm. Interesting. What does God think about bedtime? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. How does he feel about bedtimes? So Paul was also later charged with failing to take his own three children to school. They were aged 13, five and four at the time. He pled not guilty. And though the prosecution argued against granting him bail, he ultimately bonded out. He would be acquitted years later on October of 2021. But by that time, he'd already since long since moved on from Melindi. And the fact that he gets acquitted, the fact that more serious action isn't taken, the fact that his cult forms at all is very much tied to the fact that Kenya has a serious cult problem these days, one that has gotten vastly worse. Yeah, over the last 20 years or so. Most of these are Christian cults. There's in the same, like, there's a cult that killed people in the same like basic town area that his was in, right? Like, there's so many of them. And there's a lot of debate as to why Kenya has this problem right now. One issue is certainly that Kenya has a large and organized Christian right who fight tooth and nail against any limitations about what a church can do. And cult leaders like Paul have for years benefited from the state of affairs. But that's not all of the issue. I found a 2024 article on the news side, um, walkie-leashy by Martin Olaj, who used the term dark worship to describe the way secret religious networks in Kenya recruit and radicalize. He was summarizing the findings of a national crime research center study, which is a Kenyan state organization on Kenya's religious landscape. Quote, the study documents an increase in destructive practices that are being perpetrated under the guise of religious instruction, particularly targeting vulnerable populations. The investigation has uncovered disturbing patterns where religious leaders exploit followers vulnerabilities by promising solutions to personal difficulties through prosperity, gospel, divine healing, and spiritual enlightenment. This manipulation has led some Kenyans to abandon conventional medical treatment and formal education in favor of clandestine worship practices. The phenomenon appears particularly concentrated in several counties, with a notably stronger presence in rural areas compared to urban centers. These religious movements have demonstrated significant reach drawing followers from beyond Kenya's borders. The study reveals that attempts to leave these groups often result in severe consequences, raging from intimidation and social isolation to physical violence. So this is a massive growing issue. We have a same massive growing issue in the United States. I'm not picking on Kenya, but this is a big issue. No, it doesn't feel like you're picking on Kenya. It is like very interesting, but I will say all I can think about is like, do we think all of the cult leaders talk to each other? Do we think they're hanging out of them? Do you think they're like, oh, really? I think a lot of them do. I don't know about all. Yeah. I think it's like rap beefs, you know, where it's like, oh, it's easy. And they're comparing the size of their cults like, damn, you got 90 kids. I'm still stuck at 20. I think it works a lot like, you know, like streamer influencer types where like you have, you have commute people that are like tied together and they're all in the same ecosystem, but also some of them have beef and hate each other. Oh, yeah. Yeah. I was definitely saying there's definitely some like weird side of like Kenyan TikTok or Instagram where there's like, you know, influencers showing cult leaders how to get more people is like, here's how you're gonna maximize your following with your cult. Here's what B2B sales taught me about growing a cult from fucking Kenyan LinkedIn. Yeah. So I would also be remiss if I didn't point out something I read another analysis of the cult problem in Kenya by Victor Buyer writing for the star. Despite the growing incidents of religious extremism, the associated socioeconomic drivers pushing people into such sex have not been adequately or professionally framed in the media coverage often centers on the founders portraying them as isolated criminal cases rather than symptoms of deeper systemic issues. And one of the things that Victor's pointing out is that like, we can, there's a couple of things that we know are probably involved that the power of the Christian far right. But in terms of like, why has cult growth like exploded so much, there's not enough data like comprehensively to have like a clear understanding of everything that is driving this. And we shouldn't act like there is. So I don't want to act like, oh, it's all because of this, right? Yeah. This seems to be a complicated and really, really like intractable problem in Kenyan society as it is in the United States right now. So again, cults all, it's cults all the way down. It's cults all the way down. So many, it's like, it's just so interesting how it has kind of blown up. I was just gotten easier and like, you know, I, you know, oftentimes you'll hear just casual classic iffy segue. But oftentimes you'll hear like a sub, be like, oh, I like being a sub because the the dumb does all the thing for me. And I don't, I really don't have to do it. I feel good. And I feel like it's like there's an element of that where it's like, you should've just found kink. Maybe that's what you need it. - Right, the healthy thing, that's a normal thing to feel. And it's a healthy thing to engage in for a while. Probably shouldn't just let someone do all you're thinking for you forever. - Yeah, maybe we can fix this by cult having a safe word. - I sometimes I just want my girlfriend to pick what we're eating or watching tonight. I don't want to make the choice. I don't want to like give up my autonomy for cooking food forever. That seems like unhealthy. Yeah. So yeah, all of cult dynamics, this is something I really try to drive home. They all start with things that are normal and sometimes even healthy, right? That there are perversions of normal and healthy relationships. That's how cults work. Yeah, so in April of 2019, Paul McKenzie still operating his church compound out of Melindi was charged with three different crimes. Insightment to disobedience of the law, possessing and distributing films to the public, which had not been examined or classified by Kenya Film Classification Board and operating a filming studio without a valid filming license from the Kenya Film Classification Board. And I think that he gets these specific charges. I don't think this is like the government fucking up. Well, the government fucked up by not giving them harder charges, but there are people like Aisha who are like good and diligent public servants who are just trying to get them on whatever they can. And if the police are, yeah. So well, like there's in Japan, my friend was telling me this how there's the, if you buy like a sweet a card, it's like you can't be part of any like unsavory social groups. Because like that's how they are able to get the Yakuza because there's, it's so much harder to get them on their actual crimes that if you can clip them for having a bus pass when they're not supposed to have one, then you're finally able to at least get them in jail for a little bit. And I was going, it's funny you should say that 'cause that's what I was just going to say is like this feels like they were just like, how do we get looking at the government? - Anything. - Yeah. - Well, it doesn't have a license to operate as TV station. Let's fuck them for that, right? Like yeah, I think that is like the people, I think that is reasonable people in the government battling with people saying don't do anything 'cause he's Christian, right? And they're like, all right, well, let's get him on the film stuff, you know? - Yeah. - So this is the only lever they had to pull and they pull it. Paul pleads not guilty and again, the prosecution warns, hey, this court leader is really dangerous, don't give him bail. And again, the court gives him bail. He's allowed to bond out and he leaves jail a free man. His case is going to spend years winding through the courts because of what happens later. He never actually goes back to court for this. His first defense hearing was scheduled for June of 2023, but Paul had no plans to lay back and take it easy during the intervening years. Instead, he made a public show of closing his church in Belindi. One of his former cab driver friends told the standard, when he closed the church in 2019, he came here back to the cab stand and told us that he was done with the Bible and ministry, adding that he had bought land and chakahola for purposes of doing agriculture. That's like a rural, like, wooded area and partakenia. This appears to have been a smoke screen. Other reporting for the standard notes that he explained closing his church at the time by saying, "The Lord's voice told me I had done enough "and also that he closed his TV channel near the end of the year." Paul claimed to his followers, "It wasn't the government that closed down "my ministry or TV station. "I heard the Lord's voice tell me "that my nine years ministry and prophecy on the end times was over. "I was commanded to tell my followers "by December of 2019 the TV would be shut down for good. "It was hard to accept, but that was the Lord's voice." Yeah. Was it the Lord? Or was it the government who charged you with crimes? Yeah. It's God. - I'm not being fired. God told me to quit. - The Lord gave me a ticket for driving so drunk I couldn't see straight. (laughing) - Man, wow, wow play. - I love it, I love it. So Paul insisted he left the ministry and told reporters he'd begun to work as a farmer like every ordinary Kenyan is what he said. And I need to make clear, Paul made that statement as kind of a political act, sort of like a right-wing politician or mega-church leader saying like, "Rural America is the real America, right?" That is less the case in Kenyan. Agriculture employees about 40% of Kenyan workers, but the vast majority of these people are not formal workers who own or are employed regularly by a farm. They certainly do not own their own farms. The vast majority of Kenyan agricultural work is informal jobs on tea estates or processing cut flowers and the like. In other words, they're like basically sharecropping, right? Like very few Kenyans actually own land and are able to farm it, you know? And that's important. The fact that he is buying a farm shows you how much money he's made relative to whatever one else has, you know? And the reality is that pastor of McKenzie purchases a bunch of farmland and Shakahola Forest, which is this isolated rural region where most people live in these very poor villages with mud brick houses. These are not very connected to the rest of Kenya. They're certainly not super connected to the rest of the world. People make very little money there. And again, nearly everyone works on someone else's farm, right? Just kind of trying to make ends meet as much as they can. These are very poor communities. And so it's a place where Paul McKenzie could expect number one, less rule of law. And number two, if I come in here with money and a bunch of followers who've got money behind them, we can sort of take over. 'Cause they don't have any power down here, right? So Paul tries to get support from the local community initially by acting as a good neighbor. This segment from an article in People Daily describes how he did that. When he restarted his church and as his ministry grew, he began to take on more responsibilities in the wider community. He founded several outreach programs that focused on helping those classified as needy. According to the police, these programs included youth clubs and counseling services for women. Now, critically, he's providing places for them to gather and get counseling through his church. He's not feeding them. That's very important. But he does want to know who the poorest people are. And he wants to get the poorest people into his church. And he's again, not interested in providing them with things they need to survive. Just like counseling and community, right? And the real reason he does this is that he understands that women with children are some of the best people to recruit and impoverished areas. They're often the most desperate for basic necessities. And if he could provide them with anything, he could give himself to bring not only themselves, but their children with them, right? And he says like, hey, you know, I have these clubs out here, but if you want to move on to the compound, we've got power and water, right? And stuff like, you know, we've got a farm. So you think there's going to be food at least. And then maybe you leave your village with your kids and move on to the cult compound because he's got resources and you don't. The end of 2019 is also when Pastor McKenzie started preaching to his flock about an upcoming apocalypse. Now, we don't have documentation on what he actually said specifically. Or at least we have some of that for later. I don't know what he initially started claiming about the apocalypse, but it seems to be he's mostly just trying to say, hey, the world is going to end. You need to get out of the city and by farmland. The economy is going to collapse. Bad times are coming and you need to take to the country and hide on this farm with me and my followers, right? He would later tell the standard he predicted the world's economy would collapse. And he took a massive victory lap after the COVID-19 pandemic, which a Kenyan government report credits for supercharging recruitment to his rural compound, right? COVID-19 does a lot to bring him more followers, right? - They're going to imagine, yeah. - Yeah, like that's just, of course it does, right? And the fact that he, again, all these guys have been preaching the apocalypse for a while. If you start saying, yeah, the economy's going to collapse and you've been doing that for forever and then COVID hits, it sure looks like you're right for a while. - Oh yeah. - Yeah. - Yeah, we'll talk more about that, but first. A young teacher fails to show up for her first day of school. A hike of vanishes from a mountain in Colorado. - How can someone just disappear? I'm Lucy Shariff and this is Gone, the Disappearances, where we go beyond the news headlines to tell undercover stories of people who have gone missing. So when she disappeared, you know, the rumor mill, it went crazy because we had nothing, not a boot print, absolutely nothing. Listen to Gone, the Disappearances, on the iHeart radio app, Apple podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. So I went directly to the people, shaping that future. Elon Musk, Derio Ammanade, Alex Carr, Thaife Lee, Palmer Lucky, because I wanted to understand what the most consequential builders believe, what they feel, and where they think this is all headed. - This is gonna determine the fate of nations and economies and the future of humanity. Listen to the builders. on the IHOT Radio app Apple Podcast or ever get your podcasts. - First thing I hate about Ulysses is they never actually tell the Turks. I'm Dave and I've been a (beep) for my life. (laughing) - In October 2021, my brother, David, was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. A year later, he convinced me to make a podcast with him. This podcast. - Okay, so here we go. - We didn't know what we were doing, so we just started recording. We discussed cancer. - Since duration, I lost about 10 more pounds. - We fought. - Yeah, pisses me off. - And we talked openly about the fact that David was going to die. - I am afraid of being forgotten. - My brother, David, is the story of the last chapter of my brother's life. It's weird and messy and vulnerable, and I'm gonna share all of it with you. - It's a constant back and forth battle about how do I, how do I not just be alive, but I should live. - Listen to my brother, David, on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. - But more than a century, miss America's out the country of fantasy. - Well, are you ready, ladies? Okay, here we go. (cheering) - But over the past decade, the crown's been slipping. They said, "Goodbye to swimsuits." Now, hello to lawsuits. - I'm Bridget Armstrong. Now I'm back with season two of this podcast, Curse of Miss America. Investigating the rise, fall, and uncertain future of one of America's most iconic institutions. The Miss America pageant. - I never received a scholarship. I need to pay for my student loans. He looks at me and goes, "You don't look like you "suffered in the eating disorder." - It's great, but looks too ethnic. - It's a story the Miss America organization really doesn't want us to tell. - An exploitation of our Miss America's is treated by the Miss America organization as an attack on Miss America itself. - Listen to the Curse of Miss America on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcast. - There are thousands of podcasts that can tell you how to better yourself. Get worse with Kyle Prue is not one of those podcasts. So if you're interested in getting thinner, going to therapy, starting peptide, setting boundaries, taking supplements, making your better, getting closer, then I would humbly recommend other podcasts. But if you're interested in blackmail, love, bomb, and cloning yourself, or getting revenge, then we've got a little something, something for a dastardly individual like you. Fake a back injury. Get the spray tan, up your alcohol consumption. Only women should be allowed to have guns. - Kill 'em. - Kill 'em. Kill 'em with a gun. - Listen, it's already over. - The next time a bear is running at you, you just calmly stop what you're doing, you look the bear in the eye, and you say this isn't you. - Do not preserve relationships, you don't need them. - Listen to Get Worse with Kyle Prue on the IHR Radio app Apple Podcast, or wherever you get your podcasts. (upbeat music) - And we're back. So, I don't know exactly. His finances are a little obscure. There's some local Kenyan papers that have gone over like who he purchased his land from and how much, his lawyer claim he bought a 10 acre farm, which would be like the kind of property you'd buy if you wanted to have a small farm. But by 2023, he owned an 800 acre parcel of land through his cult. So, I don't know if he ever had just bought 10 acres with the plan of farming, right? But it seems like he acquired a bunch of land through time. One paper described him as doing this through subterfuge or corrosion of erstwhile friends, associates, and cult adherents. Basically, he convinces other people to buy more acres and then give them to him, right? And then he starts selling those acres to his followers who are moving from the cities. And saying, "Oh, you can have some land too on the farm, right?" So, I don't know how many he started with or what he started with, but a lot of followers start leaving Melindi or elsewhere in Kenya to buy an acre or two and start a farm. You know, they want that dream of like, "Oh, the world does seem scary." Maybe it makes sense to hide on a farm next to this church that I like his YouTube videos. So, he starts selling land. He'll take in people who are poor and just bring them onto the compound. But if you've got money and you don't want to give it up to him, he'll sell you land and you can give it to him, right? With the idea of like farming. But then once they move to take possession, he seems to just keep control of the land as if he owns it, right? 'Cause it's all on the cult compounds. He's just getting screwed both ways. And this leads me to my first theory about what was really going on with Pastor McKenzie's cult. And I think part of it is that he was operating a real estate scam. My thinking on this is informed by reporting in nation, which is another Kenyan paper on one of Paul's followers, Agni Saleem Abdallah. She was the 60-year-old mother of Grace Dowdy who'd been a member of McKenzie's church in Belindi with her mom. But once Paul got in trouble with the law and fled town, Grace left his church. Her mother didn't leave the church, right? And then one day her mom disappears from town, travels to Shakahola and purchases two acres of land from the pastor. This is in 2020. By no later than 2023, Agnes was dead. We don't know how she died specifically, but as we'll discuss in more depth in part two, the basic cause is that sometime after 2020, Pastor McKenzie starts ordering his isolated followers who are cut off from civilization and living in this vast forest compound to stop eating, to starve themselves as a way to prove their devotion to God. And he's also saying, if you starve yourself to death, you don't have to go through the tribulation. When the world ends, you don't have to go through the end of days. You'll just be with Jesus, right? It's the best way to go to Jesus, just starve yourself to death. And then you can be with him and miss the end of the world, right? And that's coming soon. It's just coming in the next couple of years. So you should start starving yourself to death now. Kids first, right? We'll talk more about that in part two. But yeah, that's what starts happening. - Wow. - I don't know who he kills first from this. I don't know when the dying starts, certainly by 2022, they're starting to die, but it may have been as early as 2020. So that all is a little unclear to me. By 2023 though, residents of the local village in Chakahola had noticed a pattern. Per that nation article, according to some followers of the church who did not want to be named, once one arrived in Chakahola village, a piece of land was sold to them at 25,000, which is like the local Kenyan currency per acre. There are suspicions that once the owner died, the land and the already built mud house would be sold to another person. So in other words, the suspicion is, maybe he is bringing followers in to buy land and then starving them to death so that he can resell their land to the next person to come in, who he then starves to death and sells their land. - Wow. - Right? - Yeah. - Yeah, over the next three years, hundreds of Kenyans start to go missing. More than 1,000 in total. Many of them are villagers who live near the new cult compound, but they come from all over Kenya, and in a few cases from outside the country. One local of a nearby village in Bungali told the nation that they had to chase past McKenzie and his cult out of their town, because he'd started brainwashing their neighbors to take their children out of school. Quote, "By then he did not tell the community to do fast, but he was preaching, said he was preaching the gospel and people should not go to school, but collectively we could not entertain the thought of not educating our children. We chased him away and he settled in Shakahola where he continued with his weird sermons, which is nice that at least one town was like, "Get the fuck out of here." - Yeah, yeah. - They were not playing a game of fuck out. - Like we will kill you. - Just the message to take from this and just carry in life. Sometimes you could just tell people, "Get the fuck out of here." - Get the fuck out of my town. Sometimes just sitting there and hoping you can convince them through reaching across the aisle and conversations and emails, it doesn't work. Sometimes you just got to be direct with that conflict and say, "Nah, dog, not gonna happen." - Nah, bro, if you don't move your house down the road, we'll burn it down. Like, yeah, you moved here because there's no law, that shit cuts both ways, my friends. - Yeah, yeah. - Like, you think the cops are coming? - No, I am. - So there was some local resistance to his teachings, just that's why they settled in Shakahola, right? There's not resistance there. And it does seem like he converted a lot of the village's original residents to his version of the faith. Meetings of the faithful in the village are initially held under a tree where prayers would be conducted. He does monthly gatherings there to help draw new members into the pastor's webs. And then once people start to show interest, they start being visited in their homes by agents of the cult who start preaching to them about like, "Hey, you should really start starving yourself." This is what God wants, right? Here's how it's explained. Christ is coming any day now, right? Paul, now calling himself Bishop McKinsey, is preaching that Christ is right about going to be here, right? But confusingly, he wants his followers to go to heaven to meet Jesus first, right? Which again, it doesn't make a lot of sense. If Christ is coming, she ain't just like, "Wait. "Did he really want me to starve myself or my kids?" He's gonna come pick us up, right? No, Jesus doesn't have that much money. Have you seen the gas prices lately? Jesus can't be picking everybody up. No, some of us need to go up here. He drives a diesel truck, man. (laughing) Like Jesus is hurting right now. Oh, come on. There's not enough room in the cab. Yes. He was 729 by my house. 729. Jesus ain't paying that shit. - Are you kidding me? No, you gotta starve yourself. Follows were urged to abandon any earthly wealth for God first, which again, I think this whole starvation thing, my theory, I don't even know how much of this he believes. I think a lot of this is just a way for him to cash out and mine his followers for money while killing them so they can't cause you problems later. Like I kind of suspect that. I don't know. - Well, that's why I was saying this feels so much different because the usual cult game plan is they also believe that and that's why they also are drinking the Kool-A. They are in on the sips. But this is a cult activity that is taking money from people, giving it to him. And he's obviously not starving himself because he's still around. - Yeah. - You saw the video, he's not a skinny man. - Yeah. - Not to body shame, but he's just clearly not starving to death. - No, he's not nourished in any way, yeah, yeah. - Yeah. Now, most of the pastor's followers lived in, again, these mud brick buildings where a lot of people, because they build them on the compound too, and he starts locking them inside to make sure that they starve themselves properly. Like that's one way they do this. Like if he doesn't trust that you're gonna starve yourself to death, he'll lock you in the room. And he has a house there and it's like a humble mud brick house like everyone else has. But he doesn't live there or keep his family there. A police report from after this all blows up noted that he kept a modern home stocked with food and his family nearby. Quote, he lives a lavish life inside the vast Shakahola ranch where he would be seen feasting. If questions about his appetite, he claims he needs the energy to preach God's gospel. - Wow. - Like, well, I gotta keep eating. God needs me to tell you to starve yourself. I can't tell you to starve yourself on an empty stomach. That's wild stuff, that's wild stuff. It really is like, whoo, like you really had them just going because I think that would be the first red flag at least for me or it's like. - This guy seems pretty well fed. - Yeah, if you're not doing it, then I'm not gonna do it. - Why am I supposed to do this? - Yeah, yeah. Why am I the only one starving? - If I start a war hammer, Quote, I'm gonna be playing a lot of war hammer. - Oh yeah, exactly, exactly, you know? You're all painting. - That's how you know it's a trustworthy Quote, like Scientology, Elron Hubbard lived in those boats with everyone else, you know? You know, he made people jump into the water, well, he didn't jump into the water to punish himself, but everyone else got to punish that way, you know? It was a good Quote, it was a good Quote. That's what I'm saying. I'm very pro-scientology now, you know? After all these bad Quotes that are irresponsible about it. - Yeah. - At least the C.O.S. That's right, the C.O.S. This gave us the movie Battlefield Earth, you know? Which isn't good, but it is a movie. - Yeah. - Kinda? Kinda? - Yeah. - Yeah. - Yeah. Anyway, a handful of his lieutenants, who I suspect were also on the money side of things, insisted that they also had dispensation from God to keep eating. Again, his lieutenants, his enforcers, his militia, they need energy, right? 'Cause they got to recruit more followers to give up their money by land and starve themselves and their children are dead for Jesus. Good stuff. So we'll talk more about all this whole horrible story ends. And this is, the scale of this is pretty fucking boggling. I'm gonna be honest with you, it's upsetting. But you know what's not upsetting, iffy? You plug in your pluggables one last time. - Oh yeah, you know me, I'm on tour right now. We're doing a bunch of stuff. Iffycomedy.com, if you wanna get the most up to date, 'cause I'm sure some shows are gonna be added. We're gonna be adding some 20, 27 dates. But if you're listening to this now and you're like, ooh, I need some more of that wit and whimsy. - Oh yeah. - Maybe live in my face. Definitely the 19th in Columbus, the 21st. I'm into coma, spoke in the 22nd, the second of December, I'm in Philly. And the third I'm in Hoboken, New Jersey. - Yeah, and yeah, listen, check out iffy shows. He will never ask you to starve yourselves to death. I might. - No. - He won, you know? - Yeah, I actually encourage you. - Yeah. - Encourage you to eat. Because then if you're sitting in the front, I can reach and grab one of your chicken wings and eat it. - You can get one of your chicken wings. - Yeah, make it seem like a bit, but it's actually that I'm hungry. - See, that's a trustworthy coat leader. If part of one of the coat rules is you always have to have chicken wings, 'cause I never know and I might wanna grab a chicken wing, you know? - Yeah, exactly. - Yeah, yeah, just like my buddy Greasy will. His coat rule would be everyone asked to have a lighter, 'cause I hate not having a lighter when I ate one. (laughing) - Okay, that's a good one. You're death, if you don't have a fucking zip up. - Yeah. - Yeah, we will light you on fire. - Yeah, that's it. Anyway, look folks, I'm not saying don't start or join a cult. Just not one that asks you to kill yourself for another one's profit. At least join a fun sex cult, you know? There's plenty of them, you know? - Oh yeah. - Find a cult leader's gonna feed you Molly. It gets something out of it as all I'm saying. - That, you know, those are the ones that I'm like, "Ah, okay." - Yeah. - But when it's the cult's where it's like, "Don't eat anything," I was like, "I love eating." - I know. - No, when it's the cult's where it's like, "Well, he fed us nothing but hike a deluxe for three years." I'm like, "Yeah, yeah, I could have joined some cults at one point in my life, but it was taking a lot of psychedelics." - Yeah. - I can see how that works. - Yeah. - This all makes sense. - Yeah. - All right, everybody. We'll see you tomorrow or Thursday, except for those of you who joined cults in the interim. - Behind the bastards is a production of CoolZone Media. For more from CoolZone Media, visit our website, CoolZoneMedia.com, or check us out on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Full video episodes of Behind the Bastards are now streaming on Netflix, dropping every Tuesday and Thursday. Hit remind me on Netflix so you don't miss an episode. For clips and our older episode catalog, continue to subscribe to our YouTube channel, youtube.com/atB Behind the Bastards. We love about 40% of you, statistically speaking. - I remember screaming one night. Where is my brother? Where is my brother? - I'm Lucy Shariff, and this is Gone, The Disappearances. Listen to Gone, The Disappearances, on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. - How do you know that cloud won't become manipulative? - This is a constant worry. - And you can actually catch the model, thinking, I think X is actually true, but I'm gonna tell the user why. - I'm Walter Isaacs, I'm my new podcast, The Builders. Listen to The Builders starting October 13th on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. - November is pancreatic cancer awareness month, and I want to tell you about my brother, David, a podcast that documents my brother's journey with this disease. - The experience of pancreatic cancer patients goes under the radar, Dr. Cal Sabai, but just because we die so fast. Listen to my brother, David, on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. - It's all just a joke. - I'm Bridget Armstrong, back with season two of the podcast, Curse of Miss America. He looks and he goes, "You don't look like you suffered "in the eating disorder." - I never received scholarship any to pay for my student loans. - Maybe this is the meta question for the podcast. - Listen to the Curse of Miss America on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.

Podcast Summary

Key Points:

  1. Paul McKinsey, a Kenyan cult leader, founded a religious community in Melindi that promoted extreme beliefs, including the rejection of education, schools, and modern society as evil.
  2. His teachings emphasized apocalypticism, anti-Western and anti-Catholic ideologies, and claimed the U.S. and global institutions were working to destroy God’s word.
  3. He gained followers by promising spiritual solutions to personal problems, leading many vulnerable individuals—especially children—to abandon school and family.
  4. Authorities repeatedly failed to act decisively, with police raids and arrests being met with releases, allowing the cult to persist despite illegal operations.
  5. In 2017, 93 children were rescued from his compound, and survivors reported being indoctrinated into believing education was satanic.
  6. McKinsey faced multiple criminal charges, including operating unregistered schools and distributing unlicensed films, but consistently avoided jail by pleading not guilty and securing bail.
  7. He publicly claimed his ministry ended due to divine command, not legal pressure, using religious rhetoric to justify abandoning his church and broadcasting activities.
  8. The case reflects a broader crisis in Kenya involving widespread religious extremism, exploitation of vulnerable populations, and systemic failures in government oversight of cults.

Summary:

Paul McKinsey, a Kenyan religious leader, founded a radical cult in Melindi that promoted extreme anti-education and anti-Western ideologies, claiming schools and modern society were evil and corrupt. Starting in 2003, he attracted followers by promising spiritual salvation and rejecting conventional life, including formal education and family life. His teachings, which included conspiracy theories about global institutions and the devil in education, gained traction among vulnerable individuals, especially children.

In 2017, authorities raided his compound and rescued 93 children who had been kept out of school. Despite facing multiple criminal charges—such as operating an unlicensed school and unregistered TV station—McKinsey consistently avoided prosecution by pleading not guilty and securing bail. He claimed his ministry ended due to divine instruction, not legal action, and publicly shifted to farming as a "normal" lifestyle.

The case highlights systemic failures in Kenya’s response to religious extremism, where powerful Christian right movements and weak enforcement allow dangerous cults to flourish. Experts note that McKinsey’s actions are part of a wider trend in Kenya, where leaders exploit vulnerability, promise miracles, and use fear and isolation to maintain control. Though details remain limited, the case underscores how cults often begin with normal or even healthy beliefs before spiraling into manipulation, violence, and social harm.

The lack of accountability and media focus on isolated incidents reflects deeper societal and institutional issues in Kenya’s religious and legal systems.

FAQs

The cult leader featured is Paul McKinsey, a Kenyan preacher who established a religious movement in Melindi, Kenya, promoting extreme beliefs and leading to the imprisonment and forced removal of children from school.

Paul McKinsey believed that education, medical services, and modern Western lifestyles were evil and satanic, claiming they were part of a global conspiracy to undermine God's plan. He taught that only worshiping God mattered, and that life without religious devotion was meaningless.

He led children to abandon school and live in his compound, where they were deprived of formal education and subjected to religious indoctrination. Many children reported feeling unsafe and were rescued from the compound in 2017 after complaints from activists and the Meyundo Children Rescue Center.

He was charged with operating an unregistered school, failing to send his own children to school, and running a TV station without proper licensing. Despite these charges, he was repeatedly released on bail and avoided serious punishment.

He claimed the decision was divinely inspired, stating that God told him to stop his ministry and close the TV station in 2019. This was widely seen as a manipulation to avoid legal consequences and a cover for continuing his activities under a new guise.

The police and government initially responded slowly, fearing backlash against religious freedoms. They conducted raids and arrests but allowed the cult to persist, often releasing McKinsey after charges due to lack of enforcement and political reluctance.

Chat with AI

Loading...

Pro features

Go deeper with this episode

Unlock creator-grade tools that turn any transcript into show notes and subtitle files.